GIFSQ ID: KBA-0291
FOOD ENGINEERING: FLOW OF LIQUID FOODS
Diagram
Laminar and turbulent flow in a pipe
Laminar flow
The liquid moves in smooth, parallel layers. Each layer slides past the next, with little mixing across the layers.
↓
Turbulent flow
The liquid moves in a chaotic, churning way, with eddies and mixing across the whole pipe.
↓
What decides it
The Reynolds number decides which flow appears. Low values give laminar flow and high values give turbulent flow.
Figure 1: Smooth layered flow compared with churning mixed flow in a pipe. Drawn in our own style from Steffe, Rheological Methods in Food Process Engineering, Freeman Press, 1996, and Rao, Rheology of Fluid and Semisolid Foods, Springer, 2010.
Introduction
Laminar flow and turbulent flow are the two regimes of flow for a liquid moving through a pipe, and every liquid food in a plant flows in one of them. In laminar flow the liquid moves in smooth layers that slide past each other, so a drop of liquid stays in its own layer as it travels down the pipe. In turbulent flow the liquid churns and mixes, with eddies that carry liquid across the pipe.
The core difference is order against mixing: laminar flow is ordered and predictable, while turbulent flow is chaotic and well mixed. Which one appears depends on the speed of flow, the size of the pipe, and the density and viscosity of the liquid, and engineers use the Reynolds number to tell them apart.
Quick comparison
Table 1: Laminar flow compared with turbulent flow
| Aspect | Laminar flow | Turbulent flow |
|---|---|---|
| Movement | Smooth layers sliding past each other | Chaotic churning with eddies |
| Mixing across the pipe | Very little mixing between layers | Strong mixing across the whole pipe |
| Reynolds number | Low, below about 2100 in a pipe | High, above about 4000 in a pipe |
| Velocity profile | Curved, fastest in the centre and slowest at the wall | Flatter, with similar speed across most of the pipe |
| Pressure drop | Lower for the same flow in general, and it rises in proportion to velocity | Higher, and it rises faster than velocity |
| Heat transfer | Slower, because heat must cross the layers | Faster, because mixing carries heat across the pipe |
| When it appears | Slow flow, narrow pipes, thick liquids | Fast flow, wide pipes, thin liquids |
| Predicting it | Easy to predict with simple equations | Needs empirical relations, because the motion is chaotic |
| Food example | Thick tomato paste moving slowly in a pipe | Water or thin milk pumped fast through a heat exchanger |
| Effect on product | Gentle, so fragile structure is kept | Can break fragile structure but mixes and heats evenly |
Scientific explanation
Definition
Laminar flow is flow in which the fluid moves in parallel layers with no mixing between layers. Turbulent flow is flow in which the fluid moves with irregular, churning motion and eddies that mix the fluid across the pipe. The two are separated by a transition range of Reynolds numbers.
Working principle
Flow stays laminar when viscous forces hold the layers in order. As speed rises, inertial forces grow stronger than viscous forces, the layers break up, and eddies form. The Reynolds number, which compares inertial forces with viscous forces, marks the change: below about 2100 the flow in a pipe is laminar, above about 4000 it is turbulent, and between those values it is in transition.
Apparatus
Steffe describes tube viscometry, in which liquid flows through a tube of known diameter and the pressure drop and flow rate are measured. A capillary or tube viscometer and a rotational viscometer are the instruments named in the sources for studying flow of liquid foods.
Measurement procedure
To find the flow regime, measure the density and viscosity of the liquid, the pipe diameter, and the average velocity of flow, then work out the Reynolds number. In tube viscometry the pressure drop along a tube of known length and diameter is measured at set flow rates, and the results show whether the flow follows the laminar relation.
Factors affecting readings
The result depends on the velocity of flow, the pipe diameter, the density of the liquid and its viscosity. Temperature matters because viscosity changes with temperature: a warm liquid is thinner and turns turbulent more easily. Rough pipe walls and bends can trip laminar flow into turbulence sooner.
Formulas and calculations
The Reynolds number is the key relation, given in Steffe and in Rao: Reynolds number, Re, equals density times velocity times pipe diameter, divided by viscosity. In symbols: Re = (rho x v x D) / mu.
Worked example: water with density 1000 kg per cubic metre flows at 0.5 m per second through a pipe 0.05 m in diameter, and its viscosity is 0.001 Pa s. Then Re equals 1000 times 0.5 times 0.05, divided by 0.001, which is 25 divided by 0.001, which is 25000. That is above 4000, so the flow is turbulent. If the same water flows at 0.02 m per second, Re equals 1000 times 0.02 times 0.05, divided by 0.001, which is 1 divided by 0.001, which is 1000. That is below 2100, so the flow is laminar.
Industrial applications
- Laminar flow: pumping thick pastes and sauces, where gentle layered flow protects texture.
- Laminar flow: tube viscometry, where laminar flow is needed to measure viscosity correctly.
- Turbulent flow: heat exchangers, where churning flow carries heat quickly to the liquid.
- Turbulent flow: cleaning in place, where fast turbulent flow scours the inside of pipes.
- Turbulent flow: mixing tanks and blending, where eddies mix ingredients fast and evenly.
Advantages and limitations
- Laminar flow, advantage: gentle and predictable, so it suits fragile products and viscosity measurement.
- Laminar flow, limitation: slow heat transfer and poor mixing, so heating takes longer and layers stay separate.
- Turbulent flow, advantage: fast mixing and fast heat transfer, so heating and blending are quick and even.
- Turbulent flow, limitation: higher pressure drop and pumping cost, and it can damage fragile food structure.
FAQ
What is the Reynolds number?
A number that compares inertial forces with viscous forces in a flowing liquid. It is worked out from density, velocity, pipe diameter and viscosity.
At what Reynolds number does flow turn turbulent?
In a pipe, below about 2100 is laminar and above about 4000 is turbulent. Between those values the flow is in transition.
Can the same liquid be laminar and turbulent?
Yes. The same liquid is laminar at low speed and turbulent at high speed in the same pipe.
Why does turbulent flow heat food faster?
Because eddies mix the liquid and carry heat across the pipe, while in laminar flow heat must cross the layers slowly.
Which flow is used to measure viscosity?
Laminar flow, in a tube viscometer, because the simple relation between pressure drop and flow rate only holds when the flow is laminar.
References and further reading
- Fellows, P., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, Woodhead Publishing (FTN book on disk).
- Steffe, J. F., Rheological Methods in Food Process Engineering, Freeman Press, 1996 (Google Books page read: Introduction to Rheology, Ch. 1, and Tube Viscometry, Ch. 2).
- Rao, M. A., Rheology of Fluid and Semisolid Foods: Principles and Applications, Springer, 2010 (Google Books page read: Ch. 2, Flow and Functional Models for Rheological Properties of Fluid Foods, p. 27).