GIFSQ ID: KBA-0351
CEREAL TECHNOLOGY: LEAVENING AGENTS
Diagram
Two white powders that make dough rise
Baking soda
Sodium bicarbonate alone. It needs an acid in the recipe to release carbon dioxide.
↓
Baking powder
Sodium bicarbonate plus a dry acid and starch. It carries its own acid, so it works with water and heat alone.
Figure 1: Baking soda needs an acid in the recipe, while baking powder carries its own acid. Drawn in our own style from the leavening agents discussion in Mathuravalli, Handbook of Bakery and Confectionery, Chapter 12, Leavening Agents, p. 78.
Introduction
Baking soda and baking powder are both white powders that make dough and batter rise, and they are often confused, but they work differently. Baking soda is sodium bicarbonate alone, and it only releases carbon dioxide when it meets an acid in the recipe, such as buttermilk, yogurt, vinegar or lemon juice. Baking powder is a complete mixture: sodium bicarbonate plus a dry acid and a little starch, so it carries its own acid and releases carbon dioxide when it meets water and heat, even in a recipe with no acid at all. Using one in place of the other without adjusting the recipe gives a flat bake, or a soapy taste.
Quick comparison
Table 1: Baking Soda compared with Baking Powder
| Aspect | Baking Soda | Baking Powder |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Sodium bicarbonate alone | Sodium bicarbonate plus a dry acid and starch |
| Needs an acid in the recipe | Yes, it needs an acid such as buttermilk or vinegar | No, it carries its own acid |
| Releases gas when | When it meets an acid and moisture | When it meets water, and again when heated |
| Gas released | Carbon dioxide | Carbon dioxide |
| Strength | Strong, a small amount gives a large rise | Weaker, because part of the powder is acid and starch |
| Taste if too much is used | Soapy and bitter, and the crumb turns yellow | Bitter and metallic, from the acid salts left behind |
| Effect on colour | Makes the crumb darker and helps browning, because it is alkaline | Little effect on colour |
| Used in | Recipes with an acid: buttermilk cakes, gingerbread, cookies with molasses | Recipes with no acid: plain cakes, scones, pancakes |
| Storage | Keeps well if kept dry | Needs dry storage, moisture starts the reaction |
| Swapping them | Cannot be swapped spoon for spoon: soda needs acid, and powder is weaker | Cannot be swapped spoon for spoon without changing the recipe |
Scientific explanation
Definition
Baking soda is sodium bicarbonate, an alkaline leavening agent that releases carbon dioxide only when it meets an acid. Baking powder is a complete leavening agent made of sodium bicarbonate, a dry acid and starch, which releases carbon dioxide when it meets water and again when it is heated.
Working principle
Baking soda works by an acid base reaction: sodium bicarbonate meets an acid in the batter, and the two react to give carbon dioxide gas, water and a salt. The gas forms bubbles that the batter traps, and the bubbles expand in the oven so the bake rises. If there is no acid, most of the soda stays unreacted and tastes soapy. Baking powder works in two stages: when it meets water, the dry acid dissolves and reacts with the bicarbonate to give a first release of gas, and when the batter is heated, a second acid in the powder reacts to give a second release. The starch keeps the powder dry in storage so the two parts do not react early.
Apparatus
The books used here name no laboratory apparatus for measuring or comparing either term, so no apparatus list is given.
Measurement procedure
The books used here give no standard laboratory procedure with volumes and steps for either term, so no procedure is invented here.
Factors affecting readings
For baking soda, the acid in the recipe decides the rise: without enough acid, the soda cannot react, and with too much soda the crumb turns soapy and yellow. For baking powder, the moisture and the oven heat decide the two stages of gas release, and the freshness of the powder decides its strength: old powder that has taken up moisture is weaker. In both cases the batter must be baked promptly, because the gas escapes if the batter stands.
Formulas and calculations
Baking soda with an acid, in words. Sodium bicarbonate + acid gives carbon dioxide + water + a salt. The carbon dioxide is the gas that lifts the batter.
Baking powder, in words. Sodium bicarbonate + dry acid + water gives carbon dioxide, and heat gives a second release of carbon dioxide from the second acid. The books used here give no amounts or ratios with numbers, so none are stated.
Industrial applications
- Baking soda: buttermilk cakes and gingerbread, where the acid in the recipe releases the gas.
- Baking soda: cookies with molasses or honey, where the acid in the syrup reacts with the soda.
- Baking soda: a pinch in tomato sauces and batters, where its alkalinity cuts acidity and helps browning.
- Baking powder: plain cakes, scones and pancakes, where the recipe holds no acid.
- Baking powder: batters and doughs that must rise in the oven without an acid ingredient.
Advantages and limitations
- Baking soda, advantage: it is strong, so a small amount gives a large rise, and it helps browning.
- Baking soda, limitation: it only works when the recipe holds an acid, and too much tastes soapy and turns the crumb yellow.
- Baking powder, advantage: it works in any recipe, because it carries its own acid, and it gives a rise in two stages.
- Baking powder, limitation: it is weaker spoon for spoon than soda, and too much leaves a bitter, metallic taste.
FAQ
What is the difference between baking soda and baking powder?
Baking soda is sodium bicarbonate alone and needs an acid in the recipe, while baking powder is bicarbonate plus a dry acid, so it works on its own.
Can I use baking powder instead of baking soda?
Only by changing the recipe. Baking powder is weaker, and it needs no acid, so a direct swap gives a different rise and taste.
What happens if I use baking soda with no acid?
Most of the soda stays unreacted, the bake rises poorly, and the crumb tastes soapy and turns yellow.
Why does baking powder work twice?
It releases gas when it meets water, then again when it is heated, because it holds two acids that react at different times.
Which one should I use for buttermilk cake?
Baking soda. The acid in the buttermilk releases the gas.
References and further reading
- Mathuravalli, S. M. D. Handbook of Bakery and Confectionery. CRC Press, 2021, Chapter 12, Leavening Agents, p. 78.
- Lane, Amy. The Baking Pocket Bible. 2011.
- Google Books pages read for this article:
- Mathuravalli, S. M. D. Handbook of Bakery and Confectionery. CRC Press, 2021 (Google Books page read)