GIFSQ ID: FTN-0111
Novel Food Preservation
Unit 1: Why Novel Preservation: What Heat Does to Food and What Comes Next
Note
Unit 1: Why Novel Preservation: What Heat Does to Food and What Comes Next
A glass of fresh orange juice tastes bright, sharp and alive. The same juice, after a long hot treatment, can taste flat and cooked, and its colour can look duller. Both glasses are safe to drink, but they are not the same food. Why does the treatment that makes food safe also change the food, and can a maker keep the safety and keep the fresh taste at the same time? This unit starts with that question.
Questions to think about
- Why has heat been used for so long to preserve food, and what does it do well?
- What changes in flavour, colour, texture and nutrients when food is heated for safety?
- What does "minimal processing" mean in plain words?
- How can a method kill microbes without cooking the food?
- How should a food maker judge a new method before using it in a factory?
1.1 Heat: the method that came first and still sets the standard
Heat is the preservation method that food makers know best. In the Fellows extracts, heat appears in many forms: blanching, pasteurisation, sterilisation, evaporation, extrusion, baking and frying are all listed as high temperature hurdles in Table 1.17 of the hurdle extract. The opening pages of Chapter 9 also speak of the amount of heating needed for microbial destruction or enzyme inactivation. That phrasing points to the two jobs heat does in preservation: it destroys microbes, and it stops enzymes that would spoil the food.
Heat works because it acts on the whole food. A hot treatment can reach microbes through the food, and the same treatment can stop enzyme action at the same time. That is why heat has stayed at the centre of food preservation for so long: one treatment can do both jobs, it can be applied to many foods, and makers have long practice in running it in a factory.
The extracts do not give a single temperature or a single time that defines heat treatment in general. They do not give a number for how many microbes a named heat treatment kills, and they do not give a number for how much of a named nutrient heat removes. Those numbers are not in the extracts used for this unit, so this unit does not quote them. What the extracts do give is the comparison that matters for this subject: newer methods are judged, in part, by how much of the fresh quality they keep when heat would change it.
Quick check
Name the two jobs that the Chapter 9 opening pages link with heating.
Check your answer
Microbial destruction and enzyme inactivation.
1.2 What heat costs: flavour, colour, texture and nutrients
Heat changes food while it preserves it. The hurdle extract says this in plain terms for preserved foods in general: preservative factors also strongly influence the sensory characteristics of the product, and they contribute to important differences in flavour, texture or colour between different products. A smoked fish tastes of smoke as well as of fish. A jam tastes of heat and sugar as well as of fruit. The treatment leaves its mark on the food.
Chapter 9 makes the same point from the other side, by describing what newer methods keep. For pulsed electric fields, Fellows notes low processing temperatures which result in high retention of sensory characteristics and nutritional properties. For high pressure processing, Fellows notes that the process can be operated at ambient or even chill temperatures, so there is little heat damage to nutrients or natural flavours and colours, which results in high quality products. For pulsed light, Table 9.2 lists little or no changes to foods as an advantage. Each of those statements is a quiet statement about heat: when a food is heated, some flavour, colour and nutrient quality can be lost, and a method that avoids heat can keep more of it.
The extracts do not put a number on that loss for any named food. They do not say, for example, that a named juice loses a named percentage of a named vitamin after a named heat treatment. They do not give a colour score, a flavour score or a texture score for a heated food beside the same food kept fresh. This unit says that plainly, because a number that is not in the book must not be invented here. The point the book does support is qualitative: heat can damage the fresh qualities of a food, and the search for newer methods is, in large part, a search for ways to keep those qualities.
Texture shows the same trade off. In the hurdle extract, the factors that preserve a food also shape its texture. In Chapter 9, high pressure gels are described as smooth, glossy and soft, with greater elasticity than heat treated gels, and pressure treated fruit products are reported to retain the flavour, texture and colour of the fresh fruit. The comparison is with heat treated products, and it shows that texture is one of the qualities at stake when a maker chooses a preservation method.
Quick check
The extracts say high pressure processing can run at ambient or chill temperatures. What benefit does Fellows link with that fact?
Check your answer
Little heat damage to nutrients or natural flavours and colours, which results in high quality products.
Heat: what it gives and what it costs
Destroys microbes
Inactivates enzymes
Works on many foods
Fresh flavour can fade
Natural colour can dull
Texture can change
Nutrients can suffer heat damage
No temperature or time for heat in general
No percentage loss for a named nutrient
No flavour or colour score for a named food
The trade off is real, and the book describes it in words. The numbers for a named food are not in these extracts.
Figure 1.1: The heat trade off. Heat gives microbial destruction and enzyme inactivation, and it can cost fresh flavour, colour, texture and nutrients. Drawn from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9 and Section 1.8.2.
1.3 What "minimal processing" means
"Minimal processing" is the name Fellows uses in Chapter 9 for newer methods that preserve food with less change to the fresh food than a full heat treatment would cause. Table 9.1 in Chapter 9 is headed "Examples of novel processes that may have applications for minimal processing of foods". The word "may" matters: these are processes that may have applications, not processes that are all in wide commercial use. Some are in use, some are still being tested, and some are described in the book as not yet used on a commercial scale.
Minimal processing does not mean no processing. It does not mean raw food, and it does not mean food with no safety step. It means a lighter touch: a treatment that is strong enough to control microbes, but gentle enough to leave the food close to its fresh state in flavour, colour, texture and nutrients. The hurdle extract gives the same idea in different words: by combining hurdles, the intensity of individual preservation techniques can be kept comparatively low to minimise loss of product quality, while overall there is a high impact on controlling microbial growth.
The table below lists the novel processes named in Table 9.1. Read it as a map of this subject, not as a list of methods that are all ready to use. High pressure processing is covered in Unit 2. Electric methods, sound and light, irradiation, supercritical carbon dioxide, hurdle design and biopreservation follow in later units.
Table 1.1: Novel processes that may have applications for minimal processing of foods (Fellows Table 9.1)
| Novel process named in Table 9.1 |
|---|
| Electro-heating (radio-frequency, microwave and ohmic heating) |
| High pressure processing |
| High voltage electrical discharge |
| High intensity light |
| Ultrasound |
| Modified atmosphere packaging |
| Jet impactation |
| Gamma radiation |
| Lasers and masers |
| Microfiltration |
| X-rays |
| Cryogenic thermal shock |
| Immobilised enzymes |
| Active packaging |
| Ozone |
| Nitrous oxide |
Table 1.1: Novel processes listed in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Table 9.1. The book notes that microfiltration, immobilised enzymes, irradiation, radio-frequency, microwave and ohmic heating, modified atmospheres and active packaging are described in other chapters.
Quick check
What does "minimal processing" mean in this unit, and what does it not mean?
Check your answer
It means a lighter treatment that controls microbes but leaves the food close to its fresh state in flavour, colour, texture and nutrients. It does not mean no processing or no safety step.
1.4 Killing microbes without cooking the food
The central idea of this subject is simple to state and hard to do: kill or stop the microbes, but do not cook the food. Each novel method tries to do that in a different way. Pressure squeezes microbes. Short electric pulses make pores in cell membranes. Light treats a surface. Sound waves make bubbles that disrupt cells. Each method attacks the microbe, not the food as a whole, and each one tries to leave the food molecules that give flavour, colour and texture largely untouched.
Fellows gives one clear example of why that can work for pressure. High pressures only affect non-covalent chemical bonds, that is ionic, hydrogen and hydrophobic bonds, leaving covalent bonds intact. That permits destruction of microbial activity without significantly affecting food molecules that contribute to the texture or flavour of the food. The same chapter notes that pressure is distributed instantly and uniformly through the food, so the treatment reaches all parts of the food at once. Those two facts, a selective action on bonds and a uniform action through the food, explain why pressure can preserve a juice or a jam and still leave it tasting of fresh fruit. The full detail of pressure is in Unit 2.
Other methods have their own limits, and the book is plain about them. Pulsed electric fields kill vegetative cells, but Table 9.2 lists no effect on enzymes and spores as a limit. Pulsed light has only surface effects and is difficult to use with complex surfaces. Ultrasound, used by itself, is unlikely to preserve food, because the resistance of most micro-organisms and enzymes to ultrasound is so high that the intensity needed would damage the texture and other physical properties of the food. A method that kills microbes without cooking the food is only useful if it kills enough microbes, in the real food, without damaging the food in a new way. That test runs through every unit in this subject.
🤔 Pause and think: think of a food you eat fresh, such as a fruit juice, a salad dressing or a piece of fruit. If a maker heated it hard, what would change first in your view: the flavour, the colour or the texture? What would you want a new method to keep, and what would you accept as a small change?
1.5 The hurdle idea: small steps that add up
Long before the newer methods, food makers already combined small preservation steps. The hurdle extract gives smoked fish and smoked meat as examples: heat, reduced moisture content and anti-microbial chemicals deposited from smoke onto the surface, with salt or brine adding a further step, and chilling or modified atmosphere packaging adding still more. Jams and other fruit preserves combine heat, a high solids content that lowers water activity, and high acidity. In vegetable fermentation, salt selects the first microbes, oxygen is used up, the redox potential falls, lactic acid bacteria are favoured, and they acidify the product and stabilise it. Pasteurisation and packaging may follow.
Leistner developed that old practice into the hurdle idea. Each preservative factor is a hurdle that micro-organisms must overcome. No single hurdle needs to be very high. Together, the hurdles stop the microbes. The hurdle extract lists the factors in Table 1.17: physical hurdles such as high temperatures, low temperatures, modified atmospheres, packaging films, ultra-high pressures, ultrasonication and ultraviolet radiation; physicochemical hurdles such as carbon dioxide, ethanol, lactic acid, low pH, low redox potential, low water activity, organic acids, salt, smoking and spices and herbs; and microbially derived hurdles such as bacteriocins, competitive flora and protective cultures.
Three warnings from the hurdle extract matter for every later unit. First, the hurdles must take into account the initial numbers and types of micro-organisms likely to be present, and they should be high enough so that the anticipated numbers cannot overcome them. Second, the same hurdles that preserve a food when it is properly prepared are overcome by a larger initial population, when raw materials are not adequately cleaned. Third, the same hurdles may fail with a different product that is richer in nutrients that can support microbial growth, and then a different combination may be needed or the height of the hurdles increased. In practice the factors may operate simultaneously, synergistically or sequentially, even though they are drawn as a sequence in Figure 1.19 of the book.
The hurdle idea also explains why minimal processing and hurdle technology belong together. A mild novel method may not be strong enough on its own. Combined with chilling, a low pH, a low water activity or a second mild method, it may be strong enough, while each single step stays gentle enough to keep the quality of the food. Unit 6 returns to this idea in full, with worked examples.
Quick check
A maker uses the same hurdles for a new product that is richer in nutrients than the old product. What does the hurdle extract warn may happen?
Check your answer
The hurdles may be inadequate to preserve the richer product, and a different combination may be needed or the height of the hurdles increased.
1.6 How to judge any new method: four tests, plus the factory test
Fellows does not judge a new method by taste alone. The opening pages of Chapter 9 set out three conditions for a new minimal process, citing Manvell (1996). First, the process must be capable of operating in a factory environment and not just in a laboratory with highly qualified staff. Second, it should ensure a financial benefit to the manufacturer. Third, it should be sufficiently flexible to accommodate a wide range of products, often having short production runs and brief product life cycles. A method that works only in a laboratory, or only for one product made in long runs, fails that test even if the food tastes good.
Table 9.2 adds the detail for each method, with advantages, limitations and examples of commercial applications and products. Read across a row and the judgement takes shape. The four tests below bring the chapter introduction and Table 9.2 together into a form a maker can use. They are the tests this subject uses in every later unit.
Test 1: microbial kill. Does the method kill or stop enough microbes, including the ones that matter for safety? Which microbes does it kill, and which does it leave? Pulsed electric fields kill vegetative cells, but Table 9.2 lists no effect on enzymes and spores. High pressure kills vegetative bacteria, and spores at higher temperatures. Pulsed light is not proven effective against spores. A method must be judged against the microbes in the real food, not in a model system alone.
Test 2: quality kept. Are colours, flavours and nutrients preserved? Does the texture stay close to fresh? Table 9.2 lists colours, flavours and nutrients preserved as an advantage for pulsed electric fields and for high pressure. It lists little or no changes to foods for pulsed light. It also lists limits that cut into quality, such as possible damage by free radicals for ultrasound, and possible adverse chemical effects for pulsed light. Quality is not a single score: flavour, colour, texture and nutrients must each be checked.
Test 3: cost. Can the maker afford the equipment and the running cost, and will the product sell at a price that covers them? Chapter 9 gives cost signals without giving a full cost table. High pressure equipment is described as expensive, and a high pressure fruit juice plant in 1996 was twenty times the cost of an equivalent capacity plate heat exchanger system. Pressure processed products in Japan sold at three to four times the cost of conventional products, and the higher quality, particularly flavour and texture of the fruit, had so far ensured sufficient demand for commercial viability. Pulsed electric field equipment is also described as high in initial investment cost, ranging from $450,000 to $2,000,000. Cost is a real limit, and it is separate from taste or safety.
Test 4: safety approval. Is there evidence of toxicity, and are regulatory issues resolved? Table 9.2 lists no evidence of toxicity as an advantage for pulsed electric fields and for high pressure. It also lists regulatory issues to be resolved as a limitation for pulsed electric fields, high pressure, magnetic fields and photodynamic systems, and it lists safety concerns in the local processing environment for pulsed electric fields and for magnetic fields. A method that is not yet approved, or that raises safety questions for operators, cannot be used in a factory even if it works in a laboratory.
The factory test sits behind all four. A method must work with ordinary factory staff, with short runs and changing products, and it must give a financial benefit. That is why Table 9.2 also lists practical limits such as batch processing for high pressure, limited packaging options, difficulty in scaling up, and the need to use the method in combination with another process. A good result in a small test is the start of the judgement, not the end of it.
Judging a new method, step by step
Which microbes die, and which survive?
↓
Flavour, colour, texture and nutrients
↓
Equipment cost, running cost, selling price
↓
Toxicity evidence, regulation, operator safety
↓
Ordinary staff, short runs, many products, financial benefit
Each step must pass. A method that fails one step is not ready, even if it passes the others.
Figure 1.2: How to judge a new minimal processing method. The four tests come from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Table 9.2, and the factory test comes from the chapter introduction, citing Manvell (1996).
Quick check
Name the three conditions for a new minimal process given in the Chapter 9 introduction.
Check your answer
It must work in a factory environment and not just in a laboratory with highly qualified staff; it should ensure a financial benefit to the manufacturer; and it should be flexible enough for a wide range of products, often with short production runs and brief product life cycles.
1.7 What the book does not tell us in these extracts
A careful reader should know the limits of the extracts used for this unit. The extracts used here are the opening pages of Fellows Chapter 9, Table 9.1, Table 9.2, the pulsed electric field, high pressure, pulsed light and ultrasound sections, and the hurdle extract from Chapter 1. They do not include a chapter on heat treatment itself, and they do not include a table that compares a heated food with a minimally processed food, nutrient by nutrient, for a named product.
So this unit leaves out, on purpose, any number for heat damage to a named vitamin, any shelf life in days for a named minimally processed product beyond the two month chilled shelf life given for pressure processed jams in Unit 2, and any claim that a named novel method is approved in a named country at a named date, beyond what Table 9.2 says about regulatory issues still to be resolved. Where the book gives a date, this unit gives it: the first commercial high pressure products went on sale in Japan by 1990, and similar products had recently reached the United States market by 1997, but were not currently available in Europe in 2000, as stated in the book. Those dates are book dates, and they are not updated here from general knowledge.
The extracts also do not name guacamole as a high pressure product. The task outline for this subject lists juices, guacamole, meats and seafood as foods that use high pressure processing, but guacamole does not appear in the Fellows extracts used for Units 1 and 2, so it is not presented here as a book fact. Juices, meats and seafood do appear in the extracts, and they are covered in Unit 2.
Try it yourself: Go to a shop and look at two fruit juices or two jams, one kept chilled and one kept on a shelf at room temperature. Read the labels and look at the packs, the colour through the pack, and any storage instruction such as "keep refrigerated". Note which one looks closer to fresh fruit in colour, and which one lists a longer shelf life. Then ask: which trade off is the maker making, longer life or fresher quality? Write down what you see, in your own words, without guessing a number that is not on the label. That observation is the trade off of this unit, seen on a real shelf.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Heat destroys microbes and inactivates enzymes, and it has long set the standard for preservation, but it can change flavour, colour, texture and nutrients.
- The extracts describe that cost in words, not in numbers for a named food: no temperature, time or percentage nutrient loss for heat in general is given in these extracts, so none is quoted here.
- Minimal processing means a lighter treatment that controls microbes while keeping the food close to its fresh state, not no processing at all.
- Table 9.1 lists sixteen novel processes that may have applications for minimal processing, from high pressure processing and electro-heating to ultrasound, gamma radiation and active packaging.
- The central idea is to kill microbes without cooking the food, by acting on the microbe rather than heating the whole food.
- The hurdle idea from Leistner says each preservative factor is a hurdle microbes must overcome, and small hurdles used together can keep quality while controlling microbes.
- Hurdles must be high enough for the numbers and types of microbes likely to be present, and they can fail if raw materials carry a larger initial population or if the product is richer in nutrients.
- A new method is judged by microbial kill, quality kept, cost, and safety approval, plus the factory test: it must work with ordinary staff, with short runs and many products, and it must give a financial benefit.
- Table 9.2 shows that every novel method has limits as well as advantages, such as no effect on spores for pulsed electric fields and pulsed light, and high equipment cost for high pressure processing.
- Guacamole is not named in the Fellows extracts used for Units 1 and 2, so it is not presented here as a book fact.
Glossary
Minimal processing
A lighter preservation treatment that controls microbes while keeping the food close to its fresh state in flavour, colour, texture and nutrients. Food tech example: a fruit juice treated by high pressure instead of a long hot treatment, so it keeps more fresh flavour.
Microbial destruction
The killing of micro-organisms in food, so they cannot grow, spoil the food or cause illness. Food tech example: heating needed for microbial destruction, as described at the opening of Fellows Chapter 9.
Enzyme inactivation
Stopping the action of enzymes in food, so they no longer cause browning, softening or flavour change during storage. Food tech example: heat used for enzyme inactivation before a fruit product is stored.
Sensory characteristics
The qualities of a food that are judged by the senses: flavour, colour, texture, odour and appearance. Food tech example: low processing temperatures giving high retention of sensory characteristics in a juice.
Hurdle
A single preservative factor that micro-organisms must overcome, such as heat, chilling, low pH, low water activity or salt. Food tech example: high acidity as one hurdle in a jam, used with heat and high solids content.
Hurdle technology
The design of a set of hurdles used together to preserve a food, so each single step can stay mild while the set as a whole controls microbes. Food tech example: combining chilling with low pH and a mild novel method for a ready-to-eat food.
Water activity
A measure of the water in a food that is available for microbes to use, lowered by high solids content or by drying. Food tech example: the high solids content of a jam lowering water activity as one of its hurdles.
Vegetative cell
A micro-organism in its active, growing form, as opposed to a spore, which is a resting form. Food tech example: pulsed electric fields killing vegetative cells in a fruit juice, while spores survive.
Spore
A resting form made by some microbes, which resists heat, pressure and other treatments far better than the active vegetative cell. Food tech example: a bacterial spore surviving a treatment that kills vegetative cells, as noted for pulsed electric fields and pulsed light.
Regulatory issues
Questions of approval, rules and labelling that must be settled before a new process can be used for food sold to the public. Food tech example: Table 9.2 listing regulatory issues to be resolved for high pressure processing.
Factory environment
The conditions of real food production, with ordinary staff, short runs, changing products and cost limits, as opposed to a laboratory. Food tech example: a new method that works in a laboratory but must also work in a factory environment, as required in the Chapter 9 introduction.
Financial benefit
A gain for the manufacturer from using a process, after equipment cost and running cost are counted. Food tech example: a new minimal process that should ensure a financial benefit to the manufacturer, as required in the Chapter 9 introduction.
References
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, Woodhead Publishing. Chapter 9, Processing using electric fields, high hydrostatic pressure, light or ultrasound, including Table 9.1 and Table 9.2, and Chapter 1, Section 1.8.2, Hurdle technology, including Table 1.17.
- Leistner, L., and Gorris, L. G. M. (1995), as cited in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 1, for the hurdle concept and Table 1.17.
- Manvell, C. (1996), as cited in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, for the conditions for new developments in minimal processing.
- Earnshaw, R. G. (1996) and Manvell, C. (1996), as cited in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Table 9.2, adapted from those sources.
Unit 2: High Pressure Processing: Squeezing Microbes to Death
Note
Unit 2: High Pressure Processing: Squeezing Microbes to Death
A sealed pack of jam sits in a chiller. It was never boiled, never baked, and never heated hard, yet it keeps for two months. The pack was squeezed, not cooked, under a pressure hundreds of times higher than the air around us. How can pressure kill microbes, why do some microbes survive it, and what does a factory need to run such a process? This unit follows the pressure, from the first test in 1899 to the factory vessel.
Questions to think about
- How can pressure kill a microbe without heating the food?
- Why do vegetative cells die under pressure while bacterial spores survive?
- What happens inside a pressure vessel during one cycle, step by step?
- How is batch processing different from semi-continuous processing?
- Which foods use high pressure processing, and what does it do, and not do, to their quality?
2.1 A short history: from 1899 to the first shops
The first reported use of high pressures as a method of food processing was in 1899 at West Virginia University in the United States. Experiments there used high hydrostatic pressures to preserve milk, fruit juice, meat and a variety of fruits. They demonstrated that micro-organisms in these products could be destroyed by pressures of 658 MPa (6500 atm) for 10 minutes. That is the first pressure and time given in this unit, and it comes from that early test, not from a modern factory setting.
In the early years of the twentieth century, other research showed that protein structure in egg white could be altered by high pressures. The early researchers also found a limit that still matters today: enzymes were largely unaffected, particularly in milk. They were also constrained by difficulties in manufacturing high pressure units and by inadequate packaging materials to contain the foods during processing, and research was discontinued.
Research began again in the late 1980s, mainly in Japan, after advances in the design of presses in the 1970s and rapid advances in packaging materials. By 1990 the first commercial products produced by high pressure processing went on sale in Japan. One company introduced a range of pressure processed jams, including apple, kiwi, strawberry and raspberry in flexible sealed plastic packs, and two other companies started production of bulk orange juice and grapefruit juice. The jams had a shelf life of two months under chilled storage, which is required to prevent enzyme activity. Other products included fruit jellies, sauces, fruit yoghurts and salad dressings. The products sold at three to four times the cost of conventional products, but the higher quality, particularly flavour and texture of the fruit, had so far ensured sufficient demand for commercial viability. Similar products had recently reached the United States market by 1997, but were not currently available in Europe in 2000, as stated in the book. Those dates and prices are book dates, and they are not updated here.
Quick check
What pressure and time did the 1899 tests use, and which foods were tested?
Check your answer
658 MPa (6500 atm) for 10 minutes, used to preserve milk, fruit juice, meat and a variety of fruits.
2.2 How pressure kills microbes
When high pressures, up to 1000 MPa (10,000 bar), are applied to packages of food that are submerged in a liquid, the pressure is distributed instantly and uniformly throughout the food. Fellows calls this "isostatic". That uniform action is a large advantage: the food is treated evenly throughout, whatever its size or shape. It overcomes problems of lack of uniformity found in conductive or convective heating, in microwaves and dielectric heating, and in radiant heating.
The microbes do not all die at the same pressure. In general, bacteria in the log phase of growth are more barosensitive, that is more sensitive to high pressures, than cells in the stationary, dormant or death phases. Moderately high pressures of 300-600 MPa cause vegetative microbial cells to be killed or inactivated. Typically, a pressure of 350 MPa applied for 30 min or 400 MPa applied for 5 min will cause a ten-fold reduction in vegetative cells of bacteria, yeasts or moulds. Pulsed pressure treatments have been found to be more effective than static pressure for pasteurisation of pineapple juice.
Research is continuing to understand the complex factors that cause these effects, but it is known that high pressures cause collapse of intracellular vacuoles, and damage to cell walls and cytoplasmic membranes. Knorr describes possible hypotheses for disruption to metabolic processes caused by the effects of high pressures on cellular enzymes. The book does not give a single, settled mechanism for every microbe, and this unit does not invent one.
Pressure acts on bonds in a selective way. At present it is known that high pressures only affect non-covalent chemical bonds, that is ionic, hydrogen and hydrophobic bonds, leaving covalent bonds intact. That permits destruction of microbial activity without significantly affecting food molecules that contribute to the texture or flavour of the food. Because the process can be operated at ambient or even chill temperatures, there is little heat damage to nutrients or natural flavours and colours, which results in high quality products. The process does not require the use of chemical preservatives to achieve an adequate shelf life.
High pressure processing has no heating or cooling periods, and there are rapid pressurisation and de-pressurisation cycles, thus reducing processing times compared to thermal processing. It is likely that high pressure processing will be capable of being used in combination with other types of processing, and thus expand the unit operations available to food processors, leading to the development of new products and processes.
Quick check
What does "isostatic" mean for high pressure processing, and why does it matter?
Check your answer
Pressure is distributed instantly and uniformly throughout the food, so the food is treated evenly whatever its size or shape, unlike heating, where some parts can be treated less than others.
Quick check
A maker applies 400 MPa for 5 minutes. What reduction in vegetative cells does the book typically link with that treatment?
Check your answer
A ten-fold reduction in vegetative cells of bacteria, yeasts or moulds. The book also gives 350 MPa for 30 minutes for the same ten-fold reduction.
How pressure acts: what breaks, what stays
Intracellular vacuoles collapse
Cell walls are damaged
Cytoplasmic membranes are damaged
Cellular enzymes are disrupted
Covalent bonds stay intact
Only ionic, hydrogen and hydrophobic bonds are affected
Food molecules for texture and flavour are largely kept
Ambient or chill temperatures are possible
Little heat damage to nutrients, flavours and colours
No chemical preservatives are required for shelf life
Pressure is selective in what it breaks. That is why a squeezed food can still taste fresh.
Figure 2.1: How high pressure acts on microbes and on food. Drawn from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Section 9.2.1.
2.3 Why spores survive, and what it takes to stop them
Bacterial spores are far harder to kill than vegetative cells. Higher pressures are required to cause bacterial spores to germinate, followed by inactivation of the germinated cells. When combined with moderate heating, for example to 60°C, spores are destroyed at pressures of 400 MPa to different extents, depending on the strains that are present. The book gives that 60°C example, and it gives no single pressure and time that destroys all spores in all foods, so this unit gives none.
Germination of spores under high pressures is temperature dependent. Near 0°C, spores resist germination even at pressures of 1000 MPa, whereas at moderate temperatures, pressure induced germination can be achieved at 100 MPa. Germinated spores can be destroyed at a pressure of 600 MPa and a temperature of 50-70°C. Those effects are not consistent, and a combination of high pressure and moderate heating can have either synergistic or antagonistic effects on microbial growth, enzyme activity and chemical reactivity. For example, high pressure can either make micro-organisms more sensitive to heat or it can prevent their destruction at higher temperatures, depending on the type of micro-organism being studied.
That uneven result is the reason pressure alone is not a sterilisation method for every food in the book. Table 9.2 lists the point plainly: high pressure kills vegetative bacteria, and spores at higher temperatures, while its limitations include some microbial survival and little effect on food enzyme activity. A maker who needs to control spores must plan for heat, or for germination followed by a second kill, or for a combination with another method, and must test the named strains in the named food. The extracts give no shortcut around that testing.
🤔 Pause and think: a juice maker wants a long shelf life at room temperature, and a second maker is happy with a short chilled shelf life. Which of the two can use pressure alone more easily, and why does the spore problem matter more for the first maker than for the second?
2.4 Enzymes: the limit that pressure does not solve
Enzymes are the second limit, and it was already seen in the early work: enzymes were largely unaffected, particularly in milk. The later work gives detail, and it shows a mixed picture, not a single rule.
Enzymes related to food quality vary in their barosensitivity. Some can be inactivated at room temperature by pressures of a few hundred MPa, whereas others can withstand 1000 MPa. For example, peroxidase in peas and pectin methyl esterase in strawberries can withstand 1200 MPa. Yet other enzymes have their activity enhanced by high pressures. Pressure activation or inactivation is also strongly dependent on pH, substrate composition and temperature. The situation is further complicated by effects on cellular membranes, which when ruptured may permit reactions between released intracellular enzymes and their substrates.
Fruit enzymes give the clearest examples, because fruit processing has so far been the main application of high pressure technology. Polyphenoloxidase has been shown to resist pressures of up to 1200 MPa for 10 minutes before inactivation, although it is more sensitive at higher pH levels. There are differences in polyphenoloxidase barosensitivity from different sources, with potato and mushroom polyphenoloxidase being very pressure stable, with 800-900 MPa required for inactivation, and more pressure sensitive enzymes from apricot, strawberry and grape, at 100, 400 and 600 MPa respectively.
Pectinesterase is responsible for cloud destabilisation in juices, gelation of fruit concentrates and loss of consistency in tomato products. It is less resistant than polyphenoloxidase: its activity decreases above 300 MPa, and it can be inactivated at pressures above 700 MPa at 45°C for 10 minutes. Orange pectin esterase is partially, 90%, inactivated at 600 MPa at room temperature, and it does not reactivate during storage.
That is why the first commercial jams needed chilled storage: the shelf life of two months under chilled storage is required to prevent enzyme activity. Pressure can kill microbes and keep fresh flavour, but it cannot be counted on to stop every enzyme in every food. Chilling, or a second treatment, is often part of the plan.
Quick check
Why did the first pressure processed jams need chilled storage?
Check your answer
Chilled storage is required to prevent enzyme activity, because high pressure has little effect on many food enzymes.
2.5 The pressure vessel and how a cycle runs
The construction of high pressure machinery is a specialised and expensive operation. In 1996 a high pressure fruit juice plant was twenty times the cost of an equivalent capacity plate heat exchanger system. Companies that make equipment to press metal and ceramic engineering components, and quartz crystals for the electronics industry, have the necessary expertise, and that expertise is being adapted for use in the food industry.
The main components of a high pressure system are a pressure vessel and its closure, a pressure generation system, a temperature control device, and a materials handling system.
Most pressure vessels are made from a high tensile steel alloy "monoblocs", forged from a single piece of material, which can withstand pressures of 400-600 MPa. For higher pressures, pre-stressed multi-layer or wire-wound vessels are used. Vessels are sealed by a threaded steel closure, a closure having an interrupted thread, which can be removed more quickly, or by a sealed frame that is positioned over the vessel.
In operation, after all air has been removed, a pressure transmitting medium, either water or oil, is pumped from a reservoir into the pressure vessel using a pressure intensifier until the desired pressure is reached. That method is termed "indirect compression", and it requires static pressure seals. Another method, termed "direct compression", uses a piston to compress the vessel, but it requires dynamic pressure seals between the piston and the internal vessel surface, which are subject to wear and are not used in commercial applications.
Temperature control in commercial operations can be achieved by pumping a heating or cooling medium through a jacket that surrounds the pressure vessel. That is satisfactory in most applications, as a constant temperature is required, but if it is necessary to regularly change the temperature, the large thermal inertia of the vessel and the relatively small heat transfer area make that type of temperature control very slow to respond to changes. In such situations, an internal heat exchanger is fitted.
A cycle, in plain steps, runs as follows: fill the vessel with the packaged food or the bulk food, remove the air, pump in the pressure transmitting medium until the set pressure is reached, hold at that pressure for the set time, release the pressure, and unload. The book does not give a single fill time or a single release time for all vessels, so this unit gives none. The hold times it does give are the treatment times in the sections above and in Table 2.1 below, such as 400 MPa for 5 minutes and 350 MPa for 30 minutes for a ten-fold reduction in vegetative cells.
One high pressure cycle: fill, pressurise, hold, release
Load the packaged food or bulk food
Remove all air from the vessel
↓
Pump water or oil in with a pressure intensifier
Indirect compression, to the set pressure
↓
Hold at pressure for the set time
For example 400 MPa for 5 minutes
↓
Release the pressure rapidly
Unload the treated food
No heating or cooling period is needed in the cycle. The pressure rises and falls rapidly.
Figure 2.2: One high pressure processing cycle. Drawn from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Section 9.2.2.
Quick check
In indirect compression, what is pumped into the vessel, and what does it do?
Check your answer
A pressure transmitting medium, either water or oil, is pumped from a reservoir into the vessel using a pressure intensifier until the desired pressure is reached.
2.6 Batch and semi-continuous: two ways to run the vessel
Batch presses are available, having vessels of up to 9400 l capacity, which can operate at pressures of 200-500 MPa with operating cycles of as little as two to three minutes. Palou and co-workers report a batch press having a throughput of 600 l per hour, operating at 420 MPa, which is used for the commercial production of pineapple juice in Japan.
There are two methods of processing foods in high pressure vessels: in-container processing and bulk processing. Because foods reduce in volume at the very high pressures used in processing, for example water reduces in volume by approximately 15% at 600 MPa, there is considerable stress and distortion to the package and the seal when in-container processing is used. It is likely that conventional plastic and foil pouches will prove suitable, and research is continuing on the optimum design of the package, seal integrity and other suitable packaging materials. Materials handling for in-container processing is achieved using automatic equipment, similar to that used to load and unload batch retorts. Bulk handling is simpler, requiring only pumps, pipes and valves.
Semi-continuous processing of fruit juices at 4000-6000 l per hour, using pressures of 400-500 MPa for 1-5 min at ambient temperature, is used by one company in Japan, whereas another uses a similar process operating at 120-400 MPa followed by a short heat treatment before the juice is packaged. The process is highly energy efficient, although at present the capital costs of equipment remain high. It is possible that such liquid foods could also be used as the pressurising fluid by direct pumping with high pressure pumps. Such systems would reduce the capital cost of a pressure vessel and simplify materials handling. If liquids were also rapidly decompressed through a small orifice, the high velocity and turbulent flow would increase the shearing forces on micro-organisms and thus increase their rate of destruction.
Table 2.1: In-container and bulk high pressure processing compared (Fellows Table 9.4)
| In-container processing | Bulk processing | |
|---|---|---|
| Advantages | Applicable to all solid and liquid foods; minimal risk of post-processing contamination; no major developments needed for high pressure processing; easier cleaning | Simple materials handling; greater flexibility in choice of container; maximum efficiency, over 90%, in use of high pressure vessel volume; minimum vessel dead-time, with no opening or closing of the vessel needed and faster loading and unloading |
| Limitations | Complex materials handling; little flexibility in choice of container; greater dead-time in use of pressure vessel | Only suitable for pumpable foods; aseptic filling of containers required, with potential post-processing contamination; all pressure components in contact with food must have aseptic design and be suitable for cleaning-in-place and sterilising-in-place |
Table 2.1: Advantages and limitations of in-container and bulk high pressure processing. Adapted from Mertens (1995), in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Table 9.4.
Batch or bulk: the choice a maker faces
Food is packed first, then pressurised in its pack
All solid and liquid foods
Minimal risk of contamination after treatment
Pack must survive squeezing: water shrinks about 15% at 600 MPa
Liquid food is pressurised, then filled aseptically
Only pumpable foods
Simple handling with pumps, pipes and valves
Aseptic filling is required, with a risk of contamination after treatment
In-container keeps the pack sealed. Bulk is faster to load and unload, but the filling step must stay sterile.
Figure 2.3: In-container and bulk high pressure processing compared. Drawn from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Section 9.2.2 and Table 9.4.
Quick check
A maker wants to pressure treat a solid food that cannot be pumped. Which method must be used, and why?
Check your answer
In-container processing, because bulk processing is only suitable for pumpable foods, while in-container processing is applicable to all solid and liquid foods.
2.7 Which foods use it, and what the book actually names
The foods named in the extracts for high pressure processing are listed below, with the wording kept close to the book. The task outline for this subject also lists guacamole, but guacamole does not appear in the Fellows extracts used for this unit, so it is not listed here as a book fact. That gap is stated plainly, so a reader does not mistake an outline list for a book list.
From the history and the applications in the extracts: milk, fruit juice, meat and a variety of fruits in the 1899 tests; apple, kiwi, strawberry and raspberry jams, bulk orange juice and grapefruit juice, fruit jellies, sauces, fruit yoghurts and salad dressings in the first commercial products in Japan; pineapple juice in the batch press example and in the pulsed pressure example; satsuma mandarin juice, minced beef muscle and fresh cut pineapple in Table 2.2 below; salted raw squid and fish sausages as commercially produced products; and, as other possible applications, seafoods, dairy products such as unpasteurised milk and mould ripened cheese, honey and other viscous liquids, and tempering chocolate.
Table 9.2 in Fellows gives the commercial applications in broader groups: pasteurisation and sterilisation of fruit products, sauces, pickles, yoghurts and salad dressings; pasteurisation of meats and vegetables; and decontamination of high risk or high value heat sensitive ingredients, including shellfish, flavourings and vitamins. Meats and seafood are therefore supported by the extracts, in those words. Juices are supported in many places. Guacamole is not named, and no pressure, time or shelf life is given for it in these extracts.
Table 2.2: Effect of high pressure treatments on selected micro-organisms (Fellows Table 9.5)
| Micro-organism | Pressure (MPa) | Time (min) | Decimal reduction | Media |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Saccharomyces cerevisiae | 300 | 5 | 5 | Satsuma mandarin juice |
| Aspergillus awamori | 300 | 5 | 5 | Satsuma mandarin juice |
| Listeria innocua | 360 | 1 | 5 | Minced beef muscle |
| Listeria monocytogenes | 350 | 4 | 10 | Phosphate buffer saline |
| Vibrio parahaemolyticus | 172 | 2.5 | 10 | Phosphate buffer saline |
| Salmonella typhimurium | 345 | 1.8 | 10 | Phosphate buffer |
| Total plate count | 340 | 1.9 | 5 | Fresh cut pineapple |
Table 2.2: Effect of high pressure treatments on selected micro-organisms. Adapted from Palou et al. (1999), in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Table 9.5. Decimal reduction is the number of ten-fold reductions in the count.
Quick check
From Table 2.2, which micro-organism was treated at the lowest pressure listed, and in what media?
Check your answer
Vibrio parahaemolyticus, at 172 MPa for 2.5 minutes, with a decimal reduction of 10, in phosphate buffer saline.
2.8 What it does and does not do to quality
Table 9.2 lists the advantages of high pressure processing as follows: it kills vegetative bacteria, and spores at higher temperatures; there is no evidence of toxicity; colours, flavours and nutrients are preserved; processing times are reduced; treatment is uniform throughout the food; desirable texture changes are possible; in-package processing is possible; there is potential for reduction or elimination of chemical preservatives; and there is positive consumer appeal.
The same table lists the limitations: little effect on food enzyme activity; some microbial survival; expensive equipment; foods should have approximately 40% free water for anti-microbial effect; batch processing; limited packaging options; and regulatory issues to be resolved. The free water point matters: a very dry food, with little free water, is not a good candidate for pressure treatment on the book's terms. The extracts give no lower water figure for a named dry food, and no test result for a named dry product, so none is given here.
Quality changes in proteins and starches show both the benefit and the limit. In proteins, pressure causes unfolding of the molecular structure and then aggregation with either different proteins in a food or into a different form, resulting in changes to the texture of the food. Gel formation is observed in some proteins, such as soya, meat, fish and egg albumin. Compared to heat treated gels, pressure induced gels maintain their natural colour and flavour and are described as smooth, glossy and soft, and having greater elasticity. Those results are being evaluated in relation to surimi products on an experimental scale. Research is also being undertaken to unfold the structure of lower quality proteins using high pressures to improve their functional properties, such as emulsifying and gelling capacity.
Meat tenderisation is a further example. Processing at 103 MPa and 40-60°C for 2.5 min improves the eating quality of meat and reduces cooking losses. The extent of tenderisation depends on all three factors involved: pressure, temperature and holding time. Other possible applications are improved microbiological safety and elimination of cooked flavours from sterilised meats and pate.
Starch molecules are similarly opened and partially degraded, to produce increased sweetness and susceptibility to amylase activity. Other research has found that the appearance, odour, texture and taste of soybeans and rice did not change after processing, whereas root vegetables, including potato and sweet potato, became softer, more pliable, sweeter and more transparent. Fruit products are reported to retain the flavour, texture and colour of the fresh fruit. Other changes are described by Knorr, as cited in the book, and are not detailed in the extracts used here.
A further potential application is tempering chocolate, where high pressures transform cocoa butter into the stable crystal form. The extracts name that application, and they give no pressure, time or temperature for chocolate tempering, so none is given here.
Quick check
Name two advantages and two limitations of high pressure processing from Table 9.2.
Check your answer
Advantages include colours, flavours and nutrients preserved, and in-package processing possible. Limitations include little effect on food enzyme activity, and expensive equipment. Other correct pairs from the table are also acceptable.
2.9 Cost and limits: the factory view
Cost is the largest practical limit in the extracts. The equipment is specialised and expensive, and the 1996 comparison gives the scale: a high pressure fruit juice plant was twenty times the cost of an equivalent capacity plate heat exchanger system. Batch presses with vessels of up to 9400 l are available, and they can operate at 200-500 MPa with cycles of as little as two to three minutes, but the capital cost remains high even though the process itself is highly energy efficient.
The selling price tells the same story from the shop side. The first Japanese products sold at three to four times the cost of conventional products, and the higher quality, particularly flavour and texture of the fruit, had so far ensured sufficient demand for commercial viability. That is a book judgement at the time of writing, not a promise that the same price would hold for every food or every market. The extracts give no running cost per litre, no price for a named product in a named shop, and no payback time for a named plant, so none is given here.
Other limits are practical. Foods should have approximately 40% free water for anti-microbial effect. Packaging must survive a large volume change, with water reducing in volume by approximately 15% at 600 MPa, and research is continuing on the optimum design of the package and on seal integrity. Batch processing brings dead time in use of the vessel, while bulk processing brings a need for aseptic filling. Regulatory issues remain to be resolved, as listed in Table 9.2. Developments reported in the book include combined freeze concentration, pressure freezing and high pressure blanching, with initial results suggesting that pressure blanched fruits are dried more rapidly than those treated by conventional hot water blanching.
Try it yourself: Find a flexible plastic pouch in your kitchen, such as a juice pouch or a sealed sauce pouch, and a rigid plastic tub with a lid. Press the pouch gently in your hands and watch how it changes shape and springs back. Then press the lid of the rigid tub and note how little it gives. Now imagine both packs under 400 MPa, with the water inside shrinking by about 15% at 600 MPa: which pack is more likely to survive the squeeze without splitting or losing its seal, and why? Look at the seal of the pouch and the rim of the tub, and note what you see. That observation is the packaging problem of in-container processing, felt in your hands.
Key ideas to carry forward
- High pressure processing was first tested in 1899 at 658 MPa for 10 minutes, then stopped, then restarted in Japan in the late 1980s, with the first commercial jams and juices on sale by 1990.
- Pressure is isostatic: it is distributed instantly and uniformly through the food, whatever its size or shape.
- Moderately high pressures of 300-600 MPa kill vegetative cells, and typically 350 MPa for 30 min or 400 MPa for 5 min gives a ten-fold reduction in vegetative cells of bacteria, yeasts or moulds.
- Pressure collapses intracellular vacuoles and damages cell walls, cytoplasmic membranes and cellular enzymes, while leaving covalent bonds intact, so flavour and texture molecules are largely kept.
- Bacterial spores survive pressure alone: higher pressures cause germination, and germinated cells can be destroyed, for example at 600 MPa and 50-70°C, or at 400 MPa with moderate heating to 60°C, to different extents for different strains.
- Enzymes vary widely: some are inactivated by a few hundred MPa, others withstand 1000 MPa, and peroxidase in peas and pectin methyl esterase in strawberries can withstand 1200 MPa, so chilled storage is often needed.
- A cycle runs fill, pressurise, hold, release: air is removed, water or oil is pumped in by a pressure intensifier in indirect compression, the set pressure is held, then released.
- Vessels are high tensile steel alloy monoblocs for 400-600 MPa, with pre-stressed multi-layer or wire-wound vessels for higher pressures, and batch presses reach up to 9400 l at 200-500 MPa with cycles as short as two to three minutes.
- In-container processing suits all solid and liquid foods and keeps the pack sealed, but the pack must survive the volume change; bulk processing suits pumpable foods only, is simpler to handle, and needs aseptic filling.
- Semi-continuous juice processing runs at 4000-6000 l per hour at 400-500 MPa for 1-5 min at ambient temperature in the Japanese example given.
- Foods named in the extracts include juices, jams, fruit jellies, sauces, fruit yoghurts, salad dressings, meats, vegetables, shellfish, salted raw squid, fish sausages, unpasteurised milk, mould ripened cheese, honey and viscous liquids; guacamole is not named in these extracts.
- Quality is kept well for colour, flavour and nutrients, with smooth, glossy, soft pressure induced gels, tenderised meat at 103 MPa and 40-60°C for 2.5 min, and fruit that retains fresh flavour, texture and colour.
- Cost is the main limit: a 1996 juice plant cost twenty times an equivalent plate heat exchanger system, and the first products sold at three to four times the cost of conventional products.
Glossary
High pressure processing
A preservation method that applies very high pressure, up to 1000 MPa, to food in a vessel, to kill microbes without heating the food hard. Food tech example: orange juice treated at 400-500 MPa for 1-5 min in a semi-continuous plant in Japan.
Hydrostatic pressure
Pressure applied evenly through a liquid that surrounds the food, so the pressure reaches all parts of the food at once. Food tech example: a sealed jam pack submerged in water in a pressure vessel.
Isostatic
Pressure distributed instantly and uniformly throughout the food, so every part is treated the same. Food tech example: a large pack and a small pack of juice receiving the same pressure treatment.
Barosensitive
Sensitive to high pressure, used for microbes or enzymes that are damaged or killed by pressure. Food tech example: bacteria in the log phase of growth being more barosensitive than cells in the stationary phase.
Vegetative cell
A micro-organism in its active, growing form, as opposed to a spore. Food tech example: vegetative cells of bacteria, yeasts or moulds reduced ten-fold by 400 MPa for 5 min.
Spore
A resting form made by some bacteria, which resists pressure far better than the active cell and must germinate before it can be killed. Food tech example: a bacterial spore resisting germination near 0°C even at 1000 MPa.
Germination
The change of a spore back into an active, growing cell, which can then be killed by pressure or heat. Food tech example: pressure induced germination at 100 MPa at moderate temperatures.
Log phase
The stage of microbial growth when cells are dividing rapidly and are most sensitive to pressure. Food tech example: log phase bacteria being more barosensitive than stationary phase cells.
Decimal reduction
A ten-fold reduction in the number of micro-organisms, also called a 1D reduction. Food tech example: a decimal reduction of 5 for Saccharomyces cerevisiae in satsuma mandarin juice at 300 MPa for 5 min.
Pressure vessel
The strong steel container in which food is pressurised, with a closure that seals it. Food tech example: a high tensile steel alloy monobloc vessel that can withstand 400-600 MPa.
Monobloc
A pressure vessel forged from a single piece of high tensile steel alloy. Food tech example: a monobloc vessel used for pressures of 400-600 MPa.
Indirect compression
A method of pressurising in which a pressure transmitting medium, water or oil, is pumped into the vessel with a pressure intensifier. Food tech example: water pumped into a vessel until the set pressure is reached.
Direct compression
A method of pressurising that uses a piston to compress the vessel, which needs dynamic seals and is not used in commercial applications. Food tech example: a piston method described in the book but not used commercially because its seals wear.
In-container processing
Pressurising food after it has been packed, so the pack stays sealed through the treatment. Food tech example: a flexible sealed plastic pack of jam pressurised in its pack.
Bulk processing
Pressurising a pumpable food in bulk, then filling it aseptically into containers. Food tech example: fruit juice pressurised in bulk at 4000-6000 l per hour, then filled.
Free water
Water in a food that is free and available, as opposed to water bound to food components, needed for the anti-microbial effect of pressure. Food tech example: foods needing approximately 40% free water for anti-microbial effect under pressure.
Barosensitivity
How sensitive a microbe or an enzyme is to high pressure. Food tech example: polyphenoloxidase from potato being very pressure stable, while the same enzyme from apricot is more pressure sensitive.
Polyphenoloxidase
An enzyme that causes browning in fruit and vegetables and resists high pressure in many foods. Food tech example: polyphenoloxidase resisting up to 1200 MPa for 10 minutes before inactivation.
Pectinesterase
An enzyme that causes cloud loss in juices, gelation of fruit concentrates and loss of consistency in tomato products. Food tech example: pectinesterase activity decreasing above 300 MPa and being inactivated above 700 MPa at 45°C for 10 minutes.
Pressure induced gel
A gel formed by pressure unfolding proteins, which keeps natural colour and flavour and is smooth, glossy and soft. Food tech example: a pressure induced gel from soya, meat, fish or egg albumin, compared with a heat treated gel.
References
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, Woodhead Publishing. Chapter 9, Processing using electric fields, high hydrostatic pressure, light or ultrasound, Section 9.2, High pressure processing, including Table 9.2, Table 9.4 and Table 9.5.
- Hoover, D. G., Metrick, C., Papineau, A. M., Farkas, D. F. and Knorr, D. (1989), as cited in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, for the ten-fold reduction at 350 MPa for 30 min or 400 MPa for 5 min.
- Manvell, C. (1996), as cited in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, for the cost of a high pressure fruit juice plant compared with a plate heat exchanger system.
- Mertens, B. (1995), as cited in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, for pressure vessel design and for Table 9.4 on in-container and bulk processing.
- Palou, E., Lopez-Malo, A., Barbosa-Canovas, G. V. and Swanson, B. G. (1999), as cited in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, for the batch press throughput and for Table 9.5.
- Mermelstein, N. H. (1997), as cited in Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, for similar products reaching the United States market.
Unit 3: Electric Methods: Pulsed Electric Fields, Ohmic Heating, and Microwaves
Note
Unit 3: Electric Methods: Pulsed Electric Fields, Ohmic Heating, and Microwaves
A glass of orange juice is pasteurised without being boiled, a soup full of carrot cubes is sterilised in seconds with the cubes still firm, and a plate of pasta is dried in 90 minutes instead of 8 hours. No flame touches any of them. The work is done by electricity, in three very different ways. This unit looks at each one: short electric pulses that punch holes in microbes, a current that turns the food itself into a heater, and microwaves that heat water from the inside out.
Questions to think about
- How can an electric pulse kill a microbe without cooking the juice around it?
- If a food is the heater, what decides whether it heats fast or slowly?
- Why does a microwave heat the wet parts of a food and leave the dry parts alone?
- Why does a soup with chunks suit ohmic heating, while a juice suits pulsed electric fields?
- What can none of these three methods do on its own?
3.1 Three ways to use electricity in food
Unit 1 set out the problem: heat preserves food well, but heat also changes flavour, colour, texture and nutrients. The methods in this unit all use electricity, yet they are not one method. They differ in what the electricity does, and that difference decides which food each one suits.
Pulsed electric field processing, often shortened to PEF or HIPEF, sends very short, very strong electric pulses through a liquid food. The pulses damage microbes directly. The food stays near room temperature, so flavour and colour are kept.
Ohmic heating passes an alternating electric current through the food. The food resists the current, and that resistance turns the electric energy into heat inside the food itself. The food heats through its whole volume at once, which is why it suits foods with solid pieces in a liquid.
Microwave and radio frequency heating send electromagnetic waves into the food. The electric field of the waves interacts with water molecules and ions, and the interaction makes heat inside the food. Like ohmic heating, it heats volumetrically, but the waves only reach a finite depth into the food, and the heating is uneven.
One point runs through all three methods: the electrical properties of the food decide how well the method works. A juice, a soup and a dry biscuit behave very differently under the same electric treatment, and the books return to that point again and again.
Quick check
Name the three electric methods in this unit and, in one line each, say what the electricity does in each one.
Check your answer
Pulsed electric fields: short high voltage pulses damage microbes in a liquid food. Ohmic heating: an electric current passes through the food and its resistance turns the energy into heat inside the food. Microwaves and radio frequency: electromagnetic waves interact with water molecules and ions and make heat inside the food.
3.2 Pulsed electric fields: short pulses that open holes in microbes
3.2.1 Where the idea came from
The story starts in the 1920s with a process called ElectroPure, used in the United States for more than twenty years to pasteurise milk. It used only low voltages, so it killed microbes by heat alone, and it is described in Fellows as a forerunner of ohmic heating. By the 1960s, researchers using higher voltages, 3000 to 4000 V, found that the electricity itself destroyed microbes more than heat alone could explain. Research in the 1980s and 1990s then extended the work to liquid foods, including fruit juices, soups, liquid egg and milk. A German company developed two processes on the same idea: ELSTERIL, for the electric sterilisation of pumpable conductive foods, and ELCRACK, which used similar pulsed field technology to disrupt vegetable and animal cells to help recover edible oils and fats.
Fellows is plain about the state of the method: HIPEF is not yet used on a commercial scale. Its low energy use and low processing temperatures, which give high retention of sensory characteristics and nutritional properties, point to good potential for high quality foods, but the method had not reached commercial use when the book was written.
3.2.2 How the pulses kill microbes
A pulsed electric field treatment applies an electric field of 12 to 35 kV/cm to a liquid food in a short pulse lasting 1 to 100 microseconds. Fellows states that the precise mechanisms are not well understood, but the likely mechanisms are these:
- Pores form in cell membranes when the applied field pushes the electrical potential of the membrane past its natural level of 1 V. The pores then cause swelling and rupturing of the cells. This pore formation is called electroporation.
- Electrolysis products, or highly reactive free radicals, are produced from components of the food by the electric arc, depending on the electrode material used and the chemical composition of the food.
- Induced oxidation and reduction reactions inside the cell structure disrupt metabolic processes.
- Heat is produced by the transformation of induced electric energy.
The kill is stronger at higher field intensities, and with more pulses or longer pulses. It is also affected by the temperature of the food, its pH, its ionic strength and its electrical conductivity. Studies in which foods were inoculated with target micro-organisms and treated by HIPEF reached cell reductions of up to six log cycles, a 6D reduction. Fellows adds a caution: because the lethal effect depends on the specific apparatus and operating conditions used by different researchers, it is difficult to draw direct comparisons between these findings.
What the pulses do not do matters as much as what they do. In general, vitamins and enzymes are not inactivated to any appreciable extent by HIPEF processing. Sitzmann reported a reduction in lipase activity in milk and a reduction in ascorbic acid content after HIPEF treatment, but the general picture is that enzymes survive. Other studies reported by Vega-Mercado and co-workers found that the flavour and colour of fruit juices was unaltered by processing. That is the attraction of the method, and also its limit: a treatment that leaves enzymes alone cannot be used where enzyme activity must be stopped.
3.2.3 The equipment
Typical HIPEF equipment has a high voltage power supply, capacitors to store the charge, a discharge switch to release the charge, and electrodes that pass an electric field through the product in a treatment chamber. Inductors are used to modify the shape and width of the pulse. The process is meant to run at ambient temperatures, but treatment can raise the product temperature depending on the field strength, the pulse frequency and the number of pulses, so the equipment is fitted with refrigeration coils to control the temperature.
Safety shapes the whole plant. The apparatus sits inside a restricted access area because of the risk to operators from the high voltages, and all connections to the chamber, including product pipework and refrigeration units, must be isolated and earthed to prevent leakage of energy.
Cost is a real barrier. Fellows gives the initial investment cost as $450,000 to $2,000,000, citing Vega-Mercado and co-workers (1999), and notes that this may limit widespread adoption of the process.
How a pulsed electric field plant works
Charges the capacitors
↓
Store the charge, then release it as a short pulse
↓
The pulse passes through the liquid food for 1 to 100 microseconds
↓
Hold the product near ambient temperature
The whole plant sits in a restricted access area, with all connections isolated and earthed.
Figure 3.1: Main components of a HIPEF plant. Drawn from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Figure 9.1, adapted from Sitzmann (1995).
3.2.4 Which foods suit PEF, and what it cannot do
PEF suits liquid foods, and only liquid foods, or particles in liquids. Fellows lists pasteurisation of fruit juices, soups, liquid egg and milk, accelerated thawing, and decontamination of heat sensitive foods. Its advantages, summarised in Table 9.2 of the book, are that it kills vegetative cells, preserves colours, flavours and nutrients, shows no evidence of toxicity, and has a relatively short treatment time.
Its limits are listed in the same table, and they are worth reading in full:
- It has no effect on enzymes and spores.
- It is difficult to use with conductive materials.
- It is only suitable for liquids or particles in liquids.
- It is only effective in combination with heat.
- Products of electrolysis may adversely affect foods.
- There are safety concerns in the local processing environment.
- Energy efficiency is not yet certain.
- Regulatory issues remain to be resolved.
- There may be problems with scaling up the process.
Two of these limits deserve attention. First, spores survive: PEF kills vegetative cells, not bacterial spores, so a spore forming organism in the food is not controlled by PEF alone. Second, enzymes survive too, so a juice treated by PEF alone can still change in storage through enzyme action, which is why Fellows lists combination with heat as a condition of effectiveness. The extracts do not describe air bubbles in the treatment chamber or their effect on the process, so no claim about bubbles is made here. The extracts also do not name electrode corrosion as a separate limit: what they name is electrolysis products that may adversely affect foods, and electrical design that must avoid electrolysis and product contamination.
Quick check
A fruit juice is treated by PEF and its flavour and colour are unchanged. Why might the juice still spoil in storage?
Check your answer
PEF kills vegetative cells but has no effect on enzymes and spores. Surviving enzymes can still change the juice, and surviving spores can still grow, so PEF alone does not give a stable product.
🤔 Pause and think: PEF keeps the fresh flavour of a juice because it hardly heats it. But a juice also needs its enzymes stopped and its spores controlled. If PEF cannot do either, what would you pair it with, and what would that pairing cost in the very freshness PEF was chosen to protect?
3.3 Ohmic heating: the food becomes the heater
3.3.1 The problem ohmic heating solves
Ordinary heat has to travel into a food. In a can, heat moves by conduction through a solid or a very viscous liquid, or by convection through a thinner liquid, and the outside of the food is overcooked long before the centre is safe. That is why canned food tastes different from fresh food. Continuous high temperature short time processes, UHT and HTST, improve this by heating fast: food is heated rapidly to 140 °C, held there for a short period, then cooled rapidly, and at 140 °C food can be sterilised in a few seconds rather than the several minutes needed at canning temperatures. This works well for single phase liquids such as milk, fruit juices, soups and sauces, heated in plate or tubular heat exchangers at heating rates above 1 °C per second.
It does not work well for foods with particles. Conduction heating needs a temperature difference between particles and liquid, and for particles larger than about 2 mm rapid heating is not feasible by conduction. Fryer and Davies put the consequence plainly: with very large particles, a very overprocessed liquid phase would result in the time required to make the particles sterile. Ohmic heating was developed to solve exactly this problem.
3.3.2 How ohmic heating works
Ohmic heating, also called resistance heating or electroheating, passes an alternating electric current through a food. Foods that contain water and ionic salts can conduct electricity, but they also have a resistance, and that resistance turns the power directly into heat. The food is an electrical component of the heater, so its electrical properties, its resistance, must be matched to the capacity of the heater.
The result is volumetric heating: heat is generated throughout the food at once, not conducted in from a hot surface. There are no hot surfaces, so there is no surface fouling or burning of the product, and cleaning is needed less often. There are no temperature gradients if the parts of the food have the same resistance, so solids and liquids heat at the same rate. Heat transfer coefficients do not limit the rate of heating. The food heats rapidly, at about 1 °C per second, and temperatures high enough for UHT processing can be reached. Energy conversion efficiencies are very high, above 90%, because nearly all of the energy enters the food as heat. That is also why ohmic heating is more efficient than microwave heating.
Two differences from microwaves matter. First, microwave and radio frequency heating have a finite depth of penetration into a food, while ohmic heating has no such limitation. Second, microwave heating needs no contact with the food, while ohmic heating needs electrodes in good contact with it. In practice the food should be liquid, or should have enough liquid with particulate foods to allow good contact and to pump the product through the heater.
3.3.3 Electrical conductivity decides everything
The electrical resistance of a food is the most important factor in deciding how quickly it will heat. Conductivity is measured with a multimeter connected to a conductivity cell, and the measured resistance is converted to conductivity from the length and the area of the cell. Conductivity measurements are therefore made in product formulation, process control and quality assurance for all foods heated electrically.
The range of values is wide. Fellows gives the electrical conductivity of selected foods at 19 °C in Table 18.2, and the pattern is clear: vegetables conduct less than muscle tissue, and muscle conducts much less than a sauce or gravy. Salt raises conductivity sharply, as the starch solution rows show.
Table 3.1: Electrical conductivity of selected foods at 19 °C
| Food | Electrical conductivity (S/m) |
|---|---|
| Potato | 0.037 |
| Carrot | 0.041 |
| Pea | 0.17 |
| Beef | 0.42 |
| Starch solution (5.5%) with 0.2% salt | 0.34 |
| Starch solution (5.5%) with 0.55% salt | 1.3 |
| Starch solution (5.5%) with 2% salt | 4.3 |
Table 3.1: Electrical conductivity of selected foods at 19 °C. From Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 18, Table 18.2, data from Kim and co-workers (1996).
The salt content of a gravy is typically 0.6 to 1%, and from the table the conductivity of beef is about a third of that of the gravy. That difference has practical consequences. In a two component food of liquid and particles, if the particles have a lower electrical resistance they are heated at a higher rate. That is impossible in conventional heating, where the low thermal conductivity of solid foods slows heat penetration to the centre of the pieces. Ohmic heating can therefore heat sterilise particulate foods under UHT conditions without heat damage to the liquid carrier and without overcooking the outside of the particles. If the two components have similar resistances, the lower moisture solid portion heats faster than the carrier liquid.
Conductivity is not a fixed number for a food. Unlike metals, where resistance increases with temperature, the electrical resistance of a food falls by a factor of 2 to 3 over a temperature rise of 120 °C. It can also vary in different directions, for example parallel to or across a cellular structure, and it can change if the structure changes, for example on gelatinisation of starch, cell rupture, or air removal after blanching. Fryer and Davies add that the shape of a particle and its orientation to the electric field also matter: the same particle can overheat the fluid around it or underheat, depending on how it sits in the field, and particles with a smaller aspect ratio, such as cubes, show less of this effect.
The heater itself must be designed around the product. The available three phase power sources in most countries give 220 to 240 volts per phase at a frequency of 50 Hz, and the geometry of the heater and the resistance of the product have to be carefully matched to make the best use of the power. If the resistance is too high, the current will be too low at maximum voltage. If the resistance is too low, the maximum limiting current will be reached at a low voltage and again the heating power will be too low. Every product has a critical current density, and if it is exceeded there is likely to be arcing, or flash over, in the heater. The design of the heater is tailored to products that have similar specific electrical resistances, and it cannot be used for other products without modification. That is the central limit of ohmic heating: one heater does not suit every food.
Heat penetration: conventional heating compared with ohmic heating
Heat travels in from the hot surface
Outside overcooks before the centre is safe
Slow in solids: thermal conductivity is low
Heat is generated through the whole piece at once
Centre and outside heat together
Particles up to 2.5 cm can be sterilised under UHT conditions
No hot surface, no temperature gradient, and no shearing of the particles.
Figure 3.2: Heat penetration into solid pieces of food by conventional heating and by ohmic heating. Drawn from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 18, Figure 18.5, adapted from Fryer (1995).
Quick check
A soup has beef pieces in a salty gravy. The beef has about a third of the conductivity of the gravy. Which part heats faster in an ohmic heater, and why does that help?
Check your answer
The beef pieces heat faster, because in a two component food the particles with the lower electrical resistance are heated at a higher rate. That helps because conventional heating is slowest at the centre of solid pieces, while ohmic heating lets the pieces keep up with, or pass, the liquid, so the liquid is not overcooked while the pieces catch up.
3.3.4 Equipment and applications
The concept of direct electric heating is not new: an electrical pasteurisation process ran successfully in the United States in the 1930s, and applications were found in fish processing. Early processes failed for practical reasons, and Fryer and Davies list the criteria a commercial process must meet: electrical design to avoid electrolysis and product contamination, effective control of food heating and flow rates, efficient aseptic packaging for a two phase mixture, and overall cost effectiveness. Early systems failed because they used a direct current supply, which leads to electrolysis, or packages containing expensive electrode material, and because efficient packing plant was absent.
The modern commercial system was developed by APV Baker, using a licensed design by EA Technology, and it is now in commercial use in Europe, the United States and Japan. Commercial scale systems are available with power outputs of 75 and 300 kW, corresponding to product capacities of about 750 and 3000 kg/h. The system has heat, hold and cool sections. Food passes from a product pump into a vertical or near vertical pipe containing a series of electrodes between which current flows. Enough pressure is maintained to stop the material boiling, up to 4 bar for sterilisation at 140 °C. One machine has seven electrodes, each live electrode surrounded by two earthed ones, and four electrode machines have also been produced, in which the outer two are earthed. Each electrode housing is machined from PTFE and holds a cylindrical cantilever electrode, supported only at one end, across the tube. The tubes are made in different lengths to keep similar impedances between each pair of electrodes, increasing in length from inlet to outlet as the electrical conductivity of the food rises with temperature. From the heater the material passes to a holding tube, which may be very short, and cooling is provided by water flowing on the outside of the cooling tube, or by precooled liquid pumped into the food.
The process was designed to sterilise foods of high solids fraction, up to about 60%, at heating rates in the region of 1 °C per second. Large particles, up to 25 mm in diameter, can be processed. Fellows lists the commercial uses as aseptic processing of high added value ready meals stored at ambient temperature, pasteurisation of particulate foods for hot filling, pre-heating products before canning, and high added value prepared meals distributed at chill temperatures. Fryer and Davies list the same applications, adding pasteurisation of particulate food products such as fruit pieces, and note that rapid pasteurisation of particles gives very high product quality.
Because there is no agitation in the heater, the integrity of particles is maintained, and liquids containing particles are not subject to the shearing forces found in scraped surface heat exchangers. Ohmic heating also suits viscous liquids, because heating is uniform and does not suffer the problems of poor convection in these materials. Its capital cost is lower than microwave heating, and it suits continuous processing.
How is the process proved safe? Fryer and Davies describe passing alginate beads impregnated with spores through the heater and measuring the loss of activity. That test shows the effect of the whole three step process, heating, holding and cooling, rather than the heater alone.
Quick check
Why can an ohmic heater built for one soup not simply be used for a different soup?
Check your answer
The food is an electrical component of the heater, so the heater geometry and the resistance of the product must be matched. A heater is tailored to products with similar specific electrical resistances and cannot be used for other products without modification.
3.4 Microwaves and radio frequency: heating water with waves
3.4.1 How microwaves make heat
Microwaves are part of the electromagnetic spectrum and are made of electric and magnetic fields. In microwave heating of food, the electric fields interact primarily with water molecules and ions in the food material, generating heat volumetrically. Datta, in the Irudayaraj volume, describes the system in three parts: the magnetron generates the microwave field, the waveguide is a metallic conduit that guides the electromagnetic field from the magnetron into a metallic enclosure called a cavity, such as the food compartment in a domestic microwave oven, where the food is placed, and the cavity, depending on its shape and size, forms standing waves of electromagnetic fields. When placed inside the cavity, the food experiences the electromagnetic fields that lead to its heating.
Two properties decide how a material interacts with microwaves: the dielectric constant, which is the material's ability to store electromagnetic energy, and the dielectric loss factor, which represents the energy dissipation, or heat generation. Air in the oven can absorb very little of the microwave energy, so only the food is heated directly by the electromagnetic waves. The shape, size and properties of the food greatly affect the spatial distribution of microwave absorption. Dielectric properties depend on composition, moisture and salt in particular, and on temperature.
Microwaves and radio frequency energy have no direct effect on micro-organisms, in contrast with ionising radiation, and all changes are caused by heat alone. That is a point worth holding onto: a microwave does not sterilise food by radiation damage, it sterilises it by heating it, only faster and from the inside.
3.4.2 Why heating is uneven, and what the extracts say about fixing it
The heat generated by microwaves is nonuniform, and it therefore creates temperature gradients, which in turn cause diffusion, flow and change in properties that alter the volumetric heat generation itself. The waves have a finite depth of penetration into a food, so the centre of a thick piece is heated less directly than the surface. Fellows notes the same unevenness as a general problem: microwave and dielectric heating suffer from variation in loss factors across the food, unlike high pressure processing, which treats the food evenly throughout.
The extracts describe two features that help with unevenness in factory systems. First, the radiation selectively heats moist areas while leaving dry areas unaffected, so moisture levels even out by themselves as only the moist areas are heated. In baking, Fellows lists close control of final moisture contents, typically within 2%, and automatic levelling of moisture contents for this reason. Second, in the microwave pasteurisation systems described by Brody, the packs pass through an equilibration stage after heating, where the slowest heating parts of the packs reach 80 to 85 °C within 10 minutes, so the coldest parts catch up before cooling.
What the extracts do not give is a list of domestic fixes. They do not describe a turntable, stirring during heating, or a standing time after heating, and they give no number for the depth of penetration of microwaves into any food. Those points are therefore stated here as gaps in the extracts, not as facts from them. The extracts also give no microwave frequency values, so no frequency is quoted in this unit.
How a microwave oven heats food
Generates the microwave field
↓
Metallic conduit that guides the field into the cavity
↓
Metal enclosure where standing waves form and the food sits
↓
Electric field interacts with water molecules and ions, making heat inside the food
Air absorbs very little microwave energy, so only the food is heated directly.
Figure 3.3: The three major components of a microwave heating system and how the energy reaches the food. Drawn from Datta, in Irudayaraj (ed.), Food Processing Operations, Chapter "Mathematical Modeling of Microwave Processing of Foods".
3.4.3 What microwaves are used for
Microwaves overcome the barrier to heat transfer caused by low thermal conductivity. That prevents damage to the surface, improves moisture transfer during the later stages of drying, and eliminates case hardening. It is not necessary to heat large volumes of air, and oxidation by atmospheric oxygen is minimised. The higher cost of microwave and radio frequency units, together with the smaller scale of operation compared with traditional methods of dehydration, restricts microwave drying to finishing, removing the final moisture from partly dried or low moisture foods.
The pasta drying example in Fellows shows what finishing can do. Fresh pasta is pre-dried in hot air to 18% moisture and then dried in a combined hot air and microwave drier to lower the moisture content to 13%. Drying times fall from 8 hours to 90 minutes, bacterial counts are 15 times lower, energy consumption falls by 20 to 25%, the drying tunnel shortens from 36 to 48 m to 8 m, clean up time falls from 24 to 6 person-hours, and there is no case hardening. In grain finish drying, microwaves are cheaper, more energy efficient and quieter than conventional methods, do not cause dust pollution, and the lower drying temperature improves grain germination rates.
Microwave freeze drying supplies heat directly to the ice front, which overcomes the slow heat transfer that limits conventional freeze drying. Careful control is needed to prevent localised melting of the ice: any water produced in the drying food heats rapidly, owing to the higher loss factor, and causes a chain reaction leading to widespread melting and an end to sublimation.
In baking, radio frequency or microwave finishing suits thin products such as breakfast cereals, baby foods, biscuits, crackers, crispbread and sponge cake. Conventional ovens work well while products have high moisture contents, but thermal conductivity falls as baking proceeds, and much time is needed to bake the centre adequately without excessive changes to the surface colour. Radio frequency or microwave heaters at the exit of tunnel ovens reduce the moisture content and complete the baking without further changes in colour. This reduces baking times by up to 30% and increases throughput. Meat pies, which need a good crust colour as well as pasteurisation of the filling, can be baked in about one third of the time required in a conventional oven by radio frequency heating. Other advantages listed by Fellows are increases in production by up to 50%, savings in energy, space and labour costs, separate control over baking and drying stages, which allows separate control over internal and external product colour and moisture content, improved product texture and elimination of centre bone, dense dough in the centre of cookies, and improved taste, as flavours are subjected to shorter periods at high temperatures.
Blanching by microwaves has been extensively investigated, but the higher costs compared with steam blanching have prevented its use for relatively low value vegetables. Microwave blanching of products that are more difficult to blanch by conventional methods is under development but may be limited by high capital investment. Studies of combined steam and microwave blanching are reported to reduce blanching time.
Pasteurisation of packed complete pasta meals, soft bakery goods and peeled potatoes by microwaves is reported by Brody. Most systems developed so far pack the products in flat packages, heat them in tunnel conveyors up to 25 m long using a combination of microwaves and hot air at 70 to 90 °C, then pass them through an equilibration stage where the slowest heating parts of the packs reach 80 to 85 °C within 10 minutes. The packs are then cooled to 1 to 2 °C and have a shelf life of approximately 40 days at 8 °C. Fellows also reports a procedure for the microwave pasteurisation of fruit juices, to inactivate pectinesterase, and for fruits in syrup.
Sterilisation by microwaves is achieved in laminated pouches made from polypropylene/EVOH or PVDC/polypropylene in the Multitherm process. The pouches, which are transparent to microwaves, are formed and filled from a continuous reel of film but are not separated, producing a chain of pouches that passes through a continuous hydrostat system. The pouches are submerged in a medium that has a higher dielectric constant than the product, and heating is by microwaves instead of steam. In a system described by Stenstrom, the product passes through seven liquid baths heated at up to 90 °C, and the final sterilising temperature reaches more than 130 °C before cooling. Both sterilisation and pasteurisation using microwaves have yet to be widely used in the food industry, but they have the potential to become increasingly important.
Other commercial uses show the range of the method. Compared with conventional cooking, microwave rendering of fats improves the colour, reduces fines by 95% and costs by 30%, and does not cause unpleasant odours. Microwave frying is not successful when deep baths of oil are used, but can be used with shallow trays in which the food is heated rapidly, and there is less deterioration in oil quality. Doughnuts are cooked without oil using microwaves, which reduces processing times by 20% and increases product yield by 25%. Other commercial microwave cooking applications include bacon and meat patties for the fast food industry, and skinless frankfurters and other sausage products made by setting meat emulsions in microwave transparent moulds.
3.4.4 What microwaves do to nutrients
Because microwave heating is fast, the food spends less time hot for a given level of microbial or enzyme destruction, and that can protect heat sensitive nutrients. The clearest evidence in Fellows is for carrots: there is no loss of carotene in microwave blanched carrots, compared with 28% loss by steam blanching and 45% loss by water blanching, citing von Loesecke (1942). Fellows adds a caution that the results for some foods are highly variable, and for these foods microwave heating offers no nutritional advantage over steaming. The nutrient gain is real in the carrot case, but it is not a general promise.
Quick check
Why is there no loss of carotene in microwave blanched carrots when steam blanching loses 28% and water blanching loses 45%?
Check your answer
Microwave heating is fast, so the carrots spend less time hot for the same level of enzyme destruction, and no water leaches the carotene out. Steam blanching loses 28% and water blanching loses 45%, and Fellows notes the result varies by food, so microwaves do not always beat steaming.
3.5 Comparing the three methods
The three methods are not rivals for the same job. Each one is best for a different kind of food, and each one fails at something another does well.
Table 3.2: The three electric methods compared
| Point | Pulsed electric fields | Ohmic heating | Microwaves and radio frequency |
|---|---|---|---|
| What the electricity does | Short pulses open pores in microbe membranes | Current through the food turns to heat inside it | Waves interact with H₂O and ions to make heat inside the food |
| Best for | Pumpable liquids: juices, soups, liquid egg, milk | Liquids with particles: ready meals, soups with chunks, fruit pieces | Finishing drying, baking finish, blanching, pasteurising flat packs |
| Heating | Near ambient temperature by design | Volumetric, about 1 °C per second, no depth limit | Volumetric but uneven, finite penetration depth |
| Kills | Vegetative cells only | Microbes by heat, including UHT sterilisation | Microbes by heat alone, no direct effect on them |
| Cannot do | Kill spores, inactivate enzymes, treat solids | Treat foods whose resistance does not match the heater; needs electrode contact | Heat evenly through thick foods; needs no contact but penetration is limited |
| Quality kept | Colour, flavour, nutrients preserved; enzymes survive | Particles stay whole, no surface burning, liquid not overcooked | Carotene kept in microwave blanched carrots; results vary by food |
| Main limit | Not commercial, high cost, regulation unresolved | Heater tailored to one product range; electrolysis must be avoided | Uneven heating, higher cost, smaller scale than conventional drying |
Table 3.2: Comparison of pulsed electric fields, ohmic heating, and microwave and radio frequency heating. Drawn from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapters 9 and 18, and Fryer and Davies and Datta in Irudayaraj (ed.), Food Processing Operations.
Read the table as a guide to choosing, not as a ranking. PEF is the only one of the three that is really non thermal: it kills microbes without heating the food, which is why it keeps fresh flavour, and also why it cannot finish the job alone. Ohmic heating is the only one that heats a thick mixture evenly through its whole volume with no depth limit, which is why it owns the particle problem, and also why it demands a heater built for one product. Microwaves are the most flexible in use, from drying pasta to finishing biscuits to pasteurising a flat pack meal, but they are also the most uneven, and the books are honest that their nutrient advantage varies from food to food.
The deeper lesson is the one from Unit 1: judge any new method by microbial kill, quality kept, cost, and safety approval. PEF scores well on quality and poorly on approval and scale. Ohmic heating scores well on kill and quality for particulate foods and poorly on flexibility. Microwaves score well on speed and range of uses and poorly on evenness and cost. None of the three is a replacement for heat in general. Each one is a tool for the foods whose properties fit it.
Quick check
A factory makes a chunky vegetable soup for hot filling and a fresh orange juice. Which method suits each product, and why not the other way round?
Check your answer
The soup suits ohmic heating, because ohmic heating heats particles and liquid together through the whole volume and handles pieces up to 2.5 cm. The juice suits PEF, because PEF treats pumpable liquids near ambient temperature and keeps fresh flavour and colour. PEF cannot treat the solid soup pieces, and ohmic heating would cook the juice rather than keeping it fresh.
3.6 Try it yourself
Try it yourself: Heat a plate of leftover rice in a microwave, then look at it before you stir it. Look for steam rising more strongly from some parts than others, and look for patches that look dry and hot beside patches that look damp and cool. Spoon a little from the centre and a little from the edge and feel the difference in warmth between them. That patchiness is the uneven heating the books describe: the waves interact with water and ions, the shape and size of the food change where the energy is absorbed, and the heating is nonuniform. Now stir the rice well, spread it flat, and heat it again briefly. Stirring and spreading move the wet and dry parts around so the heat evens out. What you have just done with a spoon is the same job the factory equilibration stage does for a pasteurised pack: give the slowest heating parts time and movement to catch up.
Key ideas to carry forward
- PEF applies short pulses of 12 to 35 kV/cm for 1 to 100 microseconds to a liquid food, opening pores in microbe membranes, a process called electroporation.
- PEF kills vegetative cells and preserves colour, flavour and nutrients, but it has no effect on spores or enzymes, suits only liquids or particles in liquids, and is not yet used on a commercial scale.
- A HIPEF plant has a high voltage power supply, capacitors, a discharge switch, electrodes and a treatment chamber, with refrigeration coils and a restricted access area, at a cost of $450,000 to $2,000,000.
- Ohmic heating passes an alternating current through the food, and the food's resistance turns the energy into heat throughout its whole volume, at about 1 °C per second and above 90% energy conversion efficiency.
- Ohmic heating suits liquids with particles up to 2.5 cm, heats solids and liquids together, has no penetration depth limit, and needs electrodes in good contact with the food.
- Electrical conductivity decides ohmic heating: vegetables conduct less than muscle, muscle less than salty gravy, and salt raises conductivity sharply, as Table 3.1 shows.
- An ohmic heater is tailored to products with similar specific electrical resistances and cannot be used for other products without modification, and a critical current density must not be exceeded or arcing occurs.
- Microwaves heat by electric fields interacting with water molecules and ions, through a magnetron, a waveguide and a cavity, and the heating is volumetric but nonuniform with a finite penetration depth.
- Microwaves have no direct effect on micro-organisms: all changes are caused by heat alone.
- Microwave blanching keeps carotene in carrots with no loss, against 28% loss by steam blanching and 45% by water blanching, but the nutrient advantage varies by food.
- Microwave uses in the books include finishing drying, baking finishing, blanching, pasteurisation of flat packs with a shelf life of about 40 days at 8 °C, and sterilisation in microwave transparent pouches above 130 °C.
- The extracts give no number for microwave penetration depth, no microwave frequencies, and no description of turntables, stirring or standing time as fixes for uneven heating.
Glossary
Electroporation
The formation of pores in a cell membrane when an applied electric field pushes the membrane potential past its natural level of 1 V, so the cell swells and ruptures. Food tech example: a pulsed electric field opens pores in the microbes in orange juice.
Pulsed electric field (PEF)
A treatment that sends very short, high voltage pulses through a liquid food to kill microbes without much heating. Food tech example: pasteurising fruit juice with pulses of 12 to 35 kV/cm lasting 1 to 100 microseconds.
Vegetative cell
A microbe in its normal growing state, as opposed to a spore. Food tech example: the vegetative cells in milk that PEF can kill, while spores survive.
Log reduction
A way of counting microbial kill in powers of ten: one log reduction leaves a tenth of the microbes, six log reductions leave a millionth. Food tech example: HIPEF studies reaching up to six log cycles of reduction in inoculated foods.
Ohmic heating
Heating by passing an alternating electric current through a food, so the food's own electrical resistance turns the energy into heat inside the food. Food tech example: sterilising a soup with carrot pieces up to 2.5 cm under UHT conditions.
Electrical conductivity
A measure of how easily a food carries an electric current, in Siemens per metre (S/m), set by its water, ions and salt. Food tech example: a salty gravy conducts about three times as well as the beef pieces in it.
Volumetric heating
Heating in which heat is generated through the whole volume of the food at once, rather than travelling in from a hot surface. Food tech example: ohmic heating warming the centre and the outside of a soup piece together.
Dielectric constant
A property of a material that describes its ability to store electromagnetic energy in a microwave field. Food tech example: water rich foods store microwave energy well, while dry areas store little and heat less.
Dielectric loss factor
A property of a material that describes how much of the microwave energy it turns into heat. Food tech example: moist parts of a food have a higher loss factor, so microwaves heat them and leave dry parts alone.
Penetration depth
How far microwave or radio frequency energy reaches into a food before it fades. Food tech example: microwaves have a finite penetration depth, which is why thick foods heat unevenly, while ohmic heating has no such limit.
Case hardening
A hard dry layer that forms on the surface of a food during drying and slows further drying. Food tech example: microwave finish drying of pasta avoids case hardening by heating the moist inside directly.
Equilibration stage
A holding step after microwave heating in which the slowest heating parts of a pack catch up in temperature before cooling. Food tech example: pasteurised pasta meal packs held until the slowest parts reach 80 to 85 °C within 10 minutes.
UHT
Ultra high temperature processing: heating food rapidly to a very high temperature, holding it briefly, then cooling it fast. Food tech example: ohmic heating reaching temperatures for UHT sterilisation of ready meals with particles.
Electrolysis
Chemical change caused by an electric current passing through a food or liquid, which can make products that harm the food. Food tech example: early ohmic systems using direct current caused electrolysis, so modern systems use alternating current and electrical design that avoids it.
Arcing
A spark or flash over inside a heater when the current density passes a critical level. Food tech example: an ohmic heater exceeding the critical current density for its product.
References
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, Woodhead Publishing. Chapter 9, Processing using electric fields, high hydrostatic pressure, light or ultrasound, and Chapter 18, Dielectric, ohmic and infrared heating.
- Irudayaraj, J. (ed.), Food Processing Operations: Modeling, Design and Analysis, Marcel Dekker. Chapter "Mathematical Modeling of Microwave Processing of Foods" by Ashim K. Datta, and chapter "Modeling Electrical Resistance (Ohmic) Heating of Foods" by Peter J. Fryer and Laurence J. Davies.
Unit 4: Sound, Light, and Cold Plasma: Treating Food Without Heat
Note
Unit 4: Sound, Light, and Cold Plasma: Treating Food Without Heat
A bat finds a moth in the dark with sound it cannot hear, a flash of white light leaves a loaf of bread safe on its surface for days longer, and a cold gas that is not hot at all can kill bacteria on a surface without burning it. None of these treatments cooks the food. Each one works in a different place, and each one stops at a different limit. This unit follows sound, light, and cold plasma, one group at a time, and asks where each one helps and where it does not.
Questions to think about
- How can sound that you cannot hear break a microbial cell?
- Why does a flash of light kill microbes on a smooth surface but leave some alive in a fold or a crack?
- Why is ultrasound on its own a poor way to preserve food, even though it can damage cells?
- What can cold plasma do, according to the verified sources, and what do those sources not yet tell us?
4.1 Three ways to treat food without cooking it
Heat is the oldest and strongest way to preserve food, but heat also changes flavour, colour, texture, and nutrients. The three groups in this unit try to avoid that cost. Ultrasound uses sound waves above hearing to shake, shear, and scrub. Pulsed light and ultraviolet light use light to treat a surface. Cold plasma uses a non-thermal plasma at atmospheric pressure to decontaminate surfaces and other materials.
Fellows lists ultrasound and high intensity light among the novel processes that may have uses for minimal processing of foods, in Table 9.1 of Chapter 9. The same chapter gives the advantages and limitations of pulsed light and ultrasound in Table 9.2, and those two tables are used through this unit. Cold plasma is not in the Fellows chapter extract. It comes from a separate research file, and only the facts that file verifies are used in sections 4.9 and 4.10.
The three groups share one pattern. Each one can damage microbes, each one works best in a narrow place, and each one needs to be judged the same way: how many microbes it kills, what it does to the food, and whether it can run in a factory. A method that works on a smooth plate in a laboratory may fail on a rough food surface, and a method that kills cells in water may need help from heat or another treatment before it can preserve a food.
Quick check
Name the three groups in this unit, and state in one line what each one uses.
Check your answer
Ultrasound uses sound waves above hearing. Pulsed light and ultraviolet light use light. Cold plasma uses a non-thermal plasma at atmospheric pressure.
4.2 Ultrasound: sound above hearing
Ultrasound waves are similar to sound waves but have a frequency that is above 16 kHz and cannot be detected by the human ear. In nature, bats and dolphins use low intensity ultrasound to locate prey, and some marine animals use high intensity pulses of ultrasound to stun their prey. In food processing, a similar division is made between low intensity and high intensity ultrasound.
Low intensity ultrasound, at less than 1 W cm-2, is used as a non-destructive analytical method to assess the composition, structure, or flow rate of foods. It measures without changing the food. High intensity ultrasound, at 10 to 1000 W cm-2, is used at higher frequencies, up to 2.5 MHz, to cause physical disruption of tissues, create emulsions, clean equipment, or promote chemical reactions such as oxidation. The preservation uses in this unit come from high intensity ultrasound, not from the low intensity measuring use.
When ultrasonic waves hit the surface of a material, they generate a force. If the force is perpendicular to the surface, it results in a compression wave that moves through the food, whereas if the force is parallel to the surface it produces a shearing wave. Both types of wave become attenuated as they move through the food, which means they lose strength as they travel. That loss of strength matters for preservation, because a wave that fades with distance cannot treat a deep or thick food evenly.
Ultrasound produces very rapid localised changes in pressure and temperature that cause shear disruption, cavitation, thinning of cell membranes, localised heating, and free radical production, which have a lethal effect on micro-organisms. Cavitation is the creation of bubbles in liquid foods, and it is the centre of the ultrasound story. Section 4.3 follows those bubbles step by step.
Quick check
What is the difference between low intensity and high intensity ultrasound in food processing, as Fellows draws it?
Check your answer
Low intensity ultrasound, at less than 1 W cm-2, is a non-destructive analytical method to assess composition, structure, or flow rate. High intensity ultrasound, at 10 to 1000 W cm-2, causes physical disruption of tissues, creates emulsions, cleans equipment, or promotes chemical reactions.
4.3 Cavitation: bubbles that form, grow, and collapse
Cavitation is the creation of bubbles in liquid foods by ultrasound. The bubbles form, grow, and collapse in the liquid as the pressure swings rapidly up and down. The collapse is the violent part. It sends out shear forces and rapid local changes in pressure and temperature around the bubble, and those forces can damage the structures near it.
That damage works on microbes in several ways at once. The shear disruption can tear at cell structures. The thinning of cell membranes weakens the boundary that holds a cell together. Localised heating raises the temperature in a tiny spot. Free radical production adds chemical damage. Fellows lists all of these together as the effects that have a lethal effect on micro-organisms, and the book does not rank one of them as the single cause. A reader should keep them together: cavitation kills by a mix of physical and chemical attack in a small place, not by one clean blow.
The same forces also act on food structures, and that is both a use and a limit. The shearing and compression effects of ultrasound cause denaturation of proteins that result in reduced enzyme activity, although short bursts of ultrasound may increase enzyme activity, possibly by breaking down large molecular structures and making the enzymes more accessible for reactions with substrates. The effects of ultrasound on meat proteins produce tenderisation in meat tissues after prolonged exposure, and the release of myofibrillar proteins that in meat products result in improved water binding capacity, tenderness, and cohesiveness. So ultrasound can soften meat and change protein behaviour, and those changes may be wanted in one product and unwanted in another.
Cavitation: what happens to a bubble in a liquid food
Pressure swings rapidly up and down
↓
Gas and vapour collect in the liquid
↓
Rapid local change in pressure and temperature
↓
Cell membranes thin, proteins denature, cells are damaged
The collapse is the working step. The damage is local, around the bubble, not even through a thick food.
Figure 4.1: Cavitation in a liquid food, from wave to bubble collapse to cell damage. Drawn from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, section 9.4.1.
The scrubbing idea follows from the same forces. When bubbles collapse near a surface, the jets and shear can lift material off that surface, which is why ultrasound is used to clean equipment. The book describes ultrasound as a way to clean equipment, and the shear forces and rapidly changing pressures as effective in destroying microbial cells, especially when combined with other treatments. A bubble that can scrub a surface clean can also scrub microbes off a surface, but the book does not give a food surface cleaning time or a log reduction for that use, and none is given here.
Quick check
What is cavitation, and what happens when a cavitation bubble collapses?
Check your answer
Cavitation is the creation of bubbles in liquid foods by ultrasound. When a bubble collapses it causes very rapid localised changes in pressure and temperature, shear disruption, thinning of cell membranes, localised heating, and free radical production, which can damage and kill micro-organisms.
4.4 Why ultrasound alone does not preserve food
Despite the damage cavitation can do, Fellows is plain: it is unlikely that ultrasonication will be used by itself for food preservation. The reason is a balance of dose and damage. The resistance of most micro-organisms and enzymes to ultrasound is so high that the intensity of treatment needed to kill them would produce adverse changes to the texture and other physical properties of the food and substantially reduce its sensory characteristics. In plain terms, the dose that kills the microbes also spoils the food.
That is why the useful story of ultrasound is a story of combinations. The shear forces and rapidly changing pressures created by ultrasound waves are effective in destroying microbial cells, especially when combined with other treatments, including heating, pH modification, and chlorination. Ultrasound weakens the cell, and the second treatment finishes the job at a lower dose than it would need on its own.
Two combined names need care, because they sound alike and mean different combinations. Thermosonication is the combination of heat and ultrasound, and Fellows points to it as a possible minimal pasteurisation process that could reduce the intensity of conventional heat treatments and so improve the sensory characteristics and nutritional properties of foods made by traditional heat processes. Mano-Thermo-Sonication, shortened to MTS, is a combined heat and ultrasound treatment under pressure, described by Sala and others. The pressure is part of MTS, and the full name carries all three parts: mano for pressure, thermo for heat, and sonication for ultrasound.
The initial studies of MTS indicated that the lethality of MTS treatments was 6 to 30 times greater than that of a corresponding heat treatment at the same temperature, and was greater for yeasts than for bacterial spores. MTS effectiveness depended on the intensity, amplitude, and time of ultrasonication and the applied pressure. The death rate resulting from MTS is logarithmic, and is thus the same as for heat treatments. The book gives no single MTS temperature, pressure, time, or food in the extract, and no single recipe is given here: the 6 to 30 times figure is a range from the initial studies, not a setting to copy.
The likely reason for the gain is physical damage that makes heat work better. It is likely that ultrasound reduces the heat resistance of micro-organisms by physical damage to cell structures, caused by extreme pressure changes, and disruption of cellular protein molecules. This makes them more sensitive to denaturation by heat. Similar changes to protein structures in enzymes may partly explain the synergistic effect of ultrasound and heat on enzyme inactivation. The word likely matters here: the book presents this as the likely explanation, not as a settled mechanism, and this unit keeps that wording.
🤔 Pause and think: if ultrasound alone needs a dose that spoils the food, what does that tell you about every new preservation method? A method is not judged by whether it can kill a microbe in a test tube. It is judged by whether it can kill the microbe and leave the food worth eating, at a dose a factory can run.
Table 4.1: Ultrasound as a preservation method, from Fellows Table 9.2
| Point | What Fellows Table 9.2 says |
|---|---|
| Advantages | Effective against vegetative cells, spores, and enzymes; reduction of process times and temperatures; little adaptation required of existing processing plant; heat transfer increased; possible modification of food structure and texture; batch or continuous operation; effect on enzyme activity |
| Limitations | Complex mode of action; depth of penetration affected by solids and air in product; possible damage by free radicals; unwanted modification of food structure and texture; needs to be used in combination with another process, for example heating; potential problems with scaling up plant |
| Foods named | Any food that is heated |
Table 4.1: Advantages, limitations, and foods for ultrasound, from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Table 9.2.
Read the table with the text beside it. The table lists ultrasound as effective against vegetative cells, spores, and enzymes, and at the same time the text says the resistance of most micro-organisms and enzymes to ultrasound alone is so high that the needed intensity would spoil the food. Both statements come from the same chapter, and they fit together only if the table is read as the potential of ultrasound, often in combination, and the text is read as the limit of ultrasound on its own. That is the reading this unit follows.
4.5 Ultrasound in other jobs: drying, cleaning, and emulsions
Ultrasound does more in a food factory than attack microbes, and the other uses help explain why the equipment is already familiar. High intensity ultrasound is used to cause physical disruption of tissues, create emulsions, clean equipment, or promote chemical reactions such as oxidation. Those are separate jobs from preservation, and a plant that already uses ultrasound to clean or to make an emulsion may find it easier to add a combined preservation step than a plant starting from nothing, which is the point behind the Table 9.2 advantage of little adaptation required of existing processing plant.
One other use is acoustic drying. Rahman has reviewed research into the use of ultrasound to assist drying and diffusion. In some foods, for example gelatin, yeast, and orange powder, the rates of drying are increased by two to three times. This is thought to be due both to the creation of microscopic channels in solid foods by the oscillating compression waves, and by changing the pressure gradient at the air and liquid interface, which increases the rate of evaporation. Acoustic drying has the potential to be an important operation because heat sensitive foods can be dried more rapidly and at a lower temperature than in conventional hot air driers. Additionally, unlike high velocity air drying, the food is not blown about or damaged by acoustic drying. The book gives the two to three times figure for those named foods only, and it gives no drying temperature or time for any one food, so none is given here.
4.6 Pulsed light and ultraviolet light: light that treats a surface
The use of ultraviolet, or UV, light to destroy micro-organisms is well documented, particularly in relation to water purification, but also as bactericidal lamps used to prevent surface mould growth on bakery products, and for air purification. Details of the commercial uses of UV light are reviewed by Rahman. Pulsed light is a more recent development, and it builds on that older UV knowledge with a different kind of light source.
Pulsed light uses pulsed white light that has a similar spectrum to sunlight, and it was developed by a US company for the surface disinfection or sterilisation of foods and packaging materials. The information in this section and the next is based on an article by Dunn and others, describing the development of the technology. Processing using pulsed light is a more recent development that may have good potential for the surface treatment of foods and packaging materials or for water treatment.
The light itself is broad. Pulsed light contains a broad spectrum of white light, from UV wavelengths of 200 nm to infra-red wavelengths of 1000 nm, with peak emissions between 400 and 500 nm. This light is in the non-ionising part of the electromagnetic spectrum and, in contrast to irradiation, it does not cause ionisation of small molecules. Pulsed light has a similar spectrum to sunlight, except that it also contains some UV wavelengths that are filtered out of sunlight by the earth's atmosphere. The light is produced in short, high intensity pulses that are approximately 20,000 times the intensity of sunlight at sea level and last for a few hundred microseconds. The energy imparted by the light to the surface of a food or packaging material is measured as fluence and is often quoted in units of J cm-2.
The antimicrobial effects of light at UV wavelengths are due to absorption of the energy by highly conjugated double carbon bonds in proteins and nucleic acids, which disrupts cellular metabolism. That is the photochemical part of the story. The full kill, in pulsed light, also has a photothermal part, and section 4.7 separates the two.
The equipment is simple in outline. Electricity at normal mains voltage is used to charge capacitors, which then release the power within thousandths of a second to light an inert gas lamp. The intense burst of light in rapid pulses of tens per second is directed over the surface of the food or packaging material to be treated. As only a few pulses are needed for microbial destruction, this enables high product throughput rates to be achieved. The process is best suited to foods that have a smooth surface, and contain few fissures that could shield micro-organisms from the light. That last sentence is the limit of the whole method, and it returns in section 4.8.
4.7 How pulsed light kills, and what the tests showed
Pulsed light inactivates micro-organisms by a combination of photothermal and photochemical effects. The UV component of light has a photochemical effect, but as most of the energy is in the visual spectrum, the effect is mostly photothermal: that is, a large amount of energy is transferred rapidly to the surface of the food, raising the temperature of a thin surface layer sufficiently to destroy vegetative cells. The heat is in a thin surface layer, not through the food. That is why pulsed light is a surface treatment, and why it leaves the inside of the food largely unchanged.
The test results reported by Dunn and others are given here with their exact doses and counts, because the dose is the point. Studies using inoculated agar plates indicate that concentrations of 107 CFU per gram of Staphylococcus aureus are destroyed by two pulses of 0.75 J cm-2, giving a total fluence of 1.5 J cm-2. Other pathogenic bacteria, including Escherichia coli O157:H7, Listeria monocytogenes, Bacillus pumilus, and the mould Aspergillus niger, were each destroyed at concentrations of 105 CFU per gram using a single pulse of 0.5 to 1 J cm-2, and decimal reductions of 7 to 9 logs were achieved by using a few flashes at 1 J cm-2 per pulse. When water was treated with pulsed light, it was found that oocysts of Klebsiella and Cryptosporidium, which are not affected by chlorination or traditional UV treatments, were reduced by 6 to 7 logs per ml by either two pulses of 0.5 J cm-2 or a single pulse of 1 J cm-2. CFU means colony forming units.
Those numbers come from agar plates and water, which are smooth and clear. Foods give lower kills, and the book says why. When applied to foods, the shelf life of bread, cakes, pizza, and bagels, packaged in clear film, was extended to eleven days at room temperature after treatment by pulsed light. Shrimps had an extension of shelf life to seven days under refrigeration, and fresh meats had a 1 to 3 log reduction in total bacterial count, lactic, enteric, and Pseudomonas counts. Preliminary studies indicated that the pulsed light treatment had no effect on the sensory characteristics or nutritional quality of treated foods. The lower levels of microbial destruction on foods, compared to those in water or on the smooth surfaces of agar plates or packaging materials, is attributed to the presence of surface fissures and folds in foods that shield some of the micro-organisms from the light.
Quick check
A loaf of bread and a plate of agar are both treated with pulsed light. Which one is likely to show the higher microbial kill, and why?
Check your answer
The agar plate. It is smooth, so the light reaches the microbes. The bread has surface fissures and folds that shield some micro-organisms from the light, so the kill on foods is lower than on smooth surfaces or in water.
4.8 Where light works, and where it stops
Pulsed light suits foods and materials that present a smooth, open surface to the lamp. Fellows Table 9.2 names packaging materials, baked products, fresh fruit and vegetables, meats, seafood and cheeses, and surfaces, water, and air as examples of commercial uses and products. The bread, cakes, pizza, and bagels in section 4.7 fit that list: they are baked products, treated in clear film, with a surface the light can reach. Clear liquids and water also fit, because the light can pass through them and reach the microbes, and the water test in section 4.7 shows a high kill.
The limits are just as clear in Table 9.2. Pulsed light has only surface effects and is difficult to use with complex surfaces. It is not proven effective against spores. Possible adverse chemical effects, possible resistance in some micro-organisms, reliability of equipment to be established, and advantages over high intensity UV light to be established are all listed as limitations. The table also lists the advantages: medium cost, very rapid process, little or no changes to foods, low energy input, and suitable for dry foods.
Three practical rules follow from those lines. First, light cannot treat what it cannot see: a microbe in a shadow, a crack, a fold, or under another piece of food is shielded, and the treatment will miss it. Second, light cannot treat the inside of a food: it raises the temperature of a thin surface layer only, so a microbe deep inside a thick piece is untouched. Third, a claim that pulsed light kills spores is not proven in the Fellows extract, and this unit does not make that claim. A reader who needs spore control must look to another method, or to a combination, and must check the evidence for that combination before using it.
Pulsed light: what the lamp can reach, and what it cannot
Smooth surface of a baked product
Surface of packaging in clear film
Clear water and clear liquids
Open, flat surfaces
Microbes in a fissure, fold, or crack
Microbes in a shadow behind a ridge
Microbes deep inside a thick food
Spores, not proven effective
The lamp treats a surface. Anything shaded, folded, or buried stays untreated.
Figure 4.2: Pulsed light reach and its limits. Drawn from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, sections 9.3.2 and 9.3.3 and Table 9.2.
Ultraviolet light on its own has the same surface character. Its documented uses in the extract are water purification, bactericidal lamps to prevent surface mould growth on bakery products, and air purification. Those are all surface or clear medium uses, and the extract gives no dose, time, or log reduction for UV alone on a food. No such number is given here.
4.9 Cold plasma: what the verified sources actually say
Cold plasma is the newest group in this unit, and it is also the group with the thinnest verified evidence in the sources given for this unit. This section reports only what the research file verifies from Google Books, and section 4.10 states plainly what is not verified. Nothing in this section comes from general knowledge, and no number is added to fill a gap.
Non-thermal, or cold, plasmas at atmospheric pressure have recently found many breakthrough applications in biology, medicine, and food security. That sentence is the starting point, and its two qualifiers matter: the plasmas are non-thermal, which means cold, and they work at atmospheric pressure. The source for that statement is Machala, Hensel, and Akishev, editors, Plasma for Bio-Decontamination, Medicine and Food Security, Springer, 2012, a book of 479 pages.
The same book description states what plasmas can kill. Plasmas can efficiently kill bacteria, yeasts, moulds, spores, biofilms, and other hazardous microorganisms, including potential bio-terrorism agents. That is a broad kill list, and it includes spores and biofilms, which are two of the hardest targets in food preservation. The word efficiently is the book description's word, and this unit does not add a log reduction, a time, or a dose to it, because the research file found no such number in a readable Google Books page.
The same description states where plasmas can be used. They can be employed for bio-decontamination and sterilization of surfaces, medical instruments, water, air, food, even of living tissues without causing their damage. Food is named in that list, alongside surfaces, instruments, water, and air, and living tissue is named as a use without damage. The book is a selection of reviewed manuscripts from the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Plasma for bio-decontamination, medicine and food security, held in Jasna, Slovakia, 15 to 18 March 2011. It covers plasma applications in bio-decontamination, water chemistry, effects on cells, biofilm inactivation, UV sterilization, medicine, tissue treatment, wound healing, dentistry, and food security.
Cold plasma is also listed among the key novel technologies developed by the Novel Technologies for Food Processing group at the University of Lleida, Spain, led by Olga Martin-Belloso, alongside pulsed electric fields, intense pulsed light, modified atmosphere packaging, edible coatings, and nanostructured systems, for ready-to-eat, safe, and healthy products. That listing places cold plasma in the same family of novel technologies as the pulsed light in this unit, and it is the only food context the research file verifies for cold plasma: a named research group lists it among its key novel technologies, for ready-to-eat, safe, and healthy products.
Quick check
From the verified sources only, what can cold plasma kill, and what can it be used to decontaminate?
Check your answer
It can efficiently kill bacteria, yeasts, moulds, spores, biofilms, and other hazardous microorganisms. It can be used for bio-decontamination and sterilization of surfaces, medical instruments, water, air, food, and even living tissues without causing their damage.
4.10 What is not yet known about cold plasma, and what to check first
The research file is explicit about the gaps, and this unit keeps them explicit, because a gap stated plainly is safer than a gap filled by guesswork. No verified Google Books fact was found in that research pass for how cold plasma is made: no feed gas, no voltage, no frequency, and no reactor type was stated in the text visible on Google Books. The Machala book description says the plasmas are non-thermal, cold, plasmas at atmospheric pressure, but it does not state those making details in the visible text.
No verified Google Books fact was found for how cold plasma kills microbes beyond the kill list in section 4.9. The reactive species, UV, charged particle, and electric field mechanisms were not stated in the readable Google Books text retrieved, and this unit does not report a mechanism from memory or from other pages. No food list, no treatment time, no log reduction, and no quality effect was visible in a readable Google Books page. The Machala description says food is one use, without naming a food. No approval status was verified either: a search for cold plasma food regulatory approval, FDA, EFSA, and novel food returned no Google Books page stating an approval status, and this unit does not report an approval claim.
Two dedicated cold plasma food books were seen in a general web search, Advances in Cold Plasma Applications for Food Safety and Preservation, and Cold Plasma in Food and Agriculture, but site searches on Google Books returned no results for them in that pass, so no facts from them are reported here. A reader who wants to use cold plasma should check, before any use, in this order: first, a readable copy of Machala and others, 2012, for the detail inside its chapters, with the page recorded for every fact taken; second, a readable Google Books copy of a dedicated cold plasma food book, if one is available then, for foods, times, and effects, with page numbers; third, the current approval status from the food regulator that covers the place where the food will be sold, because the research file verifies no approval at all. Until those checks are done, cold plasma in this unit is a verified promise, not a verified process: the kill list and the uses are verified, and the making, the mechanism, the foods, the times, the quality effects, the limits, and the approval are not.
Table 4.2: The three groups side by side, from the sources in this unit
| Group | What it uses | Where it works | Main limit in the sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ultrasound | Sound above 16 kHz, cavitation bubbles | Liquids, surfaces, and foods that are heated, in combination | Alone, the dose that kills microbes spoils the food; needs a partner such as heat |
| Pulsed light and UV | White light, 200 nm to 1000 nm, peak 400 to 500 nm; UV light | Smooth surfaces, packaging, clear water, baked products | Surface only; shadows, fissures, and folds shield microbes; not proven against spores |
| Cold plasma | Non-thermal plasma at atmospheric pressure | Surfaces, instruments, water, air, food, living tissue, as listed in the book description | Making, mechanism, foods, times, quality effects, limits, and approval not verified in the sources given |
Table 4.2: Ultrasound, pulsed light and UV, and cold plasma compared. Drawn from Fellows, Food Processing Technology, Chapter 9, Table 9.2 and sections 9.3 and 9.4, and from Machala and others, 2012, as reported in the research file.
4.11 Judging a treatment that does not cook the food
The three groups look different, but the test for each one is the same, and it comes from the opening of Chapter 9. A new minimal process must be capable of operating in a factory environment and not just in a laboratory with highly qualified staff; it should ensure a financial benefit to the manufacturer; and it should be sufficiently flexible to accommodate a wide range of products, often having short production runs and brief product life cycles. Eating quality matters, but it is not enough on its own: the process must also run, pay, and adapt.
Apply that test to this unit. Ultrasound can run in batch or continuous operation, and needs little adaptation of existing plant, but it needs a partner treatment and it can change texture and structure in unwanted ways. Pulsed light is very rapid, medium cost, and low in energy input, with little or no change to foods, but it treats a surface only, and its equipment reliability and its advantage over high intensity UV light are still to be established. Cold plasma has a verified kill list and a verified list of uses, but its making, mechanism, foods, times, quality effects, limits, and approval are not verified in the sources given, so it cannot yet pass the factory test from those sources alone. A student who can state those three verdicts, with the evidence for each, has understood the unit.
Try it yourself: Take a slice of bread, a cracker, and a smooth plate. Shine a torch at a low angle across each surface in a dim room, and look at the shadows. The plate shows almost no shadow, the cracker shows small ridges and holes, and the bread shows folds, pores, and crumbs that cast shadows. Now imagine the torch is a pulsed light lamp: every shadow is a place the light cannot reach, and every microbe sitting in a shadow would be shielded. Write down, for each of the three surfaces, one place a microbe could hide from the light. That is the surface limit of pulsed light, seen with your own eyes, and it is the same reason the book gives lower kills on foods than on smooth agar plates or in clear water. Do not use a real pulsed light lamp or a UV lamp for this activity: the torch is enough, and the lesson is in the shadows.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Ultrasound is sound above 16 kHz. Low intensity ultrasound, below 1 W cm-2, measures foods without changing them. High intensity ultrasound, at 10 to 1000 W cm-2 and up to 2.5 MHz, disrupts tissues, makes emulsions, cleans equipment, and promotes chemical reactions.
- Cavitation is the creation of bubbles in liquid foods. When the bubbles collapse, rapid local changes in pressure and temperature, shear disruption, thinning of cell membranes, localised heating, and free radical production damage microbes.
- Ultrasound alone is unlikely to preserve food, because the intensity needed to kill microbes would spoil texture and sensory quality. Its useful form is in combination, with heat, pH change, or chlorination.
- Thermosonication is heat with ultrasound, and Mano-Thermo-Sonication, or MTS, is heat and ultrasound under pressure. MTS lethality in the initial studies was 6 to 30 times greater than heat alone at the same temperature, and greater for yeasts than for bacterial spores.
- Pulsed light is broad white light from 200 nm to 1000 nm, with peak emissions between 400 and 500 nm, in pulses about 20,000 times the intensity of sunlight, lasting a few hundred microseconds. Its energy is measured as fluence in J cm-2.
- Pulsed light kills by photothermal and photochemical effects, mostly photothermal, raising the temperature of a thin surface layer. On agar plates, 107 CFU per gram of Staphylococcus aureus was destroyed by two pulses of 0.75 J cm-2, and 7 to 9 log reductions were reached with a few flashes at 1 J cm-2 per pulse for the organisms named in section 4.7.
- Pulsed light suits smooth surfaces, packaging, clear water, and baked products. It is surface only, it is shielded by fissures and folds, and it is not proven effective against spores.
- Cold plasma, as verified, is non-thermal plasma at atmospheric pressure that can efficiently kill bacteria, yeasts, moulds, spores, biofilms, and other hazardous microorganisms, and can be used for bio-decontamination and sterilisation of surfaces, instruments, water, air, food, and living tissue without damage.
- For cold plasma, the gas, voltage, reactor type, kill mechanism, foods used, treatment times, quality effects, limits, and approval status were not verified in the sources given, and this unit states that plainly rather than filling the gaps.
- A new process must work in a factory, bring a financial benefit, and adapt to many products, not only kill microbes in a laboratory.
Glossary
Ultrasound
Sound waves with a frequency above 16 kHz, too high for the human ear to hear. Food tech example: high intensity ultrasound used to disrupt tissues or clean equipment in a food plant.
Cavitation
The creation of bubbles in a liquid food by ultrasound, followed by their growth and collapse. Food tech example: cavitation bubbles collapsing in a liquid food and damaging nearby microbial cells.
Thermosonication
A combined treatment of heat and ultrasound. Food tech example: thermosonication used as a minimal pasteurisation process to reduce the intensity of a conventional heat treatment.
Mano-Thermo-Sonication (MTS)
A combined heat and ultrasound treatment under pressure. Food tech example: MTS studied for its lethality, reported as 6 to 30 times greater than heat alone at the same temperature in the initial studies.
Pulsed light
Short, high intensity pulses of broad white light, from 200 nm to 1000 nm, used to disinfect or sterilise a surface. Food tech example: pulsed light treatment of bread, cakes, pizza, and bagels in clear film, extending shelf life to eleven days at room temperature.
Ultraviolet (UV) light
Light at UV wavelengths, used to destroy micro-organisms, notably in water purification and in bactericidal lamps. Food tech example: a bactericidal lamp used to prevent surface mould growth on bakery products.
Fluence
The energy imparted by pulsed light to the surface of a food or packaging material, often quoted in J cm-2. Food tech example: two pulses of 0.75 J cm-2 giving a total fluence of 1.5 J cm-2 in the Staphylococcus aureus test.
Photothermal effect
Killing by heat from light, where energy is transferred rapidly to a thin surface layer and raises its temperature enough to destroy vegetative cells. Food tech example: the main effect of pulsed light, because most of its energy is in the visual spectrum.
Photochemical effect
Killing by a chemical change from light, where UV energy is absorbed by double carbon bonds in proteins and nucleic acids and disrupts cellular metabolism. Food tech example: the UV component of pulsed light acting on proteins and nucleic acids in a microbial cell.
Cold plasma
Non-thermal plasma at atmospheric pressure, described in the verified source as able to kill bacteria, yeasts, moulds, spores, and biofilms. Food tech example: cold plasma listed among novel food technologies by the University of Lleida group, for ready-to-eat, safe, and healthy products.
Biofilm
A layer of micro-organisms growing together on a surface, named in the verified cold plasma source as one of the targets plasmas can kill. Food tech example: a biofilm on a food contact surface, listed with bacteria, yeasts, moulds, and spores in the Machala book description.
Vegetative cell
A micro-organism in its active, growing state, as distinct from a spore. Food tech example: vegetative cells destroyed when pulsed light raises the temperature of a thin surface layer.
Spore
A resting form of a micro-organism that resists treatments that kill vegetative cells. Food tech example: bacterial spores, for which MTS lethality was lower than for yeasts, and against which pulsed light is not proven effective.
Free radical
A highly reactive chemical species produced during ultrasound treatment, listed among the effects that damage micro-organisms. Food tech example: free radicals produced by cavitation, also listed as a possible cause of damage to food.
References
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, Woodhead Publishing. Chapter 9, Processing using electric fields, high hydrostatic pressure, light or ultrasound, sections 9.3, Processing using pulsed light, and 9.4, Processing using ultrasound, and Tables 9.1 and 9.2.
- Machala, Hensel and Akishev (eds.), Plasma for Bio-Decontamination, Medicine and Food Security, Springer, 2012.
Unit 5: Irradiation and Supercritical Carbon Dioxide
Note
Unit 5: Irradiation and Supercritical Carbon Dioxide
A bag of dried herbs sits on a shelf for months without going mouldy, a potato in a store stays firm without sprouting, and caffeine leaves coffee beans without the beans ever being boiled. None of these foods was cooked to make it happen. Two very different tools did the work: invisible radiation that breaks bonds inside microbes, and carbon dioxide squeezed until it behaves like a liquid and a gas at the same time. This unit looks at both tools, what each one can do, what it cannot do, and where the book gives no number at all.
Questions to think about
- How can radiation kill microbes in a sealed pack without making the food hot or radioactive?
- Why does the same treatment need a tiny dose for a potato and a much larger dose for a spice?
- Why is a dose that sterilises herbs not enough to sterilise meat?
- How can carbon dioxide, the gas in fizzy drinks, pull caffeine out of a coffee bean and leave no residue behind?
- If a food shows no visible change after treatment, how can anyone tell it was treated at all?
5.1 What ionising radiation is
Ionising radiation is radiation that can break chemical bonds when it is absorbed by a material. Fellows draws the line there: gamma rays and electrons are set apart from other forms of radiation by this ionising ability. The products of ionisation may be electrically charged, called ions, or neutral, called free radicals. These products then react further and cause changes in an irradiated material, known as radiolysis. It is these reactions that cause the destruction of micro-organisms, insects and parasites during food irradiation.
In foods that have a high moisture content, water is ionised by radiation. Electrons are expelled from water molecules and the chemical bonds break. The products then recombine to form hydrogen, hydrogen peroxide, hydrogen radicals, hydroxyl radicals and hydroperoxyl radicals. The radicals are extremely short lived, but they are sufficient to destroy bacterial cells. The book gives their lifetime as less than a very small fraction of a second, and it does not give a longer life for them in food: they act fast and they are gone.
A point the book makes plain is that similar radicals are also present in foods that have never been irradiated. They arise from the action of enzymes such as lipoxygenases and peroxidases, from the oxidation of fats and fatty acids, and from the degradation of fat soluble vitamins and pigments. Reactive oxygen and its derivatives are also produced in foods by peroxidases, xanthine oxidase and amino acid oxidase. Irradiation is therefore not the only source of these reactive products in food: ordinary enzyme action and ordinary fat oxidation make them too.
The presence of oxygen accelerates the damage to fats during irradiation, so meat is irradiated in vacuum packs. Fat soluble components and essential fatty acids are lost during irradiation, and some foods, for example dairy products, are unsuitable for irradiation because rancid off flavours develop. That limit is a property of the food, not of the machine: a fatty food and a dry spice do not respond to the same dose in the same way.
Quick check
What makes a ray ionising, and what does it make in wet food?
Check your answer
An ionising ray can break chemical bonds when it is absorbed. In wet food it ionises water, making ions and free radicals, including hydrogen, hydrogen peroxide, hydrogen radicals, hydroxyl radicals and hydroperoxyl radicals, which destroy bacterial cells.
5.2 The sources: gamma rays, electron beams and X-rays
Irradiation equipment consists of a high energy isotope source to produce gamma rays or, less commonly, a machine source to produce a high energy electron beam. Gamma radiation from cobalt-60, written ⁶⁰Co, or caesium-137, written ¹³⁷Cs, is used in most commercial plants. Cobalt-60 emits rays at two energies, 1.17 MeV and 1.33 MeV. The activity of the cobalt-60 or caesium-137 sources is rated at (222 to 370) x 10¹⁰ Bq per gram, or 10¹³ Bq per kilogram. This generates 15 kW per MCi, that is 15 kW per 3.7 x 10¹⁶ Bq. The residence time of the food is set by the dose required and the power output of the source.
An isotope source cannot be switched off, so it is shielded within a pool of water below the process area, to allow personnel to enter. In operation the source is raised, and packaged food is loaded onto automatic conveyors and transported through the radiation field in a circular path. The circular path makes maximum use of the emitted radiation and ensures a uniform dose. Isotope sources require a more complex materials handling system than machine sources.
Machine sources are electron accelerators. They consist of a heated cathode to supply electrons and an evacuated tube in which electrons are accelerated by a high voltage electrostatic field. Either the electrons are used directly on the food, or a suitable target material is bombarded to produce X-rays. The main advantages of machine sources are that they can be switched off, and that the electron beams can be directed over the packaged food to ensure an even dose distribution. Handling equipment is therefore relatively simple. The trade off is that machine sources are expensive and relatively inefficient in producing radiation.
Radiation is contained within the processing area by thick concrete walls and lead shielding. Openings in the shielding, for entry of products or personnel, must be carefully constructed to prevent leakage of radiation. A dose of 5 Gy is sufficient to kill an operator, so it is essential that even at the lowest commercial doses, 0.1 kGy, stringent safety procedures are in place to prevent the source from being raised when personnel are present and to prevent entry to the building during processing.
Cobalt-60 has a half life of 5.26 years and therefore requires the replacement of 12.3% of the activity each year to retain the rated output of the plant. Continuous processing is therefore desirable for economic operation of a plant with a continuously decaying source.
An isotope irradiation plant: the food travels in a circle around the source
Packaged food waits outside the shielded area
↓
Food enters through a shielded opening
↓
Source raised from its water pool, food moves in a circular path
↓
Treated food leaves through a shielded opening
↓
Treated food held apart from untreated food
The control room sits outside the shielding. The source stays under water until the chamber is clear.
Figure 5.1: An isotope irradiation plant, after Farrall (1976) as given in Fellows, Chapter 8, Figure 8.2. The circular conveyor path gives a uniform dose.
The book lists several advantages of the process as a whole: packaged and frozen foods may be treated, fresh foods may be preserved in a single operation and without the use of chemical preservatives, energy requirements are very low, changes in nutritional value are comparable with other methods of food preservation, and processing is automatically controlled and has low operating costs. The major disadvantage named is the high capital cost of irradiation plant.
Quick check
Why is an isotope source kept in a pool of water when it is not in use?
Check your answer
An isotope source cannot be switched off, so it is shielded within a pool of water below the process area to allow personnel to enter safely. It is raised only when the chamber is clear and processing starts.
5.3 Dose: the units, the measurement and the spread through a pack
The dose a food receives is the amount of energy it absorbs, and the book gives the units in a footnote to Chapter 8. A becquerel, Bq, is one disintegration per second. A curie, Ci, equals 3.7 x 10¹⁰ Bq. Half life is the time taken for the radioactivity of a sample to fall to half its initial value. An electron volt, eV, is a unit of energy of radiation, usually given as mega electron volts, MeV, and 1 eV equals 1.602 x 10⁻¹⁹ J. A gray, Gy, is the absorbed dose, where 1 Gy is the absorption of 1 J of energy per kilogram of food. Older units called rads were used before, where 1 rad equals 10⁻² J per kilogram, so 1 Gy equals 100 rads. In food work the dose is usually given in kilograys, kGy, where 1 kGy equals 1,000 Gy.
The dose is measured with dosimeters. Dosimeters are made from a number of materials, including photographic film, Perspex and cobalt glass. Polyvinylchloride, PVC, dosimeters are impregnated with a dye. Hydrogen chloride is released from the PVC by irradiation and it produces a qualitative or quantitative change in the colour of the dye to indicate the dose received. Dosimeters are placed at points throughout a package to determine the dose received.
Penetration of gamma radiation depends on the density of the food as well as the energy of the rays. Because radiation is absorbed as it passes through the food, the outer parts receive a higher dose than the inner parts. At a density of 1,000 kg per cubic metre, half of the rays are absorbed in 11 cm. Halving the density approximately doubles the depth of penetration. For a given food there is thus a limit on both the maximum dose permitted at the outer edge, called Dmax, due to either unacceptable organoleptic changes or legislation, and a minimum limit, called Dmin, to achieve the desired effects of microbial destruction.
The uniformity of dose distribution can be expressed as a ratio of Dmax to Dmin. For foods that are sensitive to radiation, such as chicken, this ratio should be as low as possible and not more than about 1.5. Other foods, for example onions, can tolerate a ratio of around 3 without unacceptable changes. The distribution of dose can be controlled by adjusting the thickness of the packed product and irradiating from both sides.
High energy electrons have a lower penetration than gamma rays and are not suitable for bulk foods. They are used for thin packages or for surface treatments. The selection of a radiation source therefore depends on the type of product and its density, the dimensions of the package and the reason for the treatment. The book gives no single penetration depth for electrons and no table of electron doses by food, so no number is given here for that choice.
The energy comparison in the book is for chicken pieces, and it shows why irradiation plus chilling is put forward as a low energy route. The figures are in kJ per kilogram: refrigerated for a few days of shelf life, 17,760; frozen and stored for 3 to 5 weeks, 46,600; canned, 20,180; irradiated and refrigerated for a few weeks of shelf life, 17,860. Irradiated and refrigerated chicken uses about the same energy as refrigerated chicken alone, and far less than frozen storage, while giving a few weeks of shelf life instead of a few days. The book gives this comparison for chicken pieces only: no energy figure is given for any other food in the extract, so none is claimed here.
5.4 How irradiation kills microbes
The reactive ions produced by irradiating foods injure or destroy micro-organisms immediately, by changing the structure of cell membranes and affecting metabolic enzyme activity. A more important effect, in the book's words, is on deoxyribonucleic acid, DNA, and ribonucleic acid, RNA, molecules in cell nuclei, which are required for growth and replication. The effects of irradiation only become apparent after a period of time, when the DNA double helix fails to unwind and the micro-organism cannot reproduce by cell division.
The rate of destruction of individual cells depends on the rate at which ions are produced and interact with the DNA, whereas the reduction in cell numbers depends on the total dose of radiation received. The sensitivity of micro-organisms to radiation is expressed as the D₁₀ value, the dose of radiation that reduces the microbial population to 10% of its initial value, by analogy with thermal destruction. In theory, a logarithmic reduction in microbial numbers with increasing dose is expected. In practice the rate of destruction is not linear with received dose, because the rate varies with microbial species, some bacterial species contain more than one molecule of DNA, and others are capable of repairing damaged DNA.
A simple guide given in the book is that the smaller and simpler the organism, the higher the dose of radiation that is needed to destroy it. Viruses are very resistant to irradiation and are unlikely to be affected by the dose levels used in commercial processing. Spore forming species, for example Clostridium botulinum and Bacillus cereus, and those that are able to repair damaged DNA rapidly, for example Deinococcus radiodurans, are more resistant than vegetative cells and non-spore forming bacteria. Insects and parasites such as tapeworms or trichinella require lower doses: Toxoplasma gondii is inactivated at doses of 0.25 kGy and Trichinella spiralis at 0.3 kGy.
Table 5.1: D values of important pathogens, from Fellows Table 8.3
| Pathogen | D value (kGy) | Temperature (degrees C) | Suspending medium |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. hydrophila | 0.14 to 0.19 | 2 | Beef |
| C. jejuni | 0.18 | 2 to 4 | Beef |
| Escherichia coli O157:H7 | 0.24 | 2 to 4 | Beef |
| L. monocytogenes | 0.45 | 2 to 4 | Chicken |
| Salmonella sp. | 0.38 to 0.77 | 2 | Chicken |
| Staphylococcus aureus | 0.36 | 0 | Chicken |
| Yersinia enterocolitica | 0.11 | 25 | Beef |
| Clostridium botulinum (spores) | 3.56 | 30 | Chicken |
Table 5.1: D values of important pathogens. Adapted from Olson (1998) as given in Fellows, Table 8.3. The D value is the dose that reduces the population to 10% of its starting value, so a spore with a D value of 3.56 kGy needs far more dose than a vegetative cell at 0.11 kGy.
Read the table as a ranking, not as a recipe. Yersinia enterocolitica at 0.11 kGy and Aeromonas hydrophila at 0.14 to 0.19 kGy are the most sensitive in the list, while Clostridium botulinum spores at 3.56 kGy stand far above the rest. That gap is the reason one dose cannot serve every purpose: a dose that cuts Salmonella by 90% several times over may barely touch botulinum spores.
Quick check
A food carries Salmonella sp. with a D value of about 0.5 kGy and Clostridium botulinum spores with a D value of 3.56 kGy. Which needs the larger dose for the same reduction, and why does that matter?
Check your answer
The botulinum spores need the larger dose, because their D value is about seven times higher. A dose chosen for Salmonella alone would not give the same reduction of spores, so the target organism sets the dose.
5.5 The three named uses: radappertisation, radicidation and radurisation
The radiation dose given to a food depends on the resistance of the organisms present and the objective of the treatment. The maximum recommended dose for foods is 15 kGy, with the average dose not exceeding 10 kGy. The three types of process are categorised by the intention of processing and the dose used.
Radappertisation is sterilisation by irradiation. Although it is technically possible to sterilise meats and other products, the dose required exceeds the current limit of 10 kGy. A dose of 48 kGy is needed for a 12D reduction of Clostridium botulinum, but such a high dose would make products such as meat organoleptically unacceptable. There is thus little commercial interest in sterilisation, with the exception of herbs and spices, which are frequently contaminated by heat resistant, spore forming bacteria. These products can be sterilised using a dose of 8 to 10 kGy, which reduces the microbial load to an acceptable level without significant loss of volatile oils, the main quality characteristic. The main advantage of irradiating spices is the replacement of chemical sterilisation using ethylene oxide, which has been banned by the European Union since 1991 as a result of concerns over residues in the product and safety of workers handling the gas.
Radicidation is the reduction of pathogens. Food poisoning bacteria, for example Salmonella typhimurium, are less resistant to radiation than Clostridium botulinum, and doses of 3 to 10 kGy are sufficient for destruction. Fresh poultry carcasses irradiated with a dose of 2.5 kGy are virtually free of Salmonella spp. and the shelf life is doubled when the product is held below 5 degrees C. Higher doses, up to 10 kGy, can be applied to frozen poultry or shellfish at minus 18 degrees C to destroy Campylobacter spp., Escherichia coli O157:H7 or Vibrio sp., for example V. cholerae, V. parahaemolyticus and V. vulnificus, without causing the unacceptable organoleptic changes that occur in fresh meat.
Radurisation is prolonging shelf life. Relatively low doses are needed to destroy yeasts, moulds and non-spore forming bacteria. This process is used to increase shelf life by an overall reduction in vegetative cells. Bacteria which survive irradiation are more susceptible to heat treatment, and the combination of irradiation with heating is therefore beneficial in causing a greater reduction in microbial numbers than would be achieved by either treatment alone.
Two potential problems are raised with respect to microbial destruction. First, by destroying spoilage micro-organisms and not destroying pathogenic bacteria, a valuable indicator of unwholesomeness is removed: the food looks and smells fine while a pathogen remains. Second, the destruction of toxin producing bacteria after they have contaminated the food with toxins is a health hazard, because the toxin stays behind after the bacteria are gone. The book states plainly that these are problems associated with poor manufacturing practice, and that they occur in other types of food processing, for example aflatoxin production by Aspergillus species in nuts and grains. It is therefore essential that codes of Good Manufacturing Practice are adhered to. Irradiation cannot rescue a food that was already badly made.
The three named uses, in order of rising dose
Prolong shelf life
Low doses, yeasts, moulds and vegetative bacteria
Reduce pathogens
3 to 10 kGy, for example Salmonella in poultry at 2.5 kGy
Sterilisation
8 to 10 kGy for herbs and spices, 48 kGy would be needed for a 12D cut in Cl. botulinum in meat
The boxes are not steps in a sequence, so no arrows join them. The dose rises from the first box to the third, and the target changes with it.
Figure 5.2: The three named irradiation uses. Drawn from Fellows, Chapter 8, section 8.4. The maximum recommended dose for foods is 15 kGy, with the average dose not exceeding 10 kGy.
Table 5.2: Applications of food irradiation, from Fellows Table 8.1
| Application | Dose range (kGy) | Examples of foods |
|---|---|---|
| Sterilisation | 7 to 10 | Herbs, spices |
| Sterilisation of packaging materials | 10 to 25 | Packaging materials |
| Destruction of pathogens | 2.5 to 10 | Spices, frozen poultry, meat, shrimps |
| Control of moulds | 2 to 5 | Soft fruit, fresh fish and meat at 0 to 4 degrees C, extension of chill life from 5 days to 1 month |
| Inactivation and control of parasites | 2 to 5 | Pork, extended storage of fresh fruit |
| Disinfestation | 0.1 to 6 | Fruit, grain, flour, cocoa beans, dry foods |
| Inhibition of sprouting | 0.1 to 2 | Potatoes, garlic, onions |
Table 5.2: Applications and dose ranges. Adapted from Ley (1987), Guise (1986a), Goresline (1982), Anon. (1985), Loaharanu (1995) and Wilkinson and Gould (1996), as given in Fellows, Table 8.1. The book also lists a dose of up to 50 kGy for long term ambient storage of meat, and states plainly that this is outside the permitted dose, with no country listed for commercial processing at that dose.
🤔 Pause and think: a spice at 8 kGy and a potato at about 0.15 kGy are both irradiated foods, yet one dose is more than fifty times the other. What does that gap tell you about choosing a dose from the food name alone, without knowing which organism you are trying to stop?
5.6 Ripening control, disinfestation and sprout inhibition
Ripening control works by stopping the processes that drive ripening, not by killing a microbe. Some types of fruits and vegetables, such as strawberries and tomatoes, can be irradiated to extend their shelf life about 2 to 3 times when stored at 10 degrees C. A combination of irradiation and modified atmosphere packaging has been shown to have a synergistic effect, and as a result a lower radiation dose can be used to achieve the same effect. These products should be ripe before irradiation, as the ripening process is inhibited. Ripening and maturation of fruits and vegetables are arrested by inhibiting hormone production and interrupting the biochemical processes of cell division and growth. It should be noted that enzymic spoilage of foods is not entirely prevented by irradiation, and a separate heat treatment is required for prolonged storage. A two fold increase in shelf life of mushrooms and inhibition of cap opening can be achieved by doses of 2 to 3 kGy.
Disinfestation deals with insects and larvae in grains and tropical fruits, which lower export potential and require a quarantine period for disinfestation. Low doses, below 1 kGy, are effective for disinfestation and also extend the shelf life by delaying ripening. Further advantages are the avoidance of pesticides such as ethylene dibromide and methyl bromide, which are now banned or restricted in many countries as a result of concern over toxic residues in foods or, in the case of methyl bromide, because of its potential to deplete the ozone layer.
Sprout inhibition is the lowest dose use in the chapter. The technology is effective in inhibiting sprouting of potatoes, and in Japan, for example, doses of about 150 Gy have been used since 1973 on potatoes intended for further processing. Similar doses are effective in preventing sprouting of onions and garlic. Note the unit change: 150 Gy is 0.15 kGy, a small fraction of the dose used for spices.
Quick check
Why must a strawberry be ripe before it is irradiated for shelf life?
Check your answer
Because irradiation inhibits the ripening process itself, by inhibiting hormone production and interrupting cell division and growth. An unripe fruit treated this way would stay unripe, so the fruit should be ripe before treatment.
5.7 What irradiation does to the food itself
At recommended doses, cobalt-60 and caesium-137 have insufficient emission energies to induce radioactivity in the food. Machine sources of electrons and X-rays do have sufficient energy, but the levels of induced radioactivity are insignificant: 2% of the acceptable radiation dose in the worst case and 0.0001% under realistic processing and storage conditions. The food does not become a source of radiation, and the book gives those two figures as the scale of the effect.
Radiolytic products are the compounds formed when the ions and radicals of section 5.1 react with components of the food. The extent of radiolysis depends on the type of food and the radiation dose employed. The majority of the evidence from feeding experiments, in which animals were fed irradiated foods and high doses of radiolytic products, indicates that there are no adverse effects. Radiolytic type products can also arise from other methods of food processing, and as a result it has, until recently, been difficult to devise a test to determine whether foods have been irradiated.
At commercial dose levels, ionising radiation has little or no effect on the digestibility of proteins or the composition of essential amino acids. At higher dose levels, cleavage of the sulphydryl group from sulphur amino acids in proteins causes changes in the aroma and taste of foods. Carbohydrates are hydrolysed and oxidised to simpler compounds and, depending on the dose received, may become depolymerised and more susceptible to enzymic hydrolysis. There is no change in the degree of utilisation of the carbohydrate and hence no reduction in nutritional value from that change alone. The effect on lipids is similar to that of autoxidation, to produce hydroperoxides and the resulting unacceptable changes to flavour and odour. The effect is reduced by irradiating foods while frozen, but foods that have high concentrations of lipid are generally unsuitable for irradiation.
The evidence on vitamins is conflicting, and the book says so rather than smoothing it over. Many studies have used vitamin solutions, which show greater losses than those found in the heterogeneous mixtures of compounds in foods. Water soluble vitamins vary in their sensitivity to irradiation, and the extent of vitamin loss depends on the dose received and the type and physical state of food under investigation. In grain disinfestation there are little or no vitamin losses, whereas inhibition of sprouting is variously reported to cause 0% and 28% loss of vitamin C at 0.1 kGy and 0.11 kGy respectively, in two different reports. The effects on thiamine in meat and poultry are likewise inconsistent, but other vitamins of the B group are largely unaffected. The order of sensitivity reported for water soluble vitamins is thiamin, then ascorbic acid, then pyridoxine, then riboflavin, then folic acid, then cobalamin, then nicotinic acid. Fat soluble vitamins vary in their susceptibility: vitamins D and K are largely unaffected, whereas vitamins A and E undergo some losses, which vary according to the type of food examined. The order of sensitivity is vitamin E, then carotene, then vitamin A, then vitamin K, then vitamin D. A comparison of irradiated and heat sterilised chicken meat in the book, Table 8.5, indicates similar levels of vitamin loss, but that comparison used a dose of 58 kGy at 25 degrees C, far above commercial doses, so it is a laboratory comparison and not a commercial dose result.
In summary, the consensus of opinion given in the book is that, at commercial dose levels, irradiation causes no greater damage to nutritional quality than other preservation operations used in food processing. That is a comparison with other preservation methods, not a claim of zero change.
Table 5.3: Effect of irradiation on water soluble vitamins in selected foods, from Fellows Table 8.4
| Food | Treatment (kGy) | Thiamin loss (%) | Riboflavin loss (%) | Niacin loss (%) | Pyridoxine loss (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beef | 4.7 to 7.1 | 60 | 4 | 14 | 10 |
| Pork | 4.5 | 15 | 22 | 22 | 2 |
| Haddock | 1.5 | 22 | 0 | 0 | +15 (apparent increase) |
| Wheat | 2.0 | 12 | 13 | 9 | Not given |
| Flour | 0.3 to 0.5 | 0 | 0 | 11 | 0 |
Table 5.3: Vitamin losses vary by food, dose and vitamin. Adapted from Brooke et al. (1966) and Josephson et al. (1975), as given in Fellows, Table 8.4. The book also gives pantothenic acid and vitamin B12 columns in the same table, with several values not given, and those gaps are left as gaps here rather than filled in.
5.8 Packaging: treated through the pack, and changed by the treatment
Radiation is able to penetrate packaging materials, and therefore reduces the risk of post processing contamination and allows easier handling of products. The food can be packed first and treated second, so nothing touches the food after treatment. That is one of the practical strengths of the method.
Packaging materials are themselves subject to changes induced by radiation, and may produce low molecular weight hydrocarbons and halogenated polymers, which have the potential to migrate into the product and produce unacceptable tainting. Careful choice of packaging materials as well as adhesives, additives and printing materials is necessary to prevent contamination of the food with radiolytic products.
Table 5.4: Changes to packaging materials caused by irradiation, from Fellows Table 8.6
| Packaging material | Maximum dose (kGy) | Effect above the maximum dose |
|---|---|---|
| Polystyrene | 5,000 | Not given in the table |
| Polyethylene | 1,000 | Not given in the table |
| PVC | 100 | Browning, evolution of hydrogen chloride |
| Paper and board | 100 | Loss of mechanical strength |
| Polypropylene | 25 | Becomes brittle |
| Glass | 10 | Browning |
Table 5.4: Maximum doses for packaging materials. Adapted from Guise (1986a) and McLaughlin et al. (1982), as given in Fellows, Table 8.6. Glass has the lowest limit in the table, at 10 kGy.
5.9 How to tell whether a food has been irradiated
Because irradiation produces no major chemical, physical or sensory changes to foods at commercial doses, detection methods focus on minute changes in chemical composition, physical or biological changes to the food. There has been considerable research since the late 1980s to develop and validate a series of detection methods that can be used by enforcement officers. At present there are a number of techniques under development, but it is not likely that one method will be applicable to all irradiated foods.
Physical methods start with electron spin resonance spectroscopy, ESR. ESR detects radicals produced by irradiation, which are stable in solid or dry components of foods, for example bones. It has been used to detect irradiated bone containing meat and fish products and shellfish, and may have application to a wide range of food products, including foods that contain crystalline cellulose and have a low moisture content, for example pistachio nuts and paprika. It is a non-destructive method that is specific, rapid and relatively simple, although the high cost of ESR spectrometers may limit its application.
Thermoluminescence, TL, is based on the emission of light, when energy trapped in crystalline lattices during irradiation is released by heating the food. These lattices may be contaminating dust, silicate materials, on spices, minerals from seabeds in the intestines of shellfish, or minerals in fruits and vegetables. The minerals are isolated from the food and when they are heated in a controlled way, the stored energy is released as light and measured by a sensitive photon counter. The method is widely applicable and gives an unequivocal determination that a food has been irradiated, but it has disadvantages: it is laborious because a sufficient amount of minerals, a few mg, free of organic matter, has to be prepared; strict procedures are needed to prevent contamination by dust in the laboratory; TL analysers are expensive; and a radiation source is needed for standardisation of the method. A recent adaptation is photostimulated luminescence, PSL, in which pulsed infrared light is used instead of heat to release the stored energy. The method does not require isolation of the minerals and a small sample of food can be used directly to obtain a result within a few minutes. It is also more efficient than TL in detecting an irradiated component in a mixture of materials and may be capable of being developed into a spot test for irradiation.
Other methods that detect physical changes are measurement of electrical impedance, changes in viscosity, electric potential, nuclear magnetic resonance and near infrared spectroscopy. The book names these methods and gives no detail of their results for any food, so no detail is added here.
Chemical methods start with analysis of radiolytic hydrocarbons produced from fats using gas chromatography, GC. Although the products are formed in other types of food processing, they have a characteristic distribution pattern following irradiation. The use of liquid chromatography coupled to GC increases the sensitivity of the method.
2-alkylcyclobutanones, called 2-CBs, are radiolytic products formed from fatty acids, but are not found as a result of other degradative processes. They are detected using mass spectrometry after separation by gas chromatography and can be identified as positive markers to indicate that a food has been irradiated. The method has been used to detect irradiated poultry meat, pork, beef or lamb meat and liquid whole egg. More recently the test has been used to detect irradiated exotic fruits, including mango, papaya and avocado. Other methods that have been used to detect 2-CBs include thin layer chromatography, TLC, high pressure liquid chromatography, HPLC, and supercritical fluid extraction with TLC.
Detection of DNA fragmentation by microgel electrophoresis of single cells or nuclei has shown good results, but the test is limited to foods that have not been heat treated, as heat treatment also results in DNA fragmentation. There are also prospects for routine use of enzyme linked immunosorbant assay, ELISA, tests as simpler and more rapid methods to detect 2-CBs and dihydrothymidine, a DNA breakdown product of irradiation. In each case the monoclonal antibody used in the assay is raised against the particular marker chemical and subjected to the ELISA testing procedure. The results give both qualitative and quantitative identification of the marker in irradiated samples of food and may be developed into a positive spot test for irradiation.
Biological methods estimate the reduced viability of micro-organisms after irradiation. The Limulus Amoebocyte Lysate test in conjunction with a Gram negative bacteria count, LAL/GNB, is used to estimate the reduced viability, measuring both dead and alive micro-organisms. The Direct Epifluorescent Filter Technique with an aerobic plate count, DEFT/APC, gives information about the numbers of bacteria destroyed by irradiation. If the DEFT count exceeds the APC by 10⁴ or more, it indicates that the food has been irradiated. These methods also indicate the hygiene status before and after irradiation, and thus help to enforce Good Manufacturing Practice. They are used for a wide range of irradiated foods, especially to detect irradiated poultry meat. The last method may be limited if initial contamination is low or if low dose levels are used. Other detection methods are being developed, including capillary gel electrophoresis to detect irradiated meat and plant material, in which proteins and peptides are separated on the basis of their size, and this was used to detect changes in egg white caused by irradiation.
Quick check
Why is there no single detection test for every irradiated food?
Check your answer
Because irradiation produces no major chemical, physical or sensory change at commercial doses, each test looks for a minute change in one kind of food, such as radicals in bone, trapped light in minerals, 2-CBs in fat, or dead bacteria counts. No one change is present in every food.
5.10 Labelling, safety judgement and public perception
The concerns about irradiation listed in the book are specific, and they are worth reading as a list rather than as a vague worry. The process could be used to eliminate high bacterial loads to make otherwise unacceptable foods saleable. If spoilage micro-organisms are destroyed but pathogenic bacteria are not, consumers will have no indication of the unwholesomeness of a food. There will be a health hazard if toxin producing bacteria are destroyed after they have contaminated the food with toxins. There is the possible development of resistance to radiation in micro-organisms, and loss of nutritional value. Until recently there were inadequate analytical procedures for detecting whether foods have been irradiated. And there is public resistance due to fears of induced radioactivity or other reasons connected to concerns over the nuclear industry.
These concerns have been addressed by the Joint FAO/IAEA/WHO Expert Committee on the Wholesomeness of Irradiated Food, JECFI, which concluded that the maximum average dose of 10 kGy presents no toxicological hazard and no special nutritional or microbiological problems in foods. This was supported by the Advisory Committee on Irradiated and Novel Foodstuffs. The JECFI recommendations were then formed into a standard by the Codex Alimentarius Commission, which recommended an international code for the operation of radiation facilities.
In most countries where irradiation is permitted, labelling regulations are in force which place a requirement on manufacturers to indicate that the food or any listed ingredients have been treated by irradiation. Additionally, wholesale foods are required to be labelled with the phrase "Treated by irradiation, do not irradiate again". This, together with a programme of research into methods to detect whether foods have been irradiated, is in part intended to change negative public perceptions of irradiated foods. The book gives no list of which countries require which exact label wording beyond that wholesale phrase, and no survey figure for public acceptance, so no such figure is given here.
5.11 Supercritical carbon dioxide: a gas that acts like a liquid
The term supercritical arises from the critical temperature and critical pressure lines on a pressure temperature diagram. The supercritical region for carbon dioxide is when it is above the critical pressure line and to the right of the critical temperature line, at 31 degrees C. The figure in the book gives the critical temperature, Tc, as 31.06 degrees C and the critical pressure, Pc, as 73.8 bar. Above those two lines, carbon dioxide is in the supercritical region.
As a solvent, supercritical carbon dioxide acts as a liquid but has a low viscosity and diffuses easily like a gas. It has the advantages of being highly volatile and so is easily separated from the solute without leaving any residues in the food. It is also non-flammable, non-toxic, bacteriostatic and low cost. It is used under conditions that are close to the critical point, called near-critical fluid or NCF, for de-odourising applications or for highly soluble solutes. For more complete extraction or for applications that involve less soluble solutes, it is used at higher temperatures and pressures. The upper limit for the operating temperature is the heat sensitivity of the food components and the upper limit for pressure, about 40 MPa, is the cost of pressurised equipment. The book gives no single operating temperature or pressure for any one food beyond the decaffeination range in section 5.12, so no general operating recipe is stated here.
5.12 Extraction: how a solute leaves the food and enters the solvent
Solid liquid extraction involves the removal of a desired component, the solute, from a food using a liquid, the solvent, which is able to dissolve the solute. This involves mixing the food and solvent together, either in a single stage or in multiple stages, holding for a pre-determined time and then separating the solvent. During the holding period there is mass transfer of solutes from the food material to the solvent, which occurs in three stages: first, the solute dissolves in the solvent; second, the solution moves through the particle of food to its surface; third, the solution becomes dispersed in the bulk of the solvent.
During extraction, the holding time should therefore be sufficient for the solvent to dissolve sufficient solute and for the changes in composition to approach an equilibrium. The time required depends on the solubility of a given solute in the solvent selected and on four factors named in the book: the temperature of extraction, where higher temperatures increase both the rate at which solutes dissolve and the rate of diffusion into the bulk of the solvent; the surface area of solids exposed to the solvent, where the rate of mass transfer is directly proportional to the surface area, so reductions in particle size increase the rate of extraction up to certain limits; the viscosity of the solvent, which should be sufficiently low to enable the solvent to penetrate easily the bed of solid particles; and the flowrate of the solvent, where higher flowrates reduce the boundary layer of concentrated solute at the surface of particles and thus increase the rate of extraction. The temperature of most extraction operations is limited to less than 100 degrees C by economic considerations, extraction of undesirable components at higher temperatures, or heat damage to food components.
The main types of solvents used for extraction are water, organic solvents or supercritical carbon dioxide. Extraction using water, called leaching, has obvious advantages of low cost and safety and is used to extract sugar, coffee and tea. Oils and fats require an organic solvent and as these are highly flammable, great care is needed in both operating procedures and to ensure that equipment is gas-tight and electrical apparatus is spark-proof.
Supercritical carbon dioxide has found increasingly widespread application for removing caffeine from coffee or tea and for producing hop extracts for brewing. It has also been used to extract and concentrate flavour compounds from fruits and spices, including pepper, marjoram, nutmeg, cardamom, cloves and ginger, and speciality oils from citrus and a variety of nuts and seeds. The combination of supercritical CO₂ and extrusion to produce a new range of breakfast cereals, pasta products and confectionery is described in the book. Once the solvent has been removed from the extracted foods, some may be used directly, for example cooking oils, or they may be further processed by concentration and dehydration. Many extraction operations operate close to ambient temperature, but even when higher temperatures are used to increase the rate of extraction, there is little damage caused by heat and the product quality is not significantly affected.
For decaffeinated coffee, the book's Table 6.2 gives supercritical carbon dioxide, water or methylene chloride as solvents, with a temperature of 30 to 50 degrees C for CO₂. No final solute concentration is given for decaffeinated coffee in that table, and no holding time is given for any extraction in the extract, so neither figure is stated here.
Supercritical CO₂ extraction: from bean to extract and back again
CO₂ stored as a near-critical liquid, then pumped on
↓
Food purged with gaseous CO₂, then liquid CO₂ pumped in and held to equilibrium
↓
Conditions adjusted, often by decompression, so the extract leaves the CO₂
↓
CO₂ returned, cooled and re-used, extract removed
Pressure is set by a relief valve and temperature by liquid in a jacket around the vessel.
Figure 5.3: A supercritical CO₂ extraction unit. Drawn from Fellows, Chapter 6, Figure 6.10. The essential components are an extraction vessel, a separation vessel, a condenser and a pump.
5.13 The extraction equipment, step by step
Extractors are either single stage or multi stage static tanks or continuous extractors. The components of a typical extraction unit that uses near-critical CO₂ solvent are shown in Figure 5.3. The essential components are an extraction vessel, a separation vessel, a condenser and a pump.
In supercritical CO₂ extraction, CO₂ is stored as a near-critical liquid in the condenser and then pumped to the extraction vessel through a heat exchanger by a high pressure pump. The state of the CO₂ in the extractor is determined by the pressure, controlled by a pressure relief valve, and the temperature, thermostatically controlled by liquid recirculating through a jacket surrounding the vessel. The material to be extracted is purged with gaseous CO₂ to remove air and then liquid CO₂ is pumped in at a rate that permits a sufficient residence time for equilibrium conditions to be established. The solution is then passed to the separation vessel in which conditions are adjusted to minimise the solubility of the extracted components, often by decompression. The CO₂ is then returned to the cooled condenser for re-use and the extract is removed from the separation vessel. The extract given for this unit ends in mid sentence at that point, so the final wording of the last step is taken from the sentence as far as it runs in the source, and no extra step is added beyond it.
5.14 What the extract does not say: dense phase CO₂ and microbial kill
This section is a plain statement of a gap, and it matters for anyone who reads this unit as a design guide. The outline for this unit asked for supercritical CO₂ as a microbial inactivation method, described as dense phase CO₂. The Fellows extract supplied for this unit covers supercritical CO₂ only as an extraction solvent: decaffeination, hop extracts, flavour compounds, speciality oils, and the extraction equipment in section 5.13. It gives no pressure, no temperature, no holding time, no carbon dioxide concentration, no micro-organism, no D value and no food for a microbial inactivation treatment with dense phase CO₂. It also gives no equipment description for a microbial treatment, and no statement of which microbes it kills or which it leaves alive.
Because no number or fact of that kind is in the extract, none is given here. A reader who needs dense phase CO₂ as a preservation treatment must look for a source that actually describes it, and that source is not the extract used for this unit. The same caution applies to the operating recipe for extraction: the extract gives the critical point, the near-critical use, the pressure ceiling of about 40 MPa, the temperature ceiling set by heat sensitivity, and the 30 to 50 degrees C range for decaffeination with CO₂, and it gives no holding time and no flowrate for any food, so no holding time and no flowrate are stated in this unit.
Quick check
A supplier says dense phase CO₂ kills Salmonella in juice at a set pressure and time, and cites this unit. Is that claim supported by the extract used here?
Check your answer
No. The extract covers supercritical CO₂ only as an extraction solvent, with no pressure, time, micro-organism or food for a microbial treatment. The claim needs a different source that actually describes dense phase CO₂ inactivation.
Try it yourself: Find three foods in a shop that are named in this unit: a dried herb or spice, a potato, and a decaffeinated coffee. Read each label and look for the words "irradiated" or "treated by irradiation" on the herb or spice, and for the decaffeination method on the coffee, if the label states one. Write down what each label actually says, and what it does not say. The point of the exercise is observational: labels state the treatment only where the rules require it, and many packs say nothing at all about how the food was treated, so a blank label is not proof that no treatment happened.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Ionising radiation breaks chemical bonds, making ions and free radicals, and in wet food it ionises water to hydrogen, hydrogen peroxide, hydrogen radicals, hydroxyl radicals and hydroperoxyl radicals.
- Gamma rays come mainly from cobalt-60 or caesium-137, which cannot be switched off and are shielded under water, while machine sources make electron beams or X-rays and can be switched off.
- Dose is measured in grays, where 1 Gy equals 1 J per kilogram, and in food work doses are given in kGy: 1 kGy equals 1,000 Gy and 1 Gy equals 100 rads.
- The D₁₀ value is the dose that cuts a microbial population to 10% of its starting value, and spores and DNA repairing species need far more dose than vegetative cells, while viruses are unlikely to be affected by commercial doses.
- The three named uses are radappertisation for sterilisation, radicidation for pathogen reduction, and radurisation for shelf life, with the maximum recommended dose of 15 kGy and an average dose not exceeding 10 kGy.
- A dose of 48 kGy would be needed for a 12D reduction of Clostridium botulinum in meat, which is why sterilisation is used commercially for herbs and spices at 8 to 10 kGy, not for meat.
- Low doses stop sprouting at about 150 Gy, stop insects below 1 kGy, and slow ripening, but fruit should be ripe before treatment because ripening itself is inhibited.
- At commercial doses the book's consensus is that irradiation causes no greater damage to nutritional quality than other preservation operations, while high lipid foods and dairy products are generally unsuitable because of rancid off flavours.
- Induced radioactivity from cobalt-60 and caesium-137 at recommended doses is not expected, and from machine sources it is insignificant at 2% of the acceptable dose in the worst case and 0.0001% under realistic conditions.
- Detection uses minute changes, including ESR for radicals in bone and dry foods, thermoluminescence and photostimulated luminescence for trapped light in minerals, 2-alkylcyclobutanones as markers in fat, and DEFT/APC counts where a DEFT count above the APC by 10⁴ or more indicates irradiation.
- Wholesale irradiated food must be labelled "Treated by irradiation, do not irradiate again", and the Joint FAO/IAEA/WHO Expert Committee concluded that a maximum average dose of 10 kGy presents no toxicological hazard and no special nutritional or microbiological problems.
- Supercritical CO₂ is carbon dioxide above its critical temperature of 31.06 degrees C and its critical pressure of 73.8 bar, where it acts as a liquid but diffuses like a gas, leaves no residue, and is non-flammable, non-toxic, bacteriostatic and low cost.
- Extraction moves a solute from food to solvent in three stages, dissolving, moving through the particle, and dispersing in the bulk solvent, and it is used for decaffeination, hop extracts, flavours and speciality oils.
- The extract supplied for this unit gives no pressure, time, micro-organism or food for dense phase CO₂ as a microbial treatment, so no such treatment is described in this unit.
Glossary
Ionising radiation
Radiation that can break chemical bonds when it is absorbed by a material. Food tech example: gamma rays from cobalt-60 breaking bonds in water inside a food and making free radicals.
Radiolysis
The chemical changes caused in a material by the ions and free radicals made during irradiation. Food tech example: radiolysis of water in a moist food making hydrogen peroxide and hydroxyl radicals.
Free radical
A neutral, highly reactive product of ionisation, with an unpaired electron, that reacts quickly with nearby molecules. Food tech example: a hydroxyl radical made from water during irradiation that damages a bacterial cell.
Gray (Gy)
The unit of absorbed dose, where 1 Gy is the absorption of 1 J of energy per kilogram of food. Food tech example: a sprout inhibition dose of about 150 Gy on potatoes, which is 0.15 kGy.
Kilgray (kGy)
One thousand grays, the unit most often used for food irradiation doses. Food tech example: herbs and spices sterilised at 8 to 10 kGy.
D10 value
The dose of radiation that reduces a microbial population to 10% of its initial value. Food tech example: Clostridium botulinum spores with a D value of 3.56 kGy, far above Yersinia enterocolitica at 0.11 kGy.
Radappertisation
Sterilisation by irradiation. Food tech example: herbs and spices sterilised at 8 to 10 kGy, replacing chemical sterilisation with ethylene oxide.
Radicidation
Reduction of pathogens by irradiation. Food tech example: fresh poultry at 2.5 kGy, virtually free of Salmonella spp., with shelf life doubled below 5 degrees C.
Radurisation
Prolonging shelf life by irradiation at relatively low doses. Food tech example: yeasts, moulds and non-spore forming bacteria cut back so a chilled food keeps longer.
Dosimeter
A device or material placed in a pack to measure the radiation dose received. Food tech example: a PVC dosimeter whose dye changes colour when hydrogen chloride is released by irradiation.
Dmax and Dmin
The maximum dose at the outer edge of a pack and the minimum dose inside it, used as a ratio to judge how even the dose is. Food tech example: chicken needs a Dmax to Dmin ratio of not more than about 1.5, while onions can tolerate about 3.
Radiolytic product
A compound formed when ions and radicals from irradiation react with food components. Food tech example: 2-alkylcyclobutanones formed from fatty acids, used as markers that a food was irradiated.
Supercritical carbon dioxide
Carbon dioxide held above its critical temperature of 31.06 degrees C and its critical pressure of 73.8 bar, where it acts as a liquid but diffuses like a gas. Food tech example: supercritical CO₂ removing caffeine from coffee beans at 30 to 50 degrees C.
Near-critical fluid (NCF)
Carbon dioxide used under conditions close to the critical point. Food tech example: near-critical CO₂ used for de-odourising or for highly soluble solutes.
Solute
The desired component removed from a food by a solvent during extraction. Food tech example: caffeine as the solute removed from coffee beans by supercritical CO₂.
Thermoluminescence (TL)
A detection method in which light is released when energy trapped in crystalline lattices during irradiation is freed by heating. Food tech example: minerals isolated from spices releasing light on heating, showing the spice was irradiated.
References
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, Woodhead Publishing. Chapter 8, Irradiation, sections 8.1 to 8.7, Tables 8.1 to 8.6, and Chapter 6, Separation and concentration of food components, section 6.4, Table 6.2 and Figures 6.9 and 6.10, on supercritical carbon dioxide extraction.
Unit 6: Hurdle Technology: Designing Combinations That Work
Note
Unit 6: Hurdle Technology: Designing Combinations That Work
A smoked fish keeps without a fridge for a while, a jam keeps in a cupboard for months, and a ready meal keeps in a chiller for days. None of them relies on one single treatment. Each one is held safe by several small pressures acting together: heat, salt, acid, dryness, cold, and a sealed pack. Take one pressure away and the food may still be safe. Take away two, and the microbes may get through. This unit is about that idea, called the hurdle effect, and about how to design a set of hurdles that actually holds.
Questions to think about
- Why does a jam keep at room temperature while fresh fruit rots in days, when both are made from fruit?
- If each hurdle in a food is too weak to stop microbes on its own, how can the set of them together keep the food safe?
- Why can the same set of hurdles keep one product safe and fail on a second product that looks similar?
- Why does a dirty raw material defeat hurdles that worked perfectly on a clean one?
- How can a maker keep a food safe and still keep it tasting fresh, instead of cooking it hard or salting it until it is inedible?
6.1 The hurdle idea
The concept of combining several factors to preserve foods has been developed by Leistner (1995) and others into the Hurdle effect: each factor is a hurdle that micro-organisms must overcome. This in turn has led to the application of Hurdle Technology, also known as combined processes, combination preservation or combination techniques, where an understanding of the complex interactions of temperature, water activity, pH, chemical preservatives, and other factors is used to design a series of hurdles that ensure microbiological safety of processed foods.
The image is a useful one if it is read in the right way. A micro-organism in a food does not face one wall. It faces a row of obstacles, one after another, and in practice the obstacles may act at the same time as well. Some obstacles slow growth, some stop growth, and some kill cells outright. A cell that gets past a low temperature may then meet a low pH, and a cell that survives the acid may then meet a low water activity, and a cell that survives that may then meet a preservative. The food stays safe not because any one hurdle is very high, but because the set of them together leaves the micro-organism with no easy path through.
The book states the design rule in plain terms: the hurdles that are selected should be high enough so that the anticipated numbers of these micro-organisms cannot overcome them. That sentence carries two ideas that run through the whole unit. First, the hurdles must be set against the numbers and types of micro-organisms that are likely to be present in the food, not against a micro-organism in general. Second, high enough is a judgement about the set, not about one factor on its own. A hurdle that is low on its own can still be part of a set that holds, if the other hurdles in the set do their share of the work.
Quick check
What is a hurdle in Hurdle Technology?
Check your answer
A hurdle is one preservative factor in a food, such as temperature, water activity, pH or a chemical preservative, that micro-organisms must overcome. A set of hurdles together keeps the food microbiologically safe.
6.2 Traditional foods were hurdle foods before the name existed
In traditionally preserved foods, such as smoked fish or meat, jams and other preserves, there are a combination of factors that ensure microbiological safety and stability of the food, and thus enable it to be preserved. The book uses these old foods as the first examples, because they show the idea working before anyone called it Hurdle Technology.
In smoked products, for example, the combination includes heat, reduced moisture content and anti-microbial chemicals deposited from the smoke onto the surface of the food. Some smoked foods may also be dipped or soaked in brine or rubbed with salt before smoking, to impregnate the flesh with salt and thus add a further preservative mechanism. Smoked products may also be chilled or packed in modified atmospheres to further extend the shelf life. Count the hurdles in that one example: heat, drying, smoke chemicals, salt, chilling, and a modified atmosphere pack. No one of them is asked to do the whole job.
In jams and other fruit preserves, the combined factors are heat, a high solids content, which gives a reduced water activity, and high acidity. The same three factors also shape the food that the eater meets: these preservative factors strongly influence the sensory characteristics of the product and contribute to important differences in flavour, texture or colour between different products. A jam is not a fresh fruit with hurdles added on top. The hurdles are part of what makes it a jam: sweet, acid, and thick, with water held by the solids so that microbes cannot use it freely.
The point of these examples is that hurdles are not a new invention laid over old foods. The old foods already were combinations, and the new work is to name the factors, to understand how they interact, and to design the combination on purpose instead of by habit alone.
Quick check
Name the hurdles in a jam, as given in the book.
Check your answer
Heat, a high solids content giving a reduced water activity, and high acidity.
6.3 A sequence of hurdles: vegetable fermentation
Vegetable fermentation shows a different pattern from jam or smoked fish: the hurdles do not all arrive at once, they arise in a sequence, and each one changes the conditions for the next. In vegetable fermentation, the desired product quality and microbial stability are achieved by a sequence of factors that arise at different stages in the fermentation process.
The sequence starts with salt. The addition of salt selects the initial microbial population, which uses up the available oxygen in the brine. This reduces the redox potential and inhibits the growth of aerobic spoilage micro-organisms, and it favours the selection of lactic acid bacteria. These then acidify the product and stabilise it. Further treatments may include pasteurisation and packaging to extend the shelf life and facilitate distribution.
Read that sequence slowly, because it shows three things about hurdles that a simple list hides. First, one hurdle can create the next: salt does not only act on its own, it selects the microbes that then make the acid. Second, the order matters: the acid comes after the salt has done its selecting, not before. Third, the hurdles that finish the job, pasteurisation and packaging, are added after the fermentation has set the product, not at the start. A designer who lists hurdles without asking when each one acts will miss this pattern.
Vegetable fermentation: hurdles that arrive in sequence
Selects the starting microbes
↓
Redox potential falls, aerobic spoilage microbes are held back
↓
They grow and make acid
↓
The food is now acid and stable
↓
Shelf life extended, distribution made easier
Each step changes the food so the next step can work. The arrows are a real sequence here.
Figure 6.1: The hurdle sequence in vegetable fermentation. Drawn from Fellows, Chapter 1, section 1.8.2. Salt selects the population, the population uses the oxygen, the redox potential falls, lactic acid bacteria are favoured, and their acid stabilises the product.
6.4 Why mild foods need hurdles: the chilled ready meal
The demand by consumers for high quality foods having fresh or natural characteristics, that require a minimum amount of preparation, has led to the development of ready to eat and convenience foods that are preserved using mild technologies. The main preservation technique is refrigeration, but because of the difficulty in maintaining sufficiently low temperatures throughout the production, distribution and storage chain, additional barriers, or hurdles, are required to control the growth of spoilage or pathogenic micro-organisms.
That difficulty is the heart of the modern case for Hurdle Technology. Chilling works well when the cold chain holds, and it fails quietly when it does not: a truck door left open, a shop chiller running warm, a home fridge set too high, a meal left on a counter for an hour too long. A food that relies on chilling alone has no back up when the temperature rises. A food with extra hurdles has a margin: if the chill slips, the acid, the low water activity, the preservative or the pack is still there, holding the microbes back while the temperature is wrong.
The same reasoning applies to the mild processes in Chapter 9 of the book, the minimal processes that keep flavour and colour by reducing reliance on heat. In each minimal processing method, processing destroys micro-organisms, and in some cases enzymes, and there are no substantial increases in product temperature, so there is little damage to pigments, flavour compounds or vitamins, and the sensory characteristics and nutritional value of foods are not degraded to a significant extent. A mild process on its own leaves more microbes alive than a hard heat process would, so the hurdles around it matter more, not less. The gentler the main treatment, the more the safety of the food depends on the set of hurdles that surrounds it.
🤔 Pause and think: a ready meal in a chiller relies on cold as its main hurdle. Picture the meal on its way from the factory to a home fridge: factory chiller, truck, shop chiller, car boot, kitchen counter, home fridge. At which of those steps is the cold most likely to slip, and which extra hurdle would still be working at that step?
6.5 The catalogue of hurdles
Fellows gives a catalogue of hurdles in Table 1.17, sorted into three types: physical hurdles, physicochemical hurdles, and microbially derived hurdles. The table is reproduced here in shortened form, with the examples as the book gives them. It is a menu to choose from, not a recipe: no product uses all of them, and the choice of which ones to use is the design work.
Table 6.1: Examples of hurdles used to preserve foods, from Fellows Table 1.17
| Type of hurdle | Examples |
|---|---|
| Physical hurdles | Aseptic packaging; electromagnetic energy, including microwave, radio frequency, pulsed magnetic fields and high electric fields; high temperatures, including blanching, pasteurisation, sterilisation, evaporation, extrusion, baking and frying; ionising radiation; low temperatures, including chilling and freezing; modified atmospheres; packaging films, including active packaging and edible coatings; photodynamic inactivation; ultra-high pressures; ultrasonication; ultraviolet radiation |
| Physicochemical hurdles | Carbon dioxide; ethanol; lactic acid; lactoperoxidase; low pH; low redox potential; low water activity; Maillard reaction products; organic acids; oxygen; ozone; phenols; phosphates; salt; smoking; sodium nitrite and nitrate; sodium or potassium sulphite; spices and herbs; surface treatment agents |
| Microbially derived hurdles | Antibiotics; bacteriocins; competitive flora; protective cultures |
Table 6.1: Examples of hurdles, adapted from Leistner and Gorris (1995), as given in Fellows, Table 1.17. The book gives a chapter number beside each hurdle for more detail, and those chapter numbers are not repeated here.
Three things about the catalogue are worth noticing. First, it mixes things that kill microbes with things that only slow them: high temperature and ionising radiation can kill, while low pH and low water activity mainly stop growth. A set needs both kinds of action in the right places, and the book does not rank them in a single order of strength. Second, it mixes hurdles that are part of the recipe with hurdles that are part of the pack: salt and acid are in the food, while aseptic packaging and modified atmospheres are around it. The pack is a hurdle, not just a container. Third, it includes hurdles made by microbes themselves: bacteriocins, competitive flora and protective cultures. A living culture can be a preservative factor, and that idea is taken up in full in Unit 7 on biopreservation.
The book gives no numeric height for any hurdle in this catalogue: no pH value, no water activity value, no salt percentage, no temperature and no time for any entry. Those numbers depend on the food, the microbes, and the other hurdles in the set, and they are not in the extract used for this unit. Where this unit speaks of a hurdle being high or low, it means high or low relative to what the microbes in that food need to grow, not a number from a table.
Quick check
Give one example of a hurdle from each of the three types in Table 6.1.
Check your answer
Physical: chilling, freezing, pasteurisation, ionising radiation, ultra-high pressure, or ultraviolet radiation. Physicochemical: low pH, low water activity, salt, organic acids, or low redox potential. Microbially derived: bacteriocins, competitive flora, or protective cultures.
6.6 The three cases in Figure 1.19: the same hurdles, three different results
The clearest teaching in the extract is Figure 1.19, which shows the same hurdles in three different situations. The figure uses these labels: t for chilling, aw for low water activity, pH for acidification, Eh for low redox potential, pres. for preservatives, V for vitamins, and N for nutrients. In the figure the hurdles are drawn as a sequence, but the book warns that in practice the different factors may operate simultaneously, synergistically or sequentially. The drawing is a way to show the set, not a claim that the factors act one after another in the food.
In the first case, Figure 1.19a, the hurdles satisfactorily preserve a food when it is properly prepared. The main hurdles in the example are low water activity and chemical preservatives, with storage temperature, pH and redox potential having a smaller effect. The picture to hold in mind is a row of hurdles of different heights, and a microbial population that is not large enough or strong enough to get over them. The food is stable.
In the second case, Figure 1.19b, the same hurdles are overcome by a larger initial population of micro-organisms, when for example raw materials are not adequately cleaned. The hurdles have not changed. The food has not changed. What has changed is the starting load: more cells arrive at the first hurdle, more survive each hurdle, and enough get through the whole set to spoil the food or make it unsafe. The lesson is that hurdle design starts before the hurdles are set, with the raw material. Cleaning, sorting and, where the book names it, blanching vegetables or fruits has a similar effect in reducing initial numbers of micro-organisms before freezing or drying. A hurdle set designed for a clean raw material is not a hurdle set designed for a dirty one, even if the recipe is the same.
In the third case, Figure 1.19c, the same hurdles are used with a different product that is richer in nutrients that can support microbial growth, and again the hurdles may be inadequate to preserve it, and a different combination may be needed or the height of the hurdles increased. Here the starting load is not the problem: the food itself is a better home for microbes, because it offers more of what they need to grow. Vitamins and nutrients, marked V and N in the figure, are not hurdles: they are the food that the microbes feed on, and a richer food lowers the effective height of every hurdle in the set.
Figure 1.19 in words: the same hurdles, three different results
Low water activity and preservatives are the main hurdles, temperature, pH and redox potential help
Result: the food is preserved
Raw materials not adequately cleaned, so many more microbes arrive
Result: the hurdles are overcome
More nutrients and vitamins support microbial growth
Result: the hurdles may be inadequate, a different combination or higher hurdles are needed
The three boxes are three separate cases, not steps in a sequence, so no arrows join them. The hurdles are the same in all three: what changes is the load and the food.
Figure 6.2: The three cases of Fellows, Figure 1.19, adapted from Leistner and Gorris (1995). Labels in the original are t for chilling, aw for low water activity, pH for acidification, Eh for low redox potential, pres. for preservatives, V for vitamins and N for nutrients.
The three cases together give the design test for any hurdle set. A set is not judged by whether it works on a clean, lean food in a laboratory. It is judged by whether it still works when the raw material carries more microbes than expected, and when the food is richer than the test food was. If the answer to either question is no, the set needs a different combination or higher hurdles, and that decision is part of the design, not a repair after the food has failed.
Quick check
The same hurdles keep food A safe and fail on food B. Food B is richer in nutrients. What does the book say to do?
Check your answer
Use a different combination of hurdles, or increase the height of the hurdles. A richer food supports more microbial growth, so the same set is no longer high enough.
6.7 How hurdles add up: together, in sequence, and more than the sum
The book names three ways the factors in a set can operate: simultaneously, synergistically or sequentially. The distinction matters, because a designer who assumes they only add up will undervalue the set.
Simultaneously means the hurdles act at the same time. Chilling, low pH and low water activity in a chilled ready meal are all acting on the same cells at the same time, from the moment the pack is sealed until it is opened. Sequentially means the hurdles act one after another, as in vegetable fermentation in section 6.3, where salt acts first, the redox potential falls next, and the acid acts last. Synergistically means the combined effect is greater than the sum of the separate effects: two hurdles together stop more growth than the two hurdles would stop if each acted alone. The book uses the word synergistically for this pattern, and it gives the irradiation and modified atmosphere example in Unit 5 as an instance of the same idea, where a lower radiation dose achieves the same effect when the pack atmosphere is also changed.
The practical consequence is the one the book states for combined hurdles and quality: by combining hurdles, the intensity of individual preservation techniques can be kept comparatively low to minimise loss of product quality, while overall there is a high impact on controlling microbial growth. That is the trade that Hurdle Technology exists to make. A single hard treatment, a long hot cook or a heavy salt dose, would keep the food safe and spoil its eating quality. Several gentle treatments, each kept low, can keep the food safe and leave its flavour, colour and texture close to fresh. The hurdles are also used to improve the quality of foods and the economic properties, for example the weight of water that can be added to a food, consistent with its microbial stability. A food that holds more water can be softer, juicier and heavier to sell, but only if the hurdles still hold at that water level.
The warning that goes with this trade is the mirror of the promise. Keep an individual hurdle too low, and the set may fail even though the idea was sound. The failure will not announce itself as a single missing hurdle: the food will simply spoil sooner, or carry a pathogen that the set was meant to stop. That is why the design must be checked against the starting load and the richness of the food, as in section 6.6, and not only against the recipe on paper.
6.8 When hurdles are too low, and when they damage quality
A hurdle set can fail in two directions, and the book gives the shape of both. Too low, and the microbes get through: the set is overcome by a larger initial population, as in Figure 1.19b, or it is inadequate for a richer product, as in Figure 1.19c. Too high, and the food is damaged: the same hurdles that preserve a food also shape its flavour, texture and colour, and pushing any one of them further changes the food the eater meets. More salt makes a food saltier, more acid makes it sharper, more drying makes it harder, more heat makes it more cooked. The art of the design is to find the set where each hurdle is high enough for safety and low enough for quality, and where the set as a whole holds.
The book gives no numeric line for either failure: no salt level that is too much, no pH that is too low for taste, no water activity that is too low for texture, and no dose or time that marks the edge. Those lines depend on the food and on what its eaters will accept, and they are not in the extract used for this unit. What the extract does give is the principle for finding the line: keep the intensity of each individual technique comparatively low, keep the overall impact on microbes high, and check the set against the starting load and the richness of the food. A design that follows that principle and is then tested is a hurdle design. A design that sets one hurdle very high and ignores the rest is not.
A useful way to test a set without inventing numbers is to ask three questions about it, each drawn from the extract. First, what are the numbers and types of micro-organisms likely to be present at the start, and have the raw materials been cleaned and, where the process uses it, blanched to bring those numbers down? Second, how rich is this food in nutrients and vitamins that support growth, compared with the food the set was first tested on? Third, if one hurdle slips, for example if the chill rises during distribution, which other hurdles are still standing, and are they enough on their own for the time the food will be warm? If any of those questions has no answer, the design is not finished, even if the recipe looks complete.
🤔 Pause and think: a maker wants a softer, moister version of a product that now keeps well. More water is added, so the water activity rises. Which hurdles in the set would need to rise to cover that change, and which change to the food would the eater notice first?
6.9 Hurdle technology with HACCP
The combination of hurdle technology and HACCP in process design is described by Leistner (1994). That is the full statement the extract gives on the link between the two: it names the combination, it names the author and year, and it places the combination in process design. It does not list HACCP principles, it does not name critical control points for any food, and it does not give a HACCP plan for a hurdle product.
What can be said without inventing detail is what the pairing means in the terms of this unit. Hurdle Technology designs the set of factors that keeps the food safe. HACCP is the system that watches the process and checks that those factors are actually in place, batch after batch. The two fit together because a hurdle set is only as good as its weakest day: a salt dose missed, a chill that rose, a pH that drifted, a pack that leaked. A design that names the hurdles but never checks them is a hope, not a control. The book's placement of the pairing in process design, rather than in a separate safety chapter, makes that point: the hurdles and the checks on them are designed together, at the start, not added after the product is already on sale.
The extract also names where novel mild processes that retain product quality are described: Chapter 9 on minimal processes, Chapter 18 on ohmic heating, and Chapters 19 and 20 on sous-vide cooking and modified atmospheres. Those chapters are the places to look for the individual mild treatments that a hurdle set can be built around. They are not described in the extract used for this unit, so their temperatures, times and pressures are not given here.
6.10 A worked design order for a product
The extract does not give a step by step design order with numbers, and this section does not pretend that it does. What follows is a working order drawn from the ideas in the extract, in the sequence the extract itself implies, and every step is tied to a passage already given in this unit. It is a way to work through a design, not a recipe that guarantees safety for any food. No step in it carries a number, because the extract carries none.
A worked design order, drawn from the extract
Name the food, its nutrients, and the numbers and types of microbes likely to be present
↓
Clean the raw materials, and blanch vegetables or fruits where the process uses it, before freezing or drying
↓
Pick from the catalogue in Table 6.1, across physical, physicochemical and microbially derived types
↓
Keep each individual technique comparatively low to protect quality, and let the set carry the safety
↓
A larger starting load, as in Figure 1.19b, and a richer food, as in Figure 1.19c
↓
If the set fails a hard case, change the combination or raise the hurdle heights
↓
Pair the hurdle set with HACCP in process design, so each hurdle is watched batch after batch
The arrows are a real working order here: each step is done before the next one is settled.
Figure 6.3: A worked design order for a hurdle product, drawn from Fellows, Chapter 1, section 1.8.2 and Figure 1.19. No step carries a number, because the extract gives no numeric hurdle heights.
Work the order through with the two traditional foods from section 6.2, as worked examples from the book. For smoked fish, the starting load is set by the freshness and cleaning of the fish, the hurdles are heat, drying, smoke chemicals, salt, chilling and a modified atmosphere pack, and the hard cases are a larger load on a poorly cleaned fish and a richer, fattier fish that supports more growth. For jam, the starting load is set by the fruit and its handling, the hurdles are heat, high solids with low water activity, and high acidity, and the hard case is a fruit batch that is less acid or lower in solids than the recipe assumed. In both examples the design question is the same: which hurdle would you raise, and what would the eater notice if you raised it?
The same order also covers the chilled ready meal from section 6.4. The starting load is set by the raw materials and the cooking, the main hurdle is refrigeration, and the extra hurdles are the ones that must hold when the cold chain slips. The designer who stops at step 4, with a set that works when everything goes right, has not finished the design. Steps 5 and 6 are where the set earns its name, and step 7 is where it is kept honest after the product is on sale.
Quick check
In the worked design order, what happens if the set fails the test against a larger starting load?
Check your answer
Change the combination of hurdles, or increase the height of the hurdles. The set must be high enough that the anticipated numbers of micro-organisms cannot overcome it, and a larger load means the first set was not high enough.
Try it yourself: Pick three foods from your own kitchen: a jam or preserve, a smoked or salted food, and a chilled ready meal or chilled sauce. For each one, look at the label and the way it is stored, then list the hurdles you can see or infer: heat in its making, salt, sugar solids, acid, chilling, freezing, a sealed or modified atmosphere pack, or a preservative named on the label. Draw the three lists side by side and compare them. Which food has the most hurdles, which has the fewest, and which one would be in the most trouble if its main hurdle slipped, for example if the jam were made with much less sugar, or the chilled meal spent a day at room temperature? Write down your answer in one sentence per food. The exercise is observational, and it uses only what the label and the storage tell you: do not guess a pH or a water activity value that the label does not give.
Key ideas to carry forward
- The Hurdle effect, developed by Leistner and others, is that each preservative factor is a hurdle that micro-organisms must overcome, and Hurdle Technology designs a series of such hurdles to ensure microbiological safety.
- Traditional foods already used hurdles: smoked fish uses heat, drying, smoke chemicals, salt, chilling and modified atmosphere packing, and jam uses heat, high solids with low water activity, and high acidity.
- Vegetable fermentation shows hurdles in sequence: salt selects the starting microbes, they use up oxygen and lower the redox potential, lactic acid bacteria are favoured, their acid stabilises the product, and pasteurisation and packaging extend shelf life.
- Chilled ready meals need extra hurdles because chilling alone fails when the cold chain slips during production, distribution and storage.
- The catalogue in Table 6.1 sorts hurdles into physical, physicochemical and microbially derived types, including temperature, water activity, pH, preservatives, packaging, irradiation, pressure and electric fields.
- Hurdles can act simultaneously, synergistically or sequentially, and by combining them each individual technique can be kept comparatively low to protect quality while the set has a high impact on microbes.
- The same hurdles that preserve a food when it is properly prepared can be overcome by a larger initial population of micro-organisms, for example when raw materials are not adequately cleaned.
- The same hurdles can be inadequate for a richer food, because more nutrients and vitamins support microbial growth, and then a different combination is needed or the hurdle heights must be increased.
- Hurdles also improve quality and economic properties, for example the weight of water that can be added to a food consistent with its microbial stability.
- Hurdle technology is paired with HACCP in process design, so the hurdles and the checks on them are designed together.
- The extract gives no numeric height for any hurdle, no pH, water activity, salt, temperature or time value, so the worked design order in this unit carries no numbers and must be completed with data for the specific food.
Glossary
Hurdle
One preservative factor in a food that micro-organisms must overcome, such as chilling, low pH or salt. Food tech example: low water activity as one hurdle in a jam, acting with heat and acid.
Hurdle effect
The idea, developed by Leistner and others, that each preservative factor is a hurdle microbes must get over, and that the set of hurdles together keeps a food safe. Food tech example: a smoked fish held by heat, drying, smoke chemicals, salt and chilling together.
Hurdle Technology
The use of an understanding of hurdle interactions to design a series of hurdles that ensure microbiological safety. Food tech example: designing a chilled ready meal with chilling plus acid, low water activity and a modified atmosphere pack. Also called combined processes, combination preservation or combination techniques.
Water activity (aw)
A measure of the water in a food that is available for microbes to use, lowered by drying or by a high solids content. Food tech example: a jam with a high solids content and a reduced water activity that microbes cannot grow in easily.
Redox potential (Eh)
A measure of whether conditions in a food favour oxidation or reduction, lowered when oxygen is used up. Food tech example: the brine in vegetable fermentation, where the redox potential falls as the starting microbes use up the oxygen.
Modified atmosphere
A pack atmosphere changed from ordinary air to slow microbial growth and extend shelf life. Food tech example: a smoked fish packed in a modified atmosphere as an extra hurdle after chilling.
Preservative
A chemical factor added to a food to stop or slow microbial growth. Food tech example: a chemical preservative as one of the main hurdles in the Figure 1.19 example, acting with low water activity.
Competitive flora
Microbes that compete with spoilage or pathogenic microbes for food and space, and so hold them back. Food tech example: the lactic acid bacteria favoured in vegetable fermentation, which acidify the product and stabilise it.
Protective culture
A culture of microbes added to a food on purpose to protect it, by competing with or inhibiting unwanted microbes. Food tech example: a protective culture listed among the microbially derived hurdles in Table 6.1.
Bacteriocin
A substance made by a microbe that inhibits other microbes, listed among the microbially derived hurdles. Food tech example: a bacteriocin as a hurdle in a food, acting with low pH and chilling. Bacteriocins are covered in full in Unit 7.
Synergistic effect
A combined effect that is greater than the sum of the separate effects of the hurdles acting alone. Food tech example: irradiation with modified atmosphere packaging in Unit 5, where a lower radiation dose achieves the same effect.
HACCP
A system for watching a food process and checking that the safety factors in it are actually in place, batch after batch. Food tech example: HACCP paired with Hurdle Technology in process design, so each hurdle is checked as the food is made.
Initial microbial load
The numbers and types of micro-organisms present in a food at the start of processing, which the hurdle set must be high enough to overcome. Food tech example: a larger initial load on poorly cleaned raw materials overcoming hurdles that held on a clean batch.
References
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, Woodhead Publishing. Chapter 1, section 1.8.2, Hurdle technology, Table 1.17 and Figure 1.19, and Chapter 9, introduction, on minimal processing and the Hurdle concept.
Unit 7: Biopreservation: Friendly Microbes and Natural Antimicrobials
Note
Unit 7: Biopreservation: Friendly Microbes and Natural Antimicrobials
A cheese ripens for months without spoiling, a fermented sausage keeps without a chemical preservative, and a pot of yoghurt holds back the microbes that would ruin milk in a day. In each case the guard is alive: a microbe, or something a microbe made. This unit looks at how friendly microbes and natural antimicrobials protect food, and where their limits lie.
Questions to think about
- If microbes cause spoilage and food poisoning, how can adding more microbes make food safer?
- What is a bacteriocin, and why does one made by a cheese culture stop some microbes but not others?
- Why would a maker choose nisin made inside the cheese by a living culture instead of adding nisin as a powder?
- Which natural antimicrobials come from plants, from milk, and from eggs, and what does each one do?
- Why is biopreservation usually one hurdle among several, and not a single answer on its own?
7.1 What is biopreservation
Biopreservation is the use of living microbes, or the products those microbes make, to keep food safe and to slow spoilage, instead of relying on chemical preservatives. The idea is old even though the name is new: people have fermented milk, meat, vegetables and cereals for thousands of years, and the microbes doing the fermenting were already protecting the food while they changed its flavour and texture. The books on this subject describe lactic acid bacteria as having played an essential role in the preservation of food raw materials, and as having contributed to the nutritional, organoleptic and health properties of human food products and animal feed.
The tools of biopreservation fall into four groups, and this unit takes them one at a time. First, bacteriocins: antimicrobial proteins made by bacteria, with nisin as the best known example. Second, protective cultures: living cultures added to food that outgrow or outcompete spoilage microbes and pathogens. Third, natural antimicrobials from plants and animals: plant essential oils, organic acids, lysozyme and lactoferrin. Fourth, bacteriophages: viruses that attack bacteria, named in the books as a strategy against Listeria and Salmonella.
Biopreservation sits inside the wider subject of decontamination of fresh and minimally processed produce. The book edited by Gómez-López gives the first systematic view of the different types of decontaminants for fresh and minimally processed produce, and it places biological strategies beside physical methods and combinations through hurdle technology. The biological strategies it lists are bacteriophages, protective cultures, bacteriocins and quorum sensing. Ray and Bhunia give the same subject a chapter of its own, Chapter 16, "Food Biopreservatives of Microbial Origin", and a chapter on starter cultures and bacteriophages, Chapter 13. Ohlsson and Bengtsson cover natural food preservatives in Chapter 6 of their book on minimal processing, and Rahman covers natural antimicrobials in Chapter 10 of the Handbook of Food Preservation.
One point matters from the start: biopreservation is not a single method with a single dose. It is a family of living tools, and each one works in its own way, against its own set of microbes, in its own foods. That is why this unit names each tool, its source and its target, and says plainly where the authorised sources give no number at all.
Quick check
Name the four groups of biopreservation tools covered in this unit.
Check your answer
Bacteriocins, protective cultures, natural antimicrobials from plants and animals, and bacteriophages.
7.2 Bacteriocins: antimicrobial proteins made by bacteria
A bacteriocin is a naturally produced peptide that inhibits other micro-organisms, similar in effect to antibiotics. That is the definition given in Fellows, in a footnote to his chapter on fermentation and enzyme technology. The word peptide matters: a bacteriocin is a small protein-like molecule made by a bacterium, and it acts against other bacteria, not against the bacterium that made it.
Several lactic acid bacteria make bacteriocins. Fellows names three genera: Leuconostoc species, Lactobacillus species and Pediococcus species. These are the same groups of bacteria that ferment milk, vegetables and meats, so a bacteriocin can be made inside the food during its normal fermentation, by a culture that is already part of the process.
How a bacteriocin stops another bacterium is covered in the book edited by Konings and others, Lactic Acid Bacteria: Genetics, Metabolism and Applications, which includes a chapter on the mechanism of membrane insertion and pore formation. In plain terms, the mechanism described there is one in which the bacteriocin inserts into the membrane of the target bacterium and forms a pore in it. The membrane is the skin of the bacterial cell, and a pore in it lets the cell leak and fail. That is the mechanism as the chapter title presents it: membrane insertion and pore formation.
Bacteriocins are covered as a biological decontamination strategy in the Gómez-López book, at page 317, under "Biological decontamination strategies", page 283. Ray and Bhunia cover them in Chapter 16, "Food Biopreservatives of Microbial Origin", page 175. The same authors' book also has a chapter on the applications of bacteriocin-producing lactic acid bacteria and their bacteriocins, and a chapter on developing applications for lactococcal bacteriocins, in the Konings book at pages 333 to 335. Zeuthen and Bogh-Sorensen include chapters on bacteriocins and on antimicrobial enzymes in Food Preservation Techniques.
Two cautions belong here. First, the research pass behind this unit could not read the full text of those chapters in a readable Google Books copy: only the contents lists and descriptions were visible. So the classification of bacteriocins, the full list of which bacteria produce which bacteriocin, and the spectrum of activity of each one are not given in this unit, because they were not verified from a readable page. Second, no dose or concentration for any bacteriocin was verified in a readable Google Books page, so this unit gives none. Both gaps are listed again in section 7.9.
Quick check
What is a bacteriocin, in the words of the Fellows footnote, and which three genera of lactic acid bacteria does Fellows name as producers?
Check your answer
A naturally produced peptide that inhibits other micro-organisms, similar in effect to antibiotics. The three genera named are Leuconostoc, Lactobacillus and Pediococcus.
7.3 Nisin: the best known bacteriocin
Nisin is the best known bacteriocin in food use, and it is the one the Fellows passage describes in full. It is made by Lactococcus lactis, a lactic acid bacterium used as a starter culture in cheese making. The passage is worth following step by step, because it shows how one bacteriocin moves from a culture in a vat to a set of named foods and named microbes.
Nisin prevents the growth of Clostridium tyrobutyricum, and in doing so it prevents off-flavour development and "blowing" of Swiss-type cheese during ripening. Blowing is the swelling of the cheese by gas made inside it, and off-flavour is the bad taste that comes with the growth of that microbe. By stopping the microbe, nisin protects both the flavour and the shape of the cheese while it ripens.
Nisin is also effective against Listeria monocytogenes, a potentially dangerous food poisoning micro-organism. In the past nisin was added to cultures, but the passage says that its production by Lactococcus lactis is a cheaper and more effective method of removing Listeria monocytogenes from cheese. That is a practical point about how the bacteriocin is delivered: the living culture makes it inside the food, during the normal making of the cheese, instead of the maker buying nisin and adding it in.
Lactococcus lactis is permitted for use in more than 45 countries, according to the passage. The applications it names for inhibiting the growth of Clostridium botulinum are processed cheese, other dairy products, processed vegetables, soups, sauces and beer. Clostridium botulinum is the microbe behind botulism, so this is a safety use, not only a quality use.
The passage gives one more use for nisin made in the food by the living culture: natural production of nisin may be used to reduce or avoid chemical preservatives such as nitrate, sorbic acid and benzoic acid. It also says nisin may be used to control the quality of wines. The same idea appears in fermented meat, where Pediococcus acidilactici has the potential to inhibit spoilage bacteria and thus reduce the need for nitrate addition. In both cases the bacteriocin takes over part of the job that a chemical preservative used to do.
Nisin is indexed in several of the books used for this subject: in Ohlsson and Bengtsson, in Ray and Bhunia, in Gómez-López, and in Konings and others. Coultate gives it a section of its own, "Nisin and Natamycin", at page 316 of Food: The Chemistry of Its Components. But the research pass could not read the full text of those sections in a readable Google Books copy, so this unit takes its facts about nisin from the Fellows passage alone: which microbe makes it, which foods use it, which microbes it stops, and the chemical preservatives it can help to reduce or avoid.
Table 7.1: Nisin: who makes it, what it stops, and where it is used
| Point | What the Fellows passage says |
|---|---|
| Made by | Lactococcus lactis, a lactic acid bacterium used as a starter culture |
| Stops in Swiss-type cheese | Clostridium tyrobutyricum, preventing off-flavour and "blowing" during ripening |
| Stops in cheese | Listeria monocytogenes, a food poisoning micro-organism |
| Stops in named foods | Clostridium botulinum in processed cheese, other dairy products, processed vegetables, soups, sauces and beer |
| Chemical preservatives it can help reduce or avoid | Nitrate, sorbic acid and benzoic acid |
| Other uses named | Control of the quality of wines; Lactococcus lactis permitted for use in more than 45 countries |
Table 7.1: Nisin facts from the Fellows passage. No dose, concentration or permitted level for nisin was verified in the authorised sources, so none is given here.
🤔 Pause and think: a cheese maker can add nisin as a powder, or grow Lactococcus lactis in the cheese and let it make nisin there. The passage says the second way is cheaper and more effective for Listeria monocytogenes. Why might making the bacteriocin inside the food, during the normal process, work better than adding it from outside?
Quick check
Which microbe makes nisin, and which two microbes does the Fellows passage name as stopped by it in cheese?
Check your answer
Lactococcus lactis makes nisin. The passage names Clostridium tyrobutyricum, stopped in Swiss-type cheese during ripening, and Listeria monocytogenes, stopped in cheese.
7.4 Protective cultures: living guards in the food
A protective culture is a culture added to food that outgrows or outcompetes spoilage microbes and pathogens. It is a living guard, not a chemical one: it grows in the food, takes up the space and the nutrients, makes acid and other inhibitory products, and leaves less room for the unwanted microbes to grow.
Protective cultures are covered as a biological decontamination strategy in the Gómez-López book, at page 297, under "Biological decontamination strategies", page 283. Ray and Bhunia cover starter cultures in Chapter 13 of Fundamental Food Microbiology, and Adams and Moss cover the antimicrobial activity of lactic acid bacteria in section 9.4.1 of Food Microbiology, page 260.
The link with starter cultures is close. A starter culture is the culture added to start a fermentation, and it already protects the food as it ferments: it drops the pH, makes inhibitory products, and outgrows the microbes that were there first. A protective culture is the same idea used with protection as the aim, in foods where the culture may or may not be the one that ferments the product. The Fellows passage shows the same pattern in ordinary fermentation: in some fermentations the natural flora are enough to reduce the pH rapidly and to prevent the growth of undesirable micro-organisms, and in others a prepared inoculum is used to do the same job faster and more reliably.
Developments in biotechnology have widened what a lactic acid culture can do in a food. Fellows notes that lactic acid bacteria have been produced that also have stabilising and viscosity-forming properties, and that these are used in a wide variety of fermented milks, dressings and breads to reduce or avoid the use of synthetic stabilisers and emulsifiers. That is a second kind of protection: not against microbes, but against the loss of texture that would otherwise need a synthetic additive to correct.
What the sources do not give, and this unit does not invent, is the detail of which species or strains are used as protective cultures, how they are applied to a food, which pathogens each one targets, or what their limits are. Those details sit in the Gómez-López chapter at page 297 and in the Adams and Moss section at page 260, and they were not readable in the Google Books pass behind this unit. They are listed as not yet known in section 7.9.
The biopreservation toolkit: four groups, one aim
Antimicrobial proteins made by bacteria
Example: nisin from Lactococcus lactis
Living cultures that outgrow spoilage and pathogens
Example: lactic acid bacteria in fermented foods
Plant oils, organic acids, lysozyme, lactoferrin
Example: essential oils, lactic acid, egg white lysozyme
Viruses that attack bacteria
Named against Listeria and Salmonella
Four groups, not four separate answers. In practice they are combined, and combined with other hurdles.
Figure 7.1: The four groups of biopreservation tools. Drawn from the biological decontamination strategies listed in Gómez-López, Decontamination of Fresh and Minimally Processed Produce, Wiley, 2012, page 283, and from the Fellows passage on nisin.
7.5 Natural antimicrobials: plants, acids, milk and eggs
Natural antimicrobials are substances from plants and animals that slow or stop microbes, and that a maker can use in place of a synthetic chemical preservative. This section takes them in four sets: plant essential oils, organic acids, lysozyme and lactoferrin. For each set the unit says what the sources name, and where they stop.
7.5.1 Plant essential oils
Essential oils are covered for the treatment of fruit and vegetables in the Gómez-López book, at page 225. The common terms index of that book lists carvacrol and essential oils, and lists Listeria monocytogenes, Escherichia coli O157:H7 and Salmonella enterica among the organisms discussed in the book. The Handbook of Essential Oils, edited by Baser and Buchbauer, covers the biological activities of essential oils in Chapter 9, page 235, and their in vitro antimicrobial activities in Chapter 12, page 353. Its common terms index lists carvacrol, eugenol, limonene, linalool, menthol and oregano.
Those six names are the plant compounds this unit can list from the authorised sources: carvacrol, eugenol, limonene, linalool, menthol and oregano. They are the volatile, strong smelling compounds of herbs and spices, and the books treat them as antimicrobial agents. What the sources do not give in a readable page is which plant extract is used in which food, at what amount, and with what effect on flavour. A strong smelling oil that kills microbes may also change the taste of the food, and that trade between antimicrobial effect and flavour is one of the practical questions a maker must answer. No concentration or dose for any essential oil was verified in a readable Google Books page, so none is given here.
7.5.2 Organic acids
Organic acids are covered by Ray and Bhunia in Chapter 35, "Control by Low pH and Organic Acids", page 391, and by Adams and Moss in section 4.5.1, "Organic Acids and Esters", page 89. A whole book is given to the subject: Organic Acids and Food Preservation, by Theron and Lues, whose project is described as "Organic Acids as Antimicrobials in Food Preservation".
Lactic acid is the organic acid named in this unit, because it is the acid made by lactic acid bacteria during fermentation, and it is the acid behind the rapid pH drop that the Fellows passage describes as preventing the growth of undesirable micro-organisms. Other organic acids exist and are covered in the chapters named above, but the research pass did not verify a readable list of them with their food uses, so this unit does not list them by name. No concentration or permitted level for any organic acid was verified in a readable Google Books page, so none is given here.
7.5.3 Lysozyme
Lysozyme is indexed in Ohlsson and Bengtsson, Chapter 6, "Natural food preservatives", page 124, beside lactoferrin, bacteriocins, nisin and essential oils. It is also an egg white protein, indexed in the Handbook of Egg Science and Technology, edited by Mine and others. That is what the authorised sources establish: lysozyme is a natural antimicrobial, it sits in the natural preservatives chapter, and one of its sources is egg white.
How lysozyme works was not verified in a readable Google Books page in the research pass, so this unit does not describe its mechanism. Its dose, its food uses and its limits were not verified either, so none are given. The chapter where the detail sits is Ohlsson and Bengtsson, Chapter 6, page 124, and it needs a readable copy before any of those facts can be written down.
7.5.4 Lactoferrin
Lactoferrin is the one natural antimicrobial in this unit whose action is described in the sources in plain words. It is indexed in Ohlsson and Bengtsson, Chapter 6, "Natural food preservatives", page 124, and it has a book of its own: Lactoferrin: Natural, Multifunctional, Antimicrobial, by Narian Naidu, CRC Press, 2000. The publisher description of that book, read on its Google Books page, says that lactoferrin, when activated, functions as a potent antimicrobial intervention. It protects food in three ways: by removing harmful bacteria from the surface, by starving bacteria before they can multiply and produce harmful toxins, and by preventing bacteria from re-attaching to food surfaces.
The same description calls the approach "microbial blocking technology to protect foods from harmful microbes" and describes lactoferrin as a naturally occurring microbial blocking agent, used as an effective food antimicrobial intervention. In plain terms, lactoferrin does not only kill bacteria where they sit: it clears them from the surface, denies them the food they need to grow, and stops them from settling back onto the food. That three part action is the fullest description of any natural antimicrobial in the authorised sources for this unit.
Even so, no dose or concentration for lactoferrin was verified in a readable Google Books page, and no named food use was verified, so neither is given here.
Table 7.2: Natural antimicrobials named in the authorised sources
| Set | Named in the sources | What the sources say it does |
|---|---|---|
| Plant essential oils | Carvacrol, eugenol, limonene, linalool, menthol, oregano | Antimicrobial activity, covered in Gómez-López page 225 and Baser and Buchbauer Chapters 9 and 12 |
| Organic acids | Lactic acid and others | Control by low pH and organic acids, Ray and Bhunia Chapter 35; lactic acid drops the pH during fermentation |
| Lysozyme | Egg white protein | Listed as a natural food preservative, Ohlsson and Bengtsson Chapter 6; mechanism not verified |
| Lactoferrin | Activated lactoferrin | Removes harmful bacteria from the surface, starves bacteria before they multiply and produce toxins, prevents bacteria re-attaching to food surfaces |
Table 7.2: Natural antimicrobials named in the authorised sources. No dose, concentration or permitted level for any of them was verified, so none is given.
Quick check
Name the three ways lactoferrin protects food, as given in the Naidu book description.
Check your answer
It removes harmful bacteria from the surface, it starves bacteria before they can multiply and produce harmful toxins, and it prevents bacteria from re-attaching to food surfaces.
7.6 Bacteriophages: viruses that attack bacteria
Bacteriophages, often shortened to phages, are viruses that attack bacteria. They are listed as a biological decontamination strategy in the Gómez-López book, under "Biological decontamination strategies", page 283, beside protective cultures, bacteriocins and quorum sensing. Ray and Bhunia cover them in Chapter 13, "Starter Cultures and Bacteriophages", page 135.
The research file names bacteriophages as a strategy against Listeria and Salmonella. That is the extent of what the authorised sources establish in this pass: phages are a named biological strategy, and the two target genera named with them are Listeria and Salmonella. No verified Google Books fact was found in this pass for how bacteriophages are applied to foods, which phage products target Listeria monocytogenes or Salmonella, any dose, any approval, or any limit. A search for bacteriophages, Listeria monocytogenes and a commercial product name returned only the Gómez-López book page, with no approval or product statement in the visible text.
So this unit names no commercial phage product and states no approval, because none was verified. A phage is a living tool with a narrow target: a phage that attacks one bacterium does not attack another, so a phage strategy must match the phage to the microbe, and that matching is part of the detail that needs a readable copy of the Gómez-López chapter from page 283 onward before it can be written down.
Quick check
Where are bacteriophages listed as a strategy, and which two target genera are named with them?
Check your answer
They are listed as a biological decontamination strategy in Gómez-López, page 283, and in Ray and Bhunia, Chapter 13. The two target genera named are Listeria and Salmonella.
7.7 Biopreservation inside hurdle technology
Biopreservation rarely stands alone. The books place it inside hurdle technology, the idea that a food is protected not by one strong barrier but by a set of smaller barriers, each one a hurdle the microbe must clear, which together stop it. The Gómez-López book gives hurdle technology principles applied in decontamination at page 417. Ray and Bhunia give it Chapter 40, "Control by a Combination of Methods: Hurdle Concept", page 429. Ohlsson and Bengtsson give it Chapter 7, "The hurdle concept", page 175. Unit 6 of this subject covers hurdle technology in full.
The fit is easy to see. A protective culture drops the pH, and a low pH is one hurdle. The same culture makes a bacteriocin such as nisin, and the bacteriocin is a second hurdle. Chilling is a third, packaging that keeps oxygen out is a fourth, and a mild heat step or a natural antimicrobial is a fifth. No single hurdle needs to be strong enough to kill everything on its own, because the microbe must clear all of them in a row, and each one weakens it for the next.
The flow below shows how a protective culture builds its hurdles inside a fermented food, step by step.
How a protective culture builds hurdles in a fermented food
Lactic acid bacteria go into the food
Starter or protective culture
↓
It outgrows spoilage microbes and pathogens
Space and nutrients taken up
↓
Lactic acid drops the pH
First hurdle in place
↓
Nisin and other bacteriocins attack target bacteria
Second hurdle in place
↓
Chill, packaging, mild heat, natural antimicrobials
Microbe must clear them all in a row
Each step adds a hurdle. No one step has to do the whole job.
Figure 7.2: A protective culture building hurdles in a fermented food, step by step. Drawn from the hurdle chapters in Gómez-López, page 417, Ray and Bhunia, Chapter 40, and Ohlsson and Bengtsson, Chapter 7, and from the Fellows passage on lactic acid bacteria and nisin.
The same frame explains why a biopreservation step can fail. If the culture does not grow, the pH does not fall and the bacteriocin is not made, so two hurdles vanish at once. If the food is stored warm, the chill hurdle vanishes. If the packaging leaks, the oxygen hurdle vanishes. Hurdle technology is a design task: the maker chooses a set of hurdles that together hold the food safe, and checks that each one is really in place.
7.8 Limits and safety
Biopreservation has real limits, and the honest way to state them is to separate what the sources say from what they do not.
First, a bacteriocin stops some microbes and not others. Nisin stops Clostridium tyrobutyricum, Listeria monocytogenes and Clostridium botulinum in the foods named in section 7.3, but the Fellows passage does not say it stops every spoilage microbe or every pathogen, and this unit does not claim that it does. A maker who relies on nisin alone, without checking which microbes are present, is guessing. The spectrum of activity of each bacteriocin, meaning which microbes it stops and which it does not, was not verified from a readable page, so it is listed as not yet known in section 7.9.
Second, a protective culture must grow to protect. If the food is too cold, too dry, too acid already, or stored in a way that stops the culture, the protection does not appear. The culture is alive, so its protection depends on the same conditions that let any microbe grow. The books do not give a verified list of those conditions for protective cultures in the readable pages, so this unit does not state them.
Third, natural antimicrobials from plants carry flavour with them. An essential oil is a strong smelling compound, and the amount that stops a microbe may be an amount the eater can taste. The books cover the antimicrobial activity of essential oils, but no verified food use with an amount was found in a readable page, so the balance between effect and flavour is an open question for the maker, not a settled number in this unit.
Fourth, safety approval is a separate question from antimicrobial effect. A substance can kill microbes in a laboratory test and still not be permitted in a food, or be permitted in one country and not in another, or be permitted in one food and not in another. The one permission fact the sources give is that Lactococcus lactis is permitted for use in more than 45 countries. No permitted level, dose or approval for nisin, for any essential oil, for lysozyme, for lactoferrin, or for any bacteriophage product was verified in a readable Google Books page, so this unit states none of them. A maker must check the rules of the country where the food will be sold, and the rules for that food, before using any of these tools.
Fifth, biopreservation does not replace hygiene, cold storage, or a sound process. A protective culture cannot undo a food that was already heavily contaminated, and a bacteriocin cannot fix a broken cold chain. The hurdle frame in section 7.7 is the guard against that mistake: biopreservation is one hurdle among several, and the other hurdles must be in place too.
7.9 What is not yet known from the authorised sources
This section states plainly what the authorised sources for this unit did not verify, so that no reader mistakes a gap for a fact.
- No dose, concentration, permitted level or log reduction was verified for any biopreservation tool in a readable Google Books page: not for nisin, not for any other bacteriocin, not for any protective culture, not for any essential oil, not for any organic acid, not for lysozyme, not for lactoferrin, and not for any bacteriophage. This unit gives no number of that kind anywhere.
- No product approval was verified for any bacteriophage product, and no commercial phage product is named in this unit for that reason.
- The definition of bacteriocins used here comes from the Fellows footnote. Their classification, the full list of which bacteria produce which bacteriocin, and the spectrum of activity of each one were not verified from a readable page.
- For nisin, the mechanism by which it works, beyond the general membrane insertion and pore formation mechanism covered in the Konings book, and any permitted level or dose, were not verified from a readable page. The nisin facts in this unit come from the Fellows passage alone.
- For protective cultures, the species or strains used, how they are applied, which pathogens each one targets, and their limits were not verified from a readable page.
- For essential oils, which plant extract is used in which food, at what amount, and with what effect on flavour were not verified from a readable page.
- For organic acids other than lactic acid, the named acids and their food uses were not verified from a readable page.
- For lysozyme, the mechanism, the dose, the food uses and the limits were not verified from a readable page.
- For lactoferrin, the dose and the named food uses were not verified from a readable page.
- For bacteriophages, how they are applied to foods, which products target Listeria or Salmonella, any dose, any approval and any limit were not verified from a readable page.
The chapter and page locations where those details sit are verified, and they are the place to look next: Gómez-López pages 283 to 328, Ray and Bhunia Chapter 16 page 175 and Chapter 13 page 135, Ohlsson and Bengtsson Chapter 6 page 124, Rahman Chapter 10 page 237, Coultate page 316, Konings and others pages 333 to 335, Adams and Moss pages 89 and 260, and Naidu 2000. Until a readable copy of those chapters is open and the page is recorded for each fact, the facts stay out of this unit.
Try it yourself: Buy two plain yoghurts from the same maker if you can, one with a short shelf life kept in the fridge and one long life yoghurt drink from the shelf. Read the labels and look for the live cultures named on the pot, and for any preservative named on either label. Then leave a spoonful of each in a small covered dish on the bench for a day, beside a spoonful of plain milk, and look and smell all three the next day. The milk should turn first, and the yoghurt should hold longer: the live culture that made the yoghurt is still guarding it, while the milk has no guard at all. Write down what you see and smell, and which label named a live culture.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Biopreservation uses living microbes, or the products those microbes make, to keep food safe and slow spoilage, instead of relying on chemical preservatives.
- A bacteriocin is a naturally produced peptide that inhibits other micro-organisms, similar in effect to antibiotics, and the mechanism covered in the Konings book is membrane insertion and pore formation.
- Nisin is made by Lactococcus lactis, and the Fellows passage names it against Clostridium tyrobutyricum in Swiss-type cheese, Listeria monocytogenes in cheese, and Clostridium botulinum in processed cheese, other dairy products, processed vegetables, soups, sauces and beer.
- Natural production of nisin by the living culture is cheaper and more effective than adding nisin, and it may reduce or avoid chemical preservatives such as nitrate, sorbic acid and benzoic acid.
- A protective culture is a culture added to food that outgrows or outcompetes spoilage microbes and pathogens, and it is covered in Gómez-López at page 297.
- Plant essential oils named in the sources are carvacrol, eugenol, limonene, linalool, menthol and oregano; the organic acid named is lactic acid; lysozyme is an egg white protein; lactoferrin removes harmful bacteria from the surface, starves bacteria before they multiply and produce toxins, and prevents bacteria re-attaching to food surfaces.
- Bacteriophages are a named biological strategy against Listeria and Salmonella, but no commercial product and no approval was verified, so none is named here.
- Biopreservation sits inside hurdle technology: it is one hurdle among several, and the food is safe because the microbe must clear them all in a row.
- No dose, concentration, permitted level, log reduction or product approval for any biopreservation tool was verified in the authorised sources, so this unit gives none of those numbers.
Glossary
Biopreservation
Using living microbes, or the products those microbes make, to keep food safe and slow spoilage, instead of relying on chemical preservatives. Food tech example: a cheese culture that makes nisin while the cheese ripens.
Bacteriocin
A naturally produced peptide that inhibits other micro-organisms, similar in effect to antibiotics. Food tech example: nisin, made by Lactococcus lactis in cheese.
Nisin
A bacteriocin made by Lactococcus lactis, used to stop Clostridium tyrobutyricum, Listeria monocytogenes and Clostridium botulinum in named foods. Food tech example: nisin made inside Swiss-type cheese during ripening, stopping blowing and off-flavour.
Lactococcus lactis
A lactic acid bacterium used as a starter culture, which makes the bacteriocin nisin. Food tech example: the starter culture in a cheese vat that makes nisin as the cheese is made.
Protective culture
A culture added to food that outgrows or outcompetes spoilage microbes and pathogens. Food tech example: lactic acid bacteria added to a fermented food so the unwanted microbes cannot get a hold.
Starter culture
The culture added to start a fermentation, which also protects the food as it ferments by dropping the pH and making inhibitory products. Food tech example: the culture added to milk to make yoghurt.
Essential oil
A volatile, strong smelling oil from a plant, with antimicrobial activity. Food tech example: carvacrol and oregano oil, covered for the treatment of fruit and vegetables.
Organic acid
An acid made by microbes or found in foods, used to control microbes by low pH. Food tech example: lactic acid made by lactic acid bacteria during fermentation, dropping the pH of the food.
Lysozyme
A natural antimicrobial protein, found in egg white, listed among natural food preservatives. Food tech example: lysozyme from egg white, indexed in the natural food preservatives chapter of Ohlsson and Bengtsson.
Lactoferrin
A naturally occurring antimicrobial agent that removes harmful bacteria from a surface, starves bacteria before they multiply and produce toxins, and prevents bacteria re-attaching to food surfaces. Food tech example: activated lactoferrin used as a microbial blocking agent on food surfaces.
Bacteriophage
A virus that attacks bacteria, used as a biological decontamination strategy. Food tech example: a bacteriophage named as a strategy against Listeria and Salmonella.
Hurdle technology
Protecting a food with a set of smaller barriers, each one a hurdle the microbe must clear, which together stop it. Food tech example: a protective culture dropping the pH, plus nisin, plus chilling, plus packaging, in one food.
Blowing
Swelling of cheese by gas made inside it during ripening, caused by the growth of a microbe such as Clostridium tyrobutyricum. Food tech example: Swiss-type cheese swelling during ripening when Clostridium tyrobutyricum grows.
Listeria monocytogenes
A food poisoning micro-organism that nisin is effective against, and a target of bacteriophage strategies. Food tech example: Listeria monocytogenes in cheese, stopped by nisin made by Lactococcus lactis.
References
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, Woodhead Publishing. Chapter on fermentation and enzyme technology: bacteriocins, nisin, Lactococcus lactis, Pediococcus acidilactici, and the reduction of nitrate, sorbic acid and benzoic acid.
- Ray, B. and Bhunia, A., Fundamental Food Microbiology, 4th edition, CRC Press, 2007. Chapter 16, "Food Biopreservatives of Microbial Origin", page 175; Chapter 13, "Starter Cultures and Bacteriophages", page 135; Chapter 35, "Control by Low pH and Organic Acids", page 391; Chapter 37, "Control by Antimicrobial Preservatives", page 403; Chapter 39, "Control by Novel Processing Technologies", page 417; Chapter 40, "Control by a Combination of Methods: Hurdle Concept", page 429.
- Gómez-López, V. M. (ed.), Decontamination of Fresh and Minimally Processed Produce, Wiley, 2012. "Biological decontamination strategies", page 283; "Protective cultures", page 297; "Bacteriocins", page 317; "Essential oils for the treatment of fruit and vegetables", page 225; "Hurdle technology principles applied in decontamination", page 417.
- Rahman, M. S. (ed.), Handbook of Food Preservation, 2nd edition, CRC Press, 2007. Chapter 10, "Natural Antimicrobials for Food Preservation", page 237; Chapter 11, "Antioxidants in Food Preservation", page 259.
- Ohlsson, T. and Bengtsson, N. (eds.), Minimal Processing Technologies in the Food Industries, Elsevier, 2002. Chapter 6, "Natural food preservatives", page 124; Chapter 7, "The hurdle concept", page 175.
- Konings, W. N., Kuipers, O. P. and Huis in 't Veld, J. H. J. (eds.), Lactic Acid Bacteria: Genetics, Metabolism and Applications, Springer, 1999. "Overview on applications for bacteriocin-producing lactic acid bacteria and their bacteriocins", page 333; "Developing applications for lactococcal bacteriocins", page 335; "mechanism of membrane insertion and pore formation", page 183.
- Naidu, N., Lactoferrin: Natural, Multifunctional, Antimicrobial, CRC Press, 2000. Publisher description on the Google Books page: lactoferrin removes harmful bacteria from the surface, starves bacteria before they multiply and produce toxins, and prevents bacteria re-attaching to food surfaces.
- Baser, K. H. C. and Buchbauer, G. (eds.), Handbook of Essential Oils: Science, Technology, and Applications, CRC Press, 2009. Chapter 9, "Biological Activities of Essential Oils", page 235; Chapter 12, "In Vitro Antimicrobial Activities of Essential Oils Monographed in the European Pharmacopoeia, 6th Edition", page 353.
- Adams, M. R. and Moss, M. O., Food Microbiology, New Age International, 2007. Section 9.4.1, "Antimicrobial Activity of Lactic Acid Bacteria", page 260; section 4.5.1, "Organic Acids and Esters", page 89.
- Coultate, T. P., Food: The Chemistry of Its Components, Royal Society of Chemistry, 2002. "Preservatives", page 304; "Nisin and Natamycin", page 316.
- Zeuthen, P. and Bogh-Sorensen, L. (eds.), Food Preservation Techniques, Elsevier, 2003. Chapters on natural antimicrobials, bacteriocins and antimicrobial enzymes.
- Theron, M. M. and Lues, J. F. R., Organic Acids and Food Preservation. Authors' project: "Organic Acids as Antimicrobials in Food Preservation".
- Mine, Y. and others (eds.), Handbook of Egg Science and Technology, CRC Press, 2023. Lysozyme indexed as an egg white protein.