GIFSQ ID: KBA-0253
FOOD CHEMISTRY: BROWNING IN FOODS
Diagram
Two kinds of non-enzymatic browning
Maillard reaction
A reducing sugar + an amino group, usually from lysine. Needs heat. Gives brown colour and roasted flavour.
↓
Caramelisation
Sugar heated alone, no protein. Needs heat. Gives brown colour and a bitter, burnt flavour.
Figure 1: The Maillard reaction needs a sugar and a protein together; caramelisation needs sugar alone. Drawn in our own style from the browning discussion in the FTN Food Chemistry notes, Units 3 and 12.
Introduction
The Maillard reaction and caramelisation are the two main forms of non-enzymatic browning, and both are driven by heat without an enzyme. The difference is the starting material: the Maillard reaction is the reaction between a reducing sugar and an amino group, usually from the amino acid lysine, while caramelisation is the browning of sugar heated alone, without protein. That is why caramelisation happens in a pan of sugar alone, where the Maillard reaction cannot happen because there is no protein to react with.
Quick comparison
Table 1: Maillard reaction compared with caramelization
| Aspect | Maillard reaction | Caramelization |
|---|---|---|
| Starting material | A reducing sugar + an amino group, usually from lysine | Sugar alone, no protein |
| Needs an enzyme | No | No |
| Needs heat | Yes | Yes |
| Stages | Sugar and amino acid join into a Schiff base, which rearranges into the Amadori product; the Amadori product breaks into fragments; the fragments join into brown melanoidin pigments | Sugar loses water, breaks into fragments, and those fragments join into brown compounds |
| Pigment | Brown melanoidins, large and complex in structure | Brown caramel compounds |
| Temperature | Runs faster at higher temperature; no single melting point, because it is a reaction of two partners | Sucrose melts near 160 C and browns above about 170 C; glucose and fructose brown at lower temperatures, because fructose browns more readily than glucose |
| pH and water activity | Favoured by a slightly alkaline pH and by water activity in the middle range, near 0.6 to 0.8; slowed by acid, cold, and very low or very high water activity | The books used here give no pH or water activity range for caramelisation, so none is stated |
| Flavour | Roasted flavour, as in bread crust, roasted coffee, and fried food | Bitter, burnt flavour of caramel |
| Where it is seen | Bread crust, roasted coffee, fried food, baked goods | Caramel colour, toffee, the top of a creme caramel, a pan of sugar alone |
| Nutritional cost | Destroys lysine, lowering the protein value; overheated milk powders are lower in protein value | No protein is involved, so no lysine is lost |
| Prevention | Keep the food cool, keep it acid, keep water activity low or high away from the middle range, keep the time at high temperature short | Keep the temperature below the browning point of the sugar, and keep the heating time short |
Scientific explanation
Definition
The Maillard reaction is the reaction between a reducing sugar and an amino group, usually from the amino acid lysine, and it is the main source of the brown colour and roasted flavour of bread crust, roasted coffee, fried food, and baked goods. Caramelisation is the browning of sugar heated alone, without protein, and it is different from the Maillard reaction in its starting material and its products.
Working principle
The Maillard reaction runs in three stages. First, the sugar and the amino acid join to form a compound called a Schiff base, which rearranges into the Amadori product. Second, the Amadori product breaks down into fragments, including the compounds that give roasted and caramel notes. Third, those fragments join with each other and with amino acids to form the brown pigments called melanoidins, which are large, complex, and poorly defined in structure. The reaction needs heat, it runs faster at higher temperature, it is favoured by a slightly alkaline pH and by a water activity in the middle range, near 0.6 to 0.8, and it is slowed by acid, by cold, and by very low or very high water activity, where the reactants cannot meet or are diluted. Caramelisation works differently: the sugar loses water, breaks into fragments, and those fragments join into brown compounds that give the colour and the bitter, burnt flavour of caramel. Sucrose melts near 160 C and browns above about 170 C, and glucose and fructose brown at lower temperatures, because fructose browns more readily than glucose.
Apparatus
The books used here name no laboratory apparatus for measuring the Maillard reaction or caramelisation, so no apparatus list is given.
Measurement procedure
The books used here give no standard laboratory procedure with volumes and steps for measuring either reaction, so no procedure is invented here. In practice, the maker reads the browning by colour and flavour, and by the temperature: a loaf browns on the crust but stays pale inside, because the crust is hotter and drier than the crumb, even though both hold the same dough.
Factors affecting readings
For the Maillard reaction, temperature, pH, water activity, and time decide the rate, and the loss of lysine is the nutritional cost of the reaction. For caramelisation, temperature and heating time decide the rate: keep the temperature below the browning point of the sugar and the time short, or the sugar gives a bitter, burnt note, as in a jam that is boiled too long. The two reactions have different activation energies, so they speed up differently with heat.
Formulas and calculations
Browning rate and temperature (Arrhenius). The Arrhenius equation says the rate constant k = A x exp(minus Ea / (R x T)), where A is a constant for the reaction, Ea is the activation energy, R is the gas constant, 8.314 joules per mol per kelvin, and T is the absolute temperature in kelvin.
Worked example: take a Maillard type reaction with Ea = 100,000 joules per mol, T1 = 373 K (100 degrees Celsius) and T2 = 383 K (110 degrees Celsius). Then k2 / k1 = e to the power 0.842 = 2.32. Ten degrees hotter makes the reaction about 2.3 times faster, which is the rule of thumb with its reasoning attached. If browning to a chosen colour takes 60 minutes at 100 degrees, it takes about 60 / 2.32 = 26 minutes at 110 degrees. A baker who raises the oven by 10 degrees and keeps the same baking time will over-brown the crust, and the calculation says by how much. The Maillard reaction and caramelisation have different activation energies, so the same 10 degree rise does not speed both by the same amount.
Industrial applications
- Maillard reaction: baking, where it gives colour and roasted flavour to bread crust; roasting coffee; frying, where it browns the surface of fried food.
- Maillard reaction: a defect to stop in milk powder, dried foods, and pale foods, where it darkens the colour and lowers protein value.
- Caramelisation: caramel colour, toffee, and the top of a creme caramel, where a brown colour or a caramel flavour is wanted.
- Caramelisation: a defect to stop when a sugar is heated too long in a food and gives a bitter, burnt note, as in a jam boiled too long.
Advantages and limitations
- Maillard reaction, advantage: it gives colour and flavour that no other reaction gives, as in bread crust, roasted coffee, and fried food.
- Maillard reaction, limitation: it destroys lysine, lowering the protein value, and it is unwanted in milk powder, dried foods, and pale foods.
- Caramelisation, advantage: it gives a brown colour and caramel flavour from sugar alone, with no protein needed.
- Caramelisation, limitation: it needs high heat, sucrose only browns above about 170 C, and if the sugar is heated too long it gives a bitter, burnt note.
FAQ
What is the difference between caramelisation and the Maillard reaction?
Caramelisation is sugar heated alone, without protein; the Maillard reaction needs a reducing sugar plus an amino group from a protein.
What are the three stages of the Maillard reaction?
First, the sugar and amino acid join and rearrange into the Amadori product; second, the Amadori product breaks into fragments; third, the fragments join into brown melanoidin pigments.
At what temperature does sucrose brown by caramelisation?
It melts near 160 C and browns above about 170 C.
Why does bread brown on the crust but stay pale inside?
The crust and the crumb hold the same dough, but the crust is hotter and drier, so the Maillard reaction runs there and not inside.
How does the Maillard reaction lower the nutritional value of a protein?
Lysine reacts with sugars and is lost to the body, so the protein value falls.
References and further reading
- FTN subject: Food Chemistry, Unit 12: Browning in Foods; Unit 3: Carbohydrates.
- Zeece, Michael. Introduction to the Chemistry of Food. Academic Press, 2020.
- Coultate, Tom. Food: The Chemistry of Its Components. 7th ed., Royal Society of Chemistry, 2023.
- Damodaran, Srinivasan, and Kirk L. Parkin. Fennema’s Food Chemistry. 5th ed., CRC Press, 2017.
- Wang, Dongfeng, Hong Lin, Jianqian Kan et al. Food Chemistry. De Gruyter, 2015.
- Google Books pages read for this article: