Size Reduction Quiz
GIFSQ ID: ART-1021
What this quiz covers
This quiz covers size reduction, the unit operation that breaks solid food material into smaller pieces by mechanical force. It opens inside the ball mill, where tumbling balls grind the feed mainly by impact as they fall and by shear as they slide over the particles, and where the balls are made of hardened steel. Run the mill too fast and it centrifuges: the balls pin against the wall at the critical speed and practically no grinding happens, which is why mills run well below critical speed.
The middle questions cover the crushers and the three classic energy laws. A gravity crusher, the Blake type jaw crusher, hangs its moving jaw from a pivot at the top, so the swing is smallest at the top and largest at the discharge opening, and it crushes by slow compression. Crushing efficiency is the surface energy of the new surface created divided by the energy the solid absorbs, and only a few percent of the input ever becomes surface energy. Rittinger’s law says work is proportional to the new surface created, Bond’s law is the intermediate law, with work going as one over the square root of particle diameter, and the work index is the gross energy in kilowatt hours per ton to reduce very large feed to a product of which 80 percent passes a 100 micron screen.
Three laws, one question: how much energy buys how much new surface
Rittinger, Kick, and Bond are one law with three exponents. Rittinger is the fine grinding law, work rising with new surface, and Bond sits in the middle, calling for relatively less energy than Rittinger for very fine products. Around them sit the machines: hammer mills smash by impact, attrition mills grind by shear and crushing between grooved plates, wet milling gives a finer product than dry milling, fibrous material tears best in a squirrel cage disintegrator, and dicing is cutting food into cubes.
How to use this quiz
Work through the 20 questions and for each machine ask which force does the work: impact, compression, shear, or cutting. The explanations below give the reason behind every correct answer.
Choose how you want to play
Answer explanations
Worked through the quiz? Here is why each correct answer is correct: the concept behind it, in plain terms.
- Which forces do the work of size reduction in a ball mill?
Correct answer: Shear and impact. Inside a ball mill the tumbling balls grind the feed mainly by impact as they fall and by shear (attrition) as they slide and roll over the particles. Compression is the job of crushers, not ball mills, which is why shear and impact is the right pair. - Which statements are true of a gravity crusher?
Correct answer: Both of these. The question describes a Blake-type jaw crusher: the moving jaw hangs from a pivot at the top, so its swing is smallest there and largest at the discharge opening at the bottom. Both statements fit that design, so both are true. - At which mill speed does centrifugation of the balls occur in a ball mill?
Correct answer: Critical speed. Centrifugation sets in at the critical speed – the speed where centrifugal force pins the balls against the mill wall and they stop tumbling. Above it the balls ride round without falling and grinding collapses, which is why mills are run well below critical speed (textbooks such as McCabe, Smith and Harriott quote roughly 65 to 80 percent of critical). - The process of breaking down solid material by mechanical force is called what?
Correct answer: Size reduction. Size reduction is the unit operation of breaking solid material into smaller pieces by mechanical force – crushing, grinding, cutting, and the like. Centrifugation separates, filtering separates, and agitation only mixes. - Crushing efficiency is defined as the ratio of what?
Correct answer: Surface energy created by crushing divided by the energy absorbed by the solid. Crushing efficiency is defined as the useful work – the surface energy of the new surface created – divided by the mechanical energy actually absorbed by the solid (McCabe, Smith and Harriott). Only a few percent of the input ever becomes surface energy, so the ratio is surface energy created over energy the solid absorbs. - What does Rittinger’s crushing law state?
Correct answer: Work required in crushing is proportional to the new surface created. Rittinger’s law (1867) says the work of crushing is proportional to the new surface area created, i.e. to the reciprocal of the product particle size. It is the n = 2 case of the general crushing law and it predicts the highest energy needs for very fine grinding. - Which statement about Bond’s crushing law is correct?
Correct answer: It calls for relatively less energy for smaller product particles than Rittinger’s law. Bond’s law is the intermediate (n = 3/2) crushing law: work goes as 1 over the square root of the particle diameter. For very fine products Rittinger’s 1/d relationship climbs faster, so Bond’s law calls for relatively less energy than Rittinger’s as particles get smaller – that is the standard comparison among the three laws. - How is the work index defined?
Correct answer: Gross energy in kWh per ton of feed to reduce very large feed so that 80% of the product passes a 100-micron screen. Bond defined the work index as the gross energy, in kilowatt-hours per ton of feed, needed to reduce material from a very large feed to a product of which 80 percent passes a 100-micron screen (Bond, 1952). It is the material-specific constant that makes the law quantitative. - Fibrous materials are best broken by which machine?
Correct answer: Squirrel cage disintegrator. Fibrous materials do not shatter under compression or impact; they tear apart best under the intense impact and attrition of a squirrel-cage disintegrator, whose cages spin in opposite directions and fling the fibres against the bars. - In a gravity crusher the material is crushed by which action?
Correct answer: Compression. A gravity (jaw) crusher crushes the feed between two jaws that close on it – a slow squeezing action, which is compression. Impact and cutting belong to hammer mills and cutters. - Which action does most of the size reduction in a ball mill?
Correct answer: Impact. Most of the size reduction in a ball mill comes from impact: the balls cascade and cataract down onto the charge, smashing particles as they land. Attrition (shear) contributes, but impact does the heavy lifting. - In a ball mill, the balls are usually made of what?
Correct answer: Steel. Mill balls are made of hardened steel – dense enough to deliver high impact energy per fall and tough enough to survive millions of collisions. Cast iron shatters too easily, bronze is too soft, and stainless steel adds cost for no grinding advantage. - What happens to grinding when the mill is centrifuging?
Correct answer: Little or no grinding takes place. When the mill centrifuges, the balls stick to the wall and ride round with it instead of tumbling and falling, so the impact and attrition that do the grinding disappear – practically no size reduction happens. - In a hammer mill, which force is involved in size reduction?
Correct answer: Impact. A hammer mill spins hammers at high speed and smashes the feed against the casing and breaker plates – pure impact action. It is the classic impact mill of food and feed processing. - Wet milling tends to produce which kind of product?
Correct answer: Finer. Wet milling gives a finer product than dry milling: the liquid disperses the particles, stops them re-agglomerating, and lets the grinding medium keep working on the finer fractions. - Cutting food material into cubes is called what?
Correct answer: Dicing. Cutting food into uniform cubes is called dicing. Slicing makes flat pieces, milling grinds, and crystallisation is a phase change, not a cutting operation. - How does an attrition mill reduce grain size?
Correct answer: Shear and crushing. An attrition (disc) mill rubs the grain between grooved plates, so the material is sheared apart and crushed between the disc faces – shear plus crushing. - What happens when an attrition mill is overfed?
Correct answer: All of these. All of these happen. Overfeeding an attrition mill packs too much material between the plates: grinding effectiveness falls, the extra friction generates excessive heat, and the overloaded mill draws more power. That is why mills are fed at their rated rate: cramming in more feed never buys more capacity (eagri, AENG 252 lecture notes). - Which law links the energy spent in crushing to the size reduction achieved?
Correct answer: Bond’s law. Bond’s law is the energy-size-reduction relation among the three classic comminution laws (Rittinger, Kick, Bond). Fick’s law is diffusion, Fourier’s is heat conduction, and Planck’s is radiation – none of them deals with crushing. - Which of these is not a method of size reduction?
Correct answer: Burning. Cutting, impact, and shear are the three mechanical actions of size reduction. Burning is combustion – it destroys the material chemically, it does not reduce its particle size.