FISH TECHNOLOGY: TYPES OF FISH
Diagram
Two mild white farmed fish
Tilapia
A warm water fish from Africa, now farmed around the world. It has a mild white flesh and a small, deep body.
↓
Catfish
A warm water fish with smooth skin and barbels like a cat’s whiskers. It has a mild white flesh and a long, low body.
↓
Both farmed
Both are farmed in ponds and tanks, and both are sold as mild white fillets. Swift covers the farming of both in the Aquaculture Training Manual.
Figure 1: Tilapia and catfish are different species, both farmed for mild white fillets. Drawn in our own style from Donald R. Swift, Aquaculture Training Manual, Wiley, 1993, which covers the farming of catfish, tilapia, carp, milkfish, mullet and turbot.
Introduction
Tilapia and catfish are the two mild white farmed fish sold as fillets, and they are easy to mix up on the counter. Tilapia is a warm water fish from Africa, now farmed around the world, while catfish is a warm water fish with smooth skin and barbels, farmed in ponds and tanks. Swift’s Aquaculture Training Manual covers the farming of both species in detail.
The core difference is the species: tilapia is a cichlid fish with scales, and catfish is a scaleless fish with barbels, and they are farmed and cooked in different ways.
Quick comparison
Table 1: Tilapia compared with Catfish
| Aspect | Tilapia | Catfish |
|---|---|---|
| Species | A cichlid fish, mainly Nile tilapia in farming | A catfish, mainly channel catfish in farming |
| Origin | Warm waters of Africa and the Middle East | Warm waters of North America and other regions |
| Skin | Scaly skin | Smooth, scaleless skin |
| Barbels | None | Has barbels, like a cat’s whiskers, around the mouth |
| Body shape | Deep, narrow body | Long, low body with a large head |
| Flesh | Mild white flesh, lean | Mild white flesh, lean, a little softer |
| Farming | Farmed in ponds, tanks and cages around the world | Farmed in ponds, mainly in warm regions |
| Feeding | Eats plants, algae and pellets; tolerates crowding | Eats pellets and feeds near the bottom |
| Typical dishes | Grilled fillets, fried tilapia, fish tacos | Fried catfish, blackened catfish, catfish stew |
| Flavour | Very mild, almost plain | Mild, a little sweeter and earthier |
Scientific explanation
Definition
Tilapia is a common name for several species of cichlid fish, native mainly to Africa and the Middle East, and in farming the name usually means Nile tilapia. Catfish is a common name for fish with smooth skin and barbels, and in farming it usually means channel catfish. Swift covers the farming of both in the Aquaculture Training Manual, and notes that tilapia is the second most cultured fish species in the world in the Webster and Lim volume on tilapia.
Both are warm water farmed fish sold as mild white fillets, which is why they are confused. The species, the skin and the barbels tell them apart.
Working principle
Tilapia farms well because it tolerates crowding, accepts pelleted feed, grows fast and breeds easily: Nile tilapia shows parental care by mouthbrooding, which keeps young fish alive. Catfish farms well because it tolerates warm, low oxygen pond water and feeds near the bottom, so it suits pond farming.
Both are lean white fish, so both cook the same way: fast, with care not to dry them out, and both take flavour from seasoning, batter or sauce rather than from the flesh itself.
Apparatus
Both are farmed in ponds, tanks and cages, with feeders and aerators. Tilapia is also farmed in cages and tanks around the world, while catfish is mostly pond farmed. The books used here name no single standard apparatus for the comparison itself.
Measurement procedure
There is no standard measurement procedure for this comparison in the books used here. In practice the fish is identified by its label, its shape and its skin: scales and no barbels means tilapia, smooth skin and barbels means catfish. In a fillet, the label is the reliable guide.
Factors affecting readings
Water temperature matters for both: both are warm water fish and grow slowly in cold water. Feed matters too: the feed sets the growth rate and the flavour. Crowding matters for tilapia, which tolerates it well, and oxygen matters for catfish ponds, which are aerated to keep the fish healthy.
Formulas and calculations
The books used for this article give no formula for this comparison, so none is given here. The comparison is qualitative: it rests on definitions, materials and method, not on a calculation.
Industrial applications
- Tilapia is used for grilled and fried fillets, where a mild white fish is wanted.
- Tilapia is used for fish tacos and sandwiches, where the mild flesh takes the seasoning.
- Catfish is used for fried catfish and blackened catfish, classic dishes in the southern United States.
- Catfish is used for stews and soups, where the soft flesh cooks fast.
- Both are used as low cost farmed white fish for shops, restaurants and ready meals.
Advantages and limitations
- Tilapia, advantage: grows fast, tolerates crowding, and is farmed around the world, so supply is steady.
- Tilapia, limitation: very mild in flavour, so it needs seasoning, and it needs warm water to grow well.
- Catfish, advantage: mild and a little sweeter, and it suits pond farming in warm regions.
- Catfish, limitation: the flesh is soft and can taste earthy if the pond water is poor, so pond care matters.
FAQ
Are tilapia and catfish the same fish?
No: they are different species. Tilapia is a cichlid with scales, and catfish is a scaleless fish with barbels. Both are mild white farmed fish, which is why they are confused.
How can I tell them apart in a shop?
By the label first: the fish must be labelled by species. In a whole fish, look for scales and no barbels for tilapia, and smooth skin with barbels for catfish.
Which is better for frying?
Both fry well: tilapia gives a firm, mild fillet, and catfish gives a softer, slightly sweeter fillet. The choice is a matter of taste, not of one being right and the other wrong.
Why are both so cheap?
Because both farm well in ponds and tanks, grow fast on pelleted feed, and are produced in large numbers. Farming keeps the price low and the supply steady.
Do both need warm water?
Yes: both are warm water fish, and both grow slowly in cold water. That is why they are farmed in warm regions and in heated tanks elsewhere.
References and further reading
- Donald R. Swift, Aquaculture Training Manual, Wiley, 1993 (Google Books page read)
- Carl D. Webster and Chhorn Lim, Tilapia: Biology, Culture, and Nutrition, Taylor and Francis, 2006
