GIFSQ ID: FTN-0037
Indigenous Foods of Nepal
Unit 1: Introduction of Indigenous Foods
Note
Unit 1: Introduction of Indigenous Foods
A question to start with
Imagine a kitchen with no refrigerator, no packet of yeast from a shop, and no printed recipe. The cook still makes food that keeps for months, tastes sour in exactly the right way, and feeds a family through a long winter. How does she do it? She uses knowledge passed down by watching, tasting, and doing, knowledge that lives in hands and memory rather than in books. That knowledge is the subject of this unit: the indigenous foods of Nepal.
Indigenous foods are foods that grew out of a place and its people. They use local crops, local animals, local water, local salt, and local microbes. They fit the climate, the altitude, the season, and the work people do. In Nepal, that means foods shaped by the Terai plains, the middle hills, and the high Himalaya, all in one country. A food that suits a hot, humid lowland kitchen may fail in a cold mountain village, and the other way round. Indigenous foods carry that local fit inside them.
What "indigenous food" means
An indigenous food is not simply an old food. It is a food whose recipe, raw material, method, and meaning all come from a community and its place. Four tests help you decide whether a food counts as indigenous:
- Local raw material: the main ingredient grows or is raised nearby. Soybean for kinema, mustard leaves for gundruk, millet for tongba, buffalo milk for dahi.
- Local method: the method uses tools and skills found in the community: sun drying, stone grinding, bamboo baskets, earthen pots, wood fire.
- Local microbes: fermentation is started by microbes already present on the raw material, on hands, on leaves, or in a previous batch, rather than by a bought starter culture.
- Local meaning: the food has a place in festivals, fasts, weddings, births, and daily meals. People know when it is eaten and why.
Try this thought experiment
Question: A packet of instant noodles is sold in every village shop in Nepal. Is it an indigenous food?
Think it through with the four tests. The raw material is factory made wheat flour and flavour powder, the method is industrial, the microbes play no part, and it has no festival or ritual place. It is a popular food in Nepal, but it is not an indigenous food. Popular and indigenous are different ideas.
A worked example: testing three foods against the four tests
Use the four tests as a scorecard. Give each food one mark for each test it passes, then read the total.
| Food | Local raw material | Local method | Local microbes | Local meaning | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gundruk | Mustard leaves from nearby fields | Sun wilting, hand squeezing, earthen pot | Lactic acid bacteria from the leaves | Winter soup, gift food | 4 of 4 |
| Selroti | Rice from local fields | Hand poured ring, fried in a pan | Yeasts and lactic acid bacteria in the batter | Tihar, weddings, guests | 4 of 4 |
| Factory biscuit | Wheat flour and oil from far away | Industrial oven, packing line | No microbes involved | None: eaten any day, anywhere | 0 of 4 |
The scorecard shows why the tests work as a set. Gundruk and selroti pass all four, so they are indigenous foods. The factory biscuit passes none, so it is not, even though it is sold in the same village shop. A food that passes three tests and fails one is worth arguing about in class: which test did it fail, and does that failure change what the food is? That argument is the point of the scorecard, and it is a better answer than a single yes or no.
Quick self-check: A factory makes gundruk from local leaves, in steel tanks, with a laboratory starter, and sells it in city shops. How many of the four tests does it pass?
Local raw material: yes. Local method: partly, the steps match the home method but the tools are industrial, so this test is half passed at best. Local microbes: no, the starter is a laboratory culture, not the microbes of the place. Local meaning: the name and the soup remain, but the festival and gift place is weaker. The honest score is about 2 of 4, which is why a factory gundruk is best called an industrial version of an indigenous food, not the same food.
Why Nepal has so many indigenous foods
Nepal packs many climates into a small area. Altitude rises from about 60 metres in the Terai to above 8,000 metres in the Himalaya. Temperature, rainfall, and the length of the growing season change with every few hundred metres of climb. No single crop or single preservation method works everywhere, so each community built its own answers.
Three forces shaped the food:
- Season: monsoon rain brings leafy greens in plenty, then winter brings scarcity. Drying and fermenting turn a short glut into food for months.
- Altitude: cold slows microbes, heat speeds them up. A ferment that takes two days in the Terai may take a week in the hills. Recipes quietly adjust time, salt, and warmth.
- Movement: traders, herders, and migrating families carried foods and methods across valleys. That is why similar fermented foods appear across the Himalaya with different names.
The big families of indigenous foods
You will meet these families again and again in this subject. Learn the map now, and every later unit will fit into it.
Fermented foods
Fermentation is the controlled action of microbes on food. Bacteria and yeasts change sugars into acids, alcohol, and flavour compounds. The acid or alcohol then protects the food from spoilage microbes. Gundruk, sinki, kinema, jand, and dahi all belong here. Fermentation is the single most important technology in this subject.
Dried and sun preserved foods
Drying removes water, and without water most microbes cannot grow. Masyaura (dried lentil nuggets), dried gundruk, and dried meat are examples. Sun, wind, and smoke do the drying work.
Beaten, puffed, and roasted grain foods
Chiura (beaten rice) and murai (puffed rice) change the shape of the grain so it cooks fast, stores well, and eats easily on a journey. No fermentation is needed, only heat and force.
Fried dough foods
Selroti is a ring of rice batter fried in oil. It keeps for days, travels well, and marks festivals. Frying drives out water and gives a crisp outside that protects the inside.
Fermented milk foods
Dahi, mahi (buttermilk), and traditional cheeses turn perishable milk into foods that keep longer and are easier to digest. Lactic acid bacteria do the main work.
THE FAMILIES OF INDIGENOUS FOODS
↓
↓
Use the diagram above as your map. Every process in this subject is one of the arrows in the middle box: a microbe, the sun, heat, or force changes a local raw material into a food that keeps.
Fermentation in one page
Fermentation deserves a short introduction here because it runs through Units 5 to 10. Three kinds of microbes matter most:
- Lactic acid bacteria: turn sugars into lactic acid. The acid drops the pH, and a low pH stops most spoilage and disease causing microbes. Dahi, gundruk, and sinki rely on them. The main reaction is simple: glucose changes to lactic acid, written as C₆H₁₂O₆ → 2 C₃H₆O₃.
- Yeasts: turn sugars into alcohol and carbon dioxide: C₆H₁₂O₆ → 2 C₂H₅OH + 2 CO₂. Jand, tongba, and raksi rely on yeasts. The CO₂ gives fizz and the alcohol gives preservation and warmth.
- Bacillus species: break down soybean protein in kinema, making ammonia (NH₃) and strong flavours. The smell is strong, and that is normal: it is a sign the right microbes are at work.
Salt, temperature, and time are the three controls the cook uses. Salt pulls water out of the raw material and favours salt tolerant lactic acid bacteria. Warmth speeds the microbes, cold slows them. Time lets acid build up until the food is safe and sour enough.
Quick self-check: Why does a ferment turn sour?
Lactic acid bacteria turn sugars into lactic acid. The acid lowers the pH, which we taste as sourness. The same acid also stops many spoilage microbes from growing, so sourness and safety grow together.
Quick self-check: What does salt do in gundruk?
Salt draws water out of the leaves, makes a brine, and favours lactic acid bacteria over spoilage microbes. It also firms the texture. Too little salt lets rot set in; too much salt stops the good bacteria as well.
How indigenous foods are learned and kept
Indigenous food knowledge is practical knowledge. It is learned by doing, not by reading a formula. A child watches a grandmother squeeze mustard leaves, pack them into a pot, and press them down until brine rises. The child learns the feel of the right squeeze, the smell of a good ferment, and the sound of rice hitting the right beat for chiura. That learning is exact, even though it is never written as a number.
This creates two strengths and one risk:
- Strength 1: the knowledge fits the place perfectly, because it was tested there for generations.
- Strength 2: it uses almost no outside input: sun, salt, fire, and local microbes.
- Risk: when young people move to cities and stop making the food, the knowledge can fade in one generation. Writing it down, as this subject does, is one way to slow that loss. But a written recipe can never fully replace the feel, smell, and taste learned at the elbow of a maker.
What food science adds
Food science does not replace traditional knowledge. It explains it, measures it, and helps keep it safe when the scale grows. Four things food science adds:
- Names for the microbes: knowing that Lactobacillus and Bacillus subtilis do the work lets a maker check a starter and spot a wrong ferment.
- Numbers for safety: pH, salt percentage, moisture, and temperature can be measured, so a batch can be checked rather than only tasted.
- Reasons for failures: a slimy gundruk, a bitter kinema, or a flat selroti each have a cause, and a cause can be fixed.
- Ways to scale up: a method that works in one earthen pot must still work in a hundred kilo batch, and that needs control of the same three factors: salt, temperature, and time.
The foods you will meet in this subject
Here is a first taste of the products that fill the later units, so the names are familiar before you study each one in detail:
- Kinema: fermented soybean, sticky and strong, eaten as a curry. You will meet it in Unit 5.
- Masyaura: dried lentil nuggets, stored for months and cooked into curry. Also Unit 5.
- Sukuti: dried meat, chewed as a snack or cooked into curry. Unit 6.
- Gundruk: fermented leafy greens, dried for winter soup. Unit 7.
- Sinki: fermented radish root, sharp and strong. Unit 7.
- Tama: fermented bamboo shoot, cooked before eating. Unit 7.
- Jand: a cloudy fermented cereal drink. Unit 8.
- Raksi: a clear distilled spirit made from jand. Unit 8.
- Tongba: fermented millet drunk warm from a shared vessel. Unit 8.
- Selroti: a ring of fried rice batter, made for festivals. Unit 9.
- Dahi: set fermented milk, eaten every day. Unit 10.
- Chhurpi: a hard, dried cheese of the high mountains. Unit 10.
- Chiura: beaten rice, eaten with dahi or curry. Unit 11.
- Murai: puffed rice, eaten as a light snack. Unit 11.
Notice the pattern: most of these foods are either fermented or dried, and many are both. Fermentation makes the flavour and the acid, drying makes the keeping quality. Together they are the two great tools of this subject, and almost every product is a combination of the two, plus heat.
A short history: how these foods began
No one knows the exact date when gundruk was first made, or who first fermented soybeans into kinema. These foods were not invented in a laboratory or written down at a single moment. They grew slowly, by trial and error, over many generations. A family that left cooked soybeans in a warm basket found they turned sticky and tasty, and they did it again. A family that packed wilted leaves into a pot found they turned sour and kept, and they did it again. The foods that worked were repeated, the foods that made people ill were dropped, and the recipes that survived are the ones that were both tasty and safe. That is why traditional knowledge deserves respect: it is the result of a long, slow experiment carried out by whole communities, not by one person in one year.
Trade and migration spread the foods. Traders carried dried foods across mountain passes because dried food is light and keeps. Herders carried chhurpi because it is hard and keeps. Families that moved to a new valley brought their recipes and adapted them to the new crops and the new climate. That is why the same idea appears under different names across the Himalaya: the idea travels, and the local version is shaped by local material.
Indigenous foods and nutrition
Indigenous foods are often nutritious, and it is worth saying why, without overstating the claim. Fermented foods carry live microbes, and they make minerals more available by reducing phytates. Dried legume foods carry protein and fibre. Leafy green ferments carry fibre and minerals from the leaves. Fermented milk carries protein, calcium, and live cultures. None of this makes any single food a medicine, and no traditional food should be sold with a medical claim unless that claim has been tested and proved. The honest statement is simpler: these foods are part of a varied diet, they use local crops, they keep without a fridge, and they have fed communities for generations. That is enough, and it is true.
Questions to think about
- Why do you think so many Nepali indigenous foods are sour, salty, or dried, rather than fresh and mild?
- Which indigenous foods from your own home fit the four tests above, and which fail one of them?
- If a food is made in a factory with the same recipe, is it still indigenous? What changes, and what stays the same?
Try it yourself: Map the foods of your kitchen
List five foods eaten in your home this week. For each one, write down the main raw material, where it came from, the method used, and whether microbes played a part. Sort them into indigenous and non indigenous using the four tests. Bring the list to your next class and compare it with a classmate from a different district: the differences are the geography of Nepal on a plate.
Practical note
The syllabus practical for this subject is preparation and quality tests of each product. In this unit, the practical is observation: visit a home or market maker, watch one indigenous food being made, and record the raw material, the method, the time, and the signs the maker uses to judge that it is ready. Do not change the recipe. Your job is to watch and record.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Indigenous foods use local raw materials, local methods, local microbes, and carry local meaning.
- Nepal's range of climates produced many different foods, because no single method fits every altitude and season.
- Fermentation, drying, puffing, and frying are the main ways these foods are made to keep.
- Salt, temperature, and time are the three controls on every ferment.
- Traditional knowledge is learned by doing; food science explains it, measures it, and helps it scale safely.
Glossary
Indigenous food
A food whose raw material, method, microbes, and meaning all come from a local community and its place. Food tech example: gundruk made from local mustard leaves, fermented in an earthen pot, is an indigenous food.
Fermentation
The controlled action of microbes on food, changing sugars into acids, alcohol, and flavour compounds. Food tech example: lactic acid bacteria ferment milk into dahi.
Lactic acid bacteria
Bacteria that turn sugars into lactic acid, lowering pH and preserving food. Food tech example: they sour gundruk and sinki.
Yeast
A single celled fungus that turns sugars into alcohol and CO₂. Food tech example: yeast ferments millet into jand.
pH
A measure of how acid or alkaline a food is; lower numbers mean more acid. Food tech example: dahi has a pH near 4.5, which stops many spoilage microbes.
Brine
Salty water formed when salt draws water out of a food. Food tech example: mustard leaves in gundruk sit in their own brine during fermentation.
Starter culture
Microbes added on purpose to start a fermentation. Food tech example: a spoon of old dahi starts a new batch of dahi.
Spoilage microbe
A microbe that makes food smell bad, change colour, or go slimy, without always causing disease. Food tech example: mould on poorly dried masyaura is spoilage.
Moisture content
The amount of water in a food, usually given as a percentage of its weight. Food tech example: dried gundruk must reach a low moisture content or it will mould in storage.
Terai
The flat lowland plains of southern Nepal, hot and humid. Food tech example: ferments run fast in the Terai because warmth speeds microbes.
Earthen pot
A pot made of fired clay, used for fermenting and storing foods. Food tech example: gundruk ferments in an earthen pot that keeps the leaves pressed under brine.
Preservation
Any method that keeps food safe and edible for longer, such as drying, fermenting, salting, or frying. Food tech example: sun drying preserves leafy greens as gundruk for the winter.
Kinema
A traditional fermented soybean food of eastern Nepal, with a sticky texture and strong smell. Food tech example: kinema is made by fermenting cooked soybeans with Bacillus species.
Gundruk
Fermented and dried leafy greens, usually mustard, radish, or cauliflower leaves. Food tech example: gundruk soup is a winter dish made from stored fermented leaves.
References
- Holzapfel, W. H., et al., Advances in Fermented Foods and Beverages, Woodhead Publishing, 2015.
- Bamforth, C. W., et al., Handbook of Food and Beverage Fermentation Technology, CRC Press, 2004.
- Adams, M. R. and Moss, M. O., Food Microbiology, Royal Society of Chemistry, 4th edition, 2018.
Unit 2: Importance of Indigenous Foods in Ethnic, Cultural, Religious, and Social Aspects
Note
Unit 2: Importance of Indigenous Foods in Ethnic, Cultural, Religious, and Social Aspects
A question to start with
Why does a family that can buy bread and biscuits still make selroti for Tihar, still serve gundruk soup when a guest arrives, and still offer jand at a wedding? The answer is not nutrition alone, and it is not price alone. The food is doing social work: it says who we are, which community we belong to, what we believe, and who we honour. This unit looks at that work, in four parts: ethnic, cultural, religious, and social.
Food is one of the clearest markers of identity. Language, dress, and music mark a community too, but food is the marker that is eaten every day, shared with guests, and carried to a new home when a family moves. Lose the food, and a part of the identity goes quiet.
Ethnic importance: food as identity
Nepal is home to many ethnic communities: Brahmin and Chhetri, Newar, Tamang, Gurung, Magar, Rai, Limbu, Sherpa, Tharu, Maithil, and many more. Each community has foods that belong to it in a strong sense. Kinema belongs most strongly to the Limbu and Rai communities of the east. Gundruk is made across the hills, but each community has its own leaf, its own salt, and its own sourness. Tongba is central to Limbu social life. Selroti is made across Nepal, yet its festival place is strongest in particular communities and households.
Three things make a food an ethnic marker:
- A recipe that is ours: the method is learned inside the community, and small differences in method mark one group from another. Two villages may both make gundruk, but the leaves, the wilting time, and the drying method differ, and people can taste the difference.
- A raw material tied to our land: millet in the hills, rice in the Terai, yak milk in the high mountains. The food proves a long relationship between a people and a place.
- A name in our language: kinema, gundruk, sinki, jand, tongba, selroti, chiura, dahi. The names themselves carry the community. When a food is renamed for a shop shelf, something is lost, even if the recipe stays the same.
Why this matters for food technology
A food technologist who only sees nutrients will miss why a community defends a recipe. If you change kinema to remove its strong smell, you may make it more acceptable to a stranger, but you have removed the very signal that tells a Limbu eater that it is kinema. Industrial versions must decide, honestly, what to keep: the flavour that marks identity, or the mildness that sells widely. There is no single right answer, but the choice must be made knowingly, and the community that owns the food should be part of the decision.
Quick self-check: Why can two villages both make gundruk and still taste different?
Because the leaves, the salt level, the wilting time, the pot, the temperature, and the drying method all differ. Each of those changes which microbes grow and how much acid forms, so the flavour differs even when the name is the same.
A worked example: three small changes, one lost food
Recipe drift is slow, so it is easy to miss. Take a village kinema and change one thing at a time, and watch what is lost at each step.
| Change made for the city market | What is lost | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| The strong smell is reduced by shortening the ferment | The savoury depth and the signal that tells a Limbu eater "this is kinema" | The food still looks like kinema, but it no longer tastes like the community version |
| The sticky texture is removed so the packet stays clean | The poly glutamic acid layer, which is the mark of a good Bacillus ferment | The buyer cannot tell a good ferment from a weak one by looking |
| The name stays, but the soybean comes from far away | The link between the food and the land and farmers who grew it | The income leaves the community, and the story on the packet is no longer true |
No single change kills the food. All three together leave a packet that carries the name and almost nothing else. The lesson for a technologist is to count the losses before approving a change, and to ask the community which losses are acceptable and which are not. A change that the community accepts is adaptation. A change made without asking is drift.
Quick self-check: A shop sells a mild, non sticky soybean curry under the name kinema. Has the recipe drifted, the name drifted, or both?
Both. The recipe drifted, because the ferment was shortened and the sticky texture was removed, and the name drifted, because the packet uses a community name for a product the community would not recognise as kinema.
Cultural importance: food as memory and season
Culture is the shared pattern of how a people live, and food carries the calendar of that pattern. Indigenous foods mark the seasons: fresh greens in the monsoon become gundruk for winter; rice harvest becomes chiura for travel and for gifts; millet harvest becomes jand for cold months. The food tells people what time of year it is, even before they look at a calendar.
Food also carries memory across generations. A grandmother's selroti is not only a fried ring: it is the taste of a childhood Tihar, the smell of a kitchen at dawn, the sound of oil in a pan. When a young person living in Kathmandu or abroad makes selroti, they are not only feeding themselves. They are practising belonging. This is why recipes travel with migrants: a food that can be made in a small flat kitchen keeps a family connected to a village they left.
Food carries knowledge of the land as well. Knowing which leaves ferment well, which millet makes the best jand, and which wood gives the best smoke for drying is ecological knowledge. It is a record of what grows where, when it is ready, and how it behaves. That record is stored in recipes, not in textbooks.
The food calendar
Think of the year as a circle of making and eating:
- Monsoon: leafy greens are plentiful. Leaves are wilted, packed, and fermented into gundruk and sinki.
- Harvest: rice and millet are threshed. Some grain is beaten into chiura, some puffed into murai, some kept for selroti batter.
- Winter: stored ferments and dried foods are eaten. Gundruk soup, kinema, and dried vegetables carry families through the lean months.
- Festivals: selroti, jand, raksi, and special snacks appear. The food marks the day as different from ordinary days.
THE YEAR OF INDIGENOUS FOODS
↓
↓
↓
The diagram shows the food year as a cycle, not a straight line. Each season's making feeds the next season's eating, and the festival foods close the circle.
Religious importance: food as offering and rule
Food and religion are tied together in Nepal in several ways. First, foods are offered to gods and ancestors. Selroti, fruits, rice, and fermented drinks appear in worship and in offerings. The offering is not only symbolic: the food that is offered is then shared and eaten, so the sacred and the social meet in one plate.
Second, religion sets rules about food. Fasting days change what is eaten: some fasts allow fruits and beaten rice but not cooked grain; some forbid certain foods entirely. Festival foods are often the foods that the rules allow on that day. A food technologist must understand that a recipe may be fixed by religion, not by taste. Changing an ingredient in a festival food can be a religious matter, not only a technical one.
Third, alcohol has a divided religious place. For some communities, jand and raksi are part of ritual and celebration, offered and shared at weddings and festivals. For others, alcohol is avoided on religious grounds. Both positions are respected, and a food business that sells fermented drinks must know which communities it serves and which it does not.
Fourth, purity rules shape who cooks, who serves, and who eats together. In some households, who may touch the cooking pot, or whether food cooked by one person may be eaten by another, follows caste and religious practice. These rules are social facts that a food business must respect. They affect packaging, serving, and marketing, and ignoring them causes real offence.
A caution for the technologist
When you read a recipe, ask whether any part of it is fixed by belief. If it is, record that fact and do not propose changing it without asking the community. Science can explain why a method is safe; it cannot decide whether a method is sacred. That decision belongs to the people who practise it.
Quick self-check: Give one example of food as an offering and one of food as a rule.
Offering: selroti and rice offered during Tihar worship and then shared. Rule: fasting days that allow chiura and fruit but not cooked rice. Both show food carrying religious meaning, not only nutrition.
Social importance: food as welcome, gift, and bond
Food is the main language of hospitality in Nepal. A guest is offered food and drink before business is discussed. Jand or tongba is offered to a guest in many hill and eastern communities; dahi and chiura are offered in others. Refusing the offer can be read as refusing friendship, so the food carries a social weight that a visitor must understand.
Food is also a gift. Chiura, selroti, gundruk, and dried foods travel as gifts between villages and to family in the city or abroad. A gift of food says: we remembered you, we made this with our hands, and we share our place with you. The gift economy keeps recipes alive, because a food that is gifted must be made well.
Food builds bonds inside a community as well. Making gundruk, selroti, or kinema is often shared work: women gather, wilt leaves, squeeze, pack, and dry together. Children learn by helping. The work itself is a social event, and the food that comes out of it tastes of that shared work. When production moves to a factory, that social making disappears, even if the product stays the same. That loss should be counted honestly when a food is industrialised.
Food, gender, and work
In many Nepali households, women hold the knowledge of indigenous foods: they know the ferment, the drying, the batter, and the timing. That knowledge is skilled work, and it is often unpaid and unrecorded. A food technology course that writes down these recipes should name that fact: the keepers of this knowledge are mostly women, and any commercial use of the knowledge should benefit them, not only the factory that scales it.
When foods travel: pride, change, and risk
Indigenous foods are now travelling: gundruk soup is served in Kathmandu restaurants, selroti is sold in city bakeries, kinema appears in shops. Travel brings pride and income, and that is good. It also brings three risks:
- Recipe drift: to suit city tastes, a maker may reduce salt, acid, or smell. Each change moves the food away from its community version. Small changes add up.
- Name drift: a food may be sold under a Nepali name but made by a method that no community would recognise. The name then misleads the buyer.
- Benefit drift: the income from a community food may go to a factory far from the community, while the community that kept the knowledge earns nothing. Fair sharing of benefits is part of the social question, not an afterthought.
A good food technologist asks, for every industrial version: who made this food first, who keeps the knowledge, and who gains from its sale? If the answer leaves out the community, the project is incomplete.
Food and language: the names carry the meaning
The names of indigenous foods are themselves a record. Kinema, gundruk, sinki, tama, jand, tongba, selroti, chiura, dahi, mahi: each name belongs to a language and a community, and each name tells an eater what to expect. A child who hears "gundruk" knows it will be sour, leafy, and cooked into soup. A child who hears "selroti" knows it will be a golden ring, crisp and sweet. When a food is renamed for a shop shelf in a language the maker does not speak, that instant recognition is lost, and the buyer must read a label to learn what the name once told them at once. Keeping the original name on a packet is therefore not only a matter of pride: it is a matter of information, and it helps the buyer know what they are buying.
Language also carries the method. Many recipes are remembered in words that describe an action: wilt, squeeze, pack, press, dry, beat, puff, fry. Those verbs are the recipe, and a student who learns the verbs learns the method. When you write a recipe in your practical record, write the verbs as well as the amounts, because the amounts alone will not teach the next maker how the food is made.
Food, health, and the body
Indigenous foods feed the body in ways that go beyond calories. Fermented foods carry live microbes that become part of the gut, and the acid in them helps the body absorb iron from a meal of lentils and greens. That matters in a country where anaemia is common: a sour food eaten with a meal can help the iron in that meal do its work. Dried legume foods carry protein and fibre that keep a person full through a long working day. Fermented milk carries calcium for bones and protein for growth, and it is easier to digest than fresh milk for people who struggle with lactose. These are real benefits, and they should be stated plainly, without turning any one food into a cure. A varied diet of these foods, with grain, vegetables, and protein together, is the health claim that the evidence supports.
Questions to think about
- Which food in your family marks a festival, and what would the festival lose if that food were replaced by a shop bought sweet?
- When a community food is sold in a city, what should stay the same and what may change? Who should decide?
- How would you record a recipe so that the taste, the method, and the meaning are all kept, not only the ingredient list?
Try it yourself: Interview a food keeper
Ask an older person in your family or neighbourhood to describe one indigenous food: when it is made, who makes it, what it is eaten with, and what would be wrong if it were missing from a festival. Write down their exact words for the "when" and "why" parts, not only the recipe. Compare your notes with a classmate who interviewed someone from a different community, and list three differences and three things that are the same.
Practical note
The syllabus practical is preparation and quality tests of each product. For this unit, the practical is a festival food record: choose one festival food, record its place in the festival, who prepares it, who eats it, and what rules govern it. Note any part of the method that is fixed by custom or belief and must not be changed.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Indigenous foods mark ethnic identity: recipe, raw material, and name all say who a community is.
- Foods carry the seasonal calendar: monsoon making feeds winter eating.
- Foods serve religion as offerings, as fasting rules, and as ritual drink or abstinence.
- Foods do social work: welcome, gift, shared labour, and bonding.
- Women hold much of this knowledge, and it is often unpaid and unrecorded.
- When a community food is industrialised, recipe, name, and benefit can all drift away from the community, and that drift must be watched.
Glossary
Ethnic identity
The sense of belonging to a community with shared language, custom, and history. Food tech example: kinema marks Limbu and Rai identity in eastern Nepal.
Culture
The shared pattern of how a people live: their customs, food, festivals, and beliefs. Food tech example: the gundruk making season is part of hill culture.
Ritual
A fixed set of actions done for religious or ceremonial reasons. Food tech example: offering selroti during Tihar worship is a ritual use of food.
Fasting
Going without some or all food for religious reasons for a set time. Food tech example: some fasts allow chiura and fruit but not cooked rice.
Hospitality
The practice of welcoming guests with food, drink, and care. Food tech example: offering tongba to a guest in a Limbu home is hospitality.
Festival food
A food made for a particular festival, not for everyday eating. Food tech example: selroti is a festival food for Tihar.
Gift economy
Sharing goods as gifts to build relationships, rather than selling them. Food tech example: sending home made gundruk to family in the city is a gift, not a sale.
Recipe drift
Slow change in a recipe as it is adapted for new tastes or new places. Food tech example: a city shop making kinema milder than the village version is recipe drift.
Migrant
A person who moves from one place to another to live or work. Food tech example: Nepali migrants abroad keep selroti making alive in their new homes.
Purity rule
A religious or social rule about what may be eaten, who may cook, or who may share food. Food tech example: some households follow rules about who may touch the cooking pot.
Community knowledge
Knowledge held by a community and passed down by practice, rather than written in books. Food tech example: the right squeeze for gundruk leaves is community knowledge.
Benefit sharing
Sharing the income or gain from a product with the community that kept the knowledge behind it. Food tech example: a fair deal would pay the kinema making community, not only the factory.
Seasonal food
A food tied to a season of growing, making, or eating. Food tech example: gundruk is a seasonal food, made when greens are plentiful.
Offering
Food or drink presented to a god or ancestor in worship. Food tech example: rice and selroti offered at a shrine are offerings.
References
- Anderson, M. M., The Festivals of Nepal, Rupa and Company, 1988.
- Holzapfel, W. H., et al., Advances in Fermented Foods and Beverages, Woodhead Publishing, 2015.
- Bamforth, C. W., et al., Handbook of Food and Beverage Fermentation Technology, CRC Press, 2004.
Unit 3: Scope of Traditional or Indigenous Foods and Industrial Production
Note
Unit 3: Scope of Traditional or Indigenous Foods and Industrial Production
A question to start with
A woman in a hill village makes two kilos of gundruk a year for her family. A factory in Kathmandu wants to make two thousand kilos a week for shops across the country. Is the factory product the same food? The leaves, salt, and microbes may be the same, but almost everything else has changed: the scale, the equipment, the workers, the packaging, the shelf life, and the customer. This unit is about that change: what indigenous foods are, how far they can reach, and what happens when they move from home to industry.
"Scope" here means two things. First, how wide is the world of traditional foods: how many foods, how many makers, how many eaters? Second, how far can each food go: can it be made in a factory, sold in a shop, and eaten far from home without losing what makes it itself?
The scope of traditional foods in Nepal
The scope is large, and it is mostly informal. Most indigenous food in Nepal is made at home or in a small local unit, eaten at home or sold in a nearby market, and never counted in official production figures. That makes the true scale hard to measure, but the shape is clear:
- Many foods, small batches: dozens of fermented, dried, puffed, and fried foods, each made in small amounts by many hands.
- Many makers, mostly women: home makers and small sellers hold the skill. Their work is real production, even though it rarely appears in industrial statistics.
- Local markets first: the first buyer is a neighbour, a local shop, or a weekly market. City and export markets come later, if at all.
- Seasonal supply: production follows the harvest. Gundruk is made when leaves are plentiful; chiura is made after the rice harvest. Supply is not steady through the year, and that is normal for these foods.
This informal scale is a strength and a limit. It is a strength because it needs little capital and uses local material. It is a limit because a home maker cannot supply a supermarket chain, meet a written specification every week, or keep a product on a shelf for months without a change in method.
Why industry is interested
Food companies look at indigenous foods for four reasons:
- Demand is already there: people know the taste and want it. A new product does not need to teach the customer what it is.
- Identity sells: buyers in cities and abroad want foods that taste of a place. A Nepali food with a Nepali name stands out on a shelf of similar products.
- Nutrition and health stories: fermented foods carry live cultures, and dried legume foods carry protein and fibre. These are honest selling points when they are measured, not only claimed.
- Local raw material: the crops already grow in Nepal. A factory that buys local soybean, millet, or mustard leaf supports local farmers and shortens its supply chain.
But interest is not the same as success. Many attempts to industrialise a traditional food fail, and they usually fail for the same reasons: the flavour changes, the texture changes, the price rises too high, or the shelf life is too short. This unit explains why each of those happens.
The journey from home to factory
Moving a food from home to factory means changing five things, one at a time or all at once. Learn these five, and you can judge any industrial plan.
1. Scale: from pot to tank
A home ferment uses an earthen pot of a few kilos. A factory uses a steel tank of hundreds of kilos. Heat moves differently in a big tank: the centre warms slower and cools slower than the edge. Salt mixes less evenly. Microbes that behaved in a small pot may behave differently in a big tank. The fix is not to copy the pot, but to control the same factors at the new scale: temperature, salt, time, and mixing. Pilot batches, made in steps of 10 kilos, then 50, then 200, catch the problems before a full run.
2. Raw material: from field to specification
A home maker picks leaves by feel and buys soybean from a known farmer. A factory needs a written specification: variety, size, moisture, and freedom from stones and mould. It needs the same quality every week, through the year. That means contracts with farmers, storage of raw material, and checks at intake. Without a specification, every batch will differ, and the customer will notice.
3. Microbes: from chance to culture
Home fermentation relies on microbes already present: on the leaves, in the air, in the pot, or in a previous batch. This is called back slopping when a little of the old batch starts the new one. It works, but the microbes differ each time, so the flavour differs too. A factory usually moves to a starter culture: a known mix of lactic acid bacteria or yeast, grown in a laboratory and added in a measured amount. The starter gives a steady flavour and a steady acid level. The trade is real: steadiness is gained, and some of the wild variety is lost. A good factory starter is chosen from the traditional microbes themselves, isolated from a good home batch, so the flavour stays close to the original.
4. Preservation and shelf life: from days to months
Home gundruk is dried in the sun and stored in a dry place. Home dahi is eaten in a day or two. A shop product must survive transport, a shelf, and a home fridge, often for weeks. That needs one or more of these: lower moisture, higher acid, pasteurisation, refrigeration, or packaging that keeps out air and moisture. Each of these changes flavour or texture a little. The maker must decide which change the food can bear. Dried gundruk can be packed dry and keep for months. Fresh kinema cannot, without refrigeration and a short life.
5. Packaging and labelling: from cloth to packet
A home food is carried in cloth, a basket, or an open pot. A factory food needs a packet that keeps out moisture, air, and light, and a label that states the name, ingredients, weight, date, and storage advice. The label must be honest: if the product is a factory version, it should not pretend to be home made. The packet must also fit the food: a crisp food needs a moisture barrier, a fermented food may need a packet that lets a little gas out, or it will swell.
HOME TO FACTORY: FIVE CHANGES
↓
↓
↓
↓
Follow the diagram from top to bottom when you judge an industrial plan. If a plan skips the middle steps, the product will drift from the home food it claims to be.
Quick self-check: Why is a starter culture steadier than wild fermentation?
A starter adds the same known microbes in the same amount every time, so the acid forms at the same speed and the flavour stays similar. Wild fermentation depends on whichever microbes happen to be present, so each batch can differ.
Which foods scale well, and which do not
Not every indigenous food is a good factory product. Judge each food on four questions:
| Question | Scales well if... | Scales badly if... |
|---|---|---|
| Does it keep? | It dries, or its acid is high | It is fresh, wet, and short lived |
| Is the flavour steady? | A starter gives the same flavour | The flavour depends on wild microbes |
| Is the raw material steady? | The crop stores or grows year round | The crop is seasonal and variable |
| Is the price right? | Local material is cheap and near | Material must be carried far and costs much |
On that test, dried gundruk, masyaura, chiura, murai, and selroti scale well: they are dry, they keep, and their methods transfer to machines. Fresh kinema, fresh dahi, and fresh tongba scale badly without a cold chain, because they are wet, live, and short lived. That does not mean they should never be sold: it means they need refrigeration, a short shelf life, and a nearby market.
A worked example: gundruk, home and factory
Home gundruk: mustard leaves are wilted, squeezed, packed in a pot, fermented for a few days, then dried in the sun. Factory gundruk: leaves are bought to specification, washed, wilted in a controlled room, salted at a measured percentage, fermented in a steel tank with a starter culture, dried in a hot air dryer to a set moisture, and packed in a moisture proof bag. The steps are the same in spirit, but every step now has a number: salt percent, temperature, time, pH, and final moisture. The numbers are what make the factory version repeatable.
A worked example: scaling up in pilot steps
The unit above says to scale up in steps of 10 kilos, then 50, then 200. Here is what that means in salt, using a recipe of 2 percent salt by weight of leaves. The rule is simple: salt in grams equals leaf weight in grams multiplied by 2, divided by 100.
| Pilot step | Leaves | Salt at 2 percent | What to check at this step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Step 1 | 10 kg | 200 g | Does the salt mix evenly? Does the pH fall on time? |
| Step 2 | 50 kg | 1 kg | Does the centre of the tank ferment as fast as the edge? |
| Step 3 | 200 kg | 4 kg | Does the dryer dry the whole load evenly, with no damp centre? |
The arithmetic is easy, and that is the point: at home, a maker judges salt by hand, and the hand is right most of the time. At 200 kilos, a hand cannot judge, and a 1 percent error means 2 kilos of salt too much or too little, which is enough to spoil the batch. Weighing is what lets the recipe survive the scale. The same table works for any salt level: at 3 percent, the 200 kilo batch needs 6 kilos of salt, because 200,000 grams multiplied by 3, divided by 100, equals 6,000 grams.
Quick self-check: A factory scales gundruk from 50 kilos to 200 kilos and keeps the salt at 2 percent. How much salt does the 200 kilo batch need, and what goes wrong if the maker keeps using the 1 kilo from the 50 kilo batch?
The 200 kilo batch needs 4 kilos of salt, because 200,000 grams times 2 divided by 100 equals 4,000 grams. Using only 1 kilo gives 0.5 percent salt, which is too little to favour lactic acid bacteria, so spoilage microbes can win and the batch can rot instead of fermenting.
Markets: local, national, export
Three markets, three different demands:
- Local market: the buyer knows the food, judges it by taste and price, and buys small amounts often. The product must taste like home.
- National market: the buyer may be from another community. The label must explain the food: what it is, how to cook it, and how to store it. A first time buyer needs instructions.
- Export market: the buyer is abroad, the food must survive a long journey, and it must meet the food law of the importing country. Labels, allergens (soybean in kinema is an allergen), and shelf life must be proved, not assumed. The Department of Food Technology and Quality Control (DFTQC) mandatory standards and the importing country's rules both apply, and the exporter must check both.
The human side of industrialisation
Industrial production changes who earns. A home maker who sold gundruk in a local market may lose that market to a factory packet, or she may gain a new role as a supplier of leaves, a trained worker, or a partner in a cooperative. Which outcome happens depends on how the business is set up. Cooperatives, where makers own a share of the processing unit, keep more of the gain in the community. Contract farming, where a factory buys leaves at a fair and written price, can also work. What fails is a plan that takes the recipe and leaves the makers behind.
Employment is also a scope question. A factory creates jobs: sorting, washing, packing, quality checking, driving, selling. But it also needs skills that a home maker may not have: reading a thermometer, writing a batch record, and following a hygiene plan. Training must be part of the plan, not an afterthought.
Risks and limits
Industrial production of traditional foods carries real risks, and a student should name them plainly:
- Loss of variety: a factory makes one version. Home versions differ by village, leaf, and season. One standard product can push many local versions out of the market.
- Loss of nutrition stories: a claim such as "probiotic" or "rich in iron" must be measured in a laboratory. An unmeasured claim misleads buyers and can break food law.
- Food safety failure at scale: a mistake in a home pot affects one family. A mistake in a factory tank affects thousands of buyers. That is why quality control, covered in Unit 4, grows more important as scale grows.
- Raw material pressure: if a factory buys all the mustard leaf or soybean in a district, local prices rise and home makers cannot afford their own raw material. Sourcing must be planned so the factory does not starve the home kitchen.
Quick self-check: Why is a factory mistake worse than a home mistake?
Because one factory batch reaches hundreds or thousands of buyers, while a home batch reaches one family. The same error in salt, temperature, or hygiene has a far wider effect at factory scale, so checking must be stricter.
Questions to think about
- Pick one food from this subject. Which of the five changes (scale, raw material, microbes, shelf life, packaging) would be hardest for it, and why?
- A factory wants to sell kinema in a city supermarket. What shelf life would you aim for, and what would you need to prove before you print it on the packet?
- Who should own the recipe when a community food becomes a factory product: the community, the factory, or both? How would you write that down fairly?
Try it yourself: Judge a factory plan
Choose one indigenous food and write a one page plan for making it in a factory: raw material specification, starter or wild ferment, preservation method, packaging, shelf life, and three quality checks. Then list three things that would be lost in moving from home to factory, and one way to reduce each loss. Keep the plan honest: if the food does not scale well, say so and name the market it does suit.
Practical note
The syllabus practical is preparation and quality tests of each product. For this unit, the practical is a scale up trial: make one product at home scale, then make the same product at ten times the amount, keeping salt percentage, time, and temperature the same. Record where the large batch behaved differently, and write down what you would change next time.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Most indigenous food production in Nepal is small, informal, seasonal, and held by home makers.
- Industry is interested because demand, identity, nutrition, and local material are already there.
- Moving home to factory changes scale, raw material, microbes, shelf life, and packaging.
- Dry foods scale well; fresh, wet, live foods need a cold chain and a short life.
- Local, national, and export markets demand different labels, instructions, and proof.
- Industrialisation must share benefits with the community that kept the knowledge, or it takes more than it gives.
Glossary
Scope
How wide something reaches: how many foods, makers, and markets it covers. Food tech example: the scope of gundruk covers home makers, local markets, and city shops.
Industrial production
Making food in a factory, in large batches, with machines, written procedures, and quality checks. Food tech example: factory packed chiura is industrial production.
Informal sector
Production and selling that happens outside formal factories and registered companies, such as home making and local markets. Food tech example: most gundruk is made and sold in the informal sector.
Specification
A written description of what a raw material or product must be: variety, size, moisture, salt, pH. Food tech example: a factory buys soybean to a written specification.
Starter culture
Known microbes added in a measured amount to start a fermentation. Food tech example: a lactic acid bacteria starter gives gundruk a steady sourness.
Back slopping
Starting a new ferment with a little of a previous batch. Food tech example: a spoon of old dahi starts new dahi, and a little old gundruk brine can start a new pot.
Pilot batch
A small trial batch made to test a method before full production. Food tech example: a 10 kilo pilot batch of gundruk tests salt and drying before a 500 kilo run.
Shelf life
The time a food stays safe and of good quality under stated storage. Food tech example: dried gundruk packed dry has a shelf life of months.
Cold chain
Keeping a food cold, without a break, from factory to shop to home. Food tech example: fresh kinema needs a cold chain to stay safe.
Allergen
A food part that causes an allergic reaction in some people and must be declared on a label. Food tech example: soybean in kinema is an allergen and must be named on the packet.
Cooperative
A business owned and run by its members, who share the gains. Food tech example: a women's cooperative that dries and packs gundruk shares the profit among its makers.
Contract farming
An agreement where a factory buys a crop from farmers at a set price and quality. Food tech example: a factory contracts farmers to grow mustard leaf for gundruk.
Moisture proof packaging
Packaging that stops water vapour passing in or out. Food tech example: dried chiura needs moisture proof packaging or it goes soft.
Value addition
Increasing the worth of a raw material by processing it. Food tech example: turning raw soybean into kinema is value addition.
Salt percentage
The weight of salt as a percentage of the weight of the food, found by dividing salt weight by food weight and multiplying by 100. Food tech example: 200 grams of salt in 10 kilos of leaves is 2 percent salt.
References
- Holzapfel, W. H., et al., Advances in Fermented Foods and Beverages, Woodhead Publishing, 2015.
- Bamforth, C. W., et al., Handbook of Food and Beverage Fermentation Technology, CRC Press, 2004.
- Adams, M. R. and Moss, M. O., Food Microbiology, Royal Society of Chemistry, 4th edition, 2018.
- Department of Food Technology and Quality Control, Mandatory Quality Standards for Food and Feed, Government of Nepal, 2082.
Unit 4: Quality Control in Traditional Foods
Note
Unit 4: Quality Control in Traditional Foods
A question to start with
Two pots of gundruk are made on the same day, from the same leaves, by the same hands. One turns out sour, firm, and fragrant. The other turns slimy, smells of rot, and is thrown away. What went wrong, and how could the maker have known earlier? That question is quality control: the habit of checking a food at each step, against a standard, so that a bad batch is caught early and a good batch can be repeated.
Quality control is not a factory invention. A home maker already does it: she smells the ferment, looks at the colour, tastes the sourness, and feels the texture. What food science adds is a written standard, a measurement, and a record, so the check does not depend on one person's memory on one day.
What quality means for a traditional food
Quality has four parts, and a food must pass all four to be a good product:
- Safety: the food must not make people ill. No harmful microbes, no toxins, no foreign matter, no harmful chemicals.
- Keeping quality: the food must stay good for its intended life: days for dahi, months for dried gundruk.
- Eating quality: colour, smell, taste, texture, and appearance must match what the buyer expects from that food.
- Honesty: the food must be what its name and label say it is, with the right ingredients and the right weight.
A food can be tasty and still fail quality: a delicious kinema with a harmful microbe is a failed product. A food can be safe and still fail: a gundruk that is safe but grey, slimy, and bitter will not be bought twice.
Hazards in traditional foods
A hazard is anything that can harm the eater. Learn the three kinds and the examples that matter for this subject:
Biological hazards
- Pathogens: disease causing microbes such as Salmonella, Staphylococcus aureus, and Escherichia coli. They enter through dirty hands, dirty water, dirty pots, or raw material that carries animal waste.
- Moulds and their toxins: moulds grow on damp dried foods and can make toxins. Aflatoxin from mould on damp grain or nuts is a serious example. A mouldy food must not be eaten, and scraping off the visible mould does not make it safe, because the toxin can spread inside.
- Wrong ferment microbes: if the right lactic acid bacteria do not grow fast enough, spoilage microbes take over and the food rots instead of fermenting.
Chemical hazards
- Too much salt or wrong additive: salt is a tool, but an excess harms health and a wrong chemical additive can be illegal.
- Pesticide residues: leaves and grain sprayed near harvest can carry residues. Washing helps, but the real control is at the farm: correct spraying and waiting time before harvest.
- Smoke and fire contaminants: foods dried over an open fire can pick up smoke compounds. Drying should use clean heat and good air flow where possible.
Physical hazards
- Stones, husk, hair, insects, pieces of pot: these enter during harvesting, threshing, drying on the ground, or poor handling. Sorting, sieving, and washing are the controls.
Quick self-check: Why is scraping mould off a food not enough?
Because some moulds make toxins that spread into the food beyond the visible mould. The food may look clean after scraping, but the toxin can still be present, so the food must be thrown away.
The three controls that matter most
Almost every traditional food in this subject is kept safe by three controls. If you control these three, most hazards are kept out.
1. Acidity: pH
Lactic acid bacteria make acid, and acid stops most pathogens. A pH below 4.6 stops the growth of Clostridium botulinum, a dangerous spore forming bacterium, and most other pathogens grow slowly or not at all below pH 4.5. Measure pH with pH paper or a pH meter, and record it. A ferment that has not reached its target pH in its target time is a warning sign: check the salt, the temperature, and the starter.
2. Salt
Salt pulls water out of food and out of microbes. A salt level of 2 to 3 percent by weight is common in vegetable ferments; the exact level depends on the food and must be written in the recipe. Weigh the salt, do not guess it by the handful. Too little salt lets spoilage win; too much salt stops the good bacteria and makes the food too salty to eat.
3. Water and moisture
Microbes need water to grow. Drying a food to a low moisture content stops them. Water activity, written a_w, measures the water that is free for microbes to use. Most bacteria need a_w above 0.90 to grow, and most moulds need a_w above 0.70. A dried food with a_w below 0.60 is stable at room temperature. The practical check is moisture content: dry the food until it is crisp and brittle, cool it before packing, and pack it dry, because warm food packed at once will sweat inside the packet and grow mould.
THE THREE CONTROLS
Use the diagram as a checklist. A batch that passes all three boxes is a batch you can trust; a batch that fails one box needs a decision before it is sold or eaten.
A worked example: three numbers from one batch
Quality control becomes real when it is worked with numbers. Take a batch of gundruk and dahi, and work the three checks below.
Salt by weighing. A maker ferments 10 kilos of mustard leaves at 2 percent salt. Salt needed equals 10,000 grams multiplied by 2, divided by 100, which is 200 grams. If the maker weighs 200 grams on a scale, the batch is right. If the maker adds salt by the handful, the batch may hold 120 grams or 300 grams, and neither can be checked later. The scale is the check.
Moisture by drying. A sample of dried gundruk weighs 100 grams. It is dried fully in an oven and then weighs 88 grams. The water lost is 100 minus 88, which is 12 grams, so the moisture content is 12 percent. A sample that dries from 100 grams to 95 grams holds only 5 percent moisture and will keep longer. The weighing tells the maker what feeling cannot: whether the centre of the batch is truly dry.
Acidity by titration. A 10 gram sample of dahi is titrated with 0.1 normal sodium hydroxide, and the titre is 9.0 millilitres. Titratable acidity as lactic acid equals the titre multiplied by the normality multiplied by 0.090, multiplied by 100, divided by the sample weight. Work it out: 9.0 times 0.1 times 0.090 times 100, divided by 10, equals 0.81 percent lactic acid. A second batch with a titre of 6.0 millilitres gives 0.54 percent, so it is less acid and milder. Two numbers, and the maker can say which batch is more sour and by how much, instead of guessing.
Quick self-check: A 10 gram sample of dahi needs 12.0 millilitres of 0.1 normal alkali to neutralise it. What is its titratable acidity as lactic acid?
12.0 times 0.1 times 0.090 times 100, divided by 10, equals 1.08 percent lactic acid. It is more acid than the 0.81 percent batch in the worked example, so it will taste sharper.
Hygiene: the base of all control
No ferment, however good, can fix dirty raw material or dirty hands. Hygiene is the base layer:
- Hands: wash with soap and clean water before handling food, and after touching anything dirty.
- Water: use clean, safe water for washing, brining, and cooking. Water that is not safe to drink is not safe for food.
- Pots and tools: wash pots, knives, and cloths, and dry them in the sun where possible. A pot that held a failed ferment must be cleaned and dried before reuse.
- Workplace: keep the making area clean, keep animals away from drying food, and dry food on a raised clean surface, not on bare ground where dust, insects, and animals can reach it.
- People: a person with diarrhoea, a skin infection, or a cold that causes coughing over food should not handle food for others that day.
Quality checks at each stage
Quality control is not one test at the end. It is a chain of small checks. The table below shows the chain for a fermented vegetable such as gundruk, and the same pattern fits the other foods in this subject.
| Stage | What to check | How to check | If it fails |
|---|---|---|---|
| Raw material | Fresh leaves, no rot, no mould | Look, smell, sort | Reject bad leaves |
| Washing | Dirt and insects removed | Wash in clean water, look | Wash again or reject |
| Wilting | Leaves soft, not rotten | Feel, look | Shorten or lengthen wilting |
| Salting | Salt weighed, mixed evenly | Weighing scale | Remix or remake |
| Fermentation | Sour smell, pH falling, no rot smell | Smell, pH paper or meter | Discard if rotten |
| Drying | Crisp, dry, no damp spots | Feel, moisture check | Dry longer |
| Packing | Dry packet, correct weight, label | Look, weigh, read label | Repack or relabel |
| Storage | Dry place, no insects, no damp | Look, smell | Move or discard |
The last column matters most. A check without a decision is only looking. Every check needs a rule written before the batch starts: what is accepted, what is fixed, and what is thrown away.
Quick self-check: At which stage would you catch stones in chiura rice?
At the raw material and sorting stage, before cooking. Stones are a physical hazard, and the control is sorting and sieving the grain before it is beaten or puffed.
Sensory checks: the human instrument
The senses are real measuring tools, and they must be trained, not only trusted. A trained checker can judge:
- Colour: gundruk should be olive green to brown, not black or grey. Dahi should be white to pale cream.
- Smell: a ferment should smell sour and clean, not putrid or like rotten eggs. Hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) smell is a warning of spoilage.
- Taste: sourness should be clean and even. Bitterness or a chemical taste is a fault.
- Texture: gundruk should be firm, not slimy. Selroti should be crisp outside and soft inside. Chiura should be thin and crisp, not thick and chewy.
- Appearance: no mould, no insects, no foreign matter, no swollen packet.
Sensory checks should be done by more than one person where possible, and the result should be written down in plain words. "Sour, clean smell, firm leaves" is a record. "Good" is not a record, because no one can repeat "good" next week.
Laboratory checks a small unit can use
A small producer does not need a full laboratory, but a few simple tests make a large difference:
- pH paper or meter: checks that a ferment has turned acid enough. This is the single most useful test in this subject.
- Salt by taste and by weighing: the real control is weighing the salt at the start. A salt test of the brine can confirm it.
- Moisture by drying: weigh a sample, dry it fully, weigh it again. The weight lost is water. This is the standard oven drying method.
- Acidity by titration: a measured amount of alkali neutralises the acid in a sample, and the amount used tells the acidity. This is a standard test for dahi and for vegetable ferments, and it is taught in food analysis courses.
- Microbial plate count: where a laboratory is available, a count of total bacteria, yeasts, moulds, and coliforms tells whether hygiene held. Coliforms in a finished ferment are a warning that dirty water or dirty hands were involved.
The DFTQC and the law
In Nepal, the Department of Food Technology and Quality Control (DFTQC) sets mandatory quality standards for foods, and the Food Act and its rules govern what may be sold. A producer who sells food must know the standard for that food: its composition, its limits, and its labelling rules. Where this subject names a Nepal specific limit or standard, it must be checked against the DFTQC mandatory standards and the Nepal Gazette, because standards are revised and a textbook number can go out of date. Never print a legal limit from memory. Check the current official source, and keep the reference.
Common faults and their causes
Learn this table, because it turns a failed batch into a lesson instead of a loss:
| Fault | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Slimy gundruk | Too little salt, too warm, dirty pot | Weigh salt, cool the ferment, clean the pot |
| Rotten smell | Spoilage microbes won, pH stayed high | Check pH early, use a starter or back slopping |
| Mould on dried food | Dried too slowly, packed damp, damp store | Dry faster with air flow, pack cool and dry |
| Bitter kinema | Over fermentation, wrong temperature | Shorten time, control temperature |
| Sour dahi too sharp | Too long, too warm | Shorten setting time, cool sooner |
| Flat selroti | Old batter, wrong rice, oil too cool | Fresh batter, correct rice, oil at right heat |
| Soft chiura | Rice too wet, beating too light | Dry paddy well, beat while hot |
Every fault has a cause in salt, temperature, time, water, or hygiene. Find the cause, change one thing, and test again. Changing three things at once teaches nothing, because you will not know which change worked.
Records: the memory of a good maker
A batch record is a short note written for each batch: date, raw material source, amounts, salt weight, temperature, time, pH, drying time, and the final check. It takes two minutes to write and it saves hours of guessing when a batch fails. It also proves, to a buyer or an inspector, that the maker checked the food. A maker who keeps records can repeat a good batch and avoid repeating a bad one. A maker who keeps no records must rely on luck.
Try it yourself: Write a batch record
Make a small batch of a fermented food at home or in class, such as a jar of fermented mustard leaves. Write a batch record: date, leaf weight, salt weight in grams, water source, pot type, room temperature, and the smell and pH on day 1, day 3, and day 5. At the end, write one sentence saying whether the batch passed and why. Keep the record: it is the start of a quality system.
Practical note
The syllabus practical is preparation and quality tests of each product. For this unit, the practical is a quality check run: take one traditional food, test its pH, its salt by weighing, its moisture by feel and by drying a sample, and its sensory quality with two checkers. Record every result and the decision for the batch.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Quality means safe, keeping, good to eat, and honest.
- Hazards are biological, chemical, and physical, and each has a control.
- Acid, salt, and water are the three controls that matter most in this subject.
- Hygiene is the base layer: no ferment can fix dirty hands, water, or pots.
- Check at each stage, decide at each stage, and write the result down.
- A fault has a cause in salt, temperature, time, water, or hygiene: find it, change one thing, and test again.
- Nepal specific limits must be checked against the current DFTQC standards and the Gazette, never printed from memory.
Glossary
Quality control
Checking a food against a standard at each stage, and deciding to accept, fix, or reject it. Food tech example: testing gundruk pH on day 3 is quality control.
Hazard
Anything in food that can harm the eater: a microbe, a toxin, a chemical, or a foreign object. Food tech example: aflatoxin in mouldy grain is a chemical hazard.
Pathogen
A microbe that causes disease. Food tech example: Salmonella in food handled with dirty hands is a pathogen.
Aflatoxin
A toxin made by some moulds on damp grain and nuts, harmful to health. Food tech example: mouldy groundnuts stored damp can carry aflatoxin.
Water activity (a_w)
A measure of the water in a food that microbes can use, from 0 to 1. Food tech example: dried gundruk with a_w below 0.60 does not support mould growth.
Titration
A laboratory test where a measured liquid is added until a reaction is complete, to find how much acid or alkali is present. Food tech example: titration finds the acidity of dahi.
Coliform
A group of bacteria used as a sign of dirty water or poor hygiene in food. Food tech example: coliforms in a finished ferment warn of dirty handling.
Sensory check
Judging food by colour, smell, taste, texture, and appearance. Food tech example: a trained checker smells gundruk for a clean sour note.
Batch record
A short written note for one batch: materials, amounts, conditions, checks, and the final decision. Food tech example: a gundruk batch record lists salt weight and pH on day 3.
Hygiene
Practices that keep food clean and free of harmful microbes: clean hands, water, tools, and workplace. Food tech example: washing hands with soap before packing selroti is hygiene.
Moisture content
The amount of water in a food as a percentage of its weight. Food tech example: chiura must reach a low moisture content to stay crisp.
DFTQC
The Department of Food Technology and Quality Control, the Nepal government body that sets mandatory food quality standards. Food tech example: a seller checks the DFTQC standard for a food before labelling it.
Spoilage
Change that makes food unpleasant or unfit to eat, such as sliminess, off smell, or mould, without always causing disease. Food tech example: slimy gundruk is spoilage.
Hydrogen sulfide (H₂S)
A gas with a rotten egg smell, made by some spoilage microbes. Food tech example: a rotten egg smell in a ferment warns of spoilage.
Titratable acidity
The total acid in a food, found by titration and given as a percentage, usually as lactic acid. Food tech example: a dahi with 0.81 percent titratable acidity is milder than one with 1.08 percent.
References
- Adams, M. R. and Moss, M. O., Food Microbiology, Royal Society of Chemistry, 4th edition, 2018.
- Department of Food Technology and Quality Control, Manual on Milk Safety, Quality and Hygiene, Government of Nepal.
- Department of Food Technology and Quality Control, Mandatory Quality Standards for Food and Feed, Government of Nepal, 2082.
- Bamforth, C. W., et al., Handbook of Food and Beverage Fermentation Technology, CRC Press, 2004.
Unit 5: Fermented Legume Products: Kinema, Masyaura, Tofu, Nutrela
Note
Unit 5: Fermented Legume Products: Kinema, Masyaura, Tofu, Nutrela
A question to start with
A soybean is hard, beany, and hard to digest when raw. A few days after cooking and fermenting, the same soybean is soft, sticky, strongly flavoured, and rich in protein that the body can use. What changed inside the bean? The answer is enzymes: protein cutting enzymes made by microbes break long protein chains into shorter pieces, and those pieces are easier to digest and full of flavour. This unit follows that change through four legume products: kinema, masyaura, tofu, and nutrela.
Legumes are seeds that grow in pods: soybean, lentil, chickpea, black gram, and their relatives. They are rich in protein, often 20 to 40 percent by dry weight, and they carry fibre, iron, and B vitamins. Their weakness is that raw legumes carry compounds that block digestion, such as trypsin inhibitors and phytates, and they cause gas. Cooking and fermentation both reduce those compounds, which is why almost every traditional legume food is cooked, fermented, or both.
Kinema: the fermented soybean
Kinema is the best known fermented legume food of eastern Nepal, made by the Limbu, Rai, and other communities. It is also made across the eastern Himalaya under different names. It is a whole soybean ferment: the beans stay whole, but they become soft, sticky, and strongly flavoured.
How kinema is made
- Clean and soak: soybeans are cleaned, washed, and soaked overnight. Soaking softens the bean and starts to remove compounds that block digestion.
- Cook: the beans are boiled until soft, usually for one to two hours. Cooking kills most microbes, softens the bean, and destroys heat sensitive trypsin inhibitors.
- Cool and inoculate: the cooked beans are cooled to a warm temperature and mixed with a small amount of previous kinema, or with ash, or with leaves that carry the right microbes. The key microbe is Bacillus subtilis and its relatives.
- Ferment: the beans are packed loosely in a bamboo basket or wrapped in leaves, covered, and kept warm for one to three days. The Bacillus grows, makes enzymes, and produces a sticky stringy layer on the beans. Ammonia (NH₃) is released as protein is broken down, and that gives kinema its strong smell.
- Eat or dry: fresh kinema is cooked into curries and soups. It can also be sun dried for storage, then soaked and cooked later.
What happens inside the bean
Bacillus subtilis makes proteases, enzymes that cut proteins into peptides and amino acids. That is why kinema is easier to digest than raw soybean, and why its flavour is deep and savoury: free amino acids, especially glutamic acid, give umami taste. The bacterium also makes a sticky polymer, poly glutamic acid, which gives the stringy texture when the beans are pulled apart. Lipases break down a little of the fat, adding flavour. The pH rises rather than falls, because ammonia is alkaline, so kinema is one of the few ferments in this subject that becomes less acid, not more.
Quality control for kinema
- Smell: strong, ammoniacal, and savoury is normal. A rotten or putrid smell is a fault.
- Texture: sticky strings when pulled apart are a good sign. Slimy in a watery way, or dry with no stickiness, is a fault.
- Colour: brown to grey brown is normal. Black, green, or pink patches are mould and the batch should be discarded.
- Time and temperature: too long or too warm gives excess ammonia and bitterness. Too short or too cold gives beans that are still hard and beany.
- Safety: the beans must be cooked fully before fermenting, and the ferment must be kept warm but not hot, covered, and away from dust and insects. Kinema is cooked again before eating, and that cooking is a safety step.
HOW KINEMA IS MADE
↓
↓
↓
↓
The diagram shows the five steps in order. The microbe step in the middle is the one that changes the bean: without Bacillus, the beans would only be cooked soybeans.
Quick self-check: Why does kinema smell strong while dahi smells only mildly sour?
Kinema is made by Bacillus breaking down protein, which releases ammonia (NH₃), a strong smelling alkaline gas. Dahi is made by lactic acid bacteria making lactic acid, which smells only mildly sour. Different microbes, different chemistry, different smell.
A worked example: acid ferments and alkaline ferments side by side
Kinema is unusual in this subject because its pH rises instead of falling. Most ferments in this subject are acid ferments: lactic acid bacteria make acid and the pH falls. Kinema is an alkaline ferment: Bacillus breaks down protein, releases ammonia (NH₃), and the pH rises. The table below puts the two kinds side by side, using numbers already given in this subject.
| Feature | Acid ferment: gundruk | Alkaline ferment: kinema | Acid ferment: dahi |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main microbe | Lactic acid bacteria | Bacillus subtilis | Lactic acid bacteria |
| Main product | Lactic acid | Ammonia (NH₃) and amino acids | Lactic acid |
| pH direction | Falls, to about 4.0 | Rises, above neutral | Falls, to about 4.5 |
| Smell | Clean sour | Strong, ammoniacal, savoury | Mildly sour |
| Safety factor | Low pH stops pathogens | Cooking before and after fermenting, plus speed of the Bacillus growth | Low pH stops pathogens |
The safety lesson is in the last row. An acid ferment protects itself: the acid it makes stops most pathogens, so a slow ferment is still fairly safe. An alkaline ferment does not protect itself with acid, so it depends on other protections: the beans must be cooked fully first, the Bacillus must grow fast and take over before spoilage microbes do, and the kinema must be cooked again before eating. That is why a kinema batch that smells rotten instead of savoury must be thrown away, and why the cooking steps are never skipped.
A worked example: a kinema batch record
A batch record turns the method into numbers that can be repeated. Here is one for a small batch, using the times in the method above.
| Step | What to record | Example entry |
|---|---|---|
| Soybean | Weight before soaking | 1 kg |
| Soak | Start time, water changed | Overnight, 12 hours |
| Cook | Boiling time | 90 minutes, until soft |
| Cool | Temperature when inoculated | Warm to the touch, about 40 °C |
| Inoculate | Starter used | 2 spoonfuls of previous kinema |
| Ferment | Time and place | 2 days, kept warm near the fire |
| Check | Smell and texture on day 2 | Strong savoury smell, sticky strings when pulled apart |
| Eat or dry | Decision | Cooked into curry the same day |
A maker who writes this record can repeat a good batch and trace a bad one. If the day 2 check shows beans that are still hard and beany, the record shows whether the cooking was short or the ferment was cold, and only one thing needs changing next time.
Quick self-check: Why is cooking the safety step for kinema in a way it is not for gundruk?
Because kinema is an alkaline ferment, so no acid forms to stop pathogens. Cooking the beans first kills the microbes already present, and cooking the finished kinema again before eating kills microbes that grew during the ferment. Gundruk protects itself with acid as well as cooking, so it has one more safety barrier.
Masyaura: dried lentil nuggets
Masyaura is a dried legume product made from black gram or other lentils, often mixed with vegetables such as cauliflower or radish. It is a preservation food: wet lentil paste is shaped into small nuggets and sun dried until hard, then stored for months and cooked into curries when fresh vegetables are scarce.
How masyaura is made
- Soak and grind: black gram is soaked overnight, dehulled, and ground into a thick paste with a little water and salt, and sometimes spices such as cumin, turmeric, and chilli.
- Mix: chopped vegetables, often cauliflower, are folded into the paste.
- Shape: the paste is dropped or shaped into small nuggets on a clean cloth or a straw mat.
- Dry: the nuggets are dried in strong sun for several days, turned so all sides dry, until they are hard and light.
- Store and cook: dried masyaura is stored in a dry airtight container. To cook, it is fried in oil until crisp, then simmered in a curry until it softens.
The food science
Drying is the preservation method here, not fermentation, although a short natural ferment can occur while the paste waits. Removing water drops the water activity below the level that bacteria and moulds need, so the nuggets keep for months. The protein of the lentil is concentrated by drying: water leaves, protein stays. Frying before cooking gives flavour and a crisp outside, and simmering lets the nugget absorb curry liquid and soften. The main quality risks are slow drying, which lets mould grow, and packing while still damp, which lets mould grow in storage. The check is simple: a fully dried nugget is hard, light, and snaps, not bends.
Quick self-check: Why must masyaura be dried until it snaps?
Because a nugget that still bends holds water inside, and that water lets mould grow during storage. A hard nugget that snaps has a low water activity, so microbes cannot grow and it keeps for months.
Tofu: soybean curd
Tofu is made by curdling soy milk, in the same way that cheese is made by curdling milk. It is not a fermented food in its basic form, although fermented tofu exists. It belongs in this unit because it is a legume product whose method teaches the science of protein curdling.
How tofu is made
- Soak and grind: soybeans are soaked and ground with water into a slurry.
- Boil and filter: the slurry is boiled and filtered through cloth. The liquid is soy milk; the solid left behind is okara, which is rich in fibre and can be cooked as a food itself.
- Curdle: a coagulant is stirred into the hot soy milk. Traditional coagulants include nigari (magnesium chloride, MgCl₂), calcium sulfate (CaSO₄), or sour liquid such as lemon juice or whey. The coagulant neutralises the charge on the soybean proteins, so they clump together into a curd.
- Press: the curd is ladled into a cloth lined mould and pressed. Light pressing gives soft silken tofu; heavy pressing gives firm tofu.
- Cool in water: the pressed block is cooled in clean water, which firms it and washes away excess coagulant taste.
The food science
Soybean proteins, mainly glycinin and beta conglycinin, stay dissolved in water because they carry a surface charge that makes them repel each other. A coagulant adds ions, calcium (Ca²⁺) or magnesium (Mg²⁺), that bridge the proteins and let them join into a network that traps water. That network is the curd. The amount of coagulant, the temperature, and the pressing time set the firmness: more coagulant and more pressing give a firmer, drier tofu. Tofu is rich in protein and low in fat, and because it is wet and near neutral pH, it is perishable: it must be kept in clean water, changed daily, and refrigerated, or it will spoil in a day or two.
Quality control for tofu
- Colour: white to pale cream. Grey or pink is spoilage.
- Smell: mild and beany. Sour or putrid is spoilage.
- Texture: firm and smooth, not slimy. Sliminess is a sign of bacterial growth.
- Water: the storage water must be clean and changed daily.
Nutrela: textured soy protein
Nutrela is a brand name that has become the common name in Nepal for textured soy protein: defatted soy flour that has been cooked under pressure and pushed through a die so that it puffs into chewy chunks or granules. It is an industrial legume product, not a traditional ferment, but it belongs in this unit because it is the industrial answer to the same need: cheap, storable, high protein food from soybean.
How it is made
Soybeans are cleaned, dehulled, and pressed to remove most of the oil. The remaining defatted flour, rich in protein, is mixed with water and cooked in an extruder: a machine that heats, presses, and pushes the mix through a shaped opening. The sudden drop in pressure as the mix leaves the die makes it puff and set into a fibrous, meat like texture. The chunks are dried, and the buyer soaks them in hot water, squeezes them, and cooks them in curry, where they absorb flavour.
The food science
Extrusion cooking uses heat, pressure, and shear to unfold proteins and line them up into fibres, while destroying trypsin inhibitors and reducing beany flavour. The dry product has a very low water activity, so it keeps for months in a dry packet. On soaking, the dried network absorbs water and becomes chewy. Its protein content is high, around 50 percent by dry weight, which is why it is used as a meat substitute in vegetarian meals. Its limits are honest ones: it is a processed product with a uniform texture, it carries little of the flavour variety of a ferment, and it depends on a factory. It complements kinema and masyaura, it does not replace them.
Quality control for nutrela
- Dryness: chunks must be dry and crisp in the packet. Damp or soft chunks are a packing fault.
- Smell: mild and nutty. Rancid or musty smell means the oil left in the flour has oxidised or the product was stored damp.
- Soaking test: good chunks swell, soften, and hold their shape. Chunks that fall apart were under extruded; chunks that stay hard were over dried or over extruded.
Comparing the four products
| Product | Main method | Main microbe or process | Keeps for | Key quality check |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kinema | Fermentation | Bacillus subtilis | Days fresh, months dried | Sticky strings, strong savoury smell |
| Masyaura | Drying | Sun drying | Months dry | Hard, snaps, no mould |
| Tofu | Curdling | Calcium or magnesium coagulant | 1 to 2 days chilled | White, firm, not slimy |
| Nutrela | Extrusion | Heat, pressure, shear | Months dry | Dry, swells on soaking |
The table shows the unit in one view: four different technologies, all starting from a legume, all solving the same problem, which is how to make a hard, perishable seed into a safe, tasty, storable protein food.
Nutrition and health
Fermented legumes are more than protein. Fermentation and cooking reduce phytates, which bind iron and zinc and stop the body absorbing them, so the minerals in kinema are more available than those in raw soybean. Fermentation also makes some B vitamins, including vitamin B₁₂ in small amounts in some Bacillus ferments, although the amount varies and should not be relied on as a sole source. The fibre in legumes feeds gut microbes, and the peptides released by fermentation are being studied for blood pressure and digestion effects. Claims of this kind must be measured before they are printed on a label: a traditional food can be nutritious without carrying a medical claim.
Questions to think about
- Why does kinema become alkaline while gundruk becomes acid, and what does that mean for which microbes can grow in each?
- A maker wants to sell dried kinema in a city shop. What would you test before you set its shelf life?
- Tofu and paneer are both curdled protein foods. What is the same in their making, and what is different?
Try it yourself: Compare two legume foods
Buy or make kinema and masyaura, or tofu and nutrela. For each, record the colour, smell, texture, and taste, then cook it in a simple curry and taste it again. Write down which steps changed the flavour most, and which product you would choose for a mountain trek and why. The answer should name water, weight, and keeping quality.
Practical note
The syllabus practical is preparation and quality tests of each product. For this unit, prepare kinema and masyaura in class: record soaking time, cooking time, fermentation temperature and time, and drying time. Test the finished products for smell, texture, colour, and, for kinema, the sticky string test. For masyaura, test hardness and snap.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Legumes are rich in protein, but raw legumes carry compounds that block digestion. Cooking and fermentation reduce them.
- Kinema is a Bacillus ferment: proteases cut protein, ammonia gives the strong smell, and the pH rises.
- Masyaura is preserved by drying: low water activity stops microbes for months.
- Tofu is made by curdling soy milk with calcium or magnesium salts, which bridge proteins into a network.
- Nutrela is made by extrusion cooking: heat, pressure, and shear turn defatted soy flour into chewy, dry, storable chunks.
- Each product has its own quality checks, and each check points to a cause in the method.
Glossary
Legume
A plant whose seeds grow in pods, such as soybean, lentil, and chickpea. Food tech example: soybean is the legume used for kinema, tofu, and nutrela.
Protease
An enzyme that cuts proteins into smaller pieces. Food tech example: Bacillus proteases cut soybean protein in kinema.
Trypsin inhibitor
A compound in raw legumes that blocks the digestive enzyme trypsin. Food tech example: boiling soybeans destroys trypsin inhibitors.
Phytate
A compound in seeds that binds iron and zinc and reduces their absorption. Food tech example: soaking and fermenting legumes reduces phytate.
Bacillus subtilis
A bacterium that ferments soybeans into kinema and similar foods. Food tech example: Bacillus subtilis makes the sticky layer on kinema.
Poly glutamic acid
A sticky polymer made by Bacillus during soybean fermentation. Food tech example: it gives kinema its stringy texture.
Ammonia (NH₃)
A strong smelling gas released when protein is broken down. Food tech example: ammonia gives kinema its strong smell.
Umami
A savoury taste given by free amino acids such as glutamic acid. Food tech example: kinema tastes savoury because fermentation frees glutamic acid.
Coagulant
A substance that makes proteins clump into a curd. Food tech example: calcium sulfate curdles soy milk into tofu.
Okara
The fibre rich solid left after filtering soy milk. Food tech example: okara can be cooked as a food instead of being thrown away.
Extrusion cooking
Cooking a mix under heat and pressure and pushing it through a shaped opening. Food tech example: extrusion makes nutrela chunks from defatted soy flour.
Textured soy protein
Dried, chewy soy chunks made by extrusion, sold as nutrela. Food tech example: soaked nutrela absorbs curry flavour like meat.
Water activity (a_w)
A measure of the water in a food that microbes can use. Food tech example: dried masyaura has a low water activity and keeps for months.
Dehulled
With the outer seed coat removed. Food tech example: black gram is dehulled before it is ground for masyaura.
Alkaline fermentation
A fermentation in which the pH rises instead of falling, because protein breakdown releases ammonia (NH₃). Food tech example: kinema is an alkaline fermentation, unlike the acid fermentation of gundruk.
References
- Holzapfel, W. H., et al., Advances in Fermented Foods and Beverages, Woodhead Publishing, 2015.
- Bamforth, C. W., et al., Handbook of Food and Beverage Fermentation Technology, CRC Press, 2004.
- Adams, M. R. and Moss, M. O., Food Microbiology, Royal Society of Chemistry, 4th edition, 2018.
- Tamang, J. P., Himalayan Fermented Foods: Microbiology, Nutrition, and Ethnic Values, CRC Press, 2010.
Unit 6: Fermented Meat and Fish Products: Introduction, Preparation, and Uses
Note
Unit 6: Fermented Meat and Fish Products: Introduction, Preparation, and Uses
A question to start with
Fresh meat spoils in a day in warm weather. Yet herders and hunters in the Himalaya have eaten meat months after the animal was killed, with no refrigerator and no factory. How? They used the same three tools you met in Unit 4: salt, drying, and fermentation, often all three at once. This unit follows meat and fish through those tools, and it is honest about the risks, because meat ferments carry the highest food safety stakes in this subject.
Meat is rich in protein, fat, iron, and B vitamins, and it is also rich in water and near neutral in pH, which is exactly what microbes need. A meat that is not preserved quickly will be taken over by spoilage and disease causing microbes. Traditional preservation therefore works fast: salt is applied at once, drying starts at once, and fermentation is allowed only where the conditions favour the right microbes.
Why ferment meat and fish at all
Fermentation does four things for meat and fish:
- It preserves: lactic acid bacteria make acid, and the acid drops the pH. A pH below 5.0 slows most pathogens, and below 4.6 stops many of them. Salt and drying add a second and third barrier.
- It flavours: enzymes from the meat itself and from microbes break down protein and fat into amino acids and fatty acids. Those give the deep, savoury, sometimes sharp flavour of fermented meat.
- It tenderises: the same enzymes soften tough muscle fibres, so meat from an old animal becomes easier to chew.
- It uses the whole animal: parts that would be hard to eat fresh, such as offal, skin, and small fish, become food instead of waste. In a mountain economy, that matters.
The traditional products of Nepal and the Himalaya
Nepal's fermented meat and fish tradition is smaller than its vegetable and milk tradition, but it is real, and it is shared with the wider Himalayan region. The products below are the ones a student of this subject should know. Some are made widely, some only in particular communities, and some are known more from the literature than from daily practice. That unevenness is itself a fact to record, not to hide.
- Sukuti: dried meat, usually buffalo or goat, cut into thin strips, salted, and dried in sun and wind, sometimes over smoke. It is not always fermented, but a light ferment can occur during drying. It is chewed as a snack or cooked into curries. Sukuti is the most widely known Nepali preserved meat.
- Fermented fish: small fish are cleaned, salted, packed in pots, and left to ferment. The salt and the acid from lactic acid bacteria preserve the fish, and the flavour becomes strong and savoury. Similar products are well known across South East Asia and the Himalayan foothills, and they are used in small amounts as a flavouring, not as a main dish.
- Fermented meat sausages and pastes: minced meat mixed with salt, spices, and sometimes rice or millet flour, packed into a casing or a pot, and fermented. The added carbohydrate feeds lactic acid bacteria, which make the acid that preserves the meat.
- Dried fish: fish are cleaned, salted, and sun dried until hard. Drying alone, without fermentation, can preserve fish for months if the drying is fast and complete.
A note on names
Names for fermented meat and fish vary by community and valley, and the same name can mean a different product in the next district. When you record a product, always record the community, the animal or fish, the salt level, and the method, not only the name. A name without a method is not a recipe.
How a fermented meat is made: the general method
Every fermented meat follows the same five steps, and the safety of the product depends on getting the order and the timing right:
- Choose fresh meat: the meat must be fresh, from a healthy animal, slaughtered cleanly. A ferment cannot make bad meat good. It can only preserve good meat.
- Cut and salt: the meat is cut into strips or minced, and salt is mixed in at 2 to 5 percent by weight, depending on the product. Salt is weighed, not guessed. Spices such as chilli, garlic, ginger, and turmeric are added: they flavour the meat and some have mild antimicrobial effects, but they are not a substitute for salt and acid.
- Add carbohydrate where needed: a little cooked rice or millet flour feeds lactic acid bacteria in sausage type products. Without it, acid forms slowly and spoilage can win.
- Pack and ferment: the meat is packed tightly into a clean pot or casing, pressing out air, and kept at a cool to warm temperature for days to weeks. Lactic acid bacteria grow, acid forms, and the pH falls. The product should be checked: a clean sour smell is good, a putrid smell is a fault and the batch must be discarded.
- Dry or cook: many products are dried after fermenting, which drops the water activity and gives a long shelf life. Fermented meat is almost always cooked before eating, and that cooking is a safety step that must not be skipped.
HOW FERMENTED MEAT IS MADE
↓
↓
↓
↓
The diagram is a safety chain. Break any link, and the chain fails: bad meat, unweighed salt, air in the pack, or no cooking at the end each create a risk on their own.
Quick self-check: Why is salt weighed in a meat ferment, not added by feel?
Because the salt level decides whether lactic acid bacteria win or spoilage microbes win. Too little salt lets pathogens grow before the acid forms. Weighing gives the same salt level every batch, and feeling does not.
A worked example: weighing salt for meat and fish
The unit gives three salt levels: 2 to 5 percent for fermented meat, and 15 to 25 percent for a long keeping fermented fish. Work them out for real batch sizes, because the difference between the two is the difference between a curry and a flavouring.
| Product | Batch size | Salt level | Salt to weigh |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fermented meat | 5 kg | 3 percent | 5,000 grams times 3, divided by 100, equals 150 grams |
| Fermented meat | 10 kg | 2 percent | 10,000 grams times 2, divided by 100, equals 200 grams |
| Fermented fish, long keeping | 2 kg | 20 percent | 2,000 grams times 20, divided by 100, equals 400 grams |
The fish example shows why fermented fish is used in small amounts: 400 grams of salt in 2 kilos of fish makes a product far too salty to eat as a main dish, and that is by design, because the salt is the main safety factor in a long fish ferment. The meat example shows the opposite risk: 150 grams of salt in 5 kilos of meat is a small amount, and a handful guessed wrong by 50 grams changes the salt level by a full percent. That is why the unit says salt is weighed, not guessed, and why the weight is written in the batch record.
A worked example: hurdles for each product
Hurdle technology says safety comes from several barriers together. The table below lists the hurdles each product in this unit relies on, so a student can see which product is safe because of many hurdles and which depends on only one or two.
| Product | Salt | Acid | Drying | Cooking before eating | Cold |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sukuti | Yes | Little | Yes, the main hurdle | Yes | No |
| Fermented fish, long keeping | Yes, the main hurdle | Yes | Little | Yes | No |
| Fermented meat sausage | Yes | Yes, the main hurdle | Sometimes | Yes | Sometimes |
| Dried fish | Yes | Little | Yes, the main hurdle | Yes | No |
Read the table from left to right for one product, and count the hurdles. Sukuti has salt, drying, and cooking: three hurdles. A fermented meat sausage has salt, acid, and cooking, with drying and cold where they apply. Any product with only one hurdle is fragile, because that single hurdle carries all the safety. That is the test to apply to any new meat or fish product: name its hurdles, count them, and ask what happens if one fails.
Quick self-check: A maker leaves salt out of a fermented fish recipe to make it less salty. Which hurdle is lost, and what is the result?
The main hurdle is lost, because in a long fish ferment the high salt level is what stops pathogens while the acid forms slowly. Without it, spoilage and pathogens can grow, and the low oxygen inside a tightly packed pot adds a botulism risk. The batch is unsafe, however good it tastes.
Sukuti in detail
Sukuti deserves a closer look because it is the most widely made preserved meat in Nepal and it shows how drying and light fermentation work together.
Thin strips of buffalo or goat meat are rubbed with salt, spices, and sometimes mustard oil, then hung in sun and wind, or over a smoky fire, until they are dry and dark. The strips are thin so that drying is fast: a thick piece dries on the outside and stays wet inside, and the wet inside rots. Drying is fastest on a windy, sunny day with good air flow, and slowest in damp, still air, which is when mould grows. The finished sukuti is hard, dark, and chewy. It is eaten as a snack, pounded and cooked with vegetables, or made into a spicy curry with onion, tomato, and chilli.
The food science is straightforward: salt pulls water out, sun and wind remove that water, and the water activity falls below the level that bacteria need. Smoke adds flavour and some compounds that slow microbes, but smoke is not a substitute for drying. The quality checks are colour (dark brown, not black or green), smell (smoky and meaty, not putrid), and texture (dry and hard, not soft or damp inside). A strip that bends and feels damp inside is not finished, and it must be dried longer.
Fermented fish in detail
Small fish are cleaned, gutted, washed, and mixed with salt, often 15 to 25 percent by weight for a long keeping product, or less for a short ferment that is eaten soon. They are packed tightly into a pot, pressed down, and covered so that brine rises over the fish. Lactic acid bacteria and salt tolerant microbes grow, acid forms, and the fish softens as its own enzymes break down protein. The product is strongly flavoured and is used in small amounts, stirred into curries and chutneys, where a little gives a deep savoury note.
The high salt level is the main safety factor in a long fish ferment, and it is also the reason the product is used in small amounts: it is too salty to eat as a main dish. The risks are real: if the salt is too low, or the fish are packed loosely with air pockets, spoilage and pathogens can grow, and the toxin of Clostridium botulinum is a danger in a low acid, low oxygen fish product. That is why this product must never be made with guesswork: salt is weighed, the pot is packed tight, and the product is cooked before eating.
The microbiology: who does the work
Three groups of microbes matter in fermented meat and fish:
- Lactic acid bacteria: Lactobacillus, Pediococcus, and related genera. They turn sugars into lactic acid, drop the pH, and make compounds that slow other microbes. They are the workers the maker wants.
- Salt tolerant staphylococci: some Staphylococcus species that do not cause disease help develop colour and flavour in fermented sausages, by breaking down fat and protein. They must be distinguished from Staphylococcus aureus, which causes food poisoning and must be kept out by hygiene and by fast acid formation.
- Spoilage and danger microbes: Salmonella, E. coli, Listeria monocytogenes, and Clostridium botulinum. They are kept out by fresh meat, clean handling, correct salt, fast acid formation, drying, and cooking. No single barrier is enough on its own: safety comes from several barriers together, which food scientists call hurdle technology.
Hurdle technology, in plain words
A hurdle is a barrier that makes life hard for a microbe. Salt is a hurdle, acid is a hurdle, drying is a hurdle, cold is a hurdle, and cooking is a hurdle. One low hurdle can be jumped, but several hurdles together stop most microbes. Traditional meat preservation is hurdle technology without the name: salt plus acid plus drying plus cooking. A factory version adds more hurdles, such as a starter culture and refrigeration, and measures each one.
Uses: how these foods are eaten
Fermented and dried meat and fish are rarely eaten alone or in large amounts. Their uses are:
- As a main protein in a curry: sukuti cooked with onion, tomato, and potato; dried fish cooked with vegetables.
- As a flavouring: a small amount of fermented fish stirred into a curry or chutney gives a deep savoury flavour that salt alone cannot give.
- As a travel and snack food: dried meat is light, keeps without a fridge, and is chewed on a journey or at work.
- As a festival and guest food: in some communities, preserved meat is served to guests and at celebrations, because it represents stored wealth: an animal turned into food that lasts.
Portion size matters for health: these foods are salty and, where smoked, carry smoke compounds. They are best eaten in modest amounts, with vegetables and grain, as part of a varied diet, not as the whole meal every day.
Quality control and safety: the non negotiable part
This is the unit where quality control matters most, because the hazard is highest. The checks are:
- Raw material: fresh meat only, from a healthy animal, kept cold and used quickly. Fish must be fresh, with clear eyes, firm flesh, and no bad smell.
- Salt: weighed at 2 to 5 percent for fermented meat, higher for long fish ferments. Record the weight.
- pH: measure the pH during fermentation. A meat ferment should fall below pH 5.0, and keep falling or hold steady. A pH that stays high while the smell turns bad is a failed batch: discard it.
- Temperature: ferment at the temperature the recipe states, and do not leave a meat ferment warm for days without acid forming. Warmth without acid is the most dangerous combination in this subject.
- Drying: dry until the product is hard and dry through, not only on the surface. Test by cutting a piece open.
- Cooking: cook fermented meat and fish well before eating. Cooking does not fix a rotten product, and a rotten product must be thrown away, not cooked and eaten.
- Storage: store dried products dry, in a clean container, away from insects and damp. Store fresh ferments chilled and use them quickly.
When to throw a batch away
Throw it away, without tasting, if it smells putrid or like rotten eggs, if it is slimy in a way the recipe does not describe, if it shows green, black, or pink mould, if the packet swells, or if the pH stayed high and the product sat warm for days. No amount of cooking, washing, or spice makes a failed meat ferment safe. The loss of one batch is always cheaper than the illness of one family.
Quick self-check: Why is a meat ferment more dangerous than a vegetable ferment if the acid forms slowly?
Because meat is rich in protein and near neutral in pH, so pathogens grow fast in it. In a vegetable ferment, the leaves are less rich and the acid forms in a food that pathogens find harder to grow in. In meat, slow acid means pathogens have time and food to multiply before the acid stops them.
Industrial production: what changes
A factory that makes fermented meat uses a starter culture of lactic acid bacteria, a controlled fermentation room at a set temperature and humidity, and a drying chamber with controlled air flow. It measures pH continuously, checks salt by weighing, and tests for pathogens in a laboratory. It packs in vacuum or modified atmosphere packaging, which removes oxygen and slows spoilage. The product is labelled with a use by date and a cooking instruction.
The industrial version is safer when it is done well, because every hurdle is measured. It is also less varied, because one starter and one recipe replace many home versions. A small producer who wants to sell fermented meat should start with dried meat, which is simpler and safer, and move to fermented meat only with training, a pH meter, and a laboratory that can test the product.
Questions to think about
- Why is sukuti cut into thin strips, and what would happen if the strips were thick?
- A maker says "my grandfather never weighed salt and no one fell ill." What would you answer, and what would you change without insulting the tradition?
- Which is safer: a home fermented fish made with guessed salt, or a factory fermented fish made with a starter and a measured pH? Why?
Try it yourself: Judge a dried meat
Buy or make a small amount of sukuti. Cut a strip open and look at the inside: is it dry through, or damp in the middle? Smell it, bend it, and note the colour. Write a short quality report: three things that are right and one thing you would improve. If you find a damp centre, say so plainly and state what you would change in the drying step.
Practical note
The syllabus practical is preparation and quality tests of each product. For this unit, prepare sukuti in class: weigh the meat and the salt, record the drying time and weather, and test the finished strips for dryness, colour, smell, and texture. Do not prepare a fermented meat in class without a teacher who can check pH and temperature at each step, because the safety stakes are higher than in the vegetable units.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Meat and fish spoil fast because they are wet, rich in protein, and near neutral in pH.
- Salt, acid, drying, and cooking are hurdles that work together; no single hurdle is enough.
- Sukuti is dried meat: thin strips, salt, sun, wind, and smoke, dried through, not only on the surface.
- Fermented fish uses high salt and lactic acid bacteria, and is used in small amounts as a flavouring.
- Lactic acid bacteria are the workers; pathogens are kept out by fresh meat, weighed salt, fast acid, drying, and cooking.
- A failed meat ferment must be thrown away, not cooked and eaten.
Glossary
Sukuti
Dried meat of Nepal, usually buffalo or goat, cut into thin strips, salted, and sun or smoke dried. Food tech example: sukuti is cooked into a spicy curry with onion and tomato.
Fermented fish
Fish preserved by salt and lactic acid bacteria, strongly flavoured, used in small amounts. Food tech example: a spoon of fermented fish flavours a vegetable curry.
Hurdle technology
Using several barriers together, such as salt, acid, drying, and cold, to stop microbes. Food tech example: sukuti uses salt, drying, and cooking as hurdles.
Listeria monocytogenes
A pathogen that can grow in chilled foods and is dangerous for pregnant women and older people. Food tech example: chilled fermented meat must be made with strict hygiene to keep Listeria out.
Clostridium botulinum
A spore forming bacterium that can make a deadly toxin in low acid, low oxygen foods. Food tech example: a loosely packed, low salt fish ferment is a botulism risk.
Staphylococcus aureus
A bacterium that can make a toxin in food, often from dirty hands. Food tech example: a food handler with a skin infection must not handle meat for others.
Offal
The internal organs of an animal, such as liver and heart, eaten as food. Food tech example: offal is sometimes preserved by drying or fermenting.
Water activity (a_w)
A measure of the water in a food that microbes can use. Food tech example: sukuti must reach a low water activity to keep without a fridge.
Starter culture
Known microbes added in a measured amount to start a fermentation. Food tech example: a factory meat ferment uses a Lactobacillus starter culture.
Modified atmosphere packaging
Packaging where the air is replaced by a gas mix that slows spoilage. Food tech example: fermented sausage packed without oxygen keeps longer.
Putrid
Smelling of rotten meat, a sign of spoilage. Food tech example: a putrid smell in a meat ferment means the batch must be discarded.
Spore
A tough resting form of some bacteria that survives heat and drying. Food tech example: Clostridium spores survive cooking and can grow later if conditions allow.
Brine
Salty water formed when salt draws water out of a food. Food tech example: fermented fish sits in its own brine during fermentation.
Vacuum packaging
Packaging from which air has been removed before sealing. Food tech example: dried sukuti packed under vacuum stays dry and keeps longer.
Botulism
Poisoning by the toxin of Clostridium botulinum, which can grow in low acid, low oxygen foods. Food tech example: a loosely packed, low salt fish ferment carries a botulism risk.
References
- Adams, M. R. and Moss, M. O., Food Microbiology, Royal Society of Chemistry, 4th edition, 2018.
- Bamforth, C. W., et al., Handbook of Food and Beverage Fermentation Technology, CRC Press, 2004.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, Woodhead Publishing, 7th edition, 2006.
- Department of Food Technology and Quality Control, Mandatory Quality Standards for Food and Feed, Government of Nepal, 2082.
Unit 7: Fermented Vegetable Products: Sinki, Gundruk, Tama, and Pickles
Note
Unit 7: Fermented Vegetable Products: Sinki, Gundruk, Tama, and Pickles
A question to start with
In the monsoon, mustard leaves grow faster than a family can eat them. In the winter, no fresh greens grow at all. How does a family eat greens in January? The answer is in a pot and on a rooftop: leaves fermented into gundruk, radish roots fermented into sinki, bamboo shoots fermented into tama, and vegetables turned into pickles. This unit follows the four great vegetable ferments of Nepal, step by step, with the science that makes each one safe.
Vegetable fermentation is the most forgiving fermentation in this subject, and the most useful. The raw material is cheap, the salt is low, the acid forms fast, and the product keeps for months when dried. It is also the fermentation that most students will make first, and the one where the three controls from Unit 4 (acid, salt, water) are easiest to practise.
Gundruk: fermented leafy greens
Gundruk is the best known fermented vegetable of Nepal. It is made from the leaves of mustard, radish, cauliflower, or other leafy greens, and it is eaten as a soup, a pickle, or a side dish, especially in winter when fresh vegetables are scarce.
How gundruk is made
- Harvest and wilt: fresh leaves are harvested, washed, and left to wilt in the sun for a day or two. Wilting softens the leaves and reduces their water a little, so they pack tightly.
- Squeeze and pack: the wilted leaves are squeezed by hand, crushed, and packed tightly into an earthen pot or a clean container. Packing tightly presses out air, and air is the enemy of a good ferment.
- Cover and ferment: the pot is covered and kept warm for 5 to 7 days, sometimes longer in cold weather. Lactic acid bacteria on the leaves turn sugars into lactic acid, and the pH falls from near neutral to about 4.0. The leaves soften, turn olive green to brown, and develop a clean sour smell.
- Dry: the fermented leaves are taken out, squeezed to remove brine, and dried in the sun until they are crisp and brittle. Drying is the step that gives gundruk its long life.
- Store: dried gundruk is stored in a dry, airtight container, away from damp. It keeps for months. To eat, it is soaked, then cooked into soup with potato, tomato, and spices, or made into a pickle with onion, chilli, and mustard oil.
The science
The wilting and squeezing do two things: they break the leaf cells so that sugars and nutrients leak out for the bacteria, and they remove air so that lactic acid bacteria, which prefer low oxygen, can grow. The bacteria are already on the leaves: no starter is needed, although a little brine from a previous batch can be used. Salt is added in some recipes at 1 to 2 percent, and in others the leaves are fermented without added salt, relying on the brine they make themselves. The acid is the main preservative during fermentation, and drying is the main preservative during storage. The final product is rich in fibre, and the fermentation makes minerals more available by reducing phytates. It also makes vitamin C losses smaller than in a fresh leaf that is simply left to rot, because the acid protects some of the vitamin.
HOW GUNDRUK IS MADE
↓
↓
↓
↓
The diagram shows the order that matters: wilt, pack tight, ferment, dry. If the pot is packed loosely, air stays inside and mould grows instead of lactic acid bacteria.
Quick self-check: Why are the leaves wilted before they are packed?
Wilting softens the leaves so they pack tightly and press out air, and it breaks leaf cells so sugars leak out for the lactic acid bacteria. Both help the right microbes grow and the wrong ones stay out.
A worked example: how much salt for a pot of gundruk
The unit says salt is added in some recipes at 1 to 2 percent. Work it out for three batch sizes, so the maker can weigh it instead of guessing.
| Leaves | Salt at 1 percent | Salt at 2 percent |
|---|---|---|
| 1 kg | 10 grams | 20 grams |
| 5 kg | 50 grams | 100 grams |
| 10 kg | 100 grams | 200 grams |
The rule is the same as in Unit 4: salt in grams equals leaf weight in grams multiplied by the percent, divided by 100. A 5 kilo batch at 1.5 percent needs 75 grams, because 5,000 times 1.5 divided by 100 equals 75. Two practical points follow. First, weigh the leaves before wilting, because wilted leaves weigh less and the salt must be weighed against the fresh weight. Second, mix the salt through the leaves evenly before packing: salt that sits in one corner leaves the rest of the pot unprotected, and the unprotected part is where mould grows first.
Keeping the leaves under brine
The most common fault in a vegetable ferment is a leaf that rises above the brine and grows mould. The fix is mechanical, not chemical: press the leaves down so their own juice covers them, and keep them down. A clean stone, a clean plate with a weight on top, or a small bag of brine placed on the leaves all work. Check the pot on day 2 and day 3: if leaves have floated up, press them down again and top up with a little clean brine made from 2 percent salt in boiled, cooled water. A ferment that stays under brine ferments cleanly; a ferment that dries on top grows mould, however good the salt level was at the start.
Quick self-check: A pot of gundruk shows white mould on leaves that floated above the brine, while the leaves under the brine smell clean and sour. What went wrong, and what do you do?
The floating leaves were exposed to air, so mould grew on them while the submerged leaves fermented cleanly. Remove the mouldy leaves and throw them away, press the rest back under the brine, and keep them pressed down. Do not stir the mould into the pot.
Sinki: fermented radish root
Sinki is made from radish roots, usually the long white radish, and it is one of the oldest ferments of Nepal. It is sharper and more pungent than gundruk, and it is used in smaller amounts, as a pickle or a soup flavouring.
How sinki is made
- Clean and cut: radish roots are cleaned, washed, and cut into pieces or shredded.
- Wilt and pack: the pieces are wilted in the sun, then packed tightly into a pit lined with leaves, or into an earthen pot, and pressed down with a heavy stone so that the juice rises and covers the pieces.
- Ferment: the pot or pit is covered and left for 3 to 4 weeks, longer than gundruk. The long, slow ferment gives sinki its strong, sharp flavour. Lactic acid bacteria do the work, and the pH falls to about 3.5 to 4.0.
- Dry: the fermented radish is taken out and dried in the sun until hard.
- Store and eat: dried sinki is stored dry and cooked into soup or pickle. It is used in small amounts because its flavour is strong.
How sinki differs from gundruk
The raw material is a root, not a leaf, so it is firmer, whiter, and richer in starch and sugars. The ferment is longer, so the acid is higher and the flavour is sharper. The pit method is older than the pot method, and it shows how fermentation was done before pots were common: a hole in the ground, lined with leaves, pressed with a stone, and covered. The science is the same, but the time is longer, and the product is stronger.
Quality control for sinki and gundruk
- Smell: clean sour is good. Putrid, rotten egg, or musty is a fault. A smell of hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) means spoilage microbes grew.
- Texture: firm, not slimy. Sliminess means the wrong microbes grew, usually because the salt was too low or the pot was packed loosely.
- Colour: olive green to brown for gundruk, pale to light brown for sinki. Black or grey is a fault.
- pH: the ferment should reach pH 4.0 to 4.5. A pH that stays above 4.6 after a week is a warning.
- Drying: dry until crisp. A piece that bends holds water and will mould in storage.
Tama: fermented bamboo shoot
Tama is fermented bamboo shoot, a food of the hills and the east, where bamboo grows. Young bamboo shoots are harvested, peeled, sliced, and fermented, and the result is a sour, slightly bitter shoot that is cooked into curries, often with potato and black eyed beans.
How tama is made
Young bamboo shoots are peeled, sliced thin, washed, and packed into a pot or a bamboo container with water, and left to ferment for a week or more. Lactic acid bacteria make the acid, and the pH falls. The shoots soften and turn sour. They are eaten fresh from the ferment, or dried for storage. Tama is almost always cooked before eating, and cooking is important: raw bamboo shoots contain cyanogenic glycosides, compounds that can release hydrogen cyanide (HCN) in the body. Washing, fermenting, and cooking all reduce these compounds to safe levels. This is a case where the traditional method is also the safety method, and skipping a step is dangerous.
The science and the safety
Bamboo shoots are rich in fibre and low in fat, and they carry a fresh, slightly bitter flavour. The cyanogenic glycosides are the hazard: they are highest in young shoots and in the tip. Peeling, slicing thin, soaking, fermenting, and boiling in water that is then thrown away all reduce the level. A tama that is eaten raw, or boiled too briefly, is a risk. The lesson is general: a traditional recipe is a safety system, and each step has a reason. A student who shortens a recipe to save time may remove the very step that makes the food safe.
Quick self-check: Why must tama be cooked well before eating?
Because raw bamboo shoots contain cyanogenic glycosides that can release hydrogen cyanide (HCN). Washing, fermenting, and boiling reduce them to safe levels, and the cooking water should be thrown away.
Pickles: the wider family
Pickles, called achar in Nepali, are the widest family of preserved vegetables in Nepal. They include oil pickles, vinegar pickles, and fermented pickles, and the three are different in science, even though they share a name.
Fermented pickles
Vegetables such as radish, carrot, cauliflower, and chilli are salted, packed, and left to ferment. Lactic acid bacteria make the acid, and the product is sour, salty, and alive with microbes. Gundruk and sinki are, in this sense, fermented pickles that are then dried.
Oil pickles
Vegetables or fruits, such as mango, lime, or chilli, are mixed with salt, spices, and mustard oil, and stored in a jar. The oil covers the pieces and keeps air out, the salt and spices slow microbes, and the acid comes from the fruit itself or from added vinegar. The oil layer is the main barrier: if pieces rise above the oil, mould grows on the exposed surface. The jar must be kept dry, and a wet spoon must never go into it.
Vinegar pickles
Vegetables are packed in vinegar, which is acetic acid (CH₃COOH) diluted in water. The vinegar drops the pH at once, without waiting for microbes, so the product is ready quickly and keeps well. The vinegar must be strong enough: a pickle in weak vinegar is not safe, because the pH will not fall far enough. The rule is to use a tested recipe and a measured amount of vinegar, not to guess.
Quality control for pickles
- Oil pickles: pieces must stay under the oil. A dry, mouldy top layer must be removed and the rest checked, and if the mould has spread, the jar must be discarded.
- Vinegar pickles: the liquid must cover the pieces, and the pH should be below 4.6. A cloudy liquid with a bad smell is a fault.
- Fermented pickles: the same checks as gundruk apply: clean sour smell, firm texture, pH below 4.6, no slime, no mould.
- All pickles: use clean, dry jars and clean, dry spoons. Water is the enemy of a pickle jar, because it dilutes the salt, acid, and oil that keep the food safe.
Drying and preservation after fermentation
Drying is the step that turns a short lived ferment into a long lived food. The science is water activity: fresh gundruk has a water activity near 0.98, and moulds and bacteria grow freely. Dried gundruk has a water activity below 0.60, and almost nothing grows. The drying must be fast enough that mould does not grow while the food is still damp, and complete enough that no damp centre remains.
Good drying practice:
- Thin layers: spread the leaves thinly, so air reaches all of them.
- Raised surface: dry on a clean mat or tray, raised off the ground, where air flows under as well as over.
- Turn often: turn the pieces so all sides dry evenly.
- Bring in at night: damp night air can rewet the food. Bring it inside at dusk and put it out again in the morning.
- Cool before packing: warm food packed at once sweats inside the packet. Cool it fully, then pack it dry.
A solar dryer, a simple box with a clear cover that traps heat and lets air flow, dries faster and cleaner than open sun drying, and it keeps insects and dust off the food. It is a good small investment for a producer who dries regularly.
Common faults in vegetable ferments
| Fault | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Slimy leaves | Too little salt, loose packing, too warm | Weigh salt, pack tight, ferment cooler |
| Rotten smell | Spoilage won, pH stayed high | Check pH early, use back slopping |
| Mould on top | Air reached the surface, pieces rose above brine | Press down, keep pieces under brine |
| Soft, mushy texture | Over fermented, too warm, old leaves | Shorten time, use fresh leaves |
| Mould in storage | Packed damp, damp store | Dry until crisp, pack cool and dry |
| Bitter tama | Under cooked, shoots too old | Use young shoots, boil and discard water |
Nutrition
Fermented vegetables keep much of the nutrition of the fresh leaf or root, and they add two things: the acid makes iron and other minerals more available, and the microbes make some B vitamins. Drying loses some vitamin C, but the dried product still carries fibre, minerals, and the acid that helps the body absorb iron from a meal. Gundruk soup with potato and lentils is a good example of a complete winter meal: the acid, the fibre, the starch, and the protein work together. The salt content is the limit: fermented vegetables are salty, and they should be eaten with unsalted foods, such as rice and potato, rather than with more salt.
Questions to think about
- Why is gundruk dried after fermenting, while a vinegar pickle is not? What does drying add that the ferment alone does not give?
- A maker packs gundruk loosely and covers it with a cloth. What will grow, and why?
- Tama is dangerous if undercooked. How would you explain that risk to a maker without frightening them away from a food their family has eaten for generations?
Try it yourself: Make a small gundruk
Take a small amount of mustard leaves, about 500 grams. Wash them, wilt them in the sun for a day, squeeze and pack them tightly into a clean glass jar, and cover the jar. Each day, smell the jar and test the pH with pH paper if you have it. Record the smell, colour, and pH on day 1, day 3, day 5, and day 7. At the end, dry a small amount in the sun and taste the soup. Write down what changed each day and what you would do differently next time.
Practical note
The syllabus practical is preparation and quality tests of each product. For this unit, prepare gundruk and a fermented pickle in class: record leaf weight, salt weight, packing method, fermentation time and temperature, and pH on day 3 and day 7. Test the dried product for crispness and the pickle for pH and sensory quality.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Gundruk is wilted, squeezed, packed tight, fermented by lactic acid bacteria, then sun dried.
- Sinki is fermented radish root, with a longer, sharper ferment than gundruk.
- Tama is fermented bamboo shoot, and it must be washed, fermented, and cooked well to reduce cyanogenic glycosides.
- Pickles include fermented, oil, and vinegar types, and each has a different science and a different safety check.
- Drying drops water activity below 0.60, which gives a long shelf life.
- The common faults all point to salt, air, temperature, time, or damp packing.
Glossary
Gundruk
Fermented and dried leafy greens, usually mustard, radish, or cauliflower leaves. Food tech example: gundruk soup is made from dried fermented leaves cooked with potato.
Sinki
Fermented radish root, dried after a long ferment, sharp in flavour. Food tech example: sinki is cooked in small amounts into soup.
Tama
Fermented bamboo shoot, sour and slightly bitter, cooked before eating. Food tech example: tama curry is made with potato and black eyed beans.
Achar
The Nepali word for pickle, covering fermented, oil, and vinegar types. Food tech example: mango achar is an oil pickle.
Wilting
Leaving leaves in the sun so they soften and lose a little water. Food tech example: mustard leaves are wilted for a day before they are packed for gundruk.
Back slopping
Starting a new ferment with a little brine or food from a previous batch. Food tech example: a little old gundruk brine can start a new pot.
Cyanogenic glycoside
A compound in some plants that can release hydrogen cyanide (HCN). Food tech example: raw bamboo shoots carry cyanogenic glycosides, reduced by cooking.
Hydrogen cyanide (HCN)
A poisonous compound that can be released from cyanogenic glycosides. Food tech example: boiling tama and discarding the water reduces HCN.
Acetic acid (CH₃COOH)
The acid in vinegar. Food tech example: vinegar pickles are preserved by acetic acid.
Water activity (a_w)
A measure of the water in a food that microbes can use, from 0 to 1. Food tech example: dried gundruk has a water activity below 0.60.
Solar dryer
A simple box with a clear cover that traps heat and dries food faster and cleaner than open sun. Food tech example: a solar dryer keeps insects off drying gundruk.
Lactic acid bacteria
Bacteria that turn sugars into lactic acid, lowering pH and preserving food. Food tech example: they ferment gundruk, sinki, and tama.
Phytate
A compound in plants that binds minerals and reduces their absorption. Food tech example: fermentation reduces phytate in gundruk leaves.
Brine
Salty water formed when salt draws water out of a food. Food tech example: gundruk leaves ferment in their own brine.
Brine coverage
Keeping fermenting food fully under its brine, so air cannot reach it. Food tech example: a clean stone holds gundruk leaves under the brine so mould cannot grow on top.
References
- Tamang, J. P., Himalayan Fermented Foods: Microbiology, Nutrition, and Ethnic Values, CRC Press, 2010.
- Holzapfel, W. H., et al., Advances in Fermented Foods and Beverages, Woodhead Publishing, 2015.
- Bamforth, C. W., et al., Handbook of Food and Beverage Fermentation Technology, CRC Press, 2004.
- Adams, M. R. and Moss, M. O., Food Microbiology, Royal Society of Chemistry, 4th edition, 2018.
Unit 8: Fermented Cereal Products: Jand, Raksi, and Tongba
Note
Unit 8: Fermented Cereal Products: Jand, Raksi, and Tongba
A question to start with
Millet is a small, hard grain that grows where rice will not: on dry hill slopes, in poor soil, in the cold. On its own, it makes a plain porridge. But give it a starter, warmth, and time, and the same grain becomes jand, a cloudy, sour, lightly sparkling drink; distil it, and it becomes raksi, a clear spirit; pour hot water over it in a wooden vessel, and it becomes tongba, a warm drink shared from a single pot. How does one grain become three drinks? The answer is yeast, and this unit follows yeast through each drink.
Cereal fermentation is the oldest use of microbes in food, and it is found in every part of the world: beer from barley, wine from grape, and jand from millet and rice. The chemistry is the same in each case, and the culture is different in each case. Learn the chemistry once, and you can understand all three drinks.
The chemistry: what yeast does
Yeast, mainly Saccharomyces cerevisiae and related species, turns sugars into alcohol and carbon dioxide. The main reaction is:
C₆H₁₂O₆ → 2 C₂H₅OH + 2 CO₂
Glucose becomes ethanol (C₂H₅OH) and carbon dioxide (CO₂). The CO₂ gives fizz and a light, lively mouthfeel. The ethanol gives warmth, flavour, and preservation, because most spoilage microbes cannot grow in alcohol.
But grain is not sugar. Millet and rice are mostly starch, which is a long chain of glucose units. Yeast cannot eat starch directly, so the starch must first be broken into sugars. That job is done by enzymes, mainly amylases, which cut starch into maltose and glucose. In Nepali cereal drinks, the amylase comes from a starter called marcha, also spelled murcha. Marcha is a small, flat cake of rice flour, herbs, and microbes, dried and stored. It carries both moulds that make amylase and yeasts that make alcohol. When marcha is mixed with cooked grain, the moulds break the starch and the yeasts ferment the sugars, in the same pot, at the same time. This joint action is called simultaneous saccharification and fermentation, and it is the heart of every drink in this unit.
Marcha: the starter that makes it possible
Marcha deserves its own section, because without it there is no jand, no raksi, and no tongba.
Marcha is made from rice flour mixed with water and powdered herbs and spices, shaped into small round cakes, and left to ferment for a few days, then dried in the sun. The herbs are not only flavour: they carry microbes and they help select the right ones. The dried cakes keep for months. To use marcha, a cake is crushed and sprinkled over cooked, cooled grain. The moulds in the cake, mainly Rhizopus and Mucor species, grow first, making amylase that turns starch into sugar. The yeasts grow next, turning sugar into alcohol. Lactic acid bacteria also grow, making a little acid that gives jand its pleasant sour note and helps keep spoilage out.
The quality of marcha decides the quality of the drink. A good marcha is dry, fragrant, and free of mould that is black or green. A marcha that was dried damp, or stored damp, will carry the wrong moulds, and the drink will taste bitter or musty. Marcha making is skilled work, and it is often done by specialists or by experienced women in a community.
Quick self-check: Why can yeast not ferment cooked millet on its own?
Because millet is mostly starch, and yeast cannot eat starch. It needs amylase to cut the starch into sugars first, and that amylase comes from the moulds in marcha.
A worked example: how much alcohol is in the glass
The unit says jand is usually 3 to 6 percent alcohol by volume, and raksi is often 25 to 45 percent. Alcohol by volume means millilitres of pure alcohol in every 100 millilitres of drink. Work it out for a serving, because a percentage on its own tells a drinker very little.
| Drink and serving | Alcohol by volume | Pure alcohol in the serving |
|---|---|---|
| Jand, one 250 ml glass at 4 percent | 4 percent | 250 times 4, divided by 100, equals 10 ml |
| Jand, one 250 ml glass at 6 percent | 6 percent | 250 times 6, divided by 100, equals 15 ml |
| Raksi, one small 30 ml measure at 30 percent | 30 percent | 30 times 30, divided by 100, equals 9 ml |
| Raksi, one 60 ml measure at 40 percent | 40 percent | 60 times 40, divided by 100, equals 24 ml |
The table shows two useful facts. First, one glass of strong jand holds about as much alcohol as one small measure of raksi. Second, a large measure of strong raksi holds more than twice the alcohol of a glass of jand, even though the glass looks bigger. That is why raksi is drunk in small amounts, with food, and why a drinker who counts glasses instead of alcohol will underestimate a strong spirit.
Why jand turns to vinegar
A jand left open to the air turns sharp and vinegary. The cause is acetic acid bacteria, which turn ethanol into acetic acid when oxygen is present:
C₂H₅OH + O₂ → CH₃COOH + H₂O
Ethanol plus oxygen becomes acetic acid plus water. The reaction needs air, so a jand kept in a closed pot, with little air above it, stays sweet and sour, while a jand left in an open jug turns to vinegar in a day or two. The fix is the same as the cause: keep the drink covered, drink it fresh, and do not store it open. A vinegary jand is not dangerous in the way a failed meat ferment is, but it is a failed drink, and it should not be served.
Quick self-check: A jand tastes sharp like vinegar on day 3, although it tasted sweet and sour on day 1. What happened, and what should the maker change?
Acetic acid bacteria turned the ethanol into acetic acid because air reached the drink. The maker should keep the pot covered with as little air as possible, drink the jand fresh, and not leave it standing open.
Jand: the fermented cereal drink
Jand, also called chhyang in some communities, is a cloudy, mildly alcoholic drink made from rice, millet, wheat, or maize. It is the most widely made cereal drink in Nepal, and it is served at festivals, weddings, and social gatherings, and as a welcome drink to guests.
How jand is made
- Cook the grain: rice or millet is washed and cooked until soft, then cooled to a warm temperature. The grain must be cooked fully, or the starch will not break down.
- Add marcha: crushed marcha is mixed evenly through the cooled grain. The amount matters: too little marcha gives a slow, weak ferment; too much gives a bitter, fast ferment.
- Ferment: the grain is packed into a clean pot, covered, and kept warm for 3 to 7 days, depending on the grain and the weather. The moulds break the starch, the yeasts make alcohol, and the lactic acid bacteria make acid. The grain softens, turns sweet and sour, and a liquid gathers.
- Add water and strain: water is added, the mixture is left for a short time, and the liquid is strained off. That liquid is jand. The remaining grain can be fermented again with more water, giving a weaker second drink.
- Drink fresh: jand is drunk fresh, within a day or two. It is cloudy, lightly sparkling, sweet and sour, and usually 3 to 6 percent alcohol by volume. It does not keep long, because the yeasts and bacteria keep working and the drink turns too sour.
The science
Jand is a live drink: the microbes are still in it when it is drunk, and the chemistry is still moving. That is why it is served fresh and why it cannot be stored like a bottled beer. The alcohol level is low because the ferment is short and the sugar is limited. The sourness comes from lactic acid, and the balance of sweet, sour, and alcohol is what makes a good jand. A jand that is too sweet has not fermented long enough; a jand that is too sour has fermented too long or too warm.
Quality control for jand
- Smell: sweet, sour, and alcoholic, in balance. A putrid or musty smell is a fault.
- Taste: sweet and sour together, with a light sparkle. Vinegar sharpness means the drink has turned to acetic acid, because air reached it and acetic acid bacteria grew.
- Colour: cloudy white to pale yellow, depending on the grain. A grey or black colour is a fault.
- Time: drink it fresh. A jand kept for a week will be sour and may be unsafe if it was made with dirty water or a dirty pot.
Raksi: the distilled spirit
Raksi is made by distilling jand. Distillation separates alcohol from water by heating: alcohol boils at a lower temperature than water, so its vapour rises first, is cooled, and condenses as a clear liquid. Raksi is therefore much stronger than jand, often 25 to 45 percent alcohol by volume, and it keeps for a long time, because its high alcohol level stops microbes.
How raksi is made
- Make jand: the fermented grain is prepared as for jand, and left until it is fully fermented.
- Distil: the fermented mash is heated in a pot with a lid and a pipe. The vapour is led through a cooling pipe, often cooled by water, and the condensed liquid is collected. The first liquid that comes off is the strongest, and the later liquid is weaker.
- Collect and store: the spirit is collected in a clean container and stored. It is clear, strong, and fiery. It is drunk in small amounts, often with water or with food, and it is used in rituals and at festivals.
The science and the safety
Distillation is a physical separation, not a chemical change: it concentrates the alcohol that yeast already made. It also concentrates other compounds, and that is where the danger lies. Methanol (CH₃OH), a poisonous alcohol, can be present in small amounts in a ferment, especially from fruit and from poor fermentation. Methanol boils at a lower temperature than ethanol, so it comes off first in the distillation. A careful distiller discards the first small amount of distillate, called the foreshot, because it carries the most methanol. A careless distiller who keeps everything, or who distils a ferment made from the wrong material, can make a spirit that blinds or kills. This is not a small risk, and it is the reason that distillation must be learned from an experienced maker and done with care.
Other safety points: the still must be clean, the cooling water must be clean, and the spirit must be stored in a clean, labelled container, away from children. Raksi is a strong drink, and it must be drunk in small amounts, with food, and never by children or by pregnant women. The health risks of heavy drinking are real, and a food technology course should state them plainly: alcohol harms the liver, the brain, and the unborn child, and no traditional value changes that fact.
FROM GRAIN TO THREE DRINKS
The diagram shows one ferment branching into three drinks. Jand is the ferment itself, tongba is jand served warm from the grain, and raksi is jand concentrated by distillation.
Quick self-check: Why is the first liquid from a still discarded?
Because methanol (CH₃OH), a poisonous alcohol, boils at a lower temperature than ethanol, so it comes off first. Discarding the foreshot removes most of the methanol and makes the spirit safer.
Tongba: the warm millet drink
Tongba is the drink of the Limbu community and the eastern hills. Fermented millet is put into a tall wooden or bamboo vessel, hot water is poured over it, and the drink is sipped through a bamboo straw that has a filter at the bottom. More hot water can be added, and the drink is shared, refilled, and drunk slowly, often in a circle of friends.
How tongba is made
The millet is cooked, cooled, mixed with marcha, and fermented in the same way as jand, but it is left in its grain form and it is not strained. When it is ready, the fermented millet is packed into the tongba vessel, hot water is poured on, and after a few minutes the liquid is sipped through the straw. The hot water draws out alcohol, sugars, and flavour from the grain. The drink is warm, cloudy, mildly alcoholic, and gently sour. The vessel and the straw are part of the drink: the straw filters the grain, and the shared vessel makes the drink a social act.
The science
Tongba is jand served in a different way, and the science is the same: starch to sugar, sugar to alcohol, with a little lactic acid for sourness. The hot water does two things: it warms the drink, which suits a cold mountain evening, and it extracts more flavour from the grain. The alcohol level is low, similar to jand, because the ferment is the same. The social science matters as much as the chemistry: tongba is drunk together, slowly, in conversation, and the vessel is passed and refilled. A factory that bottles tongba as a cold drink would keep the name and lose the practice.
Other cereal ferments
The same method makes other drinks and foods in Nepal and the Himalaya:
- Chhyang: a rice based drink similar to jand, made in many hill communities.
- Fermented porridges: cooked grain left to ferment overnight becomes a sour porridge, eaten for breakfast. The acid makes it easier to digest and keeps it safe overnight.
- Fermented batters: rice and lentil batters left to ferment become the base for pancakes and breads, where the acid and the gas from yeasts give flavour and lightness. Selroti batter, covered in Unit 9, uses a similar idea.
Properties and uses
The properties of these drinks are set by their chemistry:
- Jand: cloudy, sour, lightly sparkling, low alcohol, drunk fresh, with food, at festivals and gatherings.
- Tongba: warm, cloudy, mildly alcoholic, drunk slowly through a straw, in company, in cold weather.
- Raksi: clear, strong, fiery, drunk in small amounts, used in rituals and at festivals, and stored for months.
Their uses are social and ritual as much as nutritional. They are offered to guests, shared at weddings, poured in worship, and drunk to warm the body in winter. They also carry nutrition from the grain: B vitamins from the yeast, minerals from the millet, and energy from the alcohol and the remaining sugars. That nutrition does not make them health foods: the alcohol is the limit, and the drink should be taken in moderation, with food, and never as a substitute for a meal.
Industrial production: what is possible, and what is lost
A factory can make a millet beer by the same chemistry, with a pure yeast culture, a controlled temperature, and a measured alcohol level. It can filter, pasteurise, and bottle it, so it keeps for months. That product is a safe, steady beer, and it is sold in cities. What it loses is the live, cloudy, short lived character of jand, and the shared vessel of tongba. A factory cannot bottle a social practice.
Raksi is harder to industrialise safely without a licence, because distillation is regulated in Nepal. A legal distillery must follow the law, pay tax, label the alcohol level, and test for methanol. Home distillation is a legal and safety matter, and a student should know that the law governs who may distil and sell spirits. The DFTQC and the excise rules both apply, and the current law must be checked before any commercial plan is made.
Questions to think about
- Why does marcha carry both moulds and yeasts, and what would happen if it carried only yeasts?
- A jand tastes of vinegar. What went wrong, and what would you change next time?
- Tongba is drunk from a shared vessel through a straw. What would a factory version keep, and what would it have to give up?
Try it yourself: Watch a ferment change
If your class makes jand, record the smell and taste on day 1, day 3, day 5, and day 7: sweet, sour, alcoholic, or vinegary? Write one sentence for each day. At the end, say which day the drink was best and why. If your class does not make jand, do the same observation with a fermenting rice batter: smell it each day and record when it turns sour and when it rises.
Practical note
The syllabus practical is preparation and quality tests of each product. For this unit, prepare jand in class under teacher guidance: record grain weight, marcha weight, fermentation temperature and time, and the smell, taste, and alcohol character on each day. Test the finished drink for sensory quality and record the result. Do not attempt distillation in class without the teacher, the equipment, and the legal permission for the demonstration.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Yeast turns sugar into ethanol and CO₂, but grain starch must first be cut into sugar by amylase from marcha.
- Marcha carries moulds, yeasts, and lactic acid bacteria, and its quality decides the drink.
- Jand is a fresh, cloudy, low alcohol drink, drunk within a day or two.
- Raksi is jand concentrated by distillation, strong and long keeping, with a methanol risk if the foreshot is kept.
- Tongba is fermented millet drunk warm from a shared vessel through a straw.
- Alcohol carries real health risks, and distillation is regulated by law.
Glossary
Marcha
A dried starter cake of rice flour, herbs, and microbes that starts cereal fermentation. Food tech example: crushed marcha is mixed into cooked millet to make jand.
Saccharification
Cutting starch into sugars with enzymes. Food tech example: mould amylase in marcha saccharifies millet starch.
Amylase
An enzyme that cuts starch into maltose and glucose. Food tech example: amylase from marcha moulds frees sugars for yeast.
Ethanol (C₂H₅OH)
The alcohol in fermented drinks. Food tech example: yeast makes ethanol in jand.
Methanol (CH₃OH)
A poisonous alcohol that can appear in ferments and comes off first in distillation. Food tech example: the foreshot of raksi is discarded because it carries methanol.
Distillation
Heating a liquid and condensing its vapour to separate alcohol from water. Food tech example: distilling jand gives raksi.
Foreshot
The first small amount of liquid from a still, richest in methanol, discarded for safety. Food tech example: a careful distiller throws the foreshot away.
Jand
A cloudy, mildly alcoholic fermented cereal drink of Nepal. Food tech example: jand is strained from fermented millet and drunk fresh.
Raksi
A clear distilled spirit made from fermented grain. Food tech example: raksi is distilled from jand and stored for months.
Tongba
Fermented millet drunk warm from a vessel, with hot water added and sipped through a straw. Food tech example: tongba is shared in a circle of friends.
Chhyang
A rice based fermented drink similar to jand. Food tech example: chhyang is served at hill festivals.
Simultaneous saccharification and fermentation
Breaking starch into sugar and fermenting the sugar at the same time, in the same pot. Food tech example: marcha does this in jand making.
Acetic acid bacteria
Bacteria that turn alcohol into acetic acid when air is present. Food tech example: they turn jand vinegary if air reaches it.
Alcohol by volume
The percentage of a drink that is alcohol. Food tech example: jand is about 3 to 6 percent alcohol by volume.
Oxidation
A chemical change in which a substance gains oxygen or loses hydrogen, as when ethanol becomes acetic acid. Food tech example: air oxidises jand into vinegar.
References
- Holzapfel, W. H., et al., Advances in Fermented Foods and Beverages, Woodhead Publishing, 2015.
- Bamforth, C. W., et al., Handbook of Food and Beverage Fermentation Technology, CRC Press, 2004.
- Tamang, J. P., Himalayan Fermented Foods: Microbiology, Nutrition, and Ethnic Values, CRC Press, 2010.
- Adams, M. R. and Moss, M. O., Food Microbiology, Royal Society of Chemistry, 4th edition, 2018.
Unit 9: Selroti and Doughnut Like Products: Preparation and Uses
Note
Unit 9: Selroti and Doughnut Like Products: Preparation and Uses
A question to start with
Pour a ring of rice batter into hot oil, and it puffs, turns golden, and holds its ring shape. Pour the same batter into a pan without oil, and it stays flat and pale. What does the oil do? It does three things at once: it carries heat fast to the batter, it drives water out of the surface so a crisp crust forms, and it gives flavour. Selroti is a lesson in frying, and this unit follows that lesson, from rice to ring, and from ring to the family of doughnut like foods around the world.
Selroti is the best known fried dough food of Nepal. It is a ring of fermented rice batter, fried in oil until golden and crisp outside, soft inside. It is made for Tihar, for weddings, for guests, and for gifts, and it is eaten warm, often with tea, with pickles, or with a sweet. Its shape is a ring, and its meaning is a celebration: when selroti is being made, something special is happening.
The rice: why selroti starts with rice
Selroti is made from rice, not wheat. Rice is the staple grain of the Terai and the hills, and its flour behaves differently from wheat flour: rice has no gluten, so a rice batter cannot be kneaded into an elastic dough. Instead, it is made into a batter that flows, and that batter is poured into oil in a ring shape. The lack of gluten is a feature, not a fault: it gives selroti a light, crisp texture that a wheat dough cannot copy.
The rice is usually a local variety, soaked overnight, drained, and ground with a little water into a smooth batter. Some recipes add a little wheat flour for body, and some add a little mashed banana or cooked rice for softness. Sugar or jaggery sweetens the batter, and cardamom, cloves, or fennel give fragrance. A pinch of baking soda or a short ferment gives the gas that makes the ring puff.
Soaking and grinding
Soaking softens the grain so it grinds smoothly, and it starts a light fermentation by the microbes on the rice. Grinding must be fine: a coarse batter gives a gritty ring, and a batter with lumps fries unevenly. The batter should flow from a spoon in a steady stream, thick enough to hold a ring, thin enough to pour. That consistency is learned by feel, and it is the first skill a selroti maker learns.
Fermentation of the batter
Many selroti recipes ferment the batter for a few hours, or overnight. The microbes are yeasts and lactic acid bacteria from the rice, the air, and the grinding stone. They make a little acid and a little gas: the acid gives a mild sour note that balances the sweetness, and the gas gives lightness. A batter that has fermented too long turns too sour and the rings fall flat; a batter that has not fermented at all is dense and heavy. In cold weather the ferment is slower, so the batter is kept near the fire or in a warm place.
Baking soda is sometimes added just before frying. It reacts with the acid in the batter and releases CO₂, which puffs the ring as it fries. The amount must be small: too much soda gives a bitter, soapy taste and a yellow colour. The rule is a pinch, not a spoonful.
Quick self-check: Why does a fermented batter make a lighter selroti than a fresh batter?
Because the yeasts and bacteria make gas and a little acid during fermentation. The gas expands in the hot oil and puffs the ring, and the acid reacts with baking soda to make more CO₂. A fresh batter has no gas, so the ring stays dense.
Frying: the heart of selroti
Frying is cooking in hot oil, usually at 170 to 180 °C. The science has three parts:
- Heat transfer: oil carries heat to the batter far faster than air, so the ring cooks in a minute or two.
- Crust formation: the surface water boils off at once, the starch gelatinises, and a crisp crust forms. The crust stops oil soaking deep into the ring, so a well fried selroti is crisp, not greasy.
- Colour and flavour: the sugars and proteins on the surface brown by the Maillard reaction, giving the golden colour and the roasted, sweet smell. That reaction needs heat and a dry surface, which is why a ring fried in oil that is too cool stays pale and soaks up oil.
How selroti is fried
Oil is heated in a wide, shallow pan. The maker takes a handful of batter, or pours it from a jug with a spout, and lets it fall into the oil in a ring, moving the hand in a circle. The ring sets at once. It is turned with a stick or a fork, fried until golden on both sides, and lifted out to drain on a clean surface. The oil temperature must be watched: if the oil smokes, it is too hot and the outside will burn before the inside cooks; if the ring sinks and stays pale, the oil is too cool and the ring will be oily.
Oil quality
The oil matters as much as the batter. Fresh oil gives a clean taste. Oil that has been used many times turns dark, smokes early, and carries compounds that are bad for health. A maker should filter the oil after use, store it covered, and throw it away when it is dark, thick, or smoky. Mustard oil is used in some homes for its flavour, and refined vegetable oil in others for its neutral taste and higher smoke point. Whichever oil is used, it must be fresh and it must be hot enough before the first ring goes in.
HOW SELROTI IS MADE
↓
↓
↓
↓
Follow the diagram in order, and notice the two places where the maker judges by sense: the batter must flow in a steady stream, and the oil must be hot enough that the ring rises and sizzles at once.
A worked example: judging the batter and the oil by tests, not by guessing
Two tests decide whether a batch of selroti will fry well, and both use the senses, not instruments.
The spoon test for batter. Lift a spoon of batter and let it fall back into the bowl. If it falls in a thin, fast stream and the ring breaks as it is poured, the batter is too thin: add a little more ground rice. If it falls in slow lumps and will not pour in a ring at all, the batter is too thick: add water a spoon at a time. If it falls in a steady, ribbon like stream that holds its shape for a second before sinking, the batter is right. Write down how much water you added to reach that stream, so the next batch starts from the same point.
The drop test for oil. Before the first ring goes in, drop a small piece of batter into the oil. If it sinks and stays pale, the oil is too cool: wait, and the ring would turn greasy. If it rises at once, sizzles, and turns golden in about a minute, the oil is right. If it browns in seconds and smells burnt, the oil is too hot: take the pan off the heat for a minute before frying.
A worked example: timing a batch for Tihar
A maker needs 40 rings for guests. The pan holds 4 rings at a time, and each round takes about 2 minutes in the oil, plus about 1 minute to lift, drain, and pour the next round. That is 3 minutes per round, and 40 rings need 10 rounds, so the frying takes about 30 minutes. The batter was soaked overnight and ground in the morning, so the real work is the day before, not the frying. The lesson is planning: a maker who starts soaking the rice on the morning of Tihar will be late, while a maker who soaks it the night before fries 40 rings in half an hour.
Quick self-check: A maker pours a ring and it spreads flat in the oil instead of holding a ring shape. Which test failed, and what is the fix?
The spoon test failed: the batter is too thin, so it cannot hold a ring. The fix is to thicken the batter with a little more ground rice, then test again with a spoon before pouring another ring.
Doughnut like products: the wider family
Selroti belongs to a family of fried dough foods found in many countries. Learning the family helps you see what selroti shares and what makes it its own:
- Doughnut (wheat): a wheat dough with yeast, shaped into a ring, fried, and often glazed or sugared. Wheat gluten gives a chewy, elastic crumb that selroti does not have.
- Jalebi and jeri: a fermented wheat or chickpea batter piped into hot oil in spirals, then soaked in sugar syrup. The syrup soak is the difference: jalebi is wet and sweet through, selroti is dry and crisp.
- Puri and poori: a wheat dough rolled flat and fried so it puffs into a balloon. The puff comes from steam trapped inside, not from a ring shape.
- Malpua and similar pancakes: a batter fried as a flat cake, often soaked in syrup.
- Nepali doughnuts and fried breads: wheat based rings and cakes made in cities, often with yeast, sugar, and milk, sold in bakeries. They are doughnut like in shape and method, but they are not selroti, because their grain, their ferment, and their festival place differ.
The comparison teaches a principle: frying is one method, but the grain, the batter, the ferment, and the finishing decide the product. Change the grain from rice to wheat, and the texture changes. Change the finish from dry to syrup soaked, and the keeping quality changes. A food technologist who understands those changes can invent a new product without losing the old one.
Uses: when and how selroti is eaten
Selroti is eaten warm, soon after frying, when it is crisp outside and soft inside. It is served with tea, with potato pickle, with meat curry, or on its own as a snack. At Tihar, it is made in large amounts, given to guests, and sent as a gift to family. At weddings, it is part of the feast. It keeps for a few days in a dry container, but it is best fresh: the crispness fades as the ring absorbs moisture from the air.
Selroti also travels well, which is why it is sent to family in the city or abroad. A well fried, well drained ring, packed dry, can travel for days and still taste of home. That is a practical property, and it is one reason selroti is a good small business product.
Quality control
| Check | Good selroti | Fault, and its cause |
|---|---|---|
| Shape | Even ring, holds its shape | Broken ring: batter too thin, or poured too slowly |
| Colour | Even golden brown | Pale: oil too cool. Dark: oil too hot, or too much sugar |
| Texture outside | Crisp, not greasy | Greasy: oil too cool, or ring left in oil too long |
| Texture inside | Soft, light, cooked through | Doughy inside: oil too hot, outside cooked before inside |
| Taste | Sweet, fragrant, mild sour note | Bitter: too much soda. Sour: batter fermented too long |
| Oil | Fresh, clear, not smoking | Dark, smoky oil: throw it away and use fresh oil |
Common faults, in plain words
- Flat rings: the batter was too thin, or the ferment was too long and the gas escaped, or the soda was left out. Thicken the batter, shorten the ferment, and add the soda just before frying.
- Greasy rings: the oil was too cool, so the crust formed slowly and oil soaked in. Heat the oil until a drop of batter rises and sizzles at once.
- Burnt outside, raw inside: the oil was too hot. Lower the heat and fry a little longer.
- Hard rings: the batter was too thick, or the rice was ground too coarse. Grind finer and add a little water.
Nutrition and health
Selroti is an energy food: rice starch plus sugar plus oil gives calories, and the cardamom gives fragrance. It is not a protein food and not a vitamin food, and it should be eaten as part of a meal with protein and vegetables, not as the whole meal. The frying adds fat, and the sugar adds sweetness, so a person who eats selroti every day should eat it in modest amounts. That is not a criticism of the food: festival foods are meant to be rich, and they are eaten on festival days. The problem is only when a festival food becomes an everyday food in the same large amount.
Small scale production and selling
Selroti is a good small business for a home maker, because it needs little equipment: a grinder, a pan, oil, and a clean place to drain and pack. The points that decide success are:
- Steady batter: the same rice, the same soak, the same grind, every day, so every ring tastes the same.
- Fresh oil: oil is the main cost, and its quality is the main quality check. Do not reuse oil until it is dark.
- Packing: pack the rings only when they are cool and dry, in a clean, dry bag or box, so they stay crisp.
- Honest label: if the product is sold, the label should name the ingredients, the weight, and the date. A buyer who knows what is in the food trusts the maker.
Quick self-check: Why is a selroti fried in cool oil greasy, while one fried in hot oil is crisp?
Because hot oil makes the surface water boil off at once and a crust forms fast, and that crust stops oil soaking in. In cool oil, the crust forms slowly, so oil has time to soak into the batter before the crust seals it.
Questions to think about
- Why does selroti use rice batter, and what would change if you used wheat dough instead?
- A seller wants selroti to stay crisp for a week on a shop shelf. What would you change in the frying, cooling, and packing, and what would you refuse to change?
- Jalebi is soaked in syrup and selroti is served dry. How does that one difference change the keeping quality of each?
Try it yourself: Fry one ring well
Make a small batch of selroti batter, or watch a maker fry it. Fry three rings: one in oil that is just warm, one in oil at the right heat, and one in oil that is smoking hot. Compare the colour, the crispness, the greasiness, and the inside. Write down which one was best and what the oil temperature did in each case. If you only watch, ask the maker how they judge the oil, and write down their test in their words.
Practical note
The syllabus practical is preparation and quality tests of each product. For this unit, prepare selroti in class: record rice weight, soaking time, batter consistency, fermentation time, oil temperature, and frying time. Test the finished rings for shape, colour, crispness, greasiness, and taste, and record the faults and their causes.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Selroti is a fermented rice batter, poured as a ring into hot oil at 170 to 180 °C.
- Rice has no gluten, so selroti is a batter, not a kneaded dough, and its texture is light and crisp.
- Fermentation and a pinch of soda give gas that puffs the ring; too much soda tastes bitter.
- Hot oil forms a crisp crust fast and keeps the ring from turning greasy; cool oil makes a greasy ring.
- Selroti belongs to a wide family of fried dough foods, and the grain, batter, and finish decide each product.
- Oil quality is a quality check: dark, smoky oil must be thrown away.
Glossary
Selroti
A ring of fermented rice batter fried in oil until golden and crisp outside, soft inside. Food tech example: selroti is made for Tihar and served warm with tea.
Maillard reaction
Browning between sugars and proteins in hot, dry cooking, giving colour and roasted flavour. Food tech example: the golden colour of selroti comes from the Maillard reaction.
Smoke point
The temperature at which an oil starts to smoke and break down. Food tech example: oil heated past its smoke point gives a burnt taste to selroti.
Starch gelatinisation
Starch granules swelling and setting when heated with water, forming a structure. Food tech example: the crust of selroti sets as its starch gelatinises in hot oil.
Jaggery
Unrefined sugar made from sugarcane or palm sap. Food tech example: jaggery sweetens some selroti batters.
Baking soda
Sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO₃), which releases CO₂ when it meets acid. Food tech example: a pinch of baking soda puffs selroti batter.
Gluten
A protein in wheat that gives dough its stretch and chew. Food tech example: rice has no gluten, so selroti is a batter, not a dough.
Jalebi
A spiral of fermented batter fried in oil and soaked in sugar syrup. Food tech example: jalebi is wet and sweet through, unlike dry selroti.
Puri
A flat wheat dough fried so it puffs into a balloon. Food tech example: puri puffs because steam is trapped inside.
Crust
The crisp outer layer formed when a food is fried or baked. Food tech example: a good selroti has a crisp crust that stops oil soaking in.
Fermented batter
A batter left so yeasts and lactic acid bacteria make gas and acid. Food tech example: selroti batter ferments for a few hours before frying.
Cardamom
A fragrant spice used in selroti and sweets. Food tech example: ground cardamom gives selroti its scent.
Syrup soak
Soaking a fried food in sugar syrup after frying. Food tech example: jalebi is soaked in syrup, selroti is not.
Refined oil
Oil that has been cleaned and deodorised, with a neutral taste and a high smoke point. Food tech example: refined vegetable oil fries selroti without adding flavour.
Caramelisation
Browning of sugars alone under heat, giving a sweet, brown colour and flavour. Food tech example: the sugar in selroti batter caramelises as well as browning by the Maillard reaction.
References
- Srivastava, R. P. and Kumar, S., Fruit and Vegetable Preservation: Principles and Practices, International Book Distributing Company, 3rd edition, 2002.
- Bamforth, C. W., et al., Handbook of Food and Beverage Fermentation Technology, CRC Press, 2004.
- Adams, M. R. and Moss, M. O., Food Microbiology, Royal Society of Chemistry, 4th edition, 2018.
Unit 10: Fermented Milk Products: Dahi, Mahi, Yoghurt, and Cheese
Note
Unit 10: Fermented Milk Products: Dahi, Mahi, Yoghurt, and Cheese
A question to start with
Milk left on a warm kitchen counter turns sour in a day. Milk with a spoon of yesterday's dahi added turns into dahi in a few hours, and it tastes clean and pleasant. What is the difference? In the first case, whichever microbes happen to be in the milk take over, and some of them spoil it. In the second case, the right microbes are added in large numbers, and they take over first. That is the whole science of fermented milk: give the right microbes a head start, and they will make acid, flavour, and texture before the wrong ones get a chance.
Milk is the most perishable food in this subject. It is rich in protein, lactose (milk sugar), fat, and water, and it is near neutral in pH, so microbes grow in it fast. Fermentation is the traditional answer: turn the milk into dahi, mahi, yoghurt, or cheese, and it keeps longer, tastes better, and is easier to digest.
Dahi: the fermented milk of Nepal
Dahi is set curd, made by adding a starter to warm milk and letting it set until it is thick and pleasantly sour. It is eaten every day in Nepal, with rice, with chiura, with selroti, and on its own. It is also used in worship and at festivals, and a pot of good dahi is a sign of a well kept home.
How dahi is made
- Boil the milk: fresh milk is boiled, which kills most microbes and changes the milk proteins so the curd sets firmly. Boiling also drives off a little water, which thickens the milk.
- Cool to warm: the milk is cooled to about 40 to 45 °C, warm to the touch but not hot. Too hot kills the starter; too cool makes the setting slow and lets spoilage grow.
- Add the starter: a spoon of dahi from a previous batch is stirred in. The starter carries lactic acid bacteria, mainly Lactobacillus and Streptococcus species, which will ferment the milk.
- Set undisturbed: the pot is covered and kept warm and still for 4 to 8 hours. Moving the pot breaks the curd. The bacteria turn lactose into lactic acid, and the acid makes the milk proteins clump into a soft, smooth curd.
- Cool and eat: the dahi is cooled and eaten within a day or two. In a warm climate it will keep turning more sour, so it is best kept cool and eaten fresh.
The science
The main reaction is the same as in gundruk: lactose, a sugar, is turned into lactic acid by lactic acid bacteria. Lactose is C₁₂H₂₂O₁₁, and the bacteria split it into glucose and galactose, then turn those into lactic acid. The acid drops the pH from about 6.6 in fresh milk to about 4.5 in dahi. At that pH, the main milk protein, casein, loses its charge and clumps together, forming the curd. The fat stays trapped in the curd, giving richness, and the whey, the watery liquid, separates a little at the edges.
Dahi is easier to digest than milk for two reasons. First, much of the lactose is already broken down, so people who struggle with lactose can often eat dahi. Second, the bacteria make enzymes that start breaking down protein. Dahi also carries live cultures, which is why it is called a probiotic food, although the exact health effects depend on the strains and the amount eaten, and a label should not claim a medical effect without proof.
HOW DAHI IS MADE
↓
↓
↓
↓
The diagram shows the five steps in order. The temperature step is the one that most often goes wrong: milk that is too hot kills the starter, and milk that is too cool sets slowly and turns slimy.
Quick self-check: Why is the milk boiled before the starter is added?
Boiling kills the microbes already in the milk, so they cannot compete with the starter, and it changes the milk proteins so the curd sets firmly. Without boiling, spoilage microbes could take over and the curd would be weak.
A worked example: starter, setting, and acidity in numbers
Three small calculations make dahi making repeatable instead of a matter of luck.
Starter amount. The method uses a spoon of dahi per batch. A spoon holds about 15 grams, and the usual ratio is about one spoon per litre of milk. For 5 litres of milk, use 5 spoonfuls, about 75 grams of starter. Too little starter sets slowly and lets spoilage grow; too much starter makes the dahi set fast and turn sharp. Weigh the starter once, then use the same spoon every time.
Setting time and temperature. The milk is cooled to 40 to 45 °C and kept warm for 4 to 8 hours. In a warm kitchen the curd may set in 4 hours; in a cold room it may need 8. The check is the set, not the clock: tilt the pot gently, and if the dahi holds its shape and a little whey shows at the edge, it is set. If it still flows like milk, give it more time in a warm place.
Acidity by titration. The same titration from Unit 4 works for dahi. Titrate a 10 gram sample with 0.1 normal sodium hydroxide. If the titre is 9.0 millilitres, the titratable acidity is 0.81 percent as lactic acid. If the titre is 12.0 millilitres, it is 1.08 percent, and the dahi will taste sharper. A maker who records the titre for each batch can say exactly how sour the dahi is, and can prove it to a buyer or an inspector.
Why buffalo milk sets firmer than cow milk
Buffalo milk carries more total solids than cow milk: more fat, more protein, and more casein in every litre. More casein means a denser curd network when the acid forms, so dahi from buffalo milk sets firmer and tastes richer. Cow milk dahi is softer and lighter. Neither is wrong: the firmer set suits eating with chiura, where a soft dahi would run off the flakes, while a softer dahi suits drinking. A maker who changes milk without changing the setting time will be surprised, so the milk type belongs in the batch record, next to the starter amount and the temperature.
Quick self-check: A maker switches from buffalo milk to cow milk and the dahi sets soft and leaks whey. What changed, and what should the maker do?
Buffalo milk has more casein and more total solids, so it sets firmer. Cow milk has less, so the curd is weaker and whey separates more easily. The maker should accept a softer set, or boil the cow milk a little longer to drive off water and thicken it, and record the milk type in the batch record.
Mahi: buttermilk
Mahi is the liquid left after churning dahi or cream to make butter and ghee. It is thin, sour, and refreshing, and it is drunk on its own, or used in cooking. In the hills, mahi is made by churning dahi in a wooden churn, called a theki, with a rope or a stick. The churning breaks the fat globules, the butter clumps together, and the liquid that remains is mahi.
Mahi is low in fat, because the fat has gone into the butter, and it carries the acid and the live cultures of the dahi. It is a good drink in hot weather, and it is used to cook vegetables and lentils, where its acid softens them and adds flavour. Its keeping quality is short: it should be drunk the same day, or kept cool and used within a day.
Ghee and butter: the products that come with mahi
Churning dahi gives butter, and heating butter gently gives ghee, the clear golden fat that keeps for months without a fridge. Ghee is not a fermented product itself, but it is part of the same milk chain: milk to dahi, dahi to butter and mahi, butter to ghee. Each step removes water and concentrates fat, and the final product, ghee, has almost no water, so microbes cannot grow in it. That is why ghee keeps for months at room temperature while milk keeps for hours.
Yoghurt: dahi's close cousin
Yoghurt is the name used in the West and in factories for a set fermented milk made with a defined starter, usually Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus, grown together. The method is the same as dahi: boil, cool, add starter, set warm, cool. The difference is that yoghurt uses a known, laboratory grown starter, a controlled temperature, and often a standardised milk, so every pot tastes the same. Dahi uses a home starter that varies, so every pot tastes a little different.
In Nepal, the word yoghurt is now used for factory made cups sold in shops, and the word dahi is used for the home made pot. The science is the same, and the choice between them is about scale, steadiness, and taste. A factory yoghurt is steadier and keeps longer under refrigeration. A home dahi is more varied and more local. Both are good foods when they are made cleanly.
Flavoured and set yoghurt
Factories make yoghurt in two main forms. Set yoghurt is fermented in its final cup, so it sets as a firm curd. Stirred yoghurt is fermented in a tank, then stirred smooth and poured into cups, so it is softer and spoonable. Fruit, sugar, or flavour may be added, and the label must say so. A yoghurt with added sugar is a sweet food, not a plain fermented milk, and its nutrition is different. The buyer should read the label.
Cheese: the long keeping milk food
Cheese is milk preserved by removing water and adding acid, salt, and sometimes rennet. The traditional cheeses of Nepal include chhurpi, a hard, dried cheese of the high Himalaya, and soft fresh cheeses made from cow or buffalo milk.
How cheese is made, in general
- Curdle the milk: acid, rennet, or both make the casein clump into a curd. Rennet is an enzyme from the stomach of a young animal, or a microbial rennet, that cuts casein and makes a firm curd.
- Cut and drain: the curd is cut into pieces, and the whey drains away. Cutting more and heating the curd gives a drier cheese.
- Press: the curd is pressed in a mould, which squeezes out more whey and gives the cheese its shape.
- Salt: salt is mixed in or the cheese is soaked in brine. Salt flavours the cheese, draws out water, and slows microbes.
- Ripen or dry: a soft cheese is eaten fresh. A hard cheese is ripened, where enzymes and microbes slowly change flavour and texture, or it is dried, as chhurpi is, until it is hard enough to chew for a long time.
Chhurpi: the cheese that lasts
Chhurpi is made from yak, cow, or buffalo milk in the high mountains. The milk is heated, curdled with acid or with whey, the curd is pressed, cut into cubes or strips, and dried in the sun and wind until it is hard as stone. It is chewed slowly, like a sweet, and it softens in the mouth over a long time. It is a travel food: light, hard, and keeping for months, made for herders and travellers who need protein that does not spoil. Soft chhurpi is also made, eaten fresh as a soft, crumbly cheese.
The science is water removal taken to the extreme: chhurpi is dried until its water activity is far below the level that microbes need. The protein is concentrated, the fat is concentrated, and the flavour is strong and sour. The quality checks are dryness, hardness, and cleanliness: a chhurpi that is soft inside will mould, and a chhurpi dried on dirty ground will carry dust and insects.
Other traditional cheeses
Soft fresh cheeses are made by heating milk and adding an acid such as lemon juice or whey, then draining the curd in cloth. This is the same method as paneer, and the fresh cheese is eaten the same day, cooked into curries or eaten with bread. It is perishable, because it is wet and only mildly acid, so it must be kept cool and eaten quickly.
Quality control for fermented milk products
| Product | Main check | Good sign | Fault |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dahi | Smell, taste, set | Clean sour, firm set, smooth | Slimy, bitter, whey on top, yeasty |
| Mahi | Smell, freshness | Clean sour, fresh | Rancid, old, dirty |
| Yoghurt | pH, set, flavour | pH 4.0 to 4.5, firm, clean | Whey separation, sour too sharp, mould |
| Chhurpi | Dryness, hardness | Hard through, dry, clean | Soft centre, mould, dirty surface |
| Soft cheese | Smell, freshness | Mild, fresh, white | Sour, slimy, grey |
Common faults in dahi
- Slimy dahi: the milk was too cool when the starter was added, or the starter was weak, or the pot was moved during setting. Use fresh starter, set at 40 to 45 °C, and do not move the pot.
- Bitter dahi: the dahi was kept too long, or the milk was overheated, or the starter carried the wrong bacteria. Use fresh starter and eat the dahi fresh.
- Whey on top: the dahi was set too long or too warm, or the milk was thin. Shorten the setting time and use full milk.
- Yeasty or gassy dahi: yeasts grew because the pot was dirty or the milk was not boiled. Clean the pot, boil the milk, and use fresh starter.
- Mould on dahi: the pot was left open, or the dahi was kept too long. Cover the pot, keep it cool, and eat it fresh.
Quick self-check: Why should a dahi pot not be moved while it is setting?
Because moving breaks the soft casein network as it forms, so the curd sets weakly and whey separates. A still pot lets the network form evenly and the curd sets firm and smooth.
Hygiene and safety
Milk safety starts with the animal and the milking: clean hands, clean udder, clean bucket, and milk used quickly or cooled. Milk that sits warm for hours before it is boiled will already carry a large number of microbes, and boiling will kill them but will not remove toxins made by some of them, such as Staphylococcus aureus. The rule is to boil fresh milk promptly, and to make dahi from milk that was boiled the same day.
The starter must be fresh and clean. A starter kept for a week in a warm kitchen will carry yeasts and moulds as well as lactic acid bacteria, and the dahi will be gassy and bitter. Keep a little starter from a good batch, use it the next day, and renew it from a fresh, clean batch when it starts to taste wrong. A factory keeps its starter as a laboratory culture, frozen or freeze dried, so it never drifts.
The pots, cloths, and churns must be washed with soap and clean water, and dried in the sun. A pot that held a failed dahi must be cleaned before it is used again, or the fault will repeat.
Industrial production
A factory that makes yoghurt standardises the milk, heats it, cools it, adds a measured starter, ferments it at a controlled temperature, cools it fast, and packs it cold. It tests the pH, the acidity by titration, and the microbial count, and it keeps the product in a cold chain from factory to shop. The cold chain is the difference between a factory yoghurt that keeps for two weeks and a home dahi that keeps for two days: the factory product is cooled fast and kept cold, so the bacteria slow down and the acid stops rising.
A factory that makes hard cheese adds a ripening room, where temperature and humidity are controlled for weeks or months while enzymes change the flavour. The cost is higher, the time is longer, and the product is a different food from a fresh cheese. Both have a place, and the buyer should know which one they are buying.
Questions to think about
- Why does dahi set, while milk does not, and what does acid do to casein?
- A shop sells a yoghurt that is sweet, pink, and flavoured. Is it the same food as home dahi? What is the same, and what is different?
- Chhurpi is hard enough to chew for an hour. What does that tell you about its water content, and why does that matter for a herder?
Try it yourself: Set a pot of dahi
Boil one litre of milk, cool it to warm (test with a clean finger: warm, not hot), stir in a spoon of fresh dahi, cover the pot, and keep it warm and still for 6 hours. Do not move it. At the end, look at the set, smell it, and taste it. Write down the time, the temperature, and the result. If the dahi is slimy or bitter, write down which step you think failed and what you would change.
Practical note
The syllabus practical is preparation and quality tests of each product. For this unit, prepare dahi and a soft cheese in class: record milk volume, boiling time, cooling temperature, starter amount, setting time and temperature, and the final pH and acidity by titration. Test the dahi for set, smell, taste, and whey separation.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Dahi is milk fermented by lactic acid bacteria: lactose becomes lactic acid, pH falls to about 4.5, and casein sets into a curd.
- Boiling the milk first kills competing microbes and firms the curd; cooling to 40 to 45 °C protects the starter.
- Mahi is the liquid left after churning dahi to butter, and ghee is the clear fat that keeps for months.
- Yoghurt is dahi made with a defined starter and a controlled temperature, so it is steadier.
- Cheese is milk preserved by curdling, draining, pressing, salting, and drying or ripening. Chhurpi is the hard, dried cheese of the high Himalaya.
- Fresh milk must be boiled promptly, the starter must be fresh, and the pots must be clean, or the faults will repeat.
Glossary
Dahi
Set fermented milk made by adding a starter to warm boiled milk and letting it set. Food tech example: dahi is eaten with rice and chiura.
Mahi
Buttermilk, the sour liquid left after churning dahi to make butter. Food tech example: mahi is drunk in hot weather and used in cooking.
Yoghurt
Fermented milk made with a defined starter of Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus bulgaricus. Food tech example: factory yoghurt is set in its cup and sold chilled.
Chhurpi
A hard, dried cheese of the Himalaya, chewed slowly as a travel food. Food tech example: dried chhurpi keeps for months in a pocket.
Casein
The main protein in milk, which clumps into a curd when acid is added. Food tech example: acid from dahi bacteria makes casein set.
Lactose
Milk sugar, C₁₂H₂₂O₁₁, turned into lactic acid by bacteria. Food tech example: lactose in milk becomes lactic acid in dahi.
Whey
The watery liquid that separates from curd. Food tech example: whey drains away when cheese is pressed.
Rennet
An enzyme that cuts casein and makes a firm curd for cheese. Food tech example: rennet curdles milk for hard cheese.
Starter culture
Known microbes added to start a fermentation. Food tech example: a spoon of old dahi is the starter for new dahi.
Probiotic
A live microbe in food that may benefit health when eaten in enough amount. Food tech example: dahi carries live lactic acid bacteria.
Ghee
Clear butter fat made by heating butter, keeping for months without a fridge. Food tech example: ghee is made from butter churned from dahi.
Theki
A wooden churn used to churn dahi into butter and mahi. Food tech example: dahi is churned in a theki to make butter.
Titration
A laboratory test that finds acidity by adding a measured alkali until the acid is neutralised. Food tech example: titration measures the acidity of dahi.
Cold chain
Keeping a food cold, without a break, from factory to shop to home. Food tech example: factory yoghurt needs a cold chain to keep for two weeks.
Syneresis
The separation of whey from a set curd, seen as liquid on top of dahi. Food tech example: a dahi set too long or too warm shows syneresis.
References
- Tamime, A. Y. and Robinson, R. K., Yoghurt: Science and Technology, Woodhead Publishing, 2nd edition, 1999.
- Fox, P. F., et al., Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry, Springer, 2nd edition, 2015.
- Holzapfel, W. H., et al., Advances in Fermented Foods and Beverages, Woodhead Publishing, 2015.
- Department of Food Technology and Quality Control, Manual on Milk Safety, Quality and Hygiene, Government of Nepal.
Unit 11: Traditional Snack Foods: Chiura, Murai, and Friends
Note
Unit 11: Traditional Snack Foods: Chiura, Murai, and Friends
A question to start with
A traveller in the hills carries no stove, no fridge, and no time to cook. What does she eat for lunch? She eats food that is already cooked, dry, light, and ready: a packet of chiura, a handful of murai, a piece of selroti, a strip of sukuti. These are snack foods, and they are the oldest fast food in Nepal. This unit follows the two great grain snacks, chiura and murai, and the family of snacks around them, and it explains how heat and force turn a hard grain into a food that is ready to eat.
Snack foods are foods eaten between meals, on a journey, at work, or with tea. In Nepal, traditional snacks are not an afterthought: they are a planned part of the food system, made after the harvest, stored for months, and eaten when a full meal cannot be cooked. They are also festival and guest foods: chiura is served to guests, murai is eaten at fairs, and both are given as gifts.
Chiura: beaten rice
Chiura is rice that has been soaked, roasted, and beaten flat while it is still hot, so that each grain becomes a thin, crisp flake. It is the most widely eaten traditional snack in Nepal, served with dahi, with milk, with pickles, with meat curry, or with tea. It is also a travel food: light, dry, and ready to eat without cooking.
How chiura is made
- Soak the paddy: paddy rice, still in its husk, is soaked in water overnight, or for a day, until the grain is soft inside.
- Roast: the soaked paddy is drained and roasted in a hot pan or in a roaster, with constant stirring, until the husk cracks and the grain is hot through. The roasting gelatinises the starch: the starch granules swell with water and set, so the grain will hold its flat shape when it is beaten.
- Beat while hot: the hot paddy is poured into a mortar or a beating machine and beaten at once, while it is still hot and soft. The beating flattens each grain into a thin flake and knocks the husk off. This step must be fast: if the grain cools, it turns hard and it will not flatten, it will only crack.
- Winnow and dry: the flakes are winnowed to remove husk and broken pieces, then dried in the sun until they are crisp. Drying gives chiura its keeping quality.
- Store: dried chiura is stored in a dry, airtight container. It keeps for months if it is kept dry, and it is eaten dry or soaked briefly in milk or dahi.
The science
Chiura is a lesson in starch. Soaking lets water into the grain. Roasting heats that water, and the starch gelatinises, which means the granules swell, take up water, and form a soft, set network. Beating while the starch is hot and soft flattens the grain, and as it cools the starch sets in its new flat shape. The flake is thin, so it dries fast, and so it rehydrates fast when it is soaked in milk: a thin flake needs only a minute in dahi to soften, while a whole grain of rice needs half an hour of cooking. That is the point of chiura: the cooking is done once, at the mill, and the eating needs no cooking at all.
The quality of chiura is judged by its thinness, its crispness, and its colour. Good chiura is thin, even, white to pale cream, and crisp. Thick chiura is chewy and hard to eat. Brown or burnt chiura was roasted too hot. Damp chiura goes soft in the packet and grows mould, so the drying step must be complete and the packet must be moisture proof.
HOW CHIURA IS MADE
↓
↓
↓
↓
The diagram shows the order that matters: soak, roast, beat while hot. If the beating waits until the grain cools, the grain will crack instead of flattening, and the chiura will be broken and hard.
Quick self-check: Why must chiura be beaten while the grain is still hot?
Because the starch is soft and set only while it is hot. As it cools, the starch firms up, so a cooled grain cracks when it is beaten instead of flattening into a flake.
Murai: puffed rice
Murai is rice that has been puffed: heated so fast that the water inside the grain turns to steam, and the steam blows the grain up like a small balloon. It is light, crisp, white, and airy, and it is eaten as a snack, with tea, with milk, or with jaggery and coconut.
How murai is made
Paddy or milled rice is heated in a hot pan with sand, or in a puffing machine, at a high temperature. The heat is fast and fierce. The water inside the grain turns to steam in a fraction of a second, and the pressure blows the starch network outward. The grain expands to several times its size, turns white, and becomes crisp. The puffed grains are sieved to remove sand and broken pieces, then cooled and packed.
The science
Puffing is steam power. The grain holds a little water, about 12 to 14 percent by weight. When the grain is heated fast, that water becomes steam, and steam takes up far more space than liquid water. The pressure inside the grain rises until the starch, which is soft at that heat, stretches and bursts outward. As the puffed grain cools, the starch sets in its new, airy shape. The result is a food that is mostly air: light to carry, quick to eat, and easy to digest, because the starch is fully gelatinised and the surface area is large.
Murai is best made from a rice variety that puffs well, with the right moisture: too dry, and there is not enough steam to puff; too wet, and the grain sticks and burns. The roasting sand, where it is used, carries heat evenly to every grain, so they puff at the same time. A machine puffing unit uses hot air or a heated chamber instead of sand, and it is cleaner and steadier, which is why city murai is made in machines.
A worked example: how much steam is inside one kilo of rice
The unit says the grain holds about 12 to 14 percent water by weight. Take the middle value, 13 percent. One kilo of rice holds 130 grams of water. That is a small glass of water, and it seems too little to blow a grain up. But water as steam takes up far more space than water as a liquid: one kilo of water becomes about 1.67 cubic metres of steam at boiling point. Work it out for 130 grams: 0.13 kilos times 1.67 cubic metres per kilo equals about 0.22 cubic metres, which is about 220 litres of steam. All of that steam is made inside the grains in a fraction of a second, and it has nowhere to go except outward, stretching the soft starch until the grain bursts open and sets in its puffed shape. The puffing power was always there, hidden in the water the grain already held: the heat only releases it, and the speed is what makes it a puff instead of a slow drying.
A worked example: why a flake softens faster than a grain
Chiura softens in about a minute in dahi, while a whole grain of rice needs about half an hour of cooking to soften. The reason is shape, not chemistry. A chiura flake is thin, so milk or dahi only has to travel a short distance to reach its centre, and its surface area is large compared with its weight, so liquid meets a lot of flake at once. A whole grain is thick and round, so liquid must travel far into a small surface. The same starch, the same liquid, and the only change is the shape, yet the eating time falls from 30 minutes to 1 minute. That is why beating the rice flat is not decoration: it is the step that makes chiura a food that needs no cooking at all.
Quick self-check: A batch of murai comes out half puffed and hard in the middle. The heat was high and the pan was hot. What else could be wrong?
The grain was probably too dry: with too little water inside, there is not enough steam to puff the grain, however hot the pan is. The fix is to use grain at about 12 to 14 percent moisture, not overdried grain.
Quality control for murai
- Puff: even, white, and fully expanded. Half puffed grains are a fault: the heat was too low or the grain was too dry.
- Colour: white to pale cream. Brown grains were overheated.
- Crispness: crisp and dry. Soft murai has absorbed moisture from the air, and it must be dried again or discarded.
- Cleanliness: no sand, no stones, no husk. Sieving after puffing is the control.
Other traditional snacks
Chiura and murai are the two named in the syllabus, but the snack family is wider, and a student should know its other members:
- Selroti: covered in Unit 9, the fried ring that is both a snack and a festival food.
- Sukuti: covered in Unit 6, dried meat chewed as a snack.
- Masyaura and dried legumes: roasted chickpeas, soybeans, and lentils, eaten as a crunchy snack with tea.
- Roasted maize and millet: grains roasted in a pan until they pop or turn crisp, eaten warm with salt and chilli.
- Laddu and sweet balls: roasted flour, jaggery, and ghee rolled into balls, made for festivals and for travel.
- Puffed and beaten millet and maize: the same beating and puffing methods applied to grains other than rice, giving snacks for communities where rice is scarce.
Each of these is a snack because it is dry, ready to eat, and keeping. The method is always one of the same few: roast, beat, puff, fry, or dry. Learn those five methods, and you can understand any traditional snack.
The snack as a system: why snacks matter
Snacks are not a luxury. They are a planned part of the food system, and they do four jobs:
- They use the harvest: after the rice is threshed, some of it is beaten into chiura and some puffed into murai, so the grain is stored in a form that is ready to eat.
- They feed travellers and workers: a person who cannot stop to cook can eat chiura with dahi, or murai with tea, and keep working.
- They feed children: a child can eat a handful of murai or a piece of selroti without a fire, a pot, or a plate.
- They carry culture: chiura with dahi is served to guests, murai is eaten at fairs, and selroti marks Tihar. The snack is the food of welcome and celebration, not only of hunger.
Nutrition
Chiura and murai are mainly starch, so they give energy. Chiura keeps the fibre and minerals of the rice, and when it is eaten with dahi, the meal gains protein, calcium, and live cultures. Murai is lighter and lower in fibre, because the puffing breaks the grain open and some of the bran is lost. Neither is a complete food on its own, and both are best eaten with a protein food: dahi, milk, lentils, meat, or egg. The salt and sugar added to some snacks should be modest: a snack that is very salty or very sweet is a treat, not a daily food.
Industrial production and packaging
Chiura and murai are now made in factories and sold in packets across Nepal and abroad. The factory method is the same in spirit: soak, roast, beat or puff, dry, and pack. The differences are machines for beating and puffing, a dryer instead of the sun, and a moisture proof packet with a label. The packet is the key to shelf life: chiura and murai absorb moisture from the air in hours, and a packet that lets moisture in will give a soft, stale product. A good packet is sealed, dry inside, and filled with dry product that was cooled before packing.
The factory must also control the raw material: the rice variety, the moisture, and the freedom from stones. A stone in a packet of chiura is a physical hazard and a broken tooth, and the control is sorting and sieving before roasting. The factory must also label the product honestly: the weight, the ingredients, the date, and the storage advice, which is to keep it dry and eat it soon after opening.
A note on fried snacks
Many modern snacks are fried in oil and sold in packets: potato chips, fried noodles, and similar products. They are snacks, but they are not traditional snacks in the sense of this subject, and they carry more fat and salt than chiura or murai. A food technologist should be able to tell a buyer the difference: a traditional grain snack is a roasted grain, a fried snack is a grain cooked in oil, and the nutrition and the keeping quality differ.
Quick self-check: Why does chiura go soft in a damp room, and what stops it?
Because chiura is thin and dry, it absorbs water vapour from the air quickly. A moisture proof packet, sealed while the chiura is dry and cool, stops the moisture getting in and keeps it crisp.
Questions to think about
- Why is chiura beaten flat and murai puffed up, and what does each shape do for the eater?
- A factory wants to sell chiura in a humid city. What packaging would you choose, and what would you test before you print a shelf life on the packet?
- Which traditional snack would you choose for a school child's lunchbox, and why? Name the protein food you would pack with it.
Try it yourself: Compare chiura and murai
Take a handful of chiura and a handful of murai. Weigh each handful, look at the shape, bite each one, and note the crispness and the taste. Soak a spoon of each in a little milk or dahi for one minute and taste again: which softens faster, and why? Write down your answer in two sentences, using the words thin, surface area, and starch.
Practical note
The syllabus practical is preparation and quality tests of each product. For this unit, prepare chiura and murai in class or visit a maker: record paddy weight, soaking time, roasting time and temperature, and the yield of flakes or puffed grain. Test the finished products for thinness, puff, colour, crispness, and cleanliness, and pack a sample in a moisture proof bag to test its keeping quality over a week.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Chiura is soaked, roasted, and beaten flat while hot, so the gelatinised starch sets as a thin flake.
- Murai is heated fast so the water inside turns to steam and puffs the grain up.
- Both are dry, ready to eat, and keeping, which is why they are travel, work, and guest foods.
- Snacks do real work: they use the harvest, feed travellers and children, and carry culture.
- Chiura and murai are best eaten with a protein food such as dahi, milk, or lentils.
- Packaging must be moisture proof, and the product must be packed cool and dry, or it will go soft.
Glossary
Chiura
Beaten rice: paddy soaked, roasted, and beaten flat while hot into thin crisp flakes. Food tech example: chiura is eaten with dahi as a guest food.
Murai
Puffed rice: grain heated fast so steam puffs it into a light, crisp, airy grain. Food tech example: murai is eaten as a snack with tea.
Starch gelatinisation
Starch granules swelling with water and setting when heated, forming a structure. Food tech example: roasting gelatinises the starch in chiura rice.
Winnowing
Separating light husk from heavier grain by tossing it in the air or wind. Food tech example: chiura is winnowed to remove husk after beating.
Puffing
Heating a grain fast so steam inside expands it. Food tech example: murai is made by puffing rice in a hot pan.
Moisture proof packaging
Packaging that stops water vapour passing in or out. Food tech example: chiura needs moisture proof packaging to stay crisp.
Snack food
A food eaten between meals, on a journey, or with tea, usually dry and ready to eat. Food tech example: murai is a traditional snack food.
Paddy
Rice still in its husk, as harvested. Food tech example: chiura starts from soaked paddy rice.
Bran
The outer layer of a grain, rich in fibre. Food tech example: murai loses some bran when the grain puffs open.
Surface area
The total area of the outside of a food. Food tech example: a thin chiura flake has a large surface area, so it softens fast in milk.
Roasting
Cooking a food in dry heat, in a pan or an oven, without water or oil. Food tech example: maize is roasted in a pan for a snack.
Laddu
A sweet ball made from roasted flour, jaggery, and ghee. Food tech example: laddu is made for festivals and travel.
Physical hazard
A foreign object in food, such as a stone, that can harm the eater. Food tech example: a stone in chiura is a physical hazard.
Yield
The amount of finished product from a given amount of raw material. Food tech example: the yield of chiura is the weight of flakes from one kilo of paddy.
Steam expansion
The large increase in volume when liquid water turns to steam, about 1,700 times at boiling point. Food tech example: steam expansion puffs rice into murai.
References
- Srivastava, R. P. and Kumar, S., Fruit and Vegetable Preservation: Principles and Practices, International Book Distributing Company, 3rd edition, 2002.
- Bamforth, C. W., et al., Handbook of Food and Beverage Fermentation Technology, CRC Press, 2004.
- Adams, M. R. and Moss, M. O., Food Microbiology, Royal Society of Chemistry, 4th edition, 2018.
- Department of Food Technology and Quality Control, Mandatory Quality Standards for Food and Feed, Government of Nepal, 2082.