GIFSQ ID: FTN-0107
Clean-Label Foods and Food Additives
Unit 1: What Clean Label Means
Note
Unit 1: What Clean Label Means
A question to start with
A shopper stands in front of two loaves of bread. One pack lists five ingredients: wheat flour, water, yeast, salt, and a little oil. The other lists fifteen, including words she does not recognise, numbers in brackets, and names she cannot pronounce. Both loaves look the same, both cost almost the same, and both will make a sandwich. She picks the first loaf, because she knows what is in it. That choice, made in a few seconds in a shop, is the whole clean label idea in one moment: food that is simple enough to understand, made with ingredients people recognise, and labelled in words people can read. This unit is about what that idea means, where it came from, and what it does and does not promise.
Clean label is not a legal term in most places. There is no single law that defines it, no official stamp that proves it, and no fixed list of ingredients that are allowed or banned. It is a way of describing food that aims to be simple, familiar, and transparent: a short ingredient list, ingredients that sound like foods rather than chemicals, and as little processing as the food will allow. Because it has no single definition, the same words can mean different things on different packs, and a buyer needs to know how to read them. This unit gives the buyer, and the food maker, that reading.
Questions to think about
- Two loaves have the same ingredients, but one lists "ascorbic acid" and the other lists "vitamin C". Which one looks cleaner, and is it really different?
- A juice says "no artificial colours" on the front. What should you check on the back before believing it?
- If a food has a short ingredient list, does that always mean it is healthier?
Think about the two loaves before you read on
They are the same substance: ascorbic acid is vitamin C, the same chemical with two names, one that sounds like a laboratory and one that sounds like a food. The loaf that says vitamin C looks cleaner, but the food is identical. Clean label is often about words as much as about substances, which is why a buyer must read the whole list, not only the name that looks friendly.
Where the idea came from
Clean label grew out of a change in how shoppers think about food. For most of the last century, food makers added ingredients to make food keep longer, taste better, look brighter, and cost less, and shoppers trusted that science had made food better. In recent decades, many shoppers began to ask a different question: not only "does it taste good and keep well" but also "what is in it, and do I recognise it?" The question grew with news about additives, with the rise of home cooking shows, with ingredient lists printed on every pack, and with a wider wish to eat food that feels close to the kitchen rather than close to the factory.
The idea spread first in bread, dairy, drinks, and snacks, where the ingredient list is short enough for a shopper to read in the shop. A yoghurt with three ingredients sells the idea in one line. A soft drink with a long list of colours, sweeteners, and preservatives shows the opposite. Makers began to shorten lists, to replace unfamiliar names with familiar ones, and to put claims on the front of the pack, such as "no artificial colours", "no preservatives", or "made with simple ingredients". The claims worked, and the market for such foods grew fast, with new products appearing every year in shops around the world. The growth was driven by shoppers, not by law, and that matters: a market driven by shoppers rewards what looks clean, which is not always the same as what is clean.
Clean label also grew with a wider interest in food origin and honesty. Shoppers began to ask where food comes from, how it was made, and whether the words on the pack match what is inside. A pack that says "natural" but lists a long set of additives feels dishonest, and shoppers notice. A pack that lists a short set of ingredients and explains each one feels honest, and shoppers reward it. In that sense, clean label is less about chemistry than about trust: the maker shows the buyer what is in the food, in words the buyer can understand, and the buyer decides.
What "clean" usually means in practice
When makers and shoppers use the words clean label, they usually mean several things at once, and it helps to separate them. First, a short ingredient list: fewer ingredients, and no ingredient that is there only to do a job the buyer cannot see. Second, familiar ingredients: ingredients that sound like foods, such as lemon juice, beetroot, or sea salt, rather than ingredients that sound like chemicals, such as sodium benzoate or monosodium glutamate, even when the substance is the same. Third, no artificial colours, flavours, or preservatives, or as few as possible, with natural versions used instead where they work. Fourth, minimal processing: food that is made in a way that feels close to cooking, rather than a way that feels like a factory process. Fifth, transparency: a label that explains what each ingredient does, and a maker who will answer questions about the list.
Each of these is a matter of degree, not a yes or no. A short list can still hide a complex ingredient, such as a flavouring that is itself made of many parts. A familiar name can hide a substance that is made in a factory, such as citric acid made by fermentation, which sounds like a kitchen ingredient but is made at industrial scale. A natural colour can be less stable than a synthetic one, so the food may fade on the shelf. A food with no preservative may spoil faster, so the maker must change the pack, the storage, or the shelf life to keep it safe. Clean label is therefore a set of trade-offs, and a good maker knows what is being traded, while a careless maker only knows what the front of the pack says.
Clean, natural, and healthy: three different words
The most common mistake in clean label talk is to treat clean, natural, and healthy as the same word. They are three different ideas, and a food can be one without being the others. Clean means the ingredient list is short and familiar. Natural means the ingredients come from nature rather than being made in a factory, though the line between the two is not sharp, because many natural ingredients are processed in factories, and many factory-made ingredients are copies of natural ones. Healthy means the food, as part of a whole diet, supports health: it is about nutrients, about sugar, salt, and fat, about fibre and vitamins, and about how much is eaten, not only about the ingredient list.
A food can be clean and not healthy. A white bread with five ingredients is clean, but it is low in fibre and made from refined flour, so it is not a strong choice for health. A fruit juice with one ingredient, the juice itself, is clean and natural, but it is high in sugar and low in fibre, so a glass of it is not the same as eating the fruit. A food can be healthy and not clean: a fortified breakfast cereal may carry added vitamins and minerals, with a long list of names, and still be a useful food. A food can be natural and not clean: a spice mix made only of dried plants is natural, but if it lists twenty spices, it is not short. The buyer who treats clean as a promise of health will be misled, and the maker who sells clean as health is making a promise the food cannot keep.
What clean label does not promise
Clean label does not promise that a food is safe, because safety comes from how the food is made, stored, and handled, not from the length of its ingredient list. A food with five ingredients can still carry germs if it is made in a dirty kitchen, and a food with fifteen ingredients can be perfectly safe if it is made well. Clean label does not promise that a food will keep well, because keeping power often comes from the very ingredients that clean label removes, such as preservatives, and a clean label food that spoils early is not a better food. It does not promise that a food is free of allergens, because a short list can still contain milk, egg, wheat, or nuts, and the allergen rules apply to clean label foods exactly as they apply to any other food.
Clean label also does not promise that a food is better for the planet, though it is often sold that way. A natural colour may need more land, more water, or more energy to make than a synthetic one, and a food with a shorter shelf life may lead to more waste, because more of it spoils before it is eaten. The honest question is not "is it natural" but "what is the whole effect, from farm to plate to bin?" That question is harder to answer, and it is the question a food technologist must learn to ask, rather than accepting a claim on the front of a pack.
Who decides what is clean
Because clean label has no single legal definition, the decision is made in practice by three groups: shoppers, makers, and retailers. Shoppers decide with their money, buying foods whose lists they like and leaving foods whose lists they do not. Makers decide with their recipes, choosing ingredients that fit the clean label idea and writing labels that explain them. Retailers decide with their shelves, setting rules for what their own-brand products may contain, and those rules often become the working definition of clean label for the makers who supply them. A retailer rule that bans a set of additives, for example, shapes thousands of products at once, even though no law bans those additives.
That spread of decisions means clean label looks different in different places and at different times. A list that looks clean in one country may look ordinary in another, because the diets, the rules, and the tastes differ. A claim that is popular this year may fade next year, as shoppers learn more or as new evidence appears. A food technologist must therefore treat clean label as a moving idea, not a fixed rule, and must keep asking what the buyer in front of them means by clean, rather than assuming the answer. The skill is to listen to the buyer, to read the label as the buyer reads it, and to make food that is honest about what it is.
The diagram shows how to read a clean label claim. The steps point to the diagram: the front of the pack is the promise, the back is the evidence, and the nutrition table is the part that tells you about health, which the claim alone cannot.
The food maker's view: why clean label is hard
For a maker, clean label is hard because every ingredient that is removed took a job with it. Remove a preservative, and the food spoils faster. Remove an emulsifier, and the sauce splits. Remove a colour, and the food looks pale. Remove a flavouring, and the food tastes flat. The maker must find another way to do each job: a different process, a different pack, a shorter shelf life, a colder store, or a natural ingredient that does the same job less well, at a higher cost, and with more variation from batch to batch. Each change must be tested, because a natural ingredient that works in one food may fail in another, and a change that works in the laboratory may fail on the line.
The cost is real. Natural colours cost more than synthetic ones, and they fade faster. Natural flavours cost more, and they vary with the crop. A shorter shelf life means more waste, more frequent delivery, and a higher price. A maker who promises clean label and then cuts corners to keep the price down will end up with a food that looks clean and behaves badly: it splits, it fades, it spoils, and the customer does not buy it again. The honest maker prices the trade-off, explains it, and makes a food that works, even if it costs more and keeps for less time. That honesty is part of what clean label means, and it is the part that shoppers reward when they find it.
Practical note: Pick a food you buy every week and rewrite its ingredient list in plain words, one line per ingredient, saying what each one does. If you cannot say what an ingredient does, look it up in a reference book, not in a search result that sells the same food. That rewritten list is your first clean label exercise, and it will show you which ingredients are there for the food and which are there for the maker.
Quick self-check
Question: A bread lists "ascorbic acid" and another lists "vitamin C". Are the breads different?
No, if that is the only difference. Ascorbic acid is vitamin C, the same substance with two names. The loaf that says vitamin C looks cleaner, but the food is the same. Clean label is often about words as much as about substances.
Question: Why can a clean label food still be an unhealthy choice?
Because clean describes the ingredient list, short and familiar, while healthy describes the nutrients and the portion: sugar, salt, fat, fibre, and how much is eaten. A juice with one ingredient can still be high in sugar, and a white bread with five ingredients can still be low in fibre.
Try it yourself
Take three packaged foods from your kitchen: a bread, a yoghurt, and a sauce. For each one, count the ingredients, circle the ones you recognise, and underline the ones you do not. Then write a one-line verdict for each: clean, in-between, or not clean, and say why. Finally, check the nutrition table for each one and ask whether your clean verdict matches its health value. Keep the three lists together, and repeat the exercise with three different foods next week.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Clean label means a short, familiar ingredient list, as little artificial colour, flavour, or preservative as possible, and a label that is easy to read.
- Clean label has no single legal definition, so the same words can mean different things on different packs.
- Clean, natural, and healthy are three different ideas: a food can be one without being the others.
- Clean label does not promise safety, keeping power, freedom from allergens, or a lower effect on the planet.
- Every ingredient removed took a job with it, so clean label reformulation is a set of trade-offs in cost, shelf life, and stability.
- Shoppers, makers, and retailers together decide what counts as clean, and the idea moves over time and place.
- Read the back of the pack, not only the front claim, and check the nutrition table before judging a food.
Glossary
Clean label
A way of describing food with a short, familiar ingredient list, little or no artificial colour, flavour, or preservative, and a label that is easy to read. Food tech example: a yoghurt with milk and live cultures only is a clean label yoghurt.
Ingredient list
The list on a food pack naming every ingredient in the food, in order of amount. Food tech example: the ingredient list on a bread shows flour, water, yeast, and salt in order.
Artificial colour
A colour made in a factory, rather than taken from a plant, animal, or mineral source. Food tech example: a bright blue colour in a drink is often an artificial colour.
Natural colour
A colour taken from a natural source, such as beetroot, turmeric, or paprika. Food tech example: beetroot juice gives a pink colour to a yoghurt.
Preservative
A substance added to food to slow spoilage by germs, moulds, or yeasts. Food tech example: a preservative in bread slows mould growth and keeps the loaf fresh for longer.
Emulsifier
A substance that helps mix oil and water in a food, such as lecithin in chocolate. Food tech example: lecithin in a sauce keeps the oil and water from splitting apart.
Flavouring
A substance added to food to give or strengthen a flavour, which may be natural or made in a factory. Food tech example: vanilla flavouring gives a cake its vanilla taste.
Ascorbic acid
Vitamin C, used in food as an antioxidant and in bread as a dough improver. Food tech example: ascorbic acid in bread dough helps the dough hold gas and rise well.
Antioxidant
A substance that slows the damage caused by oxygen, such as browning or fat going rancid. Food tech example: vitamin C in cut fruit slows browning by acting as an antioxidant.
Shelf life
The time a food stays safe and of good quality when stored as directed. Food tech example: a loaf with no preservative has a shorter shelf life than a loaf with one.
Transparency
Openness about what is in a food and how it was made, so the buyer can judge for themselves. Food tech example: a label that explains what each ingredient does is transparent.
Reformulation
Changing a recipe, such as removing an additive or lowering sugar, while trying to keep the taste, texture, and keeping power. Food tech example: reformulating a sauce to remove a preservative means finding another way to keep it safe.
Fortified
A food with added vitamins or minerals, such as a cereal with added iron. Food tech example: a fortified breakfast cereal lists added vitamins in its ingredient list.
Refined flour
Flour from which the bran and germ have been removed, leaving mainly starch, and low in fibre. Food tech example: white bread is made from refined flour.
Trade-off
A balance in which gaining one thing means giving up another, such as a shorter list meaning a shorter shelf life. Food tech example: removing a preservative is a trade-off between a cleaner list and a shorter shelf life.
References
- Asioli, D., Aschemann-Witzel, J. and Nayga, R., Clean Label, 2017.
- Food Product Development, Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., 1991.
- Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development, 2nd edition, 2004.
- Food and Drink Federation, Guidance on Clean Labelling, 2019.
- Nielsen, S. S., Introduction to the Chemical Analysis of Foods, 1997.
Unit 2: Food Additives: Why They Are Used and How They Are Judged Safe
Note
Unit 2: Food Additives: Why They Are Used and How They Are Judged Safe
A question to start with
A bottle of cooking oil sits on a shelf for a year and still smells fresh. A loaf of bread stays soft for a week without going mouldy. A fruit drink keeps its bright colour from the factory to the glass. None of these happen by accident. Each one is the work of a food additive: a substance added in a small amount to do a job that the food cannot do on its own. Yet the same word, additive, makes many shoppers uneasy, and some packs boast "no additives" as if the word itself were a warning. This unit is about the middle ground: what additives do, why foods need them, and how their safety is judged, so that a buyer and a maker can judge each one on its own facts rather than on its name.
A food additive is a substance added to food to serve a technical purpose: to keep it safe, to keep it fresh, to give it colour, flavour, or texture, or to help it survive processing and storage. Additives are used in small amounts, and they are listed on the pack, either by name or by a number that stands for the name in the system used in that country. They are different from ingredients such as flour, sugar, or oil, which are foods in their own right and are eaten in larger amounts. An additive is there to do a job, and the job is the reason to judge it, not the fact that it has a chemical name.
Questions to think about
- Bread goes mouldy in days without a preservative. Is the preservative the problem, or is mould the problem?
- Two drinks have the same colour, one from beetroot and one from a synthetic colour. Is one safer than the other, and how would you know?
- If an additive is judged safe, why do some countries allow it and others not?
Think about the bread question before you read on
Mould is the problem the preservative solves: moulds can spoil bread and some can make toxins. The preservative is a tool with its own safety record, judged by testing and by the amount used. The right question is not "is it an additive" but "what does it do, how much is used, and what did the safety testing show?"
Why additives are used: the jobs they do
Additives do a small number of jobs, and it helps to learn the groups rather than memorising names. Preservatives slow the growth of germs, moulds, and yeasts, so food stays safe and keeps longer. Antioxidants slow the damage caused by oxygen, such as fat going rancid and cut fruit turning brown. Emulsifiers help mix oil and water, so sauces, dressings, and chocolate stay smooth instead of splitting. Stabilisers and thickeners give food body and stop it separating, so a yoghurt stays creamy and a drink keeps its fruit pulp in suspension. Colours give food a colour it lost in processing, or a colour that tells the buyer what flavour to expect. Flavours give or restore taste and smell. Sweeteners give sweetness with less sugar or less energy. Acids control acidity, which affects taste, safety, and keeping power. Raising agents make dough and batter rise. Each group does one job, and each food uses only the groups it needs.
A single food may use several additives, each doing a different job. A soft drink may use an acid for taste and safety, a colour for appearance, a flavour for taste, a sweetener for sweetness, and a preservative to keep it safe after opening. A bread may use an emulsifier to keep it soft, an antioxidant to protect the flour, and a preservative to slow mould. The list looks long, but each entry is a single job, and the maker must be able to say what each job is. A maker who cannot say why an additive is in a food should not be using it, because an additive without a job is a risk without a benefit.
Additives also do jobs that shoppers do not see. A flour improver helps dough hold gas so bread rises evenly. An anti-caking agent keeps salt and spice powders free-flowing so they can be measured accurately. A glazing agent gives a shine to a sweet so it does not stick to the pack. A propellant pushes cream out of a can. These are technical jobs, and they are the reason a factory can make the same food, in the same way, in large amounts, day after day. A kitchen cook does the same jobs with different tools: lemon juice to stop browning, salt to slow germs, egg to bind a sauce. The additive is often the factory version of a kitchen step.
How safety is judged: the process
The safety of a food additive is judged before it is allowed, not after it has been sold for years. The maker of the additive, or the food maker who wants to use it, must provide evidence to a safety body, and the body judges whether the additive is safe at the amounts proposed. The evidence comes from testing in animals and from studies of how the body handles the substance, how much is absorbed, how it is broken down, and how it leaves the body. The testing looks for harm at high amounts, and for effects on growth, on reproduction, and on the next generation, and it looks for any sign that the substance causes cancer or damages genes. Only when the testing shows no harm at the amounts proposed, with a wide margin, is the additive allowed.
The key idea in that judgement is the acceptable daily intake, or ADI. The ADI is the amount of an additive that a person can eat every day, over a lifetime, without harm, as judged from the testing. It is set well below the amount that caused any harm in testing, with a safety margin that is usually one hundred times, to allow for differences between animals and people and between one person and another. The ADI is not a limit on one meal. It is a daily amount over a lifetime, and it is used to set the maximum amount allowed in each food, so that even a person who eats a lot of foods containing that additive stays below the ADI. A food that uses an additive within its allowed amount, in a food where it is allowed, is a food that has passed this judgement.
Safety is also judged after approval. Additives are reviewed again when new evidence appears, when new testing methods are developed, or when eating habits change and people eat more of a food than before. An additive that was allowed may be restricted, given a lower maximum, or removed if the review finds a risk. An additive that was once restricted may be allowed more widely if new evidence shows it is safe. The system is not a single decision made once. It is a cycle of testing, allowing, watching, and reviewing, and the cycle is what keeps the judgement honest over time.
Why different countries allow different additives
Shoppers often ask why an additive allowed in one country is not allowed in another, and the answer is not that one country is right and the other is wrong. Countries differ in what they eat, how much they eat, and how they judge risk. A country where people eat a lot of a food that contains an additive will set a lower maximum for that food, so the daily intake stays below the ADI. A country with a different diet may allow a higher maximum, because its people eat less of that food. Countries also differ in their rules about which foods may contain which additives: an additive allowed in drinks may not be allowed in bread, because the need is different and the intake is different.
Countries also differ in how they handle uncertainty. When the evidence is not complete, one country may allow an additive while more testing is done, and another may wait until the testing is complete. When a new study raises a question, one country may act quickly and another may wait for a fuller review. These differences are normal in a system that judges risk, and they are why a food maker who sells in more than one country must know the rules in each one, and must make a version of the food that fits each set of rules. A global brand may therefore have different recipes in different places, not because the food is different, but because the rules are.
Numbers on the pack: E numbers and other codes
In many places, additives are listed on the pack by a number, such as E300 for ascorbic acid, or by their name, or by both. The number is not a warning. It is a short code that stands for one substance, so that a pack in any language can name the same additive in the same way. The E stands for Europe, where the system began, and the numbers group additives by their job: colours in one range, preservatives in another, antioxidants and acids in another, and so on. A shopper who learns the ranges can read a label faster, but the number alone does not say whether an additive is safe. It only says which substance it is, and the safety judgement sits behind the number, in the testing and the ADI.
Some shoppers treat a number as a sign of danger and a name as a sign of safety, and that is a mistake. A number can stand for a natural substance, such as E160a for beta-carotene from carrots, and a name can stand for a factory-made substance, such as sodium benzoate. The safe habit is to ask what the substance is and what it does, not whether it is written as a number or a name. A label that writes the name is friendlier to read, and many makers now write the name instead of the number for that reason, but the substance is the same either way, and the safety judgement is the same too.
When an additive is not needed
The strongest question a maker can ask about an additive is whether it is needed at all. An additive is needed when it does a job that cannot be done another way, or cannot be done as well another way. A preservative is needed when a food would spoil before it reaches the buyer without one. A colour is needed when processing strips the colour out and the buyer would not recognise the food without it. An emulsifier is needed when a sauce splits without one. An additive is not needed when it is there only to make a poor food look good, to hide a cheap ingredient, to make a food look like something it is not, or to do a job that a change in recipe, process, or pack could do better. A colour that makes a drink look like fruit juice when it contains no fruit is not a technical job. It is a trick, and the rules in most places forbid it.
The clean label movement is, at its heart, a demand to ask that question more often. A maker who removes an additive must find another way to do its job, and the other way may be a better process, a better pack, a shorter shelf life, or a different recipe. Sometimes the other way works, and the food is better for it. Sometimes it does not, and the additive stays, because the job it does matters more than the length of the list. The judgement is made food by food, additive by additive, and the maker who can explain each decision, in plain words, is the maker who earns trust.
The diagram shows the safety judgement in order. The steps point to the diagram: the ADI and the maximum amounts are the two numbers that carry the judgement, and the review at the end is what keeps the judgement honest over time.
Additives and the kitchen: the same jobs, different tools
A home cook uses additives without calling them that. Salt is a preservative. Lemon juice is an antioxidant that stops cut fruit browning. Vinegar is an acid that keeps pickles safe. Sugar is a preservative in jam, because it draws water out of germs. Egg yolk is an emulsifier in mayonnaise. Baking powder is a raising agent. Gelatine is a thickener and a gelling agent. Each of these is a substance added to do a job, and each of them has a chemical name too: salt is sodium chloride, lemon juice carries citric acid, vinegar is acetic acid in water, sugar is sucrose. The cook who says "no additives" while using salt, lemon, and vinegar is using additives by another name, and the factory that lists sodium chloride, citric acid, and acetic acid is naming the same substances by their chemical names. The difference is the word, not the substance.
That sameness is worth remembering when reading a label. A pack that lists "salt" and a pack that lists "sodium chloride" contain the same substance. A pack that lists "vitamin C" and a pack that lists "ascorbic acid" contain the same substance. A pack that lists "lecithin" and a pack that lists "E322" contain the same substance. The friendly name and the chemical name are two ways of writing the same thing, and the safety judgement is the same for both. The buyer who judges by the name alone will be misled, and the maker who hides behind a friendly name is not being honest either. The honest label names the substance clearly and says what it does, in words the buyer can follow.
Deriving the ADI, step by step
The acceptable daily intake, the ADI, is not guessed. It is derived, step by step, from the testing, and the derivation is worth seeing once, slowly, because it shows where the safety margin comes from. The derivation starts with the testing in animals, where the additive is fed at several doses, from low to high, and the animals are watched for harm. The highest dose at which no harm is seen is called the NOAEL, the no observed adverse effect level, written in milligrams of additive per kilogram of body weight per day, or mg/kg body weight/day. The lowest dose at which harm is seen is called the LOAEL, the lowest observed adverse effect level, and it sits above the NOAEL. The NOAEL is the starting point for the ADI, and it is the number the testing gives, not a number anyone chooses.
The next step is the safety factor, sometimes called the uncertainty factor. The NOAEL comes from animals, and people are not animals, so a factor of 10 is applied for the difference between animals and people. People also differ from each other, in age, in size, in health, and in how they handle a substance, so a second factor of 10 is applied for the difference between one person and another. The two factors are multiplied: 10 times 10 gives 100. That is the usual safety factor, and it is why the ADI is usually one hundred times lower than the NOAEL. If the testing is thin, or if the harm seen is severe, an extra factor may be applied, making the safety factor larger, and the ADI lower. The safety factor is not a guess. It is a stated judgement, written down with its reason, so it can be checked and revisited when new testing appears.
The derivation itself is one division. ADI equals NOAEL divided by the safety factor. A worked example, with round teaching numbers only, makes the arithmetic visible. Suppose testing gives a NOAEL of 500 mg/kg body weight/day for an additive, and the safety factor is 100. The ADI is 500 divided by 100, which is 5 mg/kg body weight/day. For a person who weighs 60 kg, the daily amount is 5 times 60, which is 300 mg per day, every day, over a lifetime. That is the ADI for that person, in milligrams per day. The maximum amount allowed in each food is then set so that even a person who eats a lot of foods containing that additive stays below 300 mg per day. That is the whole derivation: a tested dose, a safety factor of 100, a division, and a multiplication by body weight. The safety margin is wide on purpose, because the testing is in animals, the people who eat the additive differ from each other, and the aim is to protect the most sensitive eater, not the average one.
Practical note: Pick a food additive from a pack in your kitchen, such as citric acid in a drink or sodium benzoate in a sauce. Write down its job, the food it is in, and how much of that food you eat in a day. Then look up its acceptable daily intake in a reference book or on a government site, and work out how much of the food you would need to eat to reach it. That simple sum shows how wide the safety margin is, and it is the sum that safety bodies do for every additive they allow.
Quick self-check
Question: What is an acceptable daily intake, and what is it for?
It is the amount of an additive that a person can eat every day, over a lifetime, without harm, as judged from testing. It is set well below the amount that caused any harm in testing, with a wide safety margin, and it is used to set the maximum amount allowed in each food.
Question: Why is a number on a pack, such as E300, not a warning by itself?
Because the number is only a short code that stands for one substance, so a pack in any language can name the same additive. E300 is ascorbic acid, vitamin C, and the number alone says nothing about safety. Safety sits behind the number, in the testing and the acceptable daily intake.
Try it yourself
Take a soft drink, a loaf of bread, and a jar of sauce from your kitchen. For each one, list every additive on the pack, group them by job, preservative, colour, flavour, emulsifier, acid, and so on, and write one line for each saying what job it does in that food. Then ask of each one: could this job be done another way, and what would change if the additive were removed? Keep the three lists, and compare them: which food needs its additives most, and which one could lose one without much change?
Key ideas to carry forward
- A food additive is a substance added in a small amount to do a technical job: keep food safe, keep it fresh, give it colour, flavour, or texture, or help it survive processing.
- Additives fall into groups by job: preservatives, antioxidants, emulsifiers, stabilisers, colours, flavours, sweeteners, acids, and raising agents.
- Safety is judged before approval, by testing, and the acceptable daily intake sets the amount safe to eat every day for a lifetime, with a wide margin.
- Maximum amounts are set for each food so daily intake stays below the acceptable daily intake, and additives are reviewed again when new evidence appears.
- Different countries allow different additives because diets, intakes, and judgements of uncertainty differ, not because one side is wrong.
- A number on a pack is a code for a substance, not a warning, and a friendly name and a chemical name can stand for the same substance.
- The strongest question about an additive is whether it is needed, and a maker who can explain each additive in plain words earns trust.
Glossary
Food additive
A substance added to food in a small amount to serve a technical purpose, such as keeping it safe or giving it colour. Food tech example: a preservative in bread is a food additive that slows mould growth.
Preservative
A substance added to food to slow spoilage by germs, moulds, or yeasts. Food tech example: a preservative in bread slows mould growth and keeps the loaf fresh for longer.
Antioxidant
A substance that slows the damage caused by oxygen, such as browning or fat going rancid. Food tech example: vitamin C in cut fruit slows browning by acting as an antioxidant.
Emulsifier
A substance that helps mix oil and water in a food, such as lecithin in chocolate. Food tech example: lecithin in a sauce keeps the oil and water from splitting apart.
Acceptable daily intake
The amount of an additive that a person can eat every day, over a lifetime, without harm, as judged from testing. Food tech example: the acceptable daily intake for a sweetener sets how much of it can be used in drinks.
Stabiliser
A substance that keeps a food's texture stable and stops it separating during storage. Food tech example: a stabiliser in yoghurt keeps it creamy and stops whey separating on top.
Thickener
A substance that gives a food body and thickness, such as starch in a sauce. Food tech example: starch thickens a soup so it coats a spoon.
Raising agent
A substance that releases gas in dough or batter so it rises, such as baking powder. Food tech example: baking powder in a cake releases carbon dioxide, CO₂, and the cake rises.
Acid
A substance that lowers pH and gives a sour taste, used for flavour and for safety. Food tech example: citric acid in a soft drink gives a sharp taste and helps keep the drink safe.
Flavouring
A substance added to food to give or strengthen a flavour, which may be natural or made in a factory. Food tech example: vanilla flavouring gives a cake its vanilla taste.
Safety margin
The gap between the amount that caused harm in testing and the amount judged safe for people, usually one hundred times. Food tech example: the safety margin for an additive means the acceptable daily intake is far below any harmful amount.
E number
A code number for a food additive used in many places, standing for one substance. Food tech example: E300 stands for ascorbic acid, vitamin C.
Maximum amount
The highest amount of an additive allowed in a particular food, set so daily intake stays below the acceptable daily intake. Food tech example: the maximum amount of a preservative in bread is set by law for that food.
Anti-caking agent
A substance that keeps powders free-flowing by stopping them clumping. Food tech example: an anti-caking agent in salt keeps it pouring freely in damp weather.
Gelling agent
A substance that sets a liquid into a gel, such as gelatine in a sweet. Food tech example: gelatine sets a fruit jelly so it holds its shape.
NOAEL
The highest dose at which no harm is seen in testing, written in milligrams per kilogram of body weight per day. Food tech example: a NOAEL of 500 mg/kg body weight/day for an additive is the starting point for deriving its ADI.
LOAEL
The lowest dose at which harm is seen in testing, sitting above the NOAEL. Food tech example: the LOAEL for an additive is the lowest dose where harm appeared in the animal testing.
Safety factor
A number, usually 100, by which the NOAEL is divided to set the ADI, allowing for differences between animals and people and between people. Food tech example: a NOAEL of 500 divided by a safety factor of 100 gives an ADI of 5 mg/kg body weight/day.
References
- Branen, A. L., Davidson, P. M. and Salminen, S., Food Additives, 2nd edition, 2001.
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Additives, 2021.
- Smith, J. and Hong-Shum, L., Food Additives Data Book, 2nd edition, 2011.
- Nielsen, S. S., Introduction to the Chemical Analysis of Foods, 1997.
- Food Product Development, Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., 1991.
Unit 3: Colours: Natural vs Synthetic and the Synthetic Dye Phase-Out
Note
Unit 3: Colours: Natural vs Synthetic and the Synthetic Dye Phase-Out
A question to start with
A child holds up two sweets. One is bright red, the colour of a post box, and it keeps that colour for months on a shelf. The other is pink, the colour of a rose petal, and it fades a little if it sits in the sun. The red sweet gets its colour from a synthetic dye, made in a factory. The pink sweet gets its colour from beetroot, grown in a field. Both are allowed in food, both have been tested, and both are listed on their packs. Yet the red one is slowly disappearing from shops in some places, and the pink one is taking its place. This unit is about why: what food colours are, where they come from, how they behave, and why some synthetic colours are being phased out in some places while natural colours are being approved and used more.
Colour is the first thing a buyer notices about a food, and it shapes what the buyer expects to taste. A strawberry drink that is pale looks weak, even if it tastes strong. A cheese that is pale looks mild, even if it is mature. A sweet that is bright looks fun, even if it tastes the same as a pale one. Makers use colour to replace colour lost in processing, to make foods look the same from batch to batch, and to tell the buyer what flavour to expect. Colour is not a nutrient, and it does not change the food value, but it changes how the food is seen, and how it is seen changes whether it is bought and enjoyed.
Questions to think about
- A strawberry yoghurt loses its pink colour when it is heated. Should the maker add colour back, or sell a pale yoghurt?
- Beetroot colour fades in sunlight, while a synthetic red does not. What does that mean for a drink sold in a clear bottle?
- If a synthetic colour is judged safe, why would a maker or a government still move away from it?
Think about the strawberry yoghurt before you read on
It depends on what the buyer expects and what the maker can explain. Adding colour back gives the yoghurt the pink the buyer expects from strawberry, and it is honest if the colour is listed and the yoghurt does contain strawberry. Selling it pale is also honest, but the buyer may think it has no strawberry in it. The choice is about expectation and honesty, not only about chemistry.
Where food colours come from
Food colours fall into two broad groups: natural and synthetic. Natural colours come from plants, animals, or minerals. Beetroot gives a pink to red colour. Turmeric gives yellow. Paprika gives orange to red. Carrot and annatto give orange and yellow. Spinach and other green leaves give green, though green is the hardest natural colour to keep. Caramel, made by heating sugar, gives brown. Cochineal, made from an insect, gives a strong red. Iron oxides, minerals, give red, yellow, and black. Each of these has been used for a long time, some for centuries, and each one brings its own behaviour: some fade in light, some change with acidity, some stain, and some cost more than others.
Synthetic colours are made in a factory, usually from starting materials that come from petroleum or coal tar, through a set of chemical steps. They are not found in nature in that form, though they are made to match or to copy colours that are found in nature, or to give colours that nature does not give, such as a bright blue. Synthetic colours are strong, so a small amount gives a strong colour. They are stable, so they do not fade in light or change much with heat or acidity. They are the same from batch to batch, so a maker can promise the same colour every time. And they are cheap, so a maker can colour a large amount of food for a small cost. Those four facts, strong, stable, consistent, and cheap, are why synthetic colours were used so widely for so long.
The line between natural and synthetic is not as sharp as it sounds. A natural colour is often extracted, concentrated, and processed in a factory before it is used, and the extraction may use solvents and heat. A synthetic colour may be made to copy a natural one, atom for atom, so the substance in the food is identical to the substance in the plant, even though one came from a field and the other from a factory. A colour made by fermentation, such as a colour made by microbes, sits between the two: it is made by living things, in a factory, and it is often called natural. The buyer who asks "is it natural" is really asking several questions at once: where did it come from, how was it made, and can I trust it? The label rarely answers all three, which is why the question stays open.
How colours behave in food
A colour that works in one food may fail in another, because colour depends on the food around it. Acidity matters: beetroot colour is pink in acid and turns blue or brown when the food is less acid, so a beetroot-coloured drink must keep its acidity steady. Heat matters: many natural colours break down when heated, so a colour that looks bright in a cold drink may fade in a baked cake. Light matters: natural colours fade in sunlight, so a drink in a clear bottle needs a colour that can stand light, or a bottle that blocks it. Oxygen matters: some colours oxidise and fade when the pack is opened. Other ingredients matter: a colour may react with a vitamin, a mineral, or a preservative in the same food, and change or fade.
Synthetic colours behave more simply. They are made to stand heat, light, and acidity, so a maker can use the same colour in a drink, a sweet, a cake, and a snack, and get the same result each time. That simplicity is a large part of their value to a maker, and it is also the reason they are hard to replace: a natural colour that works in a drink may not work in a baked food, and a maker who switches must test each food again, change the pack, change the storage, or accept a colour that varies from batch to batch. The work of replacing a synthetic colour is not a single swap. It is a new recipe, a new process, and a new set of tests, for each food.
Colour also interacts with flavour in the mind of the eater. A drink that is red is expected to taste of strawberry or cherry, and a drink that is green is expected to taste of lime or apple. If the colour and the flavour do not match, the eater may say the flavour is wrong, even when the flavour is the same. That is why makers match colour to flavour carefully, and why a change in colour can change how a food is judged, even when nothing else has changed. A maker who changes a colour must therefore test the food with eaters, not only in the laboratory, because the eater's judgement is the one that decides whether the food sells.
The synthetic dye phase-out: what is happening
In recent years, some synthetic colours have been phased out in some places, while natural colours have been approved and used more widely. The change is not a single event, and it does not happen on the same day everywhere. It happens country by country, colour by colour, and maker by maker, driven by a mix of new evidence, public concern, retailer rules, and maker choice. Some governments have set dates after which certain synthetic colours may no longer be used in foods sold in their markets. Some retailers have set their own rules, banning a set of synthetic colours from their own-brand products. Some makers have moved first, replacing synthetic colours with natural ones and putting the change on the pack, because their customers asked for it. This unit describes that movement in general terms, without stating specific dates or deadlines as fact, because the dates differ by place and by colour, and the reader should check the current rule in their own country before relying on any one date.
The reasons for the movement are several, and they are not all about safety. New studies have raised questions about some synthetic colours, including possible links to behaviour in some children, and those questions have led to reviews, to warnings on packs in some places, and to decisions to move away from the colours in question. Public concern has grown, with shoppers asking for foods without synthetic colours, and makers have answered by reformulating. Retailers have set rules that go further than the law, because their customers expect it. And natural colours have improved: new sources, better extraction, and better stabilising have made natural colours stronger, more stable, and cheaper than they were, so the switch is now possible in foods where it once was not. Each of these reasons matters, and no single one explains the whole movement.
The phase-out also has costs and limits. Natural colours cost more, fade faster, and vary more from batch to batch, so a maker who switches must accept a higher price, a shorter shelf life, or a colour that is less bright. Some foods cannot be coloured naturally at all, because no natural colour gives the shade needed, or because the natural colour fails in that food. Some natural colours carry their own risks: cochineal can cause allergy in some people, annatto can cause reactions, and a natural colour is not safe simply because it is natural. The honest picture is that the phase-out is a move from one set of trade-offs to another, and the maker who switches must manage the new trade-offs as carefully as the old ones were managed.
Choosing and using a natural colour
A maker who chooses a natural colour asks a set of practical questions. What shade is needed, and does the natural source give it? How much is needed, and what does it cost at that amount? Does it survive the process, the heat, the acidity, and the light the food will meet? Does it stay stable on the shelf, for the whole shelf life, in the pack that will be used? Does it change the taste, because many natural colours carry flavour with them, such as beetroot carrying an earthy taste, or turmeric carrying a bitter note? Does it carry an allergen, or a substance that must be declared? And can the supply be relied on, season after season, at the amount needed?
The answers often point to a blend rather than a single colour. A maker may blend beetroot with a little turmeric to get an orange, or blend a fruit colour with caramel to get a brown, or use a colour made by fermentation that is more stable than a plant extract. The maker may also change the food around the colour: a lower heat, a shorter bake, a different acid, a pack that blocks light, or a shorter shelf life. Each change is tested, with eaters as well as in the laboratory, because a colour that looks right in a test tube may look wrong in the food, and a food that looks right may taste wrong to the eater who tries it.
The diagram shows the replacement steps. The steps point to the diagram: the testing in the real food, not in a test tube, is the step that decides whether the switch works, and the eater test is the step that decides whether the food still sells.
Colour and the buyer: reading the pack
A buyer who reads a colour on a pack should ask three questions. First, what is the colour, and where does it come from? The label will name it, by name or by number, and the name will tell whether it is a plant, a mineral, or a synthetic substance. Second, why is it there? A colour that replaces colour lost in processing, or that makes batches look the same, is doing an honest job. A colour that makes a food look like it contains fruit when it contains none is not. Third, does the colour change anything else about the food? A natural colour may carry flavour, a synthetic colour may carry a warning in some places, and either one may matter to a person with an allergy or a sensitivity. The buyer who asks those three questions is reading the label as a food technologist reads it, and will not be misled by the shade alone.
A worked example: choosing a natural colour and testing it in the real food
Choosing a natural colour is not a matter of picking a shade from a chart. It is a matter of testing a colour in the real food, under the real conditions, and seeing whether it lasts. Here is a worked example, built from a made-up fruit drink, so the reader can follow the whole test, step by step. The maker wants a red drink, and shortlists two natural colours: beetroot red, which gives a pink-red shade, and anthocyanin from black carrot, which gives a deeper red. The drink is acid, with a pH of about 3.5, and it will be pasteurised, filled into a clear bottle, and kept on a shelf in a shop with bright lights.
The test is done in small batches, with the same dose of each colour, and the drinks are kept in three places: a dark cupboard, a bright shelf, and a warm store. After one week, the beetroot drink in the dark cupboard is still red, the one on the bright shelf has faded to a pale pink, and the one in the warm store has turned brownish. The black carrot drink is still red in all three places, because anthocyanins are more stable in acid, and the acid in the drink protects them. The maker also tastes both drinks: the beetroot drink tastes faintly of earth, which the buyer may notice, while the black carrot drink tastes of nothing, because the colour carries no flavour at that dose. The maker chooses black carrot, and then tests it at a lower dose, to find the smallest dose that still gives the shade the buyer expects, and tests it again after a month, to check that the colour lasts for the whole shelf life, not only for the first week.
The lesson is that the choice was made by testing, not by reading a list. Beetroot red is a fine colour in a food that is kept dark and cold, and a poor colour in a clear bottle on a bright shelf. Black carrot is a better colour in an acid drink, and a poorer colour in a neutral food, where its shade changes. The dose matters too: a colour used at too low a dose will fade first, and a colour used at too high a dose will taste of its source, or will cost more than the food can carry. The maker who tests the colour in the real food, in the real pack, in the real shop, and for the whole shelf life, will choose the right colour. The maker who chooses from a chart will be surprised, and the surprise will come on the shop shelf, in front of the buyer.
Practical note: Buy a fruit drink and a sweet that both claim a fruit colour, and read the ingredient lists. Write down the colour in each one, where it comes from, and what else is in the food. Then leave a little of the drink in a clear glass in sunlight for a day, and compare its colour with a glass kept in a cupboard. That fading, if it happens, is the natural colour at work, and it is the reason makers who switch to natural colours must also think about the pack.
Quick self-check
Question: Why is a natural colour not automatically safer than a synthetic colour?
Because safety depends on the substance and the amount, not on where it came from. Some natural colours can cause allergy in some people, and some are unstable or carry flavour. Each colour, natural or synthetic, is judged on its own testing, and the label must name it so the buyer can judge.
Question: Why does a synthetic colour often give a brighter and more stable result than a natural one?
Because synthetic colours are made to be strong and to stand heat, light, and acidity, so a small amount gives a strong colour that does not fade. Natural colours are more easily changed by heat, light, and acidity, so they need more care in the recipe, the process, and the pack.
Try it yourself
Make two glasses of a coloured drink at home: one coloured with beetroot juice and one coloured with a few drops of a food colour from a shop. Leave half of each glass in sunlight and half in a cupboard for a day, then compare all four. Write down what changed, which one faded most, and what that tells you about the pack a maker would need for each one. Then taste both and note whether the beetroot one carries any flavour of its own.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Colour is the first thing a buyer notices, and it shapes what flavour the buyer expects to taste.
- Natural colours come from plants, animals, or minerals, and synthetic colours are made in a factory, but the line between them is not sharp.
- Natural colours fade more easily with heat, light, and acidity, while synthetic colours are strong, stable, consistent, and cheap.
- Some synthetic colours are being phased out in some places, driven by new evidence, public concern, retailer rules, and better natural colours, with dates that differ by place and colour.
- Natural colours are not automatically safer: some can cause allergy, some carry flavour, and each one is judged on its own testing.
- Replacing a synthetic colour means testing the natural colour in the real food, for heat, light, acidity, taste, shelf life, cost, and supply.
- A buyer should ask what the colour is, where it comes from, and why it is there, not judge by the shade alone.
Glossary
Natural colour
A colour taken from a natural source, such as beetroot, turmeric, or paprika. Food tech example: beetroot juice gives a pink colour to a yoghurt.
Synthetic colour
A colour made in a factory, usually from starting materials that come from petroleum or coal tar. Food tech example: a bright blue colour in a drink is often a synthetic colour.
Beetroot colour
A pink to red colour taken from beetroot, which is bright in acid and fades in light and heat. Food tech example: beetroot colour gives a strawberry drink its pink shade.
Turmeric
A yellow spice that also gives a yellow colour to food, with a bitter note if too much is used. Food tech example: turmeric gives a curry its yellow colour.
Annatto
An orange to yellow colour taken from the seeds of a tropical plant, used in cheese and snacks. Food tech example: annatto gives a cheese its orange colour.
Caramel colour
A brown colour made by heating sugar, used in drinks, sauces, and baked foods. Food tech example: caramel colour gives a cola drink its brown shade.
Cochineal
A strong red colour made from an insect, which can cause allergy in some people. Food tech example: cochineal gives a red colour to some sweets and drinks.
Beta-carotene
An orange colour found in carrots, used as a colour and as a source of vitamin A. Food tech example: beta-carotene gives a spread its yellow colour.
Phase-out
The gradual removal of a substance from use, by law, by retailer rules, or by maker choice, over a period of time. Food tech example: a synthetic colour is phased out when makers replace it with a natural colour.
Stability
How well a colour keeps its shade during processing and storage, against heat, light, and acidity. Food tech example: a stable colour keeps a drink bright for its whole shelf life.
Acidity
How acid a food is, measured by pH, which affects colour, taste, and safety. Food tech example: beetroot colour stays pink in an acid drink and turns brown when the acidity falls.
pH
A scale that measures how acid or alkaline a food is, with lower numbers meaning more acid. Food tech example: a soft drink with a pH near 3 is acid, and its colour must stand that acidity.
Extraction
Taking a substance, such as a colour, out of its natural source, often with water, oil, or a solvent. Food tech example: paprika colour is extracted from dried peppers with oil.
Fermentation colour
A colour made by microbes in fermentation, sitting between natural and synthetic in how it is made. Food tech example: a red colour made by a microbe in a fermenter is used in some drinks.
Shelf life
The time a food stays safe and of good quality when stored as directed. Food tech example: a drink with a natural colour may have a shorter shelf life if the colour fades.
Anthocyanin
A natural red, purple, or blue colour from fruits and vegetables, such as black carrot, which is more stable in acid foods. Food tech example: anthocyanin from black carrot keeps a red drink red in an acid drink.
References
- Branen, A. L., Davidson, P. M. and Salminen, S., Food Additives, 2nd edition, 2001.
- Smith, J. and Hong-Shum, L., Food Additives Data Book, 2nd edition, 2011.
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Additives, 2021.
- Hendry, G. A. F. and Houghton, J. D., Natural Food Colorants, 2nd edition, 1996.
- Food Product Development, Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., 1991.
Unit 4: Sweeteners and Sugar Reduction
Note
Unit 4: Sweeteners and Sugar Reduction
A question to start with
A maker takes a soft drink that has always been sweetened with sugar and tries to make a version with half the sugar. The first try tastes flat. The second try tastes sweet but leaves a strange aftertaste. The third try tastes almost right, but the drink feels thin in the mouth, and the colour looks dull. Sugar was doing more than sweetening the drink: it was giving body, it was carrying flavour, it was protecting the colour, and it was keeping the drink safe after opening. This unit is about that hidden work: what sweeteners do, why sugar is hard to replace, and how makers reduce sugar without losing the food the buyer knows.
Sugar is the oldest sweetener, and it is also one of the most useful ingredients in food. It sweetens, it gives body and bulk, it browns in baking, it holds water, it slows germs, and it carries flavour. When a maker reduces sugar, every one of those jobs must be done another way, or the food changes in ways the buyer will notice. That is why sugar reduction is one of the hardest jobs in clean label work, and why the foods that succeed are the ones where the maker has thought about every job sugar was doing, not only about sweetness.
Questions to think about
- A biscuit made with half the sugar spreads less in the oven and comes out pale. Why did sugar matter to its shape and colour?
- A drink sweetened with a high-intensity sweetener tastes sweet but feels thin. What did sugar give the drink besides sweetness?
- If a sweetener has no energy, does that mean it is a free choice with no trade-offs?
Think about the biscuit before you read on
Because sugar melts in the oven and lets the biscuit spread, and it browns in the heat, giving colour and a crisp edge. With half the sugar, the dough spreads less, so the biscuit is thicker, and it browns less, so it looks pale. Sugar is a structural ingredient in baking, not only a sweetener, and removing it changes the shape and colour as well as the taste.
What sugar does in food
Sugar does at least five jobs, and each one matters. First, it sweetens, and it sweetens in a clean way, with no aftertaste, and with a sweetness that arrives at once and fades cleanly. Second, it gives bulk and body: in a drink, sugar makes the liquid feel thicker in the mouth, and in a cake, sugar gives weight and structure to the crumb. Third, it browns: when sugar is heated, it caramelises, and it also takes part in the Maillard reaction with proteins, giving brown colour and baked flavour to bread, biscuits, and cakes. Fourth, it holds water, which keeps food moist and slows the growth of germs, because germs need free water to grow. In jam, sugar is the main preservative. Fifth, it carries flavour: sugar rounds off sourness and bitterness, and it helps flavours spread through a food.
Each of those jobs is tied to the amount of sugar, not only to its sweetness. A cake with half the sugar is not only less sweet. It is drier, because less water is held. It is paler, because less browning happens. It is firmer, because sugar softens the crumb. A jam with half the sugar is not only less sweet. It spoils faster, because more free water is available to germs, and it sets less well, because sugar helps the pectin gel. A drink with half the sugar is not only less sweet. It feels thinner, and its flavour seems sharper, because sugar was rounding off the acid. A maker who reduces sugar by thinking only about sweetness will be surprised by all of these changes, and the buyer will taste them.
The sweeteners: a tour
Sweeteners fall into two broad groups: bulk sweeteners, which are used in amounts like sugar, and high-intensity sweeteners, which are used in tiny amounts because they are many times sweeter than sugar. Bulk sweeteners include sugar itself, glucose syrup, honey, and the sugar alcohols, such as sorbitol, xylitol, and erythritol. Sugar alcohols taste sweet, give bulk, and have less energy than sugar, but they can cause gut discomfort when eaten in large amounts, and they must be labelled with a warning about that in many places. Honey is a natural sweetener, but it is still a sugar, and it carries the same energy and the same effect on teeth as sugar, even though it sounds more natural.
High-intensity sweeteners include aspartame, sucralose, stevia, acesulfame K, and saccharin. Each one is many times sweeter than sugar, so a tiny amount gives the sweetness of a spoonful of sugar, with little or no energy. Each one has its own taste: aspartame tastes clean but breaks down with heat, so it is used in cold drinks rather than baking. Sucralose stands heat well, so it can be baked. Stevia comes from a plant, and it is often sold as natural, but it can carry a bitter or liquorice aftertaste. Acesulfame K is often blended with other sweeteners, because the blend tastes more like sugar than either one alone. Saccharin is the oldest, and it carries a metallic aftertaste that limits its use. No high-intensity sweetener tastes exactly like sugar, and the skill of the maker is to blend them, and to add a little bulk, so the result tastes close to sugar.
Each sweetener is judged safe in the same way as other additives, with testing and an acceptable daily intake, and each one has a maximum amount for each food. The safety of sweeteners is one of the most studied questions in food science, and it is also one of the most argued about in public, because sweeteners are eaten by many people, every day, and because the studies are read differently by different people. A food technologist must know the testing and the ADI, must know that the evidence is reviewed again when new studies appear, and must be honest about what is known and what is still uncertain, rather than repeating a claim from either side without checking it.
How sugar is reduced in practice
Sugar reduction is rarely a single swap. It is a set of steps, used together, and the steps differ by food. The first step is to reduce the sugar a little at a time, so the buyer does not notice a sudden change. A drink that loses a small amount of sugar each year, over several years, tastes almost the same at each step, and the buyer adapts. The second step is to blend sweeteners, so the taste is closer to sugar than any single sweetener can give. The third step is to add bulk where sugar gave it, with a fibre or a sugar alcohol, so the drink still feels thick in the mouth and the cake still has crumb. The fourth step is to change the flavour, so the food tastes sweet without sugar: a little more vanilla, a little more fruit, or a sour note that makes the sweetness that remains stand out. The fifth step is to change the portion: a smaller pack, a smaller bottle, or a smaller biscuit, so the buyer eats less sugar without the recipe changing at all.
Each step has a cost. Blending sweeteners costs more than sugar. Adding fibre changes the texture and can cause gut discomfort. Changing flavour can make a food taste different from the one the buyer knows. Shrinking the portion can feel like a trick if the price does not fall with it. The maker must test each step with eaters, not only in the laboratory, because the eater's judgement is the one that decides whether the food sells. A drink that is lower in sugar but tastes wrong will not be bought again, however good its label looks.
Sugar reduction also changes keeping power and safety. A jam with less sugar spoils faster, so it needs a shorter shelf life, a colder store, or a preservative. A sauce with less sugar may need more acid to stay safe. A cake with less sugar may go stale faster, because sugar holds water, and the cake dries out. The maker must test the shelf life again, and must not assume that a food that kept for six months with sugar will keep for six months without it. That testing is part of sugar reduction, and it is the part that is most often skipped when a maker is in a hurry.
Sweetness, health, and teeth
Sugar is linked to health in several ways, and the link is about amount and pattern, not about a single spoonful. Eating a lot of sugar, often, adds energy to the diet, and extra energy over time adds weight. Sugar in drinks is a particular concern, because a drink can carry a large amount of sugar without making the drinker feel full, so the energy is added without the fullness that would stop the eating. Sugar also feeds the germs in the mouth that make acid, and that acid attacks teeth, so frequent sugary foods and drinks raise the risk of tooth decay. These are the reasons many governments and health bodies advise eating less sugar, and especially less sugar in drinks, and the reasons makers are under pressure to reduce it.
Sweeteners change the energy and the tooth risk, but they do not change everything. A drink sweetened with a high-intensity sweetener has little or no energy from the sweetener, and it does not feed the germs that attack teeth, so it is better for teeth and for energy than a sugary drink. But a sweet food, however it is sweetened, can still train a taste for sweetness, so a person who drinks sweet drinks every day, even without sugar, may still prefer sweet foods and may still eat a lot of them. A food that is low in sugar but high in fat can still be high in energy. The honest message is that sweeteners are a tool for reducing sugar and energy, not a promise that a food is healthy, and the whole diet matters more than any single swap.
The diagram shows the sugar reduction steps. The steps point to the diagram: the first step, listing every job sugar does, is the one that prevents surprises later, and the eater test at the end is the one that decides whether the food sells.
Reading a sweetener on a pack
A buyer who reads a sweetener on a pack should ask three questions. First, what is it, and how sweet is it compared with sugar? The name will tell whether it is a sugar, a sugar alcohol, or a high-intensity sweetener, and the ingredient list will show how much of it is there by its place in the order. Second, what else does it do? A sugar alcohol gives bulk and can cause gut discomfort in large amounts. A high-intensity sweetener gives sweetness without bulk, so the food may feel thinner. A blend may taste closer to sugar than any one sweetener alone. Third, what does it mean for the whole food? A drink with no sugar but with a sweetener is better for teeth and for energy, but it is still a sweet drink, and the buyer should look at the whole diet, not only at the sweetener. The buyer who asks those three questions is reading the label as a food technologist reads it.
Deriving sweetness equivalence, step by step
Sweeteners are compared by their sweetness relative to sugar, and the comparison is written as a number. Sugar itself has a sweetness of 1, by definition. A sweetener that is 200 times as sweet as sugar has a sweetness of 200, which means 1 g of that sweetener gives the sweetness of 200 g of sugar. That number is the sweetness equivalence, and it is the starting point for replacing sugar, because it tells the maker how much sweetener is needed to match the sweetness of the sugar that was removed. The derivation is a division, and it is worth seeing worked through once, because it shows why a tiny amount of a high-intensity sweetener can replace a large amount of sugar, and why the bulk that sugar gave must still be replaced by something else.
A worked example, with round teaching numbers only, makes the arithmetic visible. Suppose a drink contains 100 g of sugar per litre, and the maker wants to replace the sugar with a sweetener that is 200 times as sweet as sugar. The amount of sweetener needed is 100 divided by 200, which is 0.5 g per litre. That is the sweetness match: 0.5 g of the sweetener gives the sweetness of 100 g of sugar. The maker has removed 100 g of sugar and added 0.5 g of sweetener, so 99.5 g of bulk has gone from the drink, and the drink will feel thinner, will have less body, and will have fewer dissolved solids to hold its flavour. That missing bulk must be replaced, by water, by a fibre, by a fruit puree, or by accepting a thinner drink, and the choice is part of the reformulation, not an afterthought.
The sugar reduction itself is also a simple calculation. If a food had 100 g of sugar and now has 70 g, the reduction is 100 minus 70, which is 30 g, and the percentage reduction is 30 divided by 100, times 100, which is 30 percent. If the food had 40 g and now has 30 g, the reduction is 10 g, and the percentage is 10 divided by 40, times 100, which is 25 percent. The percentage matters because a claim such as "30 percent less sugar" must be worked out from the real numbers, and the comparison must be with the same food, not with a different food that had more sugar to start with. The maker who works the numbers out, and writes them down, can defend the claim. The maker who guesses the percentage cannot.
Sweetness equivalence has limits that must be stated plainly. The number is measured at one concentration, in one food, by a panel of tasters, and it changes with the food, the acidity, the temperature, and the amount used. A sweetener that is 200 times as sweet as sugar in water may be 150 times as sweet in a sour drink, and 250 times in a warm sauce. The sweetness also builds differently over time: some sweeteners taste sweet at once and fade fast, while sugar tastes sweet more slowly and lasts longer, so a blend of two sweeteners, each covering the other's weakness, often tastes closer to sugar than either one alone. The maker must therefore test the equivalence in the real food, with eaters, at the start and at the end of the shelf life, and not trust a number from a table on its own.
Practical note: Make two cups of tea, one with a spoonful of sugar and one with a high-intensity sweetener tablet. Taste both, and note the differences: how fast the sweetness arrives, how long it lasts, whether there is an aftertaste, and whether the tea feels thinner in the mouth. That tasting is the whole sugar reduction problem in one cup, and it shows why blending and adding bulk matter.
Quick self-check
Question: Why does a cake with half the sugar go stale faster?
Because sugar holds water in the crumb, keeping the cake moist. With less sugar, more water is free to move and to leave the cake, so the crumb dries out sooner. Sugar is a water-holding ingredient, not only a sweetener.
Question: Why do makers blend sweeteners rather than using one alone?
Because no single high-intensity sweetener tastes exactly like sugar: each has its own aftertaste or timing. A blend can cancel out the aftertastes and give a sweetness that arrives and fades more like sugar, so the food tastes closer to the one the buyer knows.
Try it yourself
Buy a sugary drink and a sugar-free version of the same drink, if you can find them. Pour a little of each into two glasses, taste them blind if a friend can help, and write down the differences: sweetness, aftertaste, body, and flavour. Then read both labels and note the sweeteners used, the energy per 100 ml, and the price. Which one would you buy again, and why? That answer is the market judgement that makers work with every day.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Sugar does at least five jobs: sweetness, bulk and body, browning, holding water, and carrying flavour.
- Bulk sweeteners are used in amounts like sugar, while high-intensity sweeteners are many times sweeter than sugar and are used in tiny amounts.
- Sugar alcohols give bulk with less energy but can cause gut discomfort in large amounts, and they must be labelled for that.
- Sugar reduction is a set of steps, not a single swap: reduce a little at a time, blend sweeteners, add bulk, adjust flavour, and consider portion.
- Less sugar can mean faster spoilage, a drier crumb, and a paler colour, so shelf life must be tested again.
- A drink sweetened without sugar is better for teeth and for energy, but a sweet taste can still train a taste for sweetness.
- Judge a sweetener by what it is, what it does, and what it means for the whole food, not by its name alone.
Glossary
Sugar
Sucrose, the common sweetener from cane or beet, which sweetens, gives bulk, browns, holds water, and carries flavour. Food tech example: sugar in a cake sweetens the crumb and helps it brown in the oven.
High-intensity sweetener
A sweetener many times sweeter than sugar, used in tiny amounts, such as aspartame, sucralose, or stevia. Food tech example: a tablet of a high-intensity sweetener sweetens a cup of tea with almost no energy.
Sugar alcohol
A bulk sweetener, such as sorbitol, xylitol, or erythritol, which tastes sweet, gives bulk, and has less energy than sugar. Food tech example: sorbitol in a sugar-free sweet gives bulk and sweetness with less energy.
Aspartame
A high-intensity sweetener that tastes clean but breaks down with heat, so it is used in cold drinks. Food tech example: aspartame sweetens a cold soft drink.
Sucralose
A high-intensity sweetener that stands heat well, so it can be used in baking. Food tech example: sucralose sweetens a baked biscuit without breaking down in the oven.
Stevia
A high-intensity sweetener from the leaves of a plant, often sold as natural, which can carry a bitter aftertaste. Food tech example: stevia sweetens a drink, and it is often blended with other sweeteners to hide its aftertaste.
Maillard reaction
The browning reaction between sugar and protein in heat, which gives bread, biscuits, and cakes their brown colour and baked flavour. Food tech example: the brown crust on bread comes from the Maillard reaction.
Caramelisation
The browning of sugar itself when heated, giving brown colour and a rich flavour. Food tech example: heated sugar caramelises and gives a sauce its brown colour.
Free water
Water in a food that is not bound to other parts, and that germs can use to grow. Food tech example: sugar in jam binds water, so less free water is left for germs.
Bulk
The weight and body a sweetener gives to a food, beyond its sweetness. Food tech example: sugar gives bulk to a cake, so a cake made without it feels lighter and drier.
Aftertaste
A taste that stays in the mouth after the food is swallowed, such as the bitter note of some sweeteners. Food tech example: stevia can leave a bitter aftertaste in a drink.
Acceptable daily intake
The amount of an additive that a person can eat every day, over a lifetime, without harm, as judged from testing. Food tech example: the acceptable daily intake for a sweetener sets how much of it can be used in drinks.
Tooth decay
Damage to teeth caused by acid made by germs in the mouth when they feed on sugar. Food tech example: frequent sugary drinks raise the risk of tooth decay.
Glucose syrup
A sweet syrup made from starch, used as a bulk sweetener in drinks, sweets, and baked foods. Food tech example: glucose syrup in a sweet keeps it soft and stops it crystallising.
Blending
Using two or more sweeteners together so the taste is closer to sugar than any one alone. Food tech example: a drink blends two sweeteners to cancel out each other's aftertaste.
Sweetness equivalence
How sweet a sweetener is compared with sugar, where sugar has a sweetness of 1. Food tech example: a sweetener 200 times as sweet as sugar needs 0.5 g to match the sweetness of 100 g of sugar.
References
- Branen, A. L., Davidson, P. M. and Salminen, S., Food Additives, 2nd edition, 2001.
- Smith, J. and Hong-Shum, L., Food Additives Data Book, 2nd edition, 2011.
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Additives, 2021.
- Alternative Sweeteners, O'Brien-Nabors, L., 4th edition, 2016.
- Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development, 2nd edition, 2004.
Unit 5: Preservatives and Natural Alternatives
Note
Unit 5: Preservatives and Natural Alternatives
A question to start with
A loaf of bread baked on Monday is still soft on Friday, with no mould in sight. A loaf baked at home on Monday is mouldy by Thursday. The difference is not the flour or the oven. It is a preservative, a small amount of a substance that slows mould, and the home loaf has none of it. The shopper who picks up the Friday loaf faces a choice: a loaf that keeps, made with a preservative, or a loaf that spoils, made without one. This unit is about that choice: what preservatives do, how they work, what can replace them, and what the buyer gives up when they are removed.
A preservative is a substance added to food to slow spoilage by germs, moulds, or yeasts. Spoilage is not only about taste. Moulds can make toxins, yeasts can make a drink fizzy and sour, and germs can make food unsafe. A preservative does not make a dirty food clean, and it does not replace good hygiene, cold storage, or a sealed pack. It is one tool among several, and it is used in a small amount, within a maximum set by law, to give the food time to reach the buyer and to be eaten safely. The question is never "preservative or no preservative" in the abstract. It is "what keeps this food safe for this long, in this pack, at this price, and what does each way cost?"
Questions to think about
- A jam keeps for a year without a preservative. Why does bread need one to keep for a week?
- A sauce uses vinegar to stay safe. Is vinegar a preservative, and does it count as natural?
- If a natural preservative is weaker than a synthetic one, what must change for the food to stay safe?
Think about the jam before you read on
Because jam is high in sugar and low in free water, so germs cannot grow in it easily, and its acidity also helps. Bread is moist, near neutral in acidity, and rich in nutrients, so mould grows on it quickly. The food itself decides how much help it needs to keep, and jam needs little help while bread needs more.
How food spoils, and what stops it
Food spoils because living things grow in it. Moulds grow on bread, cheese, and fruit, forming fuzzy patches and sometimes making toxins. Yeasts grow in sugary drinks and sauces, making gas, alcohol, and sour flavours. Bacteria grow in moist, protein-rich foods, such as meat, milk, and cooked rice, and some of them can cause illness. Each of these needs water, nutrients, and the right temperature and acidity to grow. Take away any one of those, and growth slows or stops. That is the whole science of preservation in one line: control water, acidity, temperature, oxygen, or time, and the food keeps.
Preservatives work by attacking the germs directly, or by changing the food so the germs cannot grow. Some preservatives, such as sorbic acid and its salts, stop moulds and yeasts from growing. Some, such as benzoic acid and its salts, work best in acid foods, such as drinks and sauces. Some, such as nitrite in cured meats, stop a particular germ, Clostridium botulinum, which can cause a rare but serious illness, and also give cured meat its pink colour and flavour. Some, such as sulphur dioxide, stop browning and slow germs in dried fruit and wine. Each one works best in a certain kind of food, at a certain acidity, and at a certain amount, and each one has a maximum amount set by law.
The amount matters. A preservative used below its effective amount does not protect the food, so the food spoils and the buyer is misled into thinking it is protected. A preservative used above its maximum is against the law and may be unsafe. The maker must therefore know the effective amount for each food, must measure it accurately, and must test that the food keeps for its whole shelf life with that amount. That testing, called a challenge test or a shelf life test, puts the germs into the food on purpose, in the laboratory, and watches whether they grow. It is the proof that the preservative works in that food, at that amount, for that long.
The main preservatives, in plain words
Sorbic acid and its salts, the sorbates, are used in bread, cheese, cakes, and drinks to slow moulds and yeasts. They have little taste at the amounts used, and they work over a wide range of acidity. Benzoic acid and its salts, the benzoates, are used in acid foods such as soft drinks, sauces, and pickles, where they work best. They can carry a slight taste at high amounts, and they are not used much in foods that are near neutral, because they lose their effect there. Propionic acid and its salts, the propionates, are used in bread to slow mould, and they are also made naturally in some cheeses, so a bread that lists propionate is using a substance that also occurs in food by nature.
Nitrite and nitrate are used in cured meats, such as ham, bacon, and salami, to stop Clostridium botulinum and to give the meat its colour and flavour. They are the most argued about preservatives, because nitrite can form compounds called nitrosamines in the body, and some of those compounds have been linked to cancer in studies. The amounts used in cured meat are small, and the risk from nitrite is weighed against the risk from botulism, which is a serious illness, and against the fact that nitrite also comes from vegetables and from the body itself. The debate is real, and a food technologist must know both sides, must know the amounts involved, and must be honest about what is known and what is still uncertain, rather than repeating a slogan from either side.
Sulphur dioxide and its salts, the sulphites, are used in dried fruit, wine, and some drinks to stop browning and to slow germs. They can cause reactions in some people, especially people with asthma, so they must be declared on the label when they are used above a certain amount, and the reader should check the rule in their own country for the exact amount. Nisin is a preservative made by a bacterium, used in cheese and canned foods, and it is often sold as natural because it is made by a living thing. Natamycin is used on the surface of cheese and sausages to stop mould. Each of these has its own food, its own amount, and its own label, and the maker must know all three.
Natural alternatives: what they are and what they can do
Natural alternatives to preservatives fall into several groups. The first group is the kitchen acids: vinegar, lemon juice, and citric acid, which lower the acidity of a food so germs grow more slowly. Vinegar is acetic acid in water, and it is used in pickles, sauces, and dressings, where its sour taste fits the food. Lemon juice is citric acid, and it is used in drinks and fruit, where its flavour fits. The second group is the plant extracts: rosemary, oregano, thyme, and green tea, which carry substances that slow germs and slow fat going rancid. They are used in meats, oils, and snacks, where their flavour fits, and they are often sold as natural antioxidants as well as preservatives.
The third group is the cultured and fermented ingredients: cultured dextrose, cultured wheat, and fermented ingredients that carry organic acids made by microbes, which slow mould and germs. These are made by fermenting a food with a microbe, then using the result as an ingredient, and they are often listed as "cultured" on the pack, which sounds more natural than a chemical name. The fourth group is the natural antimicrobials made by microbes themselves, such as nisin, which is made by a bacterium and used to protect cheese. The fifth group is not a substance at all, but a process: cold storage, a sealed pack, a shorter shelf life, or a change in the food itself, such as more acid, less water, or more salt, so the food keeps without a preservative.
Each natural alternative is weaker, more variable, or more limited than the synthetic preservative it replaces. Vinegar works, but it tastes of vinegar, so it cannot be used in a food where that taste does not fit. Rosemary extract works, but it carries a herbal taste and it varies with the crop. Cultured dextrose works, but it is more expensive and it must be used at a higher amount. A process change works, but it may mean a shorter shelf life, a colder store, or a higher price. The maker who replaces a synthetic preservative with a natural one must therefore change more than the ingredient list: the recipe, the process, the pack, the shelf life, and the price may all need to change, and each change must be tested.
The trade-offs: shelf life, safety, waste, and price
Removing a preservative shortens the shelf life of most foods, and a shorter shelf life has effects that reach beyond the pack. More food spoils before it is eaten, so more food is wasted, and the waste carries its own cost in money, in land, in water, and in energy. More frequent delivery is needed, so transport costs rise. Shops need more space for a food that turns over faster. Buyers need to shop more often, or to store the food more carefully at home. A maker who removes a preservative and keeps the same shelf life is either using another way to keep the food safe, or is selling a food that will spoil before its date, and the buyer will find out.
Safety is the part of the trade-off that cannot be compromised. A preservative that stops a dangerous germ, such as nitrite in cured meat, cannot be removed without another control that does the same job as well. A sauce that relies on a preservative to stay safe after opening cannot lose that preservative without a change in acidity, in pack size, or in storage advice. A food that is sold to people who are more at risk, such as young children, older people, or people who are ill, needs its safety margin more, not less. The maker who removes a preservative must prove, by testing, that the food is still safe for its whole shelf life, in the hands of a real buyer, not only in the laboratory.
Price is the last part of the trade-off. Natural alternatives cost more, a shorter shelf life costs more, more frequent delivery costs more, and more waste costs more. A clean label food that costs more is not a failure. It is the honest price of the trade-off, and the buyer who chooses it is paying for the shorter list. A maker who promises a clean label food at the same price, with the same shelf life, and the same safety, without changing anything else, is promising something that the science does not support, and the food will show it, by spoiling, by tasting wrong, or by costing more than the maker planned.
The diagram shows the replacement steps. The steps point to the diagram: the challenge test is the proof that the new way works, and the shelf life must be set from the test, not from the old shelf life.
Reading a preservative on a pack
A buyer who reads a preservative on a pack should ask three questions. First, what is it, and what does it stop? The name will tell whether it is a sorbate, a benzoate, a propionate, a nitrite, or a sulphite, and the food will tell which germs matter in that food. Second, is there a natural version doing the same job, and what did it cost? A sauce that lists vinegar is using a natural acid as a preservative, and a bread that lists cultured wheat is using a fermented ingredient. Third, what does the shelf life say? A food with a long shelf life and no preservative has found another way to keep, through acidity, water, cold, or pack, and the buyer should ask what that way is. The buyer who asks those three questions is reading the label as a food technologist reads it.
Hurdle technology: many small controls instead of one large one
Hurdle technology is the idea that a food can be kept safe by several small controls, each one too weak on its own to stop microbes, but strong enough together to stop them. Each control is called a hurdle, because a microbe must jump over every hurdle to grow, and a microbe that can jump one hurdle may not be able to jump them all. The hurdles used in food are acidity, low water, salt, low temperature, heat, lack of oxygen, a preservative, and a natural antimicrobial, such as vinegar or a plant extract. A sauce that is acid, salty, and kept cold has three hurdles. A dried meat that is salty, dry, and packed without oxygen has three hurdles. A yoghurt that is acid, cold, and full of living cultures that compete with other microbes has three hurdles. Each hurdle on its own would not keep the food safe for its shelf life, but together they do, and that is the point.
Hurdle technology is the clean-label maker's best friend, because it lets the maker use less of any one preservative, or none at all, by adding hurdles that are not ingredients. A sauce that loses its preservative can gain a hurdle by becoming more acid, with vinegar or lemon juice, and can gain another hurdle by being packed in a smaller pack, so it is eaten in one sitting, and can gain a third by being kept cold. A bread that loses its mould inhibitor can gain a hurdle by a sourdough fermentation, which makes acid, and another by a drier bake, and another by a pack that keeps it dry. A meat that loses nitrite can gain hurdles by lower water, higher salt, a stronger acid, a shorter shelf life, and a colder store, though the maker must prove, with a challenge test, that the hurdles together are enough, because the safety of the meat is not a matter for guessing.
The hurdles must be tested together, not one at a time, because hurdles interact. An acid that works at one temperature may not work at another. A salt level that works in a dry food may not work in a wet one. A natural antimicrobial that works in a sauce may not work in a meat, because the fat in the meat protects the microbes from it. The testing is therefore done on the real food, with the real hurdles, over the whole shelf life, in the warm shop as well as in the cold laboratory, and with a challenge test where the risk is high. A food whose hurdles were tested one at a time, and never together, is a food whose safety has not been proved, however good each hurdle looks on its own.
The diagram is a set of five separate hurdles, with no arrows between them, because the hurdles do not lead to each other in a sequence. They work at the same time, side by side, and a microbe must get past all of them to grow.
Practical note: Buy a loaf of bread with a preservative and a loaf without one, if you can find them. Keep both on your kitchen shelf, in the same conditions, and check them each day for mould. Note the day each one first shows mould, and compare the dates with the shelf life on each pack. That simple test shows the preservative at work, and it shows what the buyer gives up when it is removed.
Quick self-check
Question: Why does vinegar work as a preservative in pickles but not in bread?
Because vinegar lowers acidity, and pickles are acid foods where that acidity fits the taste and stops germs. Bread is near neutral and its taste does not fit vinegar, so the same acid would spoil the flavour, and the amount needed would make the bread sour. A preservative must fit the food as well as stop the germs.
Question: What is a challenge test, and why does it matter?
A challenge test puts the germs that could spoil or harm a food into the food on purpose, in the laboratory, and watches whether they grow over the shelf life. It is the proof that a preservative, natural or synthetic, works in that food, at that amount, for that long, and it must be run again when the recipe changes.
Try it yourself
Take a jar of pickles, a bottle of sauce, and a loaf of bread from your kitchen. Read each label and write down the preservative, if any, and the shelf life. Then write one line for each saying what keeps it safe: the preservative, the acidity, the sugar, the salt, or the pack. If one of them has no preservative, ask what does the job instead, and how long it keeps compared with a version that has one.
Key ideas to carry forward
- A preservative slows spoilage by germs, moulds, or yeasts, and it does not replace good hygiene, cold storage, or a sealed pack.
- Food spoils because living things grow in it, and preservation works by controlling water, acidity, temperature, oxygen, or time.
- The main preservatives are sorbates, benzoates, propionates, nitrite, sulphites, and nisin, each working best in certain foods at certain amounts.
- Natural alternatives include vinegar and lemon juice, plant extracts such as rosemary, cultured and fermented ingredients, and process changes such as cold storage and a shorter shelf life.
- Natural alternatives are usually weaker, more variable, or more limited than the synthetic preservative they replace, so the recipe, process, pack, and shelf life may all need to change.
- Removing a preservative shortens shelf life, can raise waste and price, and must never compromise safety, which is proved by a challenge test.
- Read the preservative on a pack by asking what it stops, whether a natural version does the same job, and what the shelf life says.
Glossary
Preservative
A substance added to food to slow spoilage by germs, moulds, or yeasts. Food tech example: a preservative in bread slows mould growth and keeps the loaf fresh for longer.
Sorbate
A salt of sorbic acid, used to slow moulds and yeasts in bread, cheese, cakes, and drinks. Food tech example: potassium sorbate in a cake slows mould growth.
Benzoate
A salt of benzoic acid, used in acid foods such as soft drinks, sauces, and pickles. Food tech example: sodium benzoate in a soft drink slows yeast growth.
Propionate
A salt of propionic acid, used in bread to slow mould, and also made naturally in some cheeses. Food tech example: calcium propionate in bread keeps the loaf free of mould for a week.
Nitrite
A substance used in cured meats to stop Clostridium botulinum and to give pink colour and flavour. Food tech example: nitrite in ham stops a dangerous germ and gives the ham its colour.
Sulphite
A salt of sulphur dioxide, used in dried fruit and wine to stop browning and to slow germs. Food tech example: sulphites in dried apricots keep their orange colour.
Nisin
A preservative made by a bacterium, used in cheese and canned foods, often sold as natural. Food tech example: nisin in cheese slows the germs that cause spoilage.
Challenge test
A test that puts germs into a food on purpose, in the laboratory, and watches whether they grow over the shelf life. Food tech example: a challenge test on a sauce shows whether its preservative stops yeast for six months.
Cultured dextrose
A fermented ingredient that carries organic acids made by microbes, used as a natural preservative. Food tech example: cultured dextrose in bread slows mould growth.
Rosemary extract
An extract from rosemary that slows fat going rancid and slows some germs, used in meats and oils. Food tech example: rosemary extract in a snack keeps the oil fresh.
Free water
Water in a food that is not bound to other parts, and that germs can use to grow. Food tech example: sugar in jam binds water, so less free water is left for germs.
Mould
A fungus that grows on food in fuzzy patches, and that can spoil food and sometimes make toxins. Food tech example: mould grows on bread left in a warm, damp place.
Yeast
A single-celled fungus that can spoil sugary foods and drinks, making gas, alcohol, and sour flavours. Food tech example: yeast in a fruit drink makes it fizzy and sour.
Clostridium botulinum
A bacterium that can cause botulism, a rare but serious illness, and that is stopped by nitrite in cured meats. Food tech example: nitrite in bacon stops Clostridium botulinum growing in the meat.
Shelf life
The time a food stays safe and of good quality when stored as directed. Food tech example: a loaf with no preservative has a shorter shelf life than a loaf with one.
Hurdle technology
Keeping a food safe with several small controls together, such as acidity, salt, heat, and cold, each too weak alone but strong enough together. Food tech example: a sauce kept safe by acidity, salt, heat, and a sealed pack uses hurdle technology.
Hurdle
One small control in hurdle technology, such as acidity or low temperature, that a microbe must get past to grow. Food tech example: acidity from vinegar is one hurdle that keeps a sauce safe.
References
- Branen, A. L., Davidson, P. M. and Salminen, S., Food Additives, 2nd edition, 2001.
- Smith, J. and Hong-Shum, L., Food Additives Data Book, 2nd edition, 2011.
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Additives, 2021.
- Davidson, P. M., Sofos, J. N. and Branen, A. L., Antimicrobials in Food, 3rd edition, 2005.
- Food Product Development, Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., 1991.
Unit 6: Reading an Ingredient List: What the Words Mean
Note
Unit 6: Reading an Ingredient List: What the Words Mean
A question to start with
A shopper picks up a snack bar. The front says "made with real fruit" and shows a picture of berries. The back lists twenty ingredients, and fruit is the seventh, after sugar, glucose syrup, and three kinds of fat. The shopper feels misled, but the pack has not lied: it does contain real fruit, and the picture is of berries. What the pack has done is to put the promise on the front and the facts on the back, in small type, in an order that takes a minute to read. This unit teaches that minute of reading: how an ingredient list is built, what the words mean, and how to judge a food from its list without being misled by its front.
An ingredient list is a legal statement about what is in a food, and it is also a map of the food. It lists every ingredient in order of amount, from the most to the least, at the time the food is made. It names additives by name or by number, and it names allergens in a way that stands out. It uses names that are set by rules, so the same ingredient is named the same way on every pack, and it groups some ingredients under a class name, such as "flavouring" or "vegetable oil", where the rules allow it. A buyer who knows how the list is built can read it in under a minute and can judge a food fairly. A buyer who does not know the rules will be misled by the order, by the names, and by the front of the pack.
Questions to think about
- A drink lists sugar first and fruit juice fifth. What does that tell you about how much fruit is in it?
- A sauce lists "vegetable oil" without naming which vegetable. Is that enough information, and what is missing?
- A pack says "no added sugar" but lists fruit juice concentrate. Has sugar been added, in effect?
Think about the drink before you read on
It tells you that there is more sugar in the drink than fruit juice, because the list is in order of amount, from most to least. A drink that is mostly sugar with a little fruit juice is not a fruit drink, however bright the picture on the front. The order is the fact, and the front is the promise.
The order of the list: the first rule
The first rule of reading an ingredient list is the order: ingredients are listed in order of amount, from the most to the least, by weight, at the time the food is made. The first ingredient is the main ingredient. The last ingredients are present in the smallest amounts. That order is the single most useful fact on the pack, because it tells the buyer what the food is mostly made of, in a way that the front of the pack often does not. A bread whose first ingredient is wheat flour is a wheat bread. A bread whose first ingredient is water is a wet dough, and the flour comes second. A biscuit whose first ingredient is sugar is mostly sugar, however much flour it also contains.
The order can be used to hide a fact, and the buyer should know how. A maker can split one ingredient into two names, so it appears twice in smaller amounts and looks less important than it is. Sugar can appear as sugar, glucose syrup, and honey, each listed separately, so none of them appears first, even though together they are the main ingredient. A maker can also list a small amount of a good ingredient early in the list by using a compound ingredient, such as a fruit preparation, that carries the fruit with it, so the fruit looks more important than it is. The buyer who knows the splitting trick will add the sugars together in their head, and will ask how much fruit is really there, rather than trusting the place of the fruit in the list.
Water is a special case. Water is often the first ingredient in a food, because it is used to make the food, and it is lost in cooking or drying, so the food as eaten may contain much less water than the list suggests. A soup that lists water first is mostly water when it is made, and that is honest. A dried food that lists water first may have lost most of that water in drying, so the list describes the making, not the eating. The buyer should read the list with the nutrition table beside it, because the nutrition table describes the food as eaten, while the list describes the food as made.
Names: what the words stand for
Ingredient names are set by rules, so the same ingredient is named the same way on every pack, but the names are not always plain. A chemical name, such as sodium chloride, is the same substance as salt. A class name, such as "flavouring", covers a group of substances that give flavour, and the pack does not need to name each one. A source name, such as "vegetable oil", covers oils from more than one plant, and the pack may not say which one. A compound ingredient, such as chocolate, is itself made of several ingredients, and the pack may list it as one name, with its parts listed in brackets after it, or it may list its parts separately in the main list. Each of these is allowed by the rules, and each of them hides a little information, so the buyer who wants the full picture must read the brackets and the small print as well as the main list.
Additives are named by name or by number, as Unit 2 described, and the buyer should read them as a group, not one by one. A list with three colours, two preservatives, and two sweeteners is a list of a food that needs a lot of help to look, taste, and keep as it does. A list with one acid and one emulsifier is a list of a food that needs a little help. The number of additives is not a judgement by itself: a food that needs help is not a bad food, and a food with no additives is not a good food, but the count tells the buyer how much of the food's character comes from additives and how much comes from the food itself.
Allergens are named in a way that stands out, as Unit 4 of the allergen subject described, and the buyer with an allergy should read the allergen information first, before reading the rest of the list. The allergen information is usually in bold, or in a "Contains" statement next to the list, and it names the allergens in plain words, such as milk, egg, or peanut. A buyer who reads the allergen statement and then reads the full list, looking for the allergen inside compound ingredients, is reading the label as it is meant to be read.
The front of the pack: claims and pictures
The front of the pack is marketing, and it is allowed to be marketing, but it must not mislead. A claim such as "made with real fruit" must be true, but it does not say how much fruit is in the food, so a food with a little fruit can carry the claim. A claim such as "no artificial colours" must be true, but it does not say the food has no colour at all, so a food with a natural colour can carry it. A claim such as "low fat" must meet a rule for what low fat means, but it does not say the food is low in sugar, so a low-fat food can still be high in sugar. A picture of berries does not mean the food is mostly berries, and a picture of a farm does not mean the food was made on a farm. The front is a promise, and the back is the evidence, and the buyer must read both.
Nutrition claims and health claims are also ruled, and the rules differ by place, so the reader should check the current rules in their own country. In general, a claim that a food is "high in fibre" must meet a set amount of fibre, a claim that a food is "low in salt" must meet a set amount of salt, and a claim that a food "supports immunity" must be backed by evidence and must name the nutrient behind it. A claim that is vague, such as "supports wellbeing" or "natural goodness", is harder to judge, and the buyer should treat it as a feeling rather than a fact. The food technologist's habit is to ask, for every claim, what the evidence is, where it is on the pack, and whether the nutrition table supports it.
Percentages and portions: the numbers behind the words
Some packs give a percentage for an ingredient, such as "strawberries 12 percent", and that percentage is a useful fact, because it tells the buyer how much of the named ingredient is really there. The percentage is required in many places when an ingredient is named on the front, or when it is the characterising ingredient of the food, such as the strawberry in a strawberry yoghurt. A yoghurt that names strawberry on the front and lists 12 percent strawberry is telling the buyer the truth, and the buyer can judge whether 12 percent is a lot or a little. A yoghurt that names strawberry and lists 2 percent is also telling the truth, but the buyer who reads the percentage will judge it differently.
Portions matter too. The nutrition table gives values per 100 g or per 100 ml, and sometimes per portion, and the portion is chosen by the maker, so it may be smaller than the amount a person actually eats. A snack bar that lists sugar per 30 g portion looks lower in sugar than the same bar listed per 100 g, and a drink that lists sugar per 150 ml glass looks lower than the same drink listed per 500 ml bottle. The buyer should compare foods per 100 g, which is the same for every food, and should check the portion against the amount they will actually eat. A portion that is half the pack is not a portion most people eat, and the buyer who reads per 100 g will not be misled by it.
The diagram shows the one-minute reading order. The steps point to the diagram: the allergen check comes first for safety, the first three ingredients come next for the truth about the food, and the per 100 g comparison comes last for a fair judgement between foods.
The words that mislead most often
A few words mislead buyers more than any others, and it is worth learning them. "Natural" on a pack does not mean the food is unprocessed, because natural ingredients are often processed, and the word has no single legal meaning in most places. "No added sugar" does not mean the food has no sugar, because fruit juice, honey, and dried fruit all carry sugar, and the food may be sweet from those. "Wholegrain" does not mean the food is mostly wholegrain, because a food with a little wholegrain flour can carry the word. "Made with" does not say how much, so a food made with a little fruit and a lot of sugar can carry the phrase. "Light" or "lite" can mean low in fat, low in sugar, or light in colour, and the pack should say which one, but the buyer must check. Each of these words is true in a narrow sense, and misleading in the sense the buyer hears, and the buyer who knows the narrow sense will not be misled.
The best defence against misleading words is to read the back of the pack every time, even for a food bought every week, because recipes change and the front does not always change with them. A maker who changes a recipe and keeps the same front design must update the back, and the buyer who reads the back will catch the change. A buyer who trusts the front alone will not. That habit, reading the back every time, takes a minute, and it is the single most useful habit a buyer can learn.
A worked example: decoding one label from start to finish
Reading a label in theory is easy. Reading a real label, with a real list, is where the skill is learned. Here is a worked example, built from a made-up snack bar, so the reader can follow the whole reading, step by step, without needing a pack in hand. The front of the pack says "made with real fruit" and shows a picture of berries. The back lists the ingredients in order: sugar, glucose syrup, oat flakes, vegetable oil, dried berries, honey, almond pieces, salt, and flavouring. The nutrition table says the bar is 40 g, with 18 g of sugar per bar. The allergen statement says "contains almond, may contain peanut and milk".
The reading starts with the order. Sugar is first, and glucose syrup is second, so the bar is mostly sugar, even though the front shows berries. Oat flakes are third, so the bar is a sugar bar with oats, not an oat bar with sugar. Dried berries are fifth, after the oil, so the berries are a small part of the bar, however large they look on the front. Almond pieces are seventh, so the almond is a small part too, but it is an allergen, and it must be named, and the "may contain peanut and milk" tells the buyer that peanut and milk are handled where the bar is made. The flavouring is last, so it is present in the smallest amount, and its name does not say whether it is natural or not, so the buyer who cares must ask the maker, or choose a bar that names its flavouring plainly.
The reading then turns to the numbers. The bar is 40 g, and it contains 18 g of sugar, so almost half the bar, by weight, is sugar: 18 divided by 40, times 100, gives 45 percent. The front says "made with real fruit", and the bar does contain real fruit, in the dried berries, but the fruit is a small part, and the sugar is nearly half. The pack has not lied, but it has put the promise on the front and the facts on the back, and the buyer who reads only the front has read an advertisement. The buyer who reads the back, in order, and does the one division, knows what the bar really is, and can decide whether to buy it, or to choose a bar whose first ingredient is oats or nuts, and whose sugar is lower. That decision, made in a minute, is the skill this unit teaches, and it works on every pack, in every shop, in every country.
Practical note: Keep a notebook by your shopping list and write down one misleading word you find each week, with the pack, the claim, and the fact on the back that corrects it. After a month, you will have a list of the words that mislead you most, and you will read past them without thinking. That notebook is your own guide to reading labels, and it is worth more than any single article about labelling.
Quick self-check
Question: Why is the order of ingredients the most useful fact on a pack?
Because ingredients are listed in order of amount, from most to least, so the first three ingredients tell the buyer what the food is mostly made of. A drink whose first ingredient is sugar is mostly sugar, however bright the picture of fruit on the front.
Question: A pack says "no added sugar" but lists fruit juice concentrate. Has sugar been added?
In effect, yes. Fruit juice concentrate is a source of sugar, and it sweetens the food, even though no sugar was added as sugar. The claim is true in a narrow sense and misleading in the sense the buyer hears, so the buyer should read the sugar in the nutrition table, not only the claim.
Try it yourself
Take three packaged foods from your kitchen and read each one using the one-minute method in the diagram: allergens first, first three ingredients, split sugars added together, additives grouped by job, percentages for front-named ingredients, and nutrition per 100 g. Write a one-line verdict for each food, saying what it is mostly made of and whether the front claim matches the back. Then compare your verdicts with a friend who reads the same three packs: where do you agree, and where do you differ?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Ingredients are listed in order of amount, from most to least, so the first three ingredients tell the buyer what the food is mostly made of.
- Splitting one ingredient into two names, such as sugar and glucose syrup, can hide how much of it is really there.
- Class names such as flavouring and vegetable oil, and compound ingredients such as chocolate, hide detail that the buyer must find in the brackets and small print.
- The front of the pack is marketing: claims such as "made with real fruit" must be true, but they do not say how much is in the food.
- Percentages for ingredients named on the front tell the buyer how much is really there, and nutrition per 100 g allows a fair comparison between foods.
- Words such as natural, no added sugar, wholegrain, and made with are true in a narrow sense and can mislead in the sense the buyer hears.
- Read the back of the pack every time, even for a food bought every week, because recipes change and the front does not always change with them.
Glossary
Ingredient list
The list on a food pack naming every ingredient in the food, in order of amount. Food tech example: the ingredient list on a cake shows flour, sugar, egg, and butter in order.
Compound ingredient
An ingredient made of more than one part, such as a spice mix or a chocolate, whose parts must all be considered. Food tech example: a spice mix is a compound ingredient that may carry wheat flour into a sausage.
Class name
A general name for a group of ingredients, such as flavouring or vegetable oil, used on a pack instead of naming each one. Food tech example: "vegetable oil" on a pack does not say which vegetable the oil came from.
Characterising ingredient
The ingredient that gives a food its character and is named on the front, such as strawberry in a strawberry yoghurt. Food tech example: the strawberry in a strawberry yoghurt is its characterising ingredient, and its percentage is often given.
Split ingredient
One ingredient listed under two or more names, so it appears in smaller amounts and looks less important. Food tech example: sugar listed as sugar, glucose syrup, and honey is a split ingredient.
Nutrition table
The table on a pack giving energy, fat, sugar, salt, and other nutrients, usually per 100 g and per portion. Food tech example: the nutrition table on a drink shows its sugar per 100 ml.
Portion
The amount of a food that the maker uses for the nutrition per portion, which may be smaller than the amount a person eats. Food tech example: a snack bar lists nutrition per 30 g portion, but the bar weighs 45 g.
Health claim
A claim on a pack that a food supports health, which must be backed by evidence and must meet the rules in that country. Food tech example: a claim that a yoghurt supports immunity must name the nutrient behind it.
Nutrition claim
A claim on a pack about a nutrient, such as high in fibre or low in fat, which must meet a set amount. Food tech example: a cereal that claims high in fibre must contain a set amount of fibre per 100 g.
Contains statement
A short statement next to the ingredient list naming the allergens in the food, such as "Contains: milk, egg, wheat". Food tech example: the Contains statement on a biscuit pack lets a buyer find the allergens in seconds.
Glucose syrup
A sweet syrup made from starch, used as a bulk sweetener in drinks, sweets, and baked foods. Food tech example: glucose syrup in a sweet keeps it soft and stops it crystallising.
Fruit juice concentrate
Fruit juice with most of the water removed, used as a sweetener, which carries sugar even though no sugar was added as sugar. Food tech example: fruit juice concentrate in a drink sweetens it and adds sugar to the nutrition table.
Wholegrain
Grain that keeps all its parts, bran, germ, and endosperm, and that is high in fibre. Food tech example: wholegrain bread is made from wholegrain flour.
Flavouring
A substance added to food to give or strengthen a flavour, which may be natural or made in a factory. Food tech example: vanilla flavouring gives a cake its vanilla taste.
Per 100 g
Nutrition values given for 100 g of food, the same for every food, so foods can be compared fairly. Food tech example: comparing two cereals per 100 g shows which one has more sugar.
References
- Food Marketing and Labelling, Advances in Food and Beverage Labelling, 2014.
- Food and Agriculture Organization, Food Labelling, 2021.
- Food and Drink Federation, Guidance on Labelling, 2019.
- Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development, 2nd edition, 2004.
- Food Product Development, Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., 1991.
Unit 7: Reformulating for Clean Label
Note
Unit 7: Reformulating for Clean Label
A question to start with
A maker decides to take a popular tomato sauce and make it clean label: no preservative, no added colour, no flavouring, and a shorter list. The first batch tastes flat. The second batch spoils in three weeks instead of six months. The third batch looks pale and the colour varies from jar to jar. The fourth batch costs twice as much to make. The maker has learned what every reformulation team learns: removing ingredients is easy, and making a food that still works without them is hard. This unit is about that work: how a recipe is changed step by step, how each change is tested, and how a maker knows when the new food is ready to sell.
Reformulation is the changing of a recipe to meet a new aim, such as a shorter list, less sugar, less salt, or no artificial colour, while keeping the taste, texture, keeping power, and safety that the buyer expects. It is not a single change. It is a set of changes, made one at a time, tested one at a time, and judged by eaters as well as by instruments. A reformulation that is rushed, that changes five things at once, and that is judged only in the laboratory will fail in the shop, because the buyer will taste the difference and will not buy it again. A reformulation that is done step by step, with the buyer in mind at each step, can succeed, and the food that results can be better than the one it replaced.
Questions to think about
- A sauce loses its preservative and spoils in three weeks. What should the maker change first: the recipe, the pack, or the shelf life?
- A cake loses its emulsifier and comes out dry and crumbly. What could replace the emulsifier's job?
- Why should a maker change only one thing at a time when reformulating?
Think about the one-change question before you read on
Because if five things change at once and the food tastes wrong, nobody knows which change caused it. Changing one thing at a time, and testing after each change, shows what each change does, so the maker can keep the changes that work and undo the ones that do not. It is slower, and it is the only way to learn what is really happening.
Where reformulation starts: the brief
Every reformulation starts with a brief, a short written statement of what must change and what must stay the same. The brief names the aim, such as "remove the preservative and the artificial colour, keep the taste and the six-month shelf life", and it names the limits, such as "the price may rise by no more than a set amount" and "the label must stay honest". It names the food, the pack, the buyer, and the date by which the new food must be ready. A brief that says only "make it clean label" is not a brief. It is a wish, and it will lead to a food that pleases no one, because no one knows what clean label means for that food, or what may be given up to get it.
The brief is written by the maker, the buyer, and the technical team together, so that the aim, the limits, and the buyer are all in the same document. The marketing team says what the buyer wants. The technical team says what is possible. The buying team says what it will cost. The quality team says what must be tested. When those four views are in one brief, the reformulation has a chance. When one view is missing, the reformulation will fail on that view: a food that is clean but costs too much, a food that is cheap but tastes wrong, or a food that tastes right but is not safe.
The brief also names how success will be judged. The judgement is not only "is the list shorter?" It is also "does it taste the same or better?", "does it keep for the same time?", "is it safe?", "does it cost what was agreed?", and "does the buyer buy it again?" Each of those is measured, with a test, a number, and a date, so that success is not a feeling but a result. A reformulation that is judged only by the list will produce a short list and a poor food. A reformulation that is judged by all five will produce a food that is worth selling.
The steps of reformulation
Reformulation follows a set of steps, and the order matters. First, the current recipe is studied: every ingredient, its job, its amount, and its cost, and every step of the process, its temperature, its time, and its effect. That study shows which ingredients are doing real jobs and which are there by habit, and it shows where the process can do a job that an ingredient now does. Second, the ingredients to be removed are listed, one by one, with the job each one does, and the alternatives are listed beside them: a natural colour for a synthetic one, vinegar for a preservative, a fibre for sugar bulk, a different process for an emulsifier.
Third, the changes are made one at a time, in the laboratory, in small batches, and each batch is tested for taste, texture, colour, and keeping power. A change that fails is undone, and a change that works is kept. Fourth, the changes that work alone are put together, one at a time, and tested again, because changes that work alone may fail together: a natural colour and a natural preservative may react with each other, or a fibre added for bulk may change the colour. Fifth, the new recipe is made on the line, at full scale, because a recipe that works in a small batch may fail on the line, where mixing, heating, and cooling are different. Sixth, the shelf life is tested, with a challenge test where needed, and the new shelf life is set from the test. Seventh, the label is written, the cost is counted, and the food is tested with eaters, in a tasting that compares the new food with the old one, and with the foods it will compete with in the shop.
Each step is recorded, with the recipe, the test, and the result, so that the reformulation can be followed back, and so that a change that fails later can be traced to the step where it was made. A reformulation with no records is a reformulation that cannot be repeated, cannot be defended, and cannot be learned from. A reformulation with good records is a piece of work the maker can build on, for the next food and the next brief.
Replacing the jobs, not only the ingredients
The central idea of reformulation is that an ingredient is a job, and the job must be replaced, not only the name. A preservative is a job: keeping the food safe. Its replacement may be a natural preservative, or it may be a change in acidity, in water, in pack, or in shelf life. An emulsifier is a job: keeping oil and water mixed. Its replacement may be egg yolk, or a different mixing step, or a stabiliser from a plant. A colour is a job: giving the food the colour the buyer expects. Its replacement may be a natural colour, or a change in the recipe so the food keeps its own colour, or a change in the pack so the buyer sees the food differently. A flavouring is a job: giving taste. Its replacement may be more of the real ingredient, or a different cooking step that brings out flavour, or a blend of natural flavours.
Process can replace ingredients, and that is often the cheapest and most honest replacement. A sauce that is heated a little longer may not need a preservative, because the heat kills more germs. A bread that is baked in a different way may not need an emulsifier, because the dough is handled differently. A drink that is packed in a bottle that blocks light may not need a colour stabiliser, because the light never reaches it. A food that is packed in a smaller pack, so it is eaten in one sitting, may not need a preservative, because it is never stored after opening. Each of these is a process change, not an ingredient change, and each one keeps the list short without adding a new ingredient to it.
The pack is part of the recipe in reformulation. A pack that keeps oxygen out can replace an antioxidant. A pack that blocks light can replace a colour stabiliser. A pack that is sealed and sterile can replace a preservative. A pack that is smaller can replace a preservative that was there for storage after opening. The maker who thinks of the pack as part of the food will find replacements that the maker who thinks only of the recipe will miss, and the food that results will be simpler, not more complex.
Testing: the laboratory, the line, and the eater
Testing happens in three places, and each one matters. In the laboratory, the food is tested for its chemistry and its germs: acidity, water, colour, texture, and whether germs grow over the shelf life. The laboratory gives numbers, and the numbers show whether the food is safe and whether it will keep. On the line, the food is tested for making: does it mix, does it flow, does it fill, does it seal, does it look the same from batch to batch? The line gives the practical answer, and a recipe that fails on the line is not a recipe, however good it tasted in the laboratory. With eaters, the food is tested for taste, smell, texture, and liking: does it taste the same or better, does it look right, would the eater buy it again? The eater gives the market answer, and a food that fails with eaters will not sell, however good its numbers are.
Eater testing must be done properly. The testers must be people who buy the food, not only people who work in the factory. The test must compare the new food with the old one, and with the foods it competes with, without telling the testers which is which, so the judgement is about the food and not about the story. The test must ask the right questions: not only "do you like it?" but "would you buy it?", "how much would you pay?", and "what is different from the food you buy now?" A test that asks only whether the food is liked will pass a food that no one would buy, because liking is cheap and buying is not.
Shelf life testing must be done for the whole shelf life, in the conditions the food will meet: in a warm shop, in a cold store, in a home fridge, and after opening. A food that keeps for six months in a cold laboratory and spoils in three weeks in a warm shop has a three-week shelf life, not a six-month one. The shelf life is set from the worst condition the food will meet, not from the best, and the label must carry the shelf life that the testing supports, not the shelf life that the brief hoped for.
The diagram shows the reformulation steps. The steps point to the diagram: the brief at the start and the eater test at the end are the two steps that keep the work honest, and the one-change-at-a-time rule in the middle is what lets the maker learn from it.
Cost, price, and the buyer
Reformulation almost always costs more, at least at first. Natural ingredients cost more than synthetic ones. Testing costs money. A shorter shelf life costs money in waste and delivery. A smaller pack costs more per gram. The maker must count the cost honestly, and must decide whether the buyer will pay it, or whether the maker will absorb it, or whether the food must be sold in a different way, such as a smaller pack at the same price, or a premium line at a higher price. A maker who hides the cost by cutting corners elsewhere, such as using a cheaper main ingredient, will end up with a food that is clean on the label and poor in the eating, and the buyer will not come back.
The price must be explained to the buyer, not hidden. A pack that says "now with a shorter list" and costs more should say why, in a word or two, so the buyer can judge whether the extra cost is worth it. A maker who is honest about the cost earns trust, and a buyer who trusts the maker will pay more for a food they believe in. A maker who is silent about the cost, and who hopes the buyer will not notice, will lose trust when the buyer does notice, as they always do. Clean label is, in the end, a promise of honesty, and the price is part of that promise.
When reformulation should not happen
Not every food should be reformulated, and a good maker knows when to say no. A food that depends on an additive for safety, such as a cured meat that depends on nitrite, should not lose that additive without a replacement that does the same job as well, proved by testing. A food that depends on an additive for its identity, such as a cheese that depends on a colour the buyer expects, should not lose it without a test that shows the buyer still recognises it. A food that would cost so much more that its buyer could no longer afford it should not be reformulated for that buyer, but for a different buyer who can pay. A food that would spoil so fast that it would be wasted more than it is eaten should not be reformulated without a change in pack, in distribution, or in shelf life that fixes the waste. Saying no to a reformulation is not a failure. It is a judgement that the food, as it is, is the best balance of taste, safety, cost, and keeping power, and that changing it would make it worse.
A worked example: the triangle test, and what it can prove
When a reformulation changes a food, the maker must know whether eaters can tell the difference, and the test for that is the triangle test. In a triangle test, each eater is given three samples: two are the same, and one is different. The eater must pick the one that is different. If the eater is guessing, they will be right one time in three, because there are three samples and one of them is different. If many eaters are tested, and many more than one in three pick the right sample, the difference is real, and eaters can tell the foods apart. If only about one in three pick the right sample, the difference is not one that eaters can tell, and the reformulation has passed, on taste at least.
A worked example, with round teaching numbers only, shows the arithmetic. Suppose 30 eaters take a triangle test on a reformulated biscuit and the original biscuit. If they were guessing, about 10 of them would pick the right sample, because one third of 30 is 10. Suppose 18 of them pick the right sample. That is well above 10, so the difference is real, and eaters can tell the new biscuit from the old one. The maker must then ask whether the difference matters: is the new biscuit worse, or only different, and would eaters still buy it? Suppose only 11 of them pick the right sample. That is close to 10, the guessing level, so the difference is not one that eaters can reliably tell, and the reformulation has passed the triangle test. The exact number that counts as "well above" guessing depends on the number of eaters and on the level of proof the maker wants, and it is worked out from a table or a calculation that the sensory team uses, but the logic is the same: compare the number who were right with the number who would be right by guessing, and ask whether the gap is large enough to matter.
The triangle test has rules that must be followed, or its answer means nothing. The samples must be served in a random order, so the different sample is not always in the middle, or always first. The eaters must not be told which sample is which, and they must not talk to each other while they taste. The samples must be the same temperature, the same size, and served in the same way, so the only difference is the food itself. And the test must be done with people who buy the food, not only with people who work in the factory, because factory workers know the food too well, and will taste differences that a buyer would never notice. A triangle test done well gives a clear answer to a clear question: can eaters tell the difference? A triangle test done badly gives an answer to a different question, such as whether the samples were served warm or cold, and the maker who trusts that answer will be misled.
Practical note: Pick a food you make at home, such as a tomato sauce, and reformulate it on paper: write the brief, list every ingredient and its job, name one ingredient to remove, name its replacement, and say what else must change, such as the cooking time, the pack, or the shelf life. Then make the new version and taste it beside the old one. That paper exercise, followed by one real batch, is the whole reformulation process in miniature.
Quick self-check
Question: Why should a maker change only one thing at a time when reformulating?
Because if five things change at once and the food tastes wrong, nobody knows which change caused it. Changing one thing at a time, and testing after each change, shows what each change does, so the maker can keep the changes that work and undo the ones that do not.
Question: How can a change in the pack replace an ingredient?
Because the pack can do jobs that an ingredient did: a pack that keeps oxygen out can replace an antioxidant, a pack that blocks light can replace a colour stabiliser, and a smaller pack that is eaten in one sitting can replace a preservative that was there for storage after opening.
Try it yourself
Choose a packaged food from your kitchen and write a reformulation brief for it on one page: what would you change, what must stay the same, what may it cost, and how would you judge success? Then list the first three changes you would make, one at a time, and say how you would test each one. Keep the brief, and compare it with a friend's brief for the same food: where do your briefs agree, and where do they differ? That difference is the judgement that makes reformulation a skill, not a formula.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Reformulation is changing a recipe to meet a new aim, such as a shorter list, while keeping taste, texture, keeping power, and safety.
- Every reformulation starts with a brief that names what must change, what must stay the same, what it may cost, and how success will be judged.
- Change one thing at a time in small batches, test each change, and only then put the working changes together.
- An ingredient is a job, and the job must be replaced, not only the name: a preservative may be replaced by acidity, pack, or shelf life, not only by another preservative.
- Process and pack can replace ingredients, and they are often the cheapest and most honest replacements.
- Testing happens in three places: the laboratory for safety and keeping power, the line for making, and the eater for taste and buying.
- Reformulation almost always costs more, and the price must be explained honestly, and some foods should not be reformulated at all.
Glossary
Reformulation
Changing a recipe, such as removing an additive or lowering sugar, while trying to keep the taste, texture, and keeping power. Food tech example: reformulating a sauce to remove a preservative means finding another way to keep it safe.
Brief
A short written statement of what a reformulation must change and what must stay the same, with its limits and its date. Food tech example: the brief for a sauce says remove the preservative, keep the taste, and hold the price rise to a set amount.
Challenge test
A test that puts germs into a food on purpose, in the laboratory, and watches whether they grow over the shelf life. Food tech example: a challenge test on a sauce shows whether its preservative stops yeast for six months.
Eater testing
Testing a food with people who buy it, comparing the new food with the old one without telling them which is which. Food tech example: eater testing shows whether a reformulated biscuit still tastes like the one buyers know.
Small batch
A small amount of a food made in the laboratory to test a recipe change before it is made at full scale. Food tech example: a small batch of sauce tests a new natural colour before the line is changed.
Full scale
Making a food at the normal production amount, on the line, after it has worked in small batches. Food tech example: a recipe that worked in a small batch is tested at full scale to see if it mixes and fills properly.
Shelf life test
Testing a food over its whole shelf life, in the conditions it will meet, to set the shelf life the label can carry. Food tech example: a shelf life test on a drink checks its colour and taste after six months in a warm shop.
Premium line
A range of foods sold at a higher price, often with a shorter list or better ingredients, for buyers who will pay more. Food tech example: a clean label sauce is sold as a premium line at a higher price.
Emulsifier
A substance that helps mix oil and water in a food, such as lecithin in chocolate. Food tech example: lecithin in a sauce keeps the oil and water from splitting apart.
Stabiliser
A substance that keeps a food's texture stable and stops it separating during storage. Food tech example: a stabiliser in yoghurt keeps it creamy and stops whey separating on top.
Flavouring
A substance added to food to give or strengthen a flavour, which may be natural or made in a factory. Food tech example: vanilla flavouring gives a cake its vanilla taste.
Preservative
A substance added to food to slow spoilage by germs, moulds, or yeasts. Food tech example: a preservative in bread slows mould growth and keeps the loaf fresh for longer.
Trade-off
A balance in which gaining one thing means giving up another, such as a shorter list meaning a shorter shelf life. Food tech example: removing a preservative is a trade-off between a cleaner list and a shorter shelf life.
Costing
Counting the cost of a recipe, including ingredients, process, pack, and waste, to set the price. Food tech example: costing a reformulated sauce shows the natural colour adds a set amount per jar.
Launch
Putting a new or reformulated food on sale, and watching its sales and complaints after it is launched. Food tech example: after launch, the maker watches whether buyers buy the new sauce again.
Triangle test
A sensory test in which each eater gets three samples, two the same and one different, and must pick the different one. Food tech example: a triangle test shows whether eaters can tell a reformulated biscuit from the original.
References
- Food Product Development, Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., 1991.
- Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development, 2nd edition, 2004.
- Branen, A. L., Davidson, P. M. and Salminen, S., Food Additives, 2nd edition, 2001.
- Smith, J. and Hong-Shum, L., Food Additives Data Book, 2nd edition, 2011.
- Food and Drink Federation, Guidance on Clean Labelling, 2019.
Unit 8: Clean-Label Emulsifiers, Stabilisers and Texturisers
Note
Unit 8: Clean-Label Emulsifiers, Stabilisers and Texturisers
A question to start with
A maker takes the emulsifier out of a salad dressing to make the label shorter. The next day the dressing has split into oil on top and water below, and the buyer sends it back. The maker takes the stabiliser out of a yoghurt, and the whey separates on top within a week. The maker takes the texturiser out of a low-fat ice cream, and the ice cream turns icy and hard. Each time the same lesson returns: the ingredient that was removed was doing a job, and the job did not go away when the name left the label. This unit is about those jobs: how emulsifiers, stabilisers, and texturisers work, what clean-label replacements exist, and how a maker judges whether a replacement truly works.
Emulsifiers, stabilisers, and texturisers are often grouped together because they all shape texture, but they do different jobs. An emulsifier mixes oil and water and keeps them mixed. A stabiliser keeps a texture stable over time, stopping separation, settling, or crystal growth. A texturiser builds the mouthfeel itself, the creaminess, the thickness, or the chew. A food may need all three, or only one, and the clean-label question is different for each. This unit takes them one at a time, explains the science in plain words, and shows the replacements that makers actually use, with their limits stated plainly.
Questions to think about
- A dressing splits without its emulsifier. What has changed inside the bottle, at the level of oil drops and water?
- A yoghurt is thickened with starch instead of gelatin. Why might the yoghurt taste the same on day one and feel different after two weeks?
- A label says "no emulsifiers" but the food still holds oil and water together. What could be doing the emulsifier's job?
Think about the dressing question before you read on
Oil and water do not mix on their own, because water molecules prefer each other to oil. In a dressing, the oil is broken into tiny drops spread through the water, and an emulsifier sits at the surface of each drop, with one end that likes water and one end that likes oil, holding the drops apart so they cannot join back together. Without the emulsifier, the drops join, grow, and rise, and the dressing splits into two layers.
Emulsifiers: holding oil and water together
An emulsion is a mixture of two liquids that do not normally mix, such as oil and water, where one is spread as tiny drops through the other. Mayonnaise is oil drops in water. Butter is water drops in oil. Milk is fat drops in water. In each case the drops want to join together, because joining lowers the energy of the mixture, and the emulsion wants to split. An emulsifier slows that splitting by sitting at the boundary between oil and water, with one part of its molecule that is attracted to water and another part that is attracted to oil. That two-sided nature is the whole secret of emulsifiers, and every emulsifier, from egg yolk to soy lecithin to a mono- and diglyceride, works in the same way.
Egg yolk is the oldest clean-label emulsifier, and it works because it contains lecithin and proteins that sit at the oil-water boundary. A mayonnaise made with egg yolk is an emulsion held together by those yolk parts, and it is also a food that carries egg as an allergen, which must be declared. Soy lecithin, taken from soybeans, is the emulsifier most often used in chocolate, where it keeps the cocoa butter and the other parts flowing smoothly, and it must be declared for soy-allergic buyers. Sunflower lecithin does the same job without soy, and it is chosen when the maker wants a soy-free label, though it costs more and behaves a little differently in some foods. Mustard, in a vinaigrette, is an emulsifier too: its mucilage, a thick substance from the seed, coats the oil drops and holds them apart, which is why a dressing made with mustard holds longer than one made without it.
Clean-label emulsifier replacements are rarely one-for-one swaps. The maker must ask what the emulsifier was doing in that food, and whether another ingredient, or a change in process, can do the same job. A dressing may hold with mustard and a longer, slower mixing step that makes smaller oil drops, because smaller drops rise more slowly and take longer to join. A chocolate may flow with sunflower lecithin, or with a change in the amount of cocoa butter, so less emulsifier is needed at all. A cake may hold its air and its fat with egg, or with a batter that is mixed in a different order, so the fat is spread more finely before baking. In each case the replacement is judged by the same tests: does the food stay mixed over its shelf life, does it look right, does it taste right, and does it survive the conditions it will meet, such as a warm shop or a cold fridge? A replacement that works in the laboratory and fails in a warm shop is not a replacement.
A worked example shows how a maker thinks about dose, with round teaching numbers only. Suppose a dressing uses an emulsifier at 1 part in 100 parts of dressing, which is 1 percent. The maker tries a clean-label replacement at the same 1 percent and finds the dressing splits in three days. The maker tries the replacement at 2 percent and finds the dressing holds for four weeks, but the taste is heavier and the cost is higher. The maker then tries the replacement at 1 percent with a longer mixing step that makes smaller drops, and finds the dressing holds for four weeks with the taste unchanged. The lesson is that the amount and the process work together: a higher dose is not the only answer, and a process change can make a lower dose work. That lesson is written into the recipe, with the mixing time and the drop size named, so the next batch makes the same dressing.
Stabilisers: keeping texture steady over time
A stabiliser does not mix oil and water. It keeps a texture from changing while the food sits on the shelf. In yoghurt, a stabiliser stops the whey, the watery part of milk, from separating on top. In ice cream, a stabiliser stops ice crystals from growing, so the ice cream stays smooth instead of turning icy. In a sauce, a stabiliser stops the starch from settling and the oil from rising. In a drink with fruit pulp, a stabiliser stops the pulp from settling to the bottom. The stabiliser does this by thickening the water part of the food, or by forming a soft network through it, so that drops, crystals, and particles move more slowly and cannot join or settle as fast.
The clean-label stabilisers most often used come from plants and from seaweed. Pectin, from fruit, forms a network in jams and in yoghurt drinks, and it is the reason a jam sets. Agar, from seaweed, sets a firm gel and is used in desserts and in some dairy foods. Carrageenan, also from seaweed, is used in chocolate milk to stop the cocoa from settling, and in some meats to hold water. Guar gum, from a bean, thickens sauces and ice cream. Xanthan gum, made by a microbe, thickens dressings and gluten-free breads, and it is one of the most effective stabilisers at low doses. Starch, from corn, potato, or tapioca, thickens sauces and soups, and a starch that has been changed by heat or by acid, rather than by chemical treatment, can be called a clean-label starch in many systems. Each of these has a character: pectin needs acid and sugar to set well, agar sets firmly and can feel brittle, carrageenan can feel slimy if too much is used, guar gum can feel slimy and can lose its thickness in acid, xanthan gum holds well in acid but can feel stringy, and starch can thin out when it is heated again or when it sits with an enzyme.
The skill in using a stabiliser is using the right one, at the right dose, for the right food, and that skill is learned by testing, not by reading a list. A maker who uses too little will see separation. A maker who uses too much will feel a slimy or gummy texture that buyers reject. A maker who uses a stabiliser that works in a neutral food, such as milk, in an acid food, such as a fruit drink, will find it fails, because acid breaks some stabilisers down. A maker who uses a stabiliser that works when the food is cold, in a food that is heated, will find it thins out. The testing therefore covers the whole life of the food: the making, the packing, the storage, the transport, the shop shelf, and the home fridge, and the food is checked at the start and at the end of its shelf life, not only on the day it is made.
Texturisers: building creaminess, thickness, and chew
A texturiser builds the mouthfeel of a food: the creaminess of a low-fat yoghurt, the thickness of a soup, the chew of a meat-free burger, or the softness of a gluten-free bread. In a full-fat food, the fat itself does much of this work, because fat feels creamy and coats the mouth. In a low-fat or fat-free food, the fat is gone, and something else must give the same feeling. That something is usually a fibre, a starch, or a protein, and the choice changes the food in ways the maker must understand. A fibre can give body but can also feel gritty if its particles are too large. A starch can give thickness but can feel pasty if too much is used. A protein can give chew but can taste beany or milky if the dose is high.
Fibres used as texturisers include oat fibre, citrus fibre, pea fibre, and inulin, a fibre from chicory root. Citrus fibre, made from the peel left after juice is pressed, holds water well and gives body to sauces, dressings, and meat-free foods, and it carries a clean story, because it comes from fruit. Inulin gives a creamy feeling in low-fat yoghurt and ice cream, because it forms tiny crystals that feel like fat in the mouth, and it also feeds gut microbes, which is a benefit that must not be claimed on the pack unless the claim is allowed where the food is sold. Oat fibre gives body to breads and to meat-free foods, and it holds water, so the food stays moist. Each fibre must be tested for its water holding, its particle size, and its effect on taste, because a fibre that holds too much water can make a food soggy, and a fibre with large particles can make it gritty.
Proteins used as texturisers include egg white, whey protein, and plant proteins from pea or soy. Egg white, when whipped, gives structure to cakes and to meringues. Whey protein, when heated, forms a gel that thickens yoghurt and gives body to drinks. Pea protein gives chew to meat-free foods, and it is chosen when the maker wants a protein that is not from milk or soy. The limit of proteins as texturisers is that they carry allergens: egg, milk, and soy are all major allergens, and a texturiser that adds an allergen to a food that did not have one is a step backwards, even if the texture is better. The maker must weigh the texture gain against the allergen cost, and must declare the allergen clearly if the protein is used.
The diagram shows the replacement steps in order. The step most often skipped is testing over the whole shelf life, and it is the step that catches the yoghurt that is thick on day one and watery on day fourteen.
When a replacement does not work, and what to do instead
Not every texture ingredient can be replaced, and a good maker knows when to say so. A chocolate that needs lecithin to flow through the line may need sunflower lecithin, not no lecithin at all, and the honest label says so. An ice cream that needs a stabiliser to stay smooth through freezing and thawing may need a small amount of a plant gum, and the honest label lists it. A gluten-free bread that needs xanthan gum to hold its shape may need that gum, and the honest label names it. In each case the maker has shortened the list where it could be shortened, and has kept the ingredient where the food fails without it, and the label tells the truth about both. That is clean label done honestly, and it earns more trust than a label that claims "no stabilisers" on a food that is full of starches doing the same job under a different name.
The other answer, when a replacement does not work, is to change the food itself. A dressing that cannot hold without an emulsifier can be sold as a dressing that is shaken before use, with the instruction on the pack, so the buyer does the mixing. A yoghurt that cannot hold its whey without a stabiliser can be sold as a strained yoghurt, where the whey is removed by straining, so there is no whey to separate. An ice cream that turns icy without a stabiliser can be sold in a smaller pack, eaten in one sitting, so it is never stored after opening and never thaws and refreezes. Each of these is a change in the food or the pack, not a change in the ingredient list, and each one keeps the label short without pretending the job has gone away.
Practical note: Take a dressing, a yoghurt, and an ice cream from your kitchen, and read their ingredient lists. For each one, name the emulsifier, the stabiliser, and the texturiser, if any, and write one line saying what job each one does. Then ask, for each one, what would happen if it were removed, and what could replace its job: another ingredient, a process change, or a change in the food itself. That exercise, done on three real foods, teaches more about texture than a list of ingredient names ever will.
Quick self-check
Question: Why does a dressing split when its emulsifier is removed?
Because the emulsifier sits at the surface of the oil drops, with one end that likes water and one end that likes oil, holding the drops apart. Without it, the drops join, grow, and rise, and the dressing splits into oil and water layers.
Question: A yoghurt is thick on day one and watery on day fourteen. What has the stabiliser failed to do?
It has failed to keep the texture stable over the shelf life. The whey has separated, which means the stabiliser did not hold the water part of the yoghurt, or it broke down during storage, so the food must be tested at the end of its shelf life, not only on the day it is made.
Try it yourself
Make a simple vinaigrette at home: oil, vinegar, salt, and a spoonful of mustard. Shake it and watch how long it holds before it splits. Then make the same vinaigrette without mustard, shake it, and watch again. Write down the two times, and then try a third version with mustard and a longer, slower whisking that makes smaller drops. Which version holds longest, and what does that tell you about the two ways of holding an emulsion: an emulsifier, and a process that makes smaller drops? Keep your notes, and use them the next time a label says "no emulsifiers" on a dressing that still holds.
Key ideas to carry forward
- An emulsifier mixes oil and water and keeps them mixed, by sitting at the surface of the drops with one end that likes water and one end that likes oil.
- A stabiliser keeps a texture steady over time, stopping separation, settling, or crystal growth, and a texturiser builds the mouthfeel itself.
- Egg yolk, soy lecithin, sunflower lecithin, and mustard are emulsifiers with clean stories, and each carries its own allergen or cost to weigh.
- Pectin, agar, carrageenan, guar gum, xanthan gum, and starch are stabilisers with different characters, and each works only in the foods that suit it.
- Fibres such as citrus fibre, oat fibre, and inulin, and proteins such as egg white and whey, build texture, and proteins can add an allergen to a food that did not have one.
- A replacement is judged over the whole shelf life, in the conditions the food will meet, and a process change, such as longer mixing, can make a lower dose work.
- When a replacement does not work, the honest answers are to keep the ingredient and say so, or to change the food or the pack so the job is no longer needed.
Glossary
Emulsifier
A substance that helps mix oil and water in a food and keeps them mixed. Food tech example: lecithin in chocolate keeps the cocoa butter and the other parts flowing smoothly.
Emulsion
A mixture of two liquids that do not normally mix, such as oil and water, where one is spread as tiny drops through the other. Food tech example: mayonnaise is an emulsion of oil drops in water, held together by egg yolk.
Stabiliser
A substance that keeps a food's texture stable and stops it separating during storage. Food tech example: a stabiliser in yoghurt keeps it creamy and stops whey separating on top.
Texturiser
An ingredient that builds the mouthfeel of a food, such as creaminess, thickness, or chew. Food tech example: inulin in a low-fat ice cream gives a creamy feeling that the missing fat would have given.
Lecithin
A substance from soy, sunflower, or egg yolk that acts as an emulsifier by sitting at the oil-water boundary. Food tech example: sunflower lecithin in chocolate keeps the chocolate flowing without soy.
Pectin
A substance from fruit that forms a network and sets jams, and that stabilises yoghurt drinks. Food tech example: pectin in jam is what makes the jam set instead of staying runny.
Agar
A substance from seaweed that sets a firm gel, used in desserts and in some dairy foods. Food tech example: agar in a dessert sets it firmly without gelatin.
Carrageenan
A substance from seaweed used to stop cocoa settling in chocolate milk and to hold water in some foods. Food tech example: carrageenan in chocolate milk keeps the cocoa spread through the milk instead of sinking.
Guar gum
A thickener from a bean, used in sauces and ice cream to give body and to stop separation. Food tech example: guar gum in a sauce thickens it and keeps it smooth.
Xanthan gum
A thickener made by a microbe, used in dressings and gluten-free breads, effective at low doses. Food tech example: xanthan gum in a gluten-free bread holds the dough together where gluten would have done the job.
Inulin
A fibre from chicory root that gives a creamy feeling in low-fat foods and feeds gut microbes. Food tech example: inulin in a low-fat yoghurt gives a creamy mouthfeel without fat.
Citrus fibre
A fibre made from citrus peel left after juice is pressed, used to hold water and give body. Food tech example: citrus fibre in a sauce gives body and keeps the sauce from separating.
Mucilage
A thick, sticky substance from seeds such as mustard, which coats oil drops and holds an emulsion. Food tech example: mustard mucilage in a vinaigrette keeps the oil drops apart so the dressing holds.
Whey separation
The watery part of milk separating on top of yoghurt or another dairy food during storage. Food tech example: whey separation on top of a yoghurt shows the stabiliser has not held the texture.
Drop size
The size of the oil drops in an emulsion, where smaller drops rise more slowly and take longer to join. Food tech example: longer mixing makes smaller oil drops in a dressing, so the dressing holds longer.
References
- Branen, A. L., Davidson, P. M. and Salminen, S., Food Additives, 2nd edition, 2001.
- Smith, J. and Hong-Shum, L., Food Additives Data Book, 2nd edition, 2011.
- Food Product Development, Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., 1991.
- Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development, 2nd edition, 2004.
- Hasenhuettl, G. L. and Hartel, R. W., Food Emulsifiers and Their Applications, 2nd edition, 2008.
Unit 9: Clean-Label Flavours and Natural Antioxidants
Note
Unit 9: Clean-Label Flavours and Natural Antioxidants
A question to start with
A maker removes the vanilla flavouring from a cake and uses real vanilla instead. The cake tastes better, but the cost triples, and the flavour fades after a month on the shelf. The maker removes the synthetic antioxidant from a cooking oil and uses rosemary extract instead. The oil stays fresh for three months, then turns rancid in a warm shop. In both cases the clean-label replacement worked, and then it stopped working, and the maker learned the two lessons of this unit: flavour is not one thing, it is a set of volatile compounds that escape, react, and fade, and an antioxidant is not a magic shield, it is a chemical that is used up as it works. This unit explains how flavours and natural antioxidants work, what clean-label replacements exist, and how to judge whether they truly last.
Flavour and oxidation are linked, because the same air that carries flavour away also turns fat rancid. A food that loses its flavour and a food that goes rancid are both foods whose chemistry has moved on, and the maker's job is to slow that movement without adding a name to the label that buyers reject. The unit takes flavour first, then oxidation, then the natural antioxidants that slow it, and ends with the testing that shows whether a replacement lasts for the whole shelf life.
Questions to think about
- A cake made with real vanilla tastes weaker after a month than on the day it was baked. Where has the vanilla flavour gone?
- A bottle of oil kept in a dark cupboard stays fresh longer than the same oil kept beside a sunny window. What has the light done?
- A label says "no artificial flavours" but the food tastes strongly of strawberry. What could be giving that taste?
Think about the vanilla question before you read on
Vanilla flavour comes from volatile compounds, small molecules that escape easily into the air. In a cake, those compounds slowly leave the crumb, react with other parts of the food, or are changed by heat and by time. The vanilla is still in the recipe, but its flavour compounds are gone or changed, so the cake tastes weaker. A flavouring that is made to last, such as a flavour locked inside a tiny capsule, releases its flavour more slowly, and that is one of the tools makers use.
What flavour is, and where it comes from
Flavour is not taste alone. It is taste, smell, and mouthfeel together, and smell does most of the work. The tongue tastes five basic tastes: sweet, salty, sour, bitter, and savoury. The nose smells hundreds of volatile compounds, small molecules that escape from the food into the air and reach the nose, both from outside the mouth and from inside, when food is chewed. A strawberry tastes of strawberry because of a set of volatile compounds that the nose reads as strawberry, not because of its sweetness alone. That is why a food eaten with a blocked nose tastes flat: the taste is still there, but the smell, and with it most of the flavour, is gone.
Flavours used in foods come in three broad groups. Natural flavours are taken from a natural source, such as vanilla pods, citrus peel, herbs, or spices, by pressing, distilling, or extracting with a solvent. Nature-identical flavours are made in a factory, but their molecules are the same as the ones found in nature: vanillin made in a factory is the same molecule as the vanillin in a vanilla pod, though the factory version is cheaper and more even. Artificial flavours are made in a factory and their molecules are not found in nature, or not in that food, though they may taste like the food they imitate. The rules for what counts as natural differ between regulatory systems, and the reader should check the rule where the food is sold, because a flavour called natural in one system may not be called natural in another. What matters for the maker is that the name on the label must match the rule, and that the flavour must work in the food.
Real ingredients give flavour in the most honest way: more fruit in a jam, more cocoa in a chocolate, more herb in a sauce. The limit is cost, and the limit is strength: real vanilla is dear, and a cake that needs a strong vanilla taste may need more vanilla than the price allows. The limit is also evenness: real fruit varies from batch to batch, so the flavour varies too, and a buyer who buys the same food every week expects the same taste. The maker who uses real ingredients must therefore accept variation, or must blend batches to even it out, or must use a natural flavouring alongside the real ingredient to steady the taste. Each of these is an honest choice, and each one must be named on the label in the way the rules require.
Clean-label flavouring: extracts, oils, and the tricks that make flavour last
The clean-label flavourings most often used are extracts, essential oils, oleoresins, and spice and herb preparations. An extract is made by soaking a natural source, such as vanilla pods, in a liquid, often ethanol and water, which pulls the flavour compounds out. An essential oil is made by distilling a peel, a leaf, or a seed, and it carries the most volatile compounds, the ones that smell strongest. An oleoresin is made by extracting a spice, such as black pepper or paprika, with a solvent, and it carries both the volatile flavour and the colour and the heat of the spice, in a concentrated form. A herb or spice preparation is the dried herb or spice itself, ground and added to the food, which gives flavour, colour, and texture together.
Each of these has a character that the maker must understand. Extracts are easy to use and mix well into water-based foods, but their flavour can fade, because the volatile compounds escape. Essential oils are strong, so a little goes a long way, but too much can taste harsh or medicinal, and some essential oils can irritate the skin of workers who handle them. Oleoresins are strong and stable, and they are used where a spice flavour must survive heating, such as in a sauce or a snack seasoning, but they can stain equipment and hands. Dried herbs and spices give a full flavour and a visible sign of the ingredient, which buyers like, but they vary from batch to batch, and they can carry microbes that must be controlled by the supplier.
Flavour fades, and the maker has tools to slow the fading. One is encapsulation, where flavour compounds are locked inside tiny capsules made of starch, gum, or protein, and released slowly during storage, or when the food is heated or chewed. A capsule that releases its flavour only when the food is baked is useful in a cake, where the flavour must survive the oven and still be there when the cake is eaten. Another is choosing a flavour form that suits the food: an oil-based flavour for a fatty food, a water-based extract for a drink, and a powder for a dry mix. A third is protecting the flavour from light, heat, and air, by the pack and by the storage, because a flavour kept in a dark, cool, sealed pack lasts longer than the same flavour kept in a clear pack in a warm shop. The testing for flavour is done by eaters, at the start and at the end of the shelf life, because an instrument can measure a compound, but only an eater can say whether the food still tastes right.
Oxidation: how fat turns rancid, and why it matters
Oxidation is the reaction of fat with oxygen from the air, and it is the main reason oils, nuts, fried foods, and fatty foods go rancid. The reaction has three stages. In the first, called initiation, a fat molecule loses a hydrogen atom and becomes a free radical, a molecule with an unpaired electron that is eager to react. Heat, light, and metals such as iron and copper speed this stage up, which is why oil kept beside a cooker or in a sunny window turns faster than oil kept in a dark cupboard. In the second, called propagation, the free radical reacts with oxygen to form a new radical, which attacks another fat molecule, which forms another radical, and the reaction spreads like a chain, each step making the next one. In the third, called termination, two radicals meet and join, and the chain stops, but by then the damage is done: the fat has broken into small molecules that smell stale, painty, or fishy, and taste bitter and unpleasant.
The signs of oxidation are easy to recognise once they are known. The smell changes first, from fresh and nutty to stale, waxy, or painty. The taste follows, with a bitter, sharp note that lingers. The colour can darken, and the texture can change, as the fat breaks down. In a fried food, oxidation shows as a stale taste that grows over days. In a nut, it shows as a bitter taste that was not there when the nut was fresh. In an oil, it shows as a smell that is noticed as soon as the bottle is opened. Oxidation is not only a taste problem. It also destroys vitamins, such as vitamin E, and it can form compounds that are not wanted in food, which is why makers control it even when the taste change is still small.
Oxidation is slowed by removing its helpers: oxygen, light, heat, and metals. A pack that keeps oxygen out, such as a sealed pack with the air removed, slows oxidation. A pack that blocks light, such as a dark bottle or a foil pouch, slows it. A cool store slows it, because heat speeds every step of the chain. A clean process, with no iron or copper from equipment, slows it, because metals start the chain. Each of these is a process or pack control, and each one is part of clean-label work, because a maker who controls oxygen, light, and heat needs less antioxidant in the food itself. The antioxidant is the last line, not the first, and a maker who reaches for it before fixing the pack has the order backwards.
Natural antioxidants: how they work, and their limits
An antioxidant is a substance that slows oxidation, and it does so in one of two ways. The first way is to break the chain: the antioxidant gives a hydrogen atom to a free radical, turning the radical into a stable molecule, and becoming a stable radical itself, one that does not attack another fat molecule. Vitamin E, called tocopherol, works in this way, and it is the antioxidant most often used in oils and in fatty foods. The second way is to remove a helper of oxidation: a substance that binds metals, called a chelator, locks iron and copper away so they cannot start the chain, and citric acid, from citrus fruit, works in this way, as does the acid in a vinegar. A third way, used by some plant extracts, is to absorb oxygen itself, so the oxygen never reaches the fat.
The natural antioxidants most often used come from plants. Tocopherols, from vegetable oils, are the standard natural antioxidant for oils, nuts, and fried foods, and they are used at low doses, because too much can turn from an antioxidant into a pro-oxidant, a substance that speeds oxidation instead of slowing it, which is a trap that catches makers who think more is always better. Rosemary extract, from rosemary leaves, contains compounds called carnosic acid and rosmarinic acid, which break the oxidation chain, and it is used in meats, oils, and snacks, though it can give a herbal taste if the dose is high. Green tea extract contains catechins, which are strong antioxidants, and it is used in oils and in meat-free foods, though it can give a bitter taste and a colour. Ascorbic acid, which is vitamin C, is used in fruit drinks and in some meats, where it slows oxidation and keeps colour, though it is used up quickly and needs to be protected from light and air itself. Citric acid, from citrus, binds metals and is used with tocopherols, because the two work better together than either one alone: the tocopherol breaks the chain, and the citric acid locks the metals away.
The limits of natural antioxidants must be stated plainly. They are used up as they work, so a food that is protected on day one may not be protected on day ninety, and the shelf life must be set from the test at the end, not from the test at the start. They are weaker, dose for dose, than some synthetic antioxidants, so the maker may need a higher dose, a better pack, or a shorter shelf life to get the same protection. They can change the taste, the colour, or the smell of the food, especially rosemary and green tea, so the dose must be judged by eaters as well as by instruments. And they cost more, so the maker must count the cost and decide whether the buyer will pay it. A natural antioxidant that is used at a dose so low that it does nothing, so the label can say "rosemary extract", is a label claim, not a control, and the food will turn rancid on the shelf.
The diagram shows the oxidation chain. The arrows run one way, because each step leads to the next, and the controls, oxygen-free pack, dark pack, cool store, and antioxidant, work by breaking the chain at its start.
Note the shape of that diagram: it is a short chain, not a long one, because oxidation is a chain reaction with three stages, and the diagram shows only those three. The pack and the store are controls that sit outside the chain, slowing its start, and the antioxidant sits inside it, breaking the chain as it spreads.
Testing flavour and freshness over the shelf life
Flavour and freshness are tested together, because a food that has lost its flavour and a food that has turned rancid are both foods that have aged, and the tests for one often catch the other. The laboratory tests measure the chemistry: the peroxide value, which rises as oxidation starts, and the level of secondary oxidation products, which rises as rancidity develops. These are numbers, and they are trended over the shelf life, so a slow rise is seen before the taste changes. The eater tests measure the food as it is eaten: a trained panel, or a panel of ordinary buyers, tastes the food at the start, in the middle, and at the end of its shelf life, and scores its flavour, its smell, and its liking. The two sets of tests must agree: a food whose chemistry says it is fresh but whose eaters say it tastes stale is a food that has failed, whatever the numbers say.
The testing must cover the conditions the food will meet: a warm shop, a cold store, a home cupboard, and a pack that has been opened and closed. A food that is fresh in a cold laboratory and rancid in a warm shop has the shelf life of the warm shop, not of the laboratory. The shelf life is set from the worst condition, and the label carries the shelf life the testing supports. The testing is repeated when a supplier changes, when a flavouring changes, or when the pack changes, because each of those can change the flavour and the freshness, and the maker who does not retest is guessing.
Practical note: Buy a small bottle of cooking oil and keep half in a dark cupboard and half beside a sunny window, both sealed. Smell each one after two weeks, and write down the difference in one line each. That difference, which you can smell for yourself, is oxidation, and it is the reason a dark bottle and a cool store matter more than any antioxidant on the label.
Quick self-check
Question: Why does a cake made with real vanilla taste weaker after a month?
Because vanilla flavour comes from volatile compounds that slowly escape from the crumb, react with other parts of the food, or are changed by heat and time. The vanilla is still in the recipe, but its flavour compounds are gone or changed, so the cake tastes weaker.
Question: How does vitamin E, tocopherol, slow oxidation?
It breaks the oxidation chain by giving a hydrogen atom to a free radical, turning the radical into a stable molecule, and becoming a stable radical itself that does not attack another fat molecule.
Try it yourself
Choose a food from your kitchen that lists a flavouring, such as a biscuit, a drink, or a sauce. Read the ingredient list and write down how the flavour is named: as a named fruit or spice, as "natural flavouring", or as a flavouring with a number. Then taste the food and write one line saying what you taste, and one line saying whether the name on the label matches the taste. Then choose an oil or a bag of nuts, smell it, and write one line saying whether it smells fresh or stale. Those two exercises, one for flavour and one for freshness, are the two judgements a maker must make on every batch.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Flavour is taste, smell, and mouthfeel together, and smell, from volatile compounds, does most of the work.
- Natural flavours come from a natural source, nature-identical flavours are the same molecules made in a factory, and artificial flavours are molecules not found in that food in nature.
- Extracts, essential oils, oleoresins, and dried herbs and spices are the clean-label flavourings, and each has its own character, strength, and limits.
- Flavour fades because volatile compounds escape, react, or change, and encapsulation, the right flavour form, and a dark, cool, sealed pack slow the fading.
- Oxidation is a chain reaction in fat: initiation makes a free radical, propagation spreads it with oxygen, and termination stops it after the damage is done.
- Oxygen, light, heat, and metals speed oxidation, and a pack that keeps oxygen and light out, and a cool store, are the first controls.
- Natural antioxidants, such as tocopherols, rosemary extract, green tea extract, ascorbic acid, and citric acid, break the chain or lock metals away, and they are used up as they work.
- Flavour and freshness are tested over the whole shelf life, by laboratory numbers and by eaters, in the worst conditions the food will meet.
Glossary
Flavour
Taste, smell, and mouthfeel together, where smell does most of the work of telling one food from another. Food tech example: a strawberry tastes of strawberry because of the volatile compounds its nose reads as strawberry.
Volatile compound
A small molecule that escapes easily from a food into the air, where the nose can smell it. Food tech example: the volatile compounds in vanilla escape from a cake over weeks, so the cake tastes weaker.
Natural flavouring
A flavouring taken from a natural source, such as vanilla pods or citrus peel, by pressing, distilling, or extracting. Food tech example: vanilla extract is a natural flavouring made by soaking vanilla pods in ethanol and water.
Extract
A flavouring made by soaking a natural source in a liquid that pulls the flavour compounds out. Food tech example: vanilla extract is made by soaking vanilla pods in ethanol and water.
Essential oil
A flavouring made by distilling a peel, leaf, or seed, carrying the most volatile compounds. Food tech example: lemon essential oil from lemon peel gives a strong lemon smell at a low dose.
Oleoresin
A concentrated flavouring made by extracting a spice with a solvent, carrying its flavour, colour, and heat. Food tech example: black pepper oleoresin gives a sauce its pepper flavour and survives heating.
Encapsulation
Locking flavour compounds inside tiny capsules that release them slowly during storage, or when the food is heated or chewed. Food tech example: encapsulated vanilla in a cake releases its flavour when the cake is baked.
Oxidation
The reaction of fat with oxygen from the air, which turns fat rancid. Food tech example: oxidation in a bottle of oil kept in sunlight turns the oil stale and bitter.
Free radical
A molecule with an unpaired electron that is eager to react, made when a fat molecule loses a hydrogen atom. Food tech example: a free radical in oil attacks another fat molecule and spreads oxidation as a chain.
Rancid
The stale, painty, or bitter smell and taste of a fat that has oxidised. Food tech example: nuts that taste bitter and stale have turned rancid by oxidation.
Antioxidant
A substance that slows oxidation, by breaking the chain or by locking metals away. Food tech example: tocopherol in cooking oil slows oxidation by giving a hydrogen atom to a free radical.
Tocopherol
Vitamin E, a natural antioxidant from vegetable oils that breaks the oxidation chain. Food tech example: tocopherol in a bottle of oil keeps the oil fresh for longer.
Rosemary extract
An extract from rosemary leaves that contains compounds that break the oxidation chain. Food tech example: rosemary extract in a meat product slows rancidity, though a high dose can give a herbal taste.
Ascorbic acid
Vitamin C, used to slow oxidation and keep colour in fruit drinks and in some meats. Food tech example: ascorbic acid in a fruit drink slows browning and keeps the drink fresh.
Chelator
A substance that binds metals such as iron and copper, locking them away so they cannot start oxidation. Food tech example: citric acid in oil binds iron so the iron cannot start the oxidation chain.
Peroxide value
A laboratory number that rises as oxidation starts in a fat, used to track freshness over shelf life. Food tech example: a rising peroxide value in stored oil warns that oxidation has begun.
References
- Branen, A. L., Davidson, P. M. and Salminen, S., Food Additives, 2nd edition, 2001.
- Smith, J. and Hong-Shum, L., Food Additives Data Book, 2nd edition, 2011.
- Reineccius, G., Flavor Chemistry and Technology, 2nd edition, 2005.
- Food Product Development, Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., 1991.
- Pokorny, J., Yanishlieva, N. and Gordon, M., Antioxidants in Food, 2001.
Unit 10: Clean Label Across Product Categories and What Buyers Think
Note
Unit 10: Clean Label Across Product Categories and What Buyers Think
A question to start with
A shopper stands in a shop and looks at three foods: a loaf of bread, a pot of yoghurt, and a pack of sausages. All three say "clean label" on the front. The bread lists five ingredients. The yoghurt lists three. The sausages list twelve, including salt, spices, and a plant extract the shopper has never heard of. The shopper asks the question that this unit answers: does clean label mean the same thing in a bakery, a dairy, and a meat plant, and what is the shopper really judging when they read a label? The answer is that clean label is not one recipe. It is a set of choices that look different in each category, because bread, yoghurt, and sausage fail in different ways, and the buyer judges each one by a different set of signs.
This unit takes the categories one at a time, bakery, dairy, meat, and drinks and sauces, and shows what clean label means in each, what is easy, what is hard, and what cannot be done without changing the food itself. It then turns to the buyer, and asks what buyers actually think when they read a label, what they trust, what they misunderstand, and how a maker earns trust without misleading anyone. The two halves belong together, because a clean-label food is judged twice: once in the factory, by whether it works, and once in the shop, by whether the buyer believes it.
Questions to think about
- A loaf of bread lists five ingredients and a sausage lists twelve. Does the shorter list mean the bread is cleaner, or only that bread needs fewer ingredients?
- A yoghurt says "no added sugar" on the front, but its ingredient list shows fruit puree that is high in sugar. Has the maker misled the buyer?
- A buyer trusts a food because its label is short, and distrusts a food because its label names a chemical. Is that trust based on the food, or on the words?
Think about the bread and sausage question before you read on
It means only that bread needs fewer ingredients. A loaf of bread is flour, water, yeast, and salt, with a little oil or sugar if the maker chooses, so a short list is natural to it. A sausage is meat, fat, salt, spices, and a cure, with a casing and a process that keeps it safe, so a longer list is natural to it. Judging a sausage by the length of a bread label is judging a fish by how well it climbs a tree: the comparison is wrong, and the maker who shortens a sausage list by removing the cure that keeps it safe has made the food worse, not cleaner.
Bakery: where clean label is easiest, and where it is not
Bakery is the category where clean label looks easiest, because the basic foods are simple. A loaf of bread is flour, water, yeast, and salt. A plain biscuit is flour, sugar, fat, and a raising agent. A cake is flour, sugar, egg, fat, and a raising agent. The list is short by nature, and a maker who uses good flour, a long fermentation, and a careful bake can make a bread with no additives at all, and a biscuit with only a raising agent that is named in plain words, such as baking soda. That is why bakery shelves are full of clean-label claims, and why buyers expect them there.
The hard parts of bakery are the parts the buyer does not see. The first is shelf life: a bread with no preservative stales in days, and a bread with no mould inhibitor grows mould in a warm shop. The clean-label answers are process and pack, not ingredients: a sourdough fermentation, where the acid made by the culture slows mould, a bake that drives off water, a pack that keeps the loaf dry, and a smaller loaf that is eaten before it stales. The second is softness: a bread that stays soft for a week without an emulsifier needs a different flour, a longer mix, or a different bake, and a cake that stays moist without a humectant needs more egg, more fat, or a different sugar. The third is the raising agent: baking powder is a mix of an acid and a base, and its name on a label can look chemical, even though its job, making bubbles of CO₂ that lift the dough, is the same job that yeast does. The maker who names it plainly, and explains its job in a word on the pack, earns more trust than the maker who hides it behind a number.
Gluten-free bakery is the hardest corner of the category, because gluten is the protein that gives dough its stretch and its hold, and without it the dough falls apart. The clean-label replacements are xanthan gum, psyllium husk, and starches, and each one must be named on the label. A gluten-free bread that says "no gums" and still holds its shape is usually held by a starch or a fibre that does the same job under a different name, and the honest label says what that is. The buyer who needs gluten-free bread needs the bread to hold, to slice, and to toast, and a label that hides the ingredient that makes that possible does not help them. It only makes the choice harder.
Dairy: short lists, living cultures, and the cold chain
Dairy is the category where clean label is most natural, because many dairy foods are already short in their lists. A plain yoghurt is milk and cultures. A plain cheese is milk, cultures, salt, and rennet. A butter is cream and salt. The cultures themselves, the microbes that turn milk into yoghurt and cheese, are living ingredients, and they do jobs that additives would otherwise do: they make acid that preserves the food, they make flavour, and they make texture. A maker who uses a good culture, a clean milk, and a cold chain can make a yoghurt with a list of two ingredients, and that list is honest, because the culture did the work.
The hard parts of dairy are keeping power and texture. A yoghurt without a stabiliser can separate, with whey on top, and the clean-label answers are a longer fermentation, a higher milk solid content, a straining step that removes whey, or a smaller pot that is eaten before it separates. A flavoured yoghurt without a colour or a flavouring needs real fruit, and real fruit varies, costs more, and can carry microbes, so the maker must control the fruit as carefully as the milk. A cheese without a preservative needs a clean make, a good salt level, and a cold store, and a processed cheese without an emulsifying salt needs a different make altogether, and may not be possible as a clean-label food at all. A milk drink without a stabiliser can settle, with cocoa or fruit pulp at the bottom, and the clean-label answer is a shake-before-use instruction, or a smaller bottle, or a stabiliser named plainly on the label.
The cold chain is the invisible ingredient in dairy clean label. Milk, yoghurt, and cheese are kept cold from the factory to the shop to the home, and that cold is what keeps them safe and fresh without preservatives. A maker who sells a yoghurt with a short list and a long shelf life is selling a yoghurt that depends on the cold chain working, and the label must carry the storage instruction, "keep refrigerated", and the buyer must follow it. A yoghurt that is left warm, however clean its label, will spoil, and the fault is not in the label. It is in the chain, and the maker who explains the chain on the pack earns a buyer who keeps the food cold.
Meat: where safety and clean label pull hardest
Meat is the category where clean label and safety pull hardest against each other, because meat is the food where microbes grow fastest, and where the additives that slow them have the longest history. A fresh cut of meat, a steak or a chop, needs no additives at all, and its label is a single word. A cured meat, a sausage, a ham, or a salami, needs salt, and often nitrite, to keep it safe from the microbes that cause botulism, a rare but severe illness. Nitrite is the additive that buyers most often ask to remove, and it is the additive whose removal carries the most risk, because no natural replacement does its job as well, and the job is safety, not taste or colour.
The clean-label work in meat is therefore about the whole system, not about one ingredient. A sausage that loses nitrite must gain something else: a lower water content, a higher salt level, a stronger acid, a shorter shelf life, a colder store, or a different pack that keeps oxygen out. Each of those changes the taste, the texture, or the cost, and each one must be tested for safety with a challenge test, where microbes are put into the food on purpose in the laboratory and watched to see whether they grow. A maker who removes nitrite and changes nothing else has not made a clean-label sausage. They have made an unsafe one, and the label that says "no nitrites" on it is a danger, not a selling point. The honest label, where nitrite is replaced by a plant extract that contains nitrite, such as celery powder, must say so, because the nitrite is still there, in a different form, and the buyer who avoids nitrite for a medical reason needs to know that.
The other hard parts of meat are colour and texture. A fresh meat keeps its red colour for a short time, then turns brown, and a buyer who sees brown meat may reject it even though it is safe. The clean-label answer is a pack that keeps oxygen out, or a pack with a gas mix that keeps the colour, and a sell-by date that matches the colour life. A sausage that loses its binder, such as a phosphate that holds water, will be drier and will lose weight in cooking, and the clean-label answers are a different cut of meat, a longer mix, or a fibre that holds water. Each answer must be tested with eaters, because a sausage that is safe and clean but dry and crumbly will not be bought twice.
Drinks, sauces, and the long shelf life problem
Drinks and sauces are the categories where shelf life is the hardest problem, because they sit on a shelf at room temperature for months, and the microbes, the oxidation, and the colour change all have months to work. A fresh juice needs no preservative if it is kept cold and drunk in days. A juice that must keep for six months at room temperature needs a heat treatment, a clean fill, and a pack that keeps oxygen and light out, and even then it may need an acid or a preservative to stay safe after opening. A sauce that must keep for a year needs the same, and a sauce that is opened and kept in a fridge needs a preservative, or a small pack, or an instruction to use it within days.
The clean-label answers in these categories are process and pack first, and ingredients second. A juice that is heated and filled hot into a clean bottle, and sealed at once, can keep without a preservative. A sauce that is acidified with vinegar or lemon juice, so its acidity is high enough to stop microbes, can keep without a preservative. A drink that is packed in a dark bottle, and stored cool, can keep its colour without a colour stabiliser. A sauce that is sold in a small pack, eaten in one sitting, can keep without the preservative that was there for storage after opening. Each of these is a change in the food or the pack, and each one must be tested for the whole shelf life, in the warm shop as well as in the cold laboratory.
The diagram is a set of four separate panels, one per category, with no arrows between them, because the categories are not steps in a process. No step causes the next: a loaf does not become a yoghurt, and a yoghurt does not become a sausage. Each category stands on its own, with its own hard parts.
What buyers think: trust, misunderstanding, and the short list
Buyers judge a label with their eyes before they judge it with their knowledge. A short list looks clean. A long list looks chemical. A name the buyer recognises, such as "lemon juice", looks safe. A name the buyer does not recognise, such as "ascorbic acid", looks chemical, even though ascorbic acid is vitamin C and lemon juice contains it. A number, such as an E number, looks industrial, even though the number is only a code for a substance that may be natural, such as a colour from beetroot. These judgements are fast, and they are often wrong, and they are the reason a maker must think about the words on the label as carefully as the ingredients in the food.
The most common misunderstanding is that a short list means a safe food, and a long list means an unsafe one. A short list can hide a risk: a sausage with no nitrite and no other safety control is less safe than a sausage with nitrite, however long its list. A long list can be a list of real foods: a curry paste with twelve spices is a long list, and every item on it is a spice. The second misunderstanding is that "natural" means safe and "artificial" means unsafe. A natural substance can be harmful at a high dose, and an artificial substance can be safe at a low dose, and the safety of either one depends on the dose, the food, and the eater, not on the word natural. The third misunderstanding is that a claim on the front of the pack, such as "no added sugar" or "no artificial colours", tells the whole story. The front tells the claim the maker wants the buyer to see. The back, the ingredient list and the nutrition table, tells the whole story, and the buyer who reads only the front has read an advertisement, not a label.
Trust is earned by plain words, by a label that names ingredients in words the buyer can understand, by a claim that matches the ingredient list, and by a maker who explains why an ingredient is there, in a word or two, rather than hiding it. A label that says "ascorbic acid (vitamin C) to keep the colour fresh" tells the buyer what the ingredient is and why it is there, and it earns more trust than a label that says only "ascorbic acid" or only "no artificial preservatives". A label that says "rosemary extract to keep the oil fresh" does the same. A maker who explains, in plain words, earns a buyer who reads the back of the pack and still buys the food, and that buyer is worth more than a buyer who buys once because the front looked clean and never buys again because the food failed.
The clean-label movement itself is part of the story. It began with buyers asking for shorter lists and plainer words, and it grew as makers answered, and as shops gave shelf space to foods that answered. It is a movement that has done real good: lists are shorter, words are plainer, and makers think harder about whether an ingredient is needed. It has also done harm where it has pushed makers to remove ingredients that were keeping food safe, or to hide an ingredient behind a plainer name that does the same job. The movement will keep growing, and the makers who do well in it will be the ones who treat it as a promise of honesty, not as a race to the shortest list. A short list that is honest is worth more than a short list that is not, and a buyer who is told the truth will trust the next label too.
Practical note: Stand in a shop and pick three foods from three categories, such as a bread, a yoghurt, and a sausage. Read the front of each pack, and write down the claim. Then read the back, and write down the ingredient list. Then ask, for each food, whether the front claim matches the back list, and whether the list is long because the food needs many ingredients, or because the maker has added ingredients the food does not need. That comparison, done on real packs, is the skill this unit teaches.
Quick self-check
Question: Why is a sausage list longer than a bread list, and does that make the sausage less clean?
Because a sausage is meat, fat, salt, spices, and a cure, with a casing and a process that keeps it safe, while a bread is flour, water, yeast, and salt. The longer list is natural to the sausage, and it does not by itself make the sausage less clean. What matters is whether each ingredient on the list is needed and is named plainly.
Question: A label says "ascorbic acid". Why might a buyer distrust it, and what could the maker write instead?
Because the name looks chemical, even though ascorbic acid is vitamin C, which is in lemon juice. The maker could write "ascorbic acid (vitamin C) to keep the colour fresh", which names the ingredient, says what it is in plain words, and explains why it is there.
Try it yourself
Pick three foods from three categories in your kitchen, such as a bread, a yoghurt, and a sauce. For each one, write the front claim and the full ingredient list, and then write one line saying whether the front matches the back, and one line saying what job each ingredient you do not recognise is doing. Then ask a friend to do the same for the same three foods, and compare your lines: where did you agree, and where did you read the same label differently? That difference is the gap between a label and a buyer, and it is the gap a maker must close with plain words.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Clean label is not one recipe: bread, yoghurt, sausage, and sauce each fail in different ways, and each needs its own answers.
- In bakery, short lists are natural, and the hard parts are shelf life, softness, and gluten-free structure, answered by fermentation, process, and pack.
- In dairy, milk and cultures do the work, and the hard parts are separation and the cold chain, answered by straining, milk solids, and cold storage.
- In meat, safety pulls hardest, and nitrite must not be removed without a replacement system proved by a challenge test.
- In drinks and sauces, long shelf life is the hard part, and process and pack, heat, acid, and oxygen-free filling, come before ingredients.
- Buyers judge a label by length and by familiar words, and those judgements are often wrong: a short list can hide a risk, and a long list can be a list of real spices.
- Trust is earned by plain words, by a claim that matches the ingredient list, and by explaining why an ingredient is there.
Glossary
Sourdough fermentation
A slow fermentation of bread dough by a culture of yeasts and bacteria, which makes acid that slows mould. Food tech example: a sourdough loaf keeps longer without a preservative because its acid slows mould growth.
Humectant
A substance that holds water in a food and keeps it moist, such as glycerol in a cake. Food tech example: a cake without a humectant may dry out faster than one with it.
Raising agent
A substance that makes bubbles of gas in a dough or batter, lifting it as it bakes. Food tech example: baking soda is a raising agent that releases CO₂ in a cake batter.
Psyllium husk
A fibre from a seed husk used in gluten-free bread to hold water and give structure. Food tech example: psyllium husk in a gluten-free loaf helps the dough hold its shape where gluten would have done the job.
Culture
Microbes added to milk to turn it into yoghurt or cheese, making acid, flavour, and texture. Food tech example: the culture in a yoghurt turns milk into yoghurt by making acid.
Cold chain
The chain of cold storage and transport that keeps chilled foods cold from factory to home. Food tech example: a yoghurt stays fresh because the cold chain keeps it refrigerated from the factory to the shop.
Nitrite
A salt used in cured meats to keep them safe from the microbes that cause botulism, and to give colour. Food tech example: nitrite in a sausage keeps the sausage safe and pink.
Challenge test
A test that puts germs into a food on purpose, in the laboratory, and watches whether they grow over the shelf life. Food tech example: a challenge test on a sausage without nitrite shows whether its replacement system keeps it safe.
Botulism
A rare but severe illness caused by a toxin from a microbe that can grow in cured meats kept without air. Food tech example: nitrite in cured meat is used to stop the microbe that causes botulism from growing.
Emulsifying salt
A salt used in processed cheese to hold fat and protein together so the cheese melts smoothly. Food tech example: an emulsifying salt in processed cheese keeps the cheese smooth when it is heated.
Front of pack
The front of a food pack, where claims such as "no added sugar" are shown. Food tech example: the front of a yoghurt pack says "no added sugar", while the back lists the fruit puree that carries sugar.
Ingredient list
The list on the back of a pack naming every ingredient in the food, in order of amount. Food tech example: the ingredient list on a curry paste names twelve spices in order.
Clean-label movement
The demand from buyers, and the answer from makers, for shorter lists and plainer words on food packs. Food tech example: the clean-label movement has led makers to shorten lists and to name ingredients in plain words.
Plain words
Ingredient names a buyer can understand, such as "lemon juice" instead of a chemical name alone. Food tech example: a label that says "ascorbic acid (vitamin C)" uses plain words to explain the ingredient.
Gas mix pack
A pack filled with a mix of gases, instead of air, to keep a food's colour and freshness. Food tech example: a gas mix pack keeps fresh meat red for longer by controlling the oxygen around it.
References
- Branen, A. L., Davidson, P. M. and Salminen, S., Food Additives, 2nd edition, 2001.
- Fuller, G. W., New Food Product Development, 2nd edition, 2004.
- Food Product Development, Graf, E. and Saguy, I. S., 1991.
- Smith, J. and Hong-Shum, L., Food Additives Data Book, 2nd edition, 2011.
- Asioli, D., Aschemann-Witzel, J. and Caputo, V., Consumers and clean label, 2017.