GIFSQ ID: KBA-0278
FOOD PROCESSING AND PRESERVATION: COOKING METHODS
Deep frying and shallow frying: how much oil covers the food
Deep frying
Food fully submerged in hot oil, all sides cook at once, no turning
versus
Shallow frying
Food partly submerged in a thin layer of oil, one side at a time, turned over
Figure 1: Deep frying surrounds the food with oil, while shallow frying cooks one face at a time. The two boxes are alternatives, not steps in order.
Introduction
Deep frying and shallow frying both cook food in hot oil, but they differ in how much oil covers the food. In deep frying, the food is fully submerged in hot oil, so every side cooks at once and no turning is needed. In shallow frying, the food sits in a thin layer of oil and is only partly submerged, so one side cooks at a time and the food is turned over. Deep frying is faster and more even; shallow frying uses far less oil and suits flat pieces such as fish fillets and patties.
Quick comparison
Table 1: Deep frying compared with shallow frying
| Aspect | Deep frying | Shallow frying |
|---|---|---|
| Oil level | Food fully submerged in hot oil | Thin layer of oil; food only partly submerged |
| Oil temperature | Typically 160 °C to 200 °C | Hot oil in a pan, usually at the lower end of the frying range |
| Turning | No turning needed: all sides cook at once | Food is turned so each side cooks in turn |
| Speed | Fast: hot oil surrounds the whole piece | Slower: one side at a time |
| Crust | Even crisp crust all over | Crisp on the side in the oil; the top stays paler until turned |
| Oil use | Large volume of oil in the fryer | Small amount of oil in a pan |
| Batch size | Large: baskets or continuous fryers | Small: one layer in a pan |
| Typical foods | French fries, potato chips, doughnuts, chicken pieces | Fish fillets, patties, fritters, portion cuts of meat, vegetables |
| Equipment | Deep-fat fryer, batch or continuous, with baskets | Frying pan on a heater |
Scientific explanation
Definition
Deep-fat frying is a process of cooking and drying through contact with hot oil, and it involves simultaneous heat and mass transfer. Shallow frying is a hot oil-based cooking technique in which pieces of food are cooked by partial submersion in hot oil, usually in a frying pan.
Working principle
During deep-fat frying, a food product’s surface is sealed when the product is immersed in hot oil, so that all the flavours and the juices are retained in a crispy crust. The oil serves as a heat transfer medium between the food and the fryer, and provides the food’s texture and flavour characteristics. The surface water of the food boils off as steam, and the inside warms more slowly toward 100 °C, while the dried surface browns by the Maillard reaction between sugars and proteins. The inside stays soft while the outside turns crisp, because the piece is thin and the oil heat reaches it fast. In shallow frying, only the face in the oil browns hard, while the top face, exposed to air, cooks more gently and stays paler, which is why shallow fried food is turned. Oil that is too cool makes greasier food, because cool oil does not dry and set the surface quickly, so more oil soaks in.
Apparatus
A deep-fat fryer consists of a chamber where heated oil and a food product are placed. The frying oil is directly heated by electricity, gas, or fuel oil, and the product is placed in a basket and lowered into the oil. Batch fryers are static and smaller, used in catering and restaurants, with an oil capacity of about 8 to 11 litres for countertop models and 17 to 28 litres for standard models. Continuous fryers move large amounts of product through a moving bed of oil, and are used in the food industry. Shallow frying needs only a frying pan and a heater, with enough oil to cover the bottom of the pan.
Measurement procedure
Frying is checked by oil temperature and time. Thermostats or solid-state controllers hold the oil temperature, which depends on the product and the quality wanted, typically 160 °C to 200 °C for deep frying. The factors that affect the process are the temperature of the heated oil, the frying time, and the fryer type, batch or continuous. The chemical composition of the frying oils, the physical constants, and the presence of additives and contaminants also matter. Oil content in the finished product is measured after frying, and it rises with longer frying time.
Factors affecting readings
Oil temperature is the main control: hotter oil cooks faster and sets the crust sooner, while cooler oil gives greasier food. Frying time matters too: longer time means more water lost and more oil taken up. The type of oil matters, because the oil gives the flavour and must stand the heat without breaking down. In deep frying, the food is submerged, so the heat reaches all sides at once, while in shallow frying the top side cooks by air and by heat conducted through the food, so it lags behind until the piece is turned.
Formulas and calculations
Neither deep frying nor shallow frying has a standard formula given in the books for this comparison, so this section states that plainly instead of inventing one. The numbers that do govern frying are the oil temperature range, typically 160 °C to 200 °C for deep frying, and the rule that oil content rises with frying time and falls when the oil is hot enough to set the crust fast.
Industrial applications
- Deep frying: potato chips and french fries in continuous fryers, doughnuts, chicken pieces, and snack foods made in factories at large scale.
- Shallow frying: fish fillets, patties, and fritters in restaurants and small kitchens; portion cuts of meat and vegetables where a pan and a small amount of oil are enough.
Advantages and limitations
Deep frying, advantages: fast and even cooking on all sides; crisp crust all over; suits large batches and continuous lines. Limitations: uses a large volume of oil; needs a fryer and temperature control; oil breaks down with use and must be filtered and replaced; fried food softens as it picks up moisture and its oil slowly oxidises in storage.
Shallow frying, advantages: uses far less oil; needs only a pan; easy to control by eye; keeps more of the food’s own flavour. Limitations: slower, because one side cooks at a time; browning is uneven until the food is turned; suits only flat pieces and small batches.
FAQ
What is the main difference between deep frying and shallow frying? Deep frying submerges the food fully in hot oil, so all sides cook at once, while shallow frying cooks food in a thin layer of oil, partly submerged, one side at a time, and the food is turned.
What oil temperature is used for deep frying? Typically 160 °C to 200 °C, depending on the product and the quality wanted. Thermostats or solid-state controllers hold the temperature.
Why does cool oil make greasier food? Because cool oil does not dry and set the surface quickly, so more oil soaks into the food instead of being kept out by a crisp crust.
Why is deep fried food crisp outside and soft inside? Because the hot oil seals the surface into a crispy crust that holds the juices in, while the inside warms more slowly toward 100 °C and stays soft.
Is shallow frying the same as pan frying? Yes, in plain terms: shallow frying is also called pan frying, because it is done in a pan with a small amount of oil.
References and further reading
FTN subjects: Principles of Food Processing, Unit 2 (Heat Transfer and Thermal Processing); Confectionery and Snack Foods, Unit 4 (Traditional Snack Foods); Food Chemistry, Unit 12 (Browning in Foods). Books used: Irudayaraj, J., Food Processing Operations: Modeling, Design and Analysis, Chapter 5, Deep-Fat Frying of Foods, by Rosana G. Moreira; Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, which gives frying its own chapter.