GIFSQ ID: KBA-0310
DAIRY TECHNOLOGY: FAT RICH DAIRY PRODUCTS
Diagram
Butter and margarine side by side
Butter
A dairy fat: cream churned until the milk fat gathers into a solid.
↓
Margarine
A spread made from vegetable oil: the oil is hardened and blended with water, salt and flavour.
↓
The core difference
Origin. Butter is milk fat from an animal; margarine is made from plant oils.
Figure 1: Butter compared with margarine. Drawn in our own style from Sir Robert Hutchison, Food and the Principles of Dietetics, 1901, which compares butter and margarine composition. Note: this is an old source, and margarine recipes have changed a great deal since 1901, so the modern details in this article are stated only in general terms and the article says so plainly where the old source is the limit.
Introduction
Butter and margarine look alike on the bread: both are yellow, soft spreads that melt in a hot pan. They come from opposite places, and that is the whole difference.
The core difference is origin. Butter is milk fat, made by churning cream, and it is about 80 percent milk fat. Margarine is made from vegetable oils, which are hardened and blended with water, salt and flavourings to imitate butter. A plain warning belongs here: the only Google Books source found for this pair is from 1901, and margarine has changed a great deal since then, so this article gives the comparison in general terms and does not claim modern margarine numbers from that old book.
Quick comparison
Table 1: Butter compared with Margarine
| Aspect | Butter | Margarine |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Animal: milk fat from cream | Plant: vegetable oils such as soybean, palm or sunflower oil |
| Fat type | Milk fat, rich in saturated fat and short-chain fatty acids | Vegetable fat, blended to be spreadable |
| How it is made | Cream churned until fat gathers | Oils hardened and blended with water, salt and flavour |
| Fat content | About 80 percent fat | About 80 percent fat in table margarine, made to match butter |
| Water | About 16 percent water | About 16 percent water, added during blending |
| Flavour | Fresh, creamy, dairy flavour | Made to imitate butter, flavour added |
| Melting | Melts at about 32 to 35 degrees C, melts in the mouth | Melts at a similar temperature, made to match butter |
| Cholesterol | Contains cholesterol, as all animal fats do | Contains no cholesterol, as all plant fats do |
| Keeping | Needs refrigeration, keeps weeks | Needs refrigeration, keeps weeks |
| Main use | Spreading, baking, sauces, frying | Spreading, baking, frying, as a butter substitute |
Scientific explanation
Definition
Butter is the fat-rich dairy product made by churning cream until the milk fat gathers into a mass.
Margarine is a spread made from vegetable oils that are hardened and then blended with water, salt, colour and flavour to imitate butter.
Working principle
Butter forms because churning breaks the membranes around milk fat globules, so the fat joins together and the buttermilk drains away.
Margarine forms because liquid vegetable oils are hardened, in older recipes by hydrogenation and in modern recipes often by interesterification or by blending with solid fats, then mixed with water into a stable spread that behaves like butter.
Apparatus
A churn and a butter worker for butter.
For margarine, an industrial plant with oil hardening equipment, blending tanks and a packaging line. Margarine is not a home-made product.
Measurement procedure
For butter, churn cream until butter grains form, drain the buttermilk, and work the butter smooth.
For margarine, the books on disk and the 1901 source give no home procedure, because margarine is made in a factory. The general steps are hardening the oil, blending it with water, salt and flavour, and chilling the emulsion into a spread.
Factors affecting readings
The cream temperature decides butter churning: too cold is slow, too warm is greasy.
For margarine, the oils chosen and the hardening method decide whether the spread is soft or firm and how it melts. Recipes have changed over time, so a margarine from 1901 is not the same product as a margarine sold today.
Formulas and calculations
The books give no formula for this pair, and the 1901 source gives a composition comparison, not a formula.
The 1901 source compares the two by composition and notes butter at about 74 percent butyrin in its fat, a figure from that old analysis. Modern butter is described by its measured fat, about 80 percent, and modern margarine by its label, so no worked calculation is given here.
Industrial applications
- Butter: spreading, baking and sauces where a dairy flavour is wanted.
- Butter: finishing dishes and light frying.
- Margarine: spreading and baking as a lower-cost butter substitute.
- Margarine: frying and cooking where a plant-based fat is wanted.
- Both: pastry and cakes, with the choice made on flavour, price and diet.
Advantages and limitations
- Butter advantage: natural dairy flavour and a simple making process from one ingredient, cream.
- Butter limitation: higher in saturated fat and cholesterol, and it costs more.
- Margarine advantage: no cholesterol, often cheaper, and made from plant oils.
- Margarine limitation: its flavour is added to imitate butter, and its recipe has changed over the years, so the product varies.
FAQ
Is margarine healthier than butter?
It depends on the recipe. Margarine has no cholesterol, but butter is a simple dairy fat. The honest answer needs the label of the margarine in hand, because recipes differ.
Why does margarine look like butter?
It is made to imitate butter: colour and flavour are added so it looks and tastes like butter on bread.
Can I use margarine instead of butter in baking?
Yes, in most recipes, but the flavour will be different and the texture can change, because the fat behaves slightly differently.
Is margarine made from milk?
No. It is made from vegetable oils. Some margarines add a little milk or milk solids for flavour, so check the label if you avoid dairy.
Why is the source for this article from 1901?
It is the only Google Books source found that compares butter and margarine head to head. Margarine has changed a great deal since then, so this article states the comparison in general terms and does not present modern margarine numbers from that old book.
References and further reading
- Sir Robert Hutchison, Food and the Principles of Dietetics, 1901, full view, compares butter and margarine composition (Google Books page read)
- FTN books on disk: Fat Rich Dairy Products Technology, Technology of Fats and Oils (agrimoon dairy series).