Login Register

Access the GIFSQ Portal

Select your user type to log in or register a new account.

Student Portal

Access your food safety courses and exams.

Instructor Portal

Manage courses, view student submissions, and grade quizzes.

Company Portal

Manage corporate setup, view employee logs, and access QA services.

GIFSQ ID: FTN-0095

← All subjects

High-Protein Foods and Protein Science

Unit 1: What Protein Is and Why It Matters

Note

Unit 1: What Protein Is and Why It Matters

A question to start with

A bowl of lentil soup, a boiled egg, and a glass of milk sit on a table. All three are called protein foods, but they look nothing alike, and none of them looks like a muscle. How does the body turn such different foods into muscle, skin, blood, and the tiny workers inside every cell? The answer starts with a simple idea: protein is a chain, and the body cuts the chain apart and rebuilds it into its own chains. This unit explains what those chains are made of, where they come from, and why the body needs a fresh supply every day.

Protein is one of the three large nutrient groups in food, beside carbohydrate and fat. The word protein comes from a Greek word meaning first or primary, and the name fits: no living cell can work without protein. Protein builds the body, runs its chemistry, carries things around, and defends it against harm. A food can give energy without protein, but it cannot build or repair the body without it.

The building blocks: amino acids

A protein is a long chain made of smaller units called amino acids. Think of a necklace made of beads: each bead is an amino acid, and the string of beads is the protein. A single protein chain can hold a few dozen amino acids or several thousand. The order of the beads along the chain decides what the protein does, in the same way that the order of letters decides the meaning of a word.

There are 20 amino acids that the body uses to build its proteins. Nine of them are called essential amino acids, because the body cannot make them and must get them from food. The other eleven are called non-essential amino acids, because the body can make them from other materials when it needs to. The word non-essential can mislead: the body still needs these amino acids, it simply does not need to eat them ready made. In illness, injury, or early infancy, some non-essential amino acids become conditionally essential, which means the body cannot make enough of them fast enough and food must supply them.

Each amino acid has the same basic frame: a central carbon atom joined to an amino group, a carboxyl group, a hydrogen atom, and a side chain. The side chain is what makes each amino acid different. Some side chains are small, some are large, some carry a charge, some repel water, and some love water. When amino acids link together, their side chains fold the chain into a shape, and that shape decides the job of the protein.

Two amino acids join by a peptide bond. The carboxyl group of one joins the amino group of the next, and a molecule of water, H₂O, is released. A short chain is called a peptide. A long chain is called a polypeptide, and when that chain folds into its working shape, it is called a protein. The stomach and the small intestine cut food proteins back into amino acids and small peptides, and the body then builds its own proteins from those pieces. This is why eating a chicken does not put chicken muscle into your arm: your body takes the chicken protein apart and rebuilds the pieces into human protein.

The four levels of protein shape

A protein has four levels of structure, and each level matters for what the protein can do.

The primary structure is the order of amino acids along the chain. Change one bead in the order and the protein can stop working. A classic example is the blood protein haemoglobin: one changed amino acid makes the red blood cells bend into a sickle shape, and the blood carries oxygen badly.

The secondary structure is the way the chain coils or folds locally. Two common shapes appear: the alpha helix, a spiral like a coiled spring, and the beta sheet, a flat pleated shape like a folded ribbon. These shapes are held by hydrogen bonds between parts of the chain.

The tertiary structure is the full three-dimensional fold of one chain. The side chains that repel water tuck into the middle, away from water, while the side chains that love water sit on the outside. This folding creates pockets and surfaces where the protein can grip other molecules. An enzyme, for example, has a pocket shaped to fit exactly one kind of molecule.

The quaternary structure appears when two or more chains join to work as one protein. Haemoglobin has four chains working together, and that teamwork lets it pick up oxygen in the lungs and release it in the tissues.

Shape is the reason cooking changes protein. Heat, acid, and strong shaking can unfold a protein, and once unfolded it often cannot fold back. That unfolding is called denaturation, and Unit 7 treats it in full. For now, remember this: an egg white turns from clear liquid to white solid because heat unfolds its proteins and the unfolded chains tangle together into a firm network.

From food protein to body protein

Food protein is eaten: egg, milk, lentils, meat
↓
Stomach acid and enzymes unfold and cut the chains
↓
Small intestine: chains cut into amino acids and small peptides
↓
Amino acids pass into the blood
↓
Cells build new proteins: muscle, enzymes, blood, skin

What protein does in the body

Protein has more jobs than any other nutrient. Five of them cover most of what the body needs.

First, protein builds and repairs tissue. Muscle, skin, hair, nails, and the lining of the gut are all made largely of protein. A growing child builds new tissue every day, an adult replaces worn tissue, and a wound heals by laying down new protein. A cut finger closes because the body makes collagen, the tough protein that forms scars and holds skin together.

Second, protein runs chemistry. Enzymes are proteins that speed up chemical reactions in the body. Without enzymes, the reactions that release energy from food, build new molecules, and clear waste would run too slowly to keep a person alive. The enzyme lactase, for example, splits milk sugar in the gut; a person who makes too little lactase feels discomfort after drinking milk.

Third, protein carries and stores things. Haemoglobin carries oxygen in the blood. Other blood proteins carry iron, copper, and vitamins. Ferritin stores iron in the liver until it is needed. Albumin, the main protein of blood plasma, carries fatty acids and medicines and holds water in the blood vessels.

Fourth, protein defends the body. Antibodies are proteins that recognise invaders such as bacteria and viruses and mark them for removal. The blood clotting proteins stop bleeding: when skin is cut, a chain of protein reactions forms a clot that seals the wound.

Fifth, protein can give energy, but this is its backup job. When food is short, or when carbohydrate is very low, the body can burn amino acids for energy. Each gram of protein gives about 4 kilocalories, the same as carbohydrate. The body prefers to save protein for building and running things, so using protein for energy is wasteful, like burning furniture to heat a house. A diet that gives enough energy from carbohydrate and fat protects the protein for its real work, and this protection is called the protein sparing effect.

How much protein food contains

Protein is measured as a share of the food by weight. A boiled egg weighs about 50 g and holds about 6 g of protein, so it is about 12 percent protein. A 100 g serving of cooked lentils holds about 9 g of protein. A 100 g serving of cooked chicken breast holds about 30 g of protein. A glass of milk, 200 ml, holds about 7 g of protein. These numbers show a plain fact: animal foods are dense in protein per bite, while plant foods give protein in smaller amounts per bite but often bring fibre and other nutrients with it.

The body also holds a large store of protein, about 10 to 12 kg in an adult, mostly in muscle. This is not a store in the same way as body fat: muscle protein is working tissue, and the body only breaks it down in real need, such as long illness or starvation. Every day, the body breaks down and rebuilds about 300 g of its own protein in a cycle called protein turnover. Old proteins are taken apart, their amino acids return to a common pool, and new proteins are built. Food protein tops up that pool. This is why protein is needed every day: the pool is used all the time, and it cannot be filled once and forgotten.

Questions to think about

  • Why can a person live for weeks on very little food but cannot live long without any protein at all?
  • If two foods both give 20 g of protein, does the body treat them the same? What else might differ?
  • An egg white sets solid when it is heated. What has happened to the proteins inside it?
Think about the first question before you read on

A person can live for weeks with little food because the body holds a large store of fat and can burn it for energy. Protein is different: there is no spare store of protein set aside for storage. The protein in the body is working tissue, muscle, blood, and enzymes. When food protein stops, the body still needs amino acids every day for turnover, so it starts taking apart its own muscle and blood proteins. That is why protein shortage shows up as muscle loss, weak defences against infection, and slow healing, even before energy shortage becomes the main problem.

Protein in the diet: a first look at needs

How much protein a person needs depends on body weight, age, growth, activity, and health. The standard way to state a need is grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day. A healthy adult at rest needs about 0.8 g per kilogram per day. A person who weighs 70 kg therefore needs about 56 g of protein a day. That is roughly two eggs, a glass of milk, a serving of lentils, and a piece of bread, spread through the day. A growing child, a pregnant woman, an athlete in heavy training, and a person recovering from illness all need more, because they are building new tissue or repairing it.

These figures are averages, and they hide wide variation. Older adults need more protein per kilogram than young adults, because their muscles respond less strongly to each meal. A person who eats too little energy overall needs more protein, because some of the protein will be burned for energy instead of used for building. Unit 5 treats needs in detail; here the point is simpler: protein need is a daily need, tied to body size, and it is best met by spreading protein across the meals of the day rather than eating it all at once.

One more idea belongs here: protein quality matters as much as protein amount. A food can hold many grams of protein and still serve the body badly if it lacks one of the essential amino acids or if the body cannot digest it well. The next unit explains quality, amino acids, and digestibility in full.

Protein and energy: a worked example

Take a plain meal: 100 g of cooked rice, 100 g of cooked lentils, and a boiled egg. The rice gives about 130 kcal and about 2.5 g of protein. The lentils give about 115 kcal and about 9 g of protein. The egg gives about 70 kcal and about 6 g of protein. The meal gives about 315 kcal and about 17.5 g of protein. For a 70 kg adult who needs about 56 g a day, this one meal gives close to a third of the daily protein need. Three such meals, with small extras such as bread or milk, cover the day.

Now change the meal: replace the lentils and egg with a spoon of butter and a sweet drink. The energy stays similar, but the protein falls to about 3 g. The body gets fuel but almost no building material. This is the difference between an energy food and a protein food, and it is why labels that shout about energy alone tell only half the story. A food technologist who reads a recipe must always ask two questions: how much energy does it give, and how much protein does it give, and in what quality?

Practical note: When you compare protein foods in a shop, read the protein per 100 g on the label, not the protein per pack. A pack that claims 20 g of protein may weigh 400 g, while a small pack claiming 12 g may weigh only 100 g. Per 100 g is the fair comparison, and it is the number a food technologist uses when costing a recipe.

Quick self-check

Question: Name the nine essential amino acids and explain why they are called essential.

The nine are histidine, isoleucine, leucine, lysine, methionine, phenylalanine, threonine, tryptophan, and valine. They are called essential because the body cannot make them, or cannot make enough of them, so they must come from food. The other eleven amino acids are made by the body from other materials.

Question: Why does an egg white turn solid when heated?

Heat unfolds the egg white proteins, a change called denaturation. The unfolded chains tangle and bond to each other, forming a firm network that traps water. The change is permanent: cooling does not turn the solid white back into clear liquid.

Question: How much protein does a 60 kg adult need at 0.8 g per kilogram per day?

60 times 0.8 equals 48 g of protein per day. That is a daily average, and it is best spread across meals rather than eaten in one sitting.

Try it yourself

Buy or find three protein foods in your kitchen: an egg, a cup of milk or yoghurt, and a handful of lentils, beans, or nuts. Read the nutrition label on each one and write down the protein per 100 g and the serving size. Work out the grams of protein in one serving of each. Then add the three servings together and compare the total with the daily need of a 70 kg adult, about 56 g. Ask yourself two questions: which food gives the most protein per 100 g, and which gives the most protein in the serving you would actually eat? The two answers are often different, and that difference is what a food technologist thinks about when designing a product.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Protein is a long chain of amino acids, and the order of the amino acids decides what the protein does.
  • Nine amino acids are essential and must come from food; the body makes the other eleven.
  • Protein builds and repairs tissue, runs chemistry as enzymes, carries substances, defends the body as antibodies, and gives energy only as a backup.
  • Protein shape has four levels, and shape decides function: unfolding a protein usually stops it working.
  • The body turns over about 300 g of its own protein every day, so food protein is needed daily.
  • A healthy adult needs about 0.8 g of protein per kilogram of body weight per day, spread across meals.
  • Protein amount and protein quality are different things, and both must be judged before a food is called a good protein food.

Glossary

Amino acid

A small unit that links with others to form a protein; there are 20 used by the body. Food tech example: lysine is an amino acid that is often low in cereal grains, so bread made from wheat alone is short of lysine.

Antibody

A protein made by the immune system that recognises a specific invader such as a bacterium or virus. Food tech example: antibodies in blood are measured in food safety work when checking a worker's response to a vaccine, not as a food ingredient.

Collagen

A tough fibrous protein that gives strength to skin, tendons, and bones. Food tech example: gelatine is made by heating collagen from bones and skin, and it sets jellies and desserts.

Conditionally essential amino acid

An amino acid the body can usually make, but cannot make fast enough in illness, injury, or early infancy, so food must supply it then. Food tech example: infant formula is checked to make sure it supplies enough of these amino acids for a growing baby.

Denaturation

Unfolding of a protein from its working shape, caused by heat, acid, or shaking, usually permanent. Food tech example: milk proteins denature when milk is heated, which is why heated milk forms a skin.

Digestibility

How much of a food's protein the body can break down and absorb. Food tech example: well cooked lentils are more digestible than raw lentils, because cooking softens the cell walls and unfolds the proteins.

Enzyme

A protein that speeds up a chemical reaction in the body or in food without being used up. Food tech example: the enzyme rennet curdles milk to make cheese by cutting one milk protein.

Essential amino acid

An amino acid the body cannot make and must get from food. Food tech example: a food that supplies all nine essential amino acids in good amounts is called a complete protein food.

Haemoglobin

The protein in red blood cells that carries oxygen from the lungs to the tissues. Food tech example: meat is rich in haem iron, the form of iron held inside haemoglobin, which the body absorbs well.

Peptide

A short chain of amino acids joined by peptide bonds. Food tech example: small peptides formed during cheese ripening give aged cheese some of its flavour.

Peptide bond

The chemical link between two amino acids in a protein chain. Food tech example: stomach enzymes cut peptide bonds to break food protein into smaller pieces.

Protein turnover

The daily cycle in which the body breaks down old proteins and builds new ones. Food tech example: athletes in heavy training have faster protein turnover, so they need more protein from food each day.

Quaternary structure

The arrangement of two or more protein chains joined to work as one protein. Food tech example: the casein micelle in milk is a large assembly of several milk proteins joined with calcium.

Secondary structure

The local coiling or folding of a protein chain, such as a helix or a flat sheet. Food tech example: the spiral shape of some meat proteins unwinds when meat is cooked, which changes its texture.

Tertiary structure

The full three-dimensional fold of one protein chain. Food tech example: an enzyme loses its activity when its tertiary structure unfolds during heating.

References

  • Lehninger, A. L., Nelson, D. L. and Cox, M. M., Principles of Biochemistry, 2nd edition, 1993.
  • Stryer, L., Biochemistry, 4th edition, 1995.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.

Unit 2: Protein Quality, Amino Acids and Digestibility

Note

Unit 2: Protein Quality, Amino Acids and Digestibility

A question to start with

A child eats a large bowl of rice and feels full. Another child eats a smaller meal of rice, beans, and an egg and also feels full. Both ate the same amount of protein by weight, about 15 g, yet the second child grows better over the year. Why? The difference is not the grams on the plate, it is what those grams contain and how much of them the body can use. This unit explains protein quality: the amino acid pattern, the missing pieces, and the digestibility that decides how much of the protein ever reaches the body's building sites.

Protein quality asks one plain question: how well does this food's protein meet the body's need for essential amino acids? Two measures decide the answer. The first is the amino acid pattern: does the food supply all nine essential amino acids, and in the right amounts? The second is digestibility: how much of the protein is broken down and absorbed, rather than passing through unused? A food can fail on either measure, and the best foods pass both.

Essential amino acids and the limiting amino acid

The body needs the nine essential amino acids in a set pattern, called the reference pattern. The pattern is the amount of each essential amino acid, in milligrams per gram of protein, that a healthy body needs. A food protein is judged by comparing its own pattern with the reference pattern. For each essential amino acid, the food's amount is divided by the reference amount to give a score. The lowest score is the one that matters, and the amino acid behind it is called the limiting amino acid, because it limits how well the whole protein can be used.

A simple picture helps. Imagine building a wall from nine kinds of brick, and each layer needs one brick of each kind. If you have plenty of eight kinds but very few of the ninth, you can only build as many layers as the ninth kind allows. The rest of the bricks sit unused. In the body, the scarce amino acid limits how much new protein can be built, and the leftover amino acids are burned for energy or turned into other compounds.

Cereal grains are usually limited by lysine. Wheat, rice, and maize all hold too little lysine for the reference pattern. Legumes such as beans, lentils, and peas are usually limited by the sulphur amino acids, methionine and cysteine. This is why the old pairing of grains and legumes works so well: the legume brings the lysine the grain lacks, and the grain brings the sulphur amino acids the legume lacks. A meal of rice and beans, or bread and lentil soup, gives a far better amino acid pattern than either food alone, even though the total grams of protein barely change.

Complete and incomplete proteins

A complete protein is one that supplies all nine essential amino acids in amounts close to the reference pattern. Most animal foods are complete: egg, milk, meat, fish, and poultry all score well. Egg white is often used as the standard against which other proteins are judged, because its pattern matches human need closely and it is digested very well.

An incomplete protein is one that is short of one or more essential amino acids. Most plant proteins are incomplete on their own: cereals lack lysine, legumes lack methionine, and many nuts and seeds lack lysine too. The word incomplete can mislead, because it sounds as if the food is useless. It is not. An incomplete protein still gives useful amino acids, and when two incomplete proteins complement each other, the meal becomes complete. The idea is called complementation, and it is the basis of protein planning in diets that use little or no animal food.

Two points need care. First, complementation does not need to happen in the same mouthful. The body holds a pool of free amino acids that lasts through the day, so beans at lunch and rice at dinner can still complement each other. Second, the amount matters: a tiny sprinkle of beans does not fix a large bowl of rice. The foods must each supply a fair share of the meal's protein.

Digestibility: what the body actually absorbs

Digestibility is the share of the protein eaten that is digested and absorbed. It is measured by feeding a food and collecting what leaves the body undigested, then working out what stayed inside. A food that is 95 percent digestible gives the body 95 g of usable protein from every 100 g eaten; a food that is 70 percent digestible gives only 70 g.

Animal proteins are usually highly digestible, about 90 to 97 percent, because they have no tough plant cell walls and their proteins unfold easily. Egg white, when cooked, reaches about 97 percent. Plant proteins are usually less digestible, about 70 to 90 percent, for three reasons. Plant cells have walls made of fibre that enzymes cannot easily cross, so some protein stays locked inside. Many plants carry compounds that slow digestion, such as trypsin inhibitors in raw beans and tannins in some seeds. And the protein itself may be folded in ways that resist enzymes until cooking unfolds it.

Cooking raises the digestibility of most plant proteins. Heat unfolds proteins, breaks cell walls, and destroys most trypsin inhibitors. Raw egg white is only about 50 percent digestible, because it holds a protein that blocks the digestive enzyme trypsin, while cooked egg white reaches about 97 percent. This is one of the clearest demonstrations in food science that processing changes nutrition, not only texture and flavour.

PDCAAS and DIAAS: the two scoring systems

Two scoring systems turn amino acid pattern and digestibility into one number. The older one is PDCAAS, the protein digestibility corrected amino acid score. The newer one is DIAAS, the digestible indispensable amino acid score. Both compare the food's amino acids with the reference pattern and correct for digestibility, but they do it differently.

PDCAAS takes the lowest amino acid score, the limiting amino acid, and multiplies it by the overall digestibility of the protein. The result is capped at 1.0, which means a score above 1.0 is reported as 1.0. Egg, milk, and whey all score 1.0. Soy protein scores about 1.0. Beef scores about 0.92. Wheat scores about 0.42, because it is short of lysine. The cap is a weakness: a protein that is richer than the reference pattern gets no extra credit, so PDCAAS cannot show that one complete protein is better than another.

DIAAS was built to fix the weaknesses of PDCAAS. Instead of overall digestibility, it measures digestibility for each amino acid separately at the end of the small intestine, where absorption happens. Instead of capping at 1.0, it reports the true score, so a protein can score above 1.0. Milk protein concentrate scores about 1.18, whey protein isolate about 1.09, egg about 1.13, soy protein isolate about 0.90, and cooked rice about 0.59. The higher numbers for dairy and egg show what PDCAAS hid: they supply essential amino acids in amounts above the reference pattern, so a smaller amount of them covers the need.

DIAAS needs more work to measure, because it uses samples taken from the end of the small intestine, so PDCAAS is still the score most often printed in tables and used in rules. A food technologist should know both: PDCAAS for what a label or a regulation asks for, DIAAS for the truer ranking of proteins when comparing ingredients.

How a protein quality score is built

Step 1: Measure the amino acids in the food protein
↓
Step 2: Compare each essential amino acid with the reference pattern
↓
Step 3: Find the lowest score, the limiting amino acid
↓
Step 4: Correct for digestibility, overall for PDCAAS, per amino acid for DIAAS
↓
Step 5: The final score ranks the protein

Deriving PDCAAS step by step: where the number comes from

PDCAAS looks like a single number, but it is built from three steps, and each step can be checked. The worked example in the next section uses the result; this section shows how the result is derived, so the reader can work it out for any food.

Step 1 is the amino acid score. For each essential amino acid, divide the amount in the food protein by the amount in the reference pattern. The reference pattern is the amount of each essential amino acid, in milligrams per gram of protein, that a young child needs, because the child pattern is the strictest. The formula is: amino acid score equals milligrams of the amino acid per gram of food protein, divided by milligrams of the same amino acid per gram of reference protein. Work it out for all nine essential amino acids, and keep the lowest score. That lowest score is the limiting amino acid score, and the amino acid that gives it is the limiting amino acid.

Step 2 is the digestibility correction. Measure the true faecal digestibility of the protein: the share of the protein that is digested and absorbed, corrected for the protein the body itself adds to the gut. The formula is: digestibility equals protein eaten minus protein lost in the faeces, corrected for body protein, divided by protein eaten. The result is a number between 0 and 1, such as 0.86 for wheat protein. This step is where PDCAAS is weakest, because it uses one digestibility number for the whole protein, even though each amino acid is digested a little differently.

Step 3 is the multiplication and the cap. Multiply the limiting amino acid score by the digestibility: PDCAAS equals limiting amino acid score times true faecal digestibility. Then apply the cap: if the result is above 1.0, report it as 1.0. The cap is a rule, not a measurement, and it hides real differences between complete proteins. DIAAS removes the cap and uses a separate digestibility for each amino acid, measured at the end of the small intestine, which is why its scores can rise above 1.0 and why it ranks dairy and egg above soy.

A short check shows the derivation in numbers. Take a protein with a lysine score of 0.80 and a digestibility of 0.86. Step 1 gives 0.80. Step 2 gives 0.86. Step 3 multiplies them: 0.80 times 0.86 is 0.688, about 0.69. The cap does not apply, because 0.69 is below 1.0. If the lysine score had been 1.20 and the digestibility 0.95, the product would be 1.14, and PDCAAS would report it as 1.0, while DIAAS would report the true value. The derivation shows exactly what is lost in the cap.

A worked example: wheat, beans, and the meal that fixes both

Take 100 g of wheat flour protein. It holds about 36 mg of lysine per gram of protein, while the reference pattern asks for about 45 mg per gram. Its lysine score is 36 divided by 45, about 0.80. Its other amino acids score higher, so lysine limits it. Wheat protein is about 86 percent digestible, so its PDCAAS is about 0.80 times 0.86, about 0.69 before other corrections bring the published value nearer 0.42 for some wheat products, because the exact numbers depend on the wheat type and the reference pattern used. The exact decimal is less important than the lesson: lysine is the weak link.

Now take 100 g of bean protein. It holds plenty of lysine, about 70 mg per gram, but only about 22 mg of methionine plus cysteine per gram, against a reference need of about 25 mg. Its score is limited by the sulphur amino acids. Mix the two foods in one meal, and each supplies what the other lacks. The meal's score rises above either food alone. This is not theory: feeding studies show that children grow better on a mixed cereal and legume diet than on either food alone at the same total protein intake.

Anti-nutritional factors and how processing removes them

Some plant foods carry compounds that lower protein quality. They are called anti-nutritional factors, and a food technologist must know them because processing is what removes them.

Trypsin inhibitors are proteins in raw beans, soy, and some other legumes that block the digestive enzyme trypsin. A meal of raw beans is poorly digested and can cause stomach upset. Ordinary cooking destroys them: boiling beans for the time a recipe asks for removes nearly all trypsin inhibitor activity.

Phytate, also called phytic acid, is the storage form of phosphorus in seeds and grains. It binds minerals such as iron, zinc, and calcium, and it can also bind protein, making both less available. Soaking, sprouting, and fermenting grains and legumes lower phytate. Sourdough fermentation, for example, cuts phytate in bread flour and frees minerals.

Tannins are bitter compounds in the skins of some beans, sorghum, and tea. They bind protein and slow digestion. Removing skins, soaking, and cooking all lower tannins.

Lectins are proteins in raw beans that can damage the gut lining. Kidney beans are the classic case: a few raw or undercooked kidney beans can cause severe stomach upset within hours. Full boiling destroys lectins. Slow cooking at low temperature does not, which is why a slow cooker set too low is a real hazard for kidney beans.

The lesson is practical: protein quality is not fixed by the crop. It is set by the crop plus the processing. A well cooked bean is a different food, nutritionally, from the same bean raw.

Questions to think about

  • A label says a bar holds 20 g of protein from wheat gluten. Is that the same as 20 g of protein from milk? What would you check?
  • Why does rice and beans work as a pair, and does the pair need to be eaten in the same meal?
  • A new protein powder claims a PDCAAS of 1.0. What does that tell you, and what does it hide?
Think about the bar question before you read on

No, the two are not the same. Wheat gluten is short of lysine, so its amino acid score is low, and its PDCAAS is well below 1.0. Milk protein supplies all nine essential amino acids in good amounts and scores 1.0. Twenty grams of wheat protein therefore gives the body less usable essential amino acid than 20 g of milk protein. To judge a protein food, check the source, the amino acid pattern, and the digestibility, not only the grams on the label.

Biological value and net protein utilisation

Before PDCAAS and DIAAS, two older measures were used, and they still appear in older books. Biological value measures how much of the absorbed protein the body keeps, rather than losing in urine. Net protein utilisation measures how much of the protein eaten is kept by the body, which combines digestibility and biological value. Egg has a biological value near 100, milk near 91, rice near 80, and wheat near 67. These numbers tell the same story as the newer scores: animal proteins rank high, cereals rank low, and mixing foods lifts the result. A food technologist reading an old book should know these terms, but new work uses PDCAAS and DIAAS.

Protein quality in product design

When a product is built around protein, quality decides which ingredient to pick and how much to use. A sports drink that claims to support muscle repair needs a protein with a high score and fast digestion, which points to whey. A meal replacement for a vegetarian needs a blend, such as soy plus pea, or cereal plus legume, so that the limiting amino acids are covered. A baby food must use proteins with scores near the top, because a baby has no room for waste: every gram must count.

Cost is part of the decision too. A high quality protein may cost more per kilogram, but it may cost less per gram of usable essential amino acid, because less of it is needed. Work out the cost per gram of limiting amino acid, not only the cost per kilogram of powder, before choosing. A cheap protein that needs twice the dose is not cheap.

Practical note: When you test a new protein ingredient, ask the supplier for three things: the amino acid profile in milligrams per gram of protein, the digestibility figure and how it was measured, and the PDCAAS or DIAAS value with the reference pattern named. If the supplier cannot give the amino acid profile, you cannot judge quality, and the grams on the specification sheet mean little.

Quick self-check

Question: What is a limiting amino acid, and why does it decide protein quality?

The limiting amino acid is the essential amino acid present in the lowest amount compared with the reference pattern. The body can only build new protein as far as the scarcest essential amino acid allows, so the lowest score sets the quality of the whole protein.

Question: Why is cooked egg white far more digestible than raw egg white?

Raw egg white holds a protein that blocks the digestive enzyme trypsin, and its proteins are folded tightly. Cooking destroys the blocking protein and unfolds the rest, so enzymes can cut the chains easily. Digestibility rises from about 50 percent raw to about 97 percent cooked.

Question: What is the main difference between PDCAAS and DIAAS?

PDCAAS corrects the lowest amino acid score by the overall digestibility of the protein and caps the result at 1.0. DIAAS measures digestibility for each amino acid separately at the end of the small intestine and does not cap the score, so it can show values above 1.0 and rank complete proteins against each other.

Try it yourself

Find two foods in your kitchen, one cereal and one legume: rice and beans, bread and lentils, or oats and peanuts. Look up their protein content per 100 g from a food composition table or a trusted nutrition source. Write down which amino acid limits each one: lysine for the cereal, methionine and cysteine for the legume. Then plan a meal that uses both, and work out the total protein of the meal. Write one sentence explaining why the meal is better than either food alone, using the words limiting amino acid and complementation. Keep the sentence plain enough that a neighbour with no science background can follow it.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Protein quality depends on the amino acid pattern and on digestibility, not only on grams.
  • The limiting amino acid is the essential amino acid in shortest supply against the reference pattern, and it sets the quality of the protein.
  • Cereals are usually limited by lysine, legumes by the sulphur amino acids, and pairing them fixes both gaps.
  • Animal proteins are usually 90 to 97 percent digestible; plant proteins are usually 70 to 90 percent, and cooking raises the figure.
  • PDCAAS corrects the amino acid score by overall digestibility and caps at 1.0; DIAAS measures digestibility per amino acid and does not cap.
  • Anti-nutritional factors such as trypsin inhibitors, phytate, tannins, and lectins lower protein quality, and ordinary cooking, soaking, and fermenting remove most of them.
  • In product design, judge a protein by its usable essential amino acids and its cost per usable gram, not by grams alone.

Glossary

Amino acid score

The amount of one essential amino acid in a food protein divided by the amount in the reference pattern. Food tech example: a lysine score of 0.8 means the food supplies 80 percent of the reference amount of lysine.

Anti-nutritional factor

A compound in food that lowers the availability of a nutrient. Food tech example: phytate in whole grain binds iron and zinc, so soaking or fermenting the grain improves mineral availability.

Biological value

The share of absorbed protein that the body keeps rather than losing in urine. Food tech example: egg has a biological value near 100, which is why it is used as a reference protein.

Complementation

Combining two proteins so that each supplies the amino acids the other lacks. Food tech example: rice and beans complement each other, because rice is short of lysine and beans are short of methionine.

DIAAS

Digestible indispensable amino acid score, a protein quality score that measures digestibility per amino acid at the end of the small intestine and does not cap at 1.0. Food tech example: milk protein concentrate scores about 1.18 by DIAAS, higher than soy at about 0.90.

Digestibility

The share of protein eaten that is digested and absorbed by the body. Food tech example: cooked egg white is about 97 percent digestible, while raw egg white is only about 50 percent digestible.

Essential amino acid

An amino acid the body cannot make and must get from food. Food tech example: lysine is an essential amino acid that is often low in cereal grains.

Lectin

A protein in raw beans that can damage the gut lining and cause stomach upset. Food tech example: kidney beans must be fully boiled to destroy lectins, because slow cooking at low temperature does not remove them.

Limiting amino acid

The essential amino acid in shortest supply compared with the reference pattern, which sets the quality of the protein. Food tech example: lysine is the limiting amino acid in wheat.

Net protein utilisation

The share of protein eaten that the body keeps, combining digestibility and biological value. Food tech example: a food with high digestibility but low biological value still has modest net protein utilisation.

PDCAAS

Protein digestibility corrected amino acid score, a protein quality score that multiplies the lowest amino acid score by overall digestibility and caps at 1.0. Food tech example: wheat scores well below 1.0 by PDCAAS because it is short of lysine.

Phytate

The storage form of phosphorus in seeds and grains that binds minerals and some protein. Food tech example: sourdough fermentation lowers phytate in bread flour and frees minerals for absorption.

Reference pattern

The amounts of each essential amino acid, per gram of protein, that a healthy body needs, used to judge food proteins. Food tech example: a food protein is scored by dividing each of its amino acids by the reference pattern value.

Sulphur amino acids

Methionine and cysteine, the two amino acids that carry sulphur. Food tech example: legumes are usually limited by the sulphur amino acids, which is why grain plus legume meals work well.

Trypsin inhibitor

A compound in raw legumes that blocks the digestive enzyme trypsin and lowers protein digestion. Food tech example: boiling soybeans destroys trypsin inhibitors and raises the digestibility of soy protein.

Amino acid score

One amino acid in a food protein divided by the same amino acid in the reference pattern, worked out for each essential amino acid. Food tech example: a lysine score of 0.80 means the protein holds 80 percent of the lysine the reference pattern asks for.

Reference pattern

The amounts of each essential amino acid, in milligrams per gram of protein, that the body needs, used as the yardstick for scoring a protein. Food tech example: PDCAAS compares each amino acid in a food with the reference pattern for a young child.

True faecal digestibility

The share of eaten protein that is digested and absorbed, corrected for the protein the body itself adds to the gut. Food tech example: wheat protein has a true faecal digestibility of about 0.86.

References

  • FAO, Dietary Protein Quality Evaluation in Human Nutrition: Report of an FAO Expert Consultation, 2013.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.

Unit 3: Protein in Foods: Animal, Dairy, Egg and Plant Sources

Note

Unit 3: Protein in Foods: Animal, Dairy, Egg and Plant Sources

A question to start with

A market stall sells eggs, a block of cheese, a bag of lentils, a piece of fish, and a packet of tofu. Each seller calls their food the best protein. They cannot all be right in the same way, because their proteins differ in amount, quality, cost, and what else comes with them. This unit walks through the main protein sources one by one, so that you can compare them fairly and choose the right one for a person, a meal, or a product.

Protein sources fall into two large groups: animal sources and plant sources. Animal sources are meat, fish, poultry, eggs, and dairy foods. Plant sources are legumes, cereals, nuts, seeds, and soy products. The two groups differ in three ways that matter: how much protein they hold per 100 g, how good their amino acid pattern is, and what else they bring, such as fat, fibre, vitamins, or minerals.

Meat, poultry, and fish

Meat is muscle, and muscle is about 20 percent protein by weight when cooked, with the rest mostly water and some fat. A 100 g serving of cooked lean beef holds about 26 g of protein. Cooked chicken breast holds about 30 g per 100 g. Cooked pork loin holds about 26 g per 100 g. These are dense protein foods: a small serving gives a large share of the daily need.

The protein of meat is complete, with all nine essential amino acids in good amounts, and it is about 94 to 97 percent digestible. Meat also brings iron in a form the body absorbs well, zinc, and vitamin B12, a vitamin found in useful amounts only in animal foods. The drawback is fat: some cuts carry much saturated fat, and processed meats carry salt and other additives. A food technologist who uses meat in a product must weigh protein density against fat content and cost.

Fish is similar in protein, about 20 to 25 g per 100 g cooked, with a complete amino acid pattern and high digestibility. Oily fish such as salmon and sardines bring long chain omega 3 fats as well, which are valued for heart and brain health. White fish is leaner and lower in energy. Fish protein has one special property: it spoils fast, because fish enzymes and bacteria work quickly after catching, so chilling and fast handling are part of fish protein quality in practice, not only in theory.

Poultry sits between red meat and fish in fat: chicken and turkey breast are lean, while skin and dark meat carry more fat. Poultry protein is complete and highly digestible, and poultry is often the cheapest animal protein per gram in many markets, which is why it is widely used in school meals and in ready meals.

Eggs: the reference protein

One large egg weighs about 50 g and holds about 6 g of protein, about 3.5 g in the white and 2.5 g in the yolk. The white is almost pure protein and water, with very little fat. The yolk holds the fat, the vitamins, and the cholesterol. Egg protein is the standard against which other proteins are judged: its amino acid pattern matches human need closely, and cooked egg white is about 97 percent digestible.

Eggs are also cheap protein in most markets, and they are easy to cook in many forms: boiled, fried, scrambled, baked into cakes, or dried into egg powder for factories. Egg powder is used in bakery, pasta, and ready meals, where liquid egg would be hard to handle. One caution matters in factories: raw egg can carry Salmonella, so egg products for industry are pasteurised, and recipes that use raw egg need care.

A worked comparison shows the value of eggs. A 70 kg adult needs about 56 g of protein a day. Two eggs give about 12 g, roughly a fifth of the day. Three eggs give about 18 g, roughly a third. No other single cheap food gives that much complete protein in such a small serving.

Milk and dairy foods

Milk is about 3.3 percent protein, which sounds low, but a glass of 200 ml gives about 7 g of protein, and milk is drunk in large amounts, so it adds up. Milk protein has two parts: casein, about 80 percent, and whey, about 20 percent. Casein forms soft curds in the stomach and digests slowly, giving a steady supply of amino acids over hours. Whey stays liquid and digests fast, giving a quick rise in blood amino acids. This difference is used in product design: slow casein for a meal that should satisfy for hours, fast whey for recovery after exercise.

Dairy foods concentrate milk protein. Yoghurt holds about 4 to 5 g of protein per 100 g, and strained yoghurt holds about 10 g per 100 g, because much of the water and whey has been drained away. Cheese holds about 20 to 25 g of protein per 100 g, but it also holds fat and salt, so the protein comes with a cost in energy. Cottage cheese is leaner, about 11 g of protein per 100 g with little fat.

Whey is the liquid left when cheese is made, and it was once thrown away. Today whey is dried into whey protein concentrate and whey protein isolate, which are among the most used protein ingredients in the world. Whey protein isolate holds about 90 percent protein by weight, scores high on both PDCAAS and DIAAS, and dissolves easily in drinks. Casein is also dried and used in bars, meal replacements, and cheese analogues. The dairy industry turned a waste stream into a protein industry, and Unit 4 looks at how these ingredients are used.

Legumes: beans, lentils, peas, and chickpeas

Legumes are the richest plant protein source. Dry lentils hold about 25 g of protein per 100 g, dry beans about 22 g, dry chickpeas about 20 g, and dry peas about 24 g. Cooked, the numbers fall to about 8 to 9 g per 100 g, because the seeds absorb water and swell to two or three times their dry weight. A serving of 200 g of cooked lentils gives about 18 g of protein, which is a large share of the daily need, and it also gives fibre, iron, folate, and potassium.

Legume protein is limited by the sulphur amino acids, as Unit 2 explained, and it is about 70 to 85 percent digestible when well cooked. The fibre in legumes slows digestion, which keeps a person full for longer and steadies blood sugar. The same fibre can cause gas, because gut bacteria ferment some of the fibres in the large intestine. Soaking and thorough cooking lower this effect.

Legumes are also the cheapest protein in most markets per gram, and they keep well when dry, need no chilling, and grow in many climates. For feeding large numbers of people, and for products aimed at low cost, legumes are the first plant source to consider.

Soy and its products

Soy is the exception among plant proteins: it is nearly complete. Soybeans hold about 36 g of protein per 100 g dry, the highest of any legume, and soy protein isolate scores about 1.0 on PDCAAS and about 0.90 on DIAAS. That is why soy is the plant protein most used in industry.

Soy is eaten in many forms. Tofu is made by curdling soy milk, like cheese from milk, and holds about 8 g of protein per 100 g. Tempeh is made by fermenting whole soybeans, and holds about 19 g of protein per 100 g. Soy milk holds about 3 g of protein per 100 ml, close to cow milk. Textured soy protein is made by extruding defatted soy flour, and it holds about 50 g of protein per 100 g dry; it is used in meat analogues, ready meals, and school feeding, where it stretches meat or replaces it.

One caution: soy carries trypsin inhibitors and other compounds that lower digestibility when raw, but ordinary processing, heating, and fermenting remove them. Soy is also one of the foods that must be declared as an allergen on labels in many markets, so products using soy must carry that declaration.

Cereals, nuts, and seeds

Cereals are eaten in large amounts, so even their modest protein adds up. Wheat flour holds about 11 g of protein per 100 g, rice about 7 g, maize about 9 g, and oats about 13 g. A person who eats 400 g of bread and rice in a day gets about 30 to 40 g of protein from cereals alone, which is more than half the daily need for many adults. But cereal protein is limited by lysine, so it should not be the only protein in a diet.

Nuts and seeds hold good protein: peanuts about 26 g per 100 g, almonds about 21 g, pumpkin seeds about 30 g, and sesame seeds about 18 g. But they also hold much fat, so 100 g of nuts gives about 600 kcal, and few people eat that much at once. A handful of 30 g gives about 6 to 8 g of protein, a useful extra rather than a main source. Nut and seed proteins are limited by lysine, and they are often eaten as snacks or as ingredients rather than as the centre of a meal.

Quinoa and amaranth deserve a note. Quinoa holds about 14 g of protein per 100 g dry and has a better lysine content than most cereals, so it is often called a complete plant protein. It is still lower in protein per serving than legumes, and it costs more, but it shows that the line between cereal and legume protein is not fixed.

Comparing protein sources at a glance

Animal: meat, fish, egg, milk. Dense, complete, highly digestible
↓
Dairy ingredients: whey and casein powders. Very high protein, fast or slow
↓
Legumes: beans, lentils, peas. Good protein, cheap, bring fibre
↓
Soy: tofu, tempeh, textured soy. Nearly complete plant protein
↓
Cereals, nuts, seeds: useful in quantity, limited by lysine

Comparing sources: a worked example

A product developer needs 20 g of protein in one serving and has three options: chicken breast, cooked lentils, or a whey drink. The chicken needs about 70 g of cooked meat. The lentils need about 230 g cooked, a large bowl, which also gives about 8 g of fibre. The whey drink needs about 25 g of powder in water. The chicken gives complete protein and iron, the lentils give fibre and low fat, and the whey gives the most protein in the smallest volume. There is no single winner: the right choice depends on the eater, the meal, the cost, and the product format. A ready meal uses chicken, a school lunch uses lentils, and a sports drink uses whey. Judging a source means judging it for a purpose.

Questions to think about

  • Why is milk only 3.3 percent protein but still a major protein source in many diets?
  • A vegan athlete needs 100 g of protein a day. Which plant sources would you combine, and why?
  • Why does cheese hold more protein per 100 g than milk, and what else rises with the protein?
Think about the milk question before you read on

Because milk is drunk in large volumes. A glass gives about 7 g of protein, and two or three glasses a day give 14 to 21 g, a large share of the daily need. The percentage looks low, but the serving is large and the protein is complete and highly digestible. The same logic applies to bread: wheat is only about 11 percent protein, but people eat so much bread that it becomes a major protein source.

Choosing a source for a purpose

A school meal needs cheap, safe, filling protein that children will eat: lentils, beans, eggs, and milk fit well. A hospital meal for a patient who eats little needs dense protein in a small volume: whey drinks, egg, and soft cheese fit well. A sports product needs fast, complete protein with a high score: whey isolate fits well. A product for a vegetarian needs a blend that covers the limiting amino acids: soy plus pea, or cereal plus legume, fits well. A product for a low income market needs the lowest cost per gram of usable protein: dry legumes and eggs usually win.

Sustainability and supply also matter now. Legumes need less land and water per gram of protein than meat, and they fix nitrogen in the soil, which helps the next crop. Dairy and meat need more feed, land, and water per gram. A food technologist who plans a product line today must weigh nutrition, cost, and supply together, and the balance will differ by market and by eater.

Practical note: When you compare protein sources for a recipe, build a small table with five columns: protein per 100 g, protein per serving eaten, amino acid quality, digestibility, and cost per serving. Fill it from labels and food composition tables. The best source for your purpose will show itself: it is rarely the one with the biggest single number, and it is often the one that is good enough on all five columns at once.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is soy called the exception among plant proteins?

Soy protein is nearly complete, with all nine essential amino acids in good amounts, and it scores about 1.0 on PDCAAS. Most other plant proteins are limited by lysine or by the sulphur amino acids, while soy is not limited in the same way.

Question: How does casein differ from whey in digestion speed, and why does it matter?

Casein forms curds in the stomach and digests slowly, giving a steady supply of amino acids over hours. Whey stays liquid and digests fast, giving a quick rise in blood amino acids. Slow casein suits a meal that should satisfy for hours; fast whey suits recovery after exercise.

Question: A serving of cooked lentils gives about 18 g of protein and 8 g of fibre. Why does the fibre matter for the eater?

Fibre slows digestion, keeps the eater full for longer, and steadies blood sugar. It also feeds gut bacteria. The fibre is a benefit that animal protein does not bring, and it is part of why legumes are valued beyond their protein alone.

Try it yourself

Go to a shop or open your kitchen cupboard and pick five protein foods: one meat or fish, one egg or dairy food, one legume, one cereal, and one nut or seed. For each, write down the protein per 100 g from the label and the price per pack. Work out the cost of 20 g of protein from each food: divide the pack price by the grams of protein in the pack, then multiply by 20. Rank the five foods from cheapest to dearest per 20 g of protein. Then write one line for each food saying what else it brings: fibre, fat, iron, calcium, or nothing much. The ranking by cost and the list of extras together show why a diet needs several protein sources, not one.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Animal foods give dense, complete, highly digestible protein, about 20 to 30 g per 100 g cooked meat or fish.
  • Egg protein is the reference protein: complete, about 97 percent digestible when cooked, and cheap.
  • Milk protein splits into slow casein and fast whey, and dairy foods concentrate it: cheese holds 20 to 25 g per 100 g.
  • Legumes give 8 to 9 g of protein per 100 g cooked, plus fibre, iron, and folate, at low cost.
  • Soy is nearly complete and is the most used plant protein in industry, as tofu, tempeh, soy milk, and textured soy protein.
  • Cereals give modest protein per 100 g but are eaten in large amounts, so they supply a large share of daily protein.
  • No single source is best for every purpose: judge a source by protein amount, quality, digestibility, cost, and what else it brings.

Glossary

Casein

The main protein of milk, about 80 percent of milk protein, which forms curds and digests slowly. Food tech example: cheese is made by curdling casein with rennet or acid.

Complete protein

A protein that supplies all nine essential amino acids in amounts close to the reference pattern. Food tech example: egg and milk are complete proteins.

Legume

A plant whose seeds grow in pods, such as beans, lentils, peas, and chickpeas. Food tech example: lentil soup is a legume dish that gives protein and fibre together.

Omega 3 fats

A family of fats found in oily fish and some seeds, valued for heart and brain health. Food tech example: salmon and sardines are rich in long chain omega 3 fats.

Saturated fat

A type of fat that is solid at room temperature and found in animal fats and some plant fats. Food tech example: the fat on a cut of beef is mostly saturated fat.

Tempeh

A food made by fermenting whole soybeans into a firm cake. Food tech example: sliced tempeh is fried or grilled as a protein food in vegetarian meals.

Textured soy protein

Dried, extruded soy flour with a chewy texture, used to stretch or replace meat. Food tech example: textured soy protein is added to ready meals and school lunches to raise protein at low cost.

Tofu

A food made by curdling soy milk, like cheese from milk. Food tech example: tofu cubes are added to stir fries as a protein food.

Whey

The liquid left when milk is curdled to make cheese, holding the whey proteins. Food tech example: whey is dried into whey protein powder for drinks and bars.

Whey protein concentrate

A dried whey powder holding about 80 percent protein by weight. Food tech example: whey protein concentrate is mixed into sports drinks and meal shakes.

Whey protein isolate

A dried whey powder holding about 90 percent protein by weight, with most fat and lactose removed. Food tech example: whey protein isolate dissolves clearly in water for a high protein drink.

Vitamin B12

A vitamin found in useful amounts only in animal foods, needed for blood and nerves. Food tech example: people who eat no animal foods need a B12 supplement or fortified foods.

Folate

A B vitamin needed for cell growth, found in legumes and green leaves. Food tech example: lentils are a rich source of folate, which matters in pregnancy.

Quinoa

A seed eaten as a grain, with more lysine than most cereals. Food tech example: quinoa is cooked like rice and served as a protein rich side dish.

Salmonella

A bacterium that can be present in raw egg and raw poultry and causes food poisoning. Food tech example: egg products for factories are pasteurised to remove Salmonella.

References

  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • FAO, Dietary Protein Quality Evaluation in Human Nutrition: Report of an FAO Expert Consultation, 2013.
  • National Dairy Development Board, Laboratory Handbook for Dairy Industry, March 2001.

Unit 4: Protein in Product Formulation: Bars, Drinks and Powders

Note

Unit 4: Protein in Product Formulation: Bars, Drinks and Powders

A question to start with

A protein bar holds 20 g of protein, fits in a pocket, and keeps for a year. A protein shake holds 25 g of protein in a bottle that is mostly water. A tub of powder holds 30 servings and needs only a scoop and a shaker. All three promise the same thing, but the factory work behind them is very different: one is a sticky dough that must not harden, one is a liquid that must not settle or sour, and one is a dry powder that must pour and mix. This unit explains how protein is built into bars, drinks, and powders, and what goes wrong when it is done badly.

A protein product starts with a target: how many grams of protein per serving, what kind of protein, and what the product should feel like to eat or drink. The target fixes the recipe. A bar with 20 g of protein in a 60 g bar is one third protein by weight, which is a heavy load: the protein must bind, hold shape, and stay soft. A drink with 25 g of protein in 330 ml is about 7.5 percent protein, which is a lighter load, but the protein must stay dissolved and stable for months. A powder with 25 g per 30 g scoop is more than 80 percent protein, so the powder must flow, dissolve fast, and taste acceptable.

Choosing the protein ingredient

The first choice is the protein source, and it is driven by quality, function, taste, and cost. Whey protein isolate is the first choice for clear drinks and sports shakes, because it dissolves well, tastes mild, and scores high on quality. Whey protein concentrate is cheaper and is used in milky shakes and bars. Milk protein concentrate and casein are used where a slow, filling protein is wanted, or where a creamy texture matters. Soy protein isolate is the first choice for a plant based product that needs a high score, and pea protein is often blended with it to improve taste and amino acid balance. Rice protein is used in blends where soy or dairy cannot be used, but on its own it is limited by lysine.

Each protein behaves differently in a recipe. Whey proteins denature and gel when heated, which is useful in a baked bar but a problem in a drink that is heated for safety. Casein is heat stable and thickens a drink. Soy protein holds water well and gives body to a bar. Pea protein can taste beany and gritty, so it is often masked with flavour and blended with other proteins. Collagen peptides dissolve easily in hot and cold water and give no milky taste, but collagen is short of tryptophan, an essential amino acid, so it cannot be the only protein in a product that claims complete protein.

The blend is often the answer. A bar may use whey plus soy plus pea, so that no single taste dominates and the amino acid pattern is covered. A drink may use whey plus casein, so that part of the protein is fast and part is slow. The food technologist tests blends at small scale, measures taste, texture, and stability, and only then scales up.

Protein bars: a sticky problem

A protein bar is a dough of protein powder, syrup, fat, and flavour, pressed into shape and coated or left plain. The syrup, usually glucose syrup or a sugar alcohol syrup, binds the powder and gives sweetness. The fat, often palm fat or nut butter, gives softness and flavour. The protein powder is the largest dry ingredient, often 30 to 40 percent of the bar.

The main fault in protein bars is hardening. Over weeks and months on the shelf, the bar turns from soft and chewy to hard and dry. The cause is water moving inside the bar: the protein slowly binds water and forms new links, and the syrup crystallises. The bar loses its soft bite. Makers fight hardening in several ways: they use syrups that hold water, they add glycerol, which is a humectant that holds moisture, they choose proteins that harden less, and they pack the bar in a film that stops moisture escaping. Even with these steps, a high protein bar has a shorter soft life than a cereal bar, and the shelf life on the pack is set by texture, not by safety.

Sugar alcohols such as maltitol and sorbitol are often used in bars sold as low sugar. They give sweetness and bulk with less sugar, but they can cause stomach discomfort when eaten in large amounts, and the label must carry a warning where the rules ask for it. Fibre is also added to bars, often as chicory root fibre, to raise the fibre claim and to add bulk without sugar. The fibre also feeds gut bacteria, which is a benefit, but too much fibre makes the bar gummy.

A worked recipe shows the numbers. A 60 g bar with 20 g of protein needs 25 g of whey protein concentrate at 80 percent protein. It needs about 20 g of syrup, 5 g of fat, 5 g of fibre, and the rest flavour, salt, and coating. The protein is one third of the bar, the syrup is one third, and everything else is one third. That is why a protein bar tastes different from a chocolate bar: a third of it is protein powder, and the maker must hide that fact with flavour and texture.

How a protein bar is made

Step 1: Mix protein powder with dry ingredients
↓
Step 2: Warm the syrup and fat, then add to the dry mix
↓
Step 3: Mix to a firm dough and press into a slab
↓
Step 4: Cool, cut into bars, coat if needed
↓
Step 5: Pack in moisture proof film and check texture over shelf life

Protein drinks: keeping protein dissolved and stable

A ready to drink protein shake is harder to make than it looks. The protein must stay dissolved or evenly spread for months, the drink must not sour or spoil, and it must taste like a milkshake rather than a chemistry set. The protein level is usually 5 to 10 percent by weight: a 330 ml bottle with 25 g of protein is about 7.5 percent.

Heat treatment is the first challenge. A milk based drink is heated to kill microbes, and whey protein denatures and thickens when heated. A drink that is thin before heating can turn thick and grainy after it. Makers control this by choosing heat stable proteins such as casein, by heating at a pH where the protein is stable, and by adding stabilisers such as pectin or carrageenan, which keep the protein spread evenly and stop it settling. The pH of the drink matters: at pH near 4.6, casein clumps and falls out of solution, which is how yoghurt sets, so a drink at that pH needs a stabiliser or a different protein.

Sedimentation is the second challenge. Protein particles sink over time, leaving a clear layer at the top and a thick layer at the bottom. A consumer who opens a bottle with a clear top thinks the drink is faulty. Stabilisers raise the thickness of the liquid just enough to slow settling, and the bottle is shaken before drinking. The drink is tested on the shelf for months: samples are kept at room temperature and at warm temperature, and the maker checks the top and bottom of the bottle for separation.

Flavour is the third challenge. Protein powders taste chalky, bitter, or beany, and the taste grows stronger as protein level rises. Chocolate and vanilla are the most used flavours because they mask protein taste well. Fruit flavours work in clear whey drinks, where the drink is acidic and the protein is whey isolate. Sweeteners are chosen to suit the market: sugar gives body and taste but adds energy, while high intensity sweeteners give sweetness without energy but can leave an aftertaste.

Protein powders: the simplest product, with its own faults

A protein powder looks simple: protein, flavour, sweetener, and a flow agent, packed in a tub or a sachet. But a powder that does not dissolve is a failed product. The powder must wet fast when water is added, sink rather than float, and dissolve without lumps. This property is called dispersibility, and it is set by the size of the powder particles and by whether the powder has been treated to make it dissolve faster.

Instantising is the treatment that fixes dissolving. The powder is sprayed with a little water or lecithin and dried again, so that the fine particles stick into larger, porous granules. The granules let water in quickly and sink fast. A powder that has not been instantised floats on the water and forms lumps that a shaker cannot break. A consumer judges a powder in the first ten seconds of shaking, so dispersibility is a quality that decides repeat purchase.

Powders also suffer from caking. A powder that absorbs moisture from the air forms hard lumps in the tub. The pack must keep moisture out, and the powder must be kept dry in the factory. A sachet is better than a tub for a single serving, because the tub is opened every day and each opening lets damp air in. The scoop matters too: a scoop that holds 30 g must be the right size for the powder's bulk density, or the consumer will under dose or over dose.

Quality checks for protein products

A protein product is checked in four ways before it is sold. First, the protein content is measured, usually by Kjeldahl or Dumas, and the result must match the label within the allowed tolerance. Second, the amino acid profile is checked, to confirm the quality claim. Third, the texture and flavour are checked by a panel over the shelf life, to catch hardening in bars and separation in drinks. Fourth, the microbiology is checked, to confirm that the heat treatment worked and that the product stays safe.

A common fault is protein overage: the maker adds extra protein to cover losses and variation, so the label says 20 g but the product holds 22 g. A small overage is normal practice, because protein content varies with the raw material. A large overage wastes money. The balance is set by measuring many batches and learning how much the protein varies.

Questions to think about

  • A protein bar is soft on the day it is made and hard after three months. What has changed inside the bar?
  • Why does a protein drink need stabilisers, while a glass of milk does not?
  • A powder floats on water and forms lumps when shaken. What has the maker failed to do?
Think about the bar question before you read on

Water has moved inside the bar and the protein has formed new links. The protein slowly binds water and cross links, the syrup crystallises, and moisture escapes through the pack. The bar loses its soft bite and turns hard and dry. Makers slow this with humectants such as glycerol, syrups that hold water, and moisture proof packing, but a high protein bar still hardens faster than a cereal bar.

Labelling a protein product

A protein product that claims high protein must meet the rule for that claim in the market where it is sold. The rule sets a minimum share of energy from protein, or a minimum grams per serving, and the product must meet it in every batch. The label must state the protein per serving and per 100 g or 100 ml, and it must list the protein source in the ingredients. If the product carries a claim about muscle or recovery, the claim must be one that is allowed, and the evidence must support it. Unit 6 treats labelling rules in full.

Allergen labelling matters for protein products more than for most foods, because the common protein sources are all major allergens: milk, egg, soy, peanut, tree nuts, and wheat. A bar that uses whey must declare milk. A bar that uses soy must declare soy. A factory that makes bars with peanut must clean the line before making a bar without peanut, or carry a warning that the product may contain peanut. A labelling error on a protein product is a safety error, not only a paperwork error.

Practical note: When you test a new protein bar recipe, keep five bars from the first batch and store them at room temperature. Taste one bar each week for five weeks and write down the texture: soft, firm, hard, dry, sticky. The week the bar turns hard is the end of its soft life, and the shelf life on the pack must be shorter than that week. A bar that is tested only on the day it is made will surprise you on the shelf.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is whey protein isolate used for clear protein drinks, while casein is not?

Whey protein isolate dissolves clearly in water, even at acid pH, and stays clear after heating. Casein clumps and turns cloudy at acid pH, especially near pH 4.6, so it cannot make a clear drink. Casein suits milky drinks where cloudiness is expected.

Question: What is instantising, and why does it matter for a protein powder?

Instantising is a treatment that sticks fine powder particles into larger porous granules, often with a little lecithin. The granules let water in fast and sink quickly, so the powder dissolves without lumps. A powder that has not been instantised floats and forms lumps that a shaker cannot break.

Question: Why does a maker add extra protein above the label claim?

To cover variation in the raw material and in the process, so that every batch meets the label claim. The extra is called overage. A small overage is normal practice; a large overage wastes money.

Try it yourself

Buy or borrow two protein products: a bar and a ready to drink shake, or two different powders. Read the labels and write down the protein per serving, the protein source, the first three ingredients, and the price. Then taste them and write down three words for texture and three words for flavour. Next, work out the cost of 20 g of protein from each product. Which product gives cheaper protein, and which one would you buy again for taste? The gap between the cheapest protein and the best tasting product is the gap a food technologist works in every day.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A protein bar, drink, and powder each need a different protein and a different process, even when the protein target is the same.
  • Whey isolate suits clear drinks, casein suits creamy and slow products, and soy plus pea blends suit plant based products.
  • Protein bars harden on the shelf as water moves and protein links form; humectants and moisture proof packing slow the change.
  • Protein drinks need heat stable proteins and stabilisers to stay dissolved and to stop settling over months.
  • Protein powders must be instantised so that they wet fast, sink, and dissolve without lumps.
  • Protein content, amino acid profile, texture over shelf life, and microbiology are all checked before a product is sold.
  • The common protein sources are all major allergens, so allergen labelling on a protein product is a safety matter.

Glossary

Dispersibility

How quickly and completely a powder wets and dissolves in water. Food tech example: an instantised whey powder disperses in seconds, while a fine untreated powder floats and lumps.

Glycerol

A humectant used in bars to hold moisture and keep the bar soft. Food tech example: glycerol is added to protein bars to slow hardening on the shelf.

Humectant

An ingredient that holds water in a food and stops it drying out. Food tech example: glycerol and sorbitol are humectants in protein bars.

Instantising

Treating a powder so that fine particles stick into larger porous granules that dissolve fast. Food tech example: instantised milk powder dissolves in cold water without lumps.

Maltitol

A sugar alcohol used as a sweetener and bulk agent in low sugar bars. Food tech example: a low sugar protein bar may use maltitol syrup instead of glucose syrup.

Overage

Extra nutrient added above the label claim to cover variation between batches. Food tech example: a bar labelled 20 g of protein may be made with 22 g to make sure every batch meets the claim.

Pectin

A stabiliser from fruit that keeps protein spread evenly in acid drinks. Food tech example: pectin is added to a drinking yoghurt to stop the protein settling.

Carrageenan

A stabiliser from seaweed that thickens liquids and holds particles in suspension. Food tech example: carrageenan is added to chocolate milk to stop cocoa settling.

Sedimentation

The settling of particles to the bottom of a liquid over time. Food tech example: protein powder that is not stabilised sediments in a ready to drink shake.

Sugar alcohol

A sweetener with fewer calories than sugar, such as sorbitol or maltitol, that can cause stomach discomfort in large amounts. Food tech example: sugar alcohols are used in low sugar protein bars.

Collagen peptides

Small pieces of collagen protein that dissolve easily in water. Food tech example: collagen peptides are added to drinks and powders, but they lack tryptophan, so they cannot be the only protein.

Stabiliser

An ingredient that keeps a food's structure even, such as holding particles in a drink. Food tech example: pectin and carrageenan are stabilisers in protein drinks.

Chicory root fibre

A fibre from chicory root added to bars and drinks to raise fibre and add bulk. Food tech example: chicory root fibre is used in high fibre protein bars.

Bulk density

The mass of a powder per unit of volume, which sets the size of scoop needed. Food tech example: a light fluffy powder needs a larger scoop than a dense powder for the same 30 g dose.

References

  • Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development: From Concept to Marketplace, 3rd edition, 2011.
  • Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., Food Product Development: From Concept to the Marketplace, 1991.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.

Unit 5: Protein and Health: Muscle, Ageing and Weight

Note

Unit 5: Protein and Health: Muscle, Ageing and Weight

A question to start with

Two people eat the same lunch: a sandwich with chicken, an egg, and a glass of milk. One is a 25 year old who trains in a gym four times a week. The other is a 75 year old who walks to the shops each day. The same meal does different work in the two bodies. In the young athlete it helps build new muscle after training; in the older person it helps slow the loss of muscle that comes with age. This unit explains how protein works with muscle, ageing, and body weight, and what that means for food.

Muscle is the largest store of protein in the body, about 40 percent of body weight in a young adult man and about 30 percent in a young adult woman. Muscle is not fixed: it is built and broken down all day, in a cycle called muscle protein turnover. After a meal with protein, building runs ahead of breakdown, and muscle grows a little. Between meals, breakdown runs ahead, and muscle shrinks a little. Over a day, the balance decides whether muscle grows, stays the same, or is lost. Training tips the balance toward building, and eating enough protein gives the building material.

Protein and muscle building

Muscle building needs two things at the same time: a signal and a supply. Exercise is the signal. Lifting weights, or any hard work against resistance, signals the muscle cells to build new protein. Food is the supply: amino acids from the meal provide the bricks. A signal without supply builds nothing, and a supply without signal builds little. That is why a protein shake alone, without training, does not build muscle, and why training without enough protein builds muscle slowly.

Leucine is the amino acid that matters most for the signal. When leucine rises in the blood after a meal, it switches on the building machinery inside the muscle cell. A meal needs about 2 to 3 g of leucine to switch the machinery on fully. That amount comes from about 25 to 30 g of a high quality protein such as whey, egg, or meat. A meal with only 10 g of protein gives about 1 g of leucine, which is not enough to switch the machinery on fully. This is the reason sports guidance talks about 25 to 30 g of protein per meal, not only about the daily total: each meal should be big enough to trigger building.

Timing matters less than the total, but it is not unimportant. The muscle stays sensitive to protein for a day after training, not only for an hour. The old idea of a narrow window of one hour after exercise is too strict. What matters is that protein is eaten across the day, with a good serving after training and a serving before bed, because the body builds muscle overnight too. A slow protein such as casein before bed gives a steady supply through the night.

Protein needs for athletes

An athlete in heavy training needs more protein than a person at rest. The usual guidance for endurance athletes is about 1.2 to 1.6 g per kilogram per day, and for strength athletes about 1.6 to 2.2 g per kilogram per day. A 70 kg strength athlete at 2.0 g per kilogram needs 140 g of protein a day. That is a large amount, and it is best spread over four or five meals of 25 to 35 g each, rather than eaten in one or two large servings.

More is not always better. Studies that feed athletes more than about 2.2 g per kilogram per day find little extra muscle gain, because the building machinery is already switched on and the extra amino acids are burned for energy. Very high protein intakes also leave less room for carbohydrate, which the athlete needs for energy, and they raise the load on the kidneys, which must clear the extra nitrogen. A healthy athlete with normal kidneys handles a high protein diet well, but a person with kidney disease must not follow an athlete's protein intake without medical advice.

A worked example shows the planning. A 80 kg athlete at 1.8 g per kilogram needs 144 g of protein a day. Four meals of 30 g each give 120 g, and two snacks of 12 g each, such as a glass of milk or a yoghurt, give the last 24 g. The plan is a full day of eating, not one shake. The shake is a tool for one meal, not a replacement for food.

Protein and ageing: holding on to muscle

After the age of about 50, muscle is lost slowly each year, a change called sarcopenia. Strength falls faster than muscle size, so an older person may find stairs and shopping harder even before the loss is visible. The loss has two causes: the muscle responds less strongly to each meal, a change called anabolic resistance, and many older people eat less protein, because appetite falls, chewing is harder, and meals get smaller.

The answer is more protein per meal, not less. An older adult needs about 1.0 to 1.2 g per kilogram per day, higher than the 0.8 g for a young adult, and each meal should hold 25 to 30 g of protein to switch on the building machinery. A small meal of tea and toast gives almost no protein and does not trigger building. Adding an egg, a piece of cheese, or a glass of milk to that meal changes it from a meal that lets muscle slip away to a meal that holds muscle.

Exercise matters just as much in old age. Resistance exercise, even light exercise with bands or body weight, restores some of the muscle's response to protein. Protein plus exercise works better than either alone. A food technologist who designs foods for older people should think about soft texture, small volume, high protein density, and good flavour, because an older person who eats little needs much protein in each bite.

Protein, appetite, and body weight

Protein is the most filling of the three large nutrients. A meal with protein keeps a person full for longer than a meal with the same energy from carbohydrate or fat. The reasons are several: protein slows the emptying of the stomach, it raises hormones that signal fullness, and it costs the body more energy to process, a cost called the thermic effect of food. About 20 to 30 percent of the energy in protein is used in digesting and processing it, compared with about 5 to 10 percent for carbohydrate and 0 to 3 percent for fat.

This is why high protein diets are popular for weight loss. A person who eats more protein feels full on fewer calories, so they eat less without feeling hungry. Studies show that raising protein from about 15 percent of energy to about 25 to 30 percent of energy helps people lose weight and, more importantly, helps them keep the weight off, because they lose less muscle while losing fat. Keeping muscle matters: muscle burns energy even at rest, so a person who keeps muscle burns more energy all day than a person who lost muscle with the fat.

There is a limit. A diet that is very high in protein and very low in carbohydrate can be hard to follow, and it can crowd out fruit, vegetables, and whole grains, which bring fibre and other nutrients. The best weight plan is not the highest protein plan, it is a plan with enough protein at each meal, plenty of fibre, and a modest energy cut that the person can keep for months.

Protein and the GLP-1 era

A new group of medicines for weight and blood sugar, called GLP-1 medicines, has changed how many people eat. These medicines slow the stomach, raise fullness, and lower appetite strongly. A person taking them eats much less, sometimes half as much as before. That creates a new nutrition problem: when total food falls sharply, protein intake falls with it, and the person can lose muscle along with fat.

The guidance for people on these medicines is plain: keep protein high even as food falls. Each meal should still hold 25 to 30 g of protein, and the daily total should stay near 1.2 to 1.6 g per kilogram of body weight. That is hard when appetite is low, so small, dense, soft protein foods matter: eggs, yoghurt, soft cheese, fish, lentil soup, and protein drinks. A food technologist who designs products for this group should think about small servings with high protein density, mild flavour, and easy digestion, because a large plate is now too much, but a small protein food is welcome.

Muscle loss on these medicines is not a small detail. A person who loses weight fast and loses muscle with it may end weaker than before, even at a lower weight. Protein plus resistance exercise is the pair that protects muscle while the weight falls.

How a protein meal builds muscle

Step 1: Eat 25 to 30 g of high quality protein
↓
Step 2: Leucine rises in the blood, about 2 to 3 g
↓
Step 3: The building machinery in muscle switches on
↓
Step 4: Amino acids are built into new muscle protein
↓
Step 5: Training plus protein across the day tips the balance to growth

Protein shortage and excess

Protein shortage shows up in clear ways. In children, it slows growth and weakens defences against infection. In adults, it causes muscle loss, slow wound healing, swelling from low blood protein, and hair loss. The most severe form in children is kwashiorkor, a condition where the belly swells, the skin changes, and growth stops, caused by a diet that gives enough energy but too little protein. It is a reminder that energy and protein are different needs, and a full stomach does not mean a fed body.

Protein excess is less common and less dramatic. In healthy people, the body clears the extra nitrogen in urine, and the kidneys handle the load. The main risks are that very high protein crowds out other foods, raises the intake of saturated fat when the protein comes from fatty meat, and adds cost. People with kidney disease, liver disease, or certain inherited disorders must limit protein, and they need medical guidance, not a general diet plan. A food label that urges more protein is written for healthy people, not for patients.

What the evidence does and does not support

High protein diets support muscle gain when paired with training, and they support weight loss by raising fullness. Those two claims rest on strong evidence from many trials. Claims that high protein diets harm healthy kidneys, weaken bones, or cause cancer are not supported by the evidence in healthy people. The bone claim came from an old idea that protein raises acid load and pulls calcium from bone, but trials show that protein with enough calcium supports bone, and older adults with higher protein intake keep bone better, not worse.

One claim needs care: the idea that a protein supplement alone builds muscle. It does not. The supplement is a convenient source of protein, and it works when the total diet and the training are right. A person who trains and eats enough protein from food gains the same muscle as a person who uses a supplement, because the body sees amino acids, not the brand on the tub.

Questions to think about

  • Why does a meal need about 25 g of protein to switch on muscle building, and not just 10 g?
  • An older person eats tea and toast for breakfast. What would you add, and why?
  • A person on a GLP-1 medicine eats half as much as before. Why is protein the nutrient to protect first?
Think about the first question before you read on

Muscle building switches on when leucine in the blood rises high enough, about 2 to 3 g of leucine from the meal. Ten grams of protein gives only about 1 g of leucine, which is below the trigger. Twenty five to 30 g of a high quality protein gives about 2 to 3 g of leucine, which switches the machinery on fully. The daily total matters, but each meal must also be big enough to trigger building.

Practical note: When you plan a day of eating for muscle, do not count only the daily total. Write the protein of each meal in a row: breakfast, lunch, dinner, and snacks. Circle any meal below 20 g. That meal is a missed chance to switch on muscle building, and adding an egg, a yoghurt, or a glass of milk to it is the simplest fix.

Quick self-check

Question: What is sarcopenia, and why do older adults need more protein per meal than young adults?

Sarcopenia is the slow loss of muscle and strength with age. Older muscle responds less strongly to each meal, a change called anabolic resistance, so an older person needs more protein per meal, about 25 to 30 g, to switch on the building machinery that a young person switches on with less.

Question: Why does protein help weight loss more than the same energy from carbohydrate?

Protein is more filling: it slows stomach emptying, raises fullness hormones, and costs more energy to process, about 20 to 30 percent of its energy. A person eating more protein feels full on fewer calories, so they eat less without feeling hungry, and they lose less muscle while losing fat.

Question: Does a protein shake build muscle on its own?

No. Muscle building needs a signal from exercise and a supply of amino acids from food. The shake is a convenient supply, but without training it does not build muscle, and with training and enough food protein it works no better than food alone.

Try it yourself

Write down everything you ate yesterday, meal by meal. For each meal, estimate the protein in grams from labels or food composition tables. Add the day's total and compare it with your need at 0.8 g per kilogram if you are not training, or 1.6 g per kilogram if you train hard. Then look at each meal: how many meals held 25 g or more? If one meal is low, plan a simple addition for tomorrow: an egg at breakfast, a yoghurt at lunch, or a glass of milk before bed. Repeat the check for three days and see whether the low meal becomes a habit or a one off.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Muscle is built and broken down all day, and the balance over the day decides whether muscle grows or is lost.
  • A meal needs about 25 to 30 g of high quality protein, with 2 to 3 g of leucine, to switch on muscle building fully.
  • Athletes need about 1.2 to 2.2 g of protein per kilogram per day, spread over four or five meals.
  • Older adults lose muscle with age and need more protein per meal, about 1.0 to 1.2 g per kilogram per day, plus resistance exercise.
  • Protein is the most filling nutrient and helps weight loss by keeping people full and protecting muscle.
  • People on GLP-1 medicines eat much less, so protein must be protected with small, dense, easy protein foods.
  • Protein shortage causes muscle loss, slow healing, and weak defences; protein alone, without training, does not build muscle.

Glossary

Anabolic resistance

The weaker response of older muscle to protein and exercise, so more protein is needed per meal. Food tech example: an older adult needs 25 to 30 g of protein per meal to get the same building signal a young adult gets from less.

GLP-1 medicine

A medicine that slows the stomach and lowers appetite, used for weight and blood sugar. Food tech example: a person on a GLP-1 medicine may need small high protein foods because total food intake falls sharply.

Kwashiorkor

A condition in children caused by too little protein with enough energy, marked by swelling, skin change, and slow growth. Food tech example: kwashiorkor shows that a full stomach does not mean a fed body.

Leucine

An essential amino acid that switches on muscle building when it rises in the blood. Food tech example: whey protein is rich in leucine, which is why it is used in sports products.

Muscle protein turnover

The daily cycle of building and breaking down muscle protein. Food tech example: after a protein meal, building runs ahead of breakdown, and muscle grows a little.

Sarcopenia

The slow loss of muscle mass and strength with age. Food tech example: foods for older people are designed soft, small, and protein dense to fight sarcopenia.

Thermic effect of food

The energy the body uses to digest, absorb, and process food. Food tech example: protein has a thermic effect of about 20 to 30 percent, far higher than fat.

Endurance athlete

An athlete who trains for long duration activity such as running or cycling. Food tech example: an endurance athlete needs about 1.2 to 1.6 g of protein per kilogram per day.

Strength athlete

An athlete who trains with weights to build muscle and strength. Food tech example: a strength athlete needs about 1.6 to 2.2 g of protein per kilogram per day.

Fullness hormone

A hormone released after eating that signals the brain to stop eating. Food tech example: protein raises fullness hormones more than carbohydrate or fat.

Resistance exercise

Exercise that works muscles against a load, such as weights, bands, or body weight. Food tech example: resistance exercise plus protein works better than either alone for older adults.

Protein sparing effect

The protection of body protein when enough energy comes from carbohydrate and fat. Food tech example: a diet with enough energy lets protein be used for building instead of being burned for fuel.

Nitrogen balance

The difference between nitrogen eaten as protein and nitrogen lost in urine and faeces, used to judge protein need. Food tech example: a growing child is in positive nitrogen balance, keeping more nitrogen than is lost.

References

  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • FAO, Dietary Protein Quality Evaluation in Human Nutrition: Report of an FAO Expert Consultation, 2013.
  • Wolfe, R. R., The Underappreciated Role of Muscle in Health and Disease, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2006.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.

Unit 6: Protein Analysis and Labelling

Note

Unit 6: Protein Analysis and Labelling

A question to start with

A tub of protein powder says 25 g of protein per scoop. A laboratory tests it and reports 24.1 g. A second laboratory tests the same tub and reports 26.3 g. The label says 25 g. Which number is right, and how does anyone know? The answer lies in how protein is measured, what the number really means, and how the rules let a label be checked. This unit explains the methods that measure protein, the maths that turns nitrogen into protein, and the labelling rules that turn a laboratory number into words a shopper can trust.

Protein is not measured directly in most routine tests. It is measured through nitrogen. Almost all the nitrogen in a food comes from protein, because carbohydrate and fat hold no nitrogen, and other nitrogen compounds are present only in small amounts. So the laboratory measures nitrogen, then multiplies by a factor to work out protein. That factor is the heart of the method, and it is also its weakness.

The Kjeldahl method

The Kjeldahl method is the oldest and most used protein method, and it is still the reference method in many rules. It has three steps: digestion, distillation, and titration.

In digestion, the sample is heated with concentrated sulphuric acid and a catalyst, usually copper or selenium, until the organic matter breaks down and all the nitrogen turns into ammonium sulphate. The mixture is heated for an hour or more, until it turns clear. This step is slow and uses strong acid and heat, so it is done in a fume cupboard with care.

In distillation, the digested mixture is made alkaline with sodium hydroxide, which turns the ammonium into ammonia gas. The ammonia is distilled into a measured amount of boric acid solution, where it is trapped.

In titration, the trapped ammonia is titrated with a standard acid, and the volume of acid used tells how much ammonia was present. From that volume, the laboratory works out the nitrogen in the sample, and then multiplies by the nitrogen factor to get crude protein.

The nitrogen factor is 6.25 for most foods, because most proteins hold about 16 percent nitrogen: 100 divided by 16 is 6.25. But the true factor differs by food. Milk protein holds a little more nitrogen, so its factor is 6.38. Wheat protein holds a little less, so its factor is 5.70. Soy protein uses 5.71. A laboratory that uses 6.25 for wheat overstates the protein by about 10 percent. The factor must match the food, or the answer is wrong.

A worked example shows the maths. A 2.000 g sample of milk powder is tested. The titration uses 25.00 ml of 0.1000 mol per litre hydrochloric acid. Each millilitre of 0.1000 mol per litre acid equals 0.0014 g of nitrogen. So 25.00 ml equals 0.0350 g of nitrogen. That is 0.0350 divided by 2.000, times 100, which is 1.75 percent nitrogen. Multiply by the milk factor 6.38, and the protein is 11.17 percent. If the factor 6.25 were used instead, the answer would be 10.94 percent, a small but real difference that matters on a label.

Deriving the Kjeldahl maths step by step: where 0.0014 comes from

The worked example above uses one number without proof: each millilitre of 0.1000 mol per litre hydrochloric acid equals 0.0014 g of nitrogen. This section derives that number from first principles, so the reader can work it out for any acid strength, and can check a laboratory result instead of taking it on trust.

Step 1 is the chemistry of the titration. One molecule of ammonia, NH₃, reacts with one molecule of hydrochloric acid, HCl, to make one ammonium ion. So one mole of acid used in the titration means one mole of ammonia was trapped, and one mole of ammonia holds one mole of nitrogen atoms. The titration therefore counts nitrogen atoms one for one with acid molecules.

Step 2 is the amount of acid in one millilitre. The acid strength is 0.1000 mol per litre, which means 0.1000 mol in 1000 ml. Divide by 1000: one millilitre holds 0.1000 divided by 1000, which is 0.0001 mol of acid. By step 1, that is 0.0001 mol of nitrogen.

Step 3 is the mass of that nitrogen. One mole of nitrogen atoms has a mass of 14.01 g, from the atomic mass of nitrogen. Multiply the moles by the mass per mole: 0.0001 mol times 14.01 g per mol is 0.001401 g, which rounds to 0.0014 g. That is the number used in the worked example: each millilitre of 0.1000 mol per litre acid equals 0.0014 g of nitrogen.

Step 4 is the full chain from titration to protein. Multiply the millilitres of acid by 0.0014 to get grams of nitrogen. Divide by the sample mass in grams and multiply by 100 to get percent nitrogen. Multiply by the nitrogen factor for the food to get percent protein. In symbols: percent protein equals millilitres of acid times 0.0014, divided by sample mass, times 100, times the factor. The same derivation works for any acid strength: for 0.0500 mol per litre acid, one millilitre holds 0.00005 mol, which is 0.0007 g of nitrogen, so the 0.0014 becomes 0.0007 and the rest of the chain is unchanged.

A blank titration is run beside every real test, and its acid volume is subtracted first. The blank measures the nitrogen in the reagents themselves, so the result counts only the nitrogen from the sample. A laboratory that skips the blank overstates the protein by a small amount on every test.

Kjeldahl measures all nitrogen, not only protein nitrogen. A food that holds urea, ammonia, or other nitrogen compounds will read high. This matters most for milk, where non protein nitrogen is present in small amounts, and for foods that have been adulterated with a nitrogen rich chemical. The method cannot tell protein nitrogen from other nitrogen, so it reports crude protein, not true protein. The word crude is a warning: the number is a good estimate, not a direct measure of protein.

The Dumas method

The Dumas method is the modern rival to Kjeldahl. The sample is burned in pure oxygen at about 900 °C. All the nitrogen turns into nitrogen gas, N₂, and other gases such as carbon dioxide, CO₂, and water vapour are removed. The nitrogen gas is measured, and the result is multiplied by the same nitrogen factor to give protein.

Dumas is fast: a test takes about five minutes, against two hours or more for Kjeldahl. It uses no strong acid, it is automated, and it can run many samples in a day. It has one weakness: it measures all nitrogen, just like Kjeldahl, and it can read slightly higher, because it burns nitrogen compounds that Kjeldahl misses, such as nitrate. For most foods the two methods agree within a small margin, and many laboratories now use Dumas for routine work and Kjeldahl for disputes.

The choice between them is practical. A factory that tests hundreds of samples a day uses Dumas for speed. A laboratory that tests a disputed sample uses Kjeldahl because the rules name it. A food technologist should know both methods and be able to explain why two laboratories using different methods can give slightly different numbers for the same food.

Other ways to measure protein

Several other methods measure protein more directly, and each has a use. The Biuret method adds copper sulphate in alkaline solution to a protein, and the copper binds the peptide bonds and turns violet. The depth of the colour is measured and compared with a standard. It is simple and quick, but it needs the protein to be dissolved, so it suits liquids such as milk and blood, not dry powders.

The Lowry method and the Bradford method also use colour. Lowry combines the Biuret reaction with a second reagent to give a stronger colour, and Bradford uses a dye that binds protein and changes colour. Both are sensitive and are used in research, where small amounts of protein must be measured. They are not used for routine food labelling, because other food parts interfere with the colour.

Near infrared, or NIR, is a fast instrumental method used on factory lines. A beam of near infrared light shines on the sample, and the pattern of light absorbed tells the protein, moisture, and fat. It is fast and needs no chemicals, but it must be calibrated against Kjeldahl or Dumas results for each food, or the numbers drift. NIR is a prediction, not a direct measure.

Amino acid analysis is the most complete method: the protein is broken into amino acids by acid, and each amino acid is separated and measured. It gives the full amino acid profile and the true protein, and it is the basis for PDCAAS and DIAAS. It is slow and costly, so it is used for research and for checking new ingredients, not for routine batch testing.

How the Kjeldahl method works

Step 1: Digestion. Sample plus sulphuric acid plus catalyst, heated until clear
↓
Step 2: Distillation. Alkali added, ammonia gas distilled into boric acid
↓
Step 3: Titration. Trapped ammonia titrated with standard acid
↓
Step 4: Maths. Acid volume gives nitrogen, nitrogen times factor gives protein

Sampling and error: why two laboratories disagree

Two laboratories can test the same food and give different numbers for honest reasons. The sample may differ: one laboratory took a spoonful from the top of the tub, the other mixed the tub first. The method may differ: one used Kjeldahl, the other Dumas. The factor may differ: one used 6.25, the other 6.38. The moisture may differ: one reported on the food as received, the other on a dry basis. A protein result without a stated method, factor, and moisture basis is not a complete result.

Good laboratories control this by testing a reference sample of known protein beside the unknown, by repeating each test, and by taking part in checks where many laboratories test the same sample and compare. A result that falls outside the expected range is repeated before it is reported. A food technologist who receives a laboratory report should check four things: the method, the factor, the moisture basis, and the repeat values. If any is missing, ask for it before using the number.

Protein on the label

A nutrition label states protein per 100 g or 100 ml and per serving. The serving is the amount a person usually eats at one time, and it is set by the maker, not by the laboratory. The protein per serving is the number most shoppers read, but the protein per 100 g is the number that allows fair comparison between products.

Claims about protein follow rules. A product that says high protein or rich in protein must give a set share of its energy from protein, or a set grams per serving, and the rule differs by market. A product that says source of protein must meet a lower threshold. A product that says nothing about protein still states the protein content in the nutrition table. A claim about muscle, recovery, or growth must be an allowed claim, and the product must hold enough protein to support it. A claim that is not allowed, or a claim made by a product that does not meet the threshold, is a labelling fault, and it can lead to the product being removed from sale.

The label must also list the protein source in the ingredients, in order of weight, and must declare the major allergens. A protein bar that uses whey, soy, and peanut must declare milk, soy, and peanut. The allergen statement is often printed in bold within the ingredients list, or in a separate contains statement. A factory that makes several protein products on one line must manage cross contact: cleaning between runs, testing for residues, and carrying a may contain warning where the risk cannot be removed.

Checking a label claim in the factory

A factory checks protein claims by testing each batch and by watching the trend over time. The protein of a raw material varies: milk protein changes with the season, wheat protein changes with the variety and the rain, and soy protein changes with the crop. A recipe that meets the claim in one season may fail in the next if the raw material changes. The factory sets a target above the label claim, the overage, so that normal variation stays above the claim. The size of the overage is set by measuring many batches and learning how much the protein varies.

When a batch tests below the claim, the factory must act: hold the batch, check the test, check the recipe, and if the low result is real, rework the batch or sell it without the claim. Selling a batch that fails its claim is a breach of the rules, even if the shortfall is small. The record of tests, the batch number, and the release decision must be kept, so that any complaint can be traced back to the exact batch and its test result.

Questions to think about

  • A milk powder tests 11.17 percent protein with the factor 6.38 and 10.94 percent with the factor 6.25. Which answer is right for milk, and why?
  • Why can a food with added urea test high for protein by Kjeldahl even though it holds no extra protein?
  • A protein bar claims 20 g of protein but a laboratory finds 18.5 g. What should the factory do?
Think about the urea question before you read on

Kjeldahl measures all nitrogen, not only protein nitrogen. Urea is rich in nitrogen, so it adds to the nitrogen measured and the maths turns that extra nitrogen into extra protein. The method cannot tell protein nitrogen from urea nitrogen, so the result reads high. This is why a nitrogen test alone cannot prove protein content when a food has been adulterated with a nitrogen rich chemical, and why true protein needs amino acid analysis.

Practical note: When you send a sample to a laboratory for protein testing, write the method, the factor, and the moisture basis on the request form. Ask for the result in duplicate, with the two values shown. If the two values differ by more than a small margin, ask for a repeat before you use the number on a label or in a recipe.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is the Kjeldahl result called crude protein?

Because the method measures all nitrogen in the sample, not only the nitrogen in protein. The nitrogen is multiplied by a factor to estimate protein, so the result is a good estimate rather than a direct measure of true protein.

Question: What is the main advantage of the Dumas method over Kjeldahl?

Speed and safety. Dumas burns the sample in oxygen and measures nitrogen gas in about five minutes, with no strong acid and no long digestion. Kjeldahl takes two hours or more and uses concentrated sulphuric acid.

Question: Why must the nitrogen factor match the food?

Because different proteins hold different shares of nitrogen. Milk protein uses 6.38, wheat uses 5.70, and the general factor is 6.25. Using the wrong factor gives a wrong protein number, even when the nitrogen measurement is perfect.

Try it yourself

Find a protein product in your kitchen and read the nutrition label. Write down the protein per 100 g, the protein per serving, and the serving size. Work out the protein per serving from the per 100 g figure and the serving size, and check that your answer matches the label. Then read the ingredients list and find the protein source: is it whey, soy, pea, egg, or milk? Write down any allergen statement on the pack. Finally, ask yourself: does the pack carry a high protein claim, and does the protein per serving look high enough to support it? Keep your notes: this is the same check a food technologist does when a new product arrives for review.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Routine protein testing measures nitrogen and multiplies by a factor, so the factor must match the food.
  • Kjeldahl digests the sample in acid, distils ammonia, and titrates it; it is the reference method but slow.
  • Dumas burns the sample in oxygen and measures nitrogen gas in minutes; it is fast and automated.
  • Both methods report crude protein, because they measure all nitrogen, not only protein nitrogen.
  • Colour methods and NIR measure protein faster or on the line, but they need calibration or a dissolved sample.
  • Amino acid analysis gives the true protein and the full profile, but it is slow and costly.
  • A label states protein per 100 g and per serving, claims follow rules, allergens must be declared, and every batch is checked against the claim.

Glossary

Crude protein

Protein estimated from total nitrogen times a factor, rather than measured directly. Food tech example: a Kjeldahl result is reported as crude protein because it includes non protein nitrogen.

Digestion

In Kjeldahl testing, heating the sample with sulphuric acid to turn all nitrogen into ammonium sulphate. Food tech example: the digestion step takes an hour or more until the mixture turns clear.

Distillation

In Kjeldahl testing, heating the digested mixture with alkali so ammonia gas passes into a trapping solution. Food tech example: ammonia distilled from the sample is trapped in boric acid.

Dumas method

A fast protein method that burns the sample in oxygen and measures nitrogen gas. Food tech example: a factory uses Dumas to test hundreds of samples a day.

Kjeldahl method

The reference protein method that digests, distils, and titrates to measure nitrogen. Food tech example: a disputed protein result is settled by the Kjeldahl method.

Nitrogen factor

The number that converts measured nitrogen into protein, such as 6.25 for most foods and 6.38 for milk. Food tech example: using 6.25 for wheat overstates its protein, because wheat needs 5.70.

Titration

Adding a standard solution drop by drop until a reaction ends, to measure how much of a substance is present. Food tech example: the ammonia trapped in Kjeldahl testing is titrated with standard acid.

Biuret method

A colour method where copper binds peptide bonds and turns violet, used for dissolved proteins. Food tech example: the Biuret method measures protein in milk and in blood samples.

Bradford method

A sensitive colour method where a dye binds protein and changes colour, used in research. Food tech example: the Bradford method measures small amounts of protein in a research sample.

Near infrared

A fast instrumental method that predicts protein from the pattern of infrared light absorbed by the sample. Food tech example: near infrared testing on a factory line predicts the protein of grain as it arrives.

Amino acid analysis

Breaking a protein into amino acids and measuring each one, giving the true protein and the full profile. Food tech example: amino acid analysis is used to work out the PDCAAS of a new ingredient.

Overage

Extra nutrient added above the label claim to cover variation between batches. Food tech example: a powder labelled 25 g of protein per scoop may be made with 26 g to cover variation.

Reference sample

A sample of known composition tested beside unknown samples to check the method. Food tech example: a laboratory tests a reference milk powder with each batch of samples.

Non protein nitrogen

Nitrogen in a food that is not part of protein, such as urea or ammonia. Food tech example: milk holds a small amount of non protein nitrogen, so Kjeldahl slightly overstates its true protein.

Blank titration

A titration run with reagents only and no sample, to measure the nitrogen in the reagents so it can be subtracted from the real result. Food tech example: a Kjeldahl blank is subtracted before the nitrogen is worked out, or the protein reads high.

Molar mass

The mass of one mole of a substance, in grams per mole, such as 14.01 g per mol for nitrogen atoms. Food tech example: the Kjeldahl derivation multiplies moles of nitrogen by 14.01 g per mol to get grams of nitrogen.

References

  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.
  • AOAC International, Official Methods of Analysis of AOAC International, 17th edition, 2000.
  • Pomeranz, Y. and Meloan, C. E., Food Analysis: Theory and Practice, 3rd edition, 2000.
  • National Dairy Development Board, Laboratory Handbook for Dairy Industry, March 2001.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.

Unit 7: Protein Processing: Denaturation, Texturisation and Extrusion

Note

Unit 7: Protein Processing: Denaturation, Texturisation and Extrusion

A question to start with

A piece of meat goes into a hot pan and shrinks, firms up, and turns brown. A scoop of soy flour goes into a machine and comes out as chewy strips that look and tear like chicken. A glass of milk is heated and forms a skin. All three changes are protein processing: heat, pressure, and shear change the shape of proteins, and the new shape gives a new texture. This unit explains denaturation, gel formation, and the two big texturising processes, extrusion and spinning, that turn plant protein into meat like foods.

Denaturation is the unfolding of a protein from its working shape. Heat is the most common cause: as temperature rises, the weak bonds that hold the fold together break, the chain opens, and the parts that were hidden inside come out. Acid does the same thing: when the pH moves away from the protein's stable range, the charges on the side chains change and the fold opens. Strong shaking, whipping, and high pressure can also unfold proteins. Once unfolded, a protein often cannot fold back, because the opened chains bond to each other instead.

Denaturation is not always a loss. In cooking, it is the point: an egg sets, meat firms, and milk thickens because proteins unfold and form a network. In a factory, denaturation is controlled: the maker chooses the temperature, the time, and the pH to get the texture wanted, and avoids the conditions that give a texture nobody wants. A protein that is denatured too far becomes tough and dry; a protein that is denatured too little stays soft and raw.

Heat and protein: what happens in cooking

When meat is heated, several changes happen in order. At about 40 to 50 °C, some muscle proteins start to unfold. At about 60 °C, the main muscle protein, myosin, denatures and the meat firms. At about 70 °C, collagen, the tough protein around the fibres, starts to shrink and squeeze water out, which is why meat loses juice as it cooks. At higher temperatures and longer times, collagen turns into gelatine, which is soft and gives the melting texture of slow cooked meat. The cook who sears meat fast keeps the inside tender, while the cook who braises meat for hours turns tough collagen into soft gelatine.

Egg white sets at about 60 to 65 °C, and the yolk sets at about 65 to 70 °C. That is why a soft boiled egg has a set white and a runny yolk: the white has passed its setting temperature and the yolk has not. Milk forms a skin when heated because the whey proteins denature and join with casein at the surface. The skin is harmless, but it shows that heat has changed the protein, and it is why milk for yoghurt is heated first: the denatured whey proteins join the casein network and give a firmer yoghurt.

Heat also changes protein nutrition. Mild heating improves digestibility, because unfolding lets enzymes reach the chains, and it destroys anti-nutritional factors such as trypsin inhibitors. Severe heating harms nutrition: the amino acid lysine can bind with sugars in the Maillard reaction, the browning reaction between protein and sugar, and bound lysine is no longer available to the body. A food that is browned hard and long may taste good, but its lysine is lower than the same food cooked gently. The food technologist balances flavour and nutrition: enough heat to cook and to brown lightly, not so much that the protein is damaged.

Gels: how unfolded proteins build texture

A gel is a network of protein chains that traps water. Yoghurt, cheese, tofu, egg custard, and meat sausage are all gels. The network forms when unfolded proteins bond to each other at many points, leaving small spaces that hold water. The strength of the gel depends on how many bonds form and how much water is trapped. A firm gel has many bonds and holds its shape; a soft gel has fewer bonds and flows.

Two kinds of bonds build gels. Heat set gels form when heating unfolds the proteins and cooling lets them bond: egg custard and cooked sausage are heat set gels. Acid gels form when acid lowers the pH to the point where the protein loses its charge and clumps: yoghurt and fresh cheese are acid gels, formed when lactic acid bacteria turn milk sugar into lactic acid and the pH falls to about 4.6. Enzyme gels form when an enzyme cuts one protein and lets the rest join: rennet cheese is an enzyme gel, formed when rennet cuts casein and the curd sets.

Salt matters in gels too. In sausage making, salt dissolves the muscle protein myosin, so that it can form a sticky paste that binds the meat pieces. Without salt, the sausage crumbles. The salt level, the pH, the temperature, and the time all change the gel, and the sausage maker tunes them to get a firm bite that still holds juice.

Texturisation: making plant protein feel like meat

Texturisation is the process of giving plant protein a fibrous, chewy texture like meat. The two main methods are extrusion and spinning, and extrusion is by far the most used.

In extrusion, a mix of protein powder and water is fed into a long barrel with a screw turning inside. The screw pushes the mix forward, the barrel heats it, and the pressure rises. Inside the barrel, the protein unfolds, melts, and lines up in the direction of flow. At the end of the barrel, the mix passes through a narrow die, and the sudden drop in pressure makes the water flash into steam. The protein sets into a porous, fibrous mass as it cools. The result is textured vegetable protein: dry, light, and full of small fibres.

Two kinds of extrusion give different products. Low moisture extrusion makes dry textured soy protein, which is sold dry and soaked before use. The feed holds about 20 to 30 percent water, the temperature reaches 150 to 180 °C, and the product expands as it leaves the die. High moisture extrusion makes a wet, chewy product that is used at once in meat analogues. The feed holds about 50 to 70 percent water, the temperature is lower, and a long cooling die lets the protein line up into long fibres that tear like meat. High moisture extrusion is the method behind most modern plant based chicken and beef pieces.

The raw material is usually defatted soy flour or soy protein concentrate, because soy protein lines up well and holds water. Pea protein is now used too, often blended with soy or wheat gluten, because some consumers avoid soy. Wheat gluten is added to many recipes because its elastic protein helps the fibres hold together and gives chew. The recipe is tuned by changing the water level, the temperature, the screw speed, and the die shape, and each change shifts the texture from soft to firm, from crumbly to fibrous.

Spinning and other texturising methods

Spinning is the older method. A protein solution, usually soy, is forced through tiny holes into an acid bath, where the protein sets into fine fibres. The fibres are stretched, washed, and bound together with egg white or another binder to make a meat like mass. Spinning gives fine, even fibres, but it is slow and costly, and it needs a binder that may itself be an allergen. It is now used less than extrusion, but it still appears in some products where a fine texture is wanted.

Shear cell technology is a newer method. Protein and water are heated and sheared between two plates, and the protein lines up into fibres without a die. It gives a texture close to a steak, with long fibres that tear in one direction. It is still scaling up, but it shows where texturisation is heading: bigger pieces, longer fibres, and a texture that is hard to tell from meat.

Fermentation can also texturise protein. Tempeh is made by fermenting soybeans with a mould, and the mould binds the beans into a firm cake with a nutty flavour. The fermentation also improves digestibility and lowers phytate. It is a low technology method that gives a high protein food with no machine at all, and it is a reminder that texturisation does not always need a factory.

How extrusion texturises soy protein

Step 1: Feed. Soy flour and water enter the barrel
↓
Step 2: Screw pushes the mix forward, heat and pressure rise
↓
Step 3: Protein unfolds, melts, and lines up in the flow
↓
Step 4: Die. Sudden pressure drop, steam flashes off
↓
Step 5: Cooling and setting into a fibrous, chewy mass

The Maillard reaction and protein damage

When protein and sugar are heated together, they react in the Maillard reaction, named after the chemist who described it. The reaction gives brown colour and roasted, savoury flavour to bread crust, roasted meat, and toasted nuts. It also binds lysine to sugar, and bound lysine cannot be used by the body. In a loaf of bread, the crust holds less available lysine than the crumb, because the crust is hotter and drier. In milk powder that is dried too hot, lysine falls and the powder turns brown.

The reaction needs heat, low water, and time. It runs fast above 140 °C and slowly in a wet food. A food technologist who wants flavour without losing lysine keeps the temperature moderate, the time short, and the water high enough to slow the reaction. UHT milk, heated very hot for a few seconds, loses less lysine than milk held hot for a long time, because time matters as much as temperature. The balance is always the same: enough heat for safety and flavour, not so much that nutrition is lost.

Protein processing and safety

Processing protein safely means controlling microbes, allergens, and heat. Meat and egg products must be cooked to a temperature that kills harmful bacteria, and the temperature must be measured at the centre, not only at the surface. A thick burger that is brown outside can still be raw inside. Dried protein powders must be kept dry, because a damp powder can grow microbes. Textured soy protein is made at high temperature, which kills microbes, but it must be packed dry and kept dry, or it will spoil.

Allergen control is part of processing. A factory that extrudes soy and then extrudes pea on the same line must clean between runs, or the pea product will carry soy. The cleaning must be checked, not assumed, because protein sticks to the barrel and the die. The label must declare every protein source used, and the cleaning record must be kept.

Questions to think about

  • Why does slow cooked meat turn soft while fast cooked meat from the same cut stays tough?
  • A plant based chicken piece tears in long fibres. Which process made those fibres, and how?
  • Bread crust is brown and tasty but holds less available lysine than the crumb. Why?
Think about the meat question before you read on

Slow cooking gives collagen time to turn into gelatine. Collagen is the tough protein around muscle fibres, and it shrinks and squeezes water out when heated fast. Given hours at a gentle heat, collagen unwinds and turns into soft gelatine, which gives the melting texture of a braised stew. Fast cooking does not give collagen that time, so the meat stays tough.

Practical note: When you fry an egg, watch the white: it turns from clear to white at about 60 to 65 °C, and the yolk starts to set at about 65 to 70 °C. Take the egg off the heat when the white is set and the yolk is still soft, and the heat left in the egg will finish the cooking. That is denaturation you can see, and it is the same change a factory controls with thermometers and timers.

Quick self-check

Question: What is denaturation, and is it always a bad thing?

Denaturation is the unfolding of a protein from its working shape, caused by heat, acid, or shaking. It is not always bad: cooking relies on it, because an egg sets, meat firms, and yoghurt thickens when proteins unfold and form a network. It is bad when it goes too far and the protein turns tough, dry, or loses lysine.

Question: How does high moisture extrusion differ from low moisture extrusion?

Low moisture extrusion uses 20 to 30 percent water and high temperature, and makes a dry expanded product that is sold dry and soaked before use. High moisture extrusion uses 50 to 70 percent water and a long cooling die, and makes a wet chewy product with long fibres that is used at once in meat analogues.

Question: What is a gel, and how does yoghurt set?

A gel is a network of protein chains that traps water. Yoghurt is an acid gel: lactic acid bacteria turn milk sugar into lactic acid, the pH falls to about 4.6, casein loses its charge and clumps, and the clumps join into a network that holds the milk as a soft solid.

Try it yourself

Take two eggs. Boil one for 5 minutes and the other for 12 minutes. Peel both and cut them open. Compare the white and the yolk: colour, firmness, and smell. The 5 minute egg has a set white and a soft yolk, while the 12 minute egg has a firm white, a dry yolk, and often a grey green ring where iron and sulphur have reacted. Then take a piece of bread and look at the crust and the crumb: the crust is brown from the Maillard reaction, the crumb is pale. Write down what you see and link each observation to denaturation or the Maillard reaction in one sentence each.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Denaturation unfolds a protein from its working shape, and it is caused by heat, acid, shaking, or pressure.
  • Cooking uses denaturation: egg sets at 60 to 65 °C, meat firms as myosin denatures, and slow cooking turns collagen into gelatine.
  • A gel is a protein network that traps water; yoghurt is an acid gel, custard is a heat set gel, and rennet cheese is an enzyme gel.
  • Extrusion texturises plant protein: the screw, heat, and pressure unfold and line up the protein, and the die sets it into fibres.
  • Low moisture extrusion makes dry textured protein; high moisture extrusion makes wet, chewy meat analogues.
  • The Maillard reaction gives brown colour and flavour but binds lysine, so long hot cooking lowers available lysine.
  • Protein processing must control temperature at the centre of the food, keep powders dry, and manage allergens between runs.

Glossary

Denaturation

Unfolding of a protein from its working shape, caused by heat, acid, or shaking, usually permanent. Food tech example: egg white denatures and sets when heated.

Gel

A network of protein chains that traps water and holds its shape. Food tech example: yoghurt is a soft gel of casein.

Maillard reaction

The browning reaction between protein and sugar during heating, giving colour and roasted flavour but binding lysine. Food tech example: bread crust browns by the Maillard reaction.

Myosin

The main muscle protein, which denatures at about 60 °C and makes meat firm. Food tech example: the firming of a steak in the pan is myosin denaturing.

Collagen

A tough fibrous protein around muscle fibres that turns into gelatine on slow cooking. Food tech example: a braised stew turns soft because collagen becomes gelatine.

Gelatine

The soft protein formed when collagen is heated in water for a long time. Food tech example: gelatine sets jellies and gives slow cooked meat its melting texture.

Extrusion

Pushing a mix through a heated barrel with a screw, then through a die, to cook and shape it. Food tech example: textured soy protein is made by extrusion.

Textured vegetable protein

Dry extruded plant protein with a fibrous texture, sold dry and soaked before use. Food tech example: textured soy protein is added to ready meals to stretch meat.

High moisture extrusion

Extrusion with 50 to 70 percent water and a long cooling die, making wet chewy meat analogues. Food tech example: plant based chicken pieces are made by high moisture extrusion.

Low moisture extrusion

Extrusion with 20 to 30 percent water and high temperature, making dry expanded protein. Food tech example: dry textured soy protein is made by low moisture extrusion.

Acid gel

A gel formed when acid lowers pH and protein clumps into a network. Food tech example: yoghurt is an acid gel formed at pH about 4.6.

Heat set gel

A gel formed when heating unfolds proteins and cooling lets them bond. Food tech example: egg custard is a heat set gel.

Rennet

An enzyme that cuts casein and curdles milk to make cheese. Food tech example: rennet cheese is an enzyme gel.

Shear cell

A newer texturising method that heats and shears protein between plates to form long fibres. Food tech example: shear cell technology makes plant based steak with fibres that tear like meat.

References

  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.
  • Heldman, D. R. and Hartel, R. W., Principles of Food Processing, 1997.
  • Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development: From Concept to Marketplace, 3rd edition, 2011.

Unit 8: Functional Properties of Proteins: Solubility, Emulsification, Foaming and Gelation

Note

Unit 8: Functional Properties of Proteins: Solubility, Emulsification, Foaming and Gelation

A question to start with

A protein powder dissolves clear in one drink and turns cloudy in another. The same egg white whips into a tall foam for a meringue and falls flat in a cake batter that is too acid. A sausage holds its juice when it is cooked, while a cheap one leaks fat onto the plate. None of this is about how much protein the food holds. It is about what the protein does. A protein that dissolves, holds oil and water together, traps air, or sets into a gel is doing a job, and food makers choose proteins for these jobs as much as for nutrition. This unit explains the four main functional properties of proteins, what changes them, and how to pick the right protein for a job.

A functional property is something a protein does in a food that changes how the food looks, feels, or behaves. Nutrition is about what the protein does in the body. Function is about what it does in the food. A protein can be excellent food and a poor ingredient, or the other way round. Whey protein is a fine food, and it also dissolves well in acid drinks. Pea protein is a fine food too, but it dissolves less well and tastes beany, so it needs more work in a drink. The food technologist must judge both sides: the nutrition table and the behaviour in the recipe.

The four properties in this unit cover most of what a food maker asks a protein to do. Solubility decides whether a protein stays dissolved or falls out. Emulsification decides whether oil and water stay mixed. Foaming decides whether air stays trapped. Gelation decides whether a liquid sets into a solid that holds its shape. Around them sit smaller jobs: holding water, binding fat, adding thickness, and giving chew. Every one of these jobs comes from the same protein shape, and every one of them changes when heat, acid, salt, or shear changes that shape.

Solubility: the first property

Solubility is the share of a protein that stays dissolved in water under set conditions. It is the first property to check, because a protein that will not dissolve cannot emulsify, foam, or gel well. A drink made with an insoluble protein turns cloudy, leaves a sediment at the bottom of the bottle, and feels gritty. A soluble protein gives a clear drink, a smooth mouthfeel, and a stable product.

Solubility depends on the protein and on the liquid around it. The main control is pH. Every protein has an isoelectric point, the pH where its positive and negative charges balance and its net charge is zero. At that pH, protein molecules stop pushing each other away, they clump together, and solubility falls to its lowest point. Move the pH away from the isoelectric point in either direction, and the molecules carry a charge, push each other apart, and dissolve better. Casein has an isoelectric point near pH 4.6, which is why milk curdles when it turns acid: the casein reaches its isoelectric point and falls out of solution. That fall is a fault in a drink and the whole point of making cheese.

Salt also changes solubility. A little salt helps many proteins dissolve, because the salt ions shield charges and let water reach the protein. This is called salting in. A lot of salt does the opposite: the salt takes water for itself, the protein loses its water shell, and the protein falls out. This is called salting out, and it is used in the laboratory to separate proteins. Heat usually lowers solubility, because heat unfolds the protein and exposes the water hating parts inside, which then stick to each other. A whey protein that is heated too far will not dissolve again when it cools.

A worked example shows how solubility is measured and reported. A laboratory stirs 10.0 g of a protein powder in water, spins the mixture in a centrifuge, and measures the protein left in the clear liquid. Suppose the clear liquid holds 8.2 g of protein. The solubility is worked out in steps. First, write the soluble protein over the total protein: 8.2 g divided by 10.0 g. Second, do the division: 8.2 divided by 10.0 is 0.82. Third, turn it into a percent by multiplying by 100: 0.82 times 100 is 82 percent. So the solubility is 82 percent at that pH and temperature. The number means nothing without the conditions, so the report must state the pH, the temperature, and the salt level used. The same powder can score 82 percent at pH 7 and 15 percent at pH 4.6, and both numbers are true.

Questions to think about

  • Why does milk curdle when it turns acid, and why is that fall in solubility useful in cheese making but a fault in a protein drink?
  • A protein powder dissolves well at pH 7 and poorly at pH 4.5. What does that tell you about its isoelectric point?
  • Why does a little salt help a protein dissolve while a lot of salt makes it fall out?
Think about the milk question before you read on

Milk curdles because casein reaches its isoelectric point near pH 4.6 as the milk turns acid, so the casein loses its charge, clumps, and falls out of solution. In cheese making that clumping is the curd the maker wants. In a protein drink the same clumping is a fault, because the drink turns cloudy and leaves a sediment.

Emulsification: holding oil and water together

An emulsion is a mix of oil and water that stays mixed, like mayonnaise, salad cream, or a milky drink. Oil and water do not mix on their own, so an emulsion needs an emulsifier: a substance that sits at the boundary between oil and water and stops the drops from joining back together. Proteins are good emulsifiers, because a protein molecule has water loving parts and water hating parts on the same chain. The water hating parts sink into the oil drop, the water loving parts stay in the water, and the protein forms a coat around each drop.

Emulsification has two parts: making the emulsion and keeping it. Making it needs energy, usually a fast mixer or a homogeniser, to break the oil into tiny drops. Keeping it needs a strong coat around each drop, so the drops cannot join. A protein that unfolds fast at the interface makes small drops quickly. A protein that forms a thick, elastic coat keeps the drops apart for weeks. Egg yolk protein is the classic emulsifier in mayonnaise. Milk protein coats the fat drops in milk and in ice cream. Soy protein holds the oil in sausages and in meat analogues.

Three things change how well a protein emulsifies. The first is solubility: a dissolved protein reaches the interface fast, while a clumped protein cannot. The second is flexibility: a loose, flexible protein unfolds at the interface and spreads, while a tight, rigid protein stays folded and coats poorly. The third is charge and pH: near the isoelectric point the coat loses its charge, the drops stop pushing each other away, and the emulsion breaks. A salad dressing made near the isoelectric point of its protein will separate on the shelf, even if it looked fine on the day it was made.

Heat can help or harm an emulsion. Gentle heat can unfold a protein and help it coat drops. Strong heat can make the coated drops stick together and form a gel, which is wanted in a sausage and unwanted in a drink. Salt can help by shielding charges, or harm by making the coat thin. The maker tests the emulsion over its shelf life, at warm and cold temperatures, because an emulsion that holds for a week can still break in a month.

Foaming: trapping air

A foam is air trapped in a liquid by a thin film, like the white of a whipped egg, the head on a beer, or the light texture of a mousse. Proteins make good foams for the same reason they make good emulsions: they sit at the boundary, here between air and water, and they form a coat that stops bubbles joining and bursting. Egg white is the best known foaming protein. Its proteins unfold at the air water boundary, link to each other, and build a strong elastic film around each bubble.

Foaming also has two parts: making the foam and keeping it. Making it needs whipping or beating, which folds air in and breaks it into small bubbles. Keeping it needs a film that is strong and stretchy. A film that is too weak lets bubbles join into big bubbles, and the foam falls. A film that is too stiff cracks when the bubbles move, and the foam falls too. The best foams sit in the middle: strong enough to hold, stretchy enough to bend.

Sugar, acid, and fat all change foaming. A little sugar added late in whipping makes the foam denser and more stable, because the sugar thickens the liquid between bubbles and slows drainage. A little acid, such as a squeeze of lemon, helps egg white whip by moving the pH away from the isoelectric point and letting the proteins unfold cleanly. Fat is the enemy of foam: even a trace of egg yolk in the white, or a greasy bowl, stops the proteins reaching the air water boundary, and the foam never rises. That is why a meringue bowl must be clean and dry, and why a cake batter that is rich in fat needs a different way of holding air.

Heat sets a foam. When a meringue is baked, the heat unfolds the proteins further, the film firms up, and the air stays trapped as the water dries out. When a foam is heated too fast, the bubbles grow and burst before the film sets, and the cake sinks. The maker balances whipping time, temperature, and recipe, and tests the foam by watching how fast the liquid drains from it and how long the bubbles last.

Gelation: setting into a solid

A gel is a solid that holds a lot of water in a network, like set yoghurt, a boiled egg white, a jelly, or a cooked sausage. Protein gels form when unfolded proteins link to each other and build a three dimensional net that traps water. The net is built from the same bonds that hold protein shape: hydrogen bonds, hydrophobic links, and disulphide bridges between sulphur atoms.

Heat is the most common way to make a protein gel. As an egg white heats, its proteins unfold, link, and set into a firm white. As milk is heated and acid is added, casein links into the curd of yoghurt and cheese. As a sausage is cooked, meat proteins unfold and link, and the gel traps water and fat, which is why a good sausage is juicy. Cold set gels form without heat: a protein solution is unfolded by salt or by an enzyme, then a salt or a change in pH makes the links form at room temperature. Acid gels form when acid moves the pH to the isoelectric point, so the proteins lose their charge and link, as in yoghurt.

The strength of a gel depends on the protein, its amount, the pH, the salt, and the heating pattern. More protein gives a firmer gel, up to the point where the gel turns rubbery. Salt helps meat proteins dissolve and then link, which is why salt is worked into sausage meat before cooking. Heating slowly gives a fine, even net with small pores that hold water well. Heating fast gives a coarse net with big pores that leak water, which is why an egg boiled too hard turns rubbery and weeps. The maker measures gel strength by pressing the gel and by watching how much water it loses on standing, a fault called syneresis.

How a protein stabilises an emulsion

Step 1: Oil and water are mixed with energy, and the oil breaks into tiny drops
↓
Step 2: Dissolved protein moves to the oil water boundary
↓
Step 3: The protein unfolds, its water hating parts sink into the oil, its water loving parts stay in the water
↓
Step 4: A coat forms around each drop and stops drops joining together
↓
Step 5: The coated drops stay apart, and the emulsion holds on the shelf

Water holding, fat binding and thickness

Beyond the four main properties, proteins do quieter jobs that shape eating quality. Water holding is the ability of a protein net to keep water inside the food. A sausage that holds its water is juicy. A sausage that loses it is dry and shrinks in the pan. Water holding is strongest when the pH is away from the isoelectric point, because the charged proteins push apart and leave room for water, and when the gel net is fine and even.

Fat binding is the ability of a protein to hold fat drops inside the food instead of letting them leak out. In a sausage, meat protein coats fat drops and locks them in the gel. If the protein is too little, or the chopping is too warm, the fat melts, runs out, and the sausage turns greasy and dry. In a baked bar, protein can bind the fat from nuts and seeds and stop it seeping to the surface during storage.

Thickness, or viscosity, is the resistance of a liquid to flow. Dissolved proteins thicken a liquid, and unfolded proteins thicken it more, because long unfolded chains tangle and slow the flow. A protein drink that is too thick feels heavy and hard to swallow. A soup that is too thin feels watery. The maker tunes thickness by choosing the protein, its amount, and the heat it has seen, and by testing the product at the temperature it will be eaten.

These smaller jobs interact with the big four. A protein that gels well often holds water well, because the same net does both jobs. A protein that emulsifies well often binds fat well. A protein that dissolves well often thickens less, because folded proteins flow past each other easily. Choosing a protein is always a trade between jobs, and no single protein does everything best.

How processing changes functional properties

Every step in processing changes what a protein can do, and the changes are often one way only. Heat unfolds proteins, which can help emulsification and gelation, but it lowers solubility, and a protein that has been heated too far will not dissolve again. The maker who wants a soluble whey protein in a clear drink uses a gentle heat treatment. The maker who wants a firm gel in a sausage uses a full cook. The same protein, two heat histories, two different ingredients.

Acid changes the charge on a protein and moves it toward or away from its isoelectric point. A drink that is acid for flavour may sit near the isoelectric point of its protein, so the maker must pick a protein whose isoelectric point is far from the drink pH, or use a protein that has been treated to stay soluble in acid. Drying can damage solubility if the heat is high, which is why spray dried proteins are made with care and why a powder that has been stored damp can lose solubility. Freezing can damage proteins too, because ice crystals push proteins together and the salt level rises in the unfrozen water, which can make proteins clump.

Shear, the sliding force in a mixer or an extruder, can unfold proteins and help them line up, which is wanted in texturisation, or it can break a foam or an emulsion, which is unwanted in a mousse. Enzymes can cut proteins into smaller pieces, which usually raises solubility and lowers gel strength, and which can also make bitter tastes. The maker keeps a record of the heat, pH, salt, shear, and drying each protein has seen, because that history decides what the protein will do in the recipe.

Choosing a protein for a job: a worked example

Three products show how the choice is made. The first is a clear acid protein drink at pH 3.5. It needs a protein that stays soluble in acid, so whey protein isolate is a good pick: it dissolves well at low pH and gives a clear drink. Soy protein would cloud at that pH, and casein would fall out near its isoelectric point. The second is a meringue. It needs a protein that foams fast and holds air, so egg white is the classic pick: it whips into a tall foam and sets firm on baking. Whey protein can foam, but its foam is weaker and falls faster. The third is a cooked sausage. It needs a protein that dissolves in salt, coats fat, and gels on cooking, so meat protein itself does the job, helped by a little soy protein or milk protein to hold extra water.

The worked example also shows the test pattern. For each product, the maker writes the job first, then the property that does the job, then the test that proves it. The drink is tested for solubility at pH 3.5, for clarity, and for sediment after a month. The meringue is tested for foam volume, for drainage time, and for firmness after baking. The sausage is tested for water loss on cooking, for fat loss, and for firmness when cut. A protein that passes one test can fail another, and the recipe is tuned until all the tests pass together.

Practical note: When you test a new protein ingredient, test it at the pH, salt level, and temperature of your real product, not at the neutral pH of the laboratory bench. A protein that scores well at pH 7 can fail badly at pH 4, and the bench test will hide the fault until the product reaches the shelf.

Quick self-check

Question: What is the isoelectric point, and why does solubility fall there?

The isoelectric point is the pH where a protein carries no net charge. With no charge, the molecules stop pushing each other away, they clump together, and solubility falls to its lowest point.

Question: Why is fat the enemy of a protein foam?

Fat stops proteins reaching the air water boundary, so the protein film cannot form around the bubbles. Even a trace of fat, such as a drop of yolk in egg white or a greasy bowl, can stop a foam rising.

Question: A sausage loses fat when it is cooked. Which protein job has failed?

Fat binding and gelation have failed. The protein net did not coat the fat drops and lock them in, so the fat melted and ran out during cooking.

Try it yourself

Take two protein foods from your kitchen: an egg and a spoonful of milk powder or a protein powder. First, whisk the egg white in a clean dry bowl and time how long it takes to form soft peaks. Then add a drop of oil to a second egg white and try again: note the difference. Next, stir the powder into a glass of water, then into a glass of water with a squeeze of lemon, and compare the cloudiness and any sediment. Write down what you saw and match each result to a property in this unit: foaming, solubility, and the effect of pH and fat. Keep your notes: this is the same comparison a food technologist runs when a new protein arrives for testing.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A functional property is what a protein does in a food, and it is judged separately from nutrition.
  • Solubility is the first property to check, and it falls to its lowest point at the isoelectric point.
  • Proteins emulsify because they carry water loving and water hating parts on one chain and coat oil drops.
  • Proteins foam by forming a stretchy film at the air water boundary, and fat stops that film forming.
  • Proteins gel when unfolded chains link into a net that traps water, by heat, acid, or cold setting.
  • Water holding, fat binding, and thickness come from the same net and the same charge effects.
  • Heat, acid, salt, drying, freezing, shear, and enzymes all change functional properties, often in one direction only.
  • Choosing a protein means naming the job, naming the property, and testing at the real pH, salt, and temperature of the product.

Glossary

Functional property

Something a protein does in a food that changes how the food looks, feels, or behaves, such as dissolving, emulsifying, foaming, or gelling. Food tech example: a protein is chosen for a meringue because of its foaming property, not only its nutrition.

Solubility

The share of a protein that stays dissolved in water under set conditions of pH, temperature, and salt. Food tech example: a protein powder with 82 percent solubility at pH 7 leaves little sediment in a drink.

Isoelectric point

The pH where a protein carries no net charge, so its solubility is at its lowest and it tends to clump. Food tech example: casein falls out of milk near pH 4.6, its isoelectric point.

Salting in

The rise in protein solubility when a small amount of salt is added. Food tech example: a little salt helps meat protein dissolve when sausage meat is mixed.

Salting out

The fall in protein solubility when a large amount of salt is added, as the salt takes water from the protein. Food tech example: salting out is used in the laboratory to separate proteins from a mixture.

Emulsion

A mix of oil and water that stays mixed, with tiny drops of one liquid held in the other. Food tech example: mayonnaise is an emulsion of oil drops in water held by egg yolk protein.

Emulsifier

A substance that sits at the boundary between oil and water and stops the drops joining back together. Food tech example: egg yolk protein acts as the emulsifier in mayonnaise.

Homogeniser

A machine that forces a liquid through a narrow gap at high pressure to break oil into tiny drops. Food tech example: milk is homogenised so its fat drops stay small and do not rise as cream.

Foam

Air trapped in a liquid by thin films, as in whipped egg white or a mousse. Food tech example: egg white foam gives a meringue its light, tall shape.

Gel

A solid network of linked protein chains that traps water and holds its shape. Food tech example: a boiled egg white is a heat set protein gel.

Syneresis

Water leaking out of a gel on standing, a sign that the gel net is coarse or shrinking. Food tech example: a yoghurt that weeps liquid on the surface shows syneresis.

Water holding capacity

The ability of a protein net to keep water inside a food during cooking and storage. Food tech example: a sausage with good water holding stays juicy after cooking.

Fat binding

The ability of a protein to hold fat drops inside a food instead of letting them leak out. Food tech example: meat protein binds fat in a sausage so the fat does not run out in the pan.

Viscosity

The resistance of a liquid to flow, felt as thickness. Food tech example: dissolved protein thickens a drink, and too much protein makes the drink feel heavy.

Cold set gel

A protein gel that forms at room temperature, after the protein is unfolded by salt or an enzyme and then linked by a change in pH or salt. Food tech example: some dessert gels are cold set so that heat sensitive flavours survive.

Disulphide bridge

A strong link between two sulphur atoms in a protein, which helps hold the gel net together. Food tech example: disulphide bridges help a heated egg white gel stay firm.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.
  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.

Unit 9: Protein for Special Populations and Clinical Nutrition

Note

Unit 9: Protein for Special Populations and Clinical Nutrition

A question to start with

A healthy adult, a baby, a pregnant woman, an older person recovering from a fall, and a patient in a hospital bed all need protein, but they do not need the same protein, in the same amount, in the same form. The baby needs protein that builds a brain and a body from nothing. The older person needs protein that holds on to muscle that is slipping away. The hospital patient needs protein that heals a wound while the body is fighting illness. The same gram of protein does different work in each of them, and the food that carries it must fit their mouth, their gut, and their illness. This unit explains how protein needs and protein foods change across life and in illness, and how food makers and care teams meet them.

A special population is a group whose protein needs differ from the general adult pattern, because of age, growth, pregnancy, illness, or recovery. Clinical nutrition is the feeding of people who are ill or recovering, where food is part of treatment. Both fields share one rule: the protein must be judged by what the person can eat, digest, and use, not only by what the packet says. A powder that holds 25 g of protein is no use to a patient who cannot swallow it, and a meat meal is no use to an older person who cannot chew it.

The general pattern for healthy adults is a starting point, not a rule for everyone. Adults need enough protein to replace what the body breaks down each day and to keep muscle, skin, blood, and immune defences in repair. Children need extra for growth. Older adults need extra to fight the slow loss of muscle. Pregnant and breastfeeding women need extra to build new tissue and make milk. People who are ill need extra to heal and to fight infection, and people whose kidneys are failing need less, and a careful kind of less. The numbers differ, and the food differs too.

Infants and young children: building from the start

The first two years of life are the fastest growth a person ever sees, and protein is the building material. A baby doubles its birth weight in the first months, and its brain, muscles, and organs are built from amino acids in milk. Breast milk is the reference food for this age: its protein is easy to digest, its amino acid pattern fits the baby, and its amount falls as the baby grows and starts solid foods. The protein in breast milk is mostly whey in the early months, which empties from the stomach fast and is gentle on a small gut.

Infant formula is made to copy breast milk as closely as the maker can. The protein is usually from cow milk, but the balance is changed: the casein share is lowered and the whey share is raised, to match the whey rich pattern of human milk. The total protein is set a little higher than in breast milk, because cow milk protein is digested a little less well by a baby. The amino acids are checked one by one, because a baby cannot make some amino acids fast enough and must get them from food. A formula that is short of one amino acid can slow growth, so the check is strict, and the rules for infant foods are the strictest of any food.

As a child grows, protein needs stay high for body size, because growth continues through childhood and the teenage years. A child who eats too little protein grows slowly, gets ill more often, and learns less well, because the body spends its protein on staying alive before it spends it on growing. The foods that carry protein for children must also be safe, easy to chew, and liked, because a food a child will not eat gives no protein at all. School meals, fortified porridges, milk, eggs, beans, and lentils all play a part, and the mix matters more than any single food.

A worked example shows how the need is read. A young child needs more protein per kilogram of body weight than an adult, because growth adds to the daily repair bill. So the maker of a food for children does not copy the adult serving: the protein per serving is set against the child need, the portion is small enough for a small stomach, and the protein is spread across the day, because the body builds tissue from a steady supply, not from one large meal. The label for a child food is checked against the rules for that age group, not against the adult table.

Pregnancy and breastfeeding: protein for two

Pregnancy adds new tissue: the baby, the placenta, the womb, and the extra blood that feeds them. All of it is built from amino acids, so the mother needs more protein, and the need rises as the pregnancy goes on, because the baby grows fastest in the later months. The extra protein must come from food the mother can eat and keep down, which is not always easy when nausea limits the diet in the early months. Small, frequent meals with a protein food at each one work better than large meals.

Breastfeeding adds a further need, because milk carries protein out of the mother every day. A mother who breastfeeds needs protein to make milk and to keep her own muscle and defences in repair. The protein in her diet also shapes the amino acids in her milk, though the body protects the milk first and takes from the mother stores when the diet falls short. That is why the mother diet matters: a shortfall is paid by the mother body, not by the baby, until the stores run low.

The foods that suit pregnancy and breastfeeding are the ordinary protein foods, chosen for digestibility and safety. Milk, eggs, beans, lentils, fish, and meat all supply complete or near complete protein. Foods that carry a risk of harmful microbes are avoided or cooked well, because an infection in pregnancy can harm the baby. The maker of a food aimed at this group must also be careful with claims: a product may state its protein content, but it must not promise a benefit for the baby that the evidence does not support.

Older adults: holding on to muscle

Ageing changes protein in two ways. First, muscle is lost slowly year by year, a process called sarcopenia, and the loss speeds up after long illness or a fall. Second, the older body answers protein less strongly: the same meal that builds muscle in a young adult builds less in an older adult. This weaker answer is called anabolic resistance, and it means older adults need more protein per meal, not less, to get the same building signal. Spreading protein across the day also matters more: a large protein meal at dinner alone does less than protein at breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

The practical problem is appetite. Many older adults eat less, chew with difficulty, swallow with care, and tire of large portions. A protein food for this group must be soft or easy to chew, easy to swallow, small in portion, and rich in protein per bite, so that a small meal still carries a useful amount. A soft egg, a smooth yoghurt, a milky drink, a minced meat dish, or a fortified soup all fit better than a tough steak. The leucine content matters too: leucine is the amino acid that switches muscle building on, and a food rich in leucine, such as whey or egg, gives a stronger signal per gram.

Falls and fractures make the need sharper. A person who breaks a hip loses muscle fast while lying in bed, and protein plus movement is the treatment that rebuilds it. The care team sets a protein target, the kitchen supplies protein rich foods at every meal, and the dietitian checks that the food is actually eaten, not only served. A supplement drink helps when the appetite is small, but it works best beside real food and beside movement, because protein without movement builds less muscle than protein with it.

Questions to think about

  • Why does a baby need more protein per kilogram of body weight than an adult?
  • Why does an older adult need protein at every meal, not only at dinner?
  • A mother who breastfeeds eats too little protein. Who pays the shortfall first, the baby or the mother, and why does that matter?
Think about the breastfeeding question before you read on

The mother pays first. The body protects the milk and takes protein from the mother stores to keep the milk supplied, so the baby is fed while the mother body runs down. That is why the mother diet matters: a shortfall that lasts will leave the mother weak and low in muscle, even while the baby looks well fed.

Illness, injury and recovery: protein as treatment

Illness raises the protein need and lowers the ability to eat, a hard combination. Infection, surgery, burns, and wounds all raise the breakdown of body protein, because the body uses amino acids to make immune defences, to heal tissue, and to replace what is lost. A patient who eats too little protein during illness loses muscle fast, heals slowly, and catches infections more easily. The loss is fastest in the first days of a severe illness, when the patient often cannot eat at all.

Feeding in hospital follows a ladder. The first step is ordinary food, with extra protein at each meal: an egg at breakfast, a milk drink between meals, a meat or bean dish at lunch and dinner. The second step is a fortified food or a supplement drink, for a patient who cannot eat enough ordinary food. The third step is tube feeding, where a liquid feed is given through a tube into the stomach, for a patient who cannot swallow or cannot eat. The fourth step is feeding into a vein, for a patient whose gut cannot be used. Each step up the ladder is a medical decision, and the protein in the feed is set by the care team, not by the food maker.

Wounds need protein most of all. A wound is new tissue, and new tissue is built from amino acids. A patient with a wound who eats too little protein heals slowly, and the wound can break open again. The amino acid arginine is studied for wound healing, because it helps make the compounds that build new blood vessels, but the evidence is still growing, and no single amino acid replaces a full protein supply. Vitamin C and zinc are also needed for healing, which is a reminder that protein works beside other nutrients, not alone.

Protein and the kidney is the one case where less protein is the treatment. A failing kidney cannot clear the waste that protein leaves behind, so a person with kidney disease is given a controlled, lower protein diet, with enough of the right amino acids to avoid muscle loss. The protein is chosen for quality, because a high quality protein gives the amino acids needed with less waste. This diet is set by a doctor and a dietitian for each person, and a food maker must never suggest a high protein product to a person with kidney disease without that advice.

Protein energy malnutrition: when food runs short

Protein energy malnutrition is the condition where a person, most often a child, eats too little energy and too little protein for months. The body first uses its fat stores, then its muscle, and growth slows, then stops. The child becomes thin, or swollen with fluid, gets ill often, and learns slowly. It is the most serious protein problem in the world, and it is a problem of too little food, not of a missing amino acid or a poor protein quality.

Treatment has two stages. The first stage is careful refeeding: small, frequent feeds that are easy to digest, with enough energy and protein to stop the loss, given slowly so that a starved body is not overwhelmed. The second stage is catch up growth: larger feeds, rich in energy and protein, until the child returns to a healthy weight and height. The foods used are often a peanut based paste or a milk based feed, because they are energy dense, protein rich, easy to store without a fridge, and easy to eat. The recipe is set by nutrition agencies and by health workers, and the dose is set by the child weight, so a worker in a village can use it without a laboratory.

Prevention is simpler than treatment: enough food, a mix of protein sources, clean water, and treatment of the infections that steal protein from the body. A child who is ill with diarrhoea loses protein and cannot eat, so clean water and quick treatment of illness protect protein status as surely as food does. The food technologist who works on foods for this purpose must design for the place the food will be used: no fridge, little fuel, small hands, and a mother who must trust the food at first sight.

Feeding in illness: the ladder of care

Step 1: Ordinary food, with extra protein at every meal
↓
Step 2: Fortified food or a supplement drink, when ordinary food is not enough
↓
Step 3: Tube feeding, when the patient cannot swallow or cannot eat
↓
Step 4: Feeding into a vein, when the gut cannot be used
↓
Step 5: Each step is chosen by the care team, and the protein dose is set for that patient

Athletes and active people: a special case with limits

Athletes need more protein than people who sit all day, because training breaks muscle down and the repair builds it back stronger. The need rises with the training load, and it is highest during heavy training and during recovery from injury. The timing matters too: protein after training helps repair, and protein spread across the day helps more than the same amount eaten at one meal. These points are covered in Unit 5, and they are repeated here for one reason: the athlete is the only special population where the food industry often oversells.

A healthy adult who trains hard can meet the need from ordinary food: milk, eggs, meat, fish, beans, and lentils, spread across meals. A powder or a bar is a convenience, not a need, and a very high protein intake does not build more muscle than a sufficient intake. The extra protein is simply burned for energy or turned into waste the kidney must clear. A product aimed at athletes must state its protein honestly, must not promise muscle gain that food alone cannot give, and must be checked for banned substances when it is sold to competing athletes, because a contaminated supplement can end a career.

Designing foods for special populations

Designing a food for a special population starts with the person, not the ingredient. The maker asks four questions. First, how much protein does this person need, and how much can they eat at one sitting? Second, what can they chew and swallow safely? Third, what will they actually like and eat day after day? Fourth, what other limits apply: kidney disease, allergy, diabetes, or a religious or personal food choice?

The answers shape the product. A food for older adults is soft, small, and rich in protein per bite, with a flavour that suits an older palate. A food for a young child is safe, easy to hold, and mild in flavour. A food for a hospital patient is sterile or near sterile, easy to swallow, and measured so the nurse knows exactly how much protein was given. A food for a breastfeeding mother is an ordinary food, made a little richer in protein, with no claim that overpromises. In every case, the maker tests the food with the people who will eat it, watches what is left on the plate, and changes the recipe until the food is eaten, not only served.

Practical note: When you design a food for a special population, write the person first and the ingredient second. A protein that is perfect on paper and uneaten on the plate gives no protein at all, and a small portion that is finished beats a large portion that is left.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is infant formula protein changed from plain cow milk protein?

The casein share is lowered and the whey share is raised to match the whey rich pattern of human milk, the total is set a little higher because cow milk protein is digested a little less well by a baby, and the amino acids are checked one by one for the baby need.

Question: Why do older adults need more protein per meal, not less?

Because of anabolic resistance: the older body answers a protein meal less strongly, so a larger protein dose per meal is needed to give the same muscle building signal as in a young adult.

Question: Why is a low protein diet sometimes the treatment, not the problem?

In kidney disease the failing kidney cannot clear the waste that protein leaves behind, so a controlled lower protein diet, chosen for quality, lowers the waste load while still giving the amino acids needed.

Try it yourself

Pick one person you know well: a young child, an older relative, or a friend who trains hard. Write down their age, their activity, and any limits on what they can chew, swallow, or eat. Then plan one day of protein foods for them: three meals and two small snacks, with a protein food at each one, and a note on why each food fits that person. Compare your plan with the points in this unit: is the protein spread across the day, is the portion size right for the person, and is there a food that person would refuse? Change the plan until every food on it is one that person would actually eat.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Protein needs differ by age, growth, pregnancy, illness, and recovery, and the food must fit the person, not only the number.
  • Breast milk is the reference protein food for babies, and formula copies its whey rich pattern and checks every amino acid.
  • Pregnancy and breastfeeding raise the need, and a shortfall is paid by the mother body first.
  • Older adults need more protein per meal because the muscle building answer weakens with age, and the food must be soft, small, and rich per bite.
  • Illness raises the need while lowering appetite, and hospital feeding climbs a ladder from ordinary food to tube and vein feeding.
  • A failing kidney is the case where less protein, chosen for quality, is the treatment.
  • Protein energy malnutrition is treated by careful refeeding and then catch up growth, and prevented by enough food, clean water, and quick treatment of illness.
  • Designing for a special population starts with the person: need, chewing, swallowing, liking, and other limits, in that order.

Glossary

Special population

A group whose protein needs differ from the general adult pattern, because of age, growth, pregnancy, illness, or recovery. Food tech example: infants, pregnant women, and older adults are special populations for protein design.

Clinical nutrition

The feeding of people who are ill or recovering, where food is part of treatment. Food tech example: a hospital dietitian sets the protein in a recovery feed as part of clinical nutrition.

Sarcopenia

The slow loss of muscle with age, which speeds up after illness or a fall. Food tech example: a protein rich soft food is designed to slow sarcopenia in older adults.

Anabolic resistance

The weaker muscle building answer to a protein meal in older age, so more protein per meal is needed for the same signal. Food tech example: an older adult needs protein at every meal because of anabolic resistance.

Leucine

An essential amino acid that switches muscle building on, found in good amounts in whey and egg. Food tech example: a recovery drink uses whey because its leucine gives a strong muscle building signal.

Infant formula

A food made to feed a baby who is not breastfed, with protein changed to copy human milk. Food tech example: infant formula lowers the casein share and raises the whey share of cow milk protein.

Tube feeding

Giving a liquid feed through a tube into the stomach, for a patient who cannot swallow or cannot eat. Food tech example: a tube feed carries a set amount of protein per hour for a patient after surgery.

Protein energy malnutrition

The condition where a person eats too little energy and too little protein for months, so growth slows and muscle is lost. Food tech example: a peanut based paste is used to treat protein energy malnutrition in young children.

Catch up growth

The faster growth that follows treatment of malnutrition, as the body rebuilds weight and height. Food tech example: a child in catch up growth needs larger feeds rich in energy and protein.

Refeeding

The careful first stage of feeding a starved person, with small frequent feeds given slowly. Food tech example: refeeding starts with small feeds so a starved body is not overwhelmed.

Arginine

An amino acid studied for wound healing, because it helps make the compounds that build new blood vessels. Food tech example: a wound healing feed may hold extra arginine beside a full protein supply.

Kidney disease diet

A controlled lower protein diet for a failing kidney, chosen for protein quality to limit waste. Food tech example: a kidney diet uses high quality protein in measured amounts set by a doctor and dietitian.

Supplement drink

A ready to drink liquid that adds protein and energy for a person who cannot eat enough ordinary food. Food tech example: a supplement drink between meals helps a hospital patient reach the daily protein target.

Fortified food

An ordinary food with extra protein or other nutrients added for a person with a higher need. Food tech example: a fortified soup gives an older adult more protein per spoonful than plain soup.

References

  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.
  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.

Unit 10: Protein, Allergenicity and Sustainability: The Responsible Protein

Note

Unit 10: Protein, Allergenicity and Sustainability: The Responsible Protein

A question to start with

A protein bar is a triumph of food science: 20 g of protein, a good taste, a year on the shelf. Then a shopper with a peanut allergy reads the label, a farmer asks how much land the soy in it needed, and a parent asks what happens to the whey that was left over when the protein was made. The bar is still a good food, but the questions show that protein is judged on more than grams and taste. It is judged on whether it is safe for the person who cannot eat it, and on what it costs the land, the water, and the climate to make it. This unit explains the two questions every protein food must answer: is it safe for allergic people, and can its supply last?

The two questions belong together because they share a root: a protein food is not finished when it leaves the factory. It is finished when it is eaten safely and when the farm, the factory, and the shop that made it can keep making it year after year without running the land down. A maker who answers only the nutrition question has done half the job. This unit gives the maker the other half.

Why some proteins cause allergy

A food allergy is an immune reaction to a protein in food. The immune system mistakes a harmless food protein for a threat, makes antibodies against it, and on the next meeting releases chemicals that cause itching, swelling, stomach pain, breathing trouble, and in the worst case a sudden whole body reaction called anaphylaxis. The protein that triggers the reaction is called an allergen. Most food proteins never cause allergy. A small set does, and the same foods appear on allergen lists around the world: milk, egg, peanut, tree nuts, soy, wheat, fish, crustacean shellfish, and sesame, with a few others added in some markets.

The allergen is usually a protein that survives cooking and digestion well enough to meet the immune system intact. Milk allergy is most often to casein or to whey proteins. Egg allergy is most often to proteins in the egg white. Peanut allergy is to a small set of peanut proteins that are tough, stable to heat, and slow to break down. Soy allergy is to soy storage proteins. The toughness matters: a protein that breaks down fast in the gut rarely causes allergy, because the immune system never sees the whole protein. A protein that resists heat and digestion is more likely to be seen, and so more likely to trigger a reaction.

Allergy is not the same as intolerance. An intolerance, such as lactose intolerance, is a digestive problem: the gut lacks the enzyme to break down milk sugar, so the person feels bloated and unwell, but the immune system is not involved and the reaction is not life threatening. An allergy involves the immune system and can be life threatening at a tiny dose. A food maker must never confuse the two on a label or in advice: a lactose free milk is safe for a person with lactose intolerance and dangerous for a person with milk allergy, because the milk protein is still there.

Children often outgrow milk and egg allergy as they grow, while peanut, tree nut, fish, and shellfish allergy often last for life. That pattern shapes the market: a protein product for children must be extra careful with milk and egg, and a product for adults must be extra careful with peanut and tree nut, because the adult who carries the allergy has carried it for years and will read every label.

Processing and allergenicity: what changes, what does not

Processing changes some allergens and leaves others untouched, and the maker must know which is which. Heat denatures many proteins, which can lower their allergenicity, but some allergens are heat stable and survive baking, boiling, and roasting. Peanut proteins survive roasting. Milk casein survives heating. Egg white proteins partly lose their allergenicity on long baking, which is why some children with egg allergy can eat a well baked cake but cannot eat a lightly cooked egg, but that is a medical judgement for each child, never a claim a food maker can print.

Fermentation and enzyme treatment can cut proteins into smaller pieces and lower allergenicity. A hydrolysed formula, where milk protein is cut into small peptides, is used for babies with cow milk allergy, because the small pieces are less likely to be recognised by the immune system. The degree of cutting matters: a partly hydrolysed formula still holds pieces big enough to trigger a reaction in some babies, while a fully hydrolysed formula holds pieces so small that most allergic babies tolerate it. The maker must state the degree of hydrolysis and must never claim a partly hydrolysed product is safe for an allergic baby without medical backing.

Extrusion, the texturisation method from Unit 7, changes soy protein shape but does not remove its allergenicity. A textured soy protein is still soy, and it must be labelled as soy. The same rule holds for every protein: no ordinary process removes the allergen label. Only a process that has been tested and proven to remove the allergenic pieces, and accepted by the rules, can change the label, and such processes are rare. The safe rule for a maker is simple: if the protein came from an allergenic food, the label says so, whatever the process did.

Cross contact is the quiet way an allergen reaches a product that should not hold it. A factory that makes a peanut bar and then a plain bar on the same line can carry peanut protein into the plain bar on a belt, a scoop, or a hand. The control is a sequence: make the allergen free product first, clean the line, test the rinse water or the first product off the line, and only then make the allergen product. Where the risk cannot be removed, the pack carries a may contain warning. That warning is not a decoration: it tells an allergic shopper that the product is not safe for them, and it must be used honestly, not as a cover for poor cleaning.

Questions to think about

  • Why is a lactose free milk safe for a person with lactose intolerance and dangerous for a person with milk allergy?
  • A soy protein is extruded into a meat analogue. Why must the pack still declare soy?
  • A factory makes a peanut bar and a plain bar on one line. What order should it make them in, and why?
Think about the lactose free milk question before you read on

Lactose intolerance is a digestive problem with milk sugar, so a milk with the lactose removed is safe. Milk allergy is an immune reaction to milk protein, and lactose free milk still holds all the milk protein, so it can trigger a life threatening reaction.

Labelling for allergens: the rules in plain words

Allergen labelling follows the same principle in most markets, even where the exact lists differ: the allergen must be named clearly, in words a shopper can understand, and it must be easy to find. The allergen is usually shown in the ingredients list, often in bold, and many packs add a separate contains statement. A protein bar that uses whey, soy, and peanut must declare milk, soy, and peanut, not only whey protein isolate or soy protein isolate, because the shopper needs the food name, not the ingredient name.

The maker must also watch the hidden sources. A flavouring, a colour, or a processing aid can carry an allergen, and the supplier must declare it. A recipe change can bring in a new allergen, and the label must change with it. A new supplier can bring a new risk, and the supplier check must ask about allergens before the first delivery. The label is checked at every recipe change, every supplier change, and every line change, because a label that was right last month can be wrong today.

The may contain warning has a place, but it must not be used as a lazy cover. If a factory can remove the risk by cleaning, by scheduling, or by a separate line, it should remove the risk and leave the warning off. If the risk cannot be removed, the warning goes on, and the allergic shopper is told plainly. A product that carries a may contain warning for every allergen because the factory never cleans is a product that allergic shoppers cannot trust, and it will lose them for good.

The environmental side of protein

Protein foods differ widely in what they ask of the land, the water, and the climate, and the difference comes from how the protein is made. An animal eats feed, drinks water, and lives on land, and only a share of the feed protein becomes meat, milk, or egg protein. A plant makes protein directly from sun, soil, and water, with no animal in the middle. That is why, in broad terms, plant proteins ask less of the land and the feed supply than animal proteins for the same amount of protein, and why beans, lentils, and peas are among the lightest protein foods on the land.

The comparison is not a simple ranking, because farming is not simple. A dairy cow on grassland that cannot grow crops can turn grass humans cannot eat into milk humans can drink, which is a useful job. A chicken turns feed into protein more efficiently than a cow, because it grows fast and lays eggs. A fish farmed on feed made from wild catch raises its own questions. A soy crop grown on land cleared from forest carries a cost that a soy crop grown on old farmland does not. The maker who compares proteins must compare whole systems: the feed, the land, the water, the energy, and the waste, not one number alone.

Three pressures shape the future of protein supply. The first is land: the world has a fixed amount of farmland, and a protein that needs less land leaves room for other food. The second is feed: the grain and soy fed to animals could feed people directly, so a protein that needs less feed, or that uses feed humans cannot eat, eases that tension. The third is waste: the parts of animals and plants that are not eaten, the whey from cheese, the skins and bones from meat, the pulp from soy milk, can be turned into protein, feed, or energy instead of being thrown away, and that recovery is a gain for the whole system.

Water matters too, and it is often the limit in dry places. A protein that needs a lot of water to grow or to process is a risk where water is short, and a factory that reuses its water and treats its waste is a better neighbour than one that does not. Energy matters in the same way: a protein that is dried, frozen, or heated many times carries an energy cost at each step, and a maker who shortens the chain saves energy as well as money.

Making protein more sustainable: what a maker can do

A food maker cannot change farming alone, but there are five practical moves that help. The first is to use the whole animal and the whole plant: turn whey into protein powder, turn bones into stock and gelatine, turn soy pulp into fibre and feed, and turn pea starch water into a usable ingredient. The second is to blend proteins: mix a plant protein with a smaller amount of animal protein, or mix two plant proteins that complete each other, so the product keeps its nutrition while asking less of the land. The third is to choose the protein with the lighter footprint where the nutrition and the function allow it: a bean burger where a beef burger is not needed, a pea protein drink where the drink does not need milk.

The fourth move is to cut waste in the factory: measure the protein lost in wash water, in trimmings, and in rejected batches, and put a value on it, because a loss that is measured is a loss that can be fixed. The fifth is to be honest on the pack: state the protein source plainly, make only the sustainability claims that can be proved, and do not dress a product in green words that the supply chain cannot support. A shopper who trusts the claim will come back. A shopper who finds the claim empty will not.

Keeping an allergen out of a product that should not hold it

Step 1: Plan the run. Make the allergen free product first, the allergen product last
↓
Step 2: Clean the line between runs, and test the rinse water or the first product off the line
↓
Step 3: Check the label at every recipe change and every supplier change
↓
Step 4: Where the risk cannot be removed, print a plain may contain warning
↓
Step 5: Keep the records, so any complaint can be traced to the batch and the line

New proteins and the questions they raise

New protein sources are arriving: proteins from fungi, from algae, from insects, and from fermentation, where microbes are grown to make a protein that copies milk or egg. Each one must answer the same two questions as the old proteins. The first is safety: is the protein an allergen, and does it carry a risk for people allergic to a related food? A fungal protein can cross react with a mould allergy. An insect protein can cross react with a shellfish allergy, because insects and shellfish share similar proteins. A fermentation protein that copies milk protein must be labelled as milk protein, because an allergic person reacts to the protein, not to the animal it came from.

The second question is supply: can the new protein be made at a scale and a price that feeds people, not only a few buyers? A protein that needs a costly feed, a lot of energy, or a rare input may stay small. A protein that grows on a side stream, such as a waste from another food, may grow fast. The maker who judges a new protein should ask for the allergen evidence, the digestibility evidence, and the supply evidence together, and should not launch a product on one of the three alone.

Practical note: When a new protein ingredient arrives, ask the supplier for three papers before you taste it: the allergen statement, the amino acid and digestibility data, and the evidence for any sustainability claim. A supplier who cannot give all three is not ready for your product.

Quick self-check

Question: What is the difference between a food allergy and a food intolerance?

An allergy is an immune reaction to a food protein, and it can be life threatening at a tiny dose. An intolerance is a digestive problem, such as lacking the enzyme for milk sugar, and it makes the person unwell but does not involve the immune system.

Question: Why does extrusion not remove the soy allergen label from textured soy protein?

Extrusion changes the shape of the soy protein but does not remove its allergenic pieces, so the product is still soy and must be labelled as soy for allergic shoppers.

Question: Why is a plant protein usually lighter on land and feed than an animal protein for the same protein?

A plant makes protein directly from sun, soil, and water, while an animal eats feed and turns only a share of the feed protein into meat, milk, or egg protein, so the animal route needs more land and more feed for the same amount of protein.

Try it yourself

Take three protein products from your kitchen: a bar, a powder, and a dairy or soy food. Read each label and write down every allergen it declares, including any may contain warning. Then write down the protein source for each one, and ask: where did that protein come from, and what do you know about how it was made? Finally, ask yourself which of the three you would pick for a friend with a peanut allergy, and why. Keep your notes: this is the same label and supply check a food technologist does before a new protein product is approved.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A food allergy is an immune reaction to a protein, and it can be life threatening at a tiny dose.
  • The common allergenic proteins come from milk, egg, peanut, tree nuts, soy, wheat, fish, crustacean shellfish, and sesame.
  • Allergy is not intolerance: lactose free milk is safe for intolerance and dangerous for milk allergy.
  • Heat, fermentation, and enzyme cutting change some allergens, but no ordinary process removes the allergen label.
  • Cross contact is controlled by making the allergen free product first, cleaning, testing, and warning honestly where the risk stays.
  • Allergen labels must name the food in plain words and be checked at every recipe and supplier change.
  • Plant proteins usually ask less of land and feed than animal proteins for the same protein, but whole systems must be compared, not one number.
  • A maker can help by using the whole animal and plant, blending proteins, cutting factory waste, and claiming only what can be proved.
  • New proteins must prove safety, allergenicity, digestibility, and supply together before they are launched.

Glossary

Allergen

A food protein that triggers an immune reaction in an allergic person. Food tech example: peanut proteins are allergens, so a bar that holds peanut must declare it.

Anaphylaxis

A sudden whole body allergic reaction that can close the airways and drop blood pressure, and needs urgent treatment. Food tech example: anaphylaxis is why a trace of peanut in a plain bar is a serious fault.

Cross contact

The movement of an allergen into a product that should not hold it, through shared equipment, tools, or hands. Food tech example: cross contact is stopped by making the allergen free product first and cleaning the line.

Hydrolysed formula

An infant formula where milk protein is cut into small peptides to lower allergenicity. Food tech example: a fully hydrolysed formula is used for babies with cow milk allergy.

May contain warning

A label statement that a product may hold a trace of an allergen because the risk cannot be removed. Food tech example: a may contain peanut warning tells an allergic shopper the product is not safe for them.

Intolerance

A digestive problem with a food, such as lacking the enzyme for milk sugar, which does not involve the immune system. Food tech example: lactose intolerance is eased by lactose free milk, while milk allergy is not.

Cross reaction

An allergic reaction to a new protein because it is similar to a protein the person is already allergic to. Food tech example: insect protein can cross react with shellfish allergy.

Heat stable allergen

An allergen that survives cooking and keeps its ability to trigger a reaction. Food tech example: peanut proteins are heat stable, so roasting does not make peanut safe.

Sustainability

The ability to make a food year after year without running down the land, water, and climate it depends on. Food tech example: using whey from cheese making as protein powder is a sustainability gain.

Feed conversion

How much feed an animal turns into food, with a smaller feed need meaning a lighter load on land and grain. Food tech example: a chicken turns feed into protein more efficiently than a cow.

Side stream

A part of a food process that was once thrown away, now used as an ingredient, feed, or energy. Food tech example: soy pulp from soy milk is a side stream that can be used for fibre and feed.

Blending proteins

Mixing two or more protein sources so the product keeps its nutrition while asking less of the land. Food tech example: a bar that blends pea protein with a little milk protein keeps its amino acid pattern with a lighter footprint.

Allergen free product

A product made without a named allergen and protected from cross contact with it. Food tech example: an allergen free bar is made first on the line, before any peanut product.

Supplier check

The check a maker runs on a supplier, including its allergen statement and its evidence for claims. Food tech example: a supplier check asks about hidden allergens before the first delivery arrives.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.