Login Register

Access the GIFSQ Portal

Select your user type to log in or register a new account.

Student Portal

Access your food safety courses and exams.

Instructor Portal

Manage courses, view student submissions, and grade quizzes.

Company Portal

Manage corporate setup, view employee logs, and access QA services.

GIFSQ ID: FTN-0072

← All subjects

Dairy Technology

Unit 1: Milk: Where It Comes From and What It Contains

Note

Unit 1: Milk: Where It Comes From and What It Contains

A litre of milk looks like a simple white liquid, yet it carries fat, protein, sugar, minerals, vitamins, and water in a balance no factory can copy from scratch. Where does that balance come from, and why does it change from one animal, one season, and one milking to the next? This unit traces milk from the udder to the can, and takes it apart piece by piece.

1.1 What milk is

Milk is the secretion of the mammary gland of a mammal, made to feed its young. That is the biological definition, and it explains almost everything about milk as a food. A young animal needs energy, building material for growth, water, and protection, all in one feed, and milk supplies all four at once. The dairy industry builds on that biology: we take the milk of animals that produce far more than their young need, and turn the surplus into food for people.

For the food technologist, milk is also a raw material with a split personality. It is a liquid that behaves like three foods at once. Fat floats in it as tiny globules, protein hangs in it as fine particles, and lactose and minerals dissolve in it as a true solution. Shake a bottle of milk and you see one white liquid; look closer, with the ideas of this unit in your head, and you see an emulsion, a colloidal suspension, and a solution, all in the same glass. Units 2 and 3 will take each of those apart. This unit sets the scene.

🤔 Pause and think: milk is made for a baby animal, not for a factory. Which parts of milk do you think make it hard to handle in a plant, and which parts make it easy?

Quick check

Why is milk such a complete food for a young animal?

Check your answer

It is made by the mammary gland to feed the young, so it supplies energy, building material for growth, water, and protection in a single feed.

1.2 How milk is made in the udder

Milk is made in the udder, in clusters of tiny sacs called alveoli. Each alveolus is lined with secretory cells, and those cells pull the building blocks of milk out of the blood: amino acids for protein, glucose for lactose, fatty acids for fat, and minerals and water. The cells then assemble those blocks into milk and release it into the hollow of the alveolus.

Three ideas in that picture matter for everything that follows:

  • Milk is made from blood, but it is not blood. The secretory cells choose what passes through, so milk ends up with far more lactose and casein, and far less of some blood proteins, than blood itself. That selection is why milk has its own composition, different from any other body fluid.
  • Milk is made continuously, and stored between milkings. Between milkings the milk collects in the alveoli and the ducts. If milking is delayed, pressure builds up inside the udder, and secretion slows down. Regular, complete milking keeps production high.
  • The first milk after birth is different. It is called colostrum, and section 1.3 deals with it on its own, because it is so different from normal milk that it cannot be used in the plant at all.

Milk is made in the alveoli of the udder

Blood brings building blocks
Amino acids, glucose, fatty acids, minerals.

↓

Alveolus: secretory cells
Build milk from the blocks.

↓

Ducts
Carry milk to the teat.

↓

Milking
Removes it, pressure falls, secretion speeds up again.

Figure 1.1: Milk is made in the alveoli of the udder from building blocks taken from the blood, then stored in the ducts until milking. Drawn from the description of milk secretion in Market Milk, Lesson 4, and Chemistry of Milk, Module 1.

Quick check

What are alveoli, and what do their cells do?

Check your answer

Alveoli are tiny sacs in the udder lined with secretory cells. The cells take building blocks from the blood and assemble them into milk.

1.3 Colostrum: the first milk is not for the plant

Colostrum is the milk produced in the first few days after birth. It is thick, yellowish, and very different from normal milk: much higher in protein, especially the protective proteins called immunoglobulins, higher in minerals and vitamins, and lower in lactose. A newborn animal needs it, because it carries the mother's protection against disease, and its gut can absorb those protective proteins only in the first day or so of life.

For the dairy plant, colostrum is a problem, not a raw material. Its high protein makes it clot when heated, so it cannot be pasteurised like normal milk, and its composition is so far from normal milk that it would spoil the composition of any product made from it. The rule in every dairy is simple: colostrum goes to the calf, never to the can. Milk is accepted for processing only after it has settled back to normal composition, usually after three to four days.

🤔 Pause and think: a farmer is short of milk and tempted to add the first day's colostrum to the morning can. What would happen when that milk is heated in the plant?

Quick check

Why must colostrum never go into the milk can?

Check your answer

It is far richer in protein than normal milk, so it clots on heating and cannot be pasteurised, and it would spoil the composition of any product made from it.

1.4 What milk is made of

Normal cow milk is about 87% water and about 13% total solids. The solids are the valuable part, and they split into fat and solids-not-fat. The figures below are typical values for cow milk; they vary, as section 1.6 explains, but they are the numbers to carry in your head.

ComponentTypical share in cow milkWhat it does
Waterabout 87%Carries everything else; the reason milk is heavy and spoils fast
Fatabout 3.5-4.0%Energy, flavour, and the creamy feel; carried as globules
Proteinabout 3.2-3.5%Building material; casein and whey protein
Lactose (milk sugar)about 4.6-4.8%Energy; the sugar microbes ferment into lactic acid
Minerals (ash)about 0.7%Calcium, phosphorus, potassium, and others
Total solidsabout 12.5-13%Fat plus solids-not-fat together

Two derived numbers are used constantly in the dairy trade:

  • Solids-not-fat (SNF) is total solids minus fat: about 8.5-9% in cow milk. It is protein plus lactose plus minerals. SNF is watched closely because watering milk down lowers it at once.
  • Total solids (TS) is everything that is not water: about 12.5-13% in cow milk. When a plant buys milk, it is really buying total solids, and the water is the packaging it comes in.

Worked example: what is in 100 kg of milk? At 87% water and 13% total solids, 100 kg of milk holds 87 kg of water and 13 kg of solids. If the fat is 4%, the solids-not-fat is 13 minus 4, which is 9 kg. That 9 kg is roughly 3.4 kg of protein, 4.8 kg of lactose, and 0.7 kg of minerals, with a little of other minor parts making up the rest.

Quick check

Milk tests 13% total solids and 4% fat. What is its solids-not-fat?

Check your answer

13 minus 4, which is 9%. Solids-not-fat is total solids minus fat.

1.5 Milk is not the same in every animal

Different mammals make very different milks, because their young grow at different speeds. The table below gives typical figures from the books; the pattern is what matters, not the last decimal place.

MilkWaterFatProteinLactose
Cowabout 87%about 3.9%about 3.4%about 4.8%
Buffaloabout 84%about 7%about 3.8%about 4.9%
Goatabout 87%about 4.1%about 3.4%about 4.5%
Sheepabout 83%about 6.5%about 5.5%about 4.8%
Humanabout 87%about 4.5%about 1%about 7%

Read the pattern, not just the rows. Animals whose young must double their weight fast make richer milk: sheep milk carries about 5.5% protein, and the books note that a lamb doubles its birth weight in about 15 days, while a calf takes far longer. Human milk is the opposite: low in protein, about 1%, and high in lactose, about 7%, because a human baby grows slowly and needs energy and brain-building sugars more than bulk protein. Buffalo milk is the richest of the common dairy milks, with about 7% fat, which is why it gives a higher yield of butter, ghee, and cheese per litre than cow milk.

Quick check

Why is buffalo milk prized for butter and cheese making?

Check your answer

It carries about 7% fat, nearly twice cow milk, so each litre yields more butter, ghee, and cheese.

1.6 Why the composition keeps changing

The figures in section 1.4 are averages. Real milk moves around them, and the plant has to live with that movement. The main causes are:

  • Breed and animal. Some breeds give more milk with less fat; others give less milk with more fat. Even two animals of the same breed differ.
  • Stage of lactation. Milk just after calving is richer; as lactation goes on, yield rises and fat often falls, then fat rises again late in lactation when yield drops.
  • Feed. Good feeding raises yield and can lift fat and protein a little, but feed cannot turn a low-fat breed into a high-fat one. Poor feed, or a sudden change of feed, can drop fat sharply.
  • Season. Hot weather usually cuts yield and can change composition; cold weather often lifts fat a little.
  • Health, especially mastitis. Infection of the udder (mastitis) lowers lactose and casein, raises salt and whey protein, and makes the milk taste salty. Mastitis milk also fails heat stability tests and is a poor raw material for cheese.
  • Milking itself. The first milk drawn at a milking is low in fat; the last milk, the strippings, is much richer, because fat globules are held back and come out late. Incomplete milking therefore leaves the richest milk in the udder.

The practical point is that the plant never gets identical milk twice. Standardisation, covered in Unit 4, exists precisely because of this variation: the plant measures fat and solids-not-fat on every lot and adjusts them to a fixed target before making a product.

🤔 Pause and think: if you sampled only the first milk of a milking and tested its fat, what mistake would you make about that animal?

Quick check

Name two things that change milk composition from day to day.

Check your answer

Any two of: breed and animal, stage of lactation, feed, season, udder health such as mastitis, and how complete the milking was.

1.7 The nutritive value of milk

Milk is valued as food because its nutrients come in forms the body uses easily. The protein of milk has a high biological value: it contains the essential amino acids in proportions close to what the body needs, and it is digested well. Casein, the main protein, is also a carrier of calcium and phosphorus, which is one reason milk is linked with bone health. The fat of milk carries the fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, and K, and gives milk its energy density. Lactose supplies energy and helps the body absorb calcium. Milk is also a useful source of riboflavin (vitamin B2) and vitamin B12, and of calcium and phosphorus in a form the body absorbs well.

Two cautions belong here, because a food technologist must state them plainly. First, milk is low in iron and in vitamin C, so a diet of milk alone is not complete. Second, some people cannot digest lactose, because they make little of the enzyme lactase in adult life; for them, fermented products such as yoghurt are often easier, because much of the lactose has already been turned into lactic acid. Units 7 and 12 come back to that point.

Quick check

Which two nutrients is milk notably low in?

Check your answer

Iron and vitamin C: a diet of milk alone is not complete.

1.8 Clean milk production: quality starts at the udder

Milk inside a healthy udder is nearly sterile. Almost every microbe in raw milk gets in after the milk leaves the udder, so clean milk production is about closing the doors through which microbes enter. The Market Milk lessons list the practices that matter:

  • Healthy animals, clean udders. Wash and dry the udder before milking; a wet udder drips dirty water into the milk. Check for mastitis and keep milk from an infected quarter out of the can.
  • Clean hands, clean clothes. The milker's hands are a direct route into the milk.
  • Clean milking equipment. Buckets, cans, milking machines, and cloths must be washed and dried after every use; a damp cloth left overnight is a culture of bacteria by morning.
  • A clean milking place. Dust, dung, and flies near the milking place all end up in the milk. Milking in a clean, dry shed, away from dung, cuts the bacterial load sharply.
  • Cool the milk fast. Milk leaves the udder at body temperature, near 37 °C, which is close to ideal for bacterial growth. Cooling it to 4 °C or below as soon as possible after milking slows bacterial growth to a crawl. Every hour warm milk waits is an hour bacteria use to multiply.

The same ideas carry into the plant, where they become reception tests and chilling, covered in Unit 4. The habit to build now is this: quality is not tested into milk at the plant gate; it is produced at the farm, and the plant can only preserve what the farm delivered.

Quick check

Milk leaves the udder near 37 °C. Why must it be cooled fast?

Check your answer

37 °C is close to ideal for bacterial growth, so cooling to 4 °C or below slows bacterial growth to a crawl.

1.9 Getting milk from the farm to the plant

Milk is collected from farms, cooled at collection centres, and carried to the plant in cans or in insulated tankers. Three things decide whether it arrives in good condition:

  • Time. The shorter the time between milking and chilling, and between chilling and the plant, the better the milk. Warm milk held for hours arrives sour.
  • Temperature. Chilled milk must stay chilled. A tanker that warms up on the road undoes the cooling done at the farm.
  • Cleanliness of cans and tankers. A dirty can seeds every litre poured into it, and the bacteria multiply all the way to the plant.

Where chilling is not possible at once, the books describe preservation aids such as the lactoperoxidase system, which uses a natural enzyme in milk, with a small added dose of thiocyanate and peroxide, to hold bacterial growth back for hours. It is a holding measure, not a substitute for cooling: it cannot hide poor quality milk, and pasteurisation destroys the system. Cooling remains the method that matters.

The road milk travels, from farm to plant

Farm
Milking, clean udder, clean cans.

↓
Cool fast to 4 °C or below

Collection centre
Weigh, test, chill, hold cold.

↓
Insulated tanker, kept cold

Plant gate
Reception tests, Unit 4.

Figure 1.2: The road milk travels from farm to plant, with cooling at each step. Drawn from Market Milk, Lessons 6, 7, and 9.

Quick check

What three things decide whether collected milk arrives at the plant in good condition?

Check your answer

Time, temperature (kept chilled), and cleanliness of the cans and tankers.

1.10 Working with composition numbers: total solids, and milk from different animals

Everything in this unit can be turned into numbers the plant actually uses. Two calculations matter most: total solids, and the difference between milks from different animals.

Total solids: one number that runs the plant

Total solids is the share of the milk that is not water: fat plus solids-not-fat. The plant uses it to pay for milk, to plan yields, and to check for added water.

Step 1, add the two parts. A milk at 4.0% fat and 8.5% solids-not-fat has total solids of 4.0 + 8.5 = 12.5%.

Step 2, turn the percentage into kilograms. In 100 kg of that milk there are 12.5 kg of solids and 87.5 kg of water.

Step 3, use it. If the same milk is evaporated to 50% total solids, the 12.5 kg of solids now sits in 25 kg of concentrate: 100 kg of milk has become 25 kg of concentrate, and 75 kg of water has been boiled off. That is the calculation behind Unit 5, and it starts here, with two numbers added together.

Worked example: two milks, two yields. A plant takes 100 kg of cow milk at 12.5% total solids and 100 kg of buffalo milk at 16.5% total solids. The cow milk carries 12.5 kg of solids, the buffalo milk 16.5 kg: a third more solid material from the same weight of milk. That is why buffalo milk gives more cheese, more powder, and more ghee per litre, and why a plant that pays only by the litre and not by the solids will always argue about the price.

Milk from different animals

Milk is not one liquid. The table below gives the typical ranges the books report for the four milking animals a dairy plant meets most often. The numbers are ranges, not fixed values, because breed, feed, and stage of lactation move them, as Section 1.6 explains.

Milk from four animals: typical composition

Cow
Fat 3.5-4.5%, protein 3.2-3.5%, lactose about 4.7%, total solids about 12.5%. The reference milk for most dairy technology.
Buffalo
Fat 6-8%, protein 4-4.5%, total solids about 16-17%. Richer in every solid, whiter, and higher yielding for cheese and ghee.
Goat
Fat 3.5-4.5%, protein about 3.3%, lactose about 4.4%, total solids about 12-13%. Smaller fat globules, and a different casein mix, so it behaves differently in cheese making.
Sheep
Fat 6-7%, protein 5.5-6%, total solids about 18-19%. The richest common milk, and the highest yielding per litre for cheese.

Figure 1.3: Typical composition ranges for cow, buffalo, goat, and sheep milk. Drawn from the composition tables in Fox and McSweeney, Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry, and the Handbook of Milk Composition.

Three practical readings follow from that table. First, fat and protein rise together: the richest milks are rich in both, which is why yield follows total solids, not fat alone. Second, lactose stays near 4.4 to 4.8% in all four animals, because lactose sets the water content of milk: the udder draws water in step with lactose, so a milk that is richer in fat and protein is not richer in lactose, it is simply less watery. Third, goat milk needs its own cheese recipe: its casein mix and its small fat globules give a softer curd, so a cheddar recipe copied straight from cow milk will set weakly and lose fat into the whey.

The lactation curve moves the numbers

A cow fresh after calving gives a large volume of milk that is lower in fat and protein. As the months pass, the volume falls and the fat and protein percentages climb, so late-lactation milk is smaller in volume and richer in solids. A plant that buys milk through the year sees this as a slow swing: more thin milk in the months after calving season, more rich milk later, and a cheese yield that rises and falls with it. The practical answer is the same as in Unit 4: test every lot, standardise to a fixed target, and never judge a season by one week.

🤔 Pause and think: a cheese plant finds its yield has risen by a tenth in a month, with no change in recipe or starter. The milk is from the same farms. What has most likely changed in the milk, and how would you prove it with one test?

Quick check

A milk tests 3.8% fat and 8.7% solids-not-fat. What are its total solids, and how many kilograms of solids are in 200 kg of it?

Check your answer

Total solids are 3.8 + 8.7 = 12.5%. In 200 kg of milk there are 25 kg of solids and 175 kg of water.

1.11 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a tanker arrives with milk that smells fine and is cold, but the lab reports a high bacterial count. How can cold milk carry a high count, and what does that tell you about where the bacteria came from?

  1. Milk is about 87% water and 13% total solids. If the fat is 4%, what is the solids-not-fat?
Check your answer

9%: total solids minus fat, 13 minus 4.

  1. Why is colostrum kept out of the milk can?
Check your answer

It is far richer in protein than normal milk, so it clots on heating, cannot be pasteurised, and would spoil the composition of products made from it.

  1. Sheep milk is about 5.5% protein and human milk is about 1% protein. What does that difference reflect?
Check your answer

How fast the young grow: a lamb doubles its birth weight in about 15 days and needs rich milk, while a human baby grows slowly and needs less protein and more lactose.

  1. Name three clean milk production practices that keep microbes out of milk.
Check your answer

Any three of: wash and dry the udder, clean hands and clothes, clean equipment after every use, a clean dry milking place, and cooling the milk fast to 4 °C or below.

Try it: Weigh 100 g of milk, pour it into a shallow dish, and leave it in a warm oven at low heat until all the water has gone and only a dry film is left, then weigh the film. It should be near 12-13 g: that is the total solids you have just measured, the same number the plant works with every day.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Milk is the secretion of the mammary gland, made to feed the young, and it supplies energy, building material, water, and protection in one feed.
  • Milk is made in the alveoli of the udder from building blocks taken from the blood, stored in the ducts, and released at milking.
  • Colostrum, the first milk after birth, is rich in protective protein, clots on heating, and never goes to the plant.
  • Cow milk is about 87% water and 13% total solids: about 4% fat, 3.4% protein, 4.8% lactose, and 0.7% minerals. Solids-not-fat is total solids minus fat.
  • Milk composition differs by species, because the young grow at different speeds, and it varies with breed, lactation stage, feed, season, health, and milking.
  • Milk is a good source of high-quality protein, calcium, phosphorus, riboflavin, and vitamin B12, but it is low in iron and vitamin C.
  • Milk inside a healthy udder is nearly sterile: quality is produced on the farm by clean milking and fast cooling to 4 °C or below, and the plant can only preserve what the farm delivered.

  • Total solids are fat plus solids-not-fat: a milk at 4.0% fat and 8.5% solids-not-fat carries 12.5 kg of solids in every 100 kg, and the rest is water.

  • Buffalo milk at about 16-17% total solids and sheep milk at about 18-19% give more cheese and powder per litre than cow milk at about 12.5%, while lactose stays near 4.4 to 4.8% in all four animals because it sets the water content.
  • As lactation advances the milk volume falls and the fat and protein percentages climb, so cheese yield swings through the year and the plant must test every lot and standardise.

Glossary

Alveolus

A tiny sac in the udder lined with secretory cells that make milk. Food tech example: milk is built in the alveoli from amino acids, glucose, and fatty acids taken from the blood.

Colostrum

The first milk produced after birth, thick and yellowish, very rich in protective proteins. Food tech example: colostrum clots on heating, so it is kept out of the milk can and fed to the newborn instead.

Solids-not-fat (SNF)

Everything in milk solids except the fat: protein plus lactose plus minerals. Food tech example: cow milk at 13% total solids and 4% fat has 9% solids-not-fat, and watering milk down lowers this number at once.

Total solids (TS)

Everything in milk that is not water: fat plus solids-not-fat. Food tech example: a plant buying 100 kg of milk at 13% total solids is buying 13 kg of solids and 87 kg of water.

Mastitis

Infection of the udder. Food tech example: mastitis milk has less lactose and casein and more salt, tastes salty, and fails heat stability tests, so it is kept out of cheese milk.

Lactose

Milk sugar, about 4.8% of cow milk. Food tech example: starter bacteria ferment lactose into lactic acid, which is how milk sets into yoghurt and begins to become cheese.

Casein

The main protein of cow milk, about four-fifths of its protein. Food tech example: casein clots at pH 4.6 or with rennet, and that clotting is the first step of cheese making.

Immunoglobulin

A protective protein that helps fight disease. Food tech example: colostrum is rich in immunoglobulins, which is why it is fed to the newborn in its first day of life.

Lactoperoxidase system

A natural enzyme system in milk that, with a small added dose of thiocyanate and peroxide, holds bacterial growth back for hours. Food tech example: it is a holding measure where cooling is delayed, never a substitute for chilling.

Clean milk production

Milking practices that keep microbes out of milk at the farm: clean udders, hands, equipment, and shed, plus fast cooling. Food tech example: milk from a clean, fast-cooled milking arrives at the plant with a low bacterial count.

Total solids

Everything in milk that is not water: fat plus solids-not-fat. Food tech example: a milk at 4.0% fat and 8.5% solids-not-fat has 12.5% total solids, or 12.5 kg of solids in every 100 kg of milk.

Solids-not-fat

All the milk solids except the fat: protein, lactose, and minerals together. Food tech example: solids-not-fat near 8.5% is what the plant checks when it suspects added water.

Lactation curve

The pattern of milk yield and composition through the months after calving: high volume and lower solids early, lower volume and richer solids late. Food tech example: cheese yield rises and falls through the year as the lactation curve moves the fat and protein.

References

  • Jensen, R. G., editor. Handbook of Milk Composition. Academic Press.

  • Market Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lessons 1-15.

  • Chemistry of Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Module 1.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.
  • Physical Chemistry of Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Module 1.

Unit 2: Chemistry of Milk

Note

Unit 2: Chemistry of Milk

Milk looks white and uniform, but it is really three systems sharing one glass: fat globules floating as an emulsion, casein micelles hanging as a colloidal suspension, and lactose and salts dissolved as a true solution. Take the glass apart the wrong way, and the whole system falls apart. How do the parts hold together, and what makes them let go? That is the chemistry of this unit.

2.1 Milk has three phases at once

Pour milk into a glass and it looks like one liquid. In truth it holds three phases:

  • An emulsion: milk fat, in globules about 1 to 10 micrometres across, floating in water. The globules are kept apart by a thin membrane, the fat globule membrane, made of protein and phospholipid. Break that membrane, by rough handling or churning, and the fat joins up: that joining is the start of butter.
  • A colloidal suspension: casein protein, in particles called micelles about 50 to 300 nanometres across, hanging in the liquid. Micelles are too small to see, but they scatter light, which is a large part of why milk looks white. The fat globules scatter light too.
  • A true solution: lactose, soluble salts, and whey proteins dissolved in water. This watery part, with its dissolved parts, is called the milk serum or milk plasma once the fat and casein are taken out.

That three-phase picture explains a lot of dairy technology in one stroke. Homogenisation attacks the emulsion. Rennet and acid attack the micelles. Evaporation and drying attack the solution. Every product in this subject is made by changing one phase while trying not to damage the others.

🤔 Pause and think: if you leave milk standing in a bottle, the cream rises. Which phase is moving, and why does it move up instead of down?

Quick check

Name the three phases present in milk at once.

Check your answer

An emulsion of fat globules, a colloidal suspension of casein micelles, and a true solution of lactose, salts, and whey proteins in water.

2.2 The fat globule and its membrane

Milk fat is not free oil. Each globule is wrapped in the fat globule membrane, a thin skin of protein and phospholipid that comes from the secretory cell as the globule leaves it. The membrane does three jobs: it keeps globules from joining together, it protects the fat from the enzyme lipase that would otherwise cut the fat and release rancid flavours, and it carries some of the milk's minor proteins and enzymes.

The size of the globules matters. Most are between 1 and 10 micrometres across, and the many small ones carry most of the surface area. When milk is homogenised, the globules are smashed into far smaller ones, about 1 micrometre or less, and the total surface area grows so much that there is not enough original membrane to cover it: casein and whey protein from the milk then coat the new surface instead. That new coat changes how the fat behaves in cheese, in yoghurt, and on heating, which is why homogenisation is a decision, not a habit, and Unit 4 comes back to it.

Milk fat itself is mostly triglycerides, fat molecules built from glycerol and fatty acids, with small amounts of phospholipids, sterols, and fat-soluble vitamins. The fatty acids are a mixture: short-chain acids such as butyric acid, which give butter its flavour, sit alongside long-chain saturated acids such as palmitic and stearic acids and the unsaturated oleic acid. That mixture is why milk fat is soft at fridge temperature and melts near body temperature, and why it goes rancid when lipase is allowed to work on it.

Quick check

What does the fat globule membrane do?

Check your answer

It keeps globules from joining, and it protects the fat from lipase, the enzyme that would cut the fat and release rancid flavours.

2.3 Casein: the protein that builds the curd

About four-fifths of the protein in cow milk is casein, and casein is the protein that makes cheese possible. Casein is not one protein but a family of four main ones: alpha-s1 casein, alpha-s2 casein, beta casein, and kappa casein. They gather into micelles, loose balls of casein held together with calcium phosphate, with kappa casein sitting mostly on the outside like hairs on a ball.

Those kappa casein hairs are the key to the whole system. They carry a negative charge and stick out into the liquid, so micelles repel each other and stay apart: milk stays liquid. Two things can knock the hairs down, and both are used in cheese making:

  • Acid. As lactic acid builds up, the pH falls. At pH 4.6, the isoelectric point of casein, the micelles lose their charge, the hairs collapse, and the micelles join into a curd. That is acid coagulation, the way yoghurt sets and acid cheeses begin.
  • Rennet. The enzyme chymosin in rennet clips the kappa casein hairs off the micelle surface. Without the hairs, the micelles join into a curd even at normal milk pH, near 6.6. That is rennet coagulation, the way most cheeses begin.

Casein is rich in the amino acid proline, which stops it folding into neat, compact shapes, and that open structure is part of why casein micelles are loose and open rather than tight balls. Casein also carries phosphate groups bound to its chain, and those phosphates bind calcium, which is how milk carries so much calcium in a form the body can use.

A casein micelle and the two ways it is made to clot

Casein micelle
Loose ball, 50-300 nm.
Inside
Alpha + beta casein inside, calcium phosphate bridges.
Outside
Kappa casein hairs outside.
Acid to pH 4.6
Hairs collapse. Micelles join: curd forms.
Rennet
Clips the hairs off. Micelles join: curd forms.

Figure 2.1: A casein micelle and the two ways it is made to clot: acid to pH 4.6, or rennet clipping the kappa casein hairs. Drawn from Chemistry of Milk, Module 3, and Fox and McSweeney, Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry.

Quick check

What happens to casein micelles at pH 4.6, and why?

Check your answer

At pH 4.6, the isoelectric point of casein, the micelles lose their charge and the kappa casein hairs collapse, so the micelles join into a curd.

2.4 Whey proteins: the proteins that stay in the whey

The remaining fifth of milk protein is whey protein, the proteins that stay dissolved when casein is clotted out. The two main ones are beta-lactoglobulin, the most abundant whey protein in cow milk, and alpha-lactalbumin, which is part of the enzyme system that makes lactose in the udder. Smaller whey proteins include immunoglobulins, the protective proteins, and lactoferrin, which binds iron.

Whey proteins behave very differently from casein. They are compact, folded, globular proteins, soluble in water, and they do not clot with rennet or with acid at pH 4.6. What they do respond to is heat. When milk is heated, whey proteins unfold, a change called denaturation, and the unfolded proteins can stick to casein micelles and to each other. That is why strongly heated milk sets into a firmer yoghurt, and why the heat history of milk changes how its powder behaves: the whey protein nitrogen index in Unit 5 measures exactly how much whey protein is still undamaged.

Alpha-lactalbumin deserves a special note. It is not only a milk protein; in the udder it is part of lactose synthetase, the enzyme that builds lactose from glucose and galactose. Without it, the udder could not make milk sugar at all.

🤔 Pause and think: if whey proteins do not clot with rennet, where do they go when cheese is made, and what does that mean for the whey left behind?

Quick check

How do whey proteins differ from casein when milk is heated?

Check your answer

Whey proteins unfold (denature) on heating and can stick to casein micelles, while casein itself is heat stable and does not unfold the same way.

2.5 Lactose: milk sugar and its two jobs

Lactose is the sugar of milk, about 4.6-4.8% of cow milk, and it is found in milk and nowhere else in nature in any quantity. It is a disaccharide, built from one glucose and one galactose joined together, and it is made in the udder by the lactose synthetase system that uses alpha-lactalbumin.

Lactose does two jobs in dairy technology, and both run through this whole subject:

  • It feeds fermentation. Lactic acid bacteria eat lactose and turn it into lactic acid. That acid is what sets yoghurt, starts cheese, and preserves fermented milks. Without lactose there would be no fermented dairy products at all.
  • It controls water. Lactose holds water and shapes the texture of dried and concentrated milks. When it crystallises in large crystals it causes sandiness in sweetened condensed milk, the defect met in Unit 5, and when it takes up water in a powder it causes caking.

Lactose is only mildly sweet, about a fifth as sweet as sucrose, which is why milk tastes gently sweet rather than sugary. It is also less soluble than sucrose, and that low solubility is behind the crystallisation problems above. In the gut, lactose is split by the enzyme lactase; people who make little lactase in adult life digest milk poorly, but tolerate fermented milks better, because the bacteria have already used up much of the lactose.

Quick check

Name two jobs lactose does in dairy technology.

Check your answer

It feeds fermentation, as bacteria turn it into lactic acid, and it controls water and texture in concentrated and dried milks, where its crystals can cause sandiness or caking.

2.6 Milk salts and minerals

Milk carries about 0.7% minerals, and the important ones are calcium, phosphorus, potassium, sodium, magnesium, and chloride, with small amounts of citrate. The salts matter far beyond their weight, because they hold the casein micelle together and set the balance of the milk:

  • Calcium and phosphate sit partly dissolved in the serum and partly bound inside the micelle as colloidal calcium phosphate, the bridges that hold casein together. Lose the calcium and the micelle falls apart; add the wrong salt and the milk will not stand heat.
  • Potassium and sodium are the main dissolved salts, and their balance shifts when the udder is infected: mastitis milk has more sodium and chloride and less potassium and lactose, which is one reason it tastes salty.
  • Citrate helps keep calcium dissolved and buffers the milk against pH change.

Milk also carries trace elements such as zinc, iron, copper, and iodine, in small amounts that vary with feed and with contamination from equipment. Copper is worth a mention because even tiny amounts speed up the oxidation of milk fat, giving tallowy and cardboard flavours, which is one reason dairy equipment is made of stainless steel, not copper.

Quick check

Why does the salt balance of milk matter for cheese making?

Check your answer

Calcium phosphate bridges hold the casein micelle together, so losing calcium or adding the wrong salt changes how the milk clots and stands heat.

2.7 Enzymes in milk: the quiet workers

Milk carries its own enzymes, proteins that speed up chemical changes, and several of them shape dairy technology:

  • Lipase cuts fat and releases free fatty acids. In fresh milk it is kept away from the fat by the globule membrane, but if the membrane is damaged, by rough handling, freezing, or homogenisation of raw milk, lipase gets in and the milk turns rancid. Pasteurisation destroys lipase.
  • Proteases cut protein. The native milk protease, plasmin, survives pasteurisation and works slowly in stored milk and cheese, which is part of ripening and part of why long-stored milk goes bitter.
  • Lactoperoxidase is part of the natural antibacterial system of milk, used in the preservation method met in Unit 1. Pasteurisation destroys it.
  • Alkaline phosphatase is destroyed by proper pasteurisation and survives under-pasteurisation, which is why the phosphatase test is used to check that pasteurisation was done right. Unit 13 comes back to it.
  • Xanthine oxidase sits in the fat globule membrane and is linked with the membrane's chemistry.

The rule to carry forward is simple: enzymes are not removed with the microbes. Some survive pasteurisation, and a few survive even sterilisation, so the heat history of milk decides which enzymes are still at work in the finished product.

Quick check

Why is the phosphatase test useful after pasteurisation?

Check your answer

Alkaline phosphatase is destroyed by proper pasteurisation and survives under-pasteurisation, so its presence shows the heat treatment was too light.

2.8 Minor parts: vitamins, and the things that colour milk

Milk carries fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, and K in its fat, and water-soluble vitamins, notably riboflavin (B2) and B12, in its serum. Riboflavin gives whey its greenish-yellow colour, and it is light-sensitive, which is one reason milk in clear bottles on a lit shelf loses vitamin and picks up a light-induced off-flavour. The white colour of milk itself comes from light scattered by fat globules and casein micelles, while the yellow tint of the fat comes from carotene, the pigment the animal gets from green feed.

Milk also carries dissolved gases, mainly carbon dioxide and oxygen, and small amounts of non-protein nitrogen: urea, amino acids, and other small nitrogen compounds that add up to about 5% of the total nitrogen in milk. Those minor parts are small in weight but they matter for flavour, for vitamin losses, and for the tests that check milk quality.

🤔 Pause and think: milk left in a clear bottle on a sunny shelf tastes different by evening. Which parts of the milk does the light attack, and how would you stop it?

Quick check

What gives whey its greenish-yellow colour?

Check your answer

Riboflavin, vitamin B2, dissolved in the serum.

2.9 Putting it together: why milk curdles, creams, and sours

With the chemistry in hand, three everyday events of milk fall into place:

  • Creaming. Fat globules are lighter than the serum, so they rise. Cold milk creams slowly, warm milk faster, and homogenised milk hardly at all, because the globules are too small to rise quickly.
  • Souring. Bacteria eat lactose and make lactic acid, the pH falls, and at pH 4.6 the casein micelles lose their charge and join: the milk curdles. Souring is acid coagulation happening by accident.
  • Heat clotting. Milk that is already acid, or low in calcium balance, clots when it is boiled, because heat plus acid together collapse the micelle system. Fresh milk with normal acidity stands boiling; sour milk does not.

Each of those is the same chemistry from a different angle, and each is used on purpose somewhere in dairy technology: creaming is undone by homogenisation, souring is controlled in fermentation, and heat clotting is tested for before evaporated milk is made.

Quick check

Fresh milk stands boiling, but sour milk clots when boiled. Why?

Check your answer

Sour milk is already acid, so heat plus acid together collapse the casein micelle system, while fresh milk at normal acidity stands the heat.

2.10 Where the minerals sit: soluble, colloidal, and why it matters

Milk salts are not all floating free in the liquid. Some are dissolved in the serum, and some are locked inside the casein micelles as colloidal calcium phosphate. Where each mineral sits decides how milk behaves when it is heated, cooled, or soured, so this section maps the split.

The split, mineral by mineral

About two-thirds of the calcium in milk sits in the micelles, bound as colloidal calcium phosphate, and about one-third is dissolved in the serum. Phosphorus splits in a similar way, because much of it is the phosphate half of that same colloidal complex. Potassium, sodium, and chloride, by contrast, are almost all dissolved in the serum: they are the salts that carry the electrical conductivity met in Unit 3, and they pass freely through a membrane. Magnesium sits between the two: part colloidal, part soluble.

Milk salts: where each part sits

Calcium
About two-thirds colloidal, inside the micelles as calcium phosphate. About one-third dissolved in the serum.
Phosphorus
Split like calcium: much of it is the phosphate half of the colloidal complex, the rest dissolved.
Potassium, sodium, chloride
Almost all dissolved in the serum. These are the ions that carry conductivity and set the osmotic balance.
Magnesium
Part colloidal, part soluble: between the two groups above.

Figure 2.2: Where the minerals sit in milk: colloidal inside the micelles, soluble in the serum. Drawn from the mineral distribution described in Fox and McSweeney, Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry, Chapter 5.

Worked example: the calcium in 100 kg of milk. Cow milk carries about 120 mg of calcium in each 100 g, so 100 kg of milk carries about 120 g of calcium in total. About 80 g of that sits in the micelles as colloidal calcium phosphate, and about 40 g is dissolved in the serum. Only the dissolved part is free to move, to react, or to pass through a membrane: the micelle part travels with the casein, and it goes where the curd goes when cheese is made, which is why cheese keeps most of the milk calcium and whey keeps little.

Acid moves calcium out of the micelle

When acid builds up, the micelle loses calcium. Hydrogen ions take the place of calcium in the micelle, and the calcium phosphate dissolves into the serum. By the time the milk reaches pH 4.6 and sets, much of the colloidal calcium has left the micelle: the acid curd is held together by the casein itself, not by calcium bridges, which is why an acid curd is soft and fragile next to a rennet curd, where the calcium bridges are still in place. The same shift explains why the whey from acid cheese is richer in calcium than the whey from rennet cheese: the acid moved the calcium into the liquid before the curd was cut.

Heat and cold move it the other way, and back

Heating milk moves soluble calcium phosphate the other way, out of the serum and onto the micelles, and at high heat some of it settles out as scale on the hot plates: the milk stone met in Unit 14. Cooling does the reverse: cold milk holds more calcium in solution than warm milk, which is one reason milk held cold for a long time behaves differently when it is renneted. A cheese maker who renneted cold-stored milk straight from the tank would get a slow, weak set, and the fix is in the books: warm the milk to its renneting temperature and hold it there, so the calcium moves back to where the rennet needs it, before the rennet goes in.

🤔 Pause and think: two vats of the same milk are made into cheese. One is set with acid, the other with rennet. Which whey will carry more calcium, and why does the answer follow from where the calcium sat before the milk was set?

Quick check

Why does acid cheese whey carry more calcium than rennet cheese whey?

Check your answer

Acid dissolves the colloidal calcium phosphate out of the micelles and into the serum, so the calcium leaves with the whey. Rennet leaves the calcium bridges in the curd, so the calcium stays in the cheese.

2.11 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a cheese maker heats milk hard before adding rennet, and the curd comes out weak and soft. Which protein did the heat damage, and how did that change the curd?

  1. What are the three phases in milk, and which one makes milk look white?
Check your answer

An emulsion of fat globules, a colloidal suspension of casein micelles, and a true solution of lactose and salts. The fat globules and the casein micelles scatter light, which makes milk look white.

  1. Rennet and acid both make milk clot, but they do it differently. How?
Check your answer

Acid lowers the pH to 4.6, the isoelectric point of casein, so micelles lose their charge and join. Rennet uses chymosin to clip the kappa casein hairs off the micelles, so they join even at normal pH near 6.6.

  1. Why does homogenising raw milk risk a rancid flavour?
Check your answer

Homogenisation breaks the fat globule membrane, letting lipase reach the fat and cut it into free fatty acids, which taste rancid. Pasteurising first destroys the lipase.

  1. Lactose is only mildly sweet. Why does its low solubility still cause trouble?
Check your answer

When lactose crystallises in large crystals it causes sandiness in sweetened condensed milk, and when it takes up water in a powder it causes caking.

Try it: Warm two small cups of milk. Stir a spoonful of lemon juice into one and leave the other plain. The lemon cup curdles as its pH falls toward 4.6, while the plain cup stays liquid: you have just done acid coagulation on your kitchen bench, the same chemistry that sets yoghurt.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Milk holds three phases at once: an emulsion of fat globules, a colloidal suspension of casein micelles, and a true solution of lactose and salts.
  • The fat globule membrane keeps globules apart and shields the fat from lipase; breaking it risks rancidity.
  • Casein, about four-fifths of milk protein, forms micelles held together by calcium phosphate, with kappa casein hairs on the outside keeping them apart.
  • Acid clots milk at pH 4.6, the isoelectric point of casein; rennet clots it by clipping the kappa casein hairs, even at normal pH near 6.6.
  • Whey proteins stay in the whey when casein clots, and they unfold on heating, which changes yoghurt texture and powder behaviour.
  • Lactose feeds fermentation into lactic acid and controls water and texture in concentrated and dried milks.
  • Milk salts, above all calcium and phosphate, hold the micelle together; enzymes such as lipase, plasmin, and phosphatase keep working after the microbes are gone, and phosphatase is the check for proper pasteurisation.

  • About two-thirds of milk calcium sits in the micelles as colloidal calcium phosphate and about one-third is dissolved, while potassium, sodium, and chloride are almost all dissolved in the serum.

  • Acid dissolves colloidal calcium phosphate out of the micelles into the serum, so acid curd is held together by casein alone and acid whey carries more calcium than rennet whey.
  • Heating moves soluble calcium onto the micelles and onto hot plates as scale, while cooling moves it back into solution, so cold-stored milk must be warmed and held before renneting.

Glossary

Emulsion

A mixture where droplets of one liquid float in another without dissolving. Food tech example: milk fat floats as globules in water, and churning joins those globules into butter.

Colloid

A mixture where very fine particles hang in a liquid without settling. Food tech example: casein micelles hang in milk serum as a colloid, and they scatter light, which helps make milk look white.

Micelle

A loose ball of casein molecules held together with calcium phosphate. Food tech example: rennet or acid makes micelles join into a curd, the first step of cheese making.

Kappa casein

The casein that sits mostly on the outside of the micelle, with hairs that keep micelles apart. Food tech example: rennet clips these hairs off, so the micelles join and the milk sets.

Isoelectric point

The pH at which a protein carries no net charge and is least soluble. Food tech example: casein clots at pH 4.6, its isoelectric point, which is how yoghurt sets.

Whey protein

A milk protein that stays dissolved when casein is clotted out. Food tech example: beta-lactoglobulin unfolds on heating, which is why strongly heated milk sets into a firmer yoghurt.

Denaturation

The unfolding of a protein by heat or other treatment, which changes its behaviour. Food tech example: heated whey proteins stick to casein micelles and change how milk powder dissolves.

Lactose

Milk sugar, built from glucose and galactose. Food tech example: starter bacteria ferment lactose into lactic acid, which sets yoghurt and starts cheese.

Lipase

An enzyme that cuts fat into free fatty acids. Food tech example: if the fat globule membrane is broken, lipase reaches the fat and the milk turns rancid.

Phosphatase

An enzyme in milk destroyed by proper pasteurisation. Food tech example: the phosphatase test checks pasteurised milk, since the enzyme surviving means the heat treatment was too light.

Triglyceride

A fat molecule built from glycerol and three fatty acids. Food tech example: milk fat is mostly triglycerides, and their mix of short and long fatty acids gives butter its flavour and its soft texture.

Serum

The watery part of milk with its dissolved lactose, salts, and whey proteins. Food tech example: after casein is clotted out and the fat is removed, the liquid left is whey, which comes from the serum.

Colloidal calcium phosphate

The calcium phosphate locked inside the casein micelles, holding them together. Food tech example: about two-thirds of milk calcium sits as colloidal calcium phosphate in the micelles, and it travels with the curd when cheese is made.

Salt balance

How milk minerals split between the micelles and the dissolved serum, and how acid, heat, and cold shift that split. Food tech example: acid moves calcium out of the micelles into the serum, which is why acid whey carries more calcium than rennet whey.

References

  • Chemistry of Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Modules 1-8.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.
  • Physical Chemistry of Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Module 1.

Unit 3: Physical Chemistry of Milk

Note

Unit 3: Physical Chemistry of Milk

Two samples of milk can have the same fat and the same protein, yet one pours thin and the other pours thick, one freezes at one temperature and the other at another, and one stands boiling while the other curdles. The chemistry of the parts is the same: what differs is the physics of how the parts sit together. This unit is about that physics.

3.1 Milk as a colloid: why the small things rule

A colloid is a system where particles too small to see hang in a liquid without settling. Milk is full of them. The casein micelles, 50 to 300 nanometres across, and the fat globules, 1 to 10 micrometres across, are the dispersed phase, and the serum is the continuous phase around them. The particles stay apart for two reasons: they carry the same electric charge, so they repel each other, and the kappa casein hairs on the micelles stick out and keep them from touching.

That balance is delicate, and every dairy process leans on it. Add acid and the charge falls, so the micelles join. Add rennet and the hairs are clipped, so the micelles join. Add salt in the wrong amount and the charge changes, so the milk will not stand heat. Heat the milk and the whey proteins unfold and stick to the micelles, changing their surface. The colloid is not a fixed thing: it is a balance of forces, and the maker works by tipping that balance on purpose, at the right time, in the right direction.

🤔 Pause and think: if milk were a true solution, with everything dissolved, could it ever form a curd? What would be missing?

Quick check

What keeps casein micelles apart in fresh milk?

Check your answer

Their matching electric charge makes them repel each other, and the kappa casein hairs sticking out of the micelles keep them from touching.

3.2 Density and specific gravity: the quick check that catches water

The density of milk is its mass per unit volume, and its specific gravity is its density compared with water at the same temperature. Cow milk has a specific gravity of about 1.028 to 1.034 at 15.5 °C, and buffalo milk is near 1.030 to 1.032. That number is a balance of two pulls: fat is lighter than water and pulls the figure down, while solids-not-fat are heavier than water and pull it up. Skim milk, with the fat taken out, has a higher specific gravity than whole milk.

That balance is what makes the lactometer useful. A lactometer is a hydrometer that floats in milk and reads its specific gravity. Add water to milk and the specific gravity falls toward 1.000, because water is lighter than the solids it replaces, so a low reading is a warning of watering. But fat also lowers the reading, so a rich milk and a watered milk can give the same lactometer figure. That is why the books insist on reading fat and specific gravity together: the two numbers, combined in a formula, give the solids-not-fat, and only then can watering be judged. The Quevenne lactometer used in dairies is read at a set temperature, and the reading is corrected if the milk is warmer or colder, because density changes with temperature.

Worked example: reading the balance. A milk tests 4% fat with a specific gravity of 1.032, and its solids-not-fat works out near 9%. Add 10% water and the fat falls to about 3.6% and the solids-not-fat to about 8.1%, while the specific gravity falls too. Either number alone could be explained away by a rich or a poor animal; the two together point at watering.

Quick check

Why must fat and specific gravity be read together to judge watering?

Check your answer

Fat pulls specific gravity down and solids-not-fat pull it up, so a rich milk and a watered milk can give the same lactometer reading; only the two numbers together give the solids-not-fat.

3.3 Surface tension: why milk foams and wets

Surface tension is the pull at the surface of a liquid that makes it behave like a stretched skin. Pure water has a high surface tension. Milk has a lower one, about 45 to 50 dynes per centimetre against about 72 for water, because its proteins and phospholipids gather at the surface and weaken the pull. That lower surface tension is why milk wets surfaces easily, why it foams when it is beaten or frothed, and why it climbs a little up the side of a glass.

Surface tension matters in the plant in two practical ways. First, it helps cleaning: detergents lower surface tension further, so the wash liquid spreads into corners and under deposits instead of beading up. Second, it shapes foaming: milk that foams too much in a tank or a filler slows the line and traps air in the product. Homogenisation, by breaking the fat globules and putting new protein on their surface, changes the surface behaviour of milk, which is one more reason homogenised milk foams differently from raw milk.

Quick check

Why does milk foam more easily than pure water?

Check your answer

Milk has lower surface tension, about 45 to 50 dynes per centimetre against about 72 for water, because its proteins and phospholipids gather at the surface.

3.4 Viscosity: why milk pours the way it does

Viscosity is a liquid's resistance to flow: thick liquids have high viscosity, thin liquids have low viscosity. Milk at room temperature has a viscosity of about 1.5 to 2.0 centipoise, only a little thicker than water at 1.0, and it behaves as a Newtonian fluid, meaning its viscosity does not change when you stir it faster. Cream is thicker, because it carries more fat globules that crowd each other, and its viscosity rises steeply as the fat content rises.

Three things change the viscosity of milk in the plant:

  • Temperature. Warm milk flows more easily than cold milk, so viscosity falls as temperature rises. That is why milk is heated before it is pumped through a homogeniser or an evaporator.
  • Fat content. More fat means more globules crowding the flow, so cream is far more viscous than skim milk.
  • Heat and acid. Heating milk unfolds whey proteins and thickens it a little; adding acid, as in yoghurt making, builds a gel and raises the viscosity sharply as the curd forms.

Viscosity is not a decoration: it decides how fast milk flows through pipes, how much power a pump needs, how a filler handles the product, and how a sauce or a yoghurt feels in the mouth. The plant measures it because the mouthfeel the customer feels is viscosity they can taste.

🤔 Pause and think: you heat milk for yoghurt and it thickens before any acid is added. Which proteins are doing that, and what is happening to them?

Quick check

Milk is Newtonian, but yoghurt is not. What does that mean in plain words?

Check your answer

Milk flows the same however fast you stir it, while yoghurt thins as you stir it faster, because its gel structure breaks down under stirring.

3.5 Freezing point: the most honest test for added water

The freezing point of milk is one of its most constant properties. Fresh cow milk freezes at about minus 0.52 to minus 0.56 °C, most often near minus 0.54 °C. The freezing point is set mainly by the lactose and the soluble salts dissolved in the serum: the more dissolved particles, the lower the freezing point. Fat and protein, which are not truly dissolved, barely affect it.

That constancy is what makes the freezing point the standard test for added water. Add water and the dissolved lactose and salts are diluted, so the freezing point rises toward 0 °C. A freezing point of minus 0.48 °C, for example, points at roughly 10% added water. The test is run on a cryoscope, an instrument that cools the milk carefully and reads the freezing point to a hundredth of a degree. Because the freezing point barely moves with breed, feed, or season, it catches watering that the lactometer can miss, and the books treat it as the reference method for the purpose.

How added water lifts the freezing point of milk

Pure water
Freezes at 0.00 °C.

↓
Lactose + salts dissolved pull the freezing point down

Fresh milk
Freezes near -0.54 °C.

↓
Add water: lactose + salts diluted, freezing point rises toward 0 °C

Watered milk
Freezes near -0.48 °C (about 10% added water).

Figure 3.1: How added water lifts the freezing point of milk toward 0 °C. Drawn from Physical Chemistry of Milk, Module 6, on colligative properties.

Quick check

Fresh milk freezes near minus 0.54 °C. Why does added water lift that figure?

Check your answer

Water dilutes the dissolved lactose and salts that pull the freezing point down, so the freezing point rises toward 0 °C.

3.6 Electrical conductivity: a quiet signal from the salts

Milk conducts electricity, because it carries dissolved salts, mainly the ions of potassium, sodium, chloride, and calcium, that carry charge through the liquid. The conductivity of normal milk is about 0.004 to 0.006 mhos per centimetre at 25 °C, and it rises with temperature and with salt content. Mastitis milk, which carries more sodium and chloride and less lactose, conducts more than normal milk, so conductivity is used in some milking systems as an early warning of udder infection.

Conductivity is also a process signal. It rises when milk is diluted, falls when milk is concentrated, and changes when salts are added or removed, as in demineralised whey. In cleaning, the conductivity of the rinse water tells the operator whether detergent is still in the line: detergent raises conductivity, so a rinse that reads like clean water is a rinse that has done its job.

Quick check

Why does mastitis milk conduct electricity better than normal milk?

Check your answer

It carries more sodium and chloride and less lactose, so there are more dissolved ions to carry charge.

3.7 Acidity and pH: two numbers that are not the same

Fresh milk has a pH of about 6.6 to 6.8, slightly on the acid side of neutral, and a titratable acidity of about 0.13 to 0.14% as lactic acid for cow milk and 0.14 to 0.15% for buffalo milk. Those two numbers describe different things, and confusing them causes real mistakes:

  • pH measures the free hydrogen ions in the milk right now: how acid the milk actually is at this moment. It is read on a pH meter, and it is the number that decides whether casein will clot and whether bacteria will grow.
  • Titratable acidity measures how much alkali is needed to bring the milk to a set endpoint, usually the phenolphthalein endpoint near pH 8.3. It counts not only the free acid but also the acid held in reserve by the milk's buffers, above all its proteins, phosphates, and citrates. That reserve is called natural acidity, and it is why milk with a normal pH can still show a measurable titratable acidity.

As bacteria ferment lactose into lactic acid, both numbers move, but the pH moves slowly at first, because the buffers soak up the early acid, and then falls faster once the buffers are used up. That buffer curve is why a milk can taste only slightly sour while its titratable acidity has already climbed past the point where it will clot on boiling: milk clots on boiling when its acidity reaches about 0.23% as lactic acid. The plant therefore tests both numbers, and trusts the pH for the curd and the titratable acidity for the keeping quality.

Quick check

Milk has a pH near 6.7 but a titratable acidity of 0.14%. How can both be true?

Check your answer

pH measures the free acid right now, while titratable acidity counts the acid held in reserve by the milk's buffers, such as proteins, phosphates, and citrates.

3.8 Buffers: why milk resists change

A buffer is a mixture that resists a change in pH when acid or alkali is added. Milk is well buffered, by its casein and whey proteins, its phosphates, and its citrates. That buffering does three things the maker feels directly:

  • It slows the fall of pH as lactic acid bacteria work, so fermentation takes time and the maker can control it.
  • It steadies the milk during heating, so a small change in acidity does not at once ruin the heat stability.
  • It sets the natural acidity, the 0.13 to 0.14% of fresh cow milk, which is the baseline every later acidity reading is judged against.

The buffer capacity is highest near the pH values where the milk's weak acids sit, and it falls as the milk gets very acid. That is why the pH of a fermenting milk falls slowly at first and then drops fast near the end: the buffers are spent, and the acid being made has nothing left to soak it up.

🤔 Pause and think: if milk had no buffers at all, what would happen to its pH in the first hour of fermentation, and how would that change cheese making?

Quick check

Why does the pH of fermenting milk fall slowly at first and then fast?

Check your answer

The milk's buffers, proteins, phosphates, and citrates, soak up the early acid, and once they are spent the pH drops fast.

3.9 Heat stability: will this milk stand the heat?

Heat stability is the milk's ability to stand high heat without clotting, and it decides whether a milk can be used for evaporated milk, for sterilised milk, or for long heating in any product. It is tested by heating a small tube of milk in an oil bath and noting the time until it clots. The stability is best near the milk's natural pH, about 6.6 to 6.7, and falls off on either side: too acid and the milk clots fast, too alkaline and it clots too. That is why the pH of evaporated milk is sometimes adjusted with a small dose of stabilising salt before sterilisation, and why the pilot sterilisation test in Unit 5 exists.

The factors that lower heat stability are the same ones that cause trouble everywhere in this subject: high acidity from bacterial growth, late lactation milk, milk stored cold for a long time, which lets enzymes work on the protein, and an unbalanced salt level, above all too much soluble calcium. The plant's answer is the same set of levers in reverse: use fresh milk, keep it cold and use it promptly, and test heat stability before the milk is committed to a product that needs hard heating.

Quick check

At which pH is milk most heat stable, and what lowers its heat stability?

Check your answer

Near its natural pH of 6.6 to 6.7. High acidity, late lactation, long cold storage, and unbalanced salts lower it.

3.10 Derivation: how fast cream rises, and why homogenising stops it

Cream rises because fat is lighter than the liquid around it. The speed at which it rises is not a guess: it follows Stokes law, and this section derives it one step at a time, then uses it to show why homogenisation works.

Stokes law, step by step

A fat globule rising through milk is a small sphere moving through a liquid. Three forces act on it: buoyancy pushing it up, because the globule is lighter than the milk serum; gravity pulling it down; and drag holding it back, because the liquid resists the movement. At a steady rising speed the push up and the drag balance exactly, and that balance gives Stokes law:

v = 2 × r² × g × (ρ_serum − ρ_fat) / (9 × η)

Read each symbol in plain words. v is the rising speed. r is the radius of the globule: the distance from its centre to its edge. g is the pull of gravity, 9.81 metres per second squared. ρ_serum minus ρ_fat is the density difference between the serum and the fat: the serum is heavier, so the difference is positive and the globule rises. η is the viscosity of the serum: how thick it is, and how hard it resists movement.

Two readings follow before any numbers are put in. First, the speed depends on r², the radius squared: a globule twice as wide rises four times as fast, and a globule half as wide rises four times as slowly. Second, the speed depends on the density difference and on the viscosity: colder, thicker milk holds the globules back, and warmer, thinner milk lets them rise faster, which is why cream rises faster in warm milk standing on a bench than in cold milk in a fridge.

Worked example: a globule before and after homogenising

Take a fat globule 4 micrometres across, so its radius is 2 micrometres, in milk at room temperature. The serum density is about 1,036 kg per cubic metre, the fat density about 930, so the difference is about 106 kg per cubic metre. The viscosity of milk serum is about 0.002 pascal seconds.

Step 1, square the radius: (2 × 10⁻⁶)² = 4 × 10⁻¹² square metres.

Step 2, multiply by 2, by g, and by the density difference: 2 × 4 × 10⁻¹² × 9.81 × 106 ≈ 8.3 × 10⁻⁹.

Step 3, divide by 9 times the viscosity: 9 × 0.002 = 0.018. So v ≈ 8.3 × 10⁻⁹ / 0.018 ≈ 4.6 × 10⁻⁷ metres per second.

Step 4, turn it into something a person can picture: 4.6 × 10⁻⁷ metres per second is about 1.7 millimetres per hour. In a day, that globule climbs about 4 centimetres: the cream line on a bottle left standing overnight.

Now homogenise the milk. The globules are torn to about 1 micrometre across, so the radius is 0.5 micrometres, a quarter of what it was. The speed depends on the radius squared, so it falls by a factor of 16: about 0.1 millimetres per hour. In a day, the droplet climbs about 2.5 millimetres: nothing a customer would ever see. That factor of 16 is the whole reason homogenised milk shows no cream line, and it comes from one line of maths: halve the radius twice, and the speed falls sixteen times.

Derivation: the added-water percentage from the freezing point

The freezing point test in Section 3.5 can also be turned into a number. Pure milk freezes near −0.54 °C because its lactose and salts hold the freezing point down. Added water dilutes those dissolved particles, so the freezing point rises toward 0 °C, and the rise is proportional to how much water was added.

Step 1, write the proportion. Percentage of added water ≈ (freezing point of pure milk − freezing point of the sample) / (freezing point of pure milk) × 100, using the sizes of the numbers without their minus signs.

Step 2, work an example. A sample freezes at −0.48 °C. The difference from pure milk is 0.54 − 0.48 = 0.06. Divide by 0.54: 0.06 / 0.54 ≈ 0.11, or about 11% added water. That matches the rough 10% figure given in Section 3.5, and now it is a calculation, not a memory.

Step 3, work a second one. A sample freezes at −0.51 °C. The difference is 0.03, and 0.03 / 0.54 ≈ 0.056, or about 5 to 6% added water: a small watering, but a real one, and the cryoscope catches it where the lactometer might miss it.

Step 4, note the limit. The calculation assumes the milk started at −0.54 °C, and real milk varies a little around that figure with breed, feed, and season. A plant therefore checks the freezing point against its own milk, taken from the same farms, and treats a single reading near the edge as a reason to test again, not as a verdict on its own.

🤔 Pause and think: a bottle of raw milk stands in a warm kitchen and in a cold fridge, side by side. Which one shows a cream line first, and which two parts of Stokes law explain the difference?

Quick check

Homogenising cuts a fat globule from 4 micrometres across to 1 micrometre across. How many times slower does it rise, and why?

Check your answer

About 16 times slower: the rising speed depends on the radius squared, and the radius is a quarter of what it was, so the speed falls by 4 × 4 = 16.

3.11 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: two milks test the same fat and the same protein. One freezes at minus 0.54 °C and the other at minus 0.49 °C. Which one has added water, and why can the freezing point tell you what the fat test cannot?

  1. What is a colloid, and what are the two parts of the milk colloid?
Check your answer

A colloid is a system where fine particles hang in a liquid without settling. In milk the dispersed phase is the casein micelles and fat globules, and the continuous phase is the serum.

  1. Cow milk has a specific gravity of about 1.028 to 1.034. Why does taking the fat out raise it?
Check your answer

Fat is lighter than water and pulls the figure down, while solids-not-fat are heavier than water and pull it up, so removing the fat leaves the heavier part in charge.

  1. Fresh milk freezes near minus 0.54 °C. What sets that figure, and what moves it?
Check your answer

The dissolved lactose and salts set it. Adding water dilutes them and lifts the freezing point toward 0 °C.

  1. Milk clots on boiling at about 0.23% titratable acidity. Why does pH alone not warn you in time?
Check your answer

The milk's buffers soak up early acid, so the pH falls slowly at first while the titratable acidity climbs, and by the time the pH has fallen far the milk is already past the boiling test.

Try it: Float a lactometer or a simple hydrometer in a glass of milk and note the reading, then stir in a spoonful of water and read it again. The reading falls. Now stir in a spoonful of skim milk powder instead: the reading rises. You have just felt the balance of fat and solids-not-fat that the plant measures every day.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Milk is a colloid: casein micelles and fat globules hang in serum, kept apart by charge and by kappa casein hairs, and every dairy process tips that balance on purpose.
  • Specific gravity, about 1.028 to 1.034 for cow milk, is a balance between light fat and heavy solids-not-fat, so fat and specific gravity must be read together to judge watering.
  • Milk has low surface tension, about 45 to 50 dynes per centimetre, which is why it foams and wets, and why detergents spread well in cleaning.
  • Milk is slightly thicker than water, about 1.5 to 2.0 centipoise, and flows as a Newtonian fluid until acid or heat builds a gel.
  • The freezing point, near minus 0.54 °C, is set by dissolved lactose and salts and barely moves with breed or season, so it is the reference test for added water.
  • Conductivity follows the dissolved salts, and mastitis milk, richer in sodium and chloride, conducts more.
  • pH, about 6.6 to 6.8, measures free acid now, while titratable acidity, about 0.13 to 0.14% for cow milk, counts the acid held by buffers. Milk clots on boiling near 0.23%.
  • Heat stability is best near pH 6.6 to 6.7 and is lowered by acidity, late lactation, long cold storage, and unbalanced salts.

  • Stokes law gives the rising speed of a fat globule as v = 2 × r² × g × (ρ_serum − ρ_fat) / (9 × η): the speed depends on the radius squared, so halving the radius twice cuts the speed sixteen times.

  • A 4 micrometre fat globule climbs about 1.7 millimetres per hour, while a 1 micrometre homogenised droplet climbs about 0.1 millimetres per hour: that is why homogenised milk shows no cream line.
  • The added-water percentage follows from the freezing point: (0.54 − sample freezing point) / 0.54 × 100, so a sample freezing at −0.48 °C carries about 11% added water.

Glossary

Colloid

A system where fine particles hang in a liquid without settling. Food tech example: casein micelles hang in milk serum as a colloid, and acid or rennet tips the balance so they join into a curd.

Specific gravity

The density of a liquid compared with water at the same temperature. Food tech example: cow milk reads about 1.028 to 1.034, and adding water pulls the reading toward 1.000.

Lactometer

A hydrometer that floats in milk and reads its specific gravity. Food tech example: a low lactometer reading warns of watering, but it must be read together with the fat test.

Surface tension

The pull at the surface of a liquid that makes it behave like a stretched skin. Food tech example: milk has lower surface tension than water, so it foams when beaten and wets surfaces easily.

Viscosity

A liquid's resistance to flow. Food tech example: cream is far more viscous than skim milk because its fat globules crowd each other as it flows.

Newtonian fluid

A fluid whose viscosity does not change when it is stirred faster. Food tech example: fresh milk is Newtonian, while yoghurt thins as it is stirred, because its gel breaks down.

Freezing point

The temperature at which a liquid freezes. Food tech example: fresh milk freezes near minus 0.54 °C, and added water lifts that figure toward 0 °C.

Cryoscope

An instrument that measures the freezing point of milk precisely. Food tech example: a cryoscope reading of minus 0.48 °C points at roughly 10% added water.

Conductivity

How well a liquid carries an electric current, set by its dissolved salts. Food tech example: mastitis milk conducts better than normal milk because it carries more sodium and chloride.

pH

A scale for how acid or alkaline a liquid is right now, from its free hydrogen ions. Food tech example: fresh milk has a pH of about 6.6 to 6.8, and casein clots when the pH falls to 4.6.

Titratable acidity

The acid in milk measured by how much alkali is needed to bring it to a set endpoint, including the acid held by buffers. Food tech example: fresh cow milk reads about 0.13 to 0.14% as lactic acid, and it clots on boiling near 0.23%.

Buffer

A mixture that resists a change in pH when acid or alkali is added. Food tech example: milk proteins, phosphates, and citrates buffer milk, so its pH falls slowly at first during fermentation.

Heat stability

The ability of milk to stand high heat without clotting. Food tech example: milk for evaporated milk is tested in a heated tube first, because milk with poor heat stability curdles in the can.

Stokes law

The rule for how fast a small sphere rises or sinks in a liquid: speed = 2 × r² × g × density difference / (9 × viscosity). Food tech example: a fat globule rises at a speed that depends on its radius squared, so homogenising to a quarter of the radius cuts the rising speed sixteen times.

Cryoscope

The instrument that cools milk carefully and reads its freezing point to a hundredth of a degree. Food tech example: a cryoscope reading of −0.48 °C instead of −0.54 °C points at about 11% added water.

References

  • Physical Chemistry of Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Modules 1-10.
  • Chemistry of Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Module 2.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.

Unit 4: Market Milk Processing: Separation, Standardisation, Homogenisation and Pasteurisation

Note

Unit 4: Market Milk Processing: Separation, Standardisation, Homogenisation and Pasteurisation

The milk that reaches the plant gate is not the milk that reaches the shop shelf. Between the two, the milk is weighed, tested, cooled, cleaned, split, rebuilt, and heated, and each step changes it a little. Which of those steps are about safety, which are about keeping quality, and which are about giving the customer the same milk every day? This unit follows the milk through the plant, step by step.

4.1 Reception: the plant gate decides everything

Reception is where raw milk is accepted or rejected, and the decision is made fast, because a tanker cannot wait. The reception tests, called platform tests, are quick checks done at the gate: look at the milk, smell it, taste it if needed, test its acidity, run the clot-on-boiling test, and check its temperature. Milk that smells sour, looks dirty, or clots on boiling is rejected on the spot. Milk that passes is weighed or measured, sampled for the laboratory, and sent to chilling or straight to processing.

The laboratory then runs the slower tests on the sample: fat by the Gerber method, solids-not-fat, and the bacterial checks that take hours, such as the methylene blue reduction test covered in Unit 13. The plant's rule is plain: a bad lot must be caught at the gate, because once it is mixed into a silo with good milk, the whole silo is spoiled. Reception is therefore not paperwork: it is the last point where a bad lot can be kept out cheaply.

🤔 Pause and think: a tanker arrives warm, at 20 °C, but smells fine and passes the clot test. Would you accept it? What has the warmth already done, even if the milk still smells fine?

Quick check

Why must a bad lot be caught at reception, before it enters the silo?

Check your answer

Once bad milk is mixed into a silo with good milk, the whole silo is spoiled, so reception is the last point where it can be kept out cheaply.

4.2 Chilling and storage: cold buys time

Milk is chilled to 4 °C or below as soon as it arrives, and held cold until it is processed. Chilling does not kill bacteria: it slows them to a crawl. The bacteria that grow at fridge temperature, the psychrotrophs, still grow, slowly, and their enzymes can cause bitter and rancid flavours in milk held cold for a long time, which is why the books put a limit on how long raw milk should be stored, even cold, and why Unit 8 treats psychrotrophs as a storage problem, not just a farm problem.

Storage tanks in the plant are insulated, jacketed, and fitted with slow agitators so the milk stays uniform and cold all the way through. A tank with a warm spot, or milk left standing unstirred, will sour in the warm layer while the rest stays cold. The plant's habit is to process milk promptly, first in first out, and never to top up a tank of old milk with fresh milk and call the mixture fresh.

Quick check

Does chilling kill the bacteria in milk?

Check your answer

No, it slows them to a crawl. Bacteria that grow at fridge temperature still grow slowly, and their enzymes can spoil milk held cold for too long.

4.3 Filtration and clarification: taking the dirt out

Before milk is processed, it is filtered or clarified to remove visible dirt, straw, hair, and sediment. A filter is a cloth or pad the milk passes through; a clarifier is a centrifuge that spins the milk so the heavy dirt is thrown out to the wall of the bowl. Clarification also removes some leucocytes and bacteria, and it removes the sediment that would otherwise show up in the finished milk.

Filtration is simple and cheap; clarification is faster and more thorough, and it works on hot milk as well as cold. Neither step makes dirty milk clean in the bacterial sense: the bacteria that came in with the dirt are mostly still there, and only heat treatment deals with them. What filtration and clarification do is remove the visible evidence of poor handling, and protect the later equipment from clogging.

Quick check

Does clarifying milk make it safe to drink?

Check your answer

No, it removes visible dirt and some cells, but the bacteria are mostly still there: only heat treatment deals with them.

4.4 Separation: splitting milk into cream and skim

Separation splits milk into cream and skim milk, using a centrifugal separator. Milk enters a fast-spinning bowl, and the heavier skim milk is thrown to the outside while the lighter fat globules gather near the centre, where they are drawn off as cream. The fat content of the cream is set by adjusting the flow: a cream of 40% fat is common for butter making, while a lighter cream of 18 to 22% fat is sold as table cream.

The separator works because fat is lighter than serum, the same reason cream rises in a bottle, but the centrifuge does in seconds what gravity does in hours. Warm milk separates better than cold milk, because warm milk is thinner and the globules move more easily, so milk is usually warmed to about 40 °C before separation. Separation is also where bactofugation belongs: a special high-speed centrifuge that throws bacterial spores, which are heavier than milk, out of the milk along with the dirt, cutting the spore load before heat treatment.

Worked example: where the fat goes. Start with 100 kg of milk at 4% fat: 4 kg of fat in total. Separate it into 10 kg of cream at 40% fat and 90 kg of skim milk. The cream carries 4 kg of fat, so the skim milk is left with almost no fat, about 0.05%. That is why skim milk is the starting material for skim milk powder and why cream is the starting material for butter.

Centrifugal separation of milk

Whole milk in
100 kg, 4% fat.

↓
Fast-spinning bowl

In the bowl
Heavy skim milk: thrown outward. Light cream: gathers at centre.

↓

Skim milk out
90 kg, about 0.05% fat.
Cream out
10 kg, about 40% fat.

Figure 4.1: Centrifugal separation of milk into cream and skim milk. Drawn from Market Milk, Lessons 19 and 20.

Quick check

Why is milk warmed to about 40 °C before separation?

Check your answer

Warm milk is thinner, so the fat globules move more easily and separate better in the centrifuge.

4.5 Standardisation: the same milk every day

Standardisation is adjusting the fat and solids-not-fat of milk to a fixed target, so that the milk sold today is the same as the milk sold yesterday. The plant does it by mixing whole milk, skim milk, and cream in the right proportions, using the Pearson square or a simple mass balance. A milk sold as 3% fat is made to 3% fat, whatever the incoming milk tested.

Worked example: the Pearson square idea. A plant has milk at 4.5% fat and skim milk at 0.1% fat, and wants milk at 3.0% fat. The differences are 3.0 minus 0.1, which is 2.9 parts of the 4.5% milk, and 4.5 minus 3.0, which is 1.5 parts of the 0.1% skim. Mix 2.9 parts of whole milk with 1.5 parts of skim milk and the blend tests 3.0% fat. The same arithmetic works for solids-not-fat, using skim milk powder or water-free adjustments where needed.

Standardisation is also how the plant uses its raw material well. High-fat milk is skimmed to make cream for butter, and the skim is used for standardising, for powder, or for fermented products. Nothing is wasted by accident: the fat is routed to where it pays best.

🤔 Pause and think: a plant skips standardisation and sells each day's milk as it came from the farm. What would the customer notice over a week, and what would the cheese maker notice?

Quick check

What is standardisation, and why does the plant do it?

Check your answer

Adjusting fat and solids-not-fat to a fixed target by mixing whole milk, skim milk, and cream, so the milk sold is the same every day.

4.6 Homogenisation: stopping the cream line

Homogenisation breaks the fat globules into far smaller ones, so small that they no longer rise to form a cream layer. Milk is forced at high pressure, typically 150 to 200 kg per square centimetre, through a narrow valve, and the globules are torn apart into droplets about 1 micrometre across or smaller. The total surface area of the fat grows enormously, and milk proteins coat the new surface, which keeps the tiny droplets apart.

The effects are practical and visible: homogenised milk does not form a cream line, it looks whiter, it feels smoother in the mouth, and it is easier to digest, because the small globules present more surface to digestive enzymes. The effects also reach into other products: homogenised milk makes a softer curd in cheese, a smoother yoghurt, and a whiter, more stable evaporated milk, which is why evaporated milk is homogenised before it is canned.

There is a risk to manage. Homogenising raw milk breaks the fat globule membrane and lets lipase reach the fat, which causes rancidity. The rule is therefore to pasteurise first, or to homogenise hot milk where the lipase is already destroyed, and never to homogenise raw milk and then leave it standing.

Quick check

How does homogenisation stop the cream line?

Check your answer

It breaks fat globules into droplets about 1 micrometre across, too small to rise quickly, and milk proteins coat the new surface and keep them apart.

4.7 Pasteurisation: the heat treatment that made milk safe

Pasteurisation is heating milk to a set temperature for a set time to kill the disease-causing microbes and most spoilage microbes, without changing the milk's flavour much. The two standard forms are:

MethodTemperature and timeWhere it is used
Low temperature, long time (LTLT, batch)63 °C for 30 minutesSmall plants, batch tanks
High temperature, short time (HTST)72 °C for 15 secondsLarge plants, continuous flow

The two are equivalent in killing power: the same microbes are destroyed by a lower temperature held longer or a higher temperature held briefly. The books state the definition plainly: every particle of milk must reach at least 63 °C for 30 minutes, or 72 °C for 15 seconds, or an equivalent time and temperature combination.

The HTST pasteuriser is a continuous machine built from sections: a regeneration section, where incoming cold milk is warmed by outgoing hot milk, saving energy; a heating section, where hot water or steam brings the milk to 72 °C; a holding tube, sized so the milk takes exactly 15 seconds to pass through it; and a cooling section, where the milk is chilled back to 4 °C. A flow diversion valve sends the milk back for re-heating if the temperature falls below the set point, so no under-heated milk can reach the filler. That valve is the safety heart of the machine.

Pasteurisation kills the pathogens that matter in milk, including the tuberculosis and brucellosis organisms and the common food poisoning bacteria, and it destroys lipase and the lactoperoxidase system. It does not kill bacterial spores, and it does not sterilise the milk: pasteurised milk still carries some heat-resistant bacteria and must be kept cold and used promptly. The phosphatase test checks that pasteurisation was done right, because the enzyme alkaline phosphatase is destroyed by proper pasteurisation and survives under-pasteurisation.

The HTST pasteuriser, from cold milk in to cold milk out

Cold milk in
4 °C.

↓

Regeneration
Warmed by hot outgoing milk, saves energy.

↓

Heating
To 72 °C.

↓

Holding tube
15 seconds at 72 °C.

↓

Flow diversion valve
Too cold, and the milk goes back for re-heating.

↓

Cooling
To 4 °C, then to filler.

Figure 4.2: The HTST pasteuriser, from cold milk in to cold milk out. Drawn from Market Milk, Lessons 28 and 30.

Quick check

Why does the HTST pasteuriser have a flow diversion valve?

Check your answer

It sends milk back for re-heating if the temperature falls below the set point, so no under-heated milk can reach the filler.

4.8 Sterilisation and UHT: milk that keeps without a fridge

Sterilisation heats milk far harder than pasteurisation, to kill all microbes including spores, so the milk keeps for months without refrigeration. In-bottle sterilisation heats sealed bottles to about 115 °C for 15 to 20 minutes. The UHT process, ultra-high temperature, heats milk in a continuous flow to about 135 to 150 °C for a few seconds, then fills it into sterile packs in a sterile filler: that is the long-life milk sold in cartons.

UHT milk tastes more cooked than pasteurised milk, because the high heat changes the proteins and the flavour, and it can develop a stale note on long storage. Its advantage is the shelf life: months at room temperature, with no fridge needed until the pack is opened. After opening, it is handled like pasteurised milk: kept cold and used promptly. The plant's choice between pasteurised and UHT milk is therefore a choice between fresh flavour and long keeping, and the two products serve different markets.

🤔 Pause and think: UHT milk keeps for months unopened, yet goes off in days once opened. What changes at the moment the pack is opened?

Quick check

What is the difference between pasteurised milk and UHT milk?

Check your answer

Pasteurisation kills pathogens and most spoilage microbes but not spores, and the milk must stay cold. UHT heating to about 135 to 150 °C for a few seconds kills spores too, so the sealed pack keeps for months without a fridge.

4.9 Market milk varieties: one milk, many bottles

The plant turns standardised milk into the varieties the customer buys: whole milk, reduced-fat milk, skim milk, flavoured milk, and toned milk, which is milk adjusted with skim milk and skim milk powder to a lower fat and a normal solids-not-fat. Special milks add to the range: milk fortified with vitamins, lactose-reduced milk for people who digest lactose poorly, and milk with added minerals. The varieties differ in fat and in solids, but the processing steps are the same: reception, chilling, standardisation, homogenisation where wanted, pasteurisation, cooling, and filling into clean packs.

Filling and packaging close the line. Pasteurised milk is filled cold into bottles, pouches, or cartons, and the packs are sealed, dated, and kept cold through distribution. A clean filler and cold distribution matter as much as the pasteuriser: milk pasteurised well and filled into a dirty pack, or left warm on a shop shelf, will spoil just as fast as raw milk.

Quick check

Name three market milk varieties a plant can make from the same raw milk.

Check your answer

Any three of: whole milk, reduced-fat milk, skim milk, flavoured milk, toned milk, vitamin-fortified milk, or lactose-reduced milk.

4.10 The three machines that do the work: separator bowl, plate pack, and homogeniser valve

Three machines carry most of Unit 4: the separator, the plate heat exchanger, and the homogeniser. Each one is simple in idea and exacting in detail, and each one fails in a characteristic way when it is run wrong. This section opens each one up.

The separator bowl

A separator bowl is a stack of thin conical discs spinning at several thousand revolutions per minute. Milk enters near the centre and flows outward between the discs. The discs split the milk into many thin layers, so a fat globule only has to travel a millimetre or two sideways before it reaches a disc surface and slides inward to the cream outlet, while the heavier skim milk flows outward to its own outlet. That short travel is the whole trick: without the discs, the globule would have to cross the whole bowl, and separation would be slow and poor.

The separator bowl, in outline

Milk in
Warm milk, near 40 °C, enters near the centre of the spinning bowl.

↓

Disc stack
Thin conical discs split the milk into thin layers. Fat globules travel a short distance to a disc and slide inward.

↓

Cream out
Light fat gathers near the centre and leaves through the cream outlet. Its fat content is set by the flow: a narrower cream outlet gives a richer cream.
Skim milk out
Heavy skim milk is thrown outward and leaves through the skim outlet.

Figure 4.3: The separator bowl: discs turn one wide bowl into many thin layers, so separation is fast and clean. Drawn from the description of centrifugal separation in Bylund, Dairy Processing Handbook, Chapter 6.

When separation goes wrong, the cause is usually one of three things. Milk that is too cold separates badly, because it is thick and the globules move slowly: warm it to near 40 °C. A bowl with worn seals or a wrong cream screw gives a cream that is too thin or too rich: check the outlets and the flow settings, not the milk. And a bowl that vibrates or foams has air in the feed or a blocked outlet: stop it, clean it, and check the feed line. The bowl never fixes bad milk: it only splits what it is given.

The plate heat exchanger

The plate heat exchanger is a pack of thin stainless steel plates, pressed with a chevron pattern and clamped in a frame with gaskets between them. Milk flows on one side of each plate and the heating or cooling medium flows on the other side, in the opposite direction. The channels are only a few millimetres wide, so a large heating area fits in a small frame, and the chevron pattern stirs the milk as it flows, which moves heat into the milk fast. The plates can be taken apart for cleaning, and more plates can be added when the plant wants more capacity: the machine grows by adding plates, not by buying a bigger one.

The pack is divided into sections by divider plates, and the milk passes through them in order:

The plate heat exchanger: sections in order

Regeneration section
Cold milk in at 4 °C is warmed by hot pasteurised milk flowing the other way. No steam, no refrigeration: heat is reused.

↓

Heating section
Hot water brings the milk from its regeneration temperature up to 72 °C. Only the last few degrees need fresh heat.

↓

Holding tube
A pipe outside the plate pack, sized so the milk takes 15 seconds to pass through it at 72 °C. Section 4.11 works out its length.

↓

Regeneration section, again
The hot milk now gives its heat back to the incoming cold milk, and cools itself down in the same step.

↓

Cooling section
Chilled water or ice water brings the milk down to 4 °C, ready for the filler.

Figure 4.4: The sections of an HTST pasteuriser, in the order the milk meets them. Drawn from the description of plate heat exchangers and the complete pasteuriser in Bylund, Dairy Processing Handbook, Chapter 6.

Two points of craft hide in that list. First, the flows run in opposite directions, called counter-current flow. The hottest milk meets the hottest incoming milk, and the coldest milk meets the coldest outgoing milk, so the temperature gap between the two streams stays even all the way along the pack, and heat moves steadily instead of in bursts. Second, the regeneration section is the biggest section in the pack, because it does most of the heating and most of the cooling: in a well run pasteuriser it recovers up to 94 to 95% of the heat, and the steam and the refrigeration only handle the small remainder. A pasteuriser with a fouled regeneration section shows it at once in the steam bill.

The homogeniser valve

The homogeniser valve is where the pressure built up by the pump is spent in one short, violent step. Milk at 150 to 200 bar is forced through a gap of a few hundredths of a millimetre between a valve seat and a valve plug, and the fat globules are torn apart as they pass through. The milk then hits an impact ring, which breaks the droplets smaller still, and leaves through the outlet at low pressure. A second stage valve, run at a lower pressure, breaks up the small clusters that form after the first stage, so the droplets stay separate instead of clumping.

The homogeniser valve, in outline

Milk in at high pressure
150 to 200 bar from the pump. Fat globules whole, about 3 to 4 micrometres across.

↓

The gap
A few hundredths of a millimetre between valve seat and valve plug. The milk speeds up sharply, the pressure falls, and the globules are torn apart.

↓

Impact ring
The fast jet hits the ring and breaks the droplets smaller still.

↓

Second stage valve
Lower pressure. Breaks up the clusters that formed after the first stage, so the droplets stay apart.

↓

Milk out at low pressure
Fat droplets about 1 micrometre across, coated with milk protein, too small to rise.

Figure 4.5: The two-stage homogeniser valve: pressure is spent in a narrow gap, and the fat globules are torn apart as they pass through it. Drawn from the description of homogenisers in Bylund, Dairy Processing Handbook, Chapter 6.

When homogenised milk still shows a cream line, the valve is the first suspect: a worn seat or plug opens the gap too wide, the pressure falls, and the droplets stay too big. When the milk tastes rancid, the order of steps is the suspect: raw milk was homogenised before pasteurisation, and the lipase reached the fat. And when the homogeniser shakes or the pressure jumps, air in the feed or a blocked valve is the usual cause: the pump must have a steady, air-free feed, or the pressure it builds has nowhere smooth to go.

🤔 Pause and think: a plant finds its steam bill has doubled in a month, but the milk volume is the same and the pasteuriser temperature record is perfect. Which section of the plate pack would you open first, and what would you expect to find on the plates?

Quick check

Why does the regeneration section do most of the heating and most of the cooling in a pasteuriser?

Check your answer

Because the hot pasteurised milk warms the incoming cold milk and is cooled by it in the same step, recovering up to 94 to 95% of the heat, so fresh steam and refrigeration only handle the small remainder.

4.11 Derivation: holding time, regeneration, and kill kinetics

This section works out the three calculations a pasteuriser operator uses: how long the holding tube must be, how much heat the regeneration section saves, and how much killing a time and temperature combination gives. Each one is built one small step at a time.

How long must the holding tube be?

The milk must spend 15 seconds at 72 °C. The holding tube is a pipe, and the milk flows through it at a steady rate, so the time in the tube depends on the tube volume and the flow rate.

Step 1, write down what time in a pipe means. Time equals volume divided by flow rate: t = V / Q. The volume of the tube is its cross-section area times its length: V = A × L. Put them together: t = (A × L) / Q, and turn it around to solve for the length: L = (Q × t) / A.

Step 2, find the cross-section area from the tube diameter. For a round tube, A = π × d² / 4. A tube 5 cm across has A = 3.14 × 25 / 4, which is about 19.6 cm².

Step 3, put the flow rate in matching units. A plant running 5,000 litres per hour moves 5,000,000 cm³ per 3,600 seconds, which is about 1,390 cm³ per second.

Step 4, find the milk speed in the tube. Speed equals flow rate divided by area: v = Q / A = 1,390 / 19.6, about 71 cm per second.

Step 5, find the length. L = v × t = 71 × 15, about 1,065 cm, or about 10.7 metres of tube.

Worked example: the holding tube. A pasteuriser running 5,000 litres per hour through a 5 cm tube needs about 10.7 metres of holding tube for 15 seconds at 72 °C. Double the flow to 10,000 litres per hour and the milk moves twice as fast, so the same tube gives only 7.5 seconds: the plant must double the tube length, or fit a wider tube, before it doubles the flow. That is why the holding time changes in inverse proportion to the flow rate, and why the flow rate is controlled exactly: the tube is dimensioned for one flow, and a faster flow shortens the hold.

One more point a professional checks: the milk in the middle of the tube moves faster than the milk near the wall, so the fastest drop spends less than the average 15 seconds in the tube. A well built holding tube is sized so that even the fastest drop gets its full 15 seconds, with a margin on top. A tube sized only for the average drop under-heats part of the milk.

How much heat does regeneration save?

Regeneration efficiency is the share of the heating that the outgoing milk does for the incoming milk, instead of steam. Write it as a fraction of the temperature rise the milk needs.

Step 1, the milk needs to rise from its arrival temperature to the pasteurisation temperature: from 4 °C to 72 °C, a rise of 68 °C.

Step 2, the regeneration section warms the incoming milk to some temperature below 72 °C: say it reaches 65 °C. That is a rise of 61 °C, done with recovered heat.

Step 3, divide: 61 / 68 is about 0.90, or 90% regeneration. Steam only has to lift the milk the last 7 °C, from 65 °C to 72 °C, and the cooling section only has to take the milk from its regeneration exit temperature down to 4 °C.

Worked example: the steam bill. A pasteuriser with 90% regeneration needs fresh heat for only 10% of the temperature rise, plus the small losses through the plates and pipes. A plant that lets its plates foul with milk stone loses regeneration a little at a time, and the steam bill climbs while the temperature record still looks perfect: the milk still reaches 72 °C, but steam is doing the work the outgoing milk used to do.

How much killing does a time and temperature give?

Heat killing follows two numbers. The D-value is the time at one fixed temperature that cuts a microbe population tenfold, one decimal reduction. The z-value is the temperature rise that cuts the D-value tenfold: raise the temperature by z degrees, and the same killing takes a tenth of the time.

Step 1, the log reduction from a hold. If a hold lasts t seconds at a temperature where the D-value is D seconds, the number of decimal reductions is n = t / D. A 15 second hold where D is 1.5 seconds gives 10 decimal reductions: the population falls to one ten-billionth of what it was.

Step 2, move the D-value to a new temperature. D at temperature T equals D at a reference temperature times 10 raised to the power (T_ref minus T) divided by z: D_T = D_ref × 10^((T_ref − T) / z). Hotter milk means a smaller D, and a smaller D means more killing in the same seconds.

Step 3, work an example with stated numbers. Suppose a test strain has D = 15 seconds at 63 °C and z = 8 °C. At 72 °C, D = 15 × 10^((63 − 72) / 8) = 15 × 10^(−1.125), about 1.1 seconds. A 15 second hold at 72 °C then gives 15 / 1.1, about 13 decimal reductions. The same strain held 30 minutes at 63 °C gives 1,800 / 15, or 120 decimal reductions: far more killing than needed, which is why the two treatments are treated as equivalent in practice, and why the standard is set by the toughest pathogen, not by an easy test strain.

Step 4, read the lesson. Time and temperature trade against each other, and the trade is steep: a few degrees hotter buys a large cut in time, and a few degrees cooler costs a large increase in time. That is why the flow diversion valve in Section 4.7 matters so much: milk that slips through at 68 °C instead of 72 °C has not had a small shortfall, it has had a large one, and the valve sends it back.

🤔 Pause and think: a plant wants to run its pasteuriser 20% faster to meet a big order. The holding tube stays the same. What happens to the holding time, and what must change before the faster flow is allowed?

Quick check

A holding tube is sized for 15 seconds at 5,000 litres per hour. The flow is doubled to 10,000 litres per hour. What is the holding time now, and why?

Check your answer

About 7.5 seconds: the milk moves twice as fast through the same tube, so the holding time halves, because holding time changes in inverse proportion to the flow rate.

4.12 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a plant's pasteurised milk keeps going sour two days before its date, although the pasteuriser temperature record is perfect. Where else in the line could the trouble be, and what would you check first?

  1. LTLT pasteurisation is 63 °C for 30 minutes. What is the HTST equivalent?
Check your answer

72 °C for 15 seconds: a higher temperature held briefly kills the same microbes as a lower temperature held longer.

  1. A plant has milk at 4.5% fat and skim at 0.1% fat, and wants 3.0% fat milk. How many parts of each are mixed?
Check your answer

2.9 parts of the 4.5% milk and 1.5 parts of the 0.1% skim: the differences are 3.0 minus 0.1 and 4.5 minus 3.0.

  1. Why is milk warmed to about 40 °C before separation, and why is raw milk never homogenised and left standing?
Check your answer

Warm milk is thinner, so the fat globules separate better in the centrifuge. Homogenising raw milk breaks the fat globule membrane and lets lipase reach the fat, causing rancidity.

  1. Pasteurisation kills pathogens, but pasteurised milk still needs a fridge. Why?
Check your answer

Pasteurisation does not kill bacterial spores and does not sterilise the milk, so the milk still carries some heat-resistant bacteria and must be kept cold and used promptly.

Try it: Leave a bottle of milk undisturbed in the fridge for a day, then pour off the top spoonful and taste it next to a spoonful from the bottom. The top is richer: that is creaming, the reason homogenised milk was invented. Now shake the bottle and taste again: the fat is mixed back in.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Reception is the last cheap point to reject bad milk: platform tests at the gate, laboratory tests on the sample, and a bad lot never enters the silo.
  • Chilling to 4 °C or below slows bacteria but does not kill them, and milk held cold for too long still spoils through psychrotroph enzymes.
  • Filtration and clarification remove visible dirt, but only heat makes milk safe.
  • Separation uses a centrifuge to split milk into cream and skim milk, best done warm, near 40 °C; bactofugation also throws out bacterial spores.
  • Standardisation mixes whole milk, skim milk, and cream to a fixed fat target, so the milk is the same every day.
  • Homogenisation breaks fat globules to about 1 micrometre, stopping the cream line, and it must follow pasteurisation, not come before it on raw milk.
  • Pasteurisation is 63 °C for 30 minutes or 72 °C for 15 seconds, and the HTST pasteuriser uses regeneration, a holding tube, and a flow diversion valve to guarantee every drop is heated.
  • Sterilisation and UHT heating to about 135 to 150 °C for a few seconds kill spores too, giving months of shelf life at room temperature, at the cost of a more cooked flavour.

  • The separator bowl uses a stack of thin discs so each fat globule only travels a millimetre or two, and cold milk, worn seals, or air in the feed are the usual causes of poor separation.

  • A plate heat exchanger heats and cools milk through thin chevron plates in counter-current flow, with regeneration, heating, holding, and cooling sections in order, and regeneration recovers up to 94 to 95% of the heat.
  • The homogeniser valve tears fat globules apart in a gap a few hundredths of a millimetre wide, with a second stage to stop the droplets clumping, and a worn valve shows up as a cream line.
  • Holding tube length follows L = (Q × t) / A: double the flow and the holding time halves, so the flow rate must be controlled exactly.
  • Regeneration efficiency is the recovered temperature rise divided by the total rise needed, and a fouled plate pack shows up in the steam bill before it shows up in the temperature record.
  • Heat killing follows D and z: D is the time for a tenfold fall at one temperature, z is the temperature rise that cuts D tenfold, and a few degrees cooler costs a large increase in holding time.

Glossary

Platform test

A quick test done at the plant gate when milk arrives, such as smell, acidity, and clot-on-boiling. Food tech example: milk that clots on boiling is rejected at reception, before it can spoil a whole silo.

Psychrotroph

A microbe that grows at fridge temperature. Food tech example: psychrotrophs grow slowly in chilled milk and their heat-stable enzymes turn stored milk bitter even after pasteurisation.

Clarification

Spinning milk in a centrifuge to throw out dirt and sediment. Food tech example: a clarifier removes the sediment that would otherwise show up in the finished milk.

Bactofugation

High-speed centrifuging that throws bacterial spores out of milk. Food tech example: bactofugation cuts the spore load before heat treatment, so the milk keeps better.

Standardisation

Adjusting milk fat and solids-not-fat to a fixed target by mixing whole milk, skim milk, and cream. Food tech example: milk at 4.5% fat and skim at 0.1% fat are mixed to make a steady 3.0% fat milk.

Homogenisation

Forcing milk at high pressure through a narrow valve to break fat globules into tiny droplets. Food tech example: homogenised milk forms no cream line, because its droplets are about 1 micrometre across.

Pasteurisation

Heating milk to kill pathogens and most spoilage microbes without much flavour change. Food tech example: HTST pasteurisation is 72 °C for 15 seconds, and LTLT is 63 °C for 30 minutes.

HTST

High temperature, short time: pasteurisation at 72 °C for 15 seconds in a continuous flow. Food tech example: an HTST pasteuriser uses a regeneration section, a holding tube, and a flow diversion valve.

Flow diversion valve

A valve that sends milk back for re-heating if its temperature falls below the set point. Food tech example: it is the safety heart of the HTST pasteuriser, so no under-heated milk reaches the filler.

UHT

Ultra-high temperature: heating milk to about 135 to 150 °C for a few seconds, then filling it sterile. Food tech example: UHT milk keeps for months unopened at room temperature.

Sterilisation

Heating milk hard enough to kill all microbes, including spores. Food tech example: in-bottle sterilisation heats sealed bottles to about 115 °C for 15 to 20 minutes.

Toned milk

Milk adjusted with skim milk and skim milk powder to a lower fat and a normal solids-not-fat. Food tech example: toned milk gives the customer a lighter milk without watering down its solids.

Separator bowl

The spinning bowl with a stack of thin conical discs that splits milk into cream and skim milk. Food tech example: the discs split the milk into thin layers, so a fat globule only travels a millimetre or two before it reaches a disc and slides inward to the cream outlet.

Plate heat exchanger

A pack of thin stainless steel plates with milk on one side and heating or cooling medium on the other, in opposite directions. Food tech example: an HTST pasteuriser uses a plate pack with regeneration, heating, and cooling sections, and more plates can be added to raise capacity.

Counter-current flow

Two streams flowing in opposite directions through a heat exchanger, so the temperature gap stays even along the pack. Food tech example: the hottest pasteurised milk meets the hottest incoming milk, and heat moves steadily instead of in bursts.

Regeneration

Reusing the heat of hot pasteurised milk to warm incoming cold milk, in the same step cooling the pasteurised milk. Food tech example: a well run pasteuriser recovers up to 94 to 95% of its heat by regeneration, and steam only supplies the last few degrees.

Holding tube

The pipe after the heating section, sized so milk takes the required time, 15 seconds for HTST, to pass through at temperature. Food tech example: a 5,000 litre per hour plant with a 5 cm tube needs about 10.7 metres of holding tube.

Homogeniser valve

The narrow gap between valve seat and plug where high-pressure milk is forced through and fat globules are torn apart. Food tech example: a worn valve opens the gap too wide, the pressure falls, and the milk shows a cream line again.

D-value

The time at one fixed temperature that cuts a microbe population tenfold, one decimal reduction. Food tech example: if D is 1.5 seconds at 72 °C, a 15 second hold gives 10 decimal reductions.

Z-value

The temperature rise that cuts the D-value tenfold. Food tech example: with z = 8 °C, raising the temperature by 8 °C makes the same killing take a tenth of the time.

References

  • Bylund, G. Dairy Processing Handbook. Tetra Pak Processing Systems AB, Lund, Sweden.
  • Market Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lessons 16-33.
  • Physical Chemistry of Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Modules 3 and 5.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.

Unit 5: Condensed and Dried Milk

Note

Unit 5: Condensed and Dried Milk

A tin of sweetened condensed milk can sit on a shelf for a year with no fridge. A bottle of fresh milk lasts days. What is the sugar doing that the fridge does? Hold that question: the answer is in section 5.5.

5.1 Why take the water out?

Fresh milk is about 87% water. That water is the reason milk is heavy to carry, quick to spoil, and awkward to store. Take much of the water away and three things change at once: the milk weighs far less, microbes find it much harder to grow, and the product keeps for months instead of days.

🤔 Pause and think: if taking water out is so powerful, why not dry all milk into powder and skip fresh milk altogether? What would we lose?

That is the whole idea behind this unit. There are two families of products here, and it helps to keep them apart from the start:

  • Condensed milk is still a liquid. Part of the water has been boiled off under vacuum. Sweetened condensed milk is kept safe by sugar; evaporated milk is kept safe by heat, in a sealed can.
  • Dried milk is a powder. Almost all the water has been removed, so the milk can sit on a shelf for months and be mixed back with water when it is needed.

Both families start from the same place, good fresh milk, and both punish poor raw milk. Off-flavours in the raw milk do not disappear when the milk is concentrated; they get stronger, because there is less water to dilute them. A dairy that makes powder or condensed milk therefore grades its incoming milk strictly and rejects milk that smells off, tastes off, or carries sediment.

Quick check

Fresh milk is about 87% water. Why does taking water out help milk keep?

Check your answer

Less water means less weight to carry, and microbes find it much harder to grow: so the milk keeps for months instead of days.

5.2 A short history, and what it teaches

People have tried to keep milk by drying it for centuries: travellers in Central Asia in the 1200s were already carrying a paste-like dried milk that could be mixed back with water. The modern industry began in the 1800s: Nicolas Appert condensed milk in France in 1820, and Gail Borden made the first workable condensed milk in the United States in 1856, selling it as Eagle Brand from 1858. Borden's pitch was simple and it still explains the product today: milk that keeps without cooling, and can travel far from the farm.

The lesson from that history is practical, not nostalgic. Condensed milk succeeded because it solved a transport problem. Every step in this unit, vacuum evaporation, spray drying, instantising, is a later answer to the same problem: how to move milk solids cheaply and keep them good.

Quick check

Borden's condensed milk sold from 1858. What problem was it solving?

Check your answer

Milk that keeps without cooling and can travel far from the farm: a transport problem, not just a recipe.

5.3 The raw milk: what the plant checks first

Before a litre of milk is allowed near an evaporator, the plant checks it the way a cook checks eggs before baking: a bad one spoils the batch. The checks that matter most for concentrated milks are:

  • Freshness and acidity. Milk that has already started to sour will not survive the heat of forewarming and sterilising. It curdles, or it turns thick and grainy in the can.
  • Flavour. Feed flavours, rancid notes, and barny flavours concentrate along with the solids. Milk with a strong off-flavour is rejected.
  • Cleanliness. Visible dirt or sediment is filtered out by clarification, but milk that arrives dirty is a sign of poor handling upstream.
  • Heat stability. This is the milk's ability to stand up to high heat without clotting. It is tested before evaporated milk is made, because evaporated milk is sterilised in the can. Milk that fails the heat-stability test is sent to another product.

Milk that passes is cooled to about 4.4 °C if it is not used at once, then clarified and filtered.

Quick check

Why reject milk with an off-flavour instead of just processing it?

Check your answer

Off-flavours concentrate along with the solids: there is less water left to dilute them, so they get stronger.

5.4 How evaporation works: boiling milk without burning it

Milk boils at 100 °C at normal pressure, and at that temperature it scorches, browns, and picks up a cooked flavour. So milk is never evaporated at normal pressure. Instead the evaporator works under vacuum, reduced pressure, which lowers the boiling point to roughly 50–65 °C. The milk boils gently, the water leaves as vapour, and the milk solids stay behind undamaged.

Think of it like simmering soup with the lid half off at high altitude: the liquid bubbles at a lower temperature than it would at sea level, so the food cooks more gently.

The falling-film evaporator

The workhorse of the modern plant is the falling-film evaporator. Milk runs down the inside of tall, heated tubes as a thin film, while steam heats the outside of the tubes. Because the film is thin, the milk heats fast and leaves fast: it spends only seconds at temperature. That short, gentle treatment is what keeps the flavour clean.

A falling-film evaporator in outline

Steam in
Steam heats the tubes from outside.
Milk in
Thin film runs down the inside of heated tubes, seconds of contact.
Concentrated milk out
From the bottom.
Water vapour out
From the top, to condenser.

Figure 5.1: A falling-film evaporator in outline. Milk flows down as a thin film inside steam-heated tubes; vapour leaves from the top and condensed milk collects at the bottom. Drawn from the description in Patel, Condensed and Dried Milk, Lesson 5.

Using the steam twice: multiple effect

Boiling off water takes a lot of heat, and heat costs money. A multiple-effect evaporator reuses it. The vapour boiled off in the first unit is used as the heating steam for the second unit, which works at a still lower pressure, and so on. Each unit is one "effect". Three or four effects are common. The same kilogram of steam then evaporates several kilograms of water instead of one.

Worked example: why concentration saves transport. Start with 100 kg of milk at 12.5% total solids. That is 12.5 kg of milk solids and 87.5 kg of water. Evaporate it to 50% total solids and you have 25 kg of concentrate holding the same 12.5 kg of solids. You have removed 75 kg of water: three-quarters of the weight, before the milk ever leaves the plant.

Quick check

Why is milk evaporated under vacuum instead of boiled at normal pressure?

Check your answer

Vacuum lowers the boiling point to about 50–65 °C, so the milk boils gently without scorching, browning, or picking up a cooked flavour.

5.5 Sweetened condensed milk: sugar does the preserving

Sweetened condensed milk is milk that has been evaporated and had sucrose (ordinary table sugar) added, until the sugar is close to a saturated solution in the water that is left. It is thick, pale, very sweet, and it keeps for months in a sealed can, and for weeks even after the can is opened, with no refrigeration and no sterilising heat.

The trick is the sugar ratio. This is the share of sugar in the sugar-plus-water part of the product, worked out as:

Sugar ratio = (added sugar ÷ (added sugar + water)) × 100

A sugar ratio of about 62.5% is enough to stop most microbes growing. The sugar binds the water so tightly that bacteria and yeasts cannot use it. In plain terms: the water is still there, but it is locked up.

Worked example: the sugar ratio. A batch of condensed milk has 30% total milk solids and 43.75% added sugar. The water is what is left: 100 − 30 − 43.75 = 26.25 parts. Sugar ratio = 43.75 ÷ (43.75 + 26.25) × 100 = 43.75 ÷ 70 × 100 = 62.5%. That is the target the maker aims at.

🤔 Pause and think: a maker tries to save money by using half the sugar. What do you think happens to the tin on the shelf?

Worked example: the same sum in reverse. You want 30% milk solids and a 62.5% sugar ratio. The water will be 100 − 30 = 70 parts. Sugar needed = 70 × 62.5 ÷ 100 = 43.75 parts per 100 parts of product.

A finished sweetened condensed milk typically ends up near 28% total milk solids, with about 8.55% fat and 19.45% solids-not-fat, the rest being sugar and water. The fat-to-solids-not-fat ratio is set during standardisation: 8.55 ÷ 19.45 = 0.44, so for every kilogram of solids-not-fat the milk must carry 0.44 kg of fat. If the incoming milk is short of fat, cream is added to make up the difference.

How it is made

Making sweetened condensed milk, step by step

Fresh milk
Clarify + filter, standardise (set fat : solids-not-fat).

↓

Forewarm
Gentle heat; steadies the milk for evaporation.

↓

Evaporate under vacuum
About 30% total solids.

↓

Add sugar
Dissolved in hot water, 88 °C or above.

↓

Cool + seed
With fine lactose crystals, for a smooth texture.

↓

Fill into cans
Seal.

Figure 5.2: Making sweetened condensed milk, step by step.

Two steps in that flow deserve a closer look:

  • Forewarming. The milk is heated before evaporation. This steadies the proteins, kills most microbes, and helps the finished product stay smooth instead of thickening in the can.
  • Cooling and seeding. As sweetened condensed milk cools, its lactose (milk sugar) can form large, gritty crystals: the defect called sandiness. To stop that, the maker stirs in a small amount of very fine lactose crystals, called seed, while the milk cools. The lactose then grows on the many tiny seeds instead of forming a few large crystals, and the texture stays smooth.

What goes wrong: age thickening and gelation

Sweetened condensed milk can slowly thicken as it sits: age thickening, and in bad cases it sets into a gel. The causes sit together: high storage temperature, high acidity in the milk, and a long storage time. The fix is the same set of levers in reverse: use fresh, low-acid milk, forewarm it properly, and store the cans cool.

Quick check

What sugar ratio protects sweetened condensed milk, and how is it worked out?

Check your answer

About 62.5%: sugar ÷ (sugar + water) × 100. At that level the sugar binds the water so tightly that most microbes cannot use it.

5.6 Evaporated milk: heat does the preserving

Evaporated milk is the unsweetened partner. It is milk concentrated to about twice its normal solids, sealed in a can, and then sterilised by heat. There is no sugar to protect it, so the heat treatment has to do all the work.

The standard flow is:

  1. Standardise to a fat-to-solids-not-fat ratio of about 8:18.
  2. Forewarm above 90 °C for 10 minutes. This is hotter and longer than for sweetened condensed milk, because the milk must survive sterilisation later.
  3. Concentrate under vacuum to 26–28% total milk solids.
  4. Homogenise at about 100 kg/cm² and 55–60 °C, to break the fat into tiny droplets that will not rise and form a cream layer in the can.
  5. Fill and seal the cans.
  6. Sterilise in the can: in the pilot-scale test, 15 minutes at 116–117 °C, with 15–20 minutes allowed for the cans to come up to temperature, then cool fast, to about 24 °C.

Pilot sterilisation is a small-scale test the plant runs before a full batch. Small sealed bottles of the evaporated milk, with different tiny doses of a stabilising salt, are heated exactly as the cans will be heated. The bottle that comes out smooth, with a good body and no curd, tells the maker which dose to use in the full run. It is a cheap test that prevents a whole batch of curdled cans.

Heat stability: the make-or-break property

Not all milk survives sterilisation. Some milk curdles when it is heated hard, especially milk late in lactation, milk with high acidity, or milk that has been stored cold for a long time. The plant tests heat stability with a simple check: a small tube of the milk is heated in an oil bath and the time until it clots is noted. Milk with a short clotting time is not used for evaporated milk.

Stabilising salts, usually a small amount of disodium phosphate or a similar salt, shift the milk's balance so it stands the heat better. Too little and the milk curdles; too much and the milk turns thin, or picks up a salty note. The pilot sterilisation test is how the right dose is found.

Recombined evaporated milk

Evaporated milk can also be made without fresh liquid milk at all, by recombining: mixing skim milk powder, anhydrous milk fat (pure butter oil), water, and a stabiliser, then homogenising and sterilising the mix. This is how evaporated milk is made in places and seasons where fresh milk is short. The skill is the same: get the fat-to-solids ratio right, homogenise well, and prove the heat stability before the cans are filled.

Quick check

Evaporated milk has no sugar. What preserves it instead?

Check your answer

Heat: the milk is sterilised in the sealed can, near 116–117 °C, after forewarming and concentrating to 26–28% solids.

5.7 Other ways to concentrate

Evaporation is the standard route, but two other methods appear in the books and are worth knowing:

  • Freeze concentration. Milk is partly frozen, and the ice crystals, which are almost pure water, are separated off. The liquid left behind is concentrated, and because no heat is used at all, the flavour stays very fresh. The catch is cost: freezing water takes a lot of energy, and separating tiny ice crystals from a thick liquid is slow work. It is used for high-value liquids more than for bulk milk.
  • Membrane concentration (reverse osmosis). Milk is pumped at high pressure against a membrane that lets water through but holds the milk solids back. Like freeze concentration it uses no heat, so the milk keeps its fresh flavour and its whey proteins stay undamaged. It is often used as a first step, to take milk from 12% solids to about 20%, before evaporation finishes the job, because membranes get slow and costly as the milk gets thick.

Quick check

Name one way to concentrate milk without any heat, and its drawback.

Check your answer

Freeze concentration (ice crystals are pure water and are separated off) or reverse osmosis through a membrane: both keep flavour fresh, but both are costly and slow for bulk milk.

5.8 Dried milk: turning milk into powder

Drying takes the idea one step further. Where condensed milk still holds a quarter of its weight as water, milk powder holds only about 3–4%. At that level microbes cannot grow at all, and the powder keeps for months in a sealed bag.

Spray drying: the main method

Spray drying is the method used for most of the world's milk powder. The steps are:

Spray drying: the main method

Fresh milk
Clarify, standardise, pasteurise.

↓

Forewarm + evaporate under vacuum
Concentrate, about 45-50% solids.

↓

Heat the concentrate
About 70 °C, thinner, easier to spray.

↓

Atomise
Spray into a chamber of hot air. Spinning disc or pressure nozzle; droplets are finer than a hair.

↓

Dry
Droplets dry in seconds, powder falls, damp air leaves.

↓

Separate powder from air
Cyclone.

↓

Cool, sieve, pack
Keep air and moisture out.

Figure 5.3: Spray drying, step by step.

The clever part is the speed. Each droplet is tiny, so it dries in a few seconds, and while water is evaporating from it, the droplet itself stays near the outlet-air temperature, well below the hot inlet air. That is why spray-dried milk tastes fresh instead of cooked, even though the air entering the chamber is very hot.

🤔 Pause and think: if the droplets dried slowly instead of in seconds, what would the powder taste like, and why?

Three controls decide the quality of the powder:

  • Concentrate solids. Feeding the dryer at 45–50% solids instead of 12% means far less water to evaporate, so the dryer uses less heat and makes more powder per hour. Feed it too thick, though, and the droplets get big and dry unevenly.
  • Atomisation. A spinning disc throws the milk off its edge in fine droplets; a pressure nozzle forces it through a small hole. Either way, the aim is the same: small, even droplets. Big droplets dry slowly and can scorch; very fine droplets make a dusty powder that is hard to handle.
  • Inlet and outlet air temperatures. Hotter inlet air dries faster and cheaper, but if the outlet air runs too hot the powder scorches and the flavour suffers. The operator holds the outlet temperature steady and lets the feed rate follow it: if the outlet temperature climbs, more concentrate is fed in.

Two-stage drying

In two-stage drying, the spray dryer takes the powder down to about 6–8% moisture, and a second dryer, usually a fluid-bed dryer, where warm air bubbles up through the powder, finishes it to 3–4%. The second stage uses gentler air (around 130 °C inlet), so the powder gets less heat damage, and the powder comes out with a better bulk density and a better solubility. It is the standard setup for a modern plant.

Instantising: powder that wets at once

Anyone who has tipped skim milk powder into a glass of water knows the problem: it floats, clumps, and takes a long time to sink. Instantising fixes that by agglomeration: sticking the tiny single powder particles together into loose, grape-like clusters. The clusters are bigger and full of holes, so water rushes in between them and the powder sinks and dissolves in seconds.

The Peebles process, one of the early methods, wets the powder with a fine mist of steam or water and then re-dries it, so the particles stick where they touched. Modern plants agglomerate inside the dryer itself, by letting damp particles collide and stick before they are fully dry.

Drum drying and freeze drying

  • Drum (roller) drying. Milk is spread as a thin film on a steam-heated rotating drum and scraped off as a dry sheet. It is a simple, rugged method, but the milk sits on a hot surface, so the flavour is cooked and the protein is heavily damaged. Drum-dried powder suits chocolate and bakery uses, where the cooked note does not matter and the powder's good water uptake helps. Its moisture is typically 3–4%.
  • Freeze drying. The milk is frozen and the ice is removed by sublimation, ice turning straight to vapour, under vacuum. The powder keeps its flavour and its protein almost untouched, but the equipment is slow and costly. It is used for high-value products, not bulk milk powder.

Quick check

The air entering a spray dryer is very hot. Why does the powder still taste fresh?

Check your answer

Each droplet is tiny, so it dries in a few seconds, and while water is evaporating the droplet stays near the cooler outlet-air temperature.

5.9 What the powder is like: reading the numbers

The WPN index: a quick read on heat damage

When milk is heated, some of its whey protein unfolds and loses its solubility. The Whey Protein Nitrogen (WPN) index measures how much undamaged whey protein is left in a gram of powder, in milligrams. It is the powder trade's shorthand for how hard the milk was heated:

  • Low-heat powder: high WPN index, the whey proteins are mostly untouched. Best for recombining into drinking milk and for cheese-making, where the proteins still need to work.
  • Medium-heat powder: mid-range WPN index, the everyday powder.
  • High-heat powder: low WPN index, the proteins are heavily denatured. Best for bakery and chocolate, where the powder's water uptake and flavour matter more than live protein function.

As a guide from the books: for instant products the WPN index should be about 2.5–3.5 mg, while a high-bulk-density powder should show at most 1.0 mg. Spray drying itself barely changes the index: the heat history is set earlier, in the forewarming step.

Moisture, solubility, and keeping quality

  • Moisture. Powders below 3% moisture keep their flavour best at the start and during storage. Above about 5% moisture, lactose starts to crystallise, the powder turns lumpy, and the flavour goes stale faster. The target is therefore low moisture plus a pack that keeps damp air out.
  • Solubility. A good powder should dissolve almost fully, leaving little sediment. Solubility falls when the milk has been overheated, when the powder has been stored hot or damp, or when the powder is very old. The solubility test, stir a weighed amount into water at a set temperature, spin it down, and measure the sediment, is a routine quality check.
  • Free fat. In whole milk powder some fat sits loose on the surface of the particles instead of tucked inside. This "free fat" rises as the total fat rises above about 28% of the solids, and it makes the powder oxidise faster and flow worse. It is one reason whole milk powder has a shorter shelf life than skim milk powder.
  • Bulk density. Light, fluffy powder takes up a lot of bag space and transport cost; dense powder packs tight. Agglomerated instant powder is light by design; high-density powder is made by drying at lower temperatures and handling the powder gently.

Whole milk powder and skim milk powder

  • Skim milk powder (non-fat dry milk) is made from skim milk. It is about 35% protein and keeps well because it has almost no fat to go rancid. It is the workhorse for recombined milk, yoghurt, and bakery.
  • Whole milk powder is made from standardised whole milk and carries about 26–28% fat in its solids. It tastes richer and recombines into a fuller milk, but its fat limits its shelf life: the fat slowly oxidises, giving cardboard and tallowy notes, especially if the powder is stored warm.

Spot the mistake: the 50% sugar tin

A small maker wants to cut costs, so they make sweetened condensed milk with a sugar ratio of 50% instead of 62.5%. The tins look fine, taste fine, and sell fast. Three weeks later, customers complain the tins are swelling and the milk smells yeasty. What went wrong?

Check your answer

At 50% the sugar no longer locks the water away well enough: sugar-loving yeasts can grow, make gas, and swell the tin. The 62.5% ratio is not a recipe habit; it is the line between "keeps" and "ferments". Saving sugar cost the whole batch.

Quick check

What does a high WPN index tell you about a milk powder?

Check your answer

Little heat damage: most of the whey protein is still undamaged, so the powder suits recombined milk and cheese-making.

5.10 Defects in condensed and dried milks, and what causes them

DefectWhat you seeMain causesPrevention
Sandiness (condensed milk)Gritty crystals on the tongueLactose crystals grown too large; cooling too slow; no seedingCool fast, seed with fine lactose
Age thickening / gelationMilk turns thick, then sets like jellyHigh storage temperature, high acidity, long storageFresh low-acid milk, good forewarming, cool storage
Brown colourDarkening in the can or bagMaillard browning between lactose and protein, worse when hot or dampKeep heat low, moisture low, storage cool
Oxidised / tallowy flavour (powder)Cardboard, painty, tallowy notesFree fat, air in the pack, warm storage, long storageLow moisture, gas-tight pack, cool storage
Stale flavour (powder)Flat, old tasteMoisture uptake, long storageDry pack, low moisture, cool storage
Caking / lumps (powder)Powder sets into hard lumpsMoisture above about 5%, damp air leaking inDry pack, sealed bags, dry store
Poor solubilitySediment in the glass after mixingOverheating, old powder, damp storageGentle heat history, fresh stock, dry storage
Fat separation (evaporated milk)Cream layer on top in the canPoor homogenisation, low viscosityHomogenise well, aim for a good body

Quick check

Your sweetened condensed milk turns gritty on the tongue. What is it, and what fixes it?

Check your answer

Sandiness: lactose crystals grown too large. Cool fast and seed with fine lactose crystals so the lactose grows on many tiny seeds.

5.11 Microbiology: what can still grow

Sweetened condensed milk is protected by its sugar, but it is not sterile. Sugar-loving yeasts and moulds can grow on the surface once a can is opened, and a few hardy microbes can survive in the thick, sugary mass. Evaporated milk is sterile inside its sealed can: the sterilising heat sees to that, and spoilage means the seal failed or the heat treatment was too light. Milk powder is too dry for microbes to grow, but it can carry dormant spores and microbes that wake up the moment the powder is mixed with water. That is why the water used to recombine powder must be clean, and why recombined milk is handled like fresh milk: kept cold and used promptly.

Quick check

Why must recombined milk be kept cold and used promptly, like fresh milk?

Check your answer

Milk powder can carry dormant spores and microbes that wake up the moment water is added.

5.12 Practical note: mixing powder back into milk

Weigh the powder, don't scoop it by eye: a cup of powder can weigh very different amounts depending on how fluffy it is. Sprinkle the powder onto warm water (about 40–45 °C), not hot water, and stir while you sprinkle: hot water cooks the outside of each lump and seals dry powder inside it. Let the mix stand for a few minutes so the particles finish wetting, then stir again. For drinking, chill it: recombined milk tastes much better cold, and the flavour settles after an hour in the fridge. Keep it cold and use it within a day, exactly as you would fresh milk.

Quick check

Why sprinkle powder onto warm water (40–45 °C) instead of hot water?

Check your answer

Hot water cooks the outside of each lump and seals dry powder inside it: warm water lets the particles wet through.

5.13 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: if you left a tin of sweetened condensed milk open on a warm shelf for a month, what would you expect to find, and why?

  1. Sweetened condensed milk is preserved mainly by (a) sterilising heat, (b) sugar locking up the water, (c) freezing.
Check your answer

(b) Sugar locking up the water. A sugar ratio near 62.5% binds the water so tightly that most microbes cannot use it.

  1. A batch has 30% total milk solids and 43.75% added sugar. What is the sugar ratio?
Check your answer

Water = 100 − 30 − 43.75 = 26.25 parts. Sugar ratio = 43.75 ÷ (43.75 + 26.25) × 100 = 62.5%.

  1. Why is milk evaporated under vacuum instead of boiled at normal pressure?
Check your answer

Vacuum lowers the boiling point to about 50–65 °C, so the milk boils gently without scorching, browning, or picking up a cooked flavour.

  1. Name two things the WPN index tells you about a milk powder.
Check your answer

How much undamaged whey protein is left, and therefore how hard the milk was heated: low-heat powder has a high WPN index and suits recombined milk and cheese-making; high-heat powder has a low index and suits bakery uses.

Try it: Mix 30 g of skim milk powder into 250 ml of warm water using the method in section 5.12, then taste it cold next to fresh milk. Can you tell which is which? Note the flavour difference: that gap is what forewarming and drying do to milk.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Taking water out is what makes milk light, cheap to carry, and slow to spoil. Condensed milk is still liquid; dried milk is a powder.
  • Vacuum evaporation boils milk gently at 50–65 °C so it does not scorch; falling-film evaporators do the job in seconds, and multiple effects reuse the steam.
  • Sweetened condensed milk is preserved by sugar: a sugar ratio near 62.5% locks the water away from microbes. Its make-or-break steps are standardisation, forewarming, and cooling with fine lactose seed so it does not turn sandy.
  • Evaporated milk is preserved by heat: forewarm above 90 °C, concentrate to 26–28% solids, homogenise, seal, and sterilise near 116–117 °C. Heat stability is tested first, in a small pilot run.
  • Spray drying turns concentrate into powder in seconds: atomise into hot air, dry fast, separate the powder in a cyclone. Two-stage drying and instantising (agglomeration) improve the powder.
  • The WPN index reads the heat history of a powder; moisture below 3% keeps flavour best, and above about 5% the powder cakes and goes stale.
  • The common defects, sandiness, age thickening, browning, oxidised flavour, caking, all trace back to the same few causes: heat, acid, moisture, air, and time.

Glossary

Condensed milk

Milk with part of its water boiled off under vacuum, still a liquid. Food tech example: sweetened condensed milk keeps for months in a sealed can because its sugar locks the water away, while evaporated milk keeps because it is sterilised by heat in the can.

Evaporated milk

Unsweetened milk concentrated to about twice its normal solids, sealed in a can and sterilised by heat. Food tech example: evaporated milk is concentrated to 26 to 28% total solids, then sterilised near 116 to 117 °C.

Dried milk

Milk with almost all its water removed, down to about 3 to 4% moisture, so it keeps as a powder for months. Food tech example: skim milk powder is mixed back with water to make recombined milk for drinking, yoghurt, and bakery uses.

Total solids

Everything in milk that is not water: fat, protein, lactose, and minerals added together. Food tech example: fresh milk has about 12.5% total solids, and evaporating 100 kg of it to 50% total solids leaves 25 kg of concentrate holding the same 12.5 kg of solids.

Solids-not-fat

All the milk solids except the fat: mainly protein, lactose, and minerals. Food tech example: a sweetened condensed milk with about 8.55% fat and 19.45% solids-not-fat has a fat to solids-not-fat ratio of 0.44.

Sugar ratio

The share of sugar in the sugar plus water part of sweetened condensed milk, worked out as sugar divided by sugar plus water, times 100. Food tech example: 43.75 parts sugar in 70 parts of sugar plus water gives a sugar ratio of 62.5%, the level that stops most microbes growing.

Vacuum evaporation

Boiling milk off under reduced pressure so it boils at a lower temperature. Food tech example: under vacuum milk boils at roughly 50 to 65 °C instead of 100 °C, so it does not scorch or pick up a cooked flavour.

Falling-film evaporator

An evaporator in which milk runs down the inside of tall, steam-heated tubes as a thin film. Food tech example: the milk spends only seconds at temperature in a falling-film evaporator, which keeps the flavour clean.

Multiple-effect evaporator

A set of evaporator units in which the vapour boiled off in one unit heats the next unit at a still lower pressure. Food tech example: with three or four effects, the same kilogram of steam evaporates several kilograms of water instead of one.

Forewarming

Heating milk before evaporation to steady the proteins, kill most microbes, and help the finished product stay smooth. Food tech example: evaporated milk is forewarmed above 90 °C for 10 minutes so it can survive sterilisation in the can later.

Seeding

Stirring a small amount of very fine lactose crystals into cooling sweetened condensed milk so the lactose grows on many tiny seeds. Food tech example: seeding stops sandiness, because the lactose forms many small crystals instead of a few large, gritty ones.

Sandiness

The gritty defect in sweetened condensed milk when lactose crystals grow too large. Food tech example: a condensed milk that feels gritty on the tongue has sandiness, and the fix is to cool fast and seed with fine lactose.

Age thickening

The slow thickening of sweetened condensed milk as it sits in storage, which in bad cases sets into a gel. Food tech example: high storage temperature, high acidity, and long storage cause age thickening, so cans are stored cool and made from fresh, low-acid milk.

Heat stability

The ability of milk to stand up to high heat without clotting. Food tech example: milk is tested for heat stability before evaporated milk is made, because a milk that clots on heating will curdle during sterilisation.

Pilot sterilisation

A small-scale test in which sealed bottles of evaporated milk with different tiny doses of a stabilising salt are heated exactly as the cans will be heated. Food tech example: the bottle that comes out smooth with a good body and no curd tells the maker which salt dose to use in the full run.

Spray drying

Drying milk by spraying concentrate into a chamber of hot air, so each tiny droplet dries in seconds and falls as powder. Food tech example: spray drying feeds concentrate at 45 to 50% solids, and the powder is separated from the air in a cyclone.

Instantising

Making milk powder wet and dissolve at once by agglomeration, sticking tiny powder particles together into loose, grape-like clusters. Food tech example: instantised skim milk powder sinks and dissolves in seconds, while plain powder floats and clumps.

WPN index

The Whey Protein Nitrogen index, a measure of how much undamaged whey protein is left in a gram of powder, in milligrams. Food tech example: a high WPN index means little heat damage, so low-heat powder suits recombined milk and cheese-making, while high-heat powder with a low index suits bakery uses.

References

  • Patel, H. G. Condensed and Dried Milk. Agrimoon e-course, Department of Dairy Technology, Anand Agricultural University.
  • Jana, A., Pinto, S., and Moorthy, P. R. S. Ice Cream and Frozen Desserts. Agrimoon e-course, 2016.
  • Clarke, C. The Science of Ice Cream. Royal Society of Chemistry, 2004.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.

Unit 6: Ice Cream

Note

Unit 6: Ice Cream

You can scoop ice cream at −18 °C, but a bottle of milk frozen at the same temperature is a solid block. What makes one scoopable and the other rock-hard? The answer is in the spoonful: section 6.3.

6.1 First, a spoonful: what ice cream actually is

Take a spoonful of ice cream and let it melt on your tongue. It feels cold, then smooth, then creamy, and it does not feel like a block of ice, even though half of it is ice. That is the puzzle of ice cream, and the whole unit is the answer to it.

Ice cream is not frozen milk. It is four things held together at once:

  1. Ice crystals: tiny, and there are a lot of them.
  2. Air bubbles: whipped in, making up about half the volume.
  3. Fat droplets: partly joined into clusters that give body.
  4. A thick, sweet syrup: the unfrozen liquid that glues everything together.

If any one of the four is wrong, you feel it at once: too much ice and it is crunchy; too little air and it is heavy; fat droplets that never joined and it melts into a thin puddle.

Ice cream under the microscope, in outline

Air bubble
~50% of volume.
Syrup
Sugars, proteins, stabilisers.
Ice crystal
Small, many.
Fat cluster
Droplets partly joined together.

Figure 6.1: Ice cream under the microscope, in outline. Ice crystals, air bubbles, and clusters of fat droplets sit in a continuous syrup of sugars, milk proteins, and stabilisers. The syrup never freezes solid; it is the glue. Drawn from the microstructure described in Clarke, The Science of Ice Cream, Chapters 2–5.

Quick check

Name the four things held together in a spoonful of ice cream.

Check your answer

Small ice crystals, air bubbles, clustered fat droplets, and a thick, sweet, unfrozen syrup that glues them together.

6.2 What goes into the mix

A typical ice cream mix, from Clarke's Table 3.1, is:

IngredientTypical amount (by weight)
Fat7–15%
Milk protein4–5%
Lactose (milk sugar)5–7%
Other added sugars12–16%
Stabilisers, emulsifiers, flavoursabout 0.5%
Total solids28–40%
Water60–72%

The milk solids-not-fat (MSNF), everything in the milk solids except the fat, works out at about 10–13%: the 4–5% milk protein plus the 5–7% lactose plus about 1% minerals and minor components. MSNF matters because it carries the protein that builds body, and the lactose that helps set the freezing point.

Worked example: building 100 kg of mix. A maker aiming at a mid-range ice cream might use 10 kg fat, 11 kg MSNF (skim milk powder and milk), 14 kg added sugars, 0.5 kg stabilisers and emulsifiers, and the rest water: about 64.5 kg. Total solids come to 35.5 kg, inside the 28–40% band. A premium tub pushes the fat toward 15% and cuts the air; a budget tub does the opposite.

The same ingredients can come from different raw materials. Fat and protein can arrive together as milk and cream, or separately as skim milk powder and butter oil. Which route a maker picks depends on cost, on what is available, and on the product they want, but the mix that goes into the freezer has to add up to the same kind of composition either way.

Quick check

A mix has 10% fat, 11% MSNF, 14% added sugars, and 0.5% stabilisers and emulsifiers. What are its total solids?

Check your answer

10 + 11 + 14 + 0.5 = 35.5%: inside the usual 28–40% band.

6.3 Why ice cream is soft: freezing point and the ice curve

Pure water freezes at 0 °C. Ice cream mix starts to freeze at about −2.7 °C, because the sugars and milk salts dissolved in it get in the way of ice forming. This is called freezing point depression: the more small dissolved molecules there are, the lower the freezing point. A gram of a small sugar depresses the freezing point more than a gram of table sugar, because it makes more molecules per gram: that is why makers sometimes use glucose syrup or dextrose, not only sucrose.

As the mix cools below its freezing point, pure ice starts to form, and here is the part that makes ice cream work. The ice takes only water out of the syrup, so the syrup left behind gets more concentrated, and its freezing point drops further. More cooling makes more ice, and the syrup gets sweeter and thicker still. The result is a curve, the ice curve: at each temperature, a set share of the water has turned to ice and the rest stays liquid.

For a typical ice cream, about 55% of the water is ice at −18 °C, the usual storage temperature. The other 45% is still liquid, as a thick syrup. That is why a tub at −18 °C can be scooped at all: it is not a solid block of ice, it is a frozen foam held together by syrup.

🤔 Pause and think: what would happen to the scoop if you doubled the sugar in the recipe? Softer, or harder, and why?

That curve is also the secret of soft-scoop ice cream: the kind that scoops straight from a home freezer. A soft-scoop mix is made so that less of its water turns to ice at serving temperature: an ice volume fraction of about 0.23, against about 0.30 for a standard ice cream. Less ice means a softer bite. The maker gets there by changing the sugars: using sugars that depress the freezing point more, so the ice curve shifts and less ice forms at the same temperature.

Quick check

Why is only about 55% of the water ice at −18 °C instead of all of it?

Check your answer

Ice takes only pure water out, so the syrup left behind gets more concentrated and its freezing point drops further: the ice curve.

6.4 Each ingredient earns its place

Fat: richness, body, and slow melting

Fat, at 7–15%, gives ice cream its creamy flavour, carries flavour compounds, and slows melting. But its real job is structural. During freezing, the fat droplets bump into each other and partly join: partial coalescence. The droplets keep some of their separate identity, but they stick together in clusters, and those clusters form a loose network through the product. That network is what stops a scoop from collapsing into a puddle the moment it warms up, and it is what gives ice cream a dry, firm bite instead of a wet one.

Milk solids-not-fat: body and the protein net

The milk proteins do two jobs. In the mix they help hold the fat droplets apart (they coat the droplets, like a jacket). During freezing they are pushed out of the way by the growing ice and end up concentrated in the syrup, where they thicken it and add body. Too little MSNF and the ice cream feels thin and watery; too much, and the lactose can crystallise into a sandy texture.

Sugars: sweetness, softness, and freezing control

Added sugars run at 12–16%, on top of the 5–7% lactose already in the milk. They sweeten, but they also control the ice curve: more sugar, or a sugar with smaller molecules, means a lower freezing point and softer ice cream. The trade-off is real: too much sugar makes the product too soft to hold its shape, and it can taste syrupy. Lactose is the awkward one: it is only mildly sweet, but if there is too much of it, it crystallises during storage and the texture turns sandy.

Stabilisers: the syrup's bodyguards

Stabilisers are long-chain polysaccharides: chains of sugar units, used at a fraction of a percent. The usual names are guar gum, locust bean gum, carrageenan, pectin, and sodium alginate. They do three things:

  • They thicken the unfrozen syrup, so the mix feels richer and the ice cream melts more slowly.
  • They slow down recrystallisation: the slow growth of big ice crystals at the expense of small ones during storage. Big crystals are what make old ice cream feel coarse.
  • Some of them form soft gels that help hold water and stop the product weeping.

A guar gum solution is a good picture of how they work: stir it gently and it flows; stir it fast and it thins out. That shear-thinning is handy in the factory, the mix flows easily through pumps and pipes when it is moving, then thickens again when it stops.

Emulsifiers: letting the fat cluster

Emulsifiers, usually mono- and diglycerides of fatty acids, are used in small amounts with a very specific job. Fresh from the homogeniser, every fat droplet is coated in milk protein, which keeps the droplets apart. The emulsifier elbows some of that protein off the droplet surface. With a thinner, weaker coat, the droplets can bump together and partly coalesce during freezing, which is exactly the network the ice cream needs. Without emulsifier, the droplets stay apart, the network never forms, and the ice cream melts fast and feels wet.

Air: the ingredient nobody lists

Air is not printed on the label, but it makes up about half the volume of a finished tub. It lightens the texture, softens the bite, and makes the flavour seem less intense, which is why a very airy ice cream can taste bland even with the same recipe. The amount of air is measured as overrun:

Overrun = (volume of ice cream − volume of mix) ÷ volume of mix × 100

Worked example. One litre of mix comes out of the freezer as 1.8 litres of ice cream. Overrun = (1.8 − 1.0) ÷ 1.0 × 100 = 80%. A mix that doubles in volume has 100% overrun. Premium tubs run lower; soft-serve and economy tubs run higher.

Quick check

What do stabilisers do in ice cream?

Check your answer

They thicken the unfrozen syrup, slow recrystallisation (big ice crystals growing at the expense of small ones), and help hold water so the product does not weep.

6.5 Making it, step by step

The factory flow for ice cream

Ingredients
Milk, cream, skim milk powder, sugars, stabilisers, emulsifiers.

↓

Blend
Mix, standardised to recipe.

↓

Pasteurise
Kills microbes; also helps the proteins.

↓

Homogenise
Fat broken into tiny droplets, ~1 micrometre.

↓

Cool + age
Hold cold, usually overnight. Proteins and emulsifiers settle onto the fat; stabilisers hydrate; fat partly crystallises.

↓

Freeze in a scraped-surface freezer
Mix is churned and scraped off a cold wall; air is beaten in; ice crystals stay small. Leaves the freezer at about -5 °C, soft like soft-serve.

↓

Fill into tubs
Add sauces, nuts, chocolate pieces.

↓

Harden in a blast tunnel
-30 to -45 °C air. Fast cooling freezes more water and stops the crystals and bubbles growing.

↓

Store
At -18 °C or colder, ship in the cold chain.

Figure 6.2: The factory flow for ice cream.

Three steps deserve a closer look:

  • Ageing. The mix is held cold for hours, often overnight. In that time the emulsifier finishes moving onto the fat droplets, the stabiliser fully hydrates, and some of the fat inside the droplets crystallises. Skipping ageing gives a mix that whips poorly and melts fast.

🤔 Pause and think: you are in a rush in the factory. Which step would you never skip, ageing, or hardening? What breaks if you skip each one?
- Freezing. The freezer is a cylinder with a cold wall and a rotating scraper. Mix is pumped in, air is injected, and the scraper shaves off the thin frozen layer as fast as it forms, so the ice crystals stay small: tens of micrometres across. The product leaves at about −5 °C, still soft, with roughly half its final ice formed.
- Hardening. The soft tubs go through a tunnel of very cold air, −30 to −45 °C, which pulls the temperature down fast. Fast matters: slow cooling lets crystals and bubbles grow big. A tub takes time to reach −20 °C even in a good tunnel, and the centre is always last, which is why hardening tunnels are long and the air is cold.

Quick check

Why is the mix aged cold, often overnight, before freezing?

Check your answer

The emulsifier finishes moving onto the fat droplets, the stabiliser fully hydrates, and some fat inside the droplets crystallises: the mix then whips better and melts more slowly.

6.6 Texture: why one tub is smooth and another is coarse

Smoothness is mostly about the size of the ice crystals. Small crystals, tens of micrometres, feel smooth because the tongue cannot pick them out. Big crystals feel gritty, then crunchy, then icy.

Crystals grow after manufacture by recrystallisation: in storage, small crystals melt slightly when the temperature rises and their water refreezes onto bigger crystals when it falls again. Every wobble of the freezer temperature feeds the big crystals. That is why a tub that has sat in a shop freezer that cycles, or in a home freezer that is opened often, turns coarse even if it left the factory perfectly smooth. Stabilisers slow this down, but they cannot stop it: the only real defence is a steady, cold chain.

🤔 Pause and think: why do shops keep ice cream in chest freezers with lids instead of on open shelves?

Melting matters too. A good ice cream melts evenly on the tongue, releasing flavour as it goes. If the fat network never formed, it melts into a thin liquid that runs off the tongue too fast. If too much fat clustered, it can feel buttery or greasy. The meltdown test, how much of a scoop drips through a wire mesh over time at a set temperature, is the laboratory way of checking this.

Quick check

A tub was smooth when bought and coarse a month later. What happened?

Check your answer

Recrystallisation: every temperature swing melts the smallest crystals slightly and refreezes their water onto bigger crystals.

6.7 Defects: reading the tub

DefectWhat you noticeWhat usually caused itHow to fix it
Coarse / icy textureGritty, crunchy, icy biteLarge ice crystals: slow freezing, warm hardening, temperature swings in storage, low total solids, too little stabiliserFreeze fast, harden fast at −30 to −45 °C, hold storage steady and cold, check the recipe
Sandy textureFine grit that crunchesLactose crystals: too much MSNF/lactose, long storageKeep lactose in check, avoid long warm storage
ShrinkageIce cream pulls away from the tub wallsToo much air, weak body, temperature swings, low solidsLower overrun, strengthen the mix, steady storage
Fluffy / weak bodySoft, collapses, melts fastToo much overrun, too little fat or stabiliser, fat network never formedCheck fat and emulsifier, age the mix, check the freezer
Buttery / greasyFatty coating on the mouthToo much fat clustering, over-churning, too much emulsifierEase back the emulsifier, check the freezing time
Sweet / syrupyOverly sweet, too softToo much sugar or too much low-molecular-weight sugarRebalance the sugars, watch the freezing point
Off-flavoursOxidised, cardboard, cooked notesOld ingredients, oxidised fat, overheated mix, poor hygieneFresh ingredients, correct pasteurising, clean plant

The coarse-texture row is the one to remember, because it is the most common complaint about ice cream and the causes are all in the maker's hands: freeze fast, harden fast, keep it cold, and keep the temperature steady.

Two tubs, one recipe: spot the difference

Two tubs leave the factory on the same day with the same mix. Tub A goes to a shop with a steady −20 °C cabinet. Tub B goes to a shop whose cabinet cycles between −12 °C and −20 °C. A month later, a customer says Tub B is icy and Tub A is smooth. Same recipe, same factory: so what changed?

Check your answer

Recrystallisation. Every warm swing in Tub B's cabinet melted the smallest ice crystals a little, and their water refroze onto bigger crystals. After a month of swings, the crystals are big enough for the tongue to feel. Tub A stayed cold and steady, so its crystals stayed small. The recipe did not fail: the cold chain did.

Quick check

Sandy ice cream: what causes it?

Check your answer

Lactose crystals: too much MSNF or lactose in the mix, or long storage.

6.8 Hygiene and keeping quality

Ice cream mix is a rich food for microbes, milk, sugar, and water at a friendly pH, so pasteurising the mix is not optional, and everything after pasteurising has to stay clean: the ageing tanks, the freezer, the fillers, and the hands that handle them. Once frozen, microbes cannot grow, but they are not all killed by freezing either. A tub that melts and is refrozen is a tub whose microbes have had a warm holiday. The plant's defences are the usual ones: pasteurise properly, clean and sanitise the freezer every day, keep ingredients cold and covered, and never let the cold chain break.

Quick check

Why is a tub that melted and was refrozen a problem, even though it was frozen again?

Check your answer

Freezing does not kill all microbes: they grow during the warm spell, and refreezing just pauses them again.

6.9 Practical note: the home freezer test

Buy two tubs of the same flavour from the same brand. Keep one at the back of the freezer and leave the other in the door, where the temperature swings every time the door opens. After two weeks, taste them side by side. The door tub will usually be coarser: that is recrystallisation, happening in your own kitchen. And when you serve ice cream, take it out five minutes before scooping: at −18 °C about 55% of the water is ice and the tub is hard; a few minutes at room temperature melts a little of that ice, the syrup loosens, and the flavour opens up.

Quick check

Why does ice cream taste better five minutes after leaving the freezer?

Check your answer

A little ice melts, the syrup loosens, and the flavour opens up.

6.10 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: two tubs have the same recipe, but one melts into a thin puddle in minutes while the other holds its shape on the plate. Which part of the structure failed in the fast-melting one?

  1. A mix starts to freeze at about −2.7 °C instead of 0 °C. What causes this?
Check your answer

Freezing point depression: the sugars and milk salts dissolved in the mix get in the way of ice forming, so the mix must get colder before ice appears.

  1. One litre of mix comes out of the freezer as 1.8 litres of ice cream. What is the overrun?
Check your answer

(1.8 − 1.0) ÷ 1.0 × 100 = 80% overrun.

  1. What do emulsifiers do in ice cream, and what happens without them?
Check your answer

They push some milk protein off the fat droplets so the droplets can partly coalesce into a network during freezing. Without them the droplets stay apart, the network never forms, and the ice cream melts fast and feels wet.

  1. A tub that was smooth when bought turns coarse after a month in a home freezer that is opened often. What happened?
Check your answer

Recrystallisation: each temperature swing melts the smallest ice crystals slightly and refreezes their water onto bigger crystals, so the crystals grow and the texture turns icy.

Try it: Do the home freezer test from section 6.9: one tub at the back of the freezer, one in the door, and taste them side by side after two weeks. Write down in one sentence how the textures differ.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Ice cream is four things at once: small ice crystals, air bubbles, clustered fat droplets, and a thick unfrozen syrup that glues them together.
  • A typical mix is 7–15% fat, 4–5% milk protein, 5–7% lactose, 12–16% added sugars, about 0.5% stabilisers and emulsifiers, and 28–40% total solids. MSNF runs about 10–13%.
  • Sugars depress the freezing point, so the mix starts to freeze near −2.7 °C and only about 55% of the water is ice at −18 °C. Soft-scoop ice cream has less ice still, about 0.23 of its volume against 0.30 for standard ice cream.
  • Stabilisers (guar, locust bean gum, carrageenan) thicken the syrup and slow recrystallisation; emulsifiers (mono- and diglycerides) let the fat droplets partly coalesce into the network that gives body and slow melting.
  • Overrun measures the air: (volume out − volume in) ÷ volume in × 100. Air near half the volume is normal.
  • The make is blend, pasteurise, homogenise, age, freeze with air, then harden fast in −30 to −45 °C air. Slow hardening and wobbly storage temperatures grow big ice crystals: the main cause of coarse texture.

Glossary

Ice crystals

The tiny crystals of frozen water in ice cream. Food tech example: crystals tens of micrometres across feel smooth, while big crystals grown by recrystallisation feel gritty and icy.

Partial coalescence

Fat droplets bumping together during freezing and partly joining into clusters while keeping some of their separate identity. Food tech example: partial coalescence builds the fat network that stops a scoop collapsing into a puddle as it warms.

Unfrozen syrup

The thick, sweet liquid left between the ice crystals, made of sugars, milk proteins, and stabilisers, which never freezes solid. Food tech example: at minus 18 °C about 45% of the water is still liquid as syrup, which is why a tub can be scooped at all.

Freezing point depression

The lowering of the freezing point when sugars and milk salts are dissolved in the mix. Food tech example: ice cream mix starts to freeze at about minus 2.7 °C instead of 0 °C because the dissolved sugars get in the way of ice forming.

Ice curve

The curve that shows, at each temperature, what share of the water has turned to ice and what share stays liquid as syrup. Food tech example: as more ice forms, the syrup left behind gets sweeter and thicker, so its freezing point drops further.

Soft-scoop ice cream

Ice cream made to scoop straight from a home freezer, with less of its water turned to ice at serving temperature. Food tech example: a soft-scoop mix has an ice volume fraction of about 0.23, against about 0.30 for a standard ice cream.

Milk solids-not-fat (MSNF)

Everything in the milk solids except the fat: protein, lactose, and minerals. Food tech example: MSNF runs about 10 to 13% of the mix, and too little makes the ice cream feel thin and watery.

Total solids

All the solid ingredients in the mix added together, as a share of the weight. Food tech example: a typical mix has 28 to 40% total solids, and a worked mix with 10% fat, 11% MSNF, 14% added sugars, and 0.5% stabilisers and emulsifiers comes to 35.5%.

Stabiliser

A long-chain polysaccharide used at a fraction of a percent to thicken the unfrozen syrup and slow recrystallisation. Food tech example: guar gum, locust bean gum, carrageenan, pectin, and sodium alginate are the usual stabilisers.

Shear-thinning

The way a thick liquid flows easily when stirred or pumped fast, then thickens again when it stops moving. Food tech example: a guar gum solution thins when stirred fast, which helps the mix flow through pumps and pipes in the factory.

Recrystallisation

The slow growth of big ice crystals at the expense of small ones during storage, driven by temperature swings. Food tech example: a tub kept in a freezer door that opens often turns coarse, because each warm swing melts the smallest crystals and their water refreezes onto bigger ones.

Emulsifier

An ingredient used in small amounts that elbows some milk protein off the fat droplets so the droplets can partly coalesce. Food tech example: mono- and diglycerides are the usual emulsifiers, and without them the fat network never forms and the ice cream melts fast.

Overrun

The measure of air whipped into ice cream, worked out as the volume of ice cream minus the volume of mix, divided by the volume of mix, times 100. Food tech example: one litre of mix coming out as 1.8 litres of ice cream has an overrun of 80%.

Ageing

Holding the mix cold for hours, often overnight, before freezing. Food tech example: during ageing the emulsifier finishes moving onto the fat droplets, the stabiliser fully hydrates, and some fat inside the droplets crystallises.

Hardening

Cooling the filled tubs fast in a blast tunnel of very cold air after freezing. Food tech example: hardening uses air at minus 30 to minus 45 °C, because slow cooling lets crystals and bubbles grow big.

Meltdown test

The laboratory check of how much of a scoop drips through a wire mesh over time at a set temperature. Food tech example: an ice cream whose fat network never formed melts into a thin liquid and fails the meltdown test.

Scraped-surface freezer

The freezer used for ice cream, a cylinder with a cold wall and a rotating scraper that shaves off the thin frozen layer as fast as it forms. Food tech example: the product leaves the scraped-surface freezer at about minus 5 °C, still soft, with roughly half its final ice formed.

Homogenisation

Breaking the fat into tiny droplets, about 1 micrometre across, so they stay spread through the mix. Food tech example: in ice cream making, homogenisation comes after pasteurising and before cooling and ageing.

References

  • Clarke, C. The Science of Ice Cream. Royal Society of Chemistry, 2004.
  • Jana, A., Pinto, S., and Moorthy, P. R. S. Ice Cream and Frozen Desserts. Agrimoon e-course, 2016.
  • Patel, H. G. Condensed and Dried Milk. Agrimoon e-course, Department of Dairy Technology, Anand Agricultural University.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.

Unit 7: Starter Cultures

Note

Unit 7: Starter Cultures

The same milk, the same pot: one spoonful of yesterday's yoghurt turns it into yoghurt, but a spoonful of today's milk does nothing. What is alive in that spoonful? Section 7.3 has the answer, and it involves two bacteria helping each other.

7.1 What a starter culture is, and why milk needs one

Milk left alone will sour, but it sours by accident. Whichever microbes happen to be in it take over, and the result is unpredictable: sometimes pleasant, sometimes bitter, sometimes unsafe. A starter culture replaces that accident with a plan. It is a known set of microbes, grown in pure form, added to milk on purpose, so that the milk ferments the same way every time.

The microbes in a starter are mostly lactic acid bacteria: a family of bacteria that eat lactose (milk sugar) and turn it into lactic acid. The acid is the whole point. As the acid builds up, three things happen:

  1. The milk's pH falls, and the casein proteins lose their charge and clump together: the milk sets into a curd. That is how yoghurt thickens and cheese begins.
  2. The acid itself stops most spoilage bacteria and pathogens from growing. Fermentation is one of the oldest ways of keeping food safe.
  3. Alongside the acid, the bacteria make flavour compounds: buttery, fresh, sharp notes that give each product its character.

A starter is therefore not an ingredient like sugar. It is a living workforce, and the maker's job is to keep that workforce healthy, fed, and on schedule.

Quick check

What does a starter culture do that letting milk sour by accident does not?

Check your answer

It uses known microbes, grown in pure form, so the milk ferments the same way every time.

7.2 The cast: who does what

Starter bacteria split into two working groups by the temperature they like best.

GroupLikes it atWorks inMain members
Mesophilic ("middle-loving")about 30 °C, range 22–40 °CCheddar and similar cheeses, cultured buttermilk, many soft cheesesLactococcus lactis subsp. lactis, Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris, Lactococcus lactis biovar diacetylactis, Leuconostoc mesenteroides subsp. cremoris
Thermophilic ("heat-loving")about 43 °CYoghurt, Swiss-type and Italian cheesesStreptococcus thermophilus, Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus, Lactobacillus helveticus

A few members deserve a proper introduction:

  • Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis and subsp. cremoris. The steady acid-makers of the cheese world. They are fast, reliable, and they do not make much flavour on their own: they make the acid and let the flavour bacteria do the talking.
  • Lactococcus lactis biovar diacetylactis and Leuconostoc species. The flavour-makers. They turn citrate from the milk into diacetyl, the compound that gives butter and buttermilk their buttery smell. A cheese starter that has only acid-makers tastes flat; the flavour-makers are what make it taste like something.
  • Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus. The yoghurt pair. Neither works as well alone as the two do together: a partnership worth a section of its own, below.

There is a second split, by chemistry rather than temperature:

  • Homofermentative bacteria turn lactose almost entirely into lactic acid. Lactococcus lactis is the example. They are the acid workhorses.
  • Heterofermentative bacteria turn lactose into lactic acid plus other things: carbon dioxide, acetic acid, alcohol, and flavour compounds. Leuconostoc species are the example. They make less acid and more flavour and gas, which is why they matter in products where bubbles and aroma count.

Quick check

Which starter group makes yoghurt, and at what temperature does it like to work?

Check your answer

The thermophilic group: about 43 °C.

7.3 The yoghurt partnership: two bacteria better than one

Yoghurt is made by two bacteria working together, and the partnership is a neat piece of biology. Streptococcus thermophilus grows first and fast. It uses up the oxygen in the milk, makes a little acid, and releases compounds that help its partner grow. Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus then takes over: it breaks milk protein into the small pieces (peptides and amino acids) that the streptococcus needs, and it makes most of the acid that sets the curd. The streptococcus, fed by those pieces, grows faster in turn.

Each one also makes flavour: the lactobacillus makes most of the acetaldehyde, the sharp, green-apple note that says "yoghurt" to your nose. Together they acidify milk far faster than either could alone, and they set a smooth, firm curd at 41–43 °C in about 3–4 hours. It is the textbook case of symbiosis, two organisms helping each other, and it is why yoghurt culture is sold as a pair, not as two separate bottles.

Quick check

What does Lactobacillus bulgaricus give Streptococcus thermophilus in the yoghurt partnership?

Check your answer

Peptides and amino acids from broken-down milk protein: food the streptococcus needs to grow fast.

7.4 How the acid sets the milk

Fresh milk sits near pH 6.6–6.7. As the starter makes lactic acid, the pH falls. Nothing much seems to happen until the pH reaches about 5.3, and then the change comes quickly: at about pH 4.6, the casein micelles, the tiny protein bundles that carry the milk's protein, lose the electric charge that kept them apart, and they stick together. The milk sets.

Acidification: the pH falls, and near pH 4.6 the milk sets

pH 6.6
Fresh milk, fluid. Starter makes lactic acid.

↓

pH 5.3
Milk starts to thicken.

↓

pH 4.6
Casein micelles clump, curd sets.

↓

pH 4.5
Yoghurt / dahi: smooth, set, tangy.

Figure 7.1: Acidification: the pH falls, and near pH 4.6 the milk sets. The same fall in pH is what keeps spoilage bacteria out.

Worked example: how much acid is that? A starter is usually added to milk at 1–2% by volume, and it is judged ready when the milk reaches about 0.7–0.85% lactic acid (measured as titratable acidity). That is 7–8.5 grams of lactic acid in every litre of milk: a small amount, but enough to drop the pH by two whole units, because milk is only weakly buffered. A mesophilic starter takes about 14–16 hours at 21–22 °C to get there; a thermophilic starter takes about 3–4 hours at 41–43 °C. Speed is temperature: warm milk ferments fast, cool milk ferments slowly, and the maker picks the temperature to fit the working day.

🤔 Pause and think: your yoghurt has not set after 6 hours. Is the problem the culture or the temperature, and how would you tell the two apart?

Quick check

At what pH does milk set into a curd, and why there?

Check your answer

Near pH 4.6: the casein micelles lose the electric charge that kept them apart, so they stick together.

7.5 Growing the culture: mother, intermediate, bulk

A dairy does not buy a fresh culture for every vat. It keeps a mother culture, a small amount of the starter, grown with great care, and builds it up in steps:

Growing the culture: mother, intermediate, bulk

Freeze-dried / frozen culture

From the supplier.

↓

Mother culture

A litre or two, grown in sterile skim milk. The most protected step; everything sterile.

↓

Intermediate culture

A larger volume, grown from the mother.

↓

Bulk starter

Tens or hundreds of litres, grown in a starter tank. This is what goes into the vats, at 1-2% of the milk.

↓

Vat

Cheese, yoghurt, cultured buttermilk.

Each step multiplies the bacteria by roughly a hundred, so a few grams of dried culture can seed a whole day's production. The rule at every step is the same: sterile milk, the right temperature, the right time, and no shortcuts. A dirty mother culture poisons every vat that follows it.

The milk used for growing starters is usually skim milk, heat-treated hard enough to kill everything in it, including bacteriophages (see section 7.7), and to destroy the milk's natural inhibitors. Some plants add a little yeast extract or other nutrients to help the bacteria grow.

Quick check

Why is the mother culture the most protected step in growing a starter?

Check your answer

A dirty mother culture poisons every vat that follows it: the contamination multiplies at each step.

7.6 What can go wrong with a starter: slowness

A starter that works slowly is a dairy's worst day: the vats sit full of warm milk, the acid does not come, spoilage bacteria get their chance, and the whole day's production slips. Slowness has a short list of usual suspects, and a good maker checks them in order:

  1. Antibiotics in the milk. Milk from a treated animal can carry antibiotic residues that stop starter bacteria cold. One bad can of milk can stall a whole silo.
  2. Sanitiser residues. Chlorine or quaternary ammonium compounds left in a tank or pipe after cleaning will knock a starter back. Rinsing after sanitising is not a nicety; it is part of the job.
  3. Bacteriophage. The virus that eats starter bacteria (section 7.7).
  4. Too little inoculum, or a tired culture. A culture that has been carried over too many times, or stored badly, loses its punch. Mother cultures are replaced on a schedule, not when they fail.
  5. Wrong temperature. A mesophilic starter held at 18 °C instead of 22 °C will take far longer; a thermophilic starter held at 35 °C instead of 43 °C barely moves.
  6. The milk itself. Milk that is very low in the nutrients the bacteria need, or milk carrying natural inhibitors, ferments slowly. Heating the milk properly before inoculation helps.

The practical test is simple: a good starter should bring milk to its target acidity on time. If it is late, the maker does not argue with it, they find the cause and, if the vat is at risk, they add a fresh, active culture and carry on.

Quick check

Name three things that can make a starter work slowly.

Check your answer

Antibiotic residues in the milk, sanitiser left in the tank, bacteriophage attack, a tired culture, or the wrong temperature.

7.7 Bacteriophage: the virus that eats starters

A bacteriophage, "phage" for short, is a virus that infects bacteria. It is far too small to see, it is everywhere in a dairy (in the air, in whey, on surfaces), and it has one habit that makes it a menace: it finds a starter bacterium, injects its own genetic material, forces the bacterium to make hundreds of copies of the virus, and then bursts the bacterium open. One infected cell becomes hundreds of viruses, each looking for another cell. A vat that was fermenting happily can stall completely within an hour.

🤔 Pause and think: if the phage only attacks one kind of bacterium, why can a whole vat stall?

Phages are picky: a phage that attacks Lactococcus lactis will not touch Streptococcus thermophilus, which is why mixed starters survive better than single-strain ones: the phage knocks out one member and the others carry on. But a phage that matches the main acid-maker can still stop a cheese vat dead.

Phages need calcium and magnesium ions to latch onto a bacterium and to multiply inside it. That weakness is the basis of the main defence:

  • Phage-resistant media. The milk for growing the bulk starter is treated with chelating agents, usually phosphates or citrates, that tie up the calcium and magnesium. The bacteria grow fine without the free ions; the phage cannot.
  • Strain rotation. The plant keeps several different starter strains and rotates them day by day, so a phage that builds up against Monday's strain meets a different strain on Tuesday.
  • Single-strain, phage-resistant systems. Some plants use a small set of well-tested single strains that are known to resist the phages in that plant, and replace a strain the moment it shows weakness.
  • Hygiene and separation. Whey, which can carry huge numbers of phage, is kept away from the starter room. The starter room has its own equipment, its own air, and its own staff habits: no whey splashes, no shared buckets.
  • Heat. Proper heat treatment of the milk kills phages as well as bacteria, which is why starter milk is heated hard.

Detecting phage is a laboratory job: the suspect whey or milk is spotted onto a lawn of the starter bacteria, and clear zones, plaques, show where the phage has killed the bacteria. A plant that sees plaques knows it has a phage problem before the vats tell it.

The case of the stalled vat: play detective

Monday, 9 a.m.: a cheese vat was inoculated at 8 a.m. and should be acidifying by now. The pH has not moved. The milk came from the usual supplier, the starter is a fresh DVS sachet, and the vat temperature reads 30 °C. List three suspects, then check your list.

Check your answer

1. The milk: antibiotic residues from a treated animal stop starter bacteria cold: one bad can can stall a vat. 2. The equipment: sanitiser left in the vat or pipes after cleaning knocks the starter back. 3. The temperature: 30 °C is right for a mesophilic starter, so if the starter is thermophilic (it wants about 43 °C), it will barely move: check which starter was used. Phage is the fourth suspect if the plant reuses cultures. A detective checks the milk, the rinse, and the thermometer before blaming the culture.

Quick check

Why does a phage knock out one starter but leave another untouched?

Check your answer

Phages are picky: each one attacks specific bacteria. A mixed starter survives better because the phage only hits one member.

7.8 Testing a starter: is it alive and working?

A culture is only as good as its last test. The checks a dairy runs are:

  • Activity test. The starter is added to sterile skim milk at a set rate and held at a set temperature, and the acid it makes is measured after a set time, usually as titratable acidity, with a target near 0.7–0.85% lactic acid for a ripe culture. A culture that makes acid on time is active; one that lags is tired or damaged. The Whitehead–Cox test is a standard version of this: a fixed inoculum, a fixed time and temperature, and the acidity read off at the end.
  • Purity check. The culture is plated and looked at under the microscope. A pure starter shows only the shapes it should: chains of cocci for a lactococcus, rods for a lactobacillus. Anything else is a contaminant.
  • Flavour check. A small trial fermentation is tasted and smelled. A starter that makes acid but no flavour, no diacetyl, no clean tang, is not doing its full job.
  • Phage check. The culture is tested against the phages known to be in the plant.

A new batch of culture is never put straight into production. It is tested first, and only a culture that passes goes into the mother-culture line.

Quick check

What does an activity test measure, and what is a ripe culture's target?

Check your answer

The acid the starter makes in a set time at a set temperature: a ripe culture reaches about 0.7–0.85% lactic acid.

7.9 The starter's own weapons: antimicrobial compounds

Starter bacteria do not only make acid. They make a small arsenal of compounds that hold other microbes back:

  • Lactic acid itself: the main weapon, dropping the pH below the level most spoilage bacteria and pathogens can stand.
  • Bacteriocins: small proteins that kill closely related bacteria. The best known is nisin, made by some strains of Lactococcus lactis. Nisin is used as a natural preservative in its own right.
  • Hydrogen peroxide: made by some lactic acid bacteria, and toxic to many microbes that cannot break it down.
  • Diacetyl: the buttery flavour compound, which also slows some bacteria and yeasts at higher levels.

Together these are why a well-fermented product keeps better than the milk it came from, and why a vigorous starter is the first line of defence in the vat.

Quick check

What is nisin?

Check your answer

A bacteriocin: a small protein made by some strains of Lactococcus lactis that kills closely related bacteria. It is used as a natural preservative.

7.10 Forms of starter: how cultures are sold and kept

FormWhat it isStrengthsWatch out for
LiquidA fresh, active culture in milkCheap, ready to useShort life; needs cold storage; needs daily care
FrozenConcentrated culture, frozenKeeps for months; high cell countNeeds a deep freezer; must be thawed properly
Freeze-dried (lyophilised)Culture dried under vacuum from the frozen stateLongest shelf life; ships without coolingNeeds careful rehydration; a lag before it wakes up
Concentrated frozen / driedHigh-cell-count versions of the aboveSmall dose seeds a big vatCost; handling matters more
DVS (Direct Vat Set)Concentrated culture added straight to the vatNo mother culture, no bulk tank, no propagation riskCost per vat; the culture must be fully active on arrival

DVS (Direct Vat Set) cultures have changed how many plants work: instead of nursing a mother culture every day, the maker opens a sachet, tips it into the vat, and the fermentation starts. The trade is cost against risk: DVS costs more per vat, but it removes the whole propagation chain where contamination and phage usually strike. Small plants and plants that make many different products often find that trade worth it.

🤔 Pause and think: you run a tiny dairy making three different products a week. Would you choose DVS cultures or a mother culture, and why?

Quick check

What is the big advantage of a DVS culture?

Check your answer

No mother culture, no bulk tank, no propagation chain: it removes the steps where contamination and phage usually strike.

7.11 Keeping cultures alive: preservation

A culture that is not used at once has to be put to sleep without killing it. The methods are:

  • Freezing. The culture is mixed with a protectant, glycerol or skim milk solids, and frozen. The protectant stops ice crystals from tearing the cells apart. Kept frozen, the culture stays alive for months.
  • Freeze drying. The culture is frozen, then the ice is removed by sublimation under vacuum. The dry powder keeps for months or years at cool temperatures, and wakes up when it is mixed into warm milk.
  • Keeping the strain true. Every time a culture is grown and re-grown, it can change a little: losing a trait, picking up a weakness. Culture suppliers therefore keep their master strains frozen, and grow production batches from the master, so the strain that reaches the dairy is the same one that was tested.

Quick check

Why is glycerol added before a culture is frozen?

Check your answer

It is a protectant: it stops ice crystals from tearing the cells apart, so the culture stays alive for months.

7.12 Improving starters: a note on genetics

Starter strains can be improved, and the books describe the routes: selecting natural variants that ferment faster or resist phage better, moving useful traits on plasmids, small loops of DNA that bacteria swap with each other, and, in research, more direct genetic methods. The traits makers want are practical ones: faster acid production, stronger flavour, phage resistance, and the ability to make compounds like nisin. Whatever the method, the rule is the same as for any culture: the improved strain must be tested in real milk, in real vats, before it is trusted.

Quick check

What traits do makers want in an improved starter strain?

Check your answer

Faster acid production, stronger flavour, phage resistance, and making compounds like nisin.

7.13 Practical note: keeping a yoghurt culture alive at home

Use a spoonful of live, plain yoghurt as your starter: one with no added flavours and a short ingredient list. Warm the milk to about 43 °C (warm to the touch, not hot), stir the starter in, cover the pot, and keep it warm for 4–6 hours: a switched-off oven with the light on works well. When it sets, chill it. Keep a spoonful of each batch to start the next, but start fresh from a new shop-bought pot every few batches: a home culture drifts over time, and a fresh start keeps the flavour clean. If a batch turns slimy, bitter, or refuses to set, throw it out and start again: that is what a dairy would do with a failed mother culture.

Quick check

Why start fresh from shop-bought yoghurt every few batches at home?

Check your answer

A home culture drifts over time: a fresh start keeps the flavour clean.

7.14 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a cheese plant's vats stall every Monday but run fine the rest of the week. Same milk, same staff. What would you check first, and why Monday?

  1. Milk sets into a curd near which pH, and why?
Check your answer

Near pH 4.6. At that pH the casein micelles lose the electric charge that kept them apart, so they stick together and the milk sets.

  1. Why do yoghurt's two bacteria work faster together than either does alone?
Check your answer

Symbiosis: the streptococcus grows fast, uses up oxygen, and helps its partner; the lactobacillus breaks milk protein into pieces the streptococcus needs and makes most of the acid and the acetaldehyde flavour.

  1. A vat of cheese milk stops acidifying an hour after the starter was added. Name two likely causes.
Check your answer

Bacteriophage attack on the starter bacteria, or antibiotic residues in the milk (sanitiser left in the equipment is another common cause).

  1. How does a phage-resistant medium protect a starter?
Check your answer

Chelating agents such as phosphates or citrates tie up the calcium and magnesium ions that phages need to latch onto bacteria and multiply: the bacteria grow fine without the free ions, the phage cannot.

Try it: Make yoghurt following section 7.13, and time how long it takes to set at 43 °C. Then make a second batch with half the starter. How much longer does it take? That delay is the acid-production curve you can taste.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A starter culture is a known set of lactic acid bacteria added on purpose, so milk ferments the same way every time. Its main product is lactic acid, which sets the curd and keeps spoilage bacteria out.
  • Mesophilic starters like about 30 °C and make cheese and buttermilk; thermophilic starters like about 43 °C and make yoghurt. Yoghurt's two bacteria help each other: the streptococcus grows fast and the lactobacillus feeds it and makes the flavour.
  • Homofermentative bacteria make almost only lactic acid; heterofermentative bacteria also make gas and flavour compounds such as diacetyl.
  • Milk sets near pH 4.6. A ripe starter reaches about 0.7–0.85% lactic acid: mesophilic starters in 14–16 hours at 21–22 °C, thermophilic starters in 3–4 hours at 41–43 °C.
  • Cultures are built up in steps, mother, intermediate, bulk, and a dirty mother culture spoils every vat after it.
  • Bacteriophage is the main enemy: a virus that bursts starter bacteria. The defences are phage-resistant media that tie up calcium and magnesium, strain rotation, keeping whey away from the starter room, and heat.
  • Starters are tested for activity (acid made on time), purity, flavour, and phage, and they are sold as liquid, frozen, freeze-dried, concentrated, or DVS cultures that go straight into the vat.

Glossary

Starter culture

A known set of microbes, grown in pure form, added to milk on purpose so it ferments the same way every time. Food tech example: a cheese maker adds a mesophilic starter to the vat so the milk acidifies on schedule instead of souring by accident.

Lactic acid bacteria

Bacteria that eat lactose and turn it into lactic acid. Food tech example: Lactococcus, Streptococcus, Lactobacillus, and Leuconostoc are the lactic acid bacteria behind yoghurt, cheese, and cultured buttermilk.

Mesophilic starter

A starter that likes middle temperatures, about 30 °C, with a working range of 22 to 40 °C. Food tech example: mesophilic starters make cheddar and similar cheeses and cultured buttermilk.

Thermophilic starter

A starter that likes heat, about 43 °C. Food tech example: thermophilic starters make yoghurt and Swiss-type and Italian cheeses, where the curd is cooked hotter.

Homofermentative

A bacterium that turns lactose almost entirely into lactic acid. Food tech example: Lactococcus lactis is homofermentative, which is why it is the acid workhorse of cheese starters.

Heterofermentative

A bacterium that turns lactose into lactic acid plus other things, such as carbon dioxide, acetic acid, alcohol, and flavour compounds. Food tech example: Leuconostoc species are heterofermentative, so they make less acid and more flavour and gas.

Diacetyl

The flavour compound that gives butter and buttermilk their buttery smell, made from citrate in the milk. Food tech example: Lactococcus lactis biovar diacetylactis and Leuconostoc species make diacetyl, and a starter without them tastes flat.

Symbiosis

Two organisms helping each other, each one growing better together than alone. Food tech example: in yoghurt, Streptococcus thermophilus grows fast and uses up oxygen, while Lactobacillus bulgaricus breaks protein into pieces the streptococcus needs.

Acetaldehyde

The sharp, green-apple flavour note that says yoghurt to your nose. Food tech example: Lactobacillus bulgaricus makes most of the acetaldehyde in yoghurt.

Titratable acidity

The amount of lactic acid in milk, measured by titration and given as a percentage. Food tech example: a ripe starter culture brings milk to about 0.7 to 0.85% lactic acid, which is 7 to 8.5 grams in every litre.

Mother culture

A small amount of starter, a litre or two, grown with great care in sterile skim milk, from which larger cultures are built up. Food tech example: a dirty mother culture poisons every vat that follows it, so it is the most protected step.

Bulk starter

The large volume of starter, tens or hundreds of litres, grown in a starter tank and added to the vats at 1 to 2% of the milk. Food tech example: bulk starter is grown from the intermediate culture, which is grown from the mother culture.

Bacteriophage

A virus that infects bacteria, often called phage for short. Food tech example: a phage finds a starter bacterium, forces it to make hundreds of copies of the virus, then bursts it open, and a fermenting vat can stall within an hour.

Phage-resistant media

Milk for growing bulk starter that is treated with chelating agents, usually phosphates or citrates, that tie up the calcium and magnesium ions phages need. Food tech example: the starter bacteria grow fine without the free ions, but the phage cannot latch on and multiply.

Strain rotation

Keeping several different starter strains and rotating them day by day so a phage that builds up against one strain meets a different strain the next day. Food tech example: a plant rotates strains so Monday's phage cannot stall Tuesday's vat.

Activity test

A check in which the starter is added to sterile skim milk at a set rate and temperature, and the acid it makes is measured after a set time. Food tech example: the Whitehead-Cox test is a standard activity test, with a fixed inoculum, a fixed time and temperature, and the acidity read off at the end.

Bacteriocin

A small protein made by a bacterium that kills closely related bacteria. Food tech example: nisin, made by some strains of Lactococcus lactis, is a bacteriocin used as a natural preservative.

DVS culture

Direct Vat Set culture, a concentrated culture added straight to the vat with no mother culture, bulk tank, or propagation chain. Food tech example: a maker opens a DVS sachet, tips it into the vat, and fermentation starts, which suits small plants making many different products.

References

  • Prajapati, J. B., Sankara Reddy, I., and Sreeja, V. Starter Cultures and Fermented Milk Products. Agrimoon e-course, Department of Dairy Microbiology and Biotechnology, Anand Agricultural University.
  • Sankara Reddy, I., and Puniya, A. K. Introductory Dairy Microbiology. Agrimoon e-course.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.

Unit 8: Introductory Dairy Microbiology

Note

Unit 8: Introductory Dairy Microbiology

Milk leaves the udder almost sterile. By the time it reaches your glass it can carry millions of microbes per millilitre. Where did they all come from, and which ones should worry you? Trace the chain in section 8.2.

8.1 Why milk and microbes belong in the same sentence

Milk is, from a microbe's point of view, close to a perfect food. It is mostly water, it is near neutral in pH, and it is packed with lactose, protein, fat, vitamins, and minerals. A bacterium that lands in milk finds everything it needs to grow, and at room temperature it can double every 20–30 minutes. One cell at breakfast can be millions by supper.

That is why dairy microbiology matters, and why it cuts both ways. The same richness that makes milk good food for us makes it good food for microbes: the helpful ones that ferment it into yoghurt and cheese, the spoilage ones that sour it and turn it bitter, and the pathogens that can make people ill. This unit is the map of that world: where the microbes come from, who they are, what they do to milk, how we count them, and how we keep the bad ones out.

Quick check

Why is milk close to perfect food for microbes?

Check your answer

It is mostly water, near neutral in pH, and packed with lactose, protein, fat, vitamins, and minerals.

8.2 Where do the microbes in milk come from?

Milk inside a healthy udder is nearly sterile. Almost every microbe in raw milk gets in after the milk leaves the udder. The sources form a chain, and a weak link anywhere in the chain shows up in the milk:

How microbes reach milk

Udder
Nearly sterile inside.
Teat skin + milking
Skin bacteria, hands, cloths.
Air + dust
Barn air, feed dust.
Water
Wash water, rinse water.
Equipment
Milking machine, pipes, tanks, cans. The biggest source in most plants: a poorly cleaned tank seeds every litre.
People
Hands, clothing.
Storage + transport
Warm milk grows fast.

Figure 8.1: How microbes reach milk. The udder itself adds few microbes; the milking, the equipment, and the handling add most of them.

The numbers tell the story. Milk drawn cleanly from a healthy animal may carry only a few hundred to a few thousand bacteria per millilitre. Milk handled carelessly, dirty equipment, warm storage, slow cooling, can carry millions per millilitre before it ever reaches the plant. Cooling matters more than almost anything else: milk cooled to 4 °C promptly after milking holds its microbes in check, while milk left warm lets them multiply through the day.

🤔 Pause and think: two farms deliver milk with the same count at milking. One cools it at once, one cools it two hours later. Which milk arrives worse, and by roughly how much?

Quick check

Where do most microbes in raw milk come from: the udder, or somewhere else?

Check your answer

Somewhere else: milk inside a healthy udder is nearly sterile. Most microbes enter during milking and handling: teat skin, air, water, equipment, hands, and warm storage.

8.3 The cast: the main groups of dairy microbes

Bacteria: the main actors

Bacteria are single cells, far too small to see, that grow by splitting in two. In milk they fall into groups by what they do and what temperatures they like:

  • Lactic acid bacteria. The fermenters: Lactococcus, Streptococcus, Lactobacillus, Leuconostoc. They turn lactose into lactic acid. They are the heroes of Unit 7, and the reason milk can be turned into yoghurt, cheese, and cultured buttermilk. Most are killed by pasteurisation, so they have to be added back as starters after heating.
  • Psychrotrophs. The cold-growers. They grow slowly at refrigeration temperatures (0–7 °C), with an optimum around 15–20 °C. The main one is Pseudomonas, along with Flavobacterium and Alcaligenes. They are the reason cold milk still goes off: they grow in the fridge, and they make enzymes that break down protein and fat, giving bitter, fruity, and rancid notes. Pasteurisation kills the cells, but some of their enzymes survive the heat and keep working in the pasteurised milk.
  • Thermoduric bacteria. The heat-survivors. They do not necessarily like heat, but they can live through pasteurisation: mainly spore-formers such as Bacillus species, and tough non-spore-formers such as Microbacterium and Micrococcus. They matter because they are the bacteria left standing after the milk has been heated.
  • Thermophilic bacteria. The heat-lovers, growing best at 45–55 °C. They can cause trouble in plants where milk is held warm, and in spray dryers and evaporators where warm milk sits in equipment.
  • Coliforms. A group of gut bacteria, Escherichia, Enterobacter, Citrobacter, Klebsiella, that ferment lactose with acid and gas at 35–37 °C. They do not belong in milk at all, which is exactly why they are useful: finding coliforms means faecal contamination or dirty equipment somewhere upstream. Raw milk should carry very few: the books give a guide of not more than 10 coliforms per millilitre.
  • Pathogens. The disease-causers, covered in section 8.7.

Yeasts and moulds

Yeasts are single-celled fungi that ferment sugars and can grow in acid foods where bacteria struggle, which is why they turn up in yoghurt and cultured milks, giving yeasty, gassy, and fruity off-flavours. Moulds grow as fuzzy mats on surfaces, need air, and are the usual spoilers of cheese surfaces and of sweetened condensed milk once a can is opened. Some moulds make toxins, so a mouldy dairy product is thrown away, not scraped clean.

Bacteriophages

Viruses that infect bacteria: the starter-killers from Unit 7. They are not a spoilage problem for milk itself, but they are a production problem: a phage outbreak can stall a whole day's cheese vats.

Quick check

Which group grows in the fridge, and why does it matter?

Check your answer

Psychrotrophs, mainly Pseudomonas. They grow slowly at 0–7 °C and make enzymes that turn milk bitter and rancid.

8.4 Psychrotrophs: the cold-chain spoilers

Psychrotrophs deserve a closer look because they are the main reason refrigerated milk has a limited life. A litre of raw milk cooled to 4 °C looks safe, and for the first day it mostly is. But Pseudomonas and its cold-loving relatives grow slowly even at 4 °C, and over several days they reach numbers where their enzymes start to bite.

Their enzymes are the real problem. Proteases (protein-cutting enzymes) break milk protein into bitter peptides. Lipases (fat-cutting enzymes) break milk fat into free fatty acids that taste rancid and soapy. And the worst of these enzymes are heat-stable: pasteurisation kills the Pseudomonas cells, but the enzymes they already made survive the heat and keep cutting protein and fat in the pasteurised milk on the shelf. That is why milk from a long, cold storage can go bitter even though it was pasteurised properly: the damage was done before the milk was ever heated.

The defence is not more heat; it is less time. Keep raw milk cold, move it fast, and do not let it sit for days before processing. The cold chain slows psychrotrophs down, but it does not stop them, and time is on their side.

Quick check

Pasteurisation kills the Pseudomonas cells, yet the milk still turns bitter on the shelf. Why?

Check your answer

Their protease and lipase enzymes are heat-stable: they survive pasteurisation and keep cutting protein and fat in the stored milk.

8.5 What processing does to microbes

Pasteurisation: most die, some survive

Pasteurisation, heating milk to kill pathogens and most spoilage bacteria, is a numbers game. Heat kills bacteria in proportion: each minute at a set temperature kills the same fraction of the cells still alive, not the same number. That fraction is summed up in the D-value (decimal reduction time): the time at a given temperature needed to kill 90% of a population, one decimal place, one zero off the count.

Worked example: the D-value in action. Suppose a bacterium has a D-value of 1 minute at 63 °C. Start with 1,000,000 cells per millilitre. After 1 minute, 100,000 are left. After 2 minutes, 10,000. After 3 minutes, 1,000. Each minute takes away nine-tenths of what is left. That is why pasteurisation times are set with a safety margin: the aim is to drive the pathogens down by many decimal places, not just to "kill most of them".

What survives pasteurisation is a short list: bacterial spores (notably Bacillus and Clostridium), thermoduric bacteria, and the heat-stable enzymes described above. Spores are the tough cases: dormant, armoured cells that can sit through pasteurisation and wake up later in the stored product. Sterilisation, the much harder heat treatment used for evaporated milk and UHT milk, is designed to kill spores as well.

What heat does not fix

Pasteurisation cannot undo damage. If psychrotrophs have already made bitter peptides, or if the milk has already soured, heating will not remove the bitterness or the acid. It cannot remove toxins made by Staphylococcus aureus either: the toxin survives heating that kills the bacterium. The rule stands: heat is a safety net, not a repair shop. Good milk in means good milk out; bad milk in means heated bad milk out.

🤔 Pause and think: a batch tastes bitter before pasteurising. Would you pasteurise it and sell it? Why not?

Quick check

A bacterium has a D-value of 1 minute at 63 °C. Start with 1,000,000 cells per ml: how many are left after 3 minutes?

Check your answer

1,000. Each minute removes nine-tenths of what is left: 1,000,000 → 100,000 → 10,000 → 1,000.

8.6 Counting microbes: how the plant knows

You cannot see bacteria, so the dairy counts them by growing them. The main methods are:

Standard plate count (SPC)

The workhorse test. A measured amount of milk is diluted in steps, mixed into melted agar in a Petri dish, and incubated, for the standard count, at 32 ± 1 °C or 37 °C for 48 ± 3 hours. Each living cell grows into a visible colony, and the colonies are counted.

Worked example. You dilute milk 1,000-fold, plate 1 ml, and count 85 colonies. The count is 85 × 1,000 = 85,000 colony-forming units (cfu) per millilitre. Only plates with 30–300 colonies are trusted: fewer than 30 and chance swamps the result; more than 300 and the colonies crowd each other and cannot be counted properly.

As a guide from the books, a standard plate count below 30,000 cfu per millilitre in pasteurised milk points to satisfactory quality. Raw milk counts are higher and depend on the handling, which is why the count is used to pay for milk quality and to spot a hygiene problem at a farm or in a tanker.

Direct microscopic count (DMC)

A measured drop of milk is spread over a measured area on a slide, stained, and the cells are counted under the microscope. It is fast, an answer in minutes, and it counts dead cells as well as living ones. Its weakness is sensitivity: it is unreliable when the load is below about 500,000 cells per millilitre, because too few cells land in the field of view. It is useful for a quick check on a bad sample, not for grading good milk.

Methylene blue reduction test (MBRT)

A blue dye is added to the milk, and the milk is held warm. Bacteria, as they grow and breathe, strip the colour from the dye. The faster the milk turns white, the more bacteria are in it. The test reads the other way round from the plate count: a long reduction time means few bacteria and good milk.

Reduction timeWhat it suggests
5½ hours or moreGood milk: roughly below 500,000 bacteria per millilitre, keeping quality around 40 hours
Shorter timesMore bacteria, poorer keeping quality

MBRT is quick, cheap, and needs no incubator full of plates, which is why it is still used at milk collection points. Its weakness is that anything else that reduces the dye, such as the white blood cells in mastitic milk, can shorten the time and make the milk look worse than its bacterial count alone would suggest.

Coliform count and other group counts

Coliforms are counted on a selective medium (such as violet red bile agar) that lets coliforms grow and show up as dark colonies, while holding most other bacteria back. Plates are incubated at 37 °C for 24–48 hours. Because coliforms mean faecal contamination or dirty equipment, a high coliform count is treated as a hygiene failure even if the total count looks fine. Yeasts and moulds are counted on their own acidified media, where bacteria grow poorly.

Somatic cells: counting the animal's own cells

Milk also carries somatic cells: mostly white blood cells from the udder. A healthy quarter of an udder sheds about 125,000–250,000 somatic cells per millilitre into its milk; bulk milk runs in the same range or a little higher. A sharp rise means inflammation, mastitis, and the count is used to spot it (section 8.8).

Quick check

Why are only plates with 30–300 colonies counted?

Check your answer

Fewer than 30 and chance swamps the result; more than 300 and the colonies crowd each other and cannot be counted properly.

8.7 Spoilage: how milk goes off

Spoilage is microbes eating the milk before we do, and each group leaves its own signature:

SpoilageWhat you noticeWho does it
SouringSharp, acid taste; milk curdlesLactic acid bacteria growing warm
BitternessBitter taste, sometimes with a fruity notePsychrotroph proteases cutting protein
RanciditySoapy, bitter, "goaty" tasteLipases cutting fat: psychrotrophs, or the milk's own lipase if the fat globules are damaged
RopinessMilk pours in long, slimy threadsSlime-making bacteria, including some Alcaligenes and lactic strains
Sweet curdlingMilk curdles without turning sourSpore-formers such as Bacillus: their enzymes clot the milk while the acid stays low
Gas and bloatingBubbles, blown packs, fizzGas-making coliforms and yeasts
Mouldy surfaceFuzzy growth on cheese or opened cansMoulds growing where air reaches the food

Most spoilage is a race between temperature and time. Warm milk sours fast; cold milk goes bitter slowly. The plant's answer is the same in both cases: keep it cold, keep it clean, and keep it moving.

Case file: the bitter milk, trace the culprit

A dairy's pasteurised milk turns bitter after a week on the shelf. The plate count of the pasteurised milk is low. The pasteuriser charts are normal. The raw milk was held cold for four days before processing. Who is the culprit, and why didn't pasteurisation stop them?

Check your answer

Psychrotrophs, most likely Pseudomonas. They grew slowly in the cold raw milk over four days and made heat-stable protease enzymes. Pasteurisation killed the cells (so the plate count is low), but the enzymes survived the heat and kept cutting protein in the pasteurised milk, making it bitter. The fix is not more heat: it is less time, process the raw milk sooner.

Quick check

Milk curdles but is not sour. Who did it?

Check your answer

Spore-formers such as Bacillus: sweet curdling, their enzymes clot the milk while the acid stays low.

8.8 Mastitis: when the udder is infected

Mastitis is inflammation of the udder, almost always caused by microbes getting into the teat and infecting the tissue. The main culprits are Staphylococcus aureus and Streptococcus agalactiae, along with coliforms and other environmental bacteria.

Mastitic milk is different milk: it carries far more bacteria and far more somatic cells, its chloride and catalase levels rise, its lactose and casein fall, and it tastes salty. It clots poorly, ferments badly, and its keeping quality is poor, and it can carry pathogens. That is why it is kept out of the supply: a mastitic quarter is milked separately, the milk is discarded, and the animal is treated.

Detection is straightforward once you know what to look for: a high somatic cell count, a positive California Mastitis Test (a reagent mixed with the milk that thickens into a gel when the cell count is high), a rise in chloride, or the bacteria themselves grown in the laboratory. Herds that test regularly catch mastitis early, when it is cheap to treat and before it spreads to other animals.

Quick check

Name two signs of mastitic milk.

Check your answer

A high somatic cell count, salty taste, a positive California Mastitis Test, or raised chloride: any two will do.

8.9 Milk-borne disease: infection, intoxication, and toxi-infection

Not all milk-borne illness works the same way, and the distinction matters for prevention:

  • Food infection. The live pathogen is swallowed, grows in the gut, and causes illness. Examples: Salmonella, Listeria monocytogenes, Campylobacter, and the tuberculosis bacterium Mycobacterium bovis. Pasteurisation is the main defence, because it kills the live cells.
  • Food intoxication. The bacterium grows in the food and leaves a toxin behind, and the toxin causes the illness, even if the bacterium itself is dead by the time the food is eaten. The classic case is Staphylococcus aureus: it grows in milk held warm, makes a heat-stable toxin, and the toxin survives pasteurisation. The defence is to stop the bacterium growing in the first place: keep the milk cold.

🤔 Pause and think: a carton sits on a warm kitchen counter, two hours, or eight hours. Which is the risky one, and what is growing in it?
- Toxi-infection. A mix of the two: the bacterium is swallowed, grows in the gut, and makes its toxin there. Clostridium perfringens is the usual example.

OrganismIllnessHow it reaches milkMain defence
Salmonella spp.Salmonellosis, typhoid (from S. typhi)Faecal contamination, sick animals, dirty equipmentPasteurisation, hygiene, cold storage
Listeria monocytogenesListeriosisEnvironment, soil, silage, cold-stored foods: it grows slowly even in the fridgePasteurisation, clean plant, cold chain
Staphylococcus aureusFood poisoning from its toxinSkin, hands, mastitic uddersKeep milk cold, pasteurise, good hand hygiene
Brucella spp.Brucellosis (undulant fever)Infected animals, raw milkPasteurisation, animal health control
Mycobacterium bovisTuberculosisInfected animals, raw milkPasteurisation, animal health control
Escherichia coli (pathogenic strains)Gut infectionFaecal contaminationPasteurisation, hygiene
Bacillus cereusFood poisoningSpores in soil and dust, survive pasteurisationKeep milk cold after heating; do not hold warm

Listeria deserves a special note: it is one of the few pathogens that can grow, slowly, at refrigeration temperatures. That is why ready-to-eat chilled dairy products get extra attention, and why a cold chain that is merely cool, rather than properly cold, is not enough.

Quick check

What is the difference between food infection and food intoxication?

Check your answer

Infection: the live pathogen is swallowed and grows in the gut. Intoxication: the bacterium grew in the food and left a toxin behind: the toxin causes the illness even if the bacterium is dead.

8.10 Milk's own defences: antimicrobial substances

Milk is not defenceless. It carries its own antimicrobial system, strongest in fresh milk and in colostrum (the first milk after calving):

  • Immunoglobulins. Antibodies from the mother's blood that attack specific bacteria. They are high in colostrum and fall quickly in normal milk.
  • Lactoferrin. A protein that locks up iron, starving bacteria of a nutrient they need to grow. It also damages bacterial cell walls directly.
  • Lysozyme. An enzyme that cuts the cell walls of some bacteria, especially Gram-positive ones.
  • Lactoperoxidase system. An enzyme system that, with a trace of hydrogen peroxide and thiocyanate from the milk, makes compounds that kill bacteria. It can be boosted on purpose: adding about 8–12 ppm of hydrogen peroxide activates the system, a method used to keep raw milk safe where cooling is not available.
  • Complement and other proteins. A set of blood-derived proteins that help punch holes in bacterial cells.

These defences slow bacteria down, but they are not a substitute for cooling and pasteurisation. They fade as milk is stored and heated, and they were never strong enough to make raw milk safe on their own.

Quick check

What does lactoferrin do in milk?

Check your answer

It locks up iron so bacteria cannot grow, and it also damages bacterial cell walls directly.

8.11 Practical note: taking a milk sample that means something

A test is only as good as the sample. Mix the milk well before you sample: bacteria and fat rise, and a sample skimmed off the top tells a different story from one drawn from the bottom. Use a sterile bottle, fill it, cap it at once, and get it cold (below 4 °C) and to the laboratory fast, within a day. A sample that sat warm on a bench for a day is not a sample of the milk; it is a sample of what grew in the milk afterwards. And when the laboratory reports a count, read it as a story, not a verdict: a high plate count with a low coliform count points at cold-storage growth; a high coliform count points at hygiene; a short dye-reduction time with a low plate count points at mastitic milk or a testing fault.

Quick check

Why mix the milk well before taking a sample for testing?

Check your answer

Bacteria and fat rise, so a sample from the top tells a different story from one drawn from the bottom.

8.12 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a tanker of raw milk arrives cold and smells fine, but the plant's lab says its plate count is very high. The milk was cold the whole way. How can the count be high if the milk stayed cold?

  1. You dilute milk 1,000-fold, plate 1 ml, and count 85 colonies. What is the count per millilitre?
Check your answer

85 × 1,000 = 85,000 colony-forming units (cfu) per millilitre.

  1. Good milk takes 5½ hours or more to lose its blue colour in the methylene blue test. What does a fast colour loss mean?
Check your answer

More bacteria: the bacteria strip the colour from the dye as they grow, so a short reduction time means a high bacterial load and poor keeping quality.

  1. Pasteurisation kills the Pseudomonas cells in cold-stored milk, yet the pasteurised milk still turns bitter on the shelf. Why?
Check your answer

The heat-stable protease and lipase enzymes the psychrotrophs made before pasteurisation survive the heat and keep cutting protein and fat in the stored milk.

  1. Why is finding coliforms in milk treated as a hygiene failure even when the total count looks fine?
Check your answer

Coliforms come from faecal contamination or dirty equipment and do not belong in milk at all: their presence points at a hygiene failure upstream, whatever the total count says.

Try it: Leave a small glass of milk at room temperature and keep an identical glass in the fridge. Smell and look at both after 12 hours and after 24 hours. The room-temperature glass sours (lactic acid bacteria); the fridge glass changes more slowly, and if it turns bitter after several days, that is the psychrotrophs at work.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Milk is rich food for microbes: near neutral, full of lactose, protein, and vitamins. One cell can become millions in a day at room temperature.
  • Most microbes enter after milking: from teat skin, air, water, equipment, hands, and warm storage. Equipment that is not cleaned properly seeds every litre that passes through it.
  • The main groups are lactic acid bacteria (the fermenters), psychrotrophs such as Pseudomonas (the cold-growers that make heat-stable enzymes), thermoduric spore-formers (the heat-survivors), coliforms (the hygiene indicators), yeasts and moulds, and the pathogens.
  • Pasteurisation kills by fractions: each minute at temperature removes the same share of the cells still alive. The D-value is the time needed to remove nine-tenths of them. Spores and heat-stable enzymes survive.
  • The plant counts microbes by growing them: the standard plate count (32 ± 1 °C or 37 °C, 48 ± 3 hours, count plates with 30–300 colonies), the direct microscopic count, the methylene blue reduction test (good milk takes 5½ hours or more to lose its colour), and the coliform count.
  • Spoilage has signatures: souring, bitterness, rancidity, ropiness, sweet curdling, gas. Each one points at a group of microbes and a handling fault.
  • Mastitis raises somatic cells and bacteria in the milk, and the milk is kept out of the supply. Its signs are a high cell count, a positive California Mastitis Test, and salty milk.
  • Milk-borne disease comes as infection (live pathogen, killed by pasteurisation), intoxication (heat-stable toxin, stopped by keeping milk cold), or toxi-infection (both). Listeria is the one to remember in the fridge, because it grows slowly even when cold.
  • Milk has its own defences, immunoglobulins, lactoferrin, lysozyme, and the lactoperoxidase system, but they slow bacteria down; they do not make raw milk safe.

Glossary

Psychrotroph

A bacterium that grows slowly at refrigeration temperatures, 0 to 7 °C, with an optimum around 15 to 20 °C. Food tech example: Pseudomonas is the main psychrotroph in milk, and it makes enzymes that turn cold-stored milk bitter and rancid.

Thermoduric bacteria

Bacteria that can live through pasteurisation, although they do not necessarily like heat. Food tech example: spore-formers such as Bacillus species, and tough non-spore-formers such as Microbacterium and Micrococcus, are the bacteria left standing after milk is heated.

Thermophilic bacteria

Bacteria that grow best at 45 to 55 °C. Food tech example: thermophilic bacteria can cause trouble where milk is held warm in the plant, and in spray dryers and evaporators where warm milk sits in equipment.

Coliforms

A group of gut bacteria that ferment lactose with acid and gas at 35 to 37 °C. Food tech example: finding coliforms in milk means faecal contamination or dirty equipment upstream, and raw milk should carry not more than 10 coliforms per millilitre.

Protease

An enzyme that cuts protein into smaller pieces. Food tech example: psychrotroph proteases break milk protein into bitter peptides, which is why cold-stored milk can taste bitter.

Lipase

An enzyme that cuts fat into free fatty acids. Food tech example: lipases from psychrotrophs, or the milk's own lipase when fat globules are damaged, give milk a soapy, bitter, rancid taste.

D-value

The decimal reduction time, the time at a given temperature needed to kill 90% of a bacterial population, one decimal place. Food tech example: with a D-value of 1 minute at 63 °C, 1,000,000 cells per millilitre fall to 100,000 after one minute, 10,000 after two, and 1,000 after three.

Spore

A dormant, armoured bacterial cell that can sit through pasteurisation and wake up later in the stored product. Food tech example: spores of Bacillus and Clostridium survive pasteurisation, and only the harder heat of sterilisation is designed to kill them.

Standard plate count

The workhorse test for counting bacteria, in which diluted milk is mixed into agar in a Petri dish and incubated, then the colonies are counted. Food tech example: the standard count is incubated at 32 plus or minus 1 °C or 37 °C for 48 plus or minus 3 hours, and a count below 30,000 cfu per millilitre in pasteurised milk points to satisfactory quality.

Colony-forming unit (cfu)

One living cell, counted by the visible colony it grows into on a plate. Food tech example: diluting milk 1,000-fold, plating 1 ml, and counting 85 colonies gives 85,000 cfu per millilitre.

Direct microscopic count

A fast count in which a measured drop of milk is spread on a slide, stained, and the cells are counted under the microscope. Food tech example: the direct microscopic count gives an answer in minutes, but it is unreliable below about 500,000 cells per millilitre and it counts dead cells as well as living ones.

Methylene blue reduction test

A test in which a blue dye is added to milk and held warm, and bacteria strip the colour from the dye as they grow. Food tech example: good milk takes 5 and a half hours or more to lose its blue colour, which suggests roughly below 500,000 bacteria per millilitre and a keeping quality around 40 hours.

Somatic cells

The animal's own cells in milk, mostly white blood cells from the udder. Food tech example: a healthy quarter sheds about 125,000 to 250,000 somatic cells per millilitre, and a sharp rise means inflammation, or mastitis.

Mastitis

Inflammation of the udder, almost always caused by microbes getting into the teat and infecting the tissue. Food tech example: milk from a mastitic quarter tastes salty, clots poorly, ferments badly, and is kept out of the supply.

California Mastitis Test

A test in which a reagent mixed with milk thickens into a gel when the somatic cell count is high. Food tech example: a positive California Mastitis Test is one of the signs used to spot mastitis in a herd.

Food infection

Illness caused when a live pathogen is swallowed, grows in the gut, and causes illness. Food tech example: Salmonella, Listeria monocytogenes, Campylobacter, and Mycobacterium bovis cause food infection, and pasteurisation is the main defence because it kills the live cells.

Food intoxication

Illness caused by a toxin a bacterium left behind in the food, even if the bacterium itself is dead by the time the food is eaten. Food tech example: Staphylococcus aureus grows in milk held warm, makes a heat-stable toxin, and the toxin survives pasteurisation, so the defence is to keep the milk cold.

Toxi-infection

A mix of infection and intoxication, in which the bacterium is swallowed, grows in the gut, and makes its toxin there. Food tech example: Clostridium perfringens is the usual example of toxi-infection.

Lactoferrin

A protein in milk that locks up iron, starving bacteria of a nutrient they need to grow, and also damages bacterial cell walls directly. Food tech example: lactoferrin is part of milk's own antimicrobial system, strongest in fresh milk and in colostrum, the first milk after calving.

References

  • Sankara Reddy, I., and Puniya, A. K. Introductory Dairy Microbiology. Agrimoon e-course, Department of Dairy Microbiology, SVVU, Tirupati, and Dairy Microbiology Division, NDRI, Karnal.
  • Prajapati, J. B., Sankara Reddy, I., and Sreeja, V. Starter Cultures and Fermented Milk Products. Agrimoon e-course, Department of Dairy Microbiology and Biotechnology, Anand Agricultural University.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.

Unit 9: Cheese Technology

Note

Unit 9: Cheese Technology

Cheese is milk with most of the water taken out and the rest kept under control. Ten litres of milk become about one kilogram of cheese, and the water that leaves carries the lactose and the whey proteins with it, while the casein and the fat stay behind. How does a liquid become a solid that can ripen for months and still taste of the milk it came from? This unit follows the curd from milk to cheese.

9.1 What cheese is

Cheese is the fresh or ripened product made by clotting milk, cutting the curd, draining the whey, and pressing and salting what is left. In plain terms it is concentrated milk protein and fat: the casein and most of the fat are kept, while most of the water, the lactose, and the whey proteins leave in the whey. That is why cheese keeps far longer than milk and carries far more protein and fat per kilogram.

There are hundreds of cheese varieties, and they differ in a handful of choices the maker controls: which milk is used, which starter is added, whether the curd is set by rennet or by acid, how the curd is cut and heated, how much salt is added, and how long and under what conditions the cheese ripens. Change one of those and the cheese changes: a soft cheese is high in moisture and ripens fast, a hard cheese is low in moisture and ripens slowly, and a cheese ripened by moulds tastes of the moulds that grew on it or in it.

🤔 Pause and think: if cheese is mostly casein and fat, what has happened to the lactose and the whey proteins? Where did they go, and what is done with them?

Quick check

What stays in the curd when cheese is made, and what leaves in the whey?

Check your answer

Casein and most of the fat stay in the curd, while most of the water, the lactose, and the whey proteins leave in the whey.

9.2 The milk for cheese: not every milk will do

Cheese milk must be fresh, clean, and free of anything that stops the starter or the rennet working. Milk with antibiotics in it, from a treated animal, will not ferment, because the antibiotics kill the starter bacteria. Milk with high acidity, or milk late in lactation, gives a weak curd. Mastitis milk gives a poor yield and a bitter cheese. The plant therefore tests cheese milk for acidity, for heat stability, and for freedom from antibiotics before it is used.

Buffalo milk makes cheese well, but it behaves differently from cow milk: it is richer in fat and protein, so it gives a higher yield, but its curd is whiter, softer, and harder to handle, and its fat globules are larger, so the cheese can feel greasy. The books describe process changes for buffalo milk cheese: gentler cutting, careful cooking, and attention to the fat, so that the cheese comes out firm instead of soft and oily. The lesson is general: cheese making starts with knowing the milk, not with the recipe.

Quick check

Why must cheese milk be free of antibiotics?

Check your answer

Antibiotics kill the starter bacteria, so the milk will not ferment and the cheese will not develop.

9.3 The starter: acid on schedule

The starter culture, covered in Unit 7, is added to the cheese milk so that lactic acid bacteria turn lactose into lactic acid on a schedule the maker controls. The acid does three jobs at once: it helps the rennet set the curd, it squeezes whey out of the curd as the curd firms, and it sets the pH that decides how the cheese ripens and how safe it is. Mesophilic starters, which like about 30 °C, are used for cheddar and similar cheeses, while thermophilic starters, which like about 40 to 45 °C, are used for swiss and mozzarella, where the curd is cooked hotter.

The starter must be active and free of bacteriophage, the viruses that attack starter bacteria and can stop a fermentation dead. A slow vat is the classic sign of phage trouble: the acid does not develop, the curd stays soft, and the whole batch is at risk. Plants guard against it by rotating starter strains, keeping the culture room clean, and never letting whey splash back into the culture area.

Quick check

What three jobs does the starter acid do in cheese making?

Check your answer

It helps the rennet set the curd, it squeezes whey out of the curd as the curd firms, and it sets the pH that decides ripening and safety.

9.4 Rennet: the enzyme that sets the curd

Rennet is the enzyme preparation that clots milk for most cheeses. Its active enzyme is chymosin, which clips the kappa casein hairs off the casein micelles, as described in Unit 2. Without the hairs, the micelles join, and the milk sets into a soft gel, the curd, in about 30 to 45 minutes at the setting temperature.

Calf rennet, taken from the stomach of a young calf, was the original source, and the books describe its preparation and properties in detail. Today the maker also uses rennet substitutes: microbial rennet from moulds, and fermentation-produced chymosin made by microbes carrying the calf gene. The substitutes are chosen to behave like calf rennet, because a rennet that cuts protein too aggressively gives a bitter cheese, while a weak rennet gives a soft curd and a low yield.

The amount of rennet, the temperature, and the pH all change the set. More rennet sets the milk faster but risks bitterness; too little sets it slowly and gives a weak curd. The maker judges the set by touch: the curd should split cleanly when a knife is drawn through it, with clear whey showing in the cut.

Quick check

What does chymosin do to the casein micelle?

Check your answer

It clips the kappa casein hairs off the micelle surface, so the micelles join and the milk sets into a curd.

9.5 Cutting, cooking, and draining: the curd gives up its whey

Once the curd has set, it is cut into cubes with wire knives. Cutting opens a huge surface area, and whey starts to leak out: that leaking is called syneresis. The size of the cubes decides the moisture of the cheese: small cubes, about the size of a pea, lose whey fast and give a hard, low-moisture cheese, while large cubes lose whey slowly and give a soft, high-moisture cheese.

The cut curd is then stirred and cooked, heated gently while it is stirred, which firms the curd and squeezes out more whey. Cheddar curd is cooked to about 38 to 40 °C, while swiss curd is cooked hotter, to about 50 to 54 °C, which is why swiss is firmer and drier. The maker judges the curd by squeezing a handful: it should hold together and spring back, and the whey running off it should be clear and greenish, not milky.

From milk to curd to cheese

Milk + starter + rennet

↓
Set 30-45 min

Curd
Soft gel, whey trapped inside the casein network.

↓
Cut into cubes: whey leaks out

Stir + cook
Curd firms, more whey out.

↓

Drain the whey, press the curd

↓

Salt, then ripen

Figure 9.1: From milk to curd to cheese: setting, cutting, cooking, draining, and pressing. Drawn from Cheese Technology, Lessons 5 and 17.

Quick check

Why are cheddar curds cut small and cottage cheese curds cut large?

Check your answer

Small cubes lose whey fast and give a hard, low-moisture cheese, while large cubes lose whey slowly and give a soft, high-moisture cheese.

9.6 Cheddaring, salting, and pressing

Cheddar has a step of its own, called cheddaring. After the whey is drained, the curd is cut into slabs, the slabs are piled and turned, and the curd is allowed to mat together while the acid develops. The piled curd is then milled into small pieces, salt is mixed in, and the salted curd is pressed into moulds. Salt does several jobs: it draws out more whey, it firms the curd, it controls the starter so the acid does not go too far, and it flavours the cheese.

Other cheeses skip cheddaring and press the curd directly into moulds, or ladle it into baskets, as for cottage cheese. Pressing squeezes out the last free whey and closes the curd into a solid block. The pressed cheese is then taken out of the mould, and it is ready for ripening, or, for a fresh cheese such as cottage cheese, ready to eat.

Quick check

What does salt do in cheddar besides flavouring it?

Check your answer

It draws out more whey, firms the curd, and controls the starter so the acid does not go too far.

9.7 The main families: cheddar, gouda, swiss, mozzarella, cottage

A few varieties show how the same steps give different cheeses:

  • Cheddar. A hard cheese, cooked to about 38 to 40 °C, cheddared, milled, salted, and pressed, then ripened for months. It is firm, close-textured, and sharp when mature.
  • Gouda. A semi-hard cheese, washed with warm water during making, which removes some lactose and leaves the cheese milder and sweeter than cheddar. It is pressed into round moulds and ripened with a waxed rind.
  • Swiss (Emmental). A hard cheese cooked hot, to about 50 to 54 °C, with a thermophilic starter and a propionic acid bacterium that makes carbon dioxide during ripening: the gas forms the round eyes, the holes, that mark the cheese.
  • Mozzarella. A pasta filata cheese: the curd is stretched in hot water until it turns smooth and elastic, then moulded into balls. That stretching is why mozzarella melts into strings on a pizza.
  • Cottage cheese. A fresh, acid-set cheese: the curd is cut large, cooked gently, drained, and washed, and cream is mixed back in. It is eaten fresh, with no ripening.

Quick check

What makes the holes in swiss cheese?

Check your answer

A propionic acid bacterium makes carbon dioxide during ripening, and the gas forms the round eyes.

9.8 Ripening: the cheese becomes itself

Ripening, also called curing, is the storage of cheese under controlled temperature and humidity while enzymes and microbes change it. Three kinds of change run together:

  • Protein breakdown (proteolysis). Rennet and the enzymes of the starter and of the milk slowly cut casein into smaller pieces, which softens the cheese and builds flavour. Too much proteolysis gives bitterness.
  • Fat breakdown (lipolysis). Lipases slowly release free fatty acids, which give sharp, peppery, and nutty notes. Blue cheeses take this furthest, with mould lipases making their strong flavour.
  • Lactose use. The starter uses up the remaining lactose early in ripening, so a mature cheese carries almost no lactose, which is why many people who digest milk poorly can eat mature cheese.

Ripening is slow: a cheddar ripens for months, and a mature cheddar for a year or more, while a soft cheese ripens in weeks. Temperature and humidity decide the speed: warmer ripening is faster but risks off-flavours, and a dry store cracks the rind while a damp store grows unwanted mould. Accelerated ripening, using added enzymes or higher temperatures, is described in the books, but it is a trade: speed against flavour.

🤔 Pause and think: a cheese is ripened warm to save time, and it turns bitter. Which of the three ripening changes ran too fast, and what would you change?

Quick check

Name the three kinds of change that happen during cheese ripening.

Check your answer

Protein breakdown (proteolysis), fat breakdown (lipolysis), and the starter using up the remaining lactose.

9.9 Yield: how much cheese from how much milk

Cheese yield is the weight of cheese made from a given weight of milk, and it is the number the plant watches most closely, because it decides whether the day paid. As a rule of thumb, about 10 litres of cow milk make about 1 kilogram of hard cheese, a yield of about 10%. Buffalo milk, richer in fat and protein, gives a higher yield. The yield rises with more fat and more casein in the milk, with a firm curd that loses little fat and protein into the whey, and with a higher moisture in the finished cheese, which is why moisture is controlled so tightly: a cheese that is 1% wetter than its target gives a higher yield, but it is also a cheese that may spoil faster and break its own standard.

Yield is measured on every vat, and the fat and protein lost into the whey are measured too. Fat in the whey means the curd was cut too roughly or set too weakly; protein in the whey means the milk was poor or the acid went wrong. The whey is not wasted: Unit 11 follows it into whey products.

Worked example: the yield sum. A vat of 1,000 litres of milk at 3.5% fat and 3.3% protein holds 35 kg of fat and 33 kg of protein. If 90% of the fat and 75% of the casein are kept in the curd, and the cheese is 37% moisture, the yield works out near 100 kg of cheese, about 10% of the milk. That 10% is the figure the plant plans around.

Quick check

About how much hard cheese comes from 10 litres of cow milk?

Check your answer

About 1 kilogram, a yield of about 10%.

9.10 Defects, packaging, and storage

The common defects of cheese trace back to the steps above: bitterness from too much proteolysis or a wrong rennet; a sour or acid flavour from too much starter acid; gas holes in the wrong places from unwanted bacteria; a dry, crumbly body from too little moisture; and a rind that cracks in a dry store or grows unwanted mould in a damp one. Prevention is the same in each case: good milk, a healthy starter, the right rennet dose, the right cooking and salting, and a ripening room held at the right temperature and humidity.

Cheese is packaged to protect it while it ripens and while it travels: waxed rinds, vacuum packs, and foil wraps keep moisture in and air and mould out. Hard cheeses are stored cool, near 2 to 8 °C, and a ripening room is held at about 10 to 15 °C with high humidity, so the cheese ripens slowly without drying out. A cheese that is stored warm ripens fast and goes off; a cheese stored cold barely ripens at all.

Quick check

Your cheddar tastes bitter. What is the most likely cause?

Check your answer

Too much protein breakdown during ripening, or a rennet that cuts protein too aggressively.

9.11 Derivation: cheese yield, the Van Slyke way

Section 9.9 gave the rough yield: about 10 kg of hard cheese from 100 kg of cow milk. This section derives the formula the industry uses to predict that number before the vat is even filled: the Van Slyke yield formula. It is built from the milk, not from memory.

The formula, one piece at a time

Yield (%) = [(0.93 × F + C − 0.1) × 1.09] / (1 − M)

F is the fat percentage of the milk. C is the casein percentage of the milk. M is the moisture fraction of the finished cheese, written as a decimal: 0.37 for a cheese at 37% moisture.

Step 1, the fat kept in the curd. Not all the milk fat ends up in the cheese: a little is lost into the whey. The books use 0.93, meaning 93% of the fat is kept. So the fat in the cheese, per 100 kg of milk, is 0.93 × F kilograms.

Step 2, the casein kept in the curd. Casein is the protein that builds the curd, and most of it is kept: the formula takes the casein percentage C and subtracts 0.1, a small allowance for the casein lost into the whey. The whey proteins are not in this term at all: they leave with the whey, and that is why the yield follows casein, not total protein.

Step 3, the weight the curd gains. The curd keeps some salt and some whey solids, and the formula multiplies the sum by 1.09 to allow for that gain: 9% extra weight on top of the fat and casein kept.

Step 4, turn dry curd into cheese at its target moisture. The steps above give the dry matter of the cheese. A cheese at 37% moisture is 63% dry matter, so divide by (1 − M), which is 0.63, to get the weight of cheese at that moisture.

Worked example: cheddar from cow milk

Take 100 kg of milk at 3.5% fat and 3.3% total protein. Casein is about 78% of milk protein, so C ≈ 3.3 × 0.78 ≈ 2.6%.

Step 1: fat kept = 0.93 × 3.5 = 3.26 kg.
Step 2: casein kept = 2.6 − 0.1 = 2.5 kg.
Step 3: add them and allow for the gain: (3.26 + 2.5) × 1.09 = 5.76 × 1.09 ≈ 6.28 kg of cheese dry matter.
Step 4: divide by the dry matter fraction at 37% moisture: 6.28 / 0.63 ≈ 9.97 kg of cheese per 100 kg of milk. About 10%: the rough figure from Section 9.9, now derived from the milk itself.

Reading the formula like a cheese maker

Each term points at a lever the plant can pull. More fat in the milk lifts the yield, which is why the plant standardises the fat for cheese milk instead of skimming it for butter. More casein lifts the yield, which is why late-lactation milk, richer in protein, gives more cheese per vat. A higher moisture target lifts the yield on paper, because dividing by a smaller dry matter fraction gives a bigger number, but the cheese may spoil faster and break its own standard: the books warn that moisture is the easiest yield to fake and the first thing a judge checks. And a weak set that loses fat and casein into the whey breaks the formula from underneath: the 0.93 and the 0.1 are the numbers for a good set, and a bad set loses far more.

The vat, step by step

From milk to cheese in the vat

Milk in the vat
Standardised, pasteurised, warmed to renneting temperature, starter added, acid on schedule.

↓

Rennet in, milk sets
A firm gel in 30-45 minutes. A clean break when a knife is drawn through it.

↓

Cut the curd
Curd knives cut the gel into small cubes. Small cubes lose whey faster; large cubes keep more moisture.

↓

Stir and cook
Gentle stirring and slow heating firm the curd and push whey out.

↓

Drain the whey
Whey leaves for Unit 11. The curd mats together.

↓

Cheddar, salt, press
Curd is stacked and turned, salted, and pressed into shape. Salt controls the acid and the moisture.

↓

Ripen
Cool, humid room, weeks to months. Flavour and body develop.

Figure 9.2: The cheese vat, from milk in to ripening. Drawn from the cheese making steps in Cheese Technology, Lessons 5 and 17.

When the curd will not set right

A weak, slow set usually has one of four causes, and each has its own fix. Milk that is too cold sets slowly: warm it to the renneting temperature and hold it there. Milk low in soluble calcium, such as milk held cold for a long time, sets weakly: the plant adds a small dose of calcium chloride, which restores the calcium the rennet needs. Rennet that is old, wrongly dosed, or added to milk that is too hot or too acid sets badly: check the dose, the temperature, and the age of the rennet. And milk from a treated animal, or milk carrying cleaning chemical residues, may not set at all: the starter is stopped and the rennet is blocked, and no amount of extra rennet fixes it. The plant's habit is to test a small sample before committing a whole vat: a cup of milk, a drop of rennet, and a watch tells the maker more than any argument.

🤔 Pause and think: a plant's cheddar yield falls from 10% to 9% over a month, while the milk fat tests the same. Which term of the Van Slyke formula would you check first, and what test would prove it?

Quick check

Milk at 3.5% fat and 2.6% casein is made into cheddar at 37% moisture. Work the Van Slyke formula: what yield do you expect?

Check your answer

About 10 kg per 100 kg of milk: (0.93 × 3.5 + 2.6 − 0.1) × 1.09 / 0.63 ≈ 9.97%.

9.12 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a vat of milk will not set: the starter is fine, but the milk came from an animal treated with antibiotics yesterday. What went wrong, and what should the plant have tested before the milk went into the vat?

  1. Why does cutting the curd into small cubes give a harder cheese?
Check your answer

Small cubes open a large surface area, so whey leaks out fast (syneresis), leaving a low-moisture, hard cheese.

  1. Rennet sets milk at normal pH, near 6.6. How, and what does acid do differently?
Check your answer

Rennet chymosin clips the kappa casein hairs off the micelles, so they join without acid. Acid lowers the pH to 4.6, the isoelectric point, so the micelles lose their charge and join.

  1. What makes swiss cheese firm and full of holes, and what makes mozzarella stretch?
Check your answer

Swiss curd is cooked hot, to about 50 to 54 °C, and a propionic bacterium makes carbon dioxide that forms the eyes. Mozzarella curd is stretched in hot water, which makes it smooth, elastic, and stringy when melted.

  1. About 10 litres of milk make 1 kilogram of hard cheese. What two things in the milk decide the yield most?
Check your answer

The fat and the casein content of the milk, plus how firmly the curd holds them instead of losing them into the whey.

Try it: Warm a litre of milk to about 35 °C, stir in a spoonful of lemon juice, and leave it still for 20 minutes. A soft curd forms and whey separates: cut the curd gently with a knife, leave it five minutes, and watch the whey pool in the cuts. That is acid coagulation and syneresis on your kitchen bench.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Cheese is concentrated milk protein and fat: casein and most of the fat stay in the curd, while water, lactose, and whey proteins leave in the whey.
  • Cheese milk must be fresh, clean, and free of antibiotics, or the starter will not work and the curd will be weak.
  • The starter makes lactic acid on schedule, helping the rennet, squeezing out whey, and setting the pH for ripening and safety.
  • Rennet chymosin clips kappa casein hairs so the milk sets in 30 to 45 minutes; acid sets it instead at pH 4.6.
  • Cutting opens surface for whey to leave: small cubes give hard cheese, large cubes give soft cheese, and cooking firms the curd further.
  • Cheddar is cheddared, milled, salted, and pressed; gouda is washed to stay mild; swiss is cooked hot and gassed by propionic bacteria; mozzarella is stretched in hot water; cottage cheese is fresh and unripened.
  • Ripening is protein breakdown, fat breakdown, and lactose use, running for weeks to months under controlled temperature and humidity.
  • About 10 litres of cow milk make about 1 kilogram of hard cheese, and yield is set by the fat and casein in the milk and how much of them the curd keeps.

  • The Van Slyke formula predicts cheese yield from the milk: [(0.93 × fat + casein − 0.1) × 1.09] / (1 − moisture), so a milk at 3.5% fat and 2.6% casein gives about 10% cheddar at 37% moisture.

  • Yield follows fat and casein, not total protein, because whey proteins leave with the whey, and moisture is the easiest yield to fake and the first thing a judge checks.
  • A weak set has four usual causes: milk too cold, too little soluble calcium, wrong rennet dose or condition, or milk from a treated animal, and a cup test with a drop of rennet tells the maker before a whole vat is committed.

Glossary

Curd

The soft gel formed when milk clots, a network of casein holding fat and whey. Food tech example: rennet sets milk into a curd in about 30 to 45 minutes, and cutting the curd lets the whey drain out.

Whey

The liquid left after the curd is separated, carrying water, lactose, and whey proteins. Food tech example: cheese whey is not wasted, it is made into whey powder, whey drinks, and lactose, as Unit 11 shows.

Syneresis

The leaking of whey out of the curd. Food tech example: cutting the curd into small cubes speeds syneresis, which is how a hard cheese loses more whey than a soft one.

Cheddaring

Piling and turning slabs of drained curd so they mat together while acid develops. Food tech example: cheddar curd is cheddared, then milled, salted, and pressed.

Ripening

Storing cheese under controlled temperature and humidity while enzymes and microbes change its flavour and texture. Food tech example: a cheddar ripens for months, and its casein is slowly cut into flavour pieces.

Proteolysis

The breakdown of protein into smaller pieces by enzymes. Food tech example: proteolysis softens ripening cheese and builds flavour, but too much of it makes the cheese bitter.

Lipolysis

The breakdown of fat into free fatty acids by lipases. Food tech example: lipolysis gives ripening cheese its sharp and peppery notes.

Pasta filata

Cheeses whose curd is stretched in hot water until smooth and elastic. Food tech example: mozzarella is a pasta filata cheese, which is why it melts into strings.

Bacteriophage

A virus that attacks bacteria. Food tech example: phage attacking starter bacteria can stop a cheese vat fermenting, so plants rotate starter strains.

Cheese yield

The weight of cheese made from a given weight of milk. Food tech example: about 10 litres of cow milk make about 1 kilogram of hard cheese, a yield of about 10%.

Propionic acid bacterium

A bacterium that makes propionic acid and carbon dioxide during ripening. Food tech example: in swiss cheese its carbon dioxide forms the round eyes.

Van Slyke yield formula

The formula that predicts cheese yield from milk fat, casein, and target moisture: [(0.93 × fat + casein − 0.1) × 1.09] / (1 − moisture). Food tech example: milk at 3.5% fat and 2.6% casein gives about 10% cheddar at 37% moisture.

Cheddaring

Stacking and turning blocks of curd so they mat together, expel whey, and develop acidity before salting and pressing. Food tech example: cheddared curd is salted and pressed into the shape that ripens into cheddar.

References

  • Cheese Technology. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lessons 1-32.
  • Prajapati, J. B., Sankara Reddy, I., and Sreeja, V. Starter Cultures and Fermented Milk Products. Agrimoon e-course, Anand Agricultural University.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.

Unit 10: Fat-Rich Dairy Products: Butter, Ghee and Cream

Note

Unit 10: Fat-Rich Dairy Products: Butter, Ghee and Cream

Milk fat is the most valuable part of milk by weight, and the hardest to keep. Leave cream standing and it sours, churn it and it becomes butter, heat it and it becomes ghee, and each change is a different way of taking the fat out of the milk and keeping it from going off. What decides whether cream becomes butter or goes rancid instead? The answer is in the fat globule, and in the temperature.

10.1 Cream: the starting material

Cream is the fat-rich layer of milk, made by separation, as described in Unit 4. Its fat content varies widely, from 18 to 85%, depending on how the separator is set. The common kinds are:

Kind of creamFatMain use
Table cream18-22%Poured or spooned at the table
Heavy cream30-40%Whipping, cooking, butter making
Plastic creamabout 80%Ghee making
Whipped cream30-35% fat, with air beaten inTopping, desserts

Cream is graded like milk: it must be fresh, clean, and free of off-flavours, because any flavour in the cream is carried into the butter or ghee made from it. Cream for butter is usually pasteurised, then cooled to the churning temperature and held, or ripened, so that part of its fat crystallises. That crystallisation matters, as section 10.3 explains: butter churns well only when the fat is part solid and part liquid.

Quick check

Why is cream graded strictly before butter making?

Check your answer

Any flavour in the cream is carried into the butter or ghee made from it, so off-flavours cannot be removed later.

10.2 Milk fat: what butter is made of

Milk fat is mostly triglycerides, with small amounts of phospholipids, sterols, and fat-soluble vitamins, as met in Unit 2. At fridge temperature about half of milk fat is solid and half is liquid, and at room temperature only about 20% is solid, which is why butter is firm from the fridge and spreadable after a few minutes on the bench. The mix of fatty acids decides that behaviour: short-chain acids such as butyric acid give butter its flavour, long-chain saturated acids make it firm, and oleic acid, which is unsaturated, keeps it soft.

Milk fat is also the part of milk that goes off fastest. Lipase cuts it into free fatty acids that taste rancid, and oxygen attacks its unsaturated fatty acids and gives tallowy, cardboard flavours. Butter therefore has two enemies, and both are fought the same way: keep it cold, keep it away from air and light, and keep lipase out by pasteurising the cream.

🤔 Pause and think: butter left on a sunny windowsill turns yellow on the outside and tastes stale. Which two kinds of damage are happening, and what is each one attacking?

Quick check

Why is butter firm from the fridge and spreadable on the bench?

Check your answer

At fridge temperature about half the milk fat is solid, while at room temperature only about 20% is solid, so the butter softens as it warms.

10.3 Butter: churning cream into a solid

Butter is the fat concentrate made by churning cream: gathering the fat into a compact mass and working it. By composition, butter is about 80 to 82% fat, with a maximum of about 16% water and small amounts of salt and milk solids. The steps are:

  1. Ripen the cream. The cream is cooled and held so that part of its fat crystallises. Ripened cream, soured with a starter culture, gives cultured butter with a fuller flavour; sweet cream gives sweet cream butter.
  2. Churn. The cream is beaten in a churn. The beating damages the fat globule membranes, the globules collide and join, and the fat gathers into grains, while the liquid left behind, the buttermilk, drains away.
  3. Wash and work. The butter grains are washed with cold water to remove buttermilk, which would sour in storage, then worked, or kneaded, to press out water and mix in salt evenly. Working also decides the texture: under-worked butter leaks water, over-worked butter turns greasy.

Churning works only when the fat is part solid and part liquid. If the cream is too warm, the fat is all liquid and will not gather; if it is too cold, the fat is all solid and the grains stay small and hard. The churning temperature is therefore set carefully, usually below 15.5 °C in the books, and the cream is held at that temperature long enough for the fat crystals to form before churning starts.

Making butter by churning cream

Cream
30-40% fat, pasteurised, cooled.

↓
Ripen: fat partly crystallises

Churn
Beating breaks globule membranes, globules join into butter grains.

↓
Drain off buttermilk

Wash with cold water, work in salt

↓

Butter
About 80% fat, 16% water.

Figure 10.1: Making butter by churning cream. Drawn from Fat Rich Dairy Products Technology, Lessons on churning of cream.

Quick check

Why must the cream be part solid and part liquid before churning?

Check your answer

If the fat is all liquid it will not gather into grains, and if it is all solid the grains stay small and hard: only part-crystallised fat churns well.

10.4 Buttermilk: the liquid left behind

Buttermilk is the liquid left after churning. It looks like thin milk, and it is: it carries the water, lactose, protein, and minerals of the cream, with only a little fat left in it, about 0.5% or less. It also carries fragments of the fat globule membrane, which are rich in phospholipids. Cultured buttermilk, the drink sold as buttermilk in many markets, is different: it is milk fermented with a starter culture, not the by-product of churning, although the name is the same. Both are useful: churned buttermilk is dried or used in baking and in animal feed, and cultured buttermilk is drunk as a refreshing, acid drink. Unit 11 comes back to buttermilk as a by-product.

Quick check

What is churned buttermilk, and how does it differ from cultured buttermilk?

Check your answer

Churned buttermilk is the liquid left after churning butter, with only a little fat. Cultured buttermilk is milk fermented with a starter culture, a different product that shares the name.

10.5 Ghee: butter with the water boiled away

Ghee is pure clarified milk fat, made by heating butter or cream so that the water boils off and the milk solids settle and brown. The books define it as the pure heat-clarified fat derived solely from milk, curd, or butter, and it carries almost no water, about 99.5% fat, with the rest being small amounts of flavour compounds. Because it has almost no water, ghee keeps for months at room temperature without a fridge, which is its great advantage over butter.

There are two main ways of making it:

  • From butter. Butter is heated, the water boils off, the solids settle to the bottom, and the clear fat is drawn off. The solids are allowed to brown a little, which gives ghee its nutty flavour.
  • From cream. Cream is heated directly, which is faster but needs care, because the large amount of water must boil off without scorching the solids.

The quality of ghee is judged by its flavour, its colour, its clarity, and its freedom from rancidity. Overheating gives a burnt flavour; underheating leaves water behind, and the ghee goes off in storage. The grading of ghee looks at moisture, acidity, and flavour, and good ghee is clear, golden, and nutty, with no tallowy or smoky note.

Worked example: how much ghee from butter? Start with 100 kg of butter at 80% fat and 16% water. Heating drives off the 16 kg of water and leaves the solids behind, so about 80 kg of fat is recovered as ghee, with a little loss in handling. That is why ghee is made where milk is plentiful and refrigeration is scarce: it turns a perishable fat into a shelf-stable one.

🤔 Pause and think: ghee keeps for months at room temperature while butter needs a fridge. What exactly did heating remove that makes the difference?

Quick check

Why does ghee keep for months at room temperature while butter needs a fridge?

Check your answer

Ghee is about 99.5% fat with almost no water, so microbes cannot grow in it, while butter still holds about 16% water.

10.6 Butter oil and other fat-rich products

Butter oil, also called anhydrous milk fat, is butter with the water and solids removed completely, leaving pure milk fat. It is made by melting butter, separating the fat from the water and solids, and drying the fat. It keeps well, travels well, and is used to recombine milk and to make products where a pure fat is needed, such as the recombined evaporated milk met in Unit 5.

Other fat-rich products round out the family: whipped cream, made by beating air into 30 to 35% fat cream; sterilised or canned cream, homogenised and heated so it keeps; and sour cream, cream fermented with a starter culture until it holds about 0.6% lactic acid, giving a thick, tangy product used as a topping and in cooking. Each is the same fat handled differently, and each shows the same rule: the fat must be protected from lipase, oxygen, and light, or it goes off.

Quick check

What is butter oil, and what is it used for?

Check your answer

Pure milk fat with the water and solids removed. It keeps and travels well, and is used to recombine milk and in products that need a pure fat.

10.7 Defects of butter and ghee, and how to stop them

DefectWhat you noticeMain causePrevention
Rancid flavourSharp, soapy, bitterLipase cutting the fatPasteurise the cream, churn promptly, keep cold
Tallowy, cardboard flavourStale, paintyOxygen attacking unsaturated fat, helped by copper and lightKeep air out, use stainless steel, keep in the dark
Oily, greasy bodySoft, leaks oilChurning too warm, over-workingChurn at the right temperature, work just enough
Crumbly bodyBreaks instead of spreadingChurning too cold, too much solid fatHold the cream at churning temperature before churning
Mould on butterSpots on the surfaceDirty water or air, damp storageClean water, clean churn, cold dry storage
Burnt flavour in gheeSmoky, darkOverheating, scorching the solidsHeat gently, draw the fat off before the solids burn

The pattern is the same as in every unit: the defect names the cause. Rancidity names lipase, tallowy names oxygen, and a greasy or crumbly body names the churning temperature.

Quick check

Your butter tastes tallowy, like cardboard. What caused it, and how do you stop it?

Check your answer

Oxygen attacking the unsaturated fat, helped by light and by copper. Keep air out, use stainless steel, and store the butter cold and in the dark.

10.8 Packaging and storage of fat-rich products

Butter is packed in foil or parchment, which keeps air and light out, and stored cold, near 0 to 4 °C, where it keeps for weeks. Ghee is packed in tins or jars, sealed against air, and stored cool and dark, where it keeps for months. Cream is packed cold and used promptly, because it is still a perishable milk product. The packaging lesson from Unit 15 applies here in miniature: the pack must keep out air, light, and moisture, or the fat inside will oxidise and the product will go off before its date.

Quick check

Why is butter packed in foil rather than in clear plastic?

Check your answer

Foil keeps out light and air, which would oxidise the fat and give tallowy flavours.

10.9 Butter grading and judging: what the judge looks for

Butter is judged the way other dairy products are judged: by flavour, body, texture, colour, and appearance, with flavour carrying the most weight. A good butter smells clean and mildly creamy, with no rancid, tallowy, feed, or fishy note. Its body is firm but spreadable, waxy rather than crumbly or greasy, and it cuts cleanly without leaking water. Its colour is an even pale yellow, with no streaks or mottling, and its surface is smooth and free of mould spots.

The judge also checks the salt: it should be evenly mixed, with no gritty crystals and no salty patches, and the water should be finely and evenly distributed, so that no drops bead on the cut surface. The grading of butter in the books follows the same pattern as the grading of ghee: flavour first, then body and texture, then colour and appearance, and a butter that fails on flavour cannot be saved by a good body. That is why the cream is graded before churning, as in section 10.1: the judge's verdict on the butter is mostly decided before the churn starts.

🤔 Pause and think: two butters test the same fat and the same moisture, but one tastes clean and the other tastes tallowy. Which test would have caught the difference before the butter was made, and where would you have run it?

Quick check

A butter tests 81% fat and 15% water, both in range, yet the judge marks it down. What is the judge tasting that the numbers miss?

Check your answer

Flavour: a tallowy, rancid, or feed note is a fault of flavour, and a butter with perfect composition but a bad flavour is still a bad butter.

10.10 Derivation: churning by the numbers

Section 10.3 described churning in words: cream is beaten until the fat gathers into grains and the buttermilk drains away. This section works out the same step in numbers, so the plant can tell a good churn from a poor one before the butter is weighed.

The mass balance of a churn

Start with 100 kg of cream at 40% fat. That is 40 kg of fat and 60 kg of everything else: water, protein, lactose, and minerals.

Step 1, the fat that can become butter. If every gram of fat were kept, the butter would weigh 40 / 0.80 = 50 kg, because butter is 80% fat. That is the ceiling: no churn can make more butter than the fat it is given.

Step 2, the fat that is actually kept. A good churn keeps about 99% of the fat in the butter grains and loses about 1% into the buttermilk. So the butter carries 40 × 0.99 = 39.6 kg of fat, and the butter weighs 39.6 / 0.80 = 49.5 kg.

Step 3, the buttermilk. What is left is 100 − 49.5 = 50.5 kg of buttermilk, carrying the 0.4 kg of fat that was lost, plus the water, protein, lactose, and minerals from the cream. Its fat content is 0.4 / 50.5, about 0.8%: the mark of a good churn.

Worked example: reading a churn. A plant churns 100 kg of cream at 40% fat and gets 49.5 kg of butter. The fat recovery is 49.5 × 0.80 = 39.6 kg out of 40 kg, or 99%: a good churn. The same cream churned badly gives 47.5 kg of butter: 38 kg of fat kept, 95% recovery, and 2 kg of fat lost into 52.5 kg of buttermilk, which then tests about 3.8% fat. The buttermilk fat is the tell-tale: good buttermilk from a good churn carries well under 1% fat, and a buttermilk at 3% fat or more means the churn is losing money into the drain.

Why the fat gathers: phase inversion

Cream is an oil-in-water emulsion: fat globules floating in water. Butter is the reverse, a water-in-oil emulsion: tiny water droplets trapped in a continuous mass of fat. Churning flips the system from one to the other, and the flip has a mechanism. Beating damages the fat globule membranes, and the fat crystals inside the globules, formed during the ripening hold, pierce the membranes of neighbouring globules. The globules stick, join, and grow into grains, and the water that used to surround them is squeezed out as buttermilk. That is why the fat must be part solid and part liquid: solid crystals do the piercing, and liquid fat does the joining. All solid and the grains stay small and hard; all liquid and nothing joins at all.

From cream to butter: the inversion

Cream
Oil in water: fat globules floating in water, 30-40% fat.

↓

Churn
Beating damages the globule membranes. Fat crystals pierce neighbouring globules, and the globules join into grains.

↓

Grains + buttermilk
Butter grains gather, buttermilk drains away. Good buttermilk carries well under 1% fat.

↓

Wash + work
Cold water washes out buttermilk, working presses out water and mixes in salt.

↓

Butter
Water in oil: about 80% fat, 16% water as tiny droplets, salt and milk solids. The inversion is complete.

Figure 10.2: Churning turns an oil-in-water emulsion into a water-in-oil emulsion. Drawn from the churning description in Fat Rich Dairy Products Technology, Lessons on churning of cream.

Ghee by the numbers

Ghee is butter with the water boiled away and the curd settled out. The numbers follow from the butter composition. Start with 100 kg of butter at 80% fat, 16% water, and about 4% salt and milk solids. Heating drives off the 16 kg of water, and the curd and salt settle to the bottom and are left behind. What remains is about 80 kg of pure milk fat, with a small loss on the sides of the vessel and in the residue: a plant expects 78 to 82 kg of ghee from 100 kg of butter, and a yield far below that means water was left in, or fat was lost with the residue.

🤔 Pause and think: a churn gives 49.5 kg of butter from 100 kg of 40% cream, but the buttermilk tests 3% fat. What is wrong with that pair of numbers, and where would you look first?

Quick check

100 kg of cream at 40% fat is churned with 95% fat recovery into butter at 80% fat. How much butter is made, and how much buttermilk is left?

Check your answer

38 kg of fat is kept, so 38 / 0.80 = 47.5 kg of butter, and 100 − 47.5 = 52.5 kg of buttermilk.

10.11 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a churn of cream will not gather into butter grains, however long it is beaten. The cream came straight from the separator, warm, at 30 °C. What went wrong, and what should the maker have done before churning?

  1. Butter is about 80% fat and 16% water. Ghee is about 99.5% fat. What did heating remove, and why does that change keeping quality?
Check your answer

Heating removed the water, and with almost no water left microbes cannot grow, so ghee keeps for months at room temperature.

  1. Why is cream cooled and held before churning, instead of churned warm?
Check your answer

Cooling and holding let part of the fat crystallise, and butter churns well only when the fat is part solid and part liquid.

  1. What is the difference between churned buttermilk and cultured buttermilk?
Check your answer

Churned buttermilk is the liquid left after churning butter. Cultured buttermilk is milk fermented with a starter culture.

  1. Name two defects of butter, their causes, and how to prevent each.
Check your answer

Rancid flavour from lipase: pasteurise the cream and keep it cold. Tallowy flavour from oxygen and light: keep air out, use stainless steel, and store cold and dark.

Try it: Pour 250 ml of cream into a clean jar, screw the lid on tight, and shake it hard for five to ten minutes. First it thickens into whipped cream, then it suddenly separates into butter grains and thin buttermilk. Pour off the buttermilk, knead the grains together under cold water, and taste the butter you have just churned.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Cream ranges from 18 to 85% fat, and it must be fresh and clean, because its flavours carry into butter and ghee.
  • Milk fat is mostly triglycerides, about half solid at fridge temperature and about 20% solid at room temperature, which is why butter firms in the fridge and softens on the bench.
  • Butter is about 80 to 82% fat with about 16% water, made by churning cream whose fat is part solid and part liquid, then washing and working the grains.
  • Churned buttermilk is the liquid left after churning, with little fat; cultured buttermilk is milk fermented with a starter, a different product.
  • Ghee is pure clarified milk fat, about 99.5% fat, made by boiling the water off butter or cream, and it keeps for months at room temperature because it holds almost no water.
  • Butter oil is pure milk fat with water and solids removed, used for recombining milk and for products needing a pure fat.
  • The defects name their causes: rancidity is lipase, tallowy flavour is oxygen and light, and a greasy or crumbly body is the wrong churning temperature.

  • Churning is a mass balance: 100 kg of cream at 40% fat can make at most 50 kg of butter at 80% fat, and a good churn keeping 99% of the fat makes 49.5 kg of butter and 50.5 kg of buttermilk at about 0.8% fat.

  • Churning flips the emulsion from oil-in-water to water-in-oil: fat crystals pierce the globule membranes, the globules join into grains, and the water is squeezed out as buttermilk.
  • Ghee is butter with the water boiled away: 100 kg of butter at 80% fat gives about 78 to 82 kg of ghee, and a yield far below that means water was left in or fat was lost with the residue.

Glossary

Cream

The fat-rich layer of milk, made by separation. Food tech example: heavy cream at 30 to 40% fat is the usual starting material for butter.

Churning

Beating cream so the fat globule membranes break and the fat gathers into grains. Food tech example: churning works only when the fat is part solid and part liquid.

Buttermilk

The liquid left after churning butter, or milk fermented with a starter culture. Food tech example: churned buttermilk carries the water, lactose, and protein of the cream, with only a little fat left.

Ghee

Pure heat-clarified milk fat, about 99.5% fat. Food tech example: ghee keeps for months at room temperature because it holds almost no water.

Butter oil

Pure milk fat with water and solids removed, also called anhydrous milk fat. Food tech example: butter oil is used to recombine milk where fresh milk is short.

Ripening of cream

Holding cream cool so part of its fat crystallises before churning, or souring it with a starter for cultured butter. Food tech example: ripened cream churns into butter with a fuller flavour.

Working of butter

Kneading butter grains to press out water and mix in salt evenly. Food tech example: under-worked butter leaks water, and over-worked butter turns greasy.

Rancidity

The sharp, soapy flavour when lipase cuts fat into free fatty acids. Food tech example: pasteurising the cream destroys lipase and stops rancidity in butter.

Oxidised flavour

The tallowy, cardboard flavour when oxygen attacks unsaturated fat. Food tech example: butter kept in light and air turns tallowy, so it is packed in foil and stored cold and dark.

Plastic cream

Cream of about 80% fat, made by re-separating heavy cream. Food tech example: plastic cream is used for ghee production.

Phase inversion

The flip of an emulsion from oil-in-water to water-in-oil, or the reverse. Food tech example: churning flips cream, fat globules in water, into butter, water droplets trapped in fat.

Fat recovery

The share of the fat fed to a process that ends up in the product. Food tech example: a churn that keeps 39.6 kg of 40 kg of fat has a 99% fat recovery, and its buttermilk tests about 0.8% fat.

References

  • Fat Rich Dairy Products Technology. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR.
  • Market Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lessons 19 and 20.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.
  • Chemistry of Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Module 6.

Unit 11: Dairy By-Products: Whey, Buttermilk and More

Note

Unit 11: Dairy By-Products: Whey, Buttermilk and More

Every kilogram of cheese leaves behind about nine litres of whey, and every churn leaves buttermilk, and every skim leaves skim milk. For a long time those streams were poured away, and the rivers paid for it. Then makers learned that the whey holds the lactose and the whey proteins, the buttermilk holds the membrane fragments, and the skim holds the casein, and that each one is a product in its own right. This unit follows the streams the main products leave behind, and shows what they become.

11.1 What a by-product is, and why it matters

A by-product is a stream that leaves a process as a side result, not as the product the process was built for. In a dairy the big ones are whey from cheese and from casein making, buttermilk from churning, and skim milk from separation. Together they carry a large share of the milk that entered the plant: whey alone is about 85 to 90% of the milk that went into the cheese vat.

By-products matter for two reasons. The first is money: the lactose, protein, and fat in those streams are worth recovering, and a plant that throws them away throws away part of its raw material. The second is the environment: whey is rich in lactose and protein, so it feeds microbes fast, and pouring it into a river strips the oxygen out of the water and kills the life in it. Unit 15 comes back to that effluent load. Turning a by-product into a product is therefore both a profit and a duty, and the technology of this unit is how it is done.

🤔 Pause and think: a cheese plant pours its whey into a river, and the fish downstream die. What exactly in the whey is doing the damage, and what would have to be taken out of it to stop it?

Quick check

Why is whey a problem if it is poured away, and an opportunity if it is kept?

Check your answer

It is rich in lactose and protein, so it feeds microbes fast and strips oxygen from river water, but those same lactose and proteins are worth recovering as products.

11.2 Whey: what is in it

Whey is the liquid left after casein is clotted out of milk. It is about 93% water, with about 4.5 to 5% lactose, about 0.8% whey protein, about 0.5% minerals, and a little fat. There are two kinds, and they behave differently:

  • Sweet whey comes from rennet cheese making, where the milk is clotted by rennet at normal pH. It is near pH 6, sweet, and low in acid.
  • Acid whey comes from acid cheese and casein making, where the milk is clotted by acid at pH 4.6. It is more acid, higher in minerals, especially calcium, and harder to dry, because its lactose and minerals make it sticky.

The whey proteins in whey are the proteins met in Unit 2: beta-lactoglobulin, alpha-lactalbumin, immunoglobulins, and lactoferrin. They are valuable because they dissolve easily, they carry all the essential amino acids, and they can foam, gel, and bind water in foods. That is why whey protein is sold as a food ingredient, not just as animal feed.

Quick check

What are the two kinds of whey, and how do they differ?

Check your answer

Sweet whey comes from rennet cheese at near pH 6, while acid whey comes from acid clotting at pH 4.6, is more acid, and is higher in minerals and harder to dry.

11.3 The whey flow chart: from cheese vat to products

The whey stream is handled in a sequence, and each step takes out one more part of value. The flow chart below is the map for the whole unit: read it first, then read the sections, and keep coming back to it, because every section below is one box in this chart.

The whey flow chart: from cheese vat to products

Cheese vat
Curd + whey. Drain the curd.

↓

Whey
93% water, lactose, whey protein, minerals. Separate out the fat.

↓

Whey cream
Fat recovered, back to butter making.

↓

Pasteurise, then choose a road

Road A: evaporate + spray dry
Whey powder: lactose + protein + minerals, dried. Animal feed, bakery, drinks.
Road B: membranes, ultrafilter
Whey protein concentrate (WPC) + lactose stream. WPC: foods, drinks, sports foods. Lactose: tablets, baby foods, baking.

Figure 11.1: The whey flow chart: from the cheese vat to whey powder, whey protein concentrate, and lactose. Drawn from Dairy By-Products Technology, Lessons 20-23 and 31-34.

The chart makes the logic visible. The fat is taken out first, because it is the easiest value to recover and it would foul the later steps. Then the maker chooses a road: dry the whole whey into whey powder, or split it with membranes into a protein-rich stream and a lactose-rich stream. The membrane road gives the higher-value products, and the drying road gives the simpler one, and a plant chooses by what it can sell.

Quick check

In the whey flow chart, why is the fat taken out before anything else?

Check your answer

It is the easiest value to recover, and it would foul the later steps, so whey cream is separated first and sent back to butter making.

11.4 Whey powder: drying the whole stream

Whey powder is made by evaporating whey under vacuum and spray drying it, the same drying technology met in Unit 5. The whey is first pasteurised and clarified, then evaporated to about 40 to 50% solids, then spray dried to a powder of about 3 to 4% moisture. The powder carries the lactose, the whey proteins, and the minerals of the whey, and it is used in bakery, in animal feed, in drinks, and as a food ingredient where a mild, milky flavour is wanted.

Acid whey is harder to dry than sweet whey, because its higher mineral content, especially calcium, makes the powder sticky and hygroscopic, taking up water from the air and caking. The plant handles that by blending acid whey with sweet whey, by demineralising it first, or by drying it to a lower moisture and packing it at once in moisture-proof bags.

Quick check

Why is acid whey harder to dry than sweet whey?

Check your answer

Its higher mineral content, especially calcium, makes the powder sticky and hygroscopic, so it takes up water and cakes.

11.5 Whey protein concentrates: splitting whey with membranes

Membrane separation splits whey without heat, by pushing it against a membrane that lets small molecules through and holds large ones back. Ultrafiltration holds back the whey proteins and lets water, lactose, and some minerals through. The protein-rich stream, the retentate, is then dried into whey protein concentrate, or WPC, which is graded by its protein content: WPC 35 holds about 35% protein, WPC 80 holds about 80%, and whey protein isolate holds about 90% or more.

WPC is a prized food ingredient because whey proteins foam, gel, bind water, and carry a complete set of essential amino acids. It goes into sports drinks and foods, into bakery and confectionery, into infant foods, and into drinks where a clear, soluble protein is wanted. The lactose-rich stream that passes through the membrane, the permeate, is evaporated and crystallised into lactose, covered in section 11.6, so nothing in the whey is wasted.

Worked example: what ultrafiltration keeps. Start with 100 kg of whey holding about 0.8 kg of whey protein and 5 kg of lactose. Ultrafiltration holds back most of the 0.8 kg of protein in a small volume of retentate, while most of the 5 kg of lactose passes through into the permeate. Dry the retentate and you have a protein-rich powder; crystallise the permeate and you have lactose. One stream has become two products.

🤔 Pause and think: a plant can dry whole whey into one powder, or split it with membranes into two products. When would the simple road pay better, and when would the split road pay better?

Quick check

What does ultrafiltration hold back from whey, and what passes through?

Check your answer

It holds back the whey proteins in the retentate and lets water, lactose, and some minerals through into the permeate.

11.6 Lactose: from whey sugar to tablets

Lactose is recovered from whey, usually from the permeate left after ultrafiltration, or from whole whey. The liquid is evaporated to a concentrated syrup, then cooled so the lactose crystallises out. The crystals are separated in a centrifuge, washed, and dried into a white powder. Crude lactose is refined by dissolving it again, treating it to remove colour and impurities, and crystallising it a second time.

Lactose is used where a mild, not very sweet sugar is wanted: in infant foods, in bakery, in confectionery, and as a carrier in tablets, where its free-flowing crystals carry a small dose of medicine evenly. It is also the starting material for lactitol and other lactose products. The key control in making it is crystal size: large crystals are wanted for easy separation, and fine, gritty crystals are the defect to avoid, just as in sweetened condensed milk.

Quick check

How is lactose recovered from whey?

Check your answer

The whey or permeate is evaporated to a syrup, cooled so the lactose crystallises, and the crystals are separated, washed, and dried.

11.7 Casein and caseinates: the protein taken out of skim milk

Skim milk is the starting material for casein, the main milk protein. Acid casein is made by adding acid to skim milk until the pH reaches 4.6, the isoelectric point, so the casein clots out and the whey drains away. Rennet casein is made by adding rennet instead, so the casein clots at normal pH. The curd is washed, pressed, and dried into a powder that is used in foods, in glues, in paints, and in plastics, and as the starting material for caseinates.

Caseinates are made by dissolving casein in an alkali: sodium caseinate from sodium hydroxide, calcium caseinate from calcium hydroxide. They dissolve in water, unlike casein itself, so they are used in foods where a soluble protein is needed: in coffee whiteners, in processed cheese, in bakery, and in meat products, where they bind water and fat and hold the product together. Co-precipitates, made by clotting skim milk with heat and acid together, so that casein and whey protein come down together, are a related product with similar uses.

Quick check

What is the difference between casein and sodium caseinate?

Check your answer

Casein is the protein clotted out of skim milk and does not dissolve in water, while sodium caseinate is casein dissolved in alkali, so it dissolves in water and can be used in foods.

11.8 Buttermilk and skim milk: the other streams

Buttermilk, the liquid left after churning, is about 91% water with lactose, protein, and minerals, and only a little fat. It is dried into buttermilk powder for bakery, where its phospholipids help with browning and flavour, and it is used fresh in drinks and in cooking. Skim milk itself is a by-product of separation, and it is the starting material for skim milk powder, for casein, and for fermented products, as covered in Units 5, 7, and 12.

Whey drinks are a use for whey that needs no drying at all: whey is flavoured with fruit, sweetened, and pasteurised into a refreshing drink, and fermented whey drinks use starter cultures to turn part of the lactose into lactic acid, giving a tangy, yoghurt-like drink. Those products matter because they use whey fresh, with no energy spent on drying, and they reach the customer as a drink rather than as a powder.

Quick check

Name two uses for dried buttermilk.

Check your answer

Bakery, where its phospholipids help with browning and flavour, and drinks and cooking, where it is used fresh or as a powder.

11.9 Practical note: tasting whey and making a whey drink at home

Whey is safe to taste when it is fresh and from pasteurised milk, and tasting it teaches what the numbers mean. Take the whey left after making curd at home, as in the Unit 9 activity, and taste a spoonful: it is thin, slightly sweet, and a little salty, which is the lactose and the minerals you are tasting, with almost no fat. Now make a simple whey drink: mix 200 ml of fresh whey with 50 ml of fruit juice, add a pinch of sugar if you like, chill it, and taste it next to the plain whey. The fruit covers the thinness, and the drink is refreshing, which is exactly how a commercial whey drink works.

A second practical test is the drying test. Pour a spoonful of whey into a shallow dish and leave it in a warm oven until the water is gone: the thin film left behind is the solids of the whey, about 6 to 7% of the weight you started with. That film is the lactose, protein, and minerals that a spray dryer turns into whey powder, and seeing it makes the flow chart in Figure 11.1 concrete: the water leaves, the solids stay.

Quick check

You dry 100 g of whey and are left with about 6 to 7 g of solids. What are those solids?

Check your answer

Mainly lactose, about 5 g, plus whey protein, about 0.8 g, and minerals, about 0.5 g.

11.10 Derivation: membrane separation, how much protein is kept

Section 11.5 described ultrafiltration in words: whey is pushed against a membrane, water and small molecules pass through, and protein stays behind. This section works out the same step in numbers, so the plant can tell whether its membranes are earning their keep.

Concentration factor, step by step

The concentration factor is the simplest number in membrane work: feed volume divided by retentate volume. Feed 1,000 litres of whey and keep 200 litres of retentate, and the concentration factor is 1,000 / 200 = 5. Everything the membrane holds back is, in the ideal case, five times as concentrated as it was in the feed.

Step 1, the protein in the feed. Sweet whey carries about 0.8% protein, so 1,000 litres, about 1,000 kg, carries about 8 kg of protein.

Step 2, the protein kept. A membrane in good condition keeps about 95% of the whey protein, so the retentate holds about 7.6 kg of protein in its 200 litres: about 3.8% protein, against 0.8% in the feed. The missing 0.4 kg has passed through with the permeate, through small leaks and damaged membrane areas.

Step 3, what leaves with the permeate. Lactose, minerals, and water pass through the membrane almost freely, so the 800 litres of permeate carries nearly all the lactose of the feed: about 45 kg of lactose from whey at 4.5%, in a dilute stream that the plant then evaporates or sends to lactose recovery. The split is the point of the membrane road in Figure 11.1: protein one way, lactose the other, each to its own product.

Worked example: is the membrane working? A plant feeds 1,000 litres of whey at 0.8% protein and takes 200 litres of retentate. At full recovery the retentate would test 4.0% protein. It tests 3.2%. The protein kept is 200 × 0.032 = 6.4 kg out of 8 kg, an 80% recovery: the membrane is passing protein it should hold, and the likely causes are a damaged membrane, a wrong pressure that forces protein through, or a cleaning step that has opened the pores. The plant checks the membrane first, because no later step can recover protein that has already left with the permeate.

Diafiltration: washing the protein clean

A retentate at 3.8% protein still carries lactose and minerals trapped with the protein. Diafiltration washes it: clean water is added to the retentate and the mixture is filtered again, and each wash carries more lactose and minerals through the membrane while the protein stays behind. After two or three washes the protein share of the dry matter climbs from about 35% to 80% or more, and the product becomes a whey protein concentrate that sells as a protein ingredient, not as a whey powder. The cost is water and time, and the plant's judgement is how many washes the price of the concentrate will pay for.

The membrane in outline

Ultrafiltration of whey

Whey in
1,000 litres, 0.8% protein, 4.5% lactose. Pumped against the membrane under pressure.

↓

Membrane
Tiny pores: water, lactose, and minerals pass through, protein is held back. The flow sweeps across the membrane so it does not block.

↓

Retentate
200 litres, about 3.8% protein: the whey protein concentrate stream, to spray drying.
Permeate
800 litres, lactose and minerals in water: to lactose recovery or evaporation.

Figure 11.2: Ultrafiltration splits whey into a protein-rich retentate and a lactose-rich permeate. Drawn from the membrane separation description in Dairy By-Products Technology, Lessons 31-34.

When membranes lose their edge

A membrane that is fouled with protein and minerals lets less water through, so the plant raises the pressure to keep the flow, and the higher pressure forces protein through the pores and into the permeate. The signs arrive together: the flow falls, the pressure rises, and the retentate protein stops climbing. The fix is cleaning, not pressure: a proper cleaning cycle restores the flow, and a membrane cleaned on schedule lasts far longer than one run hard and cleaned rarely. A plant that watches three numbers, flow, pressure, and retentate protein, knows the state of its membranes without opening them.

🤔 Pause and think: a whey protein concentrate tests 50% protein on a dry basis when the buyer asked for 80%. Which step was cut short, and what would you add to reach the higher protein?

Quick check

1,000 litres of whey at 0.8% protein is ultrafiltered to 200 litres of retentate at 3.2% protein. What is the concentration factor, and what share of the protein was kept?

Check your answer

The concentration factor is 5. The retentate holds 6.4 kg of the 8 kg fed, so 80% of the protein was kept.

11.11 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a cheese plant dries all its whey into whey powder, but a buyer offers more money for whey protein concentrate. What would the plant have to add to its line to make WPC, and what would happen to the lactose stream?

  1. Whey is about 93% water. What are its main solids, and in what shares?
Check your answer

About 4.5 to 5% lactose, about 0.8% whey protein, about 0.5% minerals, and a little fat.

  1. Sweet whey and acid whey come from different clotting methods. Which is which, and why is acid whey harder to dry?
Check your answer

Sweet whey comes from rennet clotting near pH 6, and acid whey from acid clotting at pH 4.6. Acid whey is higher in minerals, especially calcium, so its powder is sticky and cakes.

  1. In the whey flow chart, what are the two roads after pasteurisation, and what does each give?
Check your answer

Road A evaporates and spray dries the whole whey into whey powder. Road B ultrafilters it into whey protein concentrate and a lactose stream, which is crystallised into lactose.

  1. How is sodium caseinate made, and why is it more useful in foods than casein itself?
Check your answer

Casein is dissolved in alkali, such as sodium hydroxide. The caseinate dissolves in water, unlike casein, so it can be used in coffee whiteners, processed cheese, and bakery.

Try it: Make the whey drink from section 11.9, and keep a spoonful of the plain whey beside it. Taste both cold and write one sentence for each: the plain whey should taste thin, sweet, and a little salty, and the drink should taste like fruit first, with the whey underneath.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • By-products are the streams a process leaves behind: whey from cheese, buttermilk from churning, and skim milk from separation. They carry a large share of the milk that entered the plant.
  • Whey is about 93% water, with about 4.5 to 5% lactose, 0.8% whey protein, and 0.5% minerals. Sweet whey comes from rennet cheese near pH 6, and acid whey from acid clotting at pH 4.6.
  • The whey flow chart runs: drain the whey, take out the fat as whey cream, pasteurise, then either dry the whole whey into whey powder or split it with membranes.
  • Ultrafiltration holds back whey proteins into whey protein concentrate, graded by protein content, and lets lactose through into the permeate, which is crystallised into lactose.
  • Lactose is recovered by evaporation, crystallisation, and drying, and it is used in infant foods, bakery, confectionery, and as a tablet carrier.
  • Casein is clotted out of skim milk by acid at pH 4.6 or by rennet, and caseinates are made by dissolving casein in alkali so it dissolves in water and can be used in foods.
  • Buttermilk and whey drinks use the streams fresh, with no drying, and turning by-products into products is both a profit and a way of keeping the rivers clean.

  • The concentration factor in ultrafiltration is feed volume divided by retentate volume: 1,000 litres of whey to 200 litres of retentate is a factor of 5, so held-back protein is about five times as concentrated.

  • A membrane in good condition keeps about 95% of the whey protein; a retentate testing well below its expected protein means a damaged membrane, wrong pressure, or cleaning that opened the pores.
  • Diafiltration washes the retentate with clean water and filters again, pushing lactose and minerals through while the protein stays, lifting the protein share of the dry matter toward 80%.

Glossary

By-product

A stream that leaves a process as a side result, not the product the process was built for. Food tech example: whey is the by-product of cheese making, and it becomes whey powder and whey protein concentrate.

Sweet whey

Whey from rennet cheese making, near pH 6. Food tech example: sweet whey dries easily into whey powder.

Acid whey

Whey from acid clotting at pH 4.6, higher in minerals. Food tech example: acid whey powder is sticky and cakes, because its calcium content is high.

Whey powder

Dried whey, made by evaporation and spray drying. Food tech example: whey powder is used in bakery, drinks, and animal feed.

Ultrafiltration

Pushing a liquid against a membrane that holds back large molecules and lets small ones through. Food tech example: ultrafiltration holds back whey proteins and lets lactose through, splitting whey into two products.

Whey protein concentrate (WPC)

Dried protein-rich stream from ultrafiltered whey, graded by protein content. Food tech example: WPC 80 holds about 80% protein and goes into sports foods and drinks.

Permeate

The stream that passes through a membrane. Food tech example: the lactose-rich permeate from whey ultrafiltration is evaporated and crystallised into lactose.

Retentate

The stream held back by a membrane. Food tech example: the protein-rich retentate from whey ultrafiltration is dried into whey protein concentrate.

Casein

The main protein of milk, clotted out of skim milk by acid or rennet. Food tech example: acid casein is made by adding acid to skim milk until the pH reaches 4.6.

Caseinate

Casein dissolved in alkali, so it dissolves in water. Food tech example: sodium caseinate is used in coffee whiteners and processed cheese.

Co-precipitate

Casein and whey protein clotted out together by heat and acid. Food tech example: co-precipitates are used where a soluble milk protein is needed in foods.

Whey cream

Fat separated from whey. Food tech example: whey cream is taken out first in the whey flow chart and sent back to butter making.

Concentration factor

Feed volume divided by retentate volume in a membrane process. Food tech example: 1,000 litres of whey concentrated to 200 litres of retentate is a concentration factor of 5.

Diafiltration

Adding clean water to a retentate and filtering again, to wash small molecules such as lactose and minerals through the membrane while the protein stays behind. Food tech example: diafiltration lifts a whey protein concentrate from about 35% protein on a dry basis toward 80%.

References

  • Dairy By-Products Technology. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lessons 1-35.
  • Cheese Technology. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lessons 5 and 23.
  • Patel, H. G. Condensed and Dried Milk. Agrimoon e-course, Anand Agricultural University.
  • NDDB. Laboratory Handbook for Dairy Industry. March 2001. Chapters 5 and 16.

Unit 12: Fermented Milk Products: Yoghurt, Dahi and Cultured Milks

Note

Unit 12: Fermented Milk Products: Yoghurt, Dahi and Cultured Milks

Milk sours by accident, and the result is a gamble. Yoghurt, dahi, and cultured buttermilk sour on purpose, with known bacteria, at a known temperature, for a known time, and the result is the same every day. What turns an accident into a product is not the souring itself, but the control of it. This unit is about that control, and about the family of foods it makes.

12.1 What fermented milks are

A fermented milk is milk that has been soured on purpose by lactic acid bacteria, which eat lactose and turn it into lactic acid. As the acid builds up, the pH falls, and at pH 4.6 the casein micelles lose their charge and join into a curd, as described in Unit 2. That curd is the body of yoghurt and dahi, and the acid is what keeps the product safe, gives it its tang, and makes it keep longer than fresh milk.

Fermented milks are among the oldest dairy foods, because fermentation was one of the first ways people found to keep milk without a fridge. The modern difference is control: the maker chooses the culture, sets the temperature, and stops the fermentation at the right acidity, instead of leaving the milk to whatever microbes happen to be in it. Unit 7 covered the starter cultures themselves; this unit covers the products they make.

🤔 Pause and think: fresh milk and yoghurt start from the same milk. What has changed in the yoghurt that makes it keep longer, taste tangy, and set into a gel?

Quick check

What do lactic acid bacteria do to milk, and what happens at pH 4.6?

Check your answer

They eat lactose and turn it into lactic acid. At pH 4.6 the casein micelles lose their charge and join into a curd.

12.2 Yoghurt: the two bacteria that work as a pair

Yoghurt is made with two bacteria working together: Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus. The pair is a partnership, and each one helps the other. Streptococcus thermophilus grows fast at first, makes acid and flavour compounds, and uses up oxygen, which helps the lactobacillus grow. The lactobacillus then makes more acid and releases amino acids that feed the streptococcus. Together they acidify the milk faster and make more flavour than either one alone.

Yoghurt milk is usually standardised, often with extra skim milk powder or extra protein, so the finished yoghurt is firm and does not weep whey. It is heated hard, to about 85 °C or above for 20 to 30 minutes, which kills unwanted microbes, unfolds the whey proteins so they join the casein network and firm the gel, and drives off some water. It is then cooled to about 42 to 45 °C, the starter is added at about 1 to 3% of the milk, and the milk is held at that temperature until it sets, usually in 3 to 5 hours, at a pH near 4.5 to 4.6. Then it is cooled fast to stop the acid developing further.

Making set yoghurt, from heated milk to cooled yoghurt

Milk
Standardised, extra protein if wanted.

↓

Heat
To 85 °C or above, 20-30 min.

↓

Cool to 42-45 °C
Add starter, 1-3%: S. thermophilus + L. bulgaricus.

↓

Hold warm
3-5 hours.

↓

Set
At pH near 4.5-4.6: the gel forms.

↓

Cool fast
To 4 °C.

↓

Yoghurt
Firm, tangy, ready to eat.

Figure 12.1: Making set yoghurt, from heated milk to cooled yoghurt. Drawn from Starter Cultures and Fermented Milk Products and Tamime and Robinson, Yoghurt: Science and Technology.

Quick check

Why are two bacteria used to make yoghurt, instead of one?

Check your answer

They help each other: the streptococcus grows fast, makes acid and flavour, and uses up oxygen, while the lactobacillus makes more acid and releases amino acids that feed the streptococcus.

12.3 Set, stirred, and drinking yoghurt

Yoghurt is sold in three main forms, and the difference is when the gel is broken:

  • Set yoghurt is fermented in the pot it is sold in, so the gel is never broken. It is firm, smooth, and holds its shape when spooned.
  • Stirred yoghurt is fermented in a tank, then stirred to break the gel into a smooth, pourable mass before it is filled into pots. It is softer and creamier than set yoghurt.
  • Drinking yoghurt is stirred yoghurt thinned further, often with fruit juice or flavour, so it can be drunk from a bottle.

The same milk and the same culture can give any of the three: the difference is handling, not recipe. What matters for all three is a firm gel that does not weep whey, a clean acid flavour with no bitterness, and a texture that is smooth, not grainy. Graininess comes from heating the milk too hard or from incubating too hot; wheying off, the pool of whey on top, comes from a weak gel, often because the milk was low in protein or the yoghurt was shaken after setting.

Quick check

What is the difference between set yoghurt and stirred yoghurt?

Check your answer

Set yoghurt is fermented in its pot and its gel is never broken, while stirred yoghurt is fermented in a tank and stirred to break the gel before filling.

12.4 Dahi: the fermented milk of the household and the plant

Dahi is the traditional fermented milk made by adding a spoonful of yesterday's dahi to warm milk and leaving it to set overnight. Its culture is a mixed, natural culture, carried from batch to batch, and it usually holds mesophilic lactic acid bacteria that like room temperature, about 25 to 30 °C, rather than the thermophilic pair used for yoghurt. That is why dahi sets on a kitchen shelf while yoghurt needs a warm incubator.

In the plant, dahi is made with a known starter culture instead of a carried-over spoonful, so that it sets the same way every day. The milk is pasteurised, cooled to about 30 to 37 °C, inoculated, and held until it sets at a pH near 4.5 to 4.6, then cooled. The quality marks are the same as for yoghurt: a firm, smooth curd, a clean acid flavour, no wheying off, and no bitterness. Dahi is also the starting material for other products: churned dahi gives butter and buttermilk, strained dahi gives shrikhand, and dahi is the base of lassi, the sweet or salted drink made by thinning dahi with water.

🤔 Pause and think: dahi made with yesterday's spoonful sometimes turns out bitter or slimy, while plant dahi does not. What is in the spoonful that the plant controls and the household does not?

Quick check

Why does dahi set on a kitchen shelf while yoghurt needs a warm incubator?

Check your answer

Dahi uses mesophilic bacteria that like about 25 to 30 °C, while yoghurt uses thermophilic bacteria that need about 42 to 45 °C.

12.5 Cultured buttermilk, kefir, and koumiss

The fermented family is wider than yoghurt and dahi:

  • Cultured buttermilk is milk fermented with a mesophilic culture, including Lactococcus lactis and the flavour maker Leuconostoc, which makes diacetyl, the buttery flavour compound. It is tangy, thick, and buttery, and it is drunk as it is or used in baking.
  • Kefir is made with kefir grains, a clump of bacteria and yeasts living together. The yeasts make a little alcohol and carbon dioxide, so kefir is lightly fizzy as well as tangy, and its culture is far more mixed than a yoghurt culture.
  • Koumiss is the traditional fermented mare's milk, made with bacteria and yeasts in the same way as kefir, and it is more alcoholic than kefir, because mare's milk is richer in lactose.

Each of these shows the same principle with a different culture: the bacteria set the acid, the yeasts, where they are present, add fizz and alcohol, and the flavour compounds, above all diacetyl and acetaldehyde, decide whether the product tastes buttery, fresh, or sharp.

Quick check

What makes kefir fizzy when yoghurt is not?

Check your answer

Kefir is made with kefir grains that hold yeasts as well as bacteria, and the yeasts make carbon dioxide and a little alcohol.

12.6 Flavour and texture: what the bacteria build

The flavour of a fermented milk comes from a small set of compounds the bacteria make alongside lactic acid:

  • Diacetyl gives a buttery note, made by Leuconostoc and by Lactococcus lactis biovar diacetylactis.
  • Acetaldehyde gives the fresh, green, yoghurt note, made mainly by Lactobacillus bulgaricus.
  • Lactic acid itself gives the clean tang, and its level decides whether the product tastes pleasantly sharp or harshly sour.

Texture comes from the gel. The casein network formed at pH 4.6 holds water and fat, and the whey proteins unfolded by the heating step join that network and firm it. Too little protein and the gel is weak and weeps whey; too much heat and the gel turns grainy; too long an incubation and the acid goes too far, the gel contracts, and whey is squeezed out. The maker's controls are therefore the protein level, the heat treatment, the incubation temperature, and the time the fermentation is allowed to run.

Quick check

Which compound gives yoghurt its fresh, green note, and which gives a buttery note?

Check your answer

Acetaldehyde gives the fresh, green yoghurt note, and diacetyl gives the buttery note.

12.7 Keeping quality and health: why fermented milks keep

Fermented milks keep longer than fresh milk for two reasons. The acid, at a pH near 4.5, stops most spoilage bacteria and pathogens from growing, and the starter bacteria themselves crowd out newcomers by using up the lactose and making antibacterial compounds. Even so, fermented milks are kept cold: at room temperature the starter keeps making acid, the product turns harshly sour, and yeasts and moulds grow on the surface.

Fermented milks are also easier to digest for many people. Much of the lactose has been turned into lactic acid, so people who digest lactose poorly often tolerate yoghurt and dahi better than fresh milk. The bacteria also make B vitamins during fermentation, and the acid helps the body absorb calcium. Those are real benefits, but they are modest ones: a fermented milk is a good food, not a medicine, and the books do not claim more than that.

Quick check

Why do fermented milks keep longer than fresh milk?

Check your answer

The acid at pH near 4.5 stops most spoilage bacteria and pathogens, and the starter bacteria crowd out newcomers by using up the lactose.

12.8 Defects of fermented milks

DefectWhat you noticeMain causePrevention
Wheying offPool of whey on topWeak gel, low protein, shaking after settingRaise protein, heat the milk well, handle gently
BitternessBitter tasteToo much proteolysis, wrong culture, long storageUse the right culture, cool fast, keep storage short
Grainy textureRough, sandy feelHeating too hard, incubating too hotHeat to 85 °C, not beyond, incubate at 42-45 °C
Too sourHarsh acid tasteIncubated too long, stored warmStop at pH 4.5-4.6, cool fast, keep cold
Gassy, yeastyBubbles, yeasty smellYeast contaminationClean equipment, fresh culture, keep cold
SlimyRopy, stringy textureRopy strains, contaminationUse a non-ropy culture, keep the culture pure

Quick check

Your yoghurt has a pool of whey on top. What went wrong?

Check your answer

The gel was weak, often from low protein or from shaking the yoghurt after it set: raise the protein, heat the milk well, and handle it gently.

12.9 Probiotics and health claims: what the evidence supports

Some fermented milks are sold as probiotic foods, meaning they carry live bacteria that are claimed to benefit the gut. The bacteria named most often are strains of Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium, added alongside or instead of the usual yoghurt cultures, and they must survive the acid of the product, survive storage cold, and arrive alive in the gut in large numbers to do anything at all. That survival is the technical challenge: a probiotic that dies in the pot is a claim on a label and nothing in the food.

The evidence for probiotic benefits is real but narrow. The best supported effects are a shorter course of some kinds of diarrhoea and a better tolerance of lactose, because the bacteria help digest it. Broader claims, for immunity, for weight, or for mood, are not supported by the same weight of evidence, and the books do not make them. The rule for the maker is the same as for any food claim: the strain must be named, the dose must be stated, the bacteria must be alive at the end of shelf life, and the claim must match what has actually been shown. A yoghurt with live cultures is a good food on its own; a probiotic claim needs proof on top of that.

🤔 Pause and think: a yoghurt label says it contains live probiotic bacteria, but the pot is six weeks old and has been stored warm. What has probably happened to the bacteria, and what would you test to find out?

Quick check

What must a probiotic bacterium do to count as probiotic in the food, not just on the label?

Check your answer

It must survive the acid of the product, survive cold storage, and arrive alive in the gut in large numbers: a probiotic that dies in the pot is only a claim on a label.

12.10 Why yoghurt sets when it does: acidification in numbers

Section 12.2 told the story of the two bacteria working as a pair. This section puts numbers on that story: how fast the acid builds, what the pH milestones mean, and what to do when the set goes wrong.

The acid curve, milestone by milestone

Fresh milk sits near pH 6.6, and it is buffered: the proteins and salts soak up the first acid the bacteria make, so the pH barely moves at first. As the starter grows, the acid comes faster than the buffers can take it, and the pH falls. Near pH 5.3 the milk starts to thicken. Near pH 4.6, the isoelectric point of casein, the micelles lose their charge and join into a gel: the yoghurt sets. The maker stops the fermentation near pH 4.5 by cooling fast, before the acid goes further and the gel turns sharp and weepy.

Acidification milestones: what happens as the pH falls

pH 6.6
Fresh milk. Starter added, acid begins, buffers hold the pH nearly steady.
pH 5.3
Milk starts to thicken. The micelles are losing their charge.
pH 4.6
Casein reaches its isoelectric point. The gel sets.
pH 4.5
Target for set yoghurt. Cool fast to stop the acid here.
Below pH 4.0
Over-acidified. Sharp, sour, and likely to weep whey.

Figure 12.2: The pH milestones of yoghurt making, from fresh milk to the cooling point. Drawn from the acidification described in Tamime and Robinson, Yoghurt: Science and Technology.

The titratable acidity tells the same story in different units: fresh milk tests about 0.14 to 0.16% lactic acid, and finished yoghurt about 0.8 to 0.9%. The two numbers measure different things: pH measures how acid the milk is now, and titratable acidity measures how much acid has been made in total, including the acid the buffers soaked up. A maker watches both: the pH decides when to cool, and the acidity decides whether the flavour will be mild or sharp.

Time and temperature set the pace. At 42 to 45 °C the pair works fast and the milk sets in 3 to 5 hours. At 37 °C the same milk takes far longer, and the balance of the pair shifts: the streptococcus likes the warmth more than the lactobacillus does, so a cool incubation gives a milder yoghurt with less flavour, and a hot one gives a sharper yoghurt faster. A plant that incubates at the wrong temperature does not just wait longer: it makes a different yoghurt.

Worked example: the starter dose and the clock. A maker adds starter at 2% of the milk. At 43 °C the bacteria double roughly every 30 minutes, so in 3 hours they have doubled about 6 times: 2% becomes, in cell numbers, about 64 times the starting population. That is why the acid comes slowly at first and then all at once: the acid follows the growth, and the growth is exponential. A maker who doubles the starter dose does not halve the setting time: the clock is set by the doubling, and doubling the dose only saves about one doubling time, roughly half an hour.

When the yoghurt weeps: syneresis and its causes

Whey on the surface of a set yoghurt, called syneresis, has four usual causes, and each has its own fix. Milk with low solids makes a weak gel that cannot hold its water: raise the solids with skim milk powder or extra protein. Milk heated too gently makes a weak gel, because the whey proteins never unfolded and joined the casein network: heat to 85 °C or above for 20 to 30 minutes, as in Section 12.2. Over-acidification shrinks the gel and squeezes whey out: cool the moment the pH reaches its target, and do not let the yoghurt sit warm. And shaking or moving the yoghurt before it is cold breaks the gel: a set yoghurt is moved only after it is cold and firm.

Dahi and yoghurt, side by side

Dahi, the fermented milk of the household, and yoghurt, its industrial cousin, are the same idea with different habits:

Dahi and yoghurt: the same idea, different habits

Dahi
Mixed household culture, carried from batch to batch. Fermented at room temperature. Soft, mildly sour, and a little variable from day to day.
Yoghurt
Defined pair: S. thermophilus + L. bulgaricus. Fermented warm, at 42-45 °C. Firm, even, and the same every batch.
What they share
Lactic acid sets the milk near pH 4.6, the acid keeps spoilage bacteria out, and the live culture is the flavour.

Figure 12.3: Dahi and yoghurt compared. Drawn from Starter Cultures and Fermented Milk Products and Tamime and Robinson, Yoghurt: Science and Technology.

🤔 Pause and think: a batch of set yoghurt is perfect at pH 4.5, then sits warm for two more hours before cooling. What will it taste like, what will it look like, and which number told you both things in advance?

Quick check

Why does doubling the starter dose not halve the setting time?

Check your answer

The acid follows the growth of the bacteria, and the growth is exponential: doubling the dose only saves about one doubling time, roughly half an hour at 43 °C.

12.11 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a batch of yoghurt sets in two hours instead of four, and tastes harshly sour. The incubator was set to 50 °C instead of 43 °C. Why did it set faster, and why does it taste worse?

  1. Which two bacteria make yoghurt, and how do they help each other?
Check your answer

Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus. The streptococcus grows fast, makes acid and flavour, and uses up oxygen, while the lactobacillus makes more acid and releases amino acids that feed the streptococcus.

  1. Why is yoghurt milk heated to about 85 °C for 20 to 30 minutes before the starter is added?
Check your answer

To kill unwanted microbes, to unfold the whey proteins so they join the casein network and firm the gel, and to drive off some water.

  1. What is the difference between set yoghurt and drinking yoghurt?
Check your answer

Set yoghurt is fermented in its pot and its gel is never broken, while drinking yoghurt is stirred yoghurt thinned further, often with fruit juice, so it can be drunk.

  1. Why is dahi easier for many people to digest than fresh milk, and why does it still need a fridge?
Check your answer

Much of its lactose has been turned into lactic acid, so people who digest lactose poorly tolerate it better. It still needs a fridge because at room temperature the starter keeps making acid and yeasts and moulds grow.

Try it: Warm a litre of milk to about 43 °C, stir in two spoonfuls of plain live yoghurt, pour it into a clean jar, wrap the jar in a towel, and leave it in a warm place for four hours. It should set into a soft gel. Taste it, then make a second jar with half the starter and time how much longer it takes: that delay is the acid-production curve you can taste, the same test described in Unit 7.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Fermented milks are milk soured on purpose by lactic acid bacteria, which turn lactose into lactic acid, and at pH 4.6 the casein sets into a curd.
  • Yoghurt uses Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus as a partnership, each helping the other grow and make flavour.
  • Yoghurt milk is heated to about 85 °C for 20 to 30 minutes, cooled to 42 to 45 °C, inoculated at 1 to 3%, and held for 3 to 5 hours until it sets near pH 4.5 to 4.6, then cooled fast.
  • Set yoghurt ferments in its pot, stirred yoghurt is broken and filled, and drinking yoghurt is thinned further.
  • Dahi uses mesophilic bacteria at about 25 to 30 °C, sets on a shelf, and is the base of lassi and shrikhand.
  • Cultured buttermilk, kefir, and koumiss extend the family: kefir and koumiss add yeasts, which make carbon dioxide and a little alcohol.
  • Diacetyl gives a buttery note and acetaldehyde gives the fresh yoghurt note; texture comes from the casein gel firmed by unfolded whey proteins.
  • Fermented milks keep longer because their acid stops spoilage bacteria, and they are easier to digest because much of the lactose is already used up.

  • Yoghurt sets near pH 4.6, the isoelectric point of casein, after thickening near pH 5.3, and the maker cools fast near pH 4.5, because below pH 4.0 the yoghurt turns sharp and weepy.

  • The starter dose does not set the clock: at 43 °C the bacteria double about every 30 minutes, so doubling the dose only saves about half an hour, while the incubation temperature decides the flavour balance of the pair.
  • Syneresis has four usual causes: low solids, too gentle a heat treatment, over-acidification, and moving the yoghurt before it is cold, and each has its own fix.
  • Dahi uses a mixed household culture at room temperature, yoghurt uses a defined thermophilic pair at 42-45 °C, and both rely on lactic acid setting the milk near pH 4.6.

Glossary

Fermented milk

Milk soured on purpose by lactic acid bacteria. Food tech example: yoghurt and dahi are fermented milks, and their acid sets the casein into a gel at pH 4.6.

Streptococcus thermophilus

A heat-loving lactic acid bacterium used in yoghurt. Food tech example: it grows fast at 42 to 45 °C, makes acid and flavour, and uses up oxygen for its partner.

Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus

A heat-loving lactic acid bacterium used in yoghurt. Food tech example: it makes more acid and the fresh yoghurt note, acetaldehyde, and releases amino acids for its partner.

Set yoghurt

Yoghurt fermented in the pot it is sold in, so its gel is never broken. Food tech example: set yoghurt holds its shape when spooned.

Stirred yoghurt

Yoghurt fermented in a tank, then stirred to break the gel before filling. Food tech example: stirred yoghurt is softer and creamier than set yoghurt.

Dahi

The traditional fermented milk made with mesophilic bacteria at about 25 to 30 °C. Food tech example: dahi sets on a kitchen shelf and is the base of lassi and shrikhand.

Kefir

A fermented milk made with kefir grains holding bacteria and yeasts. Food tech example: kefir is lightly fizzy, because its yeasts make carbon dioxide.

Diacetyl

A flavour compound that gives a buttery note. Food tech example: Leuconostoc makes diacetyl in cultured buttermilk.

Acetaldehyde

A flavour compound that gives the fresh, green yoghurt note. Food tech example: Lactobacillus bulgaricus makes acetaldehyde in yoghurt.

Wheying off

Whey pooling on top of a fermented milk because its gel is weak. Food tech example: low protein or shaking after setting causes wheying off in yoghurt.

Lassi

A drink made by thinning dahi with water, sweetened or salted. Food tech example: lassi is made from dahi, not from fresh milk.

Shrikhand

Strained dahi, thickened by draining off whey, often sweetened. Food tech example: shrikhand is made by straining dahi until it is thick and creamy.

Isoelectric point

The pH at which a protein carries no net charge and stops repelling its neighbours. Food tech example: casein reaches its isoelectric point at pH 4.6, the micelles join, and yoghurt sets.

Titratable acidity

The total acid in milk or yoghurt, measured by titration and reported as percent lactic acid. Food tech example: fresh milk tests about 0.14 to 0.16% lactic acid, and finished yoghurt about 0.8 to 0.9%.

Syneresis

Whey separating and pooling on the surface of a set gel. Food tech example: yoghurt weeps whey when its solids are low, its heat treatment was too gentle, it was over-acidified, or it was moved before it was cold.

References

  • Prajapati, J. B., Sankara Reddy, I., and Sreeja, V. Starter Cultures and Fermented Milk Products. Agrimoon e-course, Anand Agricultural University.
  • Tamime, A. Y., and Robinson, R. K. Yoghurt: Science and Technology. CRC Press.
  • Fox, P. F., and McSweeney, P. L. H. Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic & Professional, 1998.

Unit 13: Quality Control and Testing of Milk and Milk Products

Note

Unit 13: Quality Control and Testing of Milk and Milk Products

A dairy sells trust as much as it sells milk. The customer cannot see the bacteria in the bottle, the water in the milk, or the fat that is missing, so the laboratory has to see them instead. How does a lab catch watering, souring, and cheating with a few quick tests at the gate and a few slow ones on the bench? This unit is the lab's toolkit.

13.1 Sampling: a bad sample makes every test wrong

Every test starts with sampling, and sampling is where most testing errors are born. A sample must represent the whole lot: the milk must be mixed well before the sample is drawn, because fat rises and solids settle, and a sample taken from the top of a tank will test high in fat while a sample from the bottom will test low. The NDDB handbook's first chapter is sampling technique for exactly that reason, and its rules are simple: mix the milk, use a clean, dry, sterile sampler, draw the sample into a clean bottle, label it at once, keep it cold, and test it promptly.

A sample that is warm, old, or badly mixed will give a wrong acidity, a wrong fat, and a wrong bacterial count, and the plant will then make a wrong decision about good milk. The lab's first job is therefore not testing: it is making sure the sample is worth testing.

🤔 Pause and think: a tanker is sampled from the top only, and the fat tests high. The plant pays for high-fat milk, then finds the silo tests normal. What went wrong, and who pays for it?

Quick check

Why must milk be mixed well before a sample is drawn?

Check your answer

Fat rises and solids settle, so a sample from the top tests high in fat and a sample from the bottom tests low: only a mixed sample represents the whole lot.

13.2 Platform tests: the quick checks at the gate

Platform tests are the quick checks done when milk arrives, covered in Unit 4, and they deserve a full listing here because they are the lab's first line:

  • Look and smell. Fresh milk is white, clean, and free of dirt, with a mild, pleasant smell. Sour, rancid, feed, or barny smells mean rejection or downgrading.
  • Temperature. Milk should arrive cold, near 4 °C. Warm milk has been growing bacteria on the road.
  • Acidity. Milk that has started to sour shows a high titratable acidity. Milk with more than 0.15% lactic acid is treated as sour milk at collection, and it is not accepted for processing.
  • Clot-on-boiling. A small tube of milk is boiled: if it clots, the milk is too acid to process, and it is rejected. Milk clots on boiling at about 0.23% acidity, as met in Unit 3.
  • Alcohol test. A little alcohol is mixed with the milk: milk that is acid or unstable clots in the alcohol, which warns the plant before the milk is heated in the pasteuriser.

These tests take minutes, and they catch the milk that must not enter the plant at all. What they cannot do is measure the bacterial load precisely, and that is the job of the tests in section 13.4.

Quick check

Milk arrives with 0.16% acidity. What does the plant do with it, and why?

Check your answer

It is treated as sour milk, since milk above 0.15% lactic acid is sour, and it is not accepted for processing.

13.3 Chemical tests: fat, solids-not-fat, and total solids

The chemical quality of milk is measured on fat, solids-not-fat, and total solids, and the NDDB handbook gives the methods the lab uses:

  • Fat by the Gerber method. Milk is mixed with sulphuric acid and amyl alcohol in a butyrometer, spun in a centrifuge, and the fat rises into the graduated neck, where it is read directly as a percentage. It is fast, rugged, and the standard method at reception.
  • Solids-not-fat. The milk is dried, or its specific gravity and fat are combined in a formula, to give the solids-not-fat, about 8.5 to 9% in cow milk. A low solids-not-fat with a normal fat points at watering.
  • Titratable acidity. The milk is titrated with sodium hydroxide to the phenolphthalein endpoint, and the acidity is reported as percent lactic acid: fresh cow milk reads 0.13 to 0.14%, and fresh buffalo milk reads 0.14 to 0.15%.
  • Protein and lactose. Protein is measured by the Kjeldahl method, which measures nitrogen and converts it to protein, and lactose by chemical or enzymatic methods. Those are slower bench tests, used for product control rather than at the gate.

For products, the handbook's chapters give the matching tests: butter is tested for fat, moisture, and salt; ghee for moisture, acidity, and flavour; milk powder for moisture, solubility, and scorched particles; and sweetened condensed milk for sugar ratio, total solids, and sandiness. The pattern is the same in each case: the lab measures the composition the product's standard promises, and checks that the product delivers it.

Quick check

How does the Gerber method measure fat?

Check your answer

Milk is mixed with sulphuric acid and amyl alcohol in a butyrometer and spun in a centrifuge, and the fat rises into the graduated neck, where it is read as a percentage.

13.4 The methylene blue test: grading milk by its bacteria

The methylene blue reduction test, or MBRT, grades raw milk by how fast its bacteria use up oxygen. A measured amount of methylene blue dye is added to 10 ml of milk, the tube is held in a water bath at 37 °C, and the time until the blue colour disappears is noted. Bacteria consume oxygen as they grow, and as the oxygen falls the dye is reduced to its colourless form, so a short reduction time means many bacteria and a long time means few.

The grading used in the dairy textbooks, as given in Introductory Dairy Microbiology, is: a reduction time of 5 hours and above is Very good milk. Shorter times grade the milk down, step by step, toward poor milk that loses its colour in under half an hour.

A note on the numbers, stated honestly because the books differ. Unit 8 of this subject says good milk takes 5 and a half hours or more to lose its blue colour. The grading table in Introductory Dairy Microbiology and the table in Market Milk Lesson 44, both reporting the same standard, put the Very good line at 5 hours and above. This unit follows the 5-hour figure from those two tables, and flags the difference: the 5 and a half hour figure in Unit 8 is the stricter reading, and a plant that applies it will reject some milk that the 5-hour line would pass as Very good. The test itself is the same in both cases, and the direction is the same: longer is better.

At reception, a shorter version of the rule applies: the methylene blue reduction time of raw milk at reception should be a minimum of 30 minutes, and milk that loses its colour faster than that is not accepted. The resazurin test works on the same idea with a different dye, changing from blue to pink to white, and it is used for a fast 10-minute check at the gate to weed out poor milk.

The methylene blue reduction test

Milk + methylene blue dye
Blue.

↓
Hold at 37 °C

Bacteria grow, use up oxygen

↓
Dye is reduced

Colourless: note the time
Read the time, then grade the milk: 5 hours and above: VERY GOOD. Shorter times: grades fall step by step.

Figure 13.1: The methylene blue reduction test. Drawn from Market Milk, Lesson 44, and Introductory Dairy Microbiology, Lesson 16.

Quick check

What does a short methylene blue reduction time mean, and what is the Very good line?

Check your answer

A short time means many bacteria, because the bacteria use up oxygen fast and reduce the dye quickly. The Very good line in the grading table is 5 hours and above.

13.5 Counting bacteria: plate counts and coliforms

The plate count is the direct way to count bacteria: the milk is diluted in steps, a measured volume is spread on agar, the plates are incubated for 24 to 72 hours, and the colonies are counted. Each colony grew from one cell, so the count, multiplied by the dilution, gives the colony-forming units per millilitre. A count of 85 colonies from 1 ml of a 1,000-fold dilution, for example, means 85,000 colony-forming units per millilitre.

Coliforms are counted separately, because they mean something different. Coliforms come from faecal contamination or dirty equipment and do not belong in milk at all, so finding them is treated as a hygiene failure even when the total count looks fine. The same logic applies to pathogens: the lab tests for them not because they are common, but because finding even a few means the product is unsafe. The phosphatase test, met in Unit 2, checks that pasteurisation was done right, because the enzyme survives under-pasteurisation.

Worked example: reading a plate. You dilute milk 1,000-fold, plate 1 ml, and count 85 colonies. The count is 85 times 1,000, which is 85,000 colony-forming units per millilitre. If you had counted 850 colonies on the same dilution, the count would be 850,000, and the milk would grade far worse.

Quick check

Why are coliforms tested separately from the total bacterial count?

Check your answer

Coliforms come from faecal contamination or dirty equipment and do not belong in milk at all, so their presence points at a hygiene failure whatever the total count says.

13.6 Detecting adulteration: water, and what is added to hide it

Adulteration is the deliberate changing of milk to cheat the buyer, and the lab's tests are built to catch it:

  • Added water is caught by the freezing point, which rises toward 0 °C from its normal near minus 0.54 °C, and by a fall in solids-not-fat and in specific gravity.
  • Starch is added to thicken watered milk, and it is caught by the iodine test, which turns blue-black with starch.
  • Sugar is added to raise the specific gravity and hide watering, and it is caught by chemical tests for added sucrose.
  • Urea is added to raise the apparent protein and the solids-not-fat, and it is caught by tests for excess urea.
  • Neutralisers such as soda are added to hide sourness, and they are caught by tests for alkalinity and by a low titratable acidity in milk that smells sour.
  • Preservatives such as formalin are added to stop milk souring, and they are caught by chemical tests, because they are not allowed in milk at all.

The lesson of the list is that every adulterant is added to hide another one: water is hidden by starch and sugar, sourness is hidden by soda, and spoilage is hidden by preservatives. The lab therefore never runs one test alone: the freezing point, the solids-not-fat, the acidity, and the adulterant tests are read together, and a milk that fails one of them is held for the rest.

🤔 Pause and think: a milk tests normal fat and normal specific gravity, but its freezing point is minus 0.48 °C. What has been added, and what else has probably been added to hide it?

Quick check

Why does the lab never run one adulteration test alone?

Check your answer

Every adulterant is added to hide another one, so the freezing point, solids-not-fat, acidity, and adulterant tests must be read together.

13.7 Judging: the human test that numbers cannot replace

Judging is the sensory examination of a dairy product: its flavour, body, texture, colour, and appearance, scored by a trained judge. The Judging of Dairy Products book sets out the scoring for each product, and the defects the judge looks for: rancid, tallowy, sour, bitter, and feed flavours in milk and butter; a weak body or a gritty texture in cheese; a coarse texture or a stale flavour in ice cream. A product can pass every chemical test and still fail judging, because the customer tastes flavour, not numbers, and a tallowy butter with perfect fat content is still a bad butter.

Judging is also the fastest test in the plant: a trained nose catches a feed flavour in seconds, while a chemical test for it would take hours. The plant therefore uses judging alongside the laboratory, not instead of it: the lab measures what the nose cannot count, and the nose catches what the lab cannot measure.

Quick check

Why does the plant judge products by taste and smell as well as by laboratory tests?

Check your answer

A product can pass every chemical test and still taste bad, and the customer tastes flavour, not numbers: a tallowy butter with perfect fat content is still a bad butter.

13.8 Quality systems: from testing to assurance

Testing catches bad milk, but quality assurance stops bad milk being made. The plant's quality system is built from the pieces in this unit and the next: clean milk production on the farm, reception tests at the gate, laboratory testing on the bench, judging of the finished product, cleaning and sanitisation of the plant, and records that let a bad batch be traced back to its farm, its vat, and its hour. The records matter because a test result with no record of where the sample came from is a number with no meaning.

The NDDB handbook's chapters on registration and reporting, and its chapters on hygienic conditions, are part of that system: they set out how samples are registered, how results are reported, and how the laboratory itself is kept clean and reliable. A laboratory that is dirty, or that uses uncalibrated instruments, will report good milk as bad and bad milk as good, and the plant will make the wrong decisions either way.

Quick check

What is the difference between quality testing and quality assurance?

Check your answer

Testing catches bad milk that has already been made, while assurance stops bad milk being made, through clean production, reception, testing, judging, cleaning, and records.

13.9 Derivation: the lactometer, the Richmond formula, and the added-water check

Sections 13.2 and 13.3 named the quick tests: the lactometer for density, the Gerber test for fat. This section derives the numbers that turn those readings into a verdict on the milk.

The lactometer reading, in plain numbers

The lactometer measures specific gravity: the density of the milk compared with water. The Quevenne lactometer reports it as lactometer degrees, L, where L = (specific gravity − 1) × 1,000. A milk with a specific gravity of 1.030 reads 30 lactometer degrees. Normal cow milk reads about 28 to 34 degrees. Water reads 0: that is why added water pulls the reading down, and why a reading below the normal range is the first sign of watering.

The reading must be taken at the temperature the instrument was calibrated for, and corrected when the milk is warmer or colder: warm milk reads low and cold milk reads high, so a reading taken without its temperature correction is a reading that cannot be trusted. The plant records the milk temperature with the reading, every time.

The Richmond formula, step by step

The Richmond formula turns two quick readings, the lactometer degrees L and the fat percentage F, into total solids, without a laboratory drying step:

Total solids (%) = 0.25 × L + 1.2 × F + 0.14

Each term has a meaning. 0.25 × L is the contribution of the solids-not-fat, because the density the lactometer reads is set mostly by the protein, lactose, and minerals. 1.2 × F is the contribution of the fat: fat is lighter than water, so it lowers the density, and the formula adds its share back. 0.14 is a small constant that corrects the fit for normal milk.

Step 1, take the readings. A milk reads 30 lactometer degrees and tests 4.0% fat by Gerber.

Step 2, work the terms: 0.25 × 30 = 7.5; 1.2 × 4.0 = 4.8; add the constant 0.14.

Step 3, add them: 7.5 + 4.8 + 0.14 = 12.44% total solids.

Step 4, find the solids-not-fat: total solids minus fat = 12.44 − 4.0 = 8.44%.

Worked example: the watering that the fat test misses. A milk tests 4.0% fat, which looks normal, but reads only 26 lactometer degrees. The Richmond formula gives total solids of 0.25 × 26 + 1.2 × 4.0 + 0.14 = 6.5 + 4.8 + 0.14 = 11.44%, and solids-not-fat of 11.44 − 4.0 = 7.44%, well below the normal 8.5%. The fat is fine and the solids are short: the milk was watered, and the fat test alone would have missed it, because watering dilutes the solids-not-fat far more visibly than it dilutes the fat. That is why the plant always runs both tests together.

What else is added to hide watering

Watering lowers the density, so the oldest trick is to add something that raises it back. The plant tests for the common additions: starch, found with iodine, which turns blue-black; urea, which raises the apparent protein and the density; detergents, which foam and raise the pH; and neutralisers such as washing soda, which hide sourness by cancelling the acid. None of these is a food, and none of them is fixed by heating: a milk that needs an addition to pass its tests is a milk to reject, and the test that catches it is cheap, fast, and done at the gate.

🤔 Pause and think: a milk reads 32 lactometer degrees and tests 3.0% fat. Work the Richmond formula. Are the solids normal, and what does the answer tell you about what was added or taken away?

Quick check

A milk reads 30 lactometer degrees and tests 4.0% fat. What are its total solids and its solids-not-fat?

Check your answer

Total solids are 0.25 × 30 + 1.2 × 4.0 + 0.14 = 12.44%, and solids-not-fat are 12.44 − 4.0 = 8.44%.

13.10 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a milk passes the clot-on-boiling test, its fat tests normal, and its specific gravity tests normal, but its freezing point is minus 0.47 °C. What has happened to this milk, and which test caught it when the others did not?

  1. Why must milk be mixed before a sample is drawn?
Check your answer

Fat rises and solids settle, so an unmixed sample does not represent the whole lot.

  1. Milk with more than 0.15% lactic acid is treated as sour at collection. What test would have warned the plant even earlier, and how?
Check your answer

The clot-on-boiling test: milk that clots on boiling is too acid to process, and milk clots on boiling at about 0.23% acidity.

  1. The methylene blue test gives a reduction time of 2 hours. Is that Very good milk, and what does the short time mean?
Check your answer

No, Very good milk takes 5 hours and above. A 2-hour time means many bacteria, which used up the oxygen fast and reduced the dye quickly.

  1. A milk tests normal on fat and specific gravity but its freezing point is high. What does that suggest, and what should the lab test next?
Check your answer

Added water, hidden by something that raises the specific gravity, such as sugar or starch. The lab should test for added sugar and starch, and re-check solids-not-fat.

Try it: Buy two small cartons of milk from different brands. Smell both, taste both, and note the flavour in one sentence each. Then leave a spoonful of each in a warm place for a day and smell them again: the one that turns sour faster had the higher bacterial load, and your nose has just done the job of a platform test.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Sampling comes first: an unmixed, warm, or old sample makes every test wrong.
  • Platform tests at the gate, look, smell, temperature, acidity, clot-on-boiling, and alcohol test, catch the milk that must not enter the plant. Milk above 0.15% lactic acid is treated as sour.
  • Fat is measured by the Gerber method, solids-not-fat from drying or from fat and specific gravity, and acidity by titration: fresh cow milk reads 0.13 to 0.14% as lactic acid.
  • The methylene blue test grades milk by bacterial load: the Very good line in the grading table is 5 hours and above, and milk that loses its colour in under 30 minutes is not accepted at reception. Unit 8 gives a stricter 5 and a half hour figure, and the difference is flagged here, not hidden.
  • Plate counts measure the total bacteria, coliforms point at hygiene failure, and the phosphatase test checks pasteurisation.
  • Adulteration is caught by reading tests together: the freezing point catches water, and starch, sugar, urea, soda, and preservatives are each caught by their own test.
  • Judging, the sensory test, catches what the laboratory cannot measure, and quality assurance, built from production, reception, testing, judging, cleaning, and records, stops bad milk being made.

  • The Richmond formula turns a lactometer reading and a fat test into total solids: total solids (%) = 0.25 × lactometer degrees + 1.2 × fat % + 0.14, and solids-not-fat are total solids minus fat.

  • A milk that tests normal for fat but low for solids-not-fat has been watered: watering dilutes the solids-not-fat far more visibly than it dilutes the fat, so the two tests must always run together.
  • Starch, urea, detergents, and neutralisers are added to hide watering or sourness, and each has its own quick test at the gate.

Glossary

Platform test

A quick test done when milk arrives at the plant gate. Food tech example: the clot-on-boiling test rejects milk that is too acid to process.

Gerber method

A fast method for measuring milk fat, using sulphuric acid and amyl alcohol in a butyrometer. Food tech example: the fat rises into the graduated neck of the butyrometer and is read as a percentage.

Methylene blue reduction test (MBRT)

A test that grades milk by how fast its bacteria use up oxygen and reduce a blue dye to colourless. Food tech example: Very good milk takes 5 hours and above to lose its blue colour.

Resazurin test

A dye test like the methylene blue test, changing from blue to pink to white. Food tech example: a 10-minute resazurin test at the gate weeds out poor milk fast.

Plate count

A count of bacteria by growing them into colonies on agar. Food tech example: 85 colonies from 1 ml of a 1,000-fold dilution means 85,000 colony-forming units per millilitre.

Coliform

A bacterium from faecal contamination or dirty equipment. Food tech example: finding coliforms in milk is treated as a hygiene failure even when the total count looks fine.

Adulteration

Deliberately changing milk to cheat the buyer. Food tech example: adding water and hiding it with starch or sugar is adulteration.

Clot-on-boiling test

Boiling a small tube of milk to see if it clots. Food tech example: milk clots on boiling at about 0.23% acidity, so a clot means the milk is too acid to process.

Judging

The sensory examination of a dairy product by a trained judge. Food tech example: a judge scores butter for flavour, body, texture, colour, and appearance.

Quality assurance

The system that stops bad milk being made, through clean production, testing, judging, cleaning, and records. Food tech example: a test result with no record of where the sample came from is a number with no meaning.

Titratable acidity

The acid in milk measured by titration with alkali. Food tech example: fresh cow milk reads 0.13 to 0.14% as lactic acid, and milk above 0.15% is treated as sour at collection.

Richmond formula

The formula that turns a lactometer reading and a fat test into total solids: total solids (%) = 0.25 × lactometer degrees + 1.2 × fat % + 0.14. Food tech example: a milk at 30 lactometer degrees and 4.0% fat has 12.44% total solids and 8.44% solids-not-fat.

Lactometer degrees

The Quevenne scale for specific gravity: lactometer degrees = (specific gravity − 1) × 1,000. Food tech example: milk with a specific gravity of 1.030 reads 30 lactometer degrees, and water reads 0.

Neutraliser

An alkaline substance added to sour milk to cancel its acid and hide the sourness. Food tech example: washing soda added to milk hides sourness but does not make the milk safe, and the plant tests for it at the gate.

References

  • Market Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lessons 41-45.
  • NDDB. Laboratory Handbook for Dairy Industry. March 2001. Chapters 1-17.
  • Sankara Reddy, I., and Puniya, A. K. Introductory Dairy Microbiology. Agrimoon e-course.
  • Judging of Dairy Products. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR.

Unit 14: Cleaning in Place and Dairy Plant Hygiene

Note

Unit 14: Cleaning in Place and Dairy Plant Hygiene

A dairy plant is cleaned more often than it produces. Every tank, pipe, and filler is washed between runs, and the washing is not a chore done after the work: it is part of the work, because milk leaves a film on every surface it touches, and that film feeds the next batch of bacteria. How do you clean a pipe you cannot take apart, and how do you know it is clean? This unit answers both questions.

14.1 Why dairy equipment gets dirty in a special way

Milk leaves a soil on equipment that is harder to remove than most food soils, because it is made of four things at once: fat, protein, lactose, and minerals. When milk is heated, the protein unfolds and sticks to the hot surface, the minerals, above all calcium phosphate, form a hard scale called milk stone, and the fat coats everything with a greasy film. That mixed soil is called milk soil, and it protects bacteria: microbes hiding under a film of milk soil survive a rinse that would kill them on a clean surface.

That is why cleaning a dairy is a chemical job, not just a scrubbing job. Water alone will not dissolve milk stone, and a cold rinse will not lift set protein. The cleaner must dissolve each part of the soil in turn, and the order matters: the books insist on rinsing first, then alkali, then acid, then disinfection, because each step deals with a different part of the soil, and a step done out of order leaves the soil behind.

🤔 Pause and think: a tank is rinsed with cold water only and looks clean. Why might it still seed the next batch of milk with bacteria?

Quick check

What is milk soil, and why does it protect bacteria?

Check your answer

It is the mixed film of fat, protein, lactose, and minerals left on equipment, including hard milk stone from heated milk, and microbes hiding under it survive a rinse that would kill them on a clean surface.

14.2 Detergents: the chemicals that lift the soil

Dairy detergents are built from several parts, each doing one job, as set out in Market Milk Lesson 36:

  • Alkalis, such as caustic soda and soda ash, dissolve protein and fat, and they are the workhorse of dairy cleaning. Caustic soda is strong and cheap, but it attacks aluminium and skin, so it is handled with care.
  • Acids, such as nitric and phosphoric acid, dissolve milk stone, the mineral scale, and they are used after the alkali step, or on their own in cold milk lines every few days.
  • Complex phosphates and sodium metasilicate soften the water, keep the soil suspended so it does not settle back, and protect the metal from corrosion.
  • Surfactants lower the surface tension of the wash liquid, so it spreads into corners and under deposits instead of beading up, as met in Unit 3.
  • Chlorine, as hypochlorite, helps remove milk stone and adds a disinfecting action, at a dose that gives 25 to 50 parts per million of available chlorine in the wash.

A detergent is chosen for the soil and the surface: a strong alkali for a hot milk line with heavy protein soil, a milder detergent for aluminium, and an acid wash where milk stone is the problem. Using the wrong detergent is worse than using none: an acid wash on a protein soil sets the protein harder, and an alkali wash on a mineral scale does nothing at all.

Quick check

Why is an acid wash used after the alkali wash, and not before it?

Check your answer

Alkali dissolves the protein and fat first, and acid then dissolves the mineral milk stone underneath: acid on a protein soil would set the protein harder.

14.3 Sanitisers: killing what the detergent leaves

Cleaning removes the soil; sanitising kills the microbes that are left. The two are different steps, and a surface must be cleaned before it can be sanitised, because soil shields microbes from the sanitiser. The sanitisers used in dairies, set out in Market Milk Lesson 37, include:

  • Chlorine compounds, such as hypochlorite, which are cheap, fast, and effective, but are weakened by organic matter and by hard water, and must be rinsed off, because chlorine left in milk gives a chemical flavour.
  • Iodophors, iodine in a carrier, which are effective, less corrosive than chlorine, and show their strength by their colour, which fades as the iodine is used up.
  • Quaternary ammonium compounds, which are stable, non-corrosive, and leave a film that keeps working, but are weakened by hard water and by soap residues.
  • Heat, in the form of hot water or steam, which is the oldest sanitiser of all, and the one with no chemical residue: water at 90 to 95 °C, or steam, kills microbes on a clean surface.

The choice depends on the surface, the water, and the product: a sanitiser that is fine for a floor may be wrong for a milk contact surface, and a sanitiser left in the line will taint the milk. The lab tests the rinse water for sanitiser residues, as covered in Market Milk Lesson 39, so that cleaning never becomes contamination.

Quick check

Why must a surface be cleaned before it can be sanitised?

Check your answer

Soil shields microbes from the sanitiser, so a dirty surface cannot be sanitised no matter how strong the chemical is.

14.4 Cleaning in place: washing a plant without taking it apart

Cleaning-in-place, or CIP, is cleaning the plant by circulating cleaning liquids through the machines and pipes without dismantling them. It is the standard method in a modern dairy, because taking a plant apart to clean it would take hours and would re-contaminate the surfaces as they were put back together. In CIP, the cleaning liquid is pumped through the circuit at high velocity, and the fast flow scrubs the surfaces mechanically as the chemicals dissolve the soil.

The figures and the cycle in this section are attributed to Market Milk, Lessons 37 and 38, which set out the CIP sequence used in the books. The standard CIP cycle runs as follows:

  1. Recover the product residue by draining the line.
  2. Expel the non-retrievable residue with water or compressed air.
  3. Warm water rinse, 50 to 60 °C, for 10 minutes, to remove as much soil as possible.
  4. Alkaline detergent, 0.5 to 1.5% solution, at 75 °C, for 30 minutes, circulated to dissolve protein and fat.
  5. Warm water rinse, 50 °C, for 5 to 8 minutes.
  6. Acidic detergent, 0.5 to 1.0% solution, at 75 °C, for 20 minutes, circulated to dissolve milk stone.
  7. Warm water rinse, 50 °C, for 5 to 8 minutes.
  8. Thermal disinfection at 90 to 95 °C with cooling for 10 minutes, or chemical disinfection with a suitable sanitiser.

Two points in that cycle deserve attention. The acid step is a daily chore in hot milk lines, where milk stone forms fast, but it is needed only every 4 to 7 days in cold milk lines, where little scale forms. And the alkaline detergent may carry 25 to 50 parts per million of available chlorine, from added hypochlorite, to help remove milk stone from metal surfaces. The cycle is a complete sequence: skipping the acid step leaves the scale, and skipping the final disinfection leaves the microbes, and either failure shows up in the next batch of milk.

The standard CIP cycle

Drain the product out

↓
Expel residue with water or air

Warm rinse
50-60 °C, 10 min.

↓
Alkali: 0.5-1.5%, 75 °C, 30 min

Warm rinse
50 °C, 5-8 min.

↓
Acid: 0.5-1.0%, 75 °C, 20 min

Warm rinse
50 °C, 5-8 min.

↓
Disinfect: 90-95 °C, 10 min, or chemical sanitiser

Clean and sanitised, ready to run

Figure 14.1: The standard CIP cycle. All temperatures, concentrations, and times are attributed to Market Milk, Lessons 37 and 38.

There are two kinds of CIP system. In a single-pass system, fresh cleaning solution is made for each cycle and then sent to drain, which is simple but uses more water and detergent. In a recirculation system, the solutions are mixed in external tanks, circulated, and topped up as needed until the cycle is complete, which costs more to build but uses less water and detergent. Small plants with short lines use a centralised CIP station, while large plants use decentralised, or satellite, stations near the circuits they serve, because pumping cleaning liquid over a long distance wastes time and heat.

🤔 Pause and think: a plant skips the acid step for a week to save time, and its milk starts failing the heat stability test. What has built up in the hot lines, and why does it affect heat stability?

Quick check

In the CIP cycle attributed to Market Milk Lessons 37 and 38, what are the alkali and acid steps?

Check your answer

Alkaline detergent at 0.5 to 1.5%, 75 °C, for 30 minutes, then acidic detergent at 0.5 to 1.0%, 75 °C, for 20 minutes, each followed by a warm water rinse at 50 °C for 5 to 8 minutes.

14.5 Sterilisation in place: steam through the whole plant

Sterilisation-in-place, or SIP, goes further than CIP: steam under pressure is passed through the whole installation to sterilise it, not just to clean and disinfect it. The air is vented out through vents protected by bacterial filters, the steam pressure is built up to a set level and held for the required time, and temperature sensors confirm that the time and temperature needed to destroy all contaminants have been reached. The steam must be pure, passed through a micro-filter, and the pipework must be built of pressure-grade stainless steel or lined tubing to stand the pressure and temperature.

SIP is used where the product must be sterile, as in UHT milk lines, and it needs highly qualified staff and equipment built to preset standards. It is the most thorough cleaning a plant can do, and also the most demanding: a SIP cycle that is cut short, or run with impure steam, leaves the plant looking clean and being dirty, which is worse than a plant that is openly dirty.

Quick check

What is the difference between CIP and SIP?

Check your answer

CIP circulates cleaning liquids to clean and disinfect the plant, while SIP passes steam under pressure through the whole installation to sterilise it.

14.6 The advantages of CIP, and what can still go wrong

The books list the advantages of CIP plainly: guaranteed and repeatable quality, full data logging for quality assurance, lower cleaning costs through recycling solutions, cleaning of areas no person can reach, better safety for operators who do not handle hazardous chemicals, less time between production runs, less labour, better control of cleaning materials, and less water use. Those are real gains, and they are why CIP replaced manual cleaning in every large dairy.

But CIP can fail, and its failures are quiet. A spray ball clogged with soil leaves a dry patch inside a tank that never gets washed. A detergent dosed too weak leaves the soil behind. A rinse that is too short leaves detergent in the line, and the next milk tastes of chemicals. A temperature that falls below the set point leaves the protein undissolved. That is why CIP circuits carry temperature sensors, flow meters, and conductivity meters, and why the rinse water is tested for detergent and sanitiser residues: the plant must prove the cleaning worked, not assume it did. The tests for detergents and sanitisers, in Market Milk Lesson 39, are the check that closes the loop.

Quick check

A CIP circuit has a clogged spray ball. What happens inside the tank, and how would the plant find out?

Check your answer

A patch of the tank never gets washed, so soil and bacteria build up there. The plant finds out by testing the rinse water and by swabbing the surface, and by the milk spoiling faster than it should.

14.7 Hygiene of people and the plant

Equipment is only half of plant hygiene: people are the other half. Hands touch products and packaging all the time, so hands are washed and gloved, aprons and caps are worn in the production area, and nobody enters the production area from a dirty area, such as the effluent area, without changing. Coughing and sneezing over open product is not allowed, and a person with a skin infection or a stomach upset is kept out of the production area.

The building matters too. Floors are washed and drained, so milk that spills is cleaned up at once instead of drying into a film that feeds bacteria. Drains are kept clear, and the effluent area is kept separate from the production area. Walls and ceilings are smooth and washable, so they can be cleaned, and the plant is laid out so that raw milk and finished product never cross paths. A plant that is well laid out is easy to clean, and a plant that is easy to clean stays clean.

Quick check

Why must staff change clothes after working in the effluent area before entering production?

Check your answer

Effluent carries heavy bacterial loads, and clothes carry those bacteria into the production area, where they can contaminate the product.

14.8 Why alkali first, then acid: the chemistry of the CIP sequence

Section 14.4 gave the CIP cycle as a list of steps. This section explains why the steps run in that order, and why swapping them makes the cleaning worse, not faster.

What each step removes

Dairy soil is two soils in one: an organic soil of fat and protein, and a mineral soil of calcium phosphate scale, called milk stone. No single chemical removes both, so the cycle uses two, in order.

What each CIP step removes

Pre-rinse with water
Loose milk and loose soil, washed out before any chemical is spent on them. Recovering this milk first cuts the effluent load, as Unit 15 explains.
Alkali, 0.5-1.5% at 75 °C
Removes fat and protein. Caustic soda turns fat into soap, a change called saponification, and dissolves and peptises the protein, lifting it off the steel.
Acid, 0.5-1.0% at 75 °C
Removes milk stone. The acid dissolves the calcium phosphate scale the alkali cannot touch, and brightens the steel.
Disinfect, hot water or sanitiser
Kills the microbes the detergent left behind. Hot water at 90-95 °C, or a chemical sanitiser at its stated dose and contact time.

Figure 14.2: What each CIP step removes, and why the order cannot be swapped. Drawn from the CIP chemistry in Market Milk, Lessons 37 and 38.

Why the order cannot be swapped

Acid first on a protein soil is a mistake the books warn about plainly: acid sets protein hard onto the steel, like egg white setting in a hot pan, and the alkali that follows must then fight a baked-on layer instead of a loose one. Alkali first lifts the fat and protein away, and the acid that follows meets bare mineral scale and dissolves it cleanly. A plant that skips the alkali to save time does not save time: it bakes its own soil on, and the next cycle takes longer than the one it skipped.

The numbers of a cleaning cycle

A circuit holding 1,000 litres of cleaning solution at 1% caustic soda carries 10 kg of caustic in the circuit. That number is why concentration is checked, not guessed: a circuit dosed by eye drifts low, and a low dose cleans slowly and leaves a film that the next milk picks up. Temperature is checked the same way: alkali at 75 °C cleans far faster than alkali at 50 °C, because heat speeds the saponification and the dissolving, and a cycle run cold is a cycle that must run longer to do the same work.

How the plant knows the plant is clean

Clean is not a feeling: it is measured. The final rinse water is checked by conductivity: detergent raises conductivity, so a rinse that reads like clean water is a rinse that has done its job, as met in Unit 3. Surfaces are checked by sight and by touch, and by swabs: a swab pressed to a surface and grown in the laboratory shows whether microbes survived, and an ATP swab, which reads the energy molecule of living cells, gives the answer in seconds instead of days. A plant that validates its cleaning this way finds its weak circuits before the milk does: a dead leg that the cleaning flow never reaches, a valve that never drains, or a tank corner where the spray ball never lands.

🤔 Pause and think: a plant skips the acid step for a week to save time, and its milk starts failing the heat stability test, as in Section 14.4. Which soil has built up, where, and why does it change the way the milk behaves on heating?

Quick check

Why must the alkali step come before the acid step in a CIP cycle?

Check your answer

Acid sets protein hard onto the steel, so the alkali must lift the fat and protein away first, and the acid that follows then meets bare mineral scale and dissolves it cleanly.

14.9 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a plant's pasteurised milk keeps failing its bacterial count, although the pasteuriser record is perfect and the raw milk is good. The filler was cleaned by CIP last night. What three things in the cleaning would you check first?

  1. What is milk stone, and which CIP step removes it?
Check your answer

Milk stone is the hard mineral scale, mainly calcium phosphate, left by heated milk. The acid detergent step, 0.5 to 1.0% at 75 °C for 20 minutes, dissolves it.

  1. In the CIP cycle from Market Milk Lessons 37 and 38, what are the rinse steps, and why are there three of them?
Check your answer

A warm rinse at 50 to 60 °C for 10 minutes before the alkali, and a warm rinse at 50 °C for 5 to 8 minutes after each detergent step. Each rinse removes the soil or the chemical before the next step.

  1. Why must a surface be cleaned before it is sanitised?
Check your answer

Soil shields microbes from the sanitiser, so a dirty surface cannot be sanitised no matter how strong the chemical is.

  1. What is the difference between a single-pass and a recirculation CIP system?
Check your answer

A single-pass system makes fresh solution for each cycle and sends it to drain, while a recirculation system reuses the solution from external tanks, topped up as needed, using less water and detergent.

Try it: Smear a little milk on a plate, leave it to dry, then try to wash it off with cold water alone. It stays. Now wash it with warm water and a drop of washing-up liquid, then rinse: it comes off. You have just done the CIP sequence in miniature: rinse, alkali with surfactant, and rinse again.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • Milk soil is a mixed film of fat, protein, lactose, and minerals, including hard milk stone, and it shields bacteria from rinses and sanitisers.
  • Alkalis dissolve protein and fat, acids dissolve milk stone, phosphates soften water and suspend soil, and surfactants spread the wash liquid into corners.
  • Cleaning removes soil and sanitising kills microbes: a surface must be cleaned before it can be sanitised, and chlorine, iodophors, quaternary ammonium compounds, and heat are the sanitisers used.
  • CIP cleans the plant by circulating cleaning liquids without dismantling it, and the standard cycle, attributed to Market Milk Lessons 37 and 38, is: drain, expel residue, warm rinse at 50 to 60 °C for 10 minutes, alkali at 0.5 to 1.5% and 75 °C for 30 minutes, warm rinse at 50 °C for 5 to 8 minutes, acid at 0.5 to 1.0% and 75 °C for 20 minutes, warm rinse at 50 °C for 5 to 8 minutes, and thermal disinfection at 90 to 95 °C for 10 minutes or chemical disinfection.
  • The acid step is daily in hot milk lines and every 4 to 7 days in cold milk lines, and the alkali may carry 25 to 50 parts per million of available chlorine to help remove milk stone.
  • Single-pass CIP makes fresh solution each cycle, while recirculation CIP reuses solution from tanks and uses less water and detergent.
  • SIP passes steam under pressure through the whole plant to sterilise it, and it needs pure steam, pressure-grade pipework, and qualified staff.
  • CIP brings repeatable quality, data logging, lower costs, and safer work, but it fails quietly, so temperature, flow, conductivity, and residue tests must prove it worked.
  • People are half of plant hygiene: clean hands, aprons, caps, and separation between dirty and clean areas.

  • Alkali removes the organic soil: caustic soda turns fat into soap and dissolves protein, while acid removes the mineral soil, the calcium phosphate milk stone the alkali cannot touch.

  • Acid first on a protein soil bakes the protein onto the steel, so the alkali step must come first and the acid step follows onto bare mineral scale.
  • Clean is measured, not felt: the final rinse is checked by conductivity, and surfaces by swabs, including ATP swabs that answer in seconds.

Glossary

Milk soil

The mixed film of fat, protein, lactose, and minerals left on equipment by milk. Food tech example: heated milk leaves milk stone, a hard calcium phosphate scale, on hot surfaces.

Milk stone

Hard mineral scale, mainly calcium phosphate, left by heated milk. Food tech example: milk stone is dissolved by the acid step of the CIP cycle.

Detergent

A cleaning chemical that lifts soil from a surface. Food tech example: caustic soda dissolves protein and fat in dairy cleaning.

Sanitiser

A chemical or heat treatment that kills microbes on a clean surface. Food tech example: hypochlorite and iodophors are dairy sanitisers.

Cleaning in place (CIP)

Cleaning a plant by circulating cleaning liquids through it without dismantling it. Food tech example: the CIP cycle runs rinse, alkali, rinse, acid, rinse, and disinfection in order.

Single-pass CIP

A CIP system that makes fresh cleaning solution for each cycle and sends it to drain. Food tech example: single-pass CIP is simple but uses more water and detergent.

Recirculation CIP

A CIP system that reuses cleaning solution from external tanks. Food tech example: recirculation CIP costs more to build but uses less water and detergent.

Sterilisation in place (SIP)

Sterilising a plant by passing steam under pressure through it. Food tech example: SIP is used in UHT milk lines, where the product must be sterile.

Surfactant

A substance that lowers surface tension so a liquid spreads. Food tech example: surfactants in detergent let the wash liquid spread into corners and under deposits.

Available chlorine

The active chlorine in a sanitiser or wash, measured in parts per million. Food tech example: the CIP alkali may carry 25 to 50 parts per million of available chlorine to help remove milk stone.

Saponification

The change in which an alkali turns fat into soap. Food tech example: caustic soda in the CIP alkali step turns milk fat into soap, which washes away with the rinse water.

Milk stone

The hard mineral scale of calcium phosphate that builds up on hot dairy surfaces. Food tech example: the acid step of a CIP cycle dissolves milk stone that the alkali step cannot touch.

ATP swab

A swab test that reads the energy molecule of living cells, giving a hygiene answer in seconds instead of days. Food tech example: an ATP swab on a tank surface shows at once whether the cleaning cycle left living microbes behind.

References

  • Market Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lessons 36-39.
  • Cleaning in Place: Dairy, Food and Beverage Operations. Tetra Pak.
  • NDDB. Laboratory Handbook for Dairy Industry. March 2001. Chapter 2.
  • Sankara Reddy, I., and Puniya, A. K. Introductory Dairy Microbiology. Agrimoon e-course.

Unit 15: Dairy Plant Management, Packaging and the Environment

Note

Unit 15: Dairy Plant Management, Packaging and the Environment

A dairy plant is a system, not a set of machines. Milk comes in one door, products go out another, water and energy flow through the middle, and waste leaves by a third door. If any part of that system is managed badly, the products suffer, the workers suffer, or the river suffers. This unit is about running the whole system, packing what it makes, and cleaning up after it.

15.1 The plant as a system

A dairy plant has departments that must work as organs of one body, in the words of the management book: reception, processing, packaging, quality control, engineering and maintenance, stores, and administration. If reception accepts bad milk, processing cannot fix it. If engineering lets a pasteuriser drift, quality control cannot test the milk safe. If packaging runs out of film, the milk has nowhere to go. The manager's job is to make those departments work together, and to make sure everybody in the company is working to accomplish the same change, which is the point the management book makes with its fourteen points for transformation: quality is not one department's job, it is the whole plant's job.

The plant is also laid out as a system. Raw milk and finished product never cross paths, clean and dirty areas are separated, and the flow runs in one direction, from reception through processing to packaging and dispatch, so that a finished product never passes back through a raw area. A plant that is laid out well is easy to clean, easy to run, and hard to contaminate; a plant that is laid out badly fights its own staff every day.

🤔 Pause and think: a plant puts its packaging store next to the raw milk reception, so that cartons are carried through the raw area to reach the filler. What could go wrong, and how would you fix the layout?

Quick check

Why must raw milk and finished product never cross paths in a plant?

Check your answer

A finished product that passes back through a raw area can be re-contaminated by raw milk, undoing the pasteurisation that made it safe.

15.2 Managing people: the plant runs on habits

Machines do not make good milk: people do, by habit. The management book's lessons on hygiene are habits written down: wash hands, wear aprons and caps, keep gloves intact and sanitary, change out of dirty clothes before entering production, and never enter the production area without an apron and cap. Spills are cleaned up at once, because milk spilled on a floor dries into a film that feeds bacteria, and the floor is washed and drained so that the film never forms.

Training is part of the system too. A worker who does not know why the CIP cycle runs in its order will skip the acid step to save time, as in Unit 14, and a worker who does not know why milk must stay cold will leave a tanker standing in the sun. The plant therefore trains its people in the reasons, not just the steps, and it checks that the training stuck by testing the product, not by asking the worker. That is the link between this unit and Unit 13: the laboratory is the plant's way of finding out whether its habits are working.

Quick check

Why does the plant train workers in the reasons for a step, not just the step itself?

Check your answer

A worker who knows why the acid step matters will not skip it to save time, while a worker who only knows the step will cut it when nobody is watching.

15.3 Packaging: what a pack must do

Packaging is not a wrapper: it is the last process step, and it decides whether the product reaches the customer in the condition the plant made it. A dairy pack must do five jobs:

  • Contain the product without leaking, through transport and handling.
  • Protect it from air, light, moisture, and microbes, which would spoil the fat and grow mould.
  • Preserve its quality, by holding the cold chain and keeping oxygen out.
  • Inform the customer, with the product name, the date, the composition, and the storage instructions.
  • Sell it, by looking clean and honest on the shelf.

The materials each do some of those jobs well and others badly. Glass is clear, inert, and easy to see through, but it is heavy and breaks. Metal cans are strong and keep out light and air, but they are heavy and costly. Paper and board are light and printable, but they let in moisture unless they are coated or laminated. Plastics, above all polyethylene, are light, cheap, and sealable, and they are the material of milk pouches and bottles, but they let in a little oxygen and light, so milk in clear plastic loses vitamins and picks up a light flavour on a lit shelf, as met in Unit 2.

Packaging materials and what each one does well

Glass
Clear + inert, heavy + breaks.
Metal
Strong + dark, heavy + costly.
Paper/board
Light + printable, needs coating.
Plastic
Light + cheap + sealable, lets in some light.

Combine them: laminates

Carton
Paper + plastic + foil layers. Light, printable, keeps out air + light.

Figure 15.1: Packaging materials and what each one does well. Drawn from Packaging of Dairy Products, Lessons 3-13.

Quick check

Why is milk in a clear plastic bottle more at risk on a lit shelf than milk in a carton?

Check your answer

Clear plastic lets in light, which destroys riboflavin and gives a light-induced off-flavour, while a carton with foil layers keeps light out.

15.4 Packs for milk and for products

Milk is packed in pouches, bottles, and cartons, filled cold and sealed, dated, and kept cold through distribution. UHT milk is packed aseptically: the milk is sterilised, the pack is sterilised, and the filling is done in a sterile zone, so the sealed pack keeps for months without a fridge. Butter is packed in foil or parchment, ghee in tins or jars, cheese in wax, vacuum packs, or foil, and milk powder in moisture-proof bags, often with a gas flush to keep oxygen out, because powder that takes up moisture cakes and powder that takes up oxygen goes tallowy.

The pack is chosen for the product's enemy. Milk's enemies are light, warmth, and time, so its pack is opaque and its distribution is cold. Powder's enemies are moisture and oxygen, so its pack is sealed and dry. Butter's enemies are air and light, so its pack is foil. The rule is the same as in every unit: name the enemy first, then choose the pack that keeps it out.

🤔 Pause and think: a milk powder is packed in a paper bag with no liner, and it cakes in a month. Which enemy got in, and what pack would have kept it out?

Quick check

Why is milk powder packed in moisture-proof bags, often with a gas flush?

Check your answer

Powder that takes up moisture cakes, and powder that takes up oxygen goes tallowy, so the pack must keep out both.

15.5 Newer packs: aseptic, vacuum, and modified atmosphere

Three newer forms of packaging extend shelf life without adding preservatives:

  • Aseptic packaging sterilises the milk and the pack separately and fills them together in a sterile zone, giving UHT milk its months of shelf life at room temperature.
  • Vacuum packaging takes the air out of the pack before sealing it, so oxygen cannot attack the fat. It is used for cheese and butter, where oxygen is the main enemy.
  • Modified atmosphere packaging replaces the air in the pack with a chosen gas mixture, usually with less oxygen and more carbon dioxide or nitrogen, which slows microbes and oxidation. It is used for cheese and for fresh products where a little air would spoil the product fast.

Active packaging goes a step further, with materials that absorb oxygen or release antimicrobial compounds inside the pack, and eco-friendly packaging uses materials that can be recycled or composted. The books note both, and the direction is plain: packaging is moving toward less material, less oxygen, and less waste, while keeping the product safe for longer.

Quick check

What is modified atmosphere packaging, and what does it do?

Check your answer

It replaces the air in the pack with a chosen gas mixture, usually with less oxygen, which slows microbes and oxidation and extends shelf life.

15.6 The environment: what leaves the plant besides products

A dairy uses a lot of water, and most of it leaves as effluent, the wastewater from washing, rinsing, and cleaning. That effluent carries milk solids, detergent, and sanitiser, and it is strong waste: its biochemical oxygen demand, or BOD, is high, because the lactose and protein in it feed microbes fast, and those microbes use up the oxygen in the river, as met in Unit 11. The plant must therefore treat its effluent before it is discharged, and the treatment is a process in its own right:

  • Screening and settling take out the solids and the fat, which are recovered where possible.
  • Biological treatment lets microbes eat the dissolved lactose and protein in aerated tanks, cutting the BOD sharply.
  • Polishing settles the treated water and checks it before discharge, so that what leaves the plant is clean enough for the river.

The best pollution control, the books insist, is not treatment at all: it is not making the waste in the first place. Recovering product before washing, as in the CIP drain step of Unit 14, saves milk and cuts the effluent load at the same time. Turning whey into products, as in Unit 11, keeps the strongest waste stream out of the drain altogether. Saving water in cleaning, by recirculating CIP solutions, cuts both the water bill and the effluent volume. Pollution control is therefore not a separate department: it is the plant running well, with nothing wasted that could have been a product.

Quick check

What is biochemical oxygen demand, and why is dairy effluent high in it?

Check your answer

It is the oxygen microbes use up as they eat the waste in water. Dairy effluent is high in it because it carries lactose and protein, which feed microbes fast.

15.7 Energy, water, and the cost of making milk products

A dairy is a heavy user of energy and water. Steam heats the pasteuriser, the evaporator, and the spray dryer; refrigeration cools the milk, the storage, and the finished product; and water washes the plant, cools the equipment, and feeds the boilers. The plant saves energy by regeneration, where outgoing hot milk warms incoming cold milk in the HTST pasteuriser, and by multiple-effect evaporation, where the vapour from one effect heats the next, both met in Units 4 and 5. It saves water by recirculating CIP solutions and by recovering condensate. Those savings are not only about cost: every litre of water saved is a litre less effluent to treat, and every unit of steam saved is fuel not burned.

The management of a plant is therefore measured in numbers: litres of water per litre of milk processed, units of steam per kilogram of powder dried, and kilograms of product per litre of milk received. A plant that watches those numbers finds its waste; a plant that does not will pay for it in fuel, in water, and in effluent charges, and will not know why.

Quick check

Name two ways a dairy saves energy, and where each is used.

Check your answer

Regeneration in the HTST pasteuriser, where outgoing hot milk warms incoming cold milk, and multiple-effect evaporation, where the vapour from one effect heats the next.

15.8 Records, traceability, and recall: the paper trail that saves the plant

Every batch a plant makes leaves a paper trail: which farm the milk came from, which silo it went into, which vat or pasteuriser ran it, which filler packed it, and which shop it was sent to. That trail is called traceability, and it is what lets a plant find a bad batch and take it back, instead of guessing which batches are affected. The NDDB handbook's chapters on registration and reporting set out how samples are registered and how results are reported, and the same discipline applies to production: every batch number, every test result, and every dispatch is written down at the time it happens, not from memory at the end of the day.

A recall is the test of that trail. When a product is found to be unsafe, the plant must find every pack from the affected batch, tell the shops to take it off the shelf, and tell the customer what to do, and it must do that fast, before more of the product is eaten. A plant with good records can recall one batch; a plant with poor records must recall everything it made that week, because it cannot prove which batches are safe. The cost of good records is a clerk's time and a disciplined habit; the cost of poor records is the whole week's production, and the trust of the customers who bought it.

🤔 Pause and think: a customer reports a sour carton, and the plant cannot say which farm the milk came from or which filler packed it. What can the plant recall, and what does that tell you about the value of the records it did not keep?

Quick check

Why is traceability worth the clerk's time it costs?

Check your answer

It lets the plant recall one affected batch instead of everything made that week, because it can prove which batches are safe and which are not.

15.9 Derivation: the effluent load, and what treatment must remove

Section 15.6 described effluent treatment in words. This section puts numbers on it: how strong dairy waste is, how much treatment it needs, and how much energy the plant can save by not making the waste in the first place.

How strong is milk as waste?

Biochemical oxygen demand, BOD, is the oxygen microbes use up as they eat the waste in water, measured in milligrams per litre. Whole milk has a BOD near 100,000 milligrams per litre: about 100 grams of oxygen demand in every litre. Domestic sewage, by comparison, runs near 300 milligrams per litre. One litre of milk poured down the drain is, in oxygen demand, roughly equal to 300 litres of household sewage.

Worked example: the milk lost to the drain. A plant loses 100 litres of milk into its drains in a day, through spills, the CIP pre-rinse, and the first flush of a line. At 100,000 milligrams per litre, that is 100 × 100 = 10,000 grams, or 10 kg of BOD. A person produces about 60 grams of BOD per day in household sewage, so 10 kg of BOD is the daily waste of about 165 people, from 100 litres of spilt milk. That is why the books insist that the best pollution control is not treatment but recovery: every litre of milk kept out of the drain is hundreds of litres of sewage the treatment plant never has to handle.

What treatment must remove

The treatment in Section 15.6 works in stages because the waste arrives in stages: fat and solids first, then dissolved lactose and protein. Screening and settling take out the solids and the fat, which are recovered where possible. Biological treatment then lets microbes eat the dissolved lactose and protein in aerated tanks, cutting the BOD sharply, and the treated water is settled and checked before discharge. The check is the point: a plant that discharges without measuring its BOD is a plant that finds out about its failure from its neighbours, not from its own records.

The energy the plant can save

Pasteurising milk takes heat, and the numbers show why regeneration matters. The specific heat of milk is about 3.9 kilojoules per kilogram per degree: heating one kilogram of milk by one degree takes about 3.9 kilojoules.

Step 1, the heat without regeneration. Heating 1,000 kg of milk from 4 °C to 72 °C is a rise of 68 degrees: 1,000 × 3.9 × 68 ≈ 265,000 kilojoules, about 265 megajoules.

Step 2, the heat with 90% regeneration. The outgoing milk does 90% of the heating, so fresh steam supplies only about 10%: about 27 megajoules, plus the small losses through the plates and pipes.

Step 3, read the saving. Regeneration cuts the steam for pasteurisation roughly tenfold, and the same logic cuts the refrigeration, because the outgoing milk is cooled by the incoming milk before the chiller ever sees it. A plant that lets its plates foul loses that saving a little at a time, and pays for it in steam, in refrigeration, and in effluent, all at once.

The plant layout, in principles

A dairy plant is laid out so that milk flows forward and never flows back: raw milk in at one end, finished product out at the other, with no crossing of the two streams. The principles are short enough to list, and each one prevents a failure the books record:

Plant layout: the principles that prevent failures

Forward flow
Raw milk enters at one end, finished product leaves at the other. Nothing flows backwards.
Raw and processed apart
Raw milk areas and pasteurised areas are separated, with their own equipment, so raw milk can never contaminate finished product.
Drainage falls to the drains
Floors slope to drains, and drains flow away from the process areas, so wash water never pools under the equipment.
Room to clean
Equipment stands clear of walls and floors, so every surface can be reached, cleaned, and checked.
Services close, stores apart
Steam, water, and refrigeration reach the process areas by short runs, while stores and chemicals sit apart from the milk.

Figure 15.2: Plant layout principles: forward flow, separation of raw and processed, and room to clean. Drawn from Dairy Plant Design and Layout.

🤔 Pause and think: a plant loses 200 litres of milk to the drain in a day. How many kilograms of BOD is that, and how many people's daily sewage does it equal? What single habit would cut it fastest?

Quick check

Heating 1,000 kg of milk from 4 °C to 72 °C takes about 265 megajoules with no regeneration. With 90% regeneration, about how much fresh heat is needed, and why?

Check your answer

About 27 megajoules: the outgoing hot milk supplies about 90% of the heating, so fresh steam only lifts the milk the last few degrees, plus the small losses.

15.10 Check yourself: quick self-check

Think about it first: a plant's effluent fails its discharge test for high BOD, although its treatment plant is running. The cheese vat is washed straight to drain every day, whey and all. What is the cheapest fix, and why does it help both the river and the plant's accounts?

  1. A dairy pack must do five jobs. Name them.
Check your answer

Contain the product, protect it from air, light, moisture, and microbes, preserve its quality, inform the customer, and sell it on the shelf.

  1. Why is UHT milk packed aseptically, and what does that give it?
Check your answer

The milk and the pack are sterilised separately and filled together in a sterile zone, so the sealed pack keeps for months without a fridge.

  1. What is BOD, and why is dairy effluent high in it?
Check your answer

Biochemical oxygen demand is the oxygen microbes use up eating waste in water. Dairy effluent carries lactose and protein, which feed microbes fast, so its BOD is high.

  1. What is the best pollution control in a dairy, and why?
Check your answer

Not making the waste in the first place: recovering product before washing and turning whey into products keeps the strongest waste out of the drain altogether.

Try it: Look at five dairy packs in a shop: a milk carton, a milk pouch or bottle, a butter foil, a cheese vacuum pack, and a powder bag. For each one, write down which enemy it is keeping out: light, air, moisture, or microbes. You will find that every pack is an answer to one of those four.

Key ideas to carry forward

  • A dairy plant is a system of departments that must work as one body, laid out so that raw milk and finished product never cross paths.
  • The plant runs on habits: clean hands, aprons and caps, spills cleaned at once, and training in the reasons, not just the steps.
  • A dairy pack must contain, protect, preserve, inform, and sell. Glass, metal, paper, and plastic each do some of those jobs well and others badly, and laminates combine them.
  • Milk is packed cold in pouches, bottles, and cartons, UHT milk aseptically, butter in foil, cheese in wax or vacuum packs, and powder in moisture-proof bags.
  • Aseptic, vacuum, and modified atmosphere packaging extend shelf life without preservatives, by keeping oxygen and microbes out.
  • Dairy effluent is strong waste with a high biochemical oxygen demand, because it carries lactose and protein, and it is treated by screening, biological treatment, and polishing.
  • The best pollution control is not making the waste: recovering product before washing and turning whey into products keeps the strongest waste out of the drain.
  • Energy is saved by regeneration in the pasteuriser and by multiple-effect evaporation, and water is saved by recirculating CIP solutions.

  • Whole milk has a BOD near 100,000 milligrams per litre, about 300 times household sewage, so 100 litres of milk lost to the drain carry about 10 kg of BOD, the daily waste of about 165 people.

  • Heating 1,000 kg of milk from 4 °C to 72 °C takes about 265 megajoules with no regeneration, and about 27 megajoules with 90% regeneration, because the outgoing milk does most of the heating.
  • Plant layout follows forward flow: raw milk in at one end, finished product out at the other, raw and processed areas apart, floors sloping to drains, and room to clean every surface.

Glossary

Effluent

The wastewater leaving a plant from washing, rinsing, and cleaning. Food tech example: dairy effluent carries milk solids and detergent, and it must be treated before discharge.

Biochemical oxygen demand (BOD)

The oxygen microbes use up as they eat waste in water. Food tech example: dairy effluent has a high BOD because its lactose and protein feed microbes fast.

Aseptic packaging

Packaging where the product and the pack are sterilised separately and filled together in a sterile zone. Food tech example: UHT milk in aseptic cartons keeps for months without a fridge.

Vacuum packaging

Packaging where the air is taken out before sealing. Food tech example: cheese in vacuum packs keeps longer because oxygen cannot attack its fat.

Modified atmosphere packaging

Packaging where the air is replaced by a chosen gas mixture. Food tech example: a cheese pack with less oxygen and more carbon dioxide slows microbes and oxidation.

Laminate

A packaging material made of layers of different materials. Food tech example: a milk carton is a laminate of paper, plastic, and foil, which is light, printable, and keeps out air and light.

Regeneration

Using outgoing hot milk to warm incoming cold milk in a pasteuriser. Food tech example: regeneration in the HTST pasteuriser saves a large share of the heating energy.

Multiple-effect evaporation

Reusing the vapour from one evaporator to heat the next. Food tech example: three or four effects let one kilogram of steam evaporate several kilograms of water.

Biological treatment

Treating effluent by letting microbes eat its dissolved lactose and protein in aerated tanks. Food tech example: biological treatment cuts the BOD of dairy effluent sharply before discharge.

Cold chain

Keeping a product cold at every step from plant to shop to home. Food tech example: pasteurised milk is filled cold and kept cold through distribution, or it spoils before its date.

BOD

Biochemical oxygen demand: the oxygen microbes use up as they eat waste in water, in milligrams per litre. Food tech example: whole milk has a BOD near 100,000 milligrams per litre, about 300 times household sewage.

Forward flow

Plant layout in which milk moves in one direction only, from raw intake to finished product, with no stream flowing backwards. Food tech example: forward flow stops raw milk ever meeting finished product on its way through the plant.

References

  • Dairy Plant Management and Pollution Control. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR.
  • Packaging of Dairy Products. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lessons 1-25.
  • Market Milk. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lesson 40.
  • Dairy Plant Design and Layout. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR.
  • Dairy By-Products Technology. Agrimoon e-course, ICAR. Lessons 1-3.