Login Register

Access the GIFSQ Portal

Select your user type to log in or register a new account.

Student Portal

Access your food safety courses and exams.

Instructor Portal

Manage courses, view student submissions, and grade quizzes.

Company Portal

Manage corporate setup, view employee logs, and access QA services.

GIFSQ ID: FTN-0105

← All subjects

Sustainable Food Packaging

Unit 1: Why Packaging Matters and Why It Must Change

Note

Unit 1: Why Packaging Matters and Why It Must Change

A question to start with

A strawberry travels from a field to a shop, then to a kitchen, and it arrives whole, clean, and fresh. Without its punnet, it would be bruised, dusty, and soft by the time it reached the shop, and much of the crop would be thrown away. With its punnet, the strawberry is protected, but the punnet is thrown away after one use, and the plastic it is made from may last for centuries. Is the punnet a hero or a villain, and how do we keep the protection while losing the waste? This unit explains why packaging matters, why it must change, and how to judge a pack fairly.

Packaging is the material that holds, protects, and carries food from where it is made to where it is eaten. It keeps food clean, keeps it from drying out or getting damp, keeps air and light away where they would spoil it, holds it together so it can be carried, and tells the buyer what is inside. Without packaging, modern food would not travel, would not keep, and would not be safe to eat in the amounts and the places we expect. The food we eat depends on packaging more than most people realise.

The problem is not packaging itself: it is the amount of packaging, the materials it is made from, and what happens to it after use. Much of today's food packaging is made from plastic, used once, and then thrown away. Some of it is recycled, much of it is not, and a large share ends up in landfill, in rivers, or in the sea, where it breaks into smaller pieces and stays for a very long time. The packaging that protects food for a week can pollute for centuries, and that is the change this subject is about.

What packaging does for food

Packaging does five jobs, and a good pack does all five well. A sustainable pack must do them too, or the food it holds will be wasted, and wasted food is worse than a wasted pack.

Protection is the first job. A pack keeps food from being crushed, bruised, or broken, and keeps dirt, microbes, and insects out. A punnet protects soft fruit, a bottle protects a drink from spilling, and a sealed bag protects crisps from being crushed. Without protection, food is damaged, and damaged food is thrown away.

Preservation is the second job. A pack slows the changes that spoil food: it keeps moisture in or out, keeps oxygen away where oxygen would turn fats rancid, and keeps light away where light would fade colour or destroy vitamins. A vacuum pack keeps meat fresh for longer, a foil pouch keeps coffee fresh, and a sealed jar keeps jam safe for months. Preservation is the job that most directly saves food from waste.

Containment is the third job. A pack holds food together so that it can be carried, stacked, and stored. A liquid needs a bottle, a powder needs a bag, and a portion needs a tray. Without containment, food cannot be moved at all.

Communication is the fourth job. A pack tells the buyer what the food is, how much there is, what is in it, when it should be eaten by, and how it should be stored. The label is part of the pack, and a pack that cannot carry its label cannot be sold honestly.

Convenience is the fifth job. A pack lets a buyer carry food home, open it, use part of it, and keep the rest. A resealable bag, a portion pack, or a bottle with a cap all make food easier to use, and easier use means less food is wasted at home.

The cost of packaging

The cost of packaging is paid in materials, in energy, and in waste. The materials are the raw stuff of the pack: plastic from oil, paper from trees, glass from sand, metal from ore. Each material must be taken from the earth, processed, and made into a pack, and each step uses energy and water and produces waste and emissions.

The energy cost is the fuel and electricity used to make, fill, transport, and dispose of the pack. A light pack uses less energy to carry than a heavy one, which is why plastic, which is light, often beats glass, which is heavy, on transport, even though glass is easier to recycle. Judging a pack by one factor alone, such as whether it is plastic, misses the whole picture: the pack must be judged on its whole life, from making to disposal.

The waste cost is what happens after use. A pack that is recycled becomes a new pack or a new product. A pack that is composted becomes soil. A pack that is reused becomes a pack again. A pack that is thrown away becomes landfill, or litter, or pollution in water. The waste cost depends on what the pack is made from, what the buyer does with it, and what waste systems exist where the buyer lives. A recyclable pack in a place with no recycling is not recycled, whatever the label says.

Questions to think about

  • A strawberry punnet protects the fruit but is thrown away after one use. What would you change about the punnet, and what must not change?
  • Why is a light plastic bottle sometimes better for the environment than a heavy glass bottle, even though glass is easier to recycle?
  • A pack is labelled recyclable, but the town has no recycling for that material. Is the pack recyclable, and who is responsible?
Think about the punnet question before you read on

You could change the material, to a recycled or compostable material, or change the design, so that it uses less material or can be reused. What must not change is the protection: the punnet must still keep the strawberries from being bruised and dirty, or the fruit will be wasted, and wasted fruit is a larger harm than the pack. A sustainable pack is one that protects the food with the least material and the least harm, not one that protects less.

The food waste link: why less packaging can mean more waste

The most important idea in sustainable packaging is the link with food waste. Packaging protects food, and food that is protected is not wasted. Food that is wasted carries a larger harm than the pack that would have protected it, because growing, making, and moving food uses far more land, water, and energy than making its pack. A cucumber wrapped in a thin plastic film can last far longer than an unwrapped cucumber, and the film, though it is plastic, saves far more food than it weighs.

This means that removing packaging is not always the sustainable choice. A shop that removes the wrap from cucumbers may sell fewer cucumbers and throw more away, and the food waste will outweigh the plastic saved. The right question is not how to remove all packaging, but how to use the least packaging that still protects the food, and how to make that packaging from the best material and dispose of it in the best way.

The balance differs for each food. A hard food such as a potato needs little protection, and its pack can be light or none at all. A soft food such as a berry needs much protection, and its pack must be strong. A food that spoils quickly needs a pack that keeps air and moisture away, while a food that keeps well needs less. A sustainable pack is designed for the food it holds, not for a general idea of what a green pack should look like.

The life cycle view: judging a pack fairly

A pack should be judged on its whole life cycle: the materials taken, the energy used to make it, the energy used to carry it, the food it saves, and what happens to it after use. This way of judging is called life cycle assessment, and it is the tool that keeps sustainable packaging honest, because it stops a pack being judged on one feature alone.

Life cycle thinking gives results that surprise people. A glass bottle, reused many times, can be the best choice, but a glass bottle used once and thrown away can be worse than a plastic bottle, because glass is heavy to carry and needs much heat to make. A paper bag, which looks natural, can be worse than a plastic bag if it is used once, because paper is heavy and needs much water and energy to make. A compostable pack, which looks green, is only green if it is actually composted, and in a landfill it can produce methane, a gas that warms the climate.

The lesson is to ask for evidence, not for a look. A pack that looks green, because it is brown paper or because it says compostable, is not necessarily green. A pack that looks plain, because it is thin plastic, may save more food and use less energy than a pack that looks green. The only way to know is to look at the whole life cycle, and to ask the maker for the evidence behind the claim.

The five jobs of a pack, and the life cycle that judges it

Protection: keep the food whole and clean
↓
Preservation: slow spoiling, keep air, light, and moisture away
↓
Containment: hold the food so it can be carried and stored
↓
Communication: tell the buyer what is inside
↓
Convenience: easy to carry, open, use, and keep
↓
Judge the pack on its whole life: making, carrying, food saved, and disposal

The diagram shows the five jobs of packaging and the life cycle that judges them. The steps point to the diagram: a sustainable pack does all five jobs with the least material and the least harm over its whole life.

The change that is needed

The change needed in packaging has three parts, and each part is work for food professionals.

Use less is the first part. Packs should use the least material that still protects the food, and empty space in a pack should be removed. A pack that is half air is waste, and a pack that is thicker than it needs to be is waste too. Lightweighting, making a pack thinner and lighter while it still does its jobs, is the simplest change, and it saves material, energy, and transport at once.

Use better materials is the second part. Packs should be made from recycled materials where they are safe for food, from materials that can be recycled or composted where the systems exist, and from materials that do not carry harmful chemicals into food. PFAS free packaging, covered in Unit 5, is part of this change, because a pack that is sustainable for the planet must also be safe for the person who eats from it.

Deal with the end is the third part. Packs should be designed for what happens after use: easy to recycle, easy to reuse, or easy to compost, and the systems to do those things must exist where the pack is sold. A pack designed for recycling in a place with no recycling is not a sustainable pack, whatever the design says. The maker, the shop, and the waste system must work together, or the pack will be wasted.

The shape of the whole subject

This subject follows the pack from its purpose to its design. The next units look at the materials: paper based packaging, compostable and biodegradable materials, and reusable and refill systems. Then comes the safety side: PFAS free food contact materials, and migration, what moves from pack to food. The final unit brings it together: designing sustainable packaging, and balancing shelf life against footprint. Each unit stands alone, but together they give one picture: a pack must protect the food first, and protect the planet second, and the two jobs can be done together when the pack is designed for the food it holds and for the place it will be used.

Practical note: Pick three food packs from your kitchen: a plastic punnet, a paper bag, and a glass jar. For each one, write down its five jobs: what does it protect, what does it preserve, what does it contain, what does it communicate, and how convenient is it? Then write down its life cycle: what is it made from, how heavy is it, how far did it travel, and what will happen to it after use? Which pack does its jobs best for the food it holds, and which one would you change first?

Quick self-check

Question: Why can removing packaging increase harm rather than reduce it?

Because packaging protects food, and food that is not protected is wasted. Growing, making, and moving food uses far more land, water, and energy than making its pack, so the food waste from removing a pack can outweigh the plastic saved.

Question: What is life cycle assessment, and why does it matter for packaging?

It is a way of judging a pack on its whole life: materials, making, carrying, food saved, and disposal. It matters because a pack judged on one feature alone, such as whether it is plastic, can look green while its whole life is worse than a plainer pack.

The buyer is part of the pack

A sustainable pack only works if the buyer uses it as designed. A recyclable pack in the wrong bin is not recycled, a compostable pack in the landfill does not compost, and a reusable pack left at home does not replace a throwaway pack. The buyer is therefore part of the packaging system, not a bystander, and the pack must be designed for the buyer as well as for the food. Clear words, clear symbols, and a pack that is easy to empty, rinse, and sort all help the buyer to do the right thing. A shop that puts the right bins where buyers can see them, and a maker that prints the disposal instruction where the buyer will read it, both help the system work. The most sustainable pack in the world fails if the buyer cannot tell what to do with it, so the design must speak plainly to the person holding it.

Try it yourself

Go to a shop and look at the fresh produce section. Find a food sold loose, a food sold in a thin film, and a food sold in a rigid punnet. For each one, ask: does this food need this pack, or could it be sold with less? Write down your answer for each, and the reason: the food's softness, its shelf life, how far it travelled, and how it is carried home. Then ask a shop worker or a fellow shopper what they think, and note whether they agree. Bring your notes to class: which foods split opinion most, and why?

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Packaging holds, protects, and carries food, and without it modern food would not travel, keep, or stay safe.
  • A pack does five jobs: protection, preservation, containment, communication, and convenience.
  • The problem is the amount of packaging, the materials it is made from, and what happens to it after use.
  • Packaging saves food from waste, and wasted food carries a larger harm than the pack that would have protected it.
  • A pack must be judged on its whole life cycle, not on one feature such as whether it is plastic.
  • The change needed is to use less, use better materials, and design for the end: recycle, reuse, or compost, where the systems exist.

Glossary

Packaging

The material that holds, protects, and carries food from where it is made to where it is eaten. Food tech example: a punnet is the packaging that protects strawberries.

Punnet

A small tray or box that holds soft fruit so that it is not bruised. Food tech example: strawberries are sold in a punnet to keep them whole.

Preservation

Keeping food from spoiling by slowing the changes that make it unsafe or unpleasant to eat. Food tech example: a vacuum pack preserves meat by keeping oxygen away.

Life cycle assessment

A method of judging a product on its whole life, from materials to disposal. Food tech example: a life cycle assessment compares a glass bottle with a plastic bottle across making, carrying, and disposal.

Lightweighting

Making a pack thinner and lighter while it still does its jobs. Food tech example: a bottle made with less plastic is lightweighted.

Food waste

Food that is grown, made, or bought but never eaten, and is thrown away. Food tech example: an unwrapped cucumber that spoils quickly becomes food waste.

Recycling

Collecting a used material and making it into a new product. Food tech example: a used glass jar is recycled into a new jar.

Composting

Breaking down a material by microbes into soil, in a compost heap or a composting plant. Food tech example: a compostable pack breaks down in an industrial composting plant.

Landfill

A place where waste is buried in the ground. Food tech example: a pack thrown away may end up in landfill, where it stays for a long time.

Methane

A gas made when organic material breaks down without air, which warms the climate. Food tech example: a compostable pack in landfill can make methane.

Single use

Made to be used once and then thrown away. Food tech example: a single use plastic punnet is used once and then discarded.

Footprint

The total impact of a product on the environment, across its whole life. Food tech example: a pack with a small footprint uses little material and energy and causes little waste.

Shelf life

How long a food stays safe and good to eat when stored as directed. Food tech example: a vacuum pack gives meat a longer shelf life.

References

  • Robertson, G. L., Food Packaging: Principles and Practice, 3rd edition, 2012.
  • Coles, R., McDowell, D. and Kirwan, M. J., Food Packaging Technology, 2003.
  • Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Loss and Food Waste, 2019.
  • Verghese, K., et al., Packaging for Sustainability, 2015.
  • Pauer, E., et al., Life Cycle Assessment of Packaging, 2019.

Unit 2: Paper Based Packaging

Note

Unit 2: Paper Based Packaging

A question to start with

A bakery sells bread in a paper bag, coffee in a paper cup, and a sandwich in a paper wrap. The paper looks natural, feels friendly, and carries a claim about being better for the planet. But the cup has a thin plastic lining so that coffee does not soak through, the bag is printed with inks, and the wrap is coated so that butter does not stain it. Is paper packaging really better than plastic, and what hides inside the paper that a buyer cannot see? This unit explains paper based packaging: what it is, what it does well, where it fails, and how to judge it fairly.

Paper based packaging is packaging made mainly from paper, board, or cardboard: the fibres of wood or other plants, pressed into sheets. It includes paper bags, cardboard boxes, cartons for milk and juice, paper cups, paper wraps, and moulded fibre trays for eggs and fruit. It is the oldest packaging material after leaves and clay, and it is still the most used packaging material in the world by weight, because it is light, cheap, easy to print, and easy to shape.

Paper feels natural because it comes from trees, and trees grow back. That feeling is partly true and partly misleading. Paper is renewable when the trees are replanted, and it is widely recycled, and it breaks down in soil far faster than plastic. But paper also needs much water and energy to make, it is heavy to carry in large amounts, and it fails where food is wet, greasy, or hot, unless it is coated, and the coating is often plastic. Judging paper fairly means looking at the whole pack, not only at the fibre.

How paper is made, and what the fibre means

Paper starts as wood, or as other plant fibres such as straw, bamboo, or bagasse, the fibre left after sugar is pressed from cane. The wood is chipped, cooked, and beaten to separate the fibres, which are then washed, pressed, and dried into sheets. The sheets are cut, folded, and glued into bags, boxes, and cartons.

The fibre can be virgin, from new trees, or recycled, from used paper collected and reprocessed. Virgin fibre is stronger and cleaner, and it is needed for food that touches the paper directly, because recycled fibre can carry inks, glues, and other substances from its earlier life. Recycled fibre is used for outer boxes, for trays, and for packs where the food does not touch the paper, or where a barrier layer sits between the recycled fibre and the food. The share of recycled fibre in a pack matters: more recycled fibre means fewer new trees, but it also means weaker fibre and a need for care about what the recycled fibre carries.

The trees matter too. Paper from forests that are managed well, where trees are replanted and wildlife is protected, is different from paper from forests that are cleared without replanting. Certification marks on a pack, given by forest schemes, tell the buyer that the fibre came from a managed forest, but the buyer must trust the scheme, and the scheme must be checked. A pack that says nothing about its fibre gives the buyer no way to know.

What paper does well

Paper does several jobs well, and those jobs explain why it is used so widely.

Paper is easy to shape and to print. A box can be folded, a bag can be glued, a carton can be printed with a label, a logo, and a picture, all in one pass. That makes paper ideal for packs that must carry a lot of information, such as a cereal box or a milk carton, and for packs that must be made quickly in large numbers.

Paper is light for its strength. A cardboard box can hold a heavy food and still be light to carry, and a paper bag can hold bread without adding much weight. Lightness matters for transport, because a lighter pack uses less fuel to carry, and that saving counts in the life cycle of the pack.

Paper is widely recycled. In many places, paper and board are the most recycled packaging materials, because the collection systems are old, the sorting is simple, and the recycled fibre has value. A paper pack put in the right bin is likely to become a new pack, while a plastic pack put in the right bin may still be thrown away if the plastic is the wrong type or is too dirty.

Paper breaks down. A paper pack that ends up in soil or in water breaks down in weeks or months, not centuries, because microbes can eat the fibre. That does not make littering paper harmless, because a paper pack in a river is still litter, and its inks and coatings may not break down, but it does mean that paper does not build up in the environment the way plastic does.

Where paper fails: water, grease, and heat

Paper fails where food is wet, greasy, or hot, because paper is made of fibres that soak up water and grease. A paper bag holding wet bread goes soft, a paper cup holding hot coffee goes weak, and a paper wrap holding butter lets grease soak through. To fix this, paper is coated or lined, and the coating is where the judgement of paper gets complicated.

The common coatings are plastic, wax, and newer water based coatings. A plastic lining, often polyethylene, keeps water and grease out, but it makes the pack hard to recycle, because the plastic and the paper must be separated, and many recycling plants cannot do it. A paper cup with a plastic lining is therefore often thrown away, even though its paper could be recycled. A wax coating keeps grease out, but wax can carry its own substances into food, and it can stop the paper from composting cleanly.

Newer coatings try to solve this: water based coatings, coatings made from plant materials, and coatings that break down in composting. These are improving, but they are not yet as good as plastic at keeping water and grease out for a long time, and they cost more. A food business that switches to a paper pack with a new coating must test it: does it keep the food fresh, does it survive transport, and does it actually recycle or compost where the buyer lives? A claim on the pack is not proof.

Paper also fails where food needs a strong barrier against air. Oxygen passes through paper easily, so paper alone cannot keep fats from going rancid or keep coffee fresh for long. A paper pack that needs a barrier is therefore lined with foil or with plastic, and the lined pack is a mixed material pack, which is harder to recycle than paper alone. The milk carton is the classic example: paper, plastic, and foil layered together, each doing a job, and together hard to separate.

Questions to think about

  • A paper coffee cup has a thin plastic lining. Is the cup paper packaging or plastic packaging, and why does the answer matter for recycling?
  • Why is recycled fibre not used for all food packaging, even though it saves trees?
  • A bakery switches from plastic bags to paper bags for bread. What should it test before the switch, and what might go wrong?
Think about the coffee cup question before you read on

It is both, and that is the problem. The cup is mostly paper by weight, but the plastic lining is what makes it work, and the lining stops the paper from being recycled in most plants, because the two materials cannot be separated easily. For recycling, the cup is a mixed material pack, and it is usually thrown away. The answer matters because calling it a paper cup makes a buyer think it will be recycled, when in most places it will not be.

Cartons, cups, and moulded fibre

Three paper packs deserve a closer look, because they show the trade offs clearly.

The carton, used for milk, juice, and soups, is a layered pack: paper for strength, plastic for water resistance, and foil for a barrier against air and light. The carton keeps food fresh without refrigeration for a long time, which saves energy and food waste, and it is light to carry. But it is hard to recycle, because the layers must be separated, and only some plants can do it. A carton is a good example of a pack that saves food and energy while it is used, but is hard to deal with after use.

The paper cup, used for hot drinks, is a paper tube with a plastic lining and a rolled rim. It is light, cheap, and safe to hold, and it replaced the foam cup in many places. But it is also a single use pack that is rarely recycled, because of the lining, and because cups are thrown away in many places, not collected. Reusable cups are the sustainable answer for regular coffee drinkers, and the paper cup is the answer for the occasional drink, not for every day.

Moulded fibre, used for egg trays and fruit trays, is made from recycled paper pressed into a shape. It is a good use of recycled fibre, because the food does not need a strong barrier, and the tray protects the food from bruising. It is also easy to recycle again, because it is plain fibre with no lining. Moulded fibre shows what paper does best: a simple shape, from recycled fibre, for a food that needs protection but not a barrier.

How to judge a paper pack

A paper pack should be judged by five checks. First, what is the fibre: virgin or recycled, and from a managed forest? Second, what is the coating or lining, and does it stop the pack from being recycled or composted? Third, what is the pack's job: does it protect the food, and would a lighter pack do the same job? Fourth, what happens after use: is the pack collected, recycled, or composted where the buyer lives? Fifth, what does the life cycle say: does the pack, with its coating and its transport, beat the pack it replaces?

A pack that passes all five is a good paper pack. A pack that fails one, such as a cup with a plastic lining in a place with no cup recycling, is a pack that looks green but is not. The buyer can run the first four checks from the label and from local knowledge, and can ask the maker for the fifth.

Judging a paper pack

Fibre: virgin or recycled, from a managed forest?
↓
Coating: plastic, wax, or new coating, and does it block recycling?
↓
Job: does it protect the food, with the least material?
↓
After use: collected, recycled, or composted where the buyer lives?
↓
Life cycle: does it beat the pack it replaces, whole life to whole life?

The diagram shows the five checks for a paper pack. The steps point to the diagram: a pack that looks green but fails one check, such as a lined cup with no recycling, is not a sustainable pack.

Paper in the sustainable future

Paper will stay a major packaging material, because it is renewable, printable, and widely recycled. Its future is in better fibre, better coatings, and better design: more recycled fibre where it is safe, coatings that do not block recycling or composting, and packs that use less material and are easy to sort. The future is also in using paper where it works best, for dry foods, for outer boxes, and for trays, and in not forcing paper where it fails, for wet and greasy foods that need a barrier paper cannot give without a lining that spoils its recycling.

A food business that switches to paper should do it for the right reason: because the paper pack does the job with less harm over its whole life, not because paper looks green. The test is the five checks, and the evidence is the life cycle, not the colour of the pack.

Practical note: Collect three paper packs from your kitchen or a shop: a cardboard box, a paper bag, and a paper cup or carton. For each one, find the fibre, the coating, and the recycling claim on the pack, and check whether the pack is collected for recycling where you live. Write down which packs are truly recyclable in your place, and which ones only look recyclable. Bring your notes to class and compare: how many paper packs in your kitchen are recycled in practice?

Quick self-check

Question: Why does a plastic lining stop a paper cup from being recycled in most places?

Because the plastic and the paper must be separated before either can be recycled, and most recycling plants cannot separate them. The cup is a mixed material pack, so it is thrown away even though its paper could be recycled on its own.

Question: Why is virgin fibre still needed for some food packaging, even though recycled fibre saves trees?

Because recycled fibre is weaker and can carry inks, glues, and other substances from its earlier life. Food that touches the paper directly needs clean, strong fibre, so virgin fibre is used there, and recycled fibre is used for outer packs and trays.

Paper and the forest

Paper begins in a forest, and the forest decides much of the pack's footprint. A forest that is managed well grows trees, cuts some, replants, and keeps the soil, the water, and the wildlife healthy, so that paper can be made from it year after year. A forest that is cleared without replanting gives paper once and then gives nothing, and the land it leaves behind loses its soil and its wildlife. The difference is why forest certification matters: a mark on a pack tells the buyer that the fibre came from a forest that is managed, not from one that was cleared. The mark is not a guarantee by itself, because schemes differ and must be checked, but a pack with no mark and no claim about its fibre gives the buyer no way to know where the trees came from. A food business that buys paper should ask its supplier where the fibre came from, and should choose fibre from managed forests where it can, because the forest is the first step in the pack's life, and a pack that starts badly cannot end well.

Try it yourself

Take a paper pack from your kitchen and a plastic pack for the same kind of food, if you can find one. Compare them on the five checks from this unit: fibre or material, coating, job, after use, and life cycle. Which pack does its job better, and which one would you choose for the food? Then try a simple test: put a spoonful of water on a plain paper bag and on a coated paper cup, and watch what happens over ten minutes. What does the test tell you about why coatings are used, and what they cost in recycling?

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Paper packaging is made from plant fibres, pressed into sheets, and shaped into bags, boxes, cartons, cups, and trays.
  • Paper is renewable, printable, light, widely recycled, and breaks down far faster than plastic.
  • Paper fails with water, grease, and heat, so it is coated or lined, often with plastic, which can block recycling.
  • Virgin fibre is clean and strong for food contact; recycled fibre saves trees but is weaker and needs care.
  • Cartons, cups, and moulded fibre each show the trade off between protection and recycling.
  • Judge a paper pack on fibre, coating, job, after use, and whole life cycle, not on its look.

Glossary

Virgin fibre

Fibre from new trees, used for paper that touches food directly because it is clean and strong. Food tech example: a milk carton uses virgin fibre for its paper layer.

Recycled fibre

Fibre from used paper collected and reprocessed into new paper. Food tech example: an egg tray made from recycled fibre is moulded fibre packaging.

Board

Thick paper, used for boxes and cartons. Food tech example: a cereal box is made from board.

Carton

A layered pack of paper, plastic, and foil, used for milk, juice, and soups. Food tech example: a milk carton keeps milk fresh without refrigeration.

Coating

A thin layer on paper that keeps water or grease out. Food tech example: a plastic coating on a paper cup keeps coffee from soaking through.

Moulded fibre

Packaging made by pressing recycled paper fibre into a shape, such as an egg tray. Food tech example: a moulded fibre tray protects eggs from bruising.

Bagasse

The fibre left after sugar is pressed from cane, used to make paper and moulded fibre. Food tech example: a tray made from bagasse is a plant fibre alternative to wood paper.

Barrier

A layer that stops air, water, or light passing through a pack. Food tech example: foil in a carton is a barrier against air and light.

Mixed material pack

A pack made from two or more materials layered together, which is hard to recycle. Food tech example: a carton of paper, plastic, and foil is a mixed material pack.

Forest certification

A mark showing that paper fibre came from a forest that is managed well, with replanting and wildlife protection. Food tech example: a certification mark on a box tells the buyer its fibre came from a managed forest.

Life cycle assessment

A method of judging a product on its whole life, from materials to disposal. Food tech example: a life cycle assessment compares a paper cup with a reusable cup.

Single use

Made to be used once and then thrown away. Food tech example: a single use paper cup is used once and then discarded.

References

  • Robertson, G. L., Food Packaging: Principles and Practice, 3rd edition, 2012.
  • Coles, R., McDowell, D. and Kirwan, M. J., Food Packaging Technology, 2003.
  • Kirwan, M. J., Paper and Paperboard Packaging Technology, 2005.
  • Verghese, K., et al., Packaging for Sustainability, 2015.
  • Food and Agriculture Organization, Forest Products, 2020.

Unit 3: Compostable and Biodegradable Materials

Note

Unit 3: Compostable and Biodegradable Materials

A question to start with

A cafe serves coffee in a cup that says compostable, and a shop sells fruit in a film that says biodegradable. The buyer puts the cup in the compost bin and the film in the garden compost, feeling that both will turn to soil. Months later, the cup is still whole in the compost heap, and the film is still whole in the garden, because the words on the pack promised more than the material can do in that place. What do compostable and biodegradable really mean, and when do they help, and when do they mislead? This unit explains the materials, the words, and the systems that decide whether they work.

Two words are used for packs that break down, and they are often confused. Biodegradable means that a material can be broken down by microbes, such as bacteria and fungi, into water, carbon dioxide, known as CO₂, and soil. It does not say how long that takes, or where it happens, or what is left behind. A plastic that takes a hundred years to break down in soil is biodegradable in a loose sense, but it is not useful, and a plastic that breaks into tiny pieces without breaking down fully is not truly biodegradable, even if the pieces are too small to see.

Compostable means more: a material that breaks down in a composting system, within a set time, into soil, without leaving harmful residues and without harming the compost. Compostable is a testable claim: the material must pass a test that shows it breaks down in industrial composting, or in home composting, within the time the test sets, and that the compost it makes is safe to use on soil. A compostable pack that is not composted, because there is no composting system where the buyer lives, does not compost, whatever the label says.

The main compostable and biodegradable materials

Several materials are sold as compostable or biodegradable for food packaging, and each has its own strengths and limits.

PLA, short for polylactic acid, is a plastic made from plant starch, usually from maize or sugar cane. It looks and feels like ordinary plastic, it is clear, and it is used for cups, lids, and films. PLA is compostable in industrial composting, where the temperature is high and steady, but it does not break down well in a home compost heap, which is cooler, and it does not break down in soil or in the sea. A PLA cup in a landfill, or in a river, stays whole for a long time, and a PLA cup in recycling can spoil a batch of ordinary plastic recycling, because it looks like the plastic it is not.

PHA, short for polyhydroxyalkanoate, is a plastic made by microbes, which store it in their cells. PHA breaks down more widely than PLA: it can break down in soil, in home compost, and in sea water, though slowly, and it is used for films, bags, and coatings. PHA costs more than PLA and more than ordinary plastic, and it is made in smaller amounts, so it is used where its wider breakdown matters, not for every pack.

Starch based materials are made from maize, potato, or other starches, sometimes mixed with other biodegradable plastics. They are used for loose fill, for bags, and for films. They break down in compost and in soil, but they are weak with water: a starch bag that gets wet goes soft, and a starch film that holds wet food can fail. They are best for dry foods and for short use.

Cellulose films, made from wood pulp, are the modern form of the clear film once known as cellophane. They are used for wrapping biscuits, sweets, and dry foods. They break down in compost and in soil, and they can be made with a barrier against moisture, but the barrier coating can slow the breakdown, so the film must be tested as a whole, not only as cellulose.

Paper with a compostable coating is also in this group: a paper cup or wrap with a coating made to break down in compost, rather than a plastic lining. The coating must be tested with the paper, because a coating that breaks down slowly can leave the paper whole in the compost.

Industrial composting and home composting

Composting comes in two forms, and the difference decides whether a pack will break down.

Industrial composting is done in a plant, where the temperature is kept high, around 55 to 60 degrees Celsius, the moisture is controlled, and the material is turned and mixed. A compostable pack in an industrial plant breaks down in weeks, because the heat and the microbes work fast. Industrial composting needs collection: the pack must be put in a compost bin, collected, and taken to the plant. A pack that is compostable in a plant but is thrown in the bin for landfill will not compost.

Home composting is done in a garden heap, where the temperature is lower and less steady, the moisture varies, and the material is turned rarely. A pack that is home compostable must break down in those cooler, slower conditions, and it must pass a test for home composting, which is stricter than the test for industrial composting. Few packs pass the home test, and a pack that says compostable without saying which kind usually means industrial composting, not home.

Soil and sea are not composting. A pack that breaks down in a compost plant may not break down in soil, and a pack that breaks down in soil may not break down in the sea, where the water is cold and the microbes are few. A claim of biodegradable in the sea must be tested in the sea, and a claim of biodegradable in soil must be tested in soil. A buyer who puts a compostable pack in the sea, or in a garden, because the label says biodegradable, is using the pack in a place it was never tested for.

Questions to think about

  • A cup says compostable. What three questions should you ask before you put it in a compost bin?
  • Why does a PLA cup break down in an industrial plant but not in a home compost heap?
  • A film says biodegradable but gives no time and no place. What is wrong with that claim?
Think about the cup questions before you read on

First, which kind of composting: industrial or home? Second, is there a collection system where you live that takes the cup to a composting plant? Third, does the cup carry a certification mark that proves it passed the test for that kind of composting? If the answer to any of these is no, the cup will not compost, and putting it in a compost bin can spoil the compost with a pack that stays whole.

Certification, and how to read a claim

Because the words compostable and biodegradable are easy to misuse, certification schemes test materials and give marks that buyers can trust. A certification mark on a pack means the material passed a test for a named kind of composting, in a named time, and that the compost it makes is safe. The common marks name industrial composting or home composting, and they show a seedling or a similar symbol. A pack with no mark, and only the word compostable in plain text, has not been proved by a test the buyer can check.

A claim should be read in full. A good claim names the material, names the kind of composting, names the time, and carries a mark. A weak claim says only biodegradable, or says compostable without naming the kind, or says plant based, which is not the same as compostable: a plant based plastic can be made from plants and still not break down. Plant based describes the source, compostable describes the end, and the two must not be confused.

Greenwashing is the word for a claim that makes a pack look greener than it is, and compostable claims are a common place for it. A pack that is compostable in a plant but sold where there is no plant, a pack that is biodegradable in a hundred years, and a pack that is plant based but not compostable are all greenwashing when the label lets the buyer think otherwise. The defence is to ask for the mark, the kind, and the system, and to treat a claim without those as unproved.

When compostable packaging helps, and when it does not

Compostable packaging helps where it is used for food that is itself composted, and where the pack and the food go to composting together. A compostable bag for food waste, a compostable wrap for a sandwich that is eaten outdoors, and a compostable cup for a cafe that collects its cups for composting are all good uses: the pack and the food share one bin, and the pack does not need to be separated from the food.

Compostable packaging does not help where it is used for a food that is not composted, or where there is no composting system. A compostable pack for a dry food that could be sold in paper, or for a food that will be recycled, adds cost and confusion without adding benefit. It also does not help where the pack is likely to be littered, because a compostable pack in a river or a field does not compost, and it is litter just as a plastic pack is litter.

The most useful question for a food business is: where will this pack go after use, and does composting fit that place? If the pack will be collected for composting, a compostable pack is a good choice. If the pack will be recycled, a recyclable pack is better. If the pack will be reused, a reusable pack is better. The end decides the material, not the other way round.

From claim to compost

The claim: compostable, but which kind, and in what time?
↓
The mark: a certification that proves the test was passed
↓
The bin: put in compost collection, not landfill or recycling
↓
The plant: high heat, steady moisture, turned and mixed
↓
The soil: compost that is safe to use, with nothing harmful left

The diagram shows the chain from a compostable claim to real compost. The steps point to the diagram: break any link, the mark, the bin, or the plant, and the pack does not compost, whatever the label says.

Testing a compostable pack

A food business that wants to use a compostable pack should test it in three ways. First, test the pack with the food: does it keep the food fresh, does it survive transport, and does it hold up for the shelf life the food needs? A pack that fails with the food is not a sustainable pack, however well it composts.

Second, test the pack in composting: does it break down in the system where it will be collected, within the time the system needs, and does it leave the compost safe? The supplier should give the certification, and the business should check that the certification matches the system it will use.

Third, test the buyer: does the buyer understand the label, and will the buyer put the pack in the right bin? A pack that confuses buyers will be put in the wrong bin, and a compostable pack in recycling can spoil a batch of recycling, while a recyclable pack in compost can spoil a batch of compost. Clear words, clear colours, and clear bins are part of the pack, not an extra.

Practical note: Look at the packs in your kitchen or a shop that say compostable, biodegradable, or plant based. For each one, write down the exact words, whether it carries a certification mark, whether it names industrial or home composting, and whether there is a collection system where you live that would take it. How many packs pass the test, and how many carry a claim without the proof behind it?

Quick self-check

Question: What is the difference between biodegradable and compostable?

Biodegradable means microbes can break a material down, without saying how long it takes or where it happens. Compostable means the material breaks down in a named composting system, within a set time, into safe soil. Compostable is the stricter and testable claim.

Question: Why is a PLA cup a problem in recycling, even though it looks like ordinary plastic?

Because PLA looks like the plastic used for bottles, but it is a different material, and it melts at a different temperature. A PLA cup in a batch of ordinary plastic recycling can spoil the batch, so it must be kept apart, and most recycling plants cannot tell it apart by eye.

Compostable packaging and food waste together

Compostable packaging works best when it is collected with food waste, because the pack and the food share one bin and one journey to the plant. A compostable bag that holds vegetable peelings, a compostable wrap that holds a sandwich eaten outdoors, and a compostable cup that holds coffee grounds all go to composting with the food they held, and the plant turns both into soil. This shared journey is the strongest case for compostable packaging, and it is why cafes, canteens, and festivals that collect food waste are the places where compostable packs make most sense. Where food waste is not collected, a compostable pack has no shared journey, and it is likely to be thrown away with general waste, where it does not compost. The lesson for a food business is to match the pack to the collection: if the business collects food waste for composting, a compostable pack fits; if it does not, a recyclable or reusable pack fits better.

Home composting or industrial composting: a decision guide

A compostable pack is only compostable in the right place, and the buyer must choose between home composting and industrial composting with care. Home composting is a heap or bin in a garden, kept warm by the microbes inside it, but it rarely passes 40 to 50 degrees Celsius, and it is turned by hand. Industrial composting is a large plant with controlled heat, moisture, and turning, reaching 55 to 70 degrees Celsius for days at a time.

The guide is simple. A pack certified for home composting can go in a home heap, because it was tested to break down at the lower heat of a home heap. A pack certified only for industrial composting must go to an industrial plant, and it will not break down in a home heap in any reasonable time. A pack with no certificate should go in neither, because its claim has not been tested.

Three checks settle the question for any pack. First, read the certificate: does it name home composting or industrial composting, and which standard was used? Second, check the stream: is there a food waste collection in your area that takes compostable packs to an industrial plant? Third, check the pack: is it free of the inks, glues, and coatings that a composting plant would reject? A pack that passes all three can be composted with confidence. A pack that fails any one of them should go in the bin its label names, and the buyer should ask the seller why it was sold as compostable where no composting exists.

Try it yourself

Take a compostable pack, if you can find one, or a pack that claims to be plant based. Write a short report on it: what is the material, what does the label claim, what certification mark does it carry, and where would it go after use in your town? Then write a verdict: is the claim proved, and would you recommend the pack to a small food business? Bring your report to class and compare: which packs earned a recommendation, and which ones were greenwashing?

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Biodegradable means microbes can break a material down, without a time or a place; compostable means it breaks down in a named composting system, in a set time, into safe soil.
  • PLA is compostable in industrial plants but not in home heaps; PHA breaks down more widely but costs more; starch and cellulose films suit dry foods and compost.
  • Industrial composting is hot and fast; home composting is cooler and slower, and few packs pass the home test.
  • A claim should name the material, the kind of composting, the time, and carry a certification mark.
  • Plant based is not the same as compostable: one describes the source, the other describes the end.
  • Compostable packaging helps where the pack and the food go to composting together, and where a collection system exists.

Glossary

Biodegradable

Able to be broken down by microbes into water, carbon dioxide, and soil, without a stated time or place. Food tech example: a plastic that takes a hundred years to break down in soil is biodegradable in a loose sense, but not useful.

Compostable

Able to break down in a named composting system, within a set time, into safe soil. Food tech example: a PLA cup is compostable in industrial composting, where the temperature is high.

PLA

Polylactic acid, a plastic made from plant starch, compostable in industrial plants. Food tech example: a clear PLA cup holds cold drinks and is collected for industrial composting.

PHA

Polyhydroxyalkanoate, a plastic made by microbes, which breaks down in soil, compost, and sea water. Food tech example: a PHA film wraps food and breaks down more widely than PLA.

Industrial composting

Composting in a plant, where temperature and moisture are controlled and the material breaks down in weeks. Food tech example: a compostable pack is taken to an industrial plant in a compost collection.

Home composting

Composting in a garden heap, cooler and slower than industrial composting. Food tech example: few packs pass the test for home composting.

Certification mark

A mark on a pack showing that it passed a test for a named kind of composting. Food tech example: a seedling mark on a cup proves it passed the industrial composting test.

Greenwashing

A claim that makes a pack look greener than it is. Food tech example: a pack that says biodegradable without a time or a place is greenwashing.

Cellulose film

A clear film made from wood pulp, used for wrapping dry foods. Food tech example: a cellulose film wraps biscuits and breaks down in compost.

Starch based material

A material made from maize, potato, or other starches, used for bags and films. Food tech example: a starch based bag holds dry goods and breaks down in compost.

Carbon dioxide

A gas made when microbes break down a material, with the formula CO₂. Food tech example: composting turns a pack into water, CO₂, and soil.

Loose fill

Small pieces of packing material used to fill empty space in a box. Food tech example: starch based loose fill protects a jar in a box and breaks down in compost.

References

  • Robertson, G. L., Food Packaging: Principles and Practice, 3rd edition, 2012.
  • Coles, R., McDowell, D. and Kirwan, M. J., Food Packaging Technology, 2003.
  • Verghese, K., et al., Packaging for Sustainability, 2015.
  • Narayan, R., Biobased and Biodegradable Plastics, 2017.
  • European Bioplastics, Bioplastics Facts and Figures, 2021.

Unit 4: Reusable and Refill Systems

Note

Unit 4: Reusable and Refill Systems

A question to start with

A cafe sells coffee in a paper cup every morning to the same commuters. Each cup is used for ten minutes and then thrown away. One commuter brings a steel cup, has it filled, and uses it for years. Another commuter borrows a cup from the cafe, returns it the next day, and the cafe washes it and lends it again. Which of the three is the most sustainable, and how many times must a reusable cup be used before it beats the throwaway cup? This unit explains reusable and refill systems: how they work, when they beat single use, and what makes them succeed or fail.

Reusable packaging is packaging that is used more than once for the same job: a bottle that is returned, washed, and refilled; a box that is sent back and used again; a cup that is borrowed and returned. Refill is a form of reuse: a buyer brings a container and fills it at a shop, or buys a refill pack that tops up a container kept at home. Both aim at the same goal: to get more uses from each pack, so that fewer packs are made, carried, and thrown away.

The idea is old. Milk bottles were returned and refilled for generations, and shoppers carried baskets and bags to market long before plastic bags. The idea is returning now because single use packaging has grown so large, and because the waste it makes is so visible. The challenge is to make reuse work in a modern food system, where food travels far, must stay safe, and must be convenient to buy.

Why reuse beats single use, and when it does not

A reusable pack uses more material and more energy to make than a single use pack, because it must be strong enough to survive many uses and many washes. A steel cup uses more metal and more energy than a paper cup. A glass bottle uses more sand and more heat than a plastic bottle. If the reusable pack is used only once or twice and then thrown away, it is worse than the single use pack, because its extra material and energy were wasted.

Reuse wins when the pack is used many times. The point where the reusable pack beats the single use pack is called the break even point, and it differs for each pack. A reusable shopping bag may break even after a few uses. A steel cup may need many uses. A glass bottle may need a dozen or more returns. The exact number depends on the material, the weight, the washing, and the transport, and it should be worked out by life cycle assessment, not guessed.

Washing is part of the cost. A reusable pack must be washed between uses, and washing uses water, energy, and detergent. A pack that is washed with hot water and harsh chemicals may lose part of its advantage, and a pack that is carried far to be washed may lose more. The washing must also be safe: a pack that is not washed well can carry microbes from one user to the next, and a food business that reuses packs must prove that its washing works.

Transport is the other part. A reusable pack must travel back to be washed and refilled, and that return journey uses fuel. A local reuse system, where packs are returned to the same shop and washed nearby, beats a system where packs travel far to a central wash plant. The best reuse systems are local, simple, and built around foods that are bought often and near home.

The main reuse models

Reuse systems fall into four models, and each fits a different food and a different place.

Return and refill at the shop is the first model. The buyer brings a container, or buys one at the shop, and fills it from a bulk dispenser: grains, oils, soaps, and dry foods are sold this way. The buyer owns the container, washes it at home, and brings it back. The shop must keep the dispensers clean, must label the food, and must make sure the buyer's container is clean and safe for food. The model works best for dry foods and for shops where buyers come often.

Borrow and return is the second model. The buyer borrows a cup, a box, or a bottle from a cafe or a restaurant, pays a deposit, and returns it later for the deposit back. The business washes the pack and lends it again. The model works best for drinks and for takeaway food, where the buyer eats nearby and can return the pack easily. The deposit must be high enough that buyers return the pack, but low enough that they will borrow it in the first place.

Return to the maker is the third model. The buyer returns a bottle or a jar to the shop, the shop sends it back to the maker, the maker washes and refills it, and sells it again. This is the old milk bottle model, and it still works for drinks and for jars where the maker is near the shop. The model needs a collection system, a wash plant, and a way to check each returned pack for damage.

Refill at home is the fourth model. The buyer keeps a durable container at home, such as a pump bottle or a jar, and buys a refill pack, often a light pouch, to top it up. The refill pack uses less material than a new container, and the durable container is used many times. The model works best for liquids and for foods used every day at home, and it needs a refill pack that is itself recyclable or compostable, or the saving is lost.

Questions to think about

  • A steel cup needs many uses to beat a paper cup. What would make a buyer actually use it that many times?
  • A cafe lends cups with a deposit. Why does the deposit matter, and what happens if it is too low?
  • Why does a local reuse system often beat a system where packs travel far to be washed?
Think about the steel cup question before you read on

The cup must be convenient to carry, pleasant to drink from, easy to wash, and part of the buyer's habit. A cup that is heavy, that leaks, or that is hard to clean will be left at home, and the buyer will take a paper cup instead. The break even point is not only a number: it is a habit, and the cup must earn its place in the buyer's daily routine before it can beat the throwaway cup.

Safety and hygiene in reuse

Reuse raises safety questions that single use does not, and they must be answered before a system starts. The first question is washing: how is the pack washed, at what temperature, with what detergent, and how is it proved clean? A pack that held milk must be washed so that no milk remains, because old milk can grow microbes. A pack that held a food with an allergen, such as peanut, must be washed so that no allergen remains for the next user.

The second question is damage: how is a returned pack checked for cracks, chips, and wear? A cracked bottle can break, a chipped cup can cut, and a worn pack can shed pieces into food. Each returned pack must be inspected, and damaged packs must be taken out of use. The inspection must be quick, because the system must handle many packs, but it must be real, because a missed crack can harm a buyer.

The third question is the buyer's container: when a buyer brings their own container, who is responsible for its cleanliness? The shop can refuse a dirty container, can offer to wash it, or can fill only containers that meet a standard. The rules for this differ from place to place, and a food business should check the current rule where it works, rather than guessing. The shop must also label the food it sells in a buyer's container, so that the buyer knows what is inside, how much there is, and when it should be eaten by.

The fourth question is traceability: if a batch of food is found to be wrong, can the packs be traced? A reuse system must keep records of which packs held which batch, so that a recall can reach the right packs. A system with no records cannot recall, and a system that cannot recall cannot be trusted with food.

What makes a reuse system succeed

Reuse systems succeed when they are convenient, cheap, and trusted. Convenience is first: the return point must be where the buyer already goes, the deposit must be easy to pay and get back, and the pack must be easy to carry and to use. A system that asks the buyer to travel far to return a pack, or to queue for a deposit, will fail, however green it is.

Cost is second: the reusable pack must not cost the buyer much more than the single use pack, or the buyer will choose the cheaper one. A deposit that is returned in full costs the buyer nothing if they return the pack, and a refill that is cheaper than a new pack gives the buyer a reason to refill. A system that costs the buyer more for the same food will need a buyer who cares enough to pay, and most buyers will not pay more for the same food every day.

Trust is third: the buyer must trust that the pack is clean, that the food is safe, and that the system really reuses the pack rather than throwing it away. Trust is built by clean packs, by clear labels, and by openness: showing the washing, naming the system, and publishing the return rate. A system that hides its washing or its return rate will be doubted, and doubt kills reuse.

Design is fourth: the pack must be designed for reuse, not only for single use. It must be strong, easy to wash, easy to stack, and easy to tell apart from a single use pack. It must also be designed for the food it holds: a cup for hot drinks must not burn the hand, a box for takeaway must not leak, and a bottle for a drink must keep the drink fresh. A pack that is hard to use will not be reused, however well it is designed for the planet.

How a borrow and return cup works

Buyer borrows a cup and pays a deposit
↓
Buyer drinks, then returns the cup to the cafe
↓
Deposit is given back in full
↓
Cup is inspected for damage, then washed hot and clean
↓
Cup is lent again, and the count of uses grows

The diagram shows the borrow and return loop. The steps point to the diagram: the loop only beats a throwaway cup when the cup is returned, washed, and lent many times, so the deposit, the washing, and the inspection must all work.

Reuse in the wider food system

Reuse is growing in food, but it is still a small share of packaging, and it will grow where it fits best: drinks, takeaway food, and dry goods bought often and near home. It will grow more slowly where food travels far, where it must stay sterile, or where the pack must be very light to carry. A food business should ask where reuse fits its food, rather than forcing reuse where it does not fit.

The future of reuse is in systems, not in single packs. A single cafe that lends cups will struggle, because buyers who borrow in one place cannot return in another. A network of cafes that share the same cup, with return points in many places, will succeed, because the buyer can return the cup wherever they are. The same is true for bottles and boxes: a shared system, with a shared deposit and shared washing, beats a lonely system. Food businesses, shops, and towns that build shared systems together will make reuse work, while businesses that act alone will find it hard.

Practical note: Count the single use packs you use in a week: cups, bags, bottles, and takeaway boxes. For each one, write whether a reusable version exists, where you would return it, and how many times you would need to use it to make it worth carrying. Then pick one pack and try the reusable version for a week. Write down what was easy, what was hard, and whether you would keep using it. Bring your notes to class: which packs were easiest to replace, and which ones resisted reuse?

Quick self-check

Question: What is the break even point for a reusable pack?

The number of uses after which the reusable pack beats a single use pack on its whole life impact. A reusable pack uses more material and energy to make, so it must be used many times before the saving from not making a new pack each time outweighs the extra making cost.

Question: Why must a returned pack be inspected, not only washed?

Because washing does not fix damage. A cracked bottle can break, a chipped cup can cut, and a worn pack can shed pieces into food. Inspection takes damaged packs out of use, so that only safe packs are lent again.

Try it yourself

Design a reuse system for a food you buy often: coffee, takeaway lunch, milk, or dry grains. Write a one page plan: which model would you use, what pack would you choose, what deposit would you set, where would buyers return the pack, how would it be washed and inspected, and how would you tell buyers about it? Then write the three things most likely to go wrong, and what you would do about each one. Bring your plan to class and compare: which systems were simplest, and which ones needed the most work to make them convenient?

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Reusable packaging is used more than once for the same job; refill is a form of reuse where a buyer tops up a container kept at home.
  • A reusable pack uses more material and energy to make, so it must be used many times to beat a single use pack.
  • The break even point differs for each pack, and it must be worked out by life cycle assessment.
  • The main models are refill at the shop, borrow and return, return to the maker, and refill at home.
  • Safety needs washing that works, inspection for damage, rules for buyers' own containers, and records for recall.
  • Reuse succeeds when it is convenient, cheap, trusted, and designed for the food and for washing.
  • Shared systems, with return points in many places, beat lonely systems.

Glossary

Reusable packaging

Packaging used more than once for the same job. Food tech example: a glass bottle returned, washed, and refilled is reusable packaging.

Refill

Topping up a container kept at home or brought to a shop, instead of buying a new container. Food tech example: a buyer refills a jar with grains from a bulk dispenser.

Break even point

The number of uses after which a reusable pack beats a single use pack on whole life impact. Food tech example: a steel cup breaks even after many uses.

Deposit

Money paid when borrowing a reusable pack, given back when the pack is returned. Food tech example: a deposit on a borrowed cup is returned in full when the cup comes back.

Bulk dispenser

A container in a shop from which buyers fill their own containers with dry food or liquid. Food tech example: a bulk dispenser lets buyers fill a jar with rice.

Borrow and return

A reuse model where a buyer borrows a pack, pays a deposit, and returns it for the deposit back. Food tech example: a cafe lends a cup that the buyer returns the next day.

Return to the maker

A reuse model where a pack is sent back to the maker, washed, refilled, and sold again. Food tech example: a milk bottle returned to the maker is washed and refilled.

Traceability

The ability to follow a food back through its supply chain to its origin, using records at each step. Food tech example: a reuse system keeps records so that a batch can be recalled.

Life cycle assessment

A method of judging a product on its whole life, from materials to disposal. Food tech example: a life cycle assessment finds the break even point for a reusable cup.

Single use

Made to be used once and then thrown away. Food tech example: a single use paper cup is used once and then discarded.

Hygiene

Keeping food and packs clean so that microbes do not grow or spread. Food tech example: hygiene in a reuse system means washing each returned pack hot and clean.

Allergen

A substance in food that can cause an allergic reaction in some people. Food tech example: a reused pack must be washed so that no allergen remains for the next user.

References

  • Robertson, G. L., Food Packaging: Principles and Practice, 3rd edition, 2012.
  • Verghese, K., et al., Packaging for Sustainability, 2015.
  • Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Loss and Food Waste, 2019.
  • Ellen MacArthur Foundation, Reuse: Rethinking Packaging, 2019.
  • Coelho, P. M., et al., Reusable Packaging Systems, 2020.

Unit 5: PFAS Free and Safe Food Contact Materials

Note

Unit 5: PFAS Free and Safe Food Contact Materials

A question to start with

A burger is served in a paper wrapper that keeps grease from soaking through to your hands. The wrapper works well, but the chemical that makes it grease resistant can move into the burger, more so when the burger is hot and greasy. The wrapper is thrown away after one meal, but the chemical stays in the body for years. How do you keep grease out of your hands without putting a lasting chemical into food, and what should a food business use instead? This unit explains safe food contact materials, why PFAS free matters, and how to choose a pack that is safe for the person who eats from it.

A food contact material is any material that touches food: packaging, wrappers, cups, trays, cookware, utensils, and the surfaces food is made on. The material must do its job without moving harmful substances into the food. That movement is called migration, and it is covered in detail in Unit 6, but the principle belongs here too: a safe food contact material is one that migrates little, and migrates nothing harmful, under the conditions it will be used in.

PFAS, the family of chemicals covered in the Food Fraud subject, is the most talked about food contact problem today, because it was used to make paper grease resistant, and because it does not break down. But PFAS is not the only concern: plastics can release additives, metals can release elements, paper can release inks and coatings, and glass and ceramics can release lead and cadmium where they are made badly. A safe pack is judged on all of these, not on one chemical alone.

What PFAS does in packaging, and why it is being removed

PFAS was used in food packaging to make paper and board resist grease and water. A takeaway box, a burger wrapper, a popcorn bag, a bakery paper, and a pizza box could all carry PFAS, so that grease did not soak through and the pack stayed clean to hold. The treatment worked well, and it was cheap, so it was used widely for many years.

The problem, explained in the Food Fraud subject, is that PFAS does not break down, that it moves from the pack into food, more so when the food is hot, greasy, and in contact for a long time, and that it builds up in the body over years. The amounts from one meal are small, but the exposure is repeated, meal after meal, and the total adds up. That is why many food businesses, and many regulators, have moved to remove PFAS from food packaging, and why PFAS free is now a claim buyers look for.

Removing PFAS is not as simple as taking it out and leaving the paper bare, because bare paper soaks up grease. The pack must still do its job, so a replacement is needed: a different coating, a different material, or a different design. The replacement must be tested for safety as well as for grease resistance, because a replacement that migrates a different harmful substance is not an improvement.

PFAS free alternatives, and how to judge them

Several alternatives to PFAS in paper packaging are now used, and each has its own strengths and limits.

Water based coatings are the most common. They are applied to paper like a paint, and they form a barrier that keeps grease and water out. They are made from plant based polymers or from other water soluble materials, and they break down more easily than PFAS. They work well for short contact, such as a sandwich wrap or a bakery paper, but they can fail with very hot, very greasy food held for a long time, so they must be tested for the food they will hold.

Plant based barriers use materials such as starch, cellulose, or other plant fibres to make a grease resistant layer. They are compostable in many cases, and they are made from renewable sources, but they can be weaker with water, and they cost more than PFAS treatment. They suit dry and lightly greasy foods best.

A different material altogether is another answer: a pack made from a material that does not need a grease treatment, such as a moulded fibre tray, a metal tray, or a plastic tray that is recyclable. Changing the material can be simpler than finding a new coating, but it changes the pack's weight, its cost, and its disposal, so the whole life cycle must be judged again.

A different design is the simplest answer of all: a pack that does not need to resist grease, because the food does not touch it, or because the food is held in a way that grease cannot soak through. A burger in a box with a grease resistant base and plain sides, or a sandwich in a wrap with a small grease resistant patch where the filling sits, uses less treated material than a fully treated pack. Design can reduce the need for a coating, and that is often the cheapest and safest change.

How to judge a PFAS free claim

A PFAS free claim should be judged by three checks. First, is the claim proved? The maker should be able to show a test result that the pack carries no PFAS, or carries it below a level that can be detected, and the test should cover the whole pack, not only the paper. A claim without a test is a promise, not a proof.

Second, what replaced the PFAS? The maker should be able to name the replacement and show that it is safe for food contact, and that it does not migrate harmful substances into food. A pack that is PFAS free but carries a different harmful coating is not a safe pack.

Third, does the pack still do its job? A PFAS free pack that lets grease soak through, or that falls apart with hot food, will be thrown away and replaced, and the food it held may be wasted. The pack must be tested with the food it will hold, for the time and the temperature it will be used at, before it is chosen.

A buyer can ask for the first two checks, and can test the third by using the pack. A food business should ask for all three in writing from its supplier, and should keep the answers on file, so that if a pack is questioned, the business can show what it asked and what it was told.

Questions to think about

  • A takeaway box says PFAS free. What three things should you ask before you trust the claim?
  • Why is a pack that is PFAS free but lets grease soak through not a good pack?
  • A supplier replaces PFAS with a new coating but cannot name what the coating is. What should the buyer do?
Think about the first question before you read on

First, is the claim proved by a test, and does the test cover the whole pack? Second, what replaced the PFAS, and is the replacement safe for food contact? Third, does the pack still do its job with hot greasy food for the time it will be used? A claim that passes all three is trustworthy; a claim that fails any one of them is not.

Other safe food contact materials

PFAS is the headline, but a safe food business checks all its food contact materials.

Plastics used for food must be made for food contact, and must be used as directed: a plastic made for cold food should not hold hot food, and a plastic made for one use should not be reused for hot food. Plastics can release additives such as plasticisers, which make the plastic flexible, and colourants, which give it colour. The release is higher with hot, fatty, or acidic food, and with long contact, so the plastic must be matched to the food and to the use.

Metals used for food, such as steel, aluminium, and tin, must be clean and must not release harmful elements. Steel is the safest common metal for food contact, because it releases little. Aluminium can release more with acidic food, so it is often coated or used for short contact. Tin cans are coated inside so that the food does not touch the metal directly, and a damaged coating can let the food touch the metal and pick up elements from it.

Glass and ceramics are safe for food contact when they are made well, because glass releases almost nothing into food, and a well made ceramic releases nothing either. The risk is with ceramics and glass made badly, or decorated with paints that carry lead or cadmium, which can move into acidic food such as tomato or citrus. A food business should buy glass and ceramics from suppliers who can show that they are made for food, and should not use decorative or antique pieces for serving food.

Paper and board, covered in Unit 2, must be checked for inks, glues, and recycled fibre. Inks on the outside of a pack should not reach the food, and a pack where the printed side touches the food is a risk. Recycled fibre can carry substances from its earlier life, so food that touches paper directly should use virgin fibre or a barrier layer.

How food contact safety is checked

Food contact materials are checked by migration testing: a sample of the material is put in contact with a liquid that stands in for food, such as water, a weak acid, or a fatty liquid, at the temperature and for the time the material will be used at, and the liquid is then tested for what moved into it. The test is run for the worst case: the hottest food, the longest contact, and the most searching liquid, so that if the material passes the test, it will be safe in normal use.

The results are judged against limits set for each substance, and against a general rule that the material must not move anything harmful into food in amounts that could harm health. The limits differ from place to place, and a food student should check the current rule in their own country rather than memorising one number. The principle is the same everywhere: test the material as it will be used, test the worst case, and keep the migration as low as can reasonably be achieved.

A food business does not need to run migration tests itself for every pack: it can ask its supplier for the test results and for a declaration that the material is made for food contact and for the uses the business needs. The business should keep those declarations on file, and should check that the declaration covers the food, the temperature, and the time it will use the pack for. A declaration for cold food does not cover hot food, and a declaration for short contact does not cover long storage.

Choosing a safe food contact pack

What food will it hold, at what temperature, for how long?
↓
Is it PFAS free, and is the claim proved by a test?
↓
What replaced the PFAS, and is the replacement safe?
↓
Does the supplier give a declaration for this food and this use?
↓
Test the pack with the real food, then keep the papers on file

The diagram shows the checks for a safe food contact pack. The steps point to the diagram: a pack that passes all five is safe for its use, and a pack that fails one, such as a declaration for cold food used for hot food, is not.

The link between safe and sustainable

A pack that is sustainable for the planet must also be safe for the person who eats from it, and a pack that is safe must also be sustainable, or it will be replaced by a pack that is neither. The two goals can conflict: a compostable coating may migrate more than a plastic coating, a recycled fibre may carry more substances than a virgin fibre, and a reusable pack may need harsh washing that leaves residues. The job of the food professional is to balance the two, and to choose the pack that is safe first, and sustainable second, because a pack that harms health cannot be called sustainable, whatever its footprint.

The balance is struck by testing: test the safety, test the function, and test the life cycle, and choose the pack that passes all three. A pack that passes safety and function but fails the life cycle can be improved by using less material or by changing the end. A pack that passes the life cycle but fails safety must be changed, because safety is not a trade off.

Practical note: Look at the food contact materials in your kitchen: the wrappers, the containers, the cookware, and the utensils. For each one, write down what it is made from, what food it touches, at what temperature, and for how long. Mark the ones that touch hot, greasy, or acidic food, because those are the ones where migration is highest. Then check one pack for a PFAS free claim, and ask the three questions from this unit: is it proved, what replaced the PFAS, and does it still do its job?

Quick self-check

Question: Why does PFAS move into food more from hot greasy food than from cold dry food?

Because heat and fat help the chemical move. Heat makes molecules move faster, and fat dissolves the chemical more easily than water does, so hot greasy food in long contact with a treated pack picks up more PFAS than cold dry food in short contact.

Question: A supplier gives a declaration that a pack is safe for cold food, but the business uses it for hot soup. What is wrong?

The declaration does not cover the use. Migration is higher with hot food, so a pack proved safe for cold food may not be safe for hot food. The business needs a declaration that covers hot food, or it needs a different pack.

Try it yourself

Choose a takeaway food you buy often, such as a burger, a sandwich, or a hot drink. Write down every material that touches the food: the wrapper, the box, the cup, the lid, and the bag. For each one, write what it is made from, whether it carries a PFAS free claim, and whether it is the right material for hot greasy food. Then write one change you would make to the set of materials to make it safer and more sustainable, and explain why. Bring your notes to class and compare: which takeaway had the most materials touching the food, and which one was hardest to improve?

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A food contact material is any material that touches food, and it must not move harmful substances into the food.
  • PFAS was used to make paper grease resistant, but it moves into food, does not break down, and builds up in the body.
  • PFAS free alternatives include water based coatings, plant based barriers, different materials, and different designs.
  • Judge a PFAS free claim by whether it is proved, what replaced the PFAS, and whether the pack still does its job.
  • Plastics, metals, glass, ceramics, and paper each have their own migration risks, and each must be matched to the food and the use.
  • Migration is tested with food stand in liquids at the worst case temperature and time, and judged against limits.
  • Safety comes first: a pack that harms health cannot be called sustainable, whatever its footprint.

Glossary

Food contact material

Any material that touches food, such as packaging, cookware, or utensils. Food tech example: a burger wrapper is a food contact material.

Migration

The movement of a substance from a material into food. Food tech example: PFAS migrates from a wrapper into hot greasy food.

PFAS free

Made without PFAS chemicals, proved by a test. Food tech example: a takeaway box labelled PFAS free should carry a test result behind the claim.

Plasticiser

A substance added to plastic to make it flexible, which can move into food. Food tech example: a plasticiser in a soft plastic wrap can migrate into fatty food.

Declaration

A written statement from a supplier that a material is made for food contact and for named uses. Food tech example: a declaration for a pack names the foods, temperatures, and times it is safe for.

Migration testing

Testing a material in contact with a liquid that stands in for food, to measure what moves into the liquid. Food tech example: migration testing puts a pack in contact with a fatty liquid at high temperature.

Food stand in

A liquid used in migration testing to stand in for a type of food, such as water, weak acid, or a fatty liquid. Food tech example: a fatty food stand in is used to test a pack for greasy food.

Water based coating

A coating applied to paper from water, used to keep grease and water out without PFAS. Food tech example: a water based coating on a sandwich wrap keeps butter from soaking through.

Virgin fibre

Fibre from new trees, used for paper that touches food directly because it is clean and strong. Food tech example: a wrapper that touches food directly uses virgin fibre.

Recycled fibre

Fibre from used paper collected and reprocessed into new paper. Food tech example: recycled fibre is used for outer boxes, not for paper that touches food directly.

Lead

A heavy metal that can move from badly made ceramics or glass into acidic food. Food tech example: lead from a painted ceramic can move into tomato sauce.

Cadmium

A heavy metal that can move from badly made ceramics into food. Food tech example: cadmium in a ceramic glaze can move into citrus juice.

References

  • Robertson, G. L., Food Packaging: Principles and Practice, 3rd edition, 2012.
  • Coles, R., McDowell, D. and Kirwan, M. J., Food Packaging Technology, 2003.
  • Cousins, I. T., et al., The High Persistence of PFAS, 2019.
  • Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Safety and PFAS, 2021.
  • Verghese, K., et al., Packaging for Sustainability, 2015.

Unit 6: Migration, What Moves from Pack to Food

Note

Unit 6: Migration, What Moves from Pack to Food

A question to start with

A tomato sauce is stored in a plastic tub, heated in a microwave, and left in the tub overnight. A bottle of oil sits in a clear plastic bottle on a sunny shelf for months. A jam is stored in a jar with a metal lid for a year. In each case, something moves between the pack and the food, in amounts too small to see or taste, but large enough to measure in a laboratory. What moves, what decides how much moves, and how do we know whether the amount matters? This unit explains migration: the science of what moves from pack to food, and how it is measured and controlled.

Migration is the movement of substances from packaging into food. It happens because packaging is made of chemicals, and chemicals move. The movement is usually slow and small, but it is always happening, and it is faster and larger when the food is hot, fatty, or acidic, when the contact lasts a long time, and when the pack is made from a material that gives up its substances easily. Migration is not a sign that a pack is bad: every pack migrates a little. The question is what migrates, how much, and whether the amount could harm health.

The substances that migrate fall into three groups. The first is the building blocks of the pack itself: the small molecules left over from making a plastic, the additives that make it flexible or coloured, and the coatings that make paper resist grease. The second is the substances that come from outside the pack: inks, glues, and recycled fibre that carry substances from their earlier life. The third is the substances that pass through the pack from outside: gases, smells, and chemicals from the air or from neighbouring packs that travel through a thin pack into the food. All three are migration, and all three are tested.

What decides how much migrates

Six factors decide how much migrates from a pack into a food, and a food professional who knows them can predict where migration will be highest and where it will be lowest.

Temperature is the first factor. Heat makes molecules move faster, so migration is higher with hot food than with cold food, and higher when a food is heated in its pack, such as in a microwave, than when it is stored cold. A pack made for cold food may migrate far more when it is heated, which is why a pack must only be used at the temperature it was made for.

Time is the second factor. Migration grows with time, fast at first and then slower, as the substance moves from the pack into the food until the two reach a balance. A food stored in a pack for a year will carry more migrated substance than the same food stored for a day, and a food that is eaten at once will carry less than a food that sits in its pack for months.

The food itself is the third factor. Fatty foods pull out fat soluble substances from a pack, because like dissolves like: a substance that dissolves in fat will move into oil, butter, and cheese more than into water. Acidic foods, such as tomato, citrus, and vinegar, pull out metals and other substances from glass, ceramics, and metals more than neutral foods do. Alcoholic foods pull out substances that water does not. The food that is most searching for a given substance is the food that will carry the most of it.

The pack material is the fourth factor. Some materials give up their substances easily, and some hold them tightly. A soft plastic with much plasticiser gives up more than a hard plastic with little. A thin pack gives up more, per amount of food, than a thick pack, because there is more surface for each gram of food. A pack made from recycled material can give up substances from its earlier life that a virgin material does not carry.

The surface area is the fifth factor. Migration depends on how much pack touches how much food. A small portion in a large pack, with much surface and little food, will carry more migrated substance per gram than a large portion in the same pack. A thin film wrapped around a food, with a large surface, migrates more per gram than a thick bottle holding the same food.

The barrier is the sixth factor. A pack with a barrier layer, such as foil or a coated layer, slows migration from outside and from the pack itself. A pack with no barrier lets gases and smells pass through, and lets substances from outside reach the food. The barrier is why a carton keeps coffee fresh and why a foil pouch keeps crisps crisp: it stops the movement that would spoil the food.

Questions to think about

  • A tomato sauce is heated in a plastic tub in a microwave. Which factors make migration higher in this case, and why?
  • Why does a fatty food pull more substances from a plastic pack than a watery food does?
  • A small portion of cheese is wrapped in a large piece of film. Why does the portion carry more migrated substance per gram than a large block in the same film?
Think about the tomato sauce question before you read on

Three factors work together: temperature, because the microwave heats the food and the pack; the food, because tomato is acidic and pulls substances from the pack; and time, if the sauce sits in the tub after heating. The tub was made for storage, not for heating, so heating it in the microwave uses it outside its intended use, and migration rises sharply. The sauce should be heated in a dish made for heating, not in its storage tub.

How migration is measured

Migration is measured in a laboratory by putting a sample of the pack in contact with a liquid that stands in for food, at the temperature and for the time the pack will be used at, and then testing the liquid for what moved into it. The liquids, called food simulants, stand in for types of food: water for watery foods, a weak acid for acidic foods, alcohol for alcoholic foods, and a fatty liquid, often olive oil or a similar oil, for fatty foods. The test is run for the worst case: the hottest temperature, the longest time, and the most searching liquid, so that if the pack passes the test, it will be safe in normal use.

Two kinds of migration are measured. Overall migration is the total amount of all substances that move from the pack into the simulant, measured by weighing what is left after the liquid is dried. It is a general check that the pack does not give up too much in total. Specific migration is the amount of one named substance, such as a particular plasticiser or a particular metal, measured by chromatography or by mass spectrometry. It is a precise check that a named substance stays below its limit.

The results are judged against limits. Overall migration has a limit for the total amount, and each named substance has its own limit, set from the science of how much of that substance a person can eat each day without harm. The limits are set with a safety margin, so that a food that stays below the limit is safe, and a food that goes above it is not. The limits differ from place to place, and a student should check the current limit in their own country rather than memorising one number.

The laboratory must be careful: it must use clean glassware, run blanks to prove that the result came from the pack and not from the laboratory, and run the test at the right temperature and time. A test run at the wrong temperature, or for the wrong time, gives a wrong answer, and a pack judged on a wrong test may be sold when it should not be, or refused when it should be sold.

Migration in real foods

Migration is not only a laboratory test: it happens in real foods on real shelves, and the examples help to show where it matters most.

Plasticisers in soft plastic are the classic case. A soft plastic wrap, a soft plastic tub, or a soft plastic seal can release plasticisers into fatty food, more so when the food is warm and when the contact lasts a long time. The amounts are small, but the foods are eaten often, and the plasticisers build up in the body, so the limits are set low and the materials are watched closely.

Metals in cans are another case. A tin can is coated inside so that the food does not touch the metal, but a damaged coating, or a long storage, can let the food touch the metal and pick up elements such as tin or iron. Acidic foods, such as tomato and pineapple, are the most searching, and they are the foods where can migration is watched most closely.

Inks and recycled fibre are a third case. A printed pack where the ink touches the food, or a recycled paper pack where the fibre carries inks and glues from its earlier life, can migrate substances into dry food. Dry food is less searching than fatty food, so the amounts are smaller, but the food is often eaten by children, and the substances are watched for that reason.

Smells and gases passing through a pack are a fourth case. A thin plastic pack can let smells from a neighbouring food, or from the air, pass into the food it holds, and can let the food's own smell pass out. A cheese stored next to a strong smelling food in a thin pack can pick up the smell, and a coffee in a thin pack can lose its aroma. The barrier of the pack decides how much passes, and a pack with no barrier is a poor choice for a food that must keep its smell or keep smells out.

What decides how much migrates

Temperature: hotter food, faster movement
↓
Time: longer contact, more movement
↓
Food: fat, acid, and alcohol pull out more
↓
Material: soft and thin packs give up more
↓
Surface: more pack per gram of food, more migration
↓
Barrier: a good barrier slows movement both ways

The diagram shows the six factors that decide migration. The steps point to the diagram: the highest migration comes when several factors work together, such as hot, fatty food in a thin soft pack for a long time.

Controlling migration

Migration is controlled in four ways, and a food business should use all four.

Choose the right material is the first control. Match the pack to the food, the temperature, and the time: a pack made for cold food should not hold hot food, a pack made for dry food should not hold fatty food, and a pack made for short use should not hold food for a long storage. The supplier's declaration, covered in Unit 5, names the uses the pack is made for, and the business should follow it.

Use a barrier is the second control. Where migration must be low, use a pack with a barrier layer, such as foil or a coated layer, that slows movement from the pack and from outside. A barrier costs more, but it protects the food and the buyer, and it is the right choice for foods that are fatty, acidic, or stored for a long time.

Keep the contact short and cool is the third control. Store food at the temperature it was made for, do not heat food in a pack made for storage, and do not store food in its pack longer than needed. A food that is moved from its pack to a dish for heating, and from its pack to a serving dish for storage, migrates less than a food that stays in its pack for every step.

Test and keep records is the fourth control. Ask the supplier for migration test results, keep them on file, and test again when the pack, the food, or the use changes. A pack that was tested for one food may not be safe for another, and a pack that was tested for cold use may not be safe for hot use. The record shows what was tested and what was found, so that if a question arises, the business can answer it.

Migration and the home cook

A home cook can control migration with simple habits. Do not heat food in a plastic tub made for storage: move the food to a glass or ceramic dish. Do not store acidic food, such as tomato, in a metal container for a long time. Do not reuse a single use plastic bottle for hot drinks. Do not store food in a printed paper bag where the ink touches the food. Use glass or steel for long storage, for hot food, and for acidic food, and use plastic only for the cold, short uses it was made for. These habits cost nothing, and they cut the migration that matters most.

Practical note: Look at the packs in your kitchen and sort them by use: cold storage, hot food, fatty food, acidic food, and long storage. For each pack, check whether it is used for the job it was made for, or for a job it was not made for. A storage tub used for microwaving, a single use bottle used for hot tea, and a printed bag used for food are all uses outside the pack's intended job. Write down the mismatches and what you would change.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is migration higher in fatty food than in watery food from the same pack?

Because like dissolves like: substances that dissolve in fat move into fatty food more easily than into water. A plasticiser that is fat soluble will be pulled out by oil, butter, or cheese far more than by water.

Question: What is the difference between overall migration and specific migration?

Overall migration is the total amount of all substances that move from a pack into a food stand in, measured by weighing. Specific migration is the amount of one named substance, measured by chromatography or mass spectrometry, and judged against its own limit.

A worked derivation: how much migrates, and how fast

Migration is governed by diffusion, and the law that describes it is Fick's law. The derivation below shows how a laboratory estimates the amount that will migrate from a pack into food, step by step, using practice numbers to show the method.

Step one: start with the law. For a substance spread evenly through a plastic film, with the food acting as a sink that takes the substance away, the amount migrated per unit area after time t is given by M = 2 × C₀ × √(D × t ÷ π), where C₀ is the starting concentration of the substance in the plastic, D is the diffusion coefficient, which measures how fast the substance moves through the plastic, and t is the contact time. The square root is the key: migration grows with the square root of time, not with time itself, so doubling the time does not double the migration, it increases it by about four tenths.

Step two: put in practice numbers. Suppose the plastic carries C₀ = 1,000,000 milligrams of the substance per cubic metre of plastic, the diffusion coefficient D is 1 × 10⁻¹³ square metres per second, which is a slow mover, and the contact time t is 30 days, which is 2,592,000 seconds. Multiply D by t: 1 × 10⁻¹³ times 2,592,000 gives 2.592 × 10⁻⁷ square metres. Divide by π, about 3.14, to get 8.25 × 10⁻⁸ square metres. Take the square root to get 2.87 × 10⁻⁴ metres.

Step three: finish the calculation. Multiply 2 times C₀ times the square root: 2 times 1,000,000 times 2.87 × 10⁻⁴ gives 574 milligrams per square metre, which is 5.74 milligrams per square decimetre of pack. The widely used overall migration limit is 10 milligrams per square decimetre, so this practice example sits inside the limit, but close enough that a warmer temperature, which raises D, or a longer time could push it over.

Step four: read the lesson. The three levers are the starting amount, the diffusion coefficient, and the time. A packer who lowers C₀ by choosing a cleaner plastic, or lowers D by choosing a plastic the substance moves slowly through, or shortens the contact time, lowers the migration. Temperature matters because D rises steeply with heat, which is why a pack that is safe in a fridge may not be safe in a hot car. The derivation is a model, not a proof: the laboratory still tests the real pack with the real food, but the model shows which lever to pull first.

Try it yourself

Take three foods from your kitchen: a fatty food such as cheese or oil, an acidic food such as tomato sauce or citrus juice, and a dry food such as rice or biscuits. For each one, write down the pack it is stored in, how long it has been in the pack, and at what temperature. Then rank the three by migration risk, and explain your ranking using the six factors from this unit. Which food has the highest risk, and what would you change about its pack or its storage to lower the risk?

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Migration is the movement of substances from packaging into food, and it happens with every pack, in small amounts.
  • Temperature, time, the food, the material, the surface area, and the barrier decide how much migrates.
  • Fatty, acidic, and alcoholic foods pull out more, and hot food migrates more than cold food.
  • Migration is measured with food simulants at the worst case temperature and time, as overall migration and as specific migration for named substances.
  • Control migration by choosing the right material, using a barrier, keeping contact short and cool, and testing and keeping records.
  • At home, do not heat food in a storage tub, do not store acidic food in metal for long, and use glass or steel for hot, fatty, and acidic foods.

Glossary

Migration

The movement of substances from packaging into food. Food tech example: a plasticiser migrates from a soft plastic wrap into cheese.

Food simulant

A liquid used in migration testing to stand in for a type of food, such as water, weak acid, alcohol, or a fatty liquid. Food tech example: olive oil is used as a simulant for fatty food.

Overall migration

The total amount of all substances that move from a pack into a food simulant. Food tech example: overall migration is measured by weighing what is left after the simulant is dried.

Specific migration

The amount of one named substance that moves from a pack into a food simulant. Food tech example: specific migration of a plasticiser is measured by chromatography.

Plasticiser

A substance added to plastic to make it flexible, which can move into food. Food tech example: a plasticiser in a soft plastic wrap can migrate into fatty food.

Barrier

A layer that stops air, water, or other substances passing through a pack. Food tech example: foil in a carton is a barrier against air and light.

Blank

A test run with no sample, used to prove that a result came from the pack and not from the laboratory. Food tech example: a blank run alongside a migration test shows whether the laboratory added anything.

Fat soluble

Able to dissolve in fat, so that a substance moves into fatty food more than into water. Food tech example: a fat soluble plasticiser migrates into cheese more than into water.

Chromatography

A family of methods that separate the parts of a mixture so each part can be seen and measured. Food tech example: chromatography measures the specific migration of a plasticiser.

Mass spectrometry

A detector that weighs molecules and names them by their weight and fragments. Food tech example: mass spectrometry names the substance that migrated into a food simulant.

Limit

The highest amount of a substance allowed to migrate into food, set from safety science. Food tech example: a plasticiser has a specific migration limit that the pack must stay below.

Safety margin

The gap between the amount that causes harm in studies and the limit set for food, which protects people. Food tech example: a migration limit is set well below the amount that harmed animals in studies.

References

  • Robertson, G. L., Food Packaging: Principles and Practice, 3rd edition, 2012.
  • Coles, R., McDowell, D. and Kirwan, M. J., Food Packaging Technology, 2003.
  • Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Contact Materials, 2021.
  • Verghese, K., et al., Packaging for Sustainability, 2015.
  • Pauer, E., et al., Life Cycle Assessment of Packaging, 2019.

Unit 7: Designing Sustainable Packaging, Shelf Life vs Footprint

Note

Unit 7: Designing Sustainable Packaging, Shelf Life vs Footprint

A question to start with

A food maker has a ready meal that must stay fresh for ten days, travel far in a truck, and be heated in a microwave. The maker can choose a heavy glass tray that keeps the food fresh and is easy to recycle, a light plastic tray that is cheap to carry but hard to recycle, or a paper tray that is light and recyclable but lets air in and shortens the shelf life. Which pack is the most sustainable, and how does the maker decide when the choices pull in different directions? This unit brings the subject together: how to design sustainable packaging, and how to balance shelf life against footprint.

Designing sustainable packaging is the work of choosing a pack that protects the food, keeps it fresh for the time it needs, can be carried safely, can be sold honestly, and causes the least harm over its whole life. It is a balance, not a single choice, because the pack that protects best is not always the pack that pollutes least, and the pack that pollutes least is not always the pack that keeps food fresh. The designer's job is to find the balance that wastes the least food and the least material together.

The balance is struck by asking the right questions in the right order. The first question is always about the food: what does it need? The second is about the journey: how far does it travel, and how is it stored? The third is about the buyer: how will they use it, and what will they do with the pack after use? The fourth is about the end: what happens to the pack where the buyer lives? A design that answers all four is a sustainable design. A design that answers only one, such as the lightest pack, or the most recyclable pack, will fail on the others.

The design brief: start with the food

Every packaging design starts with a brief: a short statement of what the pack must do. The brief names the food, its shelf life, its storage, its journey, and its buyer, and it sets the limits the pack must meet. A brief for a ready meal names ten days of shelf life, chilled storage, a long truck journey, and a buyer who will heat the meal in a microwave. A brief for a loaf of bread names a few days of shelf life, room storage, a short journey, and a buyer who will eat it at home. The two briefs lead to different packs, and that is right: the pack must fit the food, not the other way round.

The brief also names the trade offs the designer may make. A ready meal that must last ten days needs a strong barrier, and the barrier may make the pack harder to recycle. A bread that lasts a few days needs little barrier, and its pack can be simple paper. The brief should say which is more important where they conflict: for the ready meal, shelf life comes first, because a meal that spoils is wasted food, and wasted food is the larger harm. For the bread, simplicity comes first, because the food does not need a strong barrier, and a simple pack is the least harm.

The brief should also name the materials that may not be used, such as PFAS, and the claims that must be proved, such as compostable or recyclable. A brief that names what is forbidden is as useful as a brief that names what is wanted, because it stops the designer from choosing a material that will fail the safety test or the recycling test later.

Shelf life vs footprint: the central balance

Shelf life is how long a food stays safe and good to eat when stored as directed. Footprint is the total impact of the pack on the environment, across its whole life. The two pull against each other: a pack that gives a long shelf life often uses more material, a stronger barrier, and more energy to make, so its footprint is larger. A pack with a small footprint often gives a shorter shelf life, so more food is wasted, and the waste carries its own footprint.

The balance is found by looking at the whole system, food plus pack, not at the pack alone. A pack that adds a little footprint but saves a lot of food is a good pack, because the food it saves carries a far larger footprint than the pack. A pack that saves a little footprint but wastes a lot of food is a bad pack, because the food waste outweighs the pack saving. The designer should work out the balance for the food in question, with numbers where they can be found, and with judgement where they cannot.

A worked example helps. A cucumber in a thin plastic film lasts far longer than a cucumber with no film, and the film weighs a few grams while the cucumber weighs hundreds of grams. The film's footprint is tiny beside the cucumber's footprint, and the film saves the cucumber from waste, so the film is a good pack, even though it is plastic. A bottle of water in a heavy glass bottle, used once and thrown away, carries a large footprint for a food that needs little protection, so the glass is a bad pack for a single use, even though glass is easy to recycle. The same glass, reused many times, becomes a good pack, because the footprint is shared across many uses. The lesson is that the balance depends on the food, the pack, and the number of uses, not on the material alone.

The design process, step by step

Sustainable packaging is designed in steps, and each step tests the design against the brief.

The first step is to choose the material. The designer looks at the foods the pack must hold, the barrier it needs, the temperature it will face, and the end where it will go, and picks the material that does the job with the least harm. The choice is made with the whole life cycle in mind, not with the look of the material.

The second step is to choose the shape and the size. The pack should fit the food closely, with little empty space, because empty space is wasted material and wasted transport. The shape should stack well, so that many packs fit in a truck, and it should be easy to hold, open, and use. A pack that is hard to open will be torn, and a torn pack wastes food.

The third step is to choose the barrier and the seal. The barrier keeps air, moisture, and light away where they would spoil the food, and the seal keeps the pack closed until the buyer opens it. The barrier should be as strong as the food needs, and no stronger, because a stronger barrier than needed uses more material and makes recycling harder.

The fourth step is to design the label. The label must tell the buyer what the food is, how to store it, when to eat it by, and what to do with the pack after use. The label should use clear words and clear symbols for recycling, composting, or reuse, so that the buyer puts the pack in the right bin. A label that confuses the buyer wastes the design, because the pack will be put in the wrong bin.

The fifth step is to test the pack. The pack is tested with the real food, for the real shelf life, through the real journey, and by real buyers. The test checks the shelf life, the protection, the seal, the label, and the end: does the pack recycle, compost, or reuse as designed? A pack that fails a test is redesigned, not sold, because a pack sold on a failed test will fail in front of buyers.

Questions to think about

  • A ready meal needs ten days of shelf life and a light footprint. What would you give up first, shelf life or footprint, and why?
  • A cucumber in a thin film lasts far longer than one with no film. Why is the film a good pack, even though it is plastic?
  • A pack is designed to be recycled, but buyers put it in the wrong bin. What went wrong in the design?
Think about the ready meal question before you read on

Keep the shelf life, and find the footprint saving elsewhere. A meal that spoils is wasted food, and wasted food carries a far larger footprint than the pack, because growing and making the meal uses far more land, water, and energy than making its pack. The footprint can be cut by using less material, by using recycled material, or by making the pack easy to recycle, but not by cutting the shelf life the food needs.

Designing for the end: recycle, reuse, compost

A sustainable pack is designed for its end from the start, not as an afterthought. The designer asks: where will this pack be used, and what waste system exists there? If the place recycles a material, the pack should be made from that material, in a form the system can handle: a single material, easy to sort, clean, and free of linings that block recycling. If the place composts, the pack should be compostable in that system, with a mark that proves it. If the place reuses, the pack should be strong, washable, and easy to return.

Design for recycling means one material, not many layered together, and no small parts that cannot be sorted. A bottle with a cap of a different material, a label that cannot be removed, or a pack with a foil layer can all spoil recycling, even when the main material is recyclable. Design for composting means a material that breaks down in the system where it will be collected, with a mark that proves it. Design for reuse means a pack that is strong, easy to wash, and easy to stack, with a deposit or a return point that buyers will use.

The designer should also design for the buyer. A pack that is easy to empty, easy to rinse, and easy to sort will be recycled more often than a pack that is hard to empty or hard to sort. A pack with a clear symbol and a clear word, such as recycle, compost, or return, will be put in the right bin more often than a pack with a vague claim. The buyer is part of the design, not an afterthought.

Measuring the design: life cycle assessment in practice

Life cycle assessment, met in Unit 1, is the tool that measures a design. It counts the materials, the energy, the water, the transport, the food saved, and the waste, across the whole life of the pack, and it gives a number for each impact, such as the climate impact or the water use. The designer uses it to compare options: a glass tray against a plastic tray, a paper wrap against a film, a reusable cup against a throwaway cup.

The assessment is only as good as its data, and the designer must be honest about what is known and what is guessed. The food saved is the hardest part to count, because it depends on how buyers use the food, and the end is hard to count, because it depends on whether buyers recycle or throw away. A good assessment states its assumptions, tests them by changing them, and shows how the answer changes. An assessment that hides its assumptions is not a tool, it is a sales pitch.

A small business cannot run a full life cycle assessment for every pack, and it does not need to. It can use the principles: protect the food first, use the least material that does the job, choose a material that is recycled or recyclable where it is sold, design for the end, and ask the supplier for the evidence. Those principles, applied with care, give a sustainable pack without a full assessment, and a full assessment can be bought for the packs that matter most.

Designing a sustainable pack

Brief: what food, what shelf life, what journey, what buyer?
↓
Material: the least harm that still does the job
↓
Shape and size: fit the food, little empty space, stack well
↓
Barrier and seal: as strong as needed, no stronger
↓
Label: clear words for use, storage, and the right bin
↓
Test with real food, real journey, real buyers, then redesign

The diagram shows the design process in order. The steps point to the diagram: a pack that skips a step, such as skipping the test with real buyers, will fail in front of them, whatever the design says on paper.

The future of sustainable packaging

The future of packaging is in less material, better materials, and smarter systems. Packs will use less material, through thinner walls and better shapes. Materials will be more recyclable, more compostable where composting fits, and more often made from recycled content. Systems will share packs, through reuse networks and refill stations, so that fewer packs are made at all. And labels will be clearer, so that buyers put packs in the right bin and food is not wasted.

The future also needs honesty: a pack that claims to be sustainable must be able to show it, with a life cycle, a test, and a mark, not only with a green colour or a kind word. A food professional who can ask for that evidence, and who can design a pack that protects the food first and the planet second, will be useful in that future, whatever the materials are called.

Practical note: Pick a food you buy often and write a design brief for its pack: the food, the shelf life, the storage, the journey, the buyer, and the end where the buyer lives. Then design a pack for it: choose the material, the shape, the barrier, and the label, and write down why you chose each one. End with the trade off you made: what did you give up, and why? Keep the brief with your notes for this subject: it is the start of a real packaging design.

Quick self-check

Question: Why should shelf life come first when it conflicts with footprint?

Because a food that spoils is wasted, and wasted food carries a far larger footprint than the pack, from growing, making, and moving the food. The footprint can be cut in other ways, by using less material or by making the pack recyclable, but not by cutting the shelf life the food needs.

Question: What does design for recycling mean in practice?

It means one material, not many layered together, easy to sort, clean, and free of linings that block recycling, with no small parts that cannot be sorted. A pack designed this way can actually be recycled in the system where it is sold.

Packaging that saves food: the shelf-life gain in numbers

The central balance of this unit is shelf life against footprint, and it can be worked in numbers with a simple example. Suppose a shop sells 1,000 packs of fresh berries each week, each pack holding food that cost 2 money units to grow, pick, and carry. With an ordinary pack, the berries keep for 5 days, and one pack in five is thrown away unsold, which is 200 packs a week, or 400 money units of food wasted each week.

Step one: work out the gain from a better pack. A pack with a better barrier and an oxygen absorber keeps the berries for 7 days, and the waste falls from one in five to one in ten, which is 100 packs a week, or 200 money units wasted. The saving is 100 packs a week, or 200 money units of food.

Step two: work out the cost of the better pack. Suppose the better pack costs 0.10 money units more per pack than the ordinary pack. For 1,000 packs a week, the extra cost is 100 money units a week.

Step three: compare. The saving of 200 money units is larger than the extra cost of 100 money units, so the better pack pays for itself in money, before counting the land, water, and energy saved by not growing food that is thrown away. If the better pack cost 0.25 money units more per pack, the extra cost would be 250 money units, larger than the saving, and the ordinary pack would win on money, even though it wastes more food.

The lesson is that the balance has a number, and the number decides. A designer who can count the waste saved and the cost added can defend the choice of pack with arithmetic, not with a slogan, and a designer who cannot count it is guessing.

Try it yourself

Choose a pack from your kitchen that you think is wasteful: a pack with much empty space, a pack with many layers, or a pack that is hard to recycle. Redesign it on paper: draw the new pack, name the material, show the shape, and write the label. Then write a short note on what your redesign saves, in material, in transport, and in waste, and what it gives up, if anything. Bring your redesign to class and compare: which redesigns saved the most, and which ones kept the food safe?

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Designing sustainable packaging is a balance: protect the food first, and protect the planet second, with the least food waste and the least material together.
  • The design starts with a brief: the food, its shelf life, its journey, its buyer, and its end.
  • Shelf life usually comes first when it conflicts with footprint, because wasted food carries the larger harm.
  • The design process runs from material to shape, barrier, label, and test, and a pack that fails a test is redesigned, not sold.
  • Design for the end from the start: recycle, reuse, or compost, as the system where the buyer lives allows.
  • Life cycle assessment measures a design, but it must state its assumptions honestly.
  • The future is less material, better materials, shared reuse systems, and clearer labels.

Glossary

Design brief

A short statement of what a pack must do: the food, its shelf life, its journey, its buyer, and its end. Food tech example: a brief for a ready meal names ten days of shelf life and a microwave buyer.

Shelf life

How long a food stays safe and good to eat when stored as directed. Food tech example: a vacuum pack gives meat a longer shelf life.

Footprint

The total impact of a product on the environment, across its whole life. Food tech example: a pack with a small footprint uses little material and energy and causes little waste.

Life cycle assessment

A method of judging a product on its whole life, from materials to disposal. Food tech example: a life cycle assessment compares a glass tray with a plastic tray.

Barrier

A layer that stops air, water, or light passing through a pack. Food tech example: foil in a carton is a barrier against air and light.

Seal

The closure that keeps a pack shut until the buyer opens it. Food tech example: a heat seal keeps a bag of crisps closed.

Lightweighting

Making a pack thinner and lighter while it still does its jobs. Food tech example: a bottle made with less plastic is lightweighted.

Design for recycling

Designing a pack so that it can actually be recycled: one material, easy to sort, free of blocking linings. Food tech example: a bottle made from one plastic, with a label that can be removed, is designed for recycling.

Design for reuse

Designing a pack so that it can be used many times: strong, washable, and easy to return. Food tech example: a steel cup designed for reuse is strong and easy to wash.

Trade off

A choice where gaining one thing means giving up another, such as shelf life against footprint. Food tech example: a stronger barrier gives longer shelf life but a larger footprint.

Empty space

Air inside a pack where food could have been, which wastes material and transport. Food tech example: a box half full of air wastes space in a truck.

Assumption

A guess used in a calculation, which must be stated so that others can judge it. Food tech example: a life cycle assessment assumes how often buyers recycle, and states that assumption.

References

  • Robertson, G. L., Food Packaging: Principles and Practice, 3rd edition, 2012.
  • Coles, R., McDowell, D. and Kirwan, M. J., Food Packaging Technology, 2003.
  • Verghese, K., et al., Packaging for Sustainability, 2015.
  • Pauer, E., et al., Life Cycle Assessment of Packaging, 2019.
  • Ellen MacArthur Foundation, Reuse: Rethinking Packaging, 2019.

Unit 8: Bio-Based Plastics, PLA, PHA, and Bio-PE

Note

Unit 8: Bio-Based Plastics, PLA, PHA, and Bio-PE

A question to start with

A clear cup holds a cold drink. It looks like plastic, it feels like plastic, and it holds liquid like plastic. But it was made from plants, not from oil. Is it a better cup? The answer is not as simple as the label suggests, because a plastic made from plants can still behave like a plastic made from oil once it is thrown away, and a plant based plastic can still need the right factory, the right heat, and the right waste stream to break down. This unit is about bio-based plastics: what they are, how they differ from each other, and how to judge them honestly.

Bio-based means made from renewable plant or other biological material, rather than from fossil oil or gas. It does not mean biodegradable, and it does not mean compostable. Those are three different claims, and a plastic can carry one without the others. A bio-based plastic can last for decades in a landfill, just like a fossil plastic. A fossil plastic can be made biodegradable by changing its chemistry. The first skill in this unit is to keep the three words apart and to ask, for each plastic, where it came from, what it does in use, and where it goes at the end.

This unit covers the three main bio-based plastics a food student will meet: PLA, made from fermented plant sugars; PHA, made by microbes; and bio-PE, a plant based version of a familiar plastic. It explains how each one is made, what it is good at, where it fails, and how to judge the claim on the pack.

PLA: the plant plastic that needs heat to break down

PLA, or polylactic acid, is made by fermenting plant sugars, usually from corn or sugar cane, into lactic acid, and then joining the lactic acid molecules into a long chain. The result is a clear, stiff plastic that looks much like the plastic used for cold drink cups, salad boxes, and clear lids. It prints well, it holds its shape, and it is made from a renewable crop.

PLA is good at holding cold foods and dry foods, and it is a natural fit for short life, cold, single use packs: cups, lids, trays, and wraps for salads and cold drinks. It is not good at heat: a PLA cup softens in a hot drink, and a PLA tray warps in a warm display. It is also brittle compared with some other plastics, so a thin PLA pack can crack, and its barrier to oxygen and water vapour is weaker than that of the best fossil plastics, which means food in PLA may dry out or oxidise faster.

The end of life of PLA is where the most confusion sits. PLA is compostable in an industrial composting plant, where the heat, moisture, and microbes are high enough to break it down over weeks. It does not break down quickly in a home compost heap, in soil, or in the sea, where the temperature is too low. A PLA cup thrown in a home compost heap will sit there much like a fossil plastic cup. A PLA cup put in a recycling bin can also contaminate the recycling of other plastics, because it looks like a common clear plastic but melts at a different temperature. The honest claim for PLA is therefore narrow: made from plants, compostable in an industrial plant, suited to cold food, and needing the right waste stream to deliver its benefit.

Questions to think about

  • A cafe serves hot soup in a PLA cup. What will go wrong, and why?
  • Why does a PLA cup need an industrial composting plant to break down, when a home compost heap is not enough?
  • A PLA bottle is put in a recycling bin for clear plastic bottles. Why can that cause a problem for the recycler?
Think about the hot soup question before you read on

The cup will soften and may warp or leak, because PLA softens at a lower temperature than the plastic normally used for hot drinks. PLA is made for cold use, and heat is its weak point, so the cup fails at the very job the cafe gave it.

PHA: the plastic that microbes make, and microbes can eat

PHA, or polyhydroxyalkanoate, is a family of plastics made by microbes. When bacteria are fed sugars or oils and then starved of one nutrient, they store energy as PHA granules inside their cells. The granules are harvested, cleaned, and turned into a plastic that can be moulded, blown, or made into film. PHA is the most naturally degradable of the bio-based plastics: microbes in soil and in sea water can break it down, because it is a food for them, not a foreign material.

PHA is flexible where PLA is brittle, and it holds up better to heat, which makes it a candidate for a wider range of food packs, from cups and trays to films and coatings. Its barrier to oxygen is better than PLA, which helps keep food fresh. Its weakness is cost: growing microbes, feeding them, and harvesting the plastic is dearer than making PLA from fermented sugars, and dearer still than making a fossil plastic at large scale. The supply of PHA is also small, so a food business that wants it must plan around limited volumes and higher prices.

The end of life of PHA is its strongest card, but it must still be stated carefully. PHA breaks down in soil and in sea water faster than PLA, but faster does not mean at once: a PHA pack in the sea still takes time to break down, and a PHA pack is still litter while it lasts. The honest claim for PHA is that it is bio-based, it is biodegradable in more places than PLA, and it suits foods that need a tougher, warmer pack, at a higher price and a smaller scale for now.

Bio-PE: the same plastic, from a different source

Bio-PE is polyethylene made from plant ethanol, usually from sugar cane, instead of from fossil oil or gas. The chemistry is the same: the plant ethanol is turned into ethylene, and the ethylene is joined into polyethylene, the same plastic used for milk bottles, bags, and caps. Because the plastic is the same, bio-PE behaves the same in use: it is tough, it holds water well, it seals well, and it can be recycled in the same stream as fossil polyethylene.

Bio-PE is the easiest bio-based plastic to use, because nothing changes for the packer, the filler, or the recycler. A milk bottle made from bio-PE goes into the same recycling bin as a milk bottle made from fossil PE, and the recycler cannot tell them apart, which is a benefit, not a problem. The difference sits upstream: the carbon in bio-PE came from a plant that took it from the air recently, rather than from oil that held it underground for millions of years. That difference can lower the carbon footprint of the plastic, if the crop was grown without clearing new land and without heavy fertiliser use.

The limit of bio-PE is that it is not biodegradable and not compostable, because it is the same plastic as fossil PE. A bio-PE bag thrown in a river is still a plastic bag, and a bio-PE bottle in a landfill is still a bottle. The honest claim for bio-PE is narrow and strong: same plastic, same recycling, lower fossil carbon, and no change to the waste stream. A buyer who expects a bio-PE pack to disappear in compost has been misled, and a seller who implies it will has made a false claim.

Judging a bio-based plastic: four questions

Every bio-based plastic should be judged with the same four questions. First, where did it come from, and what did growing it cost in land, water, and fertiliser? A plastic from a crop grown on land cleared for that crop may carry a larger footprint than the fossil plastic it replaces. Second, what does it do in use? A plastic that fails at heat, or that lets food spoil faster, will cause more food waste than it saves in packaging, and the food waste will outweigh the packaging gain.

Third, where does it go at the end? A compostable plastic is only a gain where industrial composting exists and the pack reaches it. A recyclable plastic is only a gain where the recycling stream accepts it. A biodegradable plastic is only a gain if the place it breaks down in is the place it will actually end up. Fourth, what does it cost, and can the food carry that cost? A plastic that doubles the pack price will only be used for foods that can carry it, and a plastic that is used nowhere helps nobody.

How to judge a bio-based plastic honestly

Ask where it came from: crop, land, water, and fertiliser behind it
↓
Ask what it does in use: heat, barrier, strength, and shelf life
↓
Ask where it goes at the end: compost, recycle, or landfill, and whether that stream exists here
↓
Ask what it costs, and whether the food can carry that cost
↓
Choose the plastic that passes all four questions for this food, in this place

The diagram shows the four questions for judging a bio-based plastic. A plastic that fails any one of them is the wrong choice for that food.

Bio-based plastics and food waste: the balance that decides

The most important judgement in this unit is the balance between the pack and the food. A bio-based plastic that lets food spoil a day sooner can cause more harm than a fossil plastic that keeps food fresh, because the food carries far more water, energy, and land than the pack does. A thin PLA tray that cracks and lets air in, or a bio-based film that lets a salad dry out, may save a little plastic and waste a whole meal.

This is why the choice of a bio-based plastic must start with the food, as every packaging choice in this subject does. A cold salad in a PLA box is a good match, because the food is cold, short life, and eaten soon. A hot soup in a PLA cup is a poor match, because the heat defeats the plastic. A milk bottle in bio-PE is a good match, because the plastic is the same and the recycling is the same. A long life food that needs a strong oxygen barrier may be a poor match for PLA, and a better match for a plastic with a stronger barrier, even if that plastic is fossil based.

The future of bio-based plastics is likely to be a mix: PLA for cold, short life packs where composting exists; PHA for tougher packs where its degradability matters; and bio-PE wherever the same plastic is needed with a lower fossil footprint. None of them is a cure for plastic waste on its own, and each of them needs the right waste stream, the right food, and an honest claim to do any good.

Practical note: Collect three packs from your kitchen that claim to be plant based, compostable, or biodegradable. Read each claim and write down what it actually promises: made from plants, compostable where, biodegradable where, and in how long? Then check whether that waste stream exists where you live. A claim that needs a stream you do not have is a claim that cannot be kept.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is bio-based not the same as biodegradable?

Because bio-based describes where the plastic came from, while biodegradable describes what happens to it at the end. Bio-PE is bio-based but not biodegradable, because it is the same plastic as fossil polyethylene, while some fossil plastics can be made biodegradable by changing their chemistry.

Question: A PLA cup is compostable in an industrial plant. Why is that not enough to call it a good choice everywhere?

Because the benefit only happens if the cup reaches an industrial composting plant. Where no such plant exists, or where the cup goes to landfill or to recycling, the compostable property does nothing, and the cup may even contaminate recycling.

Other bio-based plastics to watch: bio-PET, bio-PP, and starch blends

PLA, PHA, and bio-PE are the three a student will meet most often, but three more are worth knowing. Bio-PET is the plastic of drinks bottles, made with part of its building blocks from plants instead of oil. A bottle made from bio-PET behaves exactly like a fossil PET bottle and recycles in the same stream, because the plastic is the same. The plant share is partial, not full, so the claim must state how much of the bottle is plant based, and a bottle that is 30 percent plant based is not a fully plant based bottle.

Bio-PP is polypropylene made from plant sources, used for caps, tubs, and lids. Like bio-PE, it is the same plastic as its fossil twin, so it fits the same recycling stream and the same uses. Its story is the same too: a lower fossil footprint, no change to the end of life, and no claim of biodegradability.

Starch blends are plastics made by mixing starch with other plastics to make films and bags. They can be compostable where the blend is designed for it, but the starch share varies, and a blend that is mostly fossil plastic with a little starch is not a starch plastic. The buyer should ask for the starch share and for the composting certificate, and should not accept a green colour or a leaf on the pack as proof.

The rule for all three is the same as for the main three: ask where it came from, what it does in use, where it goes at the end, and what it costs. A new name on a pack is not a new answer to those questions.

Try it yourself

Choose a food and a pack: a cold salad box, a hot drink cup, a milk bottle, or a fresh fruit punnet. Pick one bio-based plastic for it: PLA, PHA, or bio-PE. Write down why that plastic fits the food, what it would fail at, where the pack would go at the end, and whether that waste stream exists where you live. Then pick a second plastic for the same food and compare the two with the four questions in this unit. Which one wins, and does the answer change if the waste stream changes?

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Bio-based, biodegradable, and compostable are three different claims, and a plastic can carry one without the others.
  • PLA is made from fermented plant sugars, suits cold food, softens with heat, and needs industrial composting to break down.
  • PHA is made by microbes, is tougher and more degradable than PLA, but costs more and is made at a smaller scale.
  • Bio-PE is the same plastic as fossil polyethylene, made from plant ethanol, and it recycles in the same stream.
  • Judge every bio-based plastic by its source, its use, its end of life, and its cost.
  • The pack must not cause food waste: a plastic that lets food spoil sooner does more harm than good.
  • An honest claim states where the plastic came from, where it breaks down, and where that stream exists.

Glossary

Bio-based

Made from renewable plant or other biological material, rather than from fossil oil or gas. Food tech example: bio-PE is a bio-based plastic made from plant ethanol.

Biodegradable

Able to be broken down by microbes into natural substances, in a stated place and time. Food tech example: PHA is biodegradable in soil and in sea water, while bio-PE is not.

Compostable

Able to break down in composting conditions into compost, within a stated time and place. Food tech example: PLA is compostable in an industrial composting plant, but not in a home compost heap.

PLA

Polylactic acid, a clear stiff plastic made from fermented plant sugars. Food tech example: PLA is used for cold drink cups and salad boxes.

PHA

Polyhydroxyalkanoate, a family of plastics made by microbes storing energy as granules. Food tech example: PHA is used for trays and films where a tougher, more degradable plastic is wanted.

Bio-PE

Polyethylene made from plant ethanol instead of fossil oil or gas, the same plastic as fossil PE. Food tech example: a milk bottle made from bio-PE recycles in the same stream as a fossil PE bottle.

Polylactic acid

The full name of PLA, a plastic made by joining lactic acid molecules into a long chain. Food tech example: polylactic acid is made from lactic acid fermented from plant sugars.

Fermentation

A process in which microbes turn sugars into another substance, such as lactic acid. Food tech example: fermentation of plant sugars makes the lactic acid used for PLA.

Lactic acid

An acid made by fermenting sugars, used as the building block of PLA. Food tech example: lactic acid from fermented corn sugar is joined into PLA.

Barrier

How well a pack blocks oxygen, water vapour, or other gases from passing through. Food tech example: PLA has a weaker oxygen barrier than some fossil plastics, so food in PLA may oxidise faster.

Industrial composting

Composting in a large plant with high heat, moisture, and controlled microbes, which can break down plastics such as PLA. Food tech example: a PLA cup breaks down in industrial composting but not in a home heap.

Feedstock

The raw material a plastic is made from, such as plant sugars or fossil oil. Food tech example: the feedstock for bio-PE is plant ethanol from sugar cane.

Carbon footprint

The total greenhouse gas emissions linked to a product, from its making to its disposal. Food tech example: bio-PE can have a lower carbon footprint than fossil PE if its crop was grown without clearing new land.

Contamination

Mixing of one material into the recycling or composting stream of another, which harms the stream. Food tech example: PLA in a clear plastic recycling bin contaminates the recycling of other plastics.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Potter, N. N. and Hotchkiss, J. H., Food Science, 5th edition, 1995.
  • Robertson, G. L., Food Packaging: Principles and Practice, 3rd edition, 2013.
  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.

Unit 9: Active and Intelligent Packaging

Note

Unit 9: Active and Intelligent Packaging

A question to start with

A pack of fresh berries sits on a shelf. Inside the pack, a small sachet quietly absorbs the oxygen that would turn the berries soft. On the lid, a small label slowly changes colour as the days pass, showing whether the berries are still fresh. The pack is not just a box: it is working, and it is talking. This is active and intelligent packaging, and it changes the job of a pack from holding food to looking after it and telling the truth about it. This unit explains how each kind works, what it can do, and where it can mislead.

Active packaging does something to the food or to the air inside the pack: it absorbs oxygen, releases a protective gas, soaks up moisture, or kills microbes on the surface. Intelligent packaging tells something about the food or the pack: it shows temperature, time, freshness, or whether the pack was opened. The two are often used together, and both are often confused with each other, so the first skill is to keep them apart: active packaging acts, intelligent packaging informs.

Both kinds raise the same questions as every packaging choice: does it keep the food safe, does it keep the food fresh longer, can it be recycled or composted, and is the gain worth the cost? A pack that keeps berries fresh for three extra days and prevents waste is a gain. A pack that adds a battery, a chip, and a layer of plastic to a food that needs none of them is a loss.

Active packaging: oxygen absorbers, moisture control, and antimicrobial packs

The most widely used active pack is the oxygen absorber: a small sachet or a layer in the pack that takes oxygen out of the air inside. Oxygen is the enemy of fresh food: it feeds microbes, it turns fats rancid, and it browns cut fruit. Removing it slows all three. Oxygen absorbers are used in packs of dried foods, cured meats, baked foods, and coffee, where a little oxygen would do much harm. The absorber must be matched to the pack: too small and it leaves oxygen behind, too large and it wastes money, and it must not be eaten, so it is kept in a sachet that is clearly not food.

Moisture control is the second family. A desiccant sachet absorbs water vapour inside a pack of dry food, keeping crisps crisp and powders free flowing. A moisture absorbing pad under fresh meat or fish soaks up the liquid that leaks from the food, which keeps the food looking better and slows the microbes that grow in the liquid. The pad must absorb without leaking back, and it must not add anything to the food it touches.

Antimicrobial packaging is the third family, and the most delicate. The pack carries a substance that slows microbes on the food surface, either by releasing it slowly or by holding it in the pack layer that touches the food. Silver, certain organic acids, and plant extracts have all been used. The promise is a longer shelf life without adding a preservative to the food itself. The risk is that the substance moves into the food in amounts that must be checked, and that the microbes learn to live with it, so the benefit fades. Antimicrobial packs therefore need the same safety checks as a food additive, because the pack and the food are in contact and the substance can migrate.

Questions to think about

  • A pack of dried fruit carries an oxygen absorber sachet. Why must the sachet be kept separate from the fruit, and what happens if the pack is opened and closed again?
  • Why does a moisture pad under fresh fish help shelf life, when the fish itself is wet?
  • An antimicrobial pack releases its active substance slowly. Why must the amount that moves into the food be measured, even when the substance is natural?
Think about the oxygen absorber question before you read on

The sachet must be kept separate because it is not food and must not be eaten, and because it works on the air in the pack, not on the fruit itself. If the pack is opened, fresh air enters, and the absorber may be used up quickly, so it cannot protect the food again. The protection works only while the pack stays sealed.

Modified atmosphere and the active pack together

Active packaging often works with modified atmosphere packaging, in which the air inside the pack is replaced by a chosen mix of gases, usually nitrogen and carbon dioxide, with oxygen kept low. The gas mix slows microbes and browning, and the active pack then keeps the mix right: an oxygen absorber removes the oxygen that leaks in, and a carbon dioxide releaser tops up the gas that dissolves into the food. The two together hold the atmosphere steady for longer than either could alone.

The balance is delicate. Too much carbon dioxide can sour the taste of a food or collapse a pack as the gas dissolves into the food. Too little oxygen can let certain microbes grow that do not need oxygen, and some of those microbes are dangerous, so a low oxygen pack must be kept cold and must carry a clear use by date. The gas mix must be chosen for the food: leafy salads, fresh meat, baked foods, and cheese each need a different mix, and a mix that suits one can harm another.

The pack material matters too. The film must let gases pass at the right rate: too fast and the modified atmosphere escapes, too slow and the gases build up or the pack swells. A film that is right for a salad may be wrong for a meat, and a film that works at one temperature may fail at another. Active packaging is therefore a system, not a sachet: gas, film, food, temperature, and time must all be designed together.

Intelligent packaging: time, temperature, and freshness indicators

Intelligent packaging carries a device or a label that shows something about the food or its history. The simplest is a time temperature indicator: a small label that changes colour as time passes and as temperature rises, showing whether the food was kept cold. The change is driven by a chemical reaction that runs faster when warm, like the microbes that spoil the food, so the label is a rough model of the food's own history. A label that shows the food spent hours warm tells the buyer more than a printed date alone.

Freshness indicators work differently: they react to the gases or the acidity that food gives off as it spoils. A label inside a meat pack may change colour when the volatile compounds of spoilage build up, or when the acidity shifts. The idea is to show the state of this pack, not the average state of all packs made on the same day. The limit is that the indicator reads one signal, while spoilage is many signals, so an indicator can be right about one change and wrong about another.

The newest intelligent packs use printed codes and sensors: a QR code that opens the traceability record for the lot, a radio tag that lets a warehouse read many packs at once, or a sensor that measures temperature and sends the reading to a phone. These tools help the supply chain more than the buyer: they find a warm pallet, a lost case, or a pack that was opened. They also add cost, electronics, and materials that make the pack harder to recycle, so the gain must be weighed against the waste.

When smart packaging misleads, and how to judge it

Intelligent packaging can mislead in two ways. The first is false confidence: a label that stays green does not prove the food is safe, because the label reads temperature or one gas, not the microbes themselves. A buyer who trusts the label and ignores the smell, the date, and the storage will be misled. The second is false alarm: a label that turns red because the pack sat warm for an hour, even though the food is still fine, will cause good food to be thrown away, which is waste, not safety.

Active packaging can mislead too. An oxygen absorber can hide the signs of spoilage by keeping the food looking fresh while microbes grow, and a pack that keeps a food looking good for longer can tempt a seller to stretch the date beyond what is safe. The rule for both kinds is the same: the pack is a tool, not a judge. The date, the storage, and the senses still matter, and the pack must not be used to hide a problem or to extend a date that the food cannot support.

Judging a smart pack means asking four questions. Does it keep the food safer or fresher for longer, in a test, not only in a claim? Can the active substance be measured in the food, and is it inside the safe limit? Can the pack still be recycled or composted, or does the device make it waste? And is the gain worth the cost, in money and in materials? A pack that passes all four is worth using. A pack that fails one is a gadget, not a gain.

How an active and intelligent pack works together

Pack the food in a chosen gas mix, low in oxygen
↓
Oxygen absorber removes the oxygen that leaks in through the film
↓
Moisture pad soaks up liquid from the food and keeps the surface drier
↓
Time temperature label records whether the pack stayed cold
↓
Buyer reads the label, the date, and the food itself before eating

The diagram shows an active pack and an intelligent label working together. The active parts protect the food, the label reports its history, and the buyer still makes the final judgement.

Active packaging, shelf life, and food waste

The strongest case for active and intelligent packaging is food waste. A pack that gives berries three extra days, or that keeps bread soft for two extra days, can save food that would otherwise be thrown away, and the food saved is worth far more than the pack. This is why active packaging is most useful for short life, high value foods that spoil fast: berries, leafy salads, fresh meat, and fish. For a long life food that already keeps well, the gain is small and the extra pack may not be worth it.

The case must be proved with numbers, not assumed. The maker should test the food in the active pack and in the ordinary pack, side by side, and count how many days of shelf life are gained, how much food is saved, and what the extra pack costs. If the gain is one day and the cost is high, the ordinary pack may be better. If the gain is three days and the waste saved is large, the active pack wins. The test should also check the end of life: a pack with a sachet, a pad, and a label is harder to recycle than a plain pack, and that cost must be counted too.

Practical note: Buy two packs of the same short life food, one with an active feature such as a moisture pad or an oxygen absorber, and one without, if you can find them. Compare the price, the date, and the state of the food on the last day. Write down whether the active pack earned its extra cost in extra days, and what happened to the extra parts of the pack when you threw it away.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is an oxygen absorber not a substitute for keeping food cold?

Because it removes oxygen, not heat, and the microbes that grow without oxygen can still grow when warm. A low oxygen pack kept warm can be more dangerous than an ordinary pack, so the absorber must be used with cold storage and a clear use by date.

Question: A freshness label stays green but the food smells off. Which should the buyer trust?

The food and the senses, not the label. The label reads one signal, such as temperature or one gas, while spoilage is many signals. A label that says fresh cannot overrule a smell that says spoiled.

The cost question: who pays for a smart pack?

A smart pack costs more than a plain pack: the sachet, the pad, the label, or the sensor all add money, and the filling line may need to change to handle them. The question is who pays, and whether the gain is worth it to that person. A berry grower who loses a fifth of the crop to spoilage will pay for a pack that saves it, because the saved berries pay for the pack. A shop that throws away unsold salads will pay for a pack that gives two extra days, because the saved salads pay for it. A buyer who pays more for a pack that keeps food fresh at home will pay if the food saved is worth more than the extra price.

The cost falls unevenly, and that shapes who adopts smart packaging first. High value, short life foods adopt it first, because the saving is large and the pack is a small share of the price. Low value, long life foods adopt it last, because the saving is small and the pack is a large share of the price. A smart pack on a bag of rice would cost more than the rice it saves, while a smart pack on a punnet of berries can pay for itself many times over.

The cost also falls over time. The first oxygen absorbers were dear, and now they are cheap enough for everyday use. The first time temperature labels were dear, and now they are printed by the thousand. A student judging a smart pack today should ask not only what it costs now, but what it will cost when it is made at scale, and whether the food it protects is the food that needs it most.

Try it yourself

Choose a short life food: berries, salad leaves, fresh fish, or sliced bread. Design an active and intelligent pack for it: name one active feature, one intelligent feature, and the gas mix you would use. Then write down what each feature would cost, what it would add in shelf life, and what would make the pack harder to recycle. End with a judgement: is your pack worth it, and for which buyer would it be worth it?

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Active packaging acts on the food or the air inside the pack, while intelligent packaging informs about the food or its history.
  • Oxygen absorbers, moisture control, and antimicrobial packs are the main active families.
  • Modified atmosphere and active packaging work together, and the gas mix must match the food.
  • Time temperature indicators and freshness indicators model the food's history, but they read one signal, not the whole food.
  • A smart label that stays green does not prove the food is safe, and a red label can waste good food.
  • The strongest case for smart packaging is saving short life, high value food from waste.
  • Judge every smart pack by its real shelf life gain, its safety, its end of life, and its cost.

Glossary

Active packaging

Packaging that does something to the food or the air inside the pack, such as absorbing oxygen or moisture. Food tech example: an oxygen absorber sachet in a coffee pack is active packaging.

Intelligent packaging

Packaging that tells something about the food or its history, such as temperature or freshness. Food tech example: a time temperature label on a meat pack is intelligent packaging.

Oxygen absorber

A sachet or a pack layer that removes oxygen from the air inside a pack. Food tech example: an oxygen absorber in a pack of dried fruit keeps the fruit from going stale.

Desiccant

A substance that absorbs water vapour, used to keep dry foods dry inside a pack. Food tech example: a desiccant sachet in a pack of crisps keeps them crisp.

Modified atmosphere packaging

Packaging in which the air inside is replaced by a chosen mix of gases, usually low in oxygen. Food tech example: salad leaves are packed in a gas mix that slows browning and microbes.

Time temperature indicator

A label that changes colour as time passes and temperature rises, modelling the food's history. Food tech example: a time temperature indicator shows whether a chilled pack was kept cold.

Freshness indicator

A label that reacts to the gases or acidity that food gives off as it spoils. Food tech example: a freshness indicator in a meat pack changes colour when spoilage gases build up.

Antimicrobial packaging

Packaging that carries a substance that slows microbes on the food surface. Food tech example: an antimicrobial film slows mould on the surface of a cheese.

Volatile compound

A small molecule that evaporates easily and carries flavour or aroma, including the compounds of spoilage. Food tech example: volatile compounds from spoiling meat trigger a freshness indicator.

QR code

A printed square code that a phone or scanner can read to open a record or a web page. Food tech example: a QR code on a pack opens the traceability record for that lot.

Radio tag

A small tag that can be read by radio waves, used to track packs in a warehouse. Food tech example: a radio tag lets a warehouse read many cases at once without opening them.

Shelf life

How long a food stays safe and good to eat under stated storage. Food tech example: active packaging can add days to the shelf life of fresh berries.

Use by date

The date by which a food must be eaten for safety, after which it should not be eaten. Food tech example: a low oxygen pack of fresh meat carries a use by date that must be kept even when the pack looks fresh.

Moisture pad

An absorbent pad under fresh meat or fish that soaks up liquid leaking from the food. Food tech example: a moisture pad under fish keeps the surface drier and slows microbes.

References

  • Robertson, G. L., Food Packaging: Principles and Practice, 3rd edition, 2013.
  • Potter, N. N. and Hotchkiss, J. H., Food Science, 5th edition, 1995.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.

Unit 10: Recycling Systems, Circularity, and Life-Cycle Assessment of Packaging

Note

Unit 10: Recycling Systems, Circularity, and Life-Cycle Assessment of Packaging

A question to start with

A plastic bottle is dropped into a recycling bin. What happens next? The honest answer is: it depends. It depends on the plastic, the colour, the label, the cap, the food left inside, the sorting plant it reaches, and the market for the recycled plastic that comes out. Recycling is not a bin: it is a system, and a pack that is recyclable in theory can be unrecyclable in practice if any step of that system fails. This unit explains the system, the idea of circularity behind it, and the tool that judges a pack fairly: life-cycle assessment.

Circularity means keeping materials in use for as long as possible, at their highest value, instead of making a pack, using it once, and throwing it away. A circular pack is designed to be reused, recycled, or composted, and the system to do that exists where the pack is sold. A linear pack is made, used, and thrown away, and its materials are lost. The difference is not only in the pack: it is in the design, the collection, the sorting, the reprocessing, and the market for what comes out.

Life-cycle assessment, known as LCA, is the method for judging a pack across its whole life: from raw material, through making, filling, transport, use, and end of life. It counts the energy, water, and emissions at each step, and it shows where the harm really sits. Often the harm sits in the food, not the pack, or in one step that nobody expected. LCA is the tool that stops a business from fixing the visible problem while missing the larger one.

How recycling works, step by step

Recycling starts with collection: the pack must be collected separately from other waste, or it will be lost. Collection can be from the home, from a shop, or from a deposit return scheme, in which the buyer pays a small deposit on a bottle or can and gets it back when the empty pack is returned. Deposit schemes collect cleaner material than home bins, because the packs are returned whole and separate, and the return rate is high.

Next comes sorting. At a sorting plant, the collected packs are separated by material and by type, using screens, air jets, magnets, and optical sorters that read the plastic. Sorting is where many packs fail: a black plastic tray cannot be read by many optical sorters, because black absorbs the light they use. A bottle with a full sleeve label cannot be read, because the sorter sees the label, not the bottle. A pack made of two materials glued together cannot be separated, so it goes to waste. A pack that is easy to sort is a pack designed for sorting: one material, a clear code, and a label that does not hide the pack.

Then comes reprocessing: washing, shredding, melting, and turning the old pack into a new material. Reprocessing loses quality each time: a clear bottle may become a coloured bottle, then a fibre, then a park bench, in a chain called downcycling. Food grade recycling is the hardest, because the recycled plastic must be clean enough to touch food again, and only some plastics and some processes can meet that standard. A bottle that becomes a bottle again is the highest value recycling; a bottle that becomes a bench is still recycling, but the material has stepped down.

What makes a pack recyclable in practice

A pack is recyclable in practice only when four conditions hold. First, the material must be recyclable in the system where the pack is sold: a plastic that is recycled in one place may not be collected in another. Second, the pack must be designed for recycling: one material where possible, no black plastic where optical sorting is used, a label that leaves the pack visible, and a cap that can be recycled with the bottle or removed easily.

Third, the pack must reach the system clean and whole. Food left inside a pack contaminates the recycling, and a crushed or torn pack may not sort correctly. The buyer has a part to play: rinsing a pack and putting the right pack in the right bin is not a small act, because a dirty bin can send a whole load to waste. Fourth, there must be a market for the recycled material. If nobody buys recycled plastic, the sorted bales will pile up, and the system will stop. Markets grow when makers commit to using recycled material in new packs, and when buyers accept a recycled pack.

Compostable packs have their own version of the same test. A compostable pack is only compostable where industrial composting exists, where the pack is collected with food waste, and where the composting plant accepts that pack. A compostable pack put in a recycling bin contaminates recycling, and a compostable pack put in landfill breaks down slowly, if at all. The right bin matters as much as the right material.

Questions to think about

  • A black plastic tray is technically recyclable, but the sorting plant cannot read it. Is it recyclable in practice? Why or why not?
  • Why does a deposit return scheme collect cleaner material than a home recycling bin?
  • A maker uses recycled plastic in its new bottles. How does that help the recycling system, beyond saving new plastic?
Think about the black tray question before you read on

No, not in practice. Recycling in practice needs every step to work, and the tray fails at sorting, because the optical sorter cannot read black plastic. A material that cannot be sorted cannot be reprocessed, so the tray goes to waste even though its plastic could, in theory, be recycled.

Circularity: reuse, recycle, compost, in that order

Circularity ranks the ends of a pack's life. Reuse is best, because the pack is used again without being remade: a bottle washed and refilled, or a container returned and used again. Recycling is next, because the material is remade into a new pack, which takes energy but saves raw material. Composting is next for packs that cannot be reused or recycled, because the material returns to the soil, but only where composting exists. Landfill and energy recovery sit at the bottom: the material is lost, even if energy is recovered from burning it.

Design for circularity means designing for the top of that order. A pack designed for reuse is strong, washable, and standard in shape, so that many fillers can use it. A pack designed for recycling is one material, easy to sort, and made with recycled material in mind. A pack designed for composting is made of a material the composting plant accepts, and it is labelled so clearly that the buyer puts it in the right bin.

Circularity also needs the system, not only the pack. A reusable pack needs a return system, a washing plant, and a standard that all fillers accept. A recyclable pack needs collection, sorting, reprocessing, and a market. A compostable pack needs food waste collection and a composting plant. A business that designs a circular pack without checking that the system exists has designed a wish, not a pack.

Life-cycle assessment: judging a pack across its whole life

Life-cycle assessment, or LCA, is the method for judging a pack fairly. It sets a clear question: what is being compared, and for what job? The job is called the functional unit, and it is the key to a fair comparison. Comparing one bottle with one pouch is unfair if the bottle holds a litre and the pouch holds half a litre. The fair comparison is the pack needed to deliver the same amount of food, kept fresh for the same time, to the same place. A light pack that lets food spoil will look good on packaging alone and bad on the whole life, because the wasted food counts too.

LCA then counts the inputs and outputs at each step: the raw material, the energy to make the pack, the energy to fill and transport it, the food waste during its life, and the end of life. The results are grouped into impacts: greenhouse gas emissions, energy use, water use, and waste. The result is not one number but a picture, and the picture usually has a surprise: the food inside the pack often carries a larger footprint than the pack, so a pack that saves food can be the best pack even when it uses more material.

LCA has limits that a student must know. The result depends on the assumptions: how far the pack travels, how it is disposed of, and how much food is wasted. A small change in an assumption can change the answer, so a good LCA states its assumptions and tests them: if the pack goes to landfill instead of recycling, does the answer change? If the food waste is higher, does the answer change? A study that hides its assumptions is not a study to trust.

How a pack travels through the recycling system

Buyer uses the pack, rinses it, and puts it in the right bin
↓
Collection carries it to a sorting plant, whole and separate
↓
Sorting separates it by material and type, and rejects what cannot be read
↓
Reprocessing washes, shreds, and melts it into new material
↓
Maker buys the recycled material and makes a new pack from it
↓
The new pack is sold, used, and recycled again

The diagram shows the recycling loop. If any step fails, the loop breaks and the pack leaves the circle.

A worked example: a simple life-cycle comparison

A full LCA needs software and data, but the logic can be worked by hand on a simple example. Compare two packs for the same food: a glass jar and a plastic pouch, each holding the same amount of food, kept fresh for the same time. Use practice numbers to see how the comparison works.

Step one: count the pack. Suppose the glass jar weighs 200 grams and the plastic pouch weighs 20 grams. The jar uses ten times the material by weight, and glass needs high heat to make, so the making of the jar carries a larger footprint per pack.

Step two: count the transport. Suppose 1,000 packs are carried 100 kilometres. The jars weigh 200 kilograms in total, while the pouches weigh 20 kilograms, so the truck carries far less weight for the pouches, and the fuel per pack is lower.

Step three: count the reuse and the end. Suppose the jar is reused ten times, while the pouch is used once and recycled. The jar's making footprint is then divided by ten, one share per use, which may bring it below the pouch. But if the jar is used once and thrown away, its footprint per use is far above the pouch.

Step four: count the food. Suppose the pouch lets the food keep one day less than the jar, and one pack in twenty is wasted as a result. The wasted food, with its farming, water, and energy, may outweigh the whole saving from the lighter pack. The final judgement therefore depends on reuse, on food waste, and on transport, not on the pack weight alone. That is the lesson of LCA: the answer is in the whole life, not in one step.

Designing for the circle: what a maker can do now

A maker who wants a circular pack can start with five steps. First, use less material: a thinner wall, a smaller pack, or a refill that replaces a full pack. Second, use one material: a pack of one plastic, or one paper, is easier to sort and recycle than a pack of two materials glued together. Third, design for sorting: avoid black plastic where optical sorting is used, keep the label from hiding the pack, and print the material code clearly.

Fourth, use recycled material where it is safe and allowed, because that creates the market that keeps the system running. Fifth, label the pack honestly: state the material, state the right bin, and state what the buyer should do, such as rinse the pack or remove the cap. A pack that is recyclable but labelled so poorly that the buyer puts it in the wrong bin is not a circular pack in practice.

The last step is to check the system where the pack will be sold. A pack designed for a recycling system that does not exist in that place is not circular there, and the maker must either choose a different pack or help build the system. Circularity is a property of the pack and the place together, not of the pack alone.

Practical note: Take three packs from your kitchen and check each one against the four conditions of practical recyclability: is the material collected where you live, is the pack one material and easy to sort, is it clean and whole, and is there a market for it? Write down which condition each pack fails, if any, and what change in design would fix it.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is a bottle that becomes a bottle again better recycling than a bottle that becomes a bench?

Because the material stays at its highest value and can be used again as a bottle, keeping the loop closed. A bottle that becomes a bench has stepped down in value, and the next bottle must be made from new material.

Question: A light pouch uses less material than a heavy jar, but the food in the pouch spoils a day sooner. Why might the jar still win the life-cycle comparison?

Because the wasted food carries a larger footprint than the pack, in farming, water, and energy. If the pouch causes food waste, that waste can outweigh the whole saving from the lighter pack.

Try it yourself

Pick a food pack from your kitchen. Write a one page life-cycle sketch for it: the raw material, the making, the transport, the use, and the end of life. For each step, write down the main impact and one question you would ask to check it. Then design a more circular version of the same pack: one material, easy to sort, with recycled content, and a clear label. Compare the two versions: which step of the life changes most, and what would need to exist in your area for the new pack to work?

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Recycling is a system: collection, sorting, reprocessing, and a market must all work, or the loop breaks.
  • A pack is recyclable in practice only when it can be collected, sorted, reprocessed, and sold as recycled material.
  • Deposit return schemes collect cleaner material than home bins, because packs are returned whole and separate.
  • Circularity ranks reuse first, then recycling, then composting, with landfill last.
  • Life-cycle assessment judges a pack across its whole life, for the same job, and the food inside often matters more than the pack.
  • A good LCA states its assumptions and tests them, because the answer can change with the assumption.
  • Design for the circle: less material, one material, easy to sort, recycled content, and an honest label.

Glossary

Circularity

Keeping materials in use for as long as possible, at their highest value, instead of making, using once, and throwing away. Food tech example: a bottle washed and refilled is circular, while a bottle thrown away after one use is linear.

Life-cycle assessment

A method for judging a product across its whole life, from raw material to disposal, also called LCA. Food tech example: an LCA of a pack counts the energy and emissions of making, transport, use, and disposal.

Functional unit

The job a product must do, used as the basis for a fair comparison in an LCA. Food tech example: the functional unit for a pack comparison is delivering the same amount of food, kept fresh for the same time.

Deposit return scheme

A system in which the buyer pays a small deposit on a pack and gets it back when the empty pack is returned. Food tech example: a deposit return scheme for bottles collects clean bottles for recycling or reuse.

Sorting plant

A plant that separates collected packs by material and type, using screens, magnets, and optical sorters. Food tech example: a sorting plant separates clear bottles from coloured bottles and from trays.

Optical sorter

A machine that reads a pack by light and separates it by material or colour. Food tech example: an optical sorter cannot read a black plastic tray, so the tray goes to waste.

Downcycling

Recycling in which a material becomes a lower value product each time it is reused. Food tech example: a clear bottle downcycled into a fibre and then into a bench loses value at each step.

Food grade recycling

Recycling that makes a material clean enough to touch food again. Food tech example: food grade recycling of a bottle must prove the recycled plastic is safe for food contact.

Reprocessing

Washing, shredding, and melting collected packs into new material. Food tech example: reprocessing turns sorted bottles into pellets that a maker can use for new bottles.

Recycled content

The share of a new pack made from recycled material rather than new material. Food tech example: a bottle with recycled content creates a market for sorted bottles.

Linear

Describing a make, use, and throw away pattern, in which materials are lost after one use. Food tech example: a linear pack is made, used once, and sent to landfill.

Reuse

Using a pack again for the same job without remaking it. Food tech example: a glass bottle washed and refilled is reuse.

Greenhouse gas emissions

Gases that trap heat in the atmosphere, counted in an LCA as one impact of a product. Food tech example: the greenhouse gas emissions of a pack include the energy used to make and transport it.

Sleeve label

A plastic sleeve that covers a bottle or pack, which can hide the pack from a sorter. Food tech example: a full sleeve label stops an optical sorter from reading the bottle beneath it.

References

  • Robertson, G. L., Food Packaging: Principles and Practice, 3rd edition, 2013.
  • Potter, N. N. and Hotchkiss, J. H., Food Science, 5th edition, 1995.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.
  • Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Food Wastage Footprint, 2013.