GIFSQ ID: KBA-0244
FOOD SAFETY AND QUALITY ASSURANCE: FOOD SAFETY MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS
Diagram
HACCP
Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points. Seven principles. Control sits at critical control points (CCPs). Built on Codex guidance and used around the world.
HARPC
Hazard Analysis and Risk-Based Preventive Controls. A written food safety plan under the Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA). Control sits at CCPs and at other preventive controls, and a Preventive Controls Qualified Individual (PCQI) oversees the plan.
Figure 1: HACCP is the older world system built on seven principles; HARPC is the wider plan required under FSMA, built from HACCP ideas.
Introduction
HACCP and HARPC both start from the same idea: study a food process, find the hazards, and control them before food reaches the eater. HACCP is a system built on seven principles, and its control sits at critical control points. HARPC is the food safety plan required under the Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) for most registered human food facilities, and it widens HACCP: it adds preventive controls beyond CCPs, covers more hazard types, and names a qualified person to oversee the plan. In short, HACCP is the method, and HARPC is the wider legal plan built from that method.
Table 1: Quick comparison of HACCP and HARPC
| Aspect | HACCP | HARPC |
|---|---|---|
| Full name | Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points | Hazard Analysis and Risk-Based Preventive Controls |
| Origin | Built in the 1960s for food made for space travel, then formalised by Codex Alimentarius | Created by the Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA), signed into law in 2011 |
| Legal basis | A world standard adopted into law for some foods, such as meat, poultry, seafood, and juice | The Preventive Controls for Human Food rule, 21 CFR Part 117 |
| Scope | One process at a time, in any food business that uses it | Most registered human food facilities, with limited exemptions |
| Hazard types | Biological, chemical, and physical | Biological, chemical, physical, radiological, and economically motivated adulteration |
| Control points | Critical control points (CCPs) only | CCPs plus other preventive controls: process, allergen, sanitation, supply chain, and other controls, plus a recall plan |
| Allergen controls | Not named as a separate control type | Named as a separate preventive control type |
| Qualified person | A trained HACCP team | A Preventive Controls Qualified Individual (PCQI) must develop or oversee the plan |
| Reanalysis | Reviewed when the process or a hazard changes | Reanalysis at least every three years, and sooner when a change needs it |
| Records | Monitoring, corrective action, and verification records | Written food safety plan with monitoring, corrective action, verification, and supply chain records |
Scientific explanation
Definition
HACCP is a system that studies a food process, finds the hazards that matter, and controls them at the steps where control works. HARPC is a written food safety plan that does hazard analysis and then sets risk-based preventive controls to minimise or prevent the hazards found. HARPC was developed using HACCP principles, but its parts are not identical to a HACCP plan.
Working principle
HACCP works through seven principles, in order: (1) conduct a hazard analysis; (2) find the critical control points; (3) set critical limits; (4) set up monitoring of each CCP; (5) set corrective actions for when a limit is missed; (6) set verification steps; (7) keep records. A CCP is a step where control can prevent, remove, or reduce a hazard to a safe level, such as heating milk to kill microbes.
HARPC works through five main parts: (1) hazard analysis, including a risk assessment; (2) risk-based preventive controls; (3) monitoring of the controls; (4) corrective actions; (5) verification. Its five preventive control types are process controls, food allergen controls, sanitation controls, supply chain controls, and other controls, and the plan also holds a written recall plan. Most CCPs in a HACCP plan fall under process controls in a HARPC plan.
Apparatus
The systems themselves use no apparatus. At a CCP, the monitoring instruments are the tools of the step itself, such as a thermometer at a pasteuriser and a clock for the holding time.
Measurement procedure
At a HACCP CCP, monitoring checks the critical limit, such as a temperature and time, while the step runs, and the result is written down. At a HARPC preventive control, monitoring checks that the control is working, such as checking allergen cleaning or a supplier record, and the result is written down. In both systems a failed check starts a corrective action.
Factors affecting readings
The result changes with the food, the process, the hazard, and the people. A high risk food, a long process with many steps, a hazard that is hard to kill, and untrained staff all make control harder. Records that are filled in late or from memory make the system look better than it is.
Formulas and calculations
This topic has no standard formula in the books used for this article, so no worked example is given here. Do not use a made up formula for this topic.
Industrial applications
- HACCP: meat and poultry plants, seafood plants, juice plants, dairy plants, and any food factory that builds a HACCP plan for its process.
- HARPC: most registered human food facilities, from bakeries and snack makers to large processors, that must hold a written food safety plan under FSMA.
- Both: a business that exports food often runs HACCP for its process and a HARPC style plan for its buyers, so the two sit side by side.
Advantages and limitations
HACCP advantages: focused, tested over decades, and accepted around the world; it names the one step where safety is decided. HACCP limitations: it covers CCPs only, so allergen, sanitation, and supplier controls sit outside the plan unless the business adds them.
HARPC advantages: wider cover, with allergen, sanitation, and supply chain controls inside one plan, and a named qualified person. HARPC limitations: it is a legal plan for registered facilities, so small exempt businesses are outside it, and it needs more records and more trained staff time.
FAQ
Is HARPC a replacement for HACCP?
No. HARPC is built from HACCP principles, and a HARPC plan still uses CCPs. It adds controls and duties around the HACCP core.
Which one applies to my factory?
That depends on the food, the market, and the law that covers the plant. Meat, poultry, seafood, and juice plants follow HACCP rules; most other registered human food facilities need a HARPC food safety plan.
What is a PCQI?
A Preventive Controls Qualified Individual: a person trained to develop and oversee the HARPC food safety plan.
Do both systems need records?
Yes. Both need monitoring records, corrective action records, and verification records. A plan with no records cannot be checked.
References and further reading
- FTN subject Food Safety and Security, Unit 4: HACCP and Prerequisite Programmes, and Unit 5: Food Safety Management Systems and Food Law.
- FTN subject Food Quality Control and Standards, Unit 12: HACCP, Food Safety Management Systems, Audits and Certification.
- Book on disk: Food Quality Assurance: Principles and Practices.
- Google Books: Sara E. Mortimore, HACCP: A Food Industry Briefing, which sets out the seven HACCP principles and the Codex basis.
- Government source (regulatory fact): United States Food and Drug Administration, Food Safety Modernization Act, Preventive Controls for Human Food rule, 21 CFR Part 117; and the United States Department of Agriculture HARPC and HACCP overview factsheet.