GIFSQ ID: FTN-0109
Chocolate Technology
Unit 1: Types of Chocolate Products and Ingredients for Chocolate Manufacturing
Note
Unit 1: Types of Chocolate Products and Ingredients for Chocolate Manufacturing
A dark bar snaps and melts cleanly. A milk bar is softer and sweeter. A white bar has no cocoa solids at all, yet it is still called chocolate. What is in each one, and what does each ingredient do? This unit opens the three bars and reads their recipes.
1.1 From bean to bar: the ingredients in brief
Chocolate is made from cocoa beans, sugar, and, for milk and white chocolate, milk. The bean gives two things: cocoa liquor, the ground bean, which carries cocoa solids and cocoa butter together, and cocoa butter, the fat pressed out of the liquor. Cocoa powder is what is left after the butter is pressed out. Sugar sweetens. Milk adds flavour, softness, and colour. Lecithin, in a small amount, helps the melted chocolate flow. Flavour, usually vanilla, is added in a tiny amount.
The cocoa bean itself is about 53-58% cocoa butter in the cotyledon, the inner part of the bean, with cocoa solids, protein, starch, and the bitter compounds theobromine and caffeine making up the rest. Theobromine, at about 2-3% of the bean, gives chocolate its bitter note.
🤔 Pause and think: white chocolate has cocoa butter but no cocoa solids. Which flavours and colours will it have, and which will it lack?
Quick check
What two things does the cocoa bean give chocolate making?
Check your answer
Cocoa liquor, the ground bean carrying solids and butter together, and cocoa butter, the fat pressed out of the liquor; cocoa powder is what is left after pressing.
1.2 The main types of chocolate products
- Dark chocolate: cocoa liquor, cocoa butter, sugar, lecithin, and vanilla. It must carry a minimum of 35% total cocoa solids, from liquor and butter together, in the standard Afoakwa cites. It is firm, snaps cleanly, and melts at body temperature. The higher the cocoa share, the more bitter and the less sweet it tastes.
- Milk chocolate: cocoa liquor, cocoa butter, sugar, milk powder or milk solids, lecithin, and vanilla. It carries about 25-35% total cocoa solids, with milk solids softening the flavour and lightening the colour. It is softer than dark chocolate and melts more easily.
- White chocolate: cocoa butter, sugar, milk powder, lecithin, and vanilla, with no cocoa solids. It is sweet, milky, and pale, and its flavour comes from milk and vanilla, not from cocoa.
- Filled and coated chocolates: a centre, such as fondant, caramel, nut, or fruit, covered in chocolate. The chocolate must be tempered so it sets with a snap and a shine, and the centre must not leak water into the chocolate, or the chocolate will bloom.
- Chocolate for baking and drinks: cocoa powder, or chocolate with a higher cocoa share, made to melt into recipes or to mix with milk.
The three main chocolate types
Dark chocolate
Cocoa liquor + cocoa butter + sugar
Minimum 35% total cocoa solids. Firm, snaps cleanly, melts at body temperature.
Milk chocolate
Cocoa liquor + cocoa butter + sugar + milk solids
About 25-35% total cocoa solids. Softer than dark chocolate, melts more easily.
White chocolate
Cocoa butter + sugar + milk solids
No cocoa solids. Sweet, milky, and pale.
Figure 1.1: The three main chocolate types and what is in each. Drawn from the chocolate composition in Afoakwa, Chocolate Science and Technology, Chapter 12.
Quick check
What is the minimum total cocoa solids for dark chocolate in the standard Afoakwa cites, and what is missing from white chocolate?
Check your answer
Dark chocolate: a minimum of 35% total cocoa solids. White chocolate has no cocoa solids at all, only cocoa butter, sugar, and milk.
1.3 Cocoa bean: the raw material
The cocoa bean grows in a pod on the cacao tree, in warm, wet regions near the equator. The tree needs warmth, with ideal minima of 18-21 °C, and it suffers below about 13 °C. After harvest, the beans are fermented, usually for 5-6 days for Forastero beans, in heaps or boxes. Fermentation is where chocolate flavour begins: yeasts and bacteria heat the heap, break down the pulp, and start the chemical changes that make cocoa flavour precursors.
After fermentation the beans are dried, to less than about 7% moisture, then cleaned, roasted, and winnowed to remove the shell. The roasted nib, the inner bean, is ground into cocoa liquor. Roasting develops flavour and colour, and it must be even: under-roasted nibs taste raw and acidic, over-roasted nibs taste burnt and bitter.
From pod to cocoa liquor
Pod, beans + pulp
↓
Ferment, 5-6 days (Forastero)
Yeasts and bacteria heat the heap, flavour precursors form
↓
Dry, to less than about 7% moisture, clean
↓
Roast
Flavour and colour develop
↓
Winnow (shell off), nib
↓
Grind, cocoa liquor
↓
Press, cocoa butter + cocoa powder
Figure 1.2: From pod to cocoa liquor: ferment, dry, roast, winnow, grind. Drawn from Afoakwa, Chocolate Science and Technology, Chapters 3 and 5.
Quick check
What happens during fermentation of cocoa beans?
Check your answer
Yeasts and bacteria heat the heap and break down the pulp, starting the chemical changes that make cocoa flavour precursors.
1.4 Cocoa butter, sugar, milk, and flavour
- Cocoa butter: the fat of the bean, about 53-58% of the cotyledon. It is hard and brittle at room temperature, melts sharply at 34-35 °C in its best crystal form, Form V, and gives chocolate its snap and its melt in the mouth. It can crystallise in six forms, Forms I to VI, and only Form V gives the right snap, gloss, and shelf life. Unit 2 covers tempering, the process that makes Form V.
- Sugar: sucrose sweetens chocolate and gives it bulk. It must be ground fine, so the chocolate feels smooth, not gritty.
- Milk and milk products: milk powder adds flavour, softness, and a pale colour to milk and white chocolate. The milk must be fresh and heat-stable, and its fat must not go rancid in storage.
- Flavour: vanilla is the classic chocolate flavour, used in a tiny amount to round the cocoa note. Other flavours, such as mint or orange, are used in filled and flavoured bars.
- Food chemicals and allied substances: permitted colours and flavours where the recipe calls for them, and acids only where a fruit filling needs them, never in the chocolate itself.
Quick check
Why is cocoa butter's melting point so important to chocolate?
Check your answer
Because in its best crystal form, Form V, it melts at 34-35 °C, just below body temperature, so the bar is firm at room temperature and melts in the mouth.
1.5 Lecithin in chocolate: chemistry and uses
Lecithin is the most important minor ingredient in chocolate. It is a natural emulsifier, a molecule with one end that likes fat and one end that likes water, so it sits at the boundary between particles and fat and lets them slide past each other. In chocolate it coats the sugar and cocoa particles and lowers the viscosity, the thickness, of the melted chocolate, so the chocolate flows well for moulding and enrobing with less cocoa butter.
The chemistry is simple to picture: without lecithin, the dry particles grip each other and the chocolate is thick; with lecithin, each particle wears a slippery coat and the chocolate flows. The dose is small, usually about 0.3-0.5% of the chocolate, and more does not help: too much lecithin makes the chocolate thick again. PGPR, another emulsifier, is sometimes used with lecithin where a very thin flow is needed, as in enrobing.
🤔 Pause and think: a chocolate is too thick to mould, and the maker adds more cocoa butter. What cheaper change could have the same effect, and what is its limit?
Quick check
How does lecithin make melted chocolate flow better?
Check your answer
It coats the sugar and cocoa particles so they slide past each other in the cocoa butter, lowering the viscosity so the chocolate flows with less fat.
1.6 Chocolate products beyond the bar
Not all chocolate is eaten as a bar. Drinking chocolate is cocoa powder mixed with sugar, made to stir into hot milk or water: its cocoa is often Dutched, so it is dark, mild, and mixes easily. Baking chocolate is a plain, often unsweetened or dark chocolate made to melt into cakes and sauces, where its cocoa share decides the flavour and its fat decides the texture. Chocolate spreads are chocolate mixed with nut paste and oil into a soft paste that spreads at room temperature, and chocolate coatings for biscuits and wafers are made to flow thin and set fast, so they need a low viscosity and a good temper.
Each of these uses the same ingredients in a different balance. A coating needs more cocoa butter or lecithin to flow thin, while a baking chocolate needs less, so it sets firm in the cake. A spread needs a fat that stays soft at room temperature, while a bar needs a fat that stays firm. The maker's skill is not in learning new ingredients for each product, but in rebalancing the same few: cocoa solids for flavour, cocoa butter for flow and set, sugar for sweetness, and milk for softness.
🤔 Pause and think: a chocolate coating for a biscuit is too thick and sets dull. Which ingredient would you change first, and which would you change last?
Quick check
Why does a chocolate coating need a lower viscosity than a bar?
Check your answer
Because it must flow thin over the biscuit and set fast, while a bar only needs to fill a mould and set firm.
1.7 Worked example: three chocolate recipes, side by side
Chocolate recipes are percentages too, and the percentages explain the taste. The three recipes below are teaching recipes in round numbers, showing how the same ingredients in different shares make three different chocolates.
Dark chocolate, 70 percent cocoa
Cocoa mass 55 percent, cocoa butter 15 percent, sugar 29.5 percent, lecithin 0.5 percent. Cocoa solids total 70 percent. Taste: bitter, firm snap, slow melt.
Milk chocolate
Cocoa mass 20 percent, cocoa butter 15 percent, milk powder 20 percent, sugar 44.5 percent, lecithin 0.5 percent. Cocoa solids total 35 percent. Taste: sweet, soft, milky, melts fast.
White chocolate
Cocoa butter 30 percent, milk powder 25 percent, sugar 44.5 percent, lecithin 0.5 percent. Cocoa solids: none. Taste: sweet, creamy, no bitterness, melts fastest.
Read the panel as a maker would. Dark chocolate gets its bite from cocoa mass, which carries the bitter flavour compounds and the cocoa solids. Milk chocolate trades cocoa mass for milk powder and sugar, so it is sweeter and softer: milk fat softens the cocoa butter and the bar melts sooner in the mouth. White chocolate has no cocoa mass at all, so it has no chocolate bitterness: its flavour is milk, sugar, and vanilla, and its structure is cocoa butter alone. Lecithin sits at 0.5 percent in all three: at that dose it thins the chocolate so it flows in the mould, and more would not thin it further but would add flavour of its own.
Now do the batch maths. A 100 kg batch of the dark recipe needs 55 kg of cocoa mass, 15 kg of cocoa butter, 29.5 kg of sugar, and 0.5 kg of lecithin. If cocoa butter costs more than sugar, the dark bar costs more to make than the milk bar per kilogram, even before the milk powder is counted: the recipe is also a cost sheet. A student who can write the recipe as percentages can cost it, scale it to any batch size, and predict what a change will do to taste, snap, and melt.
🤔 Pause and think: a maker adds 10 percent more milk powder to the milk chocolate and cuts sugar by the same amount. What happens to sweetness, softness, and cost?
Quick check
In the worked dark chocolate recipe, how much cocoa mass and sugar go into a 100 kg batch?
Check your answer
55 kg of cocoa mass and 29.5 kg of sugar, with 15 kg of cocoa butter and 0.5 kg of lecithin.
1.8 Cocoa butter maths: where the fat in a bar comes from
A dark chocolate bar's fat comes from two places: the cocoa mass and the added cocoa butter. Cocoa mass is about half fat, so the worked dark recipe with 55 percent cocoa mass carries about 27.5 percent fat from the mass alone. Add 15 percent cocoa butter and the bar holds about 42.5 percent fat in total. That fat is what melts in the mouth and carries the flavour: a bar with less fat feels dry and hard, a bar with more fat feels soft and melts fast. Milk chocolate adds milk fat on top: 20 percent milk powder carries a few percent of milk fat, which softens the cocoa butter further and is why a milk bar melts sooner than a dark bar of the same cocoa share. A student who can add up the fat sources can predict the melt before tasting the bar, and can see why cocoa butter, the most costly ingredient, is never added carelessly.
🤔 Pause and think: the worked dark recipe has 55 percent cocoa mass and 15 percent cocoa butter. If cocoa mass is about half fat, about how much fat does the bar hold in total?
Quick check
Why does a milk chocolate bar melt sooner than a dark bar?
Check your answer
Because milk fat from the milk powder softens the cocoa butter, so the bar melts at a lower temperature and sooner in the mouth.
1.9 Check yourself: quick self-check
- What are the three main chocolate types, and what is in each?
Check your answer
Dark: cocoa liquor, cocoa butter, sugar, minimum 35% cocoa solids. Milk: the same plus milk solids, about 25-35% cocoa solids. White: cocoa butter, sugar, milk solids, no cocoa solids.
- How long are Forastero cocoa beans usually fermented?
Check your answer
Usually 5-6 days.
- What is cocoa butter's share of the bean cotyledon?
Check your answer
About 53-58%.
- At what temperature does Form V cocoa butter melt?
Check your answer
At 34-35 °C.
- Why does white chocolate have no bitterness?
Check your answer
Because it has no cocoa mass: its flavour is milk, sugar, and vanilla, with cocoa butter as its only cocoa ingredient.
- Lecithin is 0.5 percent in all three recipes. What does it do, and why not add more?
Check your answer
It thins the chocolate so it flows in the mould. More would not thin it further and would add flavour of its own.
- The worked dark recipe has 55 percent cocoa mass (about half fat) and 15 percent cocoa butter. About how much fat is in the bar in total?
Check your answer
About 42.5 percent: about 27.5 percent from the cocoa mass plus 15 percent added cocoa butter.
Try it: Taste a dark, a milk, and a white chocolate side by side. For each one write down snap, sweetness, bitterness, and melt speed. Then read the ingredient lists and match each observation to an ingredient: cocoa solids for bitterness, milk for softness, cocoa butter for melt.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Chocolate is made from cocoa liquor, cocoa butter, sugar, and, for milk and white chocolate, milk solids.
- Dark chocolate carries a minimum of 35% total cocoa solids; milk chocolate about 25-35%; white chocolate has no cocoa solids.
- The bean is fermented for 5-6 days for Forastero, dried, roasted, winnowed, and ground into liquor.
- Cocoa butter is about 53-58% of the cotyledon and melts at 34-35 °C in Form V, giving snap and melt.
- Lecithin coats particles and lowers viscosity, so chocolate flows with less cocoa butter; the dose is small, about 0.3-0.5%.
Theobromine, at about 2-3% of the bean, gives chocolate its bitter note.
Chocolate recipes are percentages: the worked dark recipe is 55 percent cocoa mass, 15 percent cocoa butter, 29.5 percent sugar, and 0.5 percent lecithin.
Milk powder and sugar trade against cocoa mass: more of them means sweeter, softer chocolate that melts faster.
A bar's fat adds up from its sources: the worked dark recipe holds about 42.5 percent fat, about 27.5 percent from cocoa mass and 15 percent added cocoa butter.
- Milk fat softens cocoa butter, so milk chocolate melts sooner than dark chocolate.
Glossary
Cocoa liquor
Ground roasted cocoa nib, carrying cocoa solids and cocoa butter together. Food tech example: cocoa liquor is the base of dark chocolate.
Cocoa butter
The fat pressed out of cocoa liquor, about 53-58% of the bean cotyledon. Food tech example: cocoa butter gives a chocolate bar its snap and melt.
Cocoa powder
The solid left after cocoa butter is pressed out of liquor, carrying about 12% fat in the common form. Food tech example: cocoa powder for drinking chocolate.
Cotyledon
The inner part of the cocoa bean, inside the shell. Food tech example: the nib is the cotyledon of the cocoa bean.
Fermentation (cocoa)
The 5-6 day heating of cocoa beans by yeasts and bacteria that starts chocolate flavour. Food tech example: fermenting Forastero beans in boxes.
Theobromine
A bitter compound in cocoa, about 2-3% of the bean. Food tech example: the bitter note in dark chocolate comes from theobromine.
Form V
The best crystal form of cocoa butter, melting at 34-35 °C, giving snap, gloss, and shelf life. Food tech example: well-tempered chocolate is in Form V.
Viscosity
How thick a liquid is and how it resists flowing. Food tech example: lecithin lowers the viscosity of melted chocolate.
Cocoa solids
The cocoa mass plus cocoa butter share of a chocolate, shown as a percentage. Food tech example: the worked dark recipe totals 70 percent cocoa solids.
Milk powder in chocolate
Dried milk that adds milk flavour and milk fat, softening the bar and speeding the melt. Food tech example: 20 percent milk powder in the worked milk chocolate recipe.
Cocoa butter share
The share of a chocolate's weight that is cocoa butter, from the cocoa mass and from added butter together. Food tech example: about 42.5 percent fat in the worked dark recipe.
References
- Afoakwa, Emmanuel Ohene. Chocolate Science and Technology. Wiley-Blackwell, 2010.
- Beckett, Stephen T. The Science of Chocolate. 2nd ed. Royal Society of Chemistry, 2008.
- Mohos, Ferenc A. Confectionery and Chocolate Engineering: Principles and Applications. 2nd ed. Wiley-Blackwell, 2017.
Unit 2: Manufacturing Technology of Different Types of Chocolates
Note
Unit 2: Manufacturing Technology of Different Types of Chocolates
Melted chocolate poured into a mould can set dull, soft, and streaked, or it can set glossy, snappy, and clean. The recipe is the same. The difference is tempering: four temperature steps that decide which crystal form the cocoa butter takes. This unit is the heart of chocolate making.
2.1 The line in outline
Chocolate making has six stages: mixing, refining, conching, tempering, moulding, and cooling. Each stage changes the chocolate in a way the next stage depends on, so the order matters and a fault at one stage shows up later as a fault in the bar.
The six stages of chocolate making
Cocoa liquor + cocoa butter + sugar + milk powder
↓
1. Mix
Blend into a coarse paste
↓
2. Refine
Grind fine: smooth, not gritty
↓
3. Conche
Stir warm for hours: flavour, flow
↓
4. Temper
Four steps: make Form V crystals
↓
5. Mould
Fill moulds, vibrate out air
↓
6. Cool
Set firm, release from mould, pack
Figure 2.1: The six stages of chocolate making. Drawn from Afoakwa, Chocolate Science and Technology, Chapters 7 and 12, and Beckett, The Science of Chocolate.
🤔 Pause and think: a bar is gritty on the tongue. Which stage failed, and why can no later stage fix it?
Quick check
Name the six stages of chocolate making in order.
Check your answer
Mixing, refining, conching, tempering, moulding, and cooling.
2.2 Mixing and refining: making it smooth
Mixing blends the ingredients into a coarse, dry paste. Refining then grinds that paste between steel rollers until the particles are small enough to feel smooth. The tongue feels particles larger than about 30 micrometres as grit, so refining aims well below that. The rollers are set tighter in stages, and the paste passes through them as a thin film.
Refining also spreads the cocoa butter over the new particle surfaces, so the chocolate starts to flow. A chocolate that is under-refined feels gritty and tastes harsh, because the flavour is locked inside large particles. A chocolate that is over-refined can feel pasty and lose its snap, so the maker refines to a target, not to the smallest possible size.
Quick check
Why must chocolate particles be ground below about 30 micrometres?
Check your answer
Because the tongue feels particles larger than about 30 micrometres as grit.
2.3 Conching: flavour and flow
Conching is long, warm stirring in a conche, a machine that kneads and shears the chocolate for hours. It does three things. First, it drives off unwanted volatile acids and moisture, softening harsh and sour notes. Second, it coats every particle evenly with cocoa butter and lecithin, so the chocolate flows smoothly. Third, it develops flavour: the warm, moving mass lets flavour compounds mix and mellow.
Conching time and temperature differ by type: dark chocolate is conched longer and warmer than milk chocolate, because its flavour needs more mellowing, while milk chocolate must not be heated so far that its milk flavour turns cooked. The maker tastes the chocolate during conching and stops when the flavour is right, not by the clock alone.
Quick check
Name three things conching does to chocolate.
Check your answer
It drives off unwanted volatile acids and moisture, coats particles evenly with cocoa butter and lecithin so the chocolate flows, and develops and mellows flavour.
2.4 Tempering: Afoakwa's four steps
Tempering is the controlled crystallisation of cocoa butter, and it is the step that decides whether the bar is glossy and snappy or dull and soft. Cocoa butter can crystallise in six forms, Forms I to VI. Only Form V, which melts at 34-35 °C, gives the right snap, gloss, contraction from the mould, and shelf life. The other forms melt too low, feel soft or waxy, or turn into bloom in storage.
Afoakwa describes tempering in four steps:
- Melting: heat the chocolate to 50 °C, so all cocoa butter crystals melt and the chocolate is fully liquid.
- Cooling to the point of crystallisation: cool to 32 °C, where crystals begin to form.
- Crystallisation: cool further to 27 °C, where crystals grow, including both stable and unstable forms.
- Conversion of unstable crystals: warm back to 29-31 °C, which melts the unstable, low-melting crystals and leaves only the stable Form V crystals as seeds.
The tempered chocolate is then moulded at once, while the Form V seeds are there to guide the rest of the butter to crystallise in Form V as it cools.
Tempering in four steps
50 °C: MELT
All cocoa butter crystals melt
↓
32 °C: COOL to crystallisation point
Crystals begin to form
↓
27 °C: CRYSTALLISE
Stable and unstable crystals grow
↓
29-31 °C: WARM BACK
Unstable crystals melt away, only Form V seeds remain
↓
MOULD AT ONCE
Form V guides setting
Figure 2.2: Tempering in four steps, after Afoakwa, Chocolate Science and Technology, Chapter 7. Drawn from the tempering sequence described in that chapter.
🤔 Pause and think: a maker skips step 4 and moulds at 27 °C. The bar sets, but what will it look like after a week on the shelf, and why?
Quick check
What are Afoakwa's four tempering steps, with temperatures?
Check your answer
1. Melt at 50 °C. 2. Cool to 32 °C, the point of crystallisation. 3. Crystallise at 27 °C. 4. Warm back to 29-31 °C to melt unstable crystals and leave only Form V seeds.
2.5 Moulding, cooling, and the types compared
Moulding fills moulds with tempered chocolate, vibrates them to shake out air bubbles, and, for filled bars, adds the centre and a chocolate back. Cooling then sets the bar in a cooling tunnel with cool, dry air. Good cooling is slow enough to let Form V crystals grow, and dry enough that no moisture condenses on the chocolate: condensed water causes sugar bloom, covered in Unit 5.
The types differ in the line, not only in the recipe. Dark chocolate is tempered and moulded as above, with the longest conche. Milk chocolate is conched cooler and shorter, and its tempering temperatures are a little lower, because milk fat softens the cocoa butter. White chocolate has no cocoa solids, so it is conched gently and tempered carefully: its pale colour shows any scorch or bloom at once. Filled chocolates need a centre that is cool and dry before enrobing, or the chocolate will crack and the centre will leak.
Quick check
Why must cooling air be dry as well as cool?
Check your answer
Because moisture condensing on the chocolate dissolves sugar on the surface and causes sugar bloom when it dries.
2.6 Practical note: preparation of milk chocolate and dark chocolate
The syllabus lists preparation of milk chocolate and dark chocolate as a practical. In a small batch, melt dark chocolate to 50 °C, cool it to 32 °C while stirring, continue to 27 °C, warm it back to 29-31 °C, and mould it at once. Do the same for milk chocolate, watching that it thickens sooner and sets softer. Compare the two bars after cooling: snap, gloss, and melt in the mouth. Then temper a second dark batch badly on purpose, by moulding at 27 °C without the warm-back step, and store both bars for a week: the badly tempered bar will bloom and soften, and the comparison will teach tempering better than any lecture.
Quick check
In the practical, what does the badly tempered comparison bar prove?
Check your answer
That skipping the warm-back step leaves unstable crystals, so the bar blooms and softens in storage while the well-tempered bar stays glossy and snappy.
2.7 Filled chocolates and enrobed centres: shells, centres, and sealing
A filled chocolate is a chocolate shell with a centre inside, and its making is a small craft inside the factory. The shell is made first: tempered chocolate is deposited into a mould, the mould is turned over so the excess runs out, and a thin shell is left behind to set. The centre, fondant, caramel, ganache, nut paste, or fruit, is then deposited into the shell while the shell is firm but still cool, and a back of tempered chocolate seals it in.
The centre must be right in two ways. It must be cool and dry enough not to melt the shell or leak water into it, because water in chocolate causes sugar bloom and a soft, spoiled shell. And it must be firm enough to hold its shape, but soft enough to eat: a centre that is too liquid will leak, and one that is too firm will feel like a stone in the mouth. Ganache, a mix of chocolate and cream, is the classic test: too much cream and it is too soft and spoils fast, too little and it sets hard.
Enrobing is the other route: centres travel on a wire belt through a curtain of tempered chocolate, are shaken to even the coat, and set in a cooling tunnel. The coat must be even, with no bare spots and no thick foot at the base, and the centre must be at room temperature, or the chocolate will crack as it sets.
🤔 Pause and think: a filled chocolate leaks its caramel centre after a week. Was the fault in the shell, the centre, or the seal? How would you tell?
Quick check
Why must a filling be cool and dry before it is sealed into a chocolate shell?
Check your answer
Because a warm or wet centre melts the shell or leaks water into it, causing sugar bloom and a soft, spoiled shell.
2.8 Worked example: particle size, conching, and the temper curve
Three numbers decide a chocolate bar: particle size, conching time, and the temper curve. Each one can be checked, and each one has a fault when it is wrong.
Particle size. Refining grinds the chocolate from gritty to smooth. A particle near 100 microns feels gritty on the tongue. A particle near 20 microns feels smooth: the tongue cannot pick out single particles at that size. The refiner must take the whole mass below about 30 microns, not only the average: a few large particles left behind will still feel gritty in an otherwise smooth bar. The test is simple: rub a little chocolate between thumb and finger, or taste it and ask whether any grit shows. A maker who refines to an average of 20 microns but leaves a tail of 100-micron particles has refined the average and failed the bar.
Conching. Conching stirs the warm chocolate for hours, sometimes 12 hours or more for a fine chocolate. It does three jobs: it drives off volatile acids that taste harsh, it coats every particle with cocoa butter so the mass flows, and it builds the flavour. A short conche leaves the chocolate harsh and thick; a long conche leaves it mellow and flowing. The worked comparison is 4 hours against 12 hours: the 4-hour bar tastes sharper and pours thicker, the 12-hour bar tastes rounder and flows thinner into the mould. Time is an ingredient here, and the conche is where it is added.
The temper curve. The practical in section 2.6 gives the curve for dark chocolate: melt to 50 °C, cool to 32 °C while stirring, continue to 27 °C, warm back to 29-31 °C, and mould at once. Each step has a job. Melting to 50 °C clears every crystal. Cooling to 27 °C grows the right crystals, Form V, along with some wrong ones. Warming back to 29-31 °C melts the wrong crystals and leaves only Form V. Moulding at once sets the bar in Form V, giving snap and gloss. Milk chocolate tempers a little cooler, because milk fat softens the cocoa butter: the warm-back step sits about 2 °C lower. A bar moulded at 27 °C without the warm-back step, the deliberate fault in the practical, will bloom within a week: the wrong crystals grow, fat rises, and the surface turns white.
🤔 Pause and think: a bar tastes smooth but blooms in a week. Is the fault in refining, conching, or tempering? What one observation rules out each of the other two?
Quick check
Why is the chocolate warmed back to 29-31 °C after cooling to 27 °C?
Check your answer
To melt the wrong crystal forms and leave only Form V, which gives snap and gloss.
2.9 Moulding yield: counting bars, not kilograms
A chocolate maker counts bars, not only kilograms. A 100 kg batch of tempered chocolate, moulded into 50 g bars, should give 2,000 bars. If the line packs 1,960 bars, 40 bars are missing: 2 kg of chocolate lost as drips, trimmings, and bars broken in demoulding. That is a 2 percent loss, and the maker should know where it went. Drips at the depositor mean the chocolate is too thin or the moulds are overfilled. Bars breaking in demoulding mean the moulds are too cold, the chocolate is under-tempered, or the bars were knocked out too soon. A yield below 98 percent is a signal, not a cost of doing business: the loss is chocolate that was bought, refined, conched, and tempered, then thrown away. The count at the end of the shift, bars packed against kilograms tempered, is the number that finds it.
🤔 Pause and think: 100 kg of chocolate should give 2,000 bars of 50 g, but only 1,960 are packed. What is the loss in percent, and what would drips at the depositor point to?
Quick check
A 100 kg batch moulded into 50 g bars should give how many bars, and what does 1,960 packed mean?
Check your answer
2,000 bars. Packing 1,960 means 40 bars, or 2 percent, were lost as drips, trimmings, or breakage.
2.10 Check yourself: quick self-check
- What are the six stages of chocolate making?
Check your answer
Mixing, refining, conching, tempering, moulding, and cooling.
- What temperature does Form V cocoa butter melt at?
Check your answer
At 34-35 °C.
- What are the four tempering steps and their temperatures?
Check your answer
Melt at 50 °C; cool to 32 °C; crystallise at 27 °C; warm back to 29-31 °C to leave only Form V seeds.
- Why is chocolate refined below about 30 micrometres?
Check your answer
Because the tongue feels larger particles as grit.
- A chocolate averages 20 microns but still feels gritty. What went wrong in refining?
Check your answer
A tail of large particles near 100 microns was left behind: the whole mass must go below about 30 microns, not only the average.
- A 4-hour conche and a 12-hour conche are compared. Which bar tastes sharper, and why?
Check your answer
The 4-hour bar: less time to drive off harsh volatile acids and to coat particles with cocoa butter.
- Bars break when they are knocked out of the moulds. Name two possible causes.
Check your answer
Any two, for example: moulds too cold, chocolate under-tempered, or bars knocked out too soon.
Try it: Melt a small piece of chocolate in a bowl over warm water, let it cool while stirring, and pour it onto a cold plate. Compare its gloss and snap with the original bar. The difference is tempering: the original was tempered, your poured piece was not.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Chocolate making has six stages: mix, refine, conche, temper, mould, cool.
- Refining grinds particles below about 30 micrometres so the chocolate feels smooth.
- Conching drives off harsh volatiles, coats particles with butter, and mellows flavour.
- Tempering follows four steps: melt at 50 °C, cool to 32 °C, crystallise at 27 °C, warm back to 29-31 °C, leaving only Form V seeds.
- Form V melts at 34-35 °C and gives snap, gloss, mould release, and shelf life.
- Cooling must be cool and dry, or sugar bloom follows.
Dark, milk, white, and filled chocolates differ in conching, tempering, and handling, not only in recipe.
Smooth chocolate needs every particle below about 30 microns: an average of 20 microns still feels gritty if a tail of 100-micron particles remains.
The temper curve clears all crystals at 50 °C, grows Form V by cooling to 27 °C, and melts the wrong forms by warming back to 29-31 °C.
Yield is counted in bars: 100 kg into 50 g bars should give 2,000 bars, and 1,960 packed is a 2 percent loss to find and fix.
Glossary
Refining
Grinding chocolate paste between steel rollers until particles are small enough to feel smooth. Food tech example: refining chocolate below about 30 micrometres.
Conching
Long, warm stirring of chocolate that drives off harsh volatiles, coats particles with butter, and mellows flavour. Food tech example: conching dark chocolate for hours.
Tempering
Controlled crystallisation of cocoa butter in four temperature steps, to make Form V crystals. Food tech example: melting at 50 °C, cooling to 27 °C, warming back to 29-31 °C.
Form V
The best crystal form of cocoa butter, melting at 34-35 °C, giving snap, gloss, and shelf life. Food tech example: well-tempered chocolate is in Form V.
Polymorphism
When one fat can crystallise in several different forms, each with its own melting point. Food tech example: cocoa butter has six polymorphic forms, I to VI.
Moulding
Filling moulds with tempered chocolate and vibrating out air bubbles. Food tech example: moulding a chocolate bar.
Cooling tunnel
A tunnel with cool, dry air that sets moulded chocolate. Food tech example: bars passing through a cooling tunnel after moulding.
Enrobing
Covering a centre with chocolate by passing it through a curtain of melted chocolate. Food tech example: enrobing a fondant centre.
Particle size
The size of solid particles in chocolate, felt on the tongue: near 100 microns feels gritty, near 20 microns feels smooth. Food tech example: refining a chocolate mass below about 30 microns.
Form V
The cocoa butter crystal form that gives a chocolate bar its snap, gloss, and clean melt. Food tech example: tempering to Form V by cooling to 27 °C and warming back to 29-31 °C.
Moulding yield
Bars packed against bars that should have been made from the chocolate tempered. Food tech example: 1,960 bars packed from a 100 kg batch that should give 2,000 is a 2 percent loss.
References
- Afoakwa, Emmanuel Ohene. Chocolate Science and Technology. Wiley-Blackwell, 2010.
- Beckett, Stephen T. The Science of Chocolate. 2nd ed. Royal Society of Chemistry, 2008.
- Mohos, Ferenc A. Confectionery and Chocolate Engineering: Principles and Applications. 2nd ed. Wiley-Blackwell, 2017.
Unit 3: Machinery Required for Chocolate Manufacturing
Note
Unit 3: Machinery Required for Chocolate Manufacturing
A conche kneads for hours, a refiner grinds to dust, a tempering machine holds four temperatures at once, and a moulding line turns liquid into bars by the thousand. What does each machine control, and what happens when it is set wrong? This unit walks the chocolate line machine by machine.
3.1 The line as a set of machines
A chocolate factory is a line of machines matched to the six stages of Unit 2. As in sugar confectionery, the machines must match each other in speed: a refiner faster than the conche will leave paste waiting, and waiting paste cools, thickens, and picks up moisture. The machines are built from food-grade stainless steel, with smooth, cleanable surfaces, and they are heated by steam or hot water and cooled by cold water, so temperatures can be held steady to within a degree.
🤔 Pause and think: a factory's bars are glossy on Monday and dull on Friday, with no recipe change. Which machine's setting would you check first, and why?
Quick check
Why must chocolate machines hold temperature to within about a degree?
Check your answer
Because tempering depends on exact temperatures, and a degree off can leave the wrong crystal form in the cocoa butter.
3.2 Mixing, refining, and conching machines
- Mixer: a heated, jacketed mixer with strong blades that blends cocoa liquor, cocoa butter, sugar, and milk powder into a coarse, crumbly paste. It must mix evenly: pockets of unmixed sugar make gritty, sweet spots in the bar.
- Refiner (five-roll refiner): a set of five steel rollers turning at different speeds, with gaps set tighter at each roller. The paste is fed at the bottom and comes off the top roller as a thin film of fine chocolate. The roller gaps set the particle size, and the operator checks it by feeling the chocolate and by measuring it.
- Conche: a long, heated trough with heavy rollers or blades that knead and shear the chocolate for hours. The conche drives off moisture and harsh volatiles, coats particles with butter, and develops flavour. A longitudinal conche moves the chocolate back and forth; a rotary conche stirs it in a round tank.
- Holding and storage tanks: jacketed, stirred tanks that keep liquid chocolate at a steady temperature, usually around 50 °C, before tempering, so it stays fully melted and ready.
From mixer to holding tank
Mixer (heated, stirred)
Ingredients, coarse paste
↓
Five-roll refiner
Rollers tighter at each stage, paste to fine film, smooth particles
↓
Conche (heated, kneaded for hours)
Flavour mellows, particles coated, flow improves
↓
Holding tank (about 50 °C, stirred)
Liquid chocolate ready for tempering
Figure 3.1: From mixer to refiner to conche to holding tank. Drawn from Afoakwa, Chocolate Science and Technology, Chapters 7 and 12.
Quick check
What does a five-roll refiner do, and what sets the particle size?
Check your answer
It grinds chocolate paste between five steel rollers turning at different speeds; the gaps between the rollers, set tighter at each stage, set the particle size.
3.3 Tempering machines
- Batch tempering machine: a jacketed tank with a stirrer and a cooling and heating jacket, run through the four steps by hand or by program: melt at 50 °C, cool to 32 °C, crystallise at 27 °C, warm back to 29-31 °C. It suits small makers and filled work.
- Continuous tempering machine: chocolate is pumped through zones held at the four temperatures in sequence, so tempered chocolate comes out without stopping. It suits large moulding lines.
- Temper meter: a small instrument that cools a sample of the chocolate and measures how it sets, telling the operator whether the temper is right before a whole line of bars is moulded. It is the cheapest insurance on the line: a wrong temper found by the meter costs a sample, while a wrong temper found in the warehouse costs a batch.
Quick check
What does a temper meter do, and why is it cheap insurance?
Check your answer
It cools a sample and measures how it sets, telling the operator whether the temper is right before moulding. A wrong temper found by the meter costs a sample; found in the warehouse it costs a batch.
3.4 Moulding, enrobing, and cooling machines
- Moulding line: a line that fills moulds with tempered chocolate, vibrates them to shake out air bubbles, scrapes off the excess, and, for filled bars, deposits the centre and backs it with chocolate.
- Enrober: a machine that passes centres on a wire belt through a curtain of tempered chocolate, then through a shaking section that evens the coat, and a cooling tunnel that sets it. The chocolate must be tempered, or the coat will bloom.
- Cooling tunnel: a tunnel with cool, dry air, usually in zones that get cooler along the tunnel, so the chocolate sets in Form V without condensation. If the air is damp, water condenses on the chocolate and sugar bloom follows.
- Demoulding and packing machines: moulds are turned over and tapped or flexed to release the bars, which are then wrapped in foil and paper or flow-packed, and boxed. Bars that do not release cleanly were under-tempered or cooled too fast.
🤔 Pause and think: bars stick in their moulds and come out with a dull back. Is the fault in tempering or in cooling? What one test would tell you?
Quick check
Why does a cooling tunnel use zones that get cooler along the tunnel?
Check your answer
So the chocolate sets gradually in Form V without thermal shock or condensation, which would cause bloom.
3.5 Cocoa processing machines: before the chocolate line
Before mixing begins, the bean is processed by its own machines.
- Cleaner and destoner: removes dirt, stones, and broken beans from the dried beans.
- Roaster: roasts the beans evenly, developing flavour and colour. Roasting is done by hot air or by drum, and time and temperature are set for the bean type.
- Winnower: cracks the roasted beans and separates the shell from the nib by air, leaving clean nibs for grinding.
- Cocoa press: presses ground liquor under high pressure to squeeze out cocoa butter, leaving cocoa cake that is ground into cocoa powder.
- Alkaliser: treats nibs or liquor with an alkali solution, the Dutch process, to raise the pH and darken the colour, in a heated, stirred vessel.
Quick check
What does a winnower do?
Check your answer
It cracks roasted beans and separates the shell from the nib by air, leaving clean nibs for grinding.
3.6 Care of the line: cleaning, calibration, and balance
Chocolate machines need the same care as sugar machines, with one extra demand: temperature calibration. A thermometer that reads one degree high will temper every batch wrong, so thermometers and temper meters are checked against a standard regularly. Rollers are checked for wear, because worn rollers cannot grind fine enough. Conches are cleaned between types, because dark chocolate left in a conche will flavour the next milk batch. And the line is balanced, so tempered chocolate is moulded at once, never left to sit and lose its temper.
The whole chocolate line, from bean to boxed bar
Cocoa line
Cleaner, roaster, winnower, press
↓
Chocolate line
Mixer, refiner, conche, tempering, moulding / enrobing, cooling tunnel, demould, wrap, box
Figure 3.2: The whole chocolate line, from bean to boxed bar. Drawn from Afoakwa, Chocolate Science and Technology, Chapters 5 and 7.
Quick check
Why must a thermometer on a tempering machine be checked against a standard?
Check your answer
Because a thermometer reading one degree high will temper every batch wrong, and tempering depends on exact temperatures.
3.7 Automation and control: sensors on the line
A modern chocolate line is watched by sensors as much as by people. Temperature sensors hold the conche, the tempering machine, and the cooling tunnel to their set points. A temper meter checks the temper of a sample before moulding. A vision camera above the line checks the colour and shape of bars and rejects cracked, bloomed, or misshapen ones. A checkweigher weighs every pack, and a metal detector guards the end of the line.
The point of automation is not to replace the maker's judgment but to catch drift before it becomes a fault. A cooling tunnel that slowly warms by a degree will not be noticed by hand, but a sensor will see it, and a degree of drift in tempering is the difference between a glossy bar and a bloomed one. The operator's job changes with automation: less turning of valves by hand, and more reading of trends, tasting of samples, and deciding when to stop the line.
The limit of automation is flavour. No sensor yet tastes a chocolate the way a trained panel does, and no camera judges whether a bar tastes harsh or mellow. The line therefore keeps its human checks: a taste at the conche, a snap test at the moulding line, and a look at the finished bar before it is boxed.
🤔 Pause and think: a sensor says the temper is right, but the bars come out dull. What would you check next, and why does the sensor not settle the question?
Quick check
What is the point of automation on a chocolate line?
Check your answer
To catch drift before it becomes a fault: a sensor sees a degree of warming in a cooling tunnel that a hand would miss.
3.8 Worked example: balancing a chocolate line
A chocolate line is balanced the same way as the sugar line in Unit 10 of Confectionery and Snack Foods: the slowest machine sets the speed. A small line has these capacities: mixer 300 kg per hour, refiner 150 kg per hour, conche 500 kg per batch over 12 hours, tempering machine 180 kg per hour, moulding line 160 kg per hour, cooling tunnel 200 kg per hour. The conche needs converting before it can be compared: 500 kg over 12 hours is about 42 kg per hour. The conche is the bottleneck by a wide margin, and the line can only make about 42 kg per hour on average, however fast the mixer and the tunnel are. The fix is a second conche, or a larger one: two conches give about 84 kg per hour, and the refiner at 150 kg per hour then becomes the next limit to watch.
The second balance is time, not speed. Tempered chocolate must be moulded at once: if the moulding line stops for 20 minutes, the tempered chocolate in the tempering machine starts to thicken and lose its temper. The operator's rule is to stop tempering before stopping moulding, so no tempered chocolate waits. The same rule runs backwards at the start of a shift: start the conche first, because it needs hours, then the refiner, then tempering only when the moulds are ready. A line started in the wrong order waits for the conche while the tempering machine idles.
Cleaning is part of the balance too. A conche that held dark chocolate must be cleaned before milk chocolate goes in, or the milk batch will taste of dark chocolate and carry its colour. The cleaning time is line time: a maker who plans three flavours in one day must count cleaning between each one, or the day's plan will overrun by hours. The log for the line should record, for each shift, the kilograms made, the kilograms lost to cleaning and changeover, and the minutes the line waited for the conche: those three numbers are the line's real capacity.
🤔 Pause and think: a conche holds 500 kg and runs 12 hours. What is its rate per hour, and why does that number, not the 500 kg, decide the line speed?
Quick check
A conche holds 500 kg per 12-hour batch. What is its rate per hour, and what does that make it on the worked line?
Check your answer
About 42 kg per hour, which makes it the bottleneck of the whole line.
3.9 Starting the line in the right order
A chocolate line started in the wrong order wastes a shift. The right order follows the slowest step: start the conche first, because it needs hours. While it runs, start the refiner and check its particle size. Start tempering only when the moulds are ready and the cooling tunnel is at temperature, because tempered chocolate must be moulded at once. The wrong order is to temper first and then discover the moulds are cold: the tempered chocolate thickens while the moulds warm, and the first bars bloom. The start-up checklist is short: conche running, refiner at size, tunnel at temperature, moulds warm and dry, tempering last. A line that starts in that order makes good bars from the first mould; a line that starts in any other order makes scrap first and good bars later.
🤔 Pause and think: the moulds are cold and the tempering machine is already running. What should the operator do, and what will happen to the first bars if the line runs anyway?
Quick check
Why is tempering started last when a chocolate line starts up?
Check your answer
Because tempered chocolate must be moulded at once: if the moulds or the cooling tunnel are not ready, it thickens and loses its temper while waiting.
3.10 Check yourself: quick self-check
- Name the machines for mixing, refining, and conching.
Check your answer
Mixer, five-roll refiner, and conche, followed by a holding tank.
- What are the two kinds of tempering machine?
Check your answer
Batch tempering machine, a jacketed stirred tank run through the four steps, and continuous tempering machine, where chocolate is pumped through zones held at the four temperatures.
- What does an enrober do?
Check your answer
It passes centres on a wire belt through a curtain of tempered chocolate, evens the coat by shaking, and sets it in a cooling tunnel.
- What does a cocoa press produce?
Check your answer
Cocoa butter squeezed out under pressure, and cocoa cake that is ground into cocoa powder.
- The moulding line stops for 20 minutes. Why must tempering stop first?
Check your answer
Because tempered chocolate left waiting thickens and loses its temper, so it must be moulded at once.
- Why must a conche be cleaned between dark and milk chocolate?
Check your answer
Because dark chocolate left in the conche will flavour and colour the next milk batch.
- Why is the conche started first at the start of a shift?
Check your answer
Because it needs hours to run, while the other machines are ready in minutes: starting it last would leave the whole line waiting.
Try it: Draw the line from Figure 3.2 on paper and write under each machine the one thing it controls: particle size for the refiner, flavour for the conche, crystal form for the tempering machine, set for the cooling tunnel. Then mark the machine whose failure would spoil the most bars, and say why.
Key ideas to carry forward
- A chocolate line is a set of machines matched in speed, built from food-grade steel, with temperature held to about a degree.
- The mixer blends, the five-roll refiner grinds to a smooth particle size, and the conche kneads for hours to mellow flavour and improve flow.
- Tempering machines run Afoakwa's four steps, batch or continuous, and a temper meter checks the temper before moulding.
- Moulding lines fill and vibrate moulds; enrobers coat centres; cooling tunnels set the chocolate in cool, dry, zoned air.
- Cocoa machines are the cleaner, roaster, winnower, cocoa press, and alkaliser.
Calibration, cleaning, and line balance are part of the product: a wrong thermometer tempers every batch wrong.
A batch machine must be converted to a rate before it can be compared: a 500 kg conche over 12 hours is about 42 kg per hour, the bottleneck of the worked line.
Tempered chocolate must be moulded at once, and the conche starts first in a shift because it needs hours.
A chocolate line starts in the order of its slowest step: conche first, refiner next, tempering last when moulds are warm and the tunnel is at temperature.
Glossary
Five-roll refiner
A set of five steel rollers with gaps set tighter at each stage, grinding chocolate paste into a fine film. Food tech example: refining chocolate below about 30 micrometres.
Conche
A heated machine that kneads and shears chocolate for hours to mellow flavour and improve flow. Food tech example: conching dark chocolate.
Temper meter
An instrument that cools a chocolate sample and measures how it sets, checking the temper. Food tech example: a temper meter reading before a moulding run.
Continuous tempering machine
A machine that pumps chocolate through zones held at the four tempering temperatures in sequence. Food tech example: tempering chocolate for a large moulding line.
Enrober
A machine that coats centres by passing them through a curtain of tempered chocolate. Food tech example: enrobing fondant centres.
Cooling tunnel
A tunnel with cool, dry air in zones that sets moulded or enrobed chocolate. Food tech example: bars setting in a cooling tunnel after moulding.
Winnower
A machine that cracks roasted cocoa beans and separates shell from nib by air. Food tech example: winnowing roasted beans into clean nibs.
Cocoa press
A press that squeezes cocoa butter out of ground cocoa liquor under high pressure. Food tech example: pressing liquor into butter and cocoa cake.
Line balance (chocolate)
Matching every machine on a chocolate line so no step waits and no tempered chocolate waits. Food tech example: a conche at 42 kg per hour limiting a line whose mixer runs at 300.
Changeover loss
Product and time lost when a line switches from one flavour or type to another, including cleaning. Food tech example: kilograms lost cleaning a conche between dark and milk chocolate.
Start-up order
The order machines are started on a line, slowest first, so no step waits and no tempered chocolate waits. Food tech example: conche first, tempering last on a chocolate line.
References
- Afoakwa, Emmanuel Ohene. Chocolate Science and Technology. Wiley-Blackwell, 2010.
- Beckett, Stephen T. The Science of Chocolate. 2nd ed. Royal Society of Chemistry, 2008.
- Mohos, Ferenc A. Confectionery and Chocolate Engineering: Principles and Applications. 2nd ed. Wiley-Blackwell, 2017.
Unit 4: Packaging Materials for Confectionery and Chocolate Wrapping and Packing, Machineries Required
Note
Unit 4: Packaging Materials for Confectionery and Chocolate Wrapping and Packing, Machineries Required
A chocolate bar leaves the cooling tunnel perfect: glossy, snappy, and clean. A week later in a warm shop it is streaked white. A hard candy leaves the line clear and dry. A week later in damp air it is sticky. In both cases the fault is not in the making: it is in the packing. This unit explains what packing must do.
4.1 What packing must do
Packing has five jobs, and a pack that fails any one of them fails the product.
- Protect: keep out moisture, oxygen, light, heat, and damage, so the product keeps its texture, flavour, and appearance.
- Contain: hold the product and its pieces together, in the right weight and count.
- Inform: carry the label: name, ingredients, weight, date, storage advice, allergen information, and maker.
- Sell: show the product, its brand, and its promise, so the buyer picks it up.
- Handle: survive transport, stacking, and shop handling without breaking, leaking, or opening.
The first job, protection, is the technical one, and it differs by product. Sugar sweets need a barrier against moisture coming in. Chocolate needs a barrier against moisture, oxygen, light, and warmth, and against picking up smells from nearby foods. Fried snacks need a barrier against oxygen and moisture, so the oil does not go stale and the crisp does not soften.
🤔 Pause and think: a chocolate bar and a bag of chips both need protection, but against different enemies. Which enemy is shared, and which is different?
Quick check
Name the five jobs of packing.
Check your answer
Protect, contain, inform, sell, and handle.
4.2 Packaging materials: what each one does
- Paper and board: cheap, printable, and easy to shape into boxes and cartons. Paper alone lets moisture and air through, so it is used as an outer pack or with a coating.
- Aluminium foil: an excellent barrier against moisture, oxygen, and light, and it folds neatly around a chocolate bar. Foil is thin, so it is often laminated to paper or film for strength.
- Plastic films: polypropylene and polyester films give a clear, strong, moisture-proof wrap. They are used as flow packs for sweets and as the inner layer of snack bags. Some films are metallised, coated with a thin layer of aluminium, to block light and oxygen as well.
- Laminates: layers of paper, foil, and film stuck together, combining the strength of one with the barrier of another. A chocolate bar wrapper is often a paper and foil laminate; a chip bag is often a metallised film laminate.
- Glass and rigid plastic: jars and tubs for sweets and spreads, giving a strong barrier and a re-usable pack, at higher cost and weight.
- Metal tins and cans: a strong barrier for toffees, biscuits, and gift packs, keeping out moisture and air for a long life.
Matching the enemy to the barrier
Moisture in
Foil, metallised film, sealed flow pack
Oxygen in
Foil, metallised film, gas-tight seal
Light in
Foil, metallised film, opaque board
Warmth
Cool storage (no pack stops heat alone)
Smells in
Foil, sealed pack (chocolate picks up odours)
Crushing
Board carton, rigid tin, good case pack
Figure 4.1: Matching the enemy to the barrier: each threat has a packing answer. Drawn from the storage and packing discussion in Mohos, Confectionery and Chocolate Engineering, Chapter 17.
Quick check
Why is chocolate often wrapped in foil, not in plain paper?
Check your answer
Because foil is an excellent barrier against moisture, oxygen, and light, and chocolate needs all three blocked, while plain paper lets moisture and air through.
4.3 Wrapping and packing machines
- Twist wrapper: wraps each sweet in a twist of waxed paper or film at high speed, straight from the cutter.
- Flow-pack machine: wraps pieces in a sealed tube of film, with a fin seal along the back and end seals, giving a moisture-proof pack for sweets, bars, and biscuits.
- Foil wrapping machine: folds foil neatly around a chocolate bar, then adds an outer paper band or sleeve.
- Cartoning machine: folds board into cartons and fills them with wrapped bars or packs.
- Case packer and palletiser: packs cartons into cases and stacks cases onto pallets for transport.
- Checkweigher and metal detector: the checkweigher rejects packs under weight, and the metal detector rejects any pack with metal in it. Both were met in Unit 11 of Confectionery and Snack Foods and belong at the end of every packing line.
- Labelling and coding machine: prints the date, batch code, and label information on the pack, so the product can be traced.
Quick check
What does a flow-pack machine make, and what seal does it use?
Check your answer
It wraps pieces in a sealed tube of film, with a fin seal along the back and end seals, giving a moisture-proof pack.
4.4 Storage after packing: the pack is not enough
A good pack slows damage, but it does not stop it. Storage conditions decide the rest. Chocolate should be stored cool, at about 15-18 °C, and dry, with a relative humidity below about 50%, away from light and from strong smells, because chocolate picks up odours easily. Sugar sweets should be stored cool and dry, so they do not pick up moisture or dry out. Fried snacks should be stored cool, dark, and dry, so the oil does not oxidise.
Temperature swings are worse than steady warmth: a bar that warms and cools again and again will bloom, as Unit 5 explains, even in a good wrapper. That is why the warehouse, the truck, and the shop shelf are part of the packing system, not separate from it.
🤔 Pause and think: a warehouse is cool at night and warm by day. Which product in this subject would suffer most from that swing, and why?
Quick check
At about what temperature and humidity should chocolate be stored?
Check your answer
Cool, at about 15-18 °C, and dry, with a relative humidity below about 50%, away from light and strong smells.
4.5 Practical note: packaging and shelf-life study of snack foods
The syllabus lists packaging and shelf-life study of snack foods as a practical, and it belongs here. Pack the same product in three different packs, for example a plain paper bag, a sealed plastic bag, and a foil-laminated bag, and store them side by side in the same place. Open one of each every week and compare crispness, smell, and appearance. The pack that keeps the product best is the one that blocks the enemy that matters most for that product: moisture for a hard candy, oxygen for a fried snack, light and warmth for chocolate. Record the week each pack fails, and the shelf life follows from the worst one.
Quick check
Why test three different packs side by side instead of one?
Check your answer
Because comparing packs under the same storage shows which barrier blocks the enemy that matters most for that product.
4.6 Using less packing: the same protection with less material
Packing protects the product, but it also costs money and material, so makers try to use less of it without losing protection. The first step is to use only the barrier that is needed: a hard candy in a dry climate needs a moisture barrier, not a heavy laminate, while a fried snack needs an oxygen barrier as well. The second step is to make the pack thinner where strength allows: a thinner film that still seals well protects as much as a thick one. The third step is to size the pack to the product: a bag with too much empty space wastes film and lets the product rattle and break.
The rule that governs all three steps is that protection comes first. A pack that uses less material but lets damp air in will spoil the product, and a spoiled product wastes far more than the packing saved. The test is the shelf-life study from Unit 5 of Confectionery and Snack Foods: if the lighter pack keeps the product for the full shelf life, it is a good pack; if it fails a week early, the saving was false.
🤔 Pause and think: a maker thins the film on a chip bag and the chips go stale a month early. Was the saving worth it? What would you measure to decide?
Quick check
What test decides whether a lighter pack is a good pack?
Check your answer
The shelf-life study: if the lighter pack keeps the product for the full shelf life, it is good; if it fails early, the saving was false.
4.7 Worked example: choosing a pack by testing it
A pack is chosen by testing, not by looking at it. A maker tests two packs for hard candy in a damp room for 4 weeks: Pack A is plain paper twist wrap, Pack B is foil-laminate flow wrap. Each week the maker weighs 10 candies from each pack and scores stickiness from 1 (dry) to 5 (stuck together). The worked results show the method: they are an example of how the test is read, not data for any real pack.
Pack A: paper twist wrap
Week 0: 10 candies weigh 50.0 g, stickiness 1. Week 2: 50.9 g, stickiness 3. Week 4: 52.1 g, stickiness 5. The candies gained 2.1 g of water, about 4 percent of their weight, and stuck together.
Pack B: foil-laminate flow wrap
Week 0: 10 candies weigh 50.0 g, stickiness 1. Week 2: 50.1 g, stickiness 1. Week 4: 50.2 g, stickiness 1. The candies gained 0.2 g of water and stayed dry and separate.
The reading is plain. Pack A lets damp air in: the candies pick up water, go sticky, and fail. Pack B keeps damp air out: the candies stay as made. The weight gain is the measurement that settles it: 2.1 g against 0.2 g in 4 weeks. A maker who only looked at the packs would have guessed the same, but the weighing proves it and gives a number to put in the specification: a good pack for hard candy in damp storage gains less than about 0.5 g per 50 g in 4 weeks. The same test works for chocolate, with a different fault to watch: instead of stickiness, the maker scores bloom and softness after a warm week, because heat, not damp, is chocolate's enemy.
The second test is the seal. Take 100 packs from the line, fill them with air, and squeeze each one under water: bubbles mean a leak. If 3 packs leak, the leak rate is 3 percent, and the cause is usually a cold sealing jaw or a fold in the film. A pack that leaks is not a pack: it is an open bag with a printed date on it. The seal test belongs in the shift log beside the weight test, because a perfect film with a bad seal protects nothing.
🤔 Pause and think: Pack A candies gained 2.1 g in 4 weeks and Pack B gained 0.2 g. What would you write in the pack specification for hard candy, and why is a number better than the words "good pack"?
Quick check
In the worked test, how much water did the candies in Pack A gain in 4 weeks, and what did that do to them?
Check your answer
2.1 g of water, about 4 percent of their weight: they went sticky and stuck together, while Pack B gained only 0.2 g and stayed dry.
4.8 Pack cost per piece: the number that decides
A pack that protects perfectly but costs too much will never be used. The cost per piece decides. A foil-laminate film costs 3 currency units per metre and wraps 20 pieces per metre, so the film costs 0.15 per piece. A paper wrap costs 1 per metre and wraps 20 pieces per metre, so it costs 0.05 per piece. The foil costs three times as much per piece, but the worked test in section 4.7 showed the paper pack lets candies gain 2.1 g of water in 4 weeks and stick together, while the foil pack lets in only 0.2 g. A maker who buys the paper pack saves 0.10 per piece and loses the product: every returned or stale pack costs far more than 0.10. The honest comparison is not film against film: it is film cost against the cost of spoiled product. For a dry candy in damp storage, the foil pack is the cheap one, because it is the one that delivers a saleable candy.
🤔 Pause and think: foil film costs 0.15 per piece and paper costs 0.05 per piece. Why is the foil pack still the cheap one for hard candy in damp storage?
Quick check
A film costs 3 per metre and wraps 20 pieces per metre. What is the film cost per piece?
Check your answer
0.15 per piece: 3 divided by 20.
4.9 Check yourself: quick self-check
- Name the five jobs of packing.
Check your answer
Protect, contain, inform, sell, and handle.
- What is a laminate, and why is it used?
Check your answer
Layers of paper, foil, and film stuck together, combining the strength of one with the barrier of another, for example a paper and foil chocolate wrapper.
- What does a metallised film add to a plain film?
Check your answer
A thin coating of aluminium that blocks light and oxygen as well as moisture.
- Why are temperature swings worse than steady warmth for chocolate?
Check your answer
Because warming and cooling again and again melts and re-forms cocoa butter crystals, causing fat bloom even in a good wrapper.
- A seal test finds 3 leaks in 100 packs. What is the leak rate, and what should the operator check?
Check your answer
3 percent. Check the sealing jaw temperature and the film for folds.
- Why does the chocolate version of the pack test score bloom and softness instead of stickiness?
Check your answer
Because heat, not damp air, is chocolate's main enemy in storage.
- Why is comparing film prices alone the wrong way to choose a pack?
Check your answer
Because the true comparison is film cost against the cost of spoiled product: a cheap pack that lets the candy go sticky loses more than it saves.
Try it: Take a chocolate bar in foil and a hard candy in a twist wrap. Leave both in a warm, damp place for a day, then compare them with fresh ones. Write down what changed in each: the candy will be sticky, the chocolate may be dull or streaked, and both changes are packing and storage stories.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Packing has five jobs: protect, contain, inform, sell, and handle.
- Sugar sweets need a moisture barrier; chocolate needs moisture, oxygen, light, and odour barriers; fried snacks need oxygen and moisture barriers.
- Foil blocks moisture, oxygen, and light; plastic films block moisture; metallised films block light and oxygen too; laminates combine strengths.
- Packing machines are the twist wrapper, flow-pack machine, foil wrapper, cartoning machine, case packer, checkweigher, metal detector, and coding machine.
- Storage matters as much as packing: chocolate at about 15-18 °C and below about 50% relative humidity, cool and dry for sweets, cool, dark, and dry for fried snacks.
Temperature swings cause bloom, and no pack alone stops heat.
A pack is chosen by weighing: in the worked test, paper wrap let candies gain 2.1 g of water in 4 weeks while foil laminate let in only 0.2 g.
A seal test of 100 packs under water finds leaks a look cannot: a perfect film with a bad seal protects nothing.
Pack cost is cost per piece: foil film at 3 per metre wrapping 20 pieces costs 0.15 per piece, against 0.05 for paper, yet foil is cheaper once spoiled product is counted.
Glossary
Laminate
Layers of paper, foil, and film stuck together to combine strength and barrier properties. Food tech example: a paper and foil laminate wrapping a chocolate bar.
Metallised film
A plastic film coated with a thin layer of aluminium to block light and oxygen. Food tech example: a metallised film bag for potato chips.
Flow pack
A sealed tube of film wrapped around a product, with a fin seal and end seals. Food tech example: a flow-packed chocolate bar.
Barrier
How well a packing material blocks moisture, oxygen, or light. Food tech example: foil has a high barrier against moisture and oxygen.
Twist wrap
A wrap twisted at both ends around a single sweet. Food tech example: a twist-wrapped toffee.
Relative humidity
How much water vapour the air holds, as a percentage of the most it could hold at that temperature. Food tech example: storing chocolate below about 50% relative humidity.
Checkweigher
A machine that weighs every pack and rejects those under weight. Food tech example: a checkweigher at the end of a packing line.
Batch code
A code printed on a pack that identifies the batch it came from, for tracing. Food tech example: a date and batch code on a chocolate bar.
Pack weight-gain test
Weighing packed food over weeks in damp storage to measure how much water the pack lets in. Food tech example: hard candy gaining 2.1 g in paper wrap against 0.2 g in foil laminate over 4 weeks.
Seal leak test
Squeezing air-filled packs under water and counting bubbles to find leaking seals. Food tech example: 3 leaks in 100 packs is a 3 percent leak rate.
Cost per piece (packing)
The packing cost for one piece, from the film price per metre divided by pieces per metre. Food tech example: film at 3 per metre wrapping 20 pieces costs 0.15 per piece.
References
- Mohos, Ferenc A. Confectionery and Chocolate Engineering: Principles and Applications. 2nd ed. Wiley-Blackwell, 2017.
- Afoakwa, Emmanuel Ohene. Chocolate Science and Technology. Wiley-Blackwell, 2010.
- Beckett, Stephen T. The Science of Chocolate. 2nd ed. Royal Society of Chemistry, 2008.
Unit 5: Bloom, Microbiological and Other Spoilage Problems of Sugar Confectionery and Chocolate Products
Note
Unit 5: Bloom, Microbiological and Other Spoilage Problems of Sugar Confectionery and Chocolate Products
A chocolate bar comes out of the wrapper streaked white. A hard candy turns cloudy and sticky. A toffee grows mould on its surface. Three different faults, three different causes, and each one can be prevented once it is named. This unit names them all.
5.1 Bloom: the white streaks on chocolate
Bloom is the most famous chocolate fault, and it comes in two kinds. Both are white or grey streaks on the surface, but their causes are different, and so are their cures.
Fat bloom is cocoa butter that has melted and re-formed on the surface. It happens when chocolate is stored warm, or warmed and cooled again and again, or when it was badly tempered. The unstable crystal forms melt first, the liquid butter moves to the surface, and it re-crystallises there as large, dull crystals, often in the most stable form, Form VI, which melts at 36 °C. The bar looks white and dusty, feels soft, and loses its snap, though it is still safe to eat.
Sugar bloom is sugar that has dissolved and re-formed on the surface. It happens when moisture condenses on the chocolate, in a damp store or a cold bar brought into warm air. The water dissolves sugar on the surface, and when the water dries, the sugar is left behind as a rough, white crust. The bar feels gritty and looks dull.
The test is simple: fat bloom feels smooth and greasy and melts when rubbed, while sugar bloom feels rough and gritty and does not melt. Fat bloom is prevented by good tempering, cool and steady storage at about 15-18 °C, and no temperature swings. Sugar bloom is prevented by dry storage, below about 50% relative humidity, and by never letting cold chocolate meet warm, damp air.
Fat bloom against sugar bloom
Fat bloom
Cause: warm storage, temperature swings, bad temper
Cocoa butter melts, moves to surface, re-forms as dull crystals (often Form VI, 36 °C)
Feel: smooth and greasy, melts when rubbed
Cure: good tempering, cool steady storage at about 15-18 °C, no temperature swings
Sugar bloom
Cause: moisture condenses on chocolate
Water dissolves surface sugar, dries, leaves a rough white crust
Feel: rough and gritty, does not melt
Cure: dry storage below about 50% relative humidity, never let cold chocolate meet warm, damp air
Figure 5.1: Fat bloom against sugar bloom: different causes, different feel, different cure. Drawn from Afoakwa, Chocolate Science and Technology, Chapter 7, and Mohos, Confectionery and Chocolate Engineering, Chapter 10.
🤔 Pause and think: a bar is white and streaked. You rub it and the white melts away. Which bloom is it, and what caused it?
Quick check
How can you tell fat bloom from sugar bloom by touch?
Check your answer
Fat bloom feels smooth and greasy and melts when rubbed; sugar bloom feels rough and gritty and does not melt.
5.2 Microbiology: what can grow, and where
Sugar confectionery and chocolate are dry foods, and dryness is their main protection. Most bacteria need a water activity of about 0.9 or above to grow, and yeasts start growing around aw 0.8. A hard candy sits far below both, so it is safe from microbes as long as it stays dry. A soft toffee or a filled chocolate sits higher, so it needs better packing and a shorter life.
The microbes that do cause trouble are the ones that like sugar and low water. Sugar-loving yeasts can ferment a soft sweet and make gas, swelling the pack. Moulds can grow on a surface that has picked up damp air, even when the inside is dry, which is why a toffee left open in a damp room grows mould on its surface first. Chocolate itself is too dry for microbes to grow, but it can carry microbes from dirty handling or from a filling that is wet: a cream or fruit centre with high water activity can grow mould or yeast inside a chocolate shell.
Dormant spores can survive in dry ingredients and wake up when water is added, so the water and milk used in making must be clean, and the plant must be kept clean and dry.
Quick check
Why does mould grow on the surface of a toffee first, not inside it?
Check your answer
Because the surface picks up damp air first, so its water activity rises there while the inside stays dry.
5.3 Other spoilage: staling, rancidity, and graining
- Staling of sugar sweets: hard candy picks up moisture and turns sticky; soft sweets lose moisture and turn hard; fondant dries and its crystals grow, turning it gritty. The cause in each case is water moving in or out, and the cure is packing that holds moisture steady.
- Rancidity in fried snacks and nuts: the oil in chips and nuts oxidises in air, light, and warmth, giving cardboard, painty, and tallowy notes. The cure is fresh oil, cool and dark storage, and packing that blocks oxygen and light, such as a metallised film bag.
- Graining: sugar crystals forming in a sweet that should be smooth or clear, such as a hard candy turning cloudy or a caramel turning gritty. The cause is a seed crystal, slow cooling, or damp storage, and the cure is glucose syrup, fast cooling, and dry packing.
- Fat separation: oil or fat rising out of a toffee, a filled chocolate, or a nut paste, leaving a greasy layer. The cause is poor emulsification or warm storage, and the cure is lecithin or GMS and cool storage.
- Colour and flavour loss: colours fade in light and acid, flavours evaporate in warmth and through loose packing. The cure is opaque packing, cool storage, and a tight seal.
- Insect and physical contamination: insects, dust, and foreign bodies enter through open doors, torn packs, or dirty handling. The cure is plant hygiene, pest control, and a metal detector and checkweigher at the end of the line.
Quick check
What causes rancidity in fried snacks, and what packing slows it?
Check your answer
Oil oxidising in air, light, and warmth. Packing that blocks oxygen and light, such as a metallised film bag, slows it, with cool and dark storage.
5.4 A fault table: see it, name it, fix it
| Fault | What you see | Main cause | Prevention |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fat bloom (chocolate) | White, dusty streaks, soft bar | Warmth, temperature swings, bad temper | Good tempering, cool steady storage at 15-18 °C |
| Sugar bloom (chocolate) | Rough white crust, gritty feel | Moisture condensing on the bar | Dry storage below about 50% relative humidity |
| Mould (toffee, filling) | Fuzzy spots on the surface | Damp air, high water activity | Dry packing, cool storage, short shelf life |
| Yeast gas (soft sweet) | Swollen pack, yeasty smell | Sugar-loving yeasts, water activity above about 0.8 | Low water activity, clean plant, good seal |
| Sticky hard candy | Soft, sticky surface | Moisture picked up from damp air | Sealed packing, dry storage |
| Hard, dry toffee | Brittle, dry, hard | Moisture lost to dry air | Sealed packing, cool storage |
| Rancid chips or nuts | Cardboard, painty, tallowy notes | Oil oxidised in air, light, warmth | Fresh oil, metallised pack, cool dark storage |
| Graining | Cloudy candy, gritty caramel | Seed crystals, slow cooling, damp storage | Glucose syrup, fast cooling, dry packing |
| Fat separation | Greasy layer on toffee or filling | Poor emulsification, warm storage | Lecithin or GMS, cool storage |
| Colour fading | Pale, dull colour | Light, acid, long storage | Opaque packing, cool storage |
Quick check
A caramel turns gritty in storage. What is the fault, and what caused it?
Check your answer
Graining: sugar crystals formed in the caramel, from a seed crystal, slow cooling, or damp storage.
5.5 Chocolate and the filling: when the centre spoils the bar
A filled chocolate can spoil from the inside, even when the chocolate itself is perfect. The centre is the risk: a cream, fruit, or fondant centre holds far more water than the chocolate around it, so its water activity is higher, and water slowly moves from the centre into the chocolate. As the chocolate takes up water, its sugar dissolves, its texture softens, and sugar bloom follows. If the centre is wet enough, yeasts and moulds can grow inside the shell, where no one can see them until the bar is bitten.
The defences are the same ones used everywhere in this subject. Keep the centre as dry as the product allows, and use a barrier, such as a fat layer or a well-sealed shell, between a wet centre and the chocolate. Keep the water activity of the centre low with sugar or glycerol, so microbes cannot grow in it. Store the bar cool and dry, and give it a shelf life set by the centre, not by the chocolate: the bar keeps only as long as its wettest part keeps.
🤔 Pause and think: a filled chocolate has a twelve-month chocolate shell and a three-month cream centre. What shelf life should the pack claim, and why?
Quick check
Why does a filled chocolate's shelf life follow its centre, not its shell?
Check your answer
Because the centre holds more water, so water moves into the chocolate, microbes can grow in the centre, and the bar keeps only as long as its wettest part keeps.
5.6 Prevention as a system: the whole subject in one page
No single step prevents spoilage. The system is the whole subject, and each unit contributes one layer.
- Formulation (Unit 13 of Confectionery and Snack Foods and Unit 1): low water activity, glucose syrup against graining, lecithin against separation.
- Process (Unit 10 of Confectionery and Snack Foods and Unit 2): correct boiling point, good tempering in four steps, clean handling.
- Packing (Unit 4): a barrier against moisture, oxygen, and light, sealed fast and sealed well.
- Storage (Unit 4): cool, dry, dark, and steady, with no temperature swings and no damp air.
- Quality checks (Unit 5 of Confectionery and Snack Foods): moisture, water activity, flavour, and texture measured through shelf life, so the shelf life is real.
When a fault appears, work backwards through those layers in order: was the formulation right, was the process right, was the pack sealed, was the storage right? The layer that failed is the one to fix, and fixing the wrong layer wastes the batch.
🤔 Pause and think: a warehouse of chocolate blooms in a heatwave. Which layer failed, and would better tempering have saved it?
Quick check
When a fault appears, what order do you check the layers in?
Check your answer
Backwards through formulation, process, packing, and storage: the layer that failed is the one to fix.
5.7 Worked cases: name it, prove it, fix it
Four cases, each one a fault a student may meet in a shop or a factory. For each one, name the fault, say what proves it, and say what fixes it. The numbers are worked examples of the reasoning, not data for any real batch.
Case 1: a chocolate bar streaked white after a warm week
Name: fat bloom. Proof: the streaks are fat, not sugar: they feel greasy, they melt when the bar is warmed gently, and the bar was stored warm. Fix: store cool and steady, temper correctly to Form V, and never let the bar warm and cool in cycles.
Case 2: a chocolate bar with white, gritty spots after damp storage
Name: sugar bloom. Proof: the spots are sugar crystals: they feel gritty, they dissolve in a drop of water, and the bar was stored damp. Fix: keep the bar dry, seal the pack, and do not move it between damp and dry air.
Case 3: a toffee with mould on its surface after a month
Name: mould spoilage. Proof: mould grows where free water is available, so the toffee's water activity must have been high enough, or damp air reached it through a leaking pack. Fix: boil to the right water content, pack in a sealed moisture barrier, and check the seal rate.
Case 4: a bag of chips that tastes stale and paint-like
Name: rancidity of the frying oil. Proof: the off flavour is in the oil, not the potato: the chips smell stale even though they are still crisp, and the oil was old or stored warm in light. Fix: use fresh oil, fry at the right temperature, store cool and dark, and do not reuse oil past its frying life.
Two rules run through all four cases. First, the fault is proved by a test, not by a look: greasy against gritty separates fat bloom from sugar bloom, and a drop of water dissolves sugar bloom but not fat bloom. Second, the fix is in the process or the pack, not in the complaint: a maker who only replaces the faulty bars will see the same fault in the next batch. The prevention system in section 5.6 is these four cases turned into routine: temper right, pack dry, seal well, store cool, and use fresh oil. A student who can work a case in this form can walk into any snack factory, see a fault, name it, prove it, and say what to change.
🤔 Pause and think: a bar has white streaks. You warm it gently and the streaks melt away, and a drop of water does nothing to them. Fat bloom or sugar bloom, and what storage fault caused it?
Quick check
How do you tell fat bloom from sugar bloom with two simple tests?
Check your answer
Fat bloom feels greasy and melts when warmed gently; sugar bloom feels gritty and dissolves in a drop of water.
5.8 Check yourself: quick self-check
- What is fat bloom, and what causes it?
Check your answer
Cocoa butter that has melted and re-formed on the surface, caused by warm storage, temperature swings, or bad tempering.
- What is sugar bloom, and what causes it?
Check your answer
Sugar dissolved by condensed moisture and left as a rough white crust when the water dries.
- At about what water activity do most bacteria and yeasts start to grow?
Check your answer
Most bacteria need about aw 0.9 or above; yeasts start around aw 0.8.
- Name two spoilage faults of sugar sweets besides bloom, and their causes.
Check your answer
Any two, for example: graining from seed crystals or damp storage; sticky hard candy from moisture pickup; rancidity from oil oxidation; mould from damp air and high water activity.
- A toffee grows mould after a month. What two things could have let it happen?
Check your answer
Its water activity was high enough for mould, or damp air reached it through a leaking pack.
- Chips taste stale and paint-like but are still crisp. What is the fault, and what is the fix?
Check your answer
Rancidity of the frying oil. Fix: fresh oil, right frying temperature, cool dark storage, and no reuse past its frying life.
Try it: Put a piece of chocolate in the fridge for an hour, then bring it out into a warm room and leave it. Watch the surface over the next hour: the dull, rough film that forms is sugar bloom from condensed moisture. Compare it with a piece kept steady at room temperature.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Fat bloom is cocoa butter melted and re-formed on the surface, often as Form VI at 36 °C, from warmth, swings, or bad temper; it feels smooth and melts when rubbed.
- Sugar bloom is sugar dissolved by condensed moisture and left as a rough crust; it feels gritty and does not melt.
- Most bacteria need water activity about 0.9, yeasts about 0.8: dry sweets are safe while they stay dry.
- Mould grows first on surfaces that pick up damp air; sugar-loving yeasts ferment soft sweets and swell packs.
- Other faults are staling by water moving in or out, rancidity by oil oxidation, graining by crystals, fat separation, colour and flavour loss, and contamination.
Prevention is a system: formulation, process, packing, storage, and quality checks, checked backwards when a fault appears.
Bloom has two kinds with two tests: fat bloom feels greasy and melts on gentle warming, sugar bloom feels gritty and dissolves in a drop of water.
- Every fault is proved by a test and fixed in the process or the pack: replacing the faulty bars alone never stops the next batch failing.
Glossary
Fat bloom
White, dusty streaks on chocolate from cocoa butter melting and re-forming on the surface. Food tech example: a chocolate bar stored warm turning white and soft.
Sugar bloom
A rough white crust on chocolate from sugar dissolved by condensed moisture and left behind when it dries. Food tech example: a cold bar brought into warm, damp air turning gritty and white.
Form VI
The most stable crystal form of cocoa butter, melting at 36 °C, often found in fat bloom. Food tech example: bloom crystals on a badly stored bar.
Water activity (aw)
A measure of the water in a food that is free for microbes and chemical reactions to use: pure water is 1.0. Food tech example: a hard candy with very low aw that microbes cannot grow in.
Rancidity
Stale, cardboard or painty flavour from oil oxidising in air, light, and warmth. Food tech example: chips in an old, open bag tasting stale.
Graining
The fault where sugar crystals form in a sweet that should be smooth or clear. Food tech example: a hard candy turning cloudy in damp storage.
Mould
Fungi that grow as fuzzy spots on damp food surfaces. Food tech example: mould on a toffee left open in a damp room.
Shelf life
How long a product keeps its quality under stated storage conditions. Food tech example: a chocolate bar with a twelve-month shelf life in cool, dry storage.
Fat bloom
White or grey streaks on chocolate from fat rising to the surface, often after warm storage or poor tempering. Food tech example: a bar streaked white after a warm week, the streaks melting on gentle warming.
Sugar bloom
White gritty spots on chocolate from sugar crystals forming after damp storage. Food tech example: a bar with gritty spots that dissolve in a drop of water.
References
- Mohos, Ferenc A. Confectionery and Chocolate Engineering: Principles and Applications. 2nd ed. Wiley-Blackwell, 2017.
- Afoakwa, Emmanuel Ohene. Chocolate Science and Technology. Wiley-Blackwell, 2010.
- Beckett, Stephen T. The Science of Chocolate. 2nd ed. Royal Society of Chemistry, 2008.