GIFSQ ID: FTN-0098
Alternative Proteins
Unit 1: Why Alternative Proteins: The Drivers
Note
Unit 1: Why Alternative Proteins: The Drivers
A question to start with
Walk down the chilled aisle of a supermarket and count the packs that carry the words plant based. Ten years ago there were a few. Today there are burgers, sausages, nuggets, milks, cheeses and ready meals, all made without meat or dairy, sitting beside the foods they imitate. At the same time, the price of feed grain rises and falls, a drought cuts a harvest in one region, and a livestock disease closes borders in another. The question behind this unit is simple: why are so many people, companies and researchers looking for new ways to make protein, and what is pushing them to do it now? The answers touch on how many people there are to feed, how much land and water food production uses, what people want to eat, and what science can now do that it could not do fifty years ago. This unit sets out those drivers one by one, so that every later unit in this subject has a reason behind it.
What protein does in the body and in food
Protein is a nutrient the body uses to build and repair tissue, to make enzymes and hormones, and to support growth in children and recovery after illness. The body builds its own proteins from smaller units called amino acids. Nine of those amino acids are essential, which means the body cannot make them and must get them from food. A food that supplies all nine in useful amounts is called a complete protein. Meat, milk and eggs are complete proteins. Most single plant foods are not: a grain may be short of lysine, a legume may be short of methionine, and that is why diets built on plants combine foods, such as beans with rice, to cover the gaps.
Protein also does work inside a food itself. It traps water, holds fat in place, forms gels, foams when whipped, and browns when heated. A sausage holds together because its proteins form a network. A bread rises and keeps its shape because wheat proteins form gluten. A meringue stands up because egg proteins trap air. When a food maker replaces animal protein with another protein, all of these jobs must still be done, and that is where much of the science in this subject lives.
The amount of protein people need depends on age, body size and activity. A small child needs protein for growth. An older adult needs it to keep muscle. An athlete needs more than a desk worker. Public health guidance in most countries sets a daily amount per kilogram of body weight, and most people in high income countries already eat more than that amount, while many people in low income countries eat less. Alternative proteins are not only about eating more protein: they are about where that protein comes from, what it costs the planet to make, and who can afford it.
More people, same planet
The number of people on Earth keeps growing, and with it the demand for protein. As incomes rise in many parts of the world, people eat more meat, milk and eggs, because those foods are valued, filling and tied to celebration and status. That rise in demand meets a fixed supply of farmland and fresh water. A field can only grow one crop at a time, and a river can only supply so much water. When demand grows faster than supply, prices rise, and the poorest buyers feel it first.
Livestock farming uses land in two ways: pasture for grazing animals, and cropland for growing feed such as maize and soy. A large share of the world's soy and maize harvest goes to animal feed rather than directly to people. Each step up the food chain loses energy: the animal eats the plant protein and turns only part of it into meat or milk. The rest is used to keep the animal alive, to move, and to stay warm. Eating the plant protein directly is far more efficient in land and energy terms, and that simple arithmetic is one of the strongest drivers behind alternative proteins.
None of this means livestock farming will vanish. Animals turn grass and crop waste that people cannot eat into foods people can eat, and they support the livelihoods of millions of farming families. The point of this unit is not to pick a winner. It is to show why a food system that adds more protein sources, instead of relying on one route only, is more secure when harvests fail, prices spike, or disease strikes a herd.
Land, water and climate
Food production uses land, water and energy, and it releases gases that warm the planet. The gases that matter most here are carbon dioxide, written CO₂, methane, written CH₄, and nitrous oxide, written N₂O. Ruminant animals such as cattle and sheep release methane as part of digestion. Fertilisers used on feed crops release nitrous oxide. Clearing forest for pasture or feed crops releases carbon dioxide stored in trees and soil. A food that needs less land, less water and fewer of these gases per kilogram of protein has a smaller footprint, and buyers, governments and food companies are all paying attention to that footprint now.
Water use is easy to picture with a simple example. A crop needs rain or irrigation to grow. An animal needs drinking water, water to grow its feed, and water to clean its housing and the processing plant. A plant protein food skips the animal step, so the water tied to feed and housing drops away. The saving is not the same for every crop: some legumes grow on rainfall alone in their home regions, while others need irrigation, and processing steps such as soaking and washing also use water. A careful comparison always counts the whole chain, from the field to the factory gate, and that habit of counting the whole chain is called life cycle assessment.
Land tells a similar story. A hectare of soy or peas produces far more protein in a year than the same hectare used to graze cattle. That does not make grazing useless: some land is too steep, dry or poor for crops and can only support grazing animals. The sensible question is where each kind of production fits best, and how to use each hectare for the food it produces most efficiently. Alternative proteins earn their place by doing well on good cropland and in factories, leaving marginal land to the animals that can use it.
Health, choice and the shopper
People change what they eat for many reasons, and protein choice is no exception. Some people stop eating meat because of concern for animals. Some do it for health, cutting back on saturated fat and on processed meat. Some do it for faith or family custom. Others keep eating meat but choose a plant based meal several times a week, a pattern often called flexitarian eating. Food companies watch these choices closely, because a shopper who buys a plant based burger once a week is a large market when multiplied across millions of shoppers.
Health claims need care. A plant based food is not healthy by magic: a burger made from pea protein, coconut fat, salt and flavourings can carry as much saturated fat and salt as a beef burger. What matters is the whole recipe, the amounts of fat, salt, sugar and fibre, and how the food fits into the rest of the diet. Protein quality matters too, and it is judged by the amino acid pattern and by how much of the protein the body can digest and use. Later units explain how makers measure protein quality and how they blend proteins to cover the gaps.
Allergy is another driver. Milk, egg, soy, wheat, peanut and tree nuts are among the foods that most often cause allergy, and food labels in most countries must name them when present. A new protein source can help people who cannot eat one of these foods, but it can also bring a new allergy of its own, and that is why safety testing of new proteins includes a check for allergy risk. A protein that is new to the diet is never assumed safe: it is tested first, and this subject returns to that testing in Unit 7.
Technology opens new doors
Fifty years ago, making a burger from peas that chewed like beef was a laboratory trick. Today it is a factory product, and the change came from better machines and better science. Extruders that push a protein paste through heat and pressure can line the proteins up into fibres that feel like meat. Fermentation tanks can grow fungi into a fibrous mass that looks and chews like chicken. Enzymes can cut proteins into pieces that dissolve, foam or gel on demand. Each of these tools is covered in its own unit later in this subject.
Research has also mapped the proteins themselves. Food scientists now know which plant proteins gel, which foam, which bind fat, and which taste bitter, and they know how heat, acidity and salt change each one. That knowledge lets a maker pick the right protein for the right job, instead of guessing. A protein that gels well goes into a sausage. A protein that foams well goes into a meringue or a whipped topping. A protein that stays clear in acid goes into a sports drink. Matching protein to job is the quiet skill behind most alternative protein products.
Cost is falling as scale rises. A new factory that makes ten tonnes a day has lower costs per kilogram than a pilot plant that makes ten kilograms. Ingredients that were once rare, such as pea protein isolate, are now made in large plants and sold by the tonne. That scale is what moves an alternative protein from a niche shop to a supermarket shelf, and from a high price to one an ordinary shopper can afford.
What this subject will cover
The units that follow take the drivers in this unit and turn them into working knowledge. Unit 2 looks at plant proteins in detail: soy, pea, wheat and legumes, how they are grown, how the protein is taken out of the seed, and what each one does well. Unit 3 turns to fungal and algal proteins, including mycoprotein and microalgae, and the fermentation that grows them. Unit 4 looks at insect protein, a source that is old in some food cultures and new in others, and the questions it raises. Unit 5 looks at hybrid products that blend plant and animal proteins. Unit 6 explains texture and flavour, the extrusion and formulation work that makes a plant protein feel and taste like the food it replaces. Unit 7 closes with nutrition, safety and labelling, the rules that decide whether a new protein can be sold and what its pack may say.
As you read, keep one habit in mind: ask what job the protein must do, and ask what it costs in land, water, energy and money to do that job. A protein that scores well on one count and badly on another is not a simple success or failure. It is a trade off, and a food technologist's work is to weigh those trade offs in the open, with numbers, instead of settling them with slogans. The rest of this subject gives you the numbers and the methods to do that weighing.
Working out the protein gap: a worked example
A claim that the world needs more protein is easy to make and hard to judge, so it helps to work the numbers by hand once. Start with one person. A widely used reference value for an adult is about 0.8 g of protein per kilogram of body weight per day, with active people, growing children and older adults needing more. A person who weighs 60 kg therefore needs about 48 g of protein a day at that reference value, and a person who weighs 80 kg needs about 64 g. Those numbers are for protein that is digested and used, so a diet built on a protein with low digestibility needs more of it on the plate to meet the same need.
Now scale the person up to a town. A town of 100,000 people, each needing about 50 g of protein a day, needs 5,000 kg of protein a day, which is 5 tonnes a day, or about 1,825 tonnes a year. That is the protein that must arrive as food, after losses in cooking, storage and waste are counted, so the food system must supply more than the people eat. A farm, a fishery and a factory each supply a share, and the question for alternative proteins is how large a share the new sources can supply, and at what cost in land, water and energy.
The derivation shows why the answer is not one number but a balance. The need depends on body weight, age, activity and digestibility. The supply depends on crops, animals, tanks and factories. The gap between them is filled by whichever source can grow fastest without using more land than the planet can spare. Alternative proteins matter because they can grow in tanks and on side streams, where land is not the limit, and the worked example shows how a maker or a student can test any claim about the gap: start with one person, multiply by the people, and ask where each kilogram will come from.
Questions to think about
- If a hectare of peas produces more protein than the same hectare grazed by cattle, why do farmers still keep cattle on some land?
- A plant based burger and a beef burger carry the same salt and saturated fat on the label. Is the plant one healthier, and what else would you check?
- Why does eating plant protein directly use less land than feeding the same plants to an animal first?
Think about the cattle question before you read on
Some land is too steep, too dry, too wet or too poor in soil for crops, and only grazing animals can turn its grass into food. Cattle also eat crop residues and by-products people cannot eat, and they give milk, manure and income to families with little cropland. The land argument is about using each hectare for what it does best, not about removing animals from every field.
The diagram shows the chain of drivers in this unit. Each driver pushes the food system toward more protein sources, and the last panel is the food technologist's job: weighing them together.
Practical note: In a practical session, compare the protein content per 100 g on the labels of five foods: dried lentils, tofu, a plant based burger, an egg, and a piece of cheese. Work out the protein per unit of price for each one from the shelf price, and note which protein gives the most protein for the money. Keep the labels, because the same comparison returns in Unit 7 when labelling rules are covered.
Quick self-check
Question: Why is a single plant food often an incomplete protein?
Because most single plant foods are short of one or more of the nine essential amino acids. A grain may be short of lysine while a legume is short of methionine. Eating the two together covers the gaps, which is why beans with rice is a classic combination.
Question: What is life cycle assessment, and why does it count the whole chain?
It is a method that adds up the land, water, energy and gas releases of a food from the field to the factory gate, and often to the plate. Counting only the factory would hide the farm, and counting only the farm would hide the processing, so the whole chain is needed for a fair comparison.
Question: How much protein does a 60 kg adult need a day at the reference value of 0.8 g per kilogram?
About 48 g a day, because 60 multiplied by 0.8 gives 48. Active people, growing children and older adults need more, and a diet built on a protein with low digestibility needs more on the plate to meet the same need.
Try it yourself
Go to a supermarket and find three plant based products: one burger, one milk and one yoghurt. Read the ingredient list of each and write down the first protein ingredient named, the protein per 100 g, and the price. Then find the animal food each one imitates and write down the same three facts. At home, compare the two lists side by side and answer in writing: which protein source is used in each plant product, how close is the protein amount to the animal original, and what is the price gap? Bring your notes to class and compare them with a classmate who shopped in a different store.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Protein builds and repairs body tissue, and it also does work inside a food: gelling, foaming, binding water and fat.
- Most single plant foods are short of one or more essential amino acids, so diets and recipes combine proteins to cover the gaps.
- Growing demand for protein meets fixed land and water, and feeding plants to animals first loses energy at each step.
- Plant proteins usually need less land and water per kilogram of protein than meat, but the whole chain must be counted.
- Shoppers choose alternative proteins for health, animals, faith and habit, and a plant label alone does not make a food healthy.
- Extrusion, fermentation and enzyme tools now let makers shape plant proteins into foods that chew and taste like meat.
A food technologist weighs nutrition, cost, footprint and safety together, never on a single count alone.
The protein gap can be worked out by hand: one person's need, multiplied by the people, shows how much protein a town or a country must supply each year.
Glossary
Amino acid
A small unit that links with others to build a protein. Food tech example: lysine is the amino acid that wheat is short of, so wheat flour is often paired with a legume in a recipe.
Complete protein
A protein that supplies all nine essential amino acids in useful amounts. Food tech example: egg is a complete protein, which is why it is used as a reference when judging other proteins.
Essential amino acid
An amino acid the body cannot make and must get from food. Food tech example: a protein quality test checks the amounts of all nine essential amino acids in a food.
Flexitarian
A person who eats meat sometimes and plant based meals often. Food tech example: flexitarian shoppers are the main buyers of plant based burgers in many supermarkets.
Life cycle assessment
A method that adds up the land, water, energy and gas releases of a product across its whole life. Food tech example: a life cycle assessment of a pea burger counts the farm, the factory and the packaging.
Methionine
An essential amino acid that legumes are often short of. Food tech example: a lentil and rice dish covers methionine from the rice and lysine from the lentils.
Lysine
An essential amino acid that grains are often short of. Food tech example: a wheat bread enriched with legume flour gains lysine from the legume.
Mycoprotein
Protein made from a fungus grown in fermentation tanks. Food tech example: mycoprotein is shaped into pieces that chew like chicken in meat free products.
Plant based
A food made mainly or wholly from plants. Food tech example: a plant based milk is made from soy, oat or almond instead of dairy milk.
Protein isolate
A protein ingredient made by taking most of the non protein parts out of a plant material. Food tech example: pea protein isolate is the main protein in many plant based burgers.
Saturated fat
A type of fat that is solid at room temperature and linked to heart health when eaten in large amounts. Food tech example: coconut fat in a plant based burger adds saturated fat, so the label must be read, not assumed.
Ruminant
An animal such as cattle or sheep that digests grass with the help of microbes in its stomach and releases methane. Food tech example: methane from ruminants is one reason the climate footprint of beef is studied closely.
Carbon dioxide
A gas released when fuels burn and forests are cleared, written CO₂. Food tech example: clearing land for feed crops releases CO₂ stored in trees and soil.
Methane
A gas released during digestion by ruminants, written CH₄. Food tech example: methane is counted in the climate footprint of beef and milk.
Nitrous oxide
A gas released from fertilised soils, written N₂O. Food tech example: fertiliser used on feed maize adds N₂O to the footprint of the meat it feeds.
Trade off
A choice where gaining one benefit means giving up another. Food tech example: a protein that is cheap and tasty may also be high in salt, so the maker weighs taste against health.
Reference value
A standard amount used for planning, such as 0.8 g of protein per kilogram of body weight per day. Food tech example: a 60 kg adult needs about 48 g of protein a day at the reference value.
Digestibility
The share of a nutrient that the body can absorb and use. Food tech example: a diet built on a protein with low digestibility needs more of it on the plate.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 2: Plant Proteins: Soy, Pea, Wheat and Legumes
Note
Unit 2: Plant Proteins: Soy, Pea, Wheat and Legumes
A question to start with
Open a bag of dried soybeans, a bag of split peas and a bag of wheat flour, and you hold three different protein factories in your hands. The soybean stores about a third of its weight as protein. The pea stores about a quarter. Wheat stores far less, about a tenth, but its protein has a talent the others lack: it stretches into an elastic network called gluten. Each of these seeds became a food industry of its own, and each one is used in a different way in alternative protein foods. This unit follows the protein from the seed to the ingredient: how it is grown, how the protein is taken out, what the main types are, and what each one does well and badly in a recipe.
The seed as a storehouse
A seed stores food for the young plant: starch for energy, oil for energy, and protein for building new tissue. The balance between them differs by crop. Soybeans store roughly 35 to 40 percent protein and about 20 percent oil, which is why soy gives both a protein ingredient and an oil. Peas store roughly 20 to 25 percent protein and little oil. Wheat grain stores roughly 10 to 14 percent protein and about 70 percent starch. Lentils and chickpeas sit near peas, at roughly 20 to 25 percent protein. These figures are typical ranges for the harvested seed, and they shift with variety, soil and season.
Inside the seed, proteins sit in bodies that the plant builds as it ripens. In soy and pea, the main storage proteins are globulins, proteins that dissolve in salt water and clump together when heated or acidified. In wheat, the main proteins are gliadin and glutenin, which join to form gluten when flour meets water. The behaviour of a protein ingredient in a recipe follows from which proteins it holds and how they were treated during extraction.
A maker who buys a plant protein rarely buys the whole seed. The seed is milled, the oil is taken out if there is much of it, and the protein is separated from the starch and fibre. The result is sold as a flour, a concentrate or an isolate, and the names tell you how much protein is in the powder. A flour is the milled seed, often 40 to 50 percent protein for soy. A concentrate is about 65 to 70 percent protein. An isolate is about 90 percent protein or more. The purer the powder, the more it costs, and the less it tastes of the original bean.
Soy: the first large scale plant protein
Soy has been a protein food for thousands of years in East Asia, eaten as tofu, tempeh, soy sauce and fermented pastes. The modern ingredient industry grew from the oil trade: soybeans are crushed for oil, and the leftover meal, rich in protein, became animal feed and then human food ingredients. Soy protein isolate is now one of the most used proteins in processed foods, because it gels, binds water, holds fat in place, and costs less than most animal proteins.
To make soy protein isolate, the beans are cleaned, cracked, dehulled and flaked, then the oil is removed with a solvent or by pressing. The defatted flakes are mixed with water at a slightly alkaline pH, near 8 to 9, which dissolves the protein. The fibre is spun out, and the liquid is then acidified to about pH 4.5, the point where soy protein is least soluble, so it falls out of the liquid as a curd. The curd is washed, neutralised, dried and milled into a powder. That sequence, dissolve at high pH, then drop out at low pH, is the standard way of making many protein isolates, and it returns in this unit for pea as well.
Soy protein has a good amino acid pattern and is close to a complete protein, though it is a little short of methionine. Its weakness is flavour: soy can taste beany and bitter, and those notes must be removed or covered. Its other weakness is allergy: soy is one of the foods that most often causes allergy, and its presence must be named on a label in most countries. Textured soy protein, made by extrusion, is the oldest meat analogue ingredient, and it still fills the centre of many budget meat free products.
Pea: the fast riser
Pea protein has grown fast in the last decade, and the reason is simple: peas are not a major allergen, they grow in cool climates, and their protein works well in burgers and drinks. Yellow peas are the usual source. The seeds are milled into flour, the flour is mixed with water, the starch and fibre are separated by spinning, and the protein is dropped out by acid, much like soy, then washed, dried and milled. Dry separation methods also exist, where milled pea flour is blown with air so the light protein particles separate from the heavy starch granules, using no water at all.
Pea protein is rich in lysine and short of methionine, so makers often blend it with rice protein, which is short of lysine and richer in methionine, to cover the gaps. The blend is a good example of protein complementing, the same idea as beans with rice on a plate, applied inside a factory recipe. Pea protein gels when heated, holds water, and gives a firm bite in a burger, but it can taste earthy and slightly bitter, and that flavour is the main problem a product developer must solve.
A worked example shows the scale. A factory makes a plant based burger with 20 g of protein per 100 g of burger. If the recipe uses pea protein isolate at 85 percent protein, each 100 g of burger needs about 24 g of isolate, because 24 multiplied by 0.85 gives about 20. A 120 g patty then carries about 29 g of isolate. At a production run of 10,000 patties, the factory needs about 290 kg of isolate for that one run. Numbers like this are how a buyer checks whether a supplier can deliver enough, and whether the price per kilogram keeps the burger affordable.
Wheat and gluten: the elastic protein
Wheat is different from soy and pea, because its value is not its amount of protein but what its protein does. When wheat flour meets water and is kneaded, two proteins, gliadin and glutenin, join into a network called gluten. Gliadin gives stretch, glutenin gives strength, and together they trap the gas made by yeast, so bread rises, and they give pasta its bite and seitan its chew. No other common plant protein does this, which is why wheat gluten, sold as dried wheat gluten, is a key ingredient in many meat analogues.
Wheat gluten is made by washing dough: flour and water are mixed, then the starch is washed away, leaving the sticky gluten behind. The gluten is dried gently and milled. In a recipe it can be kneaded with water and flavourings into seitan, a dense, chewy food that has been eaten for centuries in East Asia. In a burger, a small amount of gluten, often 5 to 10 percent of the recipe, adds chew and helps the patty hold together on a grill.
Wheat protein has clear limits. It is short of lysine, so its protein quality is lower than soy or pea. It is also one of the most common allergens, and it is the protein that people with coeliac disease cannot eat, because gluten damages their gut. A product that uses wheat gluten must name wheat on the label, and a gluten free product cannot use it at all. That trade off, great texture against a wide allergy and a dietary exclusion, is why many makers use gluten in small amounts and blend it with pea or soy.
Legumes, lentils and chickpeas
Beyond soy and pea sits a wide family of legumes: lentils, chickpeas, beans, lupins and faba beans. Each is eaten whole in some food culture, and each is now being turned into protein ingredients. Lentils cook fast, have a mild flavour, and give a soft texture, which suits soups, patties and spreads. Chickpeas give a firm, nutty bite and are the base of hummus and falafel. Lupins are high in protein, near 35 to 40 percent in the seed, but they carry bitter compounds that must be removed, and lupin is an allergen that must be labelled.
Faba beans are a rising ingredient in cool climates because they fix nitrogen in the soil, which means they take N₂ from the air and turn it into a form plants can use, cutting the need for fertiliser. Their protein is similar to pea, rich in lysine and short of methionine, and their flour works in breads and pasta. A simple rule runs through all legumes: they are good sources of protein, fibre, iron and folate, and they are short of the same amino acid, methionine, so they pair well with grains.
Whole legumes bring fibre with the protein, and that fibre is a real benefit: it slows digestion, feeds gut microbes and helps a food feel filling. An isolate loses most of that fibre. A product developer must choose between a whole legume flour, which keeps fibre and flavour but adds starch and colour, and an isolate, which gives clean protein and a neutral base but loses fibre. Many products use both: an isolate for protein strength and a whole flour for fibre, flavour and a lower cost.
Choosing between flour, concentrate and isolate
The choice between flour, concentrate and isolate is a choice between cost, function and flavour. A flour is cheapest and keeps the most of the original food, including fibre, starch and flavour, but its protein is diluted, so more of it is needed to reach a target protein level, and its flavour may not suit the product. A concentrate is a middle step: more protein, less flavour, higher cost. An isolate is the purest and most neutral, and the most expensive, and it gives the maker the most control over texture.
A worked example makes the trade off plain. A drink maker wants 10 g of protein in a 250 ml bottle. With a soy flour at 50 percent protein, the recipe needs 20 g of flour per bottle. With an isolate at 90 percent protein, it needs about 11 g. The isolate bottle is lighter, clearer and less beany, but the isolate costs roughly twice as much per kilogram, so the maker must weigh the saving in weight and flavour against the extra cost. In a burger, where texture and colour matter more than clarity, a concentrate often wins. In a clear sports drink, where cloudiness is a fault, an isolate is the only choice.
Storage matters for all of these powders. They must be kept dry, cool and sealed, because moisture lets microbes grow and lets fats oxidise, and heat damages the protein so it no longer gels or foams as it should. A warehouse that stores pea isolate beside strong smelling spices will pass the smell into the powder, so protein powders are stored away from strong odours. The specification sheet from the supplier lists protein content, moisture, particle size and microbial limits, and a factory checks each delivery against that sheet before it enters the store.
Dry fractionation in detail
Unit 2 introduced dry fractionation briefly, and it deserves a closer look, because it is the cheapest and driest way to make a protein ingredient. The seed is milled into a fine flour, and the flour is blown through a stream of air in a classifier, a tall chamber where the air lifts the light particles and lets the heavy ones fall. Protein bodies are small and light, starch granules are larger and heavier, so the light stream that leaves the top of the chamber is rich in protein, often about 50 to 60 percent, while the heavy stream that falls to the bottom is rich in starch.
The split is tuned by the air speed and the milling. Faster air lifts more, including some starch, so the protein stream is larger but less pure. Slower air lifts only the lightest protein, so the stream is smaller but purer. Finer milling makes smaller particles, which separate more cleanly, but milling too fine costs energy and can damage the protein. Sieves can refine the split further, sorting the flour by size before the air step, so the classifier receives a feed it can sort well. The operator watches the protein content of both streams and adjusts the air until the split is right.
Dry fractionation has a second benefit that wet methods lack: the protein is never dissolved, so its native structure survives, and it keeps more of its foaming and gelling power. The flour keeps its fibre, which suits breads and snacks, and the starch stream is sold for other foods, so little is wasted. The limit is purity, as Unit 2 explains, and the maker who needs 90 percent protein must still use the wet route. The dry route is the right tool where 50 to 60 percent protein is enough, and where water, energy and fibre all matter.
The diagram shows dry fractionation in order. The air speed decides the split: faster air lifts more but less purely, slower air lifts less but more purely.
Questions to think about
- Why does a soy protein isolate cost more than soy flour, and when is the extra cost worth paying?
- Pea protein is short of methionine and rice protein is short of lysine. How would you blend them to make a better protein, and how would you check it worked?
- Why can wheat gluten make a chewy meat analogue when soy and pea proteins cannot do the same job alone?
Think about the pea and rice blend before you read on
Pea is rich in lysine and short of methionine, while rice is rich in methionine and short of lysine, so a blend of the two covers both gaps. A maker would test the blend by measuring the amino acid pattern and the digestibility, then adjust the ratio until the lowest essential amino acid, the limiting one, is as high as possible. A blend of about 70 percent pea to 30 percent rice is a common starting point, but the exact ratio is set by measurement, not by guessing.
The diagram shows the standard wet route to a protein isolate. The same steps, with small changes, make soy isolate and pea isolate, and the acid step is the point where the protein falls out of solution.
Practical note: In a practical session, make a simple gluten ball: mix 200 g of strong wheat flour with 120 ml of water, knead for 5 minutes, rest for 20 minutes, then wash the dough under a slow stream of cold water in a bowl, kneading gently, until the water runs nearly clear and a stretchy ball is left. Weigh the ball, stretch it, and note how far it pulls before it tears. Then cook half in simmering water for 20 minutes and taste the chew. Record the starting flour weight, the gluten ball weight, and the stretch, and compare your numbers with a classmate who used a different flour.
Quick self-check
Question: What is the difference between a flour, a concentrate and an isolate?
A flour is the milled seed, a concentrate has part of the non protein removed and holds about 65 to 70 percent protein, and an isolate has most of the non protein removed and holds about 90 percent protein or more. The purer the powder, the more it costs and the less it tastes of the original bean.
Question: Why is soy protein dropped out of solution at about pH 4.5?
Because 4.5 is near the point where soy protein is least soluble, its isoelectric point. At that pH the protein molecules carry little net charge, so they stop repelling each other and fall out of the liquid as a curd that can be collected.
Question: Why does faster air give a larger protein stream that is less pure?
Because faster air lifts more particles, including some starch granules, so the light stream grows larger but holds more starch. Slower air lifts only the lightest protein bodies, so the stream is smaller but purer.
Try it yourself
Buy three foods from a shop: a block of tofu, a bag of dried red lentils, and a bag of plain wheat flour. Cook 100 g of lentils in water and note how much they swell and how long they take. Press the tofu, cut it into cubes, fry half plain and half after marinating in soy sauce for 20 minutes, and compare the taste. Then mix 100 g of the flour with water, knead it, and wash out the starch as in the practical note, to see how little gluten is left from a whole cup of flour. Write down the weight of each food before and after cooking or washing, and answer: which food gives the most protein per 100 g as eaten, and which one changed most in weight during preparation?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Soy, pea, wheat and legumes store protein in different amounts and in different protein types, and each type behaves differently in a recipe.
- Flour, concentrate and isolate name how pure a protein powder is, and purity trades against cost, flavour and fibre.
- The wet route to an isolate dissolves protein at alkaline pH and drops it out near pH 4.5, where it is least soluble.
- Soy protein is near complete and widely used, but it tastes beany and is a common allergen.
- Pea protein is rich in lysine and short of methionine, so it blends well with rice protein to cover the gaps.
- Wheat gluten is the only common plant protein that forms an elastic network, giving chew, but it excludes people with coeliac disease.
Whole legume flours keep fibre and flavour, while isolates give clean protein and control, and many recipes use both.
Dry fractionation sorts protein from starch with air and sieves, using no water, and it keeps the protein structure and the fibre, but it cannot reach isolate purity.
Glossary
Concentrate
A protein ingredient with part of the non protein removed, holding about 65 to 70 percent protein. Food tech example: soy protein concentrate is used in meat free sausages where a middle level of purity is enough.
Defatted
Having the oil removed from a seed or meal. Food tech example: defatted soy flakes are the starting material for soy protein isolate.
Gliadin
One of the two proteins that join to form gluten in wheat. Food tech example: gliadin gives dough its stretch when bread is kneaded.
Gluten
The elastic network formed when wheat proteins meet water and are kneaded. Food tech example: gluten traps gas in bread dough so the loaf rises.
Glutenin
One of the two proteins that join to form gluten in wheat. Food tech example: glutenin gives dough its strength so it holds its shape.
Globulin
A storage protein that dissolves in salt water, common in soy and pea. Food tech example: the main proteins of soy are globulins that clump together when heated.
Isolate
A protein ingredient with most non protein parts removed, holding about 90 percent protein or more. Food tech example: pea protein isolate is the main protein in many plant based burgers.
Isoelectric point
The pH where a protein carries little net charge and is least soluble. Food tech example: soy protein is dropped out of solution near pH 4.5, its isoelectric point.
Legume
A plant of the bean family whose seeds grow in pods and are rich in protein. Food tech example: lentils, chickpeas and peas are legumes used as protein foods.
Limiting amino acid
The essential amino acid present in the smallest amount relative to need, which sets the quality of a protein. Food tech example: methionine is often the limiting amino acid in legume proteins.
Lysine
An essential amino acid that grains are short of and legumes are rich in. Food tech example: adding lentil flour to wheat bread raises its lysine content.
Methionine
An essential amino acid that legumes are short of and grains are richer in. Food tech example: rice protein is blended with pea protein to cover methionine.
Seitan
A chewy food made from wheat gluten, kneaded and cooked with flavourings. Food tech example: seitan slices are used as a meat free roast in many recipes.
Tempeh
Fermented soybeans pressed into a firm cake. Food tech example: tempeh is sliced and fried as a protein food in Indonesian cooking.
Textured soy protein
Soy protein shaped by extrusion into chewy pieces that resemble meat. Food tech example: textured soy protein is the base of many budget meat free mince products.
Tofu
A curd made by setting soy milk with a coagulant and pressing it. Food tech example: firm tofu is cubed and fried as a protein in stir fries.
Nitrogen fixation
The process by which legume roots, with the help of microbes, turn N₂ from the air into a form plants can use. Food tech example: faba beans fix nitrogen, so the next crop in the field needs less fertiliser.
Classifier
A tall chamber where air lifts light particles and lets heavy ones fall. Food tech example: a classifier separates pea protein from pea starch with air.
Air speed
How fast air moves through a classifier, which decides the split. Food tech example: faster air lifts more flour but less purely.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 3: Fungal and Algal Proteins: Mycoprotein and Microalgae
Note
Unit 3: Fungal and Algal Proteins: Mycoprotein and Microalgae
A question to start with
A mushroom grows on a log in days, doubling its mass without a field, a plough or a season. A green alga grows in a pond or a tank, using sunlight and CO₂ to build protein faster than any crop. Both are old foods in some cultures and new ingredients in others, and both are now grown in factories as protein for the modern diet. This unit looks at how fungi and algae make protein, how they are grown at scale, what they taste like, and what limits them. The two groups are different in almost every way, except one: they make protein without farmland in the usual sense, and that is why food makers are watching them closely.
Fungi: a kingdom of protein makers
Fungi are neither plants nor animals. They include yeasts, moulds and mushrooms, and they grow by feeding on organic matter, breaking it down with enzymes and absorbing the pieces. A mushroom is the fruiting body of a fungus, the part that makes spores, while most of the fungus lives as a network of fine threads called mycelium, hidden in soil or wood. It is the mycelium, and the single cells of yeasts, that food makers harvest for protein.
Mycoprotein is the best known fungal protein food. It is made from a fungus called Fusarium venenatum, grown in large fermentation tanks on a feed of glucose syrup, with added minerals and vitamins. The fungus grows as fine threads, and those threads are harvested, heated to reduce their nucleic acid content, and then shaped into pieces that look and chew like chicken or fish. The heating step matters: fungal cells hold more nucleic acid than plant or animal cells, and eating too much nucleic acid raises uric acid in the body, so the process includes a step that breaks it down.
Mushrooms themselves are a modest protein food, roughly 2 to 4 percent protein fresh, because they are mostly water. Dried, they are far richer, and mushroom powders are used as flavourings because they carry umami, the savoury taste. The protein in fungi is generally of good quality, with a fair balance of essential amino acids, though it is often a little short of methionine, the same gap found in legumes.
How mycoprotein is grown
Mycoprotein is grown in a continuous fermentation, which means the tank keeps running while fresh feed flows in and product flows out, instead of being filled, grown and emptied in batches. The tank, called a fermenter or bioreactor, holds tens of thousands of litres. Inside it, the fungus is kept at a steady temperature, near 28 to 30 degrees Celsius, with air bubbled through to supply O₂, and the pH held near 6. The feed is a glucose syrup, often made from wheat starch, with ammonia as a nitrogen source and added salts.
The fungus grows fast, doubling in a few hours, and the threads tangle into a mass that must be kept moving so that O₂ and feed reach every part. The harvest is a slurry of fine threads. That slurry is heated to about 65 degrees Celsius for a short time, which lowers the nucleic acid content, then it is spun to remove water, mixed with a binder such as egg white or potato protein, and shaped. The shaping step is where texture is made: the threads line up as they pass through the shaping machine, giving a fibrous bite that resembles meat.
A continuous process has a clear advantage: once it is running, it produces steadily, day and night, using little land. Its weakness is that a contamination, an unwanted microbe getting into the tank, can spoil a whole run, so the tanks are built to keep everything sterile, and the feed, air and water are all filtered or heated first. The energy cost is real too: stirring a large tank, pumping air and keeping the temperature steady all use electricity, and that energy must come from somewhere, so the footprint of mycoprotein depends on the power source as much as on the fungus.
Yeasts: small cells, large protein
Yeasts are single celled fungi, and some species are grown purely for their protein. Nutritional yeast, the flaky yellow powder sold in health food shops, is a deactivated yeast, which means it is heated so it can no longer grow, and it is eaten for its savoury flavour and its protein and B vitamins. Torula yeast and other species are grown on by-products such as molasses or wood sugars, turning a waste stream into a protein ingredient.
Yeast protein is rich in lysine and short of methionine, and it carries a strong savoury flavour from the glutamic acid inside the cells, which is why yeast extracts are used as flavourings in soups, sauces and snacks. The cells also hold B vitamins, including B12 in fortified products, though yeast does not make B12 on its own: the vitamin is added during production. Yeast cells have tough walls, so the protein is easier for the body to use when the cells are broken open, a step called autolysis, where the yeast's own enzymes break the walls down.
A worked example shows the scale of yeast growth. A yeast cell doubles in about two hours under good conditions. Starting from one gram of yeast, after 24 hours of doubling every two hours there would be twelve doublings, and one gram would become about 4,000 grams if nothing limited growth. In a real tank, feed, O₂ and space limit growth long before that, and the harvest is a steady stream rather than an explosion. The arithmetic still shows why microbes are attractive: no other protein source multiplies as fast.
Microalgae: protein from sunlight and water
Microalgae are single celled organisms that photosynthesise, using sunlight, water and CO₂ to build their own food. The best known food species are Chlorella and Spirulina, the second of which is a cyanobacterium, often grouped with algae in food talk. Both are sold as dried powders and tablets, and both are rich in protein: dried Spirulina holds roughly 55 to 65 percent protein, and dried Chlorella roughly 50 to 60 percent. They also carry iron, pigments and vitamins, and their protein quality is good, with all essential amino acids present in useful amounts.
Growing microalgae needs light, and that is both the strength and the problem. In open ponds, sunlight is free, but the culture is open to contamination, to evaporation, and to weather. In closed tubes or flat panels, called photobioreactors, the culture is controlled and clean, but the equipment costs far more, and the tubes must be kept clear so light reaches the cells. The cells are harvested by spinning or filtering, then dried, often by spray drying, which turns the slurry into a fine powder.
The flavour is the main barrier to wider use. Microalgae taste green, grassy and sometimes fishy, and their colour is a strong green or blue green, which limits where they can go. A small amount, 1 to 2 percent, can be added to a pasta, a cracker or a smoothie without spoiling it, and the colour can even be a selling point in a green food. Larger amounts need flavour masking, and that is why most algae protein today is sold as a supplement or a niche ingredient rather than as the main protein in a burger.
Seaweed and the wider algae family
Seaweeds, also called macroalgae, are the large algae of the sea: kelp, nori, wakame and dulse. They are eaten widely in East Asia and in coastal communities elsewhere, usually as a vegetable or a wrap rather than as a protein food, because their protein is modest, roughly 5 to 20 percent when dried, and they are valued more for minerals, fibre and flavour. Nori, the sheet used to wrap sushi, is one of the richer seaweeds for protein, near 30 percent when dried.
Seaweed farming needs no fresh water, no fertiliser and no farmland, and it can clean coastal water by taking up excess nutrients. That makes it attractive as a sustainable crop, and its extracts, such as agar and carrageenan, are already used as gelling and thickening agents in foods around the world. As a protein source, though, seaweed is a minor player: the amounts people eat are small, and the protein is not the reason it is on the plate.
The lesson from both microalgae and seaweed is that a high protein percentage on a dry basis does not by itself make a useful protein food. What matters is how much a person actually eats, how the protein is digested, how it tastes, and what it costs to grow, harvest and dry. A powder that is 60 percent protein but eaten at 5 g a day gives only 3 g of protein, while a food that is 20 percent protein and eaten at 100 g gives 20 g. Serving size and habit decide the real contribution.
Safety, allergy and the newness question
Fungal and algal proteins raise the same safety questions as any new protein, plus a few of their own. Mycoprotein has been eaten for decades and is accepted in many countries, but a small number of people react to it with allergy, and its label must name the source fungus. New fungal species and new algae species are tested before they are sold: the tests look for toxins, for allergy risk, and for how the protein is digested.
Nucleic acid is a special concern for microbial proteins. Cells that grow fast hold more RNA, and eating large amounts of RNA raises uric acid, which can cause gout in people who are prone to it. That is why mycoprotein is heated to cut its RNA content, and why any new microbial protein must report its nucleic acid level and the step that controls it. A product that skips that step would not be accepted by a food safety authority.
Algae bring a different risk: they can take up heavy metals from their water, and open pond cultures can be contaminated by other microbes or by toxins from wild algae. A maker must test each batch for metals and microbes, and must grow the culture in controlled water. The general rule for all of these proteins is simple and strict: newness is not a fault, but it is a reason to test, and the tests are done before the food reaches the shop, not after.
Harvesting microalgae: from pond to powder
Microalgae grow as tiny cells in water, and the hardest step in making an algal protein is getting the cells out of the water. A pond or a tank may hold only a few grams of cells per litre, so harvesting means handling a huge volume of water to collect a small amount of cells. The first step is usually flocculation: adding a substance, or changing the pH, so the cells clump together into larger flakes that settle faster. The flakes are then collected by settling, by floating them with fine bubbles, or by a centrifuge that spins them out.
The second step is breaking the cells open, because the algal cell wall is tough and it shields the protein from digestive enzymes. The cells are broken by a homogeniser, by bead milling, or by an enzyme that dissolves the wall, and the broken cells release their protein, their oil and their pigments. The protein is then separated from the oil and the green pigments, because a green, fishy powder will not sell in a plain food, and the pigments and the oil are sold separately: the oil for nutrition, the pigments for colour.
The third step is drying. The wet paste is spray dried into a powder, and the powder is tested for protein, for microbes, for heavy metals and for flavour. The drying must be gentle, because harsh heat darkens the powder and damages the protein, and the powder must be packed dry and sealed, because it picks up moisture and odours easily. A maker who judges an algal protein only by its protein content is missing the story: the harvest, the breaking and the drying decide whether the powder is usable at all.
The diagram shows algal harvesting in order. The flocculation step is what makes the harvest possible, because a pond holds only a few grams of cells per litre of water.
Questions to think about
- Why is mycoprotein heated after harvest, and what would happen if that step were skipped?
- Microalgae powder is 60 percent protein, but a person eats only 5 g a day. How much protein does that really give, and why does serving size matter more than the percentage?
- Open ponds are cheaper than closed tubes for growing algae. Why would a maker still choose the tubes?
Think about the mycoprotein heating step before you read on
The heating step cuts the nucleic acid, mainly RNA, in the fungal cells. Without it, eating large amounts of mycoprotein would raise uric acid in the body, which can cause gout. The heat breaks the RNA down, so the finished food can be eaten in normal serving sizes without that risk.
The diagram shows the mycoprotein process in order. The heating step is a safety step, not a cooking step, and the shaping step is where the meat like texture is made.
Practical note: In a practical session, compare three fungal foods: fresh button mushrooms, dried shiitake, and a mycoprotein piece from a shop. Weigh 100 g of each fresh, then dry the mushroom samples in a low oven until their weight stops falling, and record the dried weight. Work out the water percentage of each, then read the protein per 100 g from the labels and work out the protein per 100 g of dry matter. Note how the ranking changes once water is taken out of the comparison.
Quick self-check
Question: Why does a continuous fermentation suit mycoprotein production?
Because the fungus grows fast and steadily, so a tank that keeps running with fresh feed flowing in and product flowing out gives a steady supply day and night, using little land. The trade off is that a contamination can spoil a whole run, so sterility matters.
Question: Why must yeast cells be broken open before their protein is fully useful?
Because yeast cells have tough walls that the body cannot easily break down. Autolysis, where the yeast's own enzymes break the walls, frees the protein inside so it can be digested and used.
Question: Why must algal cells be broken open before the protein can be used?
Because the algal cell wall is tough and it shields the protein from digestive enzymes, so an unbroken cell passes through the body with its protein still locked inside. Breaking the wall lets the enzymes reach the protein.
Try it yourself
Buy a small pack of dried Spirulina or Chlorella powder and a pack of fresh mushrooms. Stir half a teaspoon of the algae powder into a glass of water and taste it, then stir the same amount into a smoothie or a soup and taste again: how much does the other food hide the flavour? Cook the mushrooms in a dry pan until they release their water and brown, and note the smell and the savoury taste. Write down three foods where the algae colour and flavour would be acceptable, and three where they would not, and give one reason for each choice.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Fungi grow as mycelium threads or single yeast cells, and they turn feed into protein far faster than a crop or an animal.
- Mycoprotein is grown in a continuous fermentation, heated to cut nucleic acid, then shaped into fibrous pieces that chew like meat.
- Yeast protein is rich in lysine and savoury in flavour, and its cells must be broken open for the protein to be fully used.
- Microalgae such as Spirulina and Chlorella are 50 to 65 percent protein when dried, but their strong flavour and colour limit how much can be used.
- Seaweed is valued for minerals, fibre and gelling extracts, not as a main protein food, because people eat it in small amounts.
- A high protein percentage means little without serving size: 5 g of a 60 percent powder gives only 3 g of protein.
New microbial proteins must be tested for toxins, allergy and nucleic acid before they are sold, not after.
Harvesting microalgae means flocculating dilute cells, collecting them, breaking the tough walls, separating protein from oil and pigment, and drying gently.
Glossary
Autolysis
Self breakdown of cells by their own enzymes, used to open yeast cells. Food tech example: autolysed yeast extract is used as a savoury flavouring in soups.
Bioreactor
A tank or vessel where microbes are grown under controlled conditions. Food tech example: mycoprotein is grown in a large bioreactor with air, feed and temperature control.
Chlorella
A green microalga sold as a dried powder rich in protein. Food tech example: Chlorella powder is added in small amounts to green smoothies and pasta.
Continuous fermentation
A fermentation that keeps running while fresh feed flows in and product flows out. Food tech example: mycoprotein is made by continuous fermentation, giving a steady supply.
Cyanobacterium
A microbe that photosynthesises like algae, including Spirulina. Food tech example: Spirulina is a cyanobacterium sold as a protein rich powder.
Fermenter
Another name for a bioreactor, a tank where fermentation takes place. Food tech example: the fermenter for mycoprotein holds tens of thousands of litres.
Mycelium
The network of fine threads that makes up most of a fungus. Food tech example: the mycelium of the mycoprotein fungus is harvested as fine threads.
Mycoprotein
Protein food made from a fungus grown in fermentation tanks. Food tech example: mycoprotein pieces are shaped to chew like chicken.
Nucleic acid
The molecules RNA and DNA inside cells, which must be limited in microbial protein foods. Food tech example: mycoprotein is heated to cut its RNA content before shaping.
Nutritional yeast
Deactivated yeast eaten for its savoury flavour, protein and B vitamins. Food tech example: nutritional yeast flakes are sprinkled on pasta as a cheese like seasoning.
Photobioreactor
A closed transparent tank or tube where algae are grown in controlled light. Food tech example: algae grown in a photobioreactor stay clean but cost more to grow.
Spirulina
A blue green cyanobacterium sold as a dried powder, about 55 to 65 percent protein. Food tech example: Spirulina powder colours a smoothie green and adds protein.
Umami
The savoury taste found in mushrooms, soy sauce and yeast extract. Food tech example: dried shiitake powder adds umami to a soup without adding meat.
Uric acid
A substance the body makes when it breaks down nucleic acids, which can cause gout in high amounts. Food tech example: cutting RNA in mycoprotein keeps uric acid from rising after eating it.
Carrageenan
A gelling and thickening extract from red seaweed. Food tech example: carrageenan sets a dairy free dessert and thickens a sauce.
Agar
A gelling extract from seaweed that sets at room temperature. Food tech example: agar is used to set jellies and to grow microbes in a laboratory dish.
Flocculation
Making tiny cells clump together into larger flakes that settle faster. Food tech example: flocculation lets a maker harvest algae from a dilute pond.
Cell wall
The tough outer layer of a microbial or algal cell. Food tech example: breaking the algal cell wall lets digestive enzymes reach the protein.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 4: Insect Protein
Note
Unit 4: Insect Protein
A question to start with
In a market in Thailand, a vendor fries grasshoppers with chilli and lime, and buyers eat them by the handful like crisps. In a village in Mexico, chapulines, seasoned grasshoppers, are sold in paper cones. In much of Europe and North America, the same food makes shoppers pause, even though the insects are rich in protein, need little land, and are already eaten by about two billion people around the world. This unit looks at insect protein without flinching and without cheerleading: which insects are used, how they are farmed, what their protein is like, how they are turned into food, and what stands in the way of wider use.
An old food in many cultures
Eating insects has a name: entomophagy. It is practised in many parts of Asia, Africa and Latin America, where insects are gathered or farmed as a seasonal food. Grasshoppers, crickets, mealworms, palm weevil larvae, ants and termites are among the most eaten. They are usually roasted, fried or ground, and they are valued for flavour and crunch as much as for protein. The idea that insects are not food is a cultural habit of some regions, not a fact of nature, and it is worth naming that plainly before any technical discussion.
The insects used in modern food production are mostly farmed, not gathered. The main species are the house cricket, the yellow mealworm beetle larva, and the black soldier fly larva. Crickets and mealworms are farmed for human food. Black soldier fly larvae are farmed mainly for animal feed, turning food waste into protein for poultry and fish, though their use in human food is also being studied. Farming brings control: the feed is known, the conditions are steady, and the harvest is clean, which matters for safety.
A short history helps here. Insects were eaten in Europe in earlier centuries too, and they appear in old accounts of famine food, but they fell out of the diet as farming changed and as meat became cheaper. Their return is driven by the same forces as the rest of this subject: the search for protein that needs less land and feed, and the willingness of a new generation of eaters to try foods their parents did not.
Farming insects: feed, space and growth
Insect farming is simple in outline and demanding in detail. The insects are kept in stacked trays or bins in a warm, humid room, fed on grains, bran or food by-products, and harvested when they reach the right size. Crickets take about six to eight weeks to reach harvest size. Mealworms take about ten to twelve weeks. Black soldier fly larvae grow far faster, reaching harvest in about two weeks, which is why they are favoured for turning waste into feed.
Feed is the key to both cost and safety. Insects can be fed on clean grain and bran, which is safe but costs money, or on by-products such as spent grain from brewing, which is cheaper and turns a waste into a resource. What they must not be fed is manure or mixed waste of unknown origin, because anything in the feed can end up in the insect, and the rules in most countries say so. The feed list is therefore a safety document as much as a cost choice.
Space is where insects score well. Trays stack vertically, so a room the size of a small warehouse can hold a large production, using far less land than a field of soy or a herd of cattle. The insects are cold blooded, which means they do not spend feed energy on keeping warm, and a larger share of the feed becomes body mass. Water use is also low: insects drink little, and their feed carries most of the moisture they need. These are real advantages, but they are advantages of the farm, not of the plate, and the plate is where the next section matters.
What insect protein is like
Dried insects are rich in protein. Dried crickets hold roughly 55 to 65 percent protein, dried mealworms roughly 45 to 55 percent, and dried black soldier fly larvae roughly 35 to 45 percent. These are dry basis figures, and they shift with species, feed and life stage. Fresh insects are mostly water, so the protein per 100 g fresh is far lower, near 15 to 20 percent, which is close to meat. The fat content is also notable: crickets hold about 20 percent fat when dried, and mealworms more, and that fat includes both saturated and unsaturated fats.
The amino acid pattern of insect protein is good. It supplies all nine essential amino acids, and it is generally richer in lysine than grains and richer in methionine than legumes, which makes it a useful complement to both. Digestibility is good when the insects are processed well, though the hard outer shell, the exoskeleton, is made of chitin, a fibre the body cannot digest. Chitin is counted as fibre, and it can lower digestibility a little if the shell is left whole, which is why many products grind the insects finely or remove the shell.
Insects also carry minerals: iron, zinc and calcium are all present in useful amounts, and the iron in insects is absorbed better than the iron in many plants, though not as well as the iron in red meat. They carry B vitamins too, including B12 in some species. A fair summary is that insect protein is a complete, well digested protein with useful minerals, and its weak point is not nutrition but the shell, the flavour, and the eater's willingness to try it.
From insect to ingredient
The route from a live insect to a food ingredient has four steps: kill, dry, grind, and use. Killing is usually done by blanching in hot water or by freezing, both of which also cut the microbial load. Drying follows, in a hot air dryer or a freeze dryer, until the moisture is low enough to keep the product safe, usually below 10 percent. The dried insects are then milled into a flour or powder, which is the ingredient that food makers buy.
Insect flour is brown, fine, and nutty in flavour, with a mild earthy note. It is used in bars, biscuits, pasta, bread and shakes, usually at 5 to 15 percent of the recipe, where it adds protein without dominating the flavour. Whole insects are also sold as snacks, roasted and seasoned, and they keep their crunch, which is part of their appeal. The flour route hides the insect, which helps shoppers who are willing to eat the protein but not to see the legs, and that is a deliberate choice by makers, not a trick: the label must still name the insect.
A worked example shows the numbers. A protein bar of 50 g uses insect flour at 10 percent of the recipe, which is 5 g of flour. At 60 percent protein, that flour gives 3 g of protein to the bar. To make the bar a high protein bar, the maker would need more flour, or a second protein such as pea or whey, because 3 g is a modest amount. The example shows why insect flour is often a partner protein, not the only protein, in a product: its flavour and cost limit how much can be used, even when its nutrition is good.
Safety and allergy: the shell matters
Insect food must pass the same safety tests as any new food, and the insect brings two specific concerns. The first is microbes: insects raised in warm, humid trays can carry bacteria, and the killing and drying steps must cut those numbers to safe levels. The second is allergy, and it is the more important one for the eater. Insects are arthropods, related to crustaceans such as prawns and crabs, and people who are allergic to prawns can also react to insects, because the proteins are similar. The main culprit is a protein called tropomyosin, found in the muscle of both groups.
That cross allergy is why labels must name the insect clearly, and why a product that uses insect flour must also warn people with a crustacean allergy. A maker cannot hide the insect in a list of vague ingredients: the name must be plain, and the warning must be plain too. This is not a reason to ban insect food, any more than prawn allergy is a reason to ban prawns. It is a reason to label well and to tell the truth on the pack.
Microbial safety is managed by the process. Blanching in hot water kills most bacteria, drying to low moisture stops the rest from growing, and the finished flour is tested for counts of bacteria and for specific pathogens. The farm must also keep the insects away from wild insects and from contaminants in the feed. A clean farm, a hot kill step, a thorough dry, and a batch test: those four habits are the backbone of insect food safety, and they are checked by the food safety authority before the product is sold.
Will people eat it? Acceptance and the future
Acceptance is the largest barrier for insect protein in regions where insects are not already food. Studies of shoppers find the same pattern again and again: many people say they will eat a bar or a biscuit that contains insect flour, far fewer say they will eat a whole visible insect, and the gap closes when the eater has tried the food once and liked it. Taste, not argument, changes minds, and that is why makers start with familiar foods, bars, biscuits and pasta, where the insect is a flour and the eating experience is normal.
Price is the second barrier. Insect flour still costs more per kilogram than pea or soy protein, because farms are small and the drying and milling steps are costly. As farms grow and the process is automated, the price should fall, but it has not yet reached the level where insect protein can compete on price alone. Its case rests on nutrition, on sustainability, and on the story of turning by-products into food, not on being the cheapest protein on the shelf.
The future of insect protein is likely to be mixed: whole insects as snacks in regions where they are already eaten, insect flour as a partner protein in bars and baked goods elsewhere, and black soldier fly larvae as a large scale feed protein that takes pressure off soy and fishmeal in animal feed. That last use may matter most for the planet, even though the eater never sees the insect: every tonne of feed made from larvae is a tonne of soy or fish that was not needed. A food technologist who understands that chain, from waste to larvae to feed to food, understands where insect protein earns its place.
Feed conversion: how much feed makes a kilogram of insect protein
An insect farm is judged by its feed conversion ratio, the amount of feed needed to make a kilogram of insect, and the ratio decides whether the farm pays. The ratio is worked out by dividing the feed eaten by the weight gained: if 2 kg of feed makes 1 kg of insects, the ratio is 2 to 1. A lower ratio means a more efficient farm, because less feed is needed for each kilogram of insect, and the feed is the largest cost in the farm.
A worked example shows the step to protein. A farm feeds 2,000 kg of feed to a batch of larvae, and the batch gains 1,000 kg of live larvae, so the feed conversion ratio is 2 to 1. The larvae are dried, and the dry larvae hold about 50 percent protein, so 1,000 kg of live larvae, dried to about 300 kg of dry matter, holds about 150 kg of protein. The feed needed per kilogram of protein is therefore 2,000 divided by 150, which is about 13.3 kg of feed per kilogram of protein. That number is the one the farm watches, because it links the feed bill directly to the protein sold.
The ratio depends on the feed. Insects fed on grain convert it well but the grain could have fed people directly, so the gain is small. Insects fed on side streams, such as the parts of food that would otherwise be thrown away, convert a waste into protein, and the gain is large even if the ratio is worse. The temperature matters too: insects grow fastest in the warm, and a cold farm feeds the same insects for longer to reach the same weight. The maker who quotes a feed conversion ratio without naming the feed and the temperature is quoting a number without its meaning.
Questions to think about
- Why must an insect flour label name the insect plainly, and who is the warning for?
- A protein bar uses 5 g of insect flour at 60 percent protein. How much protein does that add, and why would the maker add a second protein?
- Insects are cold blooded and stack in trays. How do those two facts cut the land and feed needed per kilogram of protein?
Think about the allergy warning before you read on
Insects are arthropods, related to prawns and crabs, and they share a muscle protein called tropomyosin. People allergic to prawns can react to insects too, so the label must name the insect and warn people with a crustacean allergy. Clear labelling lets those people avoid the food while others enjoy it.
The diagram shows the insect ingredient chain. The kill step and the drying step are the safety steps, and the milling step is what turns a visible insect into a flour a cautious shopper will try.
Practical note: In a practical session, compare the protein per 100 g on the labels of three foods: a cricket flour bar, a peanut bar, and a whey protein bar, all of the same weight. Work out the protein per bar, the protein per unit of price, and the ingredient that supplies the protein in each one. Then read the allergy warning on each label and write down which allergens are named. Note how the insect bar names its source and whether it warns about crustacean allergy.
Quick self-check
Question: What is chitin, and why does it matter for insect protein?
Chitin is the tough fibre that makes up the insect exoskeleton, the hard outer shell. The body cannot digest it, so it counts as fibre and can lower digestibility a little if the shell is left whole, which is why many products grind insects finely or remove the shell.
Question: Why are black soldier fly larvae farmed mainly for feed, not for human food?
Because they grow in about two weeks on food by-products, turning waste into protein for poultry and fish. That use takes pressure off soy and fishmeal in animal feed, and it is the largest scale use of insect protein today.
Question: A farm feeds 2,000 kg of feed and gains 1,000 kg of larvae. What is the feed conversion ratio?
2 to 1, because 2,000 divided by 1,000 is 2. A lower ratio means a more efficient farm, because less feed is needed for each kilogram of insect.
Try it yourself
Buy a small pack of roasted seasoned crickets or a cricket flour bar from a health food shop or online. Taste the whole insects first if you bought them, noting the crunch, the salt and the flavour. Then try the bar, noting whether you can taste the insect at all. Ask two friends or family members to taste a piece each without telling them what it is, then tell them, and write down their honest reactions before and after. Answer in writing: did the flavour or the idea matter more to them, and what would make them buy it again?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Eating insects is an old and widespread practice, and the reluctance in some regions is cultural, not a fact of nature.
- Crickets, mealworms and black soldier fly larvae are the main farmed species, and they grow fast in stacked trays on grain or by-products.
- Dried insects hold roughly 45 to 65 percent protein, with all essential amino acids and useful iron, zinc and calcium.
- Chitin in the shell counts as fibre and can lower digestibility, so many products grind insects finely or remove the shell.
- Insect flour is used at 5 to 15 percent in bars, biscuits and pasta, often beside a second protein, because flavour and cost limit the amount.
- People allergic to prawns can react to insects because both share the protein tropomyosin, so labels must name the insect and warn clearly.
The largest near term use may be black soldier fly larvae as animal feed, turning waste into protein and easing pressure on soy and fishmeal.
Feed conversion ratio, feed eaten divided by weight gained, links the feed bill to the protein sold, and it depends on the feed and the temperature.
Glossary
Black soldier fly
A fly whose larvae grow fast on food by-products and are farmed for feed protein. Food tech example: black soldier fly larvae turn spent grain into protein for poultry feed.
Blanching
Brief heating in hot water to kill microbes and stop enzymes. Food tech example: insects are blanched before drying to cut their microbial load.
Chitin
The tough fibre that forms the insect exoskeleton. Food tech example: chitin in whole insects counts as fibre and is removed or ground fine in insect flour.
Cricket flour
A fine powder made by drying and milling crickets. Food tech example: cricket flour is added at 10 percent to a protein bar.
Cross allergy
An allergy to one food that also causes a reaction to a related food. Food tech example: a prawn allergy can cross react with insects because both share tropomyosin.
Entomophagy
The practice of eating insects as food. Food tech example: entomophagy is common in parts of Asia, Africa and Latin America.
Exoskeleton
The hard outer shell of an insect. Food tech example: the exoskeleton is ground fine or removed when insects are milled into flour.
Mealworm
The larva of a darkling beetle, farmed as a protein food. Food tech example: dried mealworms are milled into flour for biscuits and pasta.
Tropomyosin
A muscle protein shared by insects and crustaceans that can trigger allergy. Food tech example: tropomyosin is why an insect flour label warns people with a prawn allergy.
Cold blooded
Not using feed energy to keep a steady warm body temperature. Food tech example: insects are cold blooded, so more of their feed becomes body mass than in a warm blooded animal.
By-product
A useful material left over from another process. Food tech example: spent grain from brewing is a by-product fed to farmed insects.
Freeze dryer
A dryer that removes water by freezing and then turning ice directly into vapour. Food tech example: freeze dried insects keep their shape and flavour better than hot air dried ones.
Chapulines
Seasoned grasshoppers eaten as a snack in Mexico. Food tech example: chapulines are sold in paper cones in markets as a crunchy seasoned snack.
Arthropod
An animal with a hard outer shell and jointed legs, including insects and crustaceans. Food tech example: insects and prawns are both arthropods, which is why their proteins can cross react.
Digestibility
How much of a food's protein the body can break down and use. Food tech example: insect protein digestibility is good when the shell is ground fine, and lower when it is left whole.
Feed conversion ratio
Feed eaten divided by weight gained, which judges how efficiently an animal turns feed into body weight. Food tech example: a ratio of 2 to 1 means 2 kg of feed makes 1 kg of larvae.
Side stream
A stream of material that leaves a process beside the main product. Food tech example: insects fed on side streams turn a waste into protein.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 5: Hybrid Products: Blending Plant and Animal
Note
Unit 5: Hybrid Products: Blending Plant and Animal
A question to start with
A butcher in a test kitchen mixes minced beef with cooked lentils, half and half, and shapes the mix into burgers. On the grill they brown like beef burgers. At the table, tasters call them juicy and meaty, and most cannot tell that half the meat is missing. The same idea is now on supermarket shelves: burgers, sausages and nuggets that blend meat with plant protein, cutting cost and footprint while keeping the taste and chew that shoppers expect. This unit is about those hybrids: why makers blend, which blends work, how the two proteins behave together, and how honest labelling keeps the shopper informed.
Why blend at all
A hybrid product blends animal protein with plant protein in one food. The simplest reason is cost: plant protein usually costs less per kilogram than meat, so replacing a third of the meat with a plant protein cuts the recipe cost while keeping the product familiar. The second reason is footprint: less meat means less land, less feed and fewer gas releases per kilogram of finished food. The third reason is nutrition: a blend can add fibre, which meat lacks, and cut saturated fat, if the plant part replaces fatty meat rather than lean meat.
Blending is also a gentler step for the shopper than a full switch. A person who would not buy a fully plant based burger may buy a burger that is half beef and half pea, because it still tastes like beef. Food companies call this a bridge product: it moves the diet in a new direction without asking the eater to give up a familiar food. That bridge matters, because most change in diets happens gradually, one meal at a time, not in a single leap.
There is a fourth reason that matters to makers: supply security. Meat prices swing with feed costs, disease and weather. A recipe that can flex, using more plant protein when meat is dear and more meat when it is cheap, protects the factory from price shocks. The blend must still meet the label every time, so the flex has limits, but a recipe with two protein sources is less exposed than a recipe with one.
Which blends work
The most common hybrid is a burger or sausage that blends minced meat with a plant protein. Beef with pea protein or soy protein is the classic pair. Pork with soy is common in sausages. Chicken with mushroom or with chickpea flour is used in nuggets and patties. Dairy hybrids exist too: a yoghurt or a cheese that blends milk protein with a plant protein, or a drink that blends milk with oat or soy.
The blend ratio is the first decision, and it is usually set by taste panels, not by arithmetic. A 70 percent meat to 30 percent plant blend is a common starting point: the meat still sets the flavour and the chew, and the plant part is hard to detect. At 50 percent plant, the flavour changes clearly, and the maker must add flavourings, fat and colour to bring the product back. Above 50 percent plant, the product is closer to a plant based food with some meat in it, and the label and the marketing must say so plainly.
Each plant partner brings its own behaviour. Textured soy protein absorbs the meat juices and holds them, which keeps a burger juicy. Pea protein isolate binds water and gives a firm bite. Mushroom adds moisture and umami, the savoury taste, and it browns well. Lentil and chickpea flours add fibre and a soft texture, but they also add starch, which can make a patty crumbly if too much is used. A maker tests several partners at several ratios and picks the one that scores best on taste, texture, cost and nutrition together.
How the two proteins behave together
Meat protein and plant protein behave differently when heated, and a hybrid must manage both. Meat proteins, mainly myosin and actin in the muscle fibres, shrink and squeeze out water as they cook, which is why an overcooked burger is dry. Plant proteins, when heated, unfold and link into a gel that traps water. In a blend, the plant gel can catch some of the water the meat squeezes out, so the cooked burger stays juicier than a pure meat burger cooked the same way. That water holding is one of the real technical benefits of blending.
Fat behaves differently too. Meat fat melts and bastes the product from inside as it cooks. Plant fats, such as sunflower or rapeseed oil, are liquid at room temperature and must be held in place by the protein gel, or they leak out. Makers often add the plant oil as an emulsion, tiny droplets wrapped in protein, so it stays put during cooking. The choice of fat changes the nutrition: replacing animal fat with a plant oil cuts saturated fat, but it also changes flavour, because much of the flavour of meat sits in its fat.
Salt, pH and temperature all shift the blend. Salt helps meat proteins dissolve and bind, which is why sausages are salty, and it helps plant proteins gel too, up to a point. A pH near 6 suits most blends, and moving far from it can make the gel weak or the colour grey. Cooking temperature must be high enough to set the plant gel and to cook the meat safely, usually to at least 70 degrees Celsius at the centre for minced meat, and that temperature is a food safety rule, not a suggestion.
Making a hybrid in the factory
A hybrid burger line looks much like a normal burger line, with one extra step: the plant protein is hydrated first. Textured soy protein is soaked in water until it swells, often at two to three parts water to one part dry protein. Pea isolate is mixed with water into a paste. That hydrated protein is then mixed with the minced meat, the fat, the salt, the flavourings and any binder, in a bowl mixer or a blender, until the mix is even. The mix is then formed into patties, frozen or chilled, and packed.
The mixing time matters. Too little mixing leaves pockets of plant protein that show as pale spots. Too much mixing overworks the meat, making the patty rubbery. The forming machine must handle a mix that is softer than pure meat, because the plant part holds water and the mix can stick. Factories tune the water level carefully: each extra percent of water cuts cost and adds juiciness, but too much water makes the patty fall apart on the grill and the label must still be honest about how much meat is in it.
Quality checks on a hybrid line include the meat content, the protein content, the fat content, the weight of each patty, and the cooking loss, which is the weight lost when the patty is grilled. A typical cooking loss for a beef burger is about 20 to 25 percent of its raw weight. A well made hybrid can lose less, near 15 to 20 percent, because the plant gel holds water. That lower loss is a selling point for the maker and a benefit for the eater, who gets a juicier burger for the same raw weight.
Labelling a hybrid honestly
A hybrid must be labelled so the shopper knows exactly what they are buying. The name must not mislead: a product that is half beef and half pea cannot be called a beef burger without qualification, and in most countries the name must reflect the blend, such as a beef and pea burger. The ingredient list must name every protein in descending order of weight, so the shopper can see which comes first. The meat content, where the law asks for it, must be stated, and any claim such as high in protein or reduced fat must meet the legal definition for that claim.
Allergy labelling is part of honesty too. A hybrid that uses soy or wheat must name those allergens, even though the shopper may have bought the product thinking of it as a meat burger. A shopper with a soy allergy who eats a beef burger that hides soy in the blend is at risk, and the label is the protection. The same rule applies to the plant part of a dairy hybrid: a milk and oat drink must name oat and milk, not only milk.
Claims about footprint need the same care. A hybrid that uses 30 percent less meat does not automatically have a 30 percent smaller footprint, because the plant part has its own footprint from farming and processing. A maker who wants to claim a lower footprint must count the whole product, using a life cycle assessment, and must be ready to show the numbers. A vague claim such as greener or better for the planet, without numbers, is not a claim a careful maker should print.
The future of hybrids
Hybrids are likely to grow, because they ask the least of the shopper and the least of the factory. A meat factory can add a plant protein line without rebuilding the plant. A shopper can buy a familiar product at a lower price. A government that wants diets to shift can support hybrids without banning anything. That combination of low friction and real benefit is rare in food change, and it is why many analysts expect hybrids to sell more, sooner, than fully plant based products in some markets.
The science will keep improving the blends. New plant proteins with cleaner flavours, better gels and lower cost will let the plant share rise without the taste falling. Better fat emulsions will hold plant oils in place during cooking. Better flavourings, built from yeast extracts and from the browning reactions of cooking, will cover the beany notes that still betray a blend. Each improvement moves the balance a little further toward plants, and the blend ratio that is 70 to 30 today may be 50 to 50 in a few years, with no loss of eating quality.
The risk to watch is trust. If shoppers feel misled, if a burger labelled as beef turns out to be mostly pea, or if a footprint claim turns out to be empty, the whole category suffers. The defence is the one this subject repeats in every unit: name the ingredients plainly, measure the nutrition, count the footprint honestly, and let the shopper decide with true information. A hybrid that is honest about what it is will keep its buyers, and a hybrid that is not will lose them.
Blending by numbers: a worked example
A hybrid recipe is built by numbers before it is built in a bowl, and the numbers are a weighted average: each part contributes its protein in proportion to its share. The derivation is simple. A recipe holds parts with weights w1, w2 and w3, and protein fractions p1, p2 and p3. The protein in the finished food is w1 times p1, plus w2 times p2, plus w3 times p3, all divided by the total weight. That is the whole derivation, and it is worth doing by hand once, because it is how every hybrid recipe is checked against its label.
A worked example shows it. A patty weighs 100 g. It holds 40 g of minced beef at 20 percent protein, which gives 8 g of protein. It holds 30 g of hydrated textured soy at 15 percent protein, which gives 4.5 g. It holds 10 g of pea isolate at 85 percent protein, which gives 8.5 g. The other 20 g are water, fat, seasoning and binder, which give little protein. The total protein is 8 plus 4.5 plus 8.5, which is 21 g per 100 g, and the maker checks that number against the label by testing the finished patty, because the recipe on paper and the food in the pack can differ if the cooking loses water.
The same arithmetic shows the trade offs. Replacing 10 g of beef with 10 g more of textured soy cuts the protein by about 0.5 g, because beef holds 20 percent and the soy holds 15 percent, and it cuts the cost, because the soy is cheaper. Adding 5 g more pea isolate lifts the protein by about 4.3 g, but it adds a beany note and a higher cost. The maker adjusts the numbers until the protein, the cost and the taste all meet their targets, and the weighted average is the tool that makes the adjustment visible before a single patty is cooked.
Questions to think about
- Why is a 70 percent meat to 30 percent plant blend easier to sell than a 50 to 50 blend?
- A hybrid burger loses 15 percent of its weight on the grill while a beef burger loses 25 percent. What in the blend holds the water, and why does it matter?
- Why must a beef and soy burger name soy on the label even though the shopper bought it as a meat product?
Think about the cooking loss question before you read on
The plant protein forms a gel when heated, and that gel traps water that the meat proteins squeeze out as they shrink. The trapped water stays in the patty instead of dripping onto the grill, so the cooked burger weighs more and eats juicier. Lower cooking loss is a real benefit of the blend, not a trick of added water.
The diagram shows the hybrid burger line in order. Hydrating the plant protein first is the step that makes it blend evenly, and the label at the end is what keeps the product honest.
Practical note: In a practical session, make two batches of small patties: one from 200 g of minced beef alone, and one from 140 g of minced beef mixed with 60 g of hydrated textured soy protein. Season both the same way, form four patties from each batch, weigh each patty raw, grill them, and weigh each patty cooked. Work out the cooking loss as a percentage for each batch, then taste both and write down the differences in juiciness, flavour and texture. Compare your numbers with a classmate who used a different plant protein.
Quick self-check
Question: Why does a hybrid burger often stay juicier than a pure beef burger?
Because the plant protein forms a gel when heated that traps water squeezed out by the meat proteins as they shrink. The water stays in the patty instead of dripping away, so the cooked burger is juicier and loses less weight.
Question: What must the name of a hybrid product do, and why?
It must reflect the blend plainly, such as a beef and pea burger, so the shopper knows meat is only part of the product. A name that suggests pure meat would mislead the shopper and break labelling rules in most countries.
Question: A 100 g patty holds 40 g of beef at 20 percent protein and 30 g of textured soy at 15 percent protein. How much protein do those two parts give?
The beef gives 40 times 0.20, which is 8 g, and the soy gives 30 times 0.15, which is 4.5 g, so the two parts together give 12.5 g of protein.
Try it yourself
Buy a hybrid product from a shop, such as a burger or sausage that blends meat with a plant protein, and buy the pure meat version of the same product. Read both ingredient lists and write down the order of the proteins, the meat content if stated, and the protein, fat and salt per 100 g. Cook both the same way and compare the taste, the juiciness and the cooking loss by weighing before and after. Write down which one you would buy again and why, and whether the label told you enough to make that choice fairly.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Hybrids blend animal and plant protein to cut cost and footprint while keeping a familiar taste and chew.
- A 70 percent meat to 30 percent plant blend is a common starting point, because the meat still sets the flavour.
- Plant protein gels trap water that meat proteins squeeze out during cooking, so hybrids often lose less weight on the grill.
- Plant oils must be held in an emulsion or they leak during cooking, and replacing animal fat changes both nutrition and flavour.
- Hydrating the plant protein before mixing is the step that makes the blend even and stops pale spots in the patty.
- Hybrid labels must name the blend, list proteins in order, and name allergens such as soy or wheat plainly.
Footprint claims for a hybrid must count the whole product, not only the meat that was removed.
A hybrid recipe is checked by a weighted average: each part contributes its protein in proportion to its share, and the sum is checked against the label by testing.
Glossary
Bridge product
A food that moves eaters toward a new diet without asking them to give up a familiar food. Food tech example: a beef and pea burger is a bridge product for shoppers not ready for a fully plant based burger.
Cooking loss
The weight a food loses during cooking, mainly as water and fat. Food tech example: a beef burger loses about 20 to 25 percent of its raw weight on the grill.
Emulsion
A mixture where tiny droplets of one liquid are held inside another. Food tech example: plant oil is added to a hybrid as an emulsion so it stays in the patty during cooking.
Hybrid product
A food that blends animal protein with plant protein in one product. Food tech example: a sausage made from pork and soy protein is a hybrid product.
Hydrate
To soak a dry ingredient in water until it swells and softens. Food tech example: textured soy protein is hydrated with two to three parts water before it is mixed with meat.
Myosin
A main muscle protein that shrinks when meat is cooked. Food tech example: myosin shrinking squeezes water out of a beef burger on the grill.
Actin
A muscle protein that works with myosin in meat. Food tech example: actin and myosin together form the fibres that give meat its chew.
Textured soy protein
Soy protein shaped by extrusion into chewy pieces that resemble meat. Food tech example: hydrated textured soy protein is mixed with minced beef in a hybrid burger.
Umami
The savoury taste found in mushrooms, soy sauce and yeast extract. Food tech example: mushroom in a hybrid patty adds umami and moisture.
Life cycle assessment
A method that adds up the land, water, energy and gas releases of a product across its whole life. Food tech example: a hybrid burger claim must be checked by a life cycle assessment of the whole burger.
Saturated fat
A type of fat that is solid at room temperature and linked to heart health when eaten in large amounts. Food tech example: replacing beef fat with sunflower oil cuts the saturated fat in a hybrid burger.
Binder
An ingredient that holds a mixture together. Food tech example: pea protein isolate acts as a binder in a hybrid patty, holding water and fat in place.
Meat content
The share of a product that is meat, stated on the label where the law asks for it. Food tech example: a hybrid sausage label states its meat content so shoppers can compare it with a pure meat sausage.
Weighted average
An average where each part counts in proportion to its share. Food tech example: the protein of a hybrid is the weighted average of its parts.
Hydrated
Soaked in water until it has taken up liquid. Food tech example: textured soy is hydrated before it is mixed into a hybrid patty.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 6: Texture and Flavour: Extrusion and Formulation
Note
Unit 6: Texture and Flavour: Extrusion and Formulation
A question to start with
Bite into a plant based burger and your teeth meet fibres that pull apart like meat. Bite into a plant based sausage and it snaps, then yields, the way a pork sausage does. Neither texture happens by accident: both are built, step by step, in machines and in recipes. This unit explains how texture is built, how flavour is built, and how the two are tuned together. It covers extrusion, the machine at the heart of meat analogues, the ingredients that hold a product together, and the flavourings that make a pea taste like beef. By the end, you should be able to read a plant based label and see the machine and the recipe behind it.
What texture means, and how it is measured
Texture is what the mouth feels: firmness, chewiness, springiness, juiciness and how a food breaks apart. It is not one thing but a set of sensations, and food scientists measure it with machines as well as with taste panels. A texture analyser presses a probe into a sample and records the force, giving numbers for hardness and springiness. A taste panel of trained eaters scores the same sample for chewiness, juiciness and how meat like it feels. The two methods check each other: a machine number that does not match what eaters feel is a number without meaning.
Meat texture comes from structure. Muscle is built of long fibres bundled together, with fat and connective tissue between them. When you bite, the fibres pull apart along their length and resist across it, which is why meat feels fibrous rather than crumbly. A plant based food must copy that structure, and it does so by lining proteins up into fibres, then binding those fibres into a piece that holds together until the teeth pull it apart. That lining up is the job of extrusion, and the binding is the job of formulation.
A simple test shows the difference between a fibre and a crumb. Pull a piece of cooked chicken apart along the grain: it separates into strands. Pull a piece of tofu apart: it breaks into crumbs. The first is a fibrous structure, the second is a gel. A good meat analogue behaves like the chicken, not like the tofu, and every step in this unit is judged against that test.
Extrusion: the machine that makes fibres
An extruder is a machine with a long barrel, a screw turning inside it, and a shaped opening, called a die, at the end. Dry protein powder and water are fed in at one end. The screw pushes the mix forward while heaters warm the barrel and the pressure rises. Inside, the protein unfolds, melts into a thick paste, and flows toward the die. At the die, the paste is forced through a narrow slit and cooled, and as it cools the proteins line up into fibres. The sheet that comes out is then cut into pieces.
Two kinds of extrusion matter here. Low moisture extrusion makes dry, crunchy pieces such as textured soy protein: the feed holds about 20 to 30 percent water, the die lets steam escape, and the product puffs up as it leaves the die, then dries into a hard piece that must be soaked before use. High moisture extrusion makes wet, fibrous sheets that feel like meat at once: the feed holds about 50 to 70 percent water, the die is cooled so the product does not puff, and the sheet that comes out is moist, layered and chewy, ready to be cut and flavoured.
The settings decide the result. A hotter barrel unfolds the protein more, giving a firmer fibre. A faster screw pushes the mix through sooner, giving a softer product. More water gives a juicier sheet but a weaker fibre. The cooling die is the most delicate part: if it cools too fast, the outside sets before the inside lines up, and the sheet is uneven. Operators watch the temperature, the pressure and the look of the sheet, and they adjust in small steps, because a small change in water can change the texture from meat like to mushy.
Ingredients that build texture
Extrusion builds the fibre, but the recipe builds the rest of the texture. Binders hold the pieces together: methylcellulose is the best known, a plant fibre that gels when heated and melts when cooled, which is the opposite of most gels, and it is what lets a plant based burger hold together raw and then set firmly on the grill. Potato starch and wheat gluten also bind, and each brings its own behaviour: starch adds softness and holds water, gluten adds chew.
Fat gives juiciness and carries flavour. Coconut fat is solid at room temperature, so it feels like the fat in meat when the burger is raw, then melts on the grill and bastes the product. Sunflower and rapeseed oils are liquid and must be held in an emulsion. A maker often uses both: a solid fat for the raw feel and a liquid oil for the cooked juiciness. The fat content of a plant based burger is often about 15 to 20 percent, close to a beef burger, because a lean analogue tastes dry whatever the protein does.
Water is the cheapest texture ingredient and the easiest to get wrong. Too little water gives a dry, tough product. Too much gives a soft product that falls apart and a label that overstates the food and understates the water. Salt helps proteins bind and adds flavour, but too much salt is a health problem and a labelling problem. A typical plant based burger holds about 1 to 1.5 percent salt, and makers work hard to keep it there while still tasting seasoned.
Where flavour comes from
Flavour in a meat analogue comes from three places: the protein itself, the fat, and the flavourings added to the recipe. The protein itself is the problem: pea and soy proteins taste beany, earthy and bitter, and those notes must be removed or covered. Some of the beany flavour is removed during processing, by washing, by heat, or by choosing a protein made with a cleaner process. The rest is covered by flavourings.
The most important flavourings are the ones that copy cooking. When meat cooks, its proteins and sugars react in the Maillard reaction, the browning reaction that makes the smell of roast meat and toast. Flavour makers copy that reaction by heating amino acids and sugars together to make savoury flavour compounds, then add those compounds to the recipe. Yeast extracts add umami and depth. Smoke flavour adds the note of a grill. Onion, garlic, pepper and herbs add the familiar seasoning of a burger or a sausage.
Colour is part of flavour, because eaters judge with their eyes first. A raw plant based burger is often coloured pink with beetroot juice, so it looks like raw beef, and the colour fades as it cooks, so it looks cooked. That colour change is deliberate: it copies the way beef changes from red to brown. A maker must use colours that are stable on the shelf, safe, and named on the label, and must accept that a beetroot pink is not a perfect copy of meat red, only a close one.
Formulation: putting the recipe together
Formulation is the work of turning a list of ingredients into a recipe that works on a factory line and tastes right on a plate. It starts with a target: the protein per 100 g, the fat per 100 g, the salt, the price per kilogram, and the texture scores from the taste panel. The formulator then picks the protein, the fat, the binder and the flavourings, and writes a trial recipe. The trial is made in a small batch, tasted, measured, and changed, and the cycle repeats until the scores meet the target.
A worked example shows the arithmetic. A formulator wants a burger with 18 g of protein per 100 g. The recipe uses pea isolate at 85 percent protein, textured soy at 50 percent protein, and coconut fat with no protein. If the recipe holds 15 g of pea isolate, that gives 12.75 g of protein. If it holds 10 g of textured soy, that gives 5 g. The total is 17.75 g, close to the target, and a small lift in the isolate, to 15.3 g, closes the gap. The same arithmetic is done for fat, for salt, and for cost, and each change shifts the others, so formulation is a balancing act, not a single calculation.
Scale up is the hard step. A recipe that works in a 5 kg trial batch may fail in a 500 kg factory batch, because mixing, heating and cooling all behave differently at scale. The formulator therefore tests at each scale, and the factory keeps a specification sheet that lists every ingredient, its supplier, its amount, and the checks that prove each delivery meets the sheet. That discipline is what turns a good kitchen recipe into a product that tastes the same in every pack, in every shop, in every month.
Testing with eaters, not only machines
A product is not finished when the machine numbers look right: it is finished when eaters like it. Taste panels come in two kinds. A trained panel is a small group of people taught to score texture and flavour on set scales, and they give precise, repeatable numbers. A consumer panel is a larger group of ordinary shoppers, who say whether they like the product and whether they would buy it again. Both are needed: the trained panel finds the faults, and the consumer panel says whether the faults matter.
Blind testing is the rule. The eater must not know which sample is the new recipe and which is the old one, or which is plant based and which is meat, or the answers will follow the label instead of the mouth. Samples are coded with random numbers, served in a random order, and the eater scores each one alone. The results are then counted: a difference that appears in a few tasters may be chance, while a difference that appears in most tasters is real, and the statistics of the panel say which is which.
A common mistake is to test only with people who already like plant based food. They are forgiving of beany notes and soft texture, and they are not the shoppers the product must win. A good test includes meat eaters who buy the product the analogue replaces, because their verdict is the one that decides whether the product sells. The formulator who listens to that verdict, and changes the recipe because of it, is the one whose product stays on the shelf.
Specific mechanical energy: a step-by-step derivation
Extrusion is judged by a number called specific mechanical energy, which measures how much mechanical work the screw puts into each kilogram of food. The derivation is simple. The motor uses power, measured in kilowatts, and the food flows through at a mass flow rate, measured in kilograms per hour. The specific mechanical energy is the power divided by the mass flow rate, and it is usually given in kilowatt hours per tonne, or in kilojoules per kilogram. A higher number means more work per kilogram, more shear, more cooking, and usually more fibre formation.
A worked example shows the step. An extruder motor uses 30 kW of power, and the food flows at 100 kg per hour. The specific mechanical energy is 30 divided by 100, which is 0.3 kWh per kilogram, or 300 kWh per tonne. If the flow is raised to 200 kg per hour with the same power, the number falls to 0.15 kWh per kilogram, and the product will be less cooked and less fibrous. If the screw speed is raised so the motor uses 45 kW at the same flow, the number rises to 0.45 kWh per kilogram, and the product will be more cooked, darker and more fibrous, and it may burn if the number goes too high.
The number is useful because it lets a maker move a recipe from one extruder to another. Two machines with different sizes and different motors can be set to the same specific mechanical energy, and the product will be close, because the work per kilogram is the same. It is not a complete description: the temperature, the moisture and the recipe matter too, and two runs with the same number can differ if the moisture differs. But a maker who records the number for every run can repeat a good product and can diagnose a bad one, by asking whether the work per kilogram drifted, and in which direction.
Questions to think about
- Why does high moisture extrusion give a meat like sheet while low moisture extrusion gives a dry crunchy piece?
- Methylcellulose gels when heated and melts when cooled. Why is that backwards behaviour useful in a raw burger?
- A trained panel scores a new burger as firmer and drier than the target, but a consumer panel says they like it. Which verdict should the formulator follow, and why?
Think about the methylcellulose question before you read on
A raw burger must hold together in the pack and on the grill, then set firmly as it cooks. Methylcellulose gels when heated, so it firms up exactly when the burger hits the heat, holding the patty together at the moment it would otherwise fall apart. When the burger cools on the plate, the gel softens again, so the bite stays tender instead of rubbery.
The diagram shows high moisture extrusion in order. The cooling die is the key step: without cooling, the paste would puff like a snack, and with it, the proteins set into meat like fibres.
Practical note: In a practical session, compare the texture of three foods with a simple pull test: a piece of cooked chicken breast, a piece of firm tofu, and a piece of a plant based burger. Pull each one apart slowly along its length and write down whether it separates into strands or breaks into crumbs. Then press each one with a fork and note how far it springs back. Record your results in a small table and answer: which of the three is fibrous, which is a gel, and what does that tell you about how each one was made?
Quick self-check
Question: What is the difference between low moisture and high moisture extrusion?
Low moisture extrusion uses about 20 to 30 percent water and lets steam escape at the die, so the product puffs and dries into a hard piece that must be soaked. High moisture extrusion uses about 50 to 70 percent water and a cooled die, so the product comes out moist, layered and chewy, ready to eat.
Question: What is the Maillard reaction, and why does it matter for flavour?
It is the browning reaction between proteins and sugars when food is heated, which makes the smell of roast meat and toast. Flavour makers copy it by heating amino acids and sugars together, giving a plant based product the savoury cooked notes that pea protein alone lacks.
Question: An extruder uses 30 kW and the food flows at 100 kg per hour. What is the specific mechanical energy?
30 divided by 100, which is 0.3 kWh per kilogram, or 300 kWh per tonne. Raising the flow lowers the number, and raising the power raises it.
Try it yourself
Buy a plant based burger and a beef burger of the same weight. Cook both in the same pan for the same time. Before tasting, write down the colour of each one raw and cooked, and whether the colour changed. Weigh each one raw and cooked to find the cooking loss. Then taste both and score each one out of 10 for firmness, juiciness and meat like flavour. Write down which ingredient on the plant burger label you think gives it its firmness, and check your guess against this unit: is it a binder, a fat, or the extruded protein?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Texture is a set of mouth sensations, and it is measured by machines and by trained taste panels together.
- Meat feels fibrous because its proteins are lined up in long bundles, and a good analogue copies that lining up.
- High moisture extrusion lines proteins into fibres through heat, pressure and a cooling die, while low moisture extrusion makes dry puffed pieces.
- Binders such as methylcellulose hold a patty together, and the choice of fat decides juiciness and flavour.
- Pea and soy proteins taste beany and bitter, so flavourings copy the Maillard browning reaction and add umami and smoke notes.
- Formulation balances protein, fat, salt, cost and texture together, and a recipe must be retested at each larger scale.
Blind taste panels with meat eaters, not only plant based fans, give the verdict that decides whether a product sells.
Specific mechanical energy equals power divided by mass flow rate, and it lets a maker repeat a product and move a recipe between extruders.
Glossary
Binder
An ingredient that holds a mixture together. Food tech example: methylcellulose is a binder that gels when a plant based burger is heated.
Die
The shaped opening at the end of an extruder that forms the product. Food tech example: a cooling die shapes extruded protein into a flat fibrous sheet.
Extrusion
Pushing a mix through a heated barrel and a shaped opening to form a product. Food tech example: high moisture extrusion turns pea protein into meat like fibres.
Extruder
The machine that carries out extrusion, with a barrel, a screw and a die. Food tech example: the extruder screw pushes protein paste forward while heaters warm the barrel.
Maillard reaction
The browning reaction between proteins and sugars when food is heated. Food tech example: the Maillard reaction makes the smell of a grilled burger.
Methylcellulose
A plant fibre ingredient that gels when heated and melts when cooled. Food tech example: methylcellulose holds a plant based burger together on the grill.
Taste panel
A group of people who score a food for flavour and texture. Food tech example: a trained taste panel scores a new burger for chewiness and juiciness.
Texture analyser
A machine that presses a probe into a food and records the force. Food tech example: a texture analyser measures the hardness and springiness of a plant based sausage.
Umami
The savoury taste found in mushrooms, soy sauce and yeast extract. Food tech example: yeast extract adds umami to a plant based burger recipe.
High moisture extrusion
Extrusion with about 50 to 70 percent water and a cooled die, making moist fibrous sheets. Food tech example: high moisture extrusion makes the fibrous sheet that becomes plant based chicken pieces.
Low moisture extrusion
Extrusion with about 20 to 30 percent water, making dry puffed pieces. Food tech example: low moisture extrusion makes textured soy protein that must be soaked before use.
Formulation
The work of turning ingredients into a recipe that works in the factory and tastes right. Food tech example: formulation sets the protein, fat, salt and cost of a new burger.
Blind testing
Tasting where the eater does not know which sample is which. Food tech example: blind testing stops the label from changing what the eater reports.
Springiness
How far a food springs back after being pressed. Food tech example: a sausage with good springiness bounces back when pressed with a fork.
Beetroot juice
A natural colour from beetroot used to make a raw plant burger look pink. Food tech example: beetroot juice colours a plant based burger so it looks like raw beef.
Specific mechanical energy
Mechanical work put into each kilogram of food in extrusion, power divided by mass flow rate. Food tech example: a higher specific mechanical energy gives a more fibrous texturate.
Mass flow rate
How much food flows through a machine per hour. Food tech example: raising the mass flow rate lowers the specific mechanical energy.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 7: Nutrition, Safety and Labelling
Note
Unit 7: Nutrition, Safety and Labelling
A question to start with
A shopper picks up a pack of plant based mince, turns it over, and reads the label. Protein 18 g, fat 12 g, salt 1.2 g, fibre 4 g. The front of the pack says high in protein. The ingredient list names pea protein, water, rapeseed oil, salt, and beetroot juice. Is the claim true? Is the food safe? And who checked? This unit answers those questions. It explains how protein quality is measured, how new proteins are tested for safety, what a label must say and may claim, and how a shopper can read a pack with a clear eye. It is the unit that turns the whole subject from making into judging.
Measuring protein quality
Protein quantity is easy to measure: the laboratory measures nitrogen and multiplies by a factor, usually 6.25, because protein holds about 16 percent nitrogen. That gives the crude protein, and it is the number behind the protein grams on a label. But quantity is not quality. Quality asks whether the protein supplies the essential amino acids in the right amounts, and whether the body can digest it and use it.
The standard method for judging quality is called DIAAS, the Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score. It compares the digestible amount of each essential amino acid in a food with the amount a person needs, and the lowest score sets the value of the whole protein. A score above 100 means the protein supplies more than the need for every amino acid. Milk and egg score above 100. Soy scores near 90 to 100. Pea scores near 60 to 70, because it is short of methionine. Wheat scores lower still, near 40 to 50, because it is short of lysine. These scores guide makers: a low score can be lifted by blending, and the blend is checked by measuring the score again.
An older method, PDCAAS, is still seen on some labels and in older books. It works the same way but measures digestibility for the whole diet rather than for each amino acid, and it caps the score at 100, so it hides differences between excellent proteins. DIAAS is the method most authorities now prefer, and a maker who quotes a protein quality score should name the method, because the two methods give different numbers for the same food. A shopper who sees a quality claim without a method named should treat it with care.
Nutrition on the label: reading the whole pack
A nutrition label lists energy, protein, fat, saturated fat, carbohydrate, sugars, fibre and salt, usually per 100 g and per serving. The per 100 g column is the one to use for comparing products, because servings differ: one maker calls a serving 100 g and another calls it 80 g, and the per serving numbers then cannot be compared. A fair comparison always uses the same column.
Three checks matter most for alternative proteins. First, protein: is the amount close to the animal food it replaces, and is the quality good or only the quantity? Second, fat and salt: many plant based products carry as much saturated fat and salt as the meat they replace, often from coconut fat and from seasoning, so a plant label is not a promise of a leaner food. Third, fibre: plant products often add fibre, which meat lacks, and that is a real benefit for digestion and for feeling full.
Micronutrients deserve a check too. Meat supplies iron, zinc and vitamin B12 in forms the body uses well. Plant products may add these by fortification, which means adding them during manufacture, and the label will say so. Iron from plants is absorbed less well than iron from meat, and vitamin B12 does not occur naturally in plants at all, so a plant based diet that avoids all animal foods needs a fortified food or a supplement for B12. A maker who fortifies must add the nutrient in a stable form, in the right amount, and must prove it is still there at the end of shelf life.
Safety testing for a new protein
A new protein is not assumed safe because it comes from a plant. It is tested, and the tests follow a set pattern used by food safety authorities around the world. First, the source is identified: which species, which part, how it was grown and processed. Second, the composition is measured: protein, fat, carbohydrate, fibre, minerals, vitamins, and any known toxins or anti nutrients, which are compounds that block the body from using nutrients. Third, the protein is checked for allergy risk, by comparing its structure with known allergens and by testing whether blood from allergic people reacts to it.
Fourth, the protein is fed to laboratory animals in a feeding study, to look for any harmful effect over weeks or months. Fifth, the expected intake is worked out: how much of the food people will eat, and how much of the protein that means per day. If the intake is far below any level that caused harm in the tests, and the allergy check is clear, the authority may accept the protein. If not, the maker must change the process, lower the use level, or label the product with a warning.
Anti nutrients deserve a closer look, because they are common in plants. Phytate, found in seeds and legumes, binds iron and zinc and stops the body absorbing them. Trypsin inhibitors, found in raw soy, block the enzymes that digest protein. Lectins, found in raw beans, can upset the gut. Processing removes or cuts most of these: soaking, heating, fermenting and extrusion all lower them, and that is one reason a raw bean is not eaten raw and a soy isolate is not a raw bean. A safety file must show that the process used actually cuts the anti nutrients to safe levels in the finished food.
Allergens and the label that protects
Allergy labelling is one of the strictest parts of food law in most countries. A short list of foods causes most allergies: milk, egg, fish, crustaceans, peanut, tree nuts, soy, wheat, sesame and a few others, with the exact list set by each country. When a product contains one of these, the label must name it plainly, in the ingredient list and often in a separate allergy statement. A plant based product that uses soy or wheat must name it, and a product made in a factory that also handles peanut must say so where the law asks.
The rules also cover cross contact, where a food that does not contain an allergen picks up a trace of one from shared equipment. A factory that makes a soy burger and then a pea burger on the same line must clean between runs, and must test that the cleaning worked, or it must label the pea burger as possibly containing soy. The cleaning check is a real test, not a guess: swabs are taken from the equipment and tested for the allergen, and the line is not released until the result is clear.
A shopper with an allergy reads the label every time, because recipes change. A product that was safe last year may add soy this year, and the label is the only warning. That is why the label is a safety document, not a marketing surface, and why a maker who changes a recipe must change the label in the same step, before the new batch leaves the factory.
Claims: what a pack may say
A claim on a pack is a promise, and most countries set legal definitions for the common ones. A claim of high in protein usually means the food supplies at least 20 percent of its energy from protein. A claim of source of protein usually means at least 12 percent of its energy from protein. A claim of low fat, low salt or reduced fat each has its own threshold, and the maker must measure the food and prove it meets the threshold before printing the claim. A claim that is not measured is not a claim: it is a guess printed on a pack.
Health claims are stricter still. A claim that a food lowers cholesterol or supports heart health must be backed by evidence accepted by the authority, and the wording is often fixed by law, so the maker cannot invent a stronger version. A claim about the planet, such as lower carbon or plant based, is also regulated in many countries, and a vague green claim without numbers is increasingly treated as misleading. The direction of the law is clear everywhere: say what you measured, show the numbers, and do not say more.
The front of the pack is where the pressure is greatest, because the maker wants the pack to sell and the shopper wants a quick answer. The honest front of a pack names the food plainly, states the protein and the key nutrition facts, and leaves the detailed proof to the back. A shopper who reads the back, the ingredient list and the nutrition table, and compares per 100 g, will rarely be misled, whatever the front says.
Who checks, and how a maker proves it
No maker checks their own homework alone. A food safety authority in each country sets the rules for new proteins, for labelling and for claims, and the maker must send a file of evidence before a new protein is sold. The authority reads the file, asks questions, and may ask for more tests. Only when the file is accepted can the product go on sale. The exact name of the authority and the exact procedure differ by country, and a maker who sells in several countries must satisfy each one, which is why global products are often launched in one market first.
Inside the factory, checks run every day. Each delivery of protein powder is tested against its specification sheet. Each batch of finished product is tested for protein, fat, salt and microbes. Samples are kept from each batch, so that if a problem appears later, the batch can be traced and tested again. The factory keeps records of every check, and an inspector can ask to see them at any time. That record keeping is not paperwork for its own sake: it is what lets a factory find a faulty batch, recall it, and prove that the next batch is sound.
The shopper is the last checker. A shopper who reads the label, compares per 100 g, checks the allergens, and asks whether a claim is backed by a number, is doing the same work as the inspector, on a smaller scale. This subject has given you the tools for that reading: the amino acid gaps, the DIAAS scores, the anti nutrients, the allergen list and the claim thresholds. Use them on every pack you pick up, and the label will tell you the truth about the food inside it.
Working out a protein quality score: DIAAS step by step
A protein quality score compares the amino acids in a food with the amino acids a person needs, and the score used most today is called DIAAS, the digestible indispensable amino acid score. The derivation runs in four steps. First, measure the amino acids in the food, in milligrams per gram of protein. Second, measure how much of each amino acid is digested, using the digestibility of each one. Third, divide the digestible amount of each essential amino acid by the amount a person needs, in milligrams per gram of protein. Fourth, take the smallest of those ratios, multiply by 100, and that is the score. The smallest ratio sets the score, because the body can only use the protein as far as its scarcest essential amino acid allows.
A worked example shows it. A pea protein holds, per gram of protein, 70 mg of lysine, 25 mg of methionine and 40 mg of other essential amino acids, after digestibility is counted. A person needs, per gram of protein, 50 mg of lysine and 25 mg of methionine. The lysine ratio is 70 divided by 50, which is 1.4. The methionine ratio is 25 divided by 25, which is 1.0. Methionine is the smallest, so the score is 1.0 times 100, which is 100. A protein that is short of methionine would score lower: if the digestible methionine were 15 mg against a need of 25 mg, the ratio would be 0.6, and the score would be 60, even if every other amino acid were plentiful.
The score matters because it is measured on the food as eaten, with digestibility counted, and it cannot be raised by adding a cheap amino acid on paper. A maker who wants a higher score must blend proteins, as Unit 2 explains, so the blend covers the gaps, or must process the protein gently, so its digestibility stays high. A score above 100 is capped at 100 for labelling in most systems, because the body cannot use more of an amino acid than it needs. The score is a tool for comparing proteins fairly, and a reader who can work it out by hand can judge any protein claim on a pack.
Questions to think about
- Why is DIAAS preferred over the older PDCAAS method for judging protein quality?
- A plant based burger claims high in protein and carries 18 g of protein per 100 g. What else would you check before agreeing with the claim?
- Why must a maker prove a low salt claim by measurement, and what happens if the recipe changes after the claim is printed?
Think about the DIAAS question before you read on
DIAAS measures digestibility for each essential amino acid separately, at the end of the small intestine, so it shows exactly which amino acid is limiting and by how much. PDCAAS measures digestibility for the whole diet and caps the score at 100, so it hides the gap between a good protein and an excellent one. DIAAS gives the maker a sharper tool for fixing a blend.
The diagram shows the safety testing chain in order. No step is skipped because the protein comes from a plant, and the authority sees the file before the food reaches the shop.
Practical note: In a practical session, take the labels of three plant based products and one animal product they imitate. For each one, write down the protein per 100 g, the fat, the saturated fat, the salt and the fibre, and work out the protein as a share of energy using 4 kcal per gram of protein and 9 kcal per gram of fat. Then check each front of pack claim against the numbers: does the product meet the usual threshold for high in protein, and does any claim on the front fail the numbers on the back? Present your findings as a short table.
Quick self-check
Question: What is an anti nutrient, and how does processing deal with it?
An anti nutrient is a compound in a plant, such as phytate or a trypsin inhibitor, that blocks the body from using nutrients. Soaking, heating, fermenting and extrusion cut most of them to safe levels, which is why raw beans are not eaten raw and a soy isolate is not a raw bean.
Question: Why must a factory test for allergen cleaning between runs on a shared line?
Because a trace of soy or peanut left on shared equipment can end up in the next product and harm an allergic eater. Swab tests prove the cleaning worked, and the line is not released until the result is clear.
Question: Why does the smallest amino acid ratio set the DIAAS score?
Because the body can only use the protein as far as its scarcest essential amino acid allows. The smallest ratio is the limiting amino acid, and it caps how much of the protein the body can use.
Try it yourself
Go to a shop and pick up five plant based products. For each one, read the front of the pack and write down every claim you see: high in protein, plant based, lower carbon, or any other. Then turn the pack over and write down the protein, salt and saturated fat per 100 g, and the first three ingredients. At home, judge each claim against the numbers and write one sentence for each product: is the claim supported by the back of the pack, or does the back tell a different story? Keep your notes and compare them with a classmate who shopped in a different store.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Protein quality is judged by digestible essential amino acids, and DIAAS is the method most authorities now prefer.
- Soy scores near 90 to 100 on DIAAS, pea near 60 to 70, and wheat near 40 to 50, and blending can lift a low score.
- Compare products per 100 g, not per serving, because serving sizes differ between makers.
- A plant label does not promise a leaner food: many plant products carry as much saturated fat and salt as the meat they replace.
- New proteins are tested for composition, toxins, anti nutrients, allergy risk, feeding safety and expected intake before sale.
- Allergen labels must name soy, wheat, peanut and the other major allergens plainly, and factories must prove cleaning between runs.
A claim on a pack must meet a legal threshold and be backed by measurement, and the shopper is the last checker.
DIAAS is worked out in four steps: measure amino acids, count digestibility, divide by need, and take the smallest ratio, which is the limiting amino acid.
Glossary
Anti nutrient
A compound in a plant that blocks the body from using nutrients. Food tech example: phytate in seeds binds iron and zinc, and soaking and heating cut it.
Crude protein
Protein estimated by measuring nitrogen and multiplying by 6.25. Food tech example: the protein grams on a label are based on a crude protein measurement.
DIAAS
Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score, the standard method for judging protein quality. Food tech example: pea scores near 60 to 70 on DIAAS because it is short of methionine.
PDCAAS
An older protein quality score that measures whole diet digestibility and caps the score at 100. Food tech example: PDCAAS is still seen in older books but DIAAS is now preferred.
Fortification
Adding a nutrient during manufacture to raise its level in a food. Food tech example: a plant based milk is fortified with calcium and vitamin B12.
Phytate
An anti nutrient in seeds and legumes that binds iron and zinc. Food tech example: soaking lentils before cooking cuts their phytate.
Trypsin inhibitor
An anti nutrient in raw soy that blocks the enzymes that digest protein. Food tech example: heating soy destroys trypsin inhibitors, which is why soy is always cooked.
Lectin
An anti nutrient in raw beans that can upset the gut. Food tech example: boiling kidney beans destroys lectins, while slow cooking at low heat may not.
Cross contact
A trace of an allergen picked up from shared equipment. Food tech example: a pea burger made after a soy burger on the same line must be tested for soy cross contact.
Allergen
A food that can trigger an allergic reaction in some people. Food tech example: soy, wheat and peanut are major allergens that must be named on a label.
Claim
A statement on a pack about nutrition or health that must meet a legal definition. Food tech example: a high in protein claim means at least 20 percent of the energy comes from protein.
Specification sheet
A document that lists what a delivered ingredient must meet. Food tech example: a pea isolate delivery is checked against its specification sheet for protein, moisture and microbes.
Feeding study
A study where laboratory animals are fed a new food to look for harmful effects. Food tech example: a new protein is fed to animals for weeks before it is accepted for sale.
Vitamin B12
A vitamin found in animal foods and fortified foods, not naturally in plants. Food tech example: a plant based diet needs a fortified food or a supplement for vitamin B12.
Per 100 g
The column on a nutrition label that lets products be compared fairly. Food tech example: comparing protein per 100 g is fair, while comparing per serving is not, because servings differ.
DIAAS
Digestible indispensable amino acid score, a protein quality score that counts digestibility. Food tech example: a pea protein scores near 100 when its methionine is covered by blending.
Indispensable amino acid
An amino acid the body cannot make and must get from food. Food tech example: lysine and methionine are indispensable amino acids.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 8: Alternative Protein Ingredients: Isolates, Concentrates and Texturates
Note
Unit 8: Alternative Protein Ingredients: Isolates, Concentrates and Texturates
A question to start with
Walk into a factory that makes plant based burgers and you will not find sacks of soybeans or peas on the production line. You will find sacks of powder: pale powders labelled isolate, concentrate and textured protein, each with a specification sheet that lists protein content, moisture, colour and how it behaves in water. Those powders are the real working materials of alternative protein foods. The seed, the fungus or the insect is only the starting point. This unit follows the journey from raw material to ingredient: how protein is separated and purified, how dry methods differ from wet methods, how a powder is given a chewy texture, and how a maker chooses the right ingredient for a recipe.
From raw material to ingredient: the ingredient ladder
Every alternative protein starts as a raw material that holds protein mixed with other things: starch, fibre, oil, water and minerals. An ingredient maker separates the protein from the rest, step by step, and each step up the ladder gives a purer powder. At the bottom sits the flour: the milled raw material with nothing removed. A soy flour holds about 40 to 50 percent protein. A pea flour holds about 20 to 25 percent. A mycoprotein paste is not a flour at all, but it sits at the same end of the ladder, a whole food with protein, fibre and water together.
One step up sits the concentrate, with part of the starch, fibre and oil removed, holding about 65 to 70 percent protein. One more step up sits the isolate, holding about 90 percent protein or more. The names sound like marketing words, but they are really process words: they name how much was taken away. The same ladder applies across sources. Insect meal can be defatted and concentrated. Microalgae can be broken open and its protein separated from its oil and its green pigments. The raw material changes, the ladder stays the same.
Each step up the ladder costs money, water and energy, and loses some protein on the way. A maker therefore buys the lowest rung that does the job. A soup or a sauce that needs body and flavour may work well with a flour. A burger that needs a firm bite and a clean colour may need a concentrate. A clear sports drink that must stay clear in the bottle needs an isolate, because any starch or fibre would cloud it. The first skill of ingredient buying is to match the rung to the job, and to pay for purity only where the product truly needs it.
Wet fractionation: dissolving and dropping out
Wet fractionation is the standard way of making a protein isolate, and it works because proteins dissolve and fall out of solution as the pH changes. The raw material is milled and mixed with water at a slightly alkaline pH, near 8 to 9, where the protein dissolves. The fibre and starch do not dissolve, so they are spun out in a centrifuge or filtered away. The protein rich liquid is then acidified to about pH 4.5, near the isoelectric point where the protein is least soluble, so the protein falls out as a curd. The curd is washed, neutralised, dried and milled into a powder.
The same steps, with small changes, make soy isolate, pea isolate, lupin isolate and faba bean isolate. What changes is the detail: the pH that dissolves best, the temperature that must not be passed, the washing steps that remove bitter compounds. Lupins, for example, carry bitter alkaloids that must be washed away, and a maker who skips that wash sells a bitter ingredient. Pea protein needs care with its earthy flavour, which is reduced by washing and by choosing the right drying temperature. The process is a balance: harsher conditions give a higher yield and a cleaner powder, but they can damage the protein so it no longer gels or foams.
Wet fractionation uses a lot of water, and the wash water carries away starch, sugars and minerals that must be treated before release. That water is not waste in the best plants: the starch can be sold, the fibre can go to animal feed or to fibre ingredients, and the water can be cleaned and reused. A maker who judges a wet process only by the isolate it makes is missing half the story. The side streams decide whether the process pays and whether its footprint is small. This is why ingredient plants are often built beside a mill or a starch plant, so the streams of one process feed the next.
Dry fractionation: air, sieves and no water
Dry fractionation separates protein from starch without water, using air and particle size. The seed is milled into a fine flour, and the flour is blown through a stream of air. Protein bodies are small and light, starch granules are larger and heavier, so the air carries the protein away while the starch falls. The light stream is collected as a protein rich fraction, often about 50 to 60 percent protein, and the heavy stream is collected as starch. Sieves can refine the split further, sorting particles by size before the air step.
Dry fractionation has clear strengths. It uses no water, so there is no wash water to treat and no drying step that eats energy. The protein is never dissolved, so its native structure survives better, and it often keeps more of its foaming and gelling power. The flour keeps its fibre, which is a benefit in breads and snacks where fibre is wanted. The weakness is purity: dry methods cannot reach the 90 percent protein of a wet isolate, so a dry fraction suits products where 50 to 60 percent protein is enough, and where fibre and flavour are welcome.
The choice between wet and dry is a choice about the product, not about which method is better in general. A maker of a high protein clear drink needs a wet isolate. A maker of a protein enriched bread or a snack bar may do better with a dry fraction, which costs less, uses less water, keeps the fibre, and tastes more like the original food. Some plants run both: a dry step first, to take out the easy protein cheaply, and a wet step on the leftover stream, to recover the rest. That combination is a good example of process design: use the cheap step where it works, and spend the dear step only where it is needed.
Texturates: giving protein a chew
A protein powder has no chew. To make a mince, a chunk or a strip that feels like meat, the protein must be texturised, and the main tool is extrusion. In high moisture extrusion, a protein dough is pushed through a heated barrel by a screw, cooked under pressure, and forced through a cooling die. The heat and the shear line the protein molecules up into fibres, and the cooling sets them, so the product comes out as a fibrous slab that can be cut into strips or shreds. In low moisture extrusion, the same idea runs drier and cooler, and the product comes out as dry, spongy chunks, known as textured vegetable protein, which the maker rehydrates before use.
Texturates can be made from soy, pea, wheat gluten, mycoprotein and insect protein, and each source gives a different chew. Soy texturate is firm and springy. Pea texturate is softer and paler. Wheat gluten texturate is the chewiest of all, because gluten forms long elastic strands. A maker blends sources to tune the bite: a little gluten for chew, a little pea for a pale colour, a little soy for firmness. Fat is added after texturising, because fat in the extruder would coat the protein and stop the fibres from forming, so the recipe adds oil in a later mixing step, where it sits between the fibres like the fat in meat.
The quality of a texturate is judged by the eater, not by the machine. A good texturate tears into fibres along one direction, like cooked chicken, and resists across the fibres. It holds water when it is heated, so it stays juicy on a grill. It does not fall apart in a sauce. The tests are simple and physical: pull it, press it, cook it, weigh it before and after cooking to see how much water it lost. A texturate that loses half its weight on cooking will taste dry, whatever the label says, and the fix is in the recipe and the extrusion settings, not in the marketing.
Functional ingredients: what the powder must do
A protein ingredient is bought for what it does, not only for how much protein it holds. The functions a maker tests are solubility, gelling, foaming, emulsifying, water holding and fat holding. Solubility decides whether the powder dissolves in a drink or sinks to the bottom. Gelling decides whether it sets firm when heated, as in a sausage. Foaming decides whether it whips into a stable foam, as in a mousse. Emulsifying decides whether it holds oil and water together, as in a dressing. Water holding decides whether a burger stays juicy. Each function is tested with a simple laboratory method, and the results are printed on the specification sheet.
Processing changes function. Heat a protein too far and it denatures, unfolding and clumping, and it will no longer dissolve or foam. Dry it too hot and it darkens and tastes cooked. Wash it too harshly and it loses the small molecules that help it emulsify. That is why two isolates with the same protein content can behave very differently: one was made gently and still gels, the other was made harshly and does not. A buyer who compares only protein content is buying blind. The function tests are what separate a good ingredient from a poor one.
A worked example shows how a buyer checks a delivery. A specification sheet promises 85 percent protein and a solubility of at least 70 percent at pH 7. The factory tests a sample: 10 g of powder in 100 ml of water at pH 7, stirred, spun, and the protein in the clear liquid measured. If 6 g of the 8.5 g of protein stays in the liquid, the solubility is about 70 percent, and the delivery passes. If only 4 g stays, the solubility is about 47 percent, the delivery fails, and the factory calls the supplier. The number on the sheet is only a promise. The test is the proof.
Buying, testing and storing an ingredient
Buying a protein ingredient starts with the specification sheet, a one page document that lists protein content, moisture, ash, fat, particle size, colour, microbial limits and the function tests, with a limit for each. The factory checks every delivery against that sheet: a protein test, a moisture test, a check for off smells, and a microbial test. A delivery that fails any limit is held, not used, and the supplier is told. The sheet is also a legal document: if a finished product fails its label claim, the sheet shows what was bought and what was promised.
Storage decides whether a good powder stays good. Protein powders must be kept dry, cool and sealed, away from strong smells, because they pick up odours easily. Moisture is the main enemy: a powder that picks up water clumps, loses function and can grow microbes. Heat is the second enemy: a warm warehouse slowly damages the protein so it gels less well. Texturates are stored dry too, and rehydrated only when they are needed, because a wet texturate spoils fast. The store is not a cupboard: it is part of the quality system, with a temperature record and a first in, first out rule.
The last buying question is the simplest: can the supplier deliver the same ingredient next month, and the month after? A product that depends on one small supplier is at risk, because a crop failure or a factory stoppage can halt production. Makers therefore qualify two suppliers for each key ingredient, and test both, so a switch is possible without changing the product. The ingredient shelf of a factory is a small library of powders, each with a sheet, a test and a backup supplier, and keeping that library in order is quiet work that decides whether the product on the shelf is the same every week.
Questions to think about
- Why does a maker buy the lowest rung of the ingredient ladder that does the job, rather than the purest powder every time?
- A dry fraction reaches only 50 to 60 percent protein while a wet isolate reaches 90 percent. When would the dry fraction still be the better choice?
- Two isolates both hold 85 percent protein, but one gels and one does not. What explains the difference, and how would a buyer tell them apart before buying?
Think about the two isolates before you read on
The difference is how the protein was treated during making: heat, pH and drying change the protein shape, and a harsh process can denature it so it no longer gels or foams, even though the protein content is the same. A buyer tells them apart by the function tests on the specification sheet, such as gelling and solubility, and by testing a sample in the real recipe, not by reading the protein number alone.
The diagram shows the ingredient ladder: from a raw material to a tested powder on the shelf, with texturising as a separate step where chew is needed.
Practical note: In a practical session, compare three powders: a soy flour, a pea protein concentrate and a pea protein isolate, if your laboratory can supply them. Weigh 10 g of each into 100 ml of water at room temperature, stir for one minute, and note which dissolves, which sinks, and which thickens. Heat each mixture gently and note which sets into a gel. Record the colour, the smell and the thickness of each, and answer: which powder would you choose for a clear drink, which for a burger, and which for a protein enriched bread, and why?
Quick self-check
Question: Question: What is the difference between a concentrate and an isolate?
A concentrate has part of the non protein removed and holds about 65 to 70 percent protein, while an isolate has most of the non protein removed and holds about 90 percent protein or more. The isolate costs more and tastes less of the original food, but it gives the maker more control.
Question: Question: Why is fat added after texturising, not in the extruder?
Because fat in the extruder coats the protein and stops the fibres from forming. The oil is added in a later mixing step, where it sits between the fibres like the fat in meat, so the product stays juicy without losing its fibrous bite.
Try it yourself
Visit a shop and read the ingredient lists of three plant based products: a burger, a sausage and a protein drink. Write down every protein ingredient you find, and note whether it is named as a flour, a concentrate, an isolate or a textured protein. Then look at the protein content per 100 g on the nutrition panel and answer: does the product with the purest sounding ingredient also hold the most protein, and what else on the list explains the difference?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Flour, concentrate and isolate name how much non protein was removed, and purity trades against cost, flavour, fibre and water use.
- Wet fractionation dissolves protein at alkaline pH and drops it out near pH 4.5, where it is least soluble.
- Dry fractionation sorts protein from starch with air and sieves, using no water and keeping the protein structure, but it cannot reach isolate purity.
- Extrusion lines protein molecules into fibres, and fat is added after texturising so the fibres can form.
- A protein ingredient is judged by its functions, solubility, gelling, foaming, emulsifying and water holding, not by its protein number alone.
- Every delivery is checked against its specification sheet, and powders are stored dry, cool and sealed, away from strong smells.
- Qualifying a second supplier for each key ingredient protects production when one supply fails.
Glossary
Concentrate
A protein ingredient with part of the non protein removed, holding about 65 to 70 percent protein. Food tech example: soy protein concentrate is used in meat free sausages where a middle level of purity is enough.
Fractionation
Separating a raw material into parts, such as protein, starch and fibre, by wet or dry methods. Food tech example: pea flour is fractionated to separate its protein from its starch.
Isolate
A protein ingredient with most non protein parts removed, holding about 90 percent protein or more. Food tech example: pea protein isolate is the main protein in many plant based burgers.
Texturate
A protein shaped by extrusion into fibrous or spongy pieces that feel like meat. Food tech example: soy texturate is rehydrated and used as meat free mince.
High moisture extrusion
Extrusion with enough water that the product comes out as a wet, fibrous slab. Food tech example: high moisture extrusion makes plant based chicken strips.
Textured vegetable protein
Dry, spongy chunks of extruded plant protein that are rehydrated before use. Food tech example: textured vegetable protein is stirred into a sauce as a mince substitute.
Solubility
How much of a protein dissolves in water under set conditions. Food tech example: a protein drink needs an isolate with high solubility at pH 7.
Gelling
Setting into a firm network when heated or cooled. Food tech example: soy protein gels when a sausage is cooked, holding the shape.
Emulsifying
Holding oil and water together in a stable mix. Food tech example: soy protein emulsifies the fat in a plant based dressing.
Water holding
How much water a protein keeps when it is heated or pressed. Food tech example: a burger with good water holding stays juicy on the grill.
Specification sheet
A document listing what an ingredient must meet: protein, moisture, function tests and microbial limits. Food tech example: a factory checks each delivery against its specification sheet.
Denature
To unfold a protein by heat, pH or shear so it loses its shape and often its function. Food tech example: overheating an isolate denatures it so it no longer foams.
Side stream
A stream of material that leaves a process beside the main product, such as starch or fibre. Food tech example: the starch stream from pea fractionation is sold for other foods.
Dry fractionation
Separating protein from starch with air and sieves, using no water. Food tech example: dry fractionation gives a pea fraction of about 50 to 60 percent protein.
Wet fractionation
Separating protein by dissolving it in water and dropping it out by acid. Food tech example: wet fractionation makes soy isolate at about 90 percent protein.
Defatted
Having the oil removed from a seed or meal. Food tech example: defatted soy flakes are the starting material for soy protein isolate.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 9: Sustainability and Life Cycle Assessment of Alternative Proteins
Note
Unit 9: Sustainability and Life Cycle Assessment of Alternative Proteins
A question to start with
A pack of plant based burgers claims it is better for the planet. A pack of mycoprotein claims a smaller footprint than beef. A news story claims the opposite. How does anyone check? The tool that food scientists use is called life cycle assessment, and it works by counting everything that goes into a food, from the field to the factory to the plate, and everything that comes out, including the gases that warm the planet. This unit explains that tool in plain words, shows how a footprint per kilogram of protein is worked out step by step, and teaches the reader to ask the questions that separate a careful claim from a slogan.
What a footprint counts
Life cycle assessment, usually shortened to LCA, is a method for counting the environmental effects of a product across its whole life. It starts by drawing a boundary: where does the counting start and stop? For a protein food, the boundary often runs from the field or the fermentation tank, through processing, packaging and transport, to the shop and the home, and sometimes to the waste bin. Everything inside the boundary is counted. Everything outside it is named and left out, and a careful study says what it left out.
Inside the boundary, the study counts inputs and outputs. Inputs include land, water, energy, fertiliser, feed and packaging. Outputs include the food itself, and the releases to air, water and soil, including carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide, the gases that warm the planet. Each gas is converted to the same unit, usually carbon dioxide equivalent, so the warming effect of all the gases can be added into one number. Water use, land use and energy use are counted separately, because one number cannot carry them all.
The value of LCA is that it forces the counting to be complete and open. A claim that a product is better for the planet means little on its own. A claim with a boundary, a functional unit and a list of what was counted can be checked, repeated and argued about. That is the difference between a slogan and a study, and this unit teaches the reader to look for the study behind the slogan.
The functional unit: per kilogram of protein
A footprint number means nothing until you know what it is per unit of. A kilogram of burger and a kilogram of dry protein powder are not the same amount of food, so comparing them directly is a mistake. LCA solves this with a functional unit: the amount of function being compared. For protein foods the usual functional unit is one kilogram of protein, or one kilogram of protein eaten, which also allows for digestibility. All the inputs and outputs are then divided by that unit, so the comparison is fair.
The step by step derivation is simple, and it is worth doing by hand once. Start with the footprint of one kilogram of finished product, call it F. Find the protein fraction of the product, call it p, the amount of protein in each kilogram. The footprint per kilogram of protein is F divided by p. A burger with a footprint of 4 units per kilogram and a protein fraction of 0.20, that is 20 percent protein, has a footprint per kilogram of protein of 4 divided by 0.20, which is 20 units. A dry powder with a footprint of 10 units per kilogram and a protein fraction of 0.85 has a footprint per kilogram of protein of 10 divided by 0.85, which is about 11.8 units. The powder looked worse per kilogram of product and better per kilogram of protein, because it carries far more protein in each kilogram.
A careful study goes one step further and adjusts for digestibility, because a kilogram of protein that the body cannot digest does not feed a person. The digestible protein is the protein fraction multiplied by the digestibility, a number between zero and one. The footprint per kilogram of digestible protein is F divided by the digestible protein. That is the fairest comparison of all, and it is the one a reader should ask for when a claim compares very different foods. A study that hides its functional unit is hiding the comparison itself.
Hotspots: where the footprint comes from
Every protein chain has hotspots, the steps where most of the footprint sits. Finding them is the main practical use of LCA, because a maker can only cut what it can see. For plant proteins, the hotspots are usually the farm and the factory. The farm contributes fertiliser, tractor fuel and the gases released from soil. The factory contributes the energy for milling, separation and drying, and the water for wet fractionation. Transport is usually a small share for a dry powder, and a larger share for a wet, heavy food that travels cold.
For mycoprotein and microalgae, the hotspots shift. The fermentation tank needs sugar, air and power for stirring and cooling, and the sugar itself comes from a crop, so the farm is still in the chain, one step back. Drying is often the largest energy step, because removing water from a wet paste takes a lot of heat. For insect protein, the hotspot is the feed: what the insects eat decides the footprint, and insects fed on side streams that would otherwise be waste carry a far smaller footprint than insects fed on grain grown for them.
For hybrid products, the hotspot is usually the animal part, because animal farming carries the largest footprint per kilogram of protein in the blend. That is why a hybrid that replaces a third of the meat with plant protein cuts the footprint by roughly a third of the animal share, not by a third of the whole, and why the exact blend ratio matters. A maker who knows the hotspots can spend money where it cuts the footprint most, and a reader who knows them can ask the right question: which step dominates, and what is being done about it?
Land, water and climate: reading the three numbers
Three numbers appear in almost every footprint claim: land, water and climate. They measure different things, and they do not always move together. Land use counts the area needed to grow the crop or to rear the animal, over a year. A protein that grows in a tank, like mycoprotein, uses far less land per kilogram of protein than a protein that grows in a field, because the tank stacks production vertically and runs all year. A protein from a legume uses less land than a protein from an animal, because the animal must first eat a crop grown on land.
Water use counts the water taken from rivers and aquifers, not the rain that falls on a field, and it is counted where it is taken, because a litre in a dry region matters more than a litre in a wet one. Wet fractionation uses water in the factory, and that water must be cleaned before release. Dry fractionation uses almost none. Irrigation is the largest water use for many crops, and a crop that grows with rain carries a smaller water footprint than the same crop grown with irrigation in a dry region.
Climate counts the warming gases, converted to carbon dioxide equivalent. Methane matters here, because it warms far more per kilogram than carbon dioxide over a short period, and it comes from animals and from flooded fields. Nitrous oxide matters too, because it comes from fertiliser and warms far more per kilogram than carbon dioxide. A study that reports only carbon dioxide and hides methane and nitrous oxide is not counting the climate at all. The reader should look for the words carbon dioxide equivalent, and for a list of the gases included.
Trade-offs no single number shows
A single footprint number can hide a trade off. A protein that uses little land may use a lot of energy for drying. A protein that uses little water may need fertiliser that harms rivers. A protein with a small climate footprint may come from a crop grown on land cleared from forest, and the clearing itself may not be counted if the study draws its boundary after the clearing. A good LCA names these trade offs, and a good reader looks for them.
Biodiversity is the trade off most often missing. A field of one crop, grown year after year, supports few wild species, while a varied farm with legumes, hedges and rotations supports many. The LCA numbers for land use do not show that difference, because a hectare is counted as a hectare whatever grows on it. Nutrition is another missing piece: a protein food that also gives fibre, iron and vitamins feeds a person better than a pure protein powder with the same footprint, and the numbers alone do not show it.
Waste is a third. A process that turns its side streams into food, feed or ingredients carries a smaller footprint than one that throws them away, but only if the study credits the side stream properly. The rule for crediting is a judgement, and different studies judge it differently, which is why two studies of the same food can give different answers. None of this makes LCA useless. It makes LCA a tool that must be read with its assumptions open, not a single number to be believed on its own.
Using LCA honestly: questions to ask before believing a claim
A reader who wants to judge a footprint claim can ask six questions. First, what is the functional unit: per kilogram of product, per kilogram of protein, or per kilogram of digestible protein? Second, where is the boundary: does it include the farm, the factory, the shop, the home and the waste? Third, what is compared: the same food, the same meal, or the same amount of protein? Fourth, which gases are counted, and are methane and nitrous oxide in the number? Fifth, what was left out, and does the study say so? Sixth, who paid for the study, and was it checked by an independent reviewer?
A claim that cannot answer those questions is not a finding, it is an advertisement. A claim that answers them can still be argued about, and that is a good sign: science moves by argument, and a study that invites checking is doing its job. The reader should also remember that a footprint is a snapshot, not a verdict for all time. A fermentation plant that switches to renewable power cuts its footprint the next year. A crop grown with better farming cuts its footprint the next season. The numbers move as the process improves, and a claim from five years ago may no longer describe the product on the shelf today.
The last question is the most practical: what would change the answer? If the feed changes, if the drying changes, if the blend ratio changes, how far does the footprint move? A maker who can answer that question knows the process deeply. A reader who can ask it cannot be misled by a single number, because the reader is looking at the system, not the slogan.
Questions to think about
- A burger has a footprint of 4 units per kilogram and 20 percent protein. A powder has a footprint of 10 units per kilogram and 85 percent protein. Which has the smaller footprint per kilogram of protein, and why does the answer surprise people?
- Why does a footprint study need to state its boundary, and what goes wrong when the boundary is hidden?
- A protein with a small climate footprint is grown on land cleared from forest. Why might the footprint number still look good, and what should the reader ask?
Think about the burger and the powder before you read on
The burger gives 4 divided by 0.20, which is 20 units per kilogram of protein. The powder gives 10 divided by 0.85, which is about 11.8 units per kilogram of protein. The powder wins, even though its footprint per kilogram of product is larger, because each kilogram of powder carries far more protein. Comparing per kilogram of product is the mistake that makes the powder look worse.
The diagram shows the steps of a life cycle assessment in order. The functional unit and the boundary are set first, because they decide what the final number means.
Practical note: In a practical session, take two foods from a shop, such as a plant based burger and a pack of dried lentils, and write down what you would need to count for a footprint of each: the farm inputs, the factory steps, the packaging, the transport and the cooking at home. Then find a footprint claim for one of them, on a pack or on a website, and test it with the six questions in the last section. Write down which questions the claim answers and which it leaves blank, and answer: is the claim a finding you can check, or a slogan?
Quick self-check
Question: Question: What is a functional unit, and why does it matter?
The functional unit is the amount of function being compared, such as one kilogram of protein or one kilogram of digestible protein. It matters because a kilogram of burger and a kilogram of dry powder hold very different amounts of protein, so comparing them per kilogram of product is unfair.
Question: Question: What is a hotspot in a life cycle assessment?
A hotspot is the step where most of the footprint sits, such as the farm for a crop protein or the drying step for mycoprotein. Finding hotspots shows a maker where to spend effort to cut the footprint most.
Try it yourself
Choose a protein food you eat often, and sketch its chain on paper: the farm or tank, the factory, the pack, the shop, your kitchen and the bin. Mark the step you think is the hotspot, and write one sentence for why you think so. Then ask a friend to sketch the same food and compare: did you both pick the same hotspot, and what did each of you leave out? The differences show how much judgement goes into drawing a boundary.
Key ideas to carry forward
- Life cycle assessment counts inputs and outputs across a stated boundary, from field or tank to plate and waste.
- The functional unit, often one kilogram of protein or digestible protein, makes comparisons fair.
- Footprint per kilogram of protein equals footprint per kilogram of product divided by the protein fraction.
- Hotspots show where most of the footprint sits, and they differ by source: farm, drying, feed or the animal part of a blend.
- Land, water and climate are separate numbers and do not always move together.
- Biodiversity, nutrition and waste are trade-offs that a single footprint number can hide.
- A footprint claim must answer six questions about unit, boundary, comparison, gases, omissions and review before it can be believed.
Glossary
Life cycle assessment
A method for counting the environmental effects of a product across its whole life, from raw material to waste. Food tech example: a life cycle assessment counts the land, water and gases of a plant based burger.
Functional unit
The amount of function being compared, such as one kilogram of protein. Food tech example: comparing two foods per kilogram of protein is fairer than per kilogram of product.
Boundary
The line that says where a life cycle assessment starts and stops counting. Food tech example: a study boundary that stops at the factory gate leaves out the shop and the home.
Carbon dioxide equivalent
A unit that converts the warming effect of different gases into the same scale. Food tech example: methane is converted to carbon dioxide equivalent so it can be added to the total.
Hotspot
The step in a chain where most of the footprint sits. Food tech example: drying is often the hotspot for mycoprotein production.
Methane
A gas that warms the planet far more per kilogram than carbon dioxide over a short period. Food tech example: methane from animals is counted in the climate footprint of meat.
Nitrous oxide
A gas released from fertiliser and soil that warms far more per kilogram than carbon dioxide. Food tech example: nitrous oxide from fertilised fields is counted in a crop protein footprint.
Digestibility
The share of a nutrient that the body can absorb and use. Food tech example: a footprint per kilogram of digestible protein adjusts for how much protein the body can actually use.
Side stream
A stream of material that leaves a process beside the main product, such as starch or fibre. Food tech example: crediting a side stream properly changes the footprint of pea fractionation.
Trade-off
A gain in one thing that costs something in another. Food tech example: a protein that uses little land may use a lot of energy for drying.
Biodiversity
The variety of living things in a place. Food tech example: a varied farm supports more biodiversity than a field of one crop.
Water footprint
The water taken from rivers and aquifers to make a product. Food tech example: wet fractionation adds to the water footprint of an isolate.
Land use
The area of land needed to make a product over a year. Food tech example: a tank grown protein uses less land per kilogram of protein than a field grown one.
Renewable power
Energy from sources that renew, such as sun, wind and water. Food tech example: a fermentation plant that switches to renewable power cuts its footprint.
Independent review
Checking of a study by experts who did not carry it out. Food tech example: a footprint claim checked by independent review is easier to trust.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 10: Single-Cell Protein and Air-Based Protein
Note
Unit 10: Single-Cell Protein and Air-Based Protein
A question to start with
Imagine a protein factory with no fields, no animals and no harvest season: a steel tank where microbes eat gas from the air and turn it into protein, day and night, all year. That factory exists, and the food it makes is called single-cell protein. The idea is old, the technology is new, and the newest version feeds microbes on hydrogen and carbon dioxide, the gases in air, so the protein is sometimes called air-based protein. This unit explains what single-cell protein is, which microbes make it, how gas becomes food, and where this strange protein fits on the plate.
What single-cell protein is
Single-cell protein is protein from microbes grown for food: bacteria, yeasts and fungi, harvested as whole cells and dried into a powder or a paste. The name is honest: the food is the cell itself, not a protein extracted from it. Each cell holds protein, nucleic acids, vitamins, minerals and fats, and the powder is eaten as an ingredient in foods or feeds. The idea grew in the last century, when scientists looked for protein that did not need farmland, and it returns now because tanks can run anywhere, in any season, on feedstocks that fields cannot use.
The attraction is speed and density. A microbe can double in an hour or less, while a crop takes months and an animal takes years. A tank stacks production vertically, so a small floor area makes a large amount of protein. The microbes can eat many things: sugars from crops, alcohols, methane, hydrogen and carbon dioxide. The choice of food decides the footprint, the cost and the story: a microbe fed on sugar from a crop still depends on a field, while a microbe fed on gas from air does not.
Single-cell protein is not a new food in every sense. Yeast extracts have flavoured foods for a century, and mycoprotein, covered in Unit 3, is a fungus grown in tanks and eaten as a meat-like food. What is new is the scale and the feedstock: bacteria grown on gas, yeasts grown on side streams, and fungi grown on sugars from waste. The unit that follows treats mycoprotein as a cousin, not a repeat, and focuses on the bacterial and yeast proteins that are new to the food shelf.
The microbes: bacteria, yeasts and fungi
Bacteria are the fastest growers and the richest in protein, often holding 60 to 70 percent protein in the dry cell. They double quickly, they eat a wide range of feedstocks, and they are the microbes of choice for gas fermentation. Their weakness is their small size and their nucleic acid content: bacterial cells hold a lot of RNA, which the human body turns into uric acid, so the RNA must be reduced by a heat step before the protein is eaten in large amounts. They are also harder to harvest, because small cells are slow to settle and need strong centrifuges.
Yeasts are larger, easier to harvest, and familiar to food makers, because baking and brewing yeasts have been eaten for centuries. A yeast grown for protein holds about 45 to 55 percent protein, and it brings B vitamins with it. Yeasts grow on sugars, on alcohols and on some side streams, and they tolerate acid conditions that keep many contaminants out. Their flavour is strong and savoury, which suits stocks, spreads and snacks, and limits them in plain foods where a neutral taste is needed.
Filamentous fungi grow as threads, and their cells link into a fibrous mass that feels like meat, which is why mycoprotein works as a meat analogue. They hold about 40 to 50 percent protein, and they grow well on sugars and starches. Each microbe is a trade off between speed, protein content, ease of harvest, flavour and safety, and the choice of microbe is the first decision in any single-cell protein project. A maker does not pick the fastest microbe. The maker picks the microbe whose strengths fit the food and whose weaknesses can be managed.
Gas fermentation: protein from air
Gas fermentation feeds microbes on gases instead of sugars. Two routes are used. In the first, hydrogen oxidising bacteria eat hydrogen and carbon dioxide, with oxygen, and build their cells from the carbon in the carbon dioxide. The overall change, in words, is carbon dioxide plus hydrogen plus oxygen becoming microbial cells plus water. The hydrogen is made by splitting water with electricity, so the whole chain runs on power, water and air. In the second route, methane eating bacteria, called methanotrophs, eat methane and oxygen and build their cells from the methane carbon. The methane can come from natural gas or from biogas made by rotting waste.
The tank for gas fermentation is a bioreactor with a gas feed, and its hardest problem is getting the gas into the liquid. Hydrogen and methane dissolve poorly in water, so the tank must stir hard and bubble finely to give the gas a large surface to dissolve across. The microbes grow fast once the gas dissolves, and the broth is harvested continuously, with fresh gas flowing in and cells flowing out. The process runs day and night, because the microbes do not sleep, and the output is steady, which suits a factory that wants a constant supply.
A worked example shows the scale. A tank holds 10,000 litres of broth, and the cells grow to 20 g of dry cells per litre. The tank then holds 200 kg of dry cells. If the cells hold 60 percent protein, the tank holds 120 kg of protein. If the tank is harvested once a day, it makes about 120 kg of protein a day, or about 44 tonnes a year. Those numbers are simple multiplications, but they are how a maker checks whether a tank is big enough, whether the gas supply can keep up, and whether the drying step can handle the daily harvest.
From gas to food: the process steps
The process runs in five steps. First, the gas is prepared: hydrogen is made by splitting water, carbon dioxide is captured and cleaned, and methane is cleaned of sulphur compounds that would poison the microbes. Second, the gas is fed to the bioreactor, where the microbes grow in a mineral liquid with the gas bubbling through. Third, the broth is harvested, and the cells are separated from the liquid in a centrifuge. Fourth, the cells are treated with heat to reduce their RNA, because a high RNA intake raises uric acid in the body, and the heat step breaks the RNA down. Fifth, the cells are dried, usually by spray drying, into a powder, and packed.
The heat step for RNA deserves care, because it is the step that makes the protein safe to eat in larger amounts. The cells are held at a warm temperature for a short time, which switches on the cell's own enzymes that break RNA apart. The fragments wash away, and the RNA content falls to a level the body can handle. The same step slightly changes the flavour and the colour, giving a savoury note, so the powder suits savoury foods better than sweet ones. A maker who skips the heat step sells a powder that can only be eaten in small amounts, and the label must say so.
Safety testing for a single-cell protein covers the microbe itself, the feedstock, and the finished powder. The microbe must be identified and shown to make no toxins. The gas and the minerals must be food grade, because anything in the feed can end up in the cell. The powder is tested for microbes, for heavy metals, for RNA content and for allergy, because some people react to yeast and fungal proteins. The approval file for a new single-cell protein is judged like any new food: on the evidence for the specific microbe, the specific process and the specific product.
Nutrition and the RNA question
Single-cell protein is rich in protein and in B vitamins, and it carries minerals such as iron and zinc. Its amino acid pattern is good: bacterial protein is usually rich in lysine and short of methionine, like a legume, so it blends well with grain proteins. Yeast protein is similar, with a good balance and a strong savoury flavour from its natural glutamate. The protein digests well once the cell wall is broken by drying and cooking, because an unbroken cell wall can shield the protein from digestive enzymes, and a powder that is not processed well passes through the body with its protein still locked inside.
The RNA question is the main nutrition limit. Microbial cells hold far more RNA than animal or plant foods, because they grow fast and need many ribosomes, the machines that make protein. The body breaks RNA down to uric acid, and too much uric acid can cause gout in people who are prone to it. The heat step described above cuts the RNA to a level where a normal serving is safe, and the approved serving size on a label reflects that limit. A product that uses single-cell protein as a small part of a recipe, such as 10 percent of a burger, has no RNA problem at all, because the serving carries only a small amount of the powder.
Allergy is the second question. People who react to yeast may react to a yeast protein, and people who react to fungi may react to a fungal protein. The label must name the source plainly, so a shopper with an allergy can avoid it. That naming is not a warning against the food. It is the same honest labelling that soy, wheat and milk carry, and it lets the food reach the many people who can eat it safely while protecting the few who cannot.
Where single-cell protein fits: feed, food and the future
Single-cell protein first reached the market as animal feed, where it replaces fish meal and soy meal in feeds for fish, poultry and pigs. Feed is a kinder first market than food, because the safety questions are fewer and the volumes are large, and a feed plant proves the process at scale before the food plant is built. The step from feed to food is real and large: food needs a cleaner process, a fuller safety file, a label the shopper understands, and a flavour the eater enjoys. A powder that works in fish feed may taste too strong for a human food, and the maker must solve that before the food launch.
In human food, single-cell protein fits best where its strengths are used and its weaknesses are hidden. It fits in savoury foods, where its flavour is a benefit: stocks, sauces, spreads, snacks and meat analogues. It fits in blends, where it lifts the protein of a grain or a legume food without dominating the flavour. It fits in foods for places where farmland is scarce, because a tank needs little land and runs all year. It fits less well in sweet foods, in clear drinks, and in foods where a neutral colour is needed, because the powder is tan to brown and tastes savoury.
The future of single-cell protein depends on three things: cheap clean power for making hydrogen, cheap carbon dioxide capture, and a safety file that regulators and shoppers trust. If power is dear, the protein is dear, because the gas is made with power. If the safety file is thin, the approval waits. If the flavour is not solved, the shopper buys once and not again. The technology is ready in the tank. The work now is in the economics, the evidence and the eating.
Questions to think about
- Why must bacterial single-cell protein be heat treated to reduce its RNA before it is eaten in large amounts?
- A tank holds 10,000 litres at 20 g of dry cells per litre, and the cells hold 60 percent protein. How much protein does one harvest give, and what limits how often the tank can be harvested?
- Single-cell protein reached animal feed before human food. Why is feed a kinder first market, and what must change before the same powder can be sold as a human food?
Think about the RNA question before you read on
Microbial cells hold far more RNA than animal or plant foods because they grow fast and need many ribosomes. The body breaks RNA down to uric acid, and too much uric acid can cause gout in people who are prone to it. A warm heat step switches on the cell's own enzymes that break RNA apart, cutting it to a level where a normal serving is safe.
The diagram shows gas fermentation in order: from gas preparation to a tested powder. The heat step for RNA is what makes the powder safe to eat in larger amounts.
Practical note: In a practical session, compare a yeast extract spread with a plain savoury sauce: taste a small amount of each, and note the savoury depth, the saltiness and the aftertaste. Then stir a spoonful of the yeast extract into a bowl of plain cooked lentils and taste again: note how the savoury note lifts a plain food, and how little is needed. Record the amounts you used and answer: why does a strong flavoured protein suit blends and savoury foods better than a plain food where it would dominate?
Quick self-check
Question: Question: What is single-cell protein?
Protein from microbes grown for food: bacteria, yeasts or fungi, harvested as whole cells and dried into a powder or paste. The food is the cell itself, not a protein extracted from it.
Question: Question: Why do gas fed microbes need strong stirring and fine bubbles?
Because hydrogen and methane dissolve poorly in water, so the tank must give the gas a large surface to dissolve across. Without strong stirring and fine bubbles, the microbes starve for gas even while the tank is full of it.
Try it yourself
Read the label of a savoury spread, a stock cube or a meat free product in a shop, and look for yeast extract, yeast protein or mycoprotein in the ingredient list. Write down the product, the position of the ingredient in the list, and the protein content per 100 g. Then answer: is the microbial ingredient there for protein, for flavour, or for both, and how can you tell from its position in the list and the protein number?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Single-cell protein is protein from whole microbial cells: bacteria, yeasts or fungi, dried into a powder or paste.
- Bacteria grow fastest and hold the most protein, but they carry the most RNA and are hardest to harvest.
- Yeasts are familiar, easy to harvest and rich in B vitamins, with a strong savoury flavour.
- Gas fermentation feeds microbes on hydrogen and carbon dioxide, or on methane, so protein is made from air and water.
- A heat step breaks down RNA to a safe level, and it gives the powder a savoury note.
- The protein digests well once the cell wall is broken, and it blends well with grain proteins.
- Single-cell protein reached feed first, and its future in human food depends on power cost, a full safety file and a flavour eaters enjoy.
Glossary
Single-cell protein
Protein from microbes grown for food, harvested as whole cells. Food tech example: bacterial protein powder is used as an ingredient in savoury foods.
Methanotroph
A bacterium that eats methane and builds its cells from it. Food tech example: methanotrophs are grown in tanks fed with methane gas.
Hydrogen oxidising bacteria
Bacteria that eat hydrogen and carbon dioxide and build cells from the carbon dioxide. Food tech example: hydrogen oxidising bacteria make protein from air and water.
Ribosome
The machine inside a cell that builds protein. Food tech example: fast growing microbes hold many ribosomes, and ribosomes are made of RNA.
RNA
A molecule that carries instructions inside a cell and is rich in fast growing microbes. Food tech example: single-cell protein is heat treated to reduce its RNA before eating.
Uric acid
A substance the body makes when it breaks down RNA, which can cause gout in excess. Food tech example: too much RNA in a food raises uric acid, so the RNA is reduced first.
Biogas
Gas made by rotting waste, mostly methane and carbon dioxide. Food tech example: biogas can feed methane eating bacteria that make protein.
Centrifuge
A machine that spins a liquid fast to separate cells from liquid. Food tech example: a centrifuge spins fermentation broth to harvest bacterial cells.
Spray drying
Drying by blowing a liquid as a fine mist into a hot chamber. Food tech example: spray drying turns harvested cells into a powder.
Mycoprotein
Protein food made from a filamentous fungus grown in tanks. Food tech example: mycoprotein is shaped into meat-like pieces for burgers and pies.
Yeast extract
A savoury paste made by breaking yeast cells open and concentrating the contents. Food tech example: yeast extract flavours stocks, spreads and sauces.
Glutamate
A natural substance that gives a savoury taste. Food tech example: yeast protein is rich in glutamate, which gives it a savoury flavour.
Feedstock
The material a microbe is fed, such as sugar, gas or a side stream. Food tech example: the feedstock decides the footprint of a single-cell protein.
Cell wall
The tough outer layer of a microbial cell. Food tech example: drying and cooking break the cell wall so digestive enzymes can reach the protein.
Fish meal
A protein feed made from dried fish, often replaced by single-cell protein. Food tech example: bacterial protein replaces fish meal in fish feed.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 11: Consumer Acceptance and Marketing of Alternative Proteins
Note
Unit 11: Consumer Acceptance and Marketing of Alternative Proteins
A question to start with
A new protein can be perfect in the laboratory and still fail in the shop, because the shopper decides with the eyes, the nose and the memory of the last meal, not with a specification sheet. People do not buy protein. They buy a burger that tastes good, a milk that pours well, a snack their children will eat. This unit is about that decision: why new foods meet resistance, what shoppers weigh up, how words and labels help or harm, and how honest marketing turns a first taste into a repeat purchase.
The first reaction: newness and disgust
The first reaction to a new protein is often caution, and that caution has a name: food neophobia, the reluctance to eat a food that is new. It is strongest in children and weaker in adults who already eat widely, but it appears in every market. It is not ignorance. It is a protective reflex: in the past, eating an unknown food could poison a person, so the brain treats the unknown with care. A new protein must pass that reflex before taste is even judged.
Disgust is a sharper reaction, and it appears most with insects and with foods that look strange. A whole insect on a plate can disgust a shopper who would happily eat the same insect ground into a bar, because the form hides the source. That is why insect protein sells as a flour in a bar or a pasta, not as a whole insect in a shop, in markets where insects are not a familiar food. The reaction is about the form and the story, not about the nutrition, and a maker who ignores it will blame the shopper for a failure that belongs to the product.
Familiarity is the slow cure. A food that is eaten in small amounts, in a familiar form, with a familiar flavour, becomes less strange each time. A plant based burger that looks, cooks and smells like a burger asks little of the eater. A mycoprotein pie that looks like a pie asks little too. The products that fail most often are the ones that ask the eater to change the form, the flavour and the idea all at once. The rule for a new protein is to change one thing at a time, and to let the familiar carry the new.
What shoppers weigh: taste, price, health and planet
When shoppers are asked what matters, four things appear every time: taste, price, health and planet. Taste comes first, and it is not close: a product that tastes worse than the food it replaces will not be bought twice, whatever its footprint or its protein number. The first bite must be good, and the second bite, the one that decides whether the shopper buys again, must be just as good. That is why tasting trials matter more than advertising, and why a product that wins a tasting often wins the shelf.
Price comes second, and it is judged against the food the product replaces, not against other new foods. A plant based burger is compared with a beef burger, not with another plant based burger. If it costs twice as much and tastes the same, most shoppers will buy the beef burger, and only the most committed will pay the difference. The price gap closes as production grows, but a new product cannot wait for that: it must give the shopper a reason to pay more today, such as a better taste, a better nutrition panel, or a smaller pack at a lower price that lets the shopper try it cheaply.
Health and planet matter, but they matter differently. Health is personal: a shopper buys a high protein, high fibre food for their own body, and the benefit is felt. Planet is shared: a shopper buys a lower footprint food for the world, and the benefit is not felt at all. That is why health claims usually sell better than planet claims, and why the strongest marketing joins them: a food that is good for the eater and lighter on the planet, with the eater first. A claim that asks the shopper to pay more and enjoy less, for the planet alone, will find few buyers.
Naming and framing: words that help and words that harm
The name of a product is the first taste. A name that says what the food is and how to use it helps the shopper: a plant based burger, a pea protein drink, a mushroom mince. A name that says what the food is not, or that uses a word the shopper does not know, harms it. Words such as alternative, substitute and imitation tell the shopper that the food is a copy of something better, and a copy is judged against the original and found wanting. Words that name the main ingredient, pea, mushroom, oat, tell the shopper what to expect and what the flavour will be.
Framing is the story around the name. A product framed as a new food, with its own flavour and its own place, is judged on its own terms. A product framed as a fake meat is judged as meat, and it must then match meat bite for bite, which is a harder test. The most successful plant based products are the ones that stopped apologising for not being meat and started selling their own taste: a smoky bean burger, a crisp mushroom steak, a creamy oat drink. The framing does not change the food. It changes the test the eater applies to it.
The label must carry the framing honestly. A pack that shows a farm and a field while the food was made in a tank misleads the shopper, and the shopper who feels misled does not buy again. A pack that names the protein source plainly, lists allergens clearly, and gives a true protein number, earns trust even when the food is new. Trust is the only marketing that compounds: a trusted brand can launch a second product and the shopper will try it, while a distrusted brand must win the shopper from nothing every time.
Tasting: the moment that changes minds
No advertisement changes a mind like a taste. A shopper who tastes a good plant based burger in a shop, at a market stall or at a friend's table, learns in one bite what a hundred claims cannot teach. That is why tasting is the most effective marketing for a new protein, and why makers spend more on sampling than on slogans. A small free taste costs the maker little and gives the shopper the only evidence that matters: the flavour in the mouth.
The tasting must be set up well. The food must be cooked the way the shopper would cook it at home, not the way a chef would present it in a restaurant. The portion must be small enough to try without commitment and large enough to judge. The person offering it must answer questions honestly: what is it made of, how much protein does it hold, what allergens does it carry? A tasting that hides the ingredients feels like a trick, and a trick ends the trust before it starts.
The second tasting matters more than the first. A shopper who buys a product after a free taste and finds it different at home, because the home cooking was different, or the pack was older, will not buy a third time. The maker must therefore make the product robust: it must cook well in a home pan, in a home oven, and from frozen, not only in a demonstration kitchen. The gap between the tasting and the home is where many new proteins fail, quietly, one disappointed shopper at a time.
Marketing honestly: claims, labels and trust
A claim on a pack is a promise, and the shopper reads it as one. A protein claim must be true per serving, not per 100 g of dry powder that no one eats. A high fibre claim must be true in the food as eaten. A planet claim must be backed by a study with a boundary and a functional unit, as Unit 9 explains, and the study must be available to anyone who asks. A claim that is true in the laboratory and false on the plate is still a false claim, and the shopper who catches it tells friends.
The label carries more than claims. It carries the ingredient list, the allergens, the nutrition panel, the storage instructions and the cooking instructions. Each one is a chance to earn trust or to lose it. An ingredient list that hides the protein source behind a vague word loses trust. An allergen warning that is clear and plain earns it. Cooking instructions that work the first time earn it twice over, because the shopper who cooks it well eats it well.
Marketing that lasts is marketing that respects the shopper. It does not call the shopper ignorant for not buying, it does not hide the price, and it does not promise what the food cannot do. It shows the food, it lets the shopper taste it, it tells the truth about the protein, the price and the footprint, and it lets the shopper decide. That sounds slow, and it is slow. It is also the only marketing that survives the first bad review, because the shoppers who bought on a true claim stay, while the shoppers who bought on a slogan leave.
Who buys first, and how a market grows
A new protein is not bought by everyone at once. It is bought first by a small group: people who already eat widely, who care about health or the planet, who enjoy trying new foods, and who can afford to pay more. Those first buyers are the most important customers a maker will ever have, because they taste, they talk, and they forgive a small fault while the product improves. A maker who listens to them, and changes the recipe on their feedback, builds a product that the next group will buy.
The next group buys when the price falls, the taste improves, and the product appears in the shops they already use. They do not read about the product in a journal. They see it on a shelf beside the food they already buy, they see a friend eat it, and they try it. That is why shelf position matters: a plant based burger hidden in a separate freezer is bought by the few who seek it, while the same burger on the shelf beside beef is tried by the many who did not plan to buy it.
The last group buys when the product is normal: when it costs the same, tastes as good, and is sold everywhere. That takes years, and it takes a product that is good enough to be ordinary. The market grows one group at a time, and the maker who tries to sell to the last group first, with a high price and a strange form, will wait a long time. The patient route is the fast route: win the first buyers, earn the second, and the third will follow.
Questions to think about
- Why does taste come before health and planet in what shoppers weigh, and what does that mean for how a new protein should be marketed?
- A whole insect on a plate disgusts a shopper who happily eats the same insect ground into a bar. What does that tell a maker about form?
- Why is the second tasting, at home, more important than the first tasting in a shop?
Think about the insect bar before you read on
The reaction is about form and story, not nutrition: a whole insect looks strange and triggers disgust, while the same insect ground into a familiar bar hides the source and lets the eater judge the flavour. A maker who changes the form, not the ingredient, removes the barrier without changing the food.
The diagram shows the path from seeing a product to buying it again. The home cooking step is where many new proteins fail, because the food must work in a home pan, not only in a demonstration kitchen.
Practical note: In a practical session, run a small tasting with three friends: cook a plant based burger and a meat burger, cut both into small pieces, and ask each friend to taste without knowing which is which. Ask them to score taste, texture and juiciness from 1 to 5, and to guess which piece is which. Record the scores and the guesses, and answer: did the plant based piece win on taste, did anyone guess wrong, and what would you change in the cooking or the seasoning to close the gap?
Quick self-check
Question: Question: What is food neophobia?
The reluctance to eat a food that is new. It is a protective reflex, strongest in children and weaker in adults who already eat widely, and it is overcome by familiarity: small amounts, familiar forms and familiar flavours, tried more than once.
Question: Question: Why should a product be framed as a new food rather than a fake meat?
Because a fake meat is judged against meat bite for bite, a harder test, while a new food is judged on its own terms. Naming the main ingredient, such as pea or mushroom, tells the shopper what to expect and what the flavour will be.
Try it yourself
Visit a shop and look at three plant based products on the shelf. For each one, write down the name, the first three ingredients, the price per 100 g, and the protein per 100 g. Then compare each with the animal food it sits beside, and answer: which product makes the clearest case for a shopper to try it, and which one hides its case behind vague words or a high price?
Key ideas to carry forward
- Food neophobia, the reluctance to eat what is new, is a protective reflex, and familiarity is its slow cure.
- Taste comes first for shoppers, then price, then health, then planet, and marketing must respect that order.
- Names and framing set the test the eater applies: a new food is judged on its own terms, a fake meat against meat.
- A free taste is the most effective marketing, but the home cooking must match the tasting or the shopper will not buy again.
- Claims on a pack are promises: protein per serving, allergens named plainly, and planet claims backed by a study.
- Markets grow one group at a time: first buyers who try new foods, then the many who see it on the shelf, then the last group when it is normal.
- Trust compounds: a trusted brand can launch a second product and the shopper will try it.
Glossary
Food neophobia
The reluctance to eat a food that is new. Food tech example: a child who refuses a new protein food shows food neophobia, which fades with repeated small tastes.
Disgust
A strong feeling of revulsion towards a food, often triggered by its form or its source. Food tech example: a whole insect can trigger disgust while the same insect ground into a bar does not.
Framing
The story around a product that shapes how the eater judges it. Food tech example: framing a burger as a smoky bean burger, not a fake meat, sets a fairer test.
First buyer
A shopper who tries a new food early, before most people. Food tech example: first buyers taste, talk and forgive small faults while the product improves.
Repeat purchase
Buying the same product a second time, which shows the first buy was a success. Food tech example: a burger that earns a repeat purchase has passed the home cooking test.
Sampling
Giving shoppers a small free taste of a product. Food tech example: sampling in a shop lets a shopper judge a plant based burger with no risk.
Blind tasting
Tasting without knowing which product is which. Food tech example: a blind tasting shows whether eaters can tell a plant based burger from a meat burger.
Shelf position
Where a product sits in a shop, which decides who sees it. Food tech example: a plant based burger beside beef is tried by shoppers who did not plan to buy it.
Claim
A statement on a pack about what a food does or holds. Food tech example: a high protein claim must be true per serving, not per 100 g of dry powder.
Allergen
A food that can cause an allergic reaction in some people. Food tech example: soy and wheat must be named as allergens on a label.
Nutrition panel
The table on a pack listing energy, protein, fat and other nutrients. Food tech example: a shopper reads the nutrition panel to compare two burgers.
Early adopter
A person who tries a new product before most people do. Food tech example: early adopters of plant based burgers were people who already ate widely.
Value for money
What a shopper gets for the price paid. Food tech example: a plant based burger must offer value for money against a beef burger.
Trust
A shopper's belief that a brand tells the truth. Food tech example: a brand that names its protein source plainly earns trust.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.
Unit 12: The Wider Family: Precision Fermentation and Cultivated Meat
Note
Unit 12: The Wider Family: Precision Fermentation and Cultivated Meat
A question to start with
Plant, fungal, algal and insect proteins are only part of the alternative protein story. Two more technologies sit beside them: precision fermentation, which uses microbes to make single ingredients such as whey and casein, and cultivated meat, which grows real animal cells in a tank. This unit introduces both as neighbours, not as repeats: the full treatment of each lives in its own subject, and this unit shows how the three routes meet, how they combine in one product, and how a maker chooses between them.
Three ways to make protein without a farm animal
The alternative protein family has three routes, and each starts from a different idea. The plant and microbe route grows protein in a field or a tank, from a seed, a fungus, an alga or an insect. The precision fermentation route gives a microbe a new gene, so the microbe makes one chosen ingredient, such as a whey protein or an egg white protein, and the ingredient is purified out of the broth. The cultivated meat route grows animal cells themselves, muscle and fat cells, in a tank, so the finished food is meat at the level of the cell.
The three routes differ in what they make. The plant route makes whole foods and powders, with fibre and flavour included. The fermentation route makes single ingredients, pure and precise, that are added to foods in small amounts. The cultivated route makes meat itself, with the same cells as meat from an animal. A burger can be made by any of the three routes, but the burger will not be the same: a plant burger is a new food built from powders, a fermentation burger is a plant burger with a fermentation made protein added, and a cultivated burger is meat grown from cells.
The three routes also differ in what they need. The plant route needs land, seed and a mill. The fermentation route needs a strain, a sugar feed and a bioreactor, plus a purification plant. The cultivated route needs cell lines, a rich culture medium and a large bioreactor, plus a scaffold to give the cells structure. The costs, the safety files and the approvals differ too, which is why the three routes are reaching the market at different speeds, and why a maker must understand all three before choosing one.
What precision fermentation adds to the shelf
Precision fermentation adds ingredients that plants cannot make well. The clearest example is dairy protein: a yeast given the gene for a whey protein makes that whey protein, which is purified and dried into a powder that behaves like whey from milk. It foams, it gels, it sets in yoghurt, and it carries the same amino acids, because it is the same molecule. Casein, the protein that makes cheese stretch and melt, is harder, because casein works as a group of four proteins in a micelle, but fermentation made casein is being built step by step, one protein at a time.
Egg white protein is a second example. The main protein of egg white, which whips into a foam and sets into a gel, can be made by fermentation, and it gives bakers a foam that works like egg without the egg. Sweet proteins are a third: proteins that taste sweet without sugar, made by fermentation in tiny amounts, because a little goes a long way. Colours, fats and vitamins made by fermentation are a fourth group, and they let a plant based food carry a colour or a fat that would otherwise need an animal or a rare plant.
For the alternative protein maker, fermentation ingredients are tools, not rivals. A plant based cheese that melts poorly can be helped by a little fermentation made casein. A plant based ice cream that lacks creaminess can be helped by fermentation made whey. A drink that needs a clean foam can use a fermentation made egg white protein. The full story, how the microbe is designed, how the tank is run, and how the product is purified and approved, is told in the precision fermentation subject, and the reader who wants the detail should go there next.
What cultivated meat adds
Cultivated meat adds the real thing: animal cells, grown without the animal. The starting point is a small sample of cells, often stem cells, which are grown in a tank in a liquid called culture medium, a rich broth of sugars, amino acids, vitamins and growth signals. The cells divide, and when there are enough of them, they are gathered and shaped, sometimes on a scaffold that gives them structure, into a piece of meat. The meat holds the same proteins as meat from an animal, because it is made of the same cells.
The promise is plain: meat without rearing and slaughtering an animal, with the flavour and nutrition of meat, and with a footprint that can be smaller if the medium and the power are clean. The difficulty is also plain: the medium is dear, the cells grow slowly compared with microbes, and a thick piece of meat needs a structure that a tank alone cannot give. The first products are therefore small pieces, nuggets and mince, where structure matters less, and the first markets are those where shoppers will pay a premium for a new meat.
For the alternative protein maker, cultivated meat is a partner for hybrids. A cultivated plus plant hybrid blends a small amount of cultivated meat with a larger amount of plant protein, so the product tastes like meat, because real meat cells are in it, while the cost stays near a plant product, because most of the weight is plant. That blend is covered in depth in the cultivated meat subject, in its unit on hybrid products, and it is the most likely first meeting point of the two routes on a supermarket shelf.
Blending across the family: hybrid products of the future
The most interesting products of the next decade may not belong to one route at all. They may blend all three: a plant base for bulk and fibre, a fermentation made protein for function, and a cultivated meat for flavour. A burger built that way could carry the chew of a texturate, the melt of a fermentation made casein, and the meaty flavour of real fat cells grown in a tank. Each route does what it does best, and none is asked to do what it does worst.
Blending across the family raises new questions. The label must name every source plainly, so a shopper with a milk allergy knows that a fermentation made whey protein is present, and a shopper who avoids meat knows that cultivated cells are in the food. The safety file must cover each part, and the parts together, because a blend is a new food, not three old foods in one pack. The price must be worked out for the blend, not for each part alone, because the parts interact: a little cultivated fat may let the maker use a cheaper plant base, and a little fermentation made protein may let the maker use less cultivated meat.
A worked example shows the idea. A hybrid patty weighs 100 g and holds 20 g of protein. Suppose 10 g of that protein comes from pea isolate, 5 g from fermentation made whey, and 5 g from cultivated cells. The pea gives bulk and fibre, the whey gives binding and a creamy note, and the cultivated cells give the meaty flavour. The maker must test the blend as a whole: does it hold together on a grill, does it taste like meat, does it cost less than a fully cultivated patty? If the answer to all three is yes, the blend earns its place. If the answer to any is no, the blend is changed, and the test is run again.
Shared questions: safety, labelling and acceptance
All three routes face the same three questions, and each is judged on its own evidence. The safety question is: is this specific food safe for the people who will eat it, in the amounts they will eat? The answer needs a file with the identity of the product, the process that made it, the tests for microbes and chemicals, and the allergy check. A plant protein, a fermentation protein and a cultivated meat each need their own file, because the risks are different: a plant protein may carry a known allergen, a fermentation protein may carry a trace of its host microbe, and a cultivated meat may carry a residue of its medium.
The labelling question is: does the shopper know what they are eating? The label must name the source, the allergens and the protein content, in words the shopper understands. A fermentation made whey protein is whey, and a shopper with a milk allergy must be told so, even though no cow was involved. A cultivated meat is meat, and a shopper who avoids meat must be told so, even though no animal was reared. Honest naming is not a burden on these foods. It is what lets them be trusted.
The acceptance question is: will the shopper buy it twice? The answer depends on taste, price, familiarity and trust, as Unit 11 explains, and it applies to all three routes. A fermentation made ingredient that is hidden inside a familiar food faces little resistance. A cultivated meat that is sold as a steak faces the full test of meat. The routes differ in how much they ask of the eater, and the wise maker asks little at first, and more later, as the eater grows familiar.
Choosing the right route: a decision guide
A maker with a product idea can choose between the routes with six questions. First, what must the food do: is it a whole food, a single ingredient, or meat itself? Second, what must it taste like: a new flavour, or the flavour of meat, milk or egg? Third, how much can it cost: must it match a plant product today, or can it carry a premium? Fourth, how soon must it launch: is the route ready now, or is it still scaling up? Fifth, what does the safety file need, and how long will approval take? Sixth, who is the eater, and how much newness will they accept?
A worked decision shows the guide in use. A maker wants a cheese that melts and stretches. A plant base alone melts poorly, so the plant route fails the first question. A fermentation made casein melts well, so the fermentation route passes. A cultivated route makes no sense for cheese, because cheese is not meat. The choice is fermentation, blended with a plant base for bulk. A maker who wants a steak faces the opposite choice: only the cultivated route makes a steak from real muscle cells, so the choice is cultivated, blended with plant protein to cut the cost.
The guide does not pick a winner for all time. It picks the route that fits this product, this price, this eater and this year. The routes are improving at different speeds, and a choice that is right today may be wrong in five years, when a fermentation made casein is cheaper, or a cultivated steak is dear no longer. The maker who understands all three routes can switch when the time is right, and the reader who understands them can follow the whole family, not only one branch.
Questions to think about
- A maker wants a cheese that melts and stretches. Why is precision fermentation a better route than a plant base alone, and why is cultivated meat the wrong route for cheese?
- A hybrid patty blends pea protein, fermentation made whey and cultivated cells. What does each part contribute, and why must the blend be tested as a whole, not part by part?
- A fermentation made whey protein is whey, even though no cow was involved. Why must the label still warn a shopper with a milk allergy?
Think about the melting cheese before you read on
A plant base alone melts poorly because plant proteins do not form the casein micelle that makes cheese stretch and melt. A fermentation made casein is the same molecule as the casein in milk, so it melts and stretches like dairy cheese. Cultivated meat is the wrong route because cheese is not meat: it makes muscle cells, not the proteins that make cheese work.
The diagram shows the three routes and their meeting points. The blends are where the routes combine in one product, and each blend is tested and labelled as a whole.
Practical note: In a practical session, take three foods from a shop: a plant based burger, a yoghurt made with fermentation made protein if one is sold near you, and a conventional meat burger. Read the ingredient lists and the protein per 100 g, and note which route each product belongs to, and what each route contributes to the taste and the texture. If no fermentation made product is sold near you, use a plant based cheese instead, and answer: which route does it use, and what would a fermentation made casein add to it?
Quick self-check
Question: Question: What does precision fermentation make that plants cannot make well?
Single ingredients that are the same molecule as an animal ingredient, such as a whey protein or a casein, which behave like the animal ingredient in foaming, gelling and melting, while a plant protein can only imitate them.
Question: Question: Why is a hybrid of plant protein and cultivated meat likely to reach the shelf before a fully cultivated steak?
Because the plant part carries most of the weight and keeps the cost near a plant product, while a small amount of cultivated meat gives the meaty flavour. A fully cultivated steak needs far more cells, more medium and more structure, so it costs more and takes longer to scale.
Try it yourself
Choose a food you eat often, such as a burger, a cheese or a yoghurt, and write down which of the three routes could make it, and what each route would do well and badly. Then pick the route you would choose for that food today, and write one sentence for why, using the six questions in the last section. Share your choice with a friend and ask them to argue for a different route: the argument will show you the trade-offs more clearly than the choice alone.
Key ideas to carry forward
- The family has three routes: plant and microbe foods, precision fermentation ingredients, and cultivated meat.
- Precision fermentation makes single ingredients that are the same molecule as an animal ingredient, such as whey and casein.
- Cultivated meat grows real animal cells, and it is most likely to reach the shelf first in hybrids with plant protein.
- Blends across the family let each route do what it does best: plant for bulk, fermentation for function, cultivated for flavour.
- Each route needs its own safety file, because the risks are different.
- Labels must name every source plainly, including fermentation made whey for a milk allergy and cultivated cells for a shopper who avoids meat.
- The right route depends on the product, the price, the timing and the eater, and the answer changes as the routes improve.
Glossary
Precision fermentation
Using a microbe given a new gene to make one chosen ingredient, such as a whey protein. Food tech example: precision fermentation makes whey protein without a cow.
Cultivated meat
Meat grown from animal cells in a tank, without rearing an animal. Food tech example: cultivated meat is made of the same muscle cells as meat from an animal.
Casein
The main protein of milk, which makes cheese stretch and melt. Food tech example: fermentation made casein helps a plant based cheese melt.
Micelle
A cluster of casein proteins in milk that gives cheese its structure. Food tech example: casein micelles hold together in milk and set into curd.
Whey protein
The protein left in the liquid when milk curdles. Food tech example: fermentation made whey protein foams and gels like whey from milk.
Culture medium
The rich liquid that feeds animal cells in a tank. Food tech example: culture medium holds sugars, amino acids and growth signals for cultivated meat.
Cell line
Cells grown in a laboratory that keep dividing and can be used again and again. Food tech example: a cultivated meat maker grows meat from a stored cell line.
Scaffold
A structure that gives growing cells shape, so meat feels like meat. Food tech example: cells grown on a scaffold form a piece with fibres and bite.
Egg white protein
The main protein of egg white, which whips into a foam. Food tech example: fermentation made egg white protein gives bakers a foam without eggs.
Sweet protein
A protein that tastes sweet without sugar. Food tech example: sweet proteins made by fermentation sweeten a drink in tiny amounts.
Hybrid product
A food that blends two or more protein sources, such as plant and cultivated meat. Food tech example: a hybrid patty blends pea protein with cultivated cells.
Safety file
The set of evidence that shows a new food is safe to eat. Food tech example: each new protein needs its own safety file for its own process and product.
Cross-reference
A pointer from one subject to another where the full treatment lives. Food tech example: this unit cross-refers the reader to the precision fermentation subject for the full detail.
Stem cell
A cell that can divide and become different kinds of cell. Food tech example: cultivated meat often starts from stem cells that become muscle and fat.
Growth signal
A substance in culture medium that tells cells to divide or to mature. Food tech example: growth signals in the medium tell stem cells to become muscle.
References
- Nadathur, S. R., Wanasundara, J. P. D. and Scanlin, L., Sustainable Protein Sources, 2017.
- Damodaran, S., Parkin, K. L. and Fennema, O. R., Fennema's Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2007.
- Belitz, H. D., Grosch, W. and Schieberle, P., Food Chemistry, 4th edition, 2009.
- Fellows, P. J., Food Processing Technology, 4th edition, 2017.
- Lawrie, R. A. and Ledward, D. A., Lawrie's Meat Science, 7th edition, 2006.