GIFSQ ID: FTN-0100
Cultivated Meat and 3D-Printed Foods
Unit 1: What Cultivated Meat Is: Cells, Culture and Bioreactors
Note
Unit 1: What Cultivated Meat Is: Cells, Culture and Bioreactors
A question to start with
A steak grows on a cow over years, fed on grass and grain, walking a field. Now imagine the same meat, the same muscle cells, grown without the cow, in a steel tank, fed on a liquid rich in sugars, amino acids and vitamins. The cells divide, join into fibres, and form a piece of meat that can be cooked and eaten. That is cultivated meat: real meat, made from animal cells, grown outside the animal. This unit explains what it is, how a few cells become a harvest, what the cells need to grow, and how the tank that grows them works. It is the starting point for the whole subject, and it answers the first question every shopper asks: is it meat?
Is it meat? The cell is the answer
Cultivated meat is meat in the biological sense: it is made of animal muscle cells, the same kind of cells that make up a steak or a chicken breast. A muscle cell from a cow, grown in a tank, is still a cow muscle cell, with the same proteins, the same fats, and the same structure. What is missing is the animal around it: no bones, no skin, no gut, no brain. The meat is grown, not raised, and that difference is the whole idea.
The cells come from a small sample taken from a living animal, usually by a biopsy, a tiny piece of muscle taken with a needle under veterinary care. From that sample, scientists pick out the cells that can grow and divide, mainly muscle stem cells, also called satellite cells, which sit beside muscle fibres and repair them when they are damaged. Those cells are the seed of the whole process: a few thousand cells from a biopsy can, in principle, grow into tonnes of meat, because each cell divides again and again.
The distinction that matters for the shopper is between cultivated meat and plant based meat. A plant based burger is made from pea or soy protein and imitates meat. Cultivated meat is made from animal cells and is meat, with the same proteins and the same nutrition, though its fat, its texture and its flavour depend on how it is grown, as later units explain. The label must make that distinction plain, because a shopper who wants meat and a shopper who avoids meat need opposite information.
The cells: stem cells and what they become
The starting cells are muscle stem cells, which can do two things: they can divide to make more of themselves, and they can turn into muscle fibres, the long cells that contract and give meat its chew. In the body, that turning is called differentiation, and it is guided by signals from the tissue around the cell. In a tank, the maker guides it by changing the liquid the cells grow in, swapping a growth liquid that tells the cells to divide for a differentiation liquid that tells them to join into fibres.
Other cell types matter too. Fat cells give meat its flavour, its juiciness and its marbling, the white streaks in a steak. Connective tissue cells make collagen, the protein that holds muscle together and that turns into gelatine when cooked slowly. A piece of meat that is only muscle fibres will taste lean and dry, like a very lean cut cooked without fat. A good cultivated meat therefore grows more than one cell type, or adds fat made another way, and the balance of muscle, fat and connective tissue is what the maker tunes to copy a cut of meat.
Cells have a limit: they can only divide a certain number of times before they stop, a limit called the Hayflick limit for normal cells. A production process needs cells that keep dividing for many generations, so makers use cells that divide well, and they store them frozen in a cell bank, so that every production run starts from the same young cells. Immortalised cell lines, cells changed so that they divide without limit, are used in research, but their use in food raises questions that a safety authority must answer before they can be sold.
The culture medium: what cells eat
Cells in a tank cannot graze or hunt: they must be fed by the liquid around them, called the culture medium. The medium holds sugars, mainly glucose, for energy, amino acids for building protein, vitamins, minerals, and growth factors, which are signals that tell the cells to divide. The classic medium was built for medical research and used foetal bovine serum, a liquid taken from calf blood, which is dear, variable, and defeats the purpose of making meat without animals. Replacing it has been one of the main technical tasks of the field.
Serum free media replace the serum with a set of known ingredients: a base liquid, a sugar, amino acids, vitamins, minerals, and a small number of growth factors made by fermentation. Each growth factor is a protein that tells the cells to grow, and each one must be made, purified and added in the right amount. The medium is the largest running cost of cultivated meat, often more than half the cost of a batch, so a cheaper medium is the fastest route to a cheaper product, just as a cheaper sugar is the fastest route to a cheaper fermentation protein.
A worked example shows the scale. A tank holds 10,000 litres of medium. If the medium costs 5 per litre, the tank costs 50,000 to fill. If the cells turn that medium into 100 kg of meat, the medium alone costs 500 per kilogram of meat. If a better medium costs 1 per litre, the cost falls to 100 per kilogram. Those numbers are examples, not prices from any one company, and they show why every maker works on the medium first: it is where the money goes, and where the savings are.
The bioreactor: growing cells at scale
The bioreactor for cultivated meat looks like the bioreactor for fermentation, but it works more gently. Animal cells have no tough wall like a yeast cell: they are fragile, and a stirrer that spins too fast will tear them apart. The tank therefore stirs slowly, or uses a different design, such as a tank where the liquid is moved by bubbles of air, or a tank where the cells grow on small beads, called microcarriers, that float in the liquid and give the cells a surface to hold onto.
Animal cells need O₂, a steady temperature near 37 degrees Celsius, the body temperature of most farm animals, and a pH near 7.4, the pH of blood. The tank holds those steady with heaters, with CO₂ gas to control the pH, and with air or O₂ bubbled through the liquid. Waste products, mainly lactic acid and ammonia, build up as the cells grow, and they must be removed or they will slow the cells down. In a large tank, the medium is therefore changed or refreshed during the run, or the run is kept short.
The run follows a pattern. First, the cells are grown in the growth medium, dividing until there are many of them. Then the medium is changed to the differentiation medium, and the cells join into fibres. Then the fibres are harvested, washed, and shaped into a product. A run takes days to weeks, depending on the product, and the harvest is a mass of fibres that must then be given structure, which is the work of Unit 2.
From fibres to food: the first products
The first cultivated meat products to reach shops were not steaks: they were minced and formed products, such as nuggets, burgers and sausages, where the fibres are mixed, shaped and cooked. That choice is practical: a nugget does not need the structure of a steak, only fibres, fat, flavour and a coating. A steak needs fibres lined up in one direction, fat marbled through them, and connective tissue holding them together, and that structure is far harder to grow, which is why whole cuts are still in development.
The harvest is handled like minced meat. The fibres are washed to remove the medium, mixed with fat, salt and flavourings, formed into shapes, and cooked. The fat may be cultivated fat cells, grown in the same way as the muscle, or plant fat, or a mix of the two. The flavour comes from the meat itself, from the fat, and from the cooking, where the Maillard reaction browns the surface and makes the smell of cooked meat. A nugget made this way tastes like chicken because it is chicken, grown from chicken cells.
The scale of the first plants is small. A pilot plant may make kilograms per week, while a meat factory makes tonnes per day. That gap is the challenge of the next decade: larger tanks, cheaper medium, better cells, and a harvest that can be shaped into the foods shoppers buy. The units that follow take each of those challenges in turn, starting with the structure that turns fibres into meat.
Why it matters, and what it does not do
Cultivated meat matters for the same reasons as the rest of this subject: it offers meat without raising and slaughtering an animal, without the land and feed of livestock farming, and without the diseases that can sweep through a herd. It also offers meat that can be made where it is eaten, in a city, in a dry region, or in a place with little farmland, because a tank needs a building, not a field. And it offers meat with a known history: every batch comes from known cells, grown in a known tank, on a known medium.
What it does not do is replace farming at once. It makes meat, not milk, not eggs, not leather, not manure, and it does not keep a rural countryside or a farming family in work. It also needs energy, water, a sterile plant, and a safety file, and its footprint depends on the power source and the medium, just as the footprint of fermentation depends on the sugar and the power. A fair judgement counts the whole chain, from the cells to the shop, and compares it with the whole chain of farmed meat.
The honest summary is this: cultivated meat is real meat, grown from animal cells in a tank, and it is the newest way of making an old food. It is not a copy, it is not a plant, and it is not yet cheap. The rest of this subject explains how it is structured, printed, judged for safety, priced, and received by the shoppers who will decide whether it stays.
The culture medium in numbers: a worked feeding example
A bioreactor is fed by numbers, and the most important number is glucose, the sugar the cells burn for energy. The operator measures the glucose in the medium every few hours, and feeds more when it falls. A worked example shows the arithmetic. A tank holds 10,000 litres of medium with 5 g of glucose per litre, which is 50 kg of glucose in total. If the cells eat 10 kg of glucose a day, the tank runs out in five days, so the operator feeds 10 kg a day to hold the level steady.
The feed must rise as the cells multiply, because more cells eat more sugar. If the cells double every day, the demand doubles too, so the operator raises the feed a little each day, watching the glucose number to check the feed is right. Too little feed starves the cells, and they slow down and stop dividing. Too much feed makes the cells eat fast and make lactic acid, which turns the medium acid and slows them down anyway. The right feed is the one that holds the glucose steady, neither rising nor falling, while the cells keep dividing.
The second number the operator watches is pH, which falls as lactic acid builds up. When the pH falls below its set range, the operator adds a base to neutralise the acid, or changes the medium, or slows the feed so the cells make less acid. The third number is dissolved oxygen, which falls when the cells demand more air than the tank can give. When it falls, the operator raises the stirring or the air flow. The three numbers together are the dashboard of the tank, and the feeding example shows how a maker reads it: glucose tells how much food is left, pH tells whether waste is building up, and oxygen tells whether the cells can breathe.
Questions to think about
- Why is a plant based burger an imitation of meat while cultivated meat is meat, and why must the label make that plain?
- Why is the culture medium often more than half the cost of a batch of cultivated meat?
- Why did the first cultivated products reach shops as nuggets and burgers, not as steaks?
Think about the medium cost question before you read on
The medium holds everything the cells need: glucose, amino acids, vitamins, minerals and growth factors, and it must be made to a high purity, kept sterile, and refreshed during the run. The growth factors are proteins made by fermentation, and they are dear. A tank holds thousands of litres, so the medium for one run costs far more than the cells that started it, and a cheaper medium is the fastest route to a cheaper product.
The diagram shows the cultivated meat chain in order. The cell bank is the master copy, the medium change is the signal that turns dividing cells into muscle fibres, and the shaping step turns fibres into food.
Practical note: In a practical session, compare the structure of three meats: a chicken breast, a beef steak, and a sausage. Cut a small piece of each and pull it apart slowly along its length, noting whether it separates into strands or breaks into crumbs. Then look at the cut surface and note the fat: is it marbled through the meat, or in a layer, or mixed in? Record your observations in a table and answer: which of the three would be hardest to grow in a tank, and why does the steak need more structure than the sausage?
Quick self-check
Question: What is differentiation, and why does a maker change the medium to cause it?
Differentiation is the change where a muscle stem cell stops dividing and joins with others to form a muscle fibre. The maker changes the liquid from a growth medium, which tells cells to divide, to a differentiation medium, which tells them to form fibres.
Question: Why are animal cells harder to grow in a tank than yeast cells?
Because animal cells have no tough wall, so a fast stirrer can tear them apart, and because they need a steady temperature near 37 degrees Celsius, a pH near 7.4, and a complex medium with growth factors. Yeast cells are tougher, grow in a simpler medium, and survive stronger stirring.
Question: A tank holds 10,000 litres at 5 g of glucose per litre, and the cells eat 10 kg a day. How long does the glucose last without feeding?
The tank holds 50 kg of glucose in total, so at 10 kg a day it lasts five days. The operator feeds 10 kg a day to hold the level steady.
Try it yourself
Buy a chicken breast and a pack of chicken nuggets from a shop. Cook both and taste them side by side. Write down the texture of each: does the breast pull apart into strands, and does the nugget? Note the fat, the flavour and the juiciness of each. Then read the ingredient list of the nuggets and write down what holds them together. Answer in writing: if cultivated chicken were sold as nuggets first, would the eater notice a difference, and what would give it away?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Cultivated meat is made of animal muscle cells grown in a tank, so it is meat, not an imitation of meat.
- Muscle stem cells divide to make more cells and then differentiate into muscle fibres when the medium changes.
- Fat cells and connective tissue give meat its flavour, juiciness and marbling, so a good product needs more than muscle alone.
- The culture medium holds sugars, amino acids, vitamins, minerals and growth factors, and it is often the largest cost.
- Animal cells are fragile and need gentle stirring, a temperature near 37 degrees Celsius, and a pH near 7.4.
- The first products are minced and formed foods such as nuggets, because a steak needs a structure that is far harder to grow.
Cultivated meat offers meat without raising an animal, but it still needs energy, water, a sterile plant and a safety file.
Glucose, pH and dissolved oxygen are the dashboard of the tank, and the feed is adjusted to hold them steady.
Glossary
Biopsy
A small piece of tissue taken from a living animal. Food tech example: a muscle biopsy gives the stem cells that start a cultivated meat line.
Cell bank
A frozen store of identical vials of a cell line. Food tech example: every production run of cultivated meat starts from one vial of the cell bank.
Culture medium
The liquid that feeds cells growing in a tank. Food tech example: the culture medium for cultivated meat holds glucose, amino acids and growth factors.
Cultivated meat
Meat made by growing animal cells in a tank. Food tech example: cultivated chicken nuggets are made from chicken muscle cells grown without a bird.
Differentiation
The change where a stem cell stops dividing and becomes a specialised cell. Food tech example: muscle stem cells differentiate into muscle fibres when the medium changes.
Growth factor
A protein signal that tells cells to divide. Food tech example: growth factors in the culture medium tell muscle stem cells to keep dividing.
Microcarrier
A small bead that floats in a tank and gives cells a surface to grow on. Food tech example: muscle cells grow on microcarriers in a large bioreactor.
Muscle stem cell
A cell beside muscle fibres that can divide and become a muscle fibre. Food tech example: muscle stem cells, also called satellite cells, are the seed of cultivated meat.
Satellite cell
Another name for a muscle stem cell. Food tech example: satellite cells repair muscle in the body and are harvested for cultivated meat.
Serum free medium
A culture medium made from known ingredients without animal serum. Food tech example: a serum free medium replaces calf serum with fermentation made growth factors.
Marbling
Streaks of fat running through meat. Food tech example: marbling in a steak gives flavour and juiciness when the meat is cooked.
Maillard reaction
The browning reaction between proteins and sugars when food is heated. Food tech example: the Maillard reaction makes the smell of a grilled cultivated burger.
Hayflick limit
The number of times a normal cell can divide before it stops. Food tech example: a production cell line must divide many times, so the Hayflick limit shapes which cells can be used.
Collagen
The protein that holds muscle together and turns into gelatine when cooked. Food tech example: collagen in connective tissue gives a slow cooked meat its texture.
Foetal bovine serum
A liquid from calf blood once used to feed cells in tanks. Food tech example: foetal bovine serum is being replaced by serum free media in cultivated meat.
Glucose
A sugar that cells burn for energy. Food tech example: glucose in the medium is measured every few hours and fed when it falls.
Lactic acid
A waste product cells make when they eat sugar, which turns the medium acid. Food tech example: lactic acid build up lowers the pH of a cell culture.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 2: Scaffolds and Structure: Making Meat Feel Like Meat
Note
Unit 2: Scaffolds and Structure: Making Meat Feel Like Meat
A question to start with
A pile of muscle fibres is not a steak. It is a pile of fibres, soft, formless, and nothing like the meat on a plate. What turns fibres into meat is structure: fibres lined up in one direction, fat marbled between them, and a network holding them together so that the teeth meet resistance, then yield, then meet fibres pulling apart. In the animal, that structure is built by the body over months. In a tank, it must be built by the maker, and the tool for building it is called a scaffold. This unit explains what scaffolds are, what they are made of, how cells grow on them, and how a maker turns a scaffold full of cells into a cut of meat.
Why meat needs structure
Meat is a structured food. Under a microscope, a piece of muscle shows long fibres bundled together, with fat cells between the bundles and a web of connective tissue around them. The fibres run in one direction, which is why meat has a grain, and why it pulls apart along the grain and resists across it. The fat sits in streaks and pockets, melting as the meat cooks and basting it from inside. The connective tissue, mainly collagen, holds the bundles together and gives the meat its firmness.
That structure decides the eating experience. A steak is firm because its fibres are long, aligned and held tight. A sausage is soft because its meat is minced, so the fibres are short and mixed, and fat and water are held in a gel. A chicken breast is tender because its fibres are fine and its connective tissue is thin. A tough cut, such as shin, is tough because its connective tissue is thick, and it needs slow cooking to turn the collagen into gelatine.
A cultivated meat that ignores structure will fail the mouth even if its chemistry is right. A shapeless mass of fibres tastes like mince that was never formed, soft and uniform, with no grain and no bite. The maker's job is therefore not only to grow cells but to give them a shape, and that shape must survive cooking, slicing and chewing. The scaffold is the tool that does it.
What a scaffold is
A scaffold is a support that cells grow on, giving them a shape to follow. It can be a sponge, a mesh, a sheet, or a set of fibres, and it must do four things. First, it must be safe to eat, or it must be removed before the meat is eaten, because anything left in the food must be food. Second, it must be porous, with holes that let the medium flow through and feed the cells inside, because cells more than a millimetre from the medium will starve. Third, it must be strong enough to hold its shape while the cells grow, but soft enough to chew. Fourth, it must guide the cells: its fibres or pores must run in the direction the meat fibres should run, so the cells line up along it.
Scaffolds are made from materials that are already foods or that the body can break down. Common choices include collagen, the protein of connective tissue; gelatine, made from collagen; alginate, a gelling extract from seaweed; cellulose, the fibre of plants; and textured soy or wheat protein, the same materials used in plant based meat. Each one brings its own behaviour: collagen is familiar to the body and to the mouth, alginate sets into a gel that can be shaped, cellulose is firm and cheap, and textured plant protein already feels fibrous.
A scaffold can be eaten with the meat or removed before eating. An edible scaffold stays in the product and becomes part of its texture, which is simpler, but it must taste right and must be named on the label. A removable scaffold is taken out after the cells have grown and formed their own network, which is cleaner for the label but harder to do without tearing the meat. Most makers today use edible scaffolds, because they are simpler and because they add to the texture rather than taking away from it.
How cells grow on a scaffold
The process starts by seeding the scaffold: the cells are mixed into a liquid and poured or pumped through the scaffold, so that they settle into its pores and stick to its surfaces. The seeded scaffold is then placed in a bioreactor, where medium flows through it, feeding the cells and carrying away waste. The cells divide, fill the pores, and begin to join into fibres along the direction of the scaffold.
Oxygen is the limiting factor. A cell that sits more than a few hundred micrometres from flowing medium will run short of O₂, because O₂ moves slowly through tissue. A thick piece of meat, several centimetres across, cannot be fed by soaking it in medium: the outside will grow and the inside will starve. That is why scaffolds are built with channels, like the blood vessels in an animal, that carry medium deep into the piece. A scaffold with channels can grow a thicker piece than a solid sponge, and the design of those channels is one of the main research problems in the field.
A worked example shows the limit. O₂ moves through tissue at a rate that feeds cells only about 200 micrometres from a source, which is about the width of two human hairs. A steak 2 cm thick is 20,000 micrometres across, or 100 times that distance. Without channels, only the outer skin of the steak would grow, and the centre would die. With channels spaced a few hundred micrometres apart, every cell sits near a flow of medium, and the whole piece can grow. The channel spacing, not the tank size, sets how thick a cultivated steak can be.
From scaffold to steak: shaping and finishing
Once the cells have filled the scaffold and formed fibres, the piece is harvested and finished. Finishing has several steps: the piece is washed to remove the medium, it may be pressed gently to give it the right density, fat is added, either as cultivated fat cells grown beside the muscle or as plant fat marbled into the piece, and the surface is shaped, trimmed and packed. The piece is then chilled or frozen, like any meat, and sent to the shop or the kitchen.
Fat deserves its own note, because it is half the eating experience. A lean piece of cultivated muscle, with no fat, will taste dry and plain, whatever the fibre structure. Makers add fat in one of three ways: they grow fat cells on the same scaffold, they grow fat cells separately and mix them in, or they add a plant fat that melts like animal fat. Each way has a trade off: cultivated fat tastes most like meat fat but costs most to grow, while plant fat is cheap but tastes less like meat. Many makers use a mix, with enough cultivated fat to carry the flavour and enough plant fat to keep the cost down.
Colour and flavour are finished at the same stage. The red colour of raw meat comes from myoglobin, the protein that holds O₂ in muscle, and a cultivated piece must hold enough myoglobin to look red, or it will look pale. The flavour comes from the fat, from the proteins, and from cooking, where the Maillard reaction browns the surface. A piece that looks right, smells right when it cooks, and pulls apart along a grain is a piece that has passed the structure test, and that test is judged by eaters, not by machines alone.
Scaffolds from plants and from the sea
Some of the most promising scaffolds come from plants and from the sea, because they are cheap, edible and easy to shape. A scaffold made from decellularised spinach, a spinach leaf with its cells washed away, leaving only the network of veins, has been used in research to grow muscle cells along the veins, which run like the grain of meat. A scaffold made from cellulose, the fibre of wood or cotton, can be spun into threads that line cells up. A scaffold made from alginate can be printed into a shape with channels built in, which links this unit to Unit 3 on 3D printing.
Each plant scaffold brings a question: does it taste right, does it chew right, and does the label need to name it? Cellulose is fibre, and it adds fibre to the meat, which is a benefit for digestion but a change in texture if too much is used. Alginate is a familiar gelling agent in foods, and it is already named on labels. A spinach scaffold is a novelty, and a shopper may not want to hear that their steak grew on a spinach leaf, even if the leaf is gone and only its shape remains. The label must be honest, and the maker must be ready to explain the scaffold in plain words.
The choice of scaffold also affects cost. A scaffold made from a cheap plant fibre, produced by the tonne, costs far less than a scaffold made from purified collagen, produced by the kilogram. A maker who wants a steak at a price a shopper will pay must choose a scaffold that is cheap, edible, and easy to make at scale, as well as one that guides cells well. That combination, cheap and good, is rare, and it is why scaffold research is one of the busiest parts of the field.
What still needs solving
Three problems still limit cultivated whole cuts. The first is thickness: growing a piece thicker than a few millimetres, with every cell fed, needs channels that work like blood vessels, and no one has yet built a channel system that feeds a thick steak as well as a real animal does. The second is cost: the scaffold, the medium and the time in the tank all cost money, and a steak that takes weeks to grow in a tank will cost more than a steak that grows on a farm, until the process is faster and cheaper.
The third is the eating test. A steak is judged by its bite, its juice, its flavour and its smell, and each of those depends on the balance of muscle, fat and connective tissue, and on how they are arranged. A scaffold that lines fibres up well but holds no fat will taste lean. A scaffold that holds fat well but lines fibres up poorly will taste soft. Getting both right, in the same piece, at a price a shopper will pay, is the work of the next decade.
The progress is real, and it is worth naming. Thin pieces, such as a cultivated chicken fillet a few millimetres thick, have been made and eaten. Minced products, where structure matters less, are already on sale in some markets. Whole cuts are the next step, and each improvement in scaffolds, in channels, and in fat brings them closer. The maker who understands the scaffold understands where the field stands: the cells are ready, the structure is catching up.
Scaffolds from the kitchen and the field
A scaffold does not need to be made in a laboratory. Some of the most useful scaffolds come from the kitchen and the field, and they are edible, cheap and familiar. Alginate, from seaweed, sets into a soft gel that cells can grow on, and it is eaten with the meat. Collagen, from animal tissue, is familiar to the body and to the mouth, and it gives a scaffold that the cells recognise. Cellulose, from plants, is strong and cheap, and it can be shaped into fibres that guide the cells into lines, like the fibres of a steak.
The most striking kitchen scaffold is a decellularised leaf. A spinach leaf is washed with a solution that removes its cells, leaving only the network of veins and the cellulose frame behind. Muscle cells are then seeded onto that frame, and they grow along the veins, which carry medium deep into the piece like blood vessels. The leaf is edible, it is cheap, and it gives the meat a structure that a tank alone cannot. The same idea works with other plant tissues: a leaf, a stem or a piece of fruit, washed clean of its cells, leaves a frame that animal cells can grow on.
Edible scaffolds have a clear advantage: they stay in the food and are eaten with it, so there is no step to remove them, and no waste. Their limit is strength: a soft alginate gel cannot hold a thick steak on its own, and a leaf frame is thin, so it suits thin pieces, such as a slice or a sheet, better than a thick cut. The maker therefore matches the scaffold to the product: a soft gel for a mince, a leaf frame for a thin slice, a strong fibre scaffold for a thicker piece. The scaffold is not a single material. It is a shelf of materials, from the kitchen and the field, each with its own job.
The diagram shows a decellularised leaf scaffold in order. The vein network carries medium deep into the piece, like blood vessels, and the frame is eaten with the meat.
Questions to think about
- Why can a thick steak not be grown by soaking a scaffold in medium, and what must the scaffold hold instead?
- Why must a scaffold be porous, and what happens to cells that sit far from flowing medium?
- A maker can use an edible scaffold or a removable one. What is the trade off between the two choices?
Think about the thickness question before you read on
O₂ moves through tissue only about 200 micrometres, so cells deep inside a thick piece would starve if the scaffold were solid. The scaffold must hold channels, like blood vessels, that carry medium deep into the piece, so every cell sits near a flow of food and O₂. The spacing of those channels, not the size of the tank, sets how thick a cultivated steak can be.
The diagram shows the scaffold route in order. The channels are the key step: without them, only the outside of a thick piece would grow, and the centre would starve.
Practical note: In a practical session, make a simple scaffold from gelatine: dissolve gelatine in hot water, pour it into a shallow tray, and let it set. Then press a fork into it in lines, making grooves that run one way, and lay thin strips of cooked chicken along the grooves. Note how the strips line up and how the gelatine holds them. Then make a second tray without grooves and lay the strips at random. Compare the two: which one pulls apart along a grain, and which one breaks in any direction? Record your observations and answer: what did the grooves do that the flat gelatine did not?
Quick self-check
Question: What four things must a scaffold do?
It must be safe to eat or removable, it must be porous so medium can flow through, it must be strong enough to hold its shape while cells grow, and it must guide the cells so they line up in the direction the meat fibres should run.
Question: Why is fat as important as fibre in a cultivated steak?
Because fat gives flavour, juiciness and marbling, and a lean piece of muscle with no fat tastes dry and plain. A good cultivated meat needs fat cells or added fat beside the muscle fibres, not muscle alone.
Question: Why is a decellularised spinach leaf useful as a scaffold, and what is its limit?
Because washing away the leaf cells leaves a network of veins and a cellulose frame that muscle cells can grow along, and the frame carries medium deep into the piece. Its limit is strength and thickness: it suits thin slices better than a thick steak.
Try it yourself
Buy a beef steak and a beef burger from a shop. Cook both the same way. Cut the steak across the grain and along the grain, noting how it pulls apart in each direction. Then cut the burger the same way and note whether it has a grain at all. Write down the differences in bite, juice and flavour, and answer: which of the two would be harder to grow in a tank, and what structure would the tank need to copy?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Meat is structured: fibres lined up in one direction, fat marbled between them, connective tissue holding them together.
- A scaffold gives growing cells a shape to follow, and it must be safe, porous, strong and guiding.
- O₂ feeds cells only about 200 micrometres from a source, so a thick piece needs channels like blood vessels.
- An edible scaffold stays in the product and adds texture, while a removable scaffold is cleaner for the label but harder to remove.
- Fat gives flavour and juiciness, and a lean piece of muscle alone tastes dry, so fat must be grown or added.
- Plant and sea scaffolds such as cellulose and alginate are cheap and edible, but they must taste right and be labelled honestly.
Thickness, cost and the eating test are the three problems still limiting cultivated whole cuts.
Edible scaffolds from the kitchen and the field, alginate, collagen, cellulose and decellularised leaves, stay in the food and are eaten with it.
Glossary
Scaffold
A support that cells grow on, giving them a shape to follow. Food tech example: a collagen scaffold guides muscle cells into fibres that run one way like a steak.
Alginate
A gelling extract from seaweed used to make scaffolds and to thicken foods. Food tech example: an alginate scaffold can be printed with channels built in.
Cellulose
The fibre of plants, used to make scaffolds and to add fibre to foods. Food tech example: cellulose threads spun into a scaffold line muscle cells up.
Collagen
The protein that holds muscle together and turns into gelatine when cooked. Food tech example: a collagen scaffold is familiar to the body and to the mouth.
Gelatine
A protein made from collagen that sets into a gel. Food tech example: gelatine is used as a scaffold material and to set desserts.
Myoglobin
The protein that holds O₂ in muscle and gives raw meat its red colour. Food tech example: a cultivated steak must hold enough myoglobin to look red.
Microcarrier
A small bead that floats in a tank and gives cells a surface to grow on. Food tech example: muscle cells grow on microcarriers before they are moved to a scaffold.
Seeding
Placing cells onto a scaffold so they settle and stick. Food tech example: seeding pours a liquid of muscle stem cells through a scaffold.
Decellularised
Having the cells washed away, leaving only the structure behind. Food tech example: a decellularised spinach leaf leaves a network of veins used as a scaffold.
Grain
The direction in which meat fibres run. Food tech example: a steak pulls apart along its grain and resists across it.
Marbling
Streaks of fat running through meat. Food tech example: marbling in a steak gives flavour and juiciness when the meat is cooked.
Connective tissue
The network of collagen that holds muscle bundles together. Food tech example: thick connective tissue makes a tough cut that needs slow cooking.
Edible scaffold
A scaffold that stays in the food and is eaten with it. Food tech example: an alginate scaffold is edible and becomes part of the texture of the meat.
Channel
A passage in a scaffold that carries medium deep into a piece. Food tech example: channels in a scaffold act like blood vessels, feeding cells in the centre of a steak.
Decellularised
Having the cells washed away, leaving only the structure behind. Food tech example: a decellularised spinach leaf leaves a network of veins used as a scaffold.
Alginate
A gelling agent from seaweed that sets into a soft gel. Food tech example: an alginate scaffold is edible and becomes part of the texture of the meat.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 3: 3D Food Printing: How It Works and What It Makes
Note
Unit 3: 3D Food Printing: How It Works and What It Makes
A question to start with
A printer on a kitchen counter squeezes chocolate through a nozzle, laying down line after line, layer after layer, until a shape rises that no mould could make: a name, a flower, a tiny house. The same machine, fed with a paste of meat, potato or dough, can print a meal shaped for one person, with the nutrients that person needs, in the shape that person likes. That is 3D food printing: building food layer by layer from a digital design. This unit explains how the machines work, what foods they can print, what the paste must be like, and where printing helps and where an ordinary mould or a knife does the job better.
What 3D printing is, in plain words
3D printing, also called additive manufacturing, builds an object by adding material layer by layer, following a digital design. A normal printer puts ink on paper in a flat layer. A 3D printer puts food paste down in a line, moves a little, puts down another line, and then starts the next layer on top, until the shape is complete. The design is made on a computer, often by drawing the shape or by scanning a real object, and the printer follows the design exactly, line by line.
The idea is old in industry: machines have printed plastic, metal and ceramics layer by layer for decades. Food printing is newer, because food is soft, wet, and changes as it sits, and a paste that prints well at one temperature may collapse at another. The first food printers made simple shapes from chocolate, icing and dough. Today they print meat analogues, pasta, biscuits, and meals for people who need food in a special shape or with special nutrition.
Printing does not replace cooking: it replaces shaping. A printed food still needs to be cooked, chilled or set after printing, and the cooking step is what makes it safe and what gives it flavour. The printer builds the shape, the oven or the fridge finishes the food, and the two steps together make the product. A maker who forgets the second step has a shape, not a meal.
The machines: extrusion, binder and light
Most food printers use extrusion: a paste is pushed through a nozzle by a screw or by air pressure, and the nozzle moves across a plate, laying the paste down in lines. The paste must be thick enough to hold its shape after it leaves the nozzle, but thin enough to flow through it. That balance is the heart of food printing, and it is set by the recipe, not by the machine alone.
A second method uses a binder: a bed of dry powder, such as sugar or starch, is laid down in a thin layer, and a liquid binder is sprayed onto it in the shape of one layer. Another layer of powder follows, and the binder is sprayed again, until the shape is built inside the powder bed. The loose powder is then brushed away, leaving the printed shape. This method makes fine, detailed shapes, such as sugar sculptures, but it suits dry foods better than wet ones.
A third method uses light: a liquid resin that sets when light falls on it is cured layer by layer by a projector or a laser. This method is used for plastics and for some medical printing, and it is rarely used for food, because the resins are not foods and the light can damage nutrients. For food, extrusion is the method that matters, and the rest of this unit is about it.
The paste: what prints well
A printing paste, also called a food ink, must flow when pushed and stand still when left alone. That behaviour has a name: shear thinning. A shear thinning paste is thick in the pot, thin when it is pushed through a nozzle, and thick again the moment it lands, so it holds its shape. Mashed potato, chocolate ganache, cream cheese, hummus and soft dough all behave this way, which is why they print well. Water, milk and oil do not, because they flow and spread, and they cannot hold a shape.
The recipe sets the behaviour. A paste that is too wet will slump, and the layers will merge into a puddle. A paste that is too dry will block the nozzle or break into crumbs. A paste that holds air will print with bubbles and a rough surface. Makers tune the paste with water, with a gelling agent such as gelatine or alginate, with a starch that thickens when heated, and with a fat that sets when cooled. Each change is tested by printing a simple shape, such as a tower, and seeing whether it stands, slumps or cracks.
A worked example shows the test. A maker prints a small cylinder, 3 cm wide and 5 cm tall, from a potato paste. If the cylinder stands for 10 minutes without slumping, the paste is right. If it slumps to half its height, the paste is too wet, and the maker cuts the water by 5 percent and tries again. If the nozzle blocks, the paste is too thick, and the maker adds water by 5 percent. That cycle, print, measure, change, print again, is how a food ink is built, and it is the same cycle a baker uses when a dough is too wet or too dry, applied to a machine.
What printing makes: from chocolate to meat
The foods printed today fall into four groups. The first is decoration: chocolate shapes, sugar sculptures, icing names and cake toppers, where the printer makes a shape that a hand cannot make evenly, and the value is in the look. The second is personalised nutrition: a meal printed for one person, with the protein, the vitamins or the texture that person needs, such as a soft printed meal for an older person who cannot chew, shaped like the food it replaces so that it looks appetising.
The third is meat analogues: a paste of plant protein, fat and flavourings printed in lines that mimic the fibres of meat, with fat printed between them to mimic marbling. A printed steak can place fat exactly where the design says, which a mould cannot do, and that control over fat placement is the real advantage of printing a meat analogue. The fourth is research food: scaffolds and structures printed for cultivated meat, where the printer lays down a scaffold with channels built in, ready for cells to grow on, which links this unit back to Unit 2.
Printing is slow compared with a factory line. A machine that prints one steak in 10 minutes cannot match a line that forms a hundred steaks in a minute, and that speed gap is why printing is used for personalised, decorative and research foods, not for bulk production. The value of printing is not speed: it is control, placing each line of fat, each layer of protein, and each nutrient exactly where the design says, for one person at a time.
A further use is in hospitals and care homes, where meals must be soft enough to swallow safely yet still look like the food they replace. A printed carrot made from a soft carrot paste, or a printed piece of chicken made from a soft chicken paste, lets a person who cannot chew eat a meal that looks like a normal plate of food, rather than a bowl of uniform puree. That dignity, eating a meal that looks like a meal, is a real benefit, and it is one of the reasons hospitals are among the earliest users of food printing, even though the machines are slow and the paste must be made fresh each day.
Printing a steak: the cultivated meat link
The most talked about use of food printing is a printed steak made from cultivated cells. The idea is simple to state and hard to do: print a scaffold with channels, grow muscle cells on it, and print fat cells into the gaps, so the finished piece has fibres, fat and channels in the right places. The printer builds the structure, the cells fill it, and the result is a piece of meat with a designed marbling and a designed shape.
The steps in order are: first, print the scaffold, often from alginate or collagen, with channels running through it. Second, seed the scaffold with muscle cells and place it in a bioreactor, where medium flows through the channels. Third, print or place fat cells into the scaffold, either at the same time or after the muscle has grown. Fourth, harvest the piece, wash it, trim it and cook it. Each step has its own problems, and a failure at any step spoils the piece, which is why a printed cultivated steak is still a research product, not a shop product.
A simpler version is already working: printing a plant based steak, where the paste is a mix of plant protein, fat and flavourings, and the printer lays down fibres of protein paste with lines of fat paste between them. The printed piece is then cooked, and it eats like a steak because its structure copies a steak. That product needs no cells and no bioreactor, only a good paste and a good design, and it is the version of printed meat that shoppers are most likely to meet first.
Limits, safety and the kitchen test
Printing has clear limits. It is slow, it needs a paste that prints well, and the printed food must still be cooked or set, which can change its shape. A printed tower that stands well raw may slump in the oven, and a printed steak that looks right may dry out when it is grilled. The maker must test the whole chain, printing and cooking together, not the printing alone.
Safety needs care too. A printer has a nozzle, a tube and a container that touch the food, and each one must be cleaned between uses, or microbes will grow in the paste left behind. A paste that sits warm in a printer for hours is a risk, because microbes grow fast in warm, wet food, so the paste must be kept cool, used quickly, and the machine must be cleaned on a set schedule. A printer in a restaurant or a hospital must follow the same hygiene rules as any kitchen, and the staff must be trained to follow them.
The kitchen test is the final judge. A printed food must taste good, feel right in the mouth, and look like food, not like a plastic model. A shape that is clever but tastes of nothing will not be eaten twice. The makers who succeed are the ones who start with a food people like, a chocolate, a potato, a steak, and use the printer to make it better, in shape, in nutrition, or in personalisation, rather than starting with the machine and looking for a food to print.
Printing with cultivated cells: the bioink question
A 3D printer can print more than a paste. It can print living cells, in a paste called a bioink, and that is how a cultivated steak may one day be built layer by layer. A bioink holds muscle cells and fat cells in a soft gel, usually alginate or collagen, which flows through the nozzle and then sets, holding the cells in place. The printer lays down muscle lines and fat lines in the pattern of a steak, with the fat marbling running through the muscle, and the printed piece is then kept warm and fed with medium, so the cells grow, join and mature into meat.
The bioink must protect the cells as it prints. The nozzle squeezes the paste, and the squeeze can tear the cells if the pressure is too high or the nozzle is too narrow. The gel must be soft enough to flow and firm enough to hold, and it must let nutrients pass through to the cells after printing, or the cells in the middle will starve. The temperature must stay near body temperature, because the cells die if they are chilled or heated, and the whole printer must be sterile, because a printed piece that is contaminated will spoil before the cells can grow.
The printed piece is not yet meat. It is a shape full of young cells, and it must be matured: kept in medium, fed, and given the signals that tell the cells to become muscle and fat, to join into fibres, and to make the proteins that give meat its bite. Maturation takes days, and the piece must be fed through its whole thickness, which is why printed pieces are still thin. A thick steak needs channels in the print, like blood vessels, to carry medium to the centre, and those channels are printed into the piece as part of the design. The bioink is the beginning of a printed steak, not the end of it.
Questions to think about
- Why must a printing paste be shear thinning, and what happens if it is too wet or too dry?
- A printed steak can place fat exactly where the design says. Why is that control useful, and why can a mould not do the same?
- Why is 3D printing used for personalised and decorative foods rather than for bulk production?
Think about the shear thinning question before you read on
A shear thinning paste is thick when still and thin when pushed, so it flows through the nozzle and then stands still the moment it lands, holding its shape. A paste that is too wet will slump into a puddle, and a paste that is too dry will block the nozzle or break into crumbs. The recipe is tuned until a test shape stands without slumping and without blocking.
The diagram shows extrusion printing in order. The paste is the key: without a paste that holds its shape, the printer makes a puddle, not a food.
Practical note: In a practical session, test three kitchen pastes for printing by hand: mashed potato, soft cream cheese, and a thick chocolate spread. Put each one into a piping bag with a plain nozzle and pipe a small tower, 3 cm wide and 5 cm tall, onto a plate. Time how long each tower stands before it slumps, and note which one holds its shape best. Then thin the best paste with a teaspoon of water and repeat: how much water does it take to make the tower slump? Record your times and your water amounts in a table.
Quick self-check
Question: What is additive manufacturing, and how does it differ from moulding?
Additive manufacturing builds an object by adding material layer by layer from a digital design. Moulding pours material into a fixed shape. Printing can place fat or protein exactly where the design says, while a mould can only copy its own fixed shape.
Question: Why must a printed food still be cooked or set after printing?
Because printing only builds the shape: it does not make the food safe or give it flavour. Cooking kills microbes, sets the structure, and makes the Maillard flavours of a cooked food. A printed shape without cooking is a shape, not a meal.
Question: Why must a bioink be soft enough to flow but firm enough to hold, and what happens to the cells if the nozzle pressure is too high?
Because the gel must flow through the nozzle and then set, holding the cells in the printed pattern, while letting nutrients pass through after printing. Too much pressure tears the cells, so the nozzle and the pressure are set to protect them.
Try it yourself
Use a piping bag, or a strong plastic bag with a corner cut off, to pipe a simple design onto a plate: your name, a flower, or a small house, using mashed potato, icing, or a thick chocolate spread. Take a photo of the design at once and again after 10 minutes: has it slumped, spread, or held its shape? Write down which paste you used, how long the design held, and what you would change in the paste to make it hold longer. Answer in writing: what does your piping test tell you about what a food printer needs from its paste?
Key ideas to carry forward
- 3D food printing builds food layer by layer from a digital design, and it replaces shaping, not cooking.
- Most food printers use extrusion, pushing a paste through a moving nozzle, and the paste must be shear thinning.
- A paste that is too wet slumps into a puddle, and a paste that is too dry blocks the nozzle.
- Printing is used for decoration, personalised nutrition, meat analogues and research scaffolds, not for bulk production.
- A printed steak can place fat exactly where the design says, copying the marbling of real meat.
- A printer must be cleaned between uses, and paste must be kept cool and used quickly, or microbes will grow.
A printed food is judged by taste, texture and look, not by how clever its shape is.
A bioink holds living cells in a soft gel, prints them in the pattern of a steak, and the printed piece must then be matured and fed.
Glossary
Additive manufacturing
Building an object by adding material layer by layer. Food tech example: a 3D printer builds a chocolate shape layer by layer from a digital design.
Binder
A liquid sprayed onto a powder bed to stick one layer to the next. Food tech example: a binder sprayed onto sugar powder builds a sugar sculpture layer by layer.
Extrusion printing
Printing by pushing a paste through a moving nozzle. Food tech example: extrusion printing lays down lines of potato paste to build a shape.
Food ink
A paste made to be printed, also called a printing paste. Food tech example: a mashed potato food ink must flow through a nozzle and then hold its shape.
Shear thinning
Becoming thinner when pushed and thicker when still. Food tech example: a shear thinning paste flows through a printer nozzle and stands still on the plate.
Nozzle
The opening at the end of a printer that the paste is pushed through. Food tech example: a blocked nozzle stops a food printer until it is cleaned.
Personalised nutrition
Food made for one person's needs, such as protein, vitamins or texture. Food tech example: a printed meal for an older person can be soft and shaped like the food it replaces.
Scaffold
A support that cells grow on, giving them a shape to follow. Food tech example: a printed scaffold with channels is ready for muscle cells to grow on.
Alginate
A gelling extract from seaweed used to make scaffolds and to thicken foods. Food tech example: an alginate scaffold can be printed with channels built in.
Gelatine
A protein made from collagen that sets into a gel. Food tech example: gelatine is used to tune a printing paste so it holds its shape.
Digital design
A shape drawn on a computer that a printer follows. Food tech example: the digital design tells the printer where to place each line of fat in a printed steak.
Hygiene
The cleaning and handling rules that keep food safe. Food tech example: a food printer must be cleaned between uses so microbes do not grow in leftover paste.
Bioink
A paste holding living cells in a gel, printed layer by layer. Food tech example: a bioink prints muscle and fat cells in the pattern of a steak.
Maturation
Growing and changing young cells into mature muscle and fat after printing. Food tech example: a printed piece is matured in medium so its cells join into fibres.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 4: Nutrition and Safety of Cultivated Foods
Note
Unit 4: Nutrition and Safety of Cultivated Foods
A question to start with
A shopper holds a pack of cultivated chicken nuggets and asks the two questions that matter most: is it good for me, and is it safe? The answers are not slogans. They are measurements: the protein, the fat, the iron, the salt, the microbes, and the tests that prove the numbers. This unit explains how the nutrition of cultivated meat compares with farmed meat, what can be tuned and what cannot, how safety is tested before sale, and how a factory keeps every batch safe. By the end, you should be able to read a cultivated meat label and judge it the same way you would judge any meat label.
What is in cultivated meat
Cultivated meat is made of animal cells, so its basic composition is close to farmed meat: protein, fat, water, minerals and vitamins, in amounts that depend on the cell types and the fat. Muscle cells hold protein, mainly myosin and actin, the same proteins that give farmed meat its structure and its nutrition. Fat cells hold fat, mainly triglycerides, the same fats that give farmed meat its flavour and its energy. The amounts can be tuned: a maker who grows more fat cells makes a fattier product, and a maker who grows fewer makes a leaner one.
The amino acid pattern of cultivated muscle protein is the same as that of farmed muscle, because the cells make the same proteins. That means the protein quality is the same: all nine essential amino acids are present in useful amounts, and the protein is well digested. Iron is present in muscle cells, held in myoglobin and in other proteins, and its amount depends on how much myoglobin the cells make, which the maker can raise by growing the cells with more iron in the medium. Vitamin B12, which animals make with the help of gut microbes, is not made by muscle cells alone, so a cultivated meat may need B12 added, or the medium must supply it.
A worked example shows the comparison. A 100 g serving of farmed chicken breast holds about 31 g of protein, about 3.6 g of fat, and about 1 mg of iron. A 100 g serving of cultivated chicken, made from the same cells with a similar fat level, would hold a similar amount of protein and a similar amount of iron, if the cells were grown to the same maturity. The numbers will not match exactly, because the fat level, the iron level and the water content are set by the process, but the order of size is the same, and that is the point: cultivated meat is nutritionally meat, not a copy of meat.
Tuning nutrition: what can be changed
One advantage of growing meat in a tank is that the maker can tune its nutrition in ways a farmer cannot. The fat can be tuned: the maker can grow fat cells that hold more unsaturated fat and less saturated fat, by changing the fats in the medium, so the finished meat carries a healthier fat pattern than a farmed cut. The iron can be tuned by adding iron to the medium. The salt can be set exactly in the forming step, rather than depending on the animal's diet. And nutrients that meat lacks, such as fibre or vitamin C, can be added in the forming step, though adding them changes the product and must be named on the label.
There are limits to tuning. A muscle cell makes the proteins it is built to make, and a maker cannot ask it to make a vitamin it does not make. A fat cell stores the fats it is fed, but it also makes its own fats, so the final fat pattern is a mix of the two. And a change that improves nutrition can harm eating quality: a very lean cultivated meat, with little fat, will taste dry, whatever its protein, and a meat with too much added iron can taste metallic. The maker balances nutrition against taste, and the taste panel is the judge.
The honest claim for cultivated meat is not that it is healthier than farmed meat in every way, but that its nutrition can be set and measured, batch by batch, and that its fat and its micronutrients can be tuned. A maker who claims a healthier fat pattern must measure it and print the numbers, and a shopper who reads the label can check the claim. That is the same rule as for every food in this subject: say what you measured, show the numbers, and do not say more.
Safety testing: the file before sale
A cultivated meat cannot be sold until a food safety authority has read its safety file and accepted it. The file starts with the cells: which animal, which tissue, which cell type, how the cells were taken, and whether they were changed in any way. It then covers the medium: every ingredient in it, where it came from, and whether any trace of it remains in the finished meat. It covers the process: the tanks, the scaffold, the shaping, and the checks at each step. And it covers the finished product: its composition, its microbes, and its shelf life.
The tests on the finished product are the same kinds of tests used for farmed meat. Microbial tests count bacteria and check for specific pathogens, such as Salmonella and Listeria, which must be absent. Chemical tests check for heavy metals, for residues from the medium, and for any substance used in the process that should not remain. Allergy tests check whether the product carries the allergens of the animal it came from: a cultivated chicken product can trigger a chicken allergy, because the proteins are the same, and the label must say so.
Feeding studies are part of the file in many countries: animals are fed the cultivated meat for weeks or months and watched for any harmful effect. The doses are set far above what a person would eat, so that any risk would show up in the animals first. The authority reads the whole file, asks questions, and may ask for more tests. Only when the file is accepted can the product be sold, and the exact procedure differs by country, so a maker must satisfy each authority where the product will be sold.
Microbes: why a tank can be safer, and where it can fail
A cultivated meat plant has one safety advantage over a farm: there is no gut, no hide, and no slaughter, which are the main sources of microbes on farmed meat. The cells grow in a sterile tank, the medium is sterile, and the harvest is handled in a clean room, so the starting microbial load can be very low. That is a real advantage, and it is why cultivated meat can have a long shelf life when it is handled well.
The advantage can fail in three ways. First, contamination: a single bacterium or mould spore that gets into a tank can grow in the warm, rich medium and spoil a whole run, and the run must be discarded. Second, the forming step: once the meat leaves the sterile tank and is mixed, shaped and packed, it meets the ordinary factory environment, and the same hygiene rules as any meat factory apply. Third, the cold chain: cultivated meat is perishable, like any meat, and it must be chilled from the factory to the shop to the home, or microbes will grow.
The factory manages these risks with the same system used across the food industry: HACCP, hazard analysis and critical control points. The sterilisation of the tank, the filtration of the medium, the temperature of the cold store, and the cleaning of the forming line are all critical control points, each with a limit, a check, and a written action if the limit is missed. Samples from each batch are tested for microbes before the batch is released, and the batch number traces the meat back to the cells, the tank and the medium.
Allergy, labelling and the shopper
A cultivated meat carries the allergens of the animal it came from. A person allergic to chicken can react to cultivated chicken, because the proteins are the same. A person allergic to beef can react to cultivated beef. The label must name the animal plainly, and the allergen statement must name it too, so that an allergic shopper can avoid it. A product that hides the animal behind a vague name would put that shopper at risk.
The name of the product is still being settled in many countries. Some makers call it cultivated meat, some call it cell based meat, and some call it cultured meat. The rules differ by country, and a maker must use the name that the authority in each market accepts. What does not change is the need for honesty: the name must tell the shopper that the meat was grown from cells in a tank, not raised on a farm, and it must not suggest something the product is not.
The nutrition label for cultivated meat looks like the label for farmed meat: protein, fat, saturated fat, salt and energy per 100 g, plus the ingredient list. The shopper can compare a cultivated burger with a beef burger per 100 g, using the same column, and can judge the protein, the fat and the salt on the numbers. That comparison is the shopper's best tool, and it is the same tool this subject has taught for every food: read the back, compare per 100 g, and check the allergens.
Shelf life and the home kitchen
Cultivated meat keeps like farmed meat: it is perishable, it must be chilled, and it must be cooked before eating. The shelf life is set by testing: samples are stored at the right temperature and tested over days for microbes, for smell, for colour and for taste, until the day when the product is no longer acceptable. That day sets the use by date on the pack, and the maker must prove it with the test data, not guess it.
Cooking is a safety step as well as a flavour step. Minced and formed products, such as burgers and nuggets, must be cooked through to the centre, usually to at least 70 degrees Celsius, because mincing mixes any microbes through the product. A whole cut, such as a steak, is cooked like a farmed steak, with the outside seared and the inside cooked to the eater's taste, though the maker must still give clear cooking guidance on the pack, because the product is new and the eater may not know how it behaves.
The home kitchen needs the same habits as for any meat: keep it chilled, do not leave it warm on a counter, wash hands and boards after handling it raw, and cook it through. A cultivated meat that is handled well is as safe as a farmed meat handled well, and a cultivated meat handled badly is as risky as a farmed meat handled badly. The technology changes where the meat comes from, not how it must be treated in the kitchen.
Iron and vitamin B12: a worked comparison
Two nutrients matter most when cultivated meat is compared with plant foods: iron and vitamin B12. Iron carries oxygen in the blood, and the iron in meat is absorbed far better than the iron in plants, because meat iron is held in a form the gut takes up easily, while plant iron is held by fibre and by other substances that block it. Vitamin B12 is made only by microbes, and it is found in animal foods, not in plants, so a diet without animal foods must get it from a supplement or a fortified food.
A worked example shows the comparison. A 100 g piece of meat holds about 3 mg of iron, and the body absorbs about a quarter of it, which is about 0.75 mg. A 100 g serving of lentils holds about 3 mg of iron too, but the body absorbs only about a tenth of it, which is about 0.3 mg. The two foods hold the same iron on paper, but the meat gives the body more than twice as much. A cultivated meat holds the same iron as meat from an animal, because it is made of the same cells, so it gives the same absorbed iron, and the maker can test that by measuring the iron and by testing how much is absorbed.
Vitamin B12 is a sharper test. A 100 g piece of meat holds enough B12 for a day, while a plant food holds none. A cultivated meat must therefore be tested for B12: if the cells make it, or if it is added to the medium, the meat will carry it, and the label can say so. If the cells do not make it and it is not added, the meat will carry none, and the label must not claim it. The nutrition of cultivated meat is not automatic. It is decided by the cells, the medium and the tests, and the maker who tests both nutrients can prove the claim, while the maker who does not is guessing.
Questions to think about
- Why can a cultivated chicken product trigger a chicken allergy, even though no chicken was raised?
- A tank has no gut, hide or slaughter, so why can cultivated meat still carry microbes, and where do they enter?
- Why must a minced cultivated burger be cooked through to the centre, while a whole steak can be cooked to taste?
Think about the allergy question before you read on
Allergy is a reaction to a protein molecule, and the proteins in cultivated chicken are the same molecules as the proteins in farmed chicken, with the same amino acids in the same order. The body reacts to the molecule, not to the farm, so a person allergic to chicken can react to cultivated chicken, and the label must name chicken plainly.
The diagram shows the safety testing chain in order. The authority sees the file before the food reaches the shop, and the label must name the animal and its allergen plainly.
Practical note: In a practical session, compare the labels of three minced meat products: a beef burger, a chicken burger, and a plant based burger. For each one, write down the protein, fat, saturated fat, salt and iron per 100 g, and the allergens named. Work out which product gives the most protein per 100 g and which gives the least saturated fat. Then answer: if a cultivated beef burger were on the shelf, which numbers would you expect to match the beef burger, and which numbers might the maker have tuned?
Quick self-check
Question: Why is the fat pattern of cultivated meat tunable in a way farmed meat is not?
Because the maker sets the fats in the medium that the fat cells are fed, so the cells store more unsaturated fat and less saturated fat. A farmer can change an animal's feed too, but far less precisely, and the animal's own metabolism sets limits the tank does not have.
Question: What is HACCP, and what does a critical control point do in a cultivated meat plant?
HACCP is a system that maps every step, names the hazards, and sets a control for each one. A critical control point is a step where control is essential, such as steam sterilisation of a tank, with a limit, a check, and a written action if the limit is missed.
Question: A piece of meat and a serving of lentils both hold 3 mg of iron, but the body absorbs a quarter of the meat iron and a tenth of the lentil iron. How much does the body get from each?
From the meat, 3 times 0.25, which is about 0.75 mg. From the lentils, 3 times 0.10, which is about 0.3 mg, so the meat gives more than twice as much absorbed iron.
Try it yourself
Buy a pack of minced meat and a pack of formed meat, such as burgers or nuggets, from a shop. Read the cooking guidance on each pack and write down the temperature or the time it asks for. Cook both as directed, using a food thermometer if you have one, and note the temperature at the centre when you take them off the heat. Write down whether the guidance was easy to follow and whether the cooked product matched what the pack promised. Answer in writing: what cooking guidance would a cultivated burger need on its pack, and why would it be the same as the guidance for a farmed burger?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Cultivated meat holds the same muscle proteins as farmed meat, so its protein quality and amino acid pattern match.
- The fat pattern, the iron level and the salt can be tuned by changing the medium and the forming step.
- A safety file covers the cells, the medium, the process, the finished product, allergy and feeding studies.
- A tank has no gut, hide or slaughter, so the starting microbial load can be low, but contamination and the forming step can still bring microbes in.
- A cultivated meat carries the allergens of the animal it came from, and the label must name the animal plainly.
- Cultivated meat is perishable, must be chilled, and minced products must be cooked through to the centre.
The shopper judges a cultivated meat by the same label as a farmed meat: protein, fat, salt and allergens per 100 g.
Iron in meat is absorbed far better than iron in plants, and vitamin B12 is found in animal foods, not in plants, so both must be tested in cultivated meat.
Glossary
Myosin
A main muscle protein that shrinks when meat is cooked. Food tech example: myosin in cultivated muscle gives the meat its chew and its protein.
Actin
A muscle protein that works with myosin in meat. Food tech example: actin and myosin together form the fibres of cultivated muscle.
Myoglobin
The protein that holds O₂ in muscle and gives raw meat its red colour. Food tech example: iron in myoglobin is part of the iron in cultivated meat.
Triglyceride
The main form of fat in meat and in the body. Food tech example: fat cells in cultivated meat store triglycerides that melt when the meat is cooked.
Vitamin B12
A vitamin found in animal foods, not made by muscle cells alone. Food tech example: a cultivated meat may need vitamin B12 added, because muscle cells do not make it.
HACCP
Hazard analysis and critical control points, a system that maps hazards and sets controls. Food tech example: steam sterilisation of a tank is a critical control point in a cultivated meat plant.
Critical control point
A step where control is essential for safety. Food tech example: the temperature of the cold store is a critical control point for cultivated meat.
Salmonella
A bacterium that can cause food poisoning and must be absent from meat. Food tech example: each batch of cultivated meat is tested for Salmonella before release.
Listeria
A bacterium that grows in chilled foods and must be absent from meat. Food tech example: a cultivated meat plant tests for Listeria on its forming line.
Use by date
The date on a pack after which a perishable food should not be eaten. Food tech example: the use by date on cultivated meat is set by shelf life testing.
Cold chain
The chain of chilled storage and transport from factory to home. Food tech example: cultivated meat must stay chilled through the cold chain or microbes will grow.
Saturated fat
A type of fat that is solid at room temperature. Food tech example: tuning the medium can lower the saturated fat in cultivated meat.
Allergen
A food that can trigger an allergic reaction in some people. Food tech example: cultivated chicken is an allergen for people allergic to chicken.
Feeding study
A study where laboratory animals are fed a new food to look for harmful effects. Food tech example: a cultivated meat is fed to animals for weeks before it is accepted for sale.
Absorption
How much of a nutrient the body takes up from a food. Food tech example: iron from meat is absorbed far better than iron from lentils.
Vitamin B12
A vitamin found in animal foods and not in plants. Food tech example: cultivated meat must be tested for vitamin B12 before the label can claim it.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 5: Regulation Around the World: General Principles
Note
Unit 5: Regulation Around the World: General Principles
A question to start with
A cultivated chicken nugget is on sale in one country, under review in a second, and not yet allowed in a third. A 3D printed steak is a research product in one place and a restaurant dish in another. Why do countries decide differently about the same food, and what do they all ask before they say yes? This unit explains the general principles that every food safety system shares, how the systems differ, what a maker must prove, and what the shopper should look for on a label. It describes general principles only: no single country's rule is presented as the world's rule, and the reader is told to check the current rule in their own country.
Why new foods need approval
A food that people have eaten for generations needs no approval: its safety is shown by its history. A food that is new, made by a new process, or made from a new source, has no such history, so a food safety authority must judge it before it is sold. Cultivated meat is new in all three ways: the cells are grown in a tank, the process is new, and the food has no long history of eating. A 3D printed food may be new in its shape or its recipe, but if its ingredients are familiar and its process is cooking, it may need less review. The authority decides how much review a food needs by asking how new it is and how much is already known about it.
The purpose of approval is not to slow down new foods: it is to make sure that a food on sale is safe, that it is what its label says it is, and that the shopper is not misled. A maker who welcomes that check, and who builds the file to answer it, will reach the shop sooner than a maker who treats the authority as an obstacle. The history of every food technology, from pasteurised milk to fermentation made chymosin, shows the same pattern: the products that were tested openly and labelled plainly are the ones that stayed.
The authority that decides is a public body in each country, staffed by scientists who read the file, ask questions, and may ask for more tests. The maker pays for the tests, because the maker profits from the sale, and the authority judges the results. That separation, maker tests, authority judges, is the core of the system, and it is the same in every country, whatever the authority is called.
What the file must prove
The safety file for cultivated meat must prove five things. First, the cells: which animal, which tissue, which cell type, how the cells were taken, whether they were changed, and whether any change could make them unsafe. Second, the inputs: every ingredient in the medium, in the scaffold, and in the forming step, where each one came from, and whether any trace remains in the finished meat. Third, the process: the tanks, the sterilisation, the harvest, the shaping, and the checks at each step.
Fourth, the finished product: its composition, its protein, fat, water and minerals, its microbes, its shelf life, and whether it matches the farmed meat it claims to be. Fifth, the eater: allergy, because the proteins are the same as the animal's proteins, and intake, how much people will eat and how that compares with the doses tested in animals. A file that answers all five, with measurements, is a file that can be judged. A file that answers three and asserts the other two is a file that will be sent back.
For 3D printed foods, the file is usually simpler, because the ingredients are often familiar foods and the printing is a shaping step, not a new biology. The questions then are about the paste, the machine, and the hygiene: is the paste safe, is the printer cleaned, is the printed food cooked properly, and does the label name the ingredients? A printed food made from a new ingredient, such as a new protein or a new fat, needs the full file for that ingredient, just as any new ingredient does.
How systems differ: the same questions, different routes
Countries ask the same core questions but answer them through different procedures. In some systems, the maker sends a full file before sale, the authority reads it, and the product may be sold only when the authority says yes. In other systems, the maker notifies the authority, the authority has a set time to object, and the product may be sold if no objection is raised. In still others, the product is judged under an existing law for new foods, with a set list of tests and a set timetable. The differences are procedural, not scientific: the tests are the same, and a product that fails a safety test in one country will fail it in another.
The first approvals for cultivated meat came in the early 2020s, in a small number of countries, and each approval covered one product from one maker, not cultivated meat in general. That is an important point: an approval is given to a product, made by a process, in a plant, not to an idea. A second maker, with a different cell line, a different medium or a different plant, must send its own file and win its own approval. A shopper who hears that cultivated meat is approved in one country should ask which product, from which maker, and under what conditions, because the approval is specific, not general.
The pace of approvals differs because authorities differ in staff, in law, and in how they weigh a new technology. Some move quickly when the file is strong. Some move slowly because their law was written before the technology existed and must be updated first. Neither speed is a judgement on the food itself: a slow approval can mean a careful authority, and a fast approval can mean a strong file. The reader who needs the current position in their own country should check the food safety authority of that country, because the position changes as new files are decided.
Names and labels: what the pack must say
The name of a cultivated meat product is still being settled, and different countries have accepted different names. The names in use include cultivated meat, cultured meat, cell based meat and cell cultivated meat. Each one tries to tell the shopper the same fact in different words: this meat was grown from cells in a tank. The authority in each country decides which names it will accept, and a maker who sells in several countries may need different names on different packs. The shopper's task is to read the name and the ingredient list together, so that the words on the front and the facts on the back agree.
The label must name the animal, the allergen, the ingredients in order of weight, and the nutrition per 100 g, just as a farmed meat label does. It must also give cooking guidance, storage guidance, and a use by date set by shelf life testing. It must not suggest something the product is not: a cultivated chicken nugget cannot be sold as if it were farmed chicken, and a printed steak cannot be sold as if it were cut from an animal. The front of the pack must be honest about the newness, because a shopper who feels misled will not buy again, and a category that misleads its first buyers will not survive.
Claims about the planet follow the same rule as in the rest of this subject: a claim must be backed by a life cycle assessment of the whole product, counting the cells, the medium, the plant, the packaging and the transport, and compared with the same chain for farmed meat. A claim of lower carbon, less land or less water, without numbers, is not a claim a careful maker should print. The direction of the law in many countries is clear: say what you measured, show the numbers, and do not say more.
The factory after approval: inspection never stops
Approval is not a one off event: it is the start of a routine of inspection that runs for as long as the factory operates. Inspectors visit the plant, read the records, watch the process, and take samples for testing. The plant must keep its HACCP system running, with critical control points for sterilisation, for medium filtration, for cold storage and for cleaning, each with a limit, a check and a written action if the limit is missed. A plant that passes its approval and then lets its controls slip will lose its right to sell.
Traceability runs through the whole system. Each batch of cultivated meat carries a number that links it to the cell bank vial, the tank, the medium lots, the scaffold lot, the date and the people who ran it. Each batch of finished food that uses it carries its own number, linked back to the meat batch. If a problem appears, the maker can find every food that used the faulty batch, recall it, and prove that the next batch is sound. That chain, from vial to tank to food to shop, is what makes a new food trustworthy after the day it is approved.
The same routine applies to a 3D printing operation, at its own scale. A restaurant printer must be cleaned on a set schedule, its paste must be kept cool and used quickly, and its staff must be trained in hygiene. A factory printer must follow the same HACCP rules as any food line. The technology is new, but the discipline is old: clean, measure, record, and check, every day, without exception.
What the shopper should do
The shopper's part in regulation is simple and powerful: read the label, ask what the food is, and judge the claim against the numbers. A shopper who picks up a cultivated meat product should check the animal named, the allergen, the protein and fat per 100 g, and the cooking guidance, and should compare those numbers with the farmed meat the product replaces. A shopper who picks up a printed food should check the ingredient list and ask whether the shape is the only new thing, or whether the ingredients are new too.
The shopper should also know where to check the current rule. The food safety authority of their own country publishes its decisions, its approved products, and its labelling rules, and those publications are the source to trust, not a headline or a social media post. Rules change as new files are decided, and a rule that was true last year may have been revised. A shopper who checks the authority's own publication is a shopper who knows the current rule.
The wider lesson of this unit is that regulation is not a barrier to new food: it is the reason new food can be trusted. A product that has passed its tests, that is inspected, that is traced batch by batch, and that is labelled plainly, is a product a shopper can buy with confidence. A product that has skipped those steps is a product a shopper should avoid, whatever its claims. That rule holds for cultivated meat, for printed food, and for every food that follows them.
Reading an approval: what to look for
An approval is a public decision, and a reader can learn to read it. The approval names the product exactly: which cells, which medium, which process, which plant and which finished food were judged. It names the evidence: the tests for microbes, for chemicals, for allergy and for feeding studies, and the results of each. It names the conditions: how the food must be made, how it must be labelled, and what must be checked after sale. A reader who finds those three things, the product, the evidence and the conditions, has read the approval properly.
The approval also names what it did not judge. An approval for a cultivated chicken nugget does not approve a cultivated steak, even from the same maker, because the product, the process and the tests are different. An approval for one maker's cells does not approve another maker's cells, even if the meat looks the same, because the cell line, the medium and the plant are different. An approval that is read as a blanket permission for all cultivated meat is being misread, and the misreading is the most common mistake a reader makes.
The last thing to look for is the date and the review. An approval is a snapshot: it judges the evidence as it stood on the day it was made, and it can be reviewed if new evidence appears. A product that was approved five years ago may be made differently today, and the maker must show that the change does not alter the safety. The reader should check the date, check whether the product on the shelf matches the product in the approval, and check the label, because the label is the part of the approval the shopper sees every day.
The diagram shows the approval path in order. An approval judges a specific product, and a different product needs its own file and its own decision.
Questions to think about
- Why is an approval given to one product from one maker, not to cultivated meat in general?
- A country approves a cultivated chicken nugget quickly and a cultivated steak slowly. Does the speed tell you which food is safer, and why?
- Why must a cultivated meat label name the animal, even though no animal was raised?
Think about the approval question before you read on
An approval judges a specific file: specific cells, a specific medium, a specific process, a specific plant, and a specific finished product, all tested together. A second maker with different cells, a different medium or a different plant has a different file, and its product must be judged on its own evidence. The approval is specific because the evidence is specific.
The diagram shows the approval chain in order. Approval is given to one product from one maker, not to the idea in general, and inspection and traceability run for as long as the plant operates.
Practical note: In a practical session, pick a food safety authority's public website for your own country and find its page on new foods or novel foods. Write down the name of the authority, the name of the approval process, and one product it has approved or is reviewing. Then compare that with the same page for a second country, if you can find it, and note one difference in procedure and one question both countries ask. Present your findings as a short table and note the date you checked, because the position changes as new files are decided.
Quick self-check
Question: Why does a new food need approval while a traditional food does not?
Because a traditional food has a long history of eating that shows it is safe, while a new food, made by a new process or from a new source, has no such history, so a food safety authority must judge its file before it is sold.
Question: What five things must a cultivated meat safety file prove?
The cells, the inputs in the medium and the scaffold, the process and its checks, the finished product and its microbes and shelf life, and the eater: allergy and intake. A file that answers all five with measurements can be judged; a file that asserts any of them will be sent back.
Question: Why does an approval for a cultivated chicken nugget not approve a cultivated steak from the same maker?
Because the approval judges a specific product: specific cells, a specific medium, a specific process and a specific finished food, all tested together. A steak is a different product, so it needs its own file and its own decision.
Try it yourself
Go to a shop and pick up a food that is new to you: a plant based meat, a dairy free cheese, or a protein bar with an unfamiliar ingredient. Read its label and write down the name of the food, the first three ingredients, the allergens named, and any claim on the front. Then search for the food safety authority in your country and check whether that type of food needs approval before sale, and what the labelling rule says about its name. Write one paragraph: does the label follow the rule you found, and what would you change if it does not?
Key ideas to carry forward
- A new food needs approval because it has no long history of eating to prove it is safe.
- A safety file must prove the cells, the inputs, the process, the finished product, and the eater: allergy and intake.
- Countries ask the same core questions but differ in procedure and timing, and no single country's rule is the world's rule.
- An approval is given to one product from one maker, not to cultivated meat in general.
- Labels must name the animal, the allergen, the ingredients, the nutrition per 100 g, and the cooking guidance.
- Planet claims must be backed by a life cycle assessment of the whole product, not only of the tank.
Inspection and traceability run for as long as the plant operates, and the shopper checks the label and the authority's own publications.
An approval names the product, the evidence and the conditions, and it judges one specific product, not all cultivated meat.
Glossary
Novel food
A food or ingredient that has not been eaten widely before and needs approval. Food tech example: cultivated meat is treated as a novel food in many countries.
Food safety authority
The body in a country that judges whether a new food is safe. Food tech example: the maker sends the safety file to the food safety authority before sale.
Dossier
The set of documents sent to a food safety authority before a new ingredient is sold. Food tech example: the dossier for a cultivated meat holds cells, inputs, process and feeding studies.
HACCP
Hazard analysis and critical control points, a system that maps hazards and sets controls. Food tech example: steam sterilisation of a tank is a critical control point in a HACCP plan.
Critical control point
A step where control is essential for safety. Food tech example: filtration of the medium is a critical control point in a cultivated meat plant.
Traceability
The ability to follow a batch back to its cells, tank, feed and date. Food tech example: a batch number traces a cultivated burger to the tank it grew in.
Allergen
A food that can trigger an allergic reaction in some people. Food tech example: cultivated beef is an allergen for people allergic to beef.
Feeding study
A study where laboratory animals are fed a new food to look for harmful effects. Food tech example: a cultivated meat is fed to animals for weeks before it is accepted for sale.
Life cycle assessment
A method that adds up the land, water, energy and gas releases of a product across its whole life. Food tech example: a lower carbon claim for cultivated meat must be backed by a life cycle assessment.
Cell based meat
Another name for cultivated meat, meat grown from cells. Food tech example: cell based meat is one of the names used on packs in some countries.
Cultured meat
Another name for cultivated meat. Food tech example: cultured meat is a name used in older writing about meat grown in tanks.
Use by date
The date on a pack after which a perishable food should not be eaten. Food tech example: the use by date on cultivated meat is set by shelf life testing.
Intake
How much of a food people eat each day. Food tech example: the safety file estimates the intake of cultivated meat to compare it with the doses tested in animals.
Approval
A decision by a food safety authority that a new food may be sold. Food tech example: an approval names the exact product, evidence and conditions.
Feeding study
A study where laboratory animals eat a new food to test its safety. Food tech example: a feeding study is part of the safety file for cultivated meat.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 6: Cost, Scale and the Future
Note
Unit 6: Cost, Scale and the Future
A question to start with
The first cultivated burger cost more than a car to make. The first plant printed steak took hours to build. Today the costs are far lower, and still far higher than the foods they replace. The question behind this unit is the one that decides whether cultivated meat and printed food stay as demonstrations or become dinner: what does it cost, what drives the cost down, and how large must the industry grow before the price meets the shopper? The answers are about tanks, medium, energy, learning, and time, and they are the same kinds of answers that every new food technology has had to give.
What cultivated meat costs
The cost of cultivated meat has four parts, and the medium is the largest. The medium holds the sugars, amino acids, vitamins, minerals and growth factors that feed the cells, and a tank holds thousands of litres of it. The growth factors are the dearest part of the medium, because they are proteins made by fermentation and purified, and a small amount costs a large amount of money. A cheaper medium, with fewer growth factors or with growth factors made more cheaply, is the fastest route to a cheaper product.
The second part is the capital cost: the tanks, the clean rooms, the filters, the shaping machines and the plant itself, spread across the tonnes made over the life of the plant. A plant that makes a few tonnes a year carries a large capital cost per kilogram, while a plant that makes thousands of tonnes carries a small one. The third part is the running cost: power for heating, cooling, stirring and air, water, cleaning, labour and maintenance. The fourth part is the cost of harvest and shaping: washing the cells, mixing them with fat, forming them, and packing them.
A worked example shows the arithmetic. A tank holds 10,000 litres of medium. If the medium costs 2 per litre, the tank costs 20,000 to fill. If the cells turn that medium into 100 kg of meat, the medium alone costs 200 per kilogram of meat. If a better medium costs 0.50 per litre, the cost falls to 50 per kilogram. Those numbers are examples, not prices from any one company, and they show why the medium is where the money goes and where the savings are. The same arithmetic, with different numbers, applies to every maker.
How cost falls: better cells, cheaper medium, larger tanks
Cost falls in three ways, and each one is being worked on. First, better cells: a cell line that divides faster, that makes more protein per litre, and that needs fewer growth factors will cut the cost of every run. Cell lines are improved by picking the best cells from a biopsy, by growing them for many generations and keeping the fastest, and by changing the medium so that the cells need less of the dearest ingredients. Each improvement is small, and together they add up.
Second, a cheaper medium: growth factors made by fermentation at large scale, a simpler base liquid, and a feed that reuses the medium rather than throwing it away. Some plants recycle their medium, filtering it and adding back the nutrients the cells used, so that a litre of medium feeds more than one run. Recycling cuts the cost and cuts the waste, but it must be done carefully, or waste products will build up and slow the cells down.
Third, larger tanks and larger plants: a tank twice as large does not need twice the staff or twice the control system, and a plant that buys medium ingredients in bulk pays less per tonne. A plant that runs all year, with short stops for cleaning, spreads its capital cost across more tonnes than a plant that runs half the year. The learning curve adds a fourth fall: each run teaches the operators a better feed rate, a better stirring speed, a better harvest time, and each lesson is written into the procedure for the next run.
The footprint: counting the whole chain
The footprint of cultivated meat is counted by a life cycle assessment, which adds up the land, water, energy and gas releases across the whole chain: making the medium, running the tank, harvesting and shaping the meat, packing it, and taking it to the shop. The gases counted are CO₂, CH₄ and N₂O, added together as CO₂ equivalent. A fair comparison counts the same chain for farmed meat: growing the feed, raising the animal, slaughter, processing, packing and transport.
The results so far point in a hopeful direction, with a wide range. Cultivated meat usually needs far less land than farmed meat, because a tank uses a small floor area and the medium needs far less cropland than the feed and pasture of a cow. Water use is usually lower too, though the tank needs clean water and the medium crop needs irrigation in some regions. Gas releases are usually lower, but they depend on the power source: a plant run on coal power carries a larger footprint than the same plant run on wind or solar power, so the energy source is part of the answer, not a footnote.
The wide range matters, and it is honest to name it. One study may find a small saving and another a large one, because they assume different medium costs, different energy sources, and different yields. A maker who quotes a single footprint number without saying what was counted, and what was assumed, is not giving the shopper a fact: they are giving a headline. The careful reader asks for the full chain, the energy source, and the yield, and judges the claim on those facts.
3D printing: cost and speed
A food printer costs far less than a cultivated meat plant, but it is slow, and slowness is its cost. A printer that makes one steak in 10 minutes, running all day, makes about 140 steaks in a day, while a forming line makes thousands in an hour. The printer's cost per steak is therefore high, not because the machine is dear, but because it is slow. That is why printing is used where one piece at a time is the point, a personalised meal, a decoration, a research scaffold, and not where thousands of identical pieces are needed.
The cost of a printed food splits into the machine, the paste, and the time. The machine is a one off cost, spread across the pieces it prints. The paste is the ingredient cost, the same as any recipe. The time is the labour and the power while the printer runs, and it grows with the size and the detail of the shape. A simple shape prints fast and cheap. A detailed shape, with fine lines and many layers, prints slowly and costs more. A maker who wants a printed food to pay must choose a shape that is worth the time, and a paste that prints fast without slumping.
The future of printing is faster machines, more nozzles printing at once, and pastes that set quickly after they land, so that the next layer can follow sooner. A printer with ten nozzles can print ten lines at once, and a paste that sets in seconds can be layered faster than a paste that sets in minutes. Each improvement cuts the time per piece, and the time per piece is the cost. Even so, printing is unlikely to match a forming line for speed, and its future is in foods where control and personalisation matter more than speed.
Scale: from pilot plant to food system
The cultivated meat industry today is at pilot scale: a small number of plants, each making kilograms or tonnes, selling in a small number of markets. To become a food system, it must grow by orders of magnitude: more plants, larger tanks, cheaper medium, and a supply chain that delivers medium ingredients, scaffolds and packaging at scale. That growth needs money, and money needs confidence, and confidence needs products that sell, approvals that hold, and costs that fall. Each step depends on the others, which is why growth is slow at first and faster later, if the early steps succeed.
The comparison with other new foods is useful. Plant based meat took a decade to move from a niche shop to a supermarket shelf, and it did so because the ingredients were cheap, the machines existed, and the shoppers were ready. Fermentation made chymosin took a decade to become the standard for cheese, because it was cheaper and better than the animal product it replaced. Cultivated meat faces a harder climb than either, because its medium is dear and its tanks are new, but the climb is the same shape: early products in high value niches, then wider products as cost falls, then commodity products when the cost meets the farm.
A realistic future is a mixed one. Cultivated meat is unlikely to replace farmed meat entirely, and it does not need to. If it supplies a share of the meat eaten in cities, in dry regions, or in places with little farmland, and if it does so at a price shoppers will pay, it will have earned its place. The measure of success is not replacing the farm: it is adding a new way of making meat that is safe, affordable and honest about its footprint, alongside the farm, not instead of it.
What to watch in the next ten years
Three things will decide the next ten years. First, the medium: if growth factors become cheap, the cost of cultivated meat will fall faster than any other change can deliver. Second, the energy: if plants run on low carbon power and recycle their water and medium, the footprint will fall with the cost, and the two judgements, cheap and clean, will point the same way. Third, the shopper: if the first products taste right, are labelled plainly, and are priced fairly, shoppers will buy them again, and the industry will grow on that repeat buying.
Three risks run beside them. First, a safety failure or a misleading label could damage trust in the whole category, and trust, once lost, is slow to rebuild. Second, a cost that stays high will keep the products in a niche, however good they taste. Third, a footprint claim that turns out to be empty, because the medium crop was grown on cleared land or the power came from coal, will be found out when the numbers are counted, and the finding will hurt more than the claim helped.
The makers who succeed will be the ones who publish their numbers, cost and footprint, who improve both year after year, and who label their products plainly. The shoppers who decide will be the ones who read the label, taste the food, and buy it again if it is good. That exchange, a maker who tells the truth and a shopper who judges it, is how every new food has earned its place, and it is how cultivated meat and printed food will earn theirs.
The six-tenths rule: a step-by-step derivation
A larger tank costs more to build, but not in proportion to its size, and the rule engineers use to estimate the difference is called the six-tenths rule. The rule says the cost of a tank grows with its size raised to the power of 0.6: double the size, and the cost grows by 2 to the power of 0.6, which is about 1.5 times, not twice. The reason is that a larger tank uses more steel, but it needs only one set of pipes, one motor and one control system, so the cost per litre falls as the tank grows.
The derivation is a ratio. If a small tank costs C1 at size S1, and a large tank costs C2 at size S2, then C2 equals C1 multiplied by the ratio of S2 to S1, raised to the power of 0.6. A worked example shows it. A 10,000 litre tank costs 100,000. A 100,000 litre tank is ten times larger, so its cost is 100,000 multiplied by 10 to the power of 0.6, which is about 100,000 multiplied by 4, which is about 400,000. The large tank holds ten times as much, but it costs only about four times as much, so the cost per litre falls by more than half.
The rule is a guide, not a law. It works best for tanks of the same design, built by the same maker, and it breaks down when the tank grows so large that it needs a new design, a stronger wall, or a new cooling system. It also says nothing about the running cost: a large tank still needs more sugar, more power and more medium, and those costs grow in proportion to the size, not by the six-tenths rule. The rule tells the maker that building bigger is cheaper per litre, but it does not tell the maker that bigger is always better, because a tank that is too large for its market will sit half empty, and a half empty tank is the dearest tank of all.
Questions to think about
- Why is the medium the largest cost of cultivated meat, and what two changes would cut it fastest?
- A printer that makes one steak in 10 minutes cannot match a forming line. Why is printing still useful, and for which foods?
- Why must a footprint claim for cultivated meat name the energy source and the yield, and not only the final number?
Think about the medium cost question before you read on
The medium holds the growth factors, which are dear proteins made by fermentation, and a tank holds thousands of litres of it. The two fastest cuts are cheaper growth factors, made at larger scale, and a medium that is recycled, filtered and topped up rather than thrown away after one run. Both cut the cost per kilogram directly, and both are being worked on now.
The diagram shows the four parts of the cost. The medium dominates, so a cheaper medium and a better cell line are the fastest routes to a cheaper product.
Practical note: In a practical session, work out the cost of a meal you cook: write down every ingredient, its weight, and its price, then add the cost of power for cooking, using your energy bill as a guide, and the time you spent at a fair hourly rate. Work out the cost per serving, then change one thing, a cheaper cut of meat, a plant protein instead of meat, or a shorter cooking time, and work out the new cost per serving. Record both numbers and answer: which change cut the cost most, and did it change the eating quality?
Quick self-check
Question: Why does a plant that runs all year have a lower cost per kilogram than one that runs half the year?
Because the capital cost, the price of building the plant, is spread across the tonnes made over the life of the plant. A plant that runs all year makes more tonnes, so each kilogram carries a smaller share of the building cost.
Question: Why is a footprint number without its assumptions not a fact?
Because the result depends on what was counted, on the energy source, on the medium crop, and on the yield assumed. A different energy source or a different yield gives a different number, so the number means little without the chain and the assumptions behind it.
Question: A 10,000 litre tank costs 100,000. About how much does a 100,000 litre tank cost by the six-tenths rule, and why is it not 1,000,000?
About 400,000, because 10 to the power of 0.6 is about 4, so the cost is 100,000 times 4. A larger tank needs only one set of pipes, one motor and one control system, so its cost per litre falls.
Try it yourself
Find a new food product in a shop that is dearer than the food it replaces, such as a plant based burger or a premium protein drink. Write down its price, its weight, and the price per 100 g, then write down the same three numbers for the food it replaces. Work out the price gap as a percentage and answer in writing: what would the new product need to do, in taste, in nutrition, or in price, for you to buy it again? Keep your notes and compare them with a classmate who chose a different product.
Key ideas to carry forward
- The medium is the largest cost of cultivated meat, and its growth factors are the dearest part.
- Cost falls with better cells, a cheaper and recycled medium, larger tanks, and learning from each run.
- A life cycle assessment counts the whole chain, and the energy source can change the footprint more than the yield does.
- A food printer is slow, so its cost per piece is high, and it suits personalised, decorative and research foods, not bulk production.
- The industry is at pilot scale today, and growth needs products that sell, approvals that hold, and costs that fall together.
- A realistic future is mixed: cultivated meat adds a new way of making meat alongside the farm, not instead of it.
Makers who publish their cost and footprint numbers, and improve both, are the ones shoppers will trust.
The six-tenths rule says tank cost grows with size to the power of 0.6, so doubling the size raises the cost by about 1.5 times, not twice.
Glossary
Capital cost
The cost of building a plant, spread across the tonnes made over its life. Food tech example: the price of tanks and clean rooms is a capital cost spread across years of output.
CO₂ equivalent
A single number that adds together CO₂, CH₄ and N₂O by their warming effect. Food tech example: a life cycle assessment reports gas releases as CO₂ equivalent per kilogram of meat.
Growth factor
A protein signal that tells cells to divide. Food tech example: growth factors in the culture medium are the dearest part of making cultivated meat.
Learning curve
The fall in cost as operators learn and improve a process over time. Food tech example: each run of a cultivated meat plant teaches a better feed rate, cutting cost a little.
Life cycle assessment
A method that adds up the land, water, energy and gas releases of a product across its whole life. Food tech example: a life cycle assessment of cultivated meat counts the medium, the tank and the packaging.
Pilot plant
A small plant used to test a process before large scale production. Food tech example: most cultivated meat today is made in pilot plants making kilograms or tonnes.
Running cost
The day to day cost of operating a plant: power, water, labour and cleaning. Food tech example: power for heating and cooling is a running cost of a cultivated meat plant.
Yield
The amount of product made per amount of feed. Food tech example: a cell line that makes more meat per litre of medium has a higher yield.
Carbon dioxide
A gas released when fuels burn, written CO₂. Food tech example: the CO₂ from powering a cultivated meat plant is counted in its footprint.
Methane
A gas released from farming and waste, written CH₄. Food tech example: methane is counted in the footprint of farmed meat in a life cycle assessment.
Nitrous oxide
A gas released from fertilised soils, written N₂O. Food tech example: fertiliser on a feed crop adds N₂O to the footprint of farmed meat.
Recycling
Using a material again after cleaning or topping it up. Food tech example: recycling culture medium cuts the cost of cultivated meat.
Clean room
A room kept free of dust and microbes for sterile work. Food tech example: cultivated meat is harvested in a clean room to keep microbes out.
Six-tenths rule
A guide that tank cost grows with size to the power of 0.6. Food tech example: a tank ten times larger costs about four times as much.
Cost per litre
The cost of a tank divided by its size. Food tech example: the cost per litre falls as a tank grows, because one set of pipes serves a larger volume.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 7: Consumer Acceptance
Note
Unit 7: Consumer Acceptance
A question to start with
A new food can pass every laboratory test, win every approval, and still fail, because the shopper picks it up, looks at it, and puts it back. That moment, in the aisle, at the table, at the first bite, is where cultivated meat and printed food will succeed or fail. This unit explains how shoppers decide about a new food, what worries them, what wins them over, and how a maker can earn trust without hiding the truth. It is about people, not tanks, and it is the unit that decides whether the science in the rest of this subject becomes dinner.
The first reaction: newness and disgust
People react to a new food first with feeling, then with thought. A food that looks strange, that comes from a strange place, or that is made in a strange way can trigger disgust, a strong feeling that says do not eat this. Disgust is not a reasoned argument: it is a fast, protective response, and it is stronger for foods that come from the body, from animals, or from a laboratory. Cultivated meat triggers it in some people because it is meat made in a tank, and printed food triggers it in some because it is made by a machine.
That feeling is not fixed. People who have never eaten sushi once found raw fish disgusting, and many now eat it gladly. People who once found yoghurt strange now eat it daily. The feeling changes when the food is tried once and liked, when a trusted person eats it, or when the food is served in a familiar form, such as a nugget or a burger, rather than in a strange one. The first taste matters more than the first argument, and a maker who wants acceptance must win the first taste.
Neophobia, the fear of new foods, is a related feeling, and it is stronger in some people than in others. Children are often neophobic, and older people can be too, while younger adults and people who travel widely are often more willing to try. A maker cannot change a person's nature, but can change the situation: a small free sample, a familiar recipe, a trusted shop, and a clear label all lower the barrier to trying, and a good first taste does the rest.
What shoppers worry about
Shoppers who hesitate about cultivated meat usually name the same worries, and each one deserves an honest answer. The first is safety: is it safe to eat, and who checked? The answer is the safety file and the authority that read it, as Unit 5 explained, and a maker who can point to the approval has an answer. The second is naturalness: is it natural, and does it matter? The answer is that cultivated meat is made from animal cells, but it is grown in a tank, and a shopper who values naturalness may prefer farmed meat, while a shopper who values animal welfare may prefer the tank. Neither value is wrong, and the label must let each shopper choose.
The third worry is taste: will it taste like meat? The answer is that the first products are minced and formed, where the taste is close, and whole cuts are still being improved, so the honest answer is to let the shopper taste it. The fourth is price: will it cost more? The answer, for now, is yes, and the price will fall as the industry grows, as Unit 6 explained. The fifth is the unknown: what will happen if I eat it for years? The answer is that the proteins are the same as the proteins in farmed meat, the feeding studies found no harm, and the product is tested batch by batch, but the honest answer also admits that long term eating data will only come with time.
A worry that is ignored grows. A worry that is answered plainly, with facts and with a label that tells the truth, shrinks. The makers who earn trust are the ones who answer the hard questions in public, who publish their safety files or summaries of them, and who do not hide the tank behind a pastoral picture of a farm. A pack that shows a tank and names the cells is more trustworthy than a pack that shows a field and hides the method.
What wins shoppers over
The things that win shoppers over are simpler than the things that worry them. Taste wins first: a nugget that tastes like chicken, a burger that tastes like beef, a steak that chews like a steak. Price wins second: a product that costs the same as the farmed food it replaces is easy to choose, while a product that costs twice as much needs a strong reason. Familiarity wins third: a product sold in a familiar shop, in a familiar shape, with a familiar recipe, is easier to try than a product sold only in a special store.
Values win fourth, and they differ by shopper. Some shoppers choose cultivated meat because no animal was raised or slaughtered. Some choose it because it uses less land. Some choose it because it is made where they live, not shipped from far away. Some choose it because it is free of antibiotics or because its fat pattern is tuned. A maker who names one value plainly, and proves it with numbers, will win the shoppers who hold that value, while a maker who claims every value at once will be believed by none.
Trust in the seller wins fifth. A shopper who trusts a brand, a shop, or a chef will try a new food from that seller sooner than from a stranger. That is why the first cultivated products are often sold through a known restaurant or a known brand, where the seller's name carries the trust while the product earns its own. A maker who borrows trust must repay it with a product that is good, because a bad first taste spends the trust and does not earn it back.
Naming, framing and the label
The name on the pack shapes the first reaction. A name that says cultivated meat tells the shopper the meat was grown, and it is honest. A name that says clean meat suggests the farmed meat is dirty, and it puts off the shoppers who eat farmed meat. A name that says lab grown meat suggests a laboratory, and it puts off shoppers who do not want a laboratory in their kitchen. The name that wins is usually the plainest one, the one that says what the food is without praising it or hiding it, and the authorities in each country are settling which names they will accept.
The picture on the pack shapes the reaction too. A picture of a tank is honest but strange. A picture of a farm is familiar but false. A picture of the cooked food, a burger on a plate, a nugget in a basket, is both honest and familiar, because it shows what the shopper will eat, not where it was made. The best packs show the food, name the method in plain words, and leave the farm picture out.
The words around the name matter as much as the name. A pack that says made from animal cells, grown without raising an animal tells the truth in one sentence. A pack that says real meat, no farm needed tells the truth and adds a value. A pack that says just like meat, but better hides the method and oversells the product. The shopper who reads the pack should be able to answer three questions from it: what animal is it, how was it made, and what is in it? A pack that answers all three has done its job.
Trying, tasting and buying again
Acceptance is not one decision: it is a chain of small decisions, and each one must be won. The first is to notice the product, which needs a place on the shelf and a price that does not shock. The second is to pick it up, which needs a name and a picture that invite rather than repel. The third is to read the label, which needs plain words and honest numbers. The fourth is to buy it, which needs a price the shopper will pay for a trial. The fifth is to cook it, which needs clear guidance. The sixth is to taste it, which needs the food to be good. The seventh is to buy it again, which needs the first six to have gone well.
A failure at any step breaks the chain. A product that is never seen cannot be tried. A product that is seen but not picked up cannot be tasted. A product that is tasted and disliked will not be bought again, whatever its footprint. That is why makers spend as much effort on the shelf, the pack, the price and the recipe as they spend on the tank: the tank makes the food, but the chain makes the sale, and a sale that is not repeated is not a business.
Tastings are the fastest way to build the chain. A small free sample in a shop, a dish in a restaurant, a sample at a food festival: each one lets a shopper taste without paying, and a good taste turns a hesitant shopper into a buyer. The sample must be the real product, cooked well, served hot, with no pressure to buy. A sample that is cold, badly cooked, or served with a hard sell will do more harm than no sample at all, because the first taste is the taste the shopper remembers.
The future of acceptance
Acceptance will grow slowly, then faster, if the early products are good. The pattern of other new foods is a guide: sushi, yoghurt, tofu and plant based meat were all strange once, and each one moved from a small group of early buyers to a wider market as the food improved, the price fell, and the shoppers who tried it told their friends. Cultivated meat is likely to follow the same path, with early buyers who value the idea, then wider buyers who value the taste and the price, then ordinary buyers who buy it because it is on the shelf and it is good.
Printed food will follow a different path, because its value is not in replacing a familiar food but in making a personal one. A printed meal for an older person who cannot chew, a printed cake for a birthday, a printed steak with fat placed exactly where the eater likes it: each one is a food for one person, and its acceptance will grow person by person, in hospitals, in care homes, and in kitchens where a printer sits beside the oven. Its future is personal, not bulk, and its acceptance will be judged one eater at a time.
The final lesson of this subject is simple: the science must be good, the safety must be proven, the label must be honest, and the food must taste good. If any one of those fails, the shopper will put the pack back, and the tank will stand idle. If all four succeed, the shopper will buy, taste, and buy again, and a new way of making meat will have earned its place at the table. That is the test that matters, and it is set by the eater, not by the maker.
Designing a tasting trial
A tasting trial is how a maker learns whether shoppers will buy a food twice, and it must be designed well or it will mislead. The first design choice is blinding: the tasters must not know which sample is which, or their expectations will decide the scores before the food is tasted. A taster who knows a sample is cultivated meat may score it lower out of caution, or higher out of excitement, and neither score measures the taste. The samples are therefore coded with numbers, served in the same form, cooked the same way, and tasted in a random order.
The second choice is the number of tasters. A trial with ten tasters can show a large difference, but it cannot show a small one, because ten people vary too much. A trial with a hundred tasters can show a smaller difference, and it can also show how many tasters prefer each product, which is the number the maker needs. The maker decides the number before the trial starts, by asking how small a difference matters: if a difference of one point on a five point scale matters, the trial needs enough tasters to find it, and the number is worked out from the variation between tasters, not guessed.
The third choice is what to ask. The tasters score flavour, texture, juiciness and overall liking, each on the same scale, and they answer whether they would buy the product, and at what price. The scores are averaged, and the difference between products is tested to see whether it is real or whether it could have happened by chance. A difference that could have happened by chance is not a finding, and the maker must not launch on it. A trial that is blinded, sized well and asked well gives the maker the truth about the taste. A trial that is none of those gives the maker the answer they wanted to hear.
Questions to think about
- Why does a first taste matter more than a first argument for a new food?
- A pack shows a farm picture for a cultivated meat. Why is that picture a problem, even if the meat inside is good?
- Acceptance is a chain of small decisions from noticing to buying again. Which step in the chain matters most, and why?
Think about the farm picture question before you read on
The picture suggests the meat was raised on a farm, which is false, and a shopper who learns the truth later will feel misled, even if the meat tasted good. Trust is lost faster than it is earned, and a misleading picture spends the trust that the product needs to be bought again. A picture of the cooked food is honest and familiar, and it does not mislead.
The diagram shows the acceptance chain in order. A failure at any step breaks the chain, and a sale that is not repeated is not a business.
Practical note: In a practical session, run a small tasting with friends or classmates: buy a plant based burger and a beef burger, cook both the same way, and serve them blind, coded with random numbers, with no labels visible. Ask each taster to score both out of 10 for taste, texture and juiciness, and to guess which one is plant based. Count the scores and the guesses, then reveal the answers and discuss: did the tasters guess right, did the scores match the guesses, and what would make them buy the plant burger again? Record the results in a table.
Quick self-check
Question: What is neophobia, and how can a maker lower the barrier it creates?
Neophobia is the fear of new foods, stronger in some people than in others. A maker lowers the barrier with a small free sample, a familiar recipe and shape, a trusted shop, and a clear label, so that trying feels safe, and a good first taste does the rest.
Question: Why is a misleading pack picture a bigger problem than a plain one?
Because a shopper who learns the truth later feels misled, and trust, once lost, is slow to rebuild. A plain picture of the cooked food is honest and familiar, and it does not spend the trust the product needs to be bought again.
Question: Why must tasters in a trial not know which sample is which?
Because their expectations would decide the scores before the food is tasted: a taster who knows a sample is cultivated meat may score it lower out of caution or higher out of excitement, and neither score measures the taste.
Try it yourself
Ask three friends or family members whether they would try cultivated meat, and write down their answers in their own words, without arguing. Then ask what would change their mind: a lower price, a taste, a safety approval, or a recommendation from someone they trust? Write down each person's answer and the one thing that would matter most to them. Answer in writing: did the three people worry about the same thing, or about different things, and what does that tell you about how a maker should talk about the product?
Key ideas to carry forward
- People react to a new food first with feeling, and disgust and neophobia can block a food before it is tasted.
- A good first taste matters more than a good argument, and a familiar shape lowers the barrier to trying.
- Shoppers worry about safety, naturalness, taste, price and the unknown, and each worry deserves a plain, honest answer.
- Taste, price, familiarity, values and trust in the seller are what win shoppers over, in that order.
- The name and the picture on the pack must be plain and honest: show the cooked food, name the method, leave the farm picture out.
- Acceptance is a chain from noticing to buying again, and a failure at any step breaks the chain.
New foods move from early buyers to wider buyers as the food improves, the price falls, and tasters tell their friends.
A tasting trial must be blinded, sized to find the difference that matters, and scored on flavour, texture, juiciness and buying intent.
Glossary
Neophobia
The fear of new foods. Food tech example: a child who refuses a new food is showing neophobia, and a small familiar sample can lower the barrier.
Disgust
A strong feeling that says do not eat this, triggered by strange foods. Food tech example: disgust at meat grown in a tank fades when the food is tried once and liked.
Blind tasting
Tasting where the eater does not know which sample is which. Food tech example: a blind tasting stops the label from changing what the eater reports.
Early buyer
A shopper who tries a new food before most people do. Food tech example: early buyers of cultivated meat are often people who value the idea behind it.
Repeat buying
Buying the same product again after trying it. Food tech example: repeat buying is the test that decides whether a new food stays on the shelf.
Framing
The way a food is presented by its name, picture and words. Food tech example: framing a cultivated meat with a farm picture misleads the shopper about how it was made.
Naturalness
How natural a shopper judges a food to be. Food tech example: a shopper who values naturalness may prefer farmed meat to meat grown in a tank.
Sample
A small free taste of a food offered to a shopper. Food tech example: a free sample of a cultivated nugget lets a hesitant shopper taste without paying.
Trust
A shopper's belief that a maker tells the truth. Food tech example: trust is earned by plain labels and honest numbers, and lost by a misleading picture.
Value
A belief that guides a shopper's choice, such as animal welfare or low land use. Food tech example: a shopper who values animal welfare may choose cultivated meat for that reason.
Personalised food
A food made for one person's needs. Food tech example: a printed meal for an older person is a personalised food, soft and shaped like the food it replaces.
Shelf
The place in a shop where a product is sold. Food tech example: a cultivated meat that is never seen on the shelf cannot be tried.
Blinding
Hiding which sample is which from the tasters. Food tech example: a blind tasting shows whether eaters can tell a cultivated burger from a meat burger.
Tasting trial
A planned test where people taste foods and score them. Food tech example: a tasting trial with a hundred tasters can show a small difference in flavour.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 8: Cell Lines and Culture Media in Depth: The Biology
Note
Unit 8: Cell Lines and Culture Media in Depth: The Biology
A question to start with
Every cultivated steak starts with two things: a cell that can divide again and again, and a liquid that feeds it. The cell is called a cell line, and the liquid is called culture medium. Together they are the biology of cultivated meat, and they decide whether the meat grows, how fast it grows, what it costs, and whether it is safe. This unit looks inside both: what a cell line is, how cells divide, what the medium holds, and how a maker keeps the cells healthy from the first vial to the last tank.
What a cell line is
A cell line is a population of cells that can be grown again and again in the laboratory, all descended from one starting sample. The starting sample is a tiny piece of tissue, taken from an animal, from which the cells are separated and grown in a dish. The cells that grow are the ones that can divide in a dish, and they are kept, tested and frozen. From that first dish, a maker can grow cells for years, without going back to the animal, because each batch starts from a frozen vial of the same line.
Three kinds of cell line are used. The first is a primary cell line, taken fresh from tissue and grown for a limited number of divisions before it slows down and stops. It is close to the animal, but it does not last. The second is an immortalised cell line, where the cells have been changed, by nature or by design, so they keep dividing without stopping. It lasts, but it is further from the animal, and its safety must be proved. The third is a stem cell line, made of stem cells, which can divide for a long time and can become different kinds of cell: muscle, fat or connective tissue. Stem cells are the most flexible, and the most used for cultivated meat, because one line can make all the parts of a piece of meat.
The choice of cell line is the first decision in cultivated meat, and it shapes everything after it. A muscle stem cell line makes the fibres that give a steak its bite. A fat cell line makes the fat that gives flavour and juiciness. A maker who wants a steak needs both, and the two lines must grow well in the same medium, at the same temperature, in the same tank, or they must be grown separately and mixed later. The cell line is not a detail. It is the meat, in its earliest form.
How cells divide: growth in numbers
Cells divide by doubling: one cell becomes two, two become four, four become eight, and the number grows by multiplication, not by addition. The time one doubling takes is called the doubling time, and it is the most important number in cell biology for a maker. A cell line with a doubling time of 24 hours doubles once a day. A line with a doubling time of 48 hours takes twice as long to reach the same number of cells, and the tank must run twice as long to make the same meat.
The step by step derivation is simple, and it is worth doing by hand once. Start with N0 cells. After one doubling time, there are N0 times 2 cells. After two doubling times, there are N0 times 2 times 2, which is N0 times 4. After n doubling times, there are N0 times 2 to the power of n. To find how many doublings are needed to grow from N0 to a target number N, divide N by N0, take the logarithm base 2 of the result, and that is n. The time needed is n multiplied by the doubling time.
A worked example shows the scale. A maker starts with 1 million cells and needs 1 trillion cells for a production run. The ratio is 1 trillion divided by 1 million, which is 1 million. The logarithm base 2 of 1 million is about 20, because 2 to the power of 20 is about 1 million. So the cells must double about 20 times. At a doubling time of 24 hours, that takes about 20 days. At a doubling time of 48 hours, it takes about 40 days. That arithmetic is how a maker plans a run: the doubling time decides the calendar, and a faster line is worth more than a larger tank.
What culture medium holds
Culture medium is the liquid that feeds the cells, and it holds everything a cell needs to live and divide. The base is water with salts, to hold the pH and the salt balance steady. The food is glucose, a sugar that the cells burn for energy, and amino acids, the building blocks of protein, which the cells use to build muscle. The vitamins and minerals are the small helpers that the cells cannot make themselves. The growth signals are the messengers that tell the cells to divide, or to mature into muscle or fat.
The most debated part of the medium is serum, the liquid part of blood, which was long used because it holds many growth signals at once. Serum is dear, it varies from batch to batch, and it comes from animals, which troubles a product that promises meat without animals. Makers are therefore moving to serum free medium, where each growth signal is made separately, by fermentation or by synthesis, and added in a known amount. Serum free medium costs more to design, but it is consistent, it is free of animal blood, and it can be made at scale.
The medium is also the largest cost in cultivated meat, often more than half the cost of the finished product, so the maker watches it closely. The sugar is cheap. The amino acids are dearer. The growth signals are dearest of all, because they are made in small amounts and they are used in tiny doses. A maker who can make a growth signal cheaply, or find a cell line that needs less of it, cuts the cost of every kilogram of meat. The medium is not a broth to be poured and forgotten. It is the most expensive ingredient in the tank, and the most important to understand.
Feeding the cells: sugar, oxygen and waste
Cells eat sugar and oxygen, and they make waste: lactic acid, ammonia and carbon dioxide. The sugar is fed slowly, because a flood of sugar makes the cells eat fast, grow fast, and make more lactic acid, which turns the medium acid and slows them down. The oxygen is bubbled in gently, because cells need it to burn sugar cleanly, and without it they ferment the sugar instead, making even more lactic acid. The waste is removed by changing the medium, or by running the tank continuously with fresh medium flowing in and used medium flowing out.
The operator watches three numbers: glucose, pH and dissolved oxygen. Glucose tells how much food is left. The pH tells whether lactic acid is building up. Dissolved oxygen tells whether the cells are getting enough air. When glucose falls, more is fed. When pH falls, the medium is changed or a base is added to neutralise the acid. When oxygen falls, the stirring is raised or more air is bubbled in. The three numbers are the dashboard of the tank, and the operator reads them every hour.
A worked example shows the feeding. A tank holds 10,000 litres of medium with 5 g of glucose per litre, which is 50 kg of glucose. If the cells eat 10 kg of glucose a day, the tank runs out in five days, so the operator feeds 10 kg a day to hold the level steady. If the cells eat faster as they multiply, the feed must rise with them, and the operator raises it a little each day, watching the glucose number to check the feed is right. Too little feed starves the cells. Too much feed makes acid. The right feed is the one that holds the numbers steady.
Keeping cells healthy: contamination and passage
A cell culture is a rich, warm, sugary liquid, which is exactly what bacteria and fungi love, so contamination is the constant enemy. A single bacterium in a tank can double every 20 minutes, and in a day it can outnumber the meat cells. The defence is sterility: the tank is steamed before each run, the medium is filtered through a sterile filter, every pipe and valve is sealed, and the people who work with the cells wear gloves and work in clean rooms. No antibiotic is used in food cell culture, because an antibiotic would hide a contamination instead of preventing it, and it has no place in a food process.
The second enemy is drift: cells change as they divide, and after many divisions they may grow slower, make less muscle, or lose the ability to mature. The number of times a line has been divided is called the passage number, and a maker sets a limit: a line may be used only up to a certain passage, and then a fresh vial is opened from the cell bank. The bank is a set of frozen vials, all from the same original line, kept at very low temperature. Every production run starts from the same bank, so every batch starts from the same cells, at the same passage, and the meat stays the same.
The third enemy is mycoplasma, a tiny bacterium with no wall that is hard to see and hard to kill, and that slows cell growth without any visible sign. The maker tests for it regularly, with a laboratory test that finds its DNA, and a line that tests positive is discarded, not treated, because treatment would only hide it. The tests are part of the batch record, and they are the proof that the cells in the tank are the cells on the label, healthy and clean.
Cell banks, traceability and the safety file
The cell bank is the heart of the whole system. One vial is the master bank, opened only to make more vials. The others are the working bank, used to start each run. Each vial is labelled with the cell line, the passage number, the date and the tests it passed. When a run starts, the operator records which vial was used, which tank it went into, which medium fed it, and which people ran it. That chain of records is the traceability of the meat, and it is what lets a maker recall a batch and prove the next batch is sound.
The safety file for a cultivated meat starts with the cell line: what animal it came from, what kind of cell it is, whether it was changed, and how it was tested. It continues with the medium: every ingredient, where it came from, and whether it is food grade. It continues with the process: the tank, the sterility, the tests for contamination, and the tests on the finished meat for microbes, chemicals and allergy. The file is judged as a whole, because the safety of the meat depends on the line, the medium and the process together, not on any one of them alone.
The reader who understands cell lines and media can read a cultivated meat claim with clear eyes. A claim that names the cell line, the medium and the passage limit is a claim with evidence behind it. A claim that hides them is a story. The biology is not a mystery. It is a set of choices, each with a cost and a consequence, and the maker who makes them well grows meat that is safe, consistent and worth eating.
Questions to think about
- Why is a stem cell line the most flexible choice for cultivated meat, and what does it still need to become muscle or fat?
- A maker starts with 1 million cells, needs 1 trillion, and the doubling time is 24 hours. How many doublings are needed, and how long will it take?
- Why is serum being replaced by serum free medium, even though serum free medium costs more to design?
Think about the doubling arithmetic before you read on
The ratio is 1 trillion divided by 1 million, which is 1 million, and the logarithm base 2 of 1 million is about 20, because 2 to the power of 20 is about 1 million. So about 20 doublings are needed, and at 24 hours per doubling that takes about 20 days. At 48 hours per doubling it would take about 40 days, so the doubling time decides the calendar.
The diagram shows cell growth in order: from a frozen vial to a tank, with checks at each step. The passage limit decides when a fresh vial must be opened.
Practical note: In a practical session, grow a simple doubling on paper: start with 2 cells, double them every hour, and write down the count after each hour for 10 hours. Then repeat with a doubling time of 2 hours, and compare the two counts after 10 hours. Record both tables and answer: why does a small difference in doubling time make such a large difference in the final count, and what does that mean for choosing a cell line?
Quick self-check
Question: Question: What is a cell line, and why does every run start from a cell bank?
A cell line is a population of cells that can be grown again and again, all descended from one starting sample. Every run starts from a frozen vial of the cell bank so every batch starts from the same cells, at the same passage, and the meat stays the same.
Question: Question: What is the doubling time, and why does it decide the calendar of a run?
The doubling time is the time one cell division takes. The number of cells grows by doubling, so the time to reach a target number is the number of doublings multiplied by the doubling time, and a slower line takes far longer to make the same meat.
Try it yourself
Choose an animal food you eat, such as chicken or fish, and write a one page plan for making it by cultivation: which cells would you need, muscle or fat or both, what would the medium need to hold, and what would you test at each step? Then list the three things that could go wrong, and what you would change for each one.
Key ideas to carry forward
- A cell line is a population of cells grown again and again from one starting sample, and stem cells are the most flexible kind.
- Cells grow by doubling, and the time to reach a target is the number of doublings multiplied by the doubling time.
- Culture medium holds water, salts, glucose, amino acids, vitamins, minerals and growth signals.
- Serum is being replaced by serum free medium, which is consistent, free of animal blood, and made at scale.
- Glucose, pH and dissolved oxygen are the dashboard of the tank, and the feed is adjusted to hold them steady.
- Contamination, drift and mycoplasma are the enemies of a culture, and no antibiotic is used in food cell culture.
- The cell bank, the passage limit and the batch record give the meat its traceability and its safety file.
Glossary
Cell line
A population of cells that can be grown again and again, all descended from one starting sample. Food tech example: a cultivated meat maker grows meat from a stored muscle cell line.
Stem cell
A cell that can divide and become different kinds of cell. Food tech example: stem cells become muscle and fat in cultivated meat.
Doubling time
The time one cell division takes. Food tech example: a cell line with a doubling time of 24 hours doubles once a day.
Culture medium
The liquid that feeds cells in a tank. Food tech example: culture medium holds sugars, amino acids and growth signals for cultivated meat.
Serum
The liquid part of blood, long used in cell culture because it holds many growth signals. Food tech example: serum is being replaced by serum free medium.
Serum free medium
Culture medium with each growth signal added separately, without animal blood. Food tech example: serum free medium is consistent and free of animal blood.
Growth signal
A substance in culture medium that tells cells to divide or to mature. Food tech example: growth signals in the medium tell stem cells to become muscle.
Passage number
How many times a cell line has been divided and moved to a new vessel. Food tech example: a maker sets a passage limit so cells are used only while they are still healthy.
Cell bank
A set of frozen vials holding the same cell line, used to start each run. Food tech example: every production run starts from a vial of the working cell bank.
Mycoplasma
A tiny bacterium with no wall that slows cell growth without any visible sign. Food tech example: a cell line that tests positive for mycoplasma is discarded.
Contamination
Unwanted microbes growing in a cell culture. Food tech example: a single bacterium in a tank can outnumber the meat cells in a day.
Lactic acid
A waste product cells make when they eat sugar, which turns the medium acid. Food tech example: lactic acid build up lowers the pH of a cell culture.
Dissolved oxygen
Oxygen dissolved in the medium, which cells need to burn sugar cleanly. Food tech example: dissolved oxygen is watched every hour in a bioreactor.
Primary cell line
Cells taken fresh from tissue, grown for a limited number of divisions. Food tech example: a primary cell line is close to the animal but does not last.
Immortalised cell line
Cells changed so they keep dividing without stopping. Food tech example: an immortalised cell line lasts, but its safety must be proved.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 9: 3D Printing Materials and Food Inks
Note
Unit 9: 3D Printing Materials and Food Inks
A question to start with
A 3D food printer does not print plastic. It prints paste: chocolate, dough, mashed potato, a meat paste, a gel. The paste is called a food ink, and whether it prints well depends on how it flows: too runny and it collapses, too stiff and it will not leave the nozzle, too sticky and it clogs. This unit is about those inks: what they are made of, how flow is measured, how a printer is set for each ink, and how a printed food is finished so it can be eaten.
What a food ink is
A food ink is a paste that can be pushed through a nozzle, hold its shape after it leaves the nozzle, and then set into a food that can be eaten. It is not a single material. It is a family: chocolate that melts and sets, dough that is baked after printing, mashed potato that holds a shape, a meat paste that is cooked after printing, a gel made of starch or alginate that sets by cooling or by a chemical change. Each ink is a recipe, and the recipe is tuned for the printer as much as for the eater.
An ink has three jobs, and they pull in different directions. It must flow easily through a narrow nozzle, so it cannot be too thick. It must stop flowing the moment it leaves the nozzle, so the printed line holds its shape and the next layer can sit on it. It must then set firmly enough to be moved, cooked or eaten, without collapsing. A paste that flows well usually holds badly, and a paste that holds well usually flows badly. The art of ink design is to find the middle: a paste that flows under pressure and holds at rest.
The ingredients that give an ink its behaviour are familiar: starches that thicken, gums that bind water, fats that melt and set, proteins that gel when heated, and fibres that give body. A chocolate ink uses cocoa butter, which melts when warm and sets when cool. A dough ink uses gluten, which stretches and then sets in the oven. A gel ink uses alginate, which sets when it meets calcium. The printer does not change the food. It changes the shape, and the ink must be built to hold that shape.
How flow is measured: viscosity and yield stress
Flow is measured with two numbers. The first is viscosity, how thick a liquid is, or how hard it is to stir. Honey has a high viscosity, water has a low one. A food ink needs a viscosity that is low enough to flow through the nozzle and high enough to hold a line after it leaves. The second number is yield stress, the push needed to start a paste moving at all. Toothpaste has a yield stress: it sits in the tube until you squeeze, then it flows. A food ink needs a yield stress too, so it sits still on the plate until the next layer is printed, and it does not spread into a puddle.
The most useful property of a food ink is shear thinning: it flows more easily when it is pushed hard, and thickens again when the push stops. A shear thinning ink is thin inside the nozzle, where the push is strong, and thick on the plate, where the push is gone. That is the property that makes printing possible, and it is built into the recipe with starches and gums that line up under pressure and tangle again at rest. An ink that does not shear thin will either clog the nozzle or collapse on the plate, and no printer setting can fix it.
The tests are simple and physical. A rheometer, an instrument that stirs a paste and measures how hard it is to stir, gives the viscosity and the yield stress. A print test gives the rest: a line is printed, and the maker measures how wide it spreads, how tall it stands, and how many layers can be stacked before the bottom layer sags. The numbers from the rheometer and the shape from the print test together decide whether an ink is ready, and the maker adjusts the recipe, a little more starch, a little less water, until both agree.
Ink families: pastes, gels, fats and chocolate
Pastes are the largest family: mashed potato, chickpea paste, meat paste, dough. They are made by cooking, mashing and sieving a food into a smooth paste, then adjusting the water until the paste flows and holds. A paste that is too wet spreads. A paste that is too dry clogs. The water content is the main control, and it is measured by weighing the paste before and after drying, so the maker knows exactly how much water is in it.
Gels are the second family: starch gels, alginate gels, gelatine gels. They are made by dissolving a gelling agent in water, heating it, and letting it set. A gel ink is printed warm, while it is still liquid, and it sets as it cools on the plate. An alginate ink is printed into a bath of calcium, where it sets at once into a firm gel. Gels are used for shapes that must be soft and smooth, such as a dessert, a jelly, or a scaffold that holds cells, and they are the inks that most resemble the plastics of ordinary 3D printing.
Fats and chocolate are the third family, and they work by melting and setting. A chocolate ink is printed warm, at the temperature where cocoa butter is liquid, and it sets as it cools into a firm shape with a snap. The temperature must be controlled closely: too warm and the chocolate stays liquid and spreads, too cool and it sets in the nozzle and clogs it. A fat ink for a meat analogue is printed warm and sets as it cools, giving the marbling that makes a printed steak look like a steak. Each family has its own temperature, its own nozzle, and its own setting step, and a printer that handles one family may not handle another.
Setting the printer: nozzle, layer and speed
A printer is set by four numbers: the nozzle size, the layer height, the print speed and the temperature. The nozzle size decides how fine the detail is: a narrow nozzle prints fine lines but clogs easily, while a wide nozzle prints fast but coarsely. The layer height is the thickness of each printed layer, and it is usually set to about half the nozzle size, so each layer sticks to the one below it. The print speed decides how fast the nozzle moves, and it must match the flow of the ink: too fast and the line breaks, too slow and the ink piles up.
Temperature is the fourth setting, and it matters most for chocolate and fat inks. The ink is held warm in the cartridge, printed warm, and cooled on the plate, so the printer often has a heated nozzle and a cooled plate. A dough ink is printed at room temperature and baked after printing, so the printer needs no heating at all. A gel ink is printed warm and sets as it cools, so the plate is kept cool. The settings are tested with a small print first, a test shape that shows whether the lines are even, the layers stick, and the shape holds, before the real food is printed.
A worked example shows the print time. A food is printed in 20 layers, each layer takes 30 seconds, so the print takes 600 seconds, which is 10 minutes. If the nozzle is narrowed so each layer takes 45 seconds, the print takes 15 minutes. If the layer height is doubled so only 10 layers are needed, the print takes 5 minutes, but the shape is coarser. That arithmetic is how a maker plans a run: finer detail costs time, and a food that takes an hour to print will never sell in a busy kitchen, whatever its shape.
After printing: setting, cooking and eating
A printed food is rarely eaten as printed. It must be set, cooked or dried first. A chocolate shape is cooled until it sets firm, then lifted from the plate. A dough shape is baked, so the gluten sets and the starch gelatinises, and the printed shape becomes bread. A meat paste is cooked, so the protein sets and the fat melts, and the printed shape becomes a patty. A gel shape is left to set, or dipped in a calcium bath, until it is firm enough to move.
Cooking changes the shape, and the maker must allow for it. A dough rises in the oven, so a printed dough shape is printed smaller than the finished loaf. A meat paste shrinks as it cooks and loses water, so a printed patty is printed larger than the finished one. A gel dries and shrinks in storage, so a printed jelly is printed larger too. The shrinkage is measured by printing a test shape, cooking it, and measuring it before and after, and the difference is built into the next print. A maker who prints the finished size will serve a food that is too small, because the cooking was not counted.
Safety after printing is the same as for any food: the printed food must be cooked to a safe temperature, cooled quickly, and eaten soon or kept cold. A printed food has more surface than a whole food, because it is built in layers, so it cools faster and it can also dry out faster, and microbes can reach more of it. The maker therefore prints in a clean area, cooks the food promptly, and does not leave a printed food sitting warm for hours. The shape is new. The food safety rules are not.
Testing an ink: the printability window
An ink is ready when it prints inside its printability window: the range of settings where the lines are even, the layers stick, and the shape holds. The window is found by testing: print the same shape at different speeds, different temperatures and different water contents, and note which combinations work and which fail. The window is drawn as a simple map, with speed on one side and water content on the other, and the working region marked in the middle. A wide window means a forgiving ink that prints well even when the settings drift. A narrow window means a fussy ink that needs constant care.
The tests a maker runs are the same for every ink: a line test, a layer test, a shape test and a taste test. The line test prints one line and measures its width. The layer test prints ten layers and measures how tall they stand. The shape test prints a small cube or a star and checks whether it holds. The taste test cooks the printed food and eats it, because a shape that prints perfectly and tastes badly is still a failure. The four tests together decide whether an ink is ready for the kitchen or the factory.
The future of food inks is inks that do more: an ink that carries probiotics, an ink that changes colour as it cooks, an ink that prints a meal tuned to one person's nutrition. Each new ink must pass the same four tests, and the window must be wide enough for a real kitchen, not only for a laboratory printer. The printer is a tool. The ink is the food, and the food must print, cook and taste well, in that order.
Questions to think about
- Why does a food ink need to be shear thinning, and what goes wrong with an ink that is not?
- A food is printed in 20 layers at 30 seconds per layer. How long does the print take, and what happens to the time and the detail if the layer height is doubled?
- Why must a printed dough be printed smaller than the finished loaf, and a printed meat patty larger than the finished one?
Think about the print time before you read on
Twenty layers at 30 seconds each is 600 seconds, which is 10 minutes. Doubling the layer height halves the layers to 10, so the print takes 5 minutes, but each layer is thicker, so the shape is coarser. Finer detail costs time, and a food that takes an hour to print will never sell in a busy kitchen.
The diagram shows food ink work in order: from a recipe to a printed food that is cooked and tasted. The taste test is the last step, and a shape that prints well but tastes badly is still a failure.
Practical note: In a practical session, make a simple food ink from mashed potato: mash cooked potatoes, sieve them smooth, and divide the mash into three bowls. Leave one as it is, add a spoonful of water to the second, and a spoonful of cornflour mixed with water to the third. Pipe each one through a piping bag onto a plate, and note which flows easily, which holds a line, and which spreads. Record the results and answer: which bowl is closest to a printable ink, and what would you change to improve it?
Quick self-check
Question: Question: What is shear thinning, and why does a food ink need it?
Shear thinning means a paste flows more easily when it is pushed hard and thickens again when the push stops. An ink needs it so it is thin inside the nozzle, where the push is strong, and thick on the plate, where the push is gone, so the printed line holds its shape.
Question: Question: What is yield stress?
The push needed to start a paste moving at all. A food ink needs a yield stress so it sits still on the plate until the next layer is printed, and does not spread into a puddle.
Try it yourself
Visit a bakery or a market that sells piped foods, such as piped biscuits, piped chocolate or piped mashed potato, and look at the shapes: are the lines even, do the layers hold, does the shape stand? Write down what you see, and answer: which of those foods would print well in a 3D food printer, and which would fail, and why?
Key ideas to carry forward
- A food ink is a paste that flows through a nozzle, holds its shape, and sets into a food that can be eaten.
- Viscosity measures thickness, yield stress measures the push needed to start flow, and shear thinning lets an ink flow in the nozzle and hold on the plate.
- Pastes, gels, fats and chocolate are the main ink families, each with its own temperature and setting step.
- Nozzle size, layer height, print speed and temperature are the four printer settings, and they must match the ink.
- Print time equals layers multiplied by time per layer, so finer detail costs time.
- Cooking changes the shape: dough rises, meat shrinks, and the print must allow for it.
- An ink is ready when it prints inside its printability window and passes the line, layer, shape and taste tests.
Glossary
Food ink
A paste that can be pushed through a nozzle, hold its shape, and set into a food. Food tech example: mashed potato is tuned into a food ink for printing.
Viscosity
How thick a liquid is, or how hard it is to stir. Food tech example: honey has a high viscosity and water has a low one.
Yield stress
The push needed to start a paste moving at all. Food tech example: a food ink needs a yield stress so it does not spread into a puddle.
Shear thinning
Flowing more easily when pushed hard and thickening again when the push stops. Food tech example: a shear thinning ink is thin in the nozzle and thick on the plate.
Rheometer
An instrument that stirs a paste and measures how hard it is to stir. Food tech example: a rheometer gives the viscosity and yield stress of a food ink.
Nozzle
The narrow opening that a food ink is pushed through. Food tech example: a narrow nozzle prints fine lines but clogs easily.
Layer height
The thickness of each printed layer. Food tech example: layer height is usually set to about half the nozzle size.
Alginate
A gelling agent from seaweed that sets when it meets calcium. Food tech example: an alginate ink sets at once in a calcium bath.
Gelatine
A protein that sets into a gel when cooled. Food tech example: gelatine gels are printed warm and set as they cool.
Printability window
The range of settings where an ink prints well. Food tech example: a wide printability window means a forgiving ink.
Stearin
The solid fraction of an oil, separated by cooling. Food tech example: a fat ink uses stearin to hold its shape.
Gelatinisation
The swelling and setting of starch when it is heated with water. Food tech example: a printed dough sets in the oven as its starch gelatinises.
Marbling
Streaks of fat running through meat. Food tech example: a printed steak uses a fat ink to make marbling.
Shrinkage
Becoming smaller during cooking or drying. Food tech example: a printed meat patty shrinks as it cooks, so it is printed larger.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 10: Hybrid Cultivated Plus Plant Products
Note
Unit 10: Hybrid Cultivated Plus Plant Products
A question to start with
A fully cultivated steak is dear, and a fully plant based burger is not meat. Between them sits the hybrid: a food that blends a small amount of cultivated meat with a larger amount of plant protein, so the eater gets the flavour of real meat at a price near a plant product. This unit is about those hybrids: why they are made, how the blend is built, what each part contributes, and how a hybrid is labelled honestly.
Why blend cultivated meat with plants
The reason for a hybrid is arithmetic. Cultivated meat is dear because the cells, the medium and the tank cost more than a field and a mill. Plant protein is cheap because the crop is grown at scale and the powder is made in a mill. A blend that is mostly plant and a little cultivated meat costs far less than a fully cultivated product, while tasting far more like meat than a fully plant product. The blend buys the flavour of meat at the price of plants.
The second reason is flavour. Plant proteins can imitate the chew of meat, but they struggle with the flavour, because the flavour of meat comes from its fat, its iron and the reactions that happen when meat is cooked. A small amount of real meat cells, with real fat cells, brings those flavours into the blend, and the plant part carries them. Tasters often cannot tell a hybrid with a fifth of cultivated meat from a fully meat product, while they can tell a fully plant product at once. The cultivated part is a flavouring as much as an ingredient.
The third reason is the step for the shopper. A person who would not buy a fully cultivated steak may buy a hybrid burger, because it looks like a burger, costs like a burger, and tastes like a burger, with the new technology hidden inside a familiar form. The hybrid is a bridge, like the plant and animal hybrids of the alternative proteins subject, and it lets the eater try cultivated meat without committing to it. The bridge matters, because most change in diets happens gradually, one meal at a time.
Blend ratios: how much cultivated meat is enough
The blend ratio is the first decision, and it is set by tasting, not by arithmetic. A blend with 10 percent cultivated meat and 90 percent plant protein is cheap and close to a plant product, with a faint meaty note. A blend with 20 to 30 percent cultivated meat is the common middle: the meat flavour is clear, the cost is still near a plant product, and the texture is set by the plant part. A blend with 50 percent cultivated meat tastes strongly of meat, but it costs far more, and the maker must ask whether the extra flavour is worth the extra price.
The ratio is tested in stages. The maker builds small batches at 10, 20 and 30 percent, cooks them the same way, and asks a tasting panel to score flavour, juiciness and meatiness, and to guess which is which. The scores usually rise fast from 10 to 20 percent, and slowly from 20 to 30 percent, so the maker picks the lowest ratio that reaches the target score. That ratio is the blend, and it is written into the recipe with a tolerance, because the cultivated meat supply may vary and the recipe must still meet its label.
A worked example shows the blend arithmetic. A hybrid patty weighs 100 g and holds 20 g of protein. Suppose the recipe uses 15 g of pea protein isolate at 85 percent protein, which gives about 12.8 g of protein, and 20 g of cultivated meat at 20 percent protein, which gives 4 g of protein, and the rest of the protein comes from the other ingredients, such as binders and flavourings. The maker checks the sum against the label: if the sum is below 20 g, more isolate or more cultivated meat is added. The arithmetic is simple, but it is how the recipe is built and how the label is proved.
How the blend is built in the factory
A hybrid is built in three steps. First, the plant base is made: a texturate is hydrated, a powder is mixed with water and fat, and the base is seasoned. Second, the cultivated meat is prepared: the cells are harvested from the tank, gathered into small pieces or a mince, and kept cold. Third, the two are mixed gently, so the cultivated pieces stay whole and spread evenly through the plant base, like fat through a sausage, rather than being ground into a paste where their texture is lost.
Mixing gently matters, because the cultivated cells are soft and fragile, and hard mixing breaks them and loses the bite they bring. The mixing is done in a bowl mixer at low speed, for a short time, and the temperature is kept cold, so the fat stays firm and the mix stays even. The mixed mass is then formed into patties, nuggets or sausages, and the formed product is chilled or frozen at once, so the cultivated part does not warm up and spoil before it is cooked.
The factory must keep the two streams separate until they meet. The plant line runs dry and warm, the cultivated line runs wet and cold, and the two meet only in the mixer. The cultivated line is cleaned and sterilised like a meat line, with cold rooms, clean water and a strict cleaning schedule, while the plant line is cleaned like a dry goods line. A factory that mixes the two lines carelessly will contaminate the cultivated meat with plant dust, or the plant base with meat juices, and the product will fail its tests. The separation is part of the design, not an afterthought.
Texture and flavour: what each part contributes
The plant part gives the hybrid its body. A texturate gives the chew and the fibres, a binder gives the hold, and the fat in the plant base gives the juiciness. The plant part also gives the fibre, which meat lacks, and it holds the shape on the grill, so the patty does not fall apart. Without the plant part, a cultivated mince would be soft, wet and shapeless, because cultivated cells alone have no structure to hold them together.
The cultivated part gives the hybrid its flavour and its meatiness. The fat cells give the rich flavour of meat fat when they melt, the muscle cells give the savoury depth, and the iron in the cells gives the bloody note that plant products struggle to copy. The cultivated part also gives the colour: raw cultivated meat is pink, like raw meat, and it browns when cooked, because the same reactions happen. A hybrid that is cooked well browns like meat, smells like meat, and tastes like meat, because part of it is meat.
The two parts interact in cooking. The plant fibres hold the juices released by the cultivated cells, so the patty stays juicy. The cultivated fat melts into the plant base, carrying flavour through the whole patty. The plant binder sets as it cooks, holding the cultivated pieces in place. A hybrid that is tested only raw will miss all of this, so the maker tests the cooked product: the weight lost on cooking, the juiciness, the flavour and the colour, and the blend is adjusted until the cooked product passes. The eater never eats a raw hybrid. The test must be cooked too.
Nutrition and labelling of a hybrid
The nutrition of a hybrid sits between its two parents. The plant part brings fibre, which meat lacks, and it brings the amino acids of the plant, which are short of methionine. The cultivated part brings the complete protein of meat, with all the essential amino acids, and it brings iron and vitamin B12, which plants lack. The blend is therefore often better balanced than either part alone: the plant lifts the fibre, the cultivated meat lifts the protein quality and the iron, and the eater gets both.
The label must name both parts plainly. A shopper with a soy allergy must see the soy in the plant base. A shopper who avoids meat must see the cultivated meat, even though no animal was reared. A shopper with a milk allergy must see any dairy ingredient in the binder. The name of the product must not mislead: a hybrid burger is a hybrid burger, not a beef burger, and the pack must say what share is cultivated meat, so the shopper knows what they are buying. The protein content on the nutrition panel must be the protein of the finished product, measured by testing, not the sum of the recipe on paper.
The safety file for a hybrid covers the blend as a whole, not only the parts. The cultivated meat has its own file, the plant ingredients have their own history, and the blend is tested for microbes, for allergy and for shelf life, because a new combination can behave differently from its parts. A hybrid that is safe in its parts is not automatically safe as a whole, and the maker tests it as a whole, with the same rigour as a new food, because that is what it is.
The future of hybrids
Hybrids are likely to be the first cultivated meat most shoppers eat, because they are the cheapest way to put real meat cells on a plate, and the easiest way to earn the shopper's trust. A hybrid nugget in a fast food shop, a hybrid burger on a supermarket shelf, a hybrid sausage at a market stall: each one is a small taste of cultivated meat, in a form the shopper already knows, at a price the shopper already pays. Each taste makes the next product easier to sell, and the share of cultivated meat in the blend can rise as the cost falls.
The future blend may also change. Today the plant part is usually soy or pea. Tomorrow it may be mycoprotein, which brings a meat-like fibre, or a fermentation made protein, which brings a function the plant cannot. The cultivated part may grow from a fifth to a third to a half, as tanks grow larger and medium grows cheaper. The product may move from a burger to a steak, as scaffolds improve and the cultivated part can hold a shape on its own. Each step is a small change, tested by tasting and by price, and the hybrid is the vehicle that carries the technology forward.
The last question is the eater's: will the hybrid be judged as meat, or as a new food? The answer will decide its name, its label and its price, and it will be decided by shoppers, not by makers. A hybrid that is sold as a new food, with its own flavour and its own place, will be judged on its own terms. A hybrid that is sold as meat will be judged against meat, bite for bite. The wise maker lets the eater decide, by naming the product honestly and letting the taste speak.
Questions to think about
- Why is a hybrid with 20 percent cultivated meat often chosen over one with 50 percent, even though the 50 percent blend tastes more like meat?
- A hybrid patty holds 15 g of pea isolate at 85 percent protein and 20 g of cultivated meat at 20 percent protein. How much protein do those two parts give together?
- Why must the cultivated meat and the plant base be mixed gently, at low speed and cold, rather than ground together hard?
Think about the blend arithmetic before you read on
The pea isolate gives 15 multiplied by 0.85, which is about 12.8 g of protein, and the cultivated meat gives 20 multiplied by 0.20, which is 4 g of protein, so the two parts together give about 16.8 g. The rest of the protein in the 20 g label comes from the other ingredients, such as binders, and the maker checks the sum against the label by testing the finished product.
The diagram shows hybrid making in order: plant base and cultivated meat meet only in the mixer, and the product is tested cooked, because the eater never eats it raw.
Practical note: In a practical session, make a hybrid at home with familiar foods: mix minced meat with cooked lentils, half and half, season the mix, and shape it into small patties. Cook them beside patties of pure meat and pure lentils, and ask friends to taste all three without knowing which is which. Record the scores for flavour, juiciness and meatiness, and answer: how much meat flavour does the half blend keep, and would you buy the blend again?
Quick self-check
Question: Question: Why is a hybrid cheaper than a fully cultivated product?
Because the cultivated meat, with its dear cells, medium and tank, is only a small share of the weight, while most of the weight is cheap plant protein from a crop grown at scale. The blend buys the flavour of meat at the price of plants.
Question: Question: What does the cultivated part contribute that the plant part cannot?
The flavour and meatiness of real meat: the fat cells give rich flavour when they melt, the muscle cells give savoury depth, and the iron gives the colour and the bloody note that plant products struggle to copy.
Try it yourself
Visit a shop and look for a product that blends meat with plant protein, such as a burger or a sausage with lentils, mushrooms or pea protein in the ingredient list. Write down the blend: which meat, which plant, and in what order they appear in the list. Then answer: does the pack name the blend honestly, and would you try a cultivated plus plant hybrid if it were sold beside it?
Key ideas to carry forward
- A hybrid blends a small amount of cultivated meat with a larger amount of plant protein, buying meat flavour at a plant price.
- The blend ratio is set by tasting, and 20 to 30 percent cultivated meat is a common middle.
- The plant part gives body, chew, fibre and shape, while the cultivated part gives flavour, meatiness and colour.
- The two streams are kept separate until they meet in the mixer, and the mixing is gentle, slow and cold.
- The blend is tested cooked, because the eater never eats it raw, and the label must name both parts plainly.
- Hybrids are likely to be the first cultivated meat most shoppers eat, and the cultivated share can rise as costs fall.
- A hybrid is judged as a new food, not only as meat, and honest naming lets the eater decide.
Glossary
Hybrid product
A food that blends two or more protein sources, such as plant and cultivated meat. Food tech example: a hybrid patty blends pea protein with cultivated cells.
Blend ratio
The share of each part in a blend. Food tech example: a hybrid with 20 percent cultivated meat and 80 percent plant protein is a common blend.
Texturate
A protein shaped by extrusion into fibrous or spongy pieces that feel like meat. Food tech example: soy texturate gives a hybrid its chew.
Binder
An ingredient that holds a food together. Food tech example: a binder in a hybrid patty holds the cultivated pieces in place.
Fat cell
A cell that stores fat and gives flavour when it melts. Food tech example: fat cells in cultivated meat give a hybrid its rich flavour.
Muscle cell
A cell that forms the fibres of meat. Food tech example: muscle cells give a hybrid its savoury depth.
Iron
A mineral in meat that gives colour and a bloody note. Food tech example: iron in cultivated cells helps a hybrid look and taste like meat.
Vitamin B12
A vitamin found in animal foods and not in plants. Food tech example: cultivated meat brings vitamin B12 to a hybrid.
Methionine
An essential amino acid that legumes are short of. Food tech example: cultivated meat lifts the methionine of a pea based hybrid.
Shelf life
How long a food stays safe and good to eat. Food tech example: a hybrid is tested for shelf life as a whole, not only in its parts.
Tasting panel
A group of people who taste a food and score it. Food tech example: a tasting panel sets the blend ratio of a hybrid.
Cold chain
Keeping a food cold from factory to shop to home. Food tech example: a hybrid is chilled at once so the cultivated part stays cold.
Mince
Meat cut into small pieces. Food tech example: cultivated cells are gathered into a mince for a hybrid burger.
Bridge product
A food that helps eaters move gradually to a new diet. Food tech example: a hybrid burger is a bridge to cultivated meat.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 11: Cultivated Seafood
Note
Unit 11: Cultivated Seafood
A question to start with
Fish is the most eaten animal protein in many parts of the world, and it is also one of the hardest to farm well: wild stocks are pressed, fish farms need clean water and feed, and the fish on the plate can carry mercury and microplastics from the sea. Cultivated seafood offers another route: fish cells grown in a tank, without a sea, without a net, and without the contaminants of the ocean. This unit explains why seafood may be the first cultivated meat to reach the plate, how fish cells are grown, and what still needs solving.
Why seafood may come first
Seafood has three advantages over cultivated beef or pork. The first is structure: a fish fillet is softer and simpler than a steak, with thin fibres and little connective tissue, so it is easier to imitate with cells grown in a tank. A maker does not need a thick, marbled steak to make a fish fillet. A thin sheet of muscle cells, layered with a little fat, already looks and feels like fish. The second is value: many seafoods are dear per kilogram, so a cultivated version does not need to match the cheapest meat to compete. It needs to match a fish that is already expensive.
The third advantage is the story. Wild fish stocks are pressed in many seas, and shoppers know it. A cultivated fish that spares the sea, and that carries no mercury and no microplastics, has a clear reason to exist that a shopper can understand in one sentence. The story is not a slogan. It is the reason the product is being made, and it is tested by the same evidence as any food claim: the cells, the medium, the tests and the label.
Seafood also has a practical advantage in the tank: fish cells grow at lower temperatures than mammal cells, often near room temperature rather than body temperature, so the tank needs less heating and less cooling. That saves energy, and it makes the process cheaper to run. The lower temperature also suits the factory, because a tank that runs cool is easier to keep clean and easier to work beside. Each of these advantages is small on its own. Together they make seafood the most likely first cultivated meat on the plate.
Fish cells: muscle, fat and flavour
A fish fillet is mostly muscle, with fat running through it in thin layers. The muscle cells are long fibres, and they are grown from fish stem cells, which divide and then mature into muscle. The fat cells are grown from a second line, and they hold the oils that give fish its flavour and its nutrition, including the long chain omega-3 fats that the body needs. The two lines are grown separately, because they need different signals to mature, and they are mixed when the fillet is formed.
The flavour of fish comes from its fat and from the small molecules in its flesh, and it is delicate: a fish that tastes too strong is a failure, and a fish that tastes of nothing is a failure too. The maker must therefore grow the fat cells well, because the fat carries the flavour, and must keep the cells fresh, because fish flavour fades fast when the cells are stressed. The colour of fish is part of the flavour too: a salmon fillet is pink because of the pigments in its flesh, and a cultivated salmon must carry the same colour, either from the cells themselves or from a pigment added to the medium, in a way the safety file has judged.
A worked example shows the fillet arithmetic. A fillet weighs 100 g and holds 20 g of protein and 5 g of fat. If the maker grows 80 g of muscle cells at 22 percent protein, the muscle gives about 17.6 g of protein, and 20 g of fat cells at 10 percent protein gives 2 g more, with the rest from the binder. The maker checks the sum against the label, and adjusts the ratio of muscle to fat until the protein, the fat and the flavour all match a real fillet. The arithmetic is simple. The biology is not, because the fat cells must be grown to hold the right oils, not only the right amount of fat.
Shellfish and the wider sea
Beyond finned fish sits shellfish: shrimp, crab, lobster and scallops, which are among the dearest seafoods and the most wanted. A shrimp is mostly muscle, curled into a small shape, and it is easier to imitate than a steak, because the shape is small and the structure is simple. A cultivated shrimp is made by growing shrimp muscle cells and shaping them into a shrimp form, sometimes by 3D printing, sometimes by moulding, and the shape is set by cooking or by a gel. The eater judges a shrimp by its snap, its curve and its flavour, and the maker must match all three.
Shellfish carry a sharp allergy question. Shrimp and crab are among the foods that most often cause allergy, and a cultivated shrimp carries the same proteins as a wild shrimp, because it is made of the same cells. The label must therefore warn a shopper with a shellfish allergy, plainly, even though no sea was involved. The allergy is in the cell, not in the sea, and the maker who hides it endangers the shopper. The safety file for a cultivated shellfish covers allergy first, because it is the sharpest risk in the product.
The wider sea also holds seaweeds and microalgae, which are not cultivated seafood in the same sense, but which meet it on the plate. A seaweed gives the flavour of the sea to a cultivated fish, and a microalga gives the omega-3 oils that the fish cells may lack. The cultivated seafood of the future may be a blend: fish cells for the fillet, algal oil for the nutrition, and seaweed for the flavour of the sea. Each part is judged on its own file, and the blend is tested as a whole, like any hybrid.
What still needs solving: texture, flavour and cost
The first problem is texture. A real fish fillet flakes into layers when it is cooked, because its muscle fibres run in sheets separated by thin connective tissue. A cultivated fillet made of cells in a gel does not flake the same way, and the eater notices at once. The fix is structure: growing the cells on a scaffold that gives them direction, or printing the fillet in layers, so the cooked fish flakes. The scaffold and the printing are the hard parts, and they are where the research is focused.
The second problem is flavour. The flavour of fish comes from the sea, from the food the fish ate, and from the fats it stored, and a tank grown fish that ate only sugar and amino acids may taste plain. The maker must therefore feed the cells the precursors of flavour, or add the flavour after harvest, in a way that is honest and safe. A flavour added after harvest must be named on the label, and it must be a flavour the eater recognises as fish, not as a laboratory.
The third problem is cost. Fish cells grow slowly compared with microbes, the medium is dear, and the fillet is small, so the cost per kilogram is high. The maker cuts the cost the same way as for any cultivated meat: a faster cell line, a cheaper medium, a larger tank, and a hybrid that blends the cultivated fish with a plant base to cut the price. A cultivated shrimp that costs ten times a wild shrimp will sell only to the few who will pay for the story. A cultivated shrimp that costs twice as much may sell to many, and a cultivated shrimp that costs the same will sell to all.
Safety, mercury and the clean sea claim
A cultivated fish carries no mercury, because mercury comes from the sea, and the tank has no sea in it. It carries no microplastics, because the medium is filtered and the tank is closed. Those are real advantages, and they can be claimed, but only with evidence: the finished fish must be tested for mercury and for microplastics, and the tests must show they are absent or below the limit. A claim without a test is a slogan, and a slogan will be caught by the first independent test.
The safety file for a cultivated fish covers the same ground as for any cultivated meat: the cell line, the medium, the process, the finished product, the microbes, the chemicals and the allergy. It also covers the water: the water in the medium must be food grade, because the cells drink it, and anything in the water ends up in the fish. The factory is tested for contamination like any food factory, and the finished fish is tested batch by batch, because a tank that grows fish cells can also grow bacteria if it is not kept clean.
The label must be honest about what the fish is and what it is not. It is fish, made of fish cells, and a shopper with a fish allergy must be told so. It is not wild, it is not farmed, and the pack must not show a sea and a boat as if it were. The shopper who buys a cultivated fish for a clean sea deserves to know how it was made, and the maker who tells the truth earns the trust that sells the second pack.
The future of cultivated seafood
The future of cultivated seafood is likely to arrive in small pieces first: a shrimp, a fish ball, a fish finger, a surimi style product where the shape is simple and the flavour is carried by the fat. Those products need less structure than a fillet, they are cheaper to make, and they are eaten in forms the shopper already knows. A fish finger made of cultivated cells is a small step for the eater and a large step for the technology, and it is the step most makers are taking first.
The fillet will follow, when the scaffold and the printing are ready, and when the cost has fallen enough for a fillet to compete with a farmed one. The fillet will be judged by the flake, the flavour and the price, and it will need all three to win. The shellfish will follow too, when the allergy file is complete and the shape is right. Each product will arrive when its structure, its flavour and its cost are ready, not before, and the makers who rush a fillet before its structure is ready will teach the shopper that cultivated fish is a poor copy, which is the worst lesson to teach.
The sea will not be replaced by the tank. Wild and farmed fish will feed most people for a long time, and cultivated seafood will be a small share, for shoppers who want it, in places where it makes sense. That is enough. A small share, made well, proves the technology, earns the trust, and gives the sea a rest. The future is not a tank that replaces the ocean. It is a tank beside the ocean, making a little of what the ocean can no longer give.
Questions to think about
- Why is a fish fillet easier to imitate with cultivated cells than a beef steak, and why might seafood reach the plate first?
- A cultivated shrimp carries the same proteins as a wild shrimp. Why must its label still warn a shopper with a shellfish allergy?
- A cultivated fish carries no mercury. Why must that claim still be backed by a test on the finished fish?
Think about the shellfish allergy before you read on
The allergy is in the cell, not in the sea: a cultivated shrimp is made of the same muscle cells as a wild shrimp, so it holds the same allergy proteins. The label must warn a shopper with a shellfish allergy plainly, even though no sea was involved, because the maker who hides it endangers the shopper.
The diagram shows cultivated seafood in order: from fish cells to a tested fillet. The layering step is what makes the cooked fish flake like a real fillet.
Practical note: In a practical session, cook a fish fillet and a fish finger, and study the texture: flake the fillet with a fork and note how it separates into layers, then cut the fish finger and note how it differs. Record the flake, the juiciness and the flavour of each, and answer: which one would be easier to imitate with cells grown in a tank, and why?
Quick self-check
Question: Question: Why do fish cells grow at lower temperatures than mammal cells?
Because fish live in cool water, so their cells are built to grow near room temperature rather than body temperature. A tank that runs cool needs less heating and cooling, which saves energy and makes the process cheaper to run.
Question: Question: Why is a cultivated shrimp likely to arrive before a cultivated fillet?
Because a shrimp is small and simple in structure, and it is eaten in forms where the shape is simple, such as a fish ball or a finger. A fillet needs a layered structure that flakes when cooked, which is harder to build.
Try it yourself
Visit a fish counter or a frozen food aisle and look at the seafoods sold: fillets, fingers, shrimp, fish balls. For each one, write down the price per 100 g and the form it is sold in. Then answer: which of those forms would a cultivated seafood maker choose first, and why would the price per 100 g decide it?
Key ideas to carry forward
- A fish fillet is softer and simpler than a steak, so it is easier to imitate with cells grown in a tank.
- Fish cells grow at lower temperatures than mammal cells, which saves energy in the tank.
- A fillet is muscle and fat, and the fat carries the flavour and the omega-3 oils.
- Shellfish are dear and simple in shape, but they carry a sharp allergy that the label must name plainly.
- Texture is the hardest problem: a cultivated fillet must flake into layers when cooked.
- A cultivated fish carries no mercury and no microplastics, but the claim must be backed by tests on the finished fish.
- Small pieces, such as shrimp, fish balls and fingers, are likely to arrive before a full fillet.
Glossary
Cultivated seafood
Fish or shellfish grown from cells in a tank, without a sea or a net. Food tech example: cultivated shrimp is made of shrimp muscle cells grown in a tank.
Omega-3 fat
A long chain unsaturated fat the body needs, found in fish oil and algal oil. Food tech example: fish fat cells hold the omega-3 fats that give fish its nutrition.
Surimi
A fish paste made from minced fish, shaped into fingers, balls or imitation crab. Food tech example: a cultivated fish paste can be shaped like surimi.
Flake
To separate into thin layers when cooked, as a fish fillet does. Food tech example: a cultivated fillet must flake like a real fillet.
Connective tissue
The network of collagen that holds muscle bundles together. Food tech example: a fish fillet has little connective tissue, so it is soft.
Mercury
A toxic metal that can build up in wild fish from the sea. Food tech example: a cultivated fish carries no mercury because its tank has no sea in it.
Microplastics
Tiny pieces of plastic found in the sea and in wild fish. Food tech example: a cultivated fish carries no microplastics because its medium is filtered.
Shellfish allergy
An allergic reaction to shrimp, crab or other shellfish. Food tech example: a cultivated shrimp must warn a shopper with a shellfish allergy.
Stem cell
A cell that can divide and become different kinds of cell. Food tech example: cultivated seafood starts from fish stem cells.
Scaffold
A structure that gives growing cells shape, so meat feels like meat. Food tech example: a scaffold gives a cultivated fillet its layers.
Pigment
A substance that gives a food its colour. Food tech example: a cultivated salmon must carry the pink pigment of a real salmon.
Fish ball
A ball of minced fish, often eaten in soups. Food tech example: a fish ball is a simple form for cultivated seafood to arrive in.
Farmed fish
Fish reared in a fish farm. Food tech example: a cultivated fillet will be judged against a farmed fillet on flake, flavour and price.
Wild fish
Fish caught from the sea. Food tech example: wild fish stocks are pressed in many seas, which is one reason cultivated seafood is being made.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.
Unit 12: Ethics and Animal Welfare
Note
Unit 12: Ethics and Animal Welfare
A question to start with
Cultivated meat promises meat without slaughter, and that promise raises questions that no specification sheet can answer: is it right to grow meat from cells, does it truly spare animals, who can afford it, and who decides? This unit sets out those questions plainly, gives each side its fair hearing, and leaves the reader with the tools to judge, because the ethics of a new food are decided by eaters, not by makers.
The animal question: fewer animals, but not none
The clearest ethical claim for cultivated meat is that it spares animals from rearing and slaughter. A tank that makes a tonne of meat from cells does not need a herd, a feedlot or an abattoir, and the animals that would have been reared for that meat are never born. For a person who avoids meat because of the animal, that is a real gain, and it is the reason many supporters care about the technology at all.
The claim needs care, because the cells still come from an animal. The first sample is taken from a living animal, by a biopsy, a small piece of tissue taken with a needle. The biopsy is a minor procedure, and the animal lives, but it is still a use of an animal, and a person who believes no animal should be used at all will not accept it. The medium also raises the question: if it uses serum from animal blood, then animals are still used, and the claim of meat without animals is not yet true. Serum free medium answers that question, but only when it is actually used, and the reader should ask which medium a product used before believing the claim.
The welfare question is therefore a matter of degree, not of all or nothing. Cultivated meat uses far fewer animals than farming, and it uses them far more lightly, but it does not yet use none. A maker who claims it uses none, while still using serum or a fresh biopsy for every line, is overstating the case, and the overstatement harms the technology, because the shopper who catches it trusts the next claim less. The honest claim is the measured one: far fewer animals, used far more lightly, and moving towards none.
The welfare of the animals that remain
Farming will not disappear because cultivated meat arrives. Most meat will come from farms for a long time, and the animals on those farms still deserve care. A question the technology raises is whether it will help those animals or harm them: whether the money and attention that go to the tank will be taken from the farm, leaving farm welfare worse, or whether the tank will take the pressure off the farm, letting fewer animals be reared better.
The answer depends on how the two systems are run together. A farm that rears fewer animals, with more space, better feed and slower growth, can give those animals a better life, and the meat it sells can carry a premium that pays for it. A farm that is squeezed by a cheaper tank, and that cuts corners to compete, can give its animals a worse life. The technology does not decide that outcome. The rules, the prices and the shoppers decide it, and the reader who cares about farm animals should watch both systems, not only the tank.
The animals that give the first cell samples also deserve care. A biopsy must be taken by a trained person, with pain relief, from a healthy animal, and the animal must be kept well after it. A cell line that comes from a suffering animal carries that suffering in its story, even if the meat itself is clean. The welfare of the donor animal is part of the ethics of the product, and a maker who can show the donor was cared for earns a trust that a maker who hides the donor cannot.
The environment and the land question
The environmental ethics of cultivated meat are about more than the footprint. A tank that uses little land can spare land for forests, for wild animals, and for crops that feed people directly. That is a gain, if the spared land is actually spared, and not simply used for another farm. A tank that uses a lot of power, from a dirty source, can warm the planet more than the farm it replaces, and the gain is lost. The ethics depend on the power, the sugar and the land together, not on the tank alone.
The land question also touches the people who live on the land. A farming community that loses its animals to a tank loses its work, its income and its way of life, and the loss is real even if the planet gains. A just change is one that gives those people a part in the new system: work in the plant, a share in the supply, or time and help to change. A change that leaves them behind is not a just change, whatever the footprint says. The reader should ask not only how much land is spared, but whose land it is, and who gains from sparing it.
The waste question is part of the same ethics. A tank makes waste medium, waste cells and waste packaging, and a factory that pours its waste into a river harms the water as surely as a farm that does the same. A clean tank is one that treats its waste, reuses its water, and credits its side streams, as the life cycle assessment of the alternative proteins subject explains. The environment is not saved by moving the harm from a field to a factory. It is saved by removing the harm.
Belief, culture and the eater's choice
Food is not only nutrition. It is belief, culture and identity, and a new meat must meet those too. Some people eat meat as part of their culture, and a cultivated meat that lets them keep that food, without the slaughter they object to, is a welcome thing. Some people avoid meat as part of their belief, and a cultivated meat that is still meat, made of animal cells, is not a food they will eat, whatever the tank did. Both positions are honest, and both deserve respect, because the choice is the eater's, not the maker's.
Religious and cultural rules about meat vary, and they are decided by the communities that hold them, not by a food company. A cultivated meat may be judged differently by different communities, and the judgement may change as the technology changes: a meat made without serum may be judged differently from a meat made with it, and a meat made from a biopsy may be judged differently from one made from a line stored for years. The maker cannot decide those questions. The maker can only give the facts, plainly, so each community can judge for itself.
The eater's choice needs a label that tells the truth. A pack that calls cultivated meat simply meat, without saying how it was made, takes the choice away from the eater. A pack that names it plainly, as cultivated meat, gives the choice back. The label is the ethics made visible, and a maker who hides the making on the label is deciding for the eater, which is the one thing a maker should never do. The eater may choose to eat it, or not to eat it, and either choice is right, because it is theirs.
Who can afford it: food justice
A new food that only the rich can eat is a food that has failed the people who need it most. Cultivated meat is dear today, and its first buyers will be people who can pay a premium. That is how most new foods start, and it is not a fault in itself, but it becomes a fault if the price never falls, and the food stays a luxury while the people who eat the most meat, and who bear the most of its footprint, cannot afford it. The justice question is whether the price will fall, how fast, and who will be helped to afford it.
The price falls when the tank grows, the medium grows cheaper, and the cell line grows faster, as the cost unit of this subject explains. It also falls when the product is sold as a hybrid, blending a little cultivated meat with a plant base, so the price is near a plant product. A maker who sells only a premium steak is serving the few. A maker who sells a hybrid nugget at a common price is serving the many, and the justice of the technology is judged by the second product more than by the first.
The justice question also touches the places where the meat is made. A tank built only in rich regions, selling only to rich shoppers, does not feed the world. A tank built where the need is greatest, using local feed and local workers, does. The reader should ask where the plant is, who works in it, and who eats what it makes, because a technology that feeds only the rich is a technology that has not yet done its job.
How to judge: five questions for the reader
The ethics of cultivated meat can be judged with five questions. First, how many animals were used, and how were they treated, from the biopsy to the tank? Second, what is in the medium, and does it still use animal blood? Third, what is the footprint, counted with the same boundary as any other food, and what would change the answer? Fourth, does the label tell the truth, so the eater can choose? Fifth, who can afford it, and who gains from it, the eater, the farmer, or only the maker?
A product that answers those questions well is a product worth eating, for those who choose to eat it. A product that cannot answer them is a product to wait for. The reader need not agree with every answer to respect the questions, and the reader need not eat the meat to judge it fairly. The questions are the same for any new food, and they are the tools this subject leaves the reader with.
The last word belongs to the eater. A technology can be clever, a footprint can be small, and a steak can be perfect, and still the eater may say no, because the food does not fit their belief, their culture or their taste. That no is not ignorance. It is a choice, and a food system that respects it is a better food system than one that does not. The ethics of cultivated meat are not decided in the tank. They are decided at the table, one eater at a time.
Questions to think about
- Why is the claim that cultivated meat uses no animals not yet true for every product, and what should the reader ask before believing it?
- A cultivated meat is made of animal cells. Why might a person who avoids meat for belief still refuse to eat it, and why does that choice deserve respect?
- Why is the price of cultivated meat a question of justice, not only of business?
Think about the animal claim before you read on
The cells still come from an animal, by a biopsy, and the medium may still use serum from animal blood, so animals are still used, though far fewer and far more lightly than in farming. The honest claim is far fewer animals, used far more lightly, and moving towards none, and the reader should ask which medium a product used before believing a claim of no animals.
The diagram shows the five ethics questions in order. A product that answers them well is worth eating, for those who choose to eat it, and a product that cannot answer them is one to wait for.
Practical note: In a practical session, take a food you eat often and judge it with the five questions in the last section: how many animals were used, what went into making it, what is its footprint, does its label tell the truth, and who can afford it? Write down your answers, and then ask a friend to judge the same food. Compare your answers and note where you differ, and answer: which question did you both find hardest to answer, and why?
Quick self-check
Question: Question: Why does cultivated meat use far fewer animals than farming, but not none?
Because the cells still come from an animal, by a biopsy, and the medium may still use serum from animal blood. Far fewer animals are used, and far more lightly, but the claim of none is only true when the medium is serum free and the line is stored, not freshly taken.
Question: Question: Why must the label name cultivated meat plainly?
Because the choice is the eater's, not the maker's. A pack that calls it simply meat takes the choice away, while a pack that names it plainly lets each eater, each belief and each culture judge for itself.
Try it yourself
Choose a new food you have heard about, such as a plant based burger or a cultivated meat, and write a short judgement of it using the five questions in the last section. Share your judgement with a friend who disagrees with you, and listen to their answers to the same five questions. Write down one thing their judgement taught you that yours had missed.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Cultivated meat uses far fewer animals than farming, and far more lightly, but it does not yet use none.
- The biopsy and the medium decide the animal question: serum free medium and a stored line move the product towards no animals.
- Farming will not disappear, and the welfare of farm animals still matters as the tank arrives.
- The environment is helped only if the power is clean, the sugar is clean, and the spared land is truly spared.
- Belief, culture and identity decide whether an eater will eat cultivated meat, and the choice belongs to the eater.
- The label must name cultivated meat plainly, so each eater and each community can judge for itself.
- Price is a question of justice: a food that only the rich can eat has not yet done its job.
Glossary
Ethics
Questions about what is right and wrong in how a food is made and eaten. Food tech example: the ethics of cultivated meat cover animals, land, belief and price.
Animal welfare
The health, comfort and humane treatment of animals. Food tech example: animal welfare covers the donor animal of a cell line as well as farm animals.
Biopsy
A small piece of tissue taken from a living animal with a needle. Food tech example: a cultivated meat line starts from a biopsy taken from a healthy animal.
Serum
The liquid part of blood, long used in cell culture because it holds many growth signals. Food tech example: serum free medium removes animal blood from the tank.
Serum free medium
Culture medium with each growth signal added separately, without animal blood. Food tech example: serum free medium moves cultivated meat towards using no animals.
Food justice
Fairness in who can afford and access food. Food tech example: a cultivated meat that only the rich can eat fails the test of food justice.
Footprint
The land, water, energy and gases counted for a food across its life. Food tech example: a footprint must be counted with the same boundary for every food.
Label
The words on a pack that name a food and its ingredients. Food tech example: a label that names cultivated meat plainly lets the eater choose.
Culture
The shared beliefs, foods and customs of a community. Food tech example: meat holds a place in many cultures, and cultivated meat must meet those cultures.
Belief
A deeply held view about what is right to eat. Food tech example: a person who avoids meat for belief may still refuse cultivated meat, because it is still meat.
Donor animal
The animal from which the first cells for a cell line were taken. Food tech example: the donor animal of a cell line must be cared for.
Just change
A change that shares its gains fairly and does not leave people behind. Food tech example: a just change gives farming communities a part in the new system.
Premium
A higher price paid for a new or special food. Food tech example: a cultivated steak sold at a premium reaches only the few who can pay it.
Side stream
A stream of material that leaves a process beside the main product. Food tech example: crediting a side stream properly changes the footprint of a process.
References
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
- Warriss, P. D., Meat Science, 2nd edition, 2010.
- Godoi, F. C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B. R., Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications, 2019.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Stanbury, P. F., Whitaker, A. and Hall, S. J., Principles of Fermentation Technology, 3rd edition, 2017.