GIFSQ ID: KBA-0251
FOOD CHEMISTRY: BROWNING IN FOODS
Diagram
Two routes to brown, two different causes
Enzymatic browning
Needs the enzyme polyphenol oxidase, a phenolic substrate, and oxygen. Happens at room temperature in cut fruit.
↓
Non-enzymatic browning
Needs heat and chemistry, no enzyme. Two main forms: the Maillard reaction, and caramelisation.
Figure 1: Enzymatic browning is driven by an enzyme at room temperature; non-enzymatic browning is driven by heat without an enzyme. Drawn in our own style from the browning discussion in the FTN Food Chemistry notes, Unit 12.
Introduction
Browning in foods comes in three main kinds, and two of them are compared here. Enzymatic browning is driven by enzymes in the food, and it happens in cut fruit and vegetables. Non-enzymatic browning is driven by heat and chemistry, without enzymes, and it has two main forms: the Maillard reaction, between a sugar and a protein, and caramelisation, of sugar heated alone. The two can be told apart by three questions: does it need an enzyme, does it need heat, and does it need a sugar and a protein together?
Quick comparison
Table 1: Enzymatic browning compared with non-enzymatic browning
| Aspect | Enzymatic browning | Non-enzymatic browning |
|---|---|---|
| Driver | An enzyme, polyphenol oxidase, also called phenolase | Heat and chemistry, no enzyme |
| Needs oxygen | Yes, together with the enzyme and the substrate | No: the Maillard reaction and caramelisation do not need oxygen |
| Needs heat | No: it happens at room temperature, and heat destroys the enzyme | Yes: it needs heat, and runs faster at higher temperature |
| Needs protein | No: it needs a phenolic substrate | Maillard needs a sugar and a protein; caramelisation needs sugar alone, no protein |
| Starting material | Phenolic compounds, such as chlorogenic acid in apples and potatoes | A reducing sugar and an amino group (Maillard), or sugar alone (caramelisation) |
| Steps | Enzyme oxidises phenols into quinones; quinones join with each other and with proteins; the joins build into melanins | Sugar and amino acid join into the Amadori product, which breaks into fragments, which join into melanoidins (Maillard); or sugar loses water, breaks into fragments, and joins into brown compounds (caramelisation) |
| Pigment | Brown and black melanins | Brown melanoidins (Maillard) or brown caramel compounds |
| Where it is seen | Cut apple, cut potato, cut fruit and vegetables | Bread crust, roasted coffee, fried food (Maillard); caramel, toffee, creme caramel top (caramelisation) |
| Speed factors | Most active near neutral pH and at warm temperatures; slowed by cold, acid, and absence of oxygen | Faster at higher temperature, favoured by slightly alkaline pH and by water activity in the middle range, near 0.6 to 0.8 |
| Prevention | Blanching destroys the enzyme; acid slows it; ascorbic acid turns quinones back into phenols; keeping oxygen out removes the oxygen; cold slows it | Keep the food cool, keep it acid, keep water activity low or high away from the middle range, keep the time at high temperature short; for caramelisation, keep below the browning point of the sugar |
| Wanted or defect | A defect in cut fruit and dried fruit | Wanted in bread crust, coffee, and fried food; a defect in milk powder and pale foods |
Scientific explanation
Definition
Enzymatic browning is the browning of cut fruit and vegetables, driven by the enzyme polyphenol oxidase, also called phenolase. Non-enzymatic browning is browning driven by heat and chemistry, without enzymes, and it has two main forms: the Maillard reaction, between a sugar and a protein, and caramelisation, of sugar heated alone. A third route, ascorbic acid oxidation, is a separate kind and is not part of this comparison.
Working principle
Enzymatic browning has three steps. First, the enzyme, in the presence of oxygen, oxidises the phenolic compounds in the food, such as chlorogenic acid in apples and potatoes, into quinones. Second, the quinones, which are very reactive, join with each other and with amino acids and proteins in the food. Third, those joins build up into the brown and black pigments called melanins. Cut the fruit and the cells break, so the enzyme meets the substrate and the oxygen at the cut surface, and the browning starts in minutes. The enzyme is most active near neutral pH and at warm temperatures, and it is slowed by cold, by acid, and by the absence of oxygen. It is destroyed by heat, which is why blanching stops browning, and it is blocked by compounds that bind copper, because the enzyme carries copper at its centre, and by antioxidants such as ascorbic acid, which turn the quinones back into phenols before they can join into melanins. Non-enzymatic browning runs in stages of its own: in the Maillard reaction the sugar and the amino acid join to form a Schiff base, which rearranges into the Amadori product, which breaks down into fragments, which join into melanoidins; in caramelisation the sugar loses water, breaks into fragments, and those fragments join into brown compounds.
Apparatus
The books used here name no laboratory apparatus for measuring browning, and the practical test for this unit is a kitchen test: cut an apple into four pieces and treat each differently. No apparatus list is given beyond that test.
Measurement procedure
The apple test: cut an apple into four pieces and treat each differently, leave one in air, put one in lemon juice, put one in water, and put one in the fridge uncovered. Leave them for an hour and compare the colours. The piece in air will brown most, the piece in lemon juice will stay pale, the piece in water will brown slowly because the water limits the oxygen, and the piece in the fridge will brown more slowly than the piece in air at room temperature. That test shows the three needs of enzymatic browning, enzyme, substrate, and oxygen, and the two levers that stop it, acid and cold.
Factors affecting readings
For enzymatic browning, pH, temperature, oxygen, and the phenolic content of the fruit decide the rate. For non-enzymatic browning, temperature, pH, water activity, and time decide the rate: the Maillard reaction is fastest in the middle water activity range and at a slightly alkaline pH, and it is slowed by acid, by cold, and by very low or very high water activity, where the reactants cannot meet or are diluted. Each kind of browning has its own activation energy, so the rate rises differently with heat for each kind.
Formulas and calculations
Browning rate and temperature (Arrhenius). The Arrhenius equation says the rate constant k = A x exp(minus Ea / (R x T)), where A is a constant for the reaction, Ea is the activation energy, R is the gas constant, 8.314 joules per mol per kelvin, and T is the absolute temperature in kelvin.
Worked example: take a Maillard type reaction with Ea = 100,000 joules per mol, T1 = 373 K (100 degrees Celsius) and T2 = 383 K (110 degrees Celsius). Then k2 / k1 = e to the power 0.842 = 2.32. Ten degrees hotter makes the reaction about 2.3 times faster. If browning to a chosen colour takes 60 minutes at 100 degrees, it takes about 60 / 2.32 = 26 minutes at 110 degrees. The rule of thumb is that the rate roughly doubles for every 10 degrees Celsius rise, but the activation energy is not one number for all browning, so the doubling rule is approximate and differs between foods.
Industrial applications
- Enzymatic browning: a defect to stop in cut fruit, fresh cut vegetables, and dried fruit, where a brown apple ring looks stale.
- Enzymatic browning: blanching vegetables before freezing or drying, to destroy the enzyme.
- Non-enzymatic browning (Maillard): wanted colour and flavour in bread crust, roasted coffee, and fried food.
- Non-enzymatic browning (caramelisation): caramel colour, toffee, and the top of a creme caramel.
- Both: milk powder and dried foods, where browning is a defect to stop by keeping the food cool, dry, and acid.
Advantages and limitations
- Enzymatic browning, advantage: none for the maker, but it is a visible sign that a cut fruit is fresh and its cells are broken, and it is easy to stop.
- Enzymatic browning, limitation: it starts in minutes at room temperature, it needs only the enzyme, the substrate, and oxygen together, and it makes cut fruit look stale.
- Non-enzymatic browning, advantage: it gives colour and flavour that no other reaction gives, as in bread crust and roasted coffee.
- Non-enzymatic browning, limitation: it is unwanted in milk powder, dried foods, and pale foods, where it darkens the colour, gives a stale flavour, and destroys lysine, lowering the protein value.
FAQ
What enzyme drives enzymatic browning?
Polyphenol oxidase, also called phenolase. It oxidises phenolic compounds into quinones, which join into brown melanin pigments.
What three things must be present together for enzymatic browning?
The enzyme polyphenol oxidase, the phenolic substrate, and oxygen.
Why does lemon juice stop a cut apple browning?
Its acid lowers the pH and slows polyphenol oxidase, and its ascorbic acid turns quinones back into phenols before they can form melanins.
What is the difference between enzymatic and non-enzymatic browning?
Enzymatic browning needs an enzyme and oxygen and happens at room temperature. Non-enzymatic browning needs heat and chemistry, with no enzyme.
Why does blanching stop enzymatic browning?
Heat destroys the enzyme polyphenol oxidase, so the reaction cannot start.
References and further reading
- FTN subject: Food Chemistry, Unit 12: Browning in Foods.
- Zeece, Michael. Introduction to the Chemistry of Food. Academic Press, 2020.
- Coultate, Tom. Food: The Chemistry of Its Components. 7th ed., Royal Society of Chemistry, 2023.
- Damodaran, Srinivasan, and Kirk L. Parkin. Fennema’s Food Chemistry. 5th ed., CRC Press, 2017.
- Wang, Dongfeng, Hong Lin, Jianqian Kan et al. Food Chemistry. De Gruyter, 2015.
- Google Books pages read for this article: