Login Register

Access the GIFSQ Portal

Select your user type to log in or register a new account.

Student Portal

Access your food safety courses and exams.

Instructor Portal

Manage courses, view student submissions, and grade quizzes.

Company Portal

Manage corporate setup, view employee logs, and access QA services.

GIFSQ ID: FTN-0096

← All subjects

Gut Health, Microbiome and Fermented Foods

Unit 1: The Gut Microbiome: What It Is and Why It Matters

Note

Unit 1: The Gut Microbiome: What It Is and Why It Matters

A question to start with

A bowl of beans makes one person feel fine and another feel bloated for hours. The same food, two different guts. The difference is not in the beans, it is in the trillions of tiny living things inside each person's gut, a community so large that it outnumbers the body's own cells. This unit explains what that community is, where it lives, what it does, and why food is the main tool that shapes it.

The gut microbiome is the community of microbes that live in the gut, mostly in the large intestine. The word microbiome covers the microbes themselves and their genes. The microbes are mostly bacteria, with smaller numbers of viruses, fungi, and other tiny organisms. A healthy adult gut holds about 38 trillion bacteria, roughly the same number as the human cells in the body, and they belong to hundreds of species. Each person's mix of species is different, like a fingerprint, and it is shaped by birth, diet, medicines, illness, and age.

The gut is not one place. The stomach is acid and holds few microbes. The small intestine holds more, but food moves through it fast. The large intestine is the main home: food moves slowly there, water is absorbed, and the microbes have time to feed on what is left. The large intestine holds about 1 to 2 kg of microbes, and their waste products, their genes, and their signals reach far beyond the gut.

How the microbiome is built

A baby is born with a nearly empty gut, and the first microbes arrive during birth and in the first feeds. A baby born vaginally picks up microbes from the mother, while a baby born by caesarean picks up microbes from the skin and the surroundings. Breast milk feeds the baby and also feeds certain gut bacteria, especially Bifidobacterium, which thrives on the special sugars in human milk. Formula milk feeds a different mix. The first three years of life set the pattern: the microbiome grows more diverse as solid foods arrive, and by about age three it looks much like an adult's.

Diet keeps shaping the microbiome for life. A diet rich in fibre, fruits, vegetables, and fermented foods supports a diverse community. A diet rich in fat and sugar and low in fibre supports a less diverse community. Antibiotics can cut the community sharply: a course of antibiotics kills harmful bacteria, but it also kills many useful ones, and the community can take weeks or months to recover. Some species never return to their old levels. This is why antibiotics are used only when needed, and why food matters after a course: fibre feeds the recovery.

Age changes the microbiome too. Older adults often have a less diverse community, because they eat less fibre, take more medicines, and move less. That change is linked to weaker defences against infection and to slower digestion, which is one reason fibre and fermented foods matter more, not less, in old age.

What the microbes do: digestion

The first job of the gut microbes is to digest what the human body cannot. Human enzymes break down starch, protein, and fat in the small intestine, but they cannot break down most dietary fibre. The microbes in the large intestine can. They ferment fibre, which means they break it down without oxygen, and they turn it into short chain fatty acids: acetate, propionate, and butyrate.

Butyrate is the most important of the three. The cells that line the large intestine use butyrate as their main fuel, and a good supply keeps the gut lining strong. Propionate travels to the liver, where it helps control sugar and fat. Acetate travels around the body and is used by many tissues. Together, the short chain fatty acids give the body about 5 to 10 percent of its daily energy, a real contribution from food that the human body alone could not use.

The microbes also make vitamins. Gut bacteria make vitamin K and several B vitamins, including biotin, folate, and vitamin B12 in small amounts. The amounts are modest, and food is still the main source, but the microbial supply is a useful extra, and it shows that the microbes are not only guests: they are part of the body's supply chain.

What the microbes do: defence and training

The gut lining is a barrier one cell thick, and the microbes help hold it. They feed the lining cells with butyrate, they crowd out harmful bacteria by taking up space and food, and they make compounds that stop harmful bacteria growing. A strong barrier keeps food, microbes, and their products inside the gut, where they belong. A weak barrier lets them leak into the blood, which triggers inflammation.

The microbes also train the immune system. The gut holds about 70 percent of the body's immune cells, and they learn from the microbes which things to attack and which to leave alone. A diverse microbiome in early life teaches the immune system to tolerate food and to attack invaders. A microbiome that is too narrow in early life is linked to a higher chance of allergies and of immune problems later. This is not a simple cause and effect, but the pattern is strong enough that early diet, birth, and antibiotic use are all studied as factors.

The gut and the rest of the body

The gut talks to the brain through nerves, hormones, and microbial products, a link called the gut brain axis. The vagus nerve runs from the gut to the brain and carries signals both ways. Microbes make compounds that act like the body's own signalling chemicals, including serotonin, most of which is made in the gut. Stress changes the gut, and the gut changes mood and appetite. A person who is stressed often feels it in the stomach first, and that is not imagination: the nerve link is real.

The gut also talks to metabolism. Short chain fatty acids help control blood sugar and fat, and they signal fullness. A microbiome that makes plenty of them supports steady blood sugar. A microbiome that is low in fibre fermenters makes fewer of them, and blood sugar control is weaker. The link to body weight is real but not simple: no single microbe makes a person gain weight, and no single food fixes the microbiome. The pattern is the whole diet, over months, that shapes the community and its products.

What harms the microbiome

Four things harm the microbiome most. A low fibre diet starves the fibre fermenters, so they shrink and short chain fatty acid production falls. A high intake of alcohol damages the gut lining and shifts the community. Smoking shifts the community too, and quitting restores much of the change. Antibiotics cut the community sharply, and repeated courses cause longer lasting change. Stress, poor sleep, and lack of movement also shift the community, though the effect is smaller than diet.

The good news is that the microbiome responds to food within days. A person who adds fibre, fruit, vegetables, and fermented foods sees a change in microbial products within a week, even if the species mix takes longer to shift. The community is not fixed: it is fed every day, and every meal is a chance to feed it well or badly.

How fibre becomes fuel for the gut lining

Step 1: Fibre reaches the large intestine undigested
↓
Step 2: Gut bacteria ferment the fibre without oxygen
↓
Step 3: Fermentation makes short chain fatty acids: acetate, propionate, butyrate
↓
Step 4: Butyrate fuels the gut lining cells and keeps the barrier strong
↓
Step 5: Propionate and acetate travel to the liver and the body and help control sugar and fat

Measuring the microbiome

The microbiome is measured by reading the genes in a stool sample. The laboratory extracts DNA, reads the gene that identifies bacteria, the 16S rRNA gene, and works out which species are present and in what amounts. Newer methods read all the genes, which shows not only who is there but what they can do. These tests are used in research, and they are starting to appear in clinics, but they are not yet a routine health check.

A stool test result needs care in reading. A test that names a species and calls it good or bad is too simple: most species are good in one setting and unhelpful in another, and the amount matters as much as the name. Diversity, the number of different species and how evenly they are spread, is a better guide than any single species. A diverse community is linked to better health, while a narrow community is linked to more problems. But diversity is not a diagnosis, and a test result alone cannot say whether a person is healthy or ill.

Questions to think about

  • Why does the large intestine hold far more microbes than the stomach?
  • A course of antibiotics kills the bacteria that cause an infection. Why does it also change the gut for weeks?
  • If two people eat the same beans, why might one feel bloated and the other feel fine?
Think about the stomach question before you read on

The stomach is strongly acid, with a pH near 2, and food passes through it fast, so few microbes can survive and grow there. The large intestine is near neutral in pH, food moves slowly, and water is absorbed, so microbes have time, warmth, and food to grow. The large intestine is the main home because its conditions suit microbes, while the stomach's conditions do not.

Practical note: When you eat more fibre, raise it slowly over two weeks, not in one day. The gut bacteria that ferment fibre need time to grow, and a sudden jump in fibre gives them more food than they can handle at once, which causes gas and bloating. Drink water with the fibre, because fibre without water can make constipation worse rather than better.

Quick self-check

Question: What are short chain fatty acids, and why does butyrate matter most?

Short chain fatty acids are acetate, propionate, and butyrate, made when gut bacteria ferment fibre. Butyrate matters most because it is the main fuel of the cells that line the large intestine, and a good supply keeps the gut barrier strong.

Question: How do gut microbes help defend the body?

They feed the gut lining with butyrate, crowd out harmful bacteria by taking up space and food, make compounds that stop harmful bacteria growing, and train the immune cells in the gut to tell friend from invader.

Question: Why is diversity a better guide than any single species?

Because most species are good in one setting and unhelpful in another, and the amount matters as much as the name. A diverse community has many species doing many jobs, so it is more stable and more useful than a narrow community that depends on a few species.

Feeding the microbiome: the daily pattern

The microbiome is fed every time food is eaten, and the pattern of the whole day matters more than any single food. A day that gives the microbes many kinds of fibre gives them many kinds of food, and many species grow. A day that gives only one kind of fibre feeds only the species that can use it, and the rest shrink. The practical rule is simple: eat a wide range of plant foods, and eat some fermented food most days.

A useful target that researchers use is 30 different plant foods a week. That sounds like a lot, but it counts every fruit, vegetable, grain, bean, nut, seed, herb, and spice. A breakfast of oats with berries and seeds already gives five or six. A lunch salad with lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrot, and chickpeas gives five more. A dinner of rice, lentils, and two vegetables gives four more. Herbs and spices count too: a pinch of cumin, a clove of garlic, and a spoon of ginger each add one. Most people who cook at home with varied ingredients reach 30 in a week without trying hard, while a person who eats the same three meals every day may reach only 10.

Water matters as well. Fibre absorbs water and swells, and the gut needs water to move the fibre along. A high fibre diet without enough water can make constipation worse, because the fibre sits dry and heavy. A glass of water with each meal and water through the day is part of feeding the microbiome, not a separate matter.

The microbes also respond to how food is eaten. Chewing well breaks food into small pieces and mixes it with saliva, which starts starch digestion and makes the food easier for microbes to reach. Eating slowly and at regular times gives the gut a steady rhythm. Skipping meals for long stretches, or eating a very large meal late at night, changes the rhythm and the microbes with it. None of this needs a special diet: regular meals, varied plants, enough water, and slow chewing are the daily pattern that supports the community.

One more point belongs here: the microbiome is not a thing to be fixed once and forgotten. It is a garden that is fed daily. A week of good eating improves it, and a week of poor eating sets it back. That is not a cause for worry, it is a cause for steadiness. Small daily habits, a few more vegetables, a fermented food, a glass of water, add up over months to a community that is more diverse and more useful than one fed on the same few foods every day.

Try it yourself

Write down everything you ate yesterday and count the different plant foods: fruits, vegetables, grains, beans, nuts, and seeds. Count each type once, even if you ate it twice. A diet with 30 different plant foods a week is linked to a more diverse microbiome, while a diet with fewer than 10 is linked to a narrow one. Now plan one day that reaches 15 different plant foods: add a handful of berries to breakfast, a mixed salad at lunch, and lentils with two vegetables at dinner. The number is not a prescription, it is a way to see how narrow or wide your diet is, and to widen it one food at a time.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • The gut microbiome is the community of microbes in the gut, mostly bacteria in the large intestine, about 38 trillion in number.
  • Each person's mix is different, shaped by birth, diet, medicines, illness, and age.
  • Microbes ferment fibre into short chain fatty acids, and butyrate fuels the gut lining.
  • Microbes make some vitamins, crowd out harmful bacteria, and train the immune system.
  • The gut talks to the brain and to metabolism through nerves, hormones, and microbial products.
  • Low fibre, alcohol, smoking, and antibiotics harm the microbiome, and the community responds to food within days.
  • Diversity is a better guide to a healthy microbiome than any single species.

Glossary

Microbiome

The community of microbes in the gut, and their genes. Food tech example: a diet rich in fibre supports a diverse gut microbiome.

Microbiota

The microbes themselves that live in a place, such as the gut. Food tech example: the gut microbiota includes hundreds of bacterial species.

Large intestine

The last part of the gut, where water is absorbed and most gut microbes live. Food tech example: fibre reaches the large intestine undigested and is fermented there.

Short chain fatty acid

Acetate, propionate, or butyrate, made when gut bacteria ferment fibre. Food tech example: butyrate made from oat fibre fuels the cells lining the large intestine.

Butyrate

A short chain fatty acid that is the main fuel of the cells lining the large intestine. Food tech example: a diet rich in beans and whole grains raises butyrate production.

Fermentation

Breakdown of food by microbes without oxygen, making acids, gases, and other products. Food tech example: gut bacteria ferment fibre, and yoghurt bacteria ferment milk sugar.

Gut brain axis

The two way link between the gut and the brain through nerves, hormones, and microbial products. Food tech example: stress changes gut movement through the gut brain axis.

Vagus nerve

The long nerve that carries signals between the gut and the brain. Food tech example: the vagus nerve carries fullness signals from the gut to the brain.

Diversity

How many different species live in the microbiome and how evenly they are spread. Food tech example: eating many different plant foods is linked to higher microbiome diversity.

Bifidobacterium

A group of gut bacteria that thrives on the sugars in human milk and on some fibres. Food tech example: Bifidobacterium is common in the gut of breastfed babies.

Antibiotic

A medicine that kills bacteria, used to treat infection. Food tech example: a course of antibiotics can cut gut microbiome diversity for weeks.

Immune system

The cells and proteins that defend the body against infection and harm. Food tech example: about 70 percent of immune cells sit in the gut, where they learn from microbes.

Gut lining

The single layer of cells that separates the inside of the gut from the body. Food tech example: butyrate keeps the gut lining strong, so food and microbes stay inside the gut.

Stool sample

A sample of faeces used to test which microbes live in the gut. Food tech example: a stool sample is read by DNA testing to list the bacterial species present.

References

  • Flint, H. J., Scott, K. P., Louis, P. and Duncan, S. H., The Role of the Gut Microbiota in Nutrition and Health, Nature Reviews Gastroenterology and Hepatology, 2012.
  • Sonnenburg, J. L. and Sonnenburg, E. D., The Good Gut, 2015.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Gibson, G. R. and Roberfroid, M. B., Handbook of Prebiotics, 2008.
  • Holzapfel, W. H. and Schillinger, U., Introduction to Pre and Probiotics, Food Research International, 2002.

Unit 2: Prebiotics, Probiotics and Postbiotics

Note

Unit 2: Prebiotics, Probiotics and Postbiotics

A question to start with

A yoghurt pot says it holds live cultures. A packet of fibre powder says it feeds good bacteria. A drink says it holds postbiotics, with no live bacteria at all. Three products, three different promises, and all three claim to help the gut. Are they the same thing with different names, or three different ideas? They are three different ideas, and this unit explains each one: the live microbes, the food that feeds them, and the products they leave behind.

The three words sound alike, and that causes confusion. A probiotic is a live microbe that gives a health benefit when eaten in enough amount. A prebiotic is a food ingredient, usually a fibre, that feeds useful gut microbes and gives a health benefit. A postbiotic is a preparation of dead microbes, or of the compounds microbes make, that gives a health benefit. The difference is simple: probiotics are alive, prebiotics are food for microbes, and postbiotics are not alive at all.

Probiotics: live microbes with a job

A probiotic must meet four tests. It must be a named strain, not only a species, because two strains of the same species can behave differently. It must be alive when eaten, in a dose that has been tested. It must survive the stomach acid and bile well enough to reach the gut alive. And it must give a health benefit that has been shown in human studies. A yoghurt that holds live cultures is not automatically a probiotic: it is a probiotic only when the strain and the dose have been tested for a benefit.

The most used probiotic groups are Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium, though the names have changed in recent years as scientists reclassified them: many Lactobacillus species are now called Lactobacillus, Lacticaseibacillus, Lactiplantibacillus, and other new names. The old names still appear on labels and in books, and a food technologist should know both. Other probiotics include Saccharomyces boulardii, a yeast, and some strains of Bacillus, which form spores that survive heat and stomach acid well.

Each strain has its own job. Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG is one of the most studied strains, and it has been tested for diarrhoea in children and for gut health after antibiotics. Bifidobacterium lactis BB-12 is widely used in yoghurt and has been tested for bowel regularity. Saccharomyces boulardii is used for diarrhoea linked to antibiotics. No strain does everything, and a product that lists a strain without saying what it was tested for is making a vague promise. The strain name, written as genus, species, and strain code, such as Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG, is the key to checking the evidence.

The dose matters. Most tested doses are between 1 billion and 10 billion live cells per day, written as colony forming units, or CFU. A product that holds 100 million cells may be too low to match the tested dose, and a product that holds 100 billion is not automatically better: more is not always better, and the right dose is the tested dose. The count must also hold to the end of shelf life, not only on the day of making. A yoghurt that starts with 10 billion cells and falls to 100 million after three weeks does not deliver the tested dose at the end of its life, so the maker must add an overage and test the count through shelf life.

How probiotics work

Probiotics work in four ways. First, they compete with harmful bacteria for space and food on the gut lining, so harmful bacteria find it harder to settle. Second, they make acids, mainly lactic acid and acetic acid, which lower the pH in the gut and slow the growth of harmful bacteria. Third, they make compounds called bacteriocins, which are natural antibiotics that kill closely related bacteria. Fourth, they talk to the immune cells in the gut wall, strengthening the barrier and tuning the immune response.

A worked example shows the acid effect. A probiotic yoghurt culture turns milk sugar, lactose, into lactic acid, and the pH of the milk falls from about 6.6 to about 4.5. At pH 4.5, most harmful bacteria grow slowly or not at all, while the lactic acid bacteria thrive. The same acid that sets the yoghurt also protects it. In the gut, the acids made by probiotics and by the resident microbes keep the large intestine mildly acid, which favours useful bacteria and discourages harmful ones.

Probiotics do not usually settle in the gut for life. Most pass through in a few days and are gone a week after the person stops eating them. That is why a probiotic must be eaten regularly to keep its effect: it is a daily visitor, not a permanent resident. The exception is in early life, when the gut is still being built, and after a course of antibiotics, when the community is thin and a probiotic may help it recover faster.

Prebiotics: food for useful microbes

A prebiotic is a food ingredient that feeds useful gut microbes and gives a health benefit. To count as a prebiotic, it must resist digestion in the stomach and small intestine, be fermented by gut microbes, and feed specific useful microbes, such as Bifidobacterium, in a way that helps health. Most prebiotics are fibres: inulin, fructo-oligosaccharides, and galacto-oligosaccharides are the three best known.

Inulin is a fibre from chicory root, Jerusalem artichoke, garlic, onion, and banana. It is a chain of fructose units, and human enzymes cannot break the links, so it reaches the large intestine whole. There, Bifidobacterium ferments it and grows, and the fermentation makes short chain fatty acids. Fructo-oligosaccharides are shorter chains of the same kind, and they are used in foods and in infant formula. Galacto-oligosaccharides are chains of galactose, and they are made from lactose; they also feed Bifidobacterium, and they are added to infant formula to mimic the effect of human milk sugars.

The dose for a prebiotic effect is about 3 to 10 g a day, depending on the fibre. A food that holds 1 g of inulin per serving is unlikely to change the microbiome, while a food that holds 5 g may do so. But a high dose can cause gas and bloating, because the same fermentation that feeds useful bacteria also makes gas. A person who adds prebiotic fibre should raise it slowly, as Unit 1 explained, and drink water with it.

Ordinary foods are also prebiotic, even when they are not labelled as such. Onions, garlic, leeks, asparagus, bananas, oats, barley, and lentils all hold fibres that feed gut bacteria. A diet rich in these foods gives a prebiotic effect without any supplement. The supplement is a concentrated dose; the food is the daily supply.

Postbiotics: benefit without live microbes

A postbiotic is a preparation of dead microbes, or of the compounds microbes make, that gives a health benefit. The microbes are killed by heat, so the product holds no live cells, but it still holds the cell walls, the proteins, and the acids that the live microbes made. The benefit comes from those parts, not from live growth in the gut.

Postbiotics have three practical advantages. They are stable: they do not need chilling, they survive heat, and they keep for a long time on the shelf. They are safe for people who should not take live microbes, such as people with a weak immune system or a premature baby. And they are easy to use in foods that are heated or baked, where a live probiotic would die. A biscuit, a soup, or a hot drink can carry a postbiotic, but it cannot carry a live probiotic.

The evidence for postbiotics is newer and thinner than for probiotics. Some heat killed strains have been tested for diarrhoea, for skin health, and for immune support, and the results are promising, but the number of studies is smaller and the doses are less settled. A food technologist should treat a postbiotic claim with more care than a probiotic claim: ask for the strain, the dose, and the human study behind it, and do not assume that a dead microbe does everything the live one does.

Synbiotics: the pair

A synbiotic is a product that holds a probiotic and a prebiotic together. The idea is that the prebiotic feeds the probiotic, so the live microbe survives better and works better. A yoghurt with added inulin is a simple synbiotic. The pair must be tested together, because a prebiotic that feeds one strain may not feed another, and a dose that works alone may need changing when the two are combined. The word synbiotic is sometimes used loosely for any product with both, but the proper meaning is a tested pair.

How a probiotic count falls on the shelf: a worked calculation

A probiotic label states a count, such as 10 billion colony forming units per serving, but the count on the day of packing is not the count on the day of eating. Live microbes die slowly during storage, and the fall follows a pattern the maker can measure and plan for. This section shows the calculation, because a probiotic product that cannot prove its count at the end of shelf life cannot prove its benefit.

Microbes die in proportion to how many are alive, which means the count falls by a fixed share in each fixed time, not by a fixed number. A useful way to state the fall is the log fall: a fall of 1 log means the count drops to one tenth of what it was, a fall of 2 logs means it drops to one hundredth. The maker measures the count at packing and at set times during storage, and works out the log fall per month.

A worked example shows the steps. A yoghurt is packed with 10 billion colony forming units per serving, which is 10,000,000,000, or 10 to the power of 10. The label promises at least 1 billion, which is 10 to the power of 9, at the end of a 30 day shelf life. The allowed fall is therefore 1 log in 30 days, from 10 to the power of 10 down to 10 to the power of 9. The maker tests a batch and finds the count after 30 days is 2 billion, which is 2 times 10 to the power of 9. That is above the promised 1 billion, so the batch passes, but the margin is small: the count fell by about 0.7 log, since 10 billion divided by 2 billion is 5, and a five fold fall is about 0.7 on the log scale.

The maker then asks what happens if the yoghurt is kept warm. A second batch is stored warm, and its count falls to 200 million after 30 days, which is 2 times 10 to the power of 8. That is below the promised 1 billion, so the batch fails, and the product must be kept cold or its shelf life shortened. The calculation shows why the cold chain is not a nicety for probiotics: a warm shelf can turn a passing product into a failing one, and the label count is only true if the storage was true.

The overage rule follows from the same maths. If the maker knows the count falls by 1 log over the shelf life, the packing count must be 10 times the label promise, so that the end of shelf life count still meets it. A product that promises 1 billion at the end of life must be packed with 10 billion. The overage must be stated in the maker records, and the end of shelf life count must be measured, not assumed, because the fall varies with the strain, the food, and the storage.

Choosing and using the three

For a food maker, the choice depends on the product. A chilled yoghurt or a fermented drink suits a probiotic, because the product is cold and the microbes stay alive. A dry powder, a bar, or a biscuit suits a prebiotic, because fibre is stable and survives baking. A heated soup, a hot drink, or a product for a hospital suits a postbiotic, because no live cells are needed. A product that claims a health benefit must name the strain or the fibre, state the dose per serving, and hold that dose to the end of shelf life.

For the eater, the advice is simpler. Eat fermented foods most days for probiotics: yoghurt, kefir, kimchi, and pickles. Eat a wide range of fibre rich plants for prebiotics: onions, garlic, oats, beans, and bananas. Do not chase postbiotics as a first step: they are a useful tool for special cases, but the live foods and the fibre come first. And remember that no single product fixes the gut: the whole diet, over months, is what shapes the community.

Three ways to help the gut: how they differ

Probiotic: live microbes eaten in a tested dose, such as Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG
↓
Prebiotic: fibre that feeds useful microbes, such as inulin from chicory root
↓
Postbiotic: dead microbes or their compounds, stable and safe where live cells cannot be used
↓
Synbiotic: a tested pair of probiotic plus prebiotic in one product

A worked example: reading a probiotic label

A yoghurt pot says it holds Bifidobacterium lactis BB-12, 10 billion CFU per pot, with a best before date 21 days away. To judge it, ask four questions. Is the strain named in full? Yes, BB-12 is a strain code. Is the dose tested? BB-12 has been tested at doses near 1 to 10 billion a day, so 10 billion fits. Does the count hold to the end of shelf life? The maker must test this and add overage if the count falls; ask for the shelf life count, not only the count on the day of making. Is the benefit named? If the pot claims better bowel regularity, that is a tested benefit for BB-12; if it claims to cure a disease, that is not a food claim and should not be on the pot. Four yes answers mean a sound product; a missing strain name or a missing dose means the claim cannot be checked.

Questions to think about

  • A yoghurt says it holds live cultures but names no strain and no dose. Is it a probiotic? Why or why not?
  • Why does a postbiotic suit a biscuit, while a probiotic does not?
  • A fibre powder claims to be a prebiotic. What three tests must it pass?
Think about the yoghurt question before you read on

Not necessarily. A probiotic must be a named strain, alive in a tested dose, that gives a shown benefit. A yoghurt with live cultures that names no strain and no dose may hold live bacteria, but nobody can check whether the strain was tested or whether the dose matches the test. It is a fermented food, which is still useful, but it is not a proven probiotic until the strain and dose are named.

Practical note: When you buy a probiotic yoghurt, keep it chilled from the shop to your fridge, and eat it before the best before date. Heat and time kill live microbes, so a pot left warm in a car or eaten weeks past its date may hold far fewer live cells than the label promises. The fridge is part of the dose.

Quick self-check

Question: What is the difference between a probiotic and a prebiotic?

A probiotic is a live microbe that gives a health benefit when eaten in enough amount. A prebiotic is a food ingredient, usually a fibre, that feeds useful gut microbes and gives a health benefit. One is alive, the other is food for microbes.

Question: Why must a probiotic be named by strain, not only by species?

Because two strains of the same species can behave differently. One strain may have been tested for a benefit while another has not, so the strain code, such as GG or BB-12, is the key to checking the evidence.

Question: What is a postbiotic, and what is its main advantage?

A postbiotic is a preparation of dead microbes, or of the compounds microbes make, that gives a health benefit. Its main advantage is stability: it needs no chilling, survives heat, and is safe where live microbes cannot be used, such as in a baked food or for a person with a weak immune system.

Try it yourself

Go to a shop and find three gut health products: a yoghurt, a fibre powder or bar, and a drink or supplement. For each, write down the claim on the front, the strain name or fibre name on the back, the dose per serving, and the storage instruction. Then judge each one with the four questions from the worked example: strain or fibre named, dose stated, dose held to shelf life, benefit named and plausible. Write one line for each product saying whether its claim can be checked from the label alone. You will find that many products fail the check, and that the ones that pass it are the ones worth buying.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A probiotic is a live microbe in a tested dose that gives a shown benefit; a prebiotic is a fibre that feeds useful microbes; a postbiotic is dead microbes or their compounds that give a benefit.
  • A probiotic must be named by strain, alive at a tested dose, able to survive to the gut, and shown to help in human studies.
  • Most probiotics pass through in days and must be eaten regularly; they are visitors, not permanent residents.
  • Inulin, fructo-oligosaccharides, and galacto-oligosaccharides are the best known prebiotics, and ordinary foods such as onion, garlic, oats, and beans also feed gut bacteria.
  • Postbiotics are stable, survive heat, and suit foods and people where live microbes cannot be used.
  • A synbiotic is a tested pair of probiotic plus prebiotic in one product.
  • Judge a gut health product by strain or fibre name, dose per serving, dose at end of shelf life, and the named benefit.

Glossary

Probiotic

A live microbe that gives a health benefit when eaten in enough amount. Food tech example: Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG in a yoghurt is a probiotic tested for gut health.

Prebiotic

A food ingredient, usually a fibre, that feeds useful gut microbes and gives a health benefit. Food tech example: inulin from chicory root is a prebiotic added to yoghurt and bars.

Postbiotic

A preparation of dead microbes, or of the compounds microbes make, that gives a health benefit. Food tech example: heat killed bacteria in a biscuit are a postbiotic, because live cells would die in baking.

Synbiotic

A product that holds a probiotic and a prebiotic together as a tested pair. Food tech example: a yoghurt with BB-12 plus inulin is a synbiotic.

Colony forming unit

A count of live microbes, written as CFU, used to state a probiotic dose. Food tech example: a yoghurt with 10 billion CFU per pot holds 10 billion live cells.

Strain

A single named line of a microbial species, such as GG or BB-12, with its own tested effects. Food tech example: Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG is a strain, and its effects were tested for that strain alone.

Inulin

A fibre from chicory root and other plants, made of fructose chains, that feeds Bifidobacterium. Food tech example: inulin is added to yoghurt and bars as a prebiotic fibre.

Fructo-oligosaccharide

A short chain fibre of fructose units that feeds useful gut bacteria. Food tech example: fructo-oligosaccharides are added to infant formula and to fibre powders.

Galacto-oligosaccharide

A short chain fibre of galactose units, made from lactose, that feeds Bifidobacterium. Food tech example: galacto-oligosaccharides are added to infant formula to mimic human milk sugars.

Bacteriocin

A natural compound made by bacteria that kills closely related bacteria. Food tech example: lactic acid bacteria make bacteriocins that slow harmful bacteria in fermented foods.

Lactic acid

The acid made when lactic acid bacteria ferment sugar, which sets yoghurt and lowers pH. Food tech example: lactic acid in yoghurt gives its tang and stops harmful bacteria growing.

Saccharomyces boulardii

A probiotic yeast tested for diarrhoea linked to antibiotics. Food tech example: Saccharomyces boulardii is sold as a probiotic capsule for gut health after antibiotics.

Bifidobacterium

A group of gut bacteria that thrives on the sugars in human milk and on some fibres. Food tech example: Bifidobacterium lactis BB-12 is a probiotic strain used in yoghurt.

Lactobacillus

A group of lactic acid bacteria used in fermented foods and as probiotics. Food tech example: Lactobacillus species ferment milk into yoghurt and vegetables into pickles.

Log fall

A fall in a microbe count stated in powers of ten: a fall of 1 log means the count drops to one tenth, and a fall of 2 logs means it drops to one hundredth. Food tech example: a probiotic that falls by 1 log over its shelf life must be packed with 10 times the label count.

Colony forming unit

A live microbe counted by the colony it grows on a plate, the unit used to state a probiotic dose. Food tech example: a yoghurt label promises at least 1 billion colony forming units per serving at the end of shelf life.

References

  • Gibson, G. R. and Roberfroid, M. B., Handbook of Prebiotics, 2008.
  • Holzapfel, W. H. and Schillinger, U., Introduction to Pre and Probiotics, Food Research International, 2002.
  • FAO and WHO, Guidelines for the Evaluation of Probiotics in Food, 2002.
  • Salminen, S. and others, The International Scientific Association for Probiotics and Prebiotics Consensus Statement on the Definition and Scope of Postbiotics, Nature Reviews Gastroenterology and Hepatology, 2021.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.

Unit 3: Fibre: Types, Sources and Functions

Note

Unit 3: Fibre: Types, Sources and Functions

A question to start with

A slice of white bread, a slice of wholemeal bread, and a bowl of oats all hold starch, but the oats keep a person full for far longer, and the wholemeal bread sits between the two. The difference is fibre: the part of the plant that human enzymes cannot digest, but gut microbes can. This unit explains the types of fibre, where each type is found, and what each one does in the gut and in the body.

Fibre is the part of plant food that resists digestion in the small intestine. It is made of carbohydrate chains that human enzymes cannot break, because the links between the sugar units are of a kind the enzymes do not cut. The chains pass into the large intestine, where gut bacteria ferment some of them and the rest adds bulk to the stool. Fibre is not one thing: it is a family of compounds with different shapes, different solubility, and different jobs.

Soluble and insoluble fibre

The first split is between soluble fibre and insoluble fibre. Soluble fibre dissolves in water and forms a gel. It is fermented by gut bacteria and it slows digestion. Insoluble fibre does not dissolve in water. It adds bulk, speeds the passage of food through the gut, and is fermented little or not at all.

Soluble fibre is found in oats, barley, beans, lentils, apples, pears, citrus fruit, and psyllium husk. The best known soluble fibre is beta-glucan, found in oats and barley. When beta-glucan dissolves, it forms a thick gel that slows the emptying of the stomach and slows the absorption of sugar, so blood sugar rises more slowly after a meal. The gel also binds bile acids in the gut, and the liver uses cholesterol to make new bile acids, which lowers blood cholesterol over time. A daily intake of about 3 g of beta-glucan from oats is linked to lower blood cholesterol, and a bowl of porridge gives about 2 g.

Insoluble fibre is found in wheat bran, the skins of fruit and vegetables, whole grains, and the outer layers of seeds. It is mostly cellulose and lignin, the tough parts of the plant cell wall. Insoluble fibre absorbs water and swells, which adds bulk to the stool and speeds its passage. A faster passage means less time for harmful compounds to sit against the gut wall, and a softer stool that is easier to pass. Wheat bran is the classic example: a spoon of bran in the morning raises stool bulk clearly within a day or two.

Most plant foods hold both types. An apple holds soluble pectin in the flesh and insoluble fibre in the skin. A bean holds soluble fibre that gut bacteria ferment, which causes gas, and insoluble fibre that adds bulk. A diet that gives both types is better than a diet that gives only one, because the two types do different jobs.

Fermentable fibre and resistant starch

A second split is by how much the gut bacteria ferment the fibre. Fermentable fibres are broken down fast by bacteria and make short chain fatty acids and gas. Inulin, fructo-oligosaccharides, pectin, and beta-glucan are fermentable. Non fermentable fibres, such as cellulose and lignin, pass through largely unchanged and add bulk without making much gas.

Resistant starch is a special case. It is starch that resists digestion in the small intestine, so it behaves like fibre. It is found in green bananas, cooked and cooled potatoes and rice, raw oats, and legumes. When rice or potatoes are cooked and then cooled, some of the starch turns into a crystal form that enzymes cannot break, and it reaches the large intestine, where bacteria ferment it into butyrate. A cold potato salad therefore feeds the gut differently from a hot potato, even though the starch is the same. Resistant starch is one of the most useful fibres, because it makes butyrate and causes less gas than some other fermentable fibres.

How much fibre, and what happens without enough

The usual guidance for adults is about 25 to 30 g of fibre a day, and many adults eat far less, often 15 g or less. A day that reaches 30 g looks like this: a bowl of porridge with berries, about 6 g; two slices of wholemeal bread, about 6 g; a serving of lentils, about 8 g; an apple, about 4 g; and a serving of vegetables, about 5 g. The total is about 29 g. A day of white bread, white rice, meat, and cheese may give only 10 g, and the gut misses the rest.

Too little fibre has clear effects. Stools become hard and slow, constipation follows, and the gut bacteria that ferment fibre shrink, so short chain fatty acid production falls. Over years, a low fibre diet is linked to a higher chance of bowel problems, including diverticular disease, where small pouches form in the gut wall, and to higher blood cholesterol and less steady blood sugar. The link is not from one meal, it is from years of a narrow diet.

Too much fibre too fast also causes problems. Gas, bloating, and cramps follow when the bacteria are given more fermentable fibre than they can handle at once. The fix is to raise fibre slowly over two weeks, to drink water with it, and to spread it across meals rather than eating it all at once. A person who adds a large bowl of beans on the first day will feel worse, not better, and may give up. A person who adds a small serving each day for two weeks will feel the benefit without the discomfort.

Fibre in food products

Fibre is added to foods for three reasons: to raise the fibre claim on the label, to replace fat or sugar, and to improve texture. Inulin and chicory root fibre are added to bars, yoghurts, and drinks because they dissolve easily and taste mild. Wheat bran is added to bread and breakfast cereals. Psyllium husk is added to breads and drinks because it forms a strong gel and holds water. Resistant starch is added to baked goods to raise fibre without changing taste much.

Each added fibre behaves differently. Inulin is sweet and mild, but a large dose causes gas. Wheat bran is gritty and darkens a loaf. Psyllium is very thick and must be dosed carefully, or the drink turns to jelly. A food technologist who adds fibre must test the texture, the taste, and the gas effect, and must state the fibre per serving on the label. A claim of high fibre or source of fibre follows a rule: the product must hold a set amount per 100 g or per serving, and the rule differs by market.

A worked example shows the label maths. A bar holds 3 g of inulin and 2 g of oat fibre per 60 g bar, a total of 5 g of fibre per bar. Per 100 g, that is 5 divided by 60, times 100, which is about 8.3 g of fibre per 100 g. In many markets, a food with more than 6 g of fibre per 100 g can claim high fibre, so this bar qualifies. But the claim is only honest if the fibre is measured by an accepted method and the amount holds to the end of shelf life, which it does for fibre, because fibre does not decay like a vitamin.

What happens to fibre in the gut

Step 1: Fibre is eaten in oats, beans, fruit, and vegetables
↓
Step 2: Human enzymes cannot break it, so it passes to the large intestine
↓
Step 3: Soluble fibre forms a gel, slows sugar absorption, and binds bile acids
↓
Step 4: Bacteria ferment soluble fibre into short chain fatty acids, including butyrate
↓
Step 5: Insoluble fibre adds bulk, holds water, and speeds the stool along

Fibre and blood sugar, cholesterol, and weight

Fibre helps blood sugar in two ways. Soluble fibre forms a gel that slows the emptying of the stomach and slows the contact between starch and enzymes, so sugar enters the blood slowly. A meal with oats or beans gives a lower, longer rise in blood sugar than a meal with white bread and the same amount of starch. Over months, a high fibre diet improves blood sugar control.

Fibre helps cholesterol through the bile acid link. The liver makes bile acids from cholesterol and sends them into the gut to help digest fat. Soluble fibre binds some of those bile acids, and they leave the body in the stool. The liver then uses more cholesterol to make new bile acids, and blood cholesterol falls. The effect is modest but real, and it is strongest for beta-glucan from oats and barley.

Fibre helps weight by adding bulk without energy. A food with fibre fills the stomach and slows eating, so a person feels full on fewer calories. A bowl of porridge gives about 150 kcal and keeps a person full for hours, while a pastry with the same energy leaves them hungry soon after. The difference is fibre and water, not willpower.

Dietary patterns: the whole diet, not one fibre

So far this unit has looked at fibres one by one. In real life nobody eats a single fibre: people eat a pattern, a whole way of eating that repeats day after day, and the pattern shapes the microbiome more than any single fibre does. Four patterns show the range.

The first is the plant rich pattern: many vegetables, fruits, beans, lentils, whole grains, nuts, and seeds, with fermented foods beside them. It supplies many different fibres at once, so many different microbes are fed, and the community stays diverse. Short chain fatty acid production is high, bowel movements are regular, and the gut lining is well fed. This pattern is the one most studies link to a healthy microbiome, and it is the pattern the other units in this subject point toward.

The second is the high fat, low fibre pattern: much fried food, much meat, much sugar, and few vegetables or whole grains. It starves the fibre fermenters, so short chain fatty acid production falls, and the community grows less diverse. Bile tolerant microbes grow, because a high fat diet sends more bile into the gut, and the gut lining gets less butyrate. The pattern is linked to slower digestion, more inflammation, and a weaker barrier. The change can be seen within days of switching to the pattern, and it can be reversed within days of switching back, though the full diversity takes longer to return.

The third is the vegetarian and vegan pattern. It is usually rich in fibre and in varied plant foods, so it supports a diverse community and high short chain fatty acid production, much like the plant rich pattern. Its watch point is not the microbiome but the nutrients that plant diets can lack, such as vitamin B12, which must come from fortified foods or a supplement. The microbiome of a vegetarian is not better or worse by label: it is better or worse by how many different plant foods are eaten, and a vegetarian diet of white bread and fried snacks feeds the gut no better than any other low fibre diet.

The fourth is the fermented food rich pattern: a diet where fermented foods appear every day, such as yoghurt, kefir, kimchi, or sourdough, beside a varied plant diet. Studies find that adding fermented foods daily raises the diversity of the microbiome and lowers markers of inflammation, even when the fibre intake does not change. The effect is thought to come from the live microbes and their products, which add new members to the community and calm the immune system. The lesson is that fermented foods add something fibre alone does not, and fibre adds something fermented foods alone do not: the two work together.

A worked example shows how a pattern change is read. A person eats 15 g of fibre a day and wants to reach 30 g, the amount many guides suggest as a daily target. The gap is 30 minus 15, which is 15 g. A bowl of porridge adds about 4 g, a cup of beans adds about 10 g, and an apple adds about 4 g, which together add 18 g and close the gap. The change should be made over two weeks, not in one day, because a sudden rise in fibre feeds the fermenters fast and makes gas and bloating. The pattern, not the single food, is what the gut feels, and the pattern is what the maker should design for.

Fibre analysis: how it is measured

Fibre is measured by the AOAC method, which mimics digestion in a laboratory. The sample is treated with enzymes that digest starch and protein, the undigested residue is weighed, and the result is reported as total dietary fibre. The method is split into soluble and insoluble fibre by filtering: the part that dissolves is soluble, the part that stays on the filter is insoluble. The method is slow and needs care, because resistant starch and some fibres are hard to measure, and the result depends on the exact steps. A food technologist who reads a fibre result should check the method, because two methods can give different numbers for the same food.

Questions to think about

  • Why does a bowl of porridge keep a person full longer than white bread with the same energy?
  • A cold potato salad feeds the gut differently from a hot potato. Why?
  • Why should fibre be raised slowly over two weeks rather than all at once?
Think about the porridge question before you read on

Oats hold soluble fibre, mainly beta-glucan, which forms a gel in the stomach. The gel slows emptying and slows sugar absorption, so the meal gives a slow, steady supply of energy. White bread holds almost no fibre, so it empties fast and sugar rises fast and falls fast, leaving the person hungry again. The difference is the fibre gel, not the calories.

Practical note: When you cook rice or potatoes, cook extra and cool it in the fridge overnight. The cooling turns some starch into resistant starch, which feeds gut bacteria and makes butyrate. Reheating the rice or potatoes does not remove all the resistant starch, so a reheated portion still gives more resistant starch than a freshly cooked one. It is a free way to add fibre without changing the recipe.

Quick self-check

Question: What is the difference between soluble and insoluble fibre?

Soluble fibre dissolves in water and forms a gel, is fermented by gut bacteria, and slows digestion. Insoluble fibre does not dissolve, adds bulk to the stool, and speeds its passage. Most plant foods hold both types.

Question: What is resistant starch, and where is it found?

Resistant starch is starch that resists digestion in the small intestine and behaves like fibre. It is found in green bananas, raw oats, legumes, and cooked and cooled potatoes and rice, where cooling turns some starch into a crystal form enzymes cannot break.

Question: How does soluble fibre lower blood cholesterol?

Soluble fibre binds bile acids in the gut, and they leave the body in the stool. The liver then uses cholesterol to make new bile acids, and blood cholesterol falls over time.

Fibre and the gut lining: a closer look

The gut lining is one cell thick, and fibre helps hold it together in three ways. First, the butyrate made from fermentable fibre is the main fuel of the lining cells, and a steady supply keeps them strong and joined tightly. A lining fed with butyrate repairs itself faster when it is damaged. Second, the gel formed by soluble fibre coats the gut wall gently and slows the contact between food and the wall, so the lining is not scratched by hard, dry food. Third, the bulk of insoluble fibre keeps the stool soft and moving, so the lining is not pressed by a hard stool sitting in one place.

When fibre is very low for a long time, the microbes run short of fibre to ferment, and some of them turn to the mucus layer that coats the gut lining. The mucus layer is the slippery coat that protects the lining cells, and it is made of proteins and sugars that microbes can eat when nothing else is available. A thin mucus layer leaves the lining cells closer to the microbes and to food, and the barrier weakens. This is one of the clearest reasons to keep fibre in the diet every day: the microbes need fibre, and when they do not get it, they eat the protection instead. The effect is slow and quiet, which is why it is missed: nobody feels a thin mucus layer, but the barrier is weaker all the same.

Children and older people need fibre too, in amounts suited to their size. A child who eats fruit, vegetables, and whole grains gets fibre without needing a supplement. An older person who eats less may need soft fibre foods: cooked oats, stewed fruit, lentil soup, and soft cooked vegetables give fibre without hard chewing. The form matters as much as the amount: a fibre food that a person will actually eat is worth more than a fibre powder that sits in the cupboard.

Try it yourself

Write down everything you ate yesterday and estimate the fibre in each food from a food composition table or a trusted nutrition source. Add the day's total and compare it with the target of 25 to 30 g. Then plan one change for tomorrow that adds 5 g of fibre without changing the meal much: swap white bread for wholemeal, add a spoon of oats to breakfast, or add a handful of beans to a soup. Write down the change and the fibre it adds. Repeat the check for three days, adding one small change each day, and see how close you get to 30 g without any discomfort.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Fibre is the part of plant food that resists digestion in the small intestine and is fermented or passed through in the large intestine.
  • Soluble fibre forms a gel, slows sugar absorption, and binds bile acids; insoluble fibre adds bulk and speeds the stool.
  • Beta-glucan from oats and barley is the best studied soluble fibre for blood cholesterol.
  • Resistant starch behaves like fibre and is found in cooled rice and potatoes, green bananas, and legumes.
  • Adults need about 25 to 30 g of fibre a day, and most eat far less.
  • Fibre should be raised slowly over two weeks, with water, to avoid gas and bloating.
  • Fibre helps blood sugar, cholesterol, and weight by slowing digestion and adding bulk without energy.

Glossary

Soluble fibre

Fibre that dissolves in water and forms a gel, fermented by gut bacteria. Food tech example: beta-glucan in oats is a soluble fibre that slows sugar absorption.

Insoluble fibre

Fibre that does not dissolve in water and adds bulk to the stool. Food tech example: wheat bran is an insoluble fibre that speeds the passage of food through the gut.

Beta-glucan

A soluble fibre from oats and barley that forms a gel and helps lower blood cholesterol. Food tech example: a bowl of porridge gives about 2 g of beta-glucan.

Resistant starch

Starch that resists digestion in the small intestine and behaves like fibre. Food tech example: cooked and cooled rice holds resistant starch that gut bacteria ferment into butyrate.

Pectin

A soluble fibre from fruit that forms a gel. Food tech example: pectin in apples slows digestion and is used to set jam.

Cellulose

An insoluble fibre that forms the walls of plant cells. Food tech example: the skin of an apple holds cellulose that adds bulk to the stool.

Lignin

A tough woody part of plant cell walls that resists fermentation. Food tech example: the bran layer of wheat holds lignin that passes through largely unchanged.

Psyllium husk

The husk of psyllium seed, rich in soluble fibre that forms a strong gel. Food tech example: psyllium husk is added to bread and drinks to raise fibre and hold water.

Diverticular disease

A condition where small pouches form in the wall of the large intestine, linked to a low fibre diet. Food tech example: a high fibre diet is linked to a lower chance of diverticular disease.

Bile acid

A compound made by the liver from cholesterol to help digest fat. Food tech example: soluble fibre binds bile acids, so the liver uses more cholesterol to make new ones.

Dietary fibre

The total of all fibre types in a food, measured by the AOAC method. Food tech example: a label states total dietary fibre per 100 g, split into soluble and insoluble where the maker chooses to show it.

Fermentable fibre

Fibre that gut bacteria break down into short chain fatty acids and gas. Food tech example: inulin is a fermentable fibre that feeds Bifidobacterium.

Wholemeal

Flour or bread made from the whole grain, including the bran and germ. Food tech example: wholemeal bread holds about three times the fibre of white bread.

Dietary pattern

A whole way of eating that repeats day after day, such as a plant rich pattern or a high fat low fibre pattern. Food tech example: a dietary pattern shapes the microbiome more than any single fibre does.

Bile tolerant microbe

A gut microbe that grows well when a high fat diet sends more bile into the gut. Food tech example: a high fat low fibre pattern lets bile tolerant microbes grow while fibre fermenters shrink.

References

  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Gibson, G. R. and Roberfroid, M. B., Handbook of Prebiotics, 2008.
  • Flint, H. J., Scott, K. P., Louis, P. and Duncan, S. H., The Role of the Gut Microbiota in Nutrition and Health, Nature Reviews Gastroenterology and Hepatology, 2012.
  • AOAC International, Official Methods of Analysis of AOAC International, 17th edition, 2000.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.

Unit 4: Fermented Foods: Yoghurt, Kefir, Kimchi, Pickles and Bread

Note

Unit 4: Fermented Foods: Yoghurt, Kefir, Kimchi, Pickles and Bread

A question to start with

Milk left on a warm bench turns sour and most people throw it away. Milk with a spoon of yoghurt stirred in and kept warm turns into yoghurt, and people pay for it. Cabbage left in a jar turns soft and sour, and it becomes kimchi, a food people prize. The difference between spoilage and fermentation is control: the same microbes that can ruin food can also make it, when the right microbes are chosen and the conditions are set. This unit explains the main fermented foods, how each one is made, and what fermentation does to the food.

Fermentation is the breakdown of food by microbes without oxygen, which changes the food's flavour, texture, and keeping power. The microbes use sugars in the food and turn them into acids, gases, alcohol, and flavour compounds. The acid is the key: as the pH falls, harmful bacteria grow slowly or stop, so the food keeps longer than the raw material. Fermentation is one of the oldest ways of keeping food, used long before chilling, and it is still used for foods that people eat every day.

Yoghurt: milk set by bacteria

Yoghurt is made by adding two bacteria to milk, Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus, and holding the milk warm, at about 40 to 45 °C, for four to six hours. The bacteria turn lactose, the sugar in milk, into lactic acid. The pH falls from about 6.6 to about 4.5, and at that pH the casein proteins lose their charge, clump together, and form a soft gel. The milk sets into yoghurt.

The two bacteria work as a team. Streptococcus grows first and makes acid fast, and it also makes compounds that help Lactobacillus grow. Lactobacillus makes more acid and more flavour, including acetaldehyde, the compound that gives yoghurt its fresh, green flavour. The balance between the two sets the taste: more Streptococcus gives a mild yoghurt, more Lactobacillus gives a tangy yoghurt.

Yoghurt is strained to make a thicker product. Straining drains away whey, the liquid part, and the protein becomes more concentrated: strained yoghurt holds about 10 g of protein per 100 g, against about 4 to 5 g in plain yoghurt. The whey that drains away is acid whey, and factories must find a use for it or dispose of it safely. Yoghurt is kept chilled, and its live cultures stay alive for weeks, which is why it is a probiotic food when the strains are named and tested.

Kefir: a drink with many microbes

Kefir is a fermented milk drink made with kefir grains, which are not grains at all but small jelly like lumps of bacteria and yeast held together in a matrix. The grains hold many species: Lactobacillus, Lactococcus, Leuconostoc, and yeasts such as Saccharomyces. The milk is mixed with the grains and kept at room temperature for about 24 hours. The bacteria make lactic acid, and the yeasts make a little alcohol and carbon dioxide, so kefir is fizzy, tangy, and thinner than yoghurt.

Kefir holds more kinds of microbes than yoghurt, and its flavour is sharper, with a yeasty note. It is drunk rather than eaten with a spoon. The grains are strained out after each batch and used again, so a household can keep the same grains for years. In a factory, the grains are hard to use at scale, so many factory kefirs are made with a selected culture of a few strains instead of true grains. The label should say which method was used, because the two products differ in microbial mix.

Kimchi and sauerkraut: vegetables set by salt

Kimchi is a Korean fermented vegetable, usually cabbage and radish with chilli, garlic, and ginger. Sauerkraut is fermented cabbage from Europe. Both are made the same way: the vegetable is salted, packed tight so that air is kept out, and left to ferment. The salt draws water out of the vegetable, and the lactic acid bacteria that live on the leaves grow in the salty water. They turn the sugars in the vegetable into lactic acid, and the pH falls to about 3.5 to 4.0. At that pH, the vegetable keeps for months without chilling, and it gains a sour, savoury flavour.

The salt level matters. Too little salt, below about 2 percent, lets harmful bacteria grow before the acid forms. Too much salt, above about 3 percent, slows the lactic acid bacteria and the vegetable stays raw. The usual level is about 2 to 2.5 percent salt by weight of vegetable. The temperature matters too: a warm room ferments fast and gives a sour product in days, while a cool room ferments slowly and gives a milder product over weeks. Kimchi is often eaten young and crisp, while sauerkraut is often left to ferment longer and turn softer and more sour.

Both foods give fibre, vitamin C, and vitamin K, and they give live lactic acid bacteria when eaten raw. Cooking kills the live bacteria, so kimchi in a hot stew gives flavour and fibre but no live microbes. The salt is the drawback: a serving of kimchi can hold a large share of the day's salt, so it is eaten in small amounts as a side dish, not as a main food.

Pickles: vinegar and brine

The word pickle covers two different foods. A fermented pickle is made by salt and lactic acid bacteria, like kimchi, and it holds live microbes. A vinegar pickle is made by soaking the vegetable in vinegar, and it holds no live microbes. The two look alike in a jar, but they are different foods. A label that says pickled cucumber may mean either, so the ingredients list tells the truth: if it lists vinegar, it is a vinegar pickle; if it lists only salt and spices, it is likely fermented.

Fermented pickles need the same care as kimchi: enough salt, no air, and time. The brine must cover the vegetables, because any piece that sticks out of the brine can grow mould. A weight or a clean stone holds the vegetables down. The jar is kept at room temperature for a week or two, then moved to a cool place. The pickles turn sour, crisp, and cloudy, and the cloudiness is the bacteria, not a fault.

Bread: fermentation that makes it rise

Bread is a fermented food too, though people rarely think of it that way. Yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, ferments the sugars in the dough and makes carbon dioxide and alcohol. The gas is trapped by the gluten network in the dough, and the dough rises. The alcohol evaporates in baking. The flavour of bread comes from fermentation: the yeast makes flavour compounds, and in sourdough, lactic acid bacteria join the yeast and make acids that give the tang.

Sourdough is made with a starter, a mix of flour and water that holds wild yeast and lactic acid bacteria. The starter is fed daily with flour and water, and a spoon of it is mixed into each new dough. The dough ferments slowly, for hours, and the bacteria make lactic acid and acetic acid, which give the sour taste and which also lower phytate, freeing minerals. Sourdough keeps longer than yeast bread, because the acid slows mould. A long, slow fermentation gives more flavour and a better crumb than a fast one, which is why good bread takes time.

What fermentation does to nutrition

Fermentation changes a food in four useful ways. It makes the food keep longer, because acid stops harmful bacteria. It makes the food easier to digest, because microbes break down sugars and proteins before eating: lactose falls in yoghurt, so people who struggle with milk often manage yoghurt, and the trypsin inhibitors in soy fall when soy is fermented into tempeh. It makes new nutrients: some bacteria make B vitamins and vitamin K during fermentation. And it makes new flavours, from mild and creamy in yoghurt to sharp and savoury in kimchi.

Fermentation also removes some anti-nutritional factors. Phytate falls during sourdough fermentation, so minerals become more available. The sugars that cause gas in beans, the oligosaccharides, fall when beans are fermented. But fermentation does not remove everything, and it adds salt in vegetable ferments, so the net effect depends on the food and the recipe.

How yoghurt is made

Step 1: Heat the milk to kill unwanted microbes and denature whey protein
↓
Step 2: Cool to 40 to 45 °C and add the starter culture
↓
Step 3: Hold warm for 4 to 6 hours while bacteria make lactic acid
↓
Step 4: pH falls to about 4.5 and casein sets into a soft gel
↓
Step 5: Cool, pack, and keep chilled to hold the live cultures

A worked example: salt in kimchi

A recipe uses 1 kg of cabbage. The salt level should be about 2 percent by weight, which is 20 g of salt. The cabbage is mixed with the salt and left until water draws out, then packed tight with chilli, garlic, and ginger. If only 10 g of salt is used, the level is 1 percent, and harmful bacteria may grow before the acid forms. If 40 g is used, the level is 4 percent, and the lactic acid bacteria grow slowly, so the kimchi stays raw and too salty. The 20 g figure is not a guess: it is the level that lets the right bacteria win the race against the wrong ones.

Questions to think about

  • Why does milk with a spoon of yoghurt turn into yoghurt, while plain milk left warm turns sour and unsafe?
  • A jar of pickles lists vinegar in the ingredients. Does it hold live microbes? Why or why not?
  • Why does sourdough bread keep longer than bread made with fast yeast alone?
Think about the milk question before you read on

The spoon of yoghurt adds a large number of the right bacteria, Streptococcus and Lactobacillus, which make lactic acid fast and lower the pH to about 4.5 before harmful bacteria can grow. Plain milk left warm holds only the few microbes that were already there, and harmful bacteria can grow as fast as useful ones, so the milk sours in an uncontrolled way and may not be safe. Fermentation is controlled growth of chosen microbes; spoilage is uncontrolled growth of whatever is there.

Practical note: When you ferment vegetables at home, keep them under the brine at all times. Any piece that sticks out of the brine is open to air and can grow mould. Use a clean weight, a small jar filled with water, or a folded cabbage leaf to hold the vegetables down, and check the jar daily for the first week. A white film on the surface is often harmless yeast and can be skimmed off; a fuzzy green or black growth means the batch should be thrown away.

Quick self-check

Question: What two bacteria make yoghurt, and what does each one do?

Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus. Streptococcus grows first and makes acid fast, and it makes compounds that help Lactobacillus grow. Lactobacillus makes more acid and more flavour, including acetaldehyde, which gives yoghurt its fresh flavour.

Question: Why is the salt level in kimchi set near 2 percent?

Below about 2 percent, harmful bacteria can grow before the acid forms. Above about 3 percent, the lactic acid bacteria grow slowly and the vegetable stays raw. Near 2 to 2.5 percent, the salt draws out water and lets the lactic acid bacteria win the race.

Question: How does sourdough lower phytate in bread?

The lactic acid bacteria in the starter make acid during the long slow fermentation, and the acid activates enzymes in the flour that break down phytate. The minerals bound by phytate are freed, so they can be absorbed.

Cheese: fermentation that makes a solid food

Cheese is the most complex fermented food in this unit, and it shows how far fermentation can go. Milk is first curdled, either by rennet, which cuts casein, or by acid, which sets casein into a gel. The curd is cut, stirred, and pressed to drain the whey, and salt is added. Then the cheese is left to ripen, and the microbes inside it go to work for weeks, months, or years.

Ripening is a slow fermentation. The lactic acid bacteria in the curd keep making acid, and other microbes join them: moulds on the surface of a Brie, bacteria that make the holes in a Swiss cheese, and yeasts that give a washed rind its smell. The microbes break down protein into peptides and amino acids, which give flavour, and they break down fat into fatty acids, which give aroma. A fresh cheese tastes mild and milky, because little breakdown has happened. An aged cheese tastes sharp, nutty, and strong, because months of microbial work have built flavour.

The salt in cheese does three jobs: it stops harmful bacteria, it draws out whey, and it controls the microbes that ripen the cheese. Too little salt and the cheese ripens too fast and turns bitter; too much salt and the microbes grow slowly and the cheese stays bland. The temperature and humidity of the ripening room matter too: a cool, damp room gives a slow, even ripening, while a warm, dry room gives a fast, uneven one. A cheese maker watches the rind, the smell, and the taste, and turns the cheese regularly so that it ripens evenly on all sides.

Cheese also shows that fermentation can change a food's nutrition. The lactose in milk is mostly gone by the time the cheese is ripened, because the bacteria turned it into lactic acid, so many people who struggle with milk manage hard cheese. The calcium stays, and the protein stays, concentrated by the draining of whey. The fat stays too, so cheese is a dense food, and it is eaten in small amounts. A 30 g serving of cheddar gives about 7 g of protein and about 200 mg of calcium, which is a useful share of the day's need in a small bite.

Try it yourself

Make a small jar of fermented carrots at home. Peel and cut two carrots into sticks, mix with 10 g of salt per 500 g of carrots, and pack them tight into a clean jar. Add water to cover, hold the carrots down with a clean weight, and cover the jar with a cloth. Keep it at room temperature for five days, tasting one stick each day from day three. Write down the taste each day: salty, then less salty, then sour. When the taste is pleasantly sour, move the jar to the fridge. You have made a fermented food, and you have watched the pH fall with your own tongue.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Fermentation is controlled breakdown of food by chosen microbes, and the acid they make keeps the food safe.
  • Yoghurt is set by two bacteria that turn lactose into lactic acid and set casein into a gel at pH about 4.5.
  • Kefir is made with grains holding many bacteria and yeasts, and it is fizzy, tangy, and thinner than yoghurt.
  • Kimchi and sauerkraut are made by salting vegetables at about 2 percent salt and letting lactic acid bacteria ferment them.
  • A vinegar pickle holds no live microbes, while a fermented pickle does: the ingredients list tells which it is.
  • Bread is fermented by yeast, and sourdough adds lactic acid bacteria that give tang and lower phytate.
  • Fermentation improves keeping, digestion, and flavour, and it frees minerals by lowering phytate.

Glossary

Fermentation

Breakdown of food by microbes without oxygen, making acids, gases, and flavour compounds. Food tech example: yoghurt bacteria ferment milk sugar into lactic acid.

Lactic acid bacteria

Bacteria that turn sugar into lactic acid, used in yoghurt, cheese, kimchi, and pickles. Food tech example: Lactobacillus species are lactic acid bacteria.

Starter culture

A chosen mix of microbes added to a food to start fermentation. Food tech example: a yoghurt starter holds Streptococcus and Lactobacillus.

Kefir grain

A jelly like lump of bacteria and yeast held in a matrix, used to make kefir. Food tech example: kefir grains are strained out after each batch and used again.

Kimchi

A Korean fermented vegetable, usually cabbage and radish with chilli, garlic, and ginger. Food tech example: kimchi is salted at about 2 percent and fermented by lactic acid bacteria.

Sauerkraut

Fermented cabbage made by salting and packing cabbage so lactic acid bacteria ferment it. Food tech example: sauerkraut keeps for months at pH about 3.5 to 4.0.

Sourdough

Bread made with a starter of wild yeast and lactic acid bacteria, fermented slowly for flavour and tang. Food tech example: sourdough keeps longer than fast yeast bread because its acid slows mould.

Acetaldehyde

A flavour compound made by yoghurt bacteria that gives yoghurt its fresh, green flavour. Food tech example: a yoghurt with a strong fresh flavour holds more acetaldehyde.

Brine

Salty water used to ferment vegetables and to keep them covered. Food tech example: pickles must stay under the brine, or mould can grow on the exposed pieces.

Tempeh

A food made by fermenting whole soybeans with a mould into a firm cake. Food tech example: fermentation lowers trypsin inhibitors in soy and makes tempeh easier to digest.

Phytate

The storage form of phosphorus in seeds and grains that binds minerals. Food tech example: sourdough fermentation lowers phytate and frees minerals in bread.

Lactose

The sugar in milk, turned into lactic acid by yoghurt bacteria. Food tech example: yoghurt holds less lactose than milk, so many people who struggle with milk manage yoghurt.

Streptococcus thermophilus

One of the two yoghurt bacteria, which grows first and makes acid fast. Food tech example: Streptococcus thermophilus is added to milk with Lactobacillus to make yoghurt.

Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The yeast used to ferment bread dough and to make beer and wine. Food tech example: Saccharomyces cerevisiae makes carbon dioxide that raises bread dough.

References

  • Tamang, J. P., Himalayan Fermented Foods: Microbiology, Nutrition, and Ethnic Values, 2010.
  • Holzapfel, W. H. and Schillinger, U., Introduction to Pre and Probiotics, Food Research International, 2002.
  • Steinkraus, K. H., Handbook of Indigenous Fermented Foods, 2nd edition, 1996.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.

Unit 5: Fermentation in Industry: Cultures, Control and Safety

Note

Unit 5: Fermentation in Industry: Cultures, Control and Safety

A question to start with

A small dairy makes yoghurt in a pot on a stove, and it works. A large dairy makes 10,000 pots a day, and it must work every day, with the same taste, the same thickness, and the same safety, even when the milk changes with the season. The difference between a kitchen ferment and a factory ferment is control: the culture, the temperature, the time, and the checks that catch a fault before the product leaves the factory. This unit explains how fermentation is run at scale.

An industrial fermentation starts with the culture. A culture is a chosen mix of microbes, grown in a laboratory and supplied to the factory as a frozen or freeze dried powder. The factory buys cultures from a culture supplier, who grows them under strict conditions and tests each batch for identity, purity, and activity. The culture is named by genus, species, and strain, and the supplier gives a data sheet that states the dose, the temperature range, the time to reach the target pH, and the flavour it gives.

Cultures are kept frozen at minus 40 °C or colder, or freeze dried in sealed pouches. A frozen culture is thawed and added straight to the milk or the vegetable brine, a method called direct vat inoculation. A freeze dried culture is also added straight to the vat. The old method of growing a bulk starter in the factory, a mother culture kept alive day after day, is still used in some small dairies, but large factories prefer direct vat inoculation, because it removes the risk of a starter going wrong and it gives the same dose every time.

The fermentation: temperature, time, and pH

The three numbers that control a fermentation are temperature, time, and pH. Temperature sets the speed: yoghurt bacteria grow fastest at about 40 to 45 °C, mesophilic cheese bacteria grow fastest at about 30 °C, and sauerkraut bacteria grow at room temperature, about 20 °C. A degree too hot or too cold changes the speed and the flavour. Time follows temperature: yoghurt takes four to six hours at 43 °C, but it takes twice as long at 37 °C. The pH is the target: the fermentation is stopped when the pH reaches the set point, about 4.5 for yoghurt, about 5.2 for many cheeses, and about 3.8 for sauerkraut.

The factory measures pH through the run. A pH probe in the vat, or a sample taken every hour, shows the acid curve: slow at first while the bacteria wake up, fast in the middle as they grow, and slow again as the acid builds. The shape of the curve is a fingerprint of the culture and the milk. If the curve is slower than usual, the milk may be weak, the culture may be old, or the temperature may be low. If the curve is faster than usual, the temperature may be high, or the culture dose may be too large. The operator watches the curve and acts before the batch is lost.

Cooling stops the fermentation. When the pH reaches the target, the product is cooled fast to below 5 °C, which slows the bacteria to almost nothing. A yoghurt that is not cooled keeps fermenting, turns too sour, and separates into curd and whey. Cooling is not a small step: it fixes the flavour and the texture, and it starts the shelf life.

Bacteriophage: the hidden enemy

The biggest threat to a factory fermentation is bacteriophage, a virus that attacks bacteria. A phage that attacks the starter culture can stop a fermentation in hours: the acid curve flattens, the milk stays liquid, and the batch is lost. Phages are everywhere: in raw milk, in the air, on equipment, and in whey. They are too small to see, and they cannot be removed by normal cleaning.

Factories fight phages in four ways. They rotate cultures, using a different strain each day, so that a phage that attacks one strain cannot attack the next. They use cultures that carry phage resistance, built into the strain by the supplier. They keep the factory clean and separate the culture handling area from the whey area, because whey is the main carrier of phages. And they test the milk and the whey for phages before use. A dairy that ignores phages will lose batches, and the losses come without warning, on a day when everything else looks right.

Hygiene, cleaning, and safety

A fermentation factory is a food factory, and it follows the same hygiene rules as any other, with one extra point: the factory wants the right microbes to grow and the wrong ones to stay out. The milk or the raw material is pasteurised before the culture is added, to kill the microbes that are already there. The equipment is cleaned and sanitised between batches, and the cleaning is checked, not assumed. The air in the culture room is filtered, and staff follow a one way flow, from clean areas to less clean areas, so that microbes are not carried back.

The safety risks in fermented foods are real but manageable. The main risk is a pathogen that grows before the acid forms. In cheese, Listeria can grow if the milk is contaminated and the acid is slow. In fermented sausage, Salmonella and Escherichia coli can survive if the fermentation is too slow or the salt is too low. The control is the same in every case: pasteurise the raw material where possible, add enough culture, keep the temperature right, reach the target pH fast, and check the pH of every batch. A batch that does not reach the target pH in the set time is held and tested, not sold.

Mould is a common fault in vegetable ferments. Mould grows on the surface where air meets the brine, and it can give off flavours and, in rare cases, toxins. The control is to keep the vegetables under the brine, to keep the container covered, and to remove any mould at once. A batch with heavy mould is thrown away, not scraped clean and sold, because the mould may have grown into the food.

Quality checks and shelf life

A fermented product is checked in four ways. The pH is measured, to confirm the fermentation reached its target. The microbes are counted, to confirm the live culture is present at the claimed level. The texture and flavour are checked by a panel, to confirm the product tastes as it should. And the product is tested for pathogens, to confirm it is safe.

Shelf life is set by the slowest change that matters. For yoghurt, the live count falls slowly, the acidity rises slowly, and the texture may separate. The shelf life, often 21 to 30 days chilled, is the time during which all three stay within the set limits. For kimchi, the acidity keeps rising, so the flavour changes from mild to sour over weeks, and the shelf life is set by the flavour the buyer expects. For cheese, the shelf life is set by ripening: the cheese changes as it ages, and the maker chooses the age at which it is sold.

A worked example shows the pH check. A yoghurt vat is set to stop at pH 4.5. At hour four, the pH is 4.7, and the operator expects it to reach 4.5 in one more hour. At hour five, the pH is still 4.6. The operator checks the temperature, finds it is 39 °C instead of 43 °C, and raises it. At hour six, the pH reaches 4.5, and the vat is cooled. The batch took an hour longer than usual, but it was saved, because the pH curve was watched and the fault was found in time. A vat that is not watched is a vat that is lost.

How a factory fermentation is controlled

Step 1: Pasteurise the milk or raw material to kill unwanted microbes
↓
Step 2: Add the culture at the set dose, direct vat inoculation
↓
Step 3: Hold at the set temperature and watch the pH curve
↓
Step 4: Cool fast when the target pH is reached
↓
Step 5: Test pH, live count, flavour, and safety before release

Scaling up: from pot to plant

Scaling a fermentation from a kitchen pot to a factory vat changes three things. Heat moves slower in a large vat, so the milk takes longer to warm and longer to cool, and the bacteria experience a different temperature history. Mixing matters more: a large vat must be stirred gently so that the temperature and the culture are even, but stirring too hard breaks the curd. And the time to fill and empty the vat matters: a vat that takes an hour to fill has milk at the bottom that started fermenting an hour before the milk at the top, so the batch is uneven.

The maker handles this by testing at each scale: a laboratory batch, a pilot batch, and then the full vat. The pH curve is compared at each scale, and the dose, temperature, and time are adjusted until the curves match. A recipe that works in a pot and fails in a vat has usually failed on heating, cooling, or mixing, not on the culture. The culture is the same; the vessel is different.

Questions to think about

  • A yoghurt vat is slow to reach pH 4.5. Name three things you would check, and in what order.
  • Why do factories rotate starter cultures from day to day?
  • A batch of fermented sausage does not reach its target pH in the set time. Why must it be held and tested, not sold?
Think about the slow vat question before you read on

Check the temperature first, because a few degrees low slows the bacteria sharply. Check the culture dose and age next, because an old or under dosed culture grows slowly. Check the milk third, because milk with antibiotic residues or with a high somatic cell count can slow the culture. The pH curve tells you the fermentation is slow; the three checks tell you why.

Practical note: When you make yoghurt at home, use a thermometer, not your finger, to check the milk temperature before adding the culture. Milk hotter than 48 °C kills the starter bacteria, and milk cooler than 38 °C makes them grow too slowly. The range of 40 to 45 °C is narrow, and the thermometer is what keeps you inside it.

Quick self-check

Question: What is bacteriophage, and why is it the biggest threat to a factory fermentation?

Bacteriophage is a virus that attacks bacteria. A phage that attacks the starter culture can stop a fermentation in hours, the acid curve flattens, the milk stays liquid, and the batch is lost. Phages are everywhere and cannot be removed by normal cleaning, so factories rotate cultures and use phage resistant strains.

Question: Why is cooling a yoghurt fast important?

Cooling stops the fermentation. Without fast cooling, the bacteria keep making acid, the yoghurt turns too sour, and the curd separates into curd and whey. Cooling fixes the flavour and texture and starts the shelf life.

Question: What is direct vat inoculation?

Adding a frozen or freeze dried culture straight to the vat, without growing a bulk starter in the factory. It gives the same dose every time and removes the risk of a starter going wrong in the factory.

Fermented sausage: a worked example of control

Fermented sausage, such as salami, shows all the controls of this unit in one product. Minced meat is mixed with salt, about 2.5 to 3 percent, sugar, spices, and a starter culture of lactic acid bacteria. The mix is stuffed into casings and hung in a warm room at about 24 °C for two to three days. The bacteria ferment the sugar into lactic acid, and the pH falls from about 5.8 to about 4.8. The acid stops harmful bacteria, firms the meat, and gives the tangy flavour.

After the fast fermentation, the sausage is moved to a cool drying room at about 12 to 15 °C, where it hangs for weeks. Water leaves the sausage slowly, the weight falls by about 30 percent, and the flavour deepens as the meat's own enzymes and the microbes break down protein and fat. The salt, the acid, and the drying together make the sausage safe without cooking: the low pH, the low water, and the salt each stop bacteria, and the three together are a strong barrier.

The safety of the sausage is checked by pH and by weight loss. The pH must fall fast, within the first two days, because a slow fall lets harmful bacteria grow before the acid stops them. The weight loss must reach the target, because a sausage that is still wet in the middle can spoil. A batch that fails either check is held and tested, not sold. The maker also tests for Salmonella and Escherichia coli, and the factory is cleaned between batches to stop cross contamination. A salami made without a starter culture, with too little salt, or dried too fast on the outside while staying wet inside, is a risk, and the controls in this unit are what keep it safe.

Try it yourself

Make yoghurt at home and watch the pH curve with your tongue and a thermometer. Heat a litre of milk to 85 °C, cool it to 43 °C, stir in two spoonfuls of plain live yoghurt, and keep the pot warm for six hours. Taste a spoonful every hour from hour three: note the flavour changing from milky to tangy as the acid builds. Write down the time when the yoghurt first holds its shape on the spoon. That time is your fermentation time, and it will change if the room is cooler or the starter is older. You have just run the same check a factory runs, with a spoon instead of a pH probe.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Industrial cultures are named by strain, supplied frozen or freeze dried, and added straight to the vat.
  • Temperature, time, and pH control a fermentation, and the pH curve is watched through the run.
  • Cooling fast at the target pH stops the fermentation and fixes flavour and texture.
  • Bacteriophage can stop a fermentation in hours, and factories fight it by rotating cultures and using resistant strains.
  • Pasteurising the raw material, adding enough culture, and reaching the target pH fast are the main safety controls.
  • Shelf life is set by the slowest change that matters: live count, acidity, texture, or flavour.
  • Scaling up changes heating, cooling, and mixing, so the recipe is tested at each scale until the pH curves match.

Glossary

Starter culture

A chosen mix of microbes added to a food to start fermentation. Food tech example: a yoghurt starter holds Streptococcus and Lactobacillus.

Direct vat inoculation

Adding a frozen or freeze dried culture straight to the vat, without growing a bulk starter. Food tech example: a dairy adds direct vat culture to each yoghurt vat for a consistent dose.

Bacteriophage

A virus that attacks bacteria and can stop a fermentation. Food tech example: a phage that attacks a yoghurt starter makes the milk stay liquid.

Mesophilic culture

A culture that grows best at moderate temperature, about 20 to 35 °C. Food tech example: mesophilic cultures are used for cheddar and for sauerkraut.

Thermophilic culture

A culture that grows best at warm temperature, about 40 to 45 °C. Food tech example: yoghurt cultures are thermophilic.

Freeze dried culture

A culture dried by freezing and removing water, stored as a powder and added straight to the vat. Food tech example: freeze dried yoghurt culture is kept in a sealed pouch until use.

Acid curve

The graph of pH falling over time during a fermentation. Food tech example: a slow acid curve warns the operator that the culture or the temperature is wrong.

Listeria

A bacterium that can grow in chilled foods and cause serious illness. Food tech example: cheese makers test for Listeria because it can grow if the acid is slow.

Escherichia coli

A bacterium found in the gut, some strains of which cause food poisoning. Food tech example: fermented sausage makers test for Escherichia coli to confirm the fermentation reached its target pH.

Pasteurisation

Heating a food to kill harmful microbes without cooking it. Food tech example: milk is pasteurised before the yoghurt culture is added, so only the chosen bacteria grow.

Somatic cell count

A count of cells in milk that rises when the cow's udder is unwell, and which can slow a starter culture. Food tech example: milk with a high somatic cell count ferments slowly.

Acid whey

The liquid drained from strained yoghurt, holding water, lactose, and minerals. Food tech example: a strained yoghurt factory must find a use for its acid whey.

Pilot batch

A medium scale test batch made before full production, to check the recipe at a larger size. Food tech example: a new yoghurt is tested as a pilot batch before the first full vat.

References

  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.
  • Tamang, J. P., Himalayan Fermented Foods: Microbiology, Nutrition, and Ethnic Values, 2010.
  • Steinkraus, K. H., Handbook of Indigenous Fermented Foods, 2nd edition, 1996.
  • Holzapfel, W. H. and Schillinger, U., Introduction to Pre and Probiotics, Food Research International, 2002.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.

Unit 6: Gut Health Claims and Evidence: What Is Proven and What Is Not

Note

Unit 6: Gut Health Claims and Evidence: What Is Proven and What Is Not

A question to start with

A yoghurt pot says it supports digestive health. A fibre bar says it feeds good bacteria. A drink says it boosts immunity. All three use the language of science, but do they all rest on the same strength of evidence? They do not. Some gut health claims rest on many human trials, some rest on a handful of small studies, and some rest on a leap from a laboratory dish to a human body. This unit explains how to judge a claim, what the evidence actually supports, and where the honest answer is that nobody knows yet.

A health claim is a statement that a food or an ingredient helps health. Claims are judged by three questions. What exactly is the claim: does it name a benefit, such as better bowel regularity, or does it use vague words, such as supports wellness? What is the evidence: was it tested in people, in animals, or only in a laboratory dish? And how strong is the evidence: were the studies large, well run, and repeated by different teams, or was it one small study that has never been repeated? A claim that passes all three questions is strong. A claim that fails any of them is weak, even when it sounds scientific.

The ladder of evidence

Evidence comes in levels, and the level decides how much weight it carries. At the bottom is a laboratory study: bacteria grown in a dish, or a compound tested on cells. It shows what is possible, not what happens in a person. Above it is an animal study: a mouse or a rat fed the ingredient. It shows what happens in a living body, but a mouse gut is not a human gut, and a dose that works in a mouse may not work in a person. Above that is a human study, where people eat the food and a result is measured. Above that is a randomised controlled trial, where people are split by chance into a group that eats the food and a group that does not, and neither the people nor the researchers know who is in which group until the end. At the top is a systematic review, which gathers all the trials on one question and judges them together.

A claim that rests only on a laboratory study is weak. A claim that rests on one small human study is better, but it may be a chance finding. A claim that rests on several randomised trials that agree is strong. A claim that rests on a systematic review of many trials is strongest of all. When you read a gut health claim, ask where on this ladder the evidence sits. If the maker cannot say, the claim is not ready to be believed.

What is proven: bowel regularity and fibre

The best proven gut health benefit is also the simplest: fibre improves bowel regularity. Many trials, in many countries, show that raising fibre intake increases stool bulk, softens stools, and shortens the time food takes to pass through the gut. Wheat bran, psyllium, and mixed fibre all work, and the effect appears within days. This is the benefit behind the fibre claims on bread, cereals, and bars, and it is the one gut health claim that almost nobody disputes.

The evidence is strong because the measure is simple: stool weight, stool water, and transit time can all be measured directly, and the results repeat across studies. The dose is also clear: an extra 10 g of fibre a day raises stool weight by a useful amount, and the effect grows with the dose. The benefit is not glamorous, but it is real, and it is the foundation on which the rest of gut health stands.

What is proven: specific probiotic strains for specific problems

The second proven area is specific probiotic strains for specific problems. The key word is specific: the evidence belongs to a strain and a problem, not to probiotics in general. Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG has been tested in many trials for diarrhoea in children, and the trials show it shortens the illness by about a day. Saccharomyces boulardii has been tested for diarrhoea linked to antibiotics, and the trials show it lowers the chance of getting diarrhoea during a course. Bifidobacterium lactis BB-12 has been tested for bowel regularity, and the trials show a modest improvement.

These benefits are real, but they are narrow. A strain that helps diarrhoea may do nothing for bloating. A dose that works for one problem may not work for another. And the effect is modest: a day less of diarrhoea, a little more regular bowel habit, not a cure. A product that names the strain, the dose, and the problem it was tested for is making an honest claim. A product that says probiotics help digestion, without naming a strain or a problem, is borrowing the evidence of one strain to sell a different one.

What is partly proven: fermented foods and the microbiome

Fermented foods are widely eaten and widely praised, but the evidence for their effect on the microbiome is thinner than the praise suggests. A few trials show that eating fermented foods such as yoghurt, kimchi, and kefir raises the diversity of the gut microbiome and lowers markers of inflammation. One well known trial fed people fermented foods for ten weeks and found a rise in microbiome diversity and a fall in 19 markers of inflammation. That is a real result, but it is one trial, and it needs repeating in other groups and other places before it becomes a settled fact.

The gap is that most fermented foods have not been tested one by one. Yoghurt has been tested more than kimchi, kimchi more than sauerkraut, and many local fermented foods have never been tested at all. A food that has fed people for centuries is probably safe and probably useful, but probably is not proven. The honest statement is that fermented foods are a sensible part of a varied diet, and that the evidence for a specific benefit from a specific fermented food is still growing.

The same caution applies to the microbiome itself. Many studies link a diverse microbiome to better health, but most of them are observational: they watch people and note a link, without proving that the microbiome caused the health. A person with a diverse microbiome may also eat more vegetables, move more, and sleep better, and any of those could be the real cause. The link is real, but the cause is not settled, and a product that claims to fix the microbiome is claiming more than the evidence supports.

What is not proven: detox, immunity boosts, and cures

Several popular gut health claims have little or no evidence behind them. The idea that a food or a drink detoxes the gut is not supported: the liver and the kidneys already remove waste, and no food has been shown to detox the gut in a human trial. The idea that a probiotic boosts immunity in healthy people is weakly supported: some trials show fewer colds in people who take a probiotic, but the effect is small, it is not found in every trial, and it depends on the strain. The idea that a gut health product cures a disease, such as irritable bowel syndrome, eczema, or depression, is not supported for a food: those conditions need medical care, and a food that claims to cure them is making a medical claim it cannot support.

The gut brain link is a good example of a real idea that is often overstated. The gut and the brain do talk to each other, and microbes do make compounds that act on the brain. But no trial has shown that eating a probiotic yoghurt lifts mood or treats anxiety in a reliable way. The research is young, the trials are small, and the results are mixed. A product that says it supports mood through the gut is ahead of the evidence, and the buyer should know that.

How claims are regulated

Health claims on foods are controlled by rules, and the rules differ by market, but the principle is the same everywhere: a claim must be authorised, and the evidence must support it. A maker who wants to use a claim must submit the evidence to the authority, and the authority judges whether the trials are good enough. Claims that are authorised are listed, and a maker may use only those claims, with the exact wording the authority allows. A claim that is not authorised may not be used, even when the maker believes it is true.

This is why the same yoghurt can carry a claim in one market and not in another: the evidence was judged differently, or the maker applied in one market and not the other. It is also why many products use vague words, such as supports digestive health, instead of a precise claim: the vague words are harder to challenge, but they are also harder for the buyer to judge. A food technologist who writes a label should use an authorised claim with the authorised wording, or say nothing, rather than invent a claim that sounds scientific but has no authorisation behind it.

A worked example shows the judgement. A maker wants to claim that its oat bar lowers blood cholesterol. The evidence is that beta-glucan from oats, at 3 g a day, lowers blood cholesterol in trials. The bar holds 1 g of beta-glucan per serving. The claim fails, because the dose in the bar is below the tested dose, and a person would need to eat three bars a day to reach it. The maker has three honest choices: raise the beta-glucan to 3 g per serving, change the claim to a general fibre claim, or drop the claim. Using the claim at 1 g per serving would mislead the buyer, even though the ingredient is the right one.

The ladder of evidence for a gut health claim

Bottom: laboratory study. Shows what is possible, not what happens in a person
↓
Animal study. Shows what happens in a living body, but a mouse is not a person
↓
Human study. People eat the food and a result is measured
↓
Randomised controlled trial. People split by chance, neither side knows who got what
↓
Top: systematic review. All the trials on one question judged together

Reading a study: five questions to ask

When you read a study behind a claim, ask five questions. Who was studied: healthy people, or people with a disease, and how many? What was the dose: does it match the dose in the product? How long did the study run: days, weeks, or months? What was measured: a real outcome, such as days of diarrhoea, or a marker, such as a change in one bacterium? And who paid for the study: the maker, or an independent funder? A study paid for by the maker is not automatically wrong, but it needs independent repeating before it is trusted fully.

A marker is not an outcome. A study that shows a probiotic raises the count of one bacterium in the stool has shown a marker, not a benefit. The person may feel no different. A study that shows the same probiotic shortens diarrhoea by a day has shown an outcome, and the person feels the difference. The best studies measure outcomes, and a claim that rests only on a marker is a weak claim.

Questions to think about

  • A drink claims to detox the gut. Where on the ladder of evidence would the proof need to sit, and why is the claim weak?
  • A probiotic strain shortens diarrhoea in children. Does that prove it helps bloating in adults? Why or why not?
  • A bar holds 1 g of beta-glucan per serving and claims to lower blood cholesterol. What is wrong with the claim?
Think about the detox question before you read on

The proof would need to sit at the top of the ladder: randomised trials in people showing that the drink removes a harmful substance from the body or improves a real outcome. No such trials exist, because the liver and kidneys already remove waste, and no food has been shown to add to that in a trial. The claim rests on a laboratory idea, not on human evidence, so it is weak.

Practical note: When a sales sheet quotes a study, ask for the full paper, not only the summary. Read the methods: the number of people, the dose, the length, and what was measured. If the dose in the study is three times the dose in the product, the study does not support the product, however good the study is. The dose in the product is the dose that must have been tested.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is a systematic review stronger evidence than a single trial?

Because it gathers all the trials on one question and judges them together. A single trial may be a chance finding, or it may have used a dose or a group that does not match the product. A review shows whether the trials agree, and whether the effect holds across different people and settings.

Question: What is the difference between a marker and an outcome in a gut health study?

A marker is a measurement, such as a change in one bacterium in the stool, which may not change how the person feels. An outcome is a real result, such as fewer days of diarrhoea or more regular bowel habit, which the person feels. The best studies measure outcomes.

Question: Why is fibre and bowel regularity the strongest gut health claim?

Because many trials in many countries show the same result, the measure is direct, stool weight and transit time can be measured, and the dose is clear. The effect appears within days and repeats across studies, which is the mark of a strong claim.

Try it yourself

Find a gut health product in a shop or online and read its claim. Write down the claim word for word. Then search for the evidence: does the pack name a strain or an ingredient, a dose, and a study? If it names a study, look it up and ask the five questions: who was studied, what dose, how long, what was measured, and who paid? Write a short verdict in three lines: what the claim says, what the evidence is, and whether the evidence supports the claim at the dose on the pack. You will find that most products give you too little to judge, and that is itself a verdict.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Judge a claim by three questions: what is claimed, what is the evidence, and how strong is it?
  • Evidence runs from laboratory studies at the bottom to systematic reviews at the top, and only human trials can support a health claim.
  • Fibre and bowel regularity is the best proven gut health benefit, shown in many trials.
  • Specific probiotic strains help specific problems, such as Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG for diarrhoea in children, but the benefit is narrow and strain specific.
  • Fermented foods and microbiome diversity show promise, but the evidence is still thin and needs repeating.
  • Detox, immunity boosts, and cures are not supported by the evidence for foods.
  • A claim must be authorised, and the dose in the product must match the dose that was tested.

Glossary

Health claim

A statement that a food or an ingredient helps health. Food tech example: a claim that oat beta-glucan lowers blood cholesterol must be authorised and must match the tested dose.

Randomised controlled trial

A study where people are split by chance into a group that gets the food and a group that does not, and neither side knows who got what. Food tech example: a randomised trial of a probiotic for diarrhoea is the strongest single study.

Systematic review

A review that gathers all the trials on one question and judges them together. Food tech example: a systematic review of fibre trials confirms that fibre improves bowel regularity.

Observational study

A study that watches people and notes a link, without proving that one thing caused the other. Food tech example: a study linking a diverse microbiome to better health is observational until a trial proves the cause.

Marker

A measurement that may show a change in the body, such as a rise in one bacterium, without showing a benefit the person feels. Food tech example: a rise in Bifidobacterium in the stool is a marker, not proof of better health.

Outcome

A real result that a person feels, such as fewer days of diarrhoea. Food tech example: shortening diarrhoea by a day is an outcome, and it is stronger evidence than a marker.

Placebo

A dummy treatment with no active ingredient, used in a trial so that the effect of the real treatment can be measured. Food tech example: a probiotic trial compares the probiotic group with a placebo group.

Transit time

The time food takes to pass through the gut. Food tech example: fibre shortens transit time, so food spends less time in the gut.

Irritable bowel syndrome

A condition marked by gut pain, bloating, and changed bowel habit, which needs medical care. Food tech example: a food that claims to cure irritable bowel syndrome is making a medical claim it cannot support.

Authorised claim

A health claim that an authority has judged and allowed, with set wording. Food tech example: a maker may use only authorised claims on a label, with the exact wording allowed.

Inflammation marker

A substance in the blood that rises when the body is inflamed. Food tech example: a fermented food trial measured 19 markers of inflammation and found they fell.

Dose

The amount of an ingredient eaten, which must match the amount tested in trials. Food tech example: a probiotic tested at 10 billion CFU a day must be eaten at that dose to match the evidence.

References

  • FAO and WHO, Guidelines for the Evaluation of Probiotics in Food, 2002.
  • Gibson, G. R. and Roberfroid, M. B., Handbook of Prebiotics, 2008.
  • Flint, H. J., Scott, K. P., Louis, P. and Duncan, S. H., The Role of the Gut Microbiota in Nutrition and Health, Nature Reviews Gastroenterology and Hepatology, 2012.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Salminen, S. and others, The International Scientific Association for Probiotics and Prebiotics Consensus Statement on the Definition and Scope of Postbiotics, Nature Reviews Gastroenterology and Hepatology, 2021.

Unit 7: Fermented Foods at Home: Safe Practice

Note

Unit 7: Fermented Foods at Home: Safe Practice

A question to start with

A jar of home made sauerkraut sits on a kitchen bench, bubbling gently, smelling sharp and clean. A second jar sits beside it, with a fuzzy green growth on top and a smell that turns the stomach. Both jars started with the same cabbage and the same salt. One is food, the other is waste. The difference is a handful of simple rules: clean hands, clean jars, enough salt, no air, and knowing when to throw a batch away. This unit explains those rules, so that home fermentation is safe and repeatable.

Home fermentation is safe when it follows the same principles as factory fermentation: choose the right microbes, give them the conditions they need, keep the wrong microbes out, and check the result before eating. The home maker does not have a laboratory, a pH meter, or a culture supplier, but the same principles apply with simpler tools: salt, temperature, time, and the senses of sight, smell, and taste.

The four rules of safe home fermentation

Four rules cover most of home fermentation safety. First, start clean. Wash hands, wash the vegetables, and wash the jar and the weight in hot soapy water. The jar does not need to be sterile, but it must be clean, because dirt carries microbes that compete with the lactic acid bacteria.

Second, use enough salt. For vegetables, the salt level is about 2 to 2.5 percent by weight of the vegetable and water together. Weigh the salt, do not guess it: a spoonful can vary by half, and a batch with too little salt is the most common cause of a failed ferment. Use plain salt without iodine or anti-caking agents if you can, because iodine can slow the bacteria, though the effect is small. Sea salt and kosher salt both work.

Third, keep air out. Lactic acid bacteria grow without oxygen, while mould and many harmful bacteria need oxygen. Pack the vegetables tight, pour brine to cover them, and hold them down with a clean weight. Cover the jar with a cloth or a loose lid so that gas can escape but air and flies stay out. A jar that is open to the air will grow mould on the surface.

Fourth, keep the temperature right. Room temperature, about 18 to 22 °C, is right for most vegetable ferments. A warmer room ferments faster and can turn the food too sour too fast, while a cold room ferments slowly and the food may stay raw for weeks. A kitchen bench away from direct sun is the usual place. Once the food tastes sour enough, move the jar to the fridge, where the cold slows the bacteria and the flavour holds for weeks.

What a good ferment looks, smells, and tastes like

A good vegetable ferment bubbles in the first days, as the bacteria make carbon dioxide. The brine turns cloudy, which is the bacteria growing, not a fault. The smell turns from fresh to sharp and sour, like vinegar but softer. The taste turns from salty to sour, and the vegetable stays crisp. A white film on the surface is often a harmless yeast, called kahm yeast, which can be skimmed off. It looks flat and white, and it smells mildly yeasty.

A bad ferment looks and smells different. A fuzzy growth in green, black, pink, or orange is mould, and the batch should be thrown away. A smell of rotten eggs, putrid meat, or strong chemicals means the wrong bacteria grew, and the batch should be thrown away. A slimy texture, where the vegetables feel slippery and soft, means the batch went wrong, and it should be thrown away. The rule is plain: when in doubt, throw it out. A jar of cabbage costs little, and a stomach upset costs far more.

The most common fault is not mould but softness. Vegetables turn soft when the salt is too low, the temperature is too high, or the ferment is left too long at room temperature. Crispness is kept by using fresh firm vegetables, enough salt, and moving the jar to the fridge as soon as the taste is right. Tannin rich leaves, such as grape leaves or a tea bag, are sometimes added to pickles to keep them crisp, because tannins firm the vegetable tissue.

Yoghurt and kefir at home

Yoghurt at home needs a thermometer and a warm place. Heat the milk to 85 °C, which kills unwanted microbes and denatures the whey protein so the yoghurt sets firmly. Cool it to 43 °C, stir in two spoonfuls of plain live yoghurt per litre, and keep the pot warm for four to six hours. A warm oven with only the light on, a flask, or a yoghurt maker all work. Do not stir the pot while it sets, or the gel will break. Cool the yoghurt in the fridge, and keep a spoonful to start the next batch. After three or four batches, the culture weakens and the yoghurt turns thin or sour, so start again with a fresh pot of live yoghurt.

Kefir at home needs kefir grains, which are shared between makers or bought from a supplier. Add a spoon of grains to a jar of milk, cover with a cloth, and keep at room temperature for about 24 hours. Strain out the grains through a plastic sieve, not a metal one, because metal can harm the grains over time, and use the grains again in fresh milk. The kefir is ready when it is thick and tangy and the whey just starts to separate. If the kefir separates fully into curd and whey, it has fermented too long or too warm, and it will taste very sour. Use less time or fewer grains next time.

Milk for home yoghurt and kefir should be pasteurised milk from a shop. Raw milk carries a risk of harmful bacteria, and a home maker cannot test for them. The pasteurised milk is safe, and the starter culture will still work. If raw milk is used, it must be heated first, which makes it pasteurised in effect.

Sourdough at home

A sourdough starter is a jar of flour and water that holds wild yeast and lactic acid bacteria. To start one, mix 50 g of wholemeal flour with 50 g of water in a clean jar, cover with a cloth, and leave at room temperature. Each day, throw away half and add 50 g of flour and 50 g of water. After five to seven days, the starter should bubble, rise, and smell pleasantly sour. It is ready when it doubles in size within a few hours of feeding. A starter that smells of nail polish remover is hungry: feed it more often or with more flour.

A starter is kept by feeding it once a day if it lives on the bench, or once a week if it lives in the fridge. A fridge starter must be taken out the day before baking, fed, and left to warm and rise. The starter is a living thing, and it responds to the flour, the water, and the temperature of the kitchen. A starter made with wholemeal flour grows faster than one made with white flour, because wholemeal carries more microbes and more food for them. Tap water with chlorine can slow a new starter, so let the water stand overnight before using it, which lets the chlorine escape.

Sourdough bread at home follows a simple pattern: mix flour, water, salt, and a spoon of active starter, knead or fold the dough, leave it to rise for four to eight hours, shape it, leave it to rise again, and bake it hot. The long rise gives the bacteria time to make acid and flavour, and the acid lowers phytate and slows mould. A loaf that is baked too soon tastes bland and stales fast; a loaf that is given time tastes sour, keeps longer, and is easier to digest.

Safety of home ferments: what the science says

Home fermented vegetables are safe when the four rules are followed, because the salt and the acid together stop harmful bacteria. The pH of a finished ferment is about 3.5 to 4.0, and at that pH most harmful bacteria cannot grow. The risk comes when the salt is too low or the vegetables are exposed to air, because then the acid forms slowly and harmful bacteria have time to grow. That is why weighing the salt and keeping the vegetables under the brine are not small details: they are the safety steps.

Botulism is the risk people ask about most. Botulism is caused by Clostridium botulinum, a bacterium that grows without oxygen and makes a toxin. It grows in low acid foods, such as garlic in oil, where the pH stays above 4.6 and there is no salt or acid to stop it. It does not grow in a proper vegetable ferment, because the salt and the acid stop it: the pH falls below 4.6 fast, and the bacterium cannot grow in acid. But garlic in oil, vegetables in oil without acid, and low salt ferments are not safe at room temperature, and they must be kept in the fridge and eaten soon, or made with added acid. Never store garlic in oil at room temperature.

People with a weak immune system, pregnant women, and young children should take extra care with home ferments. They should eat ferments that are properly sour, with a clean smell and no mould, and they should avoid any batch that looks or smells wrong. Factory ferments are tested and are a safer choice for these groups, because the pH and the microbes are checked before sale.

Safe home fermentation in five steps

Step 1: Start clean. Wash hands, vegetables, jar, and weight
↓
Step 2: Weigh the salt. About 2 percent of the weight of vegetable and water
↓
Step 3: Pack tight, cover with brine, hold vegetables down, keep air out
↓
Step 4: Keep at room temperature, taste daily, move to the fridge when sour enough
↓
Step 5: Check before eating. Sour and clean is good, mould or a rotten smell means throw it away

A worked example: brine for a jar of pickles

A jar holds 500 g of cucumber and 500 g of water, a total of 1,000 g. The salt should be 2 percent of the total, which is 20 g. The maker weighs 20 g of salt, dissolves it in the water, and pours the brine over the cucumbers. If the maker guesses and adds only 10 g, the level is 1 percent, and harmful bacteria may grow before the acid forms. If the maker adds 40 g, the level is 4 percent, and the lactic acid bacteria grow slowly, so the pickles stay raw and too salty. The weighing takes a minute, and it is the difference between a safe ferment and a failed one.

Questions to think about

  • Why is weighing the salt more important than guessing it by spoonfuls?
  • A jar of sauerkraut has a fuzzy green growth on top. What should you do, and why?
  • Why must garlic in oil never be stored at room temperature?
Think about the salt question before you read on

A spoonful of salt can vary by half depending on how it is scooped and how fine the salt is, so guessing can give 1 percent when 2 percent is needed, or 4 percent when 2 percent is needed. Too little salt lets harmful bacteria grow before the acid forms, and too much salt slows the lactic acid bacteria so the food stays raw. Weighing gives the right level every time, and the right level is the safety step.

Practical note: Keep a simple log for each home ferment: the date, the vegetable, the weight of vegetable and water, the weight of salt, and the temperature of the room. When a batch works well, the log tells you how to repeat it. When a batch fails, the log tells you what changed. A notebook on the kitchen bench is the home version of a factory record, and it is what turns a lucky batch into a reliable recipe.

Quick self-check

Question: Why must fermented vegetables stay under the brine?

Because lactic acid bacteria grow without oxygen, while mould and many harmful bacteria need oxygen. A piece that sticks out of the brine is open to air and can grow mould. Holding the vegetables down with a clean weight keeps air out and lets the right bacteria win.

Question: How do you know a sourdough starter is ready to use?

It bubbles, rises, and smells pleasantly sour, and it doubles in size within a few hours of feeding. A starter that does not rise or that smells of nail polish remover is hungry and needs more feeding before it is used.

Question: Why is a cloudy brine in a vegetable ferment not a fault?

The cloudiness is the lactic acid bacteria growing in the brine. It is a sign that fermentation is happening. A clear brine after a week means the bacteria did not grow, which is a fault, while a cloudy brine is normal.

Try it yourself

Start a sourdough starter today. Mix 50 g of wholemeal flour with 50 g of water in a clean jar, cover it with a cloth, and leave it on the bench. Each day for seven days, throw away half and add 50 g of flour and 50 g of water. Write down each day what you see and smell: no change, a few bubbles, a sour smell, rising and falling. On day seven, test it: feed it in the morning and see if it doubles by the afternoon. If it does, you have a living starter, and you can bake your first loaf. If it does not, feed it for three more days and test again. Keep the log: it is your first fermentation record.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Home fermentation is safe when four rules are followed: start clean, use enough salt, keep air out, and keep the temperature right.
  • Salt should be about 2 to 2.5 percent by weight, and it should be weighed, not guessed.
  • Vegetables must stay under the brine, or mould will grow on the exposed pieces.
  • A good ferment bubbles, turns cloudy, and smells sharp and sour; mould, a rotten smell, or slime means throw the batch away.
  • Yoghurt needs milk heated to 85 °C, cooled to 43 °C, and held warm for four to six hours.
  • A sourdough starter is fed daily and is ready when it doubles within a few hours of feeding.
  • Garlic in oil and low salt ferments are not safe at room temperature, because botulism can grow where acid and salt are missing.

Glossary

Kahm yeast

A harmless white film of yeast that can grow on the surface of a ferment. Food tech example: kahm yeast on sauerkraut can be skimmed off, while fuzzy mould cannot.

Brine

Salty water used to ferment vegetables and to keep them covered. Food tech example: pickles must stay under the brine, or mould can grow on the exposed pieces.

Botulism

Illness caused by the toxin of Clostridium botulinum, which grows without oxygen in low acid foods. Food tech example: garlic in oil at room temperature can allow botulism to grow, so it must be kept in the fridge.

Clostridium botulinum

A bacterium that grows without oxygen in low acid foods and makes a toxin. Food tech example: a proper vegetable ferment stops Clostridium botulinum because the salt and acid keep the pH below 4.6.

Sourdough starter

A jar of flour and water holding wild yeast and lactic acid bacteria, fed daily and used to make bread. Food tech example: a spoon of active starter is mixed into each new dough.

Kefir grain

A jelly like lump of bacteria and yeast held in a matrix, used to make kefir. Food tech example: kefir grains are strained out after each batch and used again.

Starter culture

A chosen mix of microbes added to a food to start fermentation. Food tech example: a yoghurt starter holds Streptococcus and Lactobacillus.

Anti-caking agent

A compound added to salt to stop it clumping, which can slow fermentation slightly. Food tech example: plain salt without anti-caking agents is preferred for home ferments.

Tannin

A bitter compound in leaves and tea that can firm vegetable tissue. Food tech example: a grape leaf or a tea bag is added to pickles to keep them crisp.

pH

A measure of how acid or alkaline a food is, from 0 to 14, with 7 neutral. Food tech example: a finished sauerkraut has a pH of about 3.5 to 4.0.

Listeria

A bacterium that can grow in chilled foods and cause serious illness. Food tech example: people with a weak immune system should choose factory tested ferments.

Wholemeal flour

Flour made from the whole grain, including bran and germ. Food tech example: a sourdough starter made with wholemeal flour grows faster than one made with white flour.

References

  • Tamang, J. P., Himalayan Fermented Foods: Microbiology, Nutrition, and Ethnic Values, 2010.
  • Steinkraus, K. H., Handbook of Indigenous Fermented Foods, 2nd edition, 1996.
  • Katz, S. E., The Art of Fermentation, 2012.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.
  • Holzapfel, W. H. and Schillinger, U., Introduction to Pre and Probiotics, Food Research International, 2002.

Unit 8: The Gut Brain Axis: How the Gut Talks to the Brain

Note

Unit 8: The Gut Brain Axis: How the Gut Talks to the Brain

A question to start with

A person feels nervous before an exam and their stomach churns. Another person eats a heavy meal and feels sleepy and low. A third person is stressed for weeks and their digestion changes, even though their food has not changed. The gut and the brain are not two separate systems that happen to sit in one body. They talk to each other all day, through nerves, hormones, and the products of gut microbes, and the conversation changes how a person feels, sleeps, eats, and thinks. This unit explains the gut brain axis: the roads the messages travel, the messages themselves, and what food can and cannot do to the conversation.

The gut brain axis is the two way link between the gut and the brain. Messages travel from the brain to the gut, which is why stress changes digestion, and from the gut to the brain, which is why a gut upset changes mood. The gut has its own nerve network, the enteric nervous system, which holds more nerve cells than the spinal cord and can run much of digestion on its own. That network is sometimes called the second brain, but the name is misleading: the gut network does not think, it senses and reacts, and it reports to the brain through the vagus nerve, the long nerve that runs from the gut to the brain and carries signals both ways.

The microbes join the conversation in three ways. They make compounds that act like the body own signalling chemicals. They make short chain fatty acids that travel in the blood and reach the brain. And they train the immune system, which sends its own signals to the brain. Food shapes all three, because food feeds the microbes, food sets the speed of digestion, and food sets the hormones that tell the brain whether the body is full or hungry.

The roads: nerves, hormones and the immune system

The fastest road is the vagus nerve. It carries signals from the gut wall to the brain in milliseconds, reporting stretch, acid, nutrients, and the presence of microbes. When the stomach stretches after a meal, the vagus nerve tells the brain that food has arrived. When the gut is irritated, the vagus nerve tells the brain that something is wrong, and the brain answers with nausea or pain. The brain also sends signals back down the vagus nerve: stress speeds up or slows down the gut, changes acid production, and changes how fast food moves. That is why a stressful week can bring stomach pain, loose stools, or constipation, with no change in food at all.

The slower road is hormones. The gut makes hormones when food arrives, and they travel in the blood to the brain. Some tell the brain that the body is full and eating can stop. Others tell the brain that sugar has arrived and energy is on the way. The gut also makes most of the body serotonin, a chemical that the brain uses for mood and sleep. The serotonin made in the gut does not travel to the brain directly, because it cannot cross the blood brain barrier, but it acts on the gut nerves and on the vagus nerve, so it still changes the signals the brain receives.

The third road is the immune system. The gut holds most of the body immune cells, and they talk to the brain through signalling proteins called cytokines. When the gut is inflamed, cytokines rise, and the brain answers with tiredness, low mood, and a loss of appetite: the familiar feeling of being ill. When the gut barrier is strong and inflammation is low, the cytokine traffic is quiet, and the brain feels normal. This road is slow, measured in hours and days, but it is the road that links long term gut health to long term mood and energy.

The blood brain barrier is the gate that decides which gut products reach the brain itself. It is a tight layer of cells around the blood vessels in the brain, and it blocks most large molecules and most microbes. Short chain fatty acids cross it in small amounts. Most microbial products do not, and they act instead on the nerves, the hormones, and the immune cells outside the brain, which then send their own signals in. A claim that a food or a microbe acts directly on the brain must pass this gate test: if the compound cannot cross the barrier, it works through the nerves or the immune system, not by touching the brain.

What the microbes make: short chain fatty acids, neurotransmitters and more

Gut microbes make several compounds that matter to the brain. The best understood are the short chain fatty acids: acetate, propionate, and butyrate, made when microbes ferment fibre in the large intestine. Butyrate feeds the gut lining and keeps the barrier strong. Propionate travels to the liver and helps control sugar. Acetate travels around the body and reaches the brain in small amounts, where it is used for energy and for signalling. A diet rich in fibre raises all three, and a diet low in fibre lowers them, which is one reason a low fibre diet is linked to low energy and poor digestion.

Microbes also make compounds that act like neurotransmitters, the chemicals nerve cells use to talk. Some gut bacteria make gamma aminobutyric acid, or GABA, which calms nerve activity. Others make serotonin or its building blocks, or dopamine, or the amino acids the brain uses to make them. The amounts are small, and most of these compounds act locally on the gut nerves rather than travelling to the brain, but the local action changes the vagus nerve signals, so the brain hears a different message. The science here is young: the compounds are real, the pathways are being mapped, and the size of the effect in a healthy person is still being measured.

Microbes also make vitamins that the brain needs, including several B vitamins and vitamin K, and they change how the body handles the amino acid tryptophan, which the brain uses to make serotonin and melatonin. When the gut is inflamed, more tryptophan is pushed down a side path that makes compounds linked to low mood and poor sleep. When the gut is calm and well fed, more tryptophan stays on the path to serotonin. Food cannot force this choice, but a diet that keeps the gut calm and fed with fibre gives the brain the better odds.

Stress, sleep and appetite: the loop that runs both ways

Stress is the clearest example of the loop running both ways. Stress in the brain sends signals down to the gut: acid rises, movement changes, the barrier weakens, and the microbes shift. A stressed gut then sends signals back up: the vagus nerve reports irritation, cytokines rise, and the brain feels more anxious and sleeps worse. Poor sleep then adds to the stress, and the loop tightens. Breaking the loop can start at either end: calming the mind helps the gut, and feeding the gut well helps the mind, but neither end fixes the other on its own.

Sleep and the gut share a daily rhythm. The microbes change across the day, the gut moves food faster by day and slower by night, and the hormones that control hunger rise and fall with the clock. A meal eaten late at night is digested more slowly and can disturb sleep. A night of poor sleep raises the hunger hormone and lowers the fullness signal the next day, so the person eats more and chooses sweeter food. The practical lesson is simple: regular meals, a fibre rich diet, and a regular sleep pattern support each other, while late heavy meals and broken sleep pull against each other.

Appetite is set by the gut as much as by the brain. The gut senses the food it holds and sends fullness signals through the vagus nerve and through hormones. Protein and fibre give the strongest fullness signals, because they slow the stomach and raise the fullness hormones. Short chain fatty acids also signal fullness, which is another reason a fibre rich meal satisfies longer than a low fibre meal with the same energy. A person who eats fast, or who eats while distracted, can miss the signals, because the gut needs time to report and the brain needs time to listen.

Questions to think about

  • Why does stress change digestion even when the food has not changed?
  • Most serotonin is made in the gut, but it cannot cross the blood brain barrier. How can it still change mood?
  • A person sleeps badly for a week and then eats more sweet food. How does the gut brain loop explain that?
Think about the serotonin question before you read on

Serotonin made in the gut acts on the gut nerves and on the vagus nerve, and it changes the signals those nerves send to the brain. It does not need to reach the brain itself: the nerves carry the message for it.

What food can do, and what it cannot

Food can change the gut brain conversation, but the change is modest, slow, and general, not fast, large, and specific. A diet rich in fibre, fruit, vegetables, and fermented foods raises short chain fatty acid production within days, supports a diverse microbiome over weeks, and keeps the gut barrier strong. A diet low in fibre and high in fat and sugar does the opposite. Those are real effects, and they are the reason diet is part of gut brain health, but they are not a treatment for anxiety, depression, or any brain condition.

Fermented foods are often sold as mood foods, and the evidence does not support the claim in that form. A yoghurt or a kimchi can feed the gut and add useful microbes, but no study has shown that eating one food lifts mood in a healthy person in days, and no single strain has been proven to treat a mood condition. The honest statement is that a gut friendly diet supports the systems the brain depends on, and that is worth doing, while the claim that a food fixes mood is not proven and should not be printed.

Probiotics are studied for mood and stress, and the results so far are small and mixed. Some studies find a small improvement in self reported stress or mood, others find nothing, and the strains, doses, and people differ between studies. A probiotic is not a medicine for the brain, and a person with a mood condition needs medical care, not a yoghurt. The food technologist must be careful here: the gut brain axis is real science, and it is also a magnet for claims that run ahead of the evidence.

How a meal talks to the brain

Step 1: Food arrives in the gut, and the gut wall senses stretch, nutrients, and acid
↓
Step 2: The vagus nerve carries the signals to the brain in milliseconds
↓
Step 3: Gut hormones travel in the blood and tell the brain about fullness and energy
↓
Step 4: Microbes ferment fibre and make short chain fatty acids that feed the gut lining and signal the body
↓
Step 5: The brain answers with appetite, mood, sleep, and signals back to the gut

Gut feelings in illness: when the axis goes wrong

In some people the gut brain conversation goes wrong and becomes a condition. Irritable bowel syndrome is the best known example: the gut is more sensitive to stretch and to normal digestion, the brain reads normal signals as pain, and stress makes both worse. The cause is not one thing: the microbes, the gut nerves, the barrier, and the brain all play a part, and the treatment is a mix of diet, stress care, and medical help. A low FODMAP diet, which cuts certain fermentable carbohydrates for a time, helps some people, but it is a medical diet set by a dietitian, not a general gut health diet, and it must not be sold as one.

The gut brain axis is also studied in conditions that start in the brain, such as anxiety and depression, and in conditions that affect the whole body, such as long term stress and poor sleep. The pattern is the same: the gut and the brain share signals, so a problem at one end shows at the other, and care that helps one end often helps the other a little. The lesson for a food maker is restraint: a food can support the gut, and a supported gut is a better partner for the brain, but a food is not a treatment for a brain condition, and the label must never say it is.

Practical note: When you read a claim that a food improves mood, sleep, or stress, ask three questions: which compound is named, can it reach the brain or only the gut nerves, and was the study done in people with that problem or in healthy people? If the claim cannot answer all three, it is not proven.

Quick self-check

Question: What is the vagus nerve, and what does it carry?

The vagus nerve is the long nerve that runs from the gut to the brain and carries signals both ways: from the gut to the brain about stretch, nutrients, and irritation, and from the brain to the gut about stress and appetite.

Question: Why can a fibre rich meal satisfy longer than a low fibre meal with the same energy?

Fibre slows the stomach, raises the fullness hormones, and feeds microbes that make short chain fatty acids, which also signal fullness, so the brain hears a stronger and longer fullness message.

Question: Why is a fermented food not a proven mood treatment?

Because no study has shown that eating one fermented food lifts mood in a healthy person in days, and the probiotic studies on mood are small and mixed, so the claim runs ahead of the evidence.

Try it yourself

Keep a simple food and feeling diary for three days. At each meal, write what you ate, how fast you ate, and whether you were stressed, calm, or tired. Two hours after each meal, write how your stomach felt and how your mood and energy felt. At the end of three days, look for patterns: did fast or late meals match worse sleep, did fibre rich meals match longer fullness, did stressful days match stomach upset even when the food was the same? Write one sentence about the strongest pattern you found, and one change you could test next week. Keep your notes: this is the same pattern finding a researcher does when studying the gut brain axis, on a small scale.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • The gut brain axis is a two way link through nerves, hormones, and the immune system, and it runs all day.
  • The vagus nerve is the fast road, gut hormones are the slower road, and immune signals are the slowest.
  • The gut has its own nerve network and makes most of the body serotonin, which acts on gut nerves rather than travelling to the brain.
  • Short chain fatty acids from fibre fermentation feed the gut lining and signal fullness and energy control.
  • Stress, sleep, and appetite form a loop: each one changes the gut, and the gut changes each one back.
  • A fibre rich diet supports the conversation within days, but no single food has been proven to fix mood, sleep, or stress.
  • In irritable bowel syndrome the gut brain conversation is more sensitive, and care is a mix of diet, stress care, and medical help.
  • A food label must never claim a brain benefit that the evidence does not support.

Glossary

Gut brain axis

The two way link between the gut and the brain, through nerves, hormones, and the immune system. Food tech example: a gut brain claim on a food must be judged against the nerves and hormones that carry the message.

Vagus nerve

The long nerve that runs from the gut to the brain and carries signals both ways. Food tech example: the vagus nerve tells the brain the stomach has stretched after a meal.

Enteric nervous system

The network of nerve cells in the gut wall that runs much of digestion on its own. Food tech example: the enteric nervous system keeps food moving even when the brain is busy elsewhere.

Serotonin

A signalling chemical used for mood and sleep, most of which is made in the gut. Food tech example: serotonin made in the gut acts on gut nerves and changes the signals sent to the brain.

Neurotransmitter

A chemical that nerve cells use to send signals to each other. Food tech example: gut microbes make compounds that act like neurotransmitters on the gut nerves.

Blood brain barrier

The tight layer of cells around brain blood vessels that blocks most large molecules and microbes from reaching the brain. Food tech example: a gut compound must cross the blood brain barrier to act on the brain directly.

Cytokine

A signalling protein made by immune cells, which rises when the gut is inflamed and can change mood and energy. Food tech example: a rise in cytokines during gut inflammation brings tiredness and low mood.

Short chain fatty acid

A small acid made when gut microbes ferment fibre, such as acetate, propionate, and butyrate. Food tech example: butyrate feeds the gut lining cells and keeps the barrier strong.

GABA

Gamma aminobutyric acid, a calming neurotransmitter that some gut bacteria can make. Food tech example: GABA made in the gut acts on gut nerves and may change vagus nerve signals.

Tryptophan

An amino acid the brain uses to make serotonin and melatonin, and which the gut can push down different paths. Food tech example: a calm gut leaves more tryptophan on the path to serotonin.

Irritable bowel syndrome

A condition where the gut is more sensitive to normal digestion and the brain reads normal signals as pain. Food tech example: irritable bowel syndrome is managed with diet, stress care, and medical help together.

FODMAP

A group of fermentable carbohydrates that can cause symptoms in sensitive people and are cut for a time in a medical diet. Food tech example: a low FODMAP diet is set by a dietitian and is not a general gut health diet.

Fullness hormone

A gut hormone that travels in the blood and tells the brain the body is full and eating can stop. Food tech example: protein and fibre raise fullness hormones more than sugar does.

Melatonin

A hormone that sets the sleep rhythm, made in the brain from tryptophan. Food tech example: a late heavy meal can disturb sleep, and poor sleep then changes hunger signals the next day.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Tamang, J. P., Himalayan Fermented Foods: Microbiology, Nutrition, and Ethnic Values, 2010.
  • Steinkraus, K. H., Handbook of Indigenous Fermented Foods, 2nd edition, 1996.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.

Unit 9: Gut Health and Immunity: The Gut as a Training Ground

Note

Unit 9: Gut Health and Immunity: The Gut as a Training Ground

A question to start with

A child who eats a varied diet and plays outside catches fewer colds than a child who eats little fibre and stays indoors, or so many parents believe. A hospital patient who has taken antibiotics for weeks catches an infection that a healthy gut would have kept out. An older adult gets a vaccine and the protection is weaker than in a young adult. In each case the gut is part of the story, because the gut holds most of the body immune cells, and those cells learn their trade in the gut. This unit explains how the gut trains immunity, how the gut barrier keeps trouble out, and what food can and cannot do for the immune system.

The immune system is the body defence force: cells and proteins that tell friend from foe, attack invaders, and remember them for next time. The gut is its largest training ground, because the gut meets more foreign material than any other part of the body: food, drink, and trillions of microbes pass through it every day. The gut immune system must attack harmful microbes, tolerate food, and tolerate the useful microbes that live there. Getting that judgement right, day after day, is the work of gut immunity.

Food matters to this work in three ways. It feeds the gut lining, which is the wall the immune system stands behind. It feeds the microbes, which train the immune cells and crowd out invaders. And it supplies the nutrients the immune cells need to work: protein for building defences, vitamin A for the lining, vitamin D for immune control, zinc for cell growth, and iron for carrying oxygen to the fight. A diet short of any of these weakens the defence, and a diet that keeps the gut fed and diverse keeps it ready.

The gut barrier: a wall one cell thick

The gut lining is a single layer of cells, and it is the wall between the inside of the gut and the blood. On the gut side sit food, microbes, and their products. On the blood side sits the rest of the body, which must be kept clean. The wall must let nutrients through and keep microbes and their toxins out, and it does this with tight junctions: protein seals between the lining cells that open just enough for nutrients and stay shut against larger things.

Three layers protect the wall. The first is mucus, a thick slimy coat made by the lining, which traps microbes and keeps them away from the cells. The second is the lining cells themselves, fed by butyrate from fibre fermentation, which keeps them strong and quick to repair. The third is the immune cells just behind the wall, which catch anything that gets through and deal with it quietly, without starting a full alarm.

When the barrier weakens, the wall leaks. Small amounts of microbial products pass into the blood, the immune system answers with inflammation, and the person feels tired and unwell. The causes of a weak barrier are the familiar ones: a low fibre diet that starves the butyrate makers, heavy alcohol use, a course of antibiotics, a severe illness, and long term stress. The repair is also familiar: fibre to feed butyrate, a varied diet, enough sleep, and time. No single food repairs a barrier in a day, and a product that claims to seal a leaky gut in a week is selling a promise the science does not support.

The gut immune system: how it learns

The gut immune system learns by meeting things. In early life it meets the first microbes, the first foods, and the first small infections, and it learns which to attack and which to leave alone. A diverse microbiome in early life teaches tolerance: the immune cells learn that food proteins and useful microbes are safe, and they learn to attack only real invaders. A narrow microbiome in early life, after many antibiotics or a low fibre diet, teaches less well, and the chance of allergy and of immune problems later is higher. The pattern is strong, but it is not a simple cause: genes, birth, feeding, medicines, and diet all play a part, and no single factor decides the outcome.

The main tools of gut immunity are antibodies and immune cells. Immunoglobulin A, or IgA, is the antibody that works in the gut: it is secreted into the mucus, coats microbes, and stops them sticking to the wall, without starting inflammation. It is a quiet guard, not a loud alarm. Behind the wall sit immune cells that sample the gut contents, carry the samples to the lymph nodes, and teach the rest of the immune system what the gut has met. That teaching is why a gut infection can protect against the same microbe later, and why a vaccine swallowed or sprayed can protect the gut and the nose.

Tolerance is the hardest lesson. The immune system must not attack food, or every meal would be an allergic reaction. Special immune cells, called regulatory T cells, are trained in the gut to calm the attack on food and on useful microbes. Short chain fatty acids help train them: butyrate and propionate from fibre fermentation support the growth of regulatory T cells, which is one more reason fibre is linked to a calm immune system. When tolerance fails, the result can be a food allergy, where a food protein is attacked, or an inflammatory gut condition, where the gut attacks its own wall.

Microbes as defenders: crowding out and chemical warfare

Useful microbes defend the gut in three ways. The first is crowding out: they take up space on the wall and eat the food that harmful microbes would need, so there is no room for the invader to settle. The second is chemical: they make acids that lower the pH, and compounds called bacteriocins that stop harmful bacteria growing. Lactic acid bacteria are good at this, which is why fermented foods keep well and why the gut stays acid enough to discourage invaders. The third is signalling: useful microbes talk to the lining cells and the immune cells, keeping the barrier strong and the immune answer measured, not excessive.

Antibiotics cut this defence sharply. A course of antibiotics kills the harmful bacteria it was given for, but it also kills many useful ones, and the community can take weeks or months to recover. During that window, a harmful microbe that survives, such as Clostridioides difficile, can grow without competition and cause a severe gut infection. That is why antibiotics are used only when needed, why the full course is finished, and why food matters after a course: fibre feeds the recovery of the useful community, and fermented foods add useful microbes back, though they do not replace the lost diversity on their own.

A worked example shows the scale of the defence. A healthy gut holds hundreds of species, and a harmful microbe arriving in food must compete with all of them for space and food, survive the acid, survive the bile, and get past the mucus and the IgA before it can reach the wall. Most invaders fail at one of those steps, which is why most people can eat food with a small number of harmful microbes and feel nothing. The defence is a chain of steps, and it is strong because it has many links, not because any one link is perfect.

Questions to think about

  • Why must the gut immune system tolerate food and useful microbes, and what happens when tolerance fails?
  • How does a course of antibiotics raise the risk of a gut infection after the treatment ends?
  • Why is IgA called a quiet guard rather than a loud alarm?
Think about the tolerance question before you read on

The gut meets food and useful microbes every day, so if the immune system attacked them, every meal would trigger inflammation and allergy. When tolerance fails, the result can be a food allergy, where a food protein is attacked, or an inflammatory gut condition, where the gut attacks its own wall.

Nutrients the immune system needs

Immune cells are built and run on nutrients, and a shortage of any one of them weakens the defence. Protein is the first need: antibodies are proteins, immune cells are built from protein, and a person short of protein makes fewer defences. That is why illness raises the protein need, and why a hospital patient who eats too little protein heals slowly and catches infections more easily.

Vitamin A keeps the gut lining and the skin strong, and it helps immune cells grow and work. A shortage of vitamin A weakens the barrier and raises the chance of infection, which is why vitamin A is one of the nutrients watched most closely in children who eat too little. Vitamin D helps control the immune answer, turning it up against infection and down when the job is done. Zinc is needed for immune cells to grow and divide, and a shortage slows the answer to a new infection. Iron carries oxygen to the tissues, including the immune cells, and a shortage leaves the defence tired. Vitamin C helps immune cells work and helps the body absorb iron from plant foods.

A varied diet supplies all of these, and a supplement is only needed when the diet cannot, or when a doctor finds a shortage. A product that claims to boost immunity with a single vitamin is misleading twice over: first, because immunity needs many nutrients together, and second, because more of a nutrient is not better once the need is met. The honest claim for a food is that it supplies nutrients the immune system needs, not that it boosts immunity beyond normal.

Vaccines, ageing and the gut

The gut shapes how well vaccines work. A vaccine teaches the immune system to recognise a microbe, and the teaching is stronger when the gut microbiome is diverse and the barrier is strong. Studies in animals and in people find that a low fibre diet and recent antibiotics can weaken the vaccine answer, while a varied diet supports it. The effect is modest, and a vaccine still works without a perfect diet, but the pattern is one more reason the gut is part of immune health, not a separate system.

Ageing weakens the gut immune system in step with the rest of the body. Older adults have a less diverse microbiome, a thinner mucus layer, and immune cells that answer more slowly. That is why infections hit older adults harder, why vaccines protect them a little less, and why fibre, fermented foods, and enough protein matter more, not less, in old age. The care is the same as for the young, only the stakes are higher: keep the gut fed, keep the diet varied, and treat illness quickly.

How the gut barrier keeps trouble out

Step 1: Mucus coats the wall and traps microbes away from the cells
↓
Step 2: The lining cells, fed by butyrate, form a wall one cell thick with tight seals
↓
Step 3: IgA antibodies in the mucus coat microbes and stop them sticking
↓
Step 4: Immune cells behind the wall catch anything that gets through
↓
Step 5: Nutrients pass through in a controlled way, while microbes and their toxins stay out

Immunity claims: what is proven and what is not

Gut health and immunity attract more claims than almost any other food topic, and most of them run ahead of the evidence. What is proven is narrow: fibre supports bowel regularity and feeds the microbes that make short chain fatty acids, certain probiotic strains shorten some gut infections in some people, and nutrients such as vitamin A, vitamin D, and zinc are needed for normal immune function. What is not proven is broad: no food has been shown to boost immunity beyond normal in a healthy person, no probiotic has been shown to prevent colds in the general public, and no product has been shown to seal a leaky gut in days.

The words on a pack matter. A claim that a food contributes to the normal function of the immune system, where the food supplies a nutrient known to do that job, is a different claim from a claim that a food boosts immunity. The first can be true. The second promises more than normal, and it cannot be proven by showing that the nutrient is present. A maker who writes an immunity claim must name the nutrient, name the evidence, and use only the wording the rules allow, and must check the current rule in each market where the product is sold, because the allowed wording differs.

The reader can test any immunity claim with three questions. First, which nutrient or strain is named, and how much of it is in a serving? Second, was the benefit shown in people like the buyer, or only in animals or in a laboratory dish? Third, does the claim promise normal function or something beyond normal? A claim that fails any of the three is not a claim to trust.

Practical note: When you design or judge a food with an immunity claim, start with the nutrient, not the slogan. If the food supplies vitamin A, vitamin D, zinc, or protein in a useful amount, the claim can be written from that nutrient. If it does not, no slogan can make the claim true.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is the gut lining only one cell thick, and how does it stay safe?

It is one cell thick so nutrients can pass through quickly, and it stays safe because mucus, tight seals between cells, IgA antibodies, and immune cells behind the wall all guard it together.

Question: How do useful microbes defend the gut without the immune system?

They crowd out invaders by taking space and food, they make acids and bacteriocins that stop harmful bacteria growing, and they signal the lining cells to keep the barrier strong.

Question: Why is "boosts immunity" a claim to distrust on a food pack?

Because it promises more than normal immune function, which no food has been shown to give a healthy person, while the honest claim is that a nutrient contributes to normal immune function.

Try it yourself

Look at three foods or drinks in your kitchen that mention immunity, gut health, or defence on the pack. For each one, write down the exact claim, then find the nutrient or strain named behind it, and the amount per serving. Then ask the three questions from this unit: is the nutrient or strain named with an amount, was the benefit shown in people, and does the claim promise normal function or something beyond normal? Write one sentence for each product saying whether the claim holds up. Keep your notes: this is the same check a food technologist runs before an immunity claim is approved.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • The gut holds most of the body immune cells, and it must attack invaders while tolerating food and useful microbes.
  • The gut barrier is a wall one cell thick, guarded by mucus, tight seals, butyrate fed lining cells, IgA, and immune cells behind the wall.
  • Tolerance is trained in the gut, and short chain fatty acids from fibre help train the cells that calm the immune answer.
  • Useful microbes defend by crowding out invaders, making acids and bacteriocins, and signalling the barrier to stay strong.
  • Antibiotics cut the defence and leave a window where a harmful microbe can grow without competition.
  • Protein, vitamin A, vitamin D, zinc, iron, and vitamin C are all needed for normal immune function, and a varied diet supplies them.
  • Ageing weakens gut immunity, so fibre, fermented foods, and enough protein matter more in old age.
  • The proven claims are narrow: normal immune function from named nutrients, and some probiotic strains for some gut infections. Boosting immunity beyond normal is not proven for any food.

Glossary

Immune system

The body defence force of cells and proteins that tells friend from foe, attacks invaders, and remembers them. Food tech example: the gut holds most of the body immune cells, so gut food shapes immune training.

Gut barrier

The wall of the gut lining, mucus, and immune cells that lets nutrients through and keeps microbes and toxins out. Food tech example: fibre feeds butyrate, which keeps the gut barrier strong.

Tight junction

A protein seal between lining cells that opens just enough for nutrients and stays shut against larger things. Food tech example: tight junctions keep microbial products out of the blood.

Mucus

The thick slimy coat made by the gut lining that traps microbes and keeps them away from the cells. Food tech example: a healthy mucus layer is the first guard of the gut barrier.

Immunoglobulin A

The antibody that works in the gut, secreted into mucus to coat microbes and stop them sticking, without starting inflammation. Food tech example: IgA in the mucus is a quiet guard against invaders.

Tolerance

The immune system learning not to attack food and useful microbes. Food tech example: tolerance is trained in the gut, and when it fails, a food allergy can follow.

Regulatory T cell

An immune cell trained in the gut to calm the attack on food and useful microbes. Food tech example: short chain fatty acids help regulatory T cells grow.

Bacteriocin

A compound made by a bacterium that stops other bacteria growing. Food tech example: lactic acid bacteria make bacteriocins that help fermented foods keep well.

Inflammation

The immune answer to harm or infection, with heat, swelling, and signalling proteins, useful in the short term and harmful when it lasts. Food tech example: a weak gut barrier lets microbial products into the blood and triggers inflammation.

Clostridioides difficile

A harmful gut bacterium that can grow after antibiotics kill its competitors and cause a severe gut infection. Food tech example: a course of antibiotics leaves a window where Clostridioides difficile can grow.

Vitamin D

A vitamin that helps control the immune answer, turning it up against infection and down when the job is done. Food tech example: a food that supplies vitamin D can claim it contributes to normal immune function.

Zinc

A mineral needed for immune cells to grow and divide. Food tech example: a shortage of zinc slows the immune answer to a new infection.

Vaccine answer

How strongly the immune system responds to a vaccine and remembers the microbe. Food tech example: a diverse microbiome and a varied diet support a stronger vaccine answer.

Leaky gut

A loose name for a weak gut barrier that lets microbial products pass into the blood. Food tech example: a product that claims to seal a leaky gut in a week is selling a promise the science does not support.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Tamang, J. P., Himalayan Fermented Foods: Microbiology, Nutrition, and Ethnic Values, 2010.
  • Steinkraus, K. H., Handbook of Indigenous Fermented Foods, 2nd edition, 1996.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.

Unit 10: Microbiome Testing and Analysis: How the Gut Is Measured

Note

Unit 10: Microbiome Testing and Analysis: How the Gut Is Measured

A question to start with

A company sells a test that promises to read your gut and tell you exactly what to eat. A doctor orders a stool test to find why a patient has diarrhoea. A researcher collects stool samples from a hundred people to learn how diet changes the microbiome. All three use the word test, but they are not doing the same thing, and the answers they get are not equally useful. A test that finds a harmful bacterium in a sick patient is solid medicine. A test that lists the bacteria in a healthy person and sells a diet from the list is a guess dressed as a measurement. This unit explains how the microbiome is measured, what each method can and cannot tell, and how to judge a test before trusting it.

Measuring the microbiome is hard for three reasons. The first is that the gut holds hundreds of species, and no single test sees all of them well. The second is that the microbiome changes day by day with food, illness, and medicines, so one sample is a snapshot, not a portrait. The third is that knowing which microbes are present is not the same as knowing what they do, and a list of names without a measure of their activity can mislead. A good test states what it measures, how it measures it, and what the result means, and a test that does not state those three things should not be trusted.

The methods in this unit fall into three groups: seeing who is there, seeing what they can do, and seeing what they actually do. Each group has its own tools, its own costs, and its own limits, and the researcher or the doctor picks the group that fits the question, not the newest tool on the market.

Seeing who is there: culture, microscopy and gene reading

The oldest method is culture: growing microbes from a stool sample on plates or in tubes, then counting and identifying the colonies. Culture is direct and cheap, and it gives living microbes that can be tested further, which is why it is still the method for finding a harmful bacterium in a sick patient. Its limit is that most gut bacteria will not grow in the laboratory: they need the exact food, the exact oxygen level, and the exact neighbours they have in the gut, and the laboratory cannot copy all of that. Culture sees the microbes that like laboratory conditions and misses most of the rest, so it undercounts diversity badly.

Microscopy is older still: looking at a sample under a microscope and counting shapes. It is fast and cheap, and it can show whether a sample holds many bacteria or few, and whether the shapes look normal. It cannot name the species, and it cannot tell a useful bacterium from a harmful one that looks the same. It is a first look, not a diagnosis, and it is now used beside other methods rather than alone.

The method that changed the field is gene reading. Every bacterium carries a gene called 16S rRNA, which is similar in all bacteria but differs just enough between species to act as a name tag. The laboratory extracts DNA from a stool sample, copies the 16S gene many times, reads the copies, and matches them against a library of known bacteria. The result is a list of the groups present and their shares: how much is Bifidobacterium, how much is Bacteroides, how much is Firmicutes, and so on. The method is fast, it sees bacteria that will not grow in culture, and it can run many samples at once, which is why most research studies use it.

The 16S method has limits that matter. It usually names the genus, the group a bacterium belongs to, not the species, and it cannot tell two close species apart. It counts gene copies, not living cells, so a dead bacterium counts as much as a live one. It is biased: some bacteria copy better than others, so their share is overstated. And it says nothing about what the bacteria do, only who is there. A 16S result that shows a low share of Bifidobacterium does not prove a problem, because the healthy share varies widely between people, and a single sample cannot show whether the low share is normal for that person or a sign of trouble.

Seeing what they can do: shotgun sequencing and gene libraries

Shotgun metagenomics reads all the genes in a sample, not only the 16S name tag. The laboratory breaks all the DNA into pieces, reads them, and matches them against libraries of known genes. The result shows not only who is there, down to the species and often the strain, but also what genes they carry: which enzymes they can make, which fibres they can ferment, which vitamins they can build, and whether they carry genes for antibiotic resistance or for making toxins. That is a much richer picture than a 16S list, and it is the method used when the question is about function, not only identity.

Shotgun sequencing costs more and needs more computing, because a single sample can hold millions of gene pieces that must be matched and counted. It also needs care with the sample: DNA from food, from the person, and from dead microbes all enters the reading, and the laboratory must separate the microbial signal from the rest. The result is still a measure of what the microbes can do, not what they are doing at the moment, because a gene that is present may be switched off. A microbe that carries the gene for making butyrate may not be making it today, because it has no fibre to ferment.

A worked example shows how the two gene methods differ on the same sample. A 16S reading of a stool sample reports that the genus Bifidobacterium makes up 5 percent of the community. A shotgun reading of the same sample reports that the species are Bifidobacterium longum and Bifidobacterium adolescentis, that they carry the genes for fermenting fructo-oligosaccharides, and that they do not carry genes for making toxins. The 16S result gives a name and a share. The shotgun result gives names, jobs, and safety information. The shotgun result costs more, but it answers questions the 16S result cannot, and that is why a researcher picks shotgun when the question is about what the microbes do.

Seeing what they actually do: metabolites, proteins and activity

The third group of methods measures what the microbes are actually doing, not only what they could do. Metabolomics measures the small molecules in a stool or blood sample: the short chain fatty acids, the bile acids, the amino acids, and the other products of microbial work. A sample rich in butyrate shows that fibre fermenters are active, whatever their names are. A sample rich in a toxin shows that a harmful microbe is active, even if its share looks small. Metabolomics is the closest measure of the microbiome effect on the body, because the body feels the products, not the names.

Proteomics measures the proteins the microbes are making, and transcriptomics measures which genes are switched on. Both show activity in real time, and both are used in research rather than in routine testing, because they are costly, they need fresh samples handled with care, and they produce large amounts of data that need expert analysis. They are the methods that will matter most in the future, because they answer the question the other methods cannot: what is the microbiome doing today, in this person, after this meal?

A simpler activity measure is the breath test. A person drinks a sugar solution, and the laboratory measures the gases in their breath over the next hours. Bacteria in the small intestine ferment the sugar early and make hydrogen, which appears in the breath sooner than it should. The test is used to find small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, where bacteria that belong in the large intestine have grown in the small intestine. It is a functional test, not a list of names, and it shows why activity matters: the problem is not which bacteria are present, but where they are and what they are doing.

Questions to think about

  • Why does culture undercount gut diversity, and why is it still the method for finding a harmful bacterium in a sick patient?
  • A 16S test reports a low share of Bifidobacterium. Why does that result alone not prove a problem?
  • What does a shotgun reading tell you that a 16S reading cannot?
Think about the 16S question before you read on

The healthy share of Bifidobacterium varies widely between people, 16S counts gene copies not living cells, and it says nothing about what the bacteria are doing, so a low share in one sample cannot show whether it is normal for that person or a sign of trouble.

From sample to result: where error creeps in

A microbiome result is only as good as its sample, and error creeps in at every step. The sample itself is the first risk: a stool sample is easy to collect, but it shows the microbes of the large intestine, not the small intestine, and not the microbes stuck to the gut wall, which differ from the ones floating in the stool. A sample kept warm for hours before testing lets some bacteria grow and others die, so the result shows the storage, not the gut. A sample frozen fast and kept frozen stays truer, which is why research studies freeze samples at once.

The laboratory steps add more error. DNA extraction favours some bacteria over others, because some cell walls break easily and some resist. Copying the 16S gene favours some groups over others. Matching the readings against a library depends on how complete the library is, and a bacterium that is not in the library is reported as unknown or as its nearest neighbour, which can be wrong. The counting is also relative, not absolute: the result says a group makes up 5 percent of the community, but it does not say how many cells that is, because the total number of cells is not measured. A group can rise in share because it grew, or because another group shrank, and the test cannot tell which happened.

The analysis adds the last error. The data are cleaned, the rare groups are cut off, and the results are compared with a reference group, and each choice changes the answer. Two laboratories that test the same sample with different methods can report different lists, and both can be honest. That is why a result should always state the method, the sample handling, and the reference used, and why a result without those details cannot be compared with another result.

Judging a commercial microbiome test

Commercial microbiome tests are sold directly to the public, and they vary widely in quality. A good test states its method, usually 16S or shotgun, states how the sample should be collected and stored, and gives results as shares with a plain explanation of what is known and what is not. A poor test hides its method, gives a diet plan from a single sample, and promises to fix named problems that the test cannot prove.

The reader can judge any commercial test with five questions. First, what method is used, and is it named? Second, how is the sample collected and stored, and is the instruction clear? Third, does the result show the limits, such as the wide range of healthy values, or does it label normal variation as a problem? Fourth, is the advice general, such as eat more fibre and more varied plant foods, or is it specific, such as eat this food and avoid that one, based on a single sample? Fifth, who checks the test: is it run in an accredited laboratory, and is a health professional available to explain the result? A test that fails the first question should not be bought. A test that gives specific diet advice from one sample should not be followed.

A worked example shows the trap. A test reports that a healthy person has a low share of a fibre fermenting group and sells a supplement to raise it. The low share may be normal for that person, it may be a snapshot from a day of low fibre eating, and the supplement may not raise that group at all, because the group needs fibre, not a capsule. The general advice, to eat more fibre and more varied plant foods, would have helped without the test. The test added a number, a worry, and a sale, but it did not add a better decision.

From stool sample to result: the testing journey

Step 1: Collect the sample and freeze it fast, so the community does not change in storage
↓
Step 2: Extract DNA from the sample in the laboratory
↓
Step 3: Read the genes: 16S for names, shotgun for names and jobs
↓
Step 4: Match the readings against a library and count the shares
↓
Step 5: Report the result with the method, the limits, and the reference range

Testing in research and in medicine: two different jobs

In research, microbiome testing is used to find patterns: how diet changes the community, how a probiotic shifts it, how illness changes it. The studies use many samples, many people, and the same method throughout, so the patterns can be trusted even when a single sample cannot. The results are reported as group averages and ranges, not as a diagnosis for one person, and the papers state the method in full so another laboratory can repeat the work.

In medicine, microbiome testing is used for a narrow job: finding a harmful microbe in a sick patient. A stool culture, a test for a toxin, or a gene test for a named pathogen can find the cause of diarrhoea and guide the treatment. A broad microbiome list is rarely used to treat a patient, because the healthy range is too wide and the link between a list and a treatment is too weak. The exception is faecal microbiota transplantation, where stool from a healthy donor is given to a patient with a severe infection, and the donor stool is tested carefully for harmful microbes before it is used. That is a medical treatment, done in a hospital, with a tested donor, and it is not a test a healthy person needs.

Practical note: When you read a microbiome study or a test result, look first for the method and the sample size. A study of a hundred people with one stated method tells more than a test of one person with a hidden method, and a result that names its limits is more trustworthy than a result that hides them.

Quick self-check

Question: Why is a stool sample a snapshot, not a portrait, of the microbiome?

Because the microbiome changes day by day with food, illness, and medicines, and a stool sample shows the large intestine at one moment, not the small intestine or the wall microbes, so one sample cannot show the whole community over time.

Question: What is the main limit of the 16S method?

It usually names the genus, not the species, it counts gene copies rather than living cells, it is biased toward bacteria that copy well, and it says who is there, not what they do.

Question: Why should a single commercial test not set a specific diet?

Because one sample is a snapshot, the healthy range is wide, and a low share may be normal for that person or a result of one day of eating, so a specific diet from one sample is a guess, not a measurement.

Try it yourself

Find a commercial microbiome test online, or take a test report you already have, and judge it with the five questions from this unit: is the method named, is the sample handling clear, are the limits shown, is the advice general or specific, and is an accredited laboratory and a health professional named? Write one sentence for each question. Then write a final sentence: would you trust this test to change your diet, and why? Keep your notes: this is the same judgement a researcher makes before citing a test, and a doctor makes before ordering one.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Measuring the microbiome is hard: hundreds of species, daily change, and a list of names is not a measure of activity.
  • Culture gives living microbes and finds harmful bacteria in sick patients, but it misses most gut bacteria that will not grow in the laboratory.
  • The 16S method reads a name tag gene and lists the groups and their shares, but it names the genus, counts dead cells too, and says nothing about function.
  • Shotgun sequencing reads all the genes and shows species, jobs, and safety information, at a higher cost and with more computing.
  • Metabolomics, proteomics, and breath tests measure what the microbes actually do, which is the closest measure of their effect on the body.
  • Error creeps in at the sample, the laboratory steps, and the analysis, so a result must state its method and its handling.
  • A commercial test should name its method, show its limits, and give general advice, not a specific diet from one sample.
  • In medicine, testing finds a named harmful microbe in a sick patient, and in research it finds patterns across many people with one method.

Glossary

16S rRNA gene

A gene carried by all bacteria that differs just enough between groups to act as a name tag. Food tech example: a 16S reading lists the bacterial groups in a stool sample by their name tag genes.

Shotgun metagenomics

Reading all the genes in a sample, to show who is there and what jobs their genes can do. Food tech example: shotgun sequencing shows which species carry the genes for fermenting fibre.

Metabolomics

Measuring the small molecules in a sample, such as short chain fatty acids, to show what the microbes are actually doing. Food tech example: a sample rich in butyrate shows fibre fermenters are active.

Culture

Growing microbes from a sample on plates or in tubes, to count and identify living microbes. Food tech example: culture is still the method for finding a harmful bacterium in a sick patient.

Genus

A group of closely related species, one step above species in naming. Food tech example: Bifidobacterium is a genus, and Bifidobacterium longum is a species inside it.

Strain

A single type of microbe inside a species, with its own traits. Food tech example: a probiotic claim is proven for one strain, not for the whole species.

Reference library

A collection of known gene readings that a new reading is matched against to name it. Food tech example: a bacterium not in the library is reported as unknown or as its nearest neighbour.

Relative share

The share of a group in a community, stated as a percent, without saying how many cells that is. Food tech example: a group at 5 percent may have grown, or another group may have shrunk, and the test cannot tell which.

Breath test

A test that measures gases in the breath after drinking a sugar solution, to find bacteria fermenting in the small intestine. Food tech example: a breath test finds small intestinal bacterial overgrowth by the early rise of hydrogen.

Small intestinal bacterial overgrowth

A condition where bacteria that belong in the large intestine grow in the small intestine. Food tech example: a breath test is used to find small intestinal bacterial overgrowth.

Faecal microbiota transplantation

Giving stool from a tested healthy donor to a patient with a severe gut infection, done in a hospital. Food tech example: faecal microbiota transplantation is a medical treatment, not a test for a healthy person.

Accredited laboratory

A laboratory checked by an outside body to prove its methods, staff, and records meet a set standard. Food tech example: a commercial test run in an accredited laboratory is more trustworthy than one with no accreditation named.

Snapshot

A single measurement at one moment, which shows the state then, not the pattern over time. Food tech example: one stool sample is a snapshot of the microbiome on that day.

Transcriptomics

Measuring which genes are switched on, to show what the microbes are doing in real time. Food tech example: transcriptomics shows whether the butyrate making genes are active today.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Tamang, J. P., Himalayan Fermented Foods: Microbiology, Nutrition, and Ethnic Values, 2010.
  • Steinkraus, K. H., Handbook of Indigenous Fermented Foods, 2nd edition, 1996.
  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.