GIFSQ ID: KBA-0318
MEAT TECHNOLOGY: PRESERVATION OF MEAT
Diagram
Two ways salt and microbes preserve meat
Salt-cured meat
Salt, and usually nitrite, is added to the meat. The salt draws out water and the nitrite gives colour and stops harmful bacteria.
↓
Fermented meat
Salt is added too, but lactic acid bacteria are also at work. They eat sugars in the meat and make lactic acid, so the meat turns tangy and acid.
↓
The result
Both keep for a long time. Salt-cured meat keeps by salt and drying; fermented meat keeps by salt, acid and drying together.
Figure 1: Salt-cured meat is preserved by salt and nitrite; fermented meat is preserved by salt plus lactic acid from bacteria. Drawn in our own style from Geoffrey Campbell-Platt, Fermented Meats, and the Curing chapter (p. 46) of Pearson and Tauber, Processed Meats.
Introduction
Fermented meat and salt-cured meat are both preserved meats with a long shelf life, but the preserving work is done differently. Fermented meat is preserved by lactic acid bacteria, which make lactic acid and turn the meat tangy and acid, while salt-cured meat is preserved by salt and nitrite alone. Campbell-Platt covers fermentation as a preservation method for meat, and Pearson and Tauber cover curing in its own chapter (p. 46).
The core difference is the acid: fermented meat becomes acid as bacteria work, and that acid is part of what keeps it safe, while salt-cured meat stays near its natural acidity and relies on salt, nitrite and drying.
Quick comparison
Table 1: Fermented meat compared with Salt-cured meat
| Aspect | Fermented meat | Salt-cured meat |
|---|---|---|
| Preserving agent | Lactic acid bacteria plus salt | Salt, usually with nitrite |
| Acidity | Becomes acid: lactic acid lowers the pH and gives a tangy taste | Stays near the natural acidity of fresh meat |
| Key microbes | Lactic acid bacteria, added as a starter or present naturally | No microbes are wanted: salt and nitrite hold bacteria back |
| Flavour | Tangy, acid, complex, from fermentation | Salty, with the cured flavour from nitrite |
| Colour | Cured pink where nitrite is used, often darker from drying | Pink cured colour through the meat |
| Drying | Usually dried as well, so it keeps without chilling | Often dried as well for products such as country ham |
| Typical products | Salami, pepperoni, fermented sausages | Ham, bacon, corned beef, salt pork |
| Time to make | Days to weeks, while fermentation and drying run | Days to weeks, while the cure spreads and the meat dries |
| Needs a starter culture | Often, to make fermentation reliable | No |
| Storage | Often keeps at room temperature once dried | Often needs chilling unless dried hard |
Scientific explanation
Definition
Fermented meat is meat in which lactic acid bacteria turn sugars into lactic acid, lowering the acidity of the meat while salt holds back unwanted bacteria. Campbell-Platt treats fermentation as a preservation method for meat, set against preservation by salt and nitrate.
Salt-cured meat is meat preserved by salt, usually with nitrite or nitrate, without fermentation. Pearson and Tauber list the curing agents in the Curing chapter (p. 46): sodium chloride, nitrite, ascorbate or erythorbate, and possibly sodium phosphate, sucrose, dextrose or corn syrup and seasonings.
Working principle
Fermentation works because lactic acid bacteria eat the sugars in the meat and make lactic acid, so the pH falls and the meat turns acid. Most spoilage and harmful bacteria cannot grow well in acid, and the salt added at the start holds them back while the acid builds. Drying then takes away more water, so the finished sausage keeps for months.
Salt curing works because salt draws water out of the meat and lowers its water activity, and nitrite gives the pink colour and flavour and helps stop harmful bacteria. No acid is made, so the meat keeps its natural acidity and relies on salt, nitrite and drying alone.
Apparatus
Salt curing needs vats or tables for the cure and a cool room for the meat to rest. Fermented meat needs the same, plus a warm room where fermentation can run, and a drying room where temperature and humidity are controlled while the sausage dries. The books used here describe the methods rather than naming one standard instrument for either.
Measurement procedure
For salt-cured meat, the salt and nitrite mix is rubbed in or dissolved in brine, and the meat is held cool until the cure has spread through, then it is often dried or smoked. For fermented meat, minced meat is mixed with salt, sugars and a starter culture, stuffed into casings, held warm so the bacteria can make acid, and then dried slowly in a controlled room.
The books used here give the principles for both methods, but they do not give one single standard recipe for all products: the amounts and times change with the product being made.
Factors affecting readings
Temperature matters most for fermented meat: too cold and the bacteria work too slowly, too warm and the wrong bacteria grow. The amount of sugar sets how much acid can be made, and the salt level sets which bacteria can grow. For salt-cured meat, the salt and nitrite levels, the thickness of the piece and the drying conditions matter most.
Formulas and calculations
The books used for this article give no formula for this comparison, so none is given here. The comparison is qualitative: it rests on definitions, materials and method, not on a calculation.
Industrial applications
- Fermented meat is used for salami and pepperoni, where the tangy flavour is the point of the product.
- Fermented meat is used for dry sausages that keep without chilling, for shops and for travel.
- Salt-cured meat is used for ham and bacon, where the cured flavour and pink colour are wanted.
- Salt-cured meat is used for corned beef, where salt and nitrite preserve the meat in brine.
- Both are used where meat must keep for weeks or months without a fridge.
Advantages and limitations
- Fermented meat, advantage: the acid adds a second line of defence, so the product keeps well once dried, and the flavour is complex.
- Fermented meat, limitation: fermentation must be controlled, because the wrong temperature or salt level lets the wrong bacteria grow.
- Salt-cured meat, advantage: simple and reliable, with a steady result from the same cure.
- Salt-cured meat, limitation: relies on salt and nitrite alone, so it is saltier and has no acid to help it.
FAQ
Is salami a fermented meat?
Yes: salami is the classic fermented meat. Lactic acid bacteria make it tangy and acid, and drying then makes it keep without chilling.
Is bacon fermented?
No: bacon is salt-cured, not fermented. It is preserved by salt and nitrite, and it does not go through the acid making step that salami goes through.
Why does fermented meat taste sour?
Because lactic acid bacteria turn sugars in the meat into lactic acid, and that acid tastes tangy. The sour note is the sign that fermentation has happened.
Do fermented meats need a fridge?
A fully dried salami often keeps at room temperature, but once it is sliced, or if it is a softer fermented sausage, it should be chilled. Follow the label on the pack.
Can salt-cured meat go bad?
Yes: salt and nitrite slow bacteria but do not stop them for ever, and mould can grow on the surface. Salt-cured meat still needs the right storage, and drying or chilling, to keep well.
References and further reading
- A. M. Pearson and F. W. Tauber, Processed Meats, Springer, 2012 (Google Books page read)
- Geoffrey Campbell-Platt, Fermented Meats, Springer