Login Register

Access the GIFSQ Portal

Select your user type to log in or register a new account.

Student Portal

Access your food safety courses and exams.

Instructor Portal

Manage courses, view student submissions, and grade quizzes.

Company Portal

Manage corporate setup, view employee logs, and access QA services.

GIFSQ ID: FTN-0097

← All subjects

Functional Foods and Beverages

Unit 1: What Makes a Food Functional

Note

Unit 1: What Makes a Food Functional

A question to start with

An egg, a glass of milk, and a bowl of oats all give nutrients the body needs. A yoghurt with added plant sterols, a juice with added vitamin D, and a bar with added fibre also give nutrients, but they promise something extra: lower cholesterol, stronger bones, better digestion. What turns an ordinary food into a functional food, and where is the line between a food and a medicine? This unit explains the idea, the types, and the rules that keep the line clear.

A functional food is a food that gives a health benefit beyond basic nutrition. Every food gives nutrition: energy, protein, vitamins, and minerals that the body needs to live. A functional food gives something more, a benefit that goes beyond keeping the body fed, such as helping to lower blood cholesterol, supporting gut health, or helping to control blood sugar. The benefit comes from a compound in the food, either one that is naturally there, such as the beta-glucan in oats, or one that has been added, such as vitamin D in milk.

The word functional is used in two ways, and the difference matters. In the broad sense, any food with a benefit beyond basic nutrition is functional, including oats, beans, oily fish, and yoghurt. In the narrow sense, a functional food is a food that has been made or changed to give a benefit, such as a spread with added plant sterols or a drink with added probiotics. This subject uses the broad sense when talking about foods and the narrow sense when talking about products, and it says which sense it means.

The four ways a food becomes functional

A food becomes functional in four ways. First, it may hold the benefit naturally. Oats hold beta-glucan, which helps lower blood cholesterol. Oily fish hold long chain omega 3 fats, which help the heart. Tomatoes hold lycopene, a red pigment linked to health. These foods are functional without any change, and the job of the food technologist is to keep the benefit through processing and to state it honestly on the label.

Second, a compound may be added to the food. Vitamin D is added to milk and to breakfast cereals in many markets. Folic acid is added to flour. Plant sterols are added to spreads and yoghurts. The added compound must be stable in the food, it must survive storage and cooking, and it must be present in the amount that was tested. A drink that loses its added vitamin in a month on the shelf is not functional at the end of its life.

Third, a harmful part may be removed or reduced. Salt is lowered in bread, sugar is lowered in a drink, and saturated fat is lowered in a spread. The food is functional because it gives the same eating with less of a harmful part. The change must not ruin the taste or the texture, or the buyer will not eat it twice. A low salt bread that tastes flat is a failure, however good its numbers look.

Fourth, the food may be changed so that a compound becomes more available. Fermenting soy into tempeh makes its protein easier to digest and lowers its phytate, so the minerals are freed. Fermenting milk into yoghurt lowers its lactose, so people who struggle with milk can eat it. Sprouting grains raises their vitamin content and lowers phytate. The food is the same in name, but its nutrition has changed.

Functional foods, nutraceuticals, and medicines: the line

A functional food is still a food. It is eaten as part of a normal diet, in normal amounts, and it tastes like food. A nutraceutical is a product that sits between a food and a medicine: a capsule, a tablet, or a concentrated extract that is taken in a dose, not eaten as a meal. A medicine is a product that treats or prevents a disease, and it is tested, licensed, and sold under medical rules.

The line matters for two reasons. A food that claims to treat a disease is making a medical claim, and it will be treated as a medicine, with all the testing and licensing that needs. A food that claims a general benefit, such as helps maintain normal cholesterol, is making a health claim, and it must be authorised under food rules. The words on the pack decide which side of the line the product falls on, and a careless word can move a food into the medicine rules, where it does not belong.

A worked example shows the line. A spread with plant sterols may say it helps maintain normal blood cholesterol, which is a health claim for a food. It may not say it treats high cholesterol, which is a medical claim. The difference is one word, maintains against treats, but the rules treat them very differently. A food technologist who writes a label must know the allowed wording and use it exactly, because the wording is the claim.

The main groups of functional foods

Functional foods fall into six groups, and the rest of this subject takes each group in turn. The first group is foods that help the gut: probiotics, prebiotics, and fibre, covered in the companion subject on gut health and in Unit 4 of this subject. The second group is foods that help the heart: plant sterols, omega 3 fats, and beta-glucan, which help blood cholesterol and blood pressure. The third group is foods that help bones: calcium, vitamin D, and vitamin K, which support bone strength. The fourth group is foods that help blood sugar: fibre and resistant starch, which slow sugar absorption. The fifth group is foods that support the immune system: vitamin C, vitamin D, zinc, and some probiotics. The sixth group is foods that support the brain and the eyes: omega 3 fats, lutein, and some polyphenols.

Each group has its own compounds, its own dose, and its own evidence. A food that helps one group may do nothing for another, and a product that claims to help everything is claiming too much. The rest of this subject explains the compounds, the doses, and the evidence, so that a product can be built on one clear benefit rather than on a list of vague promises.

Why functional foods are growing

Functional foods are a large and growing market, and the growth has three drivers. The first is the buyer: people want foods that do something, not only foods that fill them, and they are willing to pay more for a food that promises a benefit. The second is the science: more is known now about which compounds help health, and at what dose, than was known twenty years ago. The third is the technology: it is now possible to add a compound to a food, keep it stable, and prove it is still there at the end of shelf life.

The growth brings a risk: a market that grows fast attracts products that promise more than they deliver. A drink with a pinch of a trendy ingredient, a bar with a claim that rests on one small study, a powder with a dose far below the tested dose, all of these are common. The job of the food technologist is to stand between the trend and the buyer: to build products where the dose matches the evidence, the claim matches the dose, and the product still tastes like food.

The daily diet as the base

One idea runs through this whole subject: a functional food is an addition to a good diet, not a replacement for it. A spread with plant sterols helps cholesterol a little, but it does not undo a diet that is high in saturated fat and low in fibre. A drink with added vitamin D helps bones a little, but it does not replace a diet with enough calcium and movement. A yoghurt with a probiotic helps the gut a little, but it does not replace a diet with varied plants and fibre.

The best functional food is often an ordinary food eaten well. Oats for breakfast, beans at lunch, oily fish twice a week, fruit and vegetables at every meal, and a fermented food most days: that pattern gives more functional benefit than any single product, because it gives many compounds at once, in the amounts and the forms the body can use. The products in this subject are useful when the diet has a gap, when a person cannot eat enough of a food, or when a benefit is needed in a small, easy serving. They are tools, not magic.

Four ways a food becomes functional

1. Naturally present: oats hold beta-glucan, oily fish hold omega 3 fats
↓
2. Added: vitamin D in milk, plant sterols in a spread, probiotics in a yoghurt
↓
3. Harmful part reduced: less salt in bread, less sugar in a drink
↓
4. Made more available: fermenting soy into tempeh, fermenting milk into yoghurt

A worked example: is it functional?

A breakfast cereal holds oats, and the label says it helps maintain normal blood cholesterol. Is it a functional food? The answer is yes, if three things are true. The oats must hold enough beta-glucan: about 3 g a day is the tested dose, and a serving of the cereal must give a fair share of that, usually 1 g or more per serving, so that three servings reach the dose, or the maker must show that the serving plus the rest of the diet reaches it. The beta-glucan must survive processing: the oats must not be so refined that the beta-glucan is lost. And the claim must be authorised, with the exact wording the authority allows. If the cereal holds only 0.3 g of beta-glucan per serving, the claim is weak, because the buyer would need ten servings a day to reach the dose. The food is the same, but the dose decides whether it is functional in practice.

Questions to think about

  • A spread says it helps maintain normal blood cholesterol, and a second spread says it treats high cholesterol. What is the difference, and why does it matter?
  • Oats are functional without any change, while a vitamin D drink is functional because a compound was added. Which way is better, and does it matter?
  • A bar claims five different health benefits. Why should that make you cautious?
Think about the spread question before you read on

Helps maintain normal blood cholesterol is a health claim for a food, and it must be authorised under food rules. Treats high cholesterol is a medical claim, because high cholesterol is a condition, and a product that claims to treat it is treated as a medicine, with testing and licensing. The difference is one word, but it decides which rules apply, and a food that uses the medical wording has crossed the line.

Practical note: When you pick up a functional food, read the back before the front. The front carries the promise, and the back carries the dose: how much of the active compound is in one serving, and how many servings give the tested dose. If the back does not name the compound and the dose, the front is a promise without a number, and you cannot judge it.

Quick self-check

Question: What is a functional food?

A food that gives a health benefit beyond basic nutrition, such as helping to lower blood cholesterol or supporting gut health. The benefit comes from a compound that is naturally in the food or added to it, and the food is still eaten as part of a normal diet.

Question: What is the difference between a functional food and a nutraceutical?

A functional food is eaten as food, in normal amounts, as part of a meal. A nutraceutical is a capsule, tablet, or concentrated extract taken in a dose, not eaten as a meal. A medicine treats or prevents a disease and is licensed under medical rules.

Question: Why is the dose the key to judging a functional food?

Because the benefit was tested at a set dose, and a product that holds far less than that dose will not give the benefit. A cereal with 0.3 g of beta-glucan per serving cannot support a cholesterol claim that needs 3 g a day, however good the ingredient is.

Functional foods around the world

Every food culture has its own functional foods, made long before the word existed. In Asia, soy foods such as tofu, tempeh, and miso give protein and fermented benefits, and green tea gives polyphenols. In the Mediterranean, olive oil gives monounsaturated fat and polyphenols, oily fish gives omega 3 fats, and yoghurt gives live cultures. In the Himalayas, fermented foods such as gundruk, made from leafy greens, and kinema, made from soybeans, give preserved vegetables and protein through the winter, when fresh food is scarce. In the Americas, beans, maize, and squash give protein, fibre, and colour together.

These foods show that functional food is not a new invention of factories: it is an old pattern of eating, where the foods that keep well and feed people through hard seasons also carry the compounds that help health. The factory's job is to keep that pattern, not to replace it with a pill. A food technologist who designs a functional product should look at the traditional foods first, because they show which compounds people already eat, in which foods, and in which amounts. The best new product is often an old food, made well and stated honestly.

Try it yourself

Go to a shop and find three foods that claim a health benefit: a spread, a yoghurt, and a drink or a cereal. For each, write down the claim on the front, the active compound and its amount per serving on the back, and the number of servings needed to reach the tested dose if you know it. Then judge each one: does the dose per serving look like a real dose, or a pinch? Write one line for each product saying whether you would buy it for the benefit or for the taste alone. The gap between the two answers is the gap between a functional food and a food with a functional label.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A functional food gives a health benefit beyond basic nutrition, from a compound that is naturally there or added.
  • A food becomes functional by holding a benefit naturally, by adding a compound, by reducing a harmful part, or by making a compound more available.
  • A functional food is still a food; a nutraceutical is a dose in a capsule or tablet; a medicine treats a disease and is licensed.
  • The wording on the pack decides whether a claim is a food claim or a medical claim.
  • The dose decides whether a product is functional in practice: it must match the dose that was tested.
  • A good diet is the base, and functional foods are tools for a gap, not a replacement for varied eating.

Glossary

Functional food

A food that gives a health benefit beyond basic nutrition. Food tech example: oats are a functional food because their beta-glucan helps lower blood cholesterol.

Nutraceutical

A product between a food and a medicine, such as a capsule or concentrated extract taken in a dose. Food tech example: a fish oil capsule is a nutraceutical, while oily fish is a functional food.

Health claim

A statement that a food or an ingredient helps health, which must be authorised. Food tech example: a claim that oat beta-glucan helps maintain normal blood cholesterol must be authorised.

Medical claim

A statement that a product treats or prevents a disease, which puts it under medicine rules. Food tech example: a spread that says it treats high cholesterol is making a medical claim.

Beta-glucan

A soluble fibre from oats and barley that forms a gel and helps lower blood cholesterol. Food tech example: a bowl of porridge gives about 2 g of beta-glucan.

Plant sterol

A compound from plants that looks like cholesterol and blocks cholesterol absorption in the gut. Food tech example: plant sterols are added to spreads and yoghurts to help maintain normal cholesterol.

Omega 3 fats

A family of fats found in oily fish and some seeds, valued for heart and brain health. Food tech example: salmon and sardines are rich in long chain omega 3 fats.

Lycopene

A red pigment in tomatoes linked to health, better absorbed when tomatoes are cooked with oil. Food tech example: tomato sauce holds more available lycopene than raw tomato.

Vitamin D

A vitamin needed for bone health and for the immune system, made in skin by sunlight and added to milk and cereals. Food tech example: milk with added vitamin D helps bones in people who get little sun.

Folic acid

The form of folate added to flour and supplements, needed for cell growth. Food tech example: folic acid is added to flour to help prevent birth defects.

Bioavailability

How much of a nutrient in a food is absorbed and used by the body. Food tech example: fermenting soy into tempeh raises the bioavailability of its minerals by lowering phytate.

Phytate

The storage form of phosphorus in seeds and grains that binds minerals. Food tech example: sprouting grains lowers phytate and frees minerals.

Authorised claim

A health claim that an authority has judged and allowed, with set wording. Food tech example: a maker may use only authorised claims on a label, with the exact wording allowed.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Goldberg, I., Functional Foods: Designer Foods, Pharmafoods, Nutraceuticals, 1994.
  • Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development: From Concept to Marketplace, 3rd edition, 2011.

Unit 2: Bioactive Compounds: Polyphenols, Carotenoids and Peptides

Note

Unit 2: Bioactive Compounds: Polyphenols, Carotenoids and Peptides

A question to start with

A blueberry is blue, a tomato is red, a cup of green tea is bitter, and a piece of dark chocolate is sharp. The colours and the tastes are not decoration: they are chemicals the plant made to protect itself, and when people eat the plant, those chemicals do work in the body too. This unit explains the main bioactive compounds in foods: the polyphenols, the carotenoids, and the peptides, what they do, and how food processing changes them.

A bioactive compound is a compound in a food that acts on the body beyond giving energy or basic nutrition. Vitamins and minerals are nutrients, and the body needs them in set amounts. Bioactive compounds are different: the body does not need them to live, but they can help health when eaten in the amounts found in a varied diet. They are the reason a diet rich in plants is linked to better health, even when the vitamin and mineral content is the same.

Polyphenols: the plant's defence

Polyphenols are a large family of compounds made by plants, with more than 8,000 kinds known. They give plants their colour, their bitter taste, and their protection against sun, insects, and disease. The main groups are flavonoids, found in tea, cocoa, berries, apples, and onions; phenolic acids, found in coffee, whole grains, and fruit; and stilbenes, found in grapes and red wine.

Flavonoids are the best studied group. Tea holds catechins, cocoa holds flavanols, berries hold anthocyanins, which give the blue and red colour, and onions hold quercetin. A cup of green tea gives about 100 to 200 mg of catechins, a piece of dark chocolate gives about 50 mg of flavanols, and a handful of blueberries gives about 100 mg of anthocyanins. These amounts are small, but they add up across a day of varied plant foods.

Polyphenols act in the body in two ways. In a laboratory dish, they act as antioxidants, which means they neutralise free radicals, the reactive molecules that can damage cells. In the body, the effect is more complex: most polyphenols are poorly absorbed, and the gut bacteria break them down into smaller compounds that are absorbed instead. The benefit may come from those smaller compounds, and from the effect of polyphenols on the gut bacteria themselves. A person who eats a polyphenol rich diet feeds gut bacteria that thrive on polyphenols, and those bacteria make useful products.

The evidence for polyphenols is promising but not settled. Trials show that cocoa flavanols can lower blood pressure a little, that tea catechins can help blood vessel function, and that berry anthocyanins can help memory in older adults. The effects are modest, a few points of blood pressure, a small change in a memory test, and they need a regular intake over weeks. No single polyphenol is a cure, and a supplement with a high dose does not give the same effect as the food, because the food brings a mix of compounds and fibre that the supplement lacks.

Carotenoids: colour that the body uses

Carotenoids are the yellow, orange, and red pigments in fruit and vegetables. The main ones are beta-carotene in carrots and sweet potatoes, lycopene in tomatoes, lutein in green leaves and egg yolk, and zeaxanthin in maize and peppers. Beta-carotene is special, because the body turns it into vitamin A, so it is both a pigment and a vitamin source. The others are not turned into vitamin A, but they act in the body in their own right.

Lycopene is the red pigment of tomatoes. It is better absorbed when tomatoes are cooked with oil, because heat breaks the cell walls and oil dissolves the pigment. Tomato sauce therefore gives more available lycopene than raw tomato, even though the raw tomato holds more lycopene by weight. A serving of tomato sauce gives about 10 mg of lycopene, and trials link a regular intake of lycopene rich foods to a lower chance of some chronic diseases, though the evidence is observational and the cause is not settled.

Lutein and zeaxanthin sit in the eye, in the macula, the part of the retina that gives sharp vision. They filter blue light and protect the eye from damage. A diet rich in green leaves, such as spinach and kale, gives about 10 mg of lutein a day, and trials show that a higher intake is linked to a lower chance of age related eye disease. Egg yolk is a good source too, because the fat in the yolk helps the body absorb lutein.

Carotenoids need fat to be absorbed. A salad with no oil gives far less carotenoid than the same salad with a spoon of oil, because the pigment must dissolve in fat to pass through the gut wall. A food technologist who makes a carotenoid rich product must add a little fat, or the pigment will pass through unused. Cooking also matters: gentle cooking breaks cell walls and frees the pigment, while long harsh cooking destroys it.

Peptides: small pieces of protein with a job

Peptides are short chains of amino acids, smaller than a protein, and some of them act on the body in useful ways. They are made when a protein is cut, either by digestion in the gut, by fermentation, or by enzymes in a factory. Milk is the richest source: when casein is fermented into cheese or yoghurt, or cut by enzymes, it releases peptides that can lower blood pressure by blocking the enzyme that raises it. These are called ACE inhibitory peptides, and they are the best studied food peptides.

A well known example comes from fermented milk: the peptides Val-Pro-Pro and Ile-Pro-Pro, made by Lactobacillus helveticus during fermentation, have been tested in trials and shown to lower blood pressure by a few points in people with high blood pressure. The effect is modest, and it needs a regular intake, but it is real, and it is the basis for some fermented milk drinks sold for blood pressure.

Other peptides come from soy, egg, and fish. Soy peptides released during fermentation into tempeh and soy sauce have been tested for blood pressure and for cholesterol. Egg white peptides have been tested for blood pressure. Fish peptides from sardine and bonito have been tested in Japan for blood pressure. In each case, the peptide is a small piece of a larger protein, and it works because its shape fits a target in the body, just as a key fits a lock.

The challenge for a food maker is to make the peptide in a reliable amount and to keep it stable. Fermentation makes peptides, but the amount varies with the culture, the time, and the temperature. Enzyme treatment in a factory gives a more reliable amount, but it costs more and it can give a bitter taste, because small peptides are often bitter. A product that claims a peptide benefit must name the peptide, state the dose, and show that the dose survives to the end of shelf life.

Glucosinolates and other bioactives

Cruciferous vegetables, such as broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, and kale, hold glucosinolates, compounds that break down into isothiocyanates when the vegetable is cut or chewed. The best known is sulforaphane, made from broccoli. Isothiocyanates activate the body's own defence enzymes, which help clear harmful compounds. Trials show that eating broccoli regularly raises the activity of those enzymes, and observational studies link a high intake of cruciferous vegetables to a lower chance of some cancers, though the cause is not settled.

Garlic holds allicin, made when garlic is crushed and an enzyme meets a sulphur compound. Allicin gives garlic its smell and its sharp taste, and it has been tested for blood pressure and for cholesterol, with modest effects. Cooking destroys the enzyme that makes allicin, so garlic that is crushed and left for a few minutes before cooking gives more allicin than garlic thrown straight into a hot pan.

Phytosterols, also called plant sterols, are covered in Unit 1 and in Unit 5, but they belong here too: they are bioactive compounds that block cholesterol absorption in the gut. A daily intake of about 2 g of plant sterols lowers blood cholesterol by about 10 percent in trials, and that is the best proven bioactive effect in this unit, because the dose is clear and the trials repeat.

Processing: what survives and what is lost

Processing changes bioactive compounds in both directions. Gentle cooking frees carotenoids and lycopene by breaking cell walls, but long harsh cooking destroys polyphenols and vitamin C. Fermentation creates peptides and frees minerals, but it can also break down some polyphenols. Drying concentrates the compounds by removing water, but it can also oxidise them if the temperature is high. Freezing holds most bioactives well, because the cold slows the reactions that destroy them.

A food technologist who wants to keep a bioactive must test the product through its life: after processing, after packing, and at the end of shelf life. A juice that holds 100 mg of polyphenols on the day it is made and 40 mg after three months has lost more than half its benefit, and the label should not claim the day one number. Light is a common destroyer: a clear bottle on a bright shelf loses polyphenols faster than a dark bottle, so the pack is part of the product.

Three families of bioactive compounds

Polyphenols: tea, cocoa, berries, apples. Colour and bitter taste, broken down by gut bacteria
↓
Carotenoids: carrots, tomatoes, green leaves. Yellow, orange, red pigments, need fat to be absorbed
↓
Peptides: milk, soy, egg, fish. Small protein pieces released by fermentation or enzymes
↓
Other bioactives: glucosinolates in broccoli, allicin in garlic, plant sterols in spreads

Deriving percent retention step by step: from lab numbers to a label dose

The worked example in the next section uses percent retention to judge a tomato sauce. This section derives the formula, so the reader can work it out for any bioactive, and can check whether a label dose survives processing and storage.

Step 1 is to measure the same thing twice, in the same units. Measure the bioactive in the food before processing, and again after processing, or at the start of storage and again at the end. The two numbers must use the same basis: per 100 g of food, per serving, or per gram of dry matter. A number per 100 g before processing cannot be compared with a number per serving after processing, because the serving and the water content may have changed.

Step 2 is the ratio. Write the amount left over the amount at the start: amount after divided by amount before. If a sauce holds 8 mg of lycopene per 100 g before heating and 7 mg after heating, the ratio is 7 divided by 8, which is 0.875.

Step 3 is the percent. Multiply the ratio by 100: 0.875 times 100 is 87.5 percent. So the retention is 87.5 percent, and the loss is 100 minus 87.5, which is 12.5 percent. In symbols: percent retention equals amount after divided by amount before, times 100.

Step 4 is the correction the careless maker forgets: water loss. If heating drives water out of the food, the food weighs less, and the bioactive per 100 g can rise even while the total bioactive falls. A sauce that loses 10 percent of its water and 12.5 percent of its lycopene will show almost no fall per 100 g, because the two losses nearly cancel. The honest check uses the total amount in the batch, or the amount per gram of dry matter, where water loss cannot hide the fall. A retention figure that does not state its basis is not a complete figure.

Step 5 is the label dose. The dose on the pack must be the amount at the end of the shelf life, worked out from the retention at the end of storage. If a juice starts at 100 mg of vitamin C per serving and its retention after six months is 70 percent, the amount at the end of life is 70 mg, and the label must be written from 70 mg, not 100 mg. If the claim needs 80 mg, the maker must raise the starting dose, shorten the shelf life, or change the pack, and must measure again to prove the fix.

A worked example: lycopene in tomato sauce

A 100 g serving of raw tomato holds about 3 mg of lycopene, but only a small share is absorbed, because the pigment is locked inside the cells. A 100 g serving of tomato sauce holds about 10 mg of lycopene, because the sauce is concentrated, and more of it is absorbed, because cooking broke the cells and the oil in the sauce dissolved the pigment. The sauce gives more lycopene and more available lycopene than the raw tomato, even though the raw tomato looks fresher. Processing, done well, can raise the benefit, not only lower it.

Questions to think about

  • Why does a salad with a spoon of oil give more carotenoids than the same salad with no oil?
  • A polyphenol supplement holds a high dose of one compound. Why might it not work as well as the food it came from?
  • How does fermentation create peptides that the original milk did not hold?
Think about the oil question before you read on

Carotenoids are fat soluble, which means they must dissolve in fat to pass through the gut wall. A salad with no oil gives the pigment nothing to dissolve in, so most of it passes through unused. A spoon of oil dissolves the pigment and carries it into the body. The fat is not an extra, it is the carrier.

Practical note: When you cook tomatoes, add a spoon of oil and cook them gently for a few minutes. The heat breaks the cell walls and frees the lycopene, and the oil dissolves it. A raw tomato salad with oil also works, but a cooked sauce gives more available lycopene per serving. The same rule applies to carrots: a little oil and gentle cooking gives more beta-carotene than raw carrot alone.

Quick self-check

Question: What is a bioactive compound, and how is it different from a vitamin?

A bioactive compound acts on the body beyond giving energy or basic nutrition, but the body does not need it to live. A vitamin is a nutrient the body needs in a set amount to avoid deficiency. Polyphenols and carotenoids are bioactives; vitamin C and vitamin D are vitamins.

Question: Why are most polyphenols poorly absorbed, and where does their benefit come from?

Most polyphenols are large molecules that the gut absorbs poorly. Gut bacteria break them into smaller compounds that are absorbed instead, and the polyphenols also feed the gut bacteria themselves. The benefit may come from those smaller compounds and from the effect on the bacteria.

Question: What are ACE inhibitory peptides, and where do they come from?

They are small peptides that lower blood pressure by blocking the enzyme that raises it. They are made when milk casein is fermented or cut by enzymes, as in fermented milk drinks, cheese, and yoghurt.

Measuring bioactives in the laboratory

Bioactive compounds are measured by methods that suit each family. Polyphenols are measured by colour methods, where a reagent turns blue in proportion to the polyphenol content, and the result is reported as gallic acid equivalents, a standard that lets different foods be compared. The colour method is quick, but it measures all polyphenols together, not one kind, and other compounds in the food can interfere with the colour.

Carotenoids are measured by high performance liquid chromatography, known as HPLC, which separates the pigments and measures each one: beta-carotene, lycopene, lutein, and zeaxanthin each give their own peak. The method is accurate, but it is slow and costly, and the sample must be protected from light and heat, or the pigments break down before they are measured. Peptides are measured by chromatography and by mass spectrometry, which separates the small chains and names them by their mass. The method can tell Val-Pro-Pro from Ile-Pro-Pro, which a colour method cannot.

A food technologist who reads a bioactive result should check the method, because two methods can give different numbers for the same food. A colour method that reports total polyphenols and an HPLC method that reports one flavonoid are measuring different things, and the numbers cannot be compared directly. The method, the standard, and the sample preparation must all be stated, or the number is not a complete result.

Try it yourself

Eat a rainbow for one day: a red food, an orange food, a yellow food, a green food, and a blue or purple food. Write down each food and the colour, and look up which bioactive gives the colour: lycopene for red tomato, beta-carotene for orange carrot, lutein for green spinach, anthocyanins for blue berries. Then cook one of them with a spoon of oil and eat it, and eat another raw with no oil. The coloured foods are the bioactives on your plate, and the oil is the carrier that helps your body use them. Keep the list: it is a simple way to see how varied your diet is.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Bioactive compounds act on the body beyond basic nutrition, but the body does not need them to live.
  • Polyphenols give plants colour and bitter taste, are poorly absorbed, and are broken down by gut bacteria into smaller compounds.
  • Carotenoids are yellow, orange, and red pigments, need fat to be absorbed, and are freed by gentle cooking.
  • Lycopene is better absorbed from cooked tomato sauce with oil than from raw tomato.
  • Lutein and zeaxanthin sit in the eye and help protect vision.
  • Peptides are small protein pieces released by fermentation or enzymes, and some lower blood pressure.
  • Processing can raise a bioactive, as cooking frees lycopene, or lower it, as harsh heat destroys polyphenols, so the product must be tested through shelf life.

Glossary

Bioactive compound

A compound in a food that acts on the body beyond giving energy or basic nutrition. Food tech example: anthocyanins in blueberries are bioactive compounds that give the blue colour.

Polyphenol

A large family of plant compounds that give colour and bitter taste and protect the plant. Food tech example: catechins in green tea are polyphenols.

Flavonoid

A group of polyphenols found in tea, cocoa, berries, and onions. Food tech example: flavanols in dark chocolate are flavonoids.

Anthocyanin

A red, blue, or purple pigment in berries and grapes, a type of flavonoid. Food tech example: anthocyanins give blueberries their blue colour.

Carotenoid

A yellow, orange, or red pigment in fruit and vegetables. Food tech example: beta-carotene in carrots is a carotenoid that the body turns into vitamin A.

Lycopene

The red pigment in tomatoes, better absorbed when tomatoes are cooked with oil. Food tech example: tomato sauce gives more available lycopene than raw tomato.

Lutein

A carotenoid that sits in the eye and filters blue light. Food tech example: spinach and egg yolk are rich in lutein.

Peptide

A short chain of amino acids, smaller than a protein. Food tech example: small peptides released during cheese ripening give flavour and may lower blood pressure.

ACE inhibitory peptide

A peptide that lowers blood pressure by blocking the enzyme that raises it. Food tech example: Val-Pro-Pro from fermented milk is an ACE inhibitory peptide.

Antioxidant

A compound that neutralises free radicals, reactive molecules that can damage cells. Food tech example: polyphenols act as antioxidants in a laboratory dish, though their effect in the body is more complex.

Free radical

A reactive molecule that can damage cells. Food tech example: the body makes free radicals during normal metabolism, and antioxidants neutralise them.

Glucosinolate

A compound in cruciferous vegetables that breaks down into isothiocyanates when the vegetable is cut. Food tech example: broccoli holds glucosinolates that make sulforaphane.

Sulforaphane

A compound made from broccoli that activates the body's defence enzymes. Food tech example: eating broccoli regularly raises the activity of defence enzymes.

Allicin

A compound made when garlic is crushed, giving its smell and sharp taste. Food tech example: garlic crushed and left for a few minutes before cooking gives more allicin.

Percent retention

The share of a bioactive left after processing or storage, worked out as the amount after divided by the amount before, times 100. Food tech example: a sauce with 7 mg of lycopene left from 8 mg has a retention of 87.5 percent.

Dry matter basis

Stating an amount per gram of dry matter, so that water loss cannot hide a fall in the bioactive. Food tech example: a retention figure on a dry matter basis shows the true lycopene loss when heating drives water out.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Goldberg, I., Functional Foods: Designer Foods, Pharmafoods, Nutraceuticals, 1994.
  • Manach, C., Scalbert, A., Morand, C., Remesy, C. and Jimenez, L., Polyphenols: Food Sources and Bioavailability, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2004.

Unit 3: Functional Beverages: Energy, Immunity, Sleep and Hydration

Note

Unit 3: Functional Beverages: Energy, Immunity, Sleep and Hydration

A question to start with

A bottle of water, a cup of coffee, a sports drink, and a small shot that promises better sleep sit on a shelf. All four are drinks, but they do very different jobs, and the buyer who picks the wrong one gets the wrong result: a drink for energy before bed, a drink for sleep before a run, or a drink for hydration that is mostly sugar. This unit explains the main functional beverages, what each one is meant to do, how it works, and what to watch for on the label.

A functional beverage is a drink that gives a benefit beyond thirst. Water gives hydration, which is itself a benefit, but a functional beverage adds something more: caffeine for alertness, electrolytes for rehydration, protein for recovery, a probiotic for the gut, or a plant extract for calm. The drink is the carrier, and the benefit comes from the ingredient dissolved or suspended in it. The challenge for the maker is to keep the ingredient stable in water, to make the drink taste good, and to prove the dose is right.

Energy drinks and caffeine

Caffeine is the most used functional ingredient in the world. It blocks the brain's sleep signal, adenosine, so the person feels alert and less tired. A cup of coffee gives about 80 to 100 mg of caffeine, a cup of tea gives about 40 to 50 mg, and an energy drink gives about 80 mg per 250 ml can, though the amount varies by brand. The effect starts in about 30 minutes and lasts for three to five hours, because caffeine is cleared slowly from the body.

Energy drinks add sugar, B vitamins, and other compounds to the caffeine. The sugar gives fast energy, but a 500 ml can may hold 50 g of sugar, which is a large amount in one drink. The B vitamins are added for the claim, but most people already get enough B vitamins from food, so the extra gives no benefit. Taurine and glucuronolactone are added to many energy drinks, but the evidence that they add anything beyond caffeine is weak. The honest statement is that an energy drink is a caffeine drink with sugar: the caffeine does the work, and the rest is flavour and marketing.

Caffeine has a safe range and a risk. Most healthy adults can take up to about 400 mg a day without harm, which is about four cups of coffee. Above that, caffeine causes a racing heart, shaking, anxiety, and poor sleep. Children, pregnant women, and people with heart problems should take far less, and energy drinks are not made for them. A label that says high caffeine content and not recommended for children is a warning that should be read, not skipped. Mixing an energy drink with alcohol is a risk, because the caffeine masks the feeling of being drunk, so the person drinks more.

Sports drinks and hydration

A sports drink is made for a person who is sweating. Sweat is mostly water, with salt, mainly sodium, and small amounts of potassium. A drink that replaces only water dilutes the blood and can lower blood sodium, which is a risk in long exercise. A sports drink replaces water, salt, and a little sugar, so that the body can keep going.

The sugar in a sports drink is not there for sweetness alone: it helps the gut absorb water. When sugar and sodium are together in the gut, they are absorbed together, and water follows them. A drink with about 6 percent sugar, which is 6 g per 100 ml, and about 20 to 30 mmol per litre of sodium, is absorbed faster than plain water. A drink with much more sugar, above 8 percent, is absorbed more slowly, because the gut must dilute it first. That is why a soft drink, with about 10 percent sugar, is a poor sports drink, even though it is wet: it sits in the stomach and sloshes.

A sports drink is needed only when exercise lasts more than an hour, or when the person is sweating heavily in heat. For a short walk, a gym session of 30 minutes, or a normal day, water is enough. The drink is a tool for a specific job, and using it for a job that water would do is a waste of sugar and money. After exercise, a drink with protein helps recovery, and a meal with salt replaces what was lost better than a drink alone.

Immunity drinks

Drinks that claim to support immunity usually add vitamin C, vitamin D, zinc, or a probiotic. Vitamin C is needed for immune cells, and a person who is short of it gets more infections, but a person who already gets enough from food gains little from extra. The dose in a drink is often 100 percent of the daily need, which is enough to fill a gap but not to boost immunity above normal. Vitamin D is different: many people are short of it, especially in winter, and a drink with added vitamin D can fill the gap. Zinc is needed for immune cells too, but the dose must be small: too much zinc blocks copper absorption and causes nausea.

A probiotic drink adds a live culture, and it must be kept chilled and drunk before the best before date, or the live count falls. The strain and the dose must be named, as Unit 2 of the gut health subject explains. A drink that says it holds probiotics but names no strain and no dose is making a claim that cannot be checked. The honest immunity drink is one that fills a real gap, vitamin D in winter, or vitamin C for a person who eats little fruit, and says so plainly.

Sleep and calm drinks

Drinks for sleep and calm are a newer group, and the evidence is thinner. They add compounds such as theanine from tea, magnesium, melatonin, or plant extracts such as chamomile, valerian, and ashwagandha. Theanine is an amino acid from tea that promotes calm without sleepiness, and trials show a small effect on relaxation. Magnesium is needed for muscle and nerve function, and a person short of it may sleep worse, but extra magnesium does not help a person who already gets enough. Melatonin is a hormone that signals night, and a small dose can help a person fall asleep, but melatonin is a medicine in some markets and a food ingredient in others, and the rules differ.

Chamomile and valerian have been used for centuries as calm drinks, but the trials are small and the results are mixed. A cup of chamomile tea is a pleasant ritual, and the ritual itself may help sleep more than the plant. A drink that promises sleep should be judged with care: the dose must be named, the trial must be in people, and the claim must be one that is allowed. A drink that says it helps you fall asleep is making a strong claim, and the evidence for most sleep drinks is not strong enough to support it.

Hydration drinks and flavoured water

The simplest functional beverage is flavoured water: water with a little flavour, sometimes with a vitamin or a mineral, and no sugar or a low calorie sweetener. It hydrates as well as water, and it suits a person who finds plain water boring. The benefit is that the person drinks more, and drinking more is the benefit. A water with added electrolytes suits a person who sweats, but a water with added sugar is a soft drink, not a hydration drink, however the label words it.

Coconut water is sold as a natural hydration drink. It holds potassium, a little sodium, and about 5 percent sugar. It hydrates well, but it is low in sodium, so it is not a full replacement for sweat loss in long exercise. It is a pleasant drink, and it is better than a sugary soft drink, but it is not a sports drink. The label should be read for sugar and salt, not only for the word natural.

Making a functional beverage: stability and taste

A functional beverage is hard to make, because water is a difficult carrier. Vitamins break down in light and in acid, probiotics die in heat and in acid, protein settles and turns cloudy, and plant extracts taste bitter. The maker must test the drink through its life: after filling, after heating for safety, and at the end of shelf life. A vitamin C drink that loses half its vitamin C in a month on a bright shelf is not functional at the end of its life, however good it was on the day it was made.

The pack is part of the product. A clear bottle lets light in and destroys vitamins, so a dark bottle or a carton is better for a vitamin drink. A probiotic drink needs chilling from the factory to the fridge, and a break in the cold chain kills the culture. A protein drink needs a stabiliser to stop settling, as the protein subject explains. The maker must also choose the flavour that masks the ingredient: citrus masks vitamin C, chocolate masks protein, and a strong fruit flavour masks a plant extract. A drink that tastes bad will not be bought twice, however good its numbers look.

Choosing the right drink for the job

Thirst and a normal day: water, or flavoured water with no sugar
↓
Alertness: coffee or tea, caffeine about 80 to 100 mg per cup
↓
Exercise over one hour: sports drink, about 6 percent sugar plus sodium
↓
Recovery after exercise: a drink with protein, about 20 to 25 g
↓
Sleep: a warm, caffeine free drink and a regular bedtime, not a promise on a bottle

A worked example: reading an energy drink label

A 500 ml can says it gives energy and holds 160 mg of caffeine, 55 g of sugar, and B vitamins. The caffeine is two cups of coffee in one can, and the sugar is about 14 teaspoons. A person who drinks the whole can takes in 160 mg of caffeine and 220 kcal of sugar. If they drink a second can, they reach 320 mg of caffeine, close to the daily limit for a healthy adult, and 110 g of sugar. The B vitamins add nothing for a person who eats normally. The label also says high caffeine content, not recommended for children, pregnant women, or people sensitive to caffeine. That warning is the most honest line on the can, and it should decide who drinks it.

Questions to think about

  • Why is a soft drink with 10 percent sugar a poor sports drink, even though it is wet?
  • An energy drink holds caffeine, sugar, and B vitamins. Which one does the work, and why?
  • A sleep drink promises better sleep. What would you check before believing it?
Think about the sports drink question before you read on

A drink with about 6 percent sugar and sodium is absorbed fast, because sugar and sodium are taken up together and water follows them. A drink with 10 percent sugar is absorbed slowly, because the gut must dilute it first, so it sits in the stomach and sloshes. The soft drink is wet, but it is not a good hydration drink during exercise.

Practical note: When you exercise for more than an hour, drink a sports drink with about 6 percent sugar and salt, and drink it in small sips through the session, not all at once at the end. A 500 ml bottle drunk slowly over an hour replaces water and salt as they are lost. For a session under an hour, water is enough, and the sports drink is a waste of sugar.

Quick self-check

Question: How does caffeine make a person feel alert?

Caffeine blocks adenosine, the brain's sleep signal, so the person feels alert and less tired. The effect starts in about 30 minutes and lasts for three to five hours, because caffeine is cleared slowly from the body.

Question: Why does a sports drink hold sugar as well as salt?

Because sugar and sodium are absorbed together in the gut, and water follows them. A drink with about 6 percent sugar and sodium is absorbed faster than plain water, which is what an athlete needs during long exercise.

Question: Why is a probiotic drink that is not chilled a risk?

Because the live microbes die in heat and over time. A probiotic drink kept warm or drunk past its best before date may hold far fewer live cells than the label promises, so the dose is lost.

Coffee and tea: the oldest functional beverages

Coffee and tea are the oldest functional beverages, drunk for centuries before the word functional existed. Coffee gives caffeine, about 80 to 100 mg per cup, and polyphenols, mainly chlorogenic acids, which give a bitter taste and which gut bacteria break down into smaller compounds. Trials link regular coffee drinking to a lower chance of some chronic diseases, though the evidence is observational and the cause is not settled. Coffee also raises blood pressure for a short time after drinking, and it can disturb sleep if drunk late in the day, so the timing matters as much as the dose.

Tea gives caffeine in a smaller dose, about 40 to 50 mg per cup, and theanine, the amino acid that promotes calm. The pair is why tea feels different from coffee: the caffeine gives alertness, and theanine softens the edge, so the drinker feels calm and alert together. Green tea gives catechins, black tea gives theaflavins, made when the leaves are oxidised, and both are polyphenols that gut bacteria break down. A cup of tea with milk gives less available polyphenol than a cup without milk, because milk protein binds some of the polyphenols, though the effect is small and the tea is still useful.

Both drinks show the same lesson as the rest of this unit: the benefit comes from the whole drink, in the amount people actually drink, over months and years, not from a single compound in a capsule. A person who drinks three cups of tea a day gets a steady supply of theanine and catechins, and a person who drinks coffee in the morning and not at night gets alertness without broken sleep. The habit is the dose.

Try it yourself

Collect three drinks from a shop: an energy drink, a sports drink, and a flavoured water. For each, write down the sugar per 100 ml, the caffeine if any, the salt if any, and the claim on the front. Work out the sugar in the whole bottle or can. Then ask: which drink suits a long run, which suits a desk worker who wants to stay alert, and which suits a person who is simply thirsty? Write one line for each drink naming the job it fits and the job it does not fit. The labels will tell you more than the front of the pack.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A functional beverage is a drink that gives a benefit beyond thirst, from an ingredient dissolved or suspended in it.
  • Caffeine blocks the sleep signal and gives alertness, but above about 400 mg a day it causes harm, and energy drinks are not for children.
  • A sports drink holds about 6 percent sugar plus sodium, so it is absorbed fast during long exercise; water is enough for short exercise.
  • Immunity drinks fill a gap, such as vitamin D in winter, but they do not boost immunity above normal in a person who already gets enough.
  • Sleep drinks have thin evidence, and the dose, the trial, and the allowed claim must all be checked.
  • Flavoured water hydrates as well as water, and it suits a person who finds plain water boring.
  • Water is a hard carrier: vitamins break down in light, probiotics die in heat, and the drink must be tested through shelf life.

Glossary

Caffeine

A compound in coffee, tea, and energy drinks that blocks the brain's sleep signal and gives alertness. Food tech example: a cup of coffee gives about 80 to 100 mg of caffeine.

Adenosine

A chemical in the brain that signals sleepiness and builds up during the day. Food tech example: caffeine blocks adenosine, so the person feels alert.

Electrolyte

A salt in body fluids, such as sodium and potassium, lost in sweat. Food tech example: a sports drink replaces sodium lost in sweat.

Taurine

A compound added to many energy drinks, with weak evidence that it adds anything beyond caffeine. Food tech example: taurine is listed on energy drink labels but does not drive the effect.

Theanine

An amino acid from tea that promotes calm without sleepiness. Food tech example: theanine is added to some calm drinks.

Melatonin

A hormone that signals night and helps a person fall asleep. Food tech example: melatonin is a medicine in some markets and a food ingredient in others, and the rules differ.

Chamomile

A plant used as a calm drink, with small and mixed trial evidence. Food tech example: a cup of chamomile tea is a pleasant ritual that may help sleep.

Coconut water

The liquid inside a coconut, sold as a natural hydration drink. Food tech example: coconut water holds potassium and about 5 percent sugar, but it is low in sodium.

Isotonic drink

A drink with about the same concentration of dissolved parts as body fluids, absorbed fast. Food tech example: a sports drink with about 6 percent sugar is isotonic.

Flavoured water

Water with a little flavour, sometimes with a vitamin or mineral, and no sugar. Food tech example: flavoured water hydrates as well as water and suits a person who finds plain water boring.

Glucuronolactone

A compound added to many energy drinks, with weak evidence that it adds anything beyond caffeine. Food tech example: glucuronolactone is listed on energy drink labels but does not drive the effect.

Sodium

A mineral lost in sweat, replaced by a sports drink. Food tech example: a sports drink holds about 20 to 30 mmol per litre of sodium.

References

  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development: From Concept to Marketplace, 3rd edition, 2011.
  • Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., Food Product Development: From Concept to the Marketplace, 1991.

Unit 4: Probiotics, Prebiotics and Synbiotics in Products

Note

Unit 4: Probiotics, Prebiotics and Synbiotics in Products

A question to start with

A yoghurt, a fibre bar, a baby formula, and a chilled drink all claim to help the gut. The yoghurt must be kept cold, the bar sits on a warm shelf for a year, the formula is a dry powder, and the drink is sold in a fridge. Four products, four different factories, and four different ways of keeping a gut health ingredient alive, or stable, until it is eaten. This unit explains how probiotics, prebiotics, and synbiotics are built into products, and what goes wrong when the product and the ingredient do not suit each other.

The first decision in a gut health product is which of the three to use. A probiotic suits a chilled, short life product, because the live microbes need cold and a short time. A prebiotic suits a dry, long life product, because fibre is stable and survives heat and storage. A synbiotic suits a product where the two can be tested together, such as a yoghurt with added inulin. A postbiotic suits a heated product, such as a soup or a biscuit, where live microbes would die. The product format decides the ingredient, not the other way round.

Probiotics in yoghurt and fermented drinks

Yoghurt is the oldest probiotic product, and it is still the best suited. The milk is pasteurised, cooled, and inoculated with the starter culture plus the probiotic strain. The yoghurt ferments, sets, and is cooled, and the probiotic strain must survive the acid, the cold, and the weeks on the shelf. The maker chooses a strain that survives acid well, such as Bifidobacterium lactis BB-12, and adds an overage, extra cells at the start, so that the count at the end of shelf life still matches the tested dose.

The dose is checked by counting live cells through shelf life. A sample is taken each week, the cells are grown on a plate, and the count is recorded. If the count falls below the tested dose before the best before date, the shelf life is shortened or the overage is raised. The count must be measured by a method that counts the probiotic strain, not only all the bacteria, because the starter culture is also present and it would hide the probiotic count.

Flavour matters too. A probiotic strain can make the yoghurt more sour, or give a yeasty note, or make the texture thinner. The maker tests the strain in a small batch first, tastes it through shelf life, and checks that the flavour stays acceptable. A yoghurt that tastes wrong will not be bought twice, however good its probiotic count is.

Probiotics in drinks, capsules, and powders

A chilled probiotic drink is made like a yoghurt, but thinner, and it is drunk rather than eaten. The culture is added to milk or to a juice base, and the drink is kept chilled. A juice based probiotic drink is harder, because the acid in the juice kills the bacteria faster than milk does. The maker must choose an acid tolerant strain, add a higher overage, and set a shorter shelf life. A drink that holds a probiotic in orange juice for three months is unlikely to hold the tested dose at the end, and the label should not promise it.

A probiotic capsule is a different product: the bacteria are freeze dried, packed in a capsule, and sold as a supplement, not as a food. The capsule protects the bacteria from acid in the stomach, and the dose is stated as CFU per capsule. A capsule is not a food, and it is not covered in this subject in detail, but a food technologist should know that a capsule and a yoghurt are judged by different rules, even when they hold the same strain.

A probiotic powder for a drink is made by freeze drying the bacteria and packing the powder in a sachet. The powder is stable at room temperature while it is dry, but it must be kept dry: a damp sachet kills the bacteria. The powder is mixed with water or milk and drunk at once. The sachet is a good format for a single dose, because the tub that is opened every day lets damp air in and the count falls.

Prebiotics in bars, cereals, and drinks

Prebiotics are easier to use than probiotics, because fibre is stable. Inulin is the most used prebiotic in products, because it dissolves easily, tastes mild and slightly sweet, and can be added to yoghurt, bars, cereals, and drinks. A bar with 5 g of inulin per serving gives a prebiotic dose, and the bar keeps for months without the fibre changing. A yoghurt with 3 g of inulin per pot gives a prebiotic dose and a synbiotic product when the yoghurt also holds a probiotic.

The dose must be balanced against gas. Inulin is fermented fast by gut bacteria, and a large dose causes gas and bloating. A product with 10 g of inulin per serving may give a strong prebiotic effect, but it may also cause discomfort, and the buyer will not eat it twice. The maker tests the dose in people, not only in the laboratory, and chooses a dose that gives a benefit without discomfort. A common dose in products is 3 to 5 g per serving.

Galacto-oligosaccharides are used in infant formula, where they mimic the sugars in human milk and feed Bifidobacterium in the baby's gut. The dose is set by the formula maker and by the rules for infant foods, which are strict. A formula that claims a prebiotic effect must show that the ingredient is safe for babies and that it gives the benefit at the dose in the formula. Infant formula is the most tightly controlled gut health product, and the evidence bar is higher than for any other food.

Synbiotics: building the pair

A synbiotic product holds a probiotic and a prebiotic together, and the pair must be tested together. The prebiotic should feed the probiotic strain, so that the live microbe survives better and works better. Inulin feeds Bifidobacterium well, so a yoghurt with BB-12 plus inulin is a sound pair. The same inulin may not feed a Lactobacillus strain as well, so the pair must be tested, not assumed.

The maker tests the pair in three ways. The probiotic count is measured through shelf life, to confirm the prebiotic does not harm it. The prebiotic is measured through shelf life, to confirm it is still there. And the product is tested in people, to confirm the pair gives the benefit that was claimed. A product that lists a probiotic and a prebiotic on the label but has never tested the pair is a synbiotic in name only.

Stability, storage, and the cold chain

The cold chain is the chain of chilled storage from the factory to the shop to the home fridge. A probiotic product that leaves the factory chilled, sits warm in a delivery van, and is then chilled again in the shop has suffered a break in the cold chain, and the live count may have fallen. The maker must test the product after a break, to see how much the count falls, and must set the shelf life for the worst case, not the best case.

A prebiotic product has no cold chain, but it has a moisture risk. A bar that absorbs moisture from the air turns soft and sticky, and a powder that absorbs moisture clumps and loses its flow. The pack must keep moisture out, and the product must be tested at warm and damp conditions, not only at room temperature. A product that is tested only in a cool dry laboratory will surprise the maker on a warm damp shelf.

Labelling a gut health product

A gut health product must name the strain or the fibre, state the dose per serving, and carry a claim that is allowed. The strain is written in full: genus, species, and strain code, such as Bifidobacterium lactis BB-12. The dose is written as CFU per serving for a probiotic, and as grams per serving for a prebiotic. The claim must be one that is authorised, and the wording must match the authorised wording. A product that says it holds probiotics but names no strain is making a claim that cannot be checked, and a buyer should not trust it.

The label must also carry the storage instruction: keep refrigerated for a probiotic yoghurt or drink, and store in a cool dry place for a prebiotic bar or powder. The best before date is the date to which the dose holds, not only the date to which the food is safe. A yoghurt that is safe to eat after its date but holds too few live cells is no longer a probiotic product, even though it is still food.

Matching the ingredient to the product

Chilled yoghurt and drinks: probiotic, live cells, short shelf life
↓
Dry bars, cereals, powders: prebiotic fibre, stable, long shelf life
↓
Heated soups and biscuits: postbiotic, no live cells needed
↓
Yoghurt plus inulin: synbiotic, a tested pair in one product

A worked example: does the count hold?

A yoghurt is made with 20 billion CFU of BB-12 per pot, and the tested dose is 10 billion per day. The maker tests the count each week. At week one, the count is 18 billion. At week two, it is 15 billion. At week three, it is 11 billion. At week four, it is 8 billion, below the tested dose. The shelf life is therefore set at three weeks, not four, because the count holds to the tested dose for three weeks only. The overage of 20 billion at the start is what gives three weeks of shelf life, and a maker who started with 10 billion would have only one week. The count, not the calendar, sets the shelf life.

Questions to think about

  • Why does a probiotic suit a chilled yoghurt, while a prebiotic suits a dry bar?
  • A yoghurt holds 20 billion CFU at the start and 8 billion at week four. Why is the shelf life set at three weeks?
  • A product lists a probiotic and a prebiotic on the label. Why must the pair be tested together?
Think about the first question before you read on

A probiotic is alive and needs cold and a short time to stay alive at the tested dose. A chilled yoghurt gives both. A dry bar gives neither: it sits warm for months, and live microbes would die. A prebiotic is a fibre, and fibre is stable in heat and in storage, so it suits a dry bar that keeps for a year. The product format decides the ingredient.

Practical note: When you test a new probiotic product, count the live cells at the start, in the middle, and at the end of shelf life, and plot the counts on a graph. The graph shows the rate of fall, and it tells you whether the shelf life is right, whether the overage is enough, and whether a break in the cold chain would push the count below the tested dose. A single count on the day of making tells you nothing about the end of shelf life.

Quick self-check

Question: Why must a probiotic yoghurt carry an overage of live cells?

Because the live count falls through shelf life, as cells die in the acid and the cold. The overage, extra cells at the start, makes sure the count at the end of shelf life still matches the tested dose. Without an overage, the yoghurt would fall below the dose before its best before date.

Question: Why is inulin the most used prebiotic in products?

Because it dissolves easily, tastes mild and slightly sweet, is stable in heat and storage, and feeds Bifidobacterium well. It can be added to yoghurt, bars, cereals, and drinks without changing the taste much.

Question: What must a gut health label name?

The strain in full for a probiotic, with genus, species, and strain code, the dose per serving as CFU for a probiotic or grams for a prebiotic, the storage instruction, and a claim that is allowed with the authorised wording.

Probiotics in cheese and other foods

Cheese can carry probiotics too, though it is harder than yoghurt. The cheese is made, salted, and ripened for weeks or months, and the probiotic strain must survive the salt, the acid, and the long ripening. The maker adds the strain to the milk with the starter culture, and the strain grows during the first days, then survives in the curd as the cheese ripens. A fresh cheese, such as a soft cheese eaten within weeks, holds the strain better than a hard cheese ripened for a year, because the long ripening and the low water give the strain a harder time.

The dose in cheese is checked the same way as in yoghurt: the live count is measured through shelf life, and the cheese is sold only while the count holds. The flavour must also be checked, because a probiotic strain can change the ripening and give a flavour that the buyer does not expect. A cheese that tastes wrong will not be bought twice, however good its probiotic count is.

Other foods that carry probiotics include fermented vegetables, such as kimchi and sauerkraut, where the live lactic acid bacteria are the probiotic, and fermented sausages, where the starter culture stays alive in the meat. These foods are probiotic in the broad sense, because they hold live microbes, but they are rarely called probiotics on the label, because the strain is not named and the dose is not tested. A food technologist should call them fermented foods, and reserve the word probiotic for a named strain at a tested dose, as Unit 2 of the gut health subject explains.

Try it yourself

Find two gut health products in a shop: a probiotic yoghurt and a prebiotic bar or cereal. For each, write down the strain or fibre name, the dose per serving, the storage instruction, and the best before date. Then ask: does the yoghurt name a strain and a dose, or only the words live cultures? Does the bar name the fibre and the grams per serving? Write one line for each product saying whether its claim can be checked from the label alone. The product that names the strain, the dose, and the storage is the one worth buying.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A probiotic suits a chilled, short life product; a prebiotic suits a dry, long life product; a postbiotic suits a heated product.
  • A probiotic yoghurt needs a strain that survives acid, an overage of live cells, and a count checked through shelf life.
  • A juice based probiotic drink is harder than a milk based one, because acid kills the bacteria faster.
  • Inulin is the most used prebiotic in products, at 3 to 5 g per serving, balanced against gas.
  • A synbiotic pair must be tested together: the prebiotic must feed the probiotic strain, and the pair must give the benefit.
  • The cold chain protects probiotics, and moisture protects prebiotics: a break in either can end the benefit.
  • A gut health label must name the strain or fibre, state the dose per serving, and carry an allowed claim.

Glossary

Overage

Extra live cells or nutrient added at the start to cover loss through shelf life. Food tech example: a yoghurt made with 20 billion CFU per pot holds 10 billion at the end of shelf life.

Cold chain

The chain of chilled storage from the factory to the shop to the home fridge. Food tech example: a break in the cold chain can kill the probiotic in a yoghurt.

Freeze dried

Dried by freezing and removing water, used to keep bacteria stable as a powder. Food tech example: freeze dried probiotic powder is packed in a sachet and mixed with water at once.

Colony forming unit

A count of live microbes, written as CFU, used to state a probiotic dose. Food tech example: a yoghurt with 10 billion CFU per pot holds 10 billion live cells.

Inulin

A fibre from chicory root and other plants, made of fructose chains, that feeds Bifidobacterium. Food tech example: inulin is added to yoghurt and bars as a prebiotic fibre.

Galacto-oligosaccharide

A short chain fibre of galactose units, made from lactose, that feeds Bifidobacterium. Food tech example: galacto-oligosaccharides are added to infant formula to mimic human milk sugars.

Synbiotic

A product that holds a probiotic and a prebiotic together as a tested pair. Food tech example: a yoghurt with BB-12 plus inulin is a synbiotic.

Postbiotic

A preparation of dead microbes, or of the compounds microbes make, that gives a health benefit. Food tech example: heat killed bacteria in a biscuit are a postbiotic.

Acid tolerant strain

A probiotic strain that survives acid well, suited to a juice drink or a sour yoghurt. Food tech example: an acid tolerant strain is chosen for a probiotic juice drink.

Infant formula

A food made to feed a baby who is not breastfed, tightly controlled by rules. Food tech example: infant formula with added galacto-oligosaccharides must show safety and benefit at the dose used.

Best before date

The date to which a food keeps its quality, including the dose of a probiotic. Food tech example: a yoghurt past its best before date may be safe but hold too few live cells.

Starter culture

A chosen mix of microbes added to a food to start fermentation. Food tech example: a yoghurt starter holds Streptococcus and Lactobacillus.

References

  • Gibson, G. R. and Roberfroid, M. B., Handbook of Prebiotics, 2008.
  • Holzapfel, W. H. and Schillinger, U., Introduction to Pre and Probiotics, Food Research International, 2002.
  • FAO and WHO, Guidelines for the Evaluation of Probiotics in Food, 2002.
  • Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development: From Concept to Marketplace, 3rd edition, 2011.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.

Unit 5: Protein and Fibre Fortification

Note

Unit 5: Protein and Fibre Fortification

A question to start with

A white loaf, a bowl of plain pasta, and a glass of juice all give energy, but none of them gives much protein or fibre. Add whey to the juice, add pea protein to the pasta, add bran to the loaf, and the same foods give far more protein and fibre, without changing the meal. That is fortification: adding a nutrient to a food that holds little of it, so that an ordinary food carries an extra benefit. This unit explains how protein and fibre are added to foods, what goes wrong, and how the dose is set.

Fortification is the adding of a nutrient to a food, either because the food holds little of it, or because the people who eat it need more of it. It is different from enrichment, which puts back a nutrient lost in processing, such as adding B vitamins to white flour. Fortification adds something new, such as adding protein to a juice or fibre to a biscuit. The nutrient may be added as a powder, a liquid, or a fibre, and the food must still taste like itself after the addition.

Why fortify with protein and fibre

Protein and fibre are the two nutrients most often added to foods, because they are the two that many diets lack. Protein is added to foods for people who need more of it: older adults, athletes, people recovering from illness, and people on medicines that lower appetite. Fibre is added to foods for people who eat too little of it: most adults eat about 15 g a day, against a target of 25 to 30 g, so a food that adds 5 g per serving closes a real gap.

Fortification is also a way to reach people who will not change their diet. A person who will not eat lentils may drink a protein juice. A person who will not eat bran may eat a fibre bar. The fortified food meets the person where they are, rather than asking them to change. That is its strength, and also its risk: a fortified food can give the impression that the diet is fixed, when only one nutrient has been added and the rest of the diet is still narrow.

Adding protein: which protein, and how much

The protein used for fortification is usually a powder: whey protein concentrate or isolate, soy protein isolate, pea protein isolate, or milk protein concentrate. The choice depends on the food. A clear juice needs whey isolate, because it dissolves clearly in acid. A milky drink needs milk protein concentrate or whey concentrate, because cloudiness is expected. A baked bar needs soy or pea protein, because they hold water and give body. A pasta needs pea or soy protein, because they survive the drying and cooking.

The dose is set by the claim. A food that claims to be a source of protein must give a set share of its energy from protein, or a set grams per serving, and the rule differs by market. A food that claims to be high in protein must give more. The maker works backwards from the claim: if the claim needs 10 g of protein per serving, and the food already holds 2 g, then 8 g must be added. If the protein powder is 80 percent protein, then 10 g of powder must be added per serving. The maths is simple, but the taste is not: 10 g of protein powder in a 200 ml juice changes the taste, the thickness, and the mouthfeel, and the maker must mask it with flavour and acid.

Protein fortification changes texture. In bread, added protein makes the dough stiffer and the loaf denser, because the protein absorbs water and interferes with the gluten network. In pasta, added protein makes the pasta firmer and less sticky, which is a benefit, but it can also make it tougher. In a drink, added protein makes the drink thicker and cloudier, and it can settle. In a biscuit, added protein makes the biscuit harder and drier. Each food has a limit: a bread can take about 5 percent added protein before the texture fails, a pasta can take about 10 percent, and a drink can take about 7 percent before it turns thick and chalky.

Adding fibre: which fibre, and how much

The fibre used for fortification is usually inulin, chicory root fibre, wheat bran, oat fibre, or psyllium husk. Inulin is the most used, because it dissolves easily, tastes mild, and can be added to drinks, yoghurts, and bars without changing the texture much. Wheat bran is used in bread and cereals, where its gritty texture is expected. Psyllium is used where a strong gel is wanted, but it must be dosed carefully, or the food turns to jelly.

The dose is set by the claim and by tolerance. A food that claims to be a source of fibre must hold a set amount per 100 g, and a food that claims to be high in fibre must hold more. A serving that adds 5 g of fibre is a useful dose, and it is tolerated by most people. A serving that adds 10 g may cause gas and bloating, because the gut bacteria ferment the fibre fast. The maker tests the dose in people and chooses a dose that gives a benefit without discomfort.

Fibre fortification changes texture too. In bread, added fibre makes the loaf denser and darker, and it absorbs water, so the recipe needs more water. In a biscuit, added fibre makes the biscuit harder and drier. In a drink, soluble fibre such as inulin dissolves and adds body, while insoluble fibre such as wheat bran settles and feels gritty. The maker must choose the fibre that suits the food: soluble fibre for a drink, insoluble fibre for a bread, and a blend for a bar.

The double fortification: protein plus fibre

A food fortified with both protein and fibre gives two benefits at once, and it is a popular format: a bar with 20 g of protein and 5 g of fibre, a drink with 15 g of protein and 3 g of fibre, a cereal with 10 g of protein and 6 g of fibre. The pair works well, because protein keeps the eater full and fibre slows digestion, so the two together give a longer feeling of fullness than either alone.

The pair also brings a practical problem: protein and fibre together absorb much water, so the food can turn dry and hard. A bar with both needs more syrup and more fat to stay soft, and a drink with both needs more water and a stabiliser to stay smooth. The maker must test the texture through shelf life, because a bar that is soft on the day it is made can turn hard in a month as the protein and fibre bind water.

Fortification for special groups

Fortification is most useful for people who eat little. An older person who eats small meals needs protein and fibre in a small volume, so a small drink with 15 g of protein and 5 g of fibre is a useful tool. A child who eats little fruit and vegetables needs fibre in a food they will eat, such as a cereal or a bar. A person on a medicine that lowers appetite needs protein in a small, easy serving, such as a yoghurt or a soup.

Hospital food is the clearest case. A patient who eats half a portion gets half the protein, and the body needs protein to heal. A fortified soup, a fortified porridge, or a fortified drink gives the full protein in the half portion the patient actually eats. The fortification is not a luxury, it is the difference between healing and losing muscle. The dose must be set by the dietitian, and the food must be tested for taste, because a patient who will not eat it gains nothing.

Checking a fortified food

A fortified food is checked in three ways. The nutrient is measured in the laboratory, to confirm the amount matches the label. The texture and flavour are checked through shelf life, to confirm the food stays acceptable. And the claim is checked against the rules, to confirm the dose meets the threshold for the claim. A food that holds less protein than the label says, or that turns hard in a month, or that claims high protein without meeting the threshold, has failed one of the three checks.

A worked example shows the label maths. A juice holds 200 ml per serving and the maker wants to claim it is a source of protein. The rule asks for at least 5 g of protein per serving. The juice naturally holds 0.5 g, so 4.5 g must be added. The maker uses whey protein isolate at 90 percent protein, so 5 g of powder must be added per serving. The powder costs money, changes the taste, and makes the juice cloudy, so the maker tests the juice with a panel and finds that 5 g is acceptable but 10 g is not. The claim is source of protein, not high protein, because the dose that tastes good is 5 g, not 10 g. The taste sets the claim, not the other way round.

How to fortify a food with protein and fibre

Step 1: Choose the claim, and work out the dose it needs per serving
↓
Step 2: Choose the protein and fibre that suit the food: clear whey for juice, inulin for a drink, bran for bread
↓
Step 3: Work out the powder needed from the protein and fibre content of the ingredient
↓
Step 4: Test taste, texture, and stability through shelf life
↓
Step 5: Measure the nutrient in the laboratory and check the claim against the rules

Questions to think about

  • A juice maker wants to add 10 g of protein per serving, but the panel says the juice tastes chalky. What should the maker do?
  • Why does added protein make bread denser, and what must the recipe change to fix it?
  • A bar holds 20 g of protein and 5 g of fibre. Why might it turn hard on the shelf?
Think about the juice question before you read on

The maker has three honest choices: lower the dose to the amount that tastes good and claim source of protein instead of high protein, change the protein to one that dissolves more clearly, such as whey isolate, or change the flavour to one that masks the protein, such as a strong citrus flavour. What the maker must not do is keep the dose and the claim while the taste fails, because a drink that tastes bad will not be bought twice.

Practical note: When you add protein powder to a food at home, add it slowly and mix it well. A spoon of whey powder stirred into porridge disappears, but a spoon dumped into a cold drink forms lumps. Mix the powder with a little warm liquid first to make a paste, then add the rest. The same rule applies in a factory: the powder must be wetted evenly, or it will form lumps that no amount of stirring will break.

Quick self-check

Question: What is the difference between fortification and enrichment?

Fortification adds a nutrient to a food that holds little of it, such as adding protein to a juice. Enrichment puts back a nutrient lost in processing, such as adding B vitamins to white flour. One adds something new, the other restores something lost.

Question: Why is inulin the most used fibre for fortification?

Because it dissolves easily, tastes mild and slightly sweet, is stable in heat and storage, and can be added to drinks, yoghurts, and bars without changing the texture much. A dose of 3 to 5 g per serving is tolerated by most people.

Question: Why does a food fortified with both protein and fibre turn hard on the shelf?

Because protein and fibre together absorb water and bind it, so the food loses its soft moisture. A bar with both needs more syrup and fat to stay soft, and the texture must be tested through shelf life, not only on the day it is made.

Fortification and the label: a closer look

A fortified food must state the added nutrient on the label, and the statement must be true through shelf life. Protein is stable, so a bar that holds 20 g of protein on the day it is made will hold close to 20 g at the end of shelf life, and the label is easy to keep true. Fibre is also stable, so a cereal that holds 6 g of fibre per serving will hold it for months. Vitamins are different: vitamin C and some B vitamins break down in light and in heat, so a drink that holds 100 percent of the daily need on the day it is made may hold only 60 percent after three months. The maker must add an overage, extra vitamin at the start, so that the amount at the end of shelf life still matches the label.

The label must also state the nutrient per 100 g and per serving, so that the buyer can compare products. A drink that says high protein must state the protein per 100 ml and per serving, and the serving must be the amount a person usually drinks. A maker who sets a small serving to make the protein look high per serving, while the protein per 100 ml is low, is misleading the buyer, even when the numbers are true. The serving must be honest, and the numbers must be checked by laboratory testing, not only by calculation from the recipe.

Try it yourself

Take a plain food from your kitchen, such as a bowl of porridge or a glass of milk, and fortify it yourself. Add a spoon of whey protein powder to the porridge and a spoon of oat bran to the milk, and write down what changes: taste, thickness, and how full you feel after an hour. Then work out the protein and fibre you added from the labels on the powders. The change you taste is the change a factory must manage, and the numbers you work out are the numbers a label must state. A fortified food is a plain food with a number added, and the number must be true.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Fortification adds a nutrient to a food that holds little of it, so that an ordinary food carries an extra benefit.
  • Protein is added as a powder, and the choice depends on the food: whey isolate for a clear juice, soy or pea for a bar, milk protein for a milky drink.
  • Fibre is added as inulin, bran, oat fibre, or psyllium, and the dose is balanced against gas and texture.
  • Protein and fibre together give a longer feeling of fullness than either alone, but they absorb water and can make a food hard.
  • Fortification is most useful for people who eat little: older adults, patients, and people on medicines that lower appetite.
  • The dose is set by the claim, the taste sets the limit, and the nutrient must be measured in the laboratory to confirm the label.

Glossary

Fortification

Adding a nutrient to a food that holds little of it. Food tech example: adding whey protein to a juice is fortification.

Enrichment

Putting back a nutrient lost in processing. Food tech example: adding B vitamins to white flour is enrichment.

Whey protein isolate

A dried whey powder holding about 90 percent protein, which dissolves clearly in water. Food tech example: whey protein isolate is used to fortify a clear juice.

Soy protein isolate

A dried soy powder holding about 90 percent protein. Food tech example: soy protein isolate is used to fortify bars and pasta.

Pea protein isolate

A dried pea powder holding about 80 percent protein. Food tech example: pea protein isolate is used to fortify plant based drinks and bars.

Inulin

A fibre from chicory root and other plants, made of fructose chains, that feeds Bifidobacterium. Food tech example: inulin is added to yoghurt and bars as a prebiotic fibre.

Chicory root fibre

A fibre from chicory root added to bars and drinks to raise fibre and add bulk. Food tech example: chicory root fibre is used in high fibre protein bars.

Oat fibre

Fibre from oat hulls, added to bread and cereals to raise fibre. Food tech example: oat fibre is added to a breakfast cereal to raise its fibre per serving.

Psyllium husk

The husk of psyllium seed, rich in soluble fibre that forms a strong gel. Food tech example: psyllium husk is added to bread to raise fibre and hold water.

Milk protein concentrate

A dried milk powder holding about 80 percent protein, with casein and whey together. Food tech example: milk protein concentrate is used to fortify a milky drink.

Mouthfeel

How a food feels in the mouth, such as thick, chalky, or smooth. Food tech example: added protein can make a drink feel chalky, which the maker must mask.

Fullness

The feeling of being satisfied after eating, which protein and fibre both raise. Food tech example: a bar with protein and fibre keeps a person full longer than a bar with sugar alone.

References

  • Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development: From Concept to Marketplace, 3rd edition, 2011.
  • Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., Food Product Development: From Concept to the Marketplace, 1991.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.

Unit 6: Claims, Labelling and Evidence

Note

Unit 6: Claims, Labelling and Evidence

A question to start with

A spread says it helps maintain normal blood cholesterol. A yoghurt says it supports digestive health. A drink says it boosts immunity. Three claims, three different words, and three different levels of proof behind them. Which claims can a maker legally use, which claims need proof, and how does a buyer tell a strong claim from a weak one? This unit explains the rules for health claims, the evidence behind them, and the labelling that turns a laboratory result into words on a pack.

A claim is a statement on a pack, in an advert, or on a website that says a food does something for health. Claims fall into three groups. A nutrition claim says what a food holds, such as high in fibre, source of protein, or low in salt. A health claim says what a food does, such as helps maintain normal blood cholesterol, or helps normal bowel function. A medical claim says a food treats, prevents, or cures a disease, such as treats high cholesterol, and a food may not make a medical claim. The three groups are judged by different rules, and a food technologist must know which group a statement falls into before writing it.

Nutrition claims: the numbers on the pack

A nutrition claim is a statement about the amount of a nutrient in a food. The rules set a threshold for each claim, and the food must meet it. A food that says high in fibre must hold a set amount of fibre per 100 g, and the amount differs by market. A food that says source of protein must hold a set share of its energy from protein, or a set grams per serving. A food that says low in salt must hold less than a set amount of salt per 100 g.

The threshold is checked by laboratory testing, and the food must meet it in every batch, not only in the first batch. A maker who uses a threshold must set the recipe above it, with an overage, so that normal variation stays above the line. A food that meets the threshold in one season and fails in the next, because the raw material changed, has a labelling fault, and the claim must be removed until the recipe is fixed.

The nutrition table on the back of the pack states the amounts per 100 g or 100 ml and per serving, for energy, protein, carbohydrate, sugars, fat, saturated fat, fibre, and salt. The serving is the amount a person usually eats at one time, and it is set by the maker. The table must be accurate, and it must be checked by testing, not only by calculation from the recipe. A recipe calculation is a good start, but the laboratory result is the proof.

Health claims: authorised wording only

A health claim is a statement that a food or an ingredient helps health, and it must be authorised. A maker who wants to use a health claim must submit the evidence to the authority, and the authority judges whether the trials are good enough. If the claim is authorised, it is listed with the exact wording that may be used, and the maker must use that wording, not a paraphrase. If the claim is not authorised, it may not be used, even when the maker believes it is true.

The evidence for a health claim must come from human trials, and it must match the product. A trial that tested 3 g of beta-glucan a day supports a claim for a product that gives 3 g a day, but it does not support a product that gives 1 g a day. A trial that tested a strain for diarrhoea supports a claim for diarrhoea, but it does not support a claim for bloating. A trial that tested adults supports a claim for adults, but it does not support a claim for children. The claim, the dose, the problem, and the people must all match the trial.

The wording matters. A claim that says helps maintain normal blood cholesterol is allowed, because it talks about maintaining a normal state. A claim that says lowers high cholesterol is a medical claim, because it talks about treating a condition, and a food may not use it. The difference is one word, maintains against lowers, but the rules treat them very differently. A food technologist who writes a label must use the authorised wording exactly, because a paraphrase can turn a food claim into a medical claim.

The evidence ladder for claims

The evidence for a claim is judged on a ladder, as Unit 6 of the gut health subject explains. Laboratory studies show what is possible, animal studies show what happens in a living body, human studies show what happens in people, randomised controlled trials show what happens when people are split by chance, and systematic reviews gather all the trials and judge them together. A claim that rests only on a laboratory study is weak. A claim that rests on several randomised trials that agree is strong.

A marker is not an outcome. A study that shows a food raises the count of one bacterium in the stool has shown a marker, not a benefit. A study that shows the same food shortens diarrhoea by a day has shown an outcome, and the person feels the difference. The best claims rest on outcomes, and a claim that rests only on a marker is a weak claim, even when the marker sounds scientific.

The dose in the product must match the dose in the trial. A study that tested 2 g of plant sterols a day supports a product that gives 2 g a day, but it does not support a product that gives 0.5 g a day. A study that tested 10 billion CFU of a probiotic a day supports a product that gives 10 billion a day, but it does not support a product that gives 1 billion a day. The dose is the bridge between the trial and the product, and a claim without a matching dose is a broken bridge.

Allergen and ingredient labelling

A functional food must list its ingredients in order of weight, and it must declare the major allergens. The common functional ingredients are all major allergens: milk, soy, egg, peanut, tree nuts, wheat, and fish. A bar with whey must declare milk. A drink with soy protein must declare soy. A product with a plant sterol from soy must declare soy, even when the sterol itself is not a protein, because the source is soy and the rules ask for the source to be declared.

The allergen statement is often printed in bold within the ingredients list, or in a separate contains statement. A factory that makes several products on one line must manage cross contact: cleaning between runs, testing for residues, and carrying a may contain warning where the risk cannot be removed. A labelling error on a functional food is a safety error, not only a paperwork error, because the buyer may be allergic to the ingredient that was not declared.

The label must also state the amount of the active compound per serving, so that the buyer can judge the dose. A spread with plant sterols must state the sterols per serving. A yoghurt with a probiotic must state the strain and the CFU per serving. A drink with vitamin D must state the vitamin D per serving. A product that hides the dose behind a blend, a mix, or a vague word is making a claim that cannot be checked, and the buyer should not trust it.

Misleading claims: what to watch for

Several kinds of misleading claim are common in functional foods. The first is the pinch claim: a product that holds a tiny amount of a trendy ingredient, far below the tested dose, and claims the benefit of the full dose. A drink with 0.1 g of beta-glucan that claims to lower cholesterol is a pinch claim. The second is the borrowed claim: a product that uses a different strain, a different ingredient, or a different dose from the one that was tested, and claims the benefit of the tested one. A yoghurt with an untested strain that claims the benefit of a tested strain is a borrowed claim.

The third is the vague claim: a product that says supports wellness, boosts vitality, or helps your body, without naming a benefit that can be measured. Vague words are hard to challenge, but they are also hard to prove, and they tell the buyer nothing. The fourth is the implied medical claim: a product that says it helps with a disease by using words that suggest treatment, such as fights high cholesterol, or beats diabetes, without saying treats. The implication is a medical claim, even when the word treats is not used.

A food technologist who reviews a competitor's product should check for all four: the dose, the strain or ingredient, the wording, and the evidence. A product that fails any of them is a weak product, and a product that passes all of them is a strong one. The check takes minutes, and it is the most useful skill in this unit.

Checking a health claim in five steps

Step 1: Is the claim authorised, with the exact wording allowed?
↓
Step 2: Does the evidence come from human trials, not only a laboratory dish?
↓
Step 3: Does the dose in the product match the dose in the trial?
↓
Step 4: Does the strain, the ingredient, and the people match the trial?
↓
Step 5: Is the benefit an outcome a person feels, not only a marker?

Building the evidence file: what sits behind a claim

A claim on a pack is the tip of a file. Behind it sits an evidence file: the papers that prove the ingredient, the dose, the food, and the wording, kept in order so that any checker, any buyer, or any regulator can follow the claim back to its source. A maker who cannot produce the file cannot defend the claim, and a claim without a file is a guess with a label.

The file has five parts. The first is the ingredient identity: the name, the source, the form, and the specification, with a test that proves each batch matches it. A sterol from one supplier is not the same as a sterol from another if the purity differs, and the file must show which one was used. The second is the dose evidence: the studies that show the benefit at the dose in the product, with the dose, the people, and the time named. A study that used a daily dose for eight weeks cannot support a product eaten once a week at half the dose.

The third is the product evidence: the tests that show the ingredient survives the process and the shelf life, and that the amount at the end of shelf life still meets the dose. The retention data from Unit 9 belongs here, with the method, the dates, and the pack named. The fourth is the wording evidence: the exact claim on the pack, the rule that allows it, and the market where it is allowed, because the same words can be allowed in one market and banned in another. The fifth is the safety file: the evidence that the dose is safe for the people who will eat it, including the groups who should not eat it, such as pregnant women for high dose vitamin A, or people on certain medicines for high dose sterols.

The file is kept live. Every recipe change, every supplier change, and every new study is added, and the claim is rechecked. A file that was right last year can be wrong today, because a supplier changed, a rule changed, or a new study weakened the evidence. The maker who keeps the file live can answer a challenge in a day. The maker who built the file once and forgot it will spend weeks rebuilding it under pressure.

A short checklist closes the file: ingredient named, dose named, studies named, product tests named, wording checked against the current rule, safety checked for the target buyer, and the whole file dated and signed. A claim that passes the checklist can go on the pack. A claim that fails any line stays off until the missing paper is found.

A worked example: the sterol spread

A spread claims it helps maintain normal blood cholesterol, and the label says it holds 2 g of plant sterols per serving of 20 g. The tested dose for plant sterols is about 2 g a day, and the trials show a fall in blood cholesterol of about 10 percent at that dose. The spread gives the full dose in one serving, so a person who eats one serving a day gets the tested dose. The claim is authorised, the wording matches, the dose matches, and the benefit is an outcome, blood cholesterol, that can be measured. The claim is strong.

Now change one number: the spread holds 0.5 g of plant sterols per serving. The person would need four servings a day, 80 g of spread, to reach the tested dose, and few people eat that much spread. The claim is still on the pack, but the dose does not match, so the claim is weak. The spread is the same food, but the dose decides whether the claim is honest. The maker has three choices: raise the sterols to 2 g per serving, change the claim to a general nutrition claim, or drop the claim.

Questions to think about

  • A drink holds 0.1 g of beta-glucan per serving and claims to lower blood cholesterol. What is wrong with the claim?
  • A yoghurt with an untested strain claims the benefit of a tested strain. What is this called, and why is it wrong?
  • Why must a health claim use the authorised wording exactly, not a paraphrase?
Think about the drink question before you read on

The tested dose for beta-glucan is about 3 g a day, and the drink gives 0.1 g per serving, so the buyer would need 30 servings a day to reach the dose. The claim borrows the benefit of the full dose for a product that gives a pinch. It is a pinch claim, and it misleads the buyer, even though the ingredient is the right one.

Practical note: When you write a label for a functional food, write the claim last, not first. First, work out the dose in the product, then find the trial that tested that dose, then check whether the claim is authorised, and only then write the wording. A label written in that order is honest, because the claim follows the evidence. A label written the other way round, claim first and dose after, is a promise looking for proof, and it usually fails the check.

Quick self-check

Question: What is the difference between a nutrition claim and a health claim?

A nutrition claim says what a food holds, such as high in fibre or source of protein, and it must meet a set threshold. A health claim says what a food does, such as helps maintain normal blood cholesterol, and it must be authorised with the exact wording allowed.

Question: Why is a medical claim not allowed on a food?

Because a medical claim says a product treats, prevents, or cures a disease, and a product that makes such a claim is treated as a medicine, with testing and licensing under medical rules. A food may make a health claim, but it may not claim to treat a disease.

Question: What is a pinch claim?

A claim made by a product that holds a tiny amount of an ingredient, far below the tested dose, and claims the benefit of the full dose. A drink with 0.1 g of beta-glucan that claims to lower cholesterol is a pinch claim.

Try it yourself

Find a functional food in a shop and read its claim. Write down the claim word for word, the active ingredient and its amount per serving, and the number of servings needed to reach the tested dose if you know it. Then run the five step check from the diagram: authorised wording, human trials, matching dose, matching strain and people, and outcome rather than marker. Write a short verdict in three lines: what the claim says, what the evidence is, and whether the claim is strong or weak. Keep the verdict: it is the same check a food technologist does when a new product arrives for review.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A nutrition claim says what a food holds and must meet a set threshold; a health claim says what a food does and must be authorised.
  • A food may not make a medical claim that it treats, prevents, or cures a disease.
  • The evidence for a health claim must come from human trials, and the claim, the dose, the problem, and the people must all match the trial.
  • A marker is not an outcome: the best claims rest on a benefit a person feels, not only on a measurement.
  • The dose in the product must match the dose in the trial, or the claim is a pinch claim.
  • Allergens must be declared, and the active compound and its amount per serving must be stated on the label.
  • Write the claim last, after the dose, the trial, and the authorisation have been checked.

Glossary

Nutrition claim

A statement about the amount of a nutrient in a food, such as high in fibre. Food tech example: a cereal that says high in fibre must hold a set amount of fibre per 100 g.

Health claim

A statement that a food or an ingredient helps health, which must be authorised. Food tech example: a claim that oat beta-glucan helps maintain normal blood cholesterol must be authorised.

Medical claim

A statement that a product treats or prevents a disease, which puts it under medicine rules. Food tech example: a spread that says it treats high cholesterol is making a medical claim.

Authorised claim

A health claim that an authority has judged and allowed, with set wording. Food tech example: a maker may use only authorised claims on a label, with the exact wording allowed.

Pinch claim

A claim made by a product that holds a tiny amount of an ingredient, far below the tested dose. Food tech example: a drink with 0.1 g of beta-glucan that claims to lower cholesterol is a pinch claim.

Borrowed claim

A claim that uses the evidence of one strain or ingredient to sell a different one. Food tech example: a yoghurt with an untested strain that claims the benefit of a tested strain is a borrowed claim.

Marker

A measurement that may show a change in the body, such as a rise in one bacterium, without showing a benefit the person feels. Food tech example: a rise in Bifidobacterium in the stool is a marker, not proof of better health.

Outcome

A real result that a person feels, such as fewer days of diarrhoea. Food tech example: shortening diarrhoea by a day is an outcome, and it is stronger evidence than a marker.

Overage

Extra nutrient added above the label claim to cover variation between batches. Food tech example: a spread labelled 2 g of plant sterols per serving may be made with 2.2 g to cover variation.

Randomised controlled trial

A study where people are split by chance into a group that gets the food and a group that does not. Food tech example: a randomised trial of plant sterols for blood cholesterol is the strongest single study.

Systematic review

A review that gathers all the trials on one question and judges them together. Food tech example: a systematic review of beta-glucan trials confirms that it helps lower blood cholesterol.

Serving

The amount of a food a person usually eats at one time, set by the maker. Food tech example: a spread serving is 20 g, and the plant sterols are stated per serving.

Evidence file

The papers kept behind a claim that prove the ingredient, the dose, the product tests, the wording, and the safety. Food tech example: a sterol claim is defended by an evidence file that names the studies, the dose, and the shelf life tests.

Specification

The written standard for an ingredient: its name, source, form, purity, and the tests that prove each batch matches it. Food tech example: a sterol specification names the purity, so a cheaper sterol cannot be swapped in silently.

References

  • Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development: From Concept to Marketplace, 3rd edition, 2011.
  • Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., Food Product Development: From Concept to the Marketplace, 1991.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Gibson, G. R. and Roberfroid, M. B., Handbook of Prebiotics, 2008.
  • FAO and WHO, Guidelines for the Evaluation of Probiotics in Food, 2002.

Unit 7: Designing a Functional Product

Note

Unit 7: Designing a Functional Product

A question to start with

A maker has an idea: a drink that helps older people get more protein, a bar that helps a busy worker get more fibre, a spread that helps maintain normal cholesterol. The idea is easy to say, and hard to make real. Between the idea and the shop shelf sit a dozen decisions: who is it for, what is the benefit, what is the dose, what is the food, how will it taste, how will it keep, what will the label say, and how will anyone know it works? This unit walks through those decisions in order, so that a functional product is built on evidence, not on hope.

Designing a functional product starts with the eater, not with the ingredient. Who is the product for, and what do they need? An older person who eats little needs protein in a small, soft, easy serving. A busy worker who skips breakfast needs fibre and protein in a bar that fits in a pocket. A person with high cholesterol needs plant sterols in a food they already eat every day, such as a spread. A child who drinks little milk needs vitamin D in a drink they like. The eater decides the food, the serving, the taste, and the price. A product designed for everyone is designed for no one.

The second decision is the benefit, and it must be one benefit, not five. A product that claims to help cholesterol, gut health, immunity, energy, and sleep is claiming too much, and no trial supports all five. A product that claims one benefit, and proves it, is a strong product. The benefit must be one that matters to the eater, that can be measured, and that the ingredient can deliver at a dose the eater will take. A benefit that needs 10 g of an ingredient a day, in a serving that can hold only 2 g, is not a benefit, it is a wish.

Choosing the ingredient and the dose

The third decision is the ingredient. The maker looks for an ingredient with human trials behind it, at a dose that fits the serving, in a form that survives the food and the shelf. Plant sterols have trials at 2 g a day, and they fit a spread, where 20 g gives the full dose. Beta-glucan has trials at 3 g a day, and it fits a cereal, where a serving gives 1 g and three servings give the dose. A probiotic strain has trials at 10 billion CFU a day, and it fits a yoghurt, where one pot gives the dose. Inulin has trials at 3 to 5 g a day, and it fits a bar, where one bar gives the dose.

The dose is worked out backwards from the trial. If the trial used 2 g a day, and the serving is 20 g of spread, then the spread must hold 2 g per 20 g, which is 10 percent sterols. If the trial used 10 billion CFU a day, and the serving is one pot, then the pot must hold 10 billion at the end of shelf life, which means 20 billion at the start, with an overage. If the dose does not fit the serving, the maker has three choices: change the serving, change the food, or change the benefit. What the maker must not do is keep the benefit and cut the dose, because that is a pinch claim.

The ingredient must also be stable in the food. A vitamin that breaks down in light needs a dark pack. A probiotic that dies in acid needs a milk base, not a juice base. A protein that thickens on heating needs a cold process, not a hot one. The maker tests the ingredient through the life of the product: after processing, after packing, and at the end of shelf life. A product that holds the dose on the day it is made and loses half of it in a month is not functional at the end of its life.

Choosing the food and the format

The fourth decision is the food itself. The food must be one the eater already eats, or will eat willingly, in the amount that gives the dose. A spread is eaten every day, so it suits a daily dose. A yoghurt is eaten most days, so it suits a daily dose. A bar is eaten when the eater is busy, so it suits a dose that is needed on busy days. A drink is drunk fast, so it suits a dose that must be taken quickly. A biscuit is eaten as a snack, so it suits a small dose.

The format must also suit the ingredient. A chilled yoghurt suits a probiotic. A dry bar suits a fibre. A heated soup suits a postbiotic. A clear juice suits a whey isolate. A milky drink suits a milk protein. The maker who forces a probiotic into a biscuit, or a fibre into a clear drink, is fighting the food, and the product will fail on stability, taste, or dose. The right pair, ingredient and food, is the one where each helps the other.

Taste is the decision that kills most functional products. A product that tastes bad will not be bought twice, however good its numbers look. The maker tests the taste with a panel, through shelf life, and changes the flavour, the sweetness, and the texture until the product tastes like a food, not like a medicine. A sterol spread must taste like a spread. A protein drink must taste like a milkshake. A fibre bar must taste like a bar. The benefit is invisible, so the taste is what the buyer judges, and it is what decides whether the product is bought again.

Testing, labelling, and the pilot

The fifth decision is testing. The product is tested in the laboratory for the nutrient, for the microbes, and for safety. It is tested by a panel for taste and texture, through shelf life. And it is tested in people, where the benefit needs proving: a small trial that shows the product gives the benefit at the dose on the pack. A maker who skips the human test is selling a promise, not a proof. The trial does not need to be large, but it must be real, with a control group, a measured outcome, and a dose that matches the product.

The sixth decision is the label. The label states the ingredient and the dose per serving, carries the claim with the authorised wording, declares the allergens, and gives the storage instruction. The claim is written last, after the dose, the trial, and the authorisation have been checked, as Unit 6 explains. A label that promises a benefit the product cannot deliver is a fault, and it can lead to the product being removed from sale.

The seventh decision is the pilot: a small run of the product, sold to a small group, to see whether people buy it, eat it, and buy it again. The pilot tests the price, the pack, the shelf position, and the taste in the real world, not only in the laboratory. A product that sells well in a pilot is ready to scale. A product that does not sell in a pilot needs a change: a lower price, a better taste, a clearer claim, or a different food. The pilot is cheaper than a full launch, and it saves the maker from a large failure.

Cost, price, and the business case

A functional product costs more than an ordinary food, because the ingredient costs money, the testing costs money, and the pack costs money. The maker must work out the cost per serving, add the margin, and set a price the eater will pay. A spread with sterols that costs twice as much as an ordinary spread must give a benefit the eater values at twice the price. A yoghurt with a probiotic that costs 50 percent more must give a benefit the eater notices. If the price is too high, the product will sit on the shelf, however good it is.

The business case also covers the scale. A product that sells a thousand units a day can afford a dedicated line. A product that sells a hundred units a day cannot, and it must share a line with other products, which raises the risk of cross contact and the cost of cleaning. The maker must be honest about the volume: a niche product for a small group needs a small line and a high price, while a mass product for a large group needs a large line and a low price. The two are different businesses, and the product must be designed for the one it will live in.

A worked example: a protein drink for older people

An older person who eats little needs protein in a small, soft, easy serving. The maker chooses a 200 ml milky drink, with 15 g of protein per serving, from milk protein concentrate and whey, which gives a complete amino acid pattern and a mild taste. The drink is heated for safety, cooled, and packed in a small carton. The protein is tested in the laboratory, the taste is tested by a panel of older people, and the drink is tested in a small trial that shows it raises protein intake in people who drink it daily.

The label says source of protein, with 15 g per serving, and it declares milk. The price is set a little above an ordinary milk drink, because the protein costs more, but the maker knows the buyer is buying protein, not milk. The pilot sells the drink in a small group of care homes, and the feedback is that the drink is too sweet, so the sugar is lowered and the pilot is run again. The second pilot sells well, and the product is launched. The idea became a product because each decision was made in order: eater, benefit, ingredient, dose, food, taste, test, label, pilot, price.

Designing a functional product in order

Step 1: Choose the eater and the need
↓
Step 2: Choose one benefit that can be measured
↓
Step 3: Choose the ingredient and the dose from human trials
↓
Step 4: Choose the food and the format that suit the ingredient
↓
Step 5: Test taste, stability, safety, and the benefit in people
↓
Step 6: Write the label last, with the authorised claim and the dose
↓
Step 7: Run a pilot, listen, change, and only then launch

Common mistakes in functional product design

Four mistakes kill most functional products. The first is too many benefits: a product that claims five things proves none of them. The second is too small a dose: a product that holds a pinch of an ingredient and claims the full benefit. The third is the wrong food: a probiotic in a biscuit, a fibre in a clear drink, a protein in a food that cannot hold it. The fourth is bad taste: a product that tastes like medicine and is bought once and never again. Each mistake is easy to make and easy to avoid, by following the order in this unit: eater, benefit, ingredient, dose, food, taste, test, label, pilot, price.

Questions to think about

  • A maker wants a bar that helps cholesterol, gut health, immunity, energy, and sleep. What is wrong with the idea?
  • A trial tested 2 g of plant sterols a day. A spread holds 0.5 g per serving. How many servings give the tested dose, and is that realistic?
  • Why should the label be written last, not first?
Think about the bar question before you read on

A product that claims five benefits proves none of them, because no trial supports all five at once, and the dose for one benefit may not fit the dose for another. The maker should choose one benefit that matters to the eater, prove it at the right dose, and build the product around it. One proven benefit is stronger than five unproven ones.

Practical note: When you have an idea for a functional product, write it down in one page: who it is for, what one benefit it gives, what ingredient gives the benefit, what dose the trial used, what food will carry it, and what it will taste like. If you cannot fill in the dose from a trial, the idea is not ready. If you cannot name the eater, the idea is not ready. The one page is the test of the idea, and it is cheaper than a factory run.

Quick self-check

Question: Why must a functional product claim one benefit, not five?

Because no trial supports five benefits at once, and the dose for one benefit may not fit the dose for another. A product that claims one benefit and proves it at the right dose is a strong product, while a product that claims five proves none of them.

Question: Why is a pilot run before a full launch?

Because a pilot tests the price, the pack, the taste, and the repeat purchase in the real world, with a small group, before the maker spends on a full launch. A product that does not sell in a pilot needs a change, and the pilot is cheaper than a large failure.

Question: What is the order of decisions in designing a functional product?

Eater, benefit, ingredient, dose, food, taste, test, label, pilot, price. The eater comes first, the label is written last, and the dose comes from human trials, not from a guess.

Try it yourself

Design a functional product on one page. Choose an eater, such as an older person, a busy worker, or a child. Choose one benefit, such as more protein, more fibre, or better cholesterol. Choose an ingredient with a trial behind it, and write down the dose the trial used. Choose a food that the eater already eats, and work out the dose per serving. Write down what it will taste like, what the label will say, and what the pilot will test. Then ask a friend to read the page and tell you whether they would buy it. The friend's answer is the first pilot, and it is free.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Design starts with the eater and the need, not with the ingredient.
  • A functional product claims one benefit that can be measured, not five.
  • The ingredient and the dose come from human trials, and the dose must fit the serving.
  • The food must be one the eater already eats, and it must suit the ingredient: chilled yoghurt for a probiotic, dry bar for a fibre.
  • Taste decides repeat purchase, so the product must taste like a food, not like a medicine.
  • The product is tested in the laboratory, by a panel, and in people, and the label is written last.
  • A pilot tests the real world before a full launch, and the price must match the benefit the eater values.

Glossary

Pilot run

A small run of a product sold to a small group to test price, taste, and repeat purchase before a full launch. Food tech example: a protein drink is piloted in care homes before it is launched widely.

Target eater

The person a product is designed for, whose need decides the food, serving, taste, and price. Food tech example: an older person who eats little is the target eater for a small protein drink.

Overage

Extra nutrient added above the label claim to cover variation between batches. Food tech example: a yoghurt made with 20 billion CFU per pot holds 10 billion at the end of shelf life.

Repeat purchase

A buyer buying a product again after the first try, which shows the product works and tastes good. Food tech example: a functional drink that tastes bad will not get repeat purchase.

Margin

The difference between the cost of making a product and the price it is sold for. Food tech example: a sterol spread costs more to make, so its price and margin must be worked out before launch.

Panel test

A test where a group of people taste a product and score it for flavour, texture, and liking. Food tech example: a protein drink is tested by a panel of older people before launch.

Control group

The group in a trial that does not get the product, so that the effect of the product can be measured. Food tech example: a trial of a sterol spread compares the spread group with a control group eating ordinary spread.

Human trial

A study where people eat a product and a result is measured. Food tech example: a human trial shows that a sterol spread lowers blood cholesterol at 2 g a day.

Cross contact

When an allergen from one product reaches another product made on the same line. Food tech example: a factory that makes a soy bar and a milk bar on one line must clean between runs to avoid cross contact.

Business case

The calculation that shows whether a product can be made and sold at a profit. Food tech example: a niche product for a small group needs a small line and a high price to make its business case.

Pinch claim

A claim made by a product that holds a tiny amount of an ingredient, far below the tested dose. Food tech example: a drink with 0.1 g of beta-glucan that claims to lower cholesterol is a pinch claim.

Authorised claim

A health claim that an authority has judged and allowed, with set wording. Food tech example: a maker may use only authorised claims on a label, with the exact wording allowed.

References

  • Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development: From Concept to Marketplace, 3rd edition, 2011.
  • Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., Food Product Development: From Concept to the Marketplace, 1991.
  • Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology: Principles and Practice, 4th edition, 2017.
  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.

Unit 8: Functional Ingredients for Heart, Bone, Brain and Eye Health

Note

Unit 8: Functional Ingredients for Heart, Bone, Brain and Eye Health

A question to start with

A spread promises to help the heart. A milk drink promises to help the bones. A capsule promises to help the brain, and a juice promises to help the eyes. Four products, four body parts, four different ingredients, and one shared question: does the ingredient in the pack do the job the pack promises, at the amount in the pack, in the people who eat it? This unit looks at functional ingredients by the health target they serve: heart, bone, brain, and eye. For each target it explains the ingredient, how it is thought to work, what the evidence shows, and what the maker must prove before the claim goes on the pack.

Grouping by target is how a maker thinks. A maker does not start with a random ingredient and hunt for a use. A maker starts with a target, such as the heart, and asks which ingredients have evidence for that target, which food can carry them, and which dose the evidence used. The same ingredient can serve more than one target, and the same target can be served by more than one ingredient, so the choice is a match between ingredient, food, dose, and evidence, not a single magic food.

The evidence in this unit is described in plain terms: what is proven, what is partly proven, and what is not proven. A claim that is proven for one ingredient at one dose cannot be borrowed by another ingredient, or by the same ingredient at a lower dose, or by a food that holds the ingredient in a form the body cannot use. That rule runs through the whole unit, and it is the rule that separates a functional food from a food with a hopeful label.

Heart health: plant sterols, soluble fibre and potassium

The heart target is the most studied of the four, and its best known ingredient is the plant sterol. Plant sterols are compounds from plants that look like cholesterol. When they are eaten, they sit in the gut and block some of the cholesterol from food and from bile from being absorbed, so less cholesterol reaches the blood. The effect is modest and it depends on dose: a spread or a yoghurt drink that holds enough plant sterols, eaten every day, lowers blood cholesterol by a small but real amount. A product that holds too little, or that is eaten only now and then, does not give the effect. The sterol spread worked example in Unit 6 shows how the claim is checked, and the same dose rule applies here.

Soluble fibre is the second heart ingredient, and it works by a different road. Oat beta glucan, the soluble fibre in oats and barley, forms a thick gel in the gut, and that gel traps bile acids and carries them out of the body. The liver then uses cholesterol from the blood to make new bile acids, so blood cholesterol falls. The effect needs a daily dose of beta glucan, eaten as part of a food that holds it in a form the gut can use. An oat porridge, an oat drink, or a barley bread can carry it. A product that names oats on the pack but holds only a trace of beta glucan cannot carry the claim.

Potassium is the third heart ingredient, and it works on blood pressure rather than cholesterol. Potassium helps the body pass sodium out in the urine, and a diet rich in potassium from fruit, vegetables, beans, and milk is linked to lower blood pressure. A food can claim it is a source of potassium when it holds a set amount, but it cannot claim to lower blood pressure from potassium alone, because blood pressure is set by the whole diet, by salt, by weight, and by medicines, not by one mineral in one food. The maker who wants a heart claim from potassium must use the allowed wording for the nutrient, not a blood pressure promise.

Bone health: calcium, vitamin D and the supporting team

Bone is living tissue that is built in youth and then slowly lost with age, and the food that supports it is the food that supplies the building materials and the helpers that use them. Calcium is the main building material: bone is mostly calcium salts, and a diet short of calcium leaves the body to take calcium from bone to keep the blood level steady. Milk, yoghurt, cheese, and calcium set tofu are rich sources, and many drinks and cereals are fortified with calcium. The calcium in a food is only useful if the body absorbs it, and absorption depends on vitamin D, on the food it comes with, and on the form of the calcium salt.

Vitamin D is the helper that controls calcium absorption in the gut. Without enough vitamin D, even a calcium rich diet is absorbed poorly. The body makes vitamin D in the skin from sunlight, and food supplies the rest, from oily fish, eggs, and fortified foods. In places and seasons where sunlight is weak, fortified foods matter more. A milk drink fortified with both calcium and vitamin D is a sensible pair, because the two nutrients work together, and the claim for each one can be written from its own evidence.

The supporting team is often forgotten. Protein is needed to build the bone matrix that calcium sits in, and an older adult short of protein loses bone faster, whatever the calcium intake. Vitamin K helps the proteins that bind calcium into bone. Magnesium is part of bone mineral. A bone health food that supplies calcium alone, to a person short of protein and vitamin D, will do less than a food that supplies the team, or a diet that does. The maker should design for the team, and should never claim that calcium alone prevents fractures, because fractures depend on bone strength, on muscle, on balance, and on falls, not on one mineral.

Brain health: omega-3 fats, B vitamins and polyphenols

Brain health is the hardest target of the four to prove, because the brain changes slowly, memory is hard to measure, and diet is only one of many factors. The best studied brain ingredient is the omega-3 fat DHA, which is a major part of brain cell membranes. Oily fish is the main food source, and fish oil and algal oil are the main ingredient sources. DHA is needed for the brain to grow in early life, and it is part of the structure of the adult brain. A food that supplies DHA can claim it contributes to normal brain function, where the rules allow that wording, but it cannot claim to improve memory or to prevent dementia, because those benefits have not been proven for a food in healthy people.

The B vitamins are the second brain ingredient, and they work by controlling homocysteine, a compound in the blood that rises when folate, vitamin B12, or vitamin B6 are short. A high homocysteine level is linked to poorer brain health, and the B vitamins lower it. That link is real, but lowering homocysteine with a supplement has not been shown to improve memory in healthy people, so the claim must stay with the nutrient, not with memory. A breakfast cereal fortified with folate and B12 can claim it supplies those vitamins, and the vitamins contribute to normal brain function, but it cannot promise a sharper mind.

Polyphenols are the third brain ingredient, and they are the least proven. Berries, cocoa, tea, and coffee hold polyphenols that reach the brain in small amounts and that act on blood flow and on nerve signals in laboratory studies. Some studies in people find a small improvement in attention or memory after eating polyphenol rich foods, others find nothing, and the doses in the studies are often higher than a normal diet supplies. The honest position is that a diet rich in fruit, vegetables, tea, and cocoa supports the brain as part of a healthy diet, and that no single polyphenol food has been proven to improve the brain on its own.

Questions to think about

  • Why can a sterol spread lower cholesterol only when it is eaten every day at the full dose?
  • Why is a milk drink fortified with both calcium and vitamin D a better pair than calcium alone?
  • Why can a food that supplies DHA claim normal brain function but not improved memory?
Think about the DHA question before you read on

DHA is part of brain structure and contributes to normal brain function, which is a nutrient claim the rules allow. Improved memory or prevention of dementia has not been proven for a food in healthy people, so that claim runs ahead of the evidence and cannot be printed.

Eye health: lutein, zeaxanthin and vitamin A

The eye target is the smallest of the four, but its ingredients are among the clearest. Lutein and zeaxanthin are carotenoids, the yellow pigments in leafy greens, corn, and egg yolk. They collect in the macula, the central part of the retina that gives sharp vision, where they filter blue light and act against the damage that light and age bring. A diet rich in leafy greens supplies them, and a supplement or a fortified food can supply a measured dose. The evidence shows that people who eat more lutein and zeaxanthin have a lower chance of age related macular degeneration, a condition that damages central vision in older age, but a food cannot claim to prevent it, because the studies are observational and the benefit is linked to the whole diet, not to one food.

Vitamin A is the eye ingredient with the longest history. It is needed to make the pigment in the retina that detects light, and a shortage causes night blindness and then blindness. Liver, egg yolk, and dairy supply vitamin A directly, and orange and dark green vegetables supply beta carotene, which the body turns into vitamin A. A food that supplies vitamin A can claim it contributes to normal vision, where the rules allow, and that claim is solid. The maker must be careful with dose: vitamin A in large amounts is toxic, so a fortified food must hold a safe amount, and a supplement that holds a very high dose must carry a warning for pregnant women, because excess vitamin A can harm the unborn baby.

The eye target shows the same dose rule as the heart. A juice that holds a trace of lutein cannot carry an eye claim. A food that holds the amount used in the studies, eaten regularly, can carry the nutrient claim, and the maker must prove the amount survives processing and storage, which is the subject of Unit 9.

Choosing an ingredient for a target: a worked example

A maker wants a heart health yoghurt drink. The target is the heart, and the candidate ingredients are plant sterols, oat beta glucan, and potassium. The sterol needs a daily dose, and the drink is eaten daily, so the dose fits. The beta glucan needs a thick gel in the gut, and a yoghurt drink can carry it, but the gel would thicken the drink and change its taste, so the maker must test the texture. The potassium is already in the milk, and the drink can claim it is a source of potassium, but that claim alone does not make a heart product.

The maker picks the sterol, because the dose fits the serving, the drink is eaten daily, and the evidence for the dose is the strongest. The maker then checks three things. First, the sterol survives the yoghurt process and the shelf life, and the amount at the end of shelf life still meets the dose. Second, the sterol does not spoil the taste or the texture, and the drink still pours and tastes like a yoghurt drink. Third, the claim uses only the allowed wording for the dose, and the pack tells the buyer that the benefit needs a daily serving as part of a varied diet. A product that passes all three can be sold. A product that fails any one of them cannot, whatever the ingredient promised on paper.

Choosing an ingredient for a health target

Step 1: Name the target: heart, bone, brain, or eye
↓
Step 2: List the ingredients with evidence for that target, and the dose the evidence used
↓
Step 3: Check the dose fits the serving, and the food is eaten often enough
↓
Step 4: Check the ingredient survives processing and shelf life, and the taste still works
↓
Step 5: Write the claim in the allowed wording, and name the dose and the daily habit it needs

What this unit does not cover, and why

Two targets are left out on purpose. The first is weight, which is covered in the protein subject and in the fortification unit, because weight is set by the whole diet and by activity, not by one ingredient. The second is immunity, which is covered in the gut health subject, because immunity needs many nutrients together and no single food has been shown to boost it beyond normal. A maker who wants a weight or immunity claim should read those units and apply the same rule: name the ingredient, name the dose, name the evidence, and use only the allowed wording.

Practical note: When you pick an ingredient for a health target, write the dose on the same line as the ingredient name. A target without a dose is a wish, not a product, and a claim without a dose cannot be checked, proved, or printed.

Quick self-check

Question: How do plant sterols lower blood cholesterol?

Plant sterols look like cholesterol, so they sit in the gut and block some of the cholesterol from food and bile from being absorbed, and less cholesterol reaches the blood.

Question: Why does bone health need protein and vitamin D as well as calcium?

Protein builds the bone matrix that calcium sits in, and vitamin D controls calcium absorption in the gut, so calcium alone, without protein and vitamin D, is absorbed poorly and built into bone poorly.

Question: Why can a lutein rich food not claim to prevent macular degeneration?

Because the evidence is observational: people who eat more lutein have a lower chance of the condition, but the benefit is linked to the whole diet, and no study has proven that one food prevents it.

Try it yourself

Pick four products from a shop or from your kitchen, one for each target in this unit: heart, bone, brain, and eye. For each one, write the target, the ingredient named for it, the amount per serving, and the exact claim on the pack. Then ask: is the amount the amount the evidence used, is the claim the allowed wording for that nutrient, and does the pack say the benefit needs a daily habit? Write one sentence for each product saying whether the claim holds up. Keep your notes: this is the same target check a food technologist runs before a functional product is approved.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A functional ingredient is chosen by target first, then by evidence, dose, food, and claim, in that order.
  • Plant sterols block cholesterol absorption in the gut and lower blood cholesterol at a daily dose.
  • Oat beta glucan traps bile acids in the gut, so the liver uses blood cholesterol to make new bile.
  • Potassium helps pass sodium out, and a diet rich in potassium is linked to lower blood pressure, but one food cannot claim to lower blood pressure alone.
  • Bone needs calcium, vitamin D, protein, vitamin K, and magnesium together, and calcium alone cannot prevent fractures.
  • DHA contributes to normal brain function, but no food has been proven to improve memory or prevent dementia.
  • B vitamins lower homocysteine, but lowering it has not been shown to improve memory in healthy people.
  • Lutein and zeaxanthin collect in the macula and filter blue light, and vitamin A is needed for the retina to detect light.
  • A claim is only as good as its dose, and a dose that does not fit the serving cannot carry the claim.

Glossary

Plant sterol

A compound from plants that looks like cholesterol and blocks some cholesterol absorption in the gut. Food tech example: a spread with plant sterols lowers blood cholesterol when eaten daily at the full dose.

Beta glucan

A soluble fibre from oats and barley that forms a thick gel in the gut and traps bile acids. Food tech example: oat beta glucan in porridge helps lower blood cholesterol.

Cholesterol

A fat like substance in the blood and in food, needed for cell walls and hormones, and linked to heart risk when its blood level is high. Food tech example: plant sterols lower blood cholesterol by blocking its absorption.

Bile acid

A substance made in the liver from cholesterol that helps digest fat in the gut. Food tech example: beta glucan traps bile acids and carries them out, so the liver uses blood cholesterol to make more.

Potassium

A mineral that helps the body pass sodium out in the urine and supports normal blood pressure. Food tech example: a food rich in potassium from fruit and beans can claim it is a source of potassium.

Calcium

The main mineral in bone, needed in the diet to build and keep bone. Food tech example: milk, yoghurt, and calcium set tofu are rich sources of calcium.

Vitamin D

A vitamin that controls calcium absorption in the gut and supports bone and immune function. Food tech example: a milk drink fortified with calcium and vitamin D pairs the building material with its helper.

DHA

Docosahexaenoic acid, an omega-3 fat that is a major part of brain cell membranes. Food tech example: oily fish and algal oil supply DHA for normal brain function.

Homocysteine

A compound in the blood that rises when folate, vitamin B12, or vitamin B6 are short, and is linked to poorer brain health. Food tech example: B vitamins lower homocysteine, but that has not been shown to improve memory.

Lutein

A yellow carotenoid from leafy greens, corn, and egg yolk that collects in the macula of the eye. Food tech example: lutein in leafy greens filters blue light in the eye.

Zeaxanthin

A yellow carotenoid that sits beside lutein in the macula and protects central vision. Food tech example: zeaxanthin from corn and egg yolk collects in the macula with lutein.

Macula

The central part of the retina that gives sharp vision. Food tech example: lutein and zeaxanthin collect in the macula, where they filter blue light.

Vitamin A

A vitamin needed to make the pigment in the retina that detects light, and a shortage causes night blindness. Food tech example: a food that supplies vitamin A can claim it contributes to normal vision.

Macular degeneration

An age related condition that damages central vision in older age. Food tech example: people who eat more lutein have a lower chance of macular degeneration, but no single food has been proven to prevent it.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Goldberg, I., Functional Foods: Designer Foods, Pharmafoods, Nutraceuticals, 1994.
  • Manach, C., Scalbert, A., Morand, C., Remesy, C. and Jimenez, L., Polyphenols: Food Sources and Bioavailability, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2004.

Unit 9: Stability and Bioavailability of Bioactives: What Survives Processing and Digestion

Note

Unit 9: Stability and Bioavailability of Bioactives: What Survives Processing and Digestion

A question to start with

A tomato sauce is rich in lycopene on the day it is made, but how much is left after a year on the shelf? A green tea drink holds polyphenols in the bottle, but how many reach the blood after the drink is swallowed? A vitamin pill holds a full dose, but how much of it does the body actually absorb? A bioactive that does not survive the factory, the shelf, and the gut gives no benefit, whatever the label says on the day of packing. This unit follows a bioactive on its journey: from the ingredient, through processing and storage, through digestion, and into the body, and it explains the two words that decide the journey: stability and bioavailability.

Stability is whether the bioactive stays intact through processing, storage, and cooking. Bioavailability is the share of the amount eaten that is absorbed and reaches the body in a form it can use. A bioactive can be stable but not bioavailable: it survives the shelf and passes through the gut untouched. It can be bioavailable but not stable: the body could use it well, but it breaks down in the factory before it is eaten. A functional food needs both, and the maker must measure both, not assume either one.

The journey has four stages, and this unit walks each one. The first is the ingredient: how much bioactive the raw material holds, and in what form. The second is processing: heat, light, oxygen, acid, and shear, and what each one does to the bioactive. The third is storage: time, temperature, light, and the pack, and how the bioactive falls over the shelf life. The fourth is digestion: release from the food, survival in the stomach, absorption in the small intestine, and the work of the liver, which can change or remove the bioactive before it reaches the rest of the body.

Stability in processing: heat, light, oxygen and acid

Heat is the most common threat and the most mixed. Heat breaks down vitamin C and many polyphenols, and a long hot process can cut them by half or more. Heat also helps some bioactives: cooking tomatoes breaks the cell walls and frees lycopene, so a cooked tomato sauce gives the body more lycopene than a raw tomato, even though the total lycopene is a little lower. Heat helps carotenoids in carrots in the same way. The maker must measure the bioactive after the process, not before, because the number before heating is not the number in the pack.

Light breaks down riboflavin, vitamin A, and many pigments. A clear bottle of milk left in the light loses riboflavin in hours. A clear bottle of juice left in the light loses colour and vitamin C. That is why milk is packed in opaque cartons and why juices are packed in dark or opaque bottles. Oxygen breaks down vitamin C, vitamin E, and unsaturated fats. A drink that is filled with air in the headspace will lose vitamin C faster than a drink filled under nitrogen. Acid breaks down some bioactives and protects others: vitamin C is more stable in acid, while some pigments change colour or break down as the pH moves.

Shear and mixing can break a bioactive by exposing it to air and to enzymes. Cutting fruit and leaving it open lets enzymes brown the flesh and destroy polyphenols. Mixing a powder into a drink with a fast mixer folds air in and speeds oxidation. The maker controls these threats with the process itself: short heat, low oxygen, dark packs, cool filling, and a recipe that protects the bioactive rather than exposing it.

Stability in storage: the shelf life of a benefit

A bioactive falls over time, and the fall follows a pattern the maker can measure. The simplest pattern is a steady fall: a fixed share is lost each month, so the amount after a year can be worked out from the amount after a month. The maker measures the bioactive at the start, after one month, after three months, and after six months, at the storage temperature the product will meet, and draws the fall on a graph. The dose on the label must be the amount at the end of the shelf life, not the amount at the start, because the buyer eats the product at the end of its life as often as at the start.

Temperature speeds the fall. A product stored warm loses its bioactive faster than the same product stored cool. A maker who tests only at room temperature will overstate the benefit for a product sold in a warm shop or a warm kitchen. Light speeds the fall too, which is why the test must use the real pack, in the real light, not a laboratory bottle in a dark cupboard. The pack is part of the product: an oxygen barrier film, a dark bottle, or a nitrogen flushed headspace can double the life of a bioactive, and the maker should test the pack as well as the recipe.

A worked example shows the retention maths. A juice holds 100 mg of vitamin C per serving on the day it is made. After three months on the shelf it holds 80 mg. The retention is worked out in steps. First, write the amount left over the amount at the start: 80 mg divided by 100 mg. Second, do the division: 80 divided by 100 is 0.80. Third, turn it into a percent by multiplying by 100: 0.80 times 100 is 80 percent. So the retention after three months is 80 percent. The maker then asks whether the fall will continue at the same rate, and measures again at six months to find out. If the retention at the end of the shelf life falls below the dose the claim needs, the maker must shorten the shelf life, raise the starting dose, or change the pack.

A derivation of the same idea shows where the numbers come from. The loss per month is the starting amount minus the amount left, divided by the months passed. In the juice example, 100 mg minus 80 mg is 20 mg lost in three months, so the loss is 20 divided by 3, about 6.7 mg per month. If the loss stayed steady, the amount after six months would be 100 mg minus 6 times 6.7 mg, which is 100 minus 40, about 60 mg. The maker must check that prediction with a real measurement at six months, because the fall often slows as the bioactive left is the tougher share, and a straight line prediction can understate the amount left. The maths gives a guide, and the measurement gives the answer.

Bioavailability: release, absorption and the liver

Bioavailability starts with release. A bioactive locked inside a plant cell wall cannot be absorbed until the wall is broken, by cooking, by chewing, or by the gut itself. Lycopene in a raw tomato is locked in, and only a small share is released. Cooking breaks the walls, and the share released rises sharply. The same rule holds for the carotenoids in carrots and for the polyphenols bound to fibre in grains: the food matrix decides how much is freed, and a bioactive that is never freed is never absorbed.

The second step is survival in the stomach. The stomach is acid, and some bioactives break down there. Polyphenols are mostly stable in acid, while some vitamins and some peptides are not. The third step is absorption in the small intestine. A bioactive that dissolves in fat, such as lycopene or beta carotene, is absorbed better with fat in the meal: a tomato sauce cooked with oil gives more lycopene to the body than the same sauce without oil. A bioactive that dissolves in water, such as vitamin C, is absorbed through a different road, and its absorption falls as the dose rises, because the transporters that carry it can only move so much at once.

The fourth step is the liver. Blood from the gut passes through the liver first, and the liver can change a bioactive, store it, or send it out in the bile back to the gut. Many polyphenols are changed in the liver into forms that are easier to pass out, so only a small share of the amount eaten ever reaches the rest of the body. That is why the blood level of a polyphenol is often far lower than the amount in the food, and why a claim based on the amount in the food, without a measure of the amount in the blood, is weak. The maker who wants a strong claim measures the bioactive in the blood after people eat the product, in a human study, not only in the food.

Encapsulation and delivery: protecting the journey

Encapsulation is the main tool a maker uses to protect a bioactive on its journey. A bioactive is wrapped in a tiny coat, often made from a starch, a gum, or a fat, which shields it from oxygen, light, and acid, and which opens at the right place in the gut. A vitamin C powder coated in fat survives a hot drink better than free vitamin C. A probiotic coated in a shell survives stomach acid better than a free probiotic. An omega-3 oil wrapped in a starch coat does not taste fishy and does not oxidise as fast as free oil.

The coat must be chosen for the journey. A coat that opens in the stomach releases the bioactive too early, where acid can destroy it. A coat that never opens releases nothing at all. A coat that opens in the small intestine is right for most bioactives, because that is where absorption happens. A coat that opens in the large intestine is right for a bioactive meant for the gut microbes, such as a prebiotic or a probiotic aimed at the colon. The maker tests the coat in a simulated gut: acid first, then the enzymes of the small intestine, then the microbes of the large intestine, and measures how much bioactive is released at each stage.

Delivery is not only a coat. The food itself can be the delivery system: fat in the meal helps fat soluble bioactives, a drink taken with food slows the stomach and gives the bioactive more time, and a powder that dissolves slowly gives a steadier supply than a powder that dissolves at once. The maker who understands delivery can use less bioactive and get more benefit, because the share that reaches the body is higher, and that is both cheaper and more honest than adding a large dose and losing most of it.

Questions to think about

  • Why can a cooked tomato sauce give the body more lycopene than a raw tomato, even though cooking lowers the total lycopene?
  • A juice holds 100 mg of vitamin C at packing and 80 mg after three months. What is the retention, and why must the label dose be set from the end of shelf life?
  • Why does a polyphenol that is rich in a food often reach only a small level in the blood?
Think about the tomato question before you read on

Cooking breaks the tomato cell walls and frees the lycopene, so a larger share is released in the gut and absorbed. The raw tomato holds more total lycopene, but most of it stays locked inside the cells and passes through untouched.

Measuring bioavailability: from the laboratory to people

Bioavailability is measured in stages. The first stage is a laboratory digestion: the food is mixed with acid and enzymes that copy the stomach, then with the enzymes of the small intestine, and the bioactive released into the liquid is measured. This is called the bioaccessible share, and it is a useful first test, because a bioactive that is never released in the laboratory will not be released in the gut. Its limit is that it does not measure absorption: release is not the same as crossing the gut wall.

The second stage is a cell test: the released bioactive is placed on a layer of gut cells grown in a dish, and the amount that passes through is measured. This shows whether the bioactive can cross the wall, but the cells in a dish are not a whole gut, and they lack the blood flow, the liver, and the microbes of a real person. The third stage is an animal study, which adds the whole body but is not a person. The fourth stage is a human study, where people eat the product and the bioactive is measured in their blood over hours. The human study is the only one that proves bioavailability in people, and it is the one a strong claim needs.

A maker should not borrow a bioavailability figure from a different food. The bioavailability of lycopene from tomato sauce is not the bioavailability of lycopene from a raw tomato, or from a capsule, because the food matrix, the fat, and the cooking are different. The figure belongs to the product, not to the ingredient, and a claim that uses a borrowed figure is a claim built on sand.

The journey of a bioactive, from pack to blood

Step 1: The bioactive is packed in the food, and the dose is set for the end of shelf life
↓
Step 2: Processing and storage test it with heat, light, oxygen, and time
↓
Step 3: Chewing and cooking free it from the food matrix
↓
Step 4: The stomach and the small intestine test it with acid and enzymes
↓
Step 5: Absorption carries it into the blood, and the liver decides how much reaches the body

Designing for survival: a checklist for the maker

A maker who designs for stability and bioavailability follows a short checklist. First, measure the bioactive in the raw material and in the finished product, and write both numbers down. Second, measure it again at the end of the shelf life, at the warmest temperature the product will meet, in the real pack. Third, set the label dose from the end of shelf life number, and add an overage only where the rules allow it and the safety margin is clear. Fourth, test the release in a simulated gut, and check whether fat, cooking, or a coat improves it. Fifth, where the claim needs it, run a human study and measure the bioactive in the blood.

The checklist also has a warning: an overage is not a free fix. Adding extra bioactive to cover the shelf life fall is allowed for some nutrients and not for others, and an overage that is too large can push the dose above a safe level, or change the taste, or cost more than a better pack would have. A dark bottle or a nitrogen flush is often cheaper than a large overage, and it protects the whole shelf life, not only the start.

Practical note: When you read a functional claim, look for the dose at the end of shelf life, not at packing. A product that proves its dose only on the day it was made has proved nothing about the product you will eat in six months.

Quick self-check

Question: What is the difference between stability and bioavailability?

Stability is whether the bioactive stays intact through processing, storage, and cooking. Bioavailability is the share of the amount eaten that is absorbed and reaches the body in a form it can use.

Question: Why does fat in a meal help the absorption of lycopene and beta carotene?

Because they dissolve in fat, so fat in the meal carries them through the gut and into the absorbing cells, while the same bioactive without fat is absorbed poorly.

Question: Why is a laboratory digestion test not proof of bioavailability?

Because it measures release into the liquid, which is the bioaccessible share, not absorption across the gut wall, and it has no blood flow, no liver, and no microbes, so only a human study proves bioavailability in people.

Try it yourself

Take a vitamin C drink, a juice, or a fortified food from your kitchen. Read the label and write down the amount of the bioactive per serving and the shelf life. Then think through the journey in this unit: what would heat, light, oxygen, and time do to that bioactive, and what would the food matrix do to its release in the gut? Write one sentence for each stage, and finish with a question you would ask the maker: was the dose measured at the end of shelf life, and was the bioavailability measured in people? Keep your notes: this is the same journey check a food technologist runs before a functional claim is approved.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A bioactive must survive the factory, the shelf, and the gut to give any benefit, and the maker must measure all three stages.
  • Heat, light, oxygen, acid, and shear each threaten different bioactives, and the pack and the process are part of the protection.
  • The dose on the label must be the amount at the end of shelf life, not at packing.
  • Retention is the amount left divided by the amount at the start, times 100, and the fall over time must be measured, not guessed.
  • Release from the food matrix is the first step of bioavailability, and cooking can free more bioactive than it destroys.
  • Fat soluble bioactives are absorbed better with fat in the meal, and water soluble ones are limited by their transporters.
  • The liver changes many bioactives before they reach the body, so the blood level is often far lower than the amount in the food.
  • Encapsulation can protect a bioactive, but the coat must open at the right place in the gut.
  • Laboratory digestion measures release, cell tests measure crossing, and only a human study proves bioavailability in people.

Glossary

Stability

Whether a bioactive stays intact through processing, storage, and cooking. Food tech example: vitamin C loses stability in light and oxygen, so juice is packed in dark bottles.

Bioavailability

The share of a bioactive eaten that is absorbed and reaches the body in a form it can use. Food tech example: lycopene from cooked tomato sauce has higher bioavailability than from a raw tomato.

Bioaccessible share

The share of a bioactive released from the food into the gut liquid in a laboratory digestion test. Food tech example: a bioactive that is never released in the test will not be released in the gut.

Retention

The share of a bioactive left after processing or storage, stated as a percent of the starting amount. Food tech example: a juice with 80 percent retention after three months holds 80 mg of vitamin C from a starting 100 mg.

Overage

Extra nutrient added above the label claim to cover the fall during shelf life. Food tech example: a maker adds an overage of vitamin C where the rules allow it, so the dose at the end of shelf life still meets the claim.

Encapsulation

Wrapping a bioactive in a tiny coat that shields it from oxygen, light, and acid and opens at the right place in the gut. Food tech example: a coated probiotic survives stomach acid better than a free one.

Food matrix

The structure of a food: its cell walls, fibres, fats, and proteins, which decide how much of a bioactive is freed in the gut. Food tech example: cooking breaks the tomato food matrix and frees lycopene.

First pass

The passage of blood from the gut through the liver first, where the liver can change or remove a bioactive. Food tech example: many polyphenols are changed in the first pass, so little reaches the rest of the body.

Fat soluble

Dissolving in fat, so absorption is better with fat in the meal. Food tech example: lycopene and beta carotene are fat soluble and need oil in the meal for good absorption.

Water soluble

Dissolving in water, so absorption uses transporters that can only move so much at once. Food tech example: vitamin C is water soluble, and its absorption falls as the dose rises.

Simulated gut

A laboratory test that copies the stomach and the small intestine with acid and enzymes, to measure release. Food tech example: a coated bioactive is tested in a simulated gut to see where its coat opens.

Oxidation

Damage by oxygen, which breaks down vitamin C, vitamin E, and unsaturated fats. Food tech example: a drink filled under nitrogen loses vitamin C more slowly than one filled with air in the headspace.

Shelf life

The time a product stays safe and keeps its claimed quality in its pack. Food tech example: the dose on the label must be the amount at the end of shelf life, not at packing.

Human study

A study where people eat the product and the bioactive is measured in their blood over hours. Food tech example: a human study is the only proof of bioavailability in people.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Manach, C., Scalbert, A., Morand, C., Remesy, C. and Jimenez, L., Polyphenols: Food Sources and Bioavailability, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2004.
  • Goldberg, I., Functional Foods: Designer Foods, Pharmafoods, Nutraceuticals, 1994.
  • Nielsen, S. S., Food Analysis, 5th edition, 2017.

Unit 10: Omega-3 and Healthy Fats: The Bioactive Fats

Note

Unit 10: Omega-3 and Healthy Fats: The Bioactive Fats

A question to start with

Fat was once the villain of the food world, and then the story changed. Some fats raise the risk of heart disease, and some fats lower it. Some fats build the brain, and some fats sit in the body as plain fuel. The difference is not how much fat a food holds, but which fats, in what balance, and in what food. This unit explains the bioactive fats: the omega-3 family, the monounsaturated fats, and the plant sterols that travel with them, how they work in the body, where they come from, and how a maker keeps them safe in a food, because the same fats that help the body are the fats that spoil fastest on the shelf.

A healthy fat is a fat that does a job beyond giving energy. The omega-3 fats EPA and DHA build brain and eye tissue, calm inflammation, and help the heart beat steadily. The monounsaturated fat oleic acid, the main fat in olive oil, helps keep blood cholesterol in a healthy pattern. The plant sterols that sit beside fats in seeds and nuts block cholesterol absorption. The trans fats made by hardening oils do the opposite, and they are the fats a maker should avoid. The unit covers each family in turn, then the practical side: oxidation, the enemy that spoils them, and the foods that carry them well.

The fat families: a map before the detail

Fats are built from fatty acids, chains of carbon atoms with a head that loves water and a tail that hates it. A saturated fatty acid has no double bonds in its chain, so it is straight and solid at room temperature, as in butter and in coconut fat. A monounsaturated fatty acid has one double bond, so it bends, and it is liquid at room temperature, as in olive oil. A polyunsaturated fatty acid has two or more double bonds, so it bends more, and it is liquid too, as in sunflower oil and fish oil.

The omega number tells where the first double bond sits, counted from the tail end of the chain. In an omega-3 fatty acid the first double bond is three carbons from the tail. In an omega-6 fatty acid it is six carbons from the tail. The body cannot make omega-3 or omega-6 fats from scratch, so they must come from food, which is why they are called essential fatty acids. The body can stretch a short omega-3, alpha linolenic acid from plants, into the longer EPA and DHA, but it does so slowly and poorly, so oily fish or algal oil is the reliable source of EPA and DHA.

The balance between omega-6 and omega-3 matters because the two families share the same enzymes in the body. A diet very rich in omega-6 and poor in omega-3 leaves the shared enzymes busy with omega-6, so less omega-3 is turned into its useful products. The modern diet in many places is heavy on omega-6 from seed oils and light on omega-3 from fish, which is why a maker who adds omega-3 to a food is adding something the diet often lacks, and why the claim must be judged against the whole diet, not the single product.

Omega-3 fats: EPA, DHA and ALA

Alpha linolenic acid, or ALA, is the plant omega-3. It is found in flaxseed, chia seed, walnuts, and rapeseed oil. The body uses ALA for energy and turns a small share into EPA and then DHA. The conversion is slow: only a small percent of ALA becomes EPA, and less becomes DHA. A food rich in ALA is a useful source of omega-3, but it is not a substitute for EPA and DHA, and a maker must not claim that an ALA rich food gives the same benefit as an oily fish. The label should name the fat: ALA, EPA, or DHA, not only omega-3.

EPA, eicosapentaenoic acid, is the omega-3 of oily fish. It helps the heart in three ways: it lowers the blood fat called triglycerides, it helps the heart beat steadily, and it calms the low level inflammation that is linked to heart disease. DHA, docosahexaenoic acid, is the omega-3 of the brain and the eye: it is a major part of brain cell membranes and of the retina, and it is needed for the brain to grow in early life and to work well in later life. Oily fish such as sardine, mackerel, and salmon are the richest food sources of both. Algal oil is the plant source of DHA, made by the same algae that fish eat, and it is the source used in vegetarian products and in infant formula.

The dose matters, as in every functional ingredient. A food that holds a trace of EPA or DHA cannot carry an omega-3 claim. A food that holds the amount used in the studies, eaten regularly, can carry the nutrient claim the rules allow, such as that EPA and DHA contribute to the normal function of the heart. A maker must measure the EPA and DHA at the end of the shelf life, because omega-3 fats oxidise, and the amount at packing is not the amount at eating. The claim must also name the daily habit: the benefit needs regular eating, not one serving.

Monounsaturated fats and olive oil: the Mediterranean pattern

Oleic acid is the main monounsaturated fat in olive oil, and it is the fat that gives olive oil its place in a healthy diet. A diet rich in oleic acid and low in saturated fat is linked to a healthier blood cholesterol pattern: the harmful LDL cholesterol is lower, and the helpful HDL cholesterol is held up. Olive oil also carries polyphenols, which protect the oil from oxidation and which are studied for their own effects on blood vessels. The benefit is linked to the whole pattern: olive oil in place of butter, with vegetables, beans, fish, and whole grains, not olive oil poured over an otherwise poor diet.

The maker can use this pattern in two ways. The first is to use olive oil or another monounsaturated oil as the fat in a product, in place of a saturated fat, and to state the fat content plainly. The second is to protect the oil: monounsaturated fats oxidise more slowly than polyunsaturated fats, but they still spoil in light, heat, and air, so the pack must be dark, the filling must keep oxygen out, and the shelf life must be set by tasting, not by hope. A rancid olive oil is worse than no olive oil at all, because the oxidised fats taste bad and the polyphenols are gone.

Other monounsaturated sources are rapeseed oil, high oleic sunflower oil, avocado, and nuts. Each one brings a different flavour and a different price, and the maker picks the one that fits the food. A salad dressing can carry olive oil. A baked bar can carry nuts. A spread can carry rapeseed oil. The claim is the same in each case: the fat is part of a healthy pattern, not a medicine, and the pack must not promise a heart benefit from one serving.

Plant sterols, stanols and the cholesterol question

Plant sterols and stanols are covered for the heart in Unit 8, and they are repeated here because they travel with fats and they are added to fat based foods. Sterols sit in the gut and block cholesterol absorption, and they are added to spreads, yoghurt drinks, and milks. The dose rule is the same: the product must hold the amount used in the studies, and it must be eaten daily. A spread that holds too little, or a milk that is drunk only now and then, cannot carry the claim.

The maker must also watch the fat the sterol travels in. A sterol spread made with a saturated fat gives the cholesterol benefit of the sterol and the cholesterol cost of the fat at the same time, so the net benefit is smaller. A sterol spread made with an unsaturated fat gives both benefits together. The recipe is the product, and the claim belongs to the recipe, not to the ingredient alone.

Oxidation: the enemy of healthy fats

The same double bonds that make omega-3 and other unsaturated fats useful also make them fragile. Oxygen attacks the double bonds, and the fat breaks into compounds that smell fishy or painty, taste bitter, and destroy the benefit. This is called oxidation, and it is the main reason a fish oil product goes off. The speed of oxidation rises with light, heat, air, and time, and with the number of double bonds: DHA, with six double bonds, oxidises faster than oleic acid, with one.

The maker fights oxidation in four ways. The first is to keep oxygen out: fill under nitrogen, leave no air in the headspace, and use a pack that blocks oxygen. The second is to keep light out: use a dark bottle or an opaque carton. The third is to keep the product cool: a fish oil kept in a fridge lasts longer than one kept on a warm shelf. The fourth is to add an antioxidant, such as vitamin E or a rosemary extract, which gives itself up to oxygen before the fat does. The antioxidant must be declared on the label where the rules ask for it, and it must be used at a level that works without changing the taste.

A worked example shows how the maker judges oxidation. A fish oil is tested for peroxide value, which measures the first products of oxidation, and for anisidine value, which measures the later products that smell bad. The maker sets a limit for each, tests the product through its shelf life, and shortens the shelf life if the values rise past the limit before the end. A product that tastes fine on the day it is made can taste fishy in three months, and the test catches that fault before the buyer does. The same test is used for any food rich in unsaturated fat: nuts, seeds, oils, and fortified drinks.

Questions to think about

  • Why is a food rich in ALA not a substitute for oily fish as a source of EPA and DHA?
  • Why does DHA oxidise faster than oleic acid?
  • A sterol spread is made with a saturated fat. Why is its net benefit smaller than the same sterol in an unsaturated fat?
Think about the ALA question before you read on

The body turns only a small share of ALA into EPA, and less into DHA, so a food rich in ALA gives the body little EPA and DHA. Oily fish and algal oil supply EPA and DHA directly, so they are the reliable sources.

Carrying healthy fats in foods: what works and what fails

The foods that carry healthy fats well are the foods that protect them. Oily fish carries EPA and DHA in its own flesh, with vitamin E and other protectors beside them, and it is eaten fresh or canned, where the can keeps oxygen out. A fish oil capsule carries the oil in a sealed coat, away from light and air. An algal oil powder carries the oil inside a starch coat, which is why it can be added to a drink or a bar without a fishy taste. A nut carries its oil inside a shell and inside cells, which is why a whole nut keeps longer than a ground nut, where the oil is exposed.

The foods that carry them badly are the foods that expose them. A clear bottle of fish oil on a sunny shelf, a ground seed left open in a warm kitchen, a fried food cooked in an oil that has been heated many times: all of these oxidise fast, and the benefit is lost before the food is eaten. The maker who adds omega-3 to a food must test the product as the buyer will keep it, not as the laboratory keeps it, and must set the shelf life by the oxidation test, not by the calendar alone.

Protecting an omega-3 oil on its journey to the buyer

Step 1: Choose the source: oily fish, algal oil, or a coated powder
↓
Step 2: Keep oxygen out: fill under nitrogen and leave no air in the headspace
↓
Step 3: Keep light out: use a dark bottle or an opaque pack
↓
Step 4: Add an antioxidant where it helps, and declare it where the rules ask
↓
Step 5: Test oxidation through the shelf life, and set the shelf life by the test

Trans fats: the fat to avoid

Trans fats are unsaturated fats with a bent bond flipped into a straight shape, made when oils are hardened by hydrogenation, and found in small amounts in some animal fats. They raise the harmful LDL cholesterol and lower the helpful HDL cholesterol, which is the opposite of what a healthy fat does, and they are linked to heart disease. Most markets now limit or ban industrially made trans fats, and a maker should avoid them entirely: use an oil that is naturally solid, such as a palm fraction or a fully hydrogenated fat that holds no trans fats, or change the recipe so no hardening is needed. A product that holds trans fats cannot carry a healthy fat claim, whatever else it holds.

Practical note: When you add an omega-3 fat to a food, test the product as the buyer will keep it: on a warm shelf, in the light, opened and closed for a week. A product that passes the laboratory test and fails the kitchen test will fail in the market.

Quick self-check

Question: Why must the body get omega-3 and omega-6 fats from food?

Because the body cannot make them from scratch, so they are essential fatty acids that must come from the diet.

Question: Why is a fish oil capsule a better carrier than a clear bottle of fish oil on a sunny shelf?

Because the capsule seals the oil away from light and air, while the clear bottle lets light and oxygen attack the double bonds and oxidise the oil.

Question: Why should a maker avoid trans fats entirely?

Because trans fats raise harmful LDL cholesterol and lower helpful HDL cholesterol, which is the opposite of a healthy fat, and they are linked to heart disease.

Try it yourself

Take three fats or oils from your kitchen: an olive oil, a seed oil, and a butter or a solid fat. Read each label and write down the saturated, monounsaturated, and polyunsaturated fat per 100 g, and any omega-3 named. Then smell and taste a little of each: is any of them rancid, and how was it stored? Write one sentence for each fat saying where its double bonds sit, how fast it would oxidise, and what food it suits best. Keep your notes: this is the same fat map a food technologist draws before choosing the fat for a new product.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Healthy fats are judged by which fats they hold, in what balance, and in what food, not by how much fat they hold.
  • The body cannot make omega-3 or omega-6 fats, so they must come from food.
  • ALA from plants is turned into EPA and DHA only slowly and poorly, so oily fish or algal oil is the reliable source.
  • EPA helps the heart by lowering triglycerides and calming inflammation, and DHA builds brain and eye tissue.
  • Oleic acid in olive oil supports a healthy cholesterol pattern as part of a whole diet, not alone.
  • Plant sterols block cholesterol absorption, but the fat they travel in changes the net benefit.
  • The double bonds that make unsaturated fats useful also make them oxidise fast, and DHA oxidises fastest.
  • Oxygen, light, heat, and time speed oxidation, and the maker fights them with nitrogen, dark packs, cool storage, and antioxidants.
  • Trans fats raise harmful cholesterol and lower helpful cholesterol, and a maker should avoid them entirely.

Glossary

Omega-3 fatty acid

A polyunsaturated fat with its first double bond three carbons from the tail, such as ALA, EPA, and DHA. Food tech example: oily fish is the richest food source of the omega-3 fats EPA and DHA.

Omega-6 fatty acid

A polyunsaturated fat with its first double bond six carbons from the tail, found in seed oils. Food tech example: a diet heavy on omega-6 seed oils and light on omega-3 leaves the shared enzymes busy with omega-6.

Essential fatty acid

A fat the body cannot make from scratch, so it must come from food. Food tech example: omega-3 and omega-6 fats are essential fatty acids.

ALA

Alpha linolenic acid, the plant omega-3 from flaxseed, chia seed, walnuts, and rapeseed oil. Food tech example: ALA is turned into EPA and DHA only slowly, so it is not a substitute for oily fish.

EPA

Eicosapentaenoic acid, the omega-3 of oily fish that helps the heart by lowering triglycerides. Food tech example: a fish oil capsule supplies EPA for normal heart function.

DHA

Docosahexaenoic acid, the omega-3 that is a major part of brain cell membranes and the retina. Food tech example: algal oil supplies DHA for vegetarian products and infant formula.

Oleic acid

The main monounsaturated fat in olive oil, which supports a healthy cholesterol pattern. Food tech example: olive oil rich in oleic acid is used in place of butter in a heart friendly recipe.

Triglyceride

A blood fat that rises with excess energy and is lowered by EPA. Food tech example: EPA lowers blood triglycerides when eaten regularly.

LDL cholesterol

The cholesterol carried in low density lipoprotein, linked to heart risk when its blood level is high. Food tech example: trans fats raise LDL cholesterol, while oleic acid helps keep it in a healthy pattern.

HDL cholesterol

The cholesterol carried in high density lipoprotein, which helps clear cholesterol from the blood. Food tech example: trans fats lower HDL cholesterol, which is the opposite of a healthy fat.

Oxidation

Damage by oxygen to the double bonds of unsaturated fats, giving rancid smells and tastes. Food tech example: DHA oxidises faster than oleic acid because it has more double bonds.

Peroxide value

A test that measures the first products of fat oxidation. Food tech example: a maker sets a peroxide limit and tests fish oil through its shelf life.

Antioxidant

A substance that gives itself up to oxygen before the fat does, slowing oxidation. Food tech example: vitamin E is added to fish oil as an antioxidant.

Trans fat

An unsaturated fat with a flipped bond, made by hardening oils, which raises harmful cholesterol. Food tech example: a maker avoids trans fats and uses an oil that is naturally solid instead.

References

  • Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
  • Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2008.
  • Whitney, E. N. and Rolfes, S. R., Understanding Nutrition, 9th edition, 2002.
  • Goldberg, I., Functional Foods: Designer Foods, Pharmafoods, Nutraceuticals, 1994.
  • Manach, C., Scalbert, A., Morand, C., Remesy, C. and Jimenez, L., Polyphenols: Food Sources and Bioavailability, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2004.