GIFSQ ID: FTN-0104
Novel Foods and Food Regulation
Unit 1: What a Novel Food Is
Note
Unit 1: What a Novel Food Is
A question to start with
A chef serves a burger that looks like beef, smells like beef, and tastes close to beef, but no cow was raised for it: the patty was grown from animal cells in a tank, or made from peas and beans shaped to act like meat. A shop sells a flour made from insects, and a drink coloured with a pigment from algae that nobody ate a generation ago. Are these foods safe to eat, who decides, and what must be proved before they can be sold? This unit explains what a novel food is, why the idea exists, and how new foods differ from the foods people have eaten for a long time.
A novel food is a food that has not been eaten by people in a significant way before, or a food made by a new process that changes it in an important way. The key idea is history of use: a food that people have eaten for generations, in a place and in a form that is known, is not novel. A food with no such history, or a familiar food made in a way that changes what is inside it, is novel, and it must be checked before it can be sold.
The idea matters because history of use is a form of evidence. When people have eaten a food for a long time, in large amounts, without clear harm, that history tells us something about its safety. A new food has no such history, so its safety must be proved in another way: by studying what it is made of, how the body handles it, and whether it could cause harm. The novel food system is the way societies ask for that proof before a new food reaches the shops.
The main kinds of novel foods
Novel foods fall into several groups, and it helps to learn them, because each group raises different questions.
The first group is new sources of familiar nutrients: proteins, oils, and fibres from sources people have not eaten before. Examples include protein from insects, protein from fungi grown in tanks, protein from single cell organisms, and oils from algae. The question for these foods is whether the protein is complete, whether it carries anything harmful, and whether it causes allergy in people who are allergic to related foods.
The second group is foods made by new processes. A familiar food made by a new method can become novel if the method changes its composition in an important way. Examples include foods made with new extraction methods, new heating methods, or new ways of growing cells. The question is what the process changed: did it create a new substance, did it remove something important, or did it change how the body absorbs the food?
The third group is plants and animals changed by breeding or by new techniques. A plant bred to make a new oil, or an animal changed so that it grows faster, raises questions about what changed in the food and whether the change is safe to eat. Precision breeding, covered in Unit 3, is the newest form of this group, and it needs care to describe fairly, because the methods differ and the rules differ from place to place.
The fourth group is foods from other parts of the world that have a history of use somewhere else but not where they are now being sold. A fruit eaten for generations in one region may be novel in another, because the people there have no history of eating it. The question is whether the history from the home region counts, and what extra proof is needed when the food is eaten by new people, in new amounts, and in new forms.
The fifth group is new ingredients added to familiar foods: a new sweetener, a new fibre, a new colour, a new vitamin form, or a new culture for fermented foods. The ingredient may be used in small amounts, but it is eaten by many people, often every day, so its safety must be proved at the level people will actually eat.
Why novel foods appear now
Novel foods are appearing faster than before, for several plain reasons. The first is the search for protein that uses less land, less water, and less feed than raising animals. Insects, fungi, algae, and cell grown meat all promise protein with a smaller footprint, and that promise drives research and investment.
The second reason is the search for foods that meet new needs: foods for people who cannot eat gluten, or dairy, or meat, or who want foods with less sugar, less fat, or more fibre. A new ingredient that gives sweetness without sugar, or creaminess without dairy, can open a whole range of products.
The third reason is science itself. New tools can read the genes of a plant, grow cells in a tank, or ferment a microbe to make a protein, and those tools create foods that could not have been made a generation ago. The science moves faster than the rules, which is why the approval process matters: it is the place where the new science is checked before it reaches the plate.
The fourth reason is trade. A food eaten in one part of the world can now be shipped to another part in days, and a company in one place can sell a new food in many places at once. That speed makes the question of who decides, and on what evidence, a shared question across borders, even though the rules still differ from place to place.
Questions to think about
- A fruit has been eaten for generations in one region but never in another. Is it a novel food in the second region, and why?
- A familiar oil is made by a new extraction method that leaves a new substance in the oil. Is the oil still the same food?
- Why does a history of safe eating count as evidence, and what are its limits?
Think about the fruit question before you read on
Yes, it can be a novel food in the second region, because novel means no significant history of use in the place where it will be sold. The history from the home region is useful evidence, and it may shorten the approval, but it does not settle the question on its own: people in the new place may eat it in different amounts, in different forms, and alongside different foods, and they may include people with allergies or conditions that the home region did not have. The history helps, but the new use must still be checked.
What novel does not mean
Three misunderstandings about novel foods are common, and it is worth clearing them at the start.
First, novel does not mean unsafe. A new food may be safe, and many novel foods are approved after careful study. The word novel means unproven by history, not dangerous. The approval process exists to find out which new foods are safe and which are not, and to keep the unsafe ones off the market.
Second, novel does not mean unnatural. Many novel foods come from natural sources: insects, algae, fungi, and plants are all natural, and a new food can be natural and still be novel, because nobody has eaten it before. The question is not whether the source is natural, but whether the food is safe to eat in the amounts people will eat it.
Third, novel does not mean the same as a new product. A new flavour of biscuit, a new shape of pasta, or a new mix of familiar ingredients is a new product, but it is not a novel food, because its ingredients all have a history of use. A novel food is new at the level of the ingredient or the process, not at the level of the recipe. A biscuit made with a novel flour is a new product that contains a novel food, and the flour is the part that needs approval.
How a novel food is judged
A novel food is judged on three questions, and every approval system, in its own way, asks the same three.
The first question is safety: could the food harm people who eat it, at the amounts they will eat, over a lifetime? This is judged by studying what the food is made of, how it is digested, whether it carries toxins or allergens, and whether animal and laboratory studies show harm. The studies must cover the people who will eat it, including children, pregnant people, and people with allergies, where the food will be eaten by them.
The second question is nutrition: does the food replace a familiar food, and if so, does it feed people as well? A novel protein that replaces meat should give the same amino acids, or the label should say what it lacks. A novel oil that replaces a familiar oil should give the same fatty acids, or the difference should be clear. A food that is safe but feeds people worse than the food it replaces can still be approved, but its label must not mislead buyers about what it gives them.
The third question is honesty: is the food what it claims to be, and does its label tell the truth? A novel food must not mislead buyers about its nature, its origin, or its benefits. A plant based drink that calls itself milk, or a cell grown meat that calls itself farm raised, raises questions of honesty as well as of safety, and the labelling rules, covered in Unit 4, exist to answer them.
The diagram shows the first decision about a new food. The steps point to the diagram: the question of history comes first, and the questions of safety, nutrition, and honesty follow.
The words buyers meet
Buyers meet novel foods under many names, and the names matter. Cell based meat, cultured meat, and cultivated meat all describe meat grown from animal cells without raising the animal. Plant based meat describes a food made from plants to act like meat. Precision fermented protein describes a protein made by a microbe that has been given the instructions to make it. Insect protein describes flour or bars made from insects. Each name tells a different story about how the food was made, and buyers deserve names that tell the true story.
The names are still settling, and different places use different words for the same food. That is why the label matters more than the marketing name: the label must say what the food is, what it is made from, and how it was made, in words a buyer can understand. A buyer who cannot tell from the label whether a burger came from a cow, a plant, or a tank cannot make a free choice, and a free choice is part of what food law protects.
Why this subject matters for food students
Food students will meet novel foods in every part of their work: in product development, where a new ingredient must be approved before it can be used; in quality and safety, where a new food must be tested and labelled; in buying, where a supplier offers a new ingredient; and in talking to buyers, who will ask whether a new food is safe and what it is. The answers need knowledge, not opinion: what the food is, what was proved, what was not proved, and what the label says.
This subject follows the novel food from its definition to its market. The next unit explains how approval works, step by step. Then comes precision breeding and new techniques, then labelling, then the regulation systems of the world in general terms, then the steps of bringing a novel food to market, and finally the case studies: what got approved, what did not, and what each case taught.
Practical note: Walk through a supermarket or an online shop and find three foods that describe themselves as plant based, cultured, fermented, or new. Read the labels and write down what each food is actually made from, how it was made, and what it claims to be. Then ask: could a buyer tell from the label alone whether the food is novel, and what questions would you still need to ask before you could judge it? Keep the labels with your notes for this subject.
Quick self-check
Question: A company launches a new flavour of biscuit using only familiar ingredients. Is the biscuit a novel food?
No. The biscuit is a new product, but its ingredients all have a history of use, so no ingredient is novel. A novel food is new at the level of the ingredient or the process, not at the level of the recipe.
Question: Why is a history of safe eating useful evidence, and what is its limit?
It is useful because many people ate the food for a long time without clear harm, which is real evidence about safety. Its limit is that the history may come from a different place, a different amount, or a different form, and it may not cover children, pregnant people, or people with allergies, so it must be weighed with care.
Try it yourself
Pick a novel food you have heard of: insect flour, cell grown meat, algae oil, or a protein made by fermentation. Write a one page profile: what is it made from, how is it made, who would eat it, what would it replace, and what three questions would you ask before you decided it was safe? Use the three judgement questions from this unit: safety, nutrition, and honesty. Bring your profile to class and compare it with a classmate who picked a different food: which food raises the hardest safety question, and why?
Key ideas to carry forward
- A novel food is a food with no significant history of eating, or a familiar food changed in an important way by a new process.
- History of use is evidence about safety, and a new food without it must prove its safety in another way.
- The main groups are new protein and nutrient sources, foods made by new processes, plants and animals changed by breeding, foods new to a place, and new ingredients in familiar foods.
- Novel does not mean unsafe, and it does not mean unnatural: it means unproven by history.
- A novel food is judged on safety, on nutrition where it replaces a familiar food, and on honesty in its labelling.
- The names on the pack matter, because buyers deserve to know whether a food came from an animal, a plant, or a tank.
Glossary
Novel food
A food with no significant history of eating, or a familiar food changed in an important way by a new process. Food tech example: flour made from insects is a novel food in places where insects have not been eaten before.
History of use
The record of people eating a food over a long time, used as evidence about its safety. Food tech example: a fruit eaten for generations in one region has a history of use there.
Cell based meat
Meat grown from animal cells in a tank, without raising the animal. Food tech example: a burger patty grown from cattle cells is cell based meat.
Plant based meat
A food made from plants to look, taste, and act like meat. Food tech example: a patty made from pea protein shaped to act like beef is plant based meat.
Precision fermentation
A method where a microbe is given instructions to make a chosen protein, which is then harvested and used as food. Food tech example: a milk protein made by yeast through precision fermentation.
Insect protein
Protein from insects, sold as flour, bars, or feed. Food tech example: flour made from crickets is an insect protein.
Algae oil
Oil from algae, used as a source of fatty acids. Food tech example: an oil from algae used in a drink as a source of omega 3 fatty acids.
Single cell protein
Protein from microbes such as bacteria, yeast, or fungi grown in tanks. Food tech example: a protein made by a fungus grown on a sugar feed is a single cell protein.
Allergen
A substance in food that can cause an allergic reaction in some people. Food tech example: a person allergic to shellfish may react to insect protein, because insects and shellfish are related.
Amino acid
A building block of protein, some of which the body cannot make and must get from food. Food tech example: a novel protein is judged on whether it gives all the essential amino acids.
Approval
Permission from a food authority to sell a novel food, given after safety, nutrition, and labelling have been judged. Food tech example: a novel oil cannot be sold until its approval is granted.
Food authority
A public body that judges food safety and gives permission to sell new foods. Food tech example: a food authority reviews the safety studies for a novel food.
Processing aid
A substance used during making that is not meant to stay in the finished food. Food tech example: an enzyme used to make a novel protein is a processing aid.
References
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Novel Foods, 2021.
- European Food Safety Authority, Guidance on Novel Foods, 2016.
- Jaffe, G., Regulatory Approval for Novel Foods, 2019.
- Verbeke, W., Consumer Acceptance of Novel Foods, 2015.
- Ritala, A., et al., Single Cell Protein, 2017.
Unit 2: How Approval Works, the General Process
Note
Unit 2: How Approval Works, the General Process
A question to start with
A company has spent years making a new protein from fungi. The protein is ready, the factory is built, and the buyers are waiting. Before a single pack can be sold, a food authority must say yes. What does the company have to show, who reads the evidence, how long does it take, and what happens if the answer is no, or yes with conditions? This unit walks through the approval process in general terms, the steps that most systems share, even though the details differ from place to place.
Approval is the gate between a new food and the market. It exists because a new food has no history of safe eating, so someone independent must check the evidence before the public is asked to eat it. The company that makes the food must prove it is safe; the authority does not have to prove it is unsafe. That rule, that the maker carries the proof, is the foundation of the whole process.
The process is slow on purpose. A new food will be eaten by many people, often every day, for years, so a mistake at the gate can harm many people for a long time. The slowness is a cost to the company, which must pay for studies and wait for an answer, but it is a protection for the buyer, who cannot test the food themselves.
The steps of approval
Most approval systems share the same steps, in the same order, even when the names of the bodies differ.
The first step is a pre submission talk. The company meets the authority, describes the food, and asks what evidence will be needed. This step saves time and money, because it stops the company from running the wrong studies or missing a study the authority will ask for. A company that skips this step often has its application sent back for missing evidence.
The second step is the application itself. The company writes a dossier, a large file of evidence that describes the food in full: what it is made of, how it is made, how it will be used, how much people will eat, and what the safety studies show. The dossier is the heart of the process, and it must be complete, honest, and clear enough for a scientist who has never seen the food to judge it.
The third step is the safety assessment. Scientists at the authority, or scientists the authority asks to help, read the dossier and judge whether the food is safe at the amounts people will eat. They look for gaps, for weak studies, and for questions the dossier does not answer, and they ask the company for more evidence where it is needed. This step takes the longest, because it is the step where the science is weighed.
The fourth step is the decision. The authority, or the government it advises, decides whether to approve the food, to approve it with conditions, or to refuse it. Conditions are common: the food may be approved only for certain uses, only in certain amounts, only with a certain label, or only for adults. A refusal means the food cannot be sold, and the company may reapply later with better evidence.
The fifth step is the listing and the label. An approved food is listed, so that buyers, businesses, and inspectors can check that it is approved and for what uses. The label is fixed at this step too: what the food must be called, what warnings it must carry, and what claims it may make. The label is part of the approval, not an afterthought.
The sixth step is monitoring after the market. Once the food is sold, the authority watches for problems: reports of allergy, reports of illness, and new science that changes the picture. If a problem appears, the approval can be changed, the conditions can be tightened, or the food can be taken off the market. Approval is not a promise that lasts forever: it lasts while the evidence supports it.
What the dossier must prove
The dossier must answer the three judgement questions from Unit 1, with evidence, not with claims.
For safety, the dossier must show what the food is made of, in full: its proteins, fats, carbohydrates, minerals, vitamins, and any smaller parts. It must show how the food is made, step by step, and what could go wrong at each step. It must show the results of laboratory studies and animal studies, where they are needed, and it must show whether the food could cause allergy, especially in people allergic to related foods. If the food is made by a microbe or a cell, the dossier must show that the microbe or cell is safe and that nothing harmful from it stays in the food.
For intake, the dossier must show how much people will eat, and who will eat it. A food eaten by everyone every day needs stronger proof than a food eaten rarely by a few people. The dossier estimates intake from the foods the new ingredient will go into, and it checks the highest eaters, not only the average eater, because the highest eater is the one most at risk. Children, pregnant people, and people who eat a lot of the food it replaces are looked at with care.
For nutrition, the dossier must show what the food gives and what it lacks, where it replaces a familiar food. A novel protein that replaces meat must be judged on its amino acids. A novel oil that replaces a familiar oil must be judged on its fatty acids. If the new food is less nourishing than the food it replaces, the label must make that clear, so that buyers are not misled.
For the process, the dossier must show that the food can be made the same way every time, and that the food tested in the studies is the same food that will be sold. A food that varies from batch to batch cannot be judged, because the studies describe one version and the shops sell another. Good manufacturing practice, the discipline of making food the same way every time, is part of the proof.
Questions to think about
- A company applies to sell a novel protein but its dossier has no study on allergy. What should the authority do, and why?
- Why does the dossier have to estimate how much the highest eaters will eat, not only the average?
- A food is approved only for use in drinks, not in bread. What does that condition mean for a baker who wants to use it?
Think about the allergy question before you read on
The authority should ask for the missing study before deciding, or refuse the application until the study is done. Allergy is a safety question that cannot be guessed: a protein from a new source may cross react with a known allergen, and the only way to know is to test it. Approving without that evidence would ask the public to take a risk the company has not measured.
Who does what
Three groups take part in approval, and each has a different job. The company makes the food, runs the studies, and writes the dossier. It has the most knowledge about the food, and it also has the most to gain from approval, so its evidence is checked by people with no stake in the outcome.
The authority reads the evidence and judges it. Its scientists must be independent, must have no financial interest in the food, and must be free to ask hard questions. In some systems the authority gives advice and a government minister makes the final decision; in others the authority decides itself. Either way, the science and the decision are kept apart from the company, so that the judgement is trusted.
The public takes part too, in many systems, through consultation: the application is published, and anyone can comment on it. Consumer groups, scientists, and other businesses can point out gaps the authority missed, or raise questions the dossier does not answer. Consultation does not decide the outcome, but it makes the process open, and openness builds trust in the final decision.
Why approval takes so long, and what can go wrong
Approval takes time because the science takes time. Studies on animals take months, studies on how the body handles a new protein take months, and the reading of a large dossier takes months. The authority may ask for more evidence, and each round of questions adds time. A company that expects a quick answer will be disappointed, and a company that plans for a long process, with money set aside for the wait, will survive it.
Things go wrong in predictable ways. The dossier is incomplete, and the authority sends it back. The studies use a different version of the food from the one that will be sold, and the results do not apply. The intake estimate is too low, because the company forgot a use, and the authority finds the gap. The allergy question is not answered, and the authority cannot approve. The label claims more than the evidence supports, and the label must be rewritten. Each of these is a delay, not a refusal, but delays cost money, and some companies run out of money before approval comes.
A refusal is different from a delay. A refusal means the evidence does not show the food is safe, or the company cannot show that it can be made safely every time. A refused company may run better studies and apply again, but it cannot sell the food while it waits. The refusal protects the public, and it also protects the honest companies, because a food approved on weak evidence would damage trust in every novel food that follows.
The diagram shows the approval journey in order. The steps point to the diagram: each step depends on the one before it, and a weak dossier makes every later step slower.
Approval in one place, and in another
Approval in one place does not mean approval everywhere. Each place has its own authority, its own rules, and its own list of approved foods, and a food approved in one place must still be approved in another before it can be sold there. Some places accept evidence from another place to speed the process, and some places have agreements to share assessments, but the decision stays local, because each place weighs the evidence in its own way and serves its own eaters.
This matters for a food business that wants to sell in many places: it must plan for several approvals, not one, and it must budget time and money for each. A company that launches in one place and assumes the rest will follow quickly will be disappointed. The wise course is to apply where the market is most ready first, learn from that process, and then apply elsewhere with a stronger dossier.
For a buyer, the lesson is simpler: a novel food sold in a shop should be approved for sale in that place, and the label should show it. A food bought online from another place may not have been approved where the buyer lives, and the buyer takes a risk by eating it. Checking the approval is part of buying a novel food wisely.
What approval does not do
Approval does not mean a food is healthy, or that it is better than the food it replaces. It means the food is safe at the amounts and uses approved, and that its label is honest. A novel sweetener that is approved is safe to eat, but it is not a health food. A novel protein that is approved is safe, but it may not feed people as well as meat, and the label should say so.
Approval also does not mean the food will be liked, or that it will sell. Taste, price, habit, and culture decide whether a new food succeeds, and many approved novel foods have failed in the market because buyers did not want them. Approval opens the door to the market; it does not guarantee a place in it.
Practical note: Imagine you work for a small company that has made a new protein from fungi. Write a one page plan for the approval journey: what would you ask in the pre submission talk, what studies would you run, who would you hire to write the dossier, and how would you pay for the wait? Then write down the three things most likely to go wrong, and what you would do about each one. Keep the plan with your novel food profile from Unit 1.
Quick self-check
Question: Who must prove that a novel food is safe, the company or the authority?
The company must prove it. The maker carries the proof, and the authority judges the evidence. The authority does not have to prove the food is unsafe before it can refuse it.
Question: Why is monitoring after the market part of approval, not an extra?
Because no study can cover every eater, every amount, and every year of eating. Monitoring watches for problems that only appear when many people eat the food over time, such as allergy in a group the studies missed, and it lets the authority change the approval if a problem appears.
The approval path at a glance
The steps of approval are easier to follow as a flow, and the flow also shows where an application can stall. Read it from top to bottom, and note that each step depends on the one before it: a weak dossier cannot be saved by a good meeting, and a good dossier cannot pass if the science is thin.
The diagram shows the approval flow. The step where most applications stall is the scientific review, because that is where thin evidence is found.
Try it yourself
Pick a novel food from your profile in Unit 1. Write a dossier outline for it: a list of the chapters your dossier would contain, from the description of the food to the safety studies, the intake estimate, the nutrition comparison, and the label. For each chapter, write one sentence saying what evidence it would hold. Then mark the chapters you think would take the longest to complete, and explain why. Bring your outline to class and compare it with a classmate: which dossier has the hardest chapter, and why?
Key ideas to carry forward
- The maker of a novel food must prove it is safe; the authority judges the proof.
- Approval follows the same broad steps everywhere: a pre submission talk, a dossier, a safety assessment, a decision, a listing and label, and monitoring after the market.
- The dossier must prove safety, intake, nutrition, and that the food can be made the same way every time.
- Conditions are common: approval may cover only certain uses, amounts, or groups of eaters.
- Approval in one place does not mean approval everywhere; each place decides for itself.
- Approval means safe at the approved uses and honest in labelling; it does not mean healthy or sure to sell.
Glossary
Dossier
The large file of evidence a company submits to ask for approval of a novel food. Food tech example: a dossier for a novel protein describes its composition, its making, its safety studies, and its label.
Safety assessment
The independent scientific judgement of whether a novel food is safe at the amounts people will eat. Food tech example: a safety assessment reads the dossier and asks for more evidence where the science is thin.
Pre submission talk
A meeting between a company and an authority before an application, to agree what evidence will be needed. Food tech example: a pre submission talk tells a company which allergy study to run.
Intake estimate
A calculation of how much of a novel food people will eat, including the highest eaters. Food tech example: an intake estimate for a novel sweetener covers drinks, biscuits, and yoghurt together.
Condition of approval
A limit placed on an approval, such as only certain uses or amounts. Food tech example: a novel oil approved only for use in drinks cannot be used in bread.
Consultation
The step where an application is published and the public can comment on it. Food tech example: a consumer group comments that a dossier has no study on children.
Good manufacturing practice
The discipline of making food the same way every time, with records and checks. Food tech example: good manufacturing practice proves that the food sold matches the food tested in the studies.
Cross reactivity
An allergic reaction to a new protein because it is similar to a known allergen. Food tech example: a person allergic to shellfish may cross react to insect protein.
Listing
The official record of approved novel foods and the uses they are approved for. Food tech example: a buyer checks the listing to see whether a novel oil is approved for sale.
Post market monitoring
Watching a food after it is sold for reports of harm or new science. Food tech example: post market monitoring catches an allergy that the studies missed.
Refusal
A decision not to approve a novel food, because the evidence does not show it is safe. Food tech example: a refusal tells the company to run better studies before applying again.
Food authority
A public body that judges food safety and gives permission to sell new foods. Food tech example: a food authority reads the dossier and gives the safety assessment.
References
- European Food Safety Authority, Guidance on Novel Foods, 2016.
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Novel Foods, 2021.
- Jaffe, G., Regulatory Approval for Novel Foods, 2019.
- Verbeke, W., Consumer Acceptance of Novel Foods, 2015.
- Knudsen, I., et al., Risk Assessment of Novel Foods, 2008.
Unit 3: Precision Breeding and New Techniques
Note
Unit 3: Precision Breeding and New Techniques
A question to start with
A wheat plant is bred so that its grain makes less of a substance that can form a harmful compound when bread is toasted. The change is tiny: a few letters in the plant's own genes are altered, and no gene from another species is added. Is that plant the same as a plant bred by crossing two wheats in a field, or is it something new that needs a different kind of check? This unit explains precision breeding and the new techniques around it, in plain terms, and shows how they differ from older breeding and from older forms of genetic change.
Breeding is the oldest food technology. For thousands of years, farmers chose the best plants and the best animals and bred from them, and the food on our plates today is the result. Traditional breeding works by crossing: pollen from one plant fertilises another, or two animals are mated, and the offspring carry a mix of both parents. The breeder then picks the offspring with the traits wanted, such as higher yield, better taste, or resistance to disease, and breeds from them again. It is slow, and it mixes many traits at once, wanted and unwanted, so the breeder must grow many plants and pick the best.
Precision breeding uses new tools to make a precise change in a plant or animal's own genes, without adding genes from another species. The best known tool is gene editing, often using a method called CRISPR, which works like a pair of scissors that can cut the genetic material at a chosen place, so that a small change can be made there. The change could be to switch off a gene, to change a few letters in a gene, or to copy a change that already exists in a related plant. Because the change is precise, the breeder does not need to mix in many unwanted traits, and the breeding is faster.
The key point for food students is the difference between precision breeding and the older genetic modification that adds a gene from another species. In the older method, a gene from one species, such as a gene from a bacterium, is added to a plant, so that the plant gains a trait it could never gain by crossing. In precision breeding, no foreign gene is added: the change is made in the plant's own genes, and the result could, in principle, have been reached by traditional breeding, though it would have taken far longer and with less certainty. That difference matters for how the food is judged and labelled, and different places draw the line in different ways.
What precision breeding can do
Precision breeding can do several useful things for food, and the examples help to show why breeders use it.
Disease resistance is one. A plant can be changed so that a virus or a fungus cannot infect it, or so that it resists the disease better. A crop that resists disease needs less spraying, yields more, and wastes less, and the food from it carries fewer damaged grains.
Nutrition is another. A plant can be changed so that its grain or its fruit carries more of a vitamin, or less of a substance that harms health, or a better balance of fatty acids. A wheat with less of the precursor that forms a harmful compound during toasting, a tomato with more of a nutrient, or an oilseed with a better oil are all examples of this kind of change.
Shelf life and waste are a third. A fruit can be changed so that it ripens more slowly, or so that it bruises less, which means less food is wasted between the farm and the shop. A mushroom that does not brown quickly, or a potato that does not bruise, are examples that have been studied.
Animal breeding is also changing. Precision breeding in animals is studied for disease resistance, for better feed use, and for animal welfare, such as animals that do not need a painful procedure because the trait that made it necessary has been bred out. Animal work raises more questions than plant work, because animals are sentient and because the changes can affect welfare, so the rules for animals are often stricter.
How the new techniques differ from older methods
Three methods are often confused, and it helps to separate them clearly.
Traditional breeding crosses two plants or animals and picks the best offspring. It mixes whole genomes, it is slow, and it cannot make a change that does not already exist in the breeding population. It is the method behind almost all the food we eat.
Genetic modification, in the older sense, adds a gene from another species, or adds a new gene made in a laboratory, to a plant or animal. The added gene gives a trait the organism could not gain by crossing, such as resistance to a herbicide, or the ability to make a vitamin it never made. The added gene stays in the organism and is passed to its offspring.
Gene editing, the main precision breeding tool, changes the organism's own genes at a chosen place, without adding a foreign gene. The change is small, often a few letters, and the result is a plant or animal that could have been bred by traditional methods, though far more slowly. Some gene edited plants carry no foreign DNA at all in the final product, because the editing tools are removed by breeding after the change is made.
There are also newer methods that sit between these groups, such as methods that change how a gene is read without changing its letters, and methods that use a microbe to make a protein without changing the food itself. The rules for these methods are still being written in many places, and a food student should expect the rules to change as the science moves.
Questions to think about
- A plant is changed so that it resists a virus, using only its own genes. How is that different from adding a gene from a bacterium?
- Why would a breeder choose gene editing over traditional crossing, even though crossing is older and more familiar?
- A gene edited plant carries no foreign DNA in the final product. Does that change how it should be labelled, and why might people disagree?
Think about the first question before you read on
Changing a plant's own genes to resist a virus uses material the plant already has, and the result could in principle have been reached by crossing, though slowly. Adding a gene from a bacterium brings in material from another species that the plant could never gain by crossing, so the plant gains a trait from outside its own kind. The first is precision breeding, the second is the older form of genetic modification, and the two are judged and labelled differently in many places.
How precision bred foods are judged
A precision bred food is judged on what changed, not only on how the change was made. The first question is always the same as for any novel food: is the food safe to eat, at the amounts people will eat? The assessor looks at what the change did to the food: did it change the nutrients, did it create a new substance, did it raise the level of a natural toxin, did it change the allergens? A change that switches off a gene may also affect other traits, and the assessor must look for those side effects.
The second question is whether the food is what it claims to be, and whether the label tells the truth. A precision bred wheat that makes less of a harmful precursor is still wheat, and its flour is still flour, but a buyer who cares about how the wheat was bred deserves to know. The labelling rules for precision bred foods differ from place to place, and they are a live debate: some places require a label, some do not, and some require a label only when the food itself is changed in a way a buyer can taste or measure.
The third question is about the wider effects: does the change affect the environment, does it affect farming, and does it affect animal welfare where animals are involved? A plant that resists disease may need less spraying, which helps the environment, but it may also affect other plants and insects, and those effects are weighed too. A food assessment that only looks at the plate and ignores the field is incomplete.
Different places draw the line between precision breeding and genetic modification in different ways, and a food student must describe that honestly rather than picking one rule and presenting it as the world rule. Some places treat precision bred foods like traditionally bred foods, with no special approval, because the change could have been reached by crossing. Other places treat them as novel foods that need approval, because the method is new. Still others have a middle path: a notification, a check that the change is truly precision breeding, and then treatment as a traditionally bred food. The rules are moving, and the right habit is to check the current rule in the place where the food will be sold.
The debate, stated fairly
Precision breeding is debated, and a food student should be able to state both sides fairly, without taking a side in a teaching note.
Those in favour say that precision breeding is a faster form of what farmers have always done, that it can make crops more nutritious, more resistant to disease, and less wasteful, and that it can help farming adapt to a changing climate with less spraying and less water. They say that the changes are small, that the foods are tested, and that the benefits for food security and for the environment are real.
Those who are cautious say that the method is new, that the long term effects are not yet known, that the changes can have side effects that are hard to predict, and that the control of the technology sits with a few large companies, which raises questions about who benefits. They say that buyers deserve a label so that they can choose, and that the environment needs careful study before a new plant is grown widely.
A food professional does not need to settle that debate in a teaching note. The professional needs to know what the method is, what it can do, what the safety questions are, what the rules say in each place, and how to label the food honestly. The debate belongs to society, and the professional's job is to give society clear facts to debate with.
The diagram shows the three methods side by side. The steps point to the diagram: the methods differ in what they add and how precise they are, and the judgement always returns to what changed in the food itself.
What to watch for as the science moves
The science of precision breeding is moving fast, and three developments are worth watching. The first is the spread of gene editing to more crops and more traits, including traits that help crops cope with heat, drought, and salty soil. The second is the use of gene editing in animals, where the welfare questions are sharper and the rules are stricter. The third is the growth of methods that do not change the food at all, such as using edited microbes to make a protein in a tank, where the food contains the protein but not the microbe.
For each development, the same questions return: what changed, is it safe, is the label honest, and what are the wider effects? A student who can ask those four questions about any new technique will be able to judge it fairly, whatever the technique is called and wherever it is used.
Practical note: Choose a crop you know well, such as wheat, rice, tomato, or potato. Write down three traits you would like to improve: one for nutrition, one for disease resistance, and one for shelf life. For each trait, write whether traditional breeding, precision breeding, or older genetic modification would be the most fitting method, and why. Then write the safety question you would ask about each change. Keep the page with your novel food profile: it is a map of how breeding choices are made.
Quick self-check
Question: What is the key difference between precision breeding and older genetic modification?
Precision breeding changes the organism's own genes without adding a gene from another species. Older genetic modification adds a gene from another species, giving a trait the organism could never gain by crossing.
Question: Why is a precision bred food judged on what changed, not only on how it was made?
Because safety depends on the food itself: its nutrients, its toxins, its allergens, and its composition. Two foods made by the same method can differ in what changed, and two foods made by different methods can end up the same, so the judgement must look at the food.
Try it yourself
Find a news story or a label that mentions a gene edited food or a precision bred crop. Write down what the story or label says the change is, and what it does not say: does it name the trait, does it say how the change was made, does it say whether the food was approved, and does it say how the food is labelled? Then write three questions you would ask the maker before you decided whether to eat it. Bring your notes to class and compare: how many stories give the full picture, and how many leave out the safety or the labelling question?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Traditional breeding crosses plants or animals and picks the best offspring; it is slow and mixes many traits at once.
- Precision breeding changes a few letters in an organism's own genes, without adding a foreign gene.
- Older genetic modification adds a gene from another species, giving a trait the organism could not gain by crossing.
- Precision breeding can improve disease resistance, nutrition, shelf life, and animal welfare.
- A precision bred food is judged on what changed in the food: safety, nutrition, labelling, and wider effects.
- Different places draw the line between precision breeding and genetic modification in different ways, and the rules are still moving.
- The debate has two sides, and a food professional should state both fairly and stick to the facts.
Glossary
Precision breeding
Changing a plant or animal's own genes precisely, without adding a gene from another species. Food tech example: a wheat changed so that its grain makes less of a harmful precursor is precision bred.
Gene editing
A method that cuts the genetic material at a chosen place so that a small change can be made there. Food tech example: gene editing switches off a gene that makes a mushroom brown quickly.
CRISPR
A widely used gene editing tool that works like scissors for genetic material, cutting at a chosen place. Food tech example: CRISPR is used to change a few letters in a tomato gene.
Traditional breeding
Crossing two plants or animals and picking the best offspring, repeated over generations. Food tech example: crossing two wheats and picking the offspring with the best grain is traditional breeding.
Genetic modification
Adding a gene from another species, or a new gene made in a laboratory, to a plant or animal. Food tech example: adding a gene from a bacterium to a plant is genetic modification in the older sense.
Genome
The full set of genetic material in an organism. Food tech example: traditional breeding mixes the whole genomes of two parents.
Trait
A feature of a plant or animal, such as yield, taste, disease resistance, or shelf life. Food tech example: slow ripening is a trait bred into a tomato.
Side effect
An unintended change caused by a breeding change, such as a change in another trait. Food tech example: switching off one gene may also change the flavour of the fruit.
Herbicide resistance
The ability of a plant to survive a weedkiller that kills other plants. Food tech example: a plant given herbicide resistance by adding a foreign gene is an older genetic modification.
Food security
Having enough safe and nourishing food for all people, now and in the future. Food tech example: crops that resist disease help food security by yielding more.
Sentient
Able to feel and to experience, used of animals in welfare discussions. Food tech example: animal breeding raises welfare questions because animals are sentient.
Notification
A middle path in some rules, where a precision bred food is notified and checked before being treated as traditionally bred. Food tech example: a breeder notifies the authority that a wheat is precision bred and not genetically modified.
References
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Gene Editing and Food, 2022.
- European Food Safety Authority, Gene Editing in Plants, 2020.
- Jaffe, G., Regulatory Approval for Novel Foods, 2019.
- National Academies of Sciences, Genetically Engineered Crops, 2016.
- Tait, J., et al., Precision Breeding and Regulation, 2021.
Unit 4: Labelling Rules for Novel Foods
Note
Unit 4: Labelling Rules for Novel Foods
A question to start with
A shopper picks up a carton that says milk, but the carton is made from oats. A second carton says plant based drink, and a third says oat milk alternative. All three hold a white liquid made from oats, but the words are different, and the shopper's choice depends on the words. A vegan shopper, a parent of a child with a milk allergy, and a shopper who wants the calcium of dairy milk will read those words differently, and one of them could be harmed by a word that misleads. What must a novel food label say, what must it not say, and who decides? This unit explains labelling for novel foods in general terms.
A label is the only conversation between the maker and the buyer at the moment of choice. The buyer cannot see the factory, cannot read the dossier, and cannot test the food. The label must therefore carry the facts the buyer needs to choose safely and freely: what the food is, what it is made from, how it was made where that matters, what it contains that could harm, and what it gives in nutrition. A label that leaves out one of those facts, or that says something false, fails the buyer.
Labelling rules for novel foods sit on top of the general labelling rules that cover all foods: the name, the ingredients, the allergens, the net amount, the date, the maker, and the nutrition. Novel foods add extra questions: what should the food be called when it imitates a familiar food, how should its making be described, and what warnings or conditions from its approval must appear on the pack?
The name: what the food may be called
The name is the most argued part of novel food labelling, because the name decides what the buyer thinks the food is. A name that borrows the name of a familiar food, such as milk, meat, or cheese, tells the buyer that the new food is like the familiar one, and that can mislead if the new food is different in nutrition, in ingredients, or in how it was made.
The general principle, shared across many places, is that a name must not mislead. A plant based drink that calls itself milk may mislead a buyer who expects the protein and calcium of dairy milk, and a parent who buys it for a child. A cell grown meat that calls itself beef without saying how it was made may mislead a buyer who wants meat from a farm. The rules in different places draw the line differently: some places ban the use of dairy names for plant drinks, some allow them with a qualifier such as oat drink, and some allow them freely. A food student should describe the principle and note that the rule differs, rather than presenting one place's rule as the world rule.
The name approved for a novel food is often fixed at approval, so that the same food carries the same name wherever it is sold in that place. The name should say what the food is, in words a buyer can understand, without borrowing the reputation of a food it is not. A flour made from insects should say so, a protein made by fermentation should say so, and a meat grown from cells should say so, in plain words, not in a code or a trade name that hides the source.
Ingredients, allergens, and the making
The ingredients list for a novel food follows the same rules as for any food: ingredients in order of weight, with allergens named clearly. For novel foods, the allergen question is sharper, because a new protein may cross react with a known allergen. A person allergic to shellfish may react to insect protein, a person allergic to egg may react to a protein made by a microbe that carries a similar protein, and a person allergic to milk may react to a milk protein made by fermentation, because the protein is the same even though no cow was involved. The label must name the allergen, and the approval may require a warning where the risk is known.
The making of the food, how it was produced, must be described where it matters to the buyer. A food grown from cells, a food made by precision fermentation, and a food made from insects are made in ways that many buyers care about, for reasons of belief, culture, or personal choice. The label should say how the food was made in plain words, so that a buyer who does not want that method can choose another food. The exact wording differs from place to place, and it is set at approval, but the principle is the same: the buyer deserves to know.
Nutrition labelling for novel foods must also be honest where the food replaces a familiar food. A plant based drink that replaces milk should show its protein, calcium, and vitamins, so that a buyer can compare it with milk. A novel protein that replaces meat should show its amino acids, or at least its protein, so that a buyer can judge whether it feeds as well. A label that shows only the good numbers and hides the missing ones misleads, even if every number on it is true.
Claims, conditions, and warnings
An approved novel food often carries conditions from its approval, and those conditions may need to appear on the label. A food approved only for adults must say so. A food approved only up to a certain amount per day must say so. A food that must carry a warning about allergy must carry it. The label is where the conditions of approval meet the buyer, and a maker who leaves a condition off the label is breaking the approval, not only the labelling rule.
Claims on the pack, such as high protein, low fat, or source of a vitamin, must follow the same rules as for any food: the claim must be true, the food must meet the level the claim needs, and the claim must not promise a health benefit that has not been proved. A novel food that claims to be a sustainable choice, or a healthy choice, must be able to support that claim with evidence, and the claim must not hide the fact that the food is new and that its long term effects are still being watched.
Marketing words that are not claims, such as natural, clean, or pure, are also watched, because they can mislead even when they are not formal claims. A novel food made in a tank is not more natural than a farm food because its label says so, and a buyer who reads natural on a pack may think the food is familiar when it is not. The honest label uses plain words about what the food is and how it was made, and leaves the marketing to words that can be proved.
Questions to think about
- A plant based drink calls itself milk on the front of the pack. Who could be misled, and how?
- A milk protein made by fermentation carries no cow, but it is the same protein as in milk. Should the label warn people with a milk allergy, and why?
- A novel food is approved only for adults. What must the label say, and what happens if it does not?
Think about the plant drink question before you read on
A parent buying for a child could be misled, because the drink may have less protein and less calcium than dairy milk, and a child who drinks it every day would get less nourishment than the parent expected. A person with a milk allergy is not at risk from the plant drink itself, but a person who wants the nutrition of milk would be misled about what the drink gives. The name borrows the reputation of milk without giving the nutrition of milk, which is why many places require a name such as oat drink instead.
What a good novel food label looks like
A good novel food label can be judged by five checks, and a student can use them on any pack.
First, the name says what the food is, in plain words, without borrowing the name of a food it is not. Second, the ingredients list names every ingredient, in order, with allergens clear. Third, the making is described where it matters, so that a buyer can tell whether the food came from a farm, a plant, a tank, or a microbe. Fourth, the nutrition lets the buyer compare the food with the familiar food it replaces. Fifth, any condition or warning from the approval is on the pack, in words a buyer can see and understand.
A label that passes all five checks lets the buyer choose freely. A label that fails any one of them takes away a part of that choice, and the buyer may eat a food they would not have chosen if they had known the truth.
The diagram shows the five label checks. The steps point to the diagram: a label that passes all five lets the buyer choose freely, and a label that fails one takes away part of that choice.
Labelling across borders
A novel food sold in many places may need different labels in each place, because the rules differ. One place may ban a dairy name for a plant drink, another may allow it with a qualifier, and a third may allow it freely. One place may require a label for a precision bred food, another may not. A business that sells in many places must make a label for each place, and it must keep the labels apart, so that a pack made for one place is not sold in another by mistake.
This is a cost for businesses, and it is a reason why some novel foods launch in one place first and expand slowly. It is also a protection for buyers, because the label in each place follows the rules of that place, and the buyer can trust that the label means what the rules say it means where they live. A buyer who buys a novel food online from another place should check whether the label follows the rules where they live, because a foreign label may use words that mean something different at home.
How labelling is checked
Labelling is checked by inspectors who visit shops and factories, read labels, and compare them with the approval and with the food inside the pack. A label that claims a food is approved when it is not, a label that leaves out an allergen, or a label that uses a name the food may not use can lead to a warning, a fine, or a recall. The checks are part of the same system as food safety checks, because a wrong label can harm health as surely as a wrong ingredient.
Businesses check their own labels too, before they are printed, by comparing the label with the approval, the recipe, and the nutrition analysis. A label check should be part of the launch of every new product, and a label should be rechecked whenever the recipe, the supplier, or the approval changes. A label that was right last year may be wrong this year, because the food changed and the label did not.
Practical note: Take a novel food label from a shop or from an online listing, and run the five checks from this unit on it. Write down the name, the ingredients, the allergens, the description of the making, the nutrition, and any warning or condition. Mark each check as pass or fail, and write what you would change to make the label pass. Keep the label and your checks with your notes for this subject.
Quick self-check
Question: Why must a milk protein made by fermentation still warn people with a milk allergy?
Because the protein is the same protein as in milk, even though no cow was involved. The body reacts to the protein, not to the cow, so a person allergic to milk protein will react to the fermented protein too, and the label must warn them.
Question: A novel food is approved for use in drinks only, but a maker puts it in a biscuit. What has gone wrong?
The maker has broken the condition of approval. The food was judged safe only for the approved uses, and a new use changes the intake and the eaters, so it needs a new approval before it can be sold in the biscuit.
When a label must change
A label is not fixed forever. It must change whenever the food changes, the approval changes, or the rule changes. A new supplier whose ingredient carries a different allergen, a new recipe that changes the nutrition, a new condition added to the approval, or a new labelling rule in the place where the food is sold all mean the label must be checked and, where needed, rewritten. A business that changes its food and forgets its label can sell a safe food under a wrong label, and a wrong label can harm a person with an allergy just as surely as a wrong ingredient.
The check should be routine, not an afterthought. Before a new batch is packed, the label should be compared with the recipe, the approval, and the current rule, line by line. The name, the ingredients, the allergens, the nutrition, and the warnings should each be checked by a second person, because a single reader misses mistakes that a second reader catches. Old labels should be counted and destroyed when a new label is printed, so that an old pack cannot be filled by mistake. A label change should be recorded with its date, so that any pack on a shelf can be traced to the label it should carry.
A worked label: reading a novel food label line by line
The labelling rules are easier to learn from one worked example than from a list of rules. Imagine a yoghurt made with a novel fibre, sold in a small pot. Here is how its label should read, line by line, with the reason for each line.
The name comes first: the yoghurt is named for what it is, with the novel fibre named in the ingredients, not hidden in the brand name. The ingredients list shows the fibre by its proper name, in order of weight, so the buyer can see how much of the pot is fibre and how much is milk, fruit, and sugar. The allergen information names milk clearly, because the yoghurt is a milk food, and it also names any allergen the novel fibre brings with it, such as a source plant that is a known allergen.
The nutrition table shows the fibre content per serving, so the buyer can judge the benefit, and it shows the energy and sugar as well, so the fibre claim cannot hide a high sugar content. The claim on the front, if one is made, states the benefit in plain words, such as a source of fibre, and it matches the amount in the pot: a claim that the yoghurt is high in fibre must be backed by a high fibre amount per serving. The storage and use instructions state how to keep the pot and by when to eat it, and the lot code and the maker's name let the buyer trace the pot back to its batch.
The test for any novel food label is to read it as a buyer who knows nothing about the food and to ask three questions: do I know what this is, do I know what is in it, and do I know what it will do for me? A label that answers all three, without hiding anything in small print, is a good label.
Try it yourself
Design a label for a novel food from your profile in Unit 1. Write the name, the ingredients list, the allergen statement, a plain description of how it was made, a short nutrition panel, and any warning or condition you think it should carry. Then ask a classmate to run the five checks on your label: which checks pass, which fail, and what would you change? Rewrite the label once after the feedback, and keep both versions to show how the label improved.
Key ideas to carry forward
- A label is the only conversation between the maker and the buyer at the moment of choice, so it must carry the facts the buyer needs.
- The name must not mislead: a novel food should not borrow the name of a familiar food it is not.
- Allergens must be named clearly, including cross reactivity where a new protein is similar to a known allergen.
- How the food was made must be described in plain words where it matters to the buyer's choice.
- Nutrition must let the buyer compare the novel food with the familiar food it replaces.
- Conditions and warnings from the approval must appear on the pack.
- Rules differ from place to place, so a food sold in many places needs a label for each place.
Glossary
Labelling
The words, marks, and pictures on a food pack that tell the buyer what the food is. Food tech example: the label on a plant based drink names its ingredients and its allergens.
Cross reactivity
An allergic reaction to a new protein because it is similar to a known allergen. Food tech example: a person allergic to shellfish may cross react to insect protein.
Allergen statement
The part of a label that names the allergens in the food clearly. Food tech example: an allergen statement on a novel protein bar names milk, egg, or nut.
Nutrition panel
The table on a label that shows energy, protein, fat, carbohydrate, and other nutrients. Food tech example: a nutrition panel lets a buyer compare a plant drink with dairy milk.
Claim
A statement on a pack about a benefit, such as high protein or source of a vitamin, which must be true and proved. Food tech example: a claim of high protein needs the food to meet the level the rule sets.
Condition of approval
A limit placed on an approval, such as only certain uses or amounts, which may need to appear on the label. Food tech example: a food approved only for adults must say so on the pack.
Qualifier
An extra word that makes a name honest, such as drink instead of milk for a plant based liquid. Food tech example: oat drink is a name with a qualifier that avoids borrowing the name milk.
Trade name
A brand name given to a food by its maker, which does not by itself tell the buyer what the food is. Food tech example: a trade name for a novel protein does not replace a plain description of its source.
Inspector
A person who checks food businesses, labels, and records to see that the rules are followed. Food tech example: an inspector reads a label and compares it with the approval for the food.
Recall
Removing a food from sale and telling buyers what to do, when the food is found to be wrong or unsafe. Food tech example: a food with a missing allergen on its label may be recalled.
Net amount
The weight or volume of food in a pack, shown on the label. Food tech example: a carton of a plant based drink shows its net volume in millilitres.
Ingredients list
The list on a label of everything in the food, in order of weight. Food tech example: an ingredients list for a novel bar names its protein source first if it weighs most.
References
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Labelling, 2021.
- European Food Safety Authority, Guidance on Novel Foods, 2016.
- Jaffe, G., Regulatory Approval for Novel Foods, 2019.
- Verbeke, W., Consumer Acceptance of Novel Foods, 2015.
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Handbook on Food Labelling, 2015.
Unit 5: Food Regulation Systems Around the World, General Principles
Note
Unit 5: Food Regulation Systems Around the World, General Principles
A question to start with
A novel protein is approved in one place, refused in a second, and still waiting for a decision in a third. The science is the same, the dossier is the same, and the food is the same, yet the answers differ. How can that be, and what does it tell us about how food regulation works around the world? This unit explains the regulation systems of the world in general terms: the principles they share, the ways they differ, and how a food professional should read them without mistaking one place's rule for a world rule.
Food regulation is the set of laws, rules, and bodies that decide what food can be sold, how it must be made, and what its label must say. Every place has its own system, shaped by its history, its food, its trade, and its way of making laws. No single system covers the world, and no single book can list every rule, because the rules change and differ. What a student can learn is the shape of the systems: the parts they share, the choices they make differently, and the principles that run through all of them.
The first principle is that food law protects people. Every system, in its own words, aims to keep food safe, to keep it honest, and to let people choose what they eat. Safety comes first: a food that harms health should not be sold, whatever its price or its promise. Honesty comes second: a food should be what it claims to be, and its label should tell the truth. Choice comes third: people should be able to know what they are eating and to choose for themselves.
The parts every system has
Every food regulation system has the same four parts, even when the names differ.
The first part is the law: the acts and regulations that set the rules. The law says what a food is, what may be added to it, what must be on its label, and what happens when the rules are broken. The law is made by governments, and it changes slowly, because changing a law takes debate and time.
The second part is the authority: the public body that applies the law. The authority may be a food safety agency, a health department, or an agriculture department, and it may be one body or several bodies sharing the work. The authority judges novel foods, sets limits for contaminants, inspects businesses, and acts when food is found to be unsafe or dishonest.
The third part is the science: the risk assessment that judges whether a food, a substance, or a process is safe. Risk assessment is done by scientists who weigh the evidence, estimate how much people will eat, and judge the chance and size of harm. The science is kept apart from the decision, so that the judgement is trusted, even when the decision is made by a minister or a government.
The fourth part is enforcement: the inspectors, the laboratories, and the penalties that make the rules real. A rule with no inspection is a wish, not a rule. Enforcement checks that businesses follow the law, tests food on the market, and acts when food is found to be wrong, by warnings, fines, recalls, or closing a business.
How systems differ: risk, precaution, and history
Systems differ in how they weigh risk and how they handle uncertainty, and those differences explain why the same novel food can be approved in one place and refused in another.
One difference is the weight given to history. Some systems treat a food with a long history of safe eating in another place as strong evidence, and approve it quickly. Other systems treat that history as only a start, and ask for more studies before approval. Neither is wrong: they weigh the same evidence differently, because they have different histories and different appetites for risk.
A second difference is precaution: what a system does when the science is not yet certain. Some systems act early, refusing or limiting a food until the science is clearer, on the ground that the public should not carry a risk the science has not yet measured. Other systems wait for proof of harm before acting, on the ground that a food should not be refused without evidence that it harms. The first is called a precautionary approach, the second a risk based approach, and most systems mix the two, using precaution for the most uncertain cases and risk based judgement where the science is strong.
A third difference is who decides and how openly. Some systems publish every application and every assessment, and let the public comment. Others decide behind closed doors and publish only the decision. Open systems build trust but take longer; closed systems are faster but must work harder to be trusted.
A fourth difference is the place of trade. Some systems are built to let food move freely between places that share rules, so that a food approved in one member place can be sold in the others. Other systems are built for one place alone, and a food must be approved there even if it is approved elsewhere. Trade shapes regulation, because a system that blocks a food also blocks the trade in that food, and a system that approves a food quickly may gain trade while another loses it.
The main families of systems, in general terms
It helps to know the main families of regulation systems in broad terms, without memorising the details of any one place.
One family is the pre market approval system, where a novel food cannot be sold until an authority has approved it. The company must prove safety before the food reaches the market, and the authority lists the approved foods. This family is used in many places for novel foods, and it is the system described in Unit 2.
A second family is the notification system, where a company tells the authority about a new food, shows that it is safe, and can sell it unless the authority objects within a set time. This is faster than pre market approval, but it puts more weight on the company to judge its own safety, and it needs strong monitoring after the market to catch problems.
A third family is the general food law system, where a food can be sold if it is safe and honest, and the maker is responsible for proving it, without a special approval for each new food. The authority checks the market, tests food, and acts when a food is found to be unsafe or dishonest. This system relies on strong enforcement and on the maker taking responsibility.
Most places use a mix: pre market approval for the newest and most uncertain foods, notification for foods with a history elsewhere, and general food law for familiar foods. A food student should ask which family a place uses for the food in question, rather than assuming one family covers everything.
Questions to think about
- A novel food is approved in one place and refused in another, on the same science. What could explain the difference?
- Why would a system use pre market approval for novel foods but general food law for familiar foods?
- What is the difference between a precautionary approach and a risk based approach, and when would each be used?
Think about the first question before you read on
The two places may weigh history differently, may take a different view of uncertainty, may have different rules about who decides, or may have different trade interests. The science is the same, but the judgement of risk is not only science: it is also a choice about how much uncertainty a society will accept, and different societies choose differently.
International bodies and shared science
Although each place makes its own rules, the science is shared. International bodies bring scientists together to judge the safety of additives, contaminants, and new foods, and their judgements are used by many places as a starting point. The best known is the Codex Alimentarius, a collection of standards, guidelines, and codes of practice for food, built jointly by the food and health bodies of the United Nations. Codex standards are not laws, but many places write their own laws to match Codex, so that food can be traded between places that share the same standards.
Other international bodies judge specific questions: the safety of a new additive, the level of a contaminant, or the risk of a new process. Their reports are read by authorities around the world, and they help to keep the science consistent even when the decisions differ. A student who reads a Codex standard or an international assessment is reading the shared science that many systems start from.
Trade agreements also shape regulation. When two places agree to trade food freely, they often agree to accept each other's assessments, or to share the work of assessing a new food, so that a company does not have to prove the same food twice. These agreements do not remove the local decision, but they make it faster and cheaper, and they help small companies that could not afford many separate approvals.
What this means for a food professional
A food professional who works with novel foods needs three habits. First, always name the place: never say a food is approved, say where it is approved, and for what uses. Second, always check the current rule: rules change, and a rule that was true last year may have changed. Third, always read the principle behind the rule: if you understand why a system requires approval, or why it requires a label, you can work with the rule even when the details differ from place to place.
The professional also needs to be careful with words in reports and on labels. Words such as approved, safe, and natural mean different things in different places, and a word that is true in one place may mislead in another. The safe habit is to quote the rule, name the place, and give the date the rule was checked, so that anyone reading the report can see where the claim came from and whether it is still current.
The diagram shows the four parts of a food regulation system. The steps point to the diagram: a system with a weak part, such as no inspection, is weak as a whole, however strong its law is on paper.
Reading a rule without inventing one
A final habit matters for this whole subject: never invent a rule number, an act number, a date, or a penalty figure. Food law is full of numbers, and a wrong number in a teaching note can mislead a student who repeats it. When a note needs a rule, it should describe the rule in general terms and direct the reader to check the current rule in their own country, from the authority itself. That habit protects the reader, and it protects the writer, because the rule will still be right when the numbers change.
Practical note: Pick a novel food from your profile in Unit 1. Write a short note on its regulation in general terms: which family of system would judge it, what evidence would be needed, and what label would it carry? Then write a second paragraph on what you do not know: which place's rule would you need to check, and where would you check it? The second paragraph is as important as the first, because it shows the limits of general knowledge and the need to check the local rule.
Quick self-check
Question: What are the four parts of every food regulation system?
The law, the authority that applies it, the science of risk assessment, and enforcement by inspectors, laboratories, and penalties. A system is only as strong as its weakest part.
Question: Why can the same novel food be approved in one place and refused in another?
Because the places weigh history, uncertainty, and risk differently, and because they have different rules about who decides and how trade is weighed. The science is shared, but the judgement of risk is a choice each society makes for itself.
How a student should read a regulation
A student meeting a food regulation for the first time should read it in four moves. First, name the place and the date: which authority wrote it, and when was it last changed? A rule without a place and a date is a rumour, not a rule. Second, find the principle: what harm is the rule trying to prevent, and who does it protect? A rule that is understood by its purpose is easier to remember than a rule learned as a list of words. Third, find the scope: which foods does it cover, and which does it leave out? A rule about novel foods does not cover familiar foods, and a rule about one ingredient does not cover another. Fourth, find the action: what must a maker do, what must a label say, and what happens if the rule is broken? A rule that is read this way can be used, while a rule that is only memorised will be forgotten when the next rule arrives. Keep a short note of each rule you read in this form: place, date, purpose, scope, and action. After a few rules, the notes become a map of how regulation works, and the map is more useful than any single rule.
Try it yourself
Choose two places you know, and imagine a novel protein that a company wants to sell in both. Write a short comparison: which family of system does each place use, who decides, is the process open to the public, and what label would the food carry? Use only general terms, and end with a list of the questions you would need to answer by checking the current rule in each place. Bring your comparison to class: where do the two systems differ most, and what would that mean for the company's launch plan?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Food regulation protects people by keeping food safe, honest, and freely chosen.
- Every system has four parts: the law, the authority, the science of risk assessment, and enforcement.
- Systems differ in how they weigh history, how they handle uncertainty, how openly they decide, and how they treat trade.
- Pre market approval, notification, and general food law are the main families, and most places mix them.
- International bodies such as Codex share the science, but each place makes its own decision.
- Always name the place, check the current rule, and never invent a rule number, act number, or date.
Glossary
Food regulation
The set of laws, rules, and bodies that decide what food can be sold, how it must be made, and what its label must say. Food tech example: food regulation decides whether a novel protein can be sold and what its label must say.
Risk assessment
The scientific judgement of whether a food, substance, or process is safe, by weighing evidence and estimating intake. Food tech example: a risk assessment judges whether a novel sweetener is safe at the amounts people will eat.
Precautionary approach
Acting early to limit a food when the science is not yet certain, rather than waiting for proof of harm. Food tech example: a precautionary limit on a new food is set until better studies are done.
Risk based approach
Acting on the measured risk, and waiting for proof of harm before refusing a food. Food tech example: a risk based system approves a food when the studies show no harm at the expected intake.
Pre market approval
A system where a novel food cannot be sold until an authority has approved it. Food tech example: a novel protein needs pre market approval before it can be sold.
Notification
A system where a company tells the authority about a new food and can sell it unless the authority objects within a set time. Food tech example: a food with a history of use elsewhere may enter by notification.
Codex Alimentarius
A collection of international food standards, guidelines, and codes of practice, built jointly by the food and health bodies of the United Nations. Food tech example: many places write their food laws to match Codex standards.
Enforcement
The inspection, testing, and penalties that make food rules real. Food tech example: enforcement checks that a novel food sold in shops is approved and labelled correctly.
Food authority
A public body that judges food safety and gives permission to sell new foods. Food tech example: a food authority reads the dossier and gives the safety assessment.
Trade agreement
An agreement between places to trade food freely, often by accepting each other's assessments. Food tech example: a trade agreement lets a company use one assessment in two places.
Consultation
The step where an application is published and the public can comment on it. Food tech example: a consumer group comments that a dossier has no study on children.
General food law
A system where a food can be sold if it is safe and honest, with the maker responsible for proving it, without a special approval for each new food. Food tech example: a familiar food is sold under general food law, with the maker responsible for its safety.
References
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Law, 2021.
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Codex Alimentarius, 2021.
- Jaffe, G., Regulatory Approval for Novel Foods, 2019.
- van der Meulen, B., Food Law, 2019.
- Roberts, M. T., Food Law in the United States, 2016.
Unit 6: Bringing a Novel Food to Market, the Steps
Note
Unit 6: Bringing a Novel Food to Market, the Steps
A question to start with
A company has an approved novel protein. The approval is in hand, the label is agreed, and the factory can make it. Now the food must reach the shops, and the shops must sell it to people who have never eaten it before. What comes between the approval and the first sale, and what can go wrong in that gap? This unit follows the steps from approval to market: making the food at scale, checking it, pricing it, talking about it, and learning from the first buyers.
Approval is the gate, but the market is the test. A food can be approved and still fail, because it tastes wrong, costs too much, is sold in the wrong place, or is described in words buyers do not trust. The steps in this unit are the work that turns an approved food into a food people actually buy, eat, and buy again.
Step one: make it at scale, the same every time
The food tested in the approval studies was made in small amounts, often in a laboratory or a pilot plant, with close control. The food sold in shops must be made in large amounts, in a factory, day after day, and it must be the same food as the one that was approved. That step, called scale up, is where many novel foods struggle.
Scale up changes the food in ways that must be checked. A fermentation that works in a small tank may behave differently in a large tank, because heat and mixing change with size. A cell culture that grows well in a laboratory may grow slowly in a large vessel. A protein that is easy to dry in small amounts may clump or spoil when dried in bulk. Each change must be tested, and the factory must prove that the food it makes matches the food that was approved, batch after batch.
Good manufacturing practice is the discipline that makes scale up work: written recipes, controlled temperatures and times, trained staff, clean equipment, and records for every batch. The factory must also have a quality system that tests each batch for the things that matter: composition, safety, and the markers that show the food is what it claims to be. A batch that fails a test must be held, not sold, and the reason for the failure must be found and fixed.
Step two: build the supply chain
A novel food needs a supply chain: the suppliers of its raw materials, the factory that makes it, the packers, the transporters, and the shops that sell it. Each link must be built and checked, because a new food has no existing chain to use, and each link can fail.
Raw materials are the first link. A protein made from fungi needs a steady supply of the feed the fungi grow on. A protein made from insects needs a steady supply of feed for the insects. A cell grown meat needs a steady supply of the growth medium the cells grow in. Each raw material must be safe, must be available in the amounts needed, and must be bought from suppliers who can be checked. A chain that depends on one supplier for a key material is a risk, and a second supplier should be found before the launch, not after a shortage.
Packaging is the second link. A novel food may need packaging that protects it, keeps it cold, or shows it off. The packaging must be safe for food contact, must carry the label agreed at approval, and must survive transport and storage. A pack that leaks, or a label that peels off, can spoil the launch.
Cold chain is the third link for foods that need chilling or freezing. A novel protein that must stay cold from the factory to the shop needs refrigerated transport, refrigerated storage, and a shop that keeps it cold. A break in the cold chain can spoil the food, and a spoiled launch can damage trust in the food before it has a chance to succeed.
Step three: price it honestly
Pricing a novel food is hard, because the cost of making it is often high at first, and the price buyers will pay is not yet known. A price too high will keep buyers away, and a price too low will lose money on every sale, which a small company cannot survive for long.
The cost of a novel food falls as production grows, because the factory is used more, the raw materials are bought in larger amounts, and the process is improved. That fall takes time, and the company must plan for it: it must have enough money to survive the early years when the price is high and the sales are low, and it must be honest with buyers about why the price is high, rather than hiding the cost or cutting corners on safety to lower it.
A price that is far below the cost of making the food is a warning sign, as in fraud work: it may mean the food is not what it claims to be, or that the company is selling at a loss to gain buyers and will raise the price later. A buyer who understands this will ask how the price is possible, and a company that can explain its price honestly will build trust.
Step four: talk about it clearly
How a novel food is talked about decides whether buyers trust it. The talk must be clear, honest, and in plain words: what the food is, how it was made, why it was made, what it gives in nutrition, and what it costs. The talk must not promise what has not been proved, and it must not hide what the food is.
Tasting is the most powerful talk. A buyer who tastes a novel food and likes it will buy it again, and a buyer who tastes it and dislikes it will not. Tasting events, samples in shops, and small packs that let a buyer try the food cheaply are all ways to let the food speak for itself. A food that needs a long explanation to be liked may have a taste problem, not a communication problem, and the company should fix the taste before it spends more on talking.
Trust is built by openness: showing the factory, naming the ingredients, publishing the approval, and answering questions honestly. Trust is lost by secrecy, by words that hide the making, and by claims that cannot be proved. A company that says its food is sustainable should be able to show the evidence, and a company that says its food is healthy should be able to show the nutrition.
Questions to think about
- A novel protein tastes good in a small laboratory batch but tastes different when made in a large factory. What went wrong, and what should the company do?
- Why is a price far below the cost of making a novel food a warning sign?
- A company describes its food as natural on the pack, but the food was grown in a tank. What is wrong with that word?
Think about the taste question before you read on
Scale up changed the food: the larger tank mixes and heats differently, so the protein, the flavour, or the texture changed. The company should compare the factory batch with the approved batch, find what changed, fix the process, and test again before selling. Selling a food that differs from the approved food breaks the approval, and selling a food that tastes wrong loses buyers.
Step five: launch small, learn, and grow
A wise launch starts small. The company sells in a few shops, or in one region, watches what happens, and learns before it grows. A small launch lets the company find problems while they are still small: a pack that leaks, a label that confuses buyers, a taste that needs fixing, a price that is too high. A large launch that finds the same problems finds them in front of many buyers at once, and the damage is larger.
Learning from the first buyers means listening, not only counting sales. The company should ask buyers what they liked, what they disliked, what the label told them, and what they would change. It should watch for complaints, for allergy reports, and for returns, and it should act on them quickly. A complaint handled well can build more trust than a launch with no complaints at all, because it shows the company listens and acts.
Growth follows learning. When the food sells well in a few shops, the company can grow to more shops, to more regions, and to more products that use the ingredient. Each growth step needs the same care as the first launch: the factory must keep up, the supply chain must keep up, and the label must stay honest. A company that grows faster than its factory can make the food well will sell a worse food, and buyers will notice.
What can go wrong after launch
Several things can go wrong after a novel food reaches the market, and each one has a fix.
A safety problem can appear that the studies missed, such as an allergy in a group that was not studied. The fix is post market monitoring, the watch kept after approval, and a quick response: hold the food, investigate, tell buyers, and change the label or the approval if needed.
A quality problem can appear, such as a batch that tastes wrong or a pack that fails. The fix is the quality system: hold the batch, find the cause, fix the process, and check the next batches more closely.
A supply problem can appear, such as a supplier who cannot deliver, or a raw material whose price rises. The fix is a second supplier, a stock of raw materials, and a plan for shortages written before the launch, not during it.
A trust problem can appear, such as a story in the news that questions the food, or a label that is found to mislead. The fix is openness: answer the questions, show the evidence, fix the label, and let buyers judge for themselves. A company that hides from a trust problem loses more trust than a company that faces it.
The diagram shows the path from approval to market. The steps point to the diagram: each step depends on the one before it, and a launch that skips a step, such as skipping the small trial, finds its problems in front of many buyers at once.
The role of the food professional
A food professional may meet a novel food at any of these steps: in the factory, checking that the scale up matches the approval; in buying, checking the suppliers; in quality, testing the batches; in labelling, checking the pack; or in talking to buyers, answering their questions. At each step, the professional's job is the same: compare the food with what was approved, compare the label with what the food is, and speak plainly about what is known and what is not yet known.
The professional should also keep learning, because novel foods change fast. A method that was new last year may be common this year, and a rule that was true last year may have changed. The habit of checking the current rule, reading the current science, and asking the maker for the current evidence is the habit that keeps a professional useful in a fast moving field.
Practical note: Pick a novel food that is already sold in shops, and trace its path from approval to market in general terms: how is it made at scale, what is its supply chain, how is it priced, how is it talked about, and where is it sold? Write a one page market map for it, and mark the step you think is hardest for a small company. Keep the map with your dossier outline from Unit 2: together they show the whole journey from an idea to a shop shelf.
Quick self-check
Question: Why should a novel food launch small rather than in every shop at once?
Because a small launch finds problems while they are still small: a leaking pack, a confusing label, a taste that needs fixing, or a price that is too high. A large launch finds the same problems in front of many buyers at once, and the damage to trust and to money is larger.
Question: What is scale up, and why can it change the food?
Scale up is making a food in large amounts in a factory, after it was made in small amounts in a laboratory. It can change the food because heat, mixing, and drying behave differently at large size, so the flavour, texture, or composition can shift, and the factory must prove the food still matches the approved food.
A worked example: building an honest price
A novel food fails if its price is built on hope, so the price must be built step by step from real costs. Work through a simple example with practice numbers, in money units per pack.
Step one: add the direct costs. The ingredients cost 1.20 units, the novel ingredient adds 0.60 units, and the pack costs 0.30 units. The direct cost is 2.10 units per pack.
Step two: add the making costs. The factory time, energy, and labour add 0.50 units, and testing and quality checks add 0.20 units. The making cost brings the total to 2.80 units per pack.
Step three: add the costs of selling. Transport, storage, and the shop's margin add 0.90 units, bringing the total to 3.70 units per pack. A small margin for the maker, say 0.30 units, brings the honest price to 4.00 units per pack.
Step four: compare with the ordinary food it replaces. If the ordinary yoghurt sells for 2.50 units, the novel yoghurt at 4.00 units must give the buyer a reason to pay the extra 1.50 units: more fibre, a better protein, or a smaller footprint. If it cannot show that reason, the price will fail, however good the food is. If it can, the price is honest, and the launch can be built on it.
Try it yourself
Choose a novel food you have seen in a shop. Buy a small pack if you can, or study its online listing. Taste it if you buy it, read its label, and note its price. Then write a short review as if you were the company's first buyer: what did you like, what did you dislike, what did the label tell you, what did it leave out, and would you buy it again? Bring your review to class and compare: which foods earned a second buy, and what did they have in common?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Approval is the gate, but the market is the test: a food can be approved and still fail.
- Scale up must prove that the factory food matches the approved food, batch after batch.
- A novel food needs a supply chain, packaging, and a cold chain where needed, built before the launch.
- Pricing must be honest, and the company must plan for high early costs that fall as production grows.
- Talking about the food must be clear and honest, and tasting lets the food speak for itself.
- A wise launch starts small, listens to the first buyers, learns, and then grows step by step.
- Post market monitoring watches for safety, quality, supply, and trust problems after launch, and each one has a fix.
Glossary
Scale up
Making a food in large amounts in a factory, after it was made in small amounts in a laboratory. Food tech example: a fermentation that works in a small tank must be proved again in a large tank.
Good manufacturing practice
The discipline of making food the same way every time, with records and checks. Food tech example: good manufacturing practice proves that the food sold matches the food tested in the studies.
Supply chain
The series of steps a food passes through from raw materials to the buyer. Food tech example: a novel protein supply chain runs from feed suppliers to the factory, the packer, and the shop.
Cold chain
The series of chilled or frozen steps that keep a food cold from the factory to the shop. Food tech example: a chilled novel protein needs a cold chain of refrigerated trucks and shop chillers.
Launch
The first sale of a food in the market, often starting small in a few shops. Food tech example: a small launch in a few shops lets a company learn before it grows.
Post market monitoring
Watching a food after it is sold for reports of harm or new science. Food tech example: post market monitoring catches an allergy that the studies missed.
Quality system
The set of checks and records that makes sure each batch of food meets its standard. Food tech example: a quality system tests each batch of a novel protein for composition and safety.
Growth medium
The liquid that feeds cells or microbes as they grow in a tank. Food tech example: cell grown meat needs a steady supply of growth medium.
Pilot plant
A small factory used to test a process before it is built at full size. Food tech example: a novel protein is first made in a pilot plant, then in a full factory.
Batch
One run of making a food, which is tested and recorded as a single lot. Food tech example: a batch of a novel protein that fails a test is held and not sold.
Tasting
Letting buyers try a food, so that taste, not only words, decides whether they buy it again. Food tech example: a tasting event in a shop lets buyers try a novel burger before buying a full pack.
Second supplier
An extra supplier for a key material, so that a problem with one does not stop production. Food tech example: a novel food maker keeps a second supplier for its main feed material.
References
- Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development, 2nd edition, 2004.
- Graf, E. and Saguy, I., Food Product Development, 1991.
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Novel Foods, 2021.
- Jaffe, G., Regulatory Approval for Novel Foods, 2019.
- Verbeke, W., Consumer Acceptance of Novel Foods, 2015.
Unit 7: Case Studies, What Got Approved, What Did Not
Note
Unit 7: Case Studies, What Got Approved, What Did Not
A question to start with
A new sweetener is approved and sells in many products. A new protein is refused, and its company goes back to the laboratory. A fruit eaten for generations in one region is approved in another after a short check, while a cell grown meat waits years for a decision. What separates the foods that pass from the foods that fail, and what do the cases teach the next company that applies? This unit looks at case studies in general terms, without inventing dates or counts, and pulls out the lessons each kind of case teaches.
Case studies are taught in general terms here for a reason: the details of approvals change, new decisions are made, and a number quoted today may be out of date tomorrow. What does not change is the pattern: the kinds of evidence that convince an authority, the kinds of gaps that lead to refusal or delay, and the kinds of foods that pass easily because their history is strong. Learn the patterns, and you can read any new case when it appears.
Cases that passed: strong history and clear evidence
The easiest approvals are for foods with a strong history of safe eating somewhere, where the new use is close to the old use. A fruit eaten for generations in one region, sold in another region in the same form and in similar amounts, can be approved after a check of its composition, its history, and its allergens, without a long programme of animal studies. The history does much of the work, and the new studies only need to cover what the history does not: how the new eaters will use it, and whether any group among them needs special care.
Another group that passes well is new ingredients with a clear and simple composition, where the safety question is narrow. A new fibre made from a familiar plant, a new oil with a well understood fatty acid pattern, or a new sweetener whose breakdown in the body is known can be approved when the dossier shows the composition, the intake, and the studies that answer the one or two questions that matter. The lesson is that a simple food with a focused question passes faster than a complex food with many open questions.
A third group is foods made by a process that is well understood, where the process itself is the proof. A protein made by fermentation, where the microbe is known, the process is controlled, and the final protein is purified and tested, can be approved when the dossier shows that the microbe is safe, that nothing harmful from it stays in the food, and that the protein itself is safe and well digested. The lesson is that a clean process, well described and well controlled, is strong evidence.
Cases that were delayed: gaps in the dossier
Many applications are not refused at first: they are delayed, because the dossier has gaps. The common gaps are worth learning, because they are the mistakes the next applicant can avoid.
The first gap is allergy. A dossier that does not study whether a new protein could cause allergy, or whether it cross reacts with a known allergen, will be sent back. Allergy cannot be guessed, and an authority will not approve a food that many people may eat without that evidence.
The second gap is intake. A dossier that estimates intake from one use but forgets another, or that estimates the average eater but not the highest eater, will be sent back. A food that is safe at a low intake may not be safe at a high intake, and the authority must know the high intake before it can decide.
The third gap is the match between the tested food and the sold food. A dossier that tests a food made in a laboratory but plans to sell a food made in a factory, without proving the two are the same, will be sent back. The studies must describe the food that will be sold, not a cousin of it.
The fourth gap is the label. A dossier that claims a benefit the studies do not support, or that uses a name that borrows the reputation of a familiar food, will be sent back for the label to be rewritten. The label is part of the approval, and a label that misleads cannot be approved even when the food itself is safe.
Each delay costs the company time and money, and some companies run out of money during the delay. The lesson is to run the pre submission talk, to ask what evidence is needed, and to write the dossier as if the authority will read it looking for gaps, because it will.
Cases that were refused: safety not shown
A refusal means the evidence does not show the food is safe, or the company cannot show that it can be made safely every time. Refusals are rarer than delays, but they teach the sharpest lessons.
One kind of refusal comes from a safety signal in the studies: an animal study shows harm, or a laboratory study shows that the food carries a toxin, or the food is found to be poorly digested so that it does not feed people as claimed. A safety signal does not always end the story: the company may change the process, lower the intake, or limit the uses, and apply again with better evidence. But a safety signal that cannot be explained or removed will end the application.
Another kind of refusal comes from a process that cannot be controlled. A food made by a microbe that cannot be kept pure, or a cell culture that varies from batch to batch, cannot be approved, because the studies describe one version and the shops would sell another. The fix is to improve the process until it is stable, and then to prove it with batch data.
A third kind of refusal comes from a food that is safe but misleading. A food that claims to replace a familiar food but feeds people far worse, and whose label hides that difference, may be refused on honesty grounds, even when the safety is fine. The fix is an honest label, or a change to the food so that it feeds people as well as the food it replaces.
Cases still waiting: the newest foods
The newest foods, such as cell grown meat and some precision fermented proteins, have waited longest in many places, and the wait itself teaches a lesson. The wait is long because the questions are new: how to judge a food grown from cells, how to test a protein made by an edited microbe, how to label a food that has no familiar form, and how to weigh benefits that are about the environment as well as about health. The authority must answer those questions before it can decide, and answering them takes time and new science.
The wait also teaches that approval is not only science: it is also a public decision, and the public must trust it. A food that is approved quickly but without public confidence may fail in the market, because buyers will not eat a food they do not trust. A slower approval that answers the public's questions, publishes its reasoning, and sets a clear label may succeed where a fast one fails. The lesson for companies is to talk to the public as well as to the authority, and to answer the questions buyers actually ask.
The diagram shows the four outcomes for a novel food application. The steps point to the diagram: the difference between them is the strength of the evidence and the size of the gaps, not the promise of the food.
Lessons for the next applicant
The cases together give a short list of lessons for any company or student who will work with a novel food.
Start with the history: if the food has a history of safe eating somewhere, use it well, and show how the new use matches the old use. If it has no history, plan for a longer programme of studies, and budget for it.
Answer the allergy question early, before the dossier is written, because it is the question most likely to cause a delay. Estimate the intake for the highest eaters, not only the average, and list every use the food will go into.
Prove that the tested food is the sold food, with batch data from the factory, not only from the laboratory. Write the label honestly, and do not claim more than the studies support.
Talk to the authority early, in the pre submission talk, and talk to the public too, in plain words, so that the questions buyers ask are answered before the launch. And keep monitoring after the market, because approval is not the end of the work: it is the start of the responsibility to watch what happens when real people eat the food.
The future of novel foods
Novel foods will keep appearing, because the reasons for them, the search for protein with a smaller footprint, the search for foods that meet new needs, and the growth of new tools, are still growing. The foods of the next years will include more proteins from fermentation, more foods from precision breeding, more cell grown foods, and more ingredients from sources that are new to the plate.
The regulation will keep moving too, as authorities learn from each case and as places share their assessments. The direction is toward more sharing, more openness, and more focus on the food itself rather than on the method alone. A student who learns the patterns in this unit, rather than memorising today's approvals, will be able to read the novel foods of tomorrow and judge them fairly.
Questions to think about
- A fruit with a long history in one region is approved quickly in another. Why did its history help, and what did the new studies still need to cover?
- A dossier is delayed because it has no allergy study. Why is that gap treated as serious rather than minor?
- A cell grown meat waits years for a decision. What makes its questions newer than the questions for a new fibre?
Think about the fruit question before you read on
Its history showed that many people ate it for a long time without clear harm, which is strong evidence about safety. The new studies still needed to cover the new eaters: how much they would eat, in what forms, and whether any group among them, such as children or people with allergies, needed special care. History helps, but it does not answer the questions about the new use.
Practical note: Pick one of the four outcomes in this unit: pass, delay, refusal, or waiting. Write a one page case file for a food you invent, or a food you have read about, that fits that outcome. Describe the food, the evidence, the gap or the strength, and the decision, and end with the lesson the case teaches the next applicant. Keep the case file with your dossier outline and your market map: together they are a complete picture of a novel food, from idea to market.
Quick self-check
Question: What is the most common reason an application is delayed rather than refused?
A gap in the dossier, such as a missing allergy study, an intake estimate that forgets a use or the highest eaters, a tested food that does not match the sold food, or a label that claims too much. A delay asks for better evidence; a refusal says the evidence does not show safety.
Question: Why does a slow approval sometimes succeed in the market where a fast one fails?
Because the slow approval answers the public's questions, publishes its reasoning, and sets a clear label, so buyers trust the food. A fast approval that leaves questions unanswered may fail because buyers will not eat a food they do not trust, however quickly it was approved.
How to read a new approval in the news
When a novel food approval appears in the news, read it with the patterns from this unit in mind, and ask five questions before you form a view. First, what is the food, and what is it made from? Second, where was it approved, and for what uses? Third, what evidence was given: a history of use, a set of studies, or both? Fourth, what conditions or warnings came with the approval? Fifth, what is still unknown: what did the authority ask to be watched after the market? A news story that answers all five gives a fair picture. A story that answers only the first two, and fills the rest with excitement or with fear, should be read with care, and the authority's own statement should be sought out. The authority's statement is the source to trust over any headline, because it names the evidence, the conditions, and the limits. A student who reads approvals this way will not be misled by a headline that calls a food a breakthrough or a danger before the evidence has been read.
Try it yourself
Find a novel food in the news or in a shop that you have not studied in this subject. Read what is said about it: is it approved, waiting, or refused, and where? Write a short case note: what is the food, what is its history, what is the safety question, and what is the label? Then judge it against the patterns in this unit: does it look like a pass, a delay, a refusal, or a waiting case, and why? Bring your note to class and compare: which foods did the class judge the same way, and where did you disagree?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Foods with a strong history and a clear, simple composition pass most easily.
- Delays come from gaps: allergy, intake, the match between tested and sold food, and the label.
- Refusals come from safety not shown, a process that cannot be controlled, or a label that misleads.
- The newest foods wait longest, because the questions themselves are new and the public must trust the answer.
- The lessons are to start with history, answer allergy early, estimate the highest intake, prove the tested food is the sold food, and label honestly.
- Approval is the start of responsibility, not the end: monitoring after the market continues the work.
- Learn the patterns, not only today's approvals, because the foods and the rules will keep moving.
Glossary
Case study
A detailed look at one food and its approval, used to teach the patterns behind the decision. Food tech example: a case study of a fruit approved on its history teaches how history is weighed.
History of use
The record of people eating a food over a long time, used as evidence about its safety. Food tech example: a fruit eaten for generations in one region has a history of use there.
Cross reactivity
An allergic reaction to a new protein because it is similar to a known allergen. Food tech example: a person allergic to shellfish may cross react to insect protein.
Intake estimate
A calculation of how much of a novel food people will eat, including the highest eaters. Food tech example: an intake estimate for a novel sweetener covers drinks, biscuits, and yoghurt together.
Safety signal
A result in a study that suggests a food may cause harm, which must be explained or removed. Food tech example: harm seen in an animal study is a safety signal that stops an approval.
Refusal
A decision not to approve a novel food, because the evidence does not show it is safe. Food tech example: a refusal tells the company to run better studies before applying again.
Delay
A pause in approval while the authority asks for more evidence to fill a gap in the dossier. Food tech example: a missing allergy study causes a delay, not a refusal.
Post market monitoring
Watching a food after it is sold for reports of harm or new science. Food tech example: post market monitoring catches an allergy that the studies missed.
Dossier
The large file of evidence a company submits to ask for approval of a novel food. Food tech example: a dossier for a novel protein describes its composition, its making, its safety studies, and its label.
Pre submission talk
A meeting between a company and an authority before an application, to agree what evidence will be needed. Food tech example: a pre submission talk tells a company which allergy study to run.
Batch data
Test results from many factory batches, showing that the food is made the same way every time. Food tech example: batch data proves that the sold food matches the tested food.
Public confidence
The trust of buyers that a food and its approval are honest and safe. Food tech example: public confidence decides whether an approved novel food will sell.
References
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Novel Foods, 2021.
- European Food Safety Authority, Guidance on Novel Foods, 2016.
- Jaffe, G., Regulatory Approval for Novel Foods, 2019.
- Verbeke, W., Consumer Acceptance of Novel Foods, 2015.
- Knudsen, I., et al., Risk Assessment of Novel Foods, 2008.
Unit 8: Novel Food Safety Assessment, Toxicology, Allergenicity, and Nutrition
Note
Unit 8: Novel Food Safety Assessment, Toxicology, Allergenicity, and Nutrition
A question to start with
A company has made a new food. It looks like food, it tastes like food, and the people who made it have eaten it themselves. Is it safe for everyone else to eat, every day, for years? The makers cannot answer that question from their own meals alone, and the buyer cannot answer it from the taste. Someone must test the food in a careful, step by step way, and that testing is called safety assessment. This unit explains how it works: the toxicology that looks for harm, the allergenicity checks that look for allergy, and the nutrition checks that ask whether the new food helps or harms the diet it joins.
Safety assessment rests on one idea: safety is not proved by the absence of a disaster, but by evidence gathered before the food reaches the shelf. The assessment asks three questions in order. First, what is in the food, exactly, and does it stay the same from batch to batch? Second, could anything in it harm health, cause allergy, or mislead the eater? Third, what happens when real people eat it in real amounts, as part of a real diet? Each question has its own methods, and each method has its own limits.
This unit describes those methods in general terms. It does not set doses, limits, or approval rules for any place: those belong to the regulator of the country, and a student should check the current rule where they work. The science is the same everywhere, even when the rules differ.
Step one: know exactly what the food is
Before any safety test can mean anything, the food must be described in full. That description is called characterisation, and it covers the identity of the food, how it is made, and what it contains. For a new ingredient, it names the source organism or material, the production method, and the composition: protein, fat, carbohydrate, fibre, water, minerals, vitamins, and any substances that are new or unusual. For a food made by a new process, it describes the process step by step and shows that the same process gives the same product every time.
Characterisation also means checking stability: does the food stay the same during storage, cooking, and use? A protein that is safe when fresh may change when heated. A fat may oxidise in storage and form new compounds. An ingredient that is safe in a drink may behave differently in a baked food. The assessment therefore tests the food as it will actually be eaten, not only as it leaves the factory.
The last part of characterisation is the specification: the written limits for the food, such as the range of protein, the maximum of a named impurity, and the microbiological limits. The specification is the promise the maker keeps for every batch, and the safety assessment is judged against it. A food that cannot be made to a stable specification cannot be assessed, because the test results would belong to one batch only.
Questions to think about
- A new protein powder varies in protein from batch to batch by a wide range. Why does that make safety assessment hard?
- Why must a new ingredient be tested in the food it will be eaten in, and not only on its own?
- A maker changes the drying temperature of its new ingredient after the safety tests are done. What should happen next, and why?
Think about the batch variation question before you read on
Because the safety tests were run on one batch, and a different batch may carry more of a harmful substance or less of a nutrient. If the composition is not stable, the test results do not describe the food that buyers will actually eat, so the assessment cannot be trusted until the maker shows the process gives the same product every time.
Toxicology: looking for harm before people eat the food
Toxicology is the study of how substances harm living things, and in novel food assessment it is used to find harm before the food reaches the market. The work starts with the composition: are there substances in the food that are already known to be harmful, or that are new and unknown? Known harmful substances are measured and compared with safe levels. New and unknown substances are tested further.
The classic toxicology tests are run in stages. First come laboratory tests on cells, which can show whether a substance damages genetic material. Then come feeding studies in animals, which show what happens when the substance is eaten over weeks or months: whether it harms the liver, the kidney, the gut, or reproduction, and at what dose the harm first appears. The doses used in animal studies are higher than the doses people would eat, so that harm, if it exists, can be seen. From the animal results, scientists work out a safe level for people, with a wide safety margin built in, because people are not animals and people differ from each other.
Toxicology has limits that a student must understand. An animal study cannot prove a food is safe for every person, including children, pregnant people, and people with illness. A short study cannot show harm that takes years to appear. And a study on one ingredient cannot show what happens when that ingredient is eaten with other foods. For those reasons, toxicology is joined to the other parts of the assessment: allergenicity, nutrition, and the monitoring that follows the launch.
Allergenicity: could the new food cause allergy?
Allergy is an immune reaction to a protein in food, and it matters for novel foods because a new protein may be new to the immune systems of the people who eat it. The assessment asks whether the new food carries proteins that could cause allergy, and whether people allergic to other foods might react to it as well.
The first check is the source. If the new food comes from a source already known to cause allergy, such as a nut, a seed, or a shellfish, the risk is higher, and the assessment must be deeper. If the new food is a protein made by a microbe, the check asks whether that protein resembles any known allergen in its structure. Computer comparison of the protein's sequence with libraries of known allergens is the standard first step, and a close match is a warning that must be followed up with laboratory tests.
The second check is the protein itself: does it survive digestion, and does it survive cooking? Proteins that resist digestion and heat are more likely to cause allergy, because they reach the gut intact and meet the immune system there. Laboratory tests can show how fast a protein breaks down in conditions like those of the stomach, and whether it keeps its shape after heating.
The third check is the people. If the new food is related to a known allergenic food, the assessment may need to test blood samples from people allergic to that food, to see whether their immune system recognises the new protein. This is called cross reactivity, and it is the reason a new food can be labelled with an allergy warning even when nobody has yet eaten it and reacted: the science predicts the risk, and the label warns the people at risk.
Nutrition: does the new food help or harm the diet?
A new food can be safe in the toxicology sense and still be a poor addition to the diet. The nutrition assessment asks what the food adds and what it replaces. A new fibre that replaces a refined starch adds bulk and slows digestion. A new protein that replaces meat adds protein but may add less iron or less vitamin B12. A new fat that replaces butter changes the fatty acid pattern of the diet. The assessment must look at the whole diet, not at the new food alone.
The first nutrition question is about the nutrients the food carries: are they present in forms the body can use? A mineral bound tightly in a plant fibre may pass through the gut unused. A protein missing one essential amino acid may be a poor protein on its own, even if its total protein looks high. Laboratory tests and feeding studies can measure how much of a nutrient is digested and absorbed, which is called bioavailability, and the assessment uses those numbers rather than the numbers on a label.
The second nutrition question is about what the new food pushes out of the diet. If a new sweet ingredient replaces sugar, the diet carries less energy from sugar, which is a gain. If a new snack replaces fruit, the diet loses fibre and vitamins, which is a loss. The assessment therefore asks how the food will actually be used: as a staple eaten every day, as an ingredient in small amounts, or as a treat eaten rarely. A food eaten daily in large amounts needs a deeper nutrition assessment than a food used in small amounts.
The third nutrition question is about the people who will eat it most. Children, older people, and people with special diets may eat more of a new food, or may depend on it for a nutrient. The assessment must check the effect on those groups, not only on a healthy adult eating a varied diet.
The diagram shows the order of safety assessment. Each step feeds the next, and no single test on its own is enough.
Exposure: how much will people actually eat?
Every part of the assessment ends in the same question: how much of this food will people eat, and how often? A substance that is harmless in a small amount can be harmful in a large amount, and a nutrient that is useful in a small amount can unbalance a diet in a large amount. The assessment therefore estimates exposure: the amount of the new food, and of each substance in it, that people will take in each day.
Exposure is estimated from food surveys, which record what people eat, and from the maker's plans for how the food will be used. The estimate is done for the average eater and for the high eater, the person who eats much more than average, because safety must hold for the high eater too. It is also done for children and other groups who may eat more per kilogram of body weight. If the high eater's exposure is close to a safe limit, the maker may need to lower the amount used, or limit the foods the ingredient can go into.
Exposure estimates are uncertain, because nobody can know exactly how a new food will be eaten before it is sold. The assessment handles that uncertainty with caution: it uses high estimates, it assumes the food will be used in every food it could go into, and it sets conditions on use, such as a maximum amount per serving. Those conditions become part of the approval, and the maker must keep to them.
What safety assessment cannot do
Safety assessment is strong, but it has limits, and an honest food professional names them. It cannot prove that a food is safe for every person in every circumstance, because people differ in age, health, genes, and diet, and no study can cover every combination. It cannot see harm that takes many years to appear, because the studies run for weeks or months, not decades. And it cannot predict how a food will be used once it is sold, because buyers are inventive: a food meant as an ingredient in small amounts may be eaten on its own in large amounts, and a food meant for adults may be eaten by children.
These limits are why the system has more than one layer. The assessment is the first layer, the conditions of use are the second, the label is the third, and post-market monitoring is the fourth. Each layer catches what the last one missed. A student who claims that a safety assessment proves a food is safe has misunderstood it: the assessment shows that the evidence, judged together, supports the food being sold under its conditions, with monitoring to follow. That is a strong claim, and it is the honest one.
Practical note: Pick a new food ingredient you have seen on a label, such as a new fibre or a new sweetener. Write down the three assessment questions for it: what could harm, what could cause allergy, and what would it add to or take from the diet? Then write down who would eat the most of it, and why. That short note is the skeleton of a safety assessment.
Quick self-check
Question: Why does safety assessment start with characterisation, before any toxicology test?
Because a test result only means something if the food tested is the food that will be sold. Characterisation proves the identity, composition, and stability of the food, so that the toxicology, allergy, and nutrition results describe the real product, not one batch only.
Question: A new protein closely matches a known allergen in its sequence. What should happen next?
The match is a warning that must be followed up, not a final verdict. The next steps are laboratory tests on digestion and heat stability, and tests on blood samples from people allergic to the known allergen, to see whether their immune system recognises the new protein. The food may also need an allergy warning on its label.
Try it yourself
Choose a novel food you have read about: a new protein, a new fibre, or a new fat. Write a one page safety assessment plan for it, with four sections: characterisation, toxicology, allergenicity, and nutrition. For each section, write down the two most important tests or checks, and one limit of those tests. End with an exposure question: who would eat the most of this food, and what would that mean for the assessment? Compare your plan with a classmate who chose a different food: which food needs the deepest assessment, and why?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Safety assessment gathers evidence before the food reaches the shelf, and it is not proved by the absence of a disaster.
- Characterisation describes the food fully, and proves it can be made the same every time.
- Toxicology looks for harm in laboratory tests and animal feeding studies, with a wide safety margin.
- Allergenicity checks the source, the protein sequence, digestion, heat, and cross reactivity with known allergens.
- Nutrition asks what the food adds, what it replaces, and who will eat the most of it.
- Exposure estimates show how much people will eat, for the average eater and the high eater alike.
- No single test proves safety: the whole picture is judged together, and the rules differ by country.
Glossary
Characterisation
A full description of a food: its identity, how it is made, what it contains, and how stable it is. Food tech example: characterisation of a new protein names its source, its amino acids, and its specification.
Specification
The written limits for a food, such as the range of protein and the maximum of a named impurity, that every batch must meet. Food tech example: a new fibre is made to a specification that sets its fibre content and its moisture limit.
Toxicology
The study of how substances harm living things, used in food to find harm before people eat a new food. Food tech example: toxicology tests show whether a new ingredient harms the liver in animal feeding studies.
Safety margin
The gap between the dose that causes harm in a test and the much lower dose allowed for people. Food tech example: a safety margin is built in because people differ from each other and from test animals.
Allergenicity
The ability of a food protein to cause an allergic reaction. Food tech example: allergenicity assessment checks whether a new protein resembles a known allergen.
Cross reactivity
An immune reaction to a new protein because it resembles a protein a person is already allergic to. Food tech example: a person allergic to one seed may react to a new protein that resembles that seed's protein.
Bioavailability
How much of a nutrient in a food is digested and absorbed by the body. Food tech example: iron bound in fibre has low bioavailability, so the body absorbs little of it.
Essential amino acid
An amino acid the body cannot make and must get from food. Food tech example: a new protein is judged by whether it carries all the essential amino acids.
Exposure
The amount of a food or a substance that a person takes in each day. Food tech example: exposure to a new sweetener is estimated for the average eater and for the high eater.
High eater
A person who eats much more than average of a food, used in safety assessment to check safety for heavy use. Food tech example: a high eater of a new snack food may take in several times the average amount of its new ingredient.
Feeding study
A study in which animals are fed a substance over weeks or months to see what harm, if any, appears. Food tech example: a feeding study shows whether a new ingredient harms the kidney at high doses.
Tolerable intake
The amount of a substance per kilogram of body weight per day that can be taken in over a lifetime without expected harm. Food tech example: exposure to a new ingredient is compared with its tolerable intake.
Stability
Whether a food stays the same during storage, cooking, and use. Food tech example: stability testing shows whether a new protein changes when the food is baked.
Sequence
The order of amino acids in a protein, compared with known allergens to look for a match. Food tech example: the sequence of a new protein is compared with a library of allergen sequences.
References
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.
- Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations and World Health Organization, Principles and Methods for the Risk Assessment of Chemicals in Food, 2009.
- Codex Alimentarius Commission, General Principles of Food Hygiene, 2020.
- Potter, N. N. and Hotchkiss, J. H., Food Science, 5th edition, 1995.
Unit 9: Novel Ingredients, Novel Fibres, Proteins, and Fats
Note
Unit 9: Novel Ingredients, Novel Fibres, Proteins, and Fats
A question to start with
Walk down a supermarket aisle and read the ingredients on a bread, a yoghurt, and a spread. Many of the words are familiar: wheat, milk, oil. But some are new: a fibre you have never heard of, a protein from a source you did not expect, a fat made in a new way. These are novel ingredients, and they are the working parts of novel foods. A novel food is often a familiar food with a new ingredient inside it. This unit is about those ingredients: the novel fibres, proteins, and fats, what they do in a food, and what a food student must check before using them.
Novel ingredients appear for three reasons. The first is health: a fibre that feeds gut microbes, a protein with a better amino acid balance, or a fat with less saturated fat. The second is sustainability: a protein grown with less land or water, or a fat made from a side stream instead of a crop. The third is function: a fibre that holds water in a gluten free bread, a protein that foams in a dairy free dessert, or a fat that stays solid without hydrogenation. A good novel ingredient usually serves more than one of these reasons at once, and a poor one serves none of them well.
This unit describes the main families of novel fibres, proteins, and fats, how each one works in food, and the questions to ask about each: what it does, what it replaces, how it is made, and what must be proved before it is used.
Novel fibres: more than roughage
Fibre is the part of plant food that the human gut cannot digest, and novel fibres are fibres from new sources or made in new ways. The best known are resistant starch, a starch that resists digestion and behaves like fibre in the gut, and inulin type fructans, chains of fructose from roots such as chicory, which feed gut microbes. Newer fibres come from side streams: fibre from fruit peels, from cereal bran, from seaweed, and from the pulp left after juice making.
A fibre's job in a food depends on its type. Soluble fibres dissolve in water and form gels, which thicken a yoghurt, hold moisture in a bread, and slow the rise of blood sugar after a meal. Insoluble fibres add bulk and structure, which give body to a biscuit and keep a breakfast cereal crisp. Fermentable fibres are eaten by gut microbes, which turn them into short chain fatty acids that feed the gut wall. A fibre that does one of these jobs well may do another poorly, so the choice of fibre must match the job.
Fibre also changes the eating experience. Too much fibre in a bread makes it dense and dry. Too much of a fermentable fibre in a drink can cause gas and discomfort, because the gut microbes ferment it quickly. The amount that helps and the amount that harms are close together for some fibres, so the dose matters, and the label must state the fibre content honestly so that buyers can judge how much they are eating.
Questions to think about
- A bread maker wants a softer crumb and a slower rise in blood sugar. Which type of fibre would help, and why?
- Why can a fibre that feeds gut microbes also cause discomfort when eaten in a large amount?
- A fibre is made from a fruit peel side stream. What must be checked about the side stream before the fibre is used in food?
Think about the bread question before you read on
A soluble, gel forming fibre would help on both counts: it holds water, which keeps the crumb soft, and it forms a gel that slows digestion, which slows the rise in blood sugar. An insoluble fibre would add bulk but would not hold water in the same way, and it could make the crumb drier rather than softer.
Novel proteins: new sources, same amino acids
Protein is judged by its amino acids, and a novel protein is judged by the same test as any protein: does it carry all the essential amino acids in the right balance, and can the body digest and use them? The new sources are many: proteins from peas, beans, and other pulses; proteins from oilseeds; proteins from algae and seaweed; proteins from fungi, including mycoprotein grown in fermenters; and proteins from insects. Each source has its own amino acid pattern, its own digestibility, and its own flavour and colour.
Pulse proteins are the most widely used, because pulses are familiar foods and their proteins are well understood. They are often low in one essential amino acid, so they are blended with a cereal protein that carries more of it, and the blend gives a complete pattern. Mycoprotein is grown as a fungus in a fermenter, and it carries fibre as well as protein, with a texture that suits meat free foods. Algae proteins are still new, and their promise is a high protein yield from a small area, but their flavour, colour, and cost are still being worked on.
A novel protein must also be checked for what comes with it. A protein from a new source may carry substances that slow digestion, such as the compounds in some beans that block protein digesting enzymes, and processing must reduce them. It may carry a flavour that limits how much can be used, such as the beany note of some pulse proteins, which must be masked or removed. And it may carry allergy risk, as the safety assessment unit explains, because a new protein may resemble a known allergen. The protein that wins is rarely the one with the best amino acid pattern on paper: it is the one that is digestible, affordable, pleasant to eat, and safe.
Novel fats: structure without the old problems
Fat gives food its richness, its melt, and its mouthfeel, and novel fats are new ways of giving those qualities with a better fatty acid pattern or a lower environmental cost. The main families are oils from new sources, such as algae oils rich in long chain fatty acids; fats made by rearranging the fatty acids on a glycerol backbone, which changes the melting point without adding saturated fat; and oleogels, in which a small amount of a structuring agent turns a liquid oil into a soft solid, so that a spread or a pastry can be made without a hard fat.
The technical question for any fat is its melting behaviour. A spread must be soft from the fridge and melt in the mouth. A pastry fat must stay solid while the pastry is worked, then melt in baking. A frying oil must stay stable at high heat. A novel fat must meet the same behaviour as the fat it replaces, or the food will fail, however good its fatty acid pattern looks on paper. This is why fat replacement is slow work: the structure of the fat is part of the food, not just a nutrient in it.
The nutrition question for a novel fat is the fatty acid pattern: how much saturated fat, how much monounsaturated fat, how much polyunsaturated fat, and whether it carries the long chain fatty acids the body needs. The sustainability question is how the fat is made: an algae oil grown in a fermenter uses little land but needs energy, while a palm oil replacement grown on land needs land but little energy. The honest comparison looks at both, and at the yield per hectare or per unit of energy, not at one number alone.
How a novel ingredient is chosen and used
Choosing a novel ingredient starts with the job, not the ingredient. The food developer writes down what the food must do: hold water, foam, set, melt, feed microbes, or carry protein, and then looks for an ingredient that does that job at a dose the buyer can accept, at a price the food can carry, and with a taste the buyer will enjoy. An ingredient that does the job at 1 percent is easier to use than one that needs 10 percent, because a large dose changes the whole food.
The next step is testing in the real food. A fibre that thickens water may not thicken a yoghurt, because the yoghurt's acid and protein change how the fibre behaves. A protein that foams in water may not foam in a fat rich dessert. A fat that melts well on its own may melt too fast in a pastry. The ingredient must be tested in the food it will be used in, at the dose it will be used at, after the processing the food will go through, and after the storage the food will face.
The last step is the label and the story. A novel ingredient must be named on the label in a way the buyer can understand, and its benefit must be stated honestly: a fibre that feeds gut microbes can be described as a fibre, not as a cure. The maker must also plan for the buyer who asks where the ingredient came from and how it was made, because a new ingredient from an unfamiliar source needs a clear, honest answer, and a vague answer will lose the buyer.
The diagram shows the path of a novel ingredient into a food. The test in the real food is the step that most often sends a developer back to the start.
Novel ingredients and the environment: a fair comparison
A novel ingredient is often sold on its environmental promise: less land, less water, or less waste than the ingredient it replaces. That promise must be checked with the same care as a health claim, because a comparison can be made to look good by choosing the wrong thing to compare. A protein grown in a fermenter uses little land, but the fermenter needs energy, sterile water, and feedstock, and the full comparison must count those too. A fat made from a side stream looks clean, but the side stream must be collected, transported, and processed, and those steps carry their own footprint.
A fair comparison uses the same measure for both sides: the same amount of protein, the same function in the food, and the same boundary, from the field or fermenter to the factory gate. It also asks what the side stream would have become without the new use: a fruit peel turned into fibre is a gain if the peel would have been thrown away, but a smaller gain if the peel was already used as animal feed. And it asks about scale: a process that works cleanly at small scale may need far more energy at large scale, when the fermenters grow and the heating and cooling loads rise.
The lesson is simple: an environmental claim is a number with a method behind it, and the method must be shown. A buyer who asks how the comparison was made, and what was left out, is asking the right question, and a maker with a real advantage will answer it gladly.
A worked example: blending proteins to a complete pattern
A single novel protein is often low in one essential amino acid, and the fix is to blend it with another protein that carries more of it. The method is a weighted average, and it can be worked by hand. Use practice numbers to see how it works.
Suppose a pulse protein carries 1.0 gram of lysine per 100 grams of protein, and a cereal protein carries 2.8 grams of lysine per 100 grams of protein. A blend of 70 parts pulse protein and 30 parts cereal protein carries lysine of 0.70 times 1.0 plus 0.30 times 2.8, which is 0.70 plus 0.84, giving 1.54 grams per 100 grams of protein. That is better than the pulse protein alone, but still below the level of a complete protein.
Step two: try a different blend. A blend of 50 parts pulse and 50 parts cereal gives 0.50 times 1.0 plus 0.50 times 2.8, which is 0.50 plus 1.40, giving 1.90 grams per 100 grams of protein. The blend improves as the share of cereal protein rises, but the cereal protein may bring its own shortfall in another amino acid, so the developer must check every essential amino acid in the same way, not only lysine.
Step three: check digestibility. A blend that looks complete on paper may still be poor if one protein is hard to digest. The developer multiplies the amino acid score by the digestibility of the blend, a step that lowers the score for poorly digested proteins. This is why the laboratory measures digestibility in the real blend, not only in each protein alone, and why the final judgement comes from the food as eaten, not from the numbers on two separate labels.
Practical note: Read the ingredients on a meat free burger or a protein bar and find the proteins named. Count how many protein sources are listed, and ask why the maker used more than one. A blend of two or three proteins usually means the maker is balancing amino acids, flavour, and texture at once, and the list is a small map of that work.
Quick self-check
Question: Why is a protein with a good amino acid pattern on paper not always a good protein in food?
Because the body must also digest it and use it, and the food must taste good and hold together. A protein that is hard to digest, or that carries a strong flavour, or that will not foam or set, may fail in the food even when its amino acid pattern looks complete.
Question: A new fat gives a spread the right melt but the spread goes rancid in storage. What went wrong?
The fat's fatty acid pattern and its stability were not tested together. A fat rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids melts well but oxidises fast, so the spread needs an antioxidant, a different fat, or a shorter shelf life. The melt test alone was not enough.
Try it yourself
Pick a familiar food that you would like to improve: a bread, a yoghurt, a spread, or a snack bar. Write down one job a novel ingredient could do in it, and choose one novel fibre, protein, or fat that could do that job. Then write down the dose you would try, what you would test in the real food, and what could go wrong in taste, texture, or storage. Compare your choice with a classmate who picked the same food: did you pick the same ingredient, and if not, which job did each of you put first?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Novel ingredients are the working parts of novel foods: fibres, proteins, and fats from new sources or made in new ways.
- Soluble fibres form gels and slow digestion, insoluble fibres add bulk, and fermentable fibres feed gut microbes.
- A novel protein is judged by its essential amino acids and by how well the body can digest and use it.
- Blending two proteins can fill the amino acid gap that each one has alone.
- A novel fat must match the melting behaviour of the fat it replaces, not only its fatty acid pattern.
- An ingredient must be tested in the real food, at the real dose, after real processing and storage.
- The dose matters: a fibre or protein that helps in a small amount can harm taste or comfort in a large amount.
- Name the ingredient honestly on the label, and state its benefit without overclaiming.
Glossary
Resistant starch
A starch that resists digestion in the small gut and behaves like fibre in the large gut. Food tech example: resistant starch in a bread adds fibre and slows the rise in blood sugar.
Inulin
A soluble fibre made of chains of fructose, found in roots such as chicory, which feeds gut microbes. Food tech example: inulin is added to a yoghurt to raise its fibre and feed gut microbes.
Soluble fibre
A fibre that dissolves in water and forms a gel. Food tech example: soluble fibre in oats thickens porridge and slows digestion.
Insoluble fibre
A fibre that does not dissolve in water and adds bulk and structure to food. Food tech example: insoluble fibre from wheat bran gives body to a breakfast cereal.
Fermentable fibre
A fibre that gut microbes eat, turning it into short chain fatty acids. Food tech example: a fermentable fibre in a drink feeds gut microbes but can cause gas if eaten in a large amount.
Short chain fatty acids
Small acids made by gut microbes from fermentable fibre, which feed the gut wall. Food tech example: short chain fatty acids from fibre fermentation support the health of the gut lining.
Mycoprotein
A protein rich food made by growing a fungus in a fermenter. Food tech example: mycoprotein gives a meat free food its chewy texture and its protein.
Oleogel
A liquid oil turned into a soft solid by a small amount of a structuring agent. Food tech example: an oleogel lets a spread be made from liquid oil without a hard fat.
Digestibility
How much of a nutrient in a food is broken down and absorbed by the body. Food tech example: a protein with low digestibility gives the body less usable protein than its label suggests.
Amino acid score
A measure of how well a protein's essential amino acids match what the body needs. Food tech example: a pulse protein scores low on one amino acid, so it is blended with a cereal protein.
Essential amino acid
An amino acid the body cannot make and must get from food. Food tech example: lysine is an essential amino acid that some pulse proteins carry in low amounts.
Lysine
An essential amino acid that is often low in pulse and cereal proteins. Food tech example: blending a pulse protein with a cereal protein raises the lysine of the blend.
Monounsaturated fat
A fat whose fatty acids carry one double bond, liquid at room temperature and more stable than polyunsaturated fat. Food tech example: olive oil is rich in monounsaturated fat.
Polyunsaturated fat
A fat whose fatty acids carry more than one double bond, liquid at room temperature but quick to oxidise. Food tech example: a spread rich in polyunsaturated fat needs protection against rancidity.
Rancidity
The stale, unpleasant flavour that develops when fats oxidise in storage. Food tech example: a novel fat rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids can turn rancid if it is not protected.
References
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Potter, N. N. and Hotchkiss, J. H., Food Science, 5th edition, 1995.
- Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.
- Phillips, G. O. and Williams, P. A., Handbook of Hydrocolloids, 2nd edition, 2009.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
Unit 10: Traditional Foods from Third Countries and Post-Market Monitoring
Note
Unit 10: Traditional Foods from Third Countries and Post-Market Monitoring
A question to start with
A fruit has been eaten for generations in one country, in soups, drinks, and festivals. A company in another country wants to sell it as a food, not as a medicine, not as a supplement, but as an ordinary food on a supermarket shelf. The fruit is not new to the world, but it is new to this market. How should it be judged: as a new invention that must prove itself from scratch, or as an old food with a long history that speaks for itself? And once it is on the shelf, who watches what happens next? This unit answers both questions: the route for traditional foods from third countries, and the monitoring that follows every novel food after launch.
A traditional food from a third country is a food with a history of safe use in its home country, eaten by many people over a long time as part of an ordinary diet. The key words are history, safe, and ordinary: the food must have been eaten as food, not as a medicine, by a large group of people, over a long period, without harm. A fruit eaten at festivals for a hundred years may qualify. A root used only as a medicine, or eaten by a few people for a few years, may not.
The idea behind the route is fairness and sense. It would be wasteful to demand the full set of new food tests for a food that generations have already eaten safely, and it would be unfair to block a food from another country simply because it is unfamiliar here. At the same time, a history of safe use in one place does not prove safety in another, because the new market may eat the food differently, in larger amounts, or in different foods. The route therefore asks for evidence of history, and then checks the new use with care.
What counts as a history of safe use
A history of safe use is not a story or a claim: it is evidence, gathered and written down. The applicant must show that the food was eaten as part of an ordinary diet, by a large number of people, over a long period, in its country of origin. The evidence can include food surveys, market records, cookbooks, trade records, and scientific papers that describe the food and how it was eaten. The stronger the evidence, the easier the route.
Three questions test the history. First, how many people ate it, and for how long? A food eaten by a whole region for generations is stronger evidence than a food eaten by one village for a decade. Second, how was it eaten? A fruit eaten fresh in small amounts is different from the same fruit eaten dried, concentrated, or as an extract in large amounts. A history of eating the whole fruit does not prove the safety of a concentrated extract, because the extract carries much more of the food's active substances in each serving. Third, was it eaten as food? A plant used as a medicine, in doses chosen to treat illness, has a different history from a plant eaten as food, and the medicine history does not prove the food use is safe.
The history must also be checked for harm. If the food caused problems in its home country, that must be reported, not hidden. A food with a clean history in its home country still needs a check for the new market: the new buyers may eat more of it, may eat it in different foods, or may include people with allergies to related foods. The history opens the door, but it does not remove the need to check the new use.
Questions to think about
- A root has been eaten for generations as a vegetable, boiled and served in small portions. A company wants to sell a concentrated powder of the same root in a drink. Does the history of the boiled vegetable prove the powder is safe? Why or why not?
- Why does a food eaten by a whole region for generations give stronger evidence than a food eaten by one village for a decade?
- A traditional food is eaten in its home country only at festivals, in small amounts. What does that mean for a company that wants to sell it as an everyday snack?
Think about the concentrated powder question before you read on
No. The history proves the boiled vegetable eaten in small portions, not the concentrated powder. The powder carries far more of the root's substances in each serving, and it is eaten in a different way, so the history of the vegetable does not cover the new form and the new dose. The powder needs its own assessment, using the history as supporting evidence, not as proof.
The route for a traditional food: how it works in general
The route for a traditional food is shorter than the full novel food route, but it is not a free pass. In general terms, the applicant gathers the evidence of history of safe use, describes the food and how it will be used in the new market, and sends that evidence to the food authority. The authority checks the evidence, asks for more where it is thin, and may consult scientific experts. If the evidence is strong and the new use is close to the old use, the food can be allowed with conditions on its use, such as the form it may be sold in, the foods it may go into, and the maximum amount per serving.
If the evidence is weak, or if the new use differs much from the old use, the authority may ask for the full safety assessment, with toxicology, allergenicity, and nutrition tests, as described in the earlier unit on safety assessment. If the evidence shows a risk, the food can be refused, or allowed only with a warning on the label. The decision, and the conditions, are published so that other makers can see what was allowed and on what terms.
The conditions matter as much as the decision. A food allowed as a whole fruit in a drink is not automatically allowed as an extract in a supplement, and a food allowed at a small dose is not automatically allowed at a large dose. A maker who changes the form, the dose, or the use must go back and ask again. This is how the system keeps a traditional food traditional: the approval follows the history, and a use that leaves the history behind needs new evidence.
Post-market monitoring: watching the food after launch
Approval is not the end of the story. Once a novel food is on the shelf, the food world must watch what happens when real people eat it in real life, over months and years. That watching is called post-market monitoring, and it exists because no assessment before launch can see everything. A rare allergy, an effect that takes years to appear, or a use nobody predicted can only be found after the food is sold.
Post-market monitoring has three parts. The first is watching for harm: collecting reports of adverse reactions, from buyers, doctors, and food businesses, and checking whether the reports point to the new food. A single report proves little, but a pattern of similar reports is a signal that must be followed up. The second is watching how the food is used: is it eaten in the amounts the assessment assumed, or in larger amounts, or by people the assessment did not expect, such as children eating a food meant for adults? The third is watching the food itself: does it stay the same from batch to batch, and does the maker keep to the conditions of its approval?
Monitoring is a shared duty. The maker must keep records, report problems, and tell the authority if the food is used in a new way. The authority must collect reports, look for patterns, and act when a pattern appears. The buyer has a part too: reporting a bad reaction, with the food's name and lot code, is how a pattern starts. A food system that listens after launch is safer than one that approves and forgets.
When monitoring finds a problem: what happens next
When monitoring finds a signal, the response follows a clear order. First, the signal is checked: is the reaction real, is it linked to the food, and how many people are affected? A few reports with a clear link matter more than many vague reports with no link. Second, the risk is judged: how serious is the harm, who is at risk, and how much of the food would cause it? Third, action is taken in proportion to the risk.
The actions range from a label change, such as adding an allergy warning, to a change in the conditions of use, such as a lower maximum amount, to a temporary stop on sales while the evidence is checked, to a full withdrawal of the food. The action is published with the reason, so that buyers understand what happened and makers of other foods can learn from it. A withdrawal is not a failure of the system: it is the system working as designed, catching a problem after launch that no test before launch could have caught.
The most useful outcome of monitoring is often a quiet one: the food is confirmed safe in real use, the conditions are shown to work, and the assessment's predictions are proved right. That confirmation builds trust in the next novel food, and it gives the maker evidence to show buyers who ask whether the food is safe. Monitoring is not suspicion of the maker: it is the proof that the approval was sound.
The diagram shows the full path of a traditional food: history first, approval with conditions, and watching after launch.
Why this route matters for the food world
The traditional food route matters because it opens the market to the foods of the world without lowering the standard of safety. It lets a fruit, a grain, or a vegetable that fed one country join the diet of another, and it lets the makers in the country of origin earn from their own food heritage. It also protects the buyer, because the route demands evidence, not stories, and it keeps the new use close to the old use that proved safe.
Post-market monitoring matters because it keeps the system honest after the launch. A novel food is approved on predictions about how it will be eaten, and predictions can be wrong. Monitoring tests those predictions against real life, and it gives the system a way to correct itself without waiting for a disaster. Together, the traditional food route and post-market monitoring show the balance at the heart of food regulation: open to new foods, careful about new risks, and willing to learn after the decision is made.
Practical note: Pick a food from another country's cuisine that you enjoy and that is sold in your local shops. Write down its history as you understand it: where it comes from, how it is eaten at home, and how it is eaten here. Then write down one way the use here differs from the use at home, in form, amount, or frequency, and one question you would ask before judging it safe in its new use.
Quick self-check
Question: Why does a history of eating a whole fruit not prove a concentrated extract of the same fruit is safe?
Because the extract carries far more of the fruit's substances in each serving, and it is eaten in a different way. The history proves the whole fruit eaten as food, not the new form at a new dose, so the extract needs its own assessment.
Question: A novel food has been on sale for a year with no reports of harm. Does that prove it is safe?
Not on its own. It is good evidence, but it must be weighed with how many people ate it, how much they ate, and whether reporting would have caught a problem. A rare reaction, or a slow effect, may not have appeared yet, so monitoring must continue and the absence of reports must not be treated as proof.
Try it yourself
Choose a traditional food from another country that you know: a fruit, a grain, a vegetable, or a drink ingredient. Write a one page application for it, in general terms: the evidence of its history of safe use, the new form and new use you propose, and the conditions you would accept on its sale. Then write a monitoring plan for its first year on the shelf: what you would watch, who would report, and what would make you change the label or pause sales. Compare your plan with a classmate who chose a different food: which food has the stronger history, and which monitoring plan is stronger?
Key ideas to carry forward
- A traditional food from a third country is a food with a long history of safe use as ordinary food in its home country.
- History must be evidence, not a story: many people, a long time, eaten as food.
- A history of the whole food does not prove a new form, a new dose, or a new use.
- The traditional food route is shorter than the full novel food route, but it is not a free pass.
- Conditions of use follow the history, and a use that leaves the history behind needs new evidence.
- Post-market monitoring watches for harm, watches real use, and watches batch quality after launch.
- When monitoring finds a signal, action follows in proportion: label, conditions, pause, or withdrawal.
- Monitoring is not suspicion: it is the proof that the approval was sound.
Glossary
Traditional food
A food with a long history of safe use as ordinary food in its country of origin. Food tech example: a fruit eaten for generations in its home country is a traditional food when it is sold in a new market.
Third country
A country outside the market where a food is being sold, used here to mean the food's country of origin. Food tech example: a fruit from a third country must show its history of safe use before it can be sold as food.
History of safe use
Evidence that a food was eaten safely as ordinary food by many people over a long time. Food tech example: market records and food surveys together show a history of safe use for a traditional grain.
Post-market monitoring
Watching a food after launch for harm, real use, and batch quality. Food tech example: post-market monitoring collects reports of reactions to a new food and looks for a pattern.
Adverse reaction
An unwanted effect on health after eating a food. Food tech example: a report of an allergic reaction after eating a new food is an adverse reaction report.
Conditions of use
The limits set on an approval, such as the form, the foods, and the maximum amount per serving. Food tech example: a traditional food is allowed as a whole fruit in drinks, under conditions of use that set the maximum amount.
Signal
A pattern in monitoring reports that suggests a real problem and must be followed up. Food tech example: several similar reports of stomach upset after one new food form a signal.
Withdrawal
The removal of a food from sale after a problem is found. Food tech example: a novel food is withdrawn when monitoring shows a risk that cannot be fixed by a label change.
Extract
A concentrated preparation made from a food, carrying more of its substances per serving than the whole food. Food tech example: an extract of a root carries far more of its active substances than the boiled root.
Ordinary diet
The everyday eating of a people, as opposed to medicinal use or rare ceremonial use. Food tech example: a fruit eaten daily as part of an ordinary diet has a stronger history than a plant used only as medicine.
Food survey
A study that records what people eat, used to show how a food was used and how much was eaten. Food tech example: a food survey in the country of origin shows how often a traditional fruit was eaten.
Food authority
The public body that judges food safety and decides whether a food may be sold. Food tech example: the food authority checks the evidence for a traditional food and sets its conditions of use.
Real use
How a food is actually eaten after launch, as opposed to how the assessment assumed it would be eaten. Food tech example: monitoring checks whether real use of a new snack matches the amounts in the assessment.
Concentrated
Made stronger by removing water or by taking out the active part, so that each serving carries more of a substance. Food tech example: a concentrated powder of a root carries more of its substances than the fresh root.
References
- Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations and World Health Organization, Principles and Methods for the Risk Assessment of Chemicals in Food, 2009.
- Codex Alimentarius Commission, General Principles of Food Hygiene, 2020.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Potter, N. N. and Hotchkiss, J. H., Food Science, 5th edition, 1995.
- Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.