GIFSQ ID: KBA-0302
FOOD CHEMISTRY: FLAVOURS
Diagram
Same flavour, different source
Natural flavour
Flavouring from a natural source, such as a plant or animal material, by a physical process.
↓
Artificial flavour
Flavouring made by chemical synthesis, not taken from a natural source.
↓
The key point
The flavour chemical can be the same molecule in both cases. The difference is the source and the legal definition, not always the taste.
Figure 1: Natural and artificial flavours differ in source and legal definition, not always in the flavour molecule itself. Drawn in our own style from Ashurst, Food Flavourings, chapter 1, and the flavour discussion in Edwards, The Science of Sugar Confectionery.
Introduction
Natural and artificial flavours both flavour food, but the words describe where the flavouring comes from, not how strong it tastes. A natural flavour is taken from a natural source, such as a plant or animal material, by a physical process. An artificial flavour is made by chemical synthesis. The flavour chemical itself can be the same molecule in both cases, which is why the label, and the law behind it, matters more than the taste alone.
Ashurst opens Food Flavourings with what natural means, including the European Flavouring Directive definition, and Edwards discusses natural and nature-identical flavourings in sugar confectionery. This article follows those two books.
Quick comparison
Table 1: Natural flavours compared with artificial flavours
| Aspect | Natural flavours | Artificial flavours |
|---|---|---|
| Source | A plant or animal material | Chemical synthesis in a factory |
| How made | Taken out by a physical process, such as extraction or distillation | Built up by chemical reactions |
| Legal meaning | Defined by law, including the European Flavouring Directive definition discussed by Ashurst | Defined by law as not from a natural source |
| Flavour molecule | Can be the same molecule as in the artificial form | Can be the same molecule as in the natural form |
| Cost and supply | Often more costly and limited by crop and season | Usually cheaper and available all year |
| Strength | Often less concentrated, so more is needed | Often highly concentrated, so little is needed |
| Stability | Can be less stable in processing and storage | Often more stable in processing and storage |
| Labelling | Labelled natural, under the legal definition | Labelled artificial, or by its chemical name where the law requires it |
| Consumer view | Often preferred by shoppers who want natural food | Often viewed with suspicion, even when the molecule is identical |
| Typical use | Fruit extracts, vanilla extract, spice oils | Synthetic vanilla, synthetic fruit flavours, flavour chemicals |
Scientific explanation
Definition
A natural flavour is a flavouring taken from a natural source, such as a plant or animal material, by a physical process, and the term has a legal definition, including the definition in the European Flavouring Directive discussed by Ashurst. An artificial flavour is a flavouring made by chemical synthesis, not taken from a natural source. The flavour chemical can be identical in the two cases: the difference is the source, not necessarily the molecule.
Working principle
Flavour is sensed by smell and taste together. A natural flavouring carries the flavour chemicals out of the plant or animal material with them, usually with other compounds from the same source, which is why a natural extract often tastes rounder. An artificial flavouring supplies the same key flavour chemicals, made by synthesis, in a controlled and concentrated form. Because the key molecule can be the same, the two can taste alike, and the difference shows in the label, the cost, and the other compounds present.
Apparatus
The books used here name no laboratory apparatus for telling the two apart, so no apparatus list is given.
Measurement procedure
The books used here name no single standard laboratory procedure for telling a natural flavour from an artificial one by taste. The distinction is made from the source and the paperwork behind the flavouring, and from analysis of the full mixture where that is done, not from one simple test.
Factors affecting readings
Crop, season and extraction method change a natural flavour. Processing heat, storage time and the food itself change both kinds of flavour. The law decides what may be called natural, and the definition differs between legal systems, so the same flavouring can be labelled differently in different places.
Formulas and calculations
The books used here give no formula for this comparison, so no formula or worked calculation is given.
Industrial applications
- Natural flavours are used in fruit drinks, vanilla products and spice foods where a natural label is wanted.
- Artificial flavours are used in sweets, soft drinks and baked goods where a stable, low cost flavour is wanted.
- Natural extracts are used in premium and clean label products.
- Artificial flavours are used where the natural source is scarce, seasonal, or too costly.
- Both are used in confectionery, where Edwards discusses emulsifiers, colours and flavours together.
Advantages and limitations
- Natural flavours: advantage: meet consumer demand for natural food and carry the full flavour of the source. Limitation: costly, variable with crop and season, and sometimes less stable.
- Artificial flavours: advantage: cheap, stable, and available all year in exact strength. Limitation: cannot be labelled natural, and some shoppers reject them.
- Natural flavours: advantage: often give a rounder flavour from the other compounds in the extract. Limitation: the supply depends on farming and harvest.
FAQ
Is a natural flavour always better tasting?
Not always. The key flavour molecule can be the same, so the taste can be alike, and the natural form may simply be rounder or more variable.
What does nature-identical mean?
It is a term Edwards uses for a flavour chemical made by synthesis that is identical to one found in nature. It is not the same as natural.
Why are artificial flavours cheaper?
They are made by synthesis in a factory, so they do not depend on crop, season or harvest.
Who decides what counts as natural?
The law decides, and Ashurst discusses the European Flavouring Directive definition. The definition differs between legal systems.
References and further reading
- Philip R. Ashurst, Food Flavourings, 3rd ed., Aspen, 1999 (Google Books page read).
- W. P. Edwards, The Science of Sugar Confectionery, Royal Society of Chemistry, 2000 (Google Books page read)
- Nak-Eon Choi and Jung H. Han, How Flavor Works: The Science of Taste and Aroma, Wiley, 2014 (Google Books page read).